Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#15 - Tony Awards 2024 Analysis #5

Jessica Lang is the “Mother” to beat this Tony season? Feature Friday! Eila & Bruce bring you the fifth installment of their Tony deep dive. They are joined by expert Matt Stashin and share who will win and who they want to win in the following categories... Read More

From the show: Behind the Awards with Eila Mell & Bruce Gotlieb

49 mins
6/3/24

Miniseries Inclusions

Featured Shows

About

Jessica Lang is the “Mother” to beat this Tony season?

Feature Friday! Eila & Bruce bring you the fifth installment of their Tony deep dive. They are joined by expert Matt Stashin and share who will win and who they want to win in the following categories. Director of a Musical, Costume Design of a Musical, Lead Actress of a Play, Lead Actor of a Play

Maria Friedman, Merrily We Roll Along, Michael Greif,, Leigh Silverman, Suffs, Jessica Stone, Water for Elephants, Danya Taymor, The Outsiders, Hells Kitchen, The Great Gatsby, Cabaret, William Jackson Harper, Uncle Vanya, Leslie Odom Jr, Purlie Victorious, Liev Schreiber, Doubt, Jeremy Strong, An Enemy of the People, Michael Stuhlbarg, Patriots, Betsy Aidem, Prayer for the French Republic, Jessica Lang, Mother Play, Rachel McAdams, Mary Jane, Sarah Paulson, Appropriate, Amy Ryan

Make sure to check out Eila's book, "The Tony Awards", and all her other amazing books: https://amzn.to/43WMu5Y.

Connect with Eila and Bruce:

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:09] Eila Mell: Hello and welcome to Behind the Awards.

[0:12] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm Bruce here with Eila as always.

[0:14] Eila Mell: Hi, Bruce.

[0:15] Bruce Gotlieb: Hi, Eila.

[0:16] Eila Mell: How are you doing?

[0:17] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm very good.

[0:18] Eila Mell: I'm excited that the Tony Awards is very close.

[0:22] Bruce Gotlieb: Moments away, you've got to. I mean, it's very exciting for us.

[0:25] Eila Mell: It's been like a marathon, really.

[0:27] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.

[0:28] Eila Mell: We've been preparing for this.

[0:29] Bruce Gotlieb: It feels like we've recorded all of these episodes in one day.

[0:32] Eila Mell: You know, it does.

[0:34] Bruce Gotlieb: Just because there's so much to talk about.

[0:35] Eila Mell: I know.

[0:36] Bruce Gotlieb: And it's something that we constantly are talking about.

[0:38] Eila Mell: I mean, we talked, we start talking about the Tonies, what? Like in August?

[0:44] Bruce Gotlieb: I think when the first show came out.

[0:44] Eila Mell: I know. Do you think there are any chances?

[0:48] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. We've handicapped this race a lot.

[0:51] Eila Mell: Absolutely.

[0:52] Bruce Gotlieb: And we have been able to secure our expert again for another week.

[0:56] Eila Mell: I mean, it's amazing that he keeps coming back for us.

[0:59] Bruce Gotlieb: So thank you, Matt Stashin, and welcome back to the show.

[1:02] Matt Stashin: Thank you for having me.

[1:03] Eila Mell: What can I say? We love the conversation with you.

[1:07] Bruce Gotlieb: Alright. Well, Eila, what categories are we discussing today?

[1:11] Eila Mell: We are in the thick of it. I mean, it's all huge, huge names. We have director of a musical, costume design of a musical, lead actor of a play, and lead actress of a play.

[1:23] Bruce Gotlieb: Alright, we have a lot to discuss.

[1:25] Eila Mell: Yeah, we do.

[1:26] Bruce Gotlieb: Alright. So I think we should just dive in.

[1:28] Eila Mell: Alright, let's dive in then.

[1:30] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm ready.

[1:31] Eila Mell: Best direction of a musical. And the nominees are Maria Friedman, Merrily We Roll Along, Michael Greif, Hell's Kitchen, Leigh Silverman, Suffs, Jessica Stone, Water for Elephants, and Danya Taymor, The Outsiders.

[1:47] Bruce Gotlieb: Where to start?

[1:48] Eila Mell: I guess we'll start with Merrily.

[1:50] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay, so everyone knows that I feel that this is the most obvious race. I think if Maria Friedman doesn't win for this production of Merrily, it'll be an upset.

[2:01] Eila Mell: Do you guys agree with me here?

[2:03] Matt Stashin: I think Merrily has a lot of momentum going for it in so many different ways.

[2:08] Bruce Gotlieb: I do think there are a couple of sleepers that could sneak in.

[2:11] Eila Mell: Okay.

[2:12] Matt Stashin: I honestly agree. I think she's a great choice. I think she probably will, but I definitely think there's other people with really good narratives behind them and really great shows.

[2:24] Eila Mell: Alright, well, I'm gonna make my case for Maria.

[2:27] Matt Stashin: Go ahead.

[2:27] Eila Mell: So she has turned Merrily into a hit for the first time. And it's, I think it's fair to say it's one of the biggest shows on Broadway right now. It's an extremely hot ticket. She knows the show because she played Mary in it in a version of it, not this one, obviously. You know, one of my favorite moments is the very end of the show because it's so bittersweet, and she just creates such a beautiful moment, and it just leaves you just ugh, well, your heart is broken, and it's just a great night of theater. So I think that, you know, all the buzz is well deserved here.

[3:05] Matt Stashin: Okay. I think that's a fair statement.

[3:08] Bruce Gotlieb: All fair.

[3:09] Eila Mell: Alright. So who wants to talk about Michael Greif?

[3:12] Matt Stashin: Oh, can I start, please?

[3:13] Bruce Gotlieb: Go ahead.

[3:15] Matt Stashin: I think Michael Greif is probably one of the ones that I'm thinking is the biggest sleeper here because the fact that somehow Michael Greif does not already have a Tony baffles me. This is the man that did Rent, the original show, Dear Evan Hansen, Next to Normal. How has he not won yet? That should be against the law.

[3:35] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. Like he needs a Tony.

[3:39] Matt Stashin: It's true, yeah. But do you think Hell's Kitchen will get him there?

[3:43] Bruce Gotlieb: I think it's possible. I think it's a really strong show. I think he definitely did a phenomenal job telling the story. And he really puts the audience into this place, into Hell's Kitchen. And he really, I think he does do a pretty masterful job of it.

[3:59] Eila Mell: Alright, well, that's a pretty strong case, Bruce.

[4:01] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, I think so. And I think, you know, with like Matt said, you have to put the audience in a neighborhood where they are. You're like a block away.

[4:10] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[4:13] Bruce Gotlieb: You're a block away, but also in a certain period of time. And while he has at his disposal, you know, lighting and costumes and all these other tech helpers to create that spirit, it's still his job as the director to take all of those pieces, put them together, and put that product on stage that makes you feel that you're where you are.

[4:39] Eila Mell: Right. I mean, I always feel like the director is really the audience's liaison. They're the first audience member.

[4:44] Matt Stashin: Absolutely.

[4:46] Bruce Gotlieb: And the job he did with those actors, there's four acting nominations from this show.

[4:50] Eila Mell: Well, that's a big deal, yeah.

[4:52] Bruce Gotlieb: So he really got the best out of everybody on that stage.

[4:55] Eila Mell: Right. And also knowing what to keep and what not to keep. You know, it's different when you do a revival because you know what works, but there's no roadmap when you're doing a show like that. He literally had to shape the show as they were rehearsing it.

[5:06] Matt Stashin: Right, and as they're writing it too, you know, the director has a role in that as well.

[5:11] Eila Mell: So yeah. I am sitting here with two big Suffs fans. So tell me about Leigh Silverman for Suffs.

[5:16] Matt Stashin: I think the direction of that show has done very well. The only thing I guess I will say is I not to say she has an easy job, but I think the director's job in this instance was made easier by Shayna Taub. Because I mean, she didn't direct the show herself, she's done everything else.

[5:38] Bruce Gotlieb: Everything else.

[5:43] Matt Stashin: Almost literally everything else. She wrote it, she wrote the music, she stars in it.

[5:46] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[5:47] Matt Stashin: So I think all of those things help her do her job with direction because the music, the book, everything is really driving this story that as a director your work is a little bit easier because it's taking off already. And maybe she has to make sure that it doesn't get carried away, you know, like a runaway train.

[6:14] Bruce Gotlieb: Um, so maybe her job almost is to keep it reined in. And also, you know, Shayna Taub may be so close to it that there are things she doesn't say.

[6:23] Matt Stashin: Well, I was also thinking that. I'm like the fact that Shayna Taub trusted Leigh Silverman with everything Shayna Taub put into this show, now taking all of this work you did and you're gonna continue to do as the star of the show and saying here to Leigh Silverman. That's a lot of trust is a testament to Leigh Silverman also.

[6:40] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, I think the show itself is done really well. You know, you're threading through time, you're telling a story that exists, so you know, people know there's an expectation.

[6:55] Matt Stashin: Yes, this is history.

[6:56] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. This is an expectation that's involved, but I think as a director, you know, it's told well. It's really told well.

[7:06] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[7:06] Bruce Gotlieb: And this is something we were talking about about shaping the show. She directed it off-Broadway.

[7:11] Matt Stashin: Yes.

[7:11] Bruce Gotlieb: And I know they made major changes to it. I don't know about major, but they definitely made changes to it between the off-Broadway and the Broadway run. And a lot of that is on her. And all of those changes were for the better. I mean, I've made no secret of how much I enjoyed Suffs.

[7:27] Matt Stashin: Yes.

[7:28] Bruce Gotlieb: That I absolutely love the show.

[7:29] Eila Mell: Alright, wonderful. And Jessica Stone, Water for Elephants.

[7:34] Matt Stashin: So there's a lot to do here because there are a lot of different elements come into play.

[7:34] Bruce Gotlieb: There are.

[7:41] Matt Stashin: And we had the privilege to interview the choreographers for Water for Elephants recently. And they shared with us, or at least Shayna shared with us that, you know, she'd been involved with this project with Jessica since I think it was 2019.

[7:59] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[8:00] Matt Stashin: So they've been living and kind of shaping what this is going to look like. You know, the out-of-town tryout in Atlanta, and you know, all of these things that get you to Broadway. I think of all the shows as the director, you know, kind of being the orchestrator of everything, you know, she's got an interesting task because you have traditional musical elements and then you also throw in, you know, circus elements and real circus performers.

[8:35] Bruce Gotlieb: Real circus performers.

[8:35] Matt Stashin: You have puppeteering, there's so many different pieces that she has to make fluid.

[8:44] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, and tell a cohesive story.

[8:47] Matt Stashin: Yeah, Water for Elephants is a very technical show.

[8:49] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, it can be, right?

[8:51] Matt Stashin: But it doesn't feel technical.

[8:52] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[8:52] Matt Stashin: But like there's a lot of things that she had to get her hands into in order to make the show work.

[8:59] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. She had to be involved with the set to make that work and the choreography, and everything had to work together, which is really what the director's job is in the first place.

[9:08] Matt Stashin: Right. I mean, not unlike any other director's job, but the sheer number of different aspects of the show, it was a hard job.

[9:13] Bruce Gotlieb: It was a hard show to do, I'm sure.

[9:19] Matt Stashin: Yeah, for sure. And then on top of that, it's also a memory play.

[9:23] Bruce Gotlieb: Mm-hmm.

[9:24] Matt Stashin: So now you're dealing not only with all of these other elements, but now you also have to touch on something, not with kid gloves, but with certain grace to do a memory play. You can't just come at that the same way you would, I don't know, Tommy.

[9:45] Bruce Gotlieb: Right, because it goes in and out of time periods.

[9:48] Matt Stashin: Right. So it jumps around. But I think, you know, it's clear when we're in a certain time period and when we're in another, and you know, I think all of that is certainly successful.

[9:57] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, I agree.

[9:58] Matt Stashin: I think she really did a beautiful job of just weaving everything together into one tapestry.

[10:03] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. And then, you know, in the moments when you're actually at the circus, you feel like you really are at the circus.

[10:10] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[10:10] Bruce Gotlieb: Not in the Broadway theater.

[10:12] Matt Stashin: Absolutely. Which is amazing. I've never experienced that feeling before. Even when I saw Pippin, who had, you know, also circus performers from the same company, this was just a different experience.

[10:24] Bruce Gotlieb: Agreed.

[10:24] Matt Stashin: And then we have The Outsiders, which Bruce and I, you know, loved and Matt, you're gonna see it soon.

[10:24] Bruce Gotlieb: I guess you are going to do it very good.

[10:32] Matt Stashin: So, Bruce, make your case for The Outsiders.

[10:35] Bruce Gotlieb: I think she does a really effective job of telling the story because again, it's something people know. I went in, probably one of the few people who hadn't seen the movie or read the book.

[10:46] Matt Stashin: Blew my mind.

[10:47] Bruce Gotlieb: I don't understand.

[10:50] Matt Stashin: But I went in without it. But there are people that went in knowing these, going in, loving the book, loving the movie. So you already have to combat people's expectations.

[11:01] Eila Mell: Um, and while Water for Elephants also was a movie and book, I just not in the same way as The Outsiders.

[11:10] Bruce Gotlieb: So different.

[11:10] Matt Stashin: And also, like with The Notebook being a movie and a book, it's just you have to, you already have a mountain to climb.

[11:18] Eila Mell: Yes.

[11:19] Bruce Gotlieb: Because people have expectations because it's something people are so familiar with.

[11:22] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[11:23] Bruce Gotlieb: But I think she told the story very, very well. And she used elements, you know, like the way she used the lighting and the sound and her direction. It was different. It wasn't expected.

[11:35] Matt Stashin: You know, I've said this to you, Bruce, a zillion times. You're probably sick of hearing about it, but it was like the lack of light and the absence of sound in certain scenes that I thought was so interesting. And she just, you know, it was like a quietly bold job of directing, I thought.

[11:55] Matt Stashin: I know we talked about before having like the sleepers.

[11:58] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[11:59] Matt Stashin: I think Danya Taymor is the other one.

[12:01] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[12:02] Matt Stashin: But really might come in. There's a lot of love for The Outsiders. Again, like I have not seen it yet, but I'm hearing the two of you talk about it like I have multiple times. She did a phenomenal job from what I understand.

[12:15] Eila Mell: Like, I really think the love for the show, she has a real shot.

[12:19] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, I can tell you that when Bruce and I went into one Schubert Alley, the guy who worked there said that everybody was buzzing about The Outsiders.

[12:27] Matt Stashin: He is, that's right. And the one thing I will say about, specifically just because they're in this category, but there are other shows that you could put in here with The Outsiders and Water for Elephants.

[12:39] Eila Mell: One of the things that I love and I think is so exciting is that they're pushing the way that you tell a story on Broadway.

[12:46] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[12:46] Eila Mell: You know, you're always gonna have people who want the quote unquote classics.

[12:52] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[12:53] Eila Mell: But that also changes generationally because, you know, people who grew up with a classic, let's say Rogers and Hammerstein musical, they're getting older.

[13:04] Bruce Gotlieb: And a lot of them are very problematic now.

[13:07] Eila Mell: Well, okay. But I appreciate that we're telling stories differently.

[13:13] Bruce Gotlieb: We're pushing choreography, we're pushing style of music.

[13:16] Eila Mell: Yeah. We're just, you know, we're just, we're revolving. And I think that's important because that is because, you know, Rent could be somebody's classic.

[13:24] Bruce Gotlieb: It could be what is.

[13:25] Eila Mell: So, but I just have to defend Rogers and Hammerstein while we're here. I want to say, I think it's very important to say that they were the sort of rebels of their time.

[13:38] Bruce Gotlieb: They were pushing boundaries that 100%.

[13:41] Eila Mell: So I just want that. And I'm not demeaning any of their work. I'm saying like the last revival of Carousel, certain plot elements were considered problematic.

[13:50] Bruce Gotlieb: Same with the last revival of Oklahoma.

[13:53] Eila Mell: Right. You know.

[13:53] Bruce Gotlieb: No, I understand. I just think it's important to continue to stretch how we put on Broadway performances because it's the three of us alone, you know, love the medium so much that you never want it to go away.

[14:12] Eila Mell: And in order for it to sustain, you have to continue to tell stories and these directors, all of them are doing, you know, both play and musical directors are doing a phenomenal job this season and so much of a phenomenal job that there's no clear-cut winners here.

[14:30] Matt Stashin: I know, and even to piggyback on that, just the way of pushing the boundaries of how you tell a story. One, not to get into snubs, but I do just kind of want to throw Alex Timbers' name out there for Here Lies Love.

[14:42] Eila Mell: I know, I know. We were disappointed that he didn't get that nomination.

[14:47] Matt Stashin: But he's got a Tony already.

[14:49] Eila Mell: He does. Alright, so with all this big talk, who is going to win, Bruce?

[14:56] Bruce Gotlieb: I think going to win. I think going to win is Merrily.

[15:01] Matt Stashin: Yeah, I mean, it's gotta be, I think.

[15:08] Eila Mell: So who, so begrudgingly then, as you just stated, so then who do you want to win?

[15:14] Matt Stashin: Can I pick two? Maybe.

[15:16] Eila Mell: No, of course we can't. I'm really, I would love to see, I mean, really any of the other four. I mean, they're all very worthy. I really, Michael Greif needs a Tony. I'm sorry, just for that reason alone, I have to go with it.

[15:32] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay. What about you, Eila? Who do you want?

[15:35] Eila Mell: I think I do want it to be Maria Friedman for Merrily.

[15:39] Bruce Gotlieb: I, yeah.

[15:40] Eila Mell: Okay. And Bruce?

[15:43] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm vacillating a little between two, but I think ultimately I'm going to go with The Outsiders.

[15:51] Eila Mell: Okay.

[15:51] Bruce Gotlieb: I just think it's done so well. Jessica Stone is just right there for me because again, just because they're pushing how we tell stories and they're doing such a great job.

[16:03] Matt Stashin: Absolutely. And I also think it's exciting to have an upset.

[16:07] Eila Mell: Yeah, it is. Can we just discuss how amazing it is? Four of the five nominees are women.

[16:11] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, absolutely.

[16:13] Eila Mell: So in both directing categories, it's mostly women.

[16:16] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.

[16:16] Eila Mell: So for the first time, I believe.

[16:18] Matt Stashin: Is it?

[16:19] Eila Mell: Well, that's amazing. I think it's only happened twice when both winners, directing winners, have been women.

[16:25] Bruce Gotlieb: There was Julie Taymor and Gary Hines. That was the first when two women won. And then it was Rachel Chavkin for Hadestown, I believe.

[16:36] Matt Stashin: Well, the one I'm thinking of is Diane Paulus and Pam McKinnon also won.

[16:40] Eila Mell: Oh.

[16:41] Matt Stashin: So I don't try to remember. I don't remember who won Best Play when Rachel Chavkin won for Hadestown. I believe it was also a woman, but I'm not 100% sure.

[16:48] Bruce Gotlieb: I don't know. We'll have to check the book.

[16:49] Eila Mell: We'll look it up. We'll be right back. We have to listen to some commercials.

[16:58] Bruce Gotlieb: Alright, what is our next category?

[17:00] Eila Mell: Costume design of a musical.

[17:02] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay, well, that's fun. Alright, so who's gonna read off the nominees?

[17:07] Eila Mell: I will do it.

[17:08] Bruce Gotlieb: Let's hear it.

[17:09] Eila Mell: We have Didi Ayate for Hell's Kitchen, Linda Cho, The Great Gatsby, David Ryanoso, Water for Elephants, Tom Scott, Cabaret, and Paul Taswell for Suffs.

[17:25] Bruce Gotlieb: Alright. So who wants to talk about Didi and Hell's Kitchen?

[17:31] Matt Stashin: So I'll start. I think that, you know, kind of what we were saying about, you know, Hell's Kitchen and you have a time period and you have a location.

[17:40] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.

[17:41] Matt Stashin: So you have to be conscious of that.

[17:44] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[17:44] Matt Stashin: The costumes need to be specific.

[17:46] Eila Mell: Yeah, you can't, you know, you can't put everyone in, you know, Oklahoma garb.

[17:51] Bruce Gotlieb: No, you certainly can't. I mean, it would be a choice. I mean, there wasn't much gingham in the 90s.

[17:56] Matt Stashin: Not really. On Halloween, I'm sure there was plenty.

[18:01] Eila Mell: So I think that, you know, you as a costumer, you're given, you know, you're given certain parameters. You're given a sandbox to play in.

[18:10] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[18:10] Matt Stashin: And you can kind of go with that. And I think, you know, the vibrancy of the design is just so evident in that show. And it had to put you into a very specific time and place. And she did that really, really well.

[18:22] Bruce Gotlieb: She did. I mean, she's really good at that. I think what's going to go against her is that people are going to think it's an easier job because it looks more modern day.

[18:31] Matt Stashin: So I think that may hurt her, unfortunately.

[18:35] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. Modern day in any regard, when you have a period piece, it's always the flashier. When there's more costumes, people seem to regard it.

[18:46] Eila Mell: And I mean, hats off to her. She has three nominations in the costume design category.

[18:52] Matt Stashin: That's amazing.

[18:52] Bruce Gotlieb: Two for a play and then have three nominations this season, which is amazing.

[18:56] Eila Mell: And of course, it's designers.

[18:58] Matt Stashin: That's right. They work so hard.

[19:01] Bruce Gotlieb: Matt, what did you think about Linda for The Great Gatsby?

[19:04] Matt Stashin: Oh, the costumes in The Great Gatsby were fair. Everything technical about The Great Gatsby, I absolutely loved.

[19:09] Bruce Gotlieb: So Linda Cho already has a Tony for A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder.

[19:13] Matt Stashin: Yeah. Which she did just an amazing job with that.

[19:18] Bruce Gotlieb: So how did the, I mean, The Great Gatsby, the period is a big character.

[19:24] Matt Stashin: Exactly. Well, that's exactly what Bruce was talking about.

[19:27] Bruce Gotlieb: So yeah, how did she do?

[19:28] Matt Stashin: She did fuh incredibly. Yeah. There's a certain opulence that The Great Gatsby has to have. It has to, or else you're not telling the right story.

[19:36] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[19:36] Matt Stashin: And, you know, the costumes did it, the set did it, you know, just phenomenally. They're showy when they need to be, they're luxe, they're all of those notes were hit.

[19:51] Bruce Gotlieb: And then what about the contrast? Like when you get to Myrtle and, you know, very effective because they definitely showed a completely different side of this society, especially during, you know, this time of history. Like the bootlegging was going on and the depression.

[20:05] Matt Stashin: You know, they're two very different sides of society, and it was conveyed pretty effectively.

[20:09] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. So she could win. I wouldn't be shocked.

[20:12] Matt Stashin: I would, she has a definite chance.

[20:15] Bruce Gotlieb: Alright, David Israel Reynoso, Water for Elephants.

[20:18] Matt Stashin: Bruce.

[20:19] Bruce Gotlieb: I think again, you know, you're put in a certain, you're in the circus in the 30s, so there's a certain style that has to be there.

[20:30] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[20:30] Bruce Gotlieb: And I appreciated different people with different stylistic choices, different pops, obviously when you're in the circus, everything's more vibrant. When you're traveling, not so much.

[20:45] Matt Stashin: Right, but as well it should be because they didn't just get in a car and drive to the next city.

[20:51] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. They're breaking down the circus, they're loading it on a train.

[20:54] Matt Stashin: Yeah, it's like hard travel.

[20:55] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. It's the kind of show that is, it's like deceptively simple. There's a lot more to those costumes than it appears at the time.

[21:04] Matt Stashin: It's not just a ringmaster in a top hat.

[21:06] Bruce Gotlieb: Exactly.

[21:06] Matt Stashin: Yeah. No, and I wonder if the deception, the deceptively, you know, quiet costumes hurt the Tony chances here because almost like being too contemporary, it appears as though there's not as much flash.

[21:26] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm afraid it might because I think the costumes were like dis, I mean it just deceptively simple and other aspects of the show were so extravagant.

[21:38] Matt Stashin: So you think the costume—

[21:39] Bruce Gotlieb: I think it might wind up getting lost in the shuffle, which would be a shame because I think he did a phenomenal job.

[21:44] Matt Stashin: But now the elephant and the horse, are those costumes? Because those were beautiful.

[21:51] Bruce Gotlieb: I mean, that's a great question that I do not know the answer to.

[21:54] Matt Stashin: I mean, I think the performer is the costume, like, you know, but the puppets in that show were beautiful. Even I loved the dog. That was so simple, yes, but so effective.

[22:07] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[22:07] Matt Stashin: And the way that that piece was passed from person to person, there wasn't just one person manipulating that puppet.

[22:17] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[22:17] Matt Stashin: And for everyone from the lead to, you know, acrobats and whomever had the task of this puppet. Right. So it's an interesting, you know, as we get more and more shows that use different elements, you know, it's that conversation of, you know, do we, our categories expanded upon? Should there be a puppetry Tony?

[22:38] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh, I mean I call it the War Horse Award, I guess. I don't know.

[22:43] Matt Stashin: Well, and I also think since the show, I saw this show in preview, so I saw it a long time ago now, but I still keep thinking about the dress she wore when they went out to dinner. Do you remember it was like sort of purplish?

[22:56] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.

[22:56] Matt Stashin: Oh, so beautiful. Really beautiful.

[22:58] Bruce Gotlieb: So yeah. So there were a lot, there was a lot of costumes in the show.

[22:59] Matt Stashin: A lot.

[23:04] Bruce Gotlieb: A lot of moments, but because there are so many moments, you wonder, will do you not that anything is diluted from it. Right. But because, you know, it's like going to a circus. There's so much to look at.

[23:15] Matt Stashin: Yeah, but I think Matt is right. When you think of that show, you're not thinking about the costumes. You're thinking about the circus performance.

[23:24] Bruce Gotlieb: Absolutely. Whereas like The Great Gatsby, you are thinking about the look of the show, the costumes.

[23:29] Matt Stashin: So, alright, but we have two more. What about the costumes in Cabaret?

[23:34] Bruce Gotlieb: I think you, again, you need that underbelly. You need that grime, that skiness, if you will.

[23:44] Matt Stashin: Yes.

[23:45] Bruce Gotlieb: So, you know, the costumes in Cabaret really stand out.

[23:51] Matt Stashin: Yeah. You know, kind of opposite of Water for Elephants.

[23:55] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[23:55] Matt Stashin: Because everything is so minimalistic that everything kind of you as a, as an audience member, you can hone in and you can kind of look at each individual element as opposed to a show where there's a lot of elements and you're kind of maybe more high level.

[24:14] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, it's minimalistic, but it's stylized.

[24:17] Matt Stashin: Right. And do you think people are coming in knowing what they think the costume should look like because this is such a beloved show?

[24:23] Bruce Gotlieb: I think by this point everybody goes into Cabaret with like a vision in their head. Like Alan Cumming's suspenders and the colors.

[24:31] Eila Mell: I mean.

[24:31] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, the hat.

[24:32] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[24:33] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, I think there's an expectation.

[24:35] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[24:36] Bruce Gotlieb: So do you think this production lives up to that? Do you think it's surpassed it? Do you think it stands alone?

[24:42] Matt Stashin: I think it I I don't think it surpassed it. Um I think I think it's I think the other incarnations are a little stronger.

[24:52] Eila Mell: Okay.

[24:53] Bruce Gotlieb: Looks wise.

[24:54] Matt Stashin: Looks wise.

[24:54] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[24:55] Matt Stashin: I I have to agree. I do give it credit for like making some pretty bold choices.

[25:00] Bruce Gotlieb: Um it's almost a thankless job, right? Because if you do something like they did before, well, that was easy. You just copy it. Or if you do something different, well, you know, it's not it's not right.

[25:13] Eila Mell: So it's hard.

[25:14] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, it's everything, as we've said before, it's the subjectiveness of it all.

[25:18] Matt Stashin: Right.

[25:19] Eila Mell: Completely. And and cabaret's tough that way, because the movie is so iconic and the Alan Cumming production is so iconic.

[25:25] Bruce Gotlieb: It really is.

[25:25] Eila Mell: That like, where do you go with it now?

[25:28] Matt Stashin: It's true.

[25:29] Eila Mell: All right, and then SUFs.

[25:31] Matt Stashin: SUFS, I think, you know, because it's so period, it kind of almost it almost gives itself a leg up because of the period of because it's very costumey.

[25:45] Bruce Gotlieb: It's it is costumey, so it's something that you know, somebody had to sit down and build these pieces.

[25:51] Matt Stashin: Yes. You know, you can't you can't just go to Macy's and find these.

[25:55] Bruce Gotlieb: No.

[25:55] Matt Stashin: It's not an off the rack situation.

[25:57] Eila Mell: And again, this designer Paul Taswell has a Tony for Hamilton.

[26:02] Matt Stashin: He knows what he's doing.

[26:04] Eila Mell: Um, he was nominated for an Oscar for designing the costumes for West Side Story.

[26:08] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[26:08] Matt Stashin: So he knows period.

[26:10] Eila Mell: He does.

[26:11] Matt Stashin: And he knows it well.

[26:12] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[26:12] Eila Mell: Um, so I think it's just a given that the these these particular costumes for SUFs have to be handled meticulously because you're in a certain period of time and there is no there's no room for interpretation when it comes to history.

[26:28] Matt Stashin: Right, because you know what these women wore.

[26:30] Eila Mell: Right. There are there are photos.

[26:32] Matt Stashin: Right.

[26:32] Eila Mell: It was, you know, every when I when the show was first coming out, the first imagery I had was Mary Poppins.

[26:39] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[26:40] Eila Mell: Because I get it. That costume was so iconic in that movie.

[26:47] Matt Stashin: There was a character on a horse.

[26:48] Eila Mell: She was pretty high up in the air.

[26:49] Matt Stashin: That is true, actually.

[26:51] Eila Mell: But not not flying.

[26:52] Matt Stashin: No fly.

[26:52] Eila Mell: No, no fly.

[26:53] Matt Stashin: No tap dancing on perscenium.

[26:55] Eila Mell: No.

[26:56] Matt Stashin: But you know, yes, that said, we know what the people look like, but then there is some imagination, obviously, you know, just making reproductions of the actual clothes.

[27:07] Eila Mell: So, you know, there's a lot of creativity there.

[27:10] Matt Stashin: So, do you think that is going to help Paul Tazwell in this category or go against him?

[27:15] Bruce Gotlieb: I think it will. I think just like with Great Gatsby also, the costumes have to show something about the characters.

[27:23] Matt Stashin: You know, and there are also uh not quite the same port moment in history, but in the same area that you have to show like the different classes of people, and there's a lot of different locations as well.

[27:35] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[27:36] Matt Stashin: I think it helps.

[27:37] Bruce Gotlieb: I think it helps them. I also think his pedigree of what he's done, especially when you're looking at a period piece, not that it's you're not having someone new come in and make a splash.

[27:49] Matt Stashin: You're having somebody who's come in and established and they've he's kind of set the bar for himself.

[27:55] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[27:56] Matt Stashin: You know, so there's an expectation.

[27:59] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[27:59] Matt Stashin: You know, it's not like some new designer on the scene that's gonna give their try at it.

[28:04] Eila Mell: No, when you go to a show that he's designed, you know it's gonna be quality.

[28:07] Bruce Gotlieb: Absolutely.

[28:08] Matt Stashin: Yeah. I think he might be doing the movie Wicked too.

[28:11] Eila Mell: Oh.

[28:11] Bruce Gotlieb: Just a little bit.

[28:12] Matt Stashin: Just a small little movie.

[28:14] Eila Mell: No hype at all.

[28:15] Bruce Gotlieb: They're making a movie.

[28:16] Matt Stashin: No.

[28:18] Bruce Gotlieb: All right. So who will win?

[28:20] Eila Mell: Matt.

[28:21] Matt Stashin: You both just stare at me.

[28:24] Eila Mell: Um I think Ray Gatsby's going to win.

[28:27] Matt Stashin: I think so too.

[28:28] Eila Mell: I'm gonna go with you on that. I think it's iconic, and I think that people want to reward that.

[28:34] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[28:35] Eila Mell: I'm gonna make it a trifecta.

[28:36] Bruce Gotlieb: Excellent.

[28:37] Eila Mell: So what do we want to win? This is a bigger question.

[28:40] Matt Stashin: This is all right, Matt.

[28:42] Eila Mell: Starting with me.

[28:43] Matt Stashin: Starting with you.

[28:44] Eila Mell: Um I'm thrilled if Great Gatsby wins, but I kind of leaning SUFs.

[28:50] Matt Stashin: Okay.

[28:51] Bruce Gotlieb: I want Great Gatsby to win.

[28:53] Matt Stashin: You do.

[28:54] Bruce Gotlieb: I do. I just I think the costumes are so they're just so beautiful.

[29:01] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[29:02] Bruce Gotlieb: So so beautiful. I just I they really really stayed with me.

[29:06] Eila Mell: All right, and I'm going to go out and go for water for elephants.

[29:11] Matt Stashin: Okay.

[29:12] Bruce Gotlieb: All right.

[29:13] Eila Mell: I'm not I'm not mad at that.

[29:14] Matt Stashin: Yeah, that there was a lot to do there.

[29:17] Bruce Gotlieb: Absolutely. And it was a job well done.

[29:19] Eila Mell: Let's take a minute to hear a word from our sponsors.

[29:26] Bruce Gotlieb: So what do we have next?

[29:28] Eila Mell: Lead actor of a play.

[29:30] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.

[29:31] Eila Mell: All right. Oh, I just lost my list, so why don't you read the nominees?

[29:36] Matt Stashin: Sure. We have William Jackson Harper for Uncle Vanya, Leslie Odom Jr., Pearly Victorious, Liev Schreiber, Doubt, Jeremy Strong, An Enemy of the People, and Michael Stuhlbarg, Patriots.

[29:52] Eila Mell: I mean, this is such a list of actors.

[29:56] Bruce Gotlieb: I don't even know where to start.

[29:57] Matt Stashin: It's all just five of the best actors working today.

[30:00] Eila Mell: It's yeah.

[30:01] Matt Stashin: So the the other thing that's actually interesting, although Leslie may be with the least amount of television credits, like these are like, you know, you have people who are primarily television actors.

[30:15] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.

[30:15] Matt Stashin: And now I wasn't thinking that way.

[30:18] Eila Mell: All right, so let's talk about that.

[30:19] Matt Stashin: So William Jackson Harper was in The Good Place.

[30:22] Bruce Gotlieb: He was in the good place.

[30:23] Matt Stashin: Who did he play?

[30:24] Bruce Gotlieb: He was Chidi.

[30:25] Matt Stashin: Right. Um, and then Liev Schreiber was Ray Donovan, but uh also a big movie star.

[30:31] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.

[30:32] Matt Stashin: Um, Jeremy Strong, everyone knows was a star of Succession.

[30:36] Bruce Gotlieb: He and Brian Cox.

[30:37] Matt Stashin: And then Michael Stuhlbarg has been in so many things.

[30:39] Bruce Gotlieb: He was in Your Honor.

[30:41] Matt Stashin: Your Honor, I that's where I know I'm from.

[30:43] Bruce Gotlieb: But he was a good one.

[30:46] Matt Stashin: From the movie.

[30:47] Bruce Gotlieb: And Boardwalk Empire.

[30:48] Matt Stashin: Yes.

[30:49] Bruce Gotlieb: So many things.

[30:50] Matt Stashin: And then Leslie Odom Jr. was in a little show on Broadway called Hamilton.

[30:54] Bruce Gotlieb: A little show.

[30:54] Matt Stashin: And then he did, he did have he was also in a little show called Smash.

[30:58] Bruce Gotlieb: And he right was nominated for an Academy Award, you know.

[31:02] Matt Stashin: Right, so he's no slouch.

[31:03] Bruce Gotlieb: No.

[31:04] Matt Stashin: But I think it's an in it's interesting, right? When we were talking about Rachel McAdams before, you have people, you know, that are able, you know, they're doing different mediums and obviously doing them well to all be nominated.

[31:16] Eila Mell: But I don't know that any of these actors are new to Broadway, are they?

[31:20] Matt Stashin: Maybe Sherry Harper.

[31:22] Eila Mell: Not new, but maybe Jeremy Strong.

[31:24] Matt Stashin: He's definitely not new to theater. He's got a ton of theater credits. I don't know if this was his first Broadway show or not.

[31:29] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.

[31:29] Eila Mell: Well, so I will tell you that William Jackson Harper for me just was incredible this season.

[31:37] Matt Stashin: Because he was in Primary Trust.

[31:39] Eila Mell: He started that and was incredible.

[31:42] Matt Stashin: And I thought he was fantastic in Uncle Vanya.

[31:45] Eila Mell: He really stole the show. I think he's a wonderful, wonderful actor. I'm so thrilled that he's nominated here.

[31:51] Matt Stashin: Anyone want to add anything about him?

[31:53] Bruce Gotlieb: Th there's nothing I can add. I mean, everything that I've seen and heard about the show says that, you know, it seems like in in this production, it is just as much about Astrov as it is about Vanya.

[32:06] Matt Stashin: Which is just a testament to how good he is.

[32:08] Eila Mell: It's yes. In this translation by Heidi Shrek, who I know you love.

[32:13] Matt Stashin: I do.

[32:13] Eila Mell: Yeah, she's wonderful.

[32:14] Matt Stashin: Um, yeah, it's it's very much uh a two-man show.

[32:18] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[32:19] Eila Mell: Um all right, so how about Leslie Odom Jr. as Pearlie?

[32:22] Matt Stashin: Uh I think he does a masterful job.

[32:26] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[32:27] Matt Stashin: You know, so much is reliant on him.

[32:31] Eila Mell: He has a heavy load to carry on his shoulders.

[32:34] Matt Stashin: Yeah. You know, not only the you know, being the title character of any show is is in and of itself a task.

[32:42] Eila Mell: But he is the the cog for everything that's happening.

[32:47] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[32:47] Eila Mell: Uh a lot of physical physicality is involved.

[32:50] Matt Stashin: Right.

[32:50] Eila Mell: That's the difference between a role like Pearlie and William Jackson Harper in um Uncle Vanya.

[32:57] Matt Stashin: He is not central to every story of that show, but Leslie Odom Jr. certainly is in Pearly Victorious.

[33:04] Bruce Gotlieb: Again, I think if you have an actor, you know, we've we've seen over the years strong actors come to stage and just be okay.

[33:16] Matt Stashin: Whether it be the work, whether it be the you know the choices or whatever the reason is, Leslie doesn't.

[33:23] Bruce Gotlieb: He comes in and he punches from the start.

[33:26] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[33:27] Bruce Gotlieb: And he doesn't let up and he can't let up. Otherwise, the show doesn't work.

[33:31] Eila Mell: Right.

[33:31] Matt Stashin: If you don't have an actor there that is going to give a hundred percent from the moment the lights come up, the show you don't have a successful Purlie Victorious.

[33:43] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[33:43] Matt Stashin: And you need someone with incredible charisma to play this role too, and he succeeds there as well.

[33:48] Eila Mell: And on top of that, he's one of the producers of the show.

[33:52] Matt Stashin: So, you know, that's a lot.

[33:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Absolutely.

[33:55] Matt Stashin: Um, so Liev Schreiber in Doubt.

[33:58] Eila Mell: What a role.

[33:59] Matt Stashin: What oh, that is one of the hardest roles.

[34:02] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[34:03] Matt Stashin: Because you have to like have the charisma to hold the audience, but you also have to make them believe that you're capable of doing these horrible things that the character's accused of.

[34:11] Eila Mell: Also, the audience literally has to have doubt.

[34:15] Matt Stashin: I mean, that's the whole show.

[34:16] Eila Mell: Right.

[34:17] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[34:17] Eila Mell: I mean, he's such a great actor.

[34:19] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[34:20] Eila Mell: And what about Jeremy Strong for An Enemy of the People?

[34:23] Matt Stashin: Well, so you're a fan of Succession.

[34:25] Eila Mell: Very much so.

[34:26] Matt Stashin: Okay. So tell me, do is it a natural jump for him to go to from Succession to An Enemy of the People?

[34:33] Eila Mell: No.

[34:34] Matt Stashin: It's a very different style of acting.

[34:38] Eila Mell: It's a very different role.

[34:39] Matt Stashin: It's just it's he has a ton of range.

[34:42] Eila Mell: Like there's nothing else I can say about it.

[34:44] Matt Stashin: And I I applaud his choice to go from a huge series like that and then to go into Ibsen.

[34:51] Eila Mell: Right.

[34:52] Matt Stashin: Because, you know, someone else would be like in a Marvel movie or something else.

[34:55] Eila Mell: So, you know, I just think it's cool that this is what he chose to do and really show off his chops.

[35:01] Bruce Gotlieb: Absolutely.

[35:02] Matt Stashin: And and you just recently saw a Pen Trees.

[35:05] Eila Mell: The other day, oh my god, Michael Stuhlbarg.

[35:08] Matt Stashin: I'm he's operatic in this role.

[35:11] Eila Mell: He's over the top, but in such a grounded, realistic way.

[35:15] Matt Stashin: I had never heard of the character he plays.

[35:18] Eila Mell: Um, although it's certainly a historical figure, but not in our in this country so much.

[35:25] Matt Stashin: We didn't grow up um with that story.

[35:28] Eila Mell: But oh my gosh, you believe every second of us, he even looks like the guy.

[35:33] Matt Stashin: And it's not because he really looks like him, but he just embodies him.

[35:36] Eila Mell: Because after the show I had to Google and look up everything because I was so riveted by his performance.

[35:41] Matt Stashin: And also Will Keene, who plays Putin in the show.

[35:44] Eila Mell: Um well, I think that that obviously speaks is a testament to the job he did.

[35:48] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[35:49] Eila Mell: If you left having to research I needed to know what the real guy looked like, what this baris I needed to know everything I could because I was so taken with his performance.

[35:59] Matt Stashin: It was exciting.

[36:00] Eila Mell: He oh my gosh.

[36:02] Matt Stashin: But it would but it was larger than life because I think that's who this man was, not because it was a hammy performance.

[36:10] Eila Mell: It wasn't that at all.

[36:11] Matt Stashin: It was grounded very much in reality.

[36:13] Eila Mell: Which I think is a a thin line to tow, especially in theater.

[36:18] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[36:18] Eila Mell: Because if you are too big, you know, there are it could be especially live.

[36:24] Matt Stashin: Oh, that's bad.

[36:25] Eila Mell: It you know, you're like, whoa.

[36:26] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[36:27] Eila Mell: So I you know, I think that that is a testament to the job that he did to be able to kind of balance all of that.

[36:33] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[36:34] Eila Mell: All right, so who do we think will win?

[36:36] Matt Stashin: This is not an easy question.

[36:38] Eila Mell: This is no merrily we roll along.

[36:41] Matt Stashin: So, all right, Matt, who do you think is going to win?

[36:44] Matt Stashin: This this is I mean, there's a lot of hard ones this year, but um I think it's going to be Jeremy Strong.

[36:51] Eila Mell: Okay. I think he's going to win.

[36:53] Matt Stashin: Any particular reason?

[36:55] Eila Mell: My gut.

[36:56] Bruce Gotlieb: Do you think that because of the fandom of Succession, do you think that helps?

[36:59] Matt Stashin: I think that's part of it. I think it's also the difference between Kendall Roy and his character here.

[37:04] Eila Mell: Okay. Um, I think he's gonna take it.

[37:07] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay. And what about you, Bruce?

[37:08] Bruce Gotlieb: I think it's gonna be Michael Stuhlbarg.

[37:11] Eila Mell: Okay. And why do you think that?

[37:14] Bruce Gotlieb: I just think there's a quiet momentum for that show. It's been like sort of like an underlying buzz. Um, and I think everybody that's seen it has been very vocal. I haven't seen the show, but I think everyone that has, I've heard a lot about him. So I think it could just be a little quiet coming in.

[37:37] Eila Mell: I think I might agree with you on that. Um, I think the more obvious choice is Leslie Odom Jr., but I feel like there's gonna be an upset here. And I feel like it could be Michael Stuhlbarg. I just think that, you know, it's a real, it's just a big fat, happy, great performance.

[37:58] Matt Stashin: There you go. So who's your want to win then?

[38:01] Eila Mell: Uh, well, this is hard. Um, my want, you gotta pick.

[38:07] Matt Stashin: I know. It's so hard.

[38:08] Eila Mell: I think it's gonna be William Jackson Harper. I just think he's so great.

[38:13] Matt Stashin: Okay. Really, really like what he does on stage.

[38:15] Bruce Gotlieb: And what about you, Matt?

[38:16] Matt Stashin: Yeah, as much as I would love to see Cheedy win a Tony, I really love for the good place knows no bounds. Um, I think my want is also Jeremy Strong.

[38:27] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay. Well, I will admit that even though I think he's wonderful, I think this role is a smaller ask than the other roles in this category. But I just, and also I think that I'm being persuaded because he was also so incredible in Primary Trust, which isn't totally fair, but I do think he's incredible.

[38:47] Bruce Gotlieb: And you, Bruce?

[38:48] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm gonna go with Leslie Odom Jr.

[38:50] Eila Mell: Okay. It would be great. I think that, um, I think there's so much, like I said, that this show relies on him for.

[39:00] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. Um, and he does it masterfully.

[39:03] Eila Mell: He really does. It would be Tony number two if he wins.

[39:05] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, it would.

[39:06] Eila Mell: All right. And one more.

[39:08] Bruce Gotlieb: One more.

[39:09] Eila Mell: All right. What category are we talking about?

[39:11] Bruce Gotlieb: We are going to delve into Lead Actress in a Play.

[39:15] Eila Mell: Okay. Would you like to do the honors of the sure?

[39:20] Bruce Gotlieb: So we have Betsy Aidem for Prayer for the French Republic, Jessica Lang, Mother Play, Rachel McAdams, Mary Jane, Sarah Paulson, Appropriate, and Amy Ryan for Doubt.

[39:34] Eila Mell: So starting, I will say, well, I'm gonna start with Amy Ryan.

[39:39] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay. So who had a week to step into this role?

[39:42] Eila Mell: Yeah. So going into this once when it was announced, you know, Tyne Daly coming in to do the, you know, Doubt was that was the marketing. And it almost seemed like a no-brainer that it would be Tyne Daly to play this role, right?

[39:56] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. It was as soon as they announced it, it just seemed obvious. Of course she's gonna play this part. Perfectly cast. You knew that she was gonna come in and just nail it.

[40:05] Eila Mell: Oh, yeah. People were already saying, well, there's one of the nominees without it even taking place.

[40:11] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. And you know, unfortunately, she got sick and had to back out of the production.

[40:17] Eila Mell: So, and Amy Ryan's no slouch when it comes to acting.

[40:23] Bruce Gotlieb: What a range. You have this woman who's, like you said, coming in a week. She wasn't part of the production. There was an understudy that was performing.

[40:30] Eila Mell: Right, who had to do performances because they were already in.

[40:33] Bruce Gotlieb: Right, because Tyne was sick and she did some performances.

[40:37] Eila Mell: She did do some. So then when they were like, okay, well, we're gonna open, we need, you know, you unfortunately, this type of show, you need a headliner.

[40:46] Bruce Gotlieb: You do. You need a per, you need somebody notable.

[40:49] Eila Mell: Right. Um, so for Amy Ryan to come in and just blow it out of the water. Yeah, that's pretty incredible. And still learn it in front of the audience, really.

[41:00] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. But people have raved about her performance. So, you know, I just hats off to her.

[41:06] Eila Mell: Yeah, and but she's so different from Tyne Daly. So it's so interesting. I mean, she had played the part before, but in a different production that she had to learn concept, you know.

[41:15] Bruce Gotlieb: A different vision of the show.

[41:17] Eila Mell: Right. So it's, I'm sure she had to change so many things that she already knew.

[41:20] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. She might have known the words, but everything else had to change.

[41:23] Eila Mell: And who knows how long ago she did. She might not have even remembered.

[41:27] Bruce Gotlieb: That's true. That's true. Like, was she off book?

[41:30] Eila Mell: Right. I mean, because you know, she's learned so many scripts since then, I'm sure, but you know, so I just left to her. I just think that's, you know, a feat in and of itself.

[41:39] Bruce Gotlieb: Amy Ryan is an actress who I think can play any type of role and just do so well. I mean, she's hilarious in The Office. She's so good in Only Murders in the Building. But then, I mean, when she does a drama, it's like, watch out. She's raw. So, you know, she's fantastic.

[41:58] Eila Mell: Um, Betsy Aidem, that was a real surprise for me that she got the nomination, and good for her.

[42:04] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, I mean, there were only originally supposed to be four nominees in the category just because of the number of eligible performances. So there had to be a tie.

[42:12] Eila Mell: Or a very close number.

[42:17] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. We don't know who's fifth. But yeah, but good for her. Um, you know, this is a long play. There's a lot to do.

[42:26] Eila Mell: And not to discard anything she's done on stage in any other season. She might be heavier in the conversation.

[42:34] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. But unfortunately.

[42:36] Eila Mell: There's so many, yeah.

[42:37] Bruce Gotlieb: The unfortunately in this category, being the fifth of what should be four, in, you know, you're in this conversation with actresses of this magnitude in class. Like so bravo. Uh, if any other season, you probably could be a front runner.

[42:57] Eila Mell: Oh, for sure. But it's unfortunate in that way, right? When you look at some of these races, right, you almost feel badly for people that I don't want to say don't have a shot, because everyone does.

[43:07] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh my god. Yeah, we don't know.

[43:09] Eila Mell: But you also want to be like, oh, if you would have just come out next season it could have been well, also what I think might go against her a little bit is that she was just in Leopoldstadt. And this is, it's not a similar play, but it has similar themes, and so maybe people would think, oh well, she's done something like that already.

[43:29] Bruce Gotlieb: I’m not saying that's the case, but I just wonder if that might go against her a little bit.

[43:33] Eila Mell: Right, where you look at Amy Ryan, who's such a chameleon and so very right.

[43:38] Bruce Gotlieb: So who knows? And then you have Rachel McAdams. She's making her Broadway debut.

[43:42] Eila Mell: Star power goes a long way in these races.

[43:45] Bruce Gotlieb: It does. It does. And I've heard she's given, I haven't seen the show, but I've heard she's given a wonderful performance.

[43:52] Eila Mell: Yeah. Uh, very believable, very, you know, gripping, all of the adjectives.

[43:57] Bruce Gotlieb: In a very hard emotional role.

[43:59] Eila Mell: Yeah. Yeah. That's not something that's easy to live night after night.

[44:03] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. She has to cover a lot of ground in that show.

[44:05] Eila Mell: Yeah. And she does it fairly effortlessly. I mean, she really is wonderful.

[44:12] Bruce Gotlieb: And then, I mean, Jessica Lang.

[44:15] Eila Mell: So you have to, so to me, and we will talk about each of them.

[44:18] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.

[44:19] Eila Mell: To me, Jessica Lang and Sarah Paulson, they are the front runners.

[44:22] Bruce Gotlieb: I think you're probably right. I think it's the Battle of American Horror Story.

[44:27] Matt Stashin: Ryan Murphy's.

[44:30] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. He'll be, will he sit in the middle maybe in one on either side?

[44:33] Eila Mell: We just call it the Ryan Murphy Tony Awards then.

[44:36] Bruce Gotlieb: So she, Jessica Lang gives a riveting, riveting performance.

[44:43] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[44:43] Bruce Gotlieb: Um, there's certain arcs and so she just, she never leaves the stage once.

[44:52] Eila Mell: No, she never leaves the stage. You don't see her in the beginning, but she's on stage from the time the lights come up.

[44:56] Bruce Gotlieb: Um, and I saw the show, I saw Appropriate because we all went together.

[45:04] Eila Mell: Yes.

[45:04] Bruce Gotlieb: And then when I, and after that I said Sarah Paulson, like everyone's saying it's Sarah Paulson's stream to lose when the lights came up at Mother Play I texted you, Eila, and I said Jessica Lang just stole the Tony.

[45:19] Matt Stashin: Do you agree?

[45:21] Matt Stashin: I, I, it's very possible. I mean, you've heard me say this, Eila, like all three of them in Mother Play, Jessica Lang and Jim Parsons and C. Lynn Bulger are probably doing some of the best work of their career. Like the acting on that stage has to be seen to be believed.

[45:36] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[45:37] Matt Stashin: And she is astounding.

[45:39] Bruce Gotlieb: She always is. I mean, she's Jessica Lang.

[45:42] Matt Stashin: Right. She's just, you know, she's iconic, but she also is the real deal talent-wise.

[45:49] Bruce Gotlieb: She's iconic for a reason.

[45:50] Matt Stashin: She delivers.

[45:51] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, she does.

[45:52] Eila Mell: All right. And then Sarah Paulson.

[45:54] Matt Stashin: Sarah Paulson does an amazing job. I mean, she's a very unlikable character.

[46:01] Bruce Gotlieb: Very unlikable character, but as much as she's unlikable, not that you're rooting for her, but I think, and I think it's a kudos to the direction and to her job as an actress, that you're at least entertaining her.

[46:16] Eila Mell: Right?

[46:16] Matt Stashin: You're, you're, you see where she's coming from, even though you might not agree with her and her ways.

[46:21] Eila Mell: She's unlikable, but you understand where she's coming from.

[46:24] Bruce Gotlieb: And her frustration.

[46:25] Eila Mell: Yeah. Right.

[46:26] Bruce Gotlieb: For sure.

[46:26] Eila Mell: Right. You might not, you might not have her back.

[46:29] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[46:30] Eila Mell: But you understand, you're like, okay. There's definitely humanity there, you know.

[46:35] Bruce Gotlieb: She's just not a one-note.

[46:36] Eila Mell: She, you know, you totally understand.

[46:39] Bruce Gotlieb: And she's a full person.

[46:41] Eila Mell: Yes. Like you could see her in at Starbucks. Like you can see her outside of the world of this play.

[46:44] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[46:47] Eila Mell: Which that's because there's so much in her life she's bringing to the character.

[46:50] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, and I think that part of, again, similar to Leslie Odom Jr., where you are the lead. This, you know, this show, everything hinges on you. It, that likewise for Sarah in this role. You have, you are doing all of the heavy lifting. You know, her supporting cast is wonderful, but if she, if she's flat, it doesn't work.

[47:15] Eila Mell: Yeah, it's a pretty crucial part.

[47:17] Bruce Gotlieb: It really is. But I do love Natalie Gold in this show.

[47:20] Eila Mell: All right, and then is that it? Do we, that's us?

[47:22] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh my gosh.

[47:24] Eila Mell: All right. So, well, who's going to win?

[47:28] Matt Stashin: I was so hoping you'd start with someone else.

[47:34] Eila Mell: No, no, I will win. I think Jessica Lang is going to win.

[47:37] Matt Stashin: Really?

[47:38] Eila Mell: I really do.

[47:38] Matt Stashin: I still think it's gonna be Sarah Paulson.

[47:41] Eila Mell: I think it's gonna be Jessica Lang.

[47:42] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay. And who do you want to win?

[47:44] Matt Stashin: I want Jessica Lang.

[47:45] Bruce Gotlieb: And Bruce.

[47:46] Bruce Gotlieb: I want Jessica Lang also.

[47:50] Eila Mell: Bruce just said it. Come on.

[47:51] Matt Stashin: Okay. Do you want me to re- I want Jessica Lang?

[47:54] Eila Mell: Okay, all right. And now Matt.

[47:56] Matt Stashin: I would like Jessica Lang as well. Although Sarah Paulson was phenomenal.

[48:00] Eila Mell: Yeah. I want Jessica Lang to win. I mean, if it's between those, well, if it's between everybody, but if we're going to narrow it down to those two, I'm gonna go with Sarah Paulson.

[48:10] Bruce Gotlieb: Jessica Lang's got a Tony, and Sarah Paulson doesn't, so and she's giving an incredible performance.

[48:18] Eila Mell: So this has been exhausting making all these big decisions.

[48:22] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, it's time to take a nap.

[48:24] Eila Mell: Okay.

[48:25] Bruce Gotlieb: A nap, but Matt, will you come back for our finale?

[48:28] Matt Stashin: Happily.

[48:29] Eila Mell: Okay. All right. Well, we're gonna catch up with you guys later. Run out, see a show, let us know what you think. See one of these shows that are nominated. Join the conversation.

[48:39] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes. Uh, DM us on Instagram, send us an email, let us know what you're seeing, what you're loving, what you're thinking.

[48:46] Eila Mell: Yes, and we'll repost you if you, if you tag us, we'll repost you.

[48:49] Bruce Gotlieb: Absolutely.

[48:50] Eila Mell: All right. Well, we will see you next time on Behind the Awards.

[48:53] Bruce Gotlieb: Bye-bye.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred