Rumors have it that Stereophonic will bring home the Tony. Feature Friday! Eila & Bruce bring you the sixth installment of their Tony deep dive. They are joined by expert Matt Stashin and share who will win and who they want to win in the following categories... Read More
From the show: Behind the Awards with Eila Mell & Bruce Gotlieb
Guests
Miniseries Inclusions
Featured Shows
About
Rumors have it that Stereophonic will bring home the Tony
Feature Friday! Eila & Bruce bring you the sixth installment of their Tony deep dive. They are joined by expert Matt Stashin and share who will win and who they want to win in the following categories. Best Musical, Best Play, Scenic Design of a Musical, Lead Actress of a Musical, Lead Actor of a Musical.
Jaja’s African Hair Braiding, Mary Jane, Mother Play, Prayer for the French Republic, Stereophonic, Hells Kitchen, Illinoise, The Outsiders, Suffs, Water for Elephants, Brody Grant, Jonathan Groff, Merrily We Roll Along, Dorian Harewood, The Notebook, Brian d’Arcy, Days of Wine and Roses, Eddie Redmayne, Cabaret, Eden Espinosa, Lempicka, Maleah Joi Moon, Maryann Plunket, Kelli O’Hara, Gayle Rankin, Back to the Future, Here Lies Love.
Make sure to check out Eila's book, "The Tony Awards", and all her other amazing books: https://amzn.to/43WMu5Y.
Connect with Eila and Bruce:
- Instagram @behind_the_awards
- Eila @eilamell
- Bruce @cominghomewithbruce
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:09] Eila Mell: Hello and welcome to Behind the Awards.
[0:11] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm Bruce.
[0:12] Eila Mell: I'm here with Bruce.
[0:14] Bruce Gotlieb: Hi, Eila.
[0:15] Eila Mell: Hi, Bruce. Tonies are so close we could taste them.
[0:18] Bruce Gotlieb: I know. We have been waiting for this moment for months.
[0:22] Eila Mell: We have been, and we've been diving into deep territory.
[0:27] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh yeah, it's so much fun.
[0:29] Eila Mell: It is so much fun. And we're so happy to have Matt Stashin back with us.
[0:33] Matt Stashin: Thank you.
[0:36] Eila Mell: Thank you for coming back to our final installment.
[0:39] Matt Stashin: Thank you for having me. This has been so much fun.
[0:42] Eila Mell: It really has. Well, Bruce, there's a lot to cover today.
[0:45] Bruce Gotlieb: There's a lot to cover.
[0:46] Eila Mell: We have five more categories.
[0:48] Bruce Gotlieb: All right.
[0:49] Eila Mell: We have Best Play, Scenic Design of a Musical, Best Musical, Lead Actor, and Actress of a Musical.
[0:58] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh, okay.
[0:59] Eila Mell: So that's a lot. Buckle up.
[1:01] Bruce Gotlieb: All right. So why don't we start with Best Play?
[1:04] Eila Mell: I think we should.
[1:05] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay. So the nominees for Best Play are Ja Ja's African Hair Braiding, Mary Jane, Mother Play, Prayer for the French Republic, and Stereophonic.
[1:05] Eila Mell: All right. So where to start? I mean, let's start with Stereophonic just to get it out of the way.
[1:22] Bruce Gotlieb: Stereophonic is the big show.
[1:25] Eila Mell: It's got the most nominations of the plays.
[1:28] Bruce Gotlieb: In history.
[1:28] Eila Mell: The most nominations in history for a play.
[1:30] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh really? I didn't know that.
[1:32] Eila Mell: Wow. And I think it's touted as the one to beat.
[1:36] Bruce Gotlieb: Absolutely. So I didn't love the play.
[1:41] Eila Mell: Mm-hmm.
[1:42] Bruce Gotlieb: I probably one of the few.
[1:44] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[1:44] Bruce Gotlieb: But I just I thought it was a little long.
[1:48] Eila Mell: I didn't really feel like I cared about the people.
[1:53] Bruce Gotlieb: Like I think they did a good job. The actresses, the actress did a good job. The set was beautiful, like there were so many elements that were good.
[2:01] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[2:02] Bruce Gotlieb: I just if we're going in as an overall encompassing award, it just to me wasn't the best play of the season.
[2:08] Eila Mell: Okay. And Matt, do you have thoughts about it?
[2:11] Matt Stashin: I think you're absolutely right. I think it's probably going to win. I think it's a kind of play that it's easier to appreciate than to love because they are presenting all of these people with all of their flaws.
[2:24] Eila Mell: You know, so it's hard to love them, but it presents them accurately, if that makes sense.
[2:33] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. Do you think that you have to be, you know, it's loosely based on Fleetwood Mac?
[2:38] Matt Stashin: No, yeah. Do you think you need to be a fan of that genre or that time period, or do you think it's universal?
[2:44] Matt Stashin: I think it helps, but I don't think it's mandatory. I definitely think it can be fairly universal because it's more about the human relationships between the people and about like the making of the art.
[2:58] Eila Mell: Right than it is about the music. The music's there as like it helps it along.
[3:04] Bruce Gotlieb: It's sort of like any episode of Behind the Music on VH1.
[3:07] Eila Mell: Right.
[3:08] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.
[3:09] Eila Mell: Right. Um I agree. I think I definitely liked it for sure. I think it is long by design. I think its length and the fact that the audience is there for such a long time sort of puts you in the frame of mind of the characters who spend much longer than they expected making this album.
[3:30] Matt Stashin: Sure.
[3:31] Eila Mell: I think it could also be successful if it were shorter, though.
[3:34] Bruce Gotlieb: I agree with you. I see why people love it. It wasn't my favorite play of the whole season, but I did like it. Um I don't know. What are you more excited about that's in this category, Bruce?
[3:45] Bruce Gotlieb: I mean, I don't want to give any of our predictions.
[3:48] Eila Mell: No, I'm just saying more excited.
[3:50] Bruce Gotlieb: Um, of these plays, I would say Ja Ja's African Hair Braiding and Mother Play are two completely different plays from one another.
[3:59] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[4:00] Bruce Gotlieb: But that stood out and grabbed me more.
[4:03] Eila Mell: Okay. Well, Ja Ja's African Hair Braiding is just a real celebration.
[4:08] Bruce Gotlieb: It is.
[4:08] Eila Mell: Um, it's so much fun, but also poignant at the end and just a slice of life of this wonderful group of people.
[4:16] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. I think if there is a sleeper in this category, that's gonna be it. I know a lot of the voters are people from out on the road from the tours, and Ja Ja's getting a tour.
[4:27] Eila Mell: Okay.
[4:28] Bruce Gotlieb: So I think if there is a sleeper, Ja Ja might be the one.
[4:32] Eila Mell: Well, that would be okay with me.
[4:33] Bruce Gotlieb: It would be super exciting too.
[4:35] Eila Mell: It really would be exciting. It would be a big upset.
[4:37] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. I mean, you think of Wicked.
[4:40] Eila Mell: Right.
[4:40] Bruce Gotlieb: Right? The year that everybody was like, well, it's Wicked. I mean, who's gonna make it? Of course it's Wicked, and then it wasn't Wicked, it was Avenue Q, right?
[4:48] Eila Mell: So I just think it's thrilling when that happens.
[4:50] Bruce Gotlieb: I know. That's what makes it so much fun.
[4:52] Eila Mell: It's so boring when it's predictable.
[4:54] Bruce Gotlieb: So I think if that were to win, why not? And it's good enough to win for sure.
[5:00] Eila Mell: It is certainly. Um but Mother Play is also really, really good. There's some humor there, but it doesn't grab your emotion right away.
[5:11] Bruce Gotlieb: But when it does, it just has a hold.
[5:15] Eila Mell: And how much of this is Paula Vogel's real life story, do we know?
[5:19] Matt Stashin: I don't remember how much per se. What I do know is that she wrote it for Celia Keenan-Bolger.
[5:28] Eila Mell: Oh, I recently read an article where Celia said that how much she felt touched to have a child.
[5:38] Bruce Gotlieb: An honor indeed. Especially from a playwright like that.
[5:41] Eila Mell: So not only the work, but yes, I believe, if memory serves me correctly, that yes, it was a slice of her life or inspired by she being the Celia Keenan-Bolger character.
[5:54] Matt Stashin: Yeah.
[5:55] Eila Mell: So, you know, you have something similar to when we were talking about SUFS. You have somebody who's writing a piece of work that they love so much that's ingrained somehow within their fiber.
[6:09] Bruce Gotlieb: More so because if it's about her life than Shannon Tau, but you can't deny what that does. You know, it ha you know it's gonna move people.
[6:23] Eila Mell: Yeah. And it does such a wonderful job of doing that. We talked with Stereophonic and we had talked in another episode about Appropriate, how the characters may not always be likable, but you get where they're coming from and you understand them.
[6:37] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[6:38] Eila Mell: In Mother Play, not only do you understand where all these people come from with all of the conflict that they have, but you also genuinely like all of them. Like, and the Jessica Lange character, the mother, could have been a monster.
[6:52] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.
[6:53] Eila Mell: Like she could have come across as such an unlikable character. And I think it's the writing of the play and Jessica Lange's performance that she just is sympathetic.
[7:04] Bruce Gotlieb: And the direction too, I'm sure.
[7:05] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[7:06] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[7:06] Eila Mell: Um, so Prayer for the French Republic.
[7:09] Bruce Gotlieb: So that is a transfer from off-Broadway.
[7:12] Eila Mell: Very beloved, right?
[7:14] Bruce Gotlieb: People, I mean, it's a piece that people love.
[7:14] Eila Mell: Yeah, well, it had this great off-Broadway run, and then it came to Broadway. Again, another long show.
[7:24] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.
[7:25] Eila Mell: Season of length.
[7:26] Bruce Gotlieb: I guess so.
[7:27] Eila Mell: Was this not quite three and a half hours?
[7:29] Bruce Gotlieb: I don't believe so.
[7:30] Eila Mell: Yeah, but over three.
[7:32] Bruce Gotlieb: Over three. I think it I do think it's a strong piece, a strong play. I think it has a place in this nomination pool, obviously.
[7:43] Eila Mell: It's timely.
[7:43] Bruce Gotlieb: It is timely. I just I think like some other categories, I just think it I wonder if it has enough gas left in the tank to be awarded the Tony.
[8:00] Eila Mell: And it also came early, didn't it?
[8:01] Bruce Gotlieb: I think it did. Relatively early.
[8:03] Eila Mell: In at least in relation to these other ones, you know, that and Ja Ja's Yes were were earlier.
[8:10] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.
[8:11] Eila Mell: Okay, I just say Manhattan Theater Club had a really good year this year.
[8:14] Bruce Gotlieb: They really did.
[8:15] Eila Mell: Three Broadway shows Ja Ja's, Prayer for the French Republic, and Mary Jane.
[8:18] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, and they're all nominated for Best Play.
[8:21] Eila Mell: That's amazing.
[8:22] Bruce Gotlieb: That's really great.
[8:22] Eila Mell: So get your subscriptions.
[8:25] Bruce Gotlieb: I guess so. Um, so yeah, and Mary Jane, I think it's being extended, right?
[8:31] Eila Mell: I believe so, yeah.
[8:31] Bruce Gotlieb: I believe they just extended it. It's doing really well.
[8:34] Eila Mell: They're all compelling choices.
[8:36] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.
[8:37] Eila Mell: So, okay, what do we think is going to win? Is this an easy one?
[8:40] Bruce Gotlieb: I think for the will win, it's an easy one.
[8:43] Eila Mell: The should win, the should win is much harder.
[8:45] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay, I think the will win, I think we could all agree is Stereophonic.
[8:49] Eila Mell: Yes, I think that that is very easy to do. There's a chance for a spoiler, but I think it will be Stereophonic.
[8:53] Matt Stashin: Okay.
[8:54] Bruce Gotlieb: And what do you want to win, Matt?
[8:55] Matt Stashin: I want Ja Ja to win.
[8:57] Eila Mell: Okay.
[8:57] Matt Stashin: That would be fun.
[9:00] Bruce Gotlieb: That would be fun.
[9:00] Eila Mell: That would be fun.
[9:00] Bruce Gotlieb: And I wouldn't turn my nose up for that.
[9:04] Eila Mell: I think my want is Mother Play.
[9:06] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.
[9:07] Eila Mell: But then I would not turn my nose up at that.
[9:10] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[9:10] Eila Mell: It's just, you know, when you get to those sleeper picks to those like ones that kind of eke into you and stay with you. We've talked about how some shows have just stayed with us and we keep talking about it.
[9:20] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.
[9:20] Eila Mell: Those shows both did that.
[9:22] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay. What about you, Eila? What's your want?
[9:26] Eila Mell: This is kind of hard for me. For me, it's between Stereophonic and Ja Ja.
[9:31] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.
[9:32] Eila Mell: And I guess I'll go with Stereophonic. I'm not 100% sure about it, but I think that's what I'll go with.
[9:41] Bruce Gotlieb: Just to be different from you guys.
[9:44] Eila Mell: Well, I think we should move on to Scenic Design of a Play.
[9:44] Bruce Gotlieb: All right, let's take a look.
[9:50] Eila Mell: Oh, sorry, Scenic Design of a Musical.
[9:52] Bruce Gotlieb: Of a Musical.
[9:53] Eila Mell: I take that back. All right, so what are the nominees?
[9:57] Bruce Gotlieb: We have Robert Brill and Peter Negrini for Hell's Kitchen.
[10:02] Eila Mell: Okay.
[10:06] Bruce Gotlieb: David Corins, Here Lies Love, Tim Hatley and Finn Ross, Back to the Future.
[10:12] Eila Mell: Ricardo Hernandez and Peter Negrini for Olympica, Tom Scott for Cabaret, and AMP featuring Tatiana Kavdekan for The Outsiders.
[10:25] Bruce Gotlieb: We apologize for any name mispronunciations.
[10:25] Eila Mell: All right, well, let's talk about the design for The Outsiders.
[10:32] Bruce Gotlieb: They certainly created the feel of Tulsa, Oklahoma in like the 60s.
[10:38] Eila Mell: Yeah, I mean, I've never been to Tulsa, Oklahoma personally.
[10:41] Bruce Gotlieb: Neither have I, but I feel like I have.
[10:42] Eila Mell: But if I were to in my head create an imagery or a feeling of what Tulsa, Oklahoma would be, I think she got it.
[10:51] Bruce Gotlieb: And also this class of people.
[10:53] Eila Mell: Yeah, you had a certain, you know, differentiation between classes of people. You had a different you had a certain environment of where this story took place.
[11:03] Bruce Gotlieb: Um, and all of that needed to happen in synergy with one another.
[11:09] Eila Mell: And she made fire on stage.
[11:11] Bruce Gotlieb: And rain.
[11:12] Eila Mell: And rain. I mean, a lot of elements in the show.
[11:15] Bruce Gotlieb: A lot of elements.
[11:16] Eila Mell: And they all worked.
[11:17] Bruce Gotlieb: Literally, fire, water.
[11:18] Eila Mell: Exactly. And they all worked.
[11:20] Bruce Gotlieb: They did.
[11:21] Eila Mell: And they worked very, very well.
[11:22] Bruce Gotlieb: They were very effective.
[11:24] Eila Mell: Yeah. There were a lot of different scenes, but you get a lot of scenes in a musical typically.
[11:28] Bruce Gotlieb: You do.
[11:28] Eila Mell: And I think that I think this the scene the design work of this show is really really tells really helps tell the story, takes on a character of itself.
[11:40] Bruce Gotlieb: And a lot of playing areas too.
[11:41] Eila Mell: Yeah, she played with you not only your normal upstage, downstage and you know, and your wing space.
[11:48] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[11:48] Eila Mell: But she played with levels of height.
[11:49] Bruce Gotlieb: And she did. Remember, she changed the level in one thing when Pony Boy and Johnny were, you know, on the run.
[11:56] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[11:57] Bruce Gotlieb: And were they in like in a barn or something?
[11:58] Eila Mell: Yeah. And then I said to Bruce, are they lower now than they were at the beginning of the scene?
[12:04] Matt Stashin: She changed it somehow.
[12:06] Eila Mell: She did.
[12:07] Matt Stashin: She played with it. And then also on stage itself, you had a car that lived on stage.
[12:12] Eila Mell: But also became things other than a car.
[12:15] Matt Stashin: And then the car would just disappear to your eye, even though you it was still there. And it also gave you different levels to play with.
[12:19] Eila Mell: Yeah, it was interesting. So I think it's a very effective design.
[12:26] Matt Stashin: Yes. Um, but if you're gonna go, if you're sitting in the front row, you might want to bring a raincoat because there's rain and there's a lot of gravel.
[12:33] Eila Mell: And gravel that gets kicked off into the house. Maybe a safety goggle.
[12:36] Matt Stashin: Maybe. Like you're gonna do it. Do they have to sign a waiver to sit there?
[12:40] Eila Mell: I mean, we weren't privy. We weren't in the very front. Um, what's next?
[12:44] Matt Stashin: So let's work our way down to Hell's Kitchen.
[12:50] Eila Mell: All right. So here you have, we've talked about it in other areas, you have to evoke a time period and a place.
[13:00] Matt Stashin: Um, and I think it's done very successfully.
[13:03] Eila Mell: Yeah. So Robert's Kitchen and Peter Negrini worked together, but Peter Negrini is the projections.
[13:09] Matt Stashin: Right. And Robert Brill is the set.
[13:11] Eila Mell: And just a little tidbit, Robert Brill did the Alan Cumming cabaret.
[13:16] Matt Stashin: He designed that, and it's sort of a full circle moment because that's also back this season as well.
[13:22] Eila Mell: So yeah. So I think it's an effective design. I think for it to do its job well, yeah, you know, it has to be effective. You don't want it to, you don't want it to you want it to help tell the story, and I think it does it.
[13:35] Matt Stashin: Right. Like a show like Hell's Kitchen, the music has to be the star.
[13:39] Eila Mell: Absolutely. Because people are coming in wanting to hear that music.
[13:42] Matt Stashin: They want to hear Empire State of Mind, they want to hear Girl on Fire, they want to hear Fallen.
[13:46] Eila Mell: I mean exactly. So you almost sort of have to, with all the design elements, you have to support the music.
[13:53] Matt Stashin: Right. In a, you know, an abstract kind of way.
[13:56] Eila Mell: Right. You have, I don't want to say lesser of a job to do, but you have to do it, maybe quieter is the right word.
[14:03] Matt Stashin: Right. You know, it has to be an underlier.
[14:06] Eila Mell: Yeah. So all right. What's the next, uh, Water for Elephants?
[14:11] Matt Stashin: I guess so. Well, I mean, this, there's a lot going on here. There is a train, there's a circus tent, there is, you know, hotel rooms and restaurants.
[14:24] Eila Mell: And there's so many different places. And I think that the design really captures the feel for each of these locations.
[14:32] Matt Stashin: But they did it kind of minimally. Like it wasn't an overwhelming gargantuan luxe set. It was done fairly simply.
[14:40] Eila Mell: Right. And that's unit, you didn't have unit sets coming in, unit pieces.
[14:44] Matt Stashin: Right. Which I think you could.
[14:46] Eila Mell: Well, you can't because there's right, there's too much. And also the same thing could be said for The Outsiders, because they did a lot with just wood planks. Like they, there wasn't a lot of realistic scenery, but they made things like the hospital bed was really just a wood plank.
[15:00] Matt Stashin: Yeah, it took a, you relied on the audience's imagination. You gave them the, you know, both of those shows gave them the blueprint of what they wanted you to see, and then said, okay, now see it.
[15:18] Eila Mell: Right. The Outsiders was definitely more bare bones.
[15:20] Matt Stashin: For sure. And Water for Elephants, you know, did it on a much bigger level.
[15:25] Eila Mell: For sure. Um, but you know, again, so the circus was so important, the element of that. But like, so there's a train. We don't actually see a train, we see elements of the set that make up a train.
[15:36] Matt Stashin: It's not a realistic looking train, but with the lights and the choreography, yeah, it becomes a train.
[15:42] Eila Mell: Right, right. Because if you just walked into the theater and saw the setup just the way it is.
[15:50] Matt Stashin: Right. Yeah, you're not thinking, look, there's a train.
[15:52] Eila Mell: No, exactly. Right. So um, and but then it's a very different story for Here Lies Love.
[15:58] Matt Stashin: Mm-hmm.
[15:59] Eila Mell: So you want to talk about what goes into that set. I mean that set was insane.
[16:04] Matt Stashin: They mean literally gutted the Broadway Theater and turned it into a nightclub.
[16:09] Eila Mell: Yes, with room for maybe 75% of the audience to be in the midst of the playing space.
[16:16] Matt Stashin: So they all stood and moved scenery.
[16:18] Eila Mell: Yeah, and if I remember correctly, there were people like their job was to herd the audience to where they needed to be so the action could take place on the dance floor.
[16:28] Matt Stashin: Like air traffic controllers in like these orange jumpsuits.
[16:31] Eila Mell: They were so cute. With the night we saw David Byrne there singing along to all the music with the actors.
[16:37] Matt Stashin: Yeah, that was part of the fun of it, that David Byrne was there at the show just, you know, with everybody else.
[16:45] Eila Mell: That was a big design.
[16:48] Matt Stashin: Yes. And not only was it the design, but it was also the video elements because that was very key to telling the story and also helping people in the audience locate where some of the actors were.
[17:00] Eila Mell: Right. Because the actors were everywhere in the theater, so you might not be able to see someone from where you're sitting.
[17:06] Matt Stashin: Yeah, we had to at one point I think we had to like lean forward to be able to see what was happening over up in the mezzanine.
[17:12] Eila Mell: Right. But there were video screens that captured some of these moments. So that was very helpful.
[17:17] Matt Stashin: Um, but that was just a massive job.
[17:20] Eila Mell: It was. It was, and it was so well done.
[17:22] Matt Stashin: It really was. Um, but again, not necessarily realistic settings, you know, but again with musicals, you don't get that.
[17:30] Eila Mell: Right. You get hints, like you get a gate. So and we know we're in front of, you know, this building, and then we get, you know, like a little pieces of the room, and that's enough because you have to get scenery on and off pretty quickly.
[17:45] Matt Stashin: But everything was grounded like in this nightclub.
[17:47] Eila Mell: Right. Yeah. Exactly. We'll be right back. We have to listen to some commercials.
[17:57] Matt Stashin: Um, all right. So what's next on our list?
[17:59] Eila Mell: Uh, Tim Hadley and Finn Ross for Back to the Future.
[18:02] Matt Stashin: Okay, so tech played a big part in this.
[18:05] Eila Mell: So Finn Ross is the video element. And in this show, you know, the scenic work is obviously important. The tech of the show is lifting so much.
[18:18] Matt Stashin: Yeah. You know, and the video is so important to invoke speed.
[18:22] Eila Mell: Yeah. You know, you're in a DeLorean, we most people have seen the movie. You know it's not just strung along at 20 miles an hour.
[18:30] Matt Stashin: Right, yeah, right. That's really important because if you don't have the right speed or feel like this is really moving, you've lost the audience.
[18:37] Eila Mell: Yeah, you do. You walk into the Winter Garden and you feel like you've stepped into a time machine.
[18:45] Matt Stashin: Really? The way that the lights all on the proscenium on the boxes, everything is moving.
[18:51] Eila Mell: Yeah. Also you, it gives you that moment. It gives you that you already are set up for a technical, a technological experience.
[19:01] Matt Stashin: Um, and I think that that is really impressive, uh, you know, work of the scenic design.
[19:06] Eila Mell: And the car.
[19:07] Matt Stashin: And the car. But also, but all of the tech, because that show has so many like iconic moments that if it doesn't play out perfectly between the car on the stage and the projection in the back and the actor that's like on a platform, you know, thinking specifically of the climax of the show.
[19:23] Eila Mell: Uh, if it all doesn't work perfectly, it, it's gonna die.
[19:29] Matt Stashin: Is this the clock tower?
[19:30] Eila Mell: It is the clock tower.
[19:31] Matt Stashin: And that's the one that I'm coming to specifically.
[19:33] Eila Mell: Yeah. Because like literally the projections in the car and Roger Bart up on the platform, it all has to be so carefully orchestrated.
[19:43] Matt Stashin: It has to work perfectly or the show's not going to work.
[19:45] Eila Mell: Yeah. And at least the night we were there it worked perfectly.
[19:49] Matt Stashin: Well yeah I mean I think it probably almost always works perfectly I think it kind of has to yeah that's the success of this show I think people are loving that.
[19:58] Eila Mell: It's the opposite of what we were saying about like The Outsiders and Water for Elephants where it's like a minimal set.
[20:03] Matt Stashin: Yeah.
[20:04] Eila Mell: This is the grand luxe.
[20:06] Matt Stashin: Well it's the 80s right so you have to, you know, it's all about extra.
[20:06] Eila Mell: Exactly right. Um what about Ricardo Hernandez and Peter Negrini for Lempicka?
[20:18] Matt Stashin: So Lempicka is interesting. There's a lot of, um, I guess may I want to call it almost like architectural type of style.
[20:27] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[20:28] Matt Stashin: Which I think lends itself to the story.
[20:31] Eila Mell: Right. Because you're talking about somebody that was a little art deco a little bit more, uh, structural.
[20:32] Matt Stashin: Well, I mean definitely the look of the show is important because she had a style of painting.
[20:44] Eila Mell: Right. So that's crucial to the show but what did you think of the decision to not use any actual paintings in this show that they were all invisible?
[20:53] Matt Stashin: I thought it was an interesting choice. I would have liked to have seen something even if it was a projection of a piece of art, not necessarily didn't have to be a replicated poster.
[21:04] Eila Mell: Right. Um, I think there were ways that you could have done some other interesting choices.
[21:10] Matt Stashin: Yeah.
[21:11] Eila Mell: Um that I think would have been a little bit more effective. I think we did see a projection at one point, right?
[21:17] Matt Stashin: Of the daughter, maybe.
[21:19] Eila Mell: Yes, but I just felt like there could have been more.
[21:21] Matt Stashin: Yeah, I agree because she was painting so much of the time and there was no actual canvas there.
[21:27] Eila Mell: Right. And I guess they didn't put anything behind it because they knew she was never going to actually paint.
[21:33] Matt Stashin: Right. But you know, it's a choice because it's a show about a painter. So you, you know, Sunday in the Park with George, we knew he didn't paint that set.
[21:42] Eila Mell: Right, but we still saw it. So I'm just throwing the question out, what did you think of that choice?
[21:46] Matt Stashin: For me, I wanted to see more.
[21:50] Eila Mell: But uh that's just me. In that show, you saw the painting with the lighting more than anything.
[21:57] Matt Stashin: Right, and that was very effective for me. I thought that was beautiful. Really beautifully done. I just to me, when I'm looking, especially, you know, you have what, seven nominations, seven nominees in this category.
[22:13] Eila Mell: Uh of all of them, I think if I'm if I'm gonna put them in a pecking order, I think this particular one's on the bottom for me.
[22:20] Matt Stashin: Okay. Uh, you know, I did think it was striking when we walked in, and it, you know, I thought the main set was really striking looking.
[22:28] Eila Mell: I don't know. It, it and I agree with you. I think it was striking, it just didn't go anywhere else for me.
[22:34] Matt Stashin: Okay.
[22:35] Eila Mell: And I think that some of these other shows, whether it be minimalistic like The Outsiders or really big like Back to the Future, it went somewhere.
[22:46] Matt Stashin: I see. It did something. This one I just think fell a little flat.
[22:50] Matt Stashin: Alright. And Matt?
[22:51] Matt Stashin: I kind of agree with both of you. I mean, I th we all saw Lempicka together.
[22:55] Eila Mell: We did.
[22:56] Matt Stashin: Um, of the three of us, I think I actually liked it the least.
[22:59] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[23:00] Matt Stashin: I mean, I can still appreciate what they were going for. I did like the fact that the general concept of the set kind of went along with her style of artwork.
[23:08] Eila Mell: It would have to, right?
[23:09] Matt Stashin: Yeah. So I like the color choices.
[23:12] Eila Mell: Yeah, the set was fairly successful, even if I had issues with other aspects of the show.
[23:17] Matt Stashin: I mean, we did see it during previews. Stuff might have changed.
[23:19] Eila Mell: I know the show has a lot of people who love it.
[23:23] Matt Stashin: So it just closed.
[23:25] Eila Mell: Yes.
[23:26] Matt Stashin: Not that long ago.
[23:27] Eila Mell: All right. And then what else is nominated here?
[23:30] Matt Stashin: Is Cabaret.
[23:31] Eila Mell: Yeah. That's the last one of the category.
[23:33] Matt Stashin: So like we've said with Cabaret, you there's a certain feeling. You're, you have to be in a period in a certain place in a certain, you know, like every a lot of these other things.
[23:45] Eila Mell: But I think in order Cabaret typically isn't a huge set.
[23:49] Matt Stashin: Mm-hmm.
[23:50] Eila Mell: You know, it's another show that's a little bit more minimalistic.
[23:52] Matt Stashin: It can be, sure.
[23:53] Eila Mell: Um, you're in a club, you're in a little seedy, a little underbelly, all of that.
[23:58] Matt Stashin: Right.
[23:58] Eila Mell: It's not gonna be beautiful looking. Right. There's no luxe like there is in Dadsby.
[24:03] Matt Stashin: Yeah. Um and Tom Scott, let's point out, did not only the set but the costumes also.
[24:08] Eila Mell: So I like that when there's like this single vision.
[24:11] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, I mean it it believe me, I I'm sure a lot of people uh and you know, collaboration is wonderful.
[24:18] Eila Mell: Um and being able to, you know, maybe see something that somebody doesn't, and vice versa, but uh you don't have to you don't have to sell your vision to somebody because you're the other person, right?
[24:30] Bruce Gotlieb: Right, yeah.
[24:31] Eila Mell: So that's probably welcomed.
[24:34] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, I I yes.
[24:35] Eila Mell: I mean it both are interesting, but I just sometimes think it's really extra interesting to see what one person comes up with, you know, when there's like it's the same person creating both aspects.
[24:49] Bruce Gotlieb: I just find it very um, you know, sometimes it really works.
[24:52] Eila Mell: I think so.
[24:53] Bruce Gotlieb: And I think for cabaret, it's very successful.
[24:56] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[24:57] Bruce Gotlieb: All right.
[24:58] Eila Mell: So do we have uh is there a consensus as to what is going to win?
[25:02] Bruce Gotlieb: Like, is there an obvious?
[25:03] Matt Stashin: I don't think there's an obvious one.
[25:05] Bruce Gotlieb: I don't think there's an obvious one at all.
[25:06] Matt Stashin: I think there's literally three or four that it might come down to.
[25:09] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh my god, that's a lot.
[25:10] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[25:11] Bruce Gotlieb: Usually that's like the category.
[25:13] Eila Mell: Before we get into what will and want, yeah, the only thing I will say that I feel like was left out here, yeah, would be the Great Gatsby.
[25:22] Matt Stashin: The Great Gatsby had a gorgeous.
[25:24] Eila Mell: The set was beautiful and the use of projection was so effective.
[25:29] Bruce Gotlieb: I think that I think it was a miss to be left out.
[25:33] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[25:33] Bruce Gotlieb: Um, and I know sometimes when we talk about things that are snubbed or left out, we go, well, what would we, you know, what would you replace it with?
[25:39] Eila Mell: And sometimes there are ones that people go, I don't know what which one I would pull out for it.
[25:44] Bruce Gotlieb: In this instance, I think it could have replaced very easily a couple of them.
[25:49] Eila Mell: Okay.
[25:50] Bruce Gotlieb: Do you want to name those?
[25:52] Matt Stashin: I I think for me personally, um, it could have replaced Limpika.
[25:56] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.
[25:57] Matt Stashin: Maybe even Cabaret.
[25:58] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.
[25:59] Matt Stashin: Um, I just think the I just think the work was so beautiful that it should be it should be in there.
[26:03] Eila Mell: And important to that story specifically.
[26:05] Bruce Gotlieb: So so important.
[26:07] Eila Mell: Another show with a there there were a lot of cars on stage this season.
[26:10] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[26:10] Eila Mell: Between the outsiders and back to the future and the Great Gatsby.
[26:13] Bruce Gotlieb: Rain and cars were in this season.
[26:16] Eila Mell: Luckily not together.
[26:17] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[26:19] Eila Mell: Although there was a car accident in the Great Gatsby.
[26:21] Bruce Gotlieb: That's true.
[26:21] Eila Mell: That's true.
[26:22] Bruce Gotlieb: It might have been raining at that point.
[26:23] Eila Mell: I don't remember.
[26:24] Bruce Gotlieb: I think it was, maybe.
[26:25] Eila Mell: All right.
[26:25] Bruce Gotlieb: So who do we think?
[26:27] Eila Mell: Matt.
[26:29] Bruce Gotlieb: We look to you.
[26:30] Matt Stashin: Look away then.
[26:31] Bruce Gotlieb: No.
[26:31] Matt Stashin: Um I'm very torn between the two grand luxe sets myself.
[26:37] Matt Stashin: Here Lies Love or Back to the Future.
[26:39] Bruce Gotlieb: I I think Back to the Future is gonna take it.
[26:42] Matt Stashin: Okay.
[26:42] Bruce Gotlieb: Because of the technical element.
[26:44] Matt Stashin: Because of the technical element.
[26:45] Bruce Gotlieb: It was it was a really difficult set to execute perfectly, and they did it.
[26:49] Eila Mell: Okay, Bruce.
[26:51] Bruce Gotlieb: I think my will win is the Outsiders.
[26:55] Eila Mell: All right.
[26:55] Bruce Gotlieb: I think it's got the show itself has a lot of momentum.
[26:59] Eila Mell: And I think people are talking about it in you know, in terms of how it is visually, but I think that that might be a quiet a quiet run.
[27:09] Matt Stashin: I think so.
[27:10] Bruce Gotlieb: And I'm gonna say Hell's Kitchen.
[27:12] Eila Mell: Okay.
[27:13] Bruce Gotlieb: We'll win.
[27:14] Eila Mell: Um, but what do we want to win?
[27:16] Bruce Gotlieb: So m my want to win, although I would be thrilled if outsiders did is back to the future.
[27:22] Eila Mell: Um I think just because what it does on a technological on a tech level, the scenes uh this uh the projections, uh the scenic elements, I just think it's it's so big and it's done so well that how do you overlook it?
[27:37] Matt Stashin: Okay, Matt.
[27:38] Matt Stashin: And my want is Here Lies Love.
[27:40] Eila Mell: Yeah, that's my want.
[27:41] Matt Stashin: I mean, one, I want that show to get recognized, and two that set was just breathtaking.
[27:46] Eila Mell: I mean, I because I saw the show with you, I love we both walked in and looked around and went, Oh my god.
[27:53] Matt Stashin: And um, it just did so much.
[27:56] Eila Mell: Yeah, it had a much bigger ask than most shows.
[27:59] Matt Stashin: So, you know, I I think for that reason.
[28:02] Bruce Gotlieb: Although, you know, if uh if any of the other ones went I I don't know.
[28:06] Matt Stashin: The Outsiders was a pretty great set too.
[28:09] Eila Mell: So uh it's very hard for me.
[28:11] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, who do you want?
[28:12] Matt Stashin: Uh Here Lies Love.
[28:13] Eila Mell: Okay.
[28:17] Bruce Gotlieb: I know, I know, I know.
[28:18] Eila Mell: Shall we dive into Best Musical?
[28:20] Bruce Gotlieb: We have to.
[28:20] Eila Mell: Okay.
[28:21] Bruce Gotlieb: We have Hell's Kitchen, Illinois, The Outsiders, SUFs, and Water for Elephants.
[28:28] Eila Mell: Where do we start?
[28:28] Bruce Gotlieb: Which one, Bruce?
[28:29] Bruce Gotlieb: Which is it gonna be?
[28:30] Eila Mell: Um, I'm gonna start with Illinois.
[28:33] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.
[28:33] Eila Mell: So Illinois came in as the last possible moment to be able to come in and it came in with a blaze.
[28:42] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.
[28:43] Eila Mell: There was such such momentum, such uh I don't want to say hype, just a lot of palatable um Anticipation.
[28:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Anticipation.
[28:55] Eila Mell: Okay.
[28:55] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, it had just come off playing off Broadway at the armory.
[28:58] Eila Mell: I believe they had like one preview before they opened.
[29:01] Bruce Gotlieb: Because there was no time.
[29:02] Eila Mell: Right.
[29:03] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[29:03] Eila Mell: And then I mean it would had this terrible tragedy.
[29:06] Bruce Gotlieb: The terrible tragedy, which uh I don't know if it I don't know if it was that.
[29:11] Eila Mell: I don't know what did, but I feel like the momentum has slowed down.
[29:15] Bruce Gotlieb: One thing that I did hear from people that were going in, now this is a dance show.
[29:19] Eila Mell: Right.
[29:20] Bruce Gotlieb: So for a musical to just be more reliant on dance, that's a different type of element.
[29:25] Eila Mell: Right, like contact.
[29:26] Bruce Gotlieb: Right, right.
[29:27] Eila Mell: I I think people went in with certain expectation, knowing it's a dance show, but the only thing I've heard afterwards was people saying, well, yeah, but it's more of a ballet.
[29:38] Bruce Gotlieb: Which I think winds up to be a little divisive.
[29:42] Eila Mell: Okay.
[29:43] Bruce Gotlieb: Because I think people love ballet or don't.
[29:47] Eila Mell: Right.
[29:48] Bruce Gotlieb: And, you know, sometimes if you're going to a Broadway show, either you want that or you don't want that.
[29:54] Eila Mell: Right.
[29:54] Bruce Gotlieb: So I think it just in and of itself winds up polarizing.
[29:58] Eila Mell: Yeah, it can.
[29:59] Bruce Gotlieb: And it can right.
[30:00] Eila Mell: Some people will stay away because they think it's just dance.
[30:03] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.
[30:03] Eila Mell: Right.
[30:03] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[30:04] Eila Mell: So I think some of the momentum because people were saying it's just gonna come in and just take over the sweep.
[30:11] Bruce Gotlieb: And I don't think it's doing that.
[30:12] Eila Mell: I don't think so either.
[30:13] Bruce Gotlieb: I think a lot of that is kind of that fire is kind of calmed down.
[30:17] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[30:18] Bruce Gotlieb: Um I I'd be curious to see how how it fares Tony Knight, but I do think a lot of the momentum that it had isn't is isn't as quite there as it was.
[30:30] Eila Mell: Yeah, I think that's a fair assessment.
[30:32] Bruce Gotlieb: Um then we have uh Hell's Kitchen.
[30:35] Eila Mell: Well, Hell's Kitchen is sort of the opposite.
[30:37] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[30:38] Eila Mell: It has it just won the drama league award for best musical.
[30:42] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.
[30:43] Eila Mell: And it has the most nominations of all the musicals, and you know, it's kind of on fire.
[30:48] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[30:48] Eila Mell: It is.
[30:49] Bruce Gotlieb: And you know, there's like you said before earlier, there's something to be said for star power.
[30:54] Eila Mell: And Alicia Keys is no slouch when it comes to Star Power.
[30:58] Bruce Gotlieb: No, and people love her too.
[30:59] Eila Mell: Yeah, her energy, the you know, her vibe, all that she kind of encompasses aside from her her abilities as as a pianist and as a songwriter.
[31:08] Bruce Gotlieb: Right, she's so talented.
[31:09] Eila Mell: She's just she's likeable too.
[31:11] Bruce Gotlieb: Like for her.
[31:13] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[31:13] Bruce Gotlieb: So I think that goes a long way as well.
[31:15] Eila Mell: Plus the incredible team that's working on this show.
[31:18] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.
[31:18] Eila Mell: So I think that the momentum and and that what that's bringing, I I think you gotta watch for that.
[31:24] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, it's it's funny because you said with Illinois, it came in with so much hype and cooled.
[31:29] Eila Mell: And I think a couple of these other shows came in with very little and have exploded.
[31:33] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[31:34] Eila Mell: I would agree with that sentence.
[31:35] Bruce Gotlieb: And the outsiders, where does that fall in that spectrum?
[31:38] Matt Stashin: I believe the same as Hell's Kitchen.
[31:40] Bruce Gotlieb: I think so.
[31:40] Matt Stashin: Okay.
[31:41] Bruce Gotlieb: I think so.
[31:42] Matt Stashin: Yeah, the Outsiders is I don't think people knew what to expect when it it first showed up.
[31:49] Bruce Gotlieb: And yeah, it's it has a big fan following.
[31:53] Eila Mell: Which is great.
[31:54] Matt Stashin: And it's one of those shows.
[31:56] Eila Mell: There are a few this season of the newer shows that stay with you.
[32:01] Matt Stashin: Or at least stayed with me.
[32:02] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[32:03] Matt Stashin: I loved the outside.
[32:04] Eila Mell: And this is one of them.
[32:05] Matt Stashin: Yeah.
[32:05] Eila Mell: That just leaving going in, no expectation.
[32:10] Matt Stashin: Which sometimes is really the way to go because you don't want to be disappointed.
[32:10] Eila Mell: You don't want to have you know a hype built up for yourself.
[32:18] Matt Stashin: Um, but leaving this show, I feel like I haven't stopped talking about it since.
[32:21] Eila Mell: Well, what I think is so successful about it is that it really was written in a way that allows for music to help tell the story in the same way that the book tells the story and the movie.
[32:32] Matt Stashin: Um it feels like a natural musical.
[32:35] Eila Mell: Yeah, I would agree with that.
[32:37] Matt Stashin: So, you know, I loved it.
[32:38] Eila Mell: And SUFS.
[32:40] Matt Stashin: I loved SUFs.
[32:42] Eila Mell: You did?
[32:42] Matt Stashin: I did.
[32:43] Eila Mell: That was Well, what about it?
[32:45] Matt Stashin: What it was just it told a story.
[32:49] Eila Mell: I mean, we all know the story of the women's suffrage movement.
[32:52] Matt Stashin: We know about Susan B.
[32:54] Eila Mell: Anthony and Well, these are names we've heard.
[32:56] Matt Stashin: I don't know that everybody's not.
[32:57] Eila Mell: None of them are in this show.
[32:59] Matt Stashin: This is the story of the other people that kind of helped the movement along and really propelled it forward.
[33:06] Eila Mell: They weren't the household names of the movement, but they were the ones who really drove it felt drove it home.
[33:10] Matt Stashin: So not the celebrated figures.
[33:12] Eila Mell: Exactly.
[33:13] Matt Stashin: Except for Ida B.
[33:14] Eila Mell: Wells at Nikki James plays.
[33:15] Matt Stashin: I think I definitely heard about her before seeing the show, but I'd never heard about Alice Paul, the Shane of Taub plays.
[33:15] Eila Mell: I'd never heard about any of these other people before.
[33:23] Matt Stashin: So I I enjoyed that aspect of it.
[33:26] Eila Mell: And it's just told the story is told so powerfully.
[33:31] Matt Stashin: It really is just a beautiful show.
[33:33] Eila Mell: Okay.
[33:34] Bruce Gotlieb: And Bruce, you agree?
[33:35] Bruce Gotlieb: I agree with that.
[33:36] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[33:36] Bruce Gotlieb: I agree with that.
[33:37] Eila Mell: And then you know, it's it's told with um you feel the movement of the movement.
[33:44] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.
[33:45] Eila Mell: You know, the piece moves.
[33:46] Bruce Gotlieb: And the piece somebody even said to me, I was talking this past weekend to somebody and we were talking about different shows that we've seen, and SUFs came up, and she said, I felt when I left the theater that I had to do something.
[33:59] Eila Mell: Ah, well that that's a lot that it motivates you.
[34:05] Bruce Gotlieb: How am I doing?
[34:06] Eila Mell: What am I doing next?
[34:06] Bruce Gotlieb: Huh.
[34:06] Eila Mell: And and somebody that I know um who was actually at the show the same night I was there, said to me after the show was like, I cannot wait for this show to get licensed for like schools so that high school girls can see these women and know this story.
[34:21] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, that's pretty great.
[34:22] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[34:23] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[34:24] Eila Mell: I think that, you know, even if it doesn't even if it doesn't win best musical to do those things.
[34:30] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.
[34:30] Eila Mell: It's doing a lot of important things.
[34:31] Bruce Gotlieb: It's gonna do more, it's gonna Tony Award's wonderful.
[34:35] Eila Mell: Yes.
[34:35] Bruce Gotlieb: Don't get me wrong, but the the fact that it could propel change in the world and the betterment of of people.
[34:43] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[34:43] Bruce Gotlieb: That's yeah, that's wonderful.
[34:45] Eila Mell: Yeah, I mean, that's that's another reward in itself.
[34:48] Bruce Gotlieb: And what about Water for Elephants, Isla?
[34:50] Eila Mell: Well, Water for Elephants, it it gives you a lot.
[34:53] Bruce Gotlieb: Um it it's certainly a traditional show.
[34:59] Eila Mell: Yes.
[34:59] Bruce Gotlieb: But it it's also very modern in the way it's told.
[35:03] Eila Mell: It's fun, it's beautiful to look at.
[35:06] Bruce Gotlieb: The music is really so gorgeous.
[35:09] Eila Mell: The choreography just brings such a special element to it.
[35:13] Bruce Gotlieb: I I think it's so hard, right?
[35:16] Eila Mell: Because there are so many great shows this season.
[35:19] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[35:19] Eila Mell: I I don't know what is going to win.
[35:22] Matt Stashin: I know.
[35:23] Eila Mell: It's one of those one of this race is so tight, and you could have also had other shows plugged in.
[35:30] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.
[35:31] Eila Mell: That you would be having the same conversation.
[35:34] Bruce Gotlieb: You know, similarly, like we were saying before, like if you were gonna say this was left out, what would you replace it with?
[35:40] Matt Stashin: Right.
[35:40] Eila Mell: This category, I don't know.
[35:42] Matt Stashin: What would you know what you take out?
[35:44] Eila Mell: Yeah, there's I mean other categories have seven nominees.
[35:48] Matt Stashin: Here lies love could have gotten in there.
[35:50] Eila Mell: Come on.
[35:51] Matt Stashin: I know.
[35:52] Eila Mell: So what do you think's gonna win, Matt?
[35:55] Matt Stashin: I honestly don't know.
[35:57] Eila Mell: I think all right.
[35:58] Matt Stashin: I think it's going to I think any of the five could win.
[36:01] Eila Mell: I think it really is that close.
[36:03] Matt Stashin: But anything could happen.
[36:05] Eila Mell: I think it's gonna come down to Hell's Kitchen or the Outsiders.
[36:08] Matt Stashin: And which is going to take it.
[36:10] Matt Stashin: I think I think the outsiders.
[36:14] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.
[36:14] Matt Stashin: I'm very think it's gonna be The Outsiders.
[36:16] Bruce Gotlieb: I think it's gonna be Hell's Kitchen.
[36:17] Matt Stashin: I think it's the same.
[36:18] Bruce Gotlieb: I think it has a lot of momentum going right now.
[36:20] Matt Stashin: I think it's the show to beat right now.
[36:22] Eila Mell: What do you want to win, Isla?
[36:24] Eila Mell: Uh um The Outsiders, maybe.
[36:28] Matt Stashin: Yeah, I think so.
[36:29] Eila Mell: Me too.
[36:30] Eila Mell: I just really loved it. I think it just I loved everything about it.
[36:35] Matt Stashin: Yeah.
[36:36] Eila Mell: I really did.
[36:36] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[36:37] Matt Stashin: And Matt?
[36:38] Matt Stashin: SUFS.
[36:39] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.
[36:39] Matt Stashin: I loved SUFS.
[36:41] Bruce Gotlieb: All right. That was my favorite.
[36:42] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[36:43] Bruce Gotlieb: I think this category come Tony Knight's gonna be so exciting.
[36:46] Eila Mell: It's going to, and it may be the last category of the show.
[36:50] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.
[36:50] Eila Mell: So all night we'll be building to this moment.
[36:52] Bruce Gotlieb: We're really no, but I wonder if we'll start to have a better idea as they give out the other awards, where they're going with those.
[36:59] Matt Stashin: Possibly, because if Hell's Kitchen starts winning everything it's nominated for.
[37:02] Bruce Gotlieb: But so hopefully they'll be spread out, so we don't know.
[37:05] Matt Stashin: But at the same time, Illinois is only nominated for three.
[37:09] Bruce Gotlieb: So if that's gonna win, there's not gonna be a lot beforehand to let us know.
[37:13] Eila Mell: I know it'll be very exciting.
[37:16] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[37:16] Eila Mell: I I don't even know how we'll contain ourselves.
[37:21] Bruce Gotlieb: Let's take a minute to hear a word from our sponsors.
[37:28] Bruce Gotlieb: All right, so we have let's go with actor of the musical first.
[37:34] Matt Stashin: Let's do it.
[37:36] Bruce Gotlieb: Brody Grant, The Outsiders.
[37:38] Matt Stashin: Okay.
[37:38] Bruce Gotlieb: Jonathan Groff, Merrily We Roll Along, Dorian Harewood, The Notebook, Brian Darcy James, Days of Wine and Roses, and Eddie Redmayne, Cabaret.
[37:49] Bruce Gotlieb: All right, well.
[37:51] Matt Stashin: So I think I'm gonna start with Eddie Redmayne.
[37:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.
[37:55] Matt Stashin: I think coming in after the Olivier's, after its successful run in London, or his successful run because he left to come here.
[38:04] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, and he won the Olivier.
[38:05] Matt Stashin: And he won for it.
[38:07] Matt Stashin: I think he had such um such buzz around it.
[38:11] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.
[38:12] Matt Stashin: Um, and I just feel like I don't want to take anything away from his performance.
[38:18] Matt Stashin: I just think it's died down, and maybe just simply because you've had performances upon performances of people that just have been like, oh wait, but what about this?
[38:18] Matt Stashin: Oh wait, but what about this?
[38:29] Matt Stashin: So it's I it's not that his performance isn't worthy of a Tony.
[38:35] Bruce Gotlieb: No.
[38:36] Matt Stashin: I just wonder if there's I don't wonder.
[38:39] Matt Stashin: I'm gonna change that. It's just I think there's so many wonderful performances this year that timing is everything.
[38:47] Matt Stashin: And I think that you lose in that momentum, but it's just you get lost in the shuffle.
[38:53] Matt Stashin: I also think had the show had a better reaction from audiences, he would have a better chance.
[38:58] Bruce Gotlieb: No, I would agree with that.
[39:00] Bruce Gotlieb: I think that you're right.
[39:01] Bruce Gotlieb: If the show did if the show was on fire a bit more, you would say, Oh, it's gotta be Eddie Redmayne.
[39:08] Matt Stashin: Right.
[39:09] Matt Stashin: Um so then I guess going next, um uh Brian Darcy James for Days of Wine and Roses.
[39:15] Matt Stashin: Um Matt, why don't you take this one?
[39:17] Matt Stashin: I'll take this one.
[39:18] Matt Stashin: Brian Darcy James was phenomenal.
[39:19] Matt Stashin: That is a hard part because he has to go through such an arc.
[39:25] Matt Stashin: It's a property a lot of people know, so it's not really a spoiler alert.
[39:28] Matt Stashin: He starts uh spoiler alert.
[39:30] Matt Stashin: He starts the show as really like a raging alcoholic.
[39:34] Matt Stashin: And really, honestly, not very likable.
[39:38] Matt Stashin: You know, he's he comes across as this suave ladies' man and he really does lure Kelly O'Hara's character into starting to drink.
[39:47] Matt Stashin: Like he is not a likable person in the beginning, and he comes so far by the end, such an arc that um it's really redemptive.
[39:56] Matt Stashin: And he just does a beautiful job.
[39:58] Bruce Gotlieb: I don't know if he's ever sung better than he did in this show.
[40:02] Matt Stashin: He's phenomenal.
[40:03] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.
[40:04] Bruce Gotlieb: That's that's high praise.
[40:05] Matt Stashin: Yeah, I think he should hire you for his uh spokesman.
[40:08] Bruce Gotlieb: I will accept.
[40:10] Matt Stashin: All right, so call my people, we'll discuss.
[40:12] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm gonna talk about Brody Grant.
[40:13] Matt Stashin: Go ahead.
[40:14] Matt Stashin: So I think he's wonderful in this show.
[40:17] Matt Stashin: However, I don't think it's his time to win a Tony yet.
[40:19] Matt Stashin: He's very new, he's very young.
[40:21] Matt Stashin: I think the nomination is his award right now.
[40:24] Matt Stashin: And that's not taking anything away from this performance.
[40:27] Matt Stashin: I just think compared to the other parts that are nominated, it's not as as meaty or as I don't know.
[40:36] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, I mean, there are certain parts that require more of an actor than others.
[40:40] Matt Stashin: Um, and luckily for him, you know, he's in a show that he's not required to lift everything himself.
[40:49] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.
[40:49] Matt Stashin: It's much more of an ensemble cast.
[40:51] Matt Stashin: And he he has this band of brothers around him that they all get to lean on one another, and how amazing is that.
[40:58] Matt Stashin: Especially in a show that is, you know, coming from a beloved novel and movie, you know, that there are certain expectations.
[41:06] Matt Stashin: You don't have to you don't have to bear all this alone.
[41:09] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.
[41:09] Matt Stashin: Um, but I would agree with what you're saying.
[41:11] Matt Stashin: I think of the nominees in this category, I think because that, because less is a required of him, and it being more of an ensemble piece, he does a beautiful job.
[41:23] Matt Stashin: You know, he he does his job beautifully, but I think uh because less is required of him as the lead, I think that's going to hurt his chances for winning a Tony.
[41:33] Bruce Gotlieb: Plus, like you said, he's got so many years to be able to win.
[41:38] Matt Stashin: Yeah, I would be careful though, though, just because I think of these performances, he's the only one that I think has like a song or a moment that has started to exist outside the show.
[41:48] Bruce Gotlieb: Great extra.
[41:49] Matt Stashin: With the great expectations um is really becoming like a pop culture item as well.
[41:54] Bruce Gotlieb: So I think that might propel him a little bit farther.
[41:57] Matt Stashin: That's a very good point.
[41:58] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, okay.
[41:59] Bruce Gotlieb: Duly noted.
[42:01] Matt Stashin: Um, well, let's talk about Dorian Harewood from The Notebook.
[42:05] Matt Stashin: I mean, he's just a wonderful actor.
[42:07] Matt Stashin: His performance was so moving.
[42:10] Eila Mell: It really was beautiful.
[42:11] Matt Stashin: It was.
[42:12] Matt Stashin: And he, you know, he speaking of heavy lifting, there's so much required, not of I won't even say of Noah, the character, but of older Noah.
[42:23] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[42:23] Matt Stashin: Yeah.
[42:23] Matt Stashin: Specifically.
[42:24] Eila Mell: Right.
[42:25] Matt Stashin: Because the You have to be drawn in emotionally and tapped into his emotion.
[42:34] Matt Stashin: Yeah.
[42:34] Eila Mell: And you have to be from the beginning.
[42:36] Matt Stashin: It's like, it's like Tracy and Hairspray.
[42:39] Matt Stashin: You have 30 seconds when that curtain opens to fall in love with that character.
[42:44] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[42:44] Matt Stashin: And the same is required of him.
[42:46] Matt Stashin: When the stage is set and he comes out, he has very limited time to bring you in.
[42:53] Matt Stashin: And he's telling the story.
[42:54] Matt Stashin: And if he doesn't, well, he's not nominated and the show isn't successful.
[43:01] Eila Mell: So I think there's a lot required of him, and he does it with such precision.
[43:04] Matt Stashin: Yeah.
[43:05] Eila Mell: Now, this is also an ensemble.
[43:07] Matt Stashin: Yeah, I was that's what I was about to say.
[43:10] Eila Mell: No, you can okay.
[43:11] Matt Stashin: I said, does it hurt him that he's sharing the role with two other people?
[43:16] Eila Mell: Yeah, I think it does.
[43:17] Matt Stashin: It's a shame because he's phenomenal in the party.
[43:19] Matt Stashin: It really is.
[43:20] Matt Stashin: And they're all different performances of this same character that work.
[43:25] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[43:25] Matt Stashin: There's connective tissue, but they're not all the same.
[43:29] Eila Mell: No, because you look at yourself in your life, right?
[43:32] Matt Stashin: Yeah.
[43:33] Matt Stashin: When you're 15 versus 25 versus 45, you are a different person.
[43:38] Eila Mell: You're a different version of yourself.
[43:39] Matt Stashin: Yeah, the fiber is still there.
[43:41] Matt Stashin: That through line is gonna be there.
[43:44] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[43:44] Matt Stashin: But Noah, you know, when he's running through the creek.
[43:49] Eila Mell: Yeah, that's not the same.
[43:51] Matt Stashin: He's not the same Noah that's building the house.
[43:53] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[43:53] Matt Stashin: And not the same Noah that's you know, caring for his wife.
[43:57] Eila Mell: Yeah and and trying to tell make sure their stories is kept alive.
[44:03] Matt Stashin: So I think it's very interesting, but I do I wonder the same way if that's gonna hurt him.
[44:08] Eila Mell: I I believe if I remember correctly, he's the oldest nominee.
[44:13] Matt Stashin: He's definitely the oldest this year.
[44:15] Eila Mell: I don't know if he's the oldest ever.
[44:16] Matt Stashin: I don't think ever.
[44:17] Eila Mell: But this year.
[44:18] Matt Stashin: But this year he's the oldest.
[44:19] Eila Mell: He's 73.
[44:20] Matt Stashin: 73, yeah.
[44:21] Bruce Gotlieb: So I mean you look at the two, right?
[44:23] Bruce Gotlieb: I I mean this is this is his first nomination.
[44:26] Bruce Gotlieb: So you look at like the the polar the juxtaposition of like Brody versus Dorian and how amazing that they both get to you know sit at the table together.
[44:37] Eila Mell: They're both great stories, and and almost talk to each other about like what their experience is like.
[44:41] Matt Stashin: Yeah.
[44:42] Bruce Gotlieb: That that would be an interesting conversation to be part of.
[44:44] Bruce Gotlieb: Um so then we have Jonathan Groff.
[44:47] Matt Stashin: Norally we roll off.
[44:49] Bruce Gotlieb: You know, you know, guys know how I feel about Merrily.
[44:51] Bruce Gotlieb: We roll along.
[44:52] Bruce Gotlieb: I think that Jonathan Groff is the one that people are talking about as the likely winner.
[44:58] Matt Stashin: Uh what do you think?
[44:59] Eila Mell: I mean, I think he's a he is a tremendous actor.
[45:03] Eila Mell: Um everything he does, he does full, right?
[45:06] Eila Mell: It's he gives you nothing less than a hundred percent when he steps on stage in a role.
[45:11] Matt Stashin: Yeah.
[45:12] Eila Mell: Um, and I think he's I think he's just winning people over.
[45:17] Bruce Gotlieb: He's a great Frank in the show.
[45:19] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[45:20] Bruce Gotlieb: He's great in the role.
[45:22] Eila Mell: He's great in everything he does.
[45:25] Matt Stashin: Um I do wonder if the ch if the fact that the show has been open for as long as it has, if some of the buzz might be spilling over to other people, and that might sway votes.
[45:38] Bruce Gotlieb: I nothing about his performance.
[45:39] Eila Mell: I mean, this is Yeah.
[45:41] Matt Stashin: Jonathan Groff, he's amazing.
[45:43] Eila Mell: I think it doesn't, though.
[45:44] Eila Mell: I think the show still has momentum.
[45:47] Eila Mell: And I also think the fact that the show has been running this long just gives people more opportunity to have seen him in it.
[45:54] Bruce Gotlieb: But you know, I'm gonna say that I think the part of Frank has less growth and some of the other characters that are nominated.
[46:05] Matt Stashin: I don't disagree.
[46:06] Eila Mell: People don't walk out talking about Franklin.
[46:08] Eila Mell: They walk out usually talking about Charlie.
[46:10] Matt Stashin: A lot of Charlie, and he is also nominated, Daniel Radcliffe.
[46:13] Bruce Gotlieb: So that that could be interesting where because he doesn't not stay with people, but because the arc it might not be as large as some other characters, whether that hurts a performance.
[46:25] Matt Stashin: But there are times where you know people don't I guess don't need that much and they still win, you know.
[46:31] Eila Mell: Exactly.
[46:32] Eila Mell: Yeah.
[46:32] Bruce Gotlieb: I mean, he's wonderful in the role, for sure.
[46:35] Matt Stashin: Oh, he's wonderful in everything he does.
[46:37] Eila Mell: Well, it's interesting to me that he and Brian Darcy James are both nominated together because they both sort of created the character of the King in Hamilton.
[46:46] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, yeah.
[46:46] Eila Mell: Brian Darcy James did it off Broadway and then Jonathan Groff did it on Broadway.
[46:51] Bruce Gotlieb: So it could be a battle of the kings.
[46:53] Matt Stashin: It could be.
[46:55] Bruce Gotlieb: I think it is probably coming down to the two of them.
[46:57] Matt Stashin: I'm not my gut tells me not to count out Brody Grant, honestly.
[47:01] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.
[47:02] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay, so who do you think's gonna win?
[47:03] Matt Stashin: Will win?
[47:04] Bruce Gotlieb: Will.
[47:05] Matt Stashin: Will win, not want.
[47:07] Matt Stashin: I'm gonna say Brian Darcy James.
[47:09] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.
[47:09] Matt Stashin: Oh, okay.
[47:10] Matt Stashin: I really do.
[47:11] Bruce Gotlieb: I think you think he will.
[47:13] Matt Stashin: I really do.
[47:14] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, that would be an upset for sure.
[47:16] Matt Stashin: Yeah, that would be interesting.
[47:17] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, let's see what happens.
[47:19] Eila Mell: I I do think it's gonna be Jonathan Groff.
[47:21] Eila Mell: I think he's at his young age, he's still a veteran, he's been around for a long time.
[47:26] Eila Mell: Spring Awakening was almost 20 years ago.
[47:28] Eila Mell: Yeah, I think I think it's time.
[47:29] Eila Mell: I think people want to reward him.
[47:31] Eila Mell: And you know, everything about this production is sort of gold, so I think it's gonna be Jonathan also.
[47:37] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[47:38] Eila Mell: For the same reasons or yeah, I just I just think I just think you can't deny what the work that he's doing.
[47:46] Matt Stashin: Not that anybody can deny any of these guys, but I just yeah exactly.
[47:50] Bruce Gotlieb: I don't I I don't think so.
[47:51] Eila Mell: But what do we want to win?
[47:53] Eila Mell: I mean, my want is obvious.
[47:55] Eila Mell: It's Chip Zion for Harmony.
[47:56] Matt Stashin: I know.
[47:57] Eila Mell: I know we all feel that way.
[48:00] Bruce Gotlieb: That was that was kind of a snub.
[48:01] Eila Mell: Yeah, it was.
[48:03] Eila Mell: I mean, we could have talked about Harmony in a bunch of these categories.
[48:05] Bruce Gotlieb: I know, but it's including best musical.
[48:08] Eila Mell: Well, but for me, Chip Zion was just the heart and soul of Harmony.
[48:12] Eila Mell: And yeah, that's a shame that he didn't get nominated.
[48:15] Bruce Gotlieb: But of this bunch, who who do you want to win?
[48:19] Matt Stashin: My heart is with Dorian Harewood.
[48:21] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm gonna say the same. I just think he does a beautiful job. I think it should be rewarded.
[48:26] Matt Stashin: I'm going to say Brian Darcy James only because I think he had more to do than Dorian Harewood.
[48:33] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.
[48:33] Matt Stashin: That's fair enough.
[48:34] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[48:35] Matt Stashin: All right. Should we go to the last category?
[48:38] Bruce Gotlieb: We have to.
[48:39] Matt Stashin: Alright. We can't prolong this just a little bit.
[48:42] Bruce Gotlieb: I know. It's been so much fun.
[48:44] Matt Stashin: So best performance by leading actress in a musical.
[48:47] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh my gosh.
[48:48] Matt Stashin: He's prolonging it. I love this.
[48:50] Bruce Gotlieb: And the nominees are.
[48:54] Matt Stashin: Eden Espinosa, Lempicka, Malia Joy Moon, Hell's Kitchen, Kelly O'Hara, Days of Wine and Roses, Mariam Plunkett, The Notebook, and Gail Rankin, Cabaret.
[49:06] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, should we start? Matt, what would you like to start with?
[49:10] Matt Stashin: I'm going to start with Kelly O'Hara.
[49:13] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.
[49:14] Matt Stashin: Who had really like everything I just said about Brian Darcy James. The same applies for Kelly O'Hara with the character arc in reverse.
[49:23] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[49:24] Matt Stashin: She starts off the play as this innocent, wide-eyed young woman. And over the course of the show, reluctantly and then fairly apologetically, she descends into alcoholism.
[49:40] Bruce Gotlieb: Um and never gets the redemption.
[49:45] Matt Stashin: You know, the show ends with her in a very tenuous place, and it really takes a performer of a lot of skill to be able to make the audience continue to empathize with her as she does that.
[49:55] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[49:55] Matt Stashin: And she does it. Kelly O'Hara is a very interesting actor, right? Because she could have just easily coasted on playing the ingenues, but she didn't. She makes interesting choices and she plays really rich characters.
[50:09] Bruce Gotlieb: And I really respect that.
[50:12] Matt Stashin: Because, you know, she looks, you know, like this perfect angel. But she plays, you know, all different, you know, just I don't know. I just think that she's been so smart about her career. She's played older than she is many times. And I think that gives her an even longer shelf life. I just think she's great. So if she won, I think it would be amazing.
[50:35] Bruce Gotlieb: I agree.
[50:36] Matt Stashin: Yeah. Bruce, you want to add there?
[50:38] Bruce Gotlieb: No, I think you guys kind of nailed it all with her. I don't think there's anything left unsaid.
[50:44] Matt Stashin: Okay. Um, Malia Joy Moon, so she is brand new to us for sure, but I think to Broadway, right?
[50:52] Bruce Gotlieb: This is her debut.
[50:53] Matt Stashin: I think so. Yeah, I think so too. Um, and she is just capturing hearts. She is really, it's exciting, right?
[51:00] Bruce Gotlieb: It is when you discover someone like this.
[51:03] Matt Stashin: Yeah, and I think that you've heard nothing but great things about her performance. The voice, the talent, it's just like off the charts.
[51:12] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.
[51:12] Matt Stashin: And so I just think that's exciting, and I think it's exciting. Uh, you know, you want to reward that. You w like you said about Brody Grant, she has so much time ahead of her.
[51:22] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.
[51:22] Matt Stashin: But sometimes you sometimes something so undeniable that it doesn't matter how much time you have.
[51:29] Bruce Gotlieb: Right, and it could be the moment for her. You know, I think in terms of what she has to do, it's a different ask than what Brody Grant has to do.
[51:39] Matt Stashin: Agreed.
[51:39] Bruce Gotlieb: So I think she has a stronger chance, even though she has a similar story.
[51:43] Matt Stashin: Yeah. Um, Plunkett, The Notebook.
[51:49] Bruce Gotlieb: I loved Mariam Plunkett. How can you not? I mean speaking of asking a lot of somebody, she is asked a lot in this part.
[52:00] Matt Stashin: It has to be, and the way that she does it, there are times that there's such nuance to her performance. She's not speaking. She's not singing. She's just existing on stage.
[52:12] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[52:12] Matt Stashin: And to do that so quietly and make the audience come along with her on her journey.
[52:20] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[52:21] Matt Stashin: Because her journey is different than any other character in the show.
[52:24] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.
[52:25] Matt Stashin: You know, I just think is exceptional. And to piggyback off what Bruce said, I mean, she does everything so quietly, and yet you cannot take your eyes off of her.
[52:36] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[52:36] Matt Stashin: Well, she does it. I will say, the lights came up when we saw The Notebook, and I turned, I said, if she is not nominated for a Tony, there is no justice.
[52:45] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[52:45] Matt Stashin: She was absolutely brilliant. Yeah, what she does in this show, it's really it's very special.
[52:52] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[52:52] Matt Stashin: So, um, you know, if you have the opportunity to see her in this show, you really should because it's such a great performance. And it yeah, it's quiet, but it's also not, right?
[53:04] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.
[53:04] Matt Stashin: You know, she's in everything, and yet she doesn't have a lot to say, even when she does speak, it's not big speeches.
[53:12] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, she does so much communicating without many words.
[53:18] Matt Stashin: Yeah, and it's like we were talking about before, you know, you could like with Jonathan Groff, like he has so much to do, and here's somebody who has so little to do on paper. I mean, I totally believe that she was suffering from Alzheimer's.
[53:36] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[53:37] Matt Stashin: Oh, yeah. And that's kudos to the directors, both directors, you know, that were able to pull this out of her.
[53:49] Bruce Gotlieb: Right, whether or not they gave her a map for what this is like or just helped give her a blueprint.
[53:58] Matt Stashin: Right. But yeah, it just, you know, they all had to really work in tandem to create this.
[54:05] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.
[54:05] Matt Stashin: Um, and I don't think one exists in this format without the other.
[54:12] Bruce Gotlieb: It almost feels like a cinematic performance.
[54:15] Matt Stashin: Yeah.
[54:15] Bruce Gotlieb: Because it's so subtle, it's so small in what she does, but yet, you know, you get it in the balcony.
[54:21] Matt Stashin: Absolutely.
[54:22] Bruce Gotlieb: You do, you really, really do. It's really special. There is a reason they're selling boxes of tissues at the merch stand.
[54:25] Matt Stashin: That's right, and it's mostly because of her and Dorian Harewood.
[54:32] Bruce Gotlieb: So then what about Eden Espinosa, Lempicka?
[54:36] Matt Stashin: Alright. Well, if we're being honest, I have to say that I wanted more from this performance. Um, I just felt like this was a little lackluster for me.
[54:47] Bruce Gotlieb: I thought the role called for more.
[54:51] Matt Stashin: It was like an Evita kind of, you know, Mel DeMargos kind of, you know, like one of these big, larger than life women. And I didn't feel in this production, and I don't know why, if it was the actress, if it was the director, if it was the book, I don't know, but I didn't get that. And I felt disappointed.
[55:07] Bruce Gotlieb: I would agree with that. I also think, you know, it's hard because I think that there are some other shows where there are what would be considered quote unquote featured actresses that were giving more in their featured role than her as a leading role.
[55:26] Matt Stashin: Um, and I don't know if that's just based on how, again, how was it written? Right. I'm not sure.
[55:30] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, it could be a number of things.
[55:33] Matt Stashin: It could be a number of things. Yeah. For me, if I'm giving a pecking order, she'd be toward the bottom of that list for me.
[55:42] Bruce Gotlieb: With that being said, the nomination didn't really surprise me just because I know how passionate the show's fans are and how passionate her fans are.
[55:51] Matt Stashin: Um, and it's a role that calls for a nomination a hundred percent.
[55:56] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, and I'm not surprised by it.
[55:58] Matt Stashin: No, I'm not surprised by it either. It just, I wouldn't have gone that direction.
[56:03] Bruce Gotlieb: And then who's left on this list?
[56:05] Matt Stashin: Uh, Gail Rankin.
[56:06] Bruce Gotlieb: So Sally Bowles is another one of those roles, though, that is, you know, if we're talking about roles that garner a nomination. Sometimes she does, sometimes she doesn't. It's, you know, it's one of those you can go either way, right?
[56:20] Matt Stashin: Natasha Richardson won the original.
[56:20] Bruce Gotlieb: Jill O'Hara.
[56:24] Matt Stashin: Was it Jill O'Hara?
[56:25] Bruce Gotlieb: Jill Hayworth.
[56:26] Matt Stashin: Jill Hay, right, thank you. Did not get nominated. Oh, Liza Minnelli, did she win the Oscar?
[56:31] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, so you know, it is a rewarded role, but sometimes it's not.
[56:36] Matt Stashin: So I don't know. What do you guys think?
[56:38] Bruce Gotlieb: It's a hard part because Sally Bowles just, if she's not played correctly, just comes across as a flighty little nothing.
[56:48] Matt Stashin: You know, she makes really poor life choices.
[56:50] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, she's kind of a mess.
[56:51] Matt Stashin: Yeah, she's an absolute mess, and you need an actress that you can sympathize with.
[56:56] Bruce Gotlieb: I like that she leans into that aspect of the character.
[57:00] Matt Stashin: I think she's playing it very smart.
[57:02] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.
[57:02] Matt Stashin: Yeah. Well, it's another one of those roles that because it's done, you know, you don't want to become a caricature of the role, and you don't want to be a replication of another performer.
[57:16] Bruce Gotlieb: No, exactly.
[57:17] Matt Stashin: I like that there are different Sallys.
[57:20] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, and there has to be because nobody's going to replicate what Liza Minnelli did. Nobody's gonna replicate what Natasha Richardson did.
[57:24] Matt Stashin: Right.
[57:27] Bruce Gotlieb: And it makes it more interesting too, because it's the kind of role where it is kind of loose, right? You could do it, you could bring different aspects of it. It doesn't have the as specific asks as other parts.
[57:40] Matt Stashin: Right.
[57:40] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. All right. It's the last time I'm gonna ask.
[57:45] Matt Stashin: Matt, what will win?
[57:48] Matt Stashin: We'll win. Um, and I had to say it one more time for you, Eila. Um, I actually think we'll win. I really want to say Mariam Plunkett, but I think Malia Joy Moon is going to win.
[58:00] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.
[58:01] Matt Stashin: Okay. All right, Bruce.
[58:02] Bruce Gotlieb: I think it's gonna be Kelly O'Hara.
[58:04] Matt Stashin: You do.
[58:05] Bruce Gotlieb: I just think her pedigree, you know, she just when she sets on stage, you give Kelly O'Hara a role, you know it's gonna be knocked out of the park.
[58:15] Matt Stashin: Yeah, it's in good hands.
[58:16] Bruce Gotlieb: I don't know. I think Tony voters, I think they cling to that.
[58:22] Matt Stashin: Do you think as many people saw the show because it's not no longer running, so that makes it harder to win. Do you think that hurts her?
[58:30] Bruce Gotlieb: I don't think it makes it easy for her.
[58:34] Matt Stashin: Yeah, uh, for sure. I think it'll be interesting. I just that if for no other reason than her pedigree, and I just think that's the way they're gonna go.
[58:46] Matt Stashin: All right, and I'm gonna say I think we might be surprised by Mariam Plunkett.
[58:51] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, I will say Mariam Plunkett is my want.
[58:53] Matt Stashin: Oh, she's absolutely my want, also. I want her to win so badly. There might be a happy dance for that one.
[59:01] Bruce Gotlieb: I think I kind of want Kelly O'Hara to win.
[59:03] Matt Stashin: Okay.
[59:04] Bruce Gotlieb: Just again, she does, you know, it's a big ask of that role.
[59:09] Matt Stashin: So oh boy. Well, we've done it.
[59:12] Bruce Gotlieb: We have done it.
[59:13] Matt Stashin: We have conquered the Tony Award nominations.
[59:16] Bruce Gotlieb: The nominations now. I think are we going to do a special episode after the Tonies?
[59:23] Matt Stashin: I mean, we gotta give the people what they want.
[59:26] Bruce Gotlieb: I think. I think we're gonna have to dissect do a little recap.
[59:29] Matt Stashin: Yes.
[59:30] Bruce Gotlieb: So, alright, that should be our next thing. We'll have to figure that out.
[59:35] Matt Stashin: Yeah. I mean, we can't stop talking about the Tonies.
[59:37] Bruce Gotlieb: No, and so we are on the precipice of Tony night.
[59:43] Matt Stashin: Oh my gosh, it's so exciting.
[59:44] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm excited. I'll have my little sheet out.
[59:47] Matt Stashin: I know. Well, we are really curious to hear what you guys think is going to win.
[59:51] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.
[59:52] Matt Stashin: So, you know, send us messages and post and tag us, and we just really want to be very involved.
[59:58] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, and as it's going on during the night, you know, we can have a running dialogue.
[1:00:04] Matt Stashin: That's right. That'll be fun.
[1:00:06] Bruce Gotlieb: All right. Well, we will all see you and talk about the Tonies next on Behind the Awards.
[1:00:15] Matt Stashin: Bye bye.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
