This episode of Beltline to Broadway features a thoughtful conversation with director and artist N.J. Agwuna, exploring her journey through Broadway, off-Broadway, and regional theater, including her work on Moulin Rouge, The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee, and the Pulitzer Prize–winning play Primary Trust... Read More
From the show: Beltline to Broadway
About
This episode of Beltline to Broadway features a thoughtful conversation with director and artist N.J. Agwuna, exploring her journey through Broadway, off-Broadway, and regional theater, including her work on Moulin Rouge, The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee, and the Pulitzer Prize–winning play Primary Trust. Agwuna reflects on lessons in leadership, collaboration, and community, particularly the importance of honoring individuality within established productions and creating welcoming spaces for artists. She discusses the inequities faced by Black women in theater, the value of mentorship and peer networks, and how community sustains artists and audiences.
NJ Agwuna is a director and theater artist whose work spans Broadway, off-Broadway, and regional stages, with a focus on collaborative storytelling, emotional clarity, and ensemble-driven work. She has served as an assistant director on productions including Moulin Rouge! The Musical on Broadway and national tour, as well as the current off-Broadway revival of The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee. Working with companies such as Third Rail Productions and Punch Drunk has given her new insight into how to affect audiences in ways that make them ask tough questions, connect with characters in new ways, and grow, shift, and change their ideas about what theatre is and their experience of it. She approaches theatre with curiosity and wonder, believing that theatre can not only heal us, but also show us all the possibilities of the world that we inhabit. She has worked on a national and international scale, continuing to explore classic texts, develop new plays, and devise and investigate new ways to explore trauma and mental illness through theatre.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:40] Lauren Van Hemert: This is the Beltline to Broadway podcast. I'm Lauren Van Hemert, your host, and on this episode, I'm chatting with NJ Agwuna. NJ has worked on Moulin Rouge and the current off-Broadway production of The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee. She tells me that the lessons learned working on those productions inform how she approaches projects like the Playmaker's Repertory Company production of Ebony Booth's Pulitzer Prize-winning play, Primary Trust. And that is where our conversation begins.
[1:21] NJ Agwuna: You've been an AD on Moulin Rouge on Broadway and the National Tour, and it was just announced that after a really amazing seven-year run, the show is gonna close in July. How has working on this show been for you and informed truly your work as an artist and director? Learning how to run a company with grace and joy and just kind of infuse that into what a show is. When I worked on Moulin Rouge, we were bringing in new performers. So I was also learning the show with them as well. So that became a little bit of a working relationship. But then watching how they got integrated into the main company was really fascinating and something that I have taken forward because it can be a bit of a—it can be hard to bring in new faces to a group that's already been working together for years and years, you know?
And Matt DiCarlo and Alex Timbers and David Rutura really showed me how to work in that way, and that's something that I like to take forward in a lot of my work, you know, and just also making sure that people feel like their ideas, their identity can be honored as we're working on existing work, you know, and they don't have to fit into who did it previously; they're bringing their own magic, and that was a really great lesson to have, you know.
[3:14] Lauren Van Hemert: You're involved in another show now, which is I think the busiest off-Broadway show, The Putnam County Spelling Bee. What do you think it is about this show, truly at this moment, that audiences are falling in love with?
[3:37] NJ Agwuna: That show has so much heart and humor and joy, and it's one of those things. Danny Mefford, our director, would say this all the time. He was like, look, you come in and you know at the end, someone has to win the spelling bee. You know what you're in for. You know, you're going on this journey, and it's like a lovely journey. There are more parts of some of these characters that you can identify with as well, even though it's such a zany, high-pressured situation, but not too high-pressured because it's a spelling bee, you know? So there are tons of laughs, there's a lot of heart. And when we started working on it, he was like, treat them like real people. The show is funny, you know. You don't have to go on and put on too much, you know, just being yourself and finding where you meet the character is like enough as well.
[4:44] NJ Agwuna: You know, I did not actually know the statistic, but I was appalled to see that since 1866, when Broadway started, only dead musicals have been directed by Black individuals. And to my count, there's only a handful of women of color directing shows on Broadway within recent years. Camille A. Brown, brilliant, Whitney White, Shell Williams. I mean, these are the names that come to mind, but unfortunately, it's a pretty short list. Talk about the challenges and inequities of being a young Black female artist, particularly in New York.
[5:32] NJ Agwuna: At this moment, it just feels like instead of trying to be pit against each other, we're trying to lean more and more into community. For me, oh, I don't know. It's one of those things that I'm lucky to be in New York where everyone is hustling together. I feel like I wouldn't have the same drive if I was in a different state or in another place. It is one of those things where you have to kind of carve out space for yourself, you know, because a lot of times you can get pigeonholed into doing just, you know, where they trust you. It's like, well, this is a Black play, so you do the Black play. Whereas I grew up doing mostly classical work. My grandfather was a professor of literature, so I did a lot of classics.
For a long time when I started working in New York, it was a lot about who you know in that sense. And I was born in Maryland and went to school in upstate New York and came to the city and was like, I know some people from Long Island, and let's see how this works out.
[6:55] NJ Agwuna: And having to work in a way that I could only do theater. Like for a while, I was like, the only way I'm gonna make it is if I do a lot of the behind-the-scenes jobs. Like when I first started working in New York, assistant directors weren't getting paid, and I mean, it's still kind of so-so now, but then I would work as a stage manager because I had those skills, and I was like, great, I will work as a stage manager so that I am being paid doing what I want to do. And then after a while, I worked at Calary Casting with James Calary, and Paul Eric Davis, who's another casting director there, was like, you have to stop stage managing if you want to be seen as a director. You will get pigeonholed into stage managing.
And I was like, that makes total sense. So then I started doing more and more readings because I was doing readings, but also stage managing to make money. And after some time of that, my mom was like, I think it's time for you to go to grad school. I was like, Yeah, sure. She's like, I think you got enough life experience; maybe it's time to apply.
[8:19] NJ Agwuna: And then that just really started catapulting and moving because then you have this space in which you are meeting more professionals, so you are meeting the people that you need to kind of know. You're also coming up with people like Columbia. There is an amazing producing class, like just a class of producers that were coming up in my cohort of theater makers, and so they're brilliant, and it's been such an honor to know them and kind of get to know them and like beyond grad school where we're still in these beautiful friendships in which we can kind of talk to each other. It is a lovely community so that is another place in where it's like, okay, I've come up with these people; they kind of know my working ethic or what my MO is, who I am as a director, but also where my interests lie, you know, in making work.
So if they hear something, they'll be like, oh, you know who you should meet? This person, you know? So that's always been really great working with the dramaturg that came up with me and the playwrights as well and developing that work so you're still constantly working on the craft and working in a way that is collaborative and conducive. So it is like this cross mentorship and allyship in that sense and also creating a director community. And Bogart said it's always good to be friends with other directors because it's such a siloed job, so it's good to have directors in your friend group that you can text and be like, I'm so sorry this is happening to me, and then everyone's like, well, let's rally, let's figure out some solutions because directors, they will be problem solvers.
They're like, okay, okay, we're all here; we've all come to the group chat or like to grab a meal with them, and they'll take care of you. Sometimes during tech, it's like, oh, you've come from tech, but we have food and a glass of wine; come sit. It's a good segue.
[10:33] NJ Agwuna: Talk about digging into this material and how you think Primary Trust speaks to the moment that we're living in. In this country, in this time, we are constantly being shocked, and you know, we think we're getting through one moment, and then something else happens that just knocks us off our feet again. And I feel like we're starting to find, and this play is like a perfect microcosm of it, community and friends to lean on to build us up, for us to all take care of each other in a way, you know, where we can be seen by our friends. We don't have to live in our imaginary mind bubbles, you know. Um, we see it in the ways that people have been showing up for people in these big times of unrest. You know, it's been a big time of showing up for people, and that's something that does tend to happen in Primary Trust. It's how we learn to self-soothe, but like also move beyond just trying to plug up our wounds by ourselves, you know.
[11:50] NJ Agwuna: It's hard not to talk about this production without talking about the design because it's stunning and wondrous. And you know, since this is a podcast and people may not see the pictures, I'll try to describe it. But upon walking into the theater, you're seeing what I can only describe as almost like a model train town that's in front of you on the stage. The amazing Lex Lean, who designed this extraordinary set and costumes, talk to me about the vision for the design and how that truly enhanced the story. In working on this, it feels like a little playground, but it is also the psychology of miniatures, you know. Um, this is a world in which he can control, it feels manageable to be able to tell this story of how he got out of this stuck place, of how he dealt with his anxiety, of how he started to grow.
Um, that he came out of his shell and he met people and he made friends, and those friends kind of played in that playground with him as well, you know. And our lighting designer Eric Norberry also added the tiny street lights that add this extra element of whimsy, you know, and those light up as well as he takes that walk through the town and reminisces and talks about when he first started to become alive to the things around him.
[13:34] NJ Agwuna: And I think there's always like a little bit of a moment for everyone where you're like, I actually haven't noticed things around me. I've been kind of walking in a haze and you know, just getting from point A to point B. And um, in that way you can see his Sam moving to Arizona as the blessing that it is because it's like I'm actually now in tune with the community around me. I just thought it was again brilliant because there are so many layers and so many entry points into it, and that's what great theater is. That's what a great play is. There is an unhurried rhythm to this play. Talk to me about the pacing of this production because I feel like you really had a handle on what Ebony Booth was going for here, and approached it in a very measured and deliberate way.
[14:42] NJ Agwuna: So one of the things that you know I've learned in the years of directing, and I learned most of this from like Anne Bogart, is like being the first audience. So like sometimes I do, I'll sit back and I'll listen to the rhythm. I'll also like be watching and I'll be like, why did that happen? And then go back and investigate why that timing took a little bit of a different turn. I'm also very in tune with anxiety and my own anxieties and those kind of self-soothing moments. So I'm like, it is gonna take whatever time it has. And um, Ebony is so brilliant that she has created this space for the actor to kind of come back to center because a lot of times when we're acting, we're asking actors to like dive into these real emotions that the body doesn't realize it's like I'm acting, I'm so sorry, I'm not really going through this emotion.
And the body is like, I think you are, I think you're anxious, and I think we gotta calm down, you know. And there's so many moments in this play where we can take a breath, you know, we can take a collective breath. Um, not just the characters, but the audience because you never know what someone is going through and how they are um relating to the work in that sense. So that was also a part of like figuring out the rhythm.
[16:14] NJ Agwuna: I did marching band in high school. So I'm always talking about muscle memory. I'm like, it's like muscle memory. We're gonna do it and do it again until it's a little bit second nature. Well, what do you hope audiences are going to get from watching this play? I truly hope that audiences leave thinking about their community and how they can like take care of each other and like who they see, you know, and who sees them, who really sees them. Um, so that they know that they're not alone, you know, that they're our friends. It’s a lovely piece. She's written a Pulitzer Prize-winning gorgeous play, and you've directed this gorgeous production, and I hope everyone gets a chance to see it. You can see the PlayMakers Repertory Company production of Primary Trust through February 15th in Chapel Hill. I'll put a link to the PlayMakers website in the episode notes.
[17:24] Lauren Van Hemert: If you like what you've heard on this episode, please consider subscribing to this podcast, follow us on social media at Beltline to Broadway, or visit us online at www.beltlinetobroadway.org. Until next time, I'll see you at the theater.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
