Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#9 - Tony Awards 2024 Analysis #2

Is there a clear winner this Tony Season…Doubt it? Magnificent Monday! Eila & Bruce bring you the second installment of their Tony deep dive. They are joined by expert Matt Stashin and share who will win and who they want to win in the following categories... Read More

From the show: Behind the Awards with Eila Mell & Bruce Gotlieb

47 mins
5/13/24

Miniseries Inclusions

Featured Shows

About

Is there a clear winner this Tony Season…Doubt it?

Magnificent Monday! Eila & Bruce bring you the second installment of their Tony deep dive. They are joined by expert Matt Stashin and share who will win and who they want to win in the following categories. Featured Actress in a Play, Lighting Design of a Musical, Costume Design of a Play and Best Original Score..

Quincy Tyler Bernstine, Juliana Canfield, Celia Keenan-Bolger, Sarah Pidgeon, Kara Young, Appropriate, Stereophonic, Jaja’s African Hair Braiding, Purlie Victorious, An Enemy of the People, Illinoise, Cabaret, Hells Kitchen, The Outsiders, Water for Elephants, Days of Wine and Roses, Here Lies Love, Suffs, The Mother Play, Doubt, David Byrne, Fat Boy Slim

Make sure to check out Eila's book, "The Tony Awards", and all her other amazing books: https://amzn.to/43WMu5Y.

Connect with Eila and Bruce:

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:09] Eila Mell: Hello and welcome to Behind the Awards.

[0:11] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm Bruce and I'm here with Eila.

[0:14] Eila Mell: Hey, Bruce.

[0:15] Bruce Gotlieb: Hi, Eila. How's everything going?

[0:16] Eila Mell: I'm good. Do you have Tony fever?

[0:19] Bruce Gotlieb: I have Tony fever.

[0:20] Eila Mell: We are in week two of our, you know, post-nomination life.

[0:26] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. Are you still reeling from some of the nominations and some of the snubs?

[0:30] Eila Mell: I am. They're still definitely top of mind.

[0:32] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[0:33] Eila Mell: Um, I feel like, although I'm not a Tony voter, I am dissecting as if I was.

[0:38] Bruce Gotlieb: I know. And I, you know, in my own mind placing my own votes.

[0:43] Eila Mell: So we, you and I went to an event and we had a conversation with a Tony voter.

[0:49] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.

[0:50] Eila Mell: Who still felt the same way we do that Chip's sign was snubbed.

[0:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.

[0:54] Eila Mell: That was one of the first things he said when we were just chatting.

[0:58] Bruce Gotlieb: And you know, he, while he wouldn't reveal all of his thoughts because he keeps apparently his job, uh, his Tony thoughts too close to his vest.

[1:07] Eila Mell: Well, it's a good thing he's taking it seriously.

[1:08] Bruce Gotlieb: He takes it very seriously.

[1:10] Eila Mell: Um, but it was very interesting to hear, you know, some thoughts from somebody who has influential love.

[1:16] Bruce Gotlieb: Who's gonna have a say?

[1:17] Eila Mell: That's right.

[1:18] Bruce Gotlieb: That's right. Everybody seems to be reeling. I mean, you hear it everywhere I go. What happened to Chip?

[1:21] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[1:23] Bruce Gotlieb: So if you guys have any thoughts on that, we'd love to hear it.

[1:27] Eila Mell: So just send us a message on our Instagram. It's just simple behind the awards.

[1:31] Bruce Gotlieb: And any other snubs or who you're rooting for, what do you think?

[1:35] Eila Mell: I personally think Steve Carell was snubbed.

[1:38] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm still going with that.

[1:39] Eila Mell: Okay.

[1:40] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay. I mean, there are just so many good performances this season.

[1:46] Eila Mell: I know.

[1:47] Bruce Gotlieb: That, I mean, of course, you want everyone to be recognized.

[1:50] Eila Mell: Yes.

[1:50] Bruce Gotlieb: It's gonna be interesting because there's no clear-cut winner.

[1:53] Eila Mell: I know.

[1:53] Bruce Gotlieb: I know.

[1:54] Eila Mell: I know. You know, some awards you probably figure, okay, this is the, if I was a betting person, I could put money down on certain categories.

[2:04] Bruce Gotlieb: That's true.

[2:05] Eila Mell: But the majority of them, I don't think so.

[2:06] Bruce Gotlieb: I know.

[2:07] Eila Mell: I know it's true.

[2:08] Bruce Gotlieb: So let's bring our special guest on, Matt Stashin.

[2:12] Matt Stashin: Hi, Matt.

[2:13] Matt Stashin: Hi, how are you?

[2:14] Eila Mell: We are very happy to welcome you back for our Tony analysis.

[2:17] Matt Stashin: I'm so happy to be here.

[2:20] Eila Mell: Um, so let's give a shout-out to our friend and friend of the show, Robin Herter.

[2:26] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, our first episode.

[2:27] Eila Mell: Yes, she was our first guest, and we went to see her in Chicago this week, where she's playing Velma Kelly.

[2:33] Bruce Gotlieb: Her Velma is so good.

[2:34] Eila Mell: Now you've seen other Velmas.

[2:36] Matt Stashin: I've seen other Velmas, and not to, you know, disparage their performances, but Robin, it's opening night with Robin at every show she does.

[2:46] Bruce Gotlieb: She's all out.

[2:48] Eila Mell: Yeah. So if anybody's that that's listening that hasn't seen Chicago or maybe hasn't seen it in a while.

[2:54] Bruce Gotlieb: And if you haven't seen Robin in it, it's worth just going to be able to do that.

[2:56] Eila Mell: It's worth the price of admission.

[2:57] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[2:58] Eila Mell: It's a great show.

[2:59] Bruce Gotlieb: Absolutely.

[3:00] Eila Mell: And she's incredible. That said, what categories are we going to be discussing today?

[3:05] Matt Stashin: We have original score, costume design of a play, lighting design of a musical, and best featured actress in a play.

[3:13] Bruce Gotlieb: All right. Well, Matt, I think we should start with music.

[3:16] Matt Stashin: What do you think?

[3:17] Bruce Gotlieb: Absolutely.

[3:18] Eila Mell: All right, Bruce, who is up for best original score?

[3:21] Bruce Gotlieb: We have Days of Wine and Roses, Adam Guettel.

[3:24] Bruce Gotlieb: Here Lies Love, David Byrne, Fat Boy Slim, Stereophonic, Will Butler, Suffs, Shayna Taub, The Outsiders, Jamestown Revival, and Justin Levine.

[3:36] Eila Mell: Matt, I know I didn't get a chance to see Days of Wine and Roses.

[3:40] Matt Stashin: I know you did.

[3:41] Eila Mell: Yes, I did. Um, so why don't you share a little bit about their orchestration and we'll dive in there?

[3:46] Matt Stashin: Tell us about the music.

[3:47] Matt Stashin: The music was absolutely beautiful. I mean, there were so many melodies that just soared, like you walked out of the theater singing.

[3:55] Eila Mell: Okay.

[3:55] Matt Stashin: And it was a very happy, not at all.

[3:57] Eila Mell: Not at all.

[3:59] Matt Stashin: But it seemed to be much more like classical musical theater score than a lot of the other nominees, which this year at least, which makes it stand out a lot more as well.

[4:07] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, that's true. Now it makes it kind of makes sense, right?

[4:10] Matt Stashin: With the pedigree of the composer, Adam Guettel.

[4:12] Eila Mell: So what's his connection to classical American musical theater?

[4:17] Matt Stashin: I believe he's related to Richard Rodgers and Mary Rodgers.

[4:20] Bruce Gotlieb: You know, mom and grandpa.

[4:21] Eila Mell: Those hacks.

[4:23] Bruce Gotlieb: Have they experienced much in musical theater?

[4:26] Matt Stashin: Or are they just trying to break in now?

[4:28] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, really.

[4:30] Matt Stashin: And of course, Adam Guettel did Light in the Piazza.

[4:33] Eila Mell: Yes.

[4:33] Matt Stashin: So he's got a Tony already.

[4:35] Bruce Gotlieb: And a well-deserved one.

[4:37] Eila Mell: So do you think he has a chance of getting another Tony?

[4:39] Matt Stashin: I think it's possible.

[4:40] Matt Stashin: Yeah, I really do. This is one of those categories where all five of the contenders are great choices that would be absolutely deserving of winning.

[4:46] Eila Mell: So, how important was the music to telling the story of this show?

[4:51] Matt Stashin: Oh, vital.

[4:51] Eila Mell: Okay.

[4:52] Matt Stashin: It really, you could tell that story as a play.

[4:55] Eila Mell: Well, it was a movie, yeah.

[4:57] Matt Stashin: Absolutely. Um, but this version of it.

[4:59] Eila Mell: Yeah, I don't think it would have worked without the music.

[5:02] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, because I always think that that's important when you're judging, you know, it's not just about the pretty songs, it's about how it is in terms of storytelling.

[5:10] Matt Stashin: Right.

[5:10] Eila Mell: Well, you and I actually went to see Here Lies Love together.

[5:14] Bruce Gotlieb: That was so much fun.

[5:15] Eila Mell: And David Byrne was there in the audience.

[5:17] Matt Stashin: Yes, he was, singing along with the cast many times.

[5:19] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.

[5:20] Eila Mell: And you also got to share space with Vanessa Williams of the Rover.

[5:24] Bruce Gotlieb: That's right.

[5:24] Eila Mell: So Matt and I chose not to be on the dance floor where most people were, but we wanted to sit for the show.

[5:30] Bruce Gotlieb: So we got this little box, which was really nice.

[5:32] Eila Mell: It held about ten people, and Vanessa Williams was part of our group of ten.

[5:37] Bruce Gotlieb: So she was part of—Vanessa Williams was part of your entourage.

[5:39] Eila Mell: She was part of our group of ten.

[5:41] Bruce Gotlieb: I think we were more part of her entourage, but she could not have been nicer.

[5:46] Matt Stashin: Yes, she was great.

[5:47] Eila Mell: And I know you guys haven't stopped talking about the music for that.

[5:52] Matt Stashin: Yeah, I really loved that. I love the title song, Here Lies Love.

[5:56] Matt Stashin: I love the finale.

[5:57] Eila Mell: Oh, that finale was gorgeous.

[5:59] Matt Stashin: Uh, what the, the old friend who she kind of dumps, her song was amazing.

[6:03] Eila Mell: I believe the actress's name, and if I butchered the pronunciation, I'm sorry, Melody Betouille.

[6:08] Matt Stashin: Okay.

[6:09] Eila Mell: She was phenomenal.

[6:10] Matt Stashin: That's all was phenomenal.

[6:12] Eila Mell: In another season with less shows, she could have gotten a nomination too.

[6:17] Matt Stashin: Not just that, I think she actually would have been a contender to win.

[6:19] Eila Mell: Yeah, she was great.

[6:21] Matt Stashin: She really was.

[6:22] Eila Mell: And how was the, assuming based on my the little that I know about the show, the music obviously a vital storyteller here.

[6:29] Matt Stashin: It was.

[6:30] Matt Stashin: I mean, there because there was so much going on, right?

[6:33] Bruce Gotlieb: This was like an event less than a show, wouldn't you say?

[6:37] Matt Stashin: Absolutely, 100%.

[6:38] Matt Stashin: I mean, there was stuff happening all over the theater.

[6:41] Eila Mell: And the theater, so for people who don't know, although most people do, David Korins, the set designer, just took apart the Broadway theater, and it was almost like a basketball court, right?

[6:54] Bruce Gotlieb: With the action happening in the middle.

[6:56] Matt Stashin: Right.

[6:56] Eila Mell: And then there was seating all around, but most of the audience was actually standing on the floor.

[7:01] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[7:02] Matt Stashin: Amongst the actors, and became part of sort of like extras in the show.

[7:07] Eila Mell: Right.

[7:07] Matt Stashin: And there were actually, if I remember correctly, like not security guards, but they were people there to direct the audience of where they had to go stand so that the action could happen in the correct places.

[7:17] Bruce Gotlieb: That's right.

[7:17] Matt Stashin: People in cool jumpsuits.

[7:19] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[7:21] Matt Stashin: And they would dance along during the show.

[7:23] Eila Mell: It was so much fun.

[7:24] Matt Stashin: It was.

[7:26] Eila Mell: And interesting, I would imagine too. I mean, obviously David Byrne is no stranger, you know, to—I mean, he's a legend, yeah.

[7:34] Bruce Gotlieb: But to theater, but Fat Boy Slim never obviously being in the Broadway circle.

[7:40] Matt Stashin: Right.

[7:40] Bruce Gotlieb: This it was his first time.

[7:42] Matt Stashin: I believe so.

[7:43] Bruce Gotlieb: I don't know.

[7:43] Matt Stashin: I probably, but I don't know for sure.

[7:45] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[7:46] Matt Stashin: It was seamless.

[7:47] Matt Stashin: Like I couldn't tell who did what.

[7:49] Eila Mell: It seemed like everything was a collaboration between the two of them.

[7:52] Matt Stashin: Who knows how they worked exactly, right?

[7:54] Eila Mell: The music was just so gorgeous.

[7:56] Matt Stashin: It was.

[7:57] Eila Mell: And again, there were a lot of songs that really stood out, correct to me.

[8:01] Matt Stashin: And a lot of it, you know, the songs definitely moved the story forward and a lot of it was told in song.

[8:06] Matt Stashin: There was a lot of music in the show.

[8:08] Eila Mell: Yeah, there was a lot of, if I remember correctly, there was a lot of like incidental music as well.

[8:13] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[8:14] Eila Mell: Which obviously is part of this nomination and is just as important sometimes in terms of like the emotion of the scene.

[8:20] Matt Stashin: Exactly, setting a mood, setting the tone.

[8:23] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[8:23] Matt Stashin: So it was all great.

[8:24] Eila Mell: And they even had their own DJ on stage.

[8:27] Matt Stashin: They did.

[8:28] Eila Mell: Very cool.

[8:28] Bruce Gotlieb: It was really great.

[8:30] Eila Mell: All right. So Bruce, I know that you really like the music for The Outsiders as do I.

[8:36] Bruce Gotlieb: I do.

[8:36] Eila Mell: I thought that it's not your traditional Broadway style.

[8:42] Bruce Gotlieb: I thought that it kind of pushed what I've been saying a lot in speaking about The Outsiders and my experiences, I feel like it's pushing the way Broadway is storytelling.

[8:54] Eila Mell: Mm-hmm.

[8:54] Bruce Gotlieb: You know, a lot of aspects of that show. You know, the dance, the lighting, the sound also.

[9:01] Eila Mell: I just, I appreciate pushing the envelope.

[9:04] Bruce Gotlieb: I appreciate a new way of storytelling without sacrificing it.

[9:07] Eila Mell: And it's also not in an obvious way.

[9:09] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[9:09] Eila Mell: So it's sort of sneaking in this little, you know, these little changes, maybe little innovations.

[9:15] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, and I think the music for this particular show really works to help tell the story.

[9:20] Matt Stashin: Yeah, it was kind of haunting, right?

[9:22] Bruce Gotlieb: Uh, kind of haunting, but it's also like, you know, we're in Tulsa, Oklahoma.

[9:26] Eila Mell: Yes.

[9:27] Bruce Gotlieb: And the music feels like, without like hitting you over the head, it feels like it would that sets you there.

[9:33] Eila Mell: Yeah, it would be from there.

[9:35] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[9:35] Eila Mell: It's not country western.

[9:37] Bruce Gotlieb: No.

[9:37] Eila Mell: It's not what you would expect traditionally, Broadway.

[9:40] Bruce Gotlieb: It's just, it's its own thing that really, you're right, puts you in that town, that time.

[9:46] Eila Mell: Right.

[9:46] Bruce Gotlieb: It's a vibe of it.

[9:47] Eila Mell: Those people, even.

[9:48] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, for sure.

[9:49] Eila Mell: And then, you know, sometimes the absence of sound.

[9:53] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, that's in certain scenes.

[9:55] Eila Mell: Absolutely.

[9:56] Bruce Gotlieb: It really did.

[9:57] Eila Mell: It took over, you know, with storytelling, and it just, I really appreciated it.

[10:01] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, I thought it was really masterful.

[10:04] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[10:04] Bruce Gotlieb: All right. So what are we missing?

[10:06] Eila Mell: Um, well, how about Suffs?

[10:08] Bruce Gotlieb: Uh, Shayna Taub, Matt.

[10:09] Matt Stashin: I know we saw Suffs together.

[10:12] Eila Mell: We did.

[10:13] Matt Stashin: Um, and I felt, and you know, be curious to hear your opinion.

[10:17] Matt Stashin: I felt like the music created similarly to The Outsiders put you in that moment.

[10:24] Eila Mell: So you felt, you know, this is about the suffragette movement.

[10:28] Matt Stashin: So a movement that is, you know, you're driving forward.

[10:31] Eila Mell: It gives you that intensity, that, you know, feeling like you're marching and that you're going towards something.

[10:37] Matt Stashin: And I felt that she did a really effective job of making you feel like, okay, I got somewhere to be, you know.

[10:44] Eila Mell: She really did.

[10:45] Matt Stashin: And the music was fantastic, but I think even there, the score of Suffs, the power was in those lyrics.

[10:52] Eila Mell: Okay.

[10:52] Matt Stashin: And what those lyrics really were able to tell us about these people in this time.

[10:58] Matt Stashin: Like each character, most of the characters got their own standout moment where they really got to show the audience who they were and why they were in the middle of this movement.

[11:10] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[11:11] Matt Stashin: And it really gave us a lot of information and it really, like we've already been saying, drove the story forward.

[11:17] Eila Mell: So was the style of song, did it change from character to character, or was it all pretty uniform?

[11:23] Matt Stashin: It varied.

[11:24] Matt Stashin: There was definitely a coherent style to the music of the show.

[11:26] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[11:27] Matt Stashin: But it definitely did, each character had their own voice.

[11:30] Eila Mell: That's kind of cool.

[11:31] Matt Stashin: Which is what a good score would do.

[11:32] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[11:33] Matt Stashin: Right. Almost like, um, you know, remember Peter and the Wolf, where each instrument was a character.

[11:39] Eila Mell: So everybody has their own sound sort of.

[11:40] Bruce Gotlieb: I forgot about that.

[11:42] Eila Mell: Yeah, and it should, right? Because if the three of us are talking about something, we all have we might agree and all be saying the same thing, but the way we say it is gonna be a little bit different.

[11:53] Matt Stashin: Yeah, different rhythms, yeah.

[11:55] Bruce Gotlieb: And you would expect that otherwise it would be robotic and it wouldn't, yeah, it wouldn't move you, or would you wouldn't feel anything from it?

[12:03] Eila Mell: Right. No, by the end, it would be boring, right? And the fact that any of these people are nominating is nominated is not only that the work that they did, but somebody must have felt something to be compelled to say this person should be nominated.

[12:16] Bruce Gotlieb: Now, could would it be fair to say that Shana Taub is an overachiever? I mean, she did everything on this show. I mean, either that or just a genius. I mean, but talk about really pouring yourself into something. I mean, I'm sure she must have been exhausted when she was done, you know, like, but to not to star, to write, to you know, like I know. You know, she and it's gotta be a passion project.

[12:40] Matt Stashin: Has to be.

[12:41] Eila Mell: Yeah. Must. And to piggyback on what Bruce said, I mean, not only did she go through all of that to write the book and to write the music and to write the lyrics, she's still living it by starring in the show every night.

[12:51] Bruce Gotlieb: Exactly, yes. And she is amazing.

[12:54] Eila Mell: Well, I will have a lot to say about her when we get to leading actress in a musical.

[12:58] Matt Stashin: Okay, well, that's another day.

[12:59] Bruce Gotlieb: I know.

[13:01] Eila Mell: All right. We have to make sure we can get you for that day.

[13:04] Matt Stashin: I'll figure it out. You know, we don't have a big budget here, Matt.

[13:09] Bruce Gotlieb: All right, and is there one more?

[13:11] Matt Stashin: There is one more. So we have Will Butler for Stereophonic.

[13:14] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay, so this is a little bit of an outlier, right? Because it's unusual, it's not unheard of, but it is unusual for a straight play to have a nomination in the category of score.

[13:25] Eila Mell: But there is a lot of music, and it's very key to the plot of Stereophonic. Spoiler alert, it takes place in the 70s, and it is a, you know, a nod to or maybe inspired by Fleetwood Mac.

[13:40] Bruce Gotlieb: It's pretty close to Fleet Mac. So, you know, there is a certain knowing that, you know, you there's a certain expectation of style.

[13:50] Eila Mell: And what is the action of the play? They are.

[13:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Right, and you walk in, it's you know where you are.

[13:56] Eila Mell: Yeah, exactly. There's no hidden agenda here.

[13:59] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes. I thought that the music styling, you know, the songs, everything, obviously it put you there.

[14:06] Eila Mell: It has to, otherwise, the show doesn't work without the right kind of music.

[14:10] Bruce Gotlieb: Correct. And I think the show doesn't work without it being, you know, without the score, without these songs.

[14:16] Eila Mell: Right. Because there is a lot of singing in it. It's nowhere near a musical, but still there's a lot of music and singing and no, because you have plenty of oh, this is a play with music. This is I would say a little over that level of because there's you know, it's almost like maybe 75%.

[14:32] Matt Stashin: Right. Especially Sarah Pidgeon has a lot of singing to do.

[14:35] Bruce Gotlieb: She does.

[14:36] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[14:36] Bruce Gotlieb: She does. And she's great.

[14:38] Matt Stashin: Absolutely. 100%.

[14:39] Eila Mell: And the music really does capture the feel of the time parody and of Fleetwood Mac and of everything that they're trying to evoke in the show.

[14:48] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. And do the actors play their own instruments? I wasn't sure about that.

[14:51] Matt Stashin: I believe they have. Anyone not a player? Playing their own instruments, they're singing live. I did read Eli Gelb is actually working the soundboard.

[14:58] Bruce Gotlieb: I know, that's amazing. So if these people didn't, you know, the musical instruments, you could maybe say they went in with their audition and it was on their special skills.

[15:10] Matt Stashin: It would have to be. The odds of them saying to somebody, Great, we want you for this part, now we're gonna teach you to play drums. There's no time. You know, you can't be that proficient back there.

[15:18] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, it's not like a movie, right where you can take some months and you know, there's no time here. So, you know, certainly a nod to Will Butler for finding people to be able to execute his plan.

[15:30] Eila Mell: Yes, you know, yeah, and it's really good music. Like this could be just on the radio anyway.

[15:35] Matt Stashin: I think so. 100%.

[15:36] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes. All right. So now the hard question: who's going to win?

[15:41] Matt Stashin: I think it's interesting because I think that I think that it's going to be Stereophonic. You know, which is funny because you have normally when multiple shows have multiple nominations, you go, Well, will they cancel each other out? And in this case, it's almost like will all the musicals that traditionally would win best score, are they gonna cancel each other out?

[16:02] Eila Mell: Right. And that would be a first because no straight play has ever won in the score category when a musical has been eligible.

[16:11] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. The one time that it happened was that one it was the pandemic year, 2020. He won for Christmas Carol.

[16:18] Matt Stashin: Right. So I think my opinion, Stereophonic will win.

[16:22] Eila Mell: Yeah, I kind of think it will too.

[16:24] Bruce Gotlieb: I think Stereophonic just has a lot of buzz. What do you think, Matt?

[16:27] Matt Stashin: I'm very torn, to be perfectly honest. I Stereophonic definitely has a chance. My gut's telling me Adam Gettel's gonna take it.

[16:35] Bruce Gotlieb: No.

[16:35] Matt Stashin: Because Days of Wine and Roses has a lot of very passionate followers.

[16:40] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.

[16:40] Matt Stashin: Um and the music was phenomenal. Even though the show's closed, you still don't know. Even though it's closed, I think in this one case, yeah.

[16:46] Bruce Gotlieb: All right. So now switching it on its head, what do you want to win?

[16:50] Matt Stashin: What do I want to win?

[16:51] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes.

[16:52] Matt Stashin: Suffs. Absolutely Suffs.

[16:55] Eila Mell: All right. Well, I would like Here Lies Love to win.

[16:57] Matt Stashin: Interesting.

[16:58] Bruce Gotlieb: And I would like The Outsiders to win.

[17:01] Matt Stashin: Okay.

[17:01] Bruce Gotlieb: I mean, I wouldn't be upset if The Outsiders took it. It's, you know, we're all we all have our own stake in the game here.

[17:08] Eila Mell: We're all over the place.

[17:09] Bruce Gotlieb: That's good. We should fill out um, you know, like little sheets and see who predicts the best.

[17:16] Matt Stashin: Wait, that's not competitive enough. Let's go to Vegas and make bets.

[17:19] Bruce Gotlieb: Come on. If we're gonna do it, we have to do it right.

[17:24] Eila Mell: We'll be right back. We have to listen to some commercials.

[17:32] Bruce Gotlieb: So now we have costume design of a play.

[17:36] Eila Mell: So should I read?

[17:37] Bruce Gotlieb: Go for it.

[17:38] Eila Mell: I'll take over. Okay, so the nominees are Didi Aite for Appropriate. And then Didi again for Ja Ja's African Hair Braiding. Enver Chakardesh. And we're so sorry for butchering anyone's names. Believe me, with a name like Isla, I understand. Um, but that's for Stereophonic. My dear Emilio Sosa for Purlie Victorious, and David Zinn, An Enemy of the People.

[18:04] Matt Stashin: What do you think about Didi's chances seeing as that she's nominated for two shows here?

[18:10] Eila Mell: I really hope they don't split the vote.

[18:13] Matt Stashin: I'm afraid they might.

[18:14] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[18:14] Matt Stashin: But I really hope they don't, and I they shouldn't because the two shows were so different.

[18:20] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. Very much so, yeah.

[18:22] Matt Stashin: And I think that's a testament to her and like how talented she really is.

[18:27] Eila Mell: And all the more so because they're both modern day, but still very different world, very different types of people.

[18:33] Bruce Gotlieb: Absolutely. And she really, you know, those clothes tell you who in this play, in the world of the play.

[18:38] Matt Stashin: Especially in Ja Ja.

[18:40] Eila Mell: Yeah. Those costumes really did a lot of work helping the audience along.

[18:45] Matt Stashin: And they were so much fun.

[18:46] Eila Mell: They were. So I mean that, you know, that was just so much fun as a play, but also to look at. You know, the tech stuff is about creating that vibe and that mood throughout the piece.

[19:01] Bruce Gotlieb: It has to help the storyline along. That's why sometimes, you know, you hear people say, whether it be costume lighting, what have you, oh, it was its own character. Because if done well, it does. It creates its own entity within the piece.

[19:17] Matt Stashin: Right.

[19:17] Eila Mell: Um, so I do speaking, you know, like Matt said, I think to be able to have the eye to be able to do that differently for different shows. I mean, that's part of her job, but to be nominated twice just proves how effective she is at doing it.

[19:32] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. And she's great. I mean, she I know that she has conversations with the actors, as most costume designers do. But she really she wants to know what touches they want on the costumes to make them feel like they're in the skin of that person.

[19:45] Matt Stashin: Sure.

[19:46] Eila Mell: She's just a wonderful designer. So now, what do you think about the costumes that Enver for Stereophonic?

[19:53] Matt Stashin: So, you know, in a way it's an easier job, right? Because we all know what they should look like.

[19:59] Eila Mell: Right. 1970s. It's costumey.

[20:02] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. And, you know, it was done really well. The costumes totally put you there.

[20:07] Eila Mell: I would wear most of it what the women were wearing.

[20:10] Bruce Gotlieb: Would you wear it still?

[20:12] Eila Mell: I would. Absolutely.

[20:13] Bruce Gotlieb: She absolutely would. In the 70s, that's just such an iconic look.

[20:19] Eila Mell: I know, and it's so much fun. I love that 70s look.

[20:22] Bruce Gotlieb: So it had the style, right? 70s was definitely there. But each individual person also then had their own style within that.

[20:32] Matt Stashin: And it was important because a couple two of the guys in the band looked very similar to each other. And so their costumes, you know, it really helped to distinguish which one was which, especially, you know, for people sitting in the back, it may be hard to tell, you know, well, which guy is this until they start talking.

[20:48] Eila Mell: Right. Granted, but still, you know, sometimes you really need that distinction.

[20:53] Matt Stashin: I agree. And also, let's give a big nod to because there's no award for this, the hair.

[20:58] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[20:59] Matt Stashin: The wigs for Stereophonic, because they were great.

[21:02] Eila Mell: And all the shows.

[21:03] Bruce Gotlieb: They were all great. I mean, let's say we have a show that takes place in the hair salon. The hairstylist did a lot of work on that. And she's she's getting an honorary Tony this year in the KMAF.

[21:12] Matt Stashin: And the math is it was just announced, I think it was last week it came out.

[21:15] Eila Mell: Yeah, she's incredible. She's an actor also.

[21:18] Bruce Gotlieb: Which is amazing. You know, the hair and makeup departments put a lot in.

[21:23] Eila Mell: Yeah. You know, and they help again help tell the story and help do all that. But when someone's really building, maybe it's time to consider that as a category.

[21:35] Bruce Gotlieb: I think it really helps tell that story.

[21:37] Eila Mell: So I agree. I think it should be. And if it's not, if they're not ready to make it its own category yet, I think it should be built into the costume category then, in the same way that projections are not their own category yet.

[21:50] Bruce Gotlieb: I hope they will be because I think you're being used more and more.

[21:53] Eila Mell: Yes, they're being used, but now they're most of the time they're in the set design category, but also sometimes in the lighting design, I guess depends on it.

[22:00] Matt Stashin: I think it depends, yeah.

[22:02] Eila Mell: Yeah. So I you know, I'm all for hair and you know, wigs and makeup and all of that having its own category and projections having its own category.

[22:12] Bruce Gotlieb: All right. I was campaigning.

[22:14] Eila Mell: That's right. I'm campaigning with the poll that I have, which is none.

[22:18] Matt Stashin: So what do you think? Uh let's talk about Purlie Victorious, Emilio Sosa.

[22:22] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, okay, so Emilio is my dear friend. I have to say that. But that being said, his work on this show is so good. Just the dresses that Ludybell wears. They just they tell you who she is, they tell you where you are, they tell you so much, and there's so much fun to look at.

[22:42] Eila Mell: I know after when we left, you were I know I remember you commenting because we all saw it together.

[22:47] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[22:47] Eila Mell: Commenting on the jeans.

[22:49] Matt Stashin: Yes.

[22:50] Eila Mell: And you were like, wait a minute.

[22:51] Matt Stashin: Right.

[22:52] Eila Mell: Okay, so the show starts, and I don't know what time period we're in. And Leslie Odom Jr. comes out in a suit, and it's it could be period, it could be modern day. You can't really tell. And so then Heather Lecia Sims, she comes out and she's wearing an apron, and it looks like she's wearing like this full dress to me. And then she turns around and she has jeans on underneath this apron. And then I said, I know.

[23:15] Matt Stashin: I know.

[23:15] Eila Mell: Okay, now I know where I am. Now I know. Gotcha. It's not modern day, but it's not period, period.

[23:22] Bruce Gotlieb: It's not like 1800s.

[23:23] Eila Mell: No, because I didn't know.

[23:25] Eila Mell: I didn't know what the story was going to be going in. So I realized, okay, we're in like 1950s, 60s.

[23:31] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. Did you feel the same way, Matt, with the costumes for Pearly?

[23:35] Matt Stashin: I really did. They were so well done. And they really they were striking because they worked. That's one thing about the tech in Pearly Victorious was everything worked together so seamlessly. You know, the costumes, the set, the lighting, the actors, like everything created one cohesive world.

[23:54] Eila Mell: Yeah. I want to borrow those dresses that she wore. I'm gonna ask Emilia.

[23:57] Bruce Gotlieb: All right, well let me have them.

[24:01] Eila Mell: We saw him at an event this week. That would have been the time.

[24:02] Bruce Gotlieb: I well you'll have to wait till the next one then.

[24:05] Eila Mell: I'll just text him. All right, so what about David Zinn's costumes for Enemy of the People? Who wants to take that one?

[24:12] Matt Stashin: Go ahead.

[24:13] Eila Mell: Oh, you were I thought you were about to say something.

[24:16] Matt Stashin: Well, I will say full disclosure. I have not seen Enemy of the People yet. I've seen photos of it.

[24:20] Eila Mell: Well, photos tell the story. Um, you know, listen, David Zinn knows what he's doing.

[24:27] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh, for sure. He has three nominations this season alone, two in the set design category and one in costume design.

[24:34] Eila Mell: So no one is doing that this season, right?

[24:36] Matt Stashin: No.

[24:37] Bruce Gotlieb: Multiple category.

[24:38] Eila Mell: Oh, well, is Shayna Taub? How many does she have?

[24:40] Matt Stashin: She might be. Uh, two or three.

[24:43] Bruce Gotlieb: If she produced stuff, then it's three. If not, it's two.

[24:45] Matt Stashin: Okay. So maybe Shayna, but definitely David. Um, his work is always just so good.

[24:52] Eila Mell: So he just, I don't know. Like I feel like the costumes there are just traditional, but a little edgy and just, you know, not exactly what I would expect from Enemy of the People, which is exciting because I've seen Enemy of the People a zillion times, you know, different productions. So when there's something, you know, just even a little different, you're happy for it.

[25:14] Bruce Gotlieb: You know, what's funny is, you know, we talked about with Ja J, right? Like the costumes being a little bit louder, a little bit more fun and in your face. You know, with this, they're understated, but they're serious costumes.

[25:28] Eila Mell: Yeah, they're serious, they're understated, but they're still just as effective.

[25:33] Matt Stashin: Right. In order to tell the story. Sometimes the flashier show or the flashier thing isn't always—

[25:34] Bruce Gotlieb: No, you certainly couldn't have that in Enemy of the People. It doesn't call for flash, it's a play about water.

[25:46] Eila Mell: Basically, in a very general way. Based on the photos that I saw, it definitely seems like it takes these period costumes and looks at it like through a modern viewpoint. But you're still in the world of the play.

[25:59] Matt Stashin: But what I love about David is that he can do anything and everything. You know, he did costumes for Almost Famous, which were incredible. And then he did the costumes and the set for Spongebob, which were so incredible.

[26:12] Eila Mell: So he won a Tony for that.

[26:14] Matt Stashin: Right, but you're doing, you know, you again, like we were talking about with Didi, you need to have a differing eye that can do all of these things.

[26:25] Bruce Gotlieb: Right, you're not gonna be a very hireable designer if you can only do one style.

[26:29] Eila Mell: Right. All right. So who do you guys think will take the Tony?

[26:35] Matt Stashin: Who do I think? I will tell you that I think again it's going to be Stereophonic.

[26:40] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.

[26:41] Matt Stashin: I think you're probably right. I think it will be Stereophonic. I think, you know, a lot of people like the look of the show.

[26:47] Eila Mell: Sure.

[26:47] Matt Stashin: And they just like the show itself. So I think it gets rewarded just for being people's favorites.

[26:52] Bruce Gotlieb: But what do you think, Bruce?

[26:53] Bruce Gotlieb: I I can get behind that. I can get behind that.

[26:55] Matt Stashin: Well, I'm not trying to convince you.

[26:57] Bruce Gotlieb: No, you're not. I mean yet you have. I'm very, I'm very uh this category I'm I'm a little muddled with.

[27:04] Eila Mell: Okay.

[27:04] Bruce Gotlieb: Uh, because I feel like there's my want is very clear cut.

[27:08] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[27:09] Bruce Gotlieb: My who will win, I'm not as definitive.

[27:14] Eila Mell: Right.

[27:15] Bruce Gotlieb: So I I think it's gonna be Emilio, though.

[27:17] Matt Stashin: You do?

[27:18] Bruce Gotlieb: That's what I think.

[27:19] Eila Mell: Okay, so you think Emilio will win.

[27:22] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, I hope so. That's shockingly enough, that's who I want to win.

[27:26] Eila Mell: Shocking. You know, it's time. He's been nominated a couple of times before. It's time for a Tony for Emilio.

[27:33] Matt Stashin: Who's your want?

[27:34] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm sorry, Isla.

[27:37] Eila Mell: My want is Ja Ja.

[27:39] Matt Stashin: Okay.

[27:40] Bruce Gotlieb: Mine too. I mean, I you know, Dee Dee is great. She needs a Tony also. I think she really needs a Tony.

[27:44] Eila Mell: Tony's all around. You know, let's have a tie. Let's have a five-way tie. Can we do that?

[27:49] Bruce Gotlieb: I mean, we can uh I don't mind a tie. Tie is okay.

[27:52] Eila Mell: All right. Have we done this category?

[27:55] Bruce Gotlieb: I think so.

[27:55] Eila Mell: All right. I think we did it justice. All right, what's next, Bruce?

[27:58] Bruce Gotlieb: We're gonna move on to lighting design of a musical.

[28:01] Eila Mell: Okay.

[28:02] Bruce Gotlieb: So I will read the categories.

[28:04] Eila Mell: Please do.

[28:04] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, the categories. The nominees. Brandon Sterling Baker for Illinois, Isabella Byrd, Cabaret, Natasha Katz, Hell's Kitchen, Bradley King and David Bengali, Water for Elephants, Brian McDevitt and Hannah S. Kim for The Outsiders.

[28:20] Eila Mell: So I just want to point out that David Bengali is projections and Hannah S. Kim's projections.

[28:25] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay. Just so people know who did what.

[28:29] Eila Mell: That's good to know. All right. So, Matt, you don't know this, but I had a very geeky moment this week with Bruce. We went to this event that I was talking about, and I introduced him to Natasha Katz.

[28:41] Matt Stashin: And I said, Bruce, this is Natasha Katz. Like I was introducing him to Mick Jagger.

[28:45] Eila Mell: You like to me she's a rock star. She's got eight Tonies.

[28:50] Matt Stashin: She does. And she was actually telling us a story about that she was going somewhere, and the person who invited was like, Oh, you should bring a Tony.

[29:02] Eila Mell: And she actually wrote it with her.

[29:04] Matt Stashin: She has some despair. It's fine.

[29:06] Eila Mell: Well, and that's what he said, and she was like, I couldn't believe. What was I thinking?

[29:10] Matt Stashin: Well, at the time, she only had one, and she did bring it. And then, right, she said, I can't believe she yeah, she was saying, I can't believe I brought this out of the house.

[29:18] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[29:18] Eila Mell: And she said, none of them have ever left the house since then.

[29:22] Bruce Gotlieb: You said she's a rock star, but she's so humble. Like she, when you introduced, you know, she was lovely, but almost like me? Like I know.

[29:31] Eila Mell: Like little old me.

[29:32] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, not too many people think that lighting designers are rock stars, but I know how talented she is. I mean, if you lighting in a show can be so masterful.

[29:41] Eila Mell: So she told me this that Marvin Hamlisch said lighting is exciting.

[29:46] Matt Stashin: It is.

[29:46] Eila Mell: It is. It's the only way on stage that you can travel instantly, and you can change the setting. It's like what a movie does with editing. That's what lighting does for a play or musical.

[30:00] Bruce Gotlieb: So that's really important because you know there's no other way to do that on stage. Everything else is in real time.

[30:05] Eila Mell: Right. So lighting can really help you travel. So being we're talking about Natasha, why don't we dive in with Hell's Kitchen?

[30:11] Matt Stashin: Yes.

[30:12] Eila Mell: I mean, just when you see her work, it elevates any show.

[30:16] Bruce Gotlieb: Sure. And you know, with the music and with all the elements, you know, you shouldn't notice the lighting if they're doing their job right.

[30:23] Matt Stashin: 100%.

[30:24] Eila Mell: Right. But it should make the show exciting. It should make it feel whatever the mood is of the show. And in a show like Hell's Kitchen, there should be a rush. You know, you should—

[30:33] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, it's vibrant.

[30:35] Eila Mell: Exactly. It brings you to certainly the 90s, right? That's when we that's where we are. You know, so it has to have a certain feel to it.

[30:44] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah. You couldn't have the same lighting in Hell's Kitchen that you have in Stereophonic.

[30:49] Eila Mell: They're completely different.

[30:50] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. Completely different moods.

[30:52] Eila Mell: Yeah. Alicia Keys' music has such a singular feel to it. And the lighting has to reflect that.

[31:00] Matt Stashin: And it really did.

[31:01] Eila Mell: Yeah. All right. So, but there are other people in this category. Isabella Bird, who did Cabaret, is having a great season because she's already—

[31:09] Matt Stashin: I should have done my research, but you know, I didn't. Sorry, you guys.

[31:13] Eila Mell: Um, she's already won an award. It was either an Outer Critics Circle or a Drama Desk. It was an honorary award. So she is being rewarded for her work as a whole. So that is great for her.

[31:24] Matt Stashin: And the lighting in Cabaret, you know, it's gotta be again talking about moods. It's gotta be—

[31:29] Eila Mell: Yeah. You're at the Kit Kat Club.

[31:32] Matt Stashin: It's right. It's not bright, happy.

[31:34] Eila Mell: No, you're not walking into the plaza. There's a certain level of like grit and seediness that you need for that show to really operate.

[31:41] Matt Stashin: Yes.

[31:41] Eila Mell: So you need to feel that.

[31:43] Matt Stashin: A hundred percent. All right. And then there's Illinois.

[31:47] Bruce Gotlieb: That's basically a dance show.

[31:49] Eila Mell: Right.

[31:49] Bruce Gotlieb: Right. Okay. So I would think that lighting is super important because with a cast of everyone dancing, you really need to know where to look.

[31:56] Eila Mell: And lighting tells you, you know, the focus is here.

[32:00] Matt Stashin: It's so hard for the average person, which I would include myself in to really know the intricacies of lighting design.

[32:07] Eila Mell: Right.

[32:08] Matt Stashin: But I think if it just evokes a feeling in you that that's good enough to judge.

[32:13] Eila Mell: It makes sense because unless you've been there through the process, you know, or unless you have you're following along in the book, right? You don't know what's coming next.

[32:21] Bruce Gotlieb: Exactly.

[32:23] Eila Mell: So you, you know, the average person, like you said, is sitting there with a play with spoken word or with song. You know, someone singing, you can okay. I you can kind of get a vibe. Okay, this is where this is going.

[32:36] Matt Stashin: Right.

[32:36] Eila Mell: With a dance show, you know, something could happen all the way on the complete opposite side of the stage, and they have to get you to look there.

[32:44] Matt Stashin: Right.

[32:44] Eila Mell: And look there on time.

[32:46] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[32:47] Eila Mell: Right. Lighting really's gonna help get you there. And then we have The Outsiders. You know, again, clearly they have to evoke a mood, a time, a place, but there's also a fire on stage.

[32:57] Matt Stashin: There's a fire on stage, there's you know, they're using smoke, they're using fire, they're using rain, they're using I mean, there's a lot, there's a lot going on, but it's not too much.

[33:06] Eila Mell: No, it's not too much. This may be the most obvious use of lighting, yes, maybe in this category.

[33:11] Matt Stashin: So this is Brian McDevitt who is already a Tony winner.

[33:15] Eila Mell: It's really the lighting there again, really effective.

[33:18] Matt Stashin: Yes, uh, kind of like you were saying with Cabaret, it sets a mood, it's taking place in Tulsa.

[33:24] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[33:24] Matt Stashin: Dirt roads, and you know.

[33:26] Eila Mell: And are you indoors? Are you outdoors? You know, it all makes a difference.

[33:28] Matt Stashin: Right.

[33:29] Eila Mell: Because the set doesn't really change.

[33:30] Matt Stashin: No.

[33:31] Eila Mell: So you need the lighting to tell you where you are.

[33:33] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[33:34] Eila Mell: And I think they do a really decent a really good job of that.

[33:36] Matt Stashin: Yes, and the projections as well, because that's part of this.

[33:40] Eila Mell: Absolutely. Um and then there's Bradley King and David Bengali for Water for Elephants.

[33:46] Matt Stashin: So this, I mean, there is, you know, there's a circus on stage. And there are just it's such beautiful choreography that the lighting really underscores that and really makes it even more beautiful.

[33:59] Eila Mell: I mean, I just I can't stop thinking about this one moment where there's a horse who does choreography, circus choreography, and it's just absolutely gorgeous. And it's all white. And you know, if the lighting weren't right, it wouldn't look right. And it would just it would take away from this beautiful moment.

[34:19] Matt Stashin: Uh you know, all that said, who's gonna win, Matt?

[34:22] Matt Stashin: Who's going to win? I think Natasha Katz might get number nine.

[34:26] Eila Mell: That would be exciting.

[34:27] Matt Stashin: I think Hell's Kitchen's gonna take this one.

[34:29] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[34:29] Matt Stashin: So then she would tie with Jules Fisher for nine Tony Awards.

[34:33] Eila Mell: So we'll see.

[34:33] Matt Stashin: We'll see. We'll talk about it in depth another day, but she's also nominated for play.

[34:37] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[34:38] Matt Stashin: So she could win two.

[34:40] Eila Mell: She should get nine and ten. Imagine.

[34:43] Bruce Gotlieb: Who do you think?

[34:45] Matt Stashin: So I am going to say for this, I think it could be Bradley King for Water for Elephants.

[34:52] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.

[34:52] Matt Stashin: I'm gonna go out on a limb and predict that.

[34:55] Eila Mell: I am going to go with The Outsiders.

[34:58] Matt Stashin: Okay.

[34:59] Eila Mell: I think it's really effective.

[35:01] Bruce Gotlieb: And who do you want to win?

[35:02] Eila Mell: Is it still The Outsiders?

[35:04] Bruce Gotlieb: It's close.

[35:05] Eila Mell: Um, but I want I think it's close, but I'm gonna go with Natasha.

[35:10] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.

[35:10] Eila Mell: I think I'm gonna stick with Water for Elephants. I think I'm gonna root there.

[35:14] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.

[35:14] Eila Mell: I'm rooting for Hells Kitchen.

[35:16] Bruce Gotlieb: I want Natasha to win.

[35:17] Eila Mell: I mean, I want her to win too, personally.

[35:19] Bruce Gotlieb: I uh you can only you only have one want.

[35:21] Eila Mell: But I'm trying to be impartial.

[35:25] Bruce Gotlieb: Don't be swayed.

[35:26] Eila Mell: I'm trying to not let personal relationships get in the way.

[35:29] Bruce Gotlieb: It's not that we have a relationship, but you know it.

[35:32] Eila Mell: Let's take a minute to hear a word from our sponsors.

[35:39] Bruce Gotlieb: What should we close the show out with, Bruce?

[35:42] Eila Mell: I think we should close it with uh featured actress of a play.

[35:45] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.

[35:46] Eila Mell: Well, there's a lot to talk about there.

[35:48] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh, yes, there is.

[35:49] Eila Mell: All right, Bruce, why don't you read those?

[35:51] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, so featured actress of a play. We have Quincy Tyler Bernstine for Doubt, Juliana Canfield for Stereophonic, Celia Keenan-Bolger for Mother Play, Sarah Pidgeon for Stereophonic, and Kara Young for Purlie Victorious.

[36:05] Eila Mell: Okay.

[36:06] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, Matt, why don't you talk about uh Quincy Tyler Bernstine in Doubt?

[36:12] Matt Stashin: She was amazing. I mean, that is such a great role.

[36:16] Bruce Gotlieb: It is one of those parts she comes in, it is not a large part. She doesn't have a lot of stage time.

[36:21] Matt Stashin: Right. But she makes such an impact on everything that happens after it and really explains so much of what happened before it.

[36:29] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[36:30] Matt Stashin: It's such a good it won Adriane Lennox a Tony for the original Broadway cast. It's it got Viola Davis an Oscar nomination for the movie and really kind of a star at Viola.

[36:40] Bruce Gotlieb: In movies and TV at least.

[36:42] Matt Stashin: With the runny nose and everything.

[36:46] Bruce Gotlieb: No, it's it's a great role written by John Patrick Shanley, a wonderful writer. Whoever gets to play that role is always super lucky.

[36:54] Matt Stashin: And so Quincy Tyler Bernstine, she I think she's got a real shot here because I think some of the others may cancel each other out.

[37:02] Bruce Gotlieb: I'm not making a prediction, I'm just saying it could happen.

[37:05] Matt Stashin: It could be a sleeper. You don't know.

[37:07] Bruce Gotlieb: And in this season where there's so many races that are tight, you don't know what people say.

[37:12] Matt Stashin: We really don't know what's gonna happen in any category except a couple.

[37:16] Bruce Gotlieb: This is one of those categories where anybody can win.

[37:20] Eila Mell: I know.

[37:20] Bruce Gotlieb: It really is.

[37:21] Eila Mell: All right, so then we have Juliana Canfield for Stereophonic.

[37:25] Bruce Gotlieb: Now, I was not expecting this nomination.

[37:27] Matt Stashin: I wasn't either.

[37:28] Bruce Gotlieb: So good for her.

[37:29] Matt Stashin: Yeah. I think it's deserved.

[37:30] Bruce Gotlieb: I agree.

[37:31] Matt Stashin: But I just Sarah Pidgeon had been getting so much attention because she's got a much showier role.

[37:37] Bruce Gotlieb: She does.

[37:37] Matt Stashin: And she's great. I mean, let's talk about both of them here.

[37:40] Bruce Gotlieb: She's fantastic.

[37:41] Matt Stashin: Now, do we think they're canceling each other out?

[37:44] Bruce Gotlieb: Not necessarily.

[37:45] Matt Stashin: Yeah, I don't think so. I just think Sarah Pidgeon has the advantage because she has a lot more to do.

[37:53] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[37:53] Matt Stashin: To be perfectly honest, I think that Sarah Pidgeon could probably have been submitted as a lead.

[38:01] Bruce Gotlieb: Maybe.

[38:01] Matt Stashin: Yeah. For Stereophonic, and I think it would have worked because it is a much showier role.

[38:06] Bruce Gotlieb: It's a bit more integral to like the main plot of the show.

[38:11] Matt Stashin: Yeah, I would yes.

[38:12] Bruce Gotlieb: So you could have made that argument.

[38:13] Matt Stashin: They chose not to. I understand why.

[38:15] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[38:16] Matt Stashin: Um it's smart for them that they decided not to.

[38:19] Bruce Gotlieb: Juliana Canfield is wonderful.

[38:21] Matt Stashin: Yeah. She really she has some incredible scenes.

[38:24] Bruce Gotlieb: It's just not as integral to the central show.

[38:27] Matt Stashin: You know, the central relationship of the show is Sarah Pidgeon and Tom Pasinka.

[38:32] Bruce Gotlieb: I think it's great that she got nominated.

[38:33] Matt Stashin: I agree. I'm glad that she was noticed because she's great in the show.

[38:37] Bruce Gotlieb: They're both great.

[38:37] Matt Stashin: I mean, Sarah Pidgeon is wonderful too.

[38:40] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[38:40] Matt Stashin: And, you know, she she has to do a lot. You know, sometimes somebody can give a performance that's a little bit more understated, uh, maybe a little quieter.

[38:49] Bruce Gotlieb: Obviously, she caught people's eye.

[38:51] Matt Stashin: She got the nomination.

[38:52] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[38:52] Matt Stashin: It's interesting to see a quieter part versus some of the other shows that had maybe the similar, similar breadth of work that didn't get it.

[39:01] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[39:02] Matt Stashin: But not that they weren't deserving. It's just only a few slots.

[39:05] Bruce Gotlieb: You're right.

[39:06] Matt Stashin: How many, how many nominees can you have?

[39:08] Bruce Gotlieb: I know.

[39:08] Matt Stashin: But Stereophonic is really, I mean, you can tell by the amount of nominations it got.

[39:13] Bruce Gotlieb: It was beloved.

[39:14] Matt Stashin: Yeah, people are just into this show.

[39:16] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[39:16] Matt Stashin: And then I was surprised. I was watching American Horror Story, this latest one, and Juliana Canfield is in that.

[39:22] Bruce Gotlieb: She's all over for the city.

[39:23] Matt Stashin: So good for her.

[39:24] Bruce Gotlieb: She was also on Succession.

[39:25] Matt Stashin: Oh, I know. She played Jeremy Strong's assistant.

[39:27] Bruce Gotlieb: That's right.

[39:28] Matt Stashin: That's right.

[39:28] Bruce Gotlieb: All right. Well, she's doing fine then. Good for her.

[39:30] Matt Stashin: So what about Celia Keenan-Bolger in Mother Play?

[39:36] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, you guys should talk about that because I know you loved her in that.

[39:39] Eila Mell: I did. So obviously Jessica Lange is the mother, so she is the lead, but Celia Keenan-Bolger is the narrator.

[39:47] Bruce Gotlieb: She's the storyteller.

[39:49] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[39:49] Bruce Gotlieb: And she has a job of going from teenager, preteen to uh to an adult woman.

[39:56] Eila Mell: Yeah, it's a big arc.

[39:57] Bruce Gotlieb: It's a big arc.

[39:58] Eila Mell: She doesn't leave the stage at all.

[40:01] Bruce Gotlieb: Um, she enters through the audience.

[40:04] Eila Mell: So all of a sudden, you you almost feel like because when it happens, it's like the lights have just gone down.

[40:09] Bruce Gotlieb: I remember sitting there being like, who is this person working?

[40:13] Eila Mell: The show's about to start.

[40:14] Bruce Gotlieb: But it's her.

[40:15] Eila Mell: And she's coming up to the stage.

[40:17] Bruce Gotlieb: Um, so other than a few, maybe a jacket here or there, and different hair, like hair being tied, not tied, or what have you.

[40:24] Eila Mell: And she's doing all this on stage.

[40:26] Bruce Gotlieb: She's changing and changing her mind.

[40:27] Eila Mell: Not really, yeah, but it's not like a noticeable I'm now becoming this age.

[40:32] Bruce Gotlieb: It's very subtle but super effective.

[40:35] Eila Mell: All right, amazing.

[40:36] Bruce Gotlieb: And you know, you said she's phenomenal in it.

[40:38] Matt Stashin: She's incredible. I mean, I think I said it in our the first episode we did for this. All three of the actors in the show are doing some of the best work of their lives.

[40:47] Eila Mell: Like the acting in Mother Play has to be seen to be believed. They're all incredible.

[40:51] Bruce Gotlieb: All right.

[40:52] Eila Mell: Well, I mean, that's a big statement.

[40:54] Bruce Gotlieb: I mean, she's she's won a Tony before.

[40:56] Eila Mell: That's right.

[40:57] Bruce Gotlieb: Also for playing a kid.

[40:58] Eila Mell: A kid in To Kill a Mockingbird.

[40:59] Bruce Gotlieb: I mean, listen, if you have if you have a niche, listen, yeah, really.

[41:03] Eila Mell: Live there.

[41:03] Bruce Gotlieb: I know.

[41:04] Matt Stashin: No, she's great. She's a she's really a great actress.

[41:08] Bruce Gotlieb: She can do anything too.

[41:09] Matt Stashin: She's one of those types.

[41:11] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[41:12] Eila Mell: Right? She can play, you know, any kind of woman.

[41:15] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, really, really remarkable.

[41:18] Eila Mell: But, you know, Kara Young also talk about remarkable.

[41:21] Bruce Gotlieb: Kara Young.

[41:22] Eila Mell: So what is she? Three for three?

[41:24] Bruce Gotlieb: Three for three.

[41:24] Eila Mell: She's been in three Broadway shows.

[41:26] Bruce Gotlieb: And three nominations.

[41:27] Eila Mell: Three nominations.

[41:27] Bruce Gotlieb: And are they three years in a row?

[41:29] Eila Mell: She was nominated last year.

[41:31] Bruce Gotlieb: I don't remember if Clydes was the year before or the year before that.

[41:36] Eila Mell: Right.

[41:36] Bruce Gotlieb: We're not a hundred percent sure.

[41:38] Eila Mell: So she's still three for three, which is incredible.

[41:41] Bruce Gotlieb: And she's young.

[41:43] Eila Mell: And three very different characters.

[41:46] Bruce Gotlieb: And she gets better in every show she's in.

[41:49] Eila Mell: She steals every show that she's in.

[41:51] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[41:51] Matt Stashin: And I think that's something similar to Celia.

[41:54] Bruce Gotlieb: Like you could see certain similarities in them.

[41:57] Matt Stashin: Right.

[41:57] Bruce Gotlieb: Like how they how they're able to chameleon themselves.

[42:01] Matt Stashin: Yes.

[42:01] Bruce Gotlieb: How they're able to take the spotlight on the show.

[42:04] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[42:05] Bruce Gotlieb: Kara Young, she makes choices in as an actor that are so so her, right?

[42:10] Matt Stashin: Like no one else would probably make those choices.

[42:12] Bruce Gotlieb: And she makes it so interesting.

[42:14] Matt Stashin: And you it she just it's like she takes it to a zillion every time.

[42:19] Bruce Gotlieb: I saw her in a reading.

[42:21] Matt Stashin: So she has a script in her hand, and you know, she's got no scenery, and she's amazing.

[42:27] Bruce Gotlieb: Like you can't even believe the work that you're seeing in front of you, and she's just doing a reading.

[42:32] Matt Stashin: Yeah, she does some interesting things.

[42:33] Bruce Gotlieb: Like she comes in with a really an energy that is like no other.

[42:38] Matt Stashin: Yeah.

[42:38] Bruce Gotlieb: She does different things with her voice.

[42:40] Matt Stashin: She does different things, right?

[42:41] Bruce Gotlieb: You know, she just really becomes, you know, this other person.

[42:48] Matt Stashin: And in this show, it's not like she comes in like gangbusters.

[42:51] Bruce Gotlieb: She doesn't.

[42:51] Matt Stashin: She comes in in a quiet way and just dominates the show.

[42:55] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[42:56] Matt Stashin: And it's so exciting to watch.

[42:57] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, and you can be quiet and energetic.

[43:00] Matt Stashin: I don't feel like I feel like people don't take those as something you could do at the same time.

[43:04] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[43:05] Matt Stashin: But you can.

[43:06] Bruce Gotlieb: Right.

[43:06] Matt Stashin: And she truly is supporting Leslie Odom Jr.'s starring role in this show too.

[43:11] Eila Mell: All right. So do we think it's gonna be Kara Young?

[43:15] Bruce Gotlieb: Sarah Pidgeon? I mean, who's it gonna be?

[43:17] Matt Stashin: Ugh. That's me trying to figure it out because literally, I mean, no one knows.

[43:23] Bruce Gotlieb: All five of these women would be deserving.

[43:26] Matt Stashin: Yeah, right.

[43:27] Bruce Gotlieb: They there's no mistake here.

[43:28] Matt Stashin: Right.

[43:29] Bruce Gotlieb: The will win.

[43:31] Matt Stashin: Yes, who will win?

[43:32] Bruce Gotlieb: My gut says it's gonna be Sarah Pidgeon.

[43:34] Matt Stashin: Okay.

[43:35] Bruce Gotlieb: I do think she's gonna wind up the love for Stereophonic and the power of what she does on that stage.

[43:41] Matt Stashin: I think she's going to.

[43:43] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, well, I could that's very convincing.

[43:45] Matt Stashin: I could see that happening.

[43:47] Bruce Gotlieb: All right, Bruce.

[43:48] Eila Mell: I think it's gonna be Celia Keenan-Bolger.

[43:50] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.

[43:50] Eila Mell: It's just the arc and and the performance, and I just don't see how you can how you can't award that.

[43:58] Bruce Gotlieb: Okay.

[43:59] Eila Mell: And I think it's gonna be Kara Young. I think it's time.

[44:01] Bruce Gotlieb: It's her third time out.

[44:03] Eila Mell: I don't know. I just feel like this is gonna be her year.

[44:07] Bruce Gotlieb: Is that your want?

[44:07] Eila Mell: Also that is also my want.

[44:09] Bruce Gotlieb: Can I predict all of our wants are going to agree with Kara Young?

[44:12] Eila Mell: So that's your want?

[44:13] Bruce Gotlieb: That's my want as well.

[44:14] Eila Mell: Well, I don't know if Bruce is gonna.

[44:16] Bruce Gotlieb: I might want Celia Keenan-Bolger.

[44:17] Eila Mell: Yeah, that's what I thought he was saying.

[44:18] Bruce Gotlieb: I loved, you know, when we left Purlie Victorious, because we also all saw that together, and we all were agreed.

[44:25] Eila Mell: Wow, you know, Kara Young's getting a Tony.

[44:29] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[44:29] Eila Mell: Like that that was it when I left Mother Play, all of the performances.

[44:33] Bruce Gotlieb: I know I texted you after about Jessica Lange.

[44:37] Eila Mell: Right.

[44:37] Bruce Gotlieb: But I I just for me personally, she moved the the she moved me so much.

[44:44] Eila Mell: More than the other two actors in the play.

[44:46] Bruce Gotlieb: Celia Keenan-Bolger, yeah.

[44:48] Eila Mell: Okay.

[44:48] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, I just there was just something in the way she told that story.

[44:52] Eila Mell: All right.

[44:52] Bruce Gotlieb: Wow.

[44:53] Eila Mell: It's a really strong category, honestly.

[44:55] Bruce Gotlieb: It is.

[44:56] Eila Mell: That's gonna be an exciting one to watch.

[44:58] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah.

[44:58] Eila Mell: This is one of those where not only are all five of these totally deserving of winning.

[45:04] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, you could have any number of other people also in there that would have been totally deserving.

[45:09] Eila Mell: I know.

[45:09] Bruce Gotlieb: And that's that's what it I guess this season is about, right?

[45:12] Eila Mell: That there's you could swap out names and still a still leave somebody off.

[45:18] Bruce Gotlieb: Well, is there anybody's name that you want to throw out there that didn't get it?

[45:22] Eila Mell: Oh, I can think of two.

[45:22] Bruce Gotlieb: Tell me.

[45:22] Eila Mell: Natalie Gold for Appropriate.

[45:26] Bruce Gotlieb: Yes, I love her in that show.

[45:28] Eila Mell: And Jane Howdy Shell from Uncle Vanya.

[45:29] Bruce Gotlieb: Oh, okay.

[45:29] Eila Mell: Uh and Anika Noni Rose could have been also.

[45:32] Bruce Gotlieb: She was great in Uncle Vanya.

[45:34] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[45:34] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, I know you told you totally loved it.

[45:36] Eila Mell: I didn't get the chance to see it, but I know you loved it.

[45:38] Bruce Gotlieb: Yeah, Alison Pill too was really good.

[45:40] Eila Mell: I do like her.

[45:41] Bruce Gotlieb: Really, really good in Uncle Vanya.

[45:43] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[45:43] Bruce Gotlieb: So maybe those three canceled each other out because how do you choose?

[45:47] Eila Mell: That's entirely possible.

[45:48] Bruce Gotlieb: I know.

[45:49] Eila Mell: It's not an easy Tony season, right?

[45:52] Bruce Gotlieb: There's no nothing's clear cut.

[45:53] Eila Mell: We've said it a million times.

[45:55] Bruce Gotlieb: It makes it fun.

[45:56] Eila Mell: It makes it exciting.

[45:57] Bruce Gotlieb: You know, you wonder how many upsets will there be.

[46:01] Eila Mell: Right.

[46:01] Bruce Gotlieb: There could be many, many upsets.

[46:03] Eila Mell: Yeah.

[46:04] Bruce Gotlieb: Because, you know, there's really not many favorites going in.

[46:07] Eila Mell: Right.

[46:08] Bruce Gotlieb: All right. Have we done it, Bruce?

[46:09] Eila Mell: I think we have.

[46:10] Bruce Gotlieb: I think we just need a respite just to kind of compose ourselves.

[46:14] Eila Mell: I mean, I'm kind of exhausted already just from thinking about it.

[46:17] Bruce Gotlieb: Exactly.

[46:18] Eila Mell: All right. Well, we will be back next week with more categories and more arguments.

[46:24] Bruce Gotlieb: And you know, more predictions.

[46:25] Eila Mell: More predictions.

[46:27] Bruce Gotlieb: We have a lot of opinions, and we are happy to share them.

[46:30] Eila Mell: So we will see you next time on Behind the Awards.

[46:33] Bruce Gotlieb: Bye bye.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred