Take a sharp left at Avenue Q and that’s how you get to Sesame Street! John Tartaglia’s journey from a 16 year old puppeteer on Sesame Street to originating the first ever puppet sex scene on Broadway... Read More
From the show: Behind the Awards with Eila Mell & Bruce Gotlieb
Guests
Featured Shows
About
Take a sharp left at Avenue Q and that’s how you get to Sesame Street!
John Tartaglia’s journey from a 16 year old puppeteer on Sesame Street to originating the first ever puppet sex scene on Broadway. John talks about the new season of Fraggle Rock on Apple TV and his full circle experience with Jim Henson.
Also in this episode - Jackee Harry’s historic Emmy win in 1987 when she became the first Black Actress to win Best Supporting Actress in a Comedy Series for 227.
Eila & Bruce discuss seeing Lempicka during previews and its new ending debut.
At the age of 16, John Tartaglia began his professional career as a puppeteer for Sesame Street. He earned a Tony award nomination for his Broadway debut in the dual roles of Princeton and Rod in Avenue Q". Other Broadway roles include Lumiere in Disney’s Beauty and the Beast and originating Pinocchio and the Magic Mirror in Shrek the Musical. John went on to create, executive produce and star in his own preschool series Johnny and the Sprites, for Disney Junior, nominated for 8 Emmy awards, including a nomination for “Outstanding Performance in a Children’s Series” followed by creating the acclaimed Off-Broadway and international touring musical "ImaginOcean" that was re-imagined for television on PBS Kids called "Jim Henson's Splash and Bubbles” (Creator, Co-Executive Producer and starring as "Splash"). John also stars as Kip the Wallaby on Jim Henson's Word Party and as Hank in Julie’s Greenroom(starring Dame Julie Andrews) both on NETFLIX.
John’s theatrical directing credits include both Stephen Schwartz's The Secret Silk and Jim Henson's Inspired Silliness for Princess Cruises, Kinky Boots(3d Theatricals), Disney's Beauty and the Beast (Maltz Jupiter Theater), Claudio Quest(NY Musical Theatre Festival- Winning 6 awards including "Best in Fest” and Best Director), Shrek The Halls(Dreamworks Theatricals), Because of Winn Dixie (Arkansas Rep and Goodspeed Operahouse development) and Jim Henson’s Musical World (Carnegie Hall).
Most recently, he finished filming the second season of the EMMY winning Fraggle Rock: Back to the Rock where he performs Gobo Fraggle, Architect Doozer, Gunge, Barry Blueberry and Sprocket the Dog as well as serving as an executive producer, writer and puppet captain.
John has worked many summer seasons at the country's award- winning oldest outdoor theater, the St Louis MUNY, directing such shows as Shrek the Musical, The Wizard of Oz, Tarzan, Annie, Matilda, Mary Poppins and most recently Disney's Beauty and the Beast. the national tours of Jim Henson’s Dinosaur Train Live and Jim Henson’s Sid the Science Kid Live! as well as several shows for Sesame Place, PA.
John can be heard every Sunday on Sirius XM On Broadway on his show “Sunday Funday with John Tartaglia.”
Make sure to check out Eila's book, "The Tony Awards", and all her other amazing books: https://amzn.to/43WMu5Y.
Connect with Eila and Bruce:
- Instagram @behind_the_awards
- Eila @eilamell
- Bruce @cominghomewithbruce
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] John Tartaglia: Oh gosh, thank you so much. Thank you, Goth. Thank you, Mama. Even though you're not here with me. Thank you, my dearest sister and best friend. Thank you, my brothers Miles, Rufus, and Anthony. Thank you, all my family. Thank you, 227 Cass, and especially Marla Gibbs for being so gracious to me. Thank you, producers Ron Bloomberg. Thank you, writers, Richard and Tracy and Dick and Jack, and thank you, Steven. And I wonder if I get paid more mummy for this. Thank you.
[0:38] Eila Mell: Hello and welcome to Behind the Awards. How's everyone doing today? I'm Eila. This is Bruce. And how amazing is Jackee Harry?
[0:48] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, 227, uh best supporting actress.
[0:52] Eila Mell: 1987, you said?
[0:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Correct. That was her Emmy win. And it was fabulous. Now, are we still going with Jackee, or is it Jackee Harry now?
[1:02] Eila Mell: I thought she brought the Harry back.
[1:04] Bruce Gotlieb: I thought she did, but I mean, I'd have to call her and ask, but I feel like it's interchangeable.
[1:10] Eila Mell: It could be. I did look up her IMDB and it had the Harry attached.
[1:15] Bruce Gotlieb: So I don't know what's happening. We're gonna have to try to get her on the show.
[1:18] Eila Mell: We will, and that way we can properly credit her.
[1:21] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, because we have these deep questions that we need the answers to.
[1:25] Eila Mell: Very much so. And I love that when she got up there to do her acceptance speech, you know, it was partially in regular voice and then partially in her character voice.
[1:32] Bruce Gotlieb: Sandra.
[1:33] Eila Mell: Yes. Oh my god. How amazing was Sandra Clark?
[1:36] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, hello, everybody. So Bruce and I went to the theater the other night.
[1:42] Eila Mell: Yes, we were going to see...
[1:44] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh, it's early on in preview still, but uh Lempica.
[1:47] Eila Mell: Yeah, we saw Lempica in previews. Now, we heard a lot about it before we went in.
[1:53] Bruce Gotlieb: We did, trying to keep an open mind and not be swayed positively, negatively. Keep level of expectation very minimal.
[2:02] Eila Mell: That's right. There were some posts that we saw that you know, people were not loving it, but we went in wanting to like it.
[2:08] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, I did. I don't know about Bruce, he's pretty bitter.
[2:12] Eila Mell: I was bitter more when we stood outside for a half hour before you opened the doors.
[2:17] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. So we had a mishap. So first of all, the city was crazy that night because apparently Shakira was doing a concert in Times Square.
[2:24] Eila Mell: Had no idea.
[2:25] Bruce Gotlieb: So um some of the streets were shut down. You couldn't even cross. The police were letting people cross only like here and there. It was a big mess to even get to the theater.
[2:37] Eila Mell: Right. And now we're standing there. It's just about 7:30, and nothing's happening.
[2:42] Bruce Gotlieb: No, no one's going in the theater. And there's a long line behind us.
[2:46] Eila Mell: Yes, and people are not happy.
[2:47] Bruce Gotlieb: No. And there's some construction going on. So this little uh I'll call it an alleyway that now the sidewalk is turned into.
[2:56] Eila Mell: Right. Where you have a line of people and then people trying to go in both ways walking by. So nobody's happy at all.
[3:04] Bruce Gotlieb: It was a mess, yeah. And then there were people extended into the street, which they the ushers were trying, not the ushers, the security.
[3:11] Eila Mell: Yeah, they were trying to discourage that, but it didn't work. Um, but they wanted us in a line in single file. It was it was a whole to-do. Anyway, they made an announcement that the show would not, but they wouldn't even let people in the theater till about 8:30.
[3:25] Bruce Gotlieb: So we weren't happy about that. And and they all they said was um was that they didn't give any reasons.
[3:32] Eila Mell: No, but I asked, I said, Well, can you tell us why that is? And he said, technical difficulties.
[3:39] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. So we all know that's code for we're not telling you the reason.
[3:42] Eila Mell: Correct. And then then online itself, people, there's speculations galore.
[3:46] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh, really?
[3:47] Eila Mell: I heard people saying, Oh, I bet Eden's sick and she can't go on.
[3:51] Bruce Gotlieb: I don't know why they're not. She was there. That was not the truth.
[3:53] Eila Mell: Yeah. So and then even when we got uh out, and then I started looking just to see what what if the internet said anything, yeah, nobody was talking about it.
[4:03] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay, well, it was early then, I guess. I did look again today, and there's been now two rumors going on on this message board.
[4:11] Eila Mell: What are the rumors?
[4:12] Bruce Gotlieb: One of them is that there was a sound issue.
[4:14] Eila Mell: Okay.
[4:15] Bruce Gotlieb: That was being rectified. And then the other rumor was that there which is true, there was somebody who was making their swing debut.
[4:23] Eila Mell: Yes.
[4:23] Bruce Gotlieb: So the speculation is that that person needed some more rehearsal time.
[4:28] Eila Mell: Okay.
[4:28] Bruce Gotlieb: And that's why we were delayed. We don't know. But to their credit, they got us in the theater well before 8:30.
[4:35] Eila Mell: They did. It really was not a big deal at all. Maybe they opened the doors at 8.
[4:39] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, I think the show started at 8:30.
[4:42] Eila Mell: Yeah. So it was just a little late. That's all. It was not a big deal.
[4:44] Bruce Gotlieb: So that was fine. No, not a big deal.
[4:47] Eila Mell: So okay. I was so excited when I bought tickets to this show because I, you know, I heard it was going to be great. And then, you know, then people started seeing it and saying that it wasn't so great. But I personally did not see what all the talk was about.
[5:02] Bruce Gotlieb: I didn't think it was a terrible show at all. I mean, the way that only a couple of people were saying But they were scathing.
[5:10] Eila Mell: Exactly. The r, you know, the first hand reviews were so bad from these few people. Maybe they had some personal vendetta against the show. But I I mean I that didn't pan out for me. I thought it was fine. What did you think?
[5:23] Bruce Gotlieb: I did think it was okay. I I've I've certainly I I've seen better. I've seen uh probably maybe worse. Um but it it was seen worse this season. It was not my favorite show.
[5:38] Eila Mell: Yeah. Um I do see um some of where people were speaking of maybe not to the gravitas that they were, but you know, I did see some things that I was like, uh okay, but it's still in previews as of this recording.
[5:53] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, and and also from what somebody I know who saw it and was telling us about it up to when we saw it, that night that we saw it was they changed the ending.
[6:04] Eila Mell: Yeah, they put in a new ending the night that we were there. And I thought the ending was beautiful, actually. I actually think the ending worked and far more better than what was described to me.
[6:13] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh, they told you?
[6:14] Eila Mell: Uh just the original ending. Not nothing really that I would be able to speak on, but just that it didn't work.
[6:21] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay. Well, this worked very well. It was actually the one of the highlights of the show.
[6:26] Eila Mell: I think so. Uh you know, the show's a little slow. I still don't know. Do I do I care about Lempica as you know, like a story? You know, sometimes you get these ideas or or these things come to be, and you wonder, is it do is it does that person have enough to tell?
[6:43] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. Yeah, I know what you mean.
[6:46] Eila Mell: Right. Sometimes a person them, you know, uh themselves is fascinating, but their story, you know, without them being there, sure having the actual person might not be as compelling as you think.
[6:58] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. I don't know. I I definitely liked the show more than you did. For sure.
[7:06] Eila Mell: And the other person that we went with also. It felt a little long to me. Um, but that could also just be because I wasn't as captivated.
[7:14] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, it didn't feel long to me. So who knows? And listen, I will say, when we were leaving the theater, people were buzzing galore.
[7:21] Eila Mell: Oh, well, what about the woman sitting next to me?
[7:23] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh, she was rocking out. She was doing like she was air drumming to the music. Throughout the whole show.
[7:28] Eila Mell: Well, she came in with a big poster that she bought.
[7:30] Bruce Gotlieb: She did. At the theater. Now listen, when I when I go to the theater, I do I do like a merch. You know that.
[7:36] Eila Mell: Well, there are two things that you look for. The magnet for our magnet wall and the Sippy Cup for our Sippy Cup wall.
[7:43] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes. Now Bruce is saying our, but he and I don't actually live together and aren't together constantly, although it might feel that way.
[7:50] Eila Mell: So when I'm going to a show, unless something tr you know intrigues me, like a shirt with like a funny saying or something like that. I normally reserve any other purchases for after.
[8:01] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.
[8:01] Eila Mell: Oh, really? How do I like how do I know I'm gonna want to make it?
[8:05] Bruce Gotlieb: So even if there's like a great shirt, you don't like the show, you don't you're not about the shirt.
[8:09] Eila Mell: Unless I'm so unless the shirt grabs me, I will buy it beforehand.
[8:13] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay. Well, Bruce But then I will wait until I.
[8:15] Eila Mell: Bruce has a rule about shirts in general that he will only buy them if they have a curse word on the shirt.
[8:21] Bruce Gotlieb: It seems to me for some reason I have I do. Or a bad word somehow.
[8:25] Eila Mell: Yeah. Which I think is a pretty great rule. You know, it gives a little flair.
[8:31] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes. Do you see any any award, you know, nominations or anything coming from it?
[8:37] Eila Mell: You know, I think that the role, the lead role, is ripe for a nomination. I mean, I don't know if she's going to get it just because there's so there are so many shows opening and there's so many great performances. This season is like palpable with the energy and the buzz. It's it's amazing.
[8:55] Bruce Gotlieb: Which I love so much.
[8:57] Eila Mell: It's so good. I know. Um but I wouldn't be surprised if Eden Espinoza got nominated. My personal favorite was Andrew Samanski.
[9:06] Bruce Gotlieb: Sure.
[9:07] Eila Mell: I would love to see him get a nomination. Uh who knows if he will. There's so many people again.
[9:11] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. And I I will say the set was a highlight for me.
[9:15] Eila Mell: Yeah, the set by Ricardo Hernandez was really great. The art deco was cool and just the way it it flowed really well.
[9:21] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes. And then the lighting by Bradley King, there were points where it the light swept across the stage like paint. It was really beautiful.
[9:30] Eila Mell: It was. It was beautiful. Bradley is a great designer. He did Fat Ham, which I just I love that show. And the lighting especially made that show so exciting.
[9:38] Bruce Gotlieb: Might have to reach out to him too.
[9:39] Eila Mell: So yeah, well, you know, he's in my Tony book.
[9:42] Bruce Gotlieb: Tony winner Bradley King.
[9:44] Eila Mell: Well, your Tony book is coming out soon too.
[9:46] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm so excited about that.
[9:48] Eila Mell: It's coming out. Well, it's just out, actually. April 16th was a good one.
[9:52] Bruce Gotlieb: That's right. So by the time this airs, it will have been out.
[9:55] Eila Mell: It will be out, yeah. So everybody should run and grab it. And it's called the Tony Awards. And it is, I guess it's it's uh springboard was for the 75th.
[10:06] Bruce Gotlieb: That's right. So yeah, it was a way to celebrate 75 years of Tony winners. That's why we wanted to do it. So I worked with the American Theater Wing on it. So that was why we did it. But then we were able to include the 76th annual.
[10:19] Bruce Gotlieb: So cool.
[10:20] Eila Mell: Yeah. So we have, you know, winners like Brandon Uranowitz and Miriam Silverman and Bonnie Milligan. So that was fun. Jay Harrison G.
[10:30] Bruce Gotlieb: Absolutely. Alex Newell.
[10:31] Eila Mell: So yeah. She got the new class with the old guard.
[10:34] Bruce Gotlieb: Exactly. So I yeah. And maybe we can, you know, entice some of them to come join us and talk about it a little bit.
[10:42] Eila Mell: Absolutely. Maybe we'll start with Miriam.
[10:46] Bruce Gotlieb: There you go. That's a good idea. Because she was so amazing in the sign in Sidney Brewstein's window.
[10:50] Eila Mell: So much fun. I know. But let's talk about John Tartaglia.
[10:55] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, he's our guest today. I mean, he's great. So if you have kids, you know him. If you're a theater fan, you know him. The thing that is so impressive to me was that he started on Sesame Street as a puppeteer at age 16.
[11:10] Eila Mell: Yes. I didn't realize that one could even do that, right?
[11:14] Bruce Gotlieb: And to this day, he's still one of the youngest puppeteers to have been a company member for Sesame Street.
[11:22] Eila Mell: That's amazing, really. Like, how does a kid get that job? Do you just write a letter?
[11:26] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, we'll ask him.
[11:27] Eila Mell: We'll have to, because I feel like it's something that like it just had to be like ingrained in him, right? Like this is something he took a passion to, a liking to, and he's now parlayed this into an amazing career.
[11:43] Bruce Gotlieb: Absolutely. Tony award-winning Avenue Q.
[11:46] Eila Mell: Yeah. And he, you know, went on to do um Shrek. He did puppeteering with.
[11:51] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. And you said he was in Beauty and the Beast.
[11:53] Eila Mell: Yes, he was a replacement for Lumiere.
[11:55] Bruce Gotlieb: Amazing.
[11:56] Eila Mell: Which is such a great role. And it's almost like he became a puppet himself, right? He became this object.
[12:02] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, right.
[12:03] Eila Mell: Which is amazing. Yeah. And he's a great singer. And well, anyway, let's let's get him on. Instead of us talking about him, let's just chat with him.
[12:12] Bruce Gotlieb: John Tartaglia, welcome to Behind the Awards.
[12:16] John Tartaglia: Thank you. Thank you for having me.
[12:18] Eila Mell: It's so exciting to have you here. I mean, I think that you probably realize that when you work in children's television, you have a place in people's hearts like no one else.
[12:28] John Tartaglia: It's true. I mean, we we like to think that we make things that have such an impact. And so I I feel like everyone's got the I call it the Fraggle face, especially when people love Fraggle Rock. They're like, oh, like their whole face comes alive. So it's it's it's a it's an honor. It really is.
[12:43] Eila Mell: And you're also there then for a long period of time because we always remember, you know, what we grew up with, and if it still remains current, or even just to draw on the memory when you're having conversations, it's still it's still there.
[12:56] John Tartaglia: That's so true. I mean, you know, I can't tell you what I binged two years ago, and I can't tell you like what what I was watching on TV 10 years ago, really, but I can certainly tell you everything about like my favorite childhood television shows. So I feel like they uh they really affect us and they like have that impact that we I think we carry with us.
[13:09] Eila Mell: I really do.
[13:16] John Tartaglia: A hundred percent.
[13:18] Eila Mell: So our childhood, it's kind of like that.
[13:20] John Tartaglia: Yeah, I mean it's it's when we're at our most, I guess our highest rate of absorption, right? And we're taking in the world and we're trying to understand it, we're trying to understand the people involved with it. And so I think, yeah, I think it I think it it it's more um impactful than maybe it is late in our later years where we learn to be super resilient and block everything out.
[13:37] Eila Mell: So yeah, right.
[13:40] John Tartaglia: So this is a show about award winners, and you are an award winner and a nominee and you know, all those wonderful things. Um, so I I just want to start in by talking about Avenue Q, but of course there's so much to talk about because like today we can all start binging Fraggle Rock back to the Rock season two.
[14:01] Eila Mell: Yeah, season two.
[14:02] John Tartaglia: Yes, adults too should watch it.
[14:04] Eila Mell: I think everybody. But let's talk about Avenue Q. How did that project come to you?
[14:09] John Tartaglia: I was working at Sesame Street as a puppeteer, and and um, when I, you know, Sesame Street at that time, I don't I can't even I don't now I think it shoots a much shorter time, but at the time it shot about five months out of the year, four to five months out of the year. And so there was a you know a big chunk of my year that wasn't taken up by it. And so I was always out doing musical theater. I was doing, you know, theater works tour, and I was doing off off Broadway shows, and I was doing, you know, anything I could do because I I had this dual passion for both puppetry and for performing. And um, and I they knew that people knew that they were at the show, and I would do a lot of like the singing pieces and and stuff like that on the show. And um, Jeff Marks, who's one of the co-composers of Avenue Q was an intern in the music department on Sesame Street, and as he tells it, was famously horrible as an intern and got fired.
[14:57] John Tartaglia: And so eventually he and Bobby Lopez met doing BMI and had this idea to do this like adult Sesame Street kind of show. And they were gonna do a presentation of it. At the time it was not gonna be, it was not thought of to be a stage show. It was gonna be like an adult television series for like Comedy Central or something like that. But they wanted to present it, you know, and just put it on feed and see what people thought of it. So at the time it was like five songs and four sketches, about four out of the five songs were still in the show. And they asked if I would do this reading because they knew that I did musical theater and of course was a puppeteer. And I always tell the story that it's true.
I had plans that night was just to work like a catering gig or something that night. And you know, my gut instinct at first was to be like, oh, I probably should do the paying job, not the free random reading of some show. But some little voice inside of me was like, do this, say yes, do this. So I did it, and of course, my life changed. So I always say to people, like, listen to that little voice, no matter how quiet it is, it's probably telling you the right thing. Um, and yeah, and it started off as a reading and the reaction in the we did it at the York theater and the reaction was like explosive. I mean, I've never felt anything like that before. And that night our future producers happened to be in the audience, and they were like, this has to be a theater piece.
[16:21] John Tartaglia: Yeah. Right, Democrat Seller, Kevin, McCollum, and Robin. That's right. Yeah. And I think I think I don't know if all three of them are there, but I know at least one of them was there. And they approached Bobby and Jeff and they're like, this needs to be a theater piece. This is a theater piece. And people loved, you know, we had the puppets kind of up like this, doing what we do. And at the time, especially, it was like people just didn't understand how we puppeteer, well, how that works. And so part of the allure and part of what made them say this has to be a theater piece, is it was so interesting to watch how we did it. So that's how it all started. And then we did readings, we did workshops and development, and then you know, fast forward a couple of years and we're off Broadway, and it just took off from there.
So it was just such an unexpected thing. And I always say I was ready at any moment to be replaced. I was like, I know how this business works, and they are not gonna take this unknown 24, 25-year-old kid that has no major theater credits on his resume. They're not even off Broadway. I was like, they're not gonna use me. And then it was like, I always would joke, I'd be like, bring in Neil Patrick Harris, bring in Anthony Rapp, bring in Joey Fatone, because they had all had some sort of puppetry experience. But no, they stuck with me, and I was so grateful that they did.
[17:31] John Tartaglia: That is pretty amazing. But you're you were the expert. There was a lot of puppetry in the show. I mean, they needed someone who it was second nature to me. I think, I mean, literally, I always say to people, it's the gift that I didn't realize would give me my theatrical career, right? Like, I mean, if you had told me when I was a kid that like being a puppeteer is what's gonna give you an extra skill set to be in a Broadway show, I would have been like, are you crazy? Like I just, you know, it's it how did before that show? I mean, you had the Lion King, but even then the puppets were kind of like gorgeous tools to tell the story, which you could argue the Avenue Q puppets are, but I mean there's part of the fascination is watching the puppetry of Avenue Q. That you know traditional Henson style. So yeah, it was just this unexpected thing. I never pictured it would happen like that.
[18:17] John Tartaglia: Right, because the odds are on your resume as an actor, you list special skills and how often you actually called on to use them. And lucky for you, this parlayed itself into everything that your career's been. So that's pretty funny. To your point, it was always like the interesting thing people like see at my special skills and be like, oh, you're a puppeteer. But it's that's not gonna work out when I'm doing a production of Bye Bye Birdie somewhere. You know what I mean? Like, like they're not gonna you know what I mean? So it was kind of like, yeah. I mean Albert is a puppet, who knows? Maybe there's a future, but yeah, it's just it was such a blend of everything I love to do in a role that was really written for me in many ways.
So it's just it's like a dream. So I was gonna be like, I was like, put me in, I'll be like tree number seven in the Lion King in the back. I'd be thrilled about that. Like I just wanted to be on Broadway. I never thought I would be holding Princeton and Rod, you know.
[19:07] John Tartaglia: Right. But you know, the puppets and the Lion King, the puppeteers blend into those and in Avenue Q, you know, you're side by side. And yet the audience just sees you as one entity. It's so interesting how it works. You know, I give so much of the credit to that to Jason Moore, our director, because you know, he really helped us find that. It was such a, it was a it was a real challenge, honestly, to figure out the balance of like, you know, as puppeteers, you never see us, right? So part of the reason Stephanie and myself and Jen and Rick were selected as the original performance puppeteers is because we had enough, I guess, charisma as people on stage with the puppets that we were interesting to watch, I suppose.
And we all had some theater training and some, you know, Stephanie did theater, Jen did theater, Rick did theater, I did theater. So we had that like chutzpah, I guess, to be on stage with the puppet. But Jason really helped us find like this moment's about just the puppet, this moment's with you and the puppet, this moment actually you need to drive it because we're not sure how we can get this across with the puppet. And the way that the spotlight would sometimes be equal on both of us, and sometimes it would just be the puppet. So I mean, that was really his vision, which I think really helped make the show what it is.
[20:13] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, that was actually my next question. How much are you acting with the puppet? Because you know, obviously you're acting as the puppet, but how much are you, John, who we can see acting on?
[20:25] John Tartaglia: Well, and sometimes, you know, it was and it was a it was like a like a healthy ego check of sometimes like Jason would come up and be like, it can't be about you right now. You know what I mean? And it would be like, okay. Because of course the musical theater performer in me was living and loving every minute of it. And then he'd be like, you're amazing, we love it, but it's really gotta be about Rod. It can't be about you, you know. So it was again, it was just finding that balance of like, you know, like the like the um, I think the moments where you you'll notice they brought the spotlight out were really in the really deep emotional sections, like when Princeton breaks up with Kate, or when you know, Rod has his revelation that he's in love with Nikki.
You know, those are big, like it's important that those moments land for the audience, otherwise you don't really carry through the rest of the night. And it was smart to be able to have give the audience the opportunity to go back and forth between our the puppet and our faces to kind of register where we were.
[21:17] John Tartaglia: Yeah. When you're puppeteering on TV, it's a different, obviously, aesthetic. Do you find that you are doing the same thing you did on stage where you're acting in like as John, you're acting and your puppet is doing whatever it's doing? Like, does your brain switch it off?
[21:36] John Tartaglia: Yeah, to some degree, because I think you know, you're you're it's the same, you're doing the same function, right? Which is like, which is which is with the puppet on, which is like you're you're you're just kind of funneling what you would do as a person into that part of your body into that puppet. You know, with Avenue Q, you're always aware that you're on stage and that you're trying to help the audience. And so you get you can be a little more like it pays off more for me to do things with my face or for me to do things with my other arm or for me to do things with my legs or a body position or whatever. But you know, when you're puppeteering for camera, they don't see us at all. And so it's all got to be through here.
And so you just have to kind of but you have to take what you would do here and put it up there. And some people that is by giving you a ton of facial expressions that help them get in up to the puppet, and other people like Frank Oz is one of the greatest puppeteers in the world who did Miss Piggy and and Yoda. You know, if you watch him, he tends to be very kind of like expressionless in his face while he's performing, yelling at the top of his lungs as Miss Piggy and screaming as Fozzie Bear, but it's really he's channeling it all up to the puppet. So it's everyone's got their different ways of making that happen. I think I'm kind of in the middle. I think if you watch me, I get facial expressions, and I find that it just helps me really be in the moment and really focused in the moment.
[22:16] John Tartaglia: One of the greatest thrills of my life was getting to meet Carol Spinney and seeing him do Oscar the Grouch live.
[22:58] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[22:59] John Tartaglia: And obviously, for people who don't know him by name, he was most famously Big Bird.
[23:04] John Tartaglia: Yes, Big Bird and Oscar. So he got to heal, you know, he'd always joke on Seth that he got to really like work out like his therapy. Because right? Because he he would play this like sweet, innocent, so kind big bird, you know, oblivious to so many things. And then this like really angry, grumpy, wise talking, you know, uh grouch. Like he got to kind of work out his therapy.
[23:25] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[23:26] John Tartaglia: Yeah, sort of like the Muppet versions of, you know, well, non-human-ish Ernie and Burt.
[23:32] John Tartaglia: Exactly. Yeah. It's like, you know, it's it's and it's funny because people always say to us, like, you know, how do you get through when you're doing something that's very innocent and sweet and like, let's talk about the letter J. And like, you know, there, there's, you know, we that's why in between takes we're we're all we're always goofing around and and you know, with bloopers and things like that, because it's just it's a way to kind of let that out and still, you know, still have fun.
[23:56] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh my god, it must be the most hilarious thing ever.
[23:59] John Tartaglia: Oh, yeah. Our crews love our bloopers. Although that's kind of what Avenue Q is, you know, dirty puppets. It's great.
[24:06] John Tartaglia: Absolutely. Yeah. We'll be right back. We have to listen to some commercials.
[24:14] John Tartaglia: There were definitely moments I remember very distinctly when Stephanie Debruzo and I were doing, we were rehearsing loud as the hell you want, and staging, you know, the puppet sex. And I remember we just like we were like, you know, having this very serious discussion about it. And I was like, yeah, this is not something we ever thought we'd be talking about, like in our careers, like how to make these two puppets look like they're making love. It was pretty, it was pretty hilarious.
[24:41] John Tartaglia: Yeah. Not just making love, but you know, having a really uh wild a really good time I mean it was like it was like you know the the things that like you know everyone thinks that puppeteers do they're always like no we don't do that that we got the chance to do amazing yeah and and obviously that's part of why the show was such a huge success because people love to see that yeah so one of the biggest upsets ever in Tony Ward history is when Avenue Q won the Tony no one saw that coming what was that night like in that moment it was it you know it's hard because people don't believe it now especially this many years later you know 21 almost 21 years later like when I when I tell them this they're like come on but like you know we genuinely did not think we were going to win it it was unheard of at that time it's changed now but it was unheard of at that time for a show like that to win the Tony Award over the big you know the big glorious musical and and I love Wicked.
[25:41] John Tartaglia: I was a big fan of Wicked you know and I was like oh they're gonna win because it was everything that a usually a Tony award winning musical has you know and people looking back we think well Wicked must have won but it didn't oh absolutely you know what I mean and it's funny because it you know it's made me more curious about like other upsets over the years where you're like what that musical didn't win for Best Musical but yeah I mean we we genuinely you know I think it was uh I can't remember if Stephanie or Anne Horata but somebody used to always would say we're just so happy to be invited to the party and that's exactly what we felt like we're like we are the nerds that got invited to the cool kids party and we're so happy to be here because we we never even dreamt that we would be on Broadway to begin with.
[26:19] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[26:19] John Tartaglia: Um, and I remember, yeah, and of course, we believed that we we could win in the sense of like that our show was what good enough to win, but we just didn't think we would. And I remember standing backstage, and Liz McCann, who you know was a legendary producer of the Tony's for many years. She was backstage, and I remember I was we were standing there waiting to do some bit that we were supposed to do. I think it might have been the bit with Rod with Hugh Jack, but I don't remember I was supposed to do. And I remember we won for best book, and it was like everyone backstage went, oh, and cheered, and like the audience went crazy, and you, you know, Jeff Jeff Winnie, our book writers, you could see the shock in his face. And I remember Liz turned to me and she saw my reaction. She was like, you never know what's gonna happen at the Tony Awards.
[27:01] John Tartaglia: And I don't know to this to this day if she knew, of course, that we were gonna win for best musical. Maybe she had heard, I don't know. I would like to think that she didn't know, but but anyway, it was just a it was such a magical, magical night. And it was, you know, when we and I've never seen this, but people say that when we won for best musical for a brief second on the monitors, wicked flashed up. I don't know if that's true.
[27:23] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh, I'll have to. I'm gonna have to go back and look.
[27:26] John Tartaglia: I just I just remember, yeah, right. I just remember that Nathan Lane like took a pause, and I forget what he did, but he he he's it's almost like he faked us out because it looked like he was gonna say wicked, and then he said Avenue Q. But I remember as he said the words Avenue Q, it was like everything went into slow motion for a second. It was such a surreal, like, what moment.
[27:47] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[27:47] John Tartaglia: Um, so every reaction you see is genuine. We all were just like hyperventilatingly shocked. We could not believe it. We were just like, you know, and and it's cool. I think it really it just said that like, you know, uh you don't have to be the big show. And and I think I don't know, it was just it was an interesting, it was an interesting outcome. And and what's funny for me is like the fandoms created this like Avenue Q versus Wicked thing, but all of us were so appreciative of each other. Kristen Chandler, who's a dear friend, was like a huge Avenue fan. So she was rooting for us. I was rooting for Wicked. You know, we we all wanted each other because that's the community, right? It's like competition is fun, but it's it's really within the community. You you're all happy everyone's working, you know what I mean? So it was it was a very um joyous and unexpected night, is what I would say.
[28:38] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, yeah. And everyone understands what the work is. It's so different from other venues, even in show business.
[28:44] John Tartaglia: Yeah, it's very special, and everyone sees it.
[28:48] John Tartaglia: Yeah, and you're in it, so you don't really see like you know, you have no concept of like if your show is good or not. You have no concept of like what are people really thinking. You're so busy in rehearsals and previews and tech and appearances and everything. You just you're just it's like you're on this like train that's moving, and so you know, it's the first time you really get to get off the train and see how people are reacting to the thing that you did.
[29:11] John Tartaglia: Yeah, and now it's just like in the zeitgeist, it's there forever. It's so it's so bizarre, it's so bizarre to me that it's this out in the world, and people send me like pictures of like international productions of it, and and you know, or or like friends who are like doing self-tapes would be like, oh, my student did purpose. I thought you'd want to see it. I'm like, oh my god, like it's so bizarre. And now with YouTube, people just incessantly watch clips over and over and over of the Tony World performance or you guys winning, like it's just it lives on in a life of its own constantly.
[29:44] John Tartaglia: It does, and you know, the thing I'm most proud of, I mean uh there's so many things about the show, but but I love that so many people are discovering puppetry because of it. Because you know, musical theater students, like if you have that now on your resume, it's even more of like a plus.
[29:59] John Tartaglia: So it's kind of taken the thing that gave us that opportunity and kind of multiplied it out there and let more people learn that skill. And even if they even they don't want to be puppeteers, they maybe had the experience of doing it and appreciating what goes into it. And you never know when you're gonna use that. So yeah, you started at 16 at Sesame Street. So the question for you is like you said, people discovering this skill. It just feels like something that you like literally were born to be a puppeteer, especially knowing that at 16, like this is what I want to do. So what made you had you discover that? Or was it one day you were like, oh my God, I want to do this watching or seeing something on TV?
I mean, it's it's a combo. I mean, I grew up, um, my my parents are both in show business. So I grew up, meet my my mother and father who are no longer together, they're divorced, but at the time they were together when I was a kid. And you know, I grew up basically backstage or in a in an audience or somebody was on stage. So I really I my earliest, earliest memories are being in or behind the scenes of a of a of a show and seeing shows and listening to cast recordings. And so I think I was, you know, it never was like a um, I never went through that period a lot of kids go through of like, you know, what do I want to be? Like I knew I wanted to be a performer. I love I got the bug real quick.
Um, and you know, it m it makes sense to me that I'm a puppeteer or that I have it in me because my even my grandmother was, you know, she she did clowning because she had to do clowning. She used to be an opera singer, and then her father was also a clown. And so it's like, I think I had this like these generations of just, you know, performance in me and not just traditional musical leader performance, obviously, other elements. But what made me realize I wanted to be a puppeteer was seeing the original Fraggle Rock at about seven years old. And seeing it on TV and just literally having this moment of like this very I always say the word visceral because it was very visceral. It's like it overtook me this moment of going, that's what I want to do.
Like, and I and it was weird because the first time I picked up a puppet, I kind of understood it. I understood the lip sync, I understood the basics that you have to usually teach people. It just felt natural to me. I'm a big believer in you're born with gifts and then everything happens for a reason. So I like to think that it was in me. I just needed to let it out and discover it. Um, but yeah, that's it really that's what started it was the original Fraggle Rock. I just knew at like seven years old, I was like, that's what I want to do. Because it also it was very theatrical, you know. It it they they sing, they dance, you know, it's everything that yes, it was like a Broadway play, but you know, but contained in this box, yeah. Exactly.
[32:36] Bruce Gotlieb: But how do you go from being a huge fan of Fraggle Rock to now creating Fraggle Rock for, you know, a whole other generation of kids? How does that happen?
[32:44] John Tartaglia: Well, you know, so since in my time doing so much puppetry, you know, I worked with the the Jumitza company. I started when I was 16 and and you know, worked on and off for the past, you know, almost 30 years of of my life doing with them. And I came out here about nine years ago to LA to work on a TV show for Henson as a performer. And while I was here, another show that I was pitching uh with Henson got picked up. And so I ended up staying here in Los Angeles, moving out here literally like overnight, like shipped my stuff out from New York. I never went home and packed it up. I just shipped it out, which is insane. And and went into production. That kind of uh I had done my Disney Channel show, Johnny and the Sprites.
So I had I'd done, I'd worked in a creator and producer aspect uh before that. But it felt like here at Henson, like it was like, this is where I want to be because like this is the company that gave me my career. And this is the company that does what I want to do, the kind of work I want to do. And so I stayed out here and started kind of working more in development and behind the scenes. And my uh one of my dearest friends here, Halle Stanford, she's the president of television here at the company and is one of the co-executive or one of the executive producers of Fraggle Rock with me. She's always been a big Fraggle fan too. And we've always like tried to find ways to bring like, what if the Fraggles did this?
What if what if the Fraggles did that? But at the time, you know, there just wasn't no one was no one was sitting around saying, let's make Fraggle Rock again. And then thanks, thank you, gods, that Apple TV Plus came along and said, you know, literally one day in a great meeting we had with them, they're like, What about Fraggle Rock? What's going on with that? And we're like, and and we just said, like, we've been wanting to bring Fraggle back, Fraggrock back forever. And um, they were on board. And what I really give them credit for is that, you know, the original Fraggle Rock was produced in Toronto, 1983 is what it premiered. And, you know, it was really at the time, it was the like the most highly sophisticated children's television you could make.
It was a huge budget, you know. I think it was at its most 18 puppeteers and big sets and beautiful, you know, uh stories and incredible music. I mean, it was just it was such a quality show, you know. And people would always say, Oh, you could never do it like that again. No one's ever gonna spend that money, no one's ever gonna want something that big, no one's ever gonna spend that time or that much effort. And Apple TV Plus said, we want to do that plus even more, like make it appeal to kids of today and take it even further. So to get that kind of an opportunity is so rare. And yeah, so we basically got to dream as big as we could, and they supported that all the way. So it's been really for me, it's been the most unexpected, like an avenue queue.
It's been an unexpected opportunity to take my knowledge as a kid. I have this like deep well of like, I could tell you like episode 76. This happened with this character. And um because to me it was like it was like my Lord of the Rings, right? Like it's it's like a lore, yeah, lore world-based show where there's so much like goodness. So yeah. So now to get to to put that into the series, now it's just like the unexpected um Christmas present I never thought I'd get. And it's such a special thing because you know, you're really creating something for kids that, like we said before, is gonna stay with them. And I can tell that you don't take that lightly.
[35:59] John Tartaglia: No, and fragile rock, I mean, I and I say this without any, you know, hyperbole, like Fraggle Rock really gave me so much of my moral compass as a person. I mean, I look back at like the things I took away from that show, even subconsciously about environmentalism, about interdependence, about peace, about tolerance, about diversity. I mean, you name it, like all those things sat in me. And and I feel like those, those to me are life lessons that you know, we uh we assume that people pick up and we assume kids pick up, but they don't always, because either either they're not lucky enough to be in a family environment where they can glean that, or you know, they're they're paying attention to the wrong part of pop culture or whatever it is that is not teaching them how to be a good citizen, how to be a good person, how to be a good friend, how to be, you know, aware that that they're not the only ones on the planet, you know, that we need each other, that that our one environment. It's not one, uh, it's one world that we all need each other to to survive.
[37:00] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, we're all together here. We're all in this together, literally.
[37:02] John Tartaglia: Let's take a minute to hear a word from our sponsors.
[37:11] Bruce Gotlieb: So, have you been to the Jim Henson exhibit at the Museum of the Moving Image?
[37:17] John Tartaglia: It's the Microsoft College curated that, Barbara Miller.
[37:20] Bruce Gotlieb: Hey, she's wonderful.
[37:22] John Tartaglia: Right? She did such a good job. So, what is that like for you to go and see all that history in one place?
[37:28] John Tartaglia: It's it's so funny because you know, I feel like what is what has been, I'm so thankful for this because I feel like this doesn't always happen on for certain people I know who work for big companies that they grow up loving. I'm still such a geeky fan. I still could sit in that exhibit for days and never get bored because I'm so intrigued by the history and I'm intrigued. You know, Jim, to me, you can tell by this giant picture of him behind me, like he is a hero to me and always has been, always will be. And I feel like, you know, what I can't get over is that his mind never stopped. And that it was like in in, you know, he he died at such a young age, so unexpectedly. But in that time, he created such an immense body of work, even things that like the three of us don't know about still.
You know what I mean? Like that that is still sitting in an archive drawer somewhere. Like he just never stopped creating and thinking. And so, and I really appreciate that. Like, I just and and the impact he made on the world. So when I go through that exhibit, I just it's this weird blend of like inspiration as an artist, and then complete nostalgia. And then, like, I always leave. I've been a few times, I always leave wanting to go make something that day. You know what I mean? Which I think is the best thing you could say about a creative person's life's work being on display is like that it inspires you to go to want do something, you know.
[38:46] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, right. Next time you're in New York, let me know because I want to go with you.
[38:50] John Tartaglia: That'll be so much.
[38:51] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh my gosh, please. And I love that they rotate stuff out too. So you like you see, you know, it's like new stuff every time. And and stuff that I'm like, that's still that's still around, like it still exists, it doesn't fall apart. Like it's amazing. When it first came, I thought it was temporary. I'm so glad that it's a permanent collection there.
[39:08] John Tartaglia: Yeah, I thought so too.
[39:10] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, and and you know, and it's wonderful for for the the Jimmitson uh family and for the company because we just had like boxes and boxes of boxes of puppets, and it's like, what are you gonna do with this? You know, and so it's so great that they're out there and and also the Center for Puppetry Arts in Atlanta is a wonderful place that has tons of of his work on display and and love supporting Jim Henson's work. So yeah, it's it's very surreal when I'm in that exhibit for sure.
[39:32] Bruce Gotlieb: Did you get to work with Jim? Was he there when you got there?
[39:34] John Tartaglia: Timing no, he he died in 1990. And and what's you know, it's a long story, but I wrote him a letter when I was eight when I knew that this is what I wanted to do. And I never met him, but he got my letter, and uh through a crazy series of events, we almost met each other, and then he passes away. And when I wrote a letter a few years later to one of his co-workers, the reason they got in touch with me is because they recognized my name because of Jim, because he hadn't talked about me to them. So much and a very unexpected kind thing that he did, like indirectly led to my career. So I always say, like, you know, I didn't meet him, but I'm here because of him.
[40:16] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. Wow, that's incredible.
[40:20] John Tartaglia: Very yeah, yeah. I still I still get very like choked up thinking about it. Cause it's like, you know, it just shows the power of kindness, right? The and and thoughtfulness.
[40:30] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, that's true. You really don't think about that, but you're absolutely right. So everyone should pay that forward and do something.
[40:35] John Tartaglia: Yeah, we've no excuse not to.
[40:38] Bruce Gotlieb: Absolutely. So all right, we've kept you a long time, but I have one last thing to tell you. My favorite day of the week is Sunday.
[40:48] John Tartaglia: Thank you. I love to listen to our show on Sirius.
[40:52] Bruce Gotlieb: Thank you. I love hosting it. It's such a um I it's all Julie James. I was a guest on her show a couple of times during the Avenue Q days, and I remember she reached out and was like, Have you ever wanted to do radio? Because you you're fun when you talk about what your nerd knowledge. And I said, I would be honored to. Um and I never thought it would be, you know, like I don't even know. I think it's like 15 years I've been doing it. So it's it's just uh it's a gift that keeps on giving. That's my I guess that's our theme today.
[41:19] John Tartaglia: That's the theme.
[41:19] Bruce Gotlieb: Um that's a good theme. All right, so I've learned I've learned I just want to say I've learned more about Broadway than I ever like, you know, I've always been a big fan, but some of the facts and figures I feel like so happy that I have the show that I get to learn by reading. I'm like, I never knew that West Side's story didn't win for best, like all these things. I'm like, what it was the avenue queue of its time, yeah. It's crazy, like things like that. I'm like, what? Like, like things I just always assumed, right?
[41:46] John Tartaglia: Do you remember your first Broadway show you saw?
[41:49] Bruce Gotlieb: I remember a few things. I remember the the one that stays in my memory because I was such a horrible child to my poor stepfather and mother that day was going to see Phantom of the Opera. Uh-huh. Um, which I think I was probably about nine or ten at the most. I was so scared of New York. I was just like, which is hilarious because then I moved there at 18 and lived there for 18 years. Um, but I was petrified of it. I don't know, I don't know why, but apparently they said that I was just like, you know, whiny and crying and being like so ridiculous the whole day, and then like went to see Phantom and was like the golden child, and like, you know, and and just was so excited. So it I I remember you were in the balcony or in the mezzanine, and I remember that the chandelier coming up by me, and that was very impactful for me for sure. That was thrilling at the time.
[42:38] John Tartaglia: Yeah, yeah. It was just it definitely made me go. I I was that kid who would like see something and then try to make it at home afterwards, you know.
[42:45] Bruce Gotlieb: So that was definitely like a performance in my room for a little while. I was trying to like make my light move and do all that stuff, you know. Very inspired.
[42:53] John Tartaglia: Where do you keep your theater worlds award?
[42:55] John Tartaglia: I keep it on uh in my office at home. I have like a little desk that has my awards on it, and it's it's there. And I I I like to I keep it in view because I like to remember like how lucky I am to have that. And and that's yeah, that award meant so much to me because it was like, okay, this is coming from my peers, you know what I mean? And and it's not that you know the Tonies and everything else aren't wonderful, of course, but there's something about like the fact that that's it's a purely performance-based award. There's no politics around, it's just about what people think it's given to the people that people think made their biggest mark in that season. Like that just that meant so much to me. I didn't expect that at all.
[43:36] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, thank you so much for joining us. Everyone needs to watch Fraggle Rock, Back to the Rock.
[43:43] John Tartaglia: Yes, that's right. Season two.
[43:46] Bruce Gotlieb: Um, on Apple TV Plus, right now, you can watch the follow John on Instagram and where else should we follow you? And what's the handle?
[43:54] John Tartaglia: Uh on Instagram, it's at Johnny Tar Tags. Believe it or not, someone already took John Tartaglia. So I was like, all right. Um and Facebook, you can follow me under my name, Jonta Taglia. And um, I'm on Cameo, so you can I can make videos for you on Cameo. I'm happy to do that.
[44:07] John Tartaglia: That's fine. He can do a lot of different voices, so that's good.
[44:11] John Tartaglia: I'll do voices, yeah. People ask for puppets all the time, and I'm like, I'm not allowed to do the puppets, but I can do the voices.
[44:15] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, no, that's what you want. You want the voices for cameo, so definitely hit him up on cameo. That's great. I I have recorded more answering machines, or not answering machines anymore. What am I? This is 1994, but I've recorded more cell phone uh outgoing messages than I can tell you as Rod. It's not even funny.
[44:32] John Tartaglia: Well, we will continue to follow you and come back next time you win an award, which will be very soon.
[44:39] John Tartaglia: I would love that. Thank you.
[44:40] Bruce Gotlieb: Thank you for having me.
[44:41] John Tartaglia: Thank you.
[44:43] Bruce Gotlieb: See you guys soon.
[44:44] John Tartaglia: Bye-bye.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
