Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#11 - Tony Awards 2024 Analysis #3

Will Lindsay Mendez Merrily Roll Along to her second Tony win? Magnificent Monday! Eila & Bruce bring you the third installment of their Tony deep dive. They are joined by expert Matt Stashin and share who will win and who they want to win in the following categories... Read More

From the show: Behind the Awards with Eila Mell & Bruce Gotlieb

44 mins
5/20/24

Miniseries Inclusions

Featured Shows

About

Will Lindsay Mendez Merrily Roll Along to her second Tony win?

Magnificent Monday! Eila & Bruce bring you the third installment of their Tony deep dive. They are joined by expert Matt Stashin and share who will win and who they want to win in the following categories. Featured Actress in a Musical, Book of a Musical, Scenic Design of a Play, Best Revival of a Play.

Shoshana Bean, Amber Iman, Nikki M James, Leslie Rodroguez Kritzer, Kecia Lewis, Lindsay Mendez, Bebe Neuwirth, Hells Kitchen, Lempicka, Monty Python’s Spamalot, Merrily We Roll Along, Cabaret, Suffs, The Notebook, Water for Elephants, The Outsiders, An Enemy of the People, Appropriate, Purlie Victorious, Jaja’s African Hair Braiding, Stereophonic

Make sure to check out Eila's book, "The Tony Awards", and all her other amazing books: https://amzn.to/43WMu5Y.

Connect with Eila and Bruce:

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:09] Eila Mell: Hello and welcome to Behind the Awards.

[0:11] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm Bruce and I'm here with Eila.

[0:13] Eila Mell: Hey, Bruce.

[0:14] Bruce Gotlieb: Hi, Eila.

[0:16] Eila Mell: How are you feeling this week?

[0:17] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, we are in the midst of Tony Award season.

[0:21] Eila Mell: I mean, it's pretty much the middle. This is our midpoint.

[0:24] Bruce Gotlieb: Week three.

[0:25] Eila Mell: And you know, it's very exciting.

[0:28] Bruce Gotlieb: It is.

[0:29] Eila Mell: I am still trying to see some shows.

[0:32] Bruce Gotlieb: I mean, time's running out.

[0:33] Eila Mell: I know.

[0:34] Bruce Gotlieb: TikTok.

[0:35] Eila Mell: Really? And maybe you should just get a hotel and just, you know, back to back, back to back.

[0:41] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[0:41] Eila Mell: So yeah, just lock myself away from my normal everyday life.

[0:45] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[0:45] Eila Mell: I have nothing to do with the show. No responsibilities but to see shows.

[0:48] Bruce Gotlieb: All right, I'm doing it.

[0:49] Eila Mell: Good. Well, you said I had to, so there you go.

[0:52] Bruce Gotlieb: All right.

[0:53] Eila Mell: So we have our special Tony correspondent.

[0:56] Bruce Gotlieb: Ooh, I like that.

[0:58] Eila Mell: Matt Stashin, hey Matt.

[0:59] Matt Stashin: Oh, does that mean I get a hat with something on it to be a correspondent?

[1:02] Bruce Gotlieb: You want to do like those newsman hats with like what did they have? Like a card in the front?

[1:05] Eila Mell: What was that? The other tunes they always had those.

[1:09] Bruce Gotlieb: Didn't he have that? Scoop Brady, remember?

[1:11] Eila Mell: That's it, yes.

[1:13] Bruce Gotlieb: All right, so we're calling him Scoop.

[1:14] Eila Mell: Scoop Matt.

[1:15] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[1:15] Eila Mell: I have a nickname. I like this.

[1:17] Matt Stashin: Welcome back.

[1:18] Eila Mell: Thank you for joining us.

[1:19] Matt Stashin: Thank you so much.

[1:20] Eila Mell: We love talking Tonys.

[1:22] Matt Stashin: For me, it's like the Super Bowl.

[1:24] Bruce Gotlieb: Better.

[1:25] Matt Stashin: I have no interest in the Super Bowl, and I have a lot of interest in this.

[1:29] Eila Mell: What? Do you have an interest in the Tonys?

[1:32] Matt Stashin: Oh, you sound like you wrote the book about it, I think.

[1:35] Eila Mell: Well, but you'd be in bookstores now.

[1:38] Matt Stashin: Yes, I did.

[1:40] Eila Mell: So it's at the Drama Bookshop.

[1:42] Matt Stashin: It was sold out.

[1:43] Eila Mell: It was sold out.

[1:44] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh my gosh.

[1:45] Eila Mell: Bruce and I went there to just look at the book because I haven't seen it in the store.

[1:49] Bruce Gotlieb: And they said it was sold out, but they're getting it.

[1:52] Eila Mell: So it should be there by now.

[1:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, next time we're in the city, we'll have to pop in again.

[1:56] Eila Mell: That's right. You know, it's also at the Museum of Broadway.

[2:00] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, we were at an event there a couple of weeks ago.

[2:02] Eila Mell: Yes.

[2:03] Bruce Gotlieb: And they had it on a table, and they had it at a few different places.

[2:09] Eila Mell: It was next to my other book, Designing Broadway, which was very exciting for me.

[2:13] Bruce Gotlieb: They live together now, the books.

[2:15] Eila Mell: Yes. Also in bookstores now.

[2:18] Bruce Gotlieb: At the Museum of Broadway.

[2:21] Eila Mell: So are you ready to dive in?

[2:23] Matt Stashin: I am so ready.

[2:24] Eila Mell: I can't wait. What categories are we doing today?

[2:35] Bruce Gotlieb: All right. Some big topics today, Matt. Can you handle it?

[2:38] Matt Stashin: I can handle it.

[2:39] Bruce Gotlieb: Can you?

[2:40] Matt Stashin: Well, I guess we'll see.

[2:41] Bruce Gotlieb: We'll find out.

[2:43] Matt Stashin: I'm a little daunted, but I think we can do it.

[2:45] Eila Mell: All right. Featured Actress in a Musical.

[2:47] Matt Stashin: Shoshana Bean for Hell's Kitchen.

[2:49] Eila Mell: Yes.

[2:49] Matt Stashin: Amber Iman, Lempicka.

[2:52] Eila Mell: Nikki M. James, Suffs.

[2:55] Matt Stashin: Leslie Rodroguez Kritzer, Monty Python's Spamalot.

[2:59] Eila Mell: Kecia Lewis, Hell's Kitchen.

[3:01] Matt Stashin: Lindsay Mendez, Merrily We Roll Along, Bebe Neuwirth for Cabaret.

[3:06] Eila Mell: I mean, that's seven.

[3:07] Matt Stashin: Now, Matt, why are there seven?

[3:09] Matt Stashin: Because when they did their original voting, there were ties.

[3:12] Eila Mell: Ties or very close.

[3:14] Matt Stashin: I hear if it's like super close.

[3:16] Eila Mell: But it has to be like really, really close.

[3:16] Matt Stashin: Really close.

[3:19] Eila Mell: Yeah. So that is a lot. I wonder if there's a limit. Like, could they read 20 if it was that close?

[3:25] Matt Stashin: I wish I knew the answer to that.

[3:26] Eila Mell: I know, me too.

[3:27] Matt Stashin: Secrets of the Tony nominators.

[3:30] Eila Mell: We could read through their, you know, the bylaws.

[3:33] Matt Stashin: Yeah, yeah.

[3:33] Eila Mell: I think it's got to be online somewhere.

[3:34] Matt Stashin: It is a big thing.

[3:35] Eila Mell: The bylaws are we researched.

[3:36] Matt Stashin: We read it, yeah.

[3:37] Eila Mell: Because we had questions.

[3:38] Matt Stashin: We did. We wanted to make sure we knew what we were talking about.

[3:41] Eila Mell: So we did read the bylaws, but it didn't really cover that so much.

[3:45] Matt Stashin: Or we didn't get through that part.

[3:46] Eila Mell: We probably didn't because I think I stopped once I got the answer I was looking for.

[3:50] Matt Stashin: I moved on.

[3:51] Eila Mell: Yeah. So I'm gonna start in the middle here just because I want to give Kecia Lewis a little nod.

[3:55] Matt Stashin: Congratulations.

[4:00] Eila Mell: Yes. She just won for her role in Hell's Kitchen, the Lortel.

[4:04] Matt Stashin: That's a big deal.

[4:06] Eila Mell: Which is amazing.

[4:07] Matt Stashin: It really is. You know, you have shows like Merrily last year was part of the Lortel Awards because it was off Broadway this season, it's on.

[4:16] Eila Mell: Yeah. Hell's Kitchen has the distinct honor of being part of both because it was also off Broadway this season and now it's on Broadway.

[4:25] Matt Stashin: I know. There's a lot for that show.

[4:27] Eila Mell: So much love.

[4:28] Matt Stashin: So much love.

[4:29] Eila Mell: And so, you know, kudos, congratulations to her.

[4:32] Matt Stashin: Yes.

[4:33] Eila Mell: And congratulations on her nomination. So what do we think? Do we think her and Shoshana Bean split a vote both from Hell's Kitchen?

[4:41] Matt Stashin: I think it's entirely possible they will split the vote. I don't think they necessarily should because both of them the parts are separate enough. They both have so much incredible stuff to do in the show. And the parts are so very different. I don't think they should cancel each other out because they are so separate from each other. But I'm afraid they might, especially in a category of seven people.

[5:06] Eila Mell: I don't think they're gonna because I don't think it's gonna matter. I think Lindsay Mendez is just the favorite.

[5:12] Matt Stashin: I think the train is going.

[5:13] Eila Mell: I do, I do. I think Lindsay Mendez is kind of unstoppable here. So I don't really I think for everyone else in this category, the honor is the nomination. And that's a big award in itself.

[5:26] Matt Stashin: Sure. And I'm not saying what I think should. I just think that this is what I think is going to happen. There was a conversation at one point for Lindsay Mendez that because she had missed a bunch of shows, that they thought that her absence and calling out of performances could hurt her chances of a nomination or her chances of a win.

[5:49] Eila Mell: Well, so clearly it didn't hurt her getting nominated.

[5:51] Matt Stashin: No.

[5:52] Eila Mell: If I were a nominator, I couldn't have voted for her because she wasn't there when I went to see the show.

[5:57] Matt Stashin: Right.

[5:58] Eila Mell: You know, so we know now that she's pregnant, probably why she was calling out. And, you know, that's certainly understandable, but if the voters and the nominators can't see you, then how can they vote for you?

[6:10] Matt Stashin: Well, I do know that it was told to me by a nominator that there were shows that they were going to see, but they had to reschedule.

[6:19] Eila Mell: Mm-hmm.

[6:20] Matt Stashin: But sometimes they can't make it. Sometimes they can.

[6:22] Eila Mell: So that's all I'm saying. It could hurt her chances. I don't think it will, but it certainly could if people aren't seeing her in it.

[6:29] Matt Stashin: Yeah. And had she not been pregnant, I think it would have hurt her a lot more.

[6:34] Eila Mell: Certainly. I think you're probably I mean, I think she probably is going to win. I don't think it's the slam dunk, no contest marathon runaway, though.

[6:45] Matt Stashin: Oh, really?

[6:46] Eila Mell: I think there is a lot of buzz and a lot of love right now for Bebe Neuwirth.

[6:50] Matt Stashin: Really? Okay.

[6:51] Eila Mell: I do. I think like everything that I've read and seen from Cabaret has said her performance is incredible.

[6:58] Matt Stashin: I mean, she does have two Tonys. Her last one was twenty-eight years ago.

[7:02] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[7:03] Matt Stashin: And no reason that she couldn't get a third.

[7:05] Eila Mell: Absolutely. Just because you have Tonys doesn't mean you shouldn't get another one.

[7:08] Matt Stashin: Just the Esquadra.

[7:09] Eila Mell: That's right. I just got a collection.

[7:12] Matt Stashin: That's right. But you know, Bebe Neuwirth has this pedigree, right? You know, her name's in a conversation or in a category, it has to have some weight to it.

[7:23] Eila Mell: Yeah, well, she knows what she's doing.

[7:26] Matt Stashin: Yeah, no, you can't and you shouldn't, although I kind of am this season, just because I really think no one else has a chance. I just think it's that clear-cut.

[7:33] Eila Mell: But I would so love to be wrong because that would be such an exciting moment. And this role is such a departure from a lot of the roles she's most famous for.

[7:43] Matt Stashin: Oh, for sure.

[7:44] Eila Mell: You know, she originated Velma in the revival of Chicago. And she was on Cheers, Nikki and Sweet Charity, Morticia Addams.

[7:52] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[7:53] Eila Mell: I mean, she can do anything. This role is such a departure for her.

[7:56] Matt Stashin: Yeah. I mean, she's incredible. Everything I've, you know, the show has gotten a lot of mixed reviews.

[8:02] Eila Mell: It has.

[8:02] Matt Stashin: But more than anything, it's all positive for her.

[8:05] Eila Mell: Right.

[8:06] Matt Stashin: So that's like the major consensus that everybody agrees that she's incredible in the show.

[8:10] Eila Mell: Yes. And it's such a sympathetic role, too.

[8:13] Matt Stashin: Right.

[8:13] Eila Mell: So I also, you know, speaking of the different nominees, I was surprised. I was surprised Nikki M. James is here, not because of her performance.

[8:25] Matt Stashin: Because she gives a wonderful performance.

[8:27] Eila Mell: Loved her in it.

[8:28] Matt Stashin: Everybody loves her in it.

[8:30] Eila Mell: Absolutely. She's terrific. The only reason why I was surprised is because there's other women that are in this show that equally give such a strong performance.

[8:39] Matt Stashin: Because the beauty of this piece is aside from Shayna Tao, because she's the lead, right?

[8:45] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[8:46] Matt Stashin: Aside from her, everybody has their moment and the moment to shine.

[8:51] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[8:51] Matt Stashin: And nobody's forsaking that.

[8:53] Eila Mell: Shine they will on that. Like they're shining. And there's a cast of heavy hitters, too.

[8:58] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[8:59] Eila Mell: Yeah, there's no slouch there.

[9:00] Matt Stashin: No.

[9:01] Eila Mell: You could have honestly filled out this category entirely from Suffs.

[9:05] Matt Stashin: You could have. I mean, you had Jen Kalella, you had Emily Skinner, you had Hannah Cruz.

[9:10] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[9:11] Matt Stashin: Who I know you loved her.

[9:12] Eila Mell: Loved her in this show, in this part.

[9:15] Matt Stashin: The cast is incredible. And kudos to Nikki M. James for getting singled out.

[9:19] Eila Mell: Well, she is a Tony Winner, man.

[9:21] Matt Stashin: She is a Tony winner.

[9:22] Eila Mell: And she is fantastic.

[9:24] Matt Stashin: Yeah. I know when I saw the show, her first scene came up. She sang her first song, and I turned to the person I saw the show with. I'm like, well, there's the Tony.

[9:33] Matt Stashin: She gives a very riveting performance.

[9:38] Eila Mell: The only thing I'll say is, and maybe it is a testament to her, is the part itself is of the supporting roles a little smaller?

[9:46] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[9:47] Eila Mell: Oh.

[9:47] Matt Stashin: But so all the more reason that, you know, if she's being singled out, then clearly she's, you know, making the most of her time on stage.

[9:56] Eila Mell: Did you see they posted a video of her coming into rehearsal the day after or coming to the theater the day after the nominations, and the whole cast and crew were just applauding her and everyone was so happy for her?

[10:08] Matt Stashin: That's fantastic.

[10:10] Eila Mell: It was amazing. Yeah, go look for it because it was great.

[10:13] Matt Stashin: So years ago I was at this event at Barney's called Fashion's Night Out, and I'm in the makeup department because it was a store-wide event, right? There were events all throughout, and so in the makeup department I look over at the woman working at the counter, and I had just seen All Shook Up, and I said, Oh, this is the actress who is in All Shook Up, Nikki M. James. So I went over to her. I said, Just want to tell you you're great in All Shook Up. It was so much fun. She said, Oh my gosh, thank you. Tomorrow I'm starting rehearsals for a brand new play by the creators of South Park.

[10:46] Eila Mell: So she was just starting Book of Mormon, for which she would, of course, win her Tony. So I've always just cheered her on ever since that moment.

[10:51] Matt Stashin: Ever since that moment, ever since she helped you with makeup.

[10:57] Eila Mell: Well, she didn't, it was just, you know, like she said she tells people, you know, I was a shop girl one day, and then the next day I'm winning a Tony. And you know, that's just the way this business is.

[11:08] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[11:10] Eila Mell: And then the only other nominee that we have is Amber Iman.

[11:22] Matt Stashin: So Amber Iman is the lead character of Lempicka.

[11:28] Eila Mell: The artist.

[11:30] Matt Stashin: Um, Amber Iman plays her muse.

[11:33] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[11:33] Matt Stashin: So this character was Lempicka's muse.

[11:37] Eila Mell: And right. I wonder if she's based on a real person.

[11:39] Matt Stashin: Probably not, probably like a compilation.

[11:41] Eila Mell: I think it's a compilation of a couple of people.

[11:43] Matt Stashin: Yeah. So, you know, the thing that was interesting to me was, you know, she yes, clearly the featured actress of this story.

[11:54] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[11:54] Eila Mell: Um, you have a couple of other people that could have been in conversation for the show, but definitely the showier bigger part of those people.

[12:02] Matt Stashin: I personally didn't love the show.

[12:05] Eila Mell: Right.

[12:06] Matt Stashin: So it did, the roles didn't really stand out.

[12:11] Eila Mell: They didn't stay with me.

[12:12] Matt Stashin: So when I saw her come up, that was why I was surprised.

[12:15] Eila Mell: I was very surprised at this nomination.

[12:17] Matt Stashin: I didn't see it coming.

[12:18] Eila Mell: I don't think a lot of people saw it coming, to be honest.

[12:20] Matt Stashin: I don't think so. I mean, they're definitely the show definitely has very passionate supporters who were pushing for nominations, especially for her.

[12:28] Eila Mell: Right.

[12:29] Matt Stashin: Personally, I was surprised. So I was listening to the radio, and they have a cast album, and her song came on, and just listening to it, not watching the show, it was great.

[12:41] Eila Mell: Yeah, I was surprised at how much I liked it.

[12:43] Matt Stashin: Because I again, you know, like do you think you liked it more?

[12:46] Eila Mell: I liked it more, yes, more on its own than watching it in the show, which is interesting, and I don't even really know why.

[12:55] Matt Stashin: It could just be it's a better, it stands better alone on its own.

[12:59] Eila Mell: Maybe, maybe in the recording studio, her having the ability to, you know, just kind of stand behind a mic and maybe sing.

[13:07] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[13:07] Eila Mell: Um, I don't know.

[13:10] Matt Stashin: No, but it's very interesting.

[13:11] Eila Mell: Yeah, at least you enjoyed it.

[13:14] Matt Stashin: I did.

[13:15] Eila Mell: I did. You know, Lempicka wasn't my favorite show either.

[13:18] Matt Stashin: Um, I have to be honest about that.

[13:20] Eila Mell: So, you know, I just I don't think that this, I don't know. I feel like another year, maybe you could have made more of a case for this performance. But I just think with all these other women it would be tough.

[13:34] Matt Stashin: Yeah, I agree with that.

[13:35] Eila Mell: And then the other one that we didn't talk about was Leslie Rodroguez Kritzer.

[13:40] Matt Stashin: Yeah, who's a great actress. And she's been around and she really is beloved by the Broadway community.

[13:48] Eila Mell: Yeah. I mean, I remember seeing her back, I don't even want to think about how many years ago it is, but she was in the original cast of Legally Blonde.

[13:55] Matt Stashin: Right.

[13:55] Eila Mell: And right after that, I saw her again in another show called The Catered Affair.

[13:59] Matt Stashin: Okay.

[14:00] Eila Mell: Where she played Faith Prince's daughter. And she's always, every time I've ever seen her, she's wonderful.

[14:05] Matt Stashin: And she's hilarious in Beetlejuice.

[14:07] Eila Mell: I mean, she's great. And this part that she's playing, so she's the lady in the league, so she has a couple of things going for her. One, she's the only woman in a sea of men.

[14:16] Matt Stashin: So she stands out immediately.

[14:18] Eila Mell: Stands out immediately. This part, she is in each act a show-stopping number. Um, Sada Ramirez originated and won a Tony for the role.

[14:28] Matt Stashin: Yes.

[14:28] Eila Mell: So all of these things help that momentum go.

[14:30] Matt Stashin: It does.

[14:31] Eila Mell: I just think that the show wasn't well received enough to really get her this Tony.

[14:37] Matt Stashin: She, but yes, I agree with you. The show wasn't well received, but similarly to other things we've talked about, but you never heard a bad thing about her performance.

[14:46] Bruce Gotlieb: No, never, never.

[14:48] Matt Stashin: I think if the show had been a little better received, I think we might be having the same conversation about her that you're giving us about Lindsay Mendez.

[14:56] Bruce Gotlieb: Could be, yeah, exactly.

[14:58] Matt Stashin: It's you know, it's always it's not really the person, it's it's the year and the positioning and who else is up and what show is popular, you know.

[15:06] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, because you have shows some years that you know come in and and you're like, why didn't this show get you know more love?

[15:13] Matt Stashin: I remember seeing Waitress and going uh when Ogi's done with his song going, how doesn't that win the Tony?

[15:20] Bruce Gotlieb: Right, and when you're in the year of Hamilton, exactly.

[15:24] Matt Stashin: So, you know, another year Oh my gosh, Christopher Fitzgerald was brilliant.

[15:29] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, yes, yes.

[15:30] Matt Stashin: He was so good. So you're right. I think you know, timing is everything.

[15:34] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. It's not that any of these women are undeserving, but some are gonna have a much tougher time than others.

[15:40] Matt Stashin: And it's funny because you have shows that you know, either rush in to try to make the cutoff.

[15:46] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[15:47] Matt Stashin: And you wonder sometimes if you would have waited a month and gone to the next season.

[15:52] Bruce Gotlieb: But then it's hard to be an early show and guy. I you don't know. You just don't know.

[15:56] Matt Stashin: That that'd be an interesting conversation to have, maybe with like a producer, you know, to see you know why why you put yourself in whatever position you do.

[16:06] Bruce Gotlieb: Exactly.

[16:07] Matt Stashin: Yeah. And are you thinking about Tony's? You have to think when a show comes in at the last minute. Maybe they are, but not always because we had Miriam Silverman on, or will be having Miriam Silverman on.

[16:17] Bruce Gotlieb: We've interviewed her.

[16:19] Matt Stashin: And she talks about how everybody assumed that the sign and Sidney Brewstein's window came in just in time to qualify for Tony's, but it wasn't the case.

[16:27] Bruce Gotlieb: She said that it was just really that was when they could get a theater.

[16:31] Matt Stashin: It wasn't to qualify for Tony's.

[16:32] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. So that's a big piece of it. Because if you don't have the theater, you don't have a show.

[16:37] Matt Stashin: You're not getting a Tony without a theater.

[16:39] Bruce Gotlieb: It's also a testament to this entire Broadway season, though. We have seven nominees in this category, and there are other people that could have been put into this category also.

[16:48] Matt Stashin: There always are. We talked about the cast of Suffs. I'm thinking of um Samantha Pauly and The Great Gatsby.

[16:54] Bruce Gotlieb: I actually really enjoyed go all the way back to Jennifer Samard and Once Upon a One More Time.

[16:59] Matt Stashin: I all know all three of us loved her.

[17:00] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.

[17:01] Matt Stashin: Yeah, she's I do not love her. She's even she can do anything.

[17:04] Bruce Gotlieb: You know, uh not for nothing. If I if I'm if I'm being honest, I'm s I would swap out uh Amber Iman for Joy Woods.

[17:12] Matt Stashin: I know you love her in The Notebook. I think that is that would be a nomination.

[17:17] Bruce Gotlieb: And Jordan Tyson too is wonderful.

[17:19] Matt Stashin: Yeah. I mean, so you do you have all of these where any other season each of these people are in this conversation?

[17:28] Bruce Gotlieb: I know. I know. So, but that's what makes it exciting.

[17:31] Matt Stashin: Right. Alright, so we have to be cutthroat. Who will win, Matt? Who's gonna win?

[17:34] Matt Stashin: I'm sorry, Eila.

[17:37] Eila Mell: Okay. I'm thinking Bebe Neuwirth. I think she's gonna win.

[17:41] Matt Stashin: Alright. I'm going out on a limb on that one, but that's the one.

[17:44] Eila Mell: Well, I think I've made it clear who I think is gonna win.

[17:47] Matt Stashin: You did.

[17:47] Eila Mell: And I am going to I'm going to begrudgingly stand beside you.

[17:53] Matt Stashin: Okay. Begrudgingly.

[17:55] Eila Mell: Why? Are you mad at me or something?

[17:57] Matt Stashin: Alright. So now who do we want to win? This is a much bigger question. Matt, who do you want to win?

[18:03] Matt Stashin: Of these seven?

[18:04] Eila Mell: Yes.

[18:05] Matt Stashin: Honestly, my heart's with Shoshana Bean.

[18:08] Eila Mell: Okay.

[18:08] Matt Stashin: I really I've been a fan of hers for a long time.

[18:12] Eila Mell: Okay. Well not. I actually loved her in Mr. Saturday Night. I've just, she's so talented and she's so good in the show.

[18:18] Matt Stashin: Okay.

[18:19] Eila Mell: And that's mine too. I think it's her time. I think she's you know, she's put in some really great work.

[18:26] Matt Stashin: Um, and not that her not that her history of work should have any indication. But you know, when you see somebody who is, you know, nominated, you know, and now nominated again, she really stands out for me for the in this season.

[18:40] Bruce Gotlieb: Alright. Well, nothing against Shoshana, but I'm not going there. I think it would be a great story if Kecia Lewis won.

[18:48] Matt Stashin: Sure. That's my really interesting. That's my want, yeah.

[18:52] Eila Mell: So interesting that none of us pick Lindsay, who is the clear favorite, Matt.

[18:58] Matt Stashin: I already said, I think you probably right, but Okay.

[19:02] Bruce Gotlieb: We'll be right back. We have to listen to some commercials.

[19:09] Bruce Gotlieb: Alright, Eila, take us to the next category.

[19:12] Eila Mell: We're gonna dip a toe into Book of a Musical.

[19:15] Bruce Gotlieb: Alright. So we have Christopher Diaz, Hell's Kitchen, Becca Brunsetter for The Notebook.

[19:22] Eila Mell: Okay, Justin Levine and Adam Rapp, The Outsiders, Shayna Taub, Suffs, and Rick Elise for Water for Elephants.

[19:31] Bruce Gotlieb: Alright. So where do we want to start? Should we go with Christopher Diaz Hell's Kitchen?

[19:35] Eila Mell: Start right at the top.

[19:37] Bruce Gotlieb: Alright. So I think that many people assumed, I was one of them, that this was going to be Alicia Keys' life story.

[19:44] Eila Mell: I thought so too originally.

[19:45] Bruce Gotlieb: And then it's not, right?

[19:47] Eila Mell: It's sort of loosely based.

[19:49] Bruce Gotlieb: Right, but it's not her. Like the lead character is not Alicia Keys.

[19:53] Eila Mell: No.

[19:53] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[19:53] Eila Mell: So Christopher Diaz, he wrote a new story.

[19:56] Bruce Gotlieb: Alright. So do we have any thoughts? Do you think he has a chance?

[20:01] Matt Stashin: The reason why, and I haven't, I'm not, I'm not gonna take anything away from his book. But the reason why I think that or what is helping him is Alicia Keys. I think that there's so much momentum and buzz for this show because of so many facets of it that you know that that's how gonna help him along the way.

[20:25] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay, well that's good help.

[20:26] Matt Stashin: Yeah, I mean, I'm sure he's not turning it down. I wouldn't. Um so I think I think it's a good story.

[20:31] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[20:32] Matt Stashin: Um, I think the book is I would say moderately strong. Um, and I think that all of the other things, uh, you know, Tom Kitt, Alicia Keys, all of these other factors that play into it, is helping helping his story.

[20:47] Eila Mell: Okay. Yeah.

[20:48] Bruce Gotlieb: Alright. I do think it's a strong book. I think it's a hard job to try to take an original story and base it on existing music.

[20:59] Matt Stashin: Right.

[20:59] Bruce Gotlieb: There's a lot of factors to do that.

[21:00] Matt Stashin: There's a lot of factors. Sometimes if it's not done really well, it just seems like they just shoehorned it in without actually giving it a a proper place or a reason to be in the show, other than I want to hear this song.

[21:14] Eila Mell: But do you think the songs almost give it like a roadmap to so I know I have to incorporate this song?

[21:19] Matt Stashin: I mean, for any musical, there are songs, but these songs are well known.

[21:23] Bruce Gotlieb: Exactly.

[21:24] Matt Stashin: So they, you know, they have a very people know the lyrics. They don't like when you change the lyrics. They won't you know so do you think that that makes it a little bit easier, maybe because you have to work in these songs or not?

[21:34] Eila Mell: I actually honestly think it makes it a little harder.

[21:37] Matt Stashin: Okay, because you have to find logical, rational ways to make these very famous songs fit the story in a natural way.

[21:45] Eila Mell: Exactly.

[21:45] Matt Stashin: So it seems like you ha you could say nothing else. But yeah, okay. That's that's why I actually think his job is harder than some of the others in this category.

[21:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay, alright. Well, Matt has spoken. Um, and so tell me about Becca Brunsetter. What else has she written, Bruce?

[22:02] Bruce Gotlieb: I know you're familiar with her work.

[22:05] Matt Stashin: She is uh was the writer on This Is Us, yeah, which was one of my favorite TV shows.

[22:09] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.

[22:10] Matt Stashin: But she has a very I mean and she's the notebook, just to remind people she has a knack uh uh of writing and and making you feel um and you know she does a beautiful job with The Notebook.

[22:24] Bruce Gotlieb: Um it's a memory play, so you know you have to you know be careful of how you tell the story, yeah, in order to be effective.

[22:33] Matt Stashin: It's about a big issue too about Alzheimer's, so yeah, and you know, so certainly the actors certainly have their weight to pull in that in that realm. But if the book isn't there, right?

[22:46] Bruce Gotlieb: It doesn't matter how good or you know, your acting capabilities are.

[22:46] Matt Stashin: Yeah. I mean, sometimes in a musical, there's there's limited dialogue, right?

[22:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[22:54] Matt Stashin: Right, so the dialogue has to do a lot, and in this musical, it really does, it gives them a lot to play.

[22:54] Eila Mell: Absolutely and when you go in to see The Notebook there's a certain expectation of the emotions that you're going to feel oh my gosh right down to the merch stand has a box of tissues that you can purchase to use during the show and there is audible sobbing coming from the audience well when I was there anyway there was some of it might have been from me I'm not gonna lie carried on a little I think I just think she really does a uh a wonderful job uh of storytelling it's so beautifully done.

[22:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, it is. And you're right, people. I mean, it was a book first, then it was an extremely famous iconic movie, and it's still actually a fresh and original story as a musical. So that's not nothing.

[22:54] Eila Mell: No, and I agree. I think she took, you know, stuff from the book, took stuff from the movie, made sure to keep what she needed to, but then also kind of put her own stamp on it. Yeah, the bones are there, but it's not the movie. It's not vastly different, but it isn't exactly what you think it's gonna be either.

[22:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Agreed. Yeah. All right, who's next? So Justin Levine, Adam Rapp for The Outsiders. I mean, you know we love The Outsiders.

[22:54] Eila Mell: We do. And so you—I went in knowing nothing. Okay, I went in no book, no movie.

[22:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Crazy to me because I, you know, that was such a big part of what I learned through high school. I mean, really means I struggled.

[24:32] Matt Stashin: So I love the book, The Outsiders. I love the movie. I mean, Patrick was crazy.

[24:39] Bruce Gotlieb: So how did it how did it feel for you then?

[24:43] Matt Stashin: You know, coming from seeing both, loving both. Did you feel like the the book?

[24:49] Eila Mell: I felt like it honored the book so much so that I wondered, is this taken directly from the book? There have, you know, are passages that sound like they really are from the book, which is wonderful because it was it it felt it really did feel like the book come to life on stage.

[25:07] Bruce Gotlieb: That's great.

[25:08] Matt Stashin: Without people just be, you know, reading it. I mean, because they were selling it, so they could have done that.

[25:12] Bruce Gotlieb: I know. Yeah, that you could buy it and if you go to the theater.

[25:16] Matt Stashin: No, I think it's a great version of The Outsiders. The author of the novel, Essie Hinton, obviously thinks so too, because she was there supporting it opening night. She's been part of this journey of this musical. Um, I think it's a great book. Uh yeah. What else can you say?

[25:31] Bruce Gotlieb: No, I thought it was really strong, a really effective storytelling, really well done. Um, you know, each of these shows kind of stand on their own.

[25:42] Matt Stashin: I know.

[25:43] Bruce Gotlieb: Um, and they're all so good. They're all so good. And this season, we keep saying it over and over again, but there's so many, like you depending on how you slice it, yeah.

[25:52] Matt Stashin: Right? Yeah.

[25:53] Bruce Gotlieb: Um, Shayna Taub was really busy doing the music and starring in Suffs, and did she slack off when it came to the book? Tell me about that.

[26:00] Matt Stashin: No. I actually, as much as I like the music, and we talked about that in our last episode. I actually think the great strength of this show is that book.

[26:09] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh, that's interesting.

[26:11] Matt Stashin: I I think she did a wonderful job of telling the story, and I know that they made changes from the original off-Broadway run to the Broadway run.

[26:19] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[26:19] Matt Stashin: Just restructuring it and really fixing a lot of things that didn't quite hit.

[26:25] Bruce Gotlieb: Mm-hmm.

[26:25] Matt Stashin: And the show is wonderful. They really they did a great job. Shayna Taub did a great job with it.

[26:31] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay. And what about Water for Elephants, Eila?

[26:34] Eila Mell: So I didn't read that and I didn't see the movie, but I did see the play. And it's I loved it. I so I'm not a circus person in real life. So I was like, believe it or not. So going in, I was like, well, this is a play about a circus, but I'm gonna be open-minded. I it took two seconds for me to be won over.

[26:55] Matt Stashin: Okay.

[26:56] Eila Mell: It's a great story. The book is really strong.

[26:59] Matt Stashin: That's Rick Ellis.

[27:00] Eila Mell: I mean, he wrote Jersey Boys. He's a veteran, he knows what he's doing.

[27:03] Matt Stashin: For sure.

[27:04] Eila Mell: Um it yeah, I mean, the story is really compelling. It's not obvious, it's not predictable. I hate when you just know what's gonna happen, and it's not that.

[27:14] Matt Stashin: Um the roles that were created are just so interesting, and there's a a lot of characters and everyone's got something substantial to do. I I just really really liked Water for Elephants.

[27:27] Bruce Gotlieb: You know, and what's interesting, I like I think about what you just said is that you don't want a story that's predictable.

[27:32] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[27:33] Bruce Gotlieb: But now you have Water for Elephants, The Notebook, and The Outsiders, all which are books into movies into a play.

[27:41] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[27:41] Bruce Gotlieb: And while you know what's gonna happen if you've either read or saw the movies, uh so for me, I I read The Notebook, I saw the movie, uh so I knew it was gonna happen, but the piece didn't feel predictable.

[27:57] Eila Mell: Because the way they do it is different.

[27:59] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. So I think that that's a testament to all three of those writers.

[28:02] Eila Mell: I do too. You know, right. It's like taking a drive, but you're taking a different route.

[28:06] Bruce Gotlieb: Exactly.

[28:06] Eila Mell: Like I know where I'm gonna end up, but I it still feels new, it still feels fresh.

[28:11] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, and it's exciting the whole way through. Did we miss any?

[28:15] Matt Stashin: No.

[28:15] Bruce Gotlieb: Any writers?

[28:16] Matt Stashin: I don't think so.

[28:17] Bruce Gotlieb: Alright. So who is going to win, Matt? Who is going to win?

[28:20] Matt Stashin: Who is going to win? I think it's going to be close. I think it's going to be Suffs.

[28:25] Eila Mell: Oh, okay.

[28:26] Matt Stashin: Shayna Taub. Yes. For the win. I do.

[28:29] Bruce Gotlieb: And I think it's going to be The Outsiders.

[28:36] Eila Mell: Okay.

[28:36] Bruce Gotlieb: And I think it has a lot of it's peaking at the right time. Um, I think it has a lot of momentum. I think uh honestly, this category it could go to anybody and it would be like, oh, I see why.

[28:49] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[28:50] Bruce Gotlieb: I know you say that a lot this year, though.

[28:52] Matt Stashin: Oh my god.

[28:52] Bruce Gotlieb: Because there's not a lot of people that are easy to eliminate this year.

[28:55] Matt Stashin: What do you think?

[28:56] Eila Mell: I think it's gonna be Christopher Diaz for Hell's Kitchen.

[28:59] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay. But who do we want to win? So tell us, who do you want?

[29:03] Matt Stashin: Um, I would like this to go to I think The Notebook.

[29:10] Eila Mell: That's Becca Brunsetter.

[29:12] Matt Stashin: That's mine too.

[29:12] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[29:13] Matt Stashin: It's actually mine also.

[29:14] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh we're all in agreement on that.

[29:18] Eila Mell: Or once our energy, maybe that'll push it over the top.

[29:22] Matt Stashin: Yeah, we'll manifest it.

[29:24] Bruce Gotlieb: So should we talk about scenic design of a play?

[29:26] Eila Mell: Why not?

[29:27] Eila Mell: All right. You know I love scenic design.

[29:30] Bruce Gotlieb: I know you do.

[29:31] Eila Mell: Your friend Derek McLean.

[29:33] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, we wrote a book together. And he's nominated for Pearly Victorious. So that's thrilling. And then he's the only one that's not double nominated in this category. So then we also have David Zinn for Ja Ja's African Hair Braiding and Stereophonic.

[29:45] Eila Mell: Yes.

[29:46] Bruce Gotlieb: And then we have Dots for Appropriate and An Enemy of the People.

[29:49] Eila Mell: So Dots is a collective. It's not like one person whose name is Dots.

[29:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. It's a few people designing together, just to point that out.

[29:58] Eila Mell: So now we've talked about it before. Do we think that these, you know, David Zinn and Dots, do they split the vote on each other?

[30:06] Bruce Gotlieb: No, I think in a design category, it's not as easy to cancel yourself out because the shows are usually so very different.

[30:14] Eila Mell: Right. I agree with that a hundred percent.

[30:16] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. So the scenic design for Appropriate, effective.

[30:21] Eila Mell: Very effective. You know, I will say without giving anything away because it is currently running. Other than at the end when something happens, there's some very obvious nature that happens. Basically, they make it very clear that there's a very long passage of time.

[30:39] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.

[30:40] Eila Mell: But aside from that, it's a house, right?

[30:42] Bruce Gotlieb: But it's a house.

[30:44] Eila Mell: Yeah, but you feel that you're in this house.

[30:47] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, you feel it there, it's done really, really well.

[30:50] Eila Mell: It is. You feel like you see the rooms that aren't on stage.

[30:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, a hundred percent.

[30:55] Eila Mell: You know, it's not like you just have this thing, but it's the way that they've done it, you know, different entry points that the cast uses throughout the show, from the windows to the front door to all the other rooms.

[31:07] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, and the mess that's there. It's done very effectively.

[31:10] Eila Mell: Yeah, I agree. You know, a set can be really, really amazing, yeah.

[31:17] Bruce Gotlieb: And like its own entity. Like for me, this season, something that's not in here, like The Cottage.

[31:24] Eila Mell: Yeah, with all like there's so much nuance in it.

[31:27] Bruce Gotlieb: Whereas Appropriate is, I dare I say, simple in comparison. You know, just because The Cottage, like there was so much detail.

[31:38] Eila Mell: There were, yeah, and but it needed to be.

[31:41] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, but I feel like Appropriate has that also. There's a lot.

[31:46] Eila Mell: Okay. I feel like there's a lot of real estate on stage, and like they use all of it.

[31:51] Bruce Gotlieb: Sure. Same with The Cottage. But to me, it's just different.

[31:55] Eila Mell: Yeah. And I just look at it as some of the traps that you needed to have in The Cottage, they had to be there. They had to be in your face.

[31:55] Bruce Gotlieb: They had to be in your face and hidden at the same time.

[32:07] Eila Mell: Right. Whereas Appropriate, everything is used, and everything is used to tell the story.

[32:14] Bruce Gotlieb: But yes, I know what you're saying. A lot of the laughs in The Cottage came from the actual set.

[32:18] Eila Mell: Right. Like things appearing and being at certain places in the set.

[32:21] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, I get it. So it's interesting, you know, when you see somebody obviously dive in to tell a story.

[32:27] Eila Mell: Right. You know, a lot of times when you walk in and you sit down in the theater, sometimes the set's right there, like Stereophonic.

[32:35] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, usually it is, and you have a half hour with this set.

[32:39] Eila Mell: Yeah, that's what's unique about set design because you get sort of this relationship with it for the half hour that you're there before the show starts.

[32:46] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[32:46] Eila Mell: That you don't with the other elements of the show.

[32:48] Bruce Gotlieb: Absolutely. So Appropriate was Dots, and they also have Enemy of the People. So they've done a lot of work this season.

[32:55] Eila Mell: They have. I mean, you know, two different sets, very different sets.

[32:58] Bruce Gotlieb: Very different. Enemy of the People is at Circle in the Square, which is in the round.

[33:02] Eila Mell: Right. You don't even have the same options in terms of design.

[33:05] Bruce Gotlieb: No, that affects how you tell the story to begin with.

[33:08] Eila Mell: Right. But you need like a, yeah, a 180-degree set.

[33:15] Bruce Gotlieb: 360.

[33:15] Eila Mell: 360, thank you.

[33:16] Bruce Gotlieb: You're welcome. I knew I was getting it wrong.

[33:19] Eila Mell: But yeah, so there's, yeah, so I mean, who knows? It could go either way.

[33:25] Bruce Gotlieb: If Dots is gonna get it at all.

[33:29] Eila Mell: Right. But then we have David Zinn. So you started to talk about Stereophonic, so let's talk about that set.

[33:36] Bruce Gotlieb: That's an amazing set.

[33:37] Eila Mell: That set is phenomenal because it has to include a working soundboard, right?

[33:42] Bruce Gotlieb: And so not only do you have a working, you have your recording studio side, then you have your sound engineering side, right? Plus like sort of living areas in the studio.

[33:53] Eila Mell: Right. The two of them have to be able to coexist like they do if you were to go to a recording studio.

[34:00] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. And you really do feel like you're at an actual studio where there are multiple rooms.

[34:04] Eila Mell: Yes.

[34:05] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. So I mean, it's, and not only do you have to be in a recording studio, but you have to be a recording studio in the 70s.

[34:14] Eila Mell: Right. Yes.

[34:15] Bruce Gotlieb: So yeah, so there's a lot of, you know, the color, like the browns, and you know, but also the equipment.

[34:21] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[34:21] Bruce Gotlieb: The equipment has, you know, you can't have modern-day equipment in there.

[34:25] Eila Mell: No, but does the equipment do a lot of the job itself, having the right equipment?

[34:29] Bruce Gotlieb: To me it does because I think if I was looking at it and it had modern-day equipment that was just in a 70s vibe or aesthetic, I think I would, yeah, I wouldn't be as taken by it.

[34:41] Eila Mell: Yeah, right. The one thing I will say, Stereophonic, of the three of us, I think I was the least enthralled by it.

[34:49] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, you looked mad when we left.

[34:51] Eila Mell: But I will tell you the set I thought was amazing.

[34:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, yeah, it really was.

[34:56] Eila Mell: So then David's other show is Ja Ja's African Hair Braiding, which is another really outstanding set.

[35:04] Bruce Gotlieb: So I mean, it's like you can't even compare one to the other, but they're both really incredible.

[35:11] Eila Mell: But you really get a sense of that hair salon and the neighborhood you're in, even from being inside it, you still get a feel of the outside.

[35:22] Bruce Gotlieb: I mean, it does take you outside here and there.

[35:24] Eila Mell: No, but you do. You have to feel like you're in that world.

[35:28] Bruce Gotlieb: Right? Like just like Stereophonic, you have to feel like you're in the world of, you know, 1970s if you were in a recording studio.

[35:36] Eila Mell: Right. You feel like you're in a hair salon.

[35:38] Bruce Gotlieb: And you do, and it's not like the Steel Magnolias hair salon, it's a very different hair salon.

[35:43] Eila Mell: You know, it's specific to that, and of course, that's what it has to be, so that's what it is. But it's just, it's so well done.

[35:49] Bruce Gotlieb: So I mean, I don't know. But then Derek comes in with this Pearly Victorious, which has more sets than like Ja Ja, which has, you know, maybe one or two locations.

[36:01] Eila Mell: Stereophonic with its one unit set. Appropriate with one.

[36:05] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. So Pearly Victorious has multiple locations.

[36:09] Eila Mell: Yes.

[36:10] Bruce Gotlieb: And it's fluid. So you don't feel like, you know, you sometimes see a show and they're moving stuff on and off.

[36:16] Eila Mell: Right.

[36:16] Bruce Gotlieb: This is, it kind of just flows from one into the next.

[36:21] Eila Mell: Yeah. With really just, mm-hmm, if you will.

[36:25] Bruce Gotlieb: And then at the end, you know, the show closed, so I'm not giving anything away. But the entire set before your eyes transforms. Like the ceiling lifts, and it becomes a church.

[36:38] Eila Mell: And it's really so, like the audience gasped when it happened.

[36:41] Bruce Gotlieb: And to, you know, to do what he did that way, yeah, is just, it really takes you, it takes your breath away.

[36:50] Eila Mell: It did. It was a moment.

[36:52] Bruce Gotlieb: A hundred percent. And you know, like when does the set get a moment in shows?

[36:55] Eila Mell: Right. Not that often, but this was a real moment, and it took you from, but it wasn't just about the set. It was about, you know, it was taking you from, there was a time, like a little bit of a time lapse.

[37:07] Bruce Gotlieb: So because they had to build this church, right? So it really built it. You saw, you know, the action of the play sort of in this scene change.

[37:14] Eila Mell: Right. Does that make sense?

[37:16] Bruce Gotlieb: Perfectly.

[37:17] Eila Mell: Okay. All right. So what do you think will win?

[37:21] Bruce Gotlieb: Stereophonic.

[37:22] Eila Mell: I like how you ask will win every single time when it's just making sure I understand the question.

[37:27] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, you know. So yeah, I think it would be tough to beat Stereophonic this year. It just seems to be the show.

[37:35] Eila Mell: Yeah. So I think that is gonna take the best scenic design. How about you, Bruce?

[37:40] Bruce Gotlieb: I think so too. Now, what do you want to win?

[37:42] Eila Mell: Um, I want Derek to win for Pearly Victorious. Just the, like I said, that reveal alone at the end is, I just, the way it was done, and it was just really, really, really great.

[37:56] Matt Stashin: My actual want isn't even on the list.

[38:01] Eila Mell: What was that?

[38:01] Matt Stashin: Greyhouse.

[38:03] Eila Mell: Oh, that was, I can't believe that didn't get nominated.

[38:05] Matt Stashin: So that was Scott Pass. That was a really good set.

[38:09] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[38:10] Matt Stashin: That was a little bit of a snub. Even though Scott is a Tony winner.

[38:15] Eila Mell: But that set just was so effective at creating the weed of the entire planet.

[38:19] Matt Stashin: No, you're completely right about that. So what's your want of this list though? I'm putting your feet to the fire.

[38:24] Eila Mell: Oh, f okay, fine. Do that. Um, Stereophonic. I think Stereophonic was the best out of the five, yeah.

[38:30] Matt Stashin: Okay, and I want Pearly Victorious to win. I think that it really told the story in a very effective way and different from, you know, a lot of other shows.

[38:42] Bruce Gotlieb: Sure. So that's my want. But we're not done yet, are we?

[38:47] Eila Mell: We can't be.

[38:49] Bruce Gotlieb: We still have to do Best Revival of a Play.

[38:52] Eila Mell: Let's take a minute to hear a word from our sponsors.

[38:59] Bruce Gotlieb: We still have to do Best Revival of a Play.

[39:01] Eila Mell: Oh my gosh. Well, that's a big category.

[39:04] Bruce Gotlieb: All right. What are the nominees?

[39:06] Eila Mell: Best Revival of a Play. We have just three.

[39:10] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.

[39:11] Eila Mell: We have Appropriate, An Enemy of the People, and Pearly Victorious.

[39:16] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh boy. See?

[39:18] Eila Mell: I know, it's hard.

[39:19] Bruce Gotlieb: All right. So let's start with Appropriate.

[39:22] Eila Mell: I loved Appropriate.

[39:23] Bruce Gotlieb: So did I. I just, I didn't know what I was going in to see. And it just grabbed me from the second it started.

[39:32] Eila Mell: Those cicadas got me.

[39:35] Bruce Gotlieb: They're very effective storytellers.

[39:36] Eila Mell: I know. They really are. No, I love this show.

[39:40] Bruce Gotlieb: Um, Eila.

[39:41] Eila Mell: I thought it was really good. I thought that, you know, it kept you on your toes a little bit.

[39:47] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[39:48] Eila Mell: You weren't sure exactly where were we going, where are we going? Who has the map?

[39:52] Bruce Gotlieb: I know. But um, you know, everything worked with each other. It was exciting. It was a good idea.

[39:58] Eila Mell: Yeah, the acting, the sound, the lighting. Everything, yeah, you know, it just one couldn't happen without the other.

[40:05] Bruce Gotlieb: It took you on a real journey.

[40:06] Eila Mell: Right, for sure. You know, and I appreciate it. One that kept you guessing of where it was going.

[40:10] Bruce Gotlieb: I know. It wasn't obvious how it was gonna end.

[40:13] Eila Mell: Yeah. I don't think any of us saw that coming.

[40:16] Bruce Gotlieb: That ending, no, absolutely not.

[40:18] Eila Mell: No, for sure. Um, and then Enemy of the People. Anyone have thoughts?

[40:21] Bruce Gotlieb: You know, again, I've seen many versions of Enemy of the People. I think this is a great way to tell Enemy of the People, right? There's a translation by Amy Herzog. It's got Jeremy Strong, it's got Michael Imperioli, Victoria Pedretti. You know, so I don't think it gets better.

[40:41] Eila Mell: It's not one of my favorite plays.

[40:43] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. Just as a play itself.

[40:45] Eila Mell: No, and it's good.

[40:47] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes. It's good, but it's almost like, you know, these other plays, in my opinion, just a level up.

[40:58] Eila Mell: I just, more fun and more, yeah.

[41:01] Matt Stashin: I would agree with that. You know, no, not to take anything away from it.

[41:04] Eila Mell: No, because again, let's beat a dead horse in any other season.

[41:09] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. And it's subjective too.

[41:11] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[41:12] Matt Stashin: Enemy of the People is a show for me at least. It's a show that I was always, I appreciated it more than I liked it.

[41:18] Eila Mell: Right, yeah.

[41:19] Matt Stashin: Like it's probably more fun to work on it than to watch it.

[41:22] Eila Mell: Amy Herzog, though, made it a much more enjoyable experience to watch than I'd really ever seen before.

[41:29] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[41:30] Eila Mell: Okay. Same with Uncle Vanya. Heidi Shrek did that translation, and she's, you know, I know you love her, Matt. And she's wonderful. I mean, this is a great translation of it, I think.

[41:41] Bruce Gotlieb: And then of course Pearly Victorious.

[41:44] Eila Mell: Which we all loved.

[41:45] Bruce Gotlieb: Loved it.

[41:46] Eila Mell: I didn't know what the story was going to be going in. I knew it was going to be good because it was written by Ossie Davis, directed by Kenny Leon. So I just knew we were in for fun.

[41:55] Bruce Gotlieb: A treat.

[41:56] Eila Mell: Absolutely. But it's hilarious. It's so much fun.

[41:59] Bruce Gotlieb: It takes you on a ride.

[42:02] Eila Mell: Yeah, you have ends and flows, right? You have the fun, you have a little humor, you have seriousness.

[42:06] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[42:07] Eila Mell: Um, it's not just funny, it's hilarious. And you, you know, when you have a show that kind of breathes for you.

[42:15] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, which is good.

[42:17] Eila Mell: Oh my gosh, yeah. I actually saw it twice, and I didn't get bored at all the second time.

[42:21] Bruce Gotlieb: You know, sometimes if you've seen it, as good as a show is, you know, that's, you're not normally, you don't normally see something more than, I almost never do, but this was so great.

[42:31] Eila Mell: It's the kind of thing where you want to bring people who haven't seen it to see it. It's that you get that enthusiastic over it.

[42:35] Bruce Gotlieb: So all right. Well, Matt, yes, what will win?

[42:41] Matt Stashin: Should I do it again?

[42:42] Eila Mell: No.

[42:44] Matt Stashin: Take away my moment.

[42:45] Bruce Gotlieb: Um, will win is Appropriate.

[42:48] Eila Mell: I think it will too.

[42:49] Matt Stashin: I do, you I think so.

[42:52] Eila Mell: Okay, it's hard, it's a hard category this year.

[42:55] Bruce Gotlieb: What do you think?

[42:56] Eila Mell: I agree. I agree.

[42:57] Matt Stashin: Oh, do you want Appropriate to win?

[43:00] Eila Mell: I honestly do. I think I do too.

[43:03] Bruce Gotlieb: As much as I love Pearly Victorious, it's really hard.

[43:08] Eila Mell: I want Pearly Victorious.

[43:09] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay, all right. Good. I'm glad somebody said Pearly Victorious because I'm that torn.

[43:14] Eila Mell: Oh well, next time we could ask you and see if that's changed.

[43:17] Bruce Gotlieb: It probably will change because it's, you know, that's what we get in an hour, see if it changes.

[43:22] Eila Mell: We have three more weeks, three more weeks of special episodes.

[43:22] Bruce Gotlieb: Of special episodes of dissecting, deep diving, of being professional know-it-alls.

[43:36] Eila Mell: We really know nothing.

[43:38] Bruce Gotlieb: Um, but we want to hear what you think is gonna win.

[43:41] Eila Mell: Yeah, so let us know your thoughts, your subs. Message us on Instagram behind the awards, and we'll include it in an upcoming episode.

[43:50] Bruce Gotlieb: We'll talk about what you guys think because that's important to us.

[43:53] Eila Mell: Yeah, all right. So that's it for today. Thank you for joining us, Matt.

[43:58] Matt Stashin: Thank you.

[43:58] Eila Mell: All right, come back next time.

[44:00] Matt Stashin: I will.

[44:01] Eila Mell: And we will see you then on Behind the Awards.

[44:04] All: Bye-bye.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred