The story might go on and on and on but our three part interview with Tony Award winner Richard Malby, Jr. must come to an end... Read More
From the show: BEHIND THE CURTAIN: BROADWAY'S LIVING LEGENDS » Podcast
Guests
About
The story might go on and on and on but our three part interview with Tony Award winner Richard Malby, Jr. must come to an end. In our last discussion, Richard discusses how an observant stage manager got him working on Miss Saigon, why Arthur Laurents isn't the next Agatha Christie, when he knew Big: The Musical wasn't going to work, and what the secret is behind his collaboration with composer David Shire. Note: Unfortunately, this interview had some audio issues. We tried to fix it to the best of our ability. Thank you so much for your patience. Become a sponsor of Behind The Curtain and get early access to interviews, private playlists, and advance knowledge of future guests so you can ask legends the your own questions. Go to patreon.com and search Behind The Curtain: http://bit.ly/2i7nWC4
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Kevin David Thomas: Guess what?
[0:01] Robert W. Schneider: What, Rob?
[0:02] Kevin David Thomas: We now have over 50 iTunes reviews.
[0:08] Robert W. Schneider: Indeed!
[0:09] Kevin David Thomas: We are climbing those iTunes rating charts.
[0:12] Robert W. Schneider: That's amazing. How do we climb even higher?
[0:15] Kevin David Thomas: Can you take me high enough?
[0:19] Robert W. Schneider: Little Rock of Ages for you.
[0:20] Kevin David Thomas: Do you know I like that you took it up so high too? You didn't leave it.
[0:23] Robert W. Schneider: You like went right to the tenor place.
[0:25] Kevin David Thomas: I was gonna do clear.
[0:26] Robert W. Schneider: No Robert Goulet.
[0:27] Kevin David Thomas: No.
[0:28] Robert W. Schneider: Can you take me?
[0:30] Kevin David Thomas: Hey enough.
[0:32] Robert W. Schneider: Thanks for coming out tonight.
[0:37] Kevin David Thomas: Thank you.
[0:38] Robert W. Schneider: And a little Sergio Frankie.
[0:39] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, a little Sergio.
[0:40] Robert W. Schneider: It's never over.
[0:42] Kevin David Thomas: Much like the 24-hour buffet down in the lobby of the Dunes Casino.
[0:48] Robert W. Schneider: Me and Sidac.
[0:52] Kevin David Thomas: Tonight's only at Dimirage.
[0:55] Robert W. Schneider: Sorry, sorry, sorry.
[0:56] Kevin David Thomas: Well, lovely listeners, this is where you come in. This is how we're gonna climb those iTunes rating charts.
[1:01] Robert W. Schneider: That's right, lovely listeners. If you love us, would you go to iTunes?
[1:05] Kevin David Thomas: Click on the iTunes store. Search for Behind the Curtain: Broadway's Living Legends.
[1:10] Robert W. Schneider: Then click on ratings and reviews. Under the customer reviews, click write a review.
[1:15] Kevin David Thomas: Then let us know what you think from one to five stars.
[1:18] Robert W. Schneider: That's right. And you can leave comments too, like "Kevin David Thomas is a god."
[1:23] Kevin David Thomas: Or "Rob, who the hell is Herve Villachaize?"
[1:27] Robert W. Schneider: Who, who, who is Herve?
[1:33] Kevin David Thomas: I fell for a scam.
[1:34] Robert W. Schneider: You felt that wasn't even the man who's never done one musical in his entire life, and he gets mentioned more than Stephen Sondheim.
[1:40] Kevin David Thomas: But I love him from James Bond.
[1:41] Robert W. Schneider: Okay, anyway. Oh guys, help us out. Please.
[1:44] Kevin David Thomas: Thanks, everyone. Hi, and welcome to part three of our interview with the wonderful RICHARD MALTBY JR.
[1:50] Robert W. Schneider: Like we had mentioned last time, the sound is a little wonky on this one, and we tried our best to clean it up.
[1:55] Kevin David Thomas: So you're just gonna need to push in those earphones just a little bit tighter to get a good sense of what RICHARD is saying.
[2:01] Robert W. Schneider: But we're really, really proud of this one, and we were so happy that he sat down with us, and we are looking forward to having him sit down and tell us some more stories in the future.
[2:09] Kevin David Thomas: Enjoy part three of RICHARD MALTBY JR.
[2:13] RICHARD MALTBY JR: You were asking about whether it was connected to Fossey?
[2:17] Kevin David Thomas: Yes.
[2:17] RICHARD MALTBY JR: And to that extent really wasn't at all in this case. Since there was no story at all that can link to the two halves. I wrote the story. That was what Cameron and Andrew bought, really.
[2:36] Kevin David Thomas: Right, you know. Why am I doing this? Why not? Why am I putting all the words?
[2:48] RICHARD MALTBY JR: I thought you were like, oh, I'm sorry, RICHARD. You were like, why am I here? Why are we talking about this? Why am I—why do I put a—but I'm happy if it's between us or the candy and for us. I couldn't do that. It's just gonna rattle around all over the—um gosh.
[3:07] RICHARD MALTBY JR: So that, okay, so that's our—that's lovely song of dance wins Bernadette Peters her first Tony Award. And you're nominated for a Tony Award as well.
[3:14] Kevin David Thomas: I was, yes. Did after winning for Ain't Misbehavin' and then being nominated, and you're now recognized not just as a lyricist, but you're recognized as a director. I mean, obviously you're recognized as a director, but did—did I mean did doors open up? I mean, did—were you able to sort of pick projects at this point? I mean, were you—you know, I mean, um song and dance came to me.
[3:35] RICHARD MALTBY JR: That you weren't just writing on. I mean you were directing shows that perhaps you weren't.
[3:39] Kevin David Thomas: I was—I was brought over to be a lyricist, you know, for aspects of love, but—but I—you know, they also knew I was a director, so you know interesting. And that formed my—it was the first relationship I had with Cameron.
[3:59] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Yeah. Which led to others, yeah, obviously.
[4:03] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, yeah. And speaking on that, so I was curious how you got involved with Miss Saigon. I mean, obviously Cameron was the director of that—I mean it was the producer of that.
[4:03] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Well, the—the other person in the rehearsals were David Caddick at the piano, music supervisor—music supervisor—me, Bernadette, and RICHARD J. Alexander, who was the—at that time he was just a stage manager but he went on to become the kind of resident American producer for Les Mis and he directed the tour for a long time, yeah. And you know he was—the king of Cameron and the Cameron Mackintosh in the United States. And as a result, RICHARD had watched me work and watched me rewrite on the spot and the care of, you know, working out the characters and everything.
[5:15] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Les Mis had opened in London. Bla Michel and Alain Boublil had started on this other show that he didn't know anything about. They have a wonderful process, which I think is really great. Their attitude is that they don't talk to anybody else but themselves through the first draft.
[5:41] Kevin David Thomas: Wow.
[5:42] RICHARD MALTBY JR: They don't want to—they don't show it to anybody. After that, they'll open it up and be available for any opinions they get, but they wanted to have one draft that was theirs from beginning to end. And it was based on this—I'm gonna really wonderful premise. Bob Michelle had seen that famous painting—uh, photograph rather—of a mother giving her child to put on a—someone who's gonna take it on a helicopter and take the child out of Vietnam so that that child would have a better life.
[6:25] Kevin David Thomas: Right.
[6:26] RICHARD MALTBY JR: It seemed like that was just a heartbreaking moment about which you could build a—you know, a show and that connected to the plot of Madame Butterfly. And so they started to work on it. They went back to the original—the novel that it's based on by Pierre Loti, the French novel, and then the original play by David Belasco. And it is the Belasco play that is the basis of the Puccini opera, so yeah, each one of them changes the story a little bit.
[7:14] Kevin David Thomas: Right.
[7:14] RICHARD MALTBY JR: And they were gonna put it in and set it in Vietnam, which was a really smart idea. And they write in French, so when they finished the first act and showed it to Cameron, he was excited by it. He got the idea that the show needed—it shouldn't be Herbert Kretzmer who had done such a wonderful job with Les Mis—that because it was in Vietnam it needed an American writer. And at that moment, I guess RICHARD J. Alexander said, "Well, then you need RICHARD," and so that's how they came over and met me, and we had a wonderful lunch. All they wanted to know was about my sex life.
[8:07] Kevin David Thomas: They just—amazing.
[8:10] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Who are you, a classic?
[8:12] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, exactly. You know. Now tell us all that.
[8:14] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Well, 90-91 must have been a busy time for you because you were also writing Closer Than Ever.
[8:21] Kevin David Thomas: Well, no, no, we're talking about '87.
[8:24] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Oh, so you worked on Miss Saigon for a—well, Miss Saigon opened in '89 and it opened '91 here, but it opened in '89 in London, so it was '86, '87, '88, and '89 opened in September.
[8:38] Kevin David Thomas: Wow.
[8:39] RICHARD MALTBY JR: It exactly paralleled Closer Than Ever, actually. I left—which was '89. I left the Drury Lane—the biggest theater in London—and the Cherry Lane—the smallest theater in New York.
[8:53] Kevin David Thomas: That's amazing.
[8:54] RICHARD MALTBY JR: And this is a gigantic show to this four character. So—and so you've reprised the review again with Closer Than Ever. Whose idea was that?
[9:03] Kevin David Thomas: I had an assistant named Stephen Scott Smith, and he said he was looking to direct things and he asked if we could—he could take some of the other songs that existed besides the stuff that went into Starting Here, Starting Now and do a nightclub event, which he did at a place called 88. It was a really terrific supper club down the village, one of the nicer ones that had an actual stage.
[9:40] RICHARD MALTBY JR: And Stephen Holden came to it and wrote this glowing review because what we hadn't realized that we had done is we'd sort of written stage two. I mean, Starting Here, Starting Now was about young love. It would—you know, those are those young songs that we wrote when we were younger and I had—oh, along the way I had a file of just song ideas. So people would tell me things or people would tell me stories or hear things. I think that's an interesting kind of contemporary idea. And every now and then I'd take one of them out and write a little bit of it or write a section of it, and then David would write a—you know, set some of it, and slowly it evolved into a series of songs.
[10:42] RICHARD MALTBY JR: They all—we put them all into a show called Urban Blight at a review at the Manhattan Theatre Club. But they were some really interesting songs, and so Stephen took that plus some other songs that hadn't been used in the other show and then put together this review. It was just a one-hour show, and what it was about was, you know, it was love stories ten years later, twenty years later. It was about more mature.
[11:21] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[11:21] RICHARD MALTBY JR: More mature that, you know, different kinds of—you know, they were the second time around songs and, yeah, with a different kind of complexity. And Stephen Holden got that and said, you know, these are songs—shows about—the show about life lived over time, which was quite an insight.
[11:45] RICHARD MALTBY JR: I mean suddenly I realized that's exactly what we had written. Um we hadn't intended to do that, but we were by writing personal stories, it turns out they had these things in common. And uh so everybody got excited and and uh um we decided to move it. We took it to Williamstown to uh to test it, and we added another character. Uh was Lynn Winterseller was the only girl in the original and and uh um we had Sally Mays. Um we had uh I think Mark Waldrop and Brand Barrett were in it. But they're both tenors, so we didn't have a a another lower voice so uh Mark didn't stay with us but um we acquired RICHARD Muans and we had added a second act and we had wrote some new songs and and and some of things and that that all became you know closer than ever.
This was happening sort of over the time while um song and dance was happening. Uh-huh and all in there all in the eighties. Yeah. Um I can't you know I can't in any way track how any where any of these songs came from. Um you know uh David would give me melodies sometimes or I'd tape something and bring it out and think this that story could go on to this music like I had the idea for Miss Byrd and David had written this song that was he written this very elaborate vamp that was supposed to have a melody that was to go over it and I just wrote the song to the vamp. That's a vamp. And uh and that became the melody so um uh you know so so all of that was was going on um when I started working on on Miss Saigon the um um the method that they that Alain used for the writing was he would go away to a hotel someplace for two or three weeks and come back with an act but that's what he did.
Um oh I should tell you that they gave me um what we met, I don't know anything. Seemed like an interesting story, an interesting project. And then the they what what they gave me was the um the whole first act played by Claude Michel on the piano and sung by Claude Michel in French.
[14:24] RICHARD MALTBY JR: So all those recitatives are I'm thinking, what on the what is going on? Had some pretty melodies every now and then, but I'm thinking, what I didn't know. I hadn't seen Le Miz and I didn't know what they were doing with their through composed shows. Um and also at that time it's about um at about that time, um for ten years after the uh the fall of Saigon, almost every novel or movie or television show or anything about Vietnam, the Vietnam War bombed. We just didn't want to look at it. Um so the two two things happened almost simultaneously. Um oh uh I thought a story about Vietnam is going to bomb and also what the hell is this weird music with this French guy singing? Um and I couldn't make any sense out of it, so I turned it down. Oh um and um and they went off to write the second act and everything.
[15:43] RICHARD MALTBY JR: And then Platoon opened, which was, oh, I guess we can look at Vietnam. It's allowed now, yeah. And then I saw Le Miz and understood what that recitative was. I didn't understand it, you know. Um So I'm thinking about it and I thought I should. I called up Cameron and said, Are you, you know, have you found hilarious yet? And he said, No, we were waiting for you, RICHARD. Come around. I thought. No, you weren't, but it's fine. You said that. That's really great that you said that. So anyway, that's that I started working on it. Can you tell us a little bit about Mr. Macintosh's relationship with his other collaborators and what that process is like?
[16:30] RICHARD MALTBY JR: He's a great producer. He was particularly a great producer early, early on. Now that he wants to do the Cameron Macintosh productions. Well, Phantom of the Opera. Apparently, Andrew Lord Webber called up Cameron and said, Cameron, I have an idea for a musical. I think we might make a few bob. And oh did they ever? Did they ever? Oh yeah. Did they ever? Wow. So you know, he did that and then uh um in the Saigon and I'm leaving one of them out. What do I like what am I maybe out? Cats. Did he do was he uh producer of Nicholas Nickleby? I mean that wasn't a musical, but he was the artist. No, but it was because of Nicholas Nickleby that he hired uh Trevor Nunn and John Carr to tear down this right huge, you know, novel and and make a musical and of course it was the you know the beginning of of uh of everything.
[18:01] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Um as a lyricist, are you open to changes and suggestions from other parties beside besides your composer? Sure. Yeah. I mean all the time. And as a director, how do you like to receive notes and feedback on things that you've created or directed? Well, you have to you you have to be open to it and you have to listen to it. Um because what you what you don't listen to is their solutions. You know, if someone says I got bored in here or my mind wandered over in here, that's really useful.
[18:38] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Um I got bored in here, but why don't you bring back that girl in in in that scene? That's not a very useful because you maybe you'd want to bring back the girl and maybe you don't, you know. Um what Alan and I did was um uh we went off to to a hotel and um and we would um spend two weeks or so um always in rather nice places, I have to tell you. It's not so shabby. Well if you're gonna spend two three weeks in a hotel, I mean, I was it his house in Gord, which is in Provence. Oh, yes. Or his or a hotel in Brittany, you know, or someplace in the in the countryside in England.
[19:27] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Yeah. Just it was not so sh it was not too bad. Um and we would we would do like half the first act or the sec half the second act, or half the first act, or the second half of the first act, or all of the second act, those are the three parts. Uh and then we would type it up and send it off to everybody to think about, and then we'd get reactions and then we would move on to the you know. And the funny thing was that that we would do the two weeks and then literally put it aside. I mean not just do something else. You know, I I didn't even think about the show, which was completely unlike anything I'd ever done because you know you you get obsessive and the show never goes away and it's always there.
[20:13] RICHARD MALTBY JR: But that wasn't what what we did. We did that. We um uh alain club Michelle who can be um or arrogant sometimes and they they were then very you know, for not sure because they were running a riding this gigantic uh hit. But when we got in the room and started working, it was selfless. It was it was totally what's the solution? How do we make the scene work? What's gonna make what's gonna happen in it? And basically what we did was we wrote a play. They they had shaped it, they had and they'd shaped it brilliantly, but they hadn't written scenes and they hadn't written real characters.
[20:59] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Um they and uh so we took largely the score as written and and made it work for the for scenes, make it made it made into a story. Um it didn't change much. I mean we added why God why we added a few other things uh and we re rewrote uh Ellen's song in the second act about twelve times. Yep. There was a time when we were going to have a concept album, so we took and did sort of pop versions of all of the songs. They had orchestrated it, they started to record it, and Cameron thought this is cheesy.
[21:43] RICHARD MALTBY JR: And uh just eight three hundred thousand dollars worth of rubber recording. Wow, and work, yeah. That's incredible. Um that's good taste. Well it is and no, he was he he was um it was his finest hour. He he um was going to have Trevor do it. Trevor um tre chess opened in New York, you know, Trevor had taken over chess for Michael Bennett and uh Cameron sud got the idea quite vividly that that Trevor's um brilliance was in a period pieces and that he wasn't a great director of modern pieces, and so he replaced him with you know the unknown up and coming Nick Heightner, yeah, who was you know breathtaking and uh um Nick when you ask about you know, do I take things that Nick was we'd sort of say, Well, this line here, that's not as good, you know, and he would nail every single moment when I had I couldn't come up with anything better, and I just sort of thought, well, I'll get by with this.
[22:56] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Yeah. He nailed every one of them. Wow. Um he was he was absolutely um terrific. But we we we went set out to write a play and we and and that's what we did.
[23:07] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Yeah. Um, we wrote a play to pre-existing music in which all of the key sentences are going to be accented in this way.
[23:17] Kevin David Thomas: Right, right.
[23:18] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Even more of a puzzle. But it was really puzzle puzzle. It happens to be exactly what I love to do.
[23:25] Kevin David Thomas: And it sounds like it was a joyous collaboration.
[23:25] RICHARD MALTBY JR: It really was. I had the best time; it was the best creative experience. Everybody was positive; it was moving towards something all the time. Um, there was no—what derails shows is different people start getting different ideas about what the show is about or where it's going, and then it starts pulling apart.
[23:54] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[23:54] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Sometimes it can get really contentious. Oh no, you're gonna do it this way. Uh, or sometimes it isn't contentious, but it is just not a unified vision. But there was a unified vision all the way through it. Cameron got the best designers; his choices of who he picked, you know, um, was astonishing. Um, I mean he cares totally about everything, every detail of the show. Um, and has a vision for it. Plus an actual grandeur in his vision, which, you know, only the great entrepreneurs have. He and Andrew had beyond—I mean nobody had those visions.
[24:44] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[24:44] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Remember that there was no such thing as worldwide theater. There were no such things as shows that went off to be done in Germany or, you know, Vienna or Asia or Tokyo. Tokyo did things, but the worldwide phenomenon of—uh, it's so true. I know you know we do take that, and we teach a lot of international students, and no matter what country they come from, the songs that they all have in their books will be from Les Mis, Miss Saigon, Phantom. I mean they are the—that's the same language—and Cats, and now, you know, I mean as a result, you know, um, Hairspray and, you know, oh sure because they—they are now worldwide. There's now a worldwide theater, and that didn't exist. They invented it.
[25:33] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Um, they would license—in the previously local producers could come in and license a show and then do it somewhere, kind of like summer stock, you know. But they had the idea that they would supervise their production. So their production went to Toronto, their production went to Vienna, their production went to, um, Sweden and, and, um, Berlin and, you know, Stuttgart, everywhere. And then they found that people were actually building theaters for them because the shows were a phenomenon for a long time.
[26:17] Kevin David Thomas: Where sponsorship is high and money is forthcoming.
[26:21] RICHARD MALTBY JR: That's beautiful, Kevin. I really added a voice onto that one too. I really was trying to go for something there. Listeners, we love creating this podcast, but it does cost money. Please don't make me sell my Angel record.
[26:30] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my gosh, the original cast recording of Angel.
[26:35] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Like nobody has it. Nobody has it. If you like what we are doing and want to keep doing more of it, please head over to Patreon.com. That's P-A-T-R-E-O-N.com.
[26:47] Kevin David Thomas: Patreon.
[26:49] RICHARD MALTBY JR: I feel Patreon.
[26:50] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, Patreon.
[26:52] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Yeah, and once you're there, search for Behind the Curtain: Broadway's Living Legends. And of course, we don't expect to give without receiving some great rewards. Such rewards include behind-the-scenes videos, shout-outs on future episodes or episodes, depending on what part of the country you're from, because I said episodes. And early access to some of our podcasts. Hell, for the right price, Kevin and I will come to your apartment and act out all of Agnes of God.
[27:18] Kevin David Thomas: So head over, friends, to P-A-T-R-E-O-N dot com to help us out. Uh, let's talk a little bit about, uh, movie to musical adaptations, which you've done a few times. You did it with Nick and Nora, and you did it with Big. How exactly does that process—or seeing something on film before you start creating it?
[27:42] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Well, they're not absolutely comparable. Nick and Nora was a new story based on those characters, and Big was an adaptation of the movie. So then going back to the first one for Nick and Nora, though, but, uh, characters that are familiar with the audience, possibly. What do you honor? What don't you honor, and how do you make that decision?
[28:00] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Well, uh, I came into the project because, uh, Charles Strouse was doing it with, uh, and Pete Gurney was gonna write the book. Oh, interesting. Uh, and Arthur was just the director, and they were looking for a lyricist. But after about five or six meetings, it became obvious to Pete Gurney that Arthur's idea—a directorial vision of the show—involved writing it. Um, and so he surprised said, "Well, in the nicest way possible, why don't you do it? You're doing it anyway." And, uh, so suddenly I was, uh, doing the show with Arthur writing the book, which I don't know I would have said yes to it because the director was sleeping with a book writer, and, uh, and it was not the only kind of, uh, thing. There was nobody correcting anybody.
[28:56] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[28:56] RICHARD MALTBY JR: You know, the director—the book writer did not have a director saying that doesn't make sense, and, uh, and the director didn't have a writer who was, uh, who was offering a variety of, uh, ideas. So, um, the thing about Nick and Nora is these—the two characters are wonderful, charming. They—she certainly ought to sing and dance. I mean, everything about her was great. Uh, Arthur wrote some—invented a really interesting set of characters for the story. He just didn't write a story. He didn't write a—um, he thought in, in, uh, the Thin Man movies, the—the mystery, the murder mystery was, uh, small, and it is sort of not the point. However, it was there.
[29:44] Kevin David Thomas: Yes.
[29:46] RICHARD MALTBY JR: And there is, I mean, the Thin Man is an actual mystery device. Right. A fat man and a skinny man have the same skeleton, and you can't, you know, you can mislead somebody by putting fat clothes on a—on the skeleton of a thin man. Um, in the—in the book that's—that, uh, device is introduced way late in the story and resolved very shortly after. The Dash Lambert didn't care very much about it, but, but still it was there.
[30:21] Kevin David Thomas: Right.
[30:22] RICHARD MALTBY JR: It was a classic Agatha Christie, um, you know, Josephine Tey, you know, revelation at the end. Yeah, and, uh, and it didn't do that for us. Uh, and for some reason we were working away and writing songs and everything. He'd written the first act, but he hadn't written the second act. We're way into working on it. We have never read the second act. And suddenly he gives us the second act, and lo and behold, the, uh, um, Christine Baranski's—the movie star's houseboy is the—she's the person she's having an affair with, and he's the one who did it. I read it and said, "Arthur, but the Butler did it. Are you kidding me? Butler did it."
[31:18] Kevin David Thomas: Um, it was a totally unsatisfying, uh, story, and I read it and I thought, um, you know, this is gonna get laughed off the stage as soon as this revelation ended. We went in rehearsal, uh, we got through, we—you know, you run through's at the end of the rehearsal, nobody laughed at the end, you know. Um, thought maybe I was wrong or anything. We get to the first performance; turns out that he did it, and the audience fell on the floor laughing at the show.
[31:50] Kevin David Thomas: Oh!
[31:50] RICHARD MALTBY JR: And, uh, you know, yeah. And it didn't, uh, unfortunately did not have a long, uh, run. Well, it did if you count the previews. The longest—and I mean the terrible thing was that when, um, um, um, when Spider-Man was in previews forever and ever. Yeah, they kept saying it's the longest ever except for it, you know, since Nick and Nora. I'd hoped that Nick and Nora would just remain buried and, you know. But they—they just kept bringing it back, and every time there was an article on this on Spider-Man, there was a preference to Nick and Nora.
[32:26] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my goodness.
[32:26] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Yeah, we previewed for like seven weeks.
[32:28] Kevin David Thomas: Oh wow.
[32:28] RICHARD MALTBY JR: And finally, uh, finally opened, and, uh, I think closed in a week.
[32:35] Kevin David Thomas: What were you doing in those seven weeks?
[32:39] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Well, Charles and I were rewriting little pieces of the score, and, uh, Char—uh, Arthur was not rewriting any of the story.
[32:48] Kevin David Thomas: Oh wow.
[32:49] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Yeah. Jonathan Tunick said it's the most money he ever made on any show because every time we rewrote something, he'd have to reorchestrate it. Um, and then Big—so going back, so now looking at Big, which is a movie that everybody is familiar with at the time. Um, you must have been a fan of the movie, I'm assuming?
[33:07] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Well, yes. Uh, uh, uh, D—it was David's wife, Didi Conn, who was in the hospital, I think with some wine or something or other, and it was on television, and she said, "That's the one you should do." And, um, we looked at it and we, um, we gotten to know John Weidman and, and, uh, asked if he would do it. He said he would, and, um, John is really, really smart, and, um, you know, with any project, the almost the first thing you do is you talk about the liabilities. You know, how are you gonna deal with a little kid who appears at the beginning and at the end, and you know, uh, how are you gonna buy that, and, uh, and what is the—what is the musical about? What is it that, you know, um, that makes this story hold?
And, um, at the—in the—in the like in the eighties, I think there were quite a number of body-changing movies. You know, oh yes, Freaky Friday, all—there was a Lily Tomlin, um, Steve Martin movie, I think All of Me, where they shift characters a whole bunch—a whole bunch of, uh, you wake up and you're the other person. Uh, um, most of them have disappeared, um, but Big is iconic, so we were trying to figure out what it was, and what it really was, it was that it was about, um, uh, the mind, particularly when you're a child, you really want to skip over the bad parts and get to the good parts.
[35:05] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Um but it's one of the truisms that life does require that you go through all the steps to get there. And um so it was it it was tapping into some something that was basic and and sort of fundamental to human beings. Universal, you know, something very universal. We all want it want to we want to do two things. One is we we we want to get to the good part in the in the past, you know. And we want to be a we we want to be a grown-up knowing all the things that we don't know yet, you know. Um and to use your words stop time as well, you know, you know so I mean it can't it it it we followed that idea uh and it it made the story again well stop time is a perfect example of stop time which is about uh the fact that you um um you nobody warns you that you know that parents live with loss you're never gonna see that two-year-old again.
You're gonna get the three-year-old, that's gonna be one, but you're never gonna get that two-year-old again, and you're never gonna get that three-year-old again, and you're never gonna get that ten-year-old again. You just until finally they get big enough to move out, and then you're never gonna see them. I mean, it's and just at the moment that you've totally gotten to know someone someone, they change. Um they become an adolescent, they become something else. They start ang you know, getting angry at you and they you know it's uh just something that we all live with and nobody ever thinks about. And uh so once we had that, once we had a big theme, once we sort of knew why this show existed, we could go to work on it wow and it's chronicled as well in a in a book I believe uh yes I wanted to ask you about yes about the book and your thoughts on the book the book is called Making It Big Oh I didn't uh uh gosh I've forgotten the name of the woman who wrote it but um uh uh she just stayed around with us uh she came in about halfway through it so that she missed some of the early stages um uh and she chronicled the outs out of town run and the and the run in New York. Um it's it's interesting but of course not totally accurate um not because she wasn't accurate but because nobody really told her what really was going on.
[37:31] Kevin David Thomas: Sure.
[37:46] RICHARD MALTBY JR: I mean you just you know um the uh um we had raised the the the money for the show largely on the on the strength of the score and uh um and when Mike Okrant came in I mean we we had thought that we would that it that Susan Strowman was going to direct it but um but she was uh at that time coming off of uh Crazy for You and they were now a a couple and they were really working well together so they decided that they would like to take this on because they want to do something modern um and uh and Mike is is uh was a um brilliant um uh force, just the most delightful person. Um but what he had learned from Crazy for You and from Me and My Girl was uh how to do comic bits and how to do comic scenes um and how to f fiddle with the with the comedy scenes, which was fine in a show that had a set score.
You have Embraceable You, it's gonna be Embraceable You, even if you do it as a tango, it's gonna still be Embraceable You. But if you've written, as we had written, very precise character songs to set up a scene, and then you start tricking the scene, the song suddenly doesn't work anymore. And so we well, and so what happened was in song and after song after song, we ended up replacing it with something else. Um and the replacements were never quite as good as the as the original. Some of the some of the stuff was good. Um and um uh we um uh but the the show that opened in New York, I wasn't I didn't feel was you know was really um a show we wanted. And we had some the bad luck of opening the day after Rent.
[39:56] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah, oh yeah.
[39:57] RICHARD MALTBY JR: The day before Rent, actually.
[39:59] Kevin David Thomas: Yeah.
[39:59] RICHARD MALTBY JR: So uh, you know, we were like the old guard that had been replaced by the new movement. Um not that Rent, as we can tell, was a the beginning of a movement. Right. I mean, big big new shows are always considered to be the beginning of a of a new age, and they never are. Yeah, yeah. West Side Story was gonna bring years of dance musicals, never happened. Uh Rent was gonna bring uh, you know, lots of edgy modern shows. It never happened. Um you do not want to be the next show that brings in rap and put it on Broadway because it's not gonna be totally gonna be cream. There's no way uh Jefferson the musical musical. Well he was brilliant. Uh he had learned, I mean, because he was a straight play director, and he had learned from two big hit musicals that he had this gift for doing um you know these sort of period shows that had pre existing scores.
Nothing had prepared him for an original score. He didn't know how to take care of it. Right. Uh he didn't know how to to you make the scene work including the song. Right, right. And and uh uh I don't think he knew that. Um and uh so uh you know it the the we were in many cases not not really happy with the way the way the show was going. It was brilliantly produced, it was beautifully designed, it was uh you know it was lovely.
[41:31] Kevin David Thomas: In uh in the very good review from the New York Times.
[41:34] RICHARD MALTBY JR: It did yeah, but not very good from the other ones. Uh it's still performed quite frequently.
[41:39] Kevin David Thomas: Not as much as you'd think.
[41:40] RICHARD MALTBY JR: It's around schools, there's a school version of it. Yes. But the big deal is that and we're going over David and John and I on the 10th of November to see the tr out of town tryout in London. It's it's going to go it's opening in Plymouth.
[41:58] Kevin David Thomas: Oh Marvin.
[41:58] RICHARD MALTBY JR: And it goes to Dublin, and if it goes well, it'll come into the West End.
[42:02] Kevin David Thomas: Oh my goodness, that's fantastic.
[42:03] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Oh, best of luck, congratulations. Yeah, so that's really good. Uh we we had pre pre-committed um after the Broadway run to a national tour. Yeah, it was booked already. Um we decided that we wanted to uh re-look at it. And we went back and uh uh Eric Schaefer joined us as the director, and and uh we would play the songs that were had written we had written originally. He said, Well, that's better than what you have. Why don't you use that? So we progressively went back and put six or seven of the original songs back in the show.
[42:41] Kevin David Thomas: And just so I'm clear that's what was on the tour, or that's what's happening right now.
[42:46] RICHARD MALTBY JR: And that's largely what what the what the show is now.
[42:51] Kevin David Thomas: Oh, marvelous.
[42:52] RICHARD MALTBY JR: We wish you the best of luck with the book. We did it in at the York Theater, you know, in a sort of a uh one of their muffy, you know, script in hand productions. Um in which I appeared, by the way.
[43:04] Kevin David Thomas: Oh I think I remember something about this.
[43:07] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Were you the guy named the guy who was playing the part of McMillan, the toy company, uh simply failed to show up for the first performance.
[43:16] Kevin David Thomas: Oops.
[43:17] RICHARD MALTBY JR: It's 21, and the stage manager's saying, I can't find him. I can't find him. It's 2:15. He's still not there. I said, Well, to this highlight a script with you know his lines, because I could at least go out there and read them. Um, but I'm still thinking he's gonna come in, and then they sort of saw the curtain, and then suddenly the show is starting, and I suddenly I'm going out there. And um I didn't know the score. Uh I didn't so and it came back. It was amazing how it came back. Um I had seen the dress rehearsal before, so I pretty much knew what the blocking was. And uh John Tartaglia, who's just a great guy, he said, Don't worry, I'll I'll pull you wherever you have to go. Shove with love.
[44:03] Kevin David Thomas: Uh with love.
[44:04] RICHARD MALTBY JR: Shove with love, exactly what exactly what it was. And there was one moment though where I had I I f I didn't this the the coffee black number, there's a you know big long sequence that I had, and I got through it all, and I was so pleased with myself. And I turned the page and there was a page full of yellowed lines. I went uh what's that? I thought I was finished. And there's another whole scene sung. And but it just came everything came back like the the bar before I you know I had to say the line.
[44:41] Kevin David Thomas: That's amazing.
[44:42] RICHARD MALTBY JR: That's incredible. So uh a col a collaboration with Mr. Shire that's lasted since your freshman year of college. What does it take to maintain a collaboration?
[44:53] RICHARD MALTBY JR: You know, you guys are still talking about it. Someone asked me that recently, and I uh the answer that came to my mind was that the the secret is that it's never ever um his idea is better than mine, or there never is any sense of it's my idea. Right uh or it's my thought, or this is the way I should think it should go. It um if we disagree, one of us will convince the other. The other may say, Well, I don't like it, but we'll try it and we'll see. And you know, and usually I find out that the other person was right. Um, you know, um we uh are always jointly working on the solution, which is not necessarily his idea or mine, you know. Um and uh I think that you know collaborations founder is the moment one person says it has to be my way.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
