Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#81 - Julia Knitel - Broadway Sleuth

Dead Outlaw star Julia Knitel gives Behind the Awards a deep dive into all things Dead Outlaw, plus her experience playing Louise in Gypsy with Beth Level and Carol King in Beautiful. Also in this episode - Katie Finneran 2010 Tony win for Promises Promises and a review of Good Night and Good Luck... Read More

From the show: Behind the Awards with Eila Mell & Bruce Gotlieb

39 mins
4/30/25

Guests

Featured Shows

About

Dead Outlaw star Julia Knitel gives Behind the Awards a deep dive into all things Dead Outlaw, plus her experience playing Louise in Gypsy with Beth Level and Carol King in Beautiful.

Also in this episode - Katie Finneran 2010 Tony win for Promises Promises and a review of Good Night and Good Luck

Julie Knitel - Broadway: Beautiful, Bye Bye Birdie. Tour: Beautiful (Carole King), Come From Away (Janice). Off-Broadway: Dead Outlaw (OCC nom), A Letter to Harvey Milk (Lortel nom), Panic of ‘29. Regional: Carole King in Beautiful at Asolo Rep, Cape Playhouse (Gertrude Lawrence Award), & Theatre Aspen (Henry nom). Louise in Gypsy at The Muny (St. Louis Theatre Circle nom), Martha in The Constant Wife(Denver Center), Ulla in The Producers (Casa Mañana), Nora in Brighton Beach Memoirs (Portland Stage). TV/film: “The Other Two,” Miles.

Make sure to check out Eila's book, "The Tony Awards", and all her other amazing books: ⁠⁠https://amzn.to/43WMu5Y⁠⁠.

Connect with Eila and Bruce:

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Eila Mell: But most of all, I want to talk to the kids at home watching. I was the kid and I watched the show, and it seems so far away from me. And I want to tell you that all of us up here on the stage and in this audience, we feel the same way. And with the world being so fast right now, I want to remind you to focus on what you love because it is the greatest passport, it is the greatest roadmap to an extraordinarily blissful life. Just focus on that one thing, don't listen to anybody else, and you will run into the right people, the right teachers, the right moments and circumstances.

[0:49] Eila Mell: Hello and welcome to Behind the Awards. I'm Eila, and I'm here with Bruce.

[0:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Hello there, Eila.

[0:55] Eila Mell: Hello, how are you?

[0:57] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm good.

[0:58] Eila Mell: So we were just listening to Katie Finneran.

[1:01] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, that was her 2010 Tony win for Promises, Promises.

[1:05] Eila Mell: I didn't see Promises, Promises, did you?

[1:07] Bruce Gotlieb: I did not get an opportunity to, no.

[1:10] Eila Mell: But I did see Katie with you in The Thanksgiving Play, and she was so good in that.

[1:16] Bruce Gotlieb: She's really one of those special actresses.

[1:20] Eila Mell: Right?

[1:20] Bruce Gotlieb: She's great.

[1:21] Eila Mell: But I just saw a play that has a lot of buzz.

[1:25] Bruce Gotlieb: Good Night and Good Luck.

[1:27] Eila Mell: Um, starring George Clooney.

[1:29] Bruce Gotlieb: That hack, George Clooney.

[1:32] Eila Mell: Um, this play is getting a lot of attention. Um, maybe for the wrong reason, because the ticket prices are so high.

[1:43] Bruce Gotlieb: They are.

[1:43] Eila Mell: I mean, it's like eight hundred dollars for many of the tickets, and up and down, but I didn't pay eight hundred dollars. But um, you know, still. I mean, honestly, as much as I love theater so much, I don't think any show is worth $800. It's just, you know, it's 90 minutes. It's so expensive. I don't know. Do you have a take on this?

[2:07] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, I mean, I think there should be some type of, you know, composite, I guess, or, you know, pricing. I feel like if a producer decides that they want to bring somebody in to do this piece that is, you know, maybe a little bit of a higher cost, that's a choice that they're making. Um, I don't necessarily think that, you know, what are they doing differently that is, you know, worth this luxury brand pricing, if you will.

[2:37] Eila Mell: Really?

[2:38] Bruce Gotlieb: Um, so I do, I think it's, without using the word unfair, I think it's unfair to pass that cost down to the consumer who's, you know, I think they would be just as happy seeing, you know, just a really strong actor in that role. You know, in any role.

[2:56] Eila Mell: Yeah, I don't think it necessarily has to be the big flashy name.

[3:00] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, that's true. I mean, this particular show probably wouldn't exist without George Clooney doing it, but I agree with you.

[3:08] Eila Mell: Well, he didn't play the part in the movie.

[3:09] Bruce Gotlieb: No, he didn't.

[3:10] Eila Mell: He didn't.

[3:11] Bruce Gotlieb: But um, you know, I just feel like we don't want theater to become just for the elite, right? We want it to be for everybody. So I just feel like, so if you have a few $800 seats, maybe have some that are in the more affordable range for other people. I don't know. But anyway, I will give you a review of this show. I like the show. I didn't love it.

[3:36] Eila Mell: I don't know why it's a play. I feel like it's, I understand why it's a movie, but I don't know that they did anything to make it theatrical. And there were a lot of it was told through screens. And actually, Joe McCarthy was a character and he played himself on screen. So, you know, a lot of it, you are watching as film. And for a lot of it, George Clooney is just sitting at a desk, but the audience, you know, some of the audience can't see him that well, you know, just based on where you're sitting.

[4:12] Bruce Gotlieb: But there he's turned to the side and there's a camera on him, and you're really seeing his face center stage on a big giant screen.

[4:22] Eila Mell: So um, I'm not against screens. I like them when used well, but I feel like George Clooney was most effective in this play at the very end when he had a monologue that he spoke right to the audience. And then you felt a connection to him. But otherwise, you know, it felt disconnected to me for a lot of it. But it wasn't only the use of screens. It was just I felt like the story took a while to even get going. I was kind of bored for the first 20 minutes.

[4:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Um, and then when it really did pick up, it was good, but it never, it was good in a way that's not theatrical. So, you know, it's something again, if it were on TV, it would work or, you know, in a movie. But when I'm there in person, I want something, you know, definitely based in reality. I don't want like an opera, but I do want it a heightened sense of, you know, maybe importance or just something more. If I'm there, you know, I just, I didn't feel like it brought to me that excitement of a live performance. Does that make sense?

[5:34] Bruce Gotlieb: What you're saying makes sense. I don't know if this piece, you know, if that's a requirement of this piece, you know.

[5:41] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[5:41] Bruce Gotlieb: When I heard of it, and I know that he's obviously playing a newscaster. Um, my initial reaction was that there would be some disconnect because when you're watching the news, you know, you're not connected to this individual who's just giving information.

[5:58] Eila Mell: Um, I almost in my head would have felt that that disconnect would be there.

[6:05] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. Uh, because they're playing a newscaster.

[6:08] Eila Mell: But we do see Edward R. Murrow, you know, in scenes that where he's not on the air.

[6:14] Bruce Gotlieb: And I just felt like George Clooney has so much charisma, but it really didn't come through in this. And I don't know why, like what happened to sort of mute him, but it felt like the whole thing was on mute. The supporting characters, everybody was good. I mean, the actors are all solid, but I don't feel like any of the parts really had enough to them to even stand out.

[6:36] Eila Mell: Nope.

[6:38] Bruce Gotlieb: Um, you know, it looked good, the sets, the costumes, lighting, sound, you know, all of that was fine. Here's one thing that you should know going in. There is constant smoking in this show.

[6:49] Eila Mell: And they're not smoking.

[6:49] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh, it's a time period.

[6:51] Eila Mell: Exactly. But they're not smoking actual cigarettes.

[6:54] Bruce Gotlieb: I can only imagine they're using, you know, whatever they use on stage, herbal cigarettes or whatever. But me included, much of the audience was coughing throughout the whole show and choking on the smoke. And I was in the box, so I could see the whole house. And um, there's just a haze over the whole audience. So it's just something, it's fine, but you know, you do feel it. So you should know if you're sensitive to that, maybe it's not the show to go to going in.

[7:23] Eila Mell: Okay. But you know, I think George Clooney will get nominated for a Tony. And I don't think that that's a bad nomination, but you know, I mean, he's doing solid work. He's good. It's just I feel like it had the potential to be much better.

[7:37] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.

[7:38] Eila Mell: So that's my review.

[7:40] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[7:41] Eila Mell: All right. Well, speaking of charismatic people, we have Julia Knitel from Dead Outlaw as our guest today.

[7:48] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh my gosh, she is so good in this show. So let's bring her out and chat.

[7:52] Julia Knitel: Hi, I'm Julia Knitel, and Behind the Awards will be right back.

[8:03] Eila Mell: I am so excited because we have Julia Knitel in our show. Welcome, Julia.

[8:06] Julia Knitel: Hi, happy to be here.

[8:10] Eila Mell: Thank you so much for joining us.

[8:11] Julia Knitel: Of course.

[8:13] Eila Mell: So we already have tickets to see Dead Outlaw. We're so excited.

[8:16] Julia Knitel: It’s a good one.

[8:20] Eila Mell: Oh my gosh. I was so sorry that I didn't get to see it off Broadway. It was so buzzy.

[8:27] Julia Knitel: Yeah, it's kind of cool because it was a very limited run. We only had like I think six weeks at the Audible Theater. And so everyone, when they heard it was announced we were coming to Broadway, either said, I can't wait to see it again, or I'm so glad I got a chance since I missed it.

[8:42] Eila Mell: Exactly. When you guys were done, when you wrapped, did you know that there were conversations happening?

[8:49] Julia Knitel: Yeah, I mean, I actually took it on. I'm the only woman in the show. And so I sort of ended up being like the sister, the mother, the party planner. I took out a lot of roles. And the role that I took on at the end of the run was definitely a sleuth for information about our Brahma.

[9:07] Eila Mell: Oh, that spread.

[9:08] Julia Knitel: That's a report. I was just like ear to the ground, trying to hear any information I could. And so we knew that there were whispers. We knew that the Schuberts were interested. We knew that the buzz was so good and we were just so well received critically and also, you know, audience response. And so we were hopeful, but we actually didn't hear for sure until I believe December of this year. So it was a long time waiting and a lot of, you know, chat going on in the group text.

[9:38] Bruce Gotlieb: So what happens though? Do you have to keep your schedule open?

[9:42] Julia Knitel: Uh, what do you do in a case like that?

[9:45] Eila Mell: I mean, it kind of what's cool about being an actor is that anything could happen, like any day, your whole schedule could go out the window. And a lot of times, you know, Broadway, at least for me and my trajectory right now, a Broadway show is always gonna take precedence. And so I had, I've done Beautiful a bunch of times. I did it on Broadway, I did it on tour, I've done it regionally, I think four times now. I had Beautiful on the books for the spring that, you know, we knew would probably not be able to work, but just in case we had it on the back burner, and once that call comes, everybody kind of just clears their schedule. We were also, we were prepared, I think in the fall, maybe like a little like way, heads up, keep it open. So we had a little bit of time.

[10:29] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, that's good because I think is everybody back from the off-Broadway?

[10:34] Julia Knitel: That's amazing.

[10:35] Eila Mell: I know, and it's such a special group, it's really good news.

[10:39] Julia Knitel: Yeah, I mean, so it's you, it's Andrew Durant, Eddie Cooper.

[10:43] Eila Mell: Amazing, amazing people.

[10:45] Julia Knitel: And more.

[10:46] Eila Mell: Yeah, I mean, it's a cast full of stars.

[10:48] Julia Knitel: It really is. And I think what's so special to me is everyone on that stage, it's nobody's Broadway debut. Um, it's nobody's like big, you know, it feels like a big break for me.

[11:00] Eila Mell: Yeah, but it's very special.

[11:02] Julia Knitel: But everybody is really like a career actor who's been in the business for a really long time and who is getting a chance to shine in a show where each role is tailor-made for them, and every person gets a really incredible step out. So it just feels like such a spectacular vehicle for a really talented group. And I just, I would stand in the wings and like watch everyone's features because it's just like star after star after star after star.

[11:28] Eila Mell: So what I know about the show going in is that it's based on a real-life person. But what's so interesting to me is that they sort of discovered his body on the set of The Six Million Dollar Man when they were only an episode.

[11:42] Julia Knitel: Is that in the play?

[11:44] Eila Mell: Oh yeah, that's actually the first scene.

[11:47] Julia Knitel: Oh, that's amazing.

[11:49] Eila Mell: It's not the Bigfoot episode, is it?

[11:51] Julia Knitel: I don't think so. I think he was in an amusement park ride, and it was like I think they were shooting like a spooky, like ooh, episode where they were in this sort of sideshow situation, and a guy on the crew literally tried to move what he thought was a puppet and pulls off his arm and sees that it's like human bone.

[12:12] Eila Mell: Oh my god.

[12:13] Julia Knitel: I know it's so spooky. And I believe when you actually hear the pitch for the musical, it's a very macabre, and it doesn't seem like it would translate well to a musical, but I promise it does. It's very, it's very delightful, it's very hilarious. There are moments of darkness and like a little bit of spook, but it's definitely like it's a very well-rounded musical.

[12:35] Eila Mell: Well, I think you know, I'm pretty damaged, so it appeals to me, all right. You didn't need to sell me on that.

[12:40] Julia Knitel: Great.

[12:40] Eila Mell: And who doesn't want a musical comedy, right?

[12:43] Julia Knitel: Who doesn't want to be laughing and just enjoying it all?

[12:46] Eila Mell: Amen. And I think that's what's cool about the show. It's this bizarre subject matter. But you know, Edamar Moses and David Yazbek and David Crummer are hilarious. Like just being in the room with them, their comedy, you know, permeates through this story and really brings it the levity that I think gives it such that I think it's why people received it so well because we're telling this sad, weird story, but also we're gonna make you laugh.

[13:11] Julia Knitel: We're gonna make you cry. I gotta say, like it's very good. Actually, that's a big promise. I know. I feel like no promises, but I think a few people cry.

[13:24] Bruce Gotlieb: All right. So now going from off Broadway to now a Broadway house, sometimes you'll see shows change a little bit, either for the space or because they can maybe tell the story a little differently now that they have more space. Have you guys even started to unpack that yet?

[13:40] Julia Knitel: Well, as the sleuth of the company, I do have some information for you. Thank you. We start rehearsals a week from yesterday, so we'll find out really like the full picture then. But I've met, I've had a drink with our lighting designer, and she showed me a few of the really cool things that she gets to play with that we didn't have the opportunity to do off Broadway. And there's some real, I mean, Heather is insane, and she is creating some real magic with some of the lights. And Sarah Lux, our costume designer, is really being given a lot of opportunity to expand the costumes in the show. Everything from off Broadway that I wore and much of what the men wore as well has been completely redesigned and just like, oh my god, every fitting I've gotten teary-eyed because it's just the most beautiful clothing I've ever put on my body.

And I know Cromer said basically their philosophy is better or more. We're not changing anything. We're just gonna make it better and make it more and just kind of ramp everything up. So I think if you saw it off Broadway, aesthetically it'll seem very familiar, but just sort of more finesse and more, you know, more fun toys to play with.

[14:52] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, now I'm glad I waited.

[14:53] Julia Knitel: Yeah.

[14:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Because I get to see a better version. But probably if I had gone off Broadway, I'd still be coming back anyway, just to say I like to see how a show evolves.

[15:02] Julia Knitel: Me too.

[15:02] Bruce Gotlieb: So is it just a given that women wear wigs a hundred percent?

[15:06] Julia Knitel: Oh, actually, so this has been a big conversation. The team really loved my hair and gave me the option to wear my hair or wear a wig. And so I'll be without a wig.

[15:18] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh, that's so nice.

[15:19] Julia Knitel: Yeah. My first runway show without one.

[15:22] Bruce Gotlieb: Really?

[15:22] Julia Knitel: It's probably gonna be just, you know, one step easier to get it ready.

[15:26] Bruce Gotlieb: It's true.

[15:27] Julia Knitel: And I'm very lucky, my hair is low maintenance, so I can just like let it dry and then they'll be getting what they want, which is ideal.

[15:33] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh my gosh.

[15:34] Julia Knitel: All right. I thought we were gonna be friends, but now I don't know.

[15:37] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm so jealous.

[15:38] Julia Knitel: It's the bob, you just gotta chop it and then it sells whatever it was.

[15:41] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh no, mine would just be a curly, frizzy mess if I didn't do anything.

[15:46] Julia Knitel: Sorry. I had a bob once and it was fun, but yeah, it was a lot of maintenance for me.

[15:50] Bruce Gotlieb: I do hear it goes either way.

[15:52] Julia Knitel: Yeah, mine is unlucky.

[15:56] Bruce Gotlieb: So, what's it like being the only woman? That must be fun.

[15:58] Julia Knitel: It's such a delight. I've always, you know, I've always gotten along really well with men. And this group of men in particular is really extraordinary. And from day one, they just like really took me under their wing and were very protective and sweet and loving. And to go through many of us were with it from its very inception. This is developed out of an album that David Yazbeck and Eric de la Penna wrote and performed in concert style. And when they first thought, let's make this into a musical, we were brought in for a reading, and it was very intimidating because the day before they started rehearsals with us, they called and said, just so you know, we're announcing an off-Broadway run, and none of you have first right of refusal. And we were like, Oh, okay. That's cool. Got it. So do good.

[16:51] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, really challenge.

[16:53] Julia Knitel: Yeah, it's been terrifying. But we got to watch how these geniuses could take this absurd story and really work it and make it into something truly spectacular. And I walked out of that workshop thinking, like, okay, well, this is the best thing I've ever been in. So I really hope I get to stay with it. And to build that alongside these seven men has just been such a gift. We all get along so well. We all like hang out, even, you know, if we didn't transfer, we'd still have that group text, and we've, you know, spent weekends away with a few of them. It's been really, it's just a dream come true. I love them.

[17:33] Bruce Gotlieb: That's so neat. That's amazing. It seems very different in tone from their last collaboration, The Band's Visit.

[17:39] Julia Knitel: Definitely.

[17:40] Bruce Gotlieb: Was that something you were a fan of?

[17:41] Julia Knitel: Absolutely. Yes. I remember I had been on tour with Beautiful, and I was only able to see The Band's Visit in its last week. And I came back again. I saw it twice in their closing week. And I just remember like, oh, this is possible. It felt like a play with music. And that's exactly my taste in theater. I want something really truthful. I want something really honest and grounded. And I, you know, when I got the email for this, and it literally said, like, you know, it's the advanced visit team for the audition. I was immediately extraordinarily intimidated because I just knew that that's exactly the kind of theater that I want to be making. And to have this opportunity was nerve-wracking and overwhelming. And I still kind of pinch myself that they chose to bring me on board.

[18:29] Bruce Gotlieb: That's amazing. You've mentioned Beautiful. So regionally, I know you've done the part, and then obviously on Broadway understudying being Carole King. Like, what's that? How do you wrap your head around that?

[18:36] Julia Knitel: Let me tell you, I actually had a whole sort of I saw last night the Broadway leading ladies at Town Hall. Oh and it was extraordinary. I cried several times. I watched Jesse Mueller perform last night and I started getting emotional because 10 years ago, I won't give my age, but I was basically an infant. And I was called by the Beautiful team. I had been in callbacks for the understudy, and they called me and said, Hey, we actually want to consider you for Carole King to originate it on the tour. I was 21, I'll tell you that. And I was like, Oh, I can't do that. I'm so I'm a child. What do you mean? And I bought myself a ticket to see Jesse do it so that I could have some idea. And I was in that audience hysterically crying.

It was one of the moments where like I saw exactly what I want to do on stage and I was so inspired and so overwhelmed. And so intimidated that anyone thought that I could even begin to try to do that. And being across the street from the Sondheim last night, where I ultimately did play that role on Broadway, watching Jesse Mueller a whole 10 years later, and just knowing that like next week all my dreams come true, and I originate a role on Broadway was like, I was tears, tears, tears.

[19:57] Bruce Gotlieb: What's emotional?

[19:59] Julia Knitel: Ah, she sang "If I Loved You." And then she and Lindsay did a little like the pre-"Mr. Snow" together. It was adorable. But yeah, it just, it's such an intimidating role because people really care about Carole King and they know her. They know her and they feel like she's their friend. And that's something that like I experienced a lot actually, like on the tour especially, because it was such a grand production and everybody, you know, the first national with it's basically the Broadway show on wheels. And everybody just at the stage door would be so connected and so engaged with me because they feel like I am Carole King. They feel like I have put into a body like the music that they, you know, grew to love. And all the songs she's written that she's never sung that they know, you know, aside from the songs that she sings. She is in us, she's in all of our marrow. She's extraordinary.

[20:56] Bruce Gotlieb: I went to see Beautiful with my aunt. It was her choice. She was in from out of town, so she got to pick the show. And I was thinking, all right, well, I'll take one for the team. And then I ended up loving it so much, being so touched, so emotional at the end, which is a lot for me because I'm pretty icy. But really, I loved it. And I went to Queen's College. So you know, there's that too. It was just so familiar, also.

[21:18] Julia Knitel: Yeah.

[21:18] Bruce Gotlieb: It was, yeah, what a special, beautiful show.

[21:22] Julia Knitel: It really is. And every time I took like a seven-year break from it because as young as I was, it was very overwhelming when I ultimately took over the tour. And I did a year and I was like, you know what? I don't think I can be around this show for a little while. Like I need to heal myself. You know, she's very self-deprecating, Carole. And it kind of wore me down and just sort of like got me to a place where I wasn't old enough or strong enough to really like bounce back at the end. And I took these seven years and then revisited it and was like, oh wow, this show really is so special and so beautiful, and what a gift that I've had it in my life for a decade.

[22:01] Bruce Gotlieb: That's great.

[22:02] Julia Knitel: Yeah, absolutely. And you did Gypsy, and now that's playing on Broadway. It's like your whole career is right in front of you. It's a long in a few locks, and such a great time for you, really. You must have been so excited.

[22:14] Julia Knitel: I feel very, very lucky. I just keep, you know, pinching, pinching.

[22:18] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[22:19] Julia Knitel: So did you always want to do theater? Was that the dream as a kid?

[22:23] Julia Knitel: Yeah, my parents are both performers. They were professional performers until they had me, and now they teach and run a community theater company in New Jersey that's actually celebrating its 30th year last year. I know. I know. And so I grew up doing, you know, a show every year, building the sets and painting and, you know, helping with the costume and running the lights and building a mic plot. And so I really grew up kind of holistically in the theater. And I never, I didn't do anything professional until I was 16. And I heard about the open call for Bye Bye Birdie at the Roundabout. I said, hey, parents, can I go to this? And they were like, yeah. I kind of thought they would say no, but they said yes. And then I booked it, which was insane. And then, you know, I kind of was just on this trajectory of, I guess I'm gonna be a Broadway actor now.

[23:15] Bruce Gotlieb: So go to college or did you just start working?

[23:19] Julia Knitel: I dropped out of high school to do Bye Bye Birdie. And then from like 17 to 19, I was auditioning and I had this like string of final callbacks for like major Broadway shows and major tours. And I was, it was me and one other person for all of them, and I didn't get them. And I was like, okay, I get it. I'm like five, 10, I'm 17. Like that's not a very good combination. And so let me take a step back and see what I need. And I found what I needed was more acting training. And so I found a BFA program that would take me with a GED. And I need, I was like, I want to stay in New York. And so I found Marymount Manhattan College, which is no longer sadly they shut down. But I did two years of their BFA acting program and then left to do a play out of town. And while I was out of town, I got Beautiful. So it's sort of just college for the second Broadway show, high school for the first Broadway show, perpetual tap out.

[24:22] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[24:23] Julia Knitel: But that's amazing. It's just, you know, life sort of told you where to go and you listened.

[24:27] Bruce Gotlieb: Amen.

[24:28] Julia Knitel: Yeah.

[24:28] Bruce Gotlieb: Which a lot of people don't have the foresight or the, you have to be able to do that. So the hat's off to you for that.

[24:35] Julia Knitel: Thank you. It's always scary. You're always just like, all right, I guess I'm gonna leap and see what happens.

[24:40] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. It's funny because in like corporate world, you always hear like, oh you have to have a bachelor's degree, you have to have a master's degree and you know then you have people that sit there and like but I've been doing the job for 20 years why do I need that paper and and you're showing everybody that you know I can go out there and I can you know learn while doing like learn from my surroundings and be able to do it all yes and actually like I think so much of so much of performing you can only really learn how to do on stage like you can only learn so much in a classroom you have to learn how to interact with an audience you have to learn how to be comfortable on the fly you have to you know a lot of what my sort of journey has been is like learning how to be a leading lady and and looking at these people who came before me and the qualities that they have that I want to emulate and the qualities that maybe I'm not so keen to and it's like you just being in the community is always a lesson and is always if you're just absorbing and and trying to really make the most of each opportunity that's when you learn how to perform I really do think it's like hours on the stage and I was fortunate enough to grow up on the stage but professionally it's been amazing.

[26:01] Julia Knitel: Well maybe next year you'll be at on the leading ladies stage in your mouth put it up you qualify now musical theater always been it or just acting in general like you know, a straight play, is that something you'd like to do?

[26:18] Julia Knitel: I love doing straight plays. I try to do like 50-50 as much as I possibly can. Um, unfortunately, I've been in a few straight plays where they make only me sing. It's a play, but Julia plays a lounge singer. But no, I try to do as many plays as I can. I find them so fulfilling and I find them so grounding. And like it really reminds me what like I think when when you're in a musical, it's very easy to get wrapped up in like the songs and and from for people to use the scenes to get to the songs. And um, my my interest is always, and I tend to gravitate toward directors like David Kromer, um, who really invest in the scene work and who like to treat things as a play with music. And so that's sort of that's my perfect middle ground.

It is nice though when you have in a play, and sometimes in a musical too, when you really have a good meaty scene that goes on for a few pages. I love it. I'm always like, should we cut this whenever I'm wearing a new work? I'm like, maybe we need like four less songs.

[27:16] Bruce Gotlieb: That sounds like the composers must love that.

[27:19] Julia Knitel: Love it. They love it.

[27:21] Bruce Gotlieb: So can you give us a sense of the music for Dead Outlaw?

[27:23] Julia Knitel: Oh, it's so good. Oh I've had I have a few friends who are like really big, big David Yazbek fans, and many of them have said like this is their favorite of his work so far. What's cool about it is it's with the influence of Eric Della Pana, David and and he are really leaning into their roots, and it's there are moments of full-on musical theater, but much of it is like rockabilly folk, country, like really down and dirty, cool bops. Like you, you know, I think it's hard to leave the theater and really have like a hummable tune. And I mean, this show is just full of them. The music is so great, and it's a joy to sing too. I feel so lucky.

[28:10] Julia Knitel: Different in style from Beautiful, I'm sure.

[28:12] Bruce Gotlieb: And Gypsy.

[28:13] Julia Knitel: Oh, very different from Gypsy. Yeah, it's cool. I get to when I heard one of the songs that I sing is called A Stranger. And you know, when you spend your life auditioning, you can't get attached to anything. You have to kind of like learn the music, go in, sing it, and hope for the best. And I heard this song and I said, Oh no. If anyone else gets to do this, I'll kill myself. And uh luckily I I didn't have to, but um, it's so beautiful. It's kind of um I don't want to say Joni Mitchell, like a little bit of Emmy Lou Harris, just like earthy, gorgeous, and it's very cool that my music sort of stands apart from the men in the show. And I kind of have these these two step outs of like really feminine, feminine songs and to come from, you know, the pen and the mouth of Eric and and David is it's such a testament to their versatility and their talent.

[29:10] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[29:10] Julia Knitel: I love when men get women and they really can write for women. David Yazbek is really truly one of them, and it's it's an honor to to sing his songs, but he just he knows he picks the right keys and he asks the right questions, and it's just I'm obsessed with him.

[29:27] Bruce Gotlieb: Is there have you found that there's a collaboration that you get to have with the creatives because you're originating this role?

[29:36] Julia Knitel: Absolutely. Um it's been so cool. It was very actually I had to get over a little bit of a lot of bit of uh imposter syndrome because this is just such a magnificent team, such a an intimidating room to be in. And once I realized, like, oh, I'm here for a reason and they they value me. Um, I was able to like lean in and collaborate with them. I think what's one of my favorite moments was when uh during the workshop, David told me he loved my voice, which was really uh quite the compliment, and I could have just died right there on the spot. But uh he wrote a new reprieve of one of the songs for me that was not originally in in the piece. And so that was a very special, yeah.

[30:21] Julia Knitel: Yeah. Unfortunately, it got cut from stage, but you can hear it on the audible version. It got snuck back in. So it's good. Fair and posterity, but and it still exists and it's for you.

[30:33] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[30:33] Julia Knitel: You can you can say that he wrote a song for you because it's different from yeah.

[30:41] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh my gosh, that's incredible.

[30:43] Julia Knitel: Um, do you feel like the character changed once you had it? You know, once it once you started working on it, did it, you know, did you adapt it in any way?

[30:52] Julia Knitel: For sure. I mean, what's really I think what was so intimidating actually at first was that I wasn't getting a lot of like explicit direction from David Cromer. And I I was like, oh, I I don't know, I I don't know what to do. And then eventually he was like, it's because it's just you, just be you. And I was like, ah, cool. So I think I definitely I bring a lot to Maggie, who's my first character, who's um the fiance to not spoiler alert, fiance to uh Andrew Durant's character Elmer. She is very much me and very much in my in my body. And then um my second main character, Millicent, who is my personal favorite, uh starts as an eight-year old girl. Ah, fine and ages to like from eight to twelve, thirteen to like nineteen. And she's definitely a little more of a departure from me, but they really let me lean into some of my comedic chops and just making her as weird as I possibly could.

[31:53] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh my gosh, that sounds so fun.

[31:56] Julia Knitel: Yeah. So much so that like I walked out on stage during tech and David Cromer got on the god mic and in my costume for the first time, and he goes, You're a menace, Julia. I tell you like here we go.

[32:09] Bruce Gotlieb: Are both characters from the same era?

[32:12] Julia Knitel: Uh Maggie is in the 1910s, and Millicent is I believe she starts in the 40s, the 40s to the 50s. So we go on a journey time-wise with this show because we know we end up in the 70s or start with the 70s.

[32:25] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh, yeah.

[32:26] Julia Knitel: It's almost a hundred years. We start in 1880 and end in 1970.

[32:31] Bruce Gotlieb: Wow. Quite the journey.

[32:33] Julia Knitel: Oh my gosh. I wish it was next week.

[32:34] Bruce Gotlieb: I want to see.

[32:34] Julia Knitel: I know. You're gonna have so much fun.

[32:39] Bruce Gotlieb: So for every kid that dreams of this career, right? You always have that moment of one day I'm gonna be standing up and and you know, uh, you know, accepting a Tony or whatever award, you know, Academy Award if you want to do film. What's the brain space like when you yourself get nominated for an Outer Critics Circle and your show's winning, you know, a Drama Desk Award? Like what how do you wrap your head around that?

[33:04] Julia Knitel: Um, it's hard to. It actually is. I I it's something I've been working on actually very heavily for the last three months, is like really being in the moment and and appreciating this incredible opportunity and this literal dream come true. Like my all of my dreams are coming true. And that can be that was something I think I was like shirking from during the off-Broadway run of just like, oh my God, this is so intense. And like, what if they go to Broadway or what if they replace me and they go to Broadway? And I like just all of these sort of panic imposter thoughts. And I have spent the last like three or four months really working on just being grateful and being present and realizing that come Monday next week, my whole life is is gonna change for the better.

And not not being afraid of that. And this opportunity is coming at me like a train, not to use a Dead Outlaw metaphor, but it's come in full force. And so I can either hop on and enjoy the ride or try to sprint away from it in fear. And I think, you know, I'm gonna, I'm gonna lean in, I'm gonna enjoy the ride. And I think the the positive response we've already gotten is only going to get so much bigger and better. And I I can't wait for more people to see this show because it really is one of the best things I've ever been in.

[34:29] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[34:30] Julia Knitel: Well, I mean, the the fact is you've already won, right? So it doesn't even matter what happens because you know, you're getting to do this.

[34:36] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, it's your role, you've earned it.

[34:39] Julia Knitel: Um people I I'm sure they're gonna love it because they already loved it and now it's just gonna be even better. But you know, I obviously, you know, awards are great. And you know, I wrote the Tony book, so obviously I love awards. Bruce loves awards, the show is fun with the awards, but they matter and they really don't matter at the same time because just getting in the room, right? Where you are, that's the real prize.

[35:05] Julia Knitel: So true.

[35:07] Bruce Gotlieb: So true.

[35:07] Julia Knitel: And it's it's something that like even just to be at the Tonys to perform on the Tonys is gonna be I'm gonna I'm just gonna be a hysterical mess the whole time I'm gonna be crying and like looking around and just you know just being able to appreciate every step of this journey is is really important to me. And just as you know a theater kid myself the most amazing thing is that now your name is gonna go down in history like every person who ever picks up that script is gonna see your name and that cast list.

[35:39] Julia Knitel: Don't make me cry yeah it's cool it it's very cool and it feels you know a lot of people have said to me like oh is this your role I gave you and I'm like no number three but it's you know it's something that I've my whole career has been building toward this moment and I I love my career. I look back at my credits and the things that I've gotten to do and I'm like I I remember I did Gypsy with Beth Level and I literally said 25 years old I could retire. Like this I just peep I'm pink and it's like I I really have had so many incredible opportunities and worked with so many incredible people and and just the whole thing has been leading to this moment and even if this is it and nobody ever hires me again all my dreams have come true and I really like I I feel so lucky and to get to do it in a show that I believe in so fiercely that is so unique and bizarre and hilarious and strange and singular is you know more than I could have ever imagined.

[36:45] Bruce Gotlieb: Well we're going to be just hearing you on.

[36:48] Julia Knitel: Yes.

[36:50] Bruce Gotlieb: We're so excited to see the show.

[36:52] Julia Knitel: So you've been so busy with this. Is there anything else that you have on the horizon?

[36:57] Bruce Gotlieb: I mean, obviously not theater wise, but is there any TV, maybe?

[37:00] Julia Knitel: Just been busy. Just yeah. Uh just been working on this. And it's kind of nice actually, not to audition. When I was in uh Sarasota most recently doing Beautiful at the Oslo, it was a three-month contract, which was a very long time. And we hadn't heard anything about Dead Outlaw. So I was in Final Callbacks for two Broadway shows that are on in this season. And I was like, I guess, I guess, like hopefully no matter what, I'll be in a show this spring. But um, it was it was a lot of auditioning, a lot of time, a lot of work, a lot of memorizing. And so the last month or so to just be like smooth sailing has been a real gift.

[37:41] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh well.

[37:43] Julia Knitel: You could tell you could tell them I'm not available.

[37:44] Bruce Gotlieb: Um I'm not available at least at least God willing, a year.

[37:48] Julia Knitel: We'll think that they get the best.

[37:50] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, that's nice.

[37:51] Julia Knitel: Do you want to say what the other show is that you auditioned for?

[37:54] Julia Knitel: I was in Final Callbacks for two different alternate positions in Operation Mincemeat.

[37:59] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh and I I gotta say, like I'm such a fan.

[38:02] Julia Knitel: I loved it so much. I loved the material. It was it's so different from Dead Outlaw, although also about a dead body. Um and I keep like, I'm like, oh, I hope it's doing well. I really like I can't wait to see it. I was such a fan of the material.

[38:18] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, they're they're doing pretty well.

[38:20] Julia Knitel: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[38:21] Bruce Gotlieb: They just extended, I think.

[38:22] Julia Knitel: I they did. I think they added a couple of weeks.

[38:23] Bruce Gotlieb: So great.

[38:24] Julia Knitel: Yeah.

[38:26] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, Julia, you are a joy. Thank you so much for joining us.

[38:28] Julia Knitel: We'd love having you.

[38:30] Bruce Gotlieb: Next time you have something exciting to talk about, or we'll give you our cell phone if you get any sleuth information.

[38:37] Julia Knitel: Oh, awesome. I'll I'll keep you in the living room.

[38:39] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, yeah. We won't tell anyone.

[38:40] Julia Knitel: Well, thank you so much. And we will see you next time on Behind the Awards.

[38:44] Julia Knitel: Thank you.

[38:44] Julia Knitel: Bye-bye.

[38:45] Julia Knitel: Bye.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred