Tony, Grammy, and Emmy Award-winning actress Rachel Bay Jones joins the pod squad to discuss the unexpected path that led her to the stage—from dreaming of becoming a marine biologist to finding her voice in theater... Read More
From the show: Beltline to Broadway
Guests
Featured Shows
About
Tony, Grammy, and Emmy Award-winning actress Rachel Bay Jones joins the pod squad to discuss the unexpected path that led her to the stage—from dreaming of becoming a marine biologist to finding her voice in theater. She reflects on the evolving industry, the struggles actors face, and why she once left the business entirely. They also discuss the emotional weight of portraying complex mothers on stage, the impact of live theater on audiences, and the importance of fostering a healthier, more supportive arts community.
About the Guest
Rachel Bay Jones is best known for originating the role of ‘Heidi Hansen’ in the Original Broadway Cast of Dear Evan Hansen, and she received a Tony Award, Emmy Award, Grammy Award, Lucille Lortel Award, and a Drama League nod for her performance.
An actress acclaimed for her versatile ability to bring life to comedic, dramatic, and character roles, she has garnered praise for her performances in Diane Paulus’ Tony Award-Winning Revivals of Pippin and Hair, went on for Patti Lupone in the Original Broadway production of Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown, wowed New York audiences in the critically acclaimed productions of Michael John LaChiusa’s First Daughter Suite and Hello Again, and received rave reviews for her performance as ‘Diana’ in The Kennedy Center’s revival production of Next to Normal, directed by Michael Grief. She can be seen on television in major on CBS’ “Young Sheldon,” “The United States of Al,” ABC’s “The Good Doctor,” Amazon’s “Panic,” “Why Women Kill” on Paramount+, ABC’s “Modern Family” & CBS’ “God Friended Me.” On Film, she starred in “Ben Is Back,” opposite Julia Roberts, and in “Critical Thinking,” directed by and opposite John Leguizamo.
Love what you hear on the podcast? Join the pod squad by joining our online community! Dive deeper into the episodes, share your thoughts, ask questions, and connect with fellow listeners. Visit https://beltlinetobroadway.org/register-2/ to join our theater fam.
Connect with Beltline to Broadway
Facebook/TikTok/Instagram @beltlinetobroadway
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Lauren Van Hemert: Welcome to Beltline to Broadway!
[0:06] Lauren Van Hemert: Oh my, that was good through about tough times.
[0:10] Lauren Van Hemert: Broadway hooray!
[0:13] Lauren Van Hemert: Let's all tune in to Beltline to Broadway.
[0:18] Lauren Van Hemert: What do you say?
[0:20] Lauren Van Hemert: You could binge any day.
[0:25] Lauren Van Hemert: Listening to Beltline to Broadway.
[0:32] Lauren Van Hemert: Beltline to Broadway!
[0:35] Lauren Van Hemert: This is the Belt Line to Broadway podcast. I'm Lauren Van Hemert, your host, and on this episode, I'm chatting with Tony, Grammy, and Emmy Award winner Rachel Bay Jones. Although both her parents were actors, when she was a kid, she didn't have aspirations of being on stage. In fact, she wanted to be a marine biologist. But all that changed when she was 12. And that is where our conversation begins.
[1:06] Lauren Van Hemert: I read that your grandmother did get to see your first Broadway show when you were a teenager. What do you remember about that experience, and was that the catalyst that was like, okay, this is it?
[1:19] Rachel Bay Jones: It's funny, you're the first person that's asked me that, and I was actually 12 years old, and I wonder if it was because I think it was shortly after that that, because I had no interest in acting, my parents were actors, and I was so shy. But yeah, my nana took me to—we went to New York for a wedding, and she wanted to take me to a Broadway show. And the show that she chose was La Cage aux Folles. It was just fabulous, you know. It felt like Broadway, like kind of old and new at the time, you know, it was wonderful. And the palace was at the Palace Theater, it just felt like everything. But it's funny that you say that because I think right shortly after that, I've always wondered why I did this.
But my mother was auditioning for a play, and I was reading the script that she had there for an audition, and I was like, oh, there's a part though I could play, I could play that part. And it was for a 13-year-old girl. And I don't for the life of me, I couldn't figure out why I had said that because I was very shy. I, you know, wasn't—it wasn't like a Broadway, but I guess it was my nana who gave me that book.
[2:31] Lauren Van Hemert: That's so funny. I read that you say, you know, being on stage in the theater, this is like your meditation. This is where you focus, and this is where you're able to be still. Is that the case then? Is that what drew you once you auditioned for that play and started getting parts?
[2:50] Rachel Bay Jones: I think what drew me then was definitely, um, it was sort of me pushing myself outside of my walls, you know, and I think a lot of us use theater as kids, and you know, I don't know, but a lot of shy people become actors, and I think I suspect that that is the reason. I mean, we can't hold a conversation with people in an intimate setting, but I can stand up on stage as this other person and show you myself. I can be seen in this way, and I can allow you to look at me, and I can communicate with you in this way, right? And I still feel like it's such a powerful way of communicating with an audience because there is that felt shared experience that exists that's aside from the world of the play, the world of the actor and the audience and how we communicate with each other while all of that is going on is really what's happening when you go to the theater.
So I feel like at the time that was something that really pushed me forward, um, was getting outside of my own shyness, and now it's, um, it's definitely that communication with the audience. Everybody says it, and the ritual of theater feels like the ritual of meditation, and we're allowed to live our lives, you know, live this. We always want to go back and live something over again and get it right, you know, and in the theater when we're doing eight shows a week for however many weeks or months or years, we are able to do that. We're able to go back and really investigate a moment while we're living in it, which is something we're not really given the opportunity to do. We're not—we don't take the opportunity to do in our daily lives, right?
[4:50] Lauren Van Hemert: Yeah, yeah. It's like the great do-over. I love that.
[4:54] Rachel Bay Jones: Yeah, exactly.
[4:57] Lauren Van Hemert: I didn't realize this, but I also saw you in Meeting Me in St. Louis.
[5:03] Rachel Bay Jones: Oh my god.
[5:05] Lauren Van Hemert: But how has the theater industry changed and evolved since the 90s?
[5:12] Rachel Bay Jones: Well, I mean, it's so different, and it's different even now and since Dear Evan Hansen and since, you know, coming back after the COVID and all of that, but um, it's changed so much. Well, the shows have changed so much, you know. Um, you know, one of the most charming changes that, you know, one of the things that I used to love that we've lost, I think a little bit was in auditioning. We used to audition in the theaters. And that was so scary and wonderful. Um, but I think auditioning has always been sort of, um, you know, for a long time was part of the reason why I didn't want to be an actor, and I have left, and I did leave the business in my 20s, and that was a big reason. Um, it was terrifying.
Um, but I think what became terrifying was when it switched to being in a room, a fluorescent lit room with a table in front of you with your, you know, the judges in front of you sitting at a table and looking at you critically and sternly, rather than stepping onto a stage of some Broadway set or an—or a theater that didn't have a set on it, or into the darkness, you could stand on stage and perform. And um, that is what we do, you know, it's not necessarily the skill of being in a room, um, with—you know, for an audition is very different than standing on a stage and living something out in a theater. And that is lost, and I—I mourn that. I love that, and I also feel like if you're in the theaters, especially these old Broadway houses, um, that there's these ghosts living in the walls that just kind of lift you up.
[7:13] Lauren Van Hemert: I feel that too. I always felt like that. You feel like you're a part of something. You're part of this history of people who have been on that stage before you, who've wanted the same things that you want. And it's kind of hard to feel that when you're like, I'm at 42nd Street Studios. It was built five years ago and not, you know.
[7:34] Rachel Bay Jones: I get that. I really do. I'm glad you mentioned that you hadn't left the industry for many years because of a bad experience. There's been so much discussion during COVID and post-COVID about caring for actors, caring for actors' mental and physical health. Have things gotten better in the industry post-COVID?
[8:04] Rachel Bay Jones: You know, my—in many ways, I'm, you know, I think people are much more careful, which is great. I think it's um, I think it's great that bad characters are being, you know, people who are doing, you know, people are watching themselves a little bit more, and I think that's fabulous. You know, you're not allowed to do that. You're not allowed to just be a jerk and or worse, um, to actors. You're not allowed to abuse other people. Um, I love that that is—that is something that's not turned a blind eye to any longer. We lose so many wonderful, talented, special artists by beating them into the ground and insisting that they grow a thick skin in order to stay in the industry, right? I do think that it's important um for us to be able to withstand criticism, uh, look at criticism when it's healthy and when it's given um without abuse.
[9:10] Rachel Bay Jones: In so many of the interviews that I've done and had conversations around some of the harm caused in this industry, some of those conversations have pointed to the fact that a lot of the abuse starts in the performance arts programs, the college programs. Do you think that's true? And do we need to maybe look at the college programs and performing arts programs a little closer so we can empower actors and performers to not just develop a thick skin but also have the agency to call out when there's harm?
[9:56] Rachel Bay Jones: Absolutely. I mean, you know, you have to look at every institution that allows that to continue. It's outrageous. It's outrageous. You know, it's hard, it's funny though. It's just—it's hard to police it. I think when you mentioned agency, that's the most important thing. I think it's very important to be able to stand up for yourself and say, no, this is not acceptable to me to have the proper channels to go through to negotiate conflict, um, and call out people who are taking advantage of their positions of power.
[10:39] Rachel Bay Jones: But I don't want that, you know. But I don't, I don't, I I think it's really important to parallel with that to alongside of that. We need to create environments where there can be healthy conflict, healthy discussion, healthy, you know, um boundary setting that you know that is that is not viewed as uh a negative thing. And and I think that's it is just setting the boundaries.
[11:07] Lauren Van Hemert: That's that's great um great takeaway. You're earned a Tony Award so deservingly for your portrayal of Heidi Hansen. I I loved I told you I love this performance so much. What did Heidi teach you about being a working mom and artist and woman?
[11:31] Rachel Bay Jones: Oh god, so much. You know, we have to pull from our lives to find resonance in the characters that we play, of course. Sometimes we sometimes it happens automatically, and sometimes it happens in a way that requires you to do quite a bit of soul searching. And Heidi was definitely the ladder for me. Um, I thought was very important for this. Um the working mom child relationship, the soul, you know, breadwinner child relationship, all of those things are really important to me, but also just the idea of motherhood and forgiveness was really something that I was trying to focus on. We are so hard on ourselves. We try so hard to be perfect for our kids. Um, and the ways in which we have regret and shame for the times that we didn't do it right, or the ways in which we have failed our children because life got in the way.
Um I think I thought those things were really important to explore for myself and also for the moms in the audience, the parents in the audience and the children, so that they could look and look at their parents and say, wow, look what look what these people are going through in order to raise me and not see just an idea of mom, you know. So as I was preparing for the role, building the role, living the role, these are things that um I was, you know, they were all right there on the surface for me in my daily life as a mother, as a working mother. I had to every day leave my kid. I would, I we moved closer or years before we had moved closer to the theater district so that I could put her to bed and get on my little kick scooter and just make it to the stage door in time for my half hour call to do a show, you know.
And so I was doing, you know, not that I was reading her bedtime stories, but still I would like make her dinner and say goodnight and then leave, you know. She was um often with a babysitter or the caregiver while I was at the theater performing a woman who has to leave her kid to go to work. And the obviously that was not lost on me while I was going through it in both places.
[14:56] Lauren Van Hemert: Your your voice has so many colors and textures to it from kind of this folk sound and tone to Heidi Hansen's growl. Like there's so much of a range. And so where does your voice naturally go?
[15:18] Rachel Bay Jones: Well, it's funny. I mean, I think my voice naturally sort of sits in a folkier place because that's where I love it to sit. And I think folk music is what it is because it sounds people kind of you sing kind of like you talk, you know. And um, so of course, naturally that's where my voice falls. But you know, I grew up listening to Broadway cast albums. From my parents would play, you know, Man of La Mancha and Pirates of Penzance, and then I would go in my room and listen to heavy metal, and you know, then I and Joni Mitchell. And so I have I've always had a very wide background of musical experience. And then one of the things that I did when I left the theater in my 20s, I lived in western North Carolina and I sang bluegrass and folk music.
And so, you know, um, all of these things kind of come out as needed. I I think I'm really I love to sing just to sing, but when I'm singing for concerts and um and especially in theater, it's always in the service of telling the story as an actor. And so when you're an actor, whether you're talking, whether you're singing, sometimes a growl is necessary, and sometimes a sweet lullaby is is called for, you know. So and purity of tone is called for. So I really like using all of the colors of my voice when I perform.
[16:54] Lauren Van Hemert: Is there a vibe we can expect? I loved um you did an interview before that 54 below concert, and you said the vibe would be magical mushrooms. What would be the vibe of this theater Raleigh concert?
[17:08] Rachel Bay Jones: God, I'm trying to condense this into a vibe right now because you're fun. That's funny because I really do that every time I my you know, my my collaborator and musical director, Randy Red, I'm you know, part of the reason we love each other so much is because we just don't like to do everything the same way every time. It doesn't feel like like my show for theater Raleigh is gonna be the same one as I would do in, you know, Northern California. It's just I feel I feel different today. You guys are different, you live in a different place. Um, I don't know. I just did some Sondheim stuff, so I'm gonna throw that in this concert. We always shake it up a little bit. So I think this one might be God Lauren I'm gonna have to think about that. I'm gonna text you.
[17:53] Lauren Van Hemert: Okay I will I would love that. Is Randy coming? Is he gonna is he coming to yes Randy Red is coming in to play with me and sing with me on a few things. He's a he's a really special guy. We actually met in in Flat Rock North Carolina we did a production of the Music Man together and we were the juveniles. We were Tommy Gealis and Zanita Shin and we were too old to be playing them at the time we thought and uh we just became really great pals and and we've been collaborating ever since whenever we can so if you could go back and and give 12 year old Rachel Bay Jones going to that show auditioning for the play a piece of advice knowing what you know now what would it what would it be?
[18:47] Rachel Bay Jones: Allow yourself to be seen that the uniqueness of you is what makes a performance interesting and the things that you think are shameful or have to be changed about your personality or have to be hidden away are actually the most beautiful things about you and inform you as an actor and make and and allow the audience to feel seen as well and the more you allow yourself to be seen the audience can feel seen and that's what this is all about.
[19:24] Lauren Van Hemert: What would surprise fans the most about Rachel Bay Jones?
[19:24] Rachel Bay Jones: Oh no I don't know that I still think about quitting the business and running off to have a farm or to live by the ocean and just swim every day and be a beach bum. I don't know you know that I still no matter how much I love it it's still I still wonder what I want to be when I grow up. Rachel Bay Jones is going to be performing with Randy Red in concert at Theater Raleigh on July 7th I'll put ticket information in the episode notes she also tells me that she'll be returning to Broadway this fall in a yet to be announced show if you like what you've heard today please consider subscribing to this podcast follow us on social media on Facebook Instagram or TikTok at Beltline to Broadway or Twitter at Beltline to be way or visit us online at www.beltline to broadway dot org until next time I'll see you at the theater beltline to Broadway.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
