Daunno's theatrical journey began with Off-Broadway productions, most notably originating the role of Orpheus in the critically acclaimed musical Hadestown (2016). His powerful performance on the show's original cast recording continues to resonate with audiences.
He later brought his charisma to Broadway with a lauded performance as Curly McLain in the unconventional 2019 revival of Oklahoma!. This portrayal earned him Tony and Grammy Award nominations, solidifying his status as a rising star.