Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#18 - Now Batting: Ellen Adair & Scotty Katzmann

It's a Baseball meets Broadway roundtable! In this week's episode, our host Al Malafronte calls some All-Star panelists to The Batter's Box to discuss all things topical in the baseball and Broadway world... Read More

From the show: Break A Bat! where Baseball Meets Broadway

48 mins
1/31/20

Guests

About

It's a Baseball meets Broadway roundtable! In this week's episode, our host Al Malafronte calls some All-Star panelists to The Batter's Box to discuss all things topical in the baseball and Broadway world.

Co-captaining the panel alongside Malafronte is someone who's been instrumental in the baseball and theatre crossover world. With diverse experience in both acting and athletics, his knowledge and expertise on both fronts are truly invaluable. It's with great pleasure to reintroduce Scotty Katzmann to the Batheads, as our special guest in Episode 18. Scotty is one of the co-founders of our podcast, and the show’s original co-host going back to when it was recorded in Malafronte’s apartment while the two would order a pizza and watch the Yankee game during the spring and summer of 2019. Although a lot has changed with the podcast since his last BPN co-hosting appearances in Episodes 1 and 5, its spirit in which he helped create remains fully intact, and that shines through in this episode.

Also joining Malafronte and Katzmann on the panel were:

Ellen Adair: Ellen is a veteran in the acting world who has an “unhealthy obsession with baseball,” as she reveals in this episode. Her acting credits include appearances on Billions, Homeland, and The Sinner, and in recent months, she’s become a regular on many fantasy baseball podcasts, as well as a guest host on the MLB Network.

Brittany Bigelow: Brittany is the host of A Broad’s Way on the BPN which explores the unpredictability of life in the theater business and how to find your sense of self through it all. With an acting background of her own, her perspective on performance and the state of the industry is both refreshing and needed.

Among the topics discussed in this episode:

• The Houston Astros sign-stealing scandal.

• What could serve as Broadway's equivalent of a fantasy baseball league.

• The roots of one’s passion for sports and the arts.

• Baseball’s Hall of Fame voting results.

• Beetlejuice unjustly being kicked out of the Winter Garden Theatre.

• Malafronte and Katzmann calling the Commissioner of Major League Baseball to task over his agenda to boost TV ratings at the expense of the record books through juiced baseballs.

• How the politics of baseball and Broadway can impact its performers.

• Broadway’s love affair with the Yankees' All-Star and flame-throwing closer Aroldis Chapman.

• Katzmann’s love of the song 'Barbara 2.0' from Beetlejuice, and how he associates it with putting everything on the line in a big game.

Connect with Scotty Katzmann on Instagram: @ghostface_scootah

Connect with Ellen Adair on Instagram: @ellenadairig

Connect with Brittany Bigelow on Instagram: @brittanymbigelow

Connect with Break a Bat! on Instagram: @break_a_bat_podcast

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:06] Al Malafronte: Hello and welcome to the Break a Bat Podcast where baseball meets Broadway, an attempt to show that my two favorite mediums don't have to live in such separate worlds and maybe even break some stigmas. We're happy to have you with us. Now let's play ball.

[0:25] Al Malafronte: Hello and welcome to Break a Bat. I'm your host, Al Malafronte, coming at you from the Broadway Podcast Network Studios. Thought we would do something a little different for tonight's show. Uh, now that uh, you know, we're approaching Super Bowl time, we could start to fully turn our attention to baseball season. Got pitchers and catchers reporting in a couple weeks. And as many of you know, there's been a whole lot going on as we get ready for the 2020 season. And of course, on the Broadway front, we have a whole new slate of shows coming up that I'm definitely excited about. So I've decided to round up some people who I thought could give all you batheads listening at home some great perspective and insight as far as everything that's been going on. Let's do some introductions.

[1:07] Al Malafronte: Sitting right alongside me is one of the backbones of the Broadway Podcast Network and the host of It's a Broad's Way, batting leadoff, Miss Brittany Bigelow.

[1:17] Brittany Bigelow: Oh God, I'm honored. I didn't know I was getting an introduction.

[1:20] Al Malafronte: That's what we do around here as cool.

[1:22] Brittany Bigelow: Thank you. Kind of par for the course. I'm honored. I've never been up to bat, so I'll take it.

[1:28] Al Malafronte: Next, we have someone whose work I've come to know in recent years, not just through her acting career, but also through her expertise on the baseball front. So when you couple those two areas of knowledge, I thought of no one better to help me co-host this episode. Her acting resume spans nearly a decade and a half with credits including Homeland, Billions, and The Sinner. And on the baseball side of things, she's recently appeared on MLB Network as a guest contributor, as well as numerous fantasy baseball podcasts. Here she is, Miss Ellen Adair.

[1:59] Ellen Adair: Hello. Does this mean I'm in the two hole?

[2:01] Al Malafronte: Yes, that's the best position to hit.

[2:03] Ellen Adair: You're familiar with the Sabermetrics now. That's like pretty big deal.

[2:07] Al Malafronte: I feel, you know, I feel pretty confident that Brittany's gonna get on base. Maybe she'll steal a base. I don't know. She's gotta be speedy if she's the leadoff hitter.

[2:12] Ellen Adair: If she does, all you gotta do is knock a little single to right field, you get her in. Awesome.

[2:19] Al Malafronte: And I saved this intro for last because there's a large chunk of you out there in the Break a Bat community who have been with us since last spring when we launched our Chapman on Broadway Instagram and then did our first podcast. It's funny at the time. We were literally recording the show in my apartment with pizza and a Yankee game on in the background. And you know, while a lot's changed, I'd like to think that the spirit of our show has remained intact. And this dude's a huge reason for that. So our cleanup hitter tonight is actually the co-founder of Break a Bat. He appeared on our first BPN episode with Angie Schwarr. Um, and we're really happy to have him back in the studio tonight. And I know he's got a lot in his mind. So if you'll please turn your attention to home plate just beyond the marquee. Now batting, Scotty Katzmann.

[3:05] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah, that's right, Al. I'm back. And you know, I'm not very happy with what's going on in baseball and Broadway right now. So Al invited me back, and I'm gonna talk about the state of baseball in Broadway. And you know how Al does these things. He likes to like recap what's been going on, but unfortunately, what's been going on right now in my two favorite things is not very good. So don't expect much from uh from I I know you viewers who like to listen to baseball, and you like to um you you know, you like to get some sort of uh entertainment and uh maybe some inspiration from what has been happening on your favorite teams, maybe say the World Series champions, but uh no, no, that's not what there's been nothing good going on in baseball, as far as I'm concerned, and I'm gonna have to break down some of the disgusting, disgusting, humiliating uh characteristics of my favorite players that I used to love. So, no, I'm not happy, and then I'm not gonna be very happy. Okay, Al, is that okay with you?

[4:04] Al Malafronte: You think he's Al's leading had led me to believe that Scotty was like maybe the mascot of the Break a Bat podcast, and he's just come in here definitely like that gif of Mr. Met like shaking his head.

[4:14] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah, I mean, there was a time when maybe I was the mascot, but uh yeah, you know, there's an Intermet fan in it. It's gonna come out today.

[4:23] Al Malafronte: He looks like an Outer Met fan too, yeah.

[4:27] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah. Are you just holding this against Ellen because she's a Phillies fan, Scotty?

[4:31] Scotty Katzmann: No, no, no, no. See, that's actually not the case. Um, I'm unhappy with one team in particular, and it's not the Phillies, it's the Astros.

[4:41] Al Malafronte: It's the Astros, okay. Well, yes, I'm a Yankee fan, so I have more and it's the Red Sox, but that doesn't mean I'm a Yankee fan.

[4:48] Scotty Katzmann: So the Dodgers should be sadder than anybody else, Dodgers fans. Let me ask you this question. You think if the Yankees and Dodgers squared off in that World Series, CC Sabathia recently said that he felt that they would have won that World Series. Do you agree?

[5:03] Ellen Adair: I was raised in a fundamentalist hatred of the Yankees, and so I'm not sure that I can give a totally unbiased answer to that question.

[5:09] Al Malafronte: What's the reason behind that?

[5:10] Ellen Adair: Oh, just that the Yankees are the evil empire, and that they were always winning when I was growing up and they were always just buying all of the good players, and you know, now I feel frustrated that they also seem to, you know, somehow always get the upside of whatever trade in addition to buying all of the players.

[5:33] Scotty Katzmann: Well, like for example, it's crazy that they got Gleyber Torres for your man.

[5:38] Ellen Adair: Yeah.

[5:39] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah, it's nuts. Well, you know, Chapman is a star. I mean, a superstar. The fastest throwing man to ever grace baseball. So let's let's I I wouldn't say the Yankees won that trade, but uh Gleyber's okay. He's all right. I mean, they got Chapman back. So, like, they did win him.

[5:56] Ellen Adair: Yeah. Very good move. Very good move by the Yankees right there.

[6:00] Scotty Katzmann: Ah, the worst. Now the the Yankee fan ratio is not in your favor anymore, Alan. Uh, and Al, I know it's been a while since you've come to Broadway. Did you know that Aroldis Chapman is Broadway's favorite Yankee?

[6:16] Ellen Adair: I did not know that. Explain the backbone of that, Scotty.

[6:19] Scotty Katzmann: Well, I mean, we can go all the way back to the speed of fastballs, which is uh it's an original piece by Al and I that uh it replaces Chapman into the sound of music. So every single number in the sound of music is based off Chapman and his fastball. Fastballs on corners and grounders to second. Like that.

[6:36] Ellen Adair: Yeah, yep.

[6:41] Scotty Katzmann: I'm in favor. Yeah. So uh he really uh there's something very theatrical about his performance that I think sticks with a lot of Broadway fans. And you know, that and the fact that he's a Yankee here in New York. Um he's really crossed over beyond just baseball and sports in general, and now he's entered into the theatrical realm.

[7:02] Al Malafronte: Ellen, when you watched game six of the ALCS last year, I mean, you saw that little smirk on his face, and you know, knowing what we know now about the Astros. Do we think that was like, damn, they knew what was coming? What what's your take on all of that?

[7:17] Ellen Adair: Well, I think that there's no evidence that the Astros were stealing signs this past year, despite the whole sort of uh controversy, uh Twitter controversy almost created by the fake Carlos Beltran's niece account, that they were wearing buzzers underneath their jerseys. There is no evidence to substantiate that. And I would also maybe point to the fact that they didn't end up winning any of their home games in the World Series as maybe um, I don't know, corroborating factor to the fact to to the notion that they were not stealing signs this past season. So I mean, m maybe they were, but there's no evidence that they were. I think the only the only thing that we have evidence for is 2017.

[8:06] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah, I mean, it's an interesting argument if you look at their World Series. Didn't necessarily favor them at home. I mean, they obviously did worse, they lost, but you you do have a lot of evidence pointing towards what happened in 2017. And I don't think that there's I mean, it's it's completely possible that nothing changed. There was no repercussions after 2017, and it's hard to say. But what we can look at are videos where there's a loud boom coming from the dugout. Um, and it just doesn't look good. And you you combine that with the fact that Astros players now just aren't very guilty. Um, Bregman obviously brushing off any accusations just doesn't look good. Altuve's comments, I think, were even worse. Um, in my opinion, just pointing towards the next World Series isn't really a good way to hang your hold your head. Hang your hat. Hold your head.

[9:01] Ellen Adair: Well, it's not a very good way to behave. You know, he should be a little more guilty. And uh, I don't know. I'm just not very happy with the Astros. And I think it's completely possible, just based off their behavior and the way they've been answering these these what should be very serious um interviews, they're they're so like unofficial. Like there should be some sort of press conference that clearly um like I want them to be like interrogated with like a bright light in their faces, you know.

[9:31] Scotty Katzmann: I think they were, and I think that that's where the you know that's the same. I want it to be more I want it to be more like humiliating, a public yeah thing.

[9:39] Ellen Adair: Yeah. Well, that's kind of I think what's been negotiated in exchange for them telling the story of what happened is basically that they get immunity. And so that's why we've got what we've got now.

[9:49] Scotty Katzmann: This is all we get. Here's what pisses me off is that in the 2017 ALCS, you notice how the Yankees and Astros squared off. Houston won all of their games at Minute Maid Park, yet they couldn't win here on Broadway. Okay. And the games that we lost that in Houston were close games. They were decided by one run um in game one, and they were decided by one run in game two. And even in game six, it was a heavyweight uh, you know, to Houston ran away with it a little bit. When you look at the legacy of a lot of those players on the Astros, which is largely connected to that 2017 World Championship, Altuve, for example. What do you think about his Hall of Fame chances after going through this this whole scandal?

[10:31] Ellen Adair: I mean, really, even if he continues his current pace, he's a fringe Hall of Famer at best versus Bonds. Who's I mean, putting aside the fact that he did cheat, the greatest baseball player ever. So I think that there's a ridiculous, misguided viewpoint on players that cheated, where they're all kind of lumped together. Bond's just a freak athlete, so you can't really say he would have been great without steroids, but I think most people would make that argument. It's just hard to say definitively what his career numbers would have been. But I mean, look at what he did early on with his. I mean, his steals numbers were insane. He he was a 400-400 player through 98. And then I guess the steroid use allegedly started in 99. The thing I mean, he was pretty jacked in 96, too. That was his 440 year.

[11:19] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah, that's right. So I mean, he was crushing it in the look up um his was it the 96 home run derby where he was doing push-ups in between uh in between his at-bats. He was pretty jacked.

[11:33] Ellen Adair: So it's hard to say when he started. But steroids were big in the 90s, and I don't know what what these but steroids are not the only way that a guy is like big and strong and able to hit home runs, you know. I feel like there's this false equivalency that, like, oh, just because they took steroids, like if I took steroids, all of a sudden I could hit home runs. There's no way that that could happen. Like they had to be tremendously talented. And so that's what's that's what makes it sad for me is that they, you know, they'd be Hall of Famers if they hadn't ever done anything to cheat, in my opinion.

[12:04] Scotty Katzmann: The thing, the dilemma that I see here for the voters is there was a lot of talk about Derek Jeter, who was inducted almost uh unanimously. Giving him his moment in the sun. And they didn't want to associate Bonds and Clemens and all the baggage that came with them uh alongside Jeter's moment. What is going to be interesting is because they only have two years left on the ballot, is that you have Big Poppy making his debut uh in two years, which will be the last year that Bonds and Clemens are on the Yeah, he's got some steroids hanging over his head. And here's the thing big poppy's beloved by the media right now. Yeah, he needs to get a bullet. How do you check Poppy on your ballot and not Bonds and Clemens?

I mean, I I'm of the opinion that I'd let Bonds and Clemens in, you know. And I guess that's just because I don't have some sort of like keep the hall small dogma about it. I feel like if somebody was really uh influential in a good way in the game of baseball, they should be part of the Hall of Fame. But I that's that's just my opinion. Um, and I'm not necessarily angry at people voting the way that they vote. But if I had a vote, like I'd I'd vote them in. Um, I feel like to your point was really good. Maybe there should just be like one class that everybody's kind of ashamed of and just like scoot Kurt Schilling in there also and just be like, this is the class that we don't really want to talk about.

I mean, Kurt Schilling has some pretty phenomenal numbers in the postseason. And uh I loved him so much when I was a child. Do you know what I mean? I had no idea he was gonna that like I was gonna grow up and he was gonna start collecting Nazi memorabilia. I had no idea. But like, in a way, I'd let him into the Hall of Fame too. Like, you know, he was part of three World Series winning teams, and he was a big reason that the the Phillies made it to the series in '93 when I was a kid and adored him. So yeah.

[14:03] Ellen Adair: Well, to be fair, I am a big fan of players who don't really care what their public image is after they retire. And Schilling just has no filter, so we're gonna have to give him credit because he was a crazy player on the field and he's continued that kind of behavior off the field. He just didn't take no for an answer. He was vicious on the mound, and he was, I mean, he's an athlete, so he was a very aggressive player who I think could definitely be admitted into the Hall of Fame just based on his stats um and based on his postseason performance. But now there is a dogma about him that I think is gonna be very negative to these uh to these writers. Um and now there's a lot of writers publishing their ballots, that's not gonna help them at all either because now you're making a political statement every time you admit a player, and then you look at players like Mariano, who are now unanimous because no one wants to say no. I think the Hall of Fame voting has changed in the past few years.

And I think that I mean, I was surprised to see that Derek Jeter wasn't even unanimous. Um I can see somebody just being like, he's gonna get in, and so I'm gonna just vote for somebody that I th that I'm worried that they'll fall off the ballot. I could see myself doing that.

[15:09] Scotty Katzmann: Is that why JJ Putz got to vote on the ballot? Ivania's got a vote. You know what? I like seeing JJ Putz's name around. So it's not to go in, but it's you know, it's nice every there's like once a year when we get a look back on JJ Putts' career and say, yeah, he wasn't quite a Hall of Famer, but he was pretty good.

[15:28] Ellen Adair: But he was a good player. He was good, he was solid. He was, you know what? I I think most fans would not object to him going into the Hall of Fame, even though he doesn't deserve it. Ellen, I have a quick question for you. How did you become the actress who is also an expert on baseball?

[15:47] Ellen Adair: Well, I was just raised on baseball. Um, my parents are both uh academics who uh study art. My mom's an art historian, and my dad is uh uh well, he's now retired, but he's a folklore professor and he's still gallivanting around the world and interviewing artists and writing books, and uh so it's not that they were in the world of sports, but they're both baseball fans. Um, and I just grew up going to baseball games and to basketball games, and I think that for that reason, like I wasn't raised to think that there was any distinction between kinds of entertainment. So, you know, when I was three years old, my parents would take me to a Shakespeare play, and they would also take me to a baseball game.

And these are just, you know, it's both kinds of drama that we enjoy, and we enjoy as a family to to talk about and to analyze. So uh I I grew up being a baseball fan, and um I played softball a little bit when I was a kid, and it was, I mean, it's been in my adulthood, however, that I've gone into, I call it my unhealthy love of baseball. Um, and uh it sort of feels like every year in the last 10 years, I've just kind of gone deeper and deeper into the into the recesses of my baseball fandom. Um, and I think that that came almost from a place of liking to have something that uh that is a hobby that isn't me making something, it's just me enjoying something, you know.

[17:37] Ellen Adair: You know, so most of my other hobbies, I like to write, I like to draw. Um, obviously, like actors, it's almost hard to have hobbies because our professions are so all consuming and it's so easy for your every waking thought to be about that because your entertainment is also, oh, I'm gonna watch a television show and think about acting. Like I can't watch a TV show without thinking about acting. It's my favorite thing to do, watch a television show and think about acting. But like there I am thinking about acting. Yeah, it is it that probably would feel a little judgmental, I would imagine, to watch a TV show as an actor and um and watch, you know, performances by these other actors. I like to think of it as like analytical more than judgmental.

Like I'm just thinking, like, oh, like why did they make those choices? Or, you know, as a writer, also thinking like, why did they make the choice to like structure this scene after that scene? Right. So yeah, I it's hard to kind of like turn my brain off for that. Um, and I think that that's why I kind of um returned to my love of baseball. It's I guess it's more, it's a little bit more than 10 years. Um, but yeah, it's just sort of like every every year I've gone farther and farther into it. And I started playing fantasy baseball and uh well, that's a deep hole right there.

[19:00] Scotty Katzmann: It is a deep hole. And I'm like relatively new to fantasy baseball. I think uh 2015 was or maybe 2016. I can't even remember it was my first year playing fantasy baseball. Um yeah, and then all of a sudden people are asking me to be on podcasts, and that like that just feels crazy to me, but I'm happy to do it. Britt, let me ask you, could we potentially have like a fantasy Broadway league? Like, what would you do? Like if you had if if you're familiar with fantasy sports?

[19:27] Brittany Bigelow: I am, but what would you fantasize with a Broadway league? Like a Tony's thing?

[19:30] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah, it could be based on how would we do that?

[19:35] Brittany Bigelow: Oh, dude, this is gonna be. I mean, I guess you would have like certain cat you would have to first pick your categories of like how you would I don't know, judge rate. Like, how would you like score a performance? So you have like a show. You would you would draft shows. That actually makes sense.

[19:52] Scotty Katzmann: I mean, that's the Tony's.

[19:57] Brittany Bigelow: Yeah, because you need something that's like like kind of objective. My husband and I have talked about if we did like a fantasy top chef draft, because we're obsessed with top chefs. Yes, totally. And we have talked through the logistics of that, but like somebody comes out at the end of the season as the winner, and then you know, okay, whoever drafted the winner ends up winning the fantasy top chef league.

[20:23] Scotty Katzmann: Here's the thing though, think about with baseball though. The MVP is not always necessarily the best player. So just because you win the Tony Award for best actor or actress, in my opinion, doesn't necessarily mean that you had the best performance because it's very political, just like the MVP in Cy Yung race.

[20:42] Brittany Bigelow: Totally. Yeah. Yeah, I think it's harder with talent that is you could hear a voice and decide if you think it's amazing and someone else can hear the voice and say, yeah, it's not my cup of tea. It's to this, it's to that. I think in sports, like, you know, I'm gonna talk football because I don't know baseball, but like everyone does a good catch in football. Like anyone could watch like a playback and you're like, oh, that was good. Uh I think it's all much more subjective and like an art form. So maybe fantasy could be like a fun, like pick a movie and do like a fantasy draft or fantasy cast of a show. But yeah, I'd be curious. It would be it would be weird for sure, but I don't think it's impossible.

[21:25] Scotty Katzmann: No. You'd need some kind of a scoring thing though. And so maybe like winning a Tony is just some points towards your person that you drafted, but not everything. Sell out shows, like attendance. Stage door people lined up for the stage door for a certain performer.

[21:42] Brittany Bigelow: Yeah, we'll just have to send like someone with a clipboard to take notes. That's demographic too, though. That stage door is like totally demographic based. And like what how the show reaches, you know, people who will wait in the cold or the rainy. And whether or not the people in it have been on TV.

[21:57] Scotty Katzmann: Totally. Or if the show, yeah, reached the masses or teenagers, because they're mostly, you know, young people who are thrilled to be there, which is a great thing. But there are a lot of shows with old broads out there.

[22:07] Brittany Bigelow: We should have rate them the same way. And now, Britt, it's pretty cool because you have a stage background. Ellen, you have a television background. Britt, did you ever, you know, being here in New York, you have a lot of access to a lot of studios that do a lot of pilots and whatnot. Did you ever catch the TV book?

[22:24] Brittany Bigelow: I think every Broadway actor probably wants like a TV film moment. It's also a shorter amount of time, most of the time, for a larger paycheck. Um, not that it's about the money, but it's not bad. Um, so I think every, you know, I think actors like to cross that border as much as they can. It's also a totally different process. So I think as much as you can play, like in both worlds, it only enhances like what you do in your primary time anyway. Um, but I would be interested to find a Broadway actor who didn't want a quick little TV and film game. Like, find me one.

[23:04] Ellen Adair: Yeah. For me in my mind, like I just compare the two um like stage acting and screen acting to Italian and French. And maybe that's just because those are the two languages that I like. That's actually speaking. But but I feel like it kind of works. So they're related. There are cognates. If you know how to speak one, it's gonna help you speak the other one. On the other hand, if you spend all your time just speaking the one language, you're gonna go back to the other language and be like, oh wait, wait, no, what's the word for this? Like, does it relate to the word in Italian for this or not?

[23:37] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah. So it's like a weird uh kind of code code switching, I guess. Scotty, you seem pretty quiet. Is that because of that Philly sat in front of uh Ellen right now? Are you are you thinking about the Luis Rojas hiring for the Mets managerial position?

[23:56] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah, first of all, I'm a big fan of the LU extended family. So I'm happy with Rojas, but he's gonna be the type of player, the type of manager that lets the players do what they want as long as the Will Ponds don't interject. And so we're gonna have to wait and see how the Will Ponds play this because they have four more years, really five more years of controlling this team. Um, I'm counting the days, but we all are it hopefully he's the good manager that leaves the pitcher in. All I want him to do is just let the pitchers pitch. Callaway didn't do that. He went to the bullpen right away, and that was the downfall of the Mets. This year is the bullpen got overused and they got worn out. Um, so as long as you can leave the players in and let them play, we're not really gonna have a problem.

I won't have an issue with Rojas. Me and him will be on good terms. But hopefully, I mean, it's really hard to say. It's super hard to say right now. He's an insider, right? But he's a newbie to this sort of position. So I mean, I think the thing that's great about Rojas is that the position that he had this past year with the Mets was basically as a conduit. I know he had a different like quality control coach or something was his title. But like that's exactly what all teams actually want in their coach is somebody who can take analytical information and explain it to the players in a way that they can use, and that was his whole job. So I mean, yes, absolutely, we'll see. Um, but I don't know that the Mets might have ended up, you know, making a silk purse out of a South Cal Carlos Beltron.

Um certainly was like the most Mets thing of all time uh to kind of have to suffer from the whole sign stealing scandal without ever having personally benefited from a stolen sign. They leave. You know what I mean? Like the Red Sox and the Astros stole some signs and they've had a lot of fallout from it, but at least they won World Series where it's like, oh, the Mets, they just lost their manager. We're used to not winning World Series, but we're not used to having. I mean, I you know what? We are used to this. We've always been in a position where we've had to make some ridiculous last minute change going into spring training. So that's not new at all. But having Beltron in the thick of it, I mean, well, he was really patient zero for the whole thing.

Because there were all these rumors that, like, oh, the sign stealing scheme was hatched by a veteran player who had learned to steal signs on another team and was struggling in April. And it's like, who was that on the Astros? Oh, Carlos Beltron. It didn't look good. So, yeah, I mean, I I sort of feel like that's that's one of the reasons that he was the only player named in that report was because he probably they found that like he kind of instigated the whole thing. And since he's not a current player, they they were kind of like, well, even though we can't, you know, technically reprimand him by suspending him or something like that. I mean, would they put that information out there so that the Mets will do something about it?

Yep, yep. And he did end up apparently lying to B B dubs. So throw that in there. But what's what's the most ridiculous about this is that they decided that they can't recommend players. I think they should. I think something should happen to these players, and nothing's going to. It's really unfortunate. Even with the whole buzzer thing thrown in there, which I guess didn't have any, I don't know, I don't know what their word for it was, but they found no evidence of the buzzers. So they're gonna brush that aside and they're gonna stick with what they originally decided with the whole 2017 allegation, which includes keeping their title and includes keeping um Altuve's MVP. So, I mean, how do we look back on this?

I mean, are fans gonna consider this a great team? They were definitely the greatest comeback story, at least of this decade, obviously, but one of the greatest in the history of baseball to go from being so bad in 2013 to so dominant, and you take the reasons that we had been telling ourselves for the past few years, which is that they have this analytical department that's completely unparalleled. And you look at uh other instances, like for example, when the the Cardinals tried to um infiltrate the analytic program of the Astros. Like, how do you judge a team that I mean, yes, they were the victim of that, but they were such a like a feel good story that had baseball so captivated for s for years, and you you just turn it all on its head in two short months.

You know who you gotta be angry at is Manfred. Manfred was Manfred knew about this as far back as 2017 and he was trying to cover his ass. Manfred was worried about the fact that baseball was already losing television ratings. And then, of course, you know, we saw what happened with the baseball in 2019. Even 2018, there was a record number of home runs. In 2019, we shattered it and then some. Rob Manfred took the place of Bud Selig, who had his own issues. But once baseball started to lose a lot of young viewers, and you know, all of a sudden he's criticizing Mike Trout for not having his priorities in line. That didn't look good either. And now all of a sudden, you're just gonna start wheeling out these suspensions to try to cover your ass.

That pisses me off. I mean, we've been told that Manfred was very vehement in his like discussions with these teams during the whole allegation or during the whole scandal. Um, because he knew that there was something going on with sign stealing, and apparently there wasn't enough evidence to like to point to a specific player. Um, so it was hard to like really suspend someone during all this, but um, he's met with multiple teams, obviously. He's told them like the sign stealing has gotta stop, guys. Yeah, I guess he's like the guy that no one has to listen to because I mean players have been getting away with it at least for a few years. So it's like kind of like it is kind of like the ball issue, Al, because we know something is going on with the ball, and he's just gonna keep playing dumb regarding the record number of home runs.

Yeah, so I mean, ow, Manfred is just gonna keep playing dumb, I think. Because we we look at like what's happened with the ball and how he's told, you know, teams and he's told fans that nothing is nothing has changed with the ball, despite MLB buying Rawlings and sh and like changing their factory. I mean, he's done some ridiculous things. Like he's got tricks up his sleeve. So I agree that like to me, I'm I'm personally I'm more concerned about two things um than I am about sign stealing, which obviously like the notion of sign stealing without technology is an allowed part of the game. And also there's an like very long history of illegal sign stealing in baseball. Doesn't make it okay, but it's not like the 2017 Astros were the first team to ever try to do this.

That's gamesmanship. Yeah, I mean, except for that there, there's because I was I was just trying to remember the name of the of the pitcher who came out recently about the 1980 White Sox having like, you know, relaying they had a camera trained on the catcher, and there was like a light on the scoreboard that would go on to let let the players know. Um, but because it's sort of distant to us, it's just like, oh, that's funny. And and that the when the when the Giants won the the pennant in was that 1950, this sort of like 50. 51 with uh Ralph Franco, yeah. Yeah, that apparently that they're like illegal sign stealing allegations for that team. I mean, I just I have to like come out and be honest that in the 19th century, the Phillies uh uh had a couple of different sign stealing schemes, one of them like using a telegraph and the other one using like somebody stood on some kind of like contraption that buzzed.

And anyway, and like it's hilarious to us, right? Because it's the 19th century, but that that you know, teams have been trying to do this the whole time. And I feel like to me, it's very obvious that now we have the technology that we need to solve this problem with technology and just have the have the catcher and the pitcher have a way to communicate via technology so that there's nothing that like that can be spied by the naked eye. And like, oh no, that will take out the aspect of the game where a batter on second base could try to look in at the signs, but I feel like that's not that big of a deal. But to me, a bigger deal is is the baseballs. And and I was actually totally willing to believe that it was um like incompetence on the part of MLB, and they just like were like, well, I don't know.

Like, I like let's we're gonna make our own baseballs now. So like let's see what that's like. You almost want to believe that that's you almost want to believe that until the 2019 postseason when all of a sudden the balls just aren't flying out of the park like they were the whole year. And they're like, oh, they're the same baseballs. No, like clearly everybody, everybody's reacting to the to the contact off of the bat, being like, yeah, we when we hear that, we know where that's going, and then it's dying on the warning track. And so, like, that was the moment when I was like, this definitely feels nefarious to me. Yeah, yeah. And obviously, Manfred's issue with baseball's declining viewership was the lack of production out of like teams.

Well, you had that like dead ball period of 2013 and 2014. There was like 38 home runs if that. Yeah, I mean, 2012 is like the lowest year for home runs. 2012 was bad, but yeah, then 13, 3014 was like the lowest runs, runs per game stat that we've had in quite some time. Then all of a sudden spiked up a little bit in 15 and then 16, they're challenging the record for most home runs in the season with 2000, and then it just kind of snowballed to where what you had last year. And it's like you have to ask yourself, you know, is Mitch Garver really a 50 home run pace player for 2020. This guy was like a journeyman, like, you know, quadruple A catcher his entire career. I I don't know what to make of it.

Yeah, seriously. Now I you mentioned your Phillies earlier. Uh now you've got a guy who established himself on Broadway, both as I guess Britney, in the Broadway terms, someone who was a player and then manage, I guess we could say like an actor and then a director, I guess we could we could say that. Like manage. Well, he went from being a catcher to being the manager of the Yankees. Oh, yeah. Or the producer, I guess. I guess the producer. Yeah. It's kind of like a dory. Because maybe the coach would be the director. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. So Joe Girardi now is the manager of Ellen's Philadelphia Phillies. So Ellen, what do you think?

[34:48] Ellen Adair: I have no idea. That works for me. I'm really excited. He's a nice marriage of an analytical mindset and the kind of more old school baseball dude that the Phillies were clearly going to bring in.

[35:03] Scotty Katzmann: And I mean, even like Met fans, and like I wasn't really one of those people, really wanted Girardi, which is a little weird to me because I mean it would feel so weird having Girardi manage the Mets.

[35:13] Ellen Adair: But you guys had Willie Randolph, managed.

[35:15] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah, it's Randolph is cool.

[35:17] Ellen Adair: Okay.

[35:17] Scotty Katzmann: He's got the cool factory.

[35:18] Ellen Adair: I wouldn't say Girardi has that.

[35:20] Scotty Katzmann: You don't like his nicknames for players like Hicksie and Koki and Hughesy?

[35:24] Ellen Adair: They're not, it's like he gave a little bit of thought into them.

[35:27] Scotty Katzmann: Think about enough.

[35:28] Ellen Adair: Think about this. Gabe Kaplers were equally bad.

[35:30] Scotty Katzmann: What were Gabe Kaplers?

[35:32] Ellen Adair: Because I'm gonna raise you no matter what you say.

[35:41] Scotty Katzmann: Give me an example.

[35:42] Ellen Adair: Knowles for Nola.

[35:45] Scotty Katzmann: Okay.

[35:45] Ellen Adair: Andrew Andrew Jones was Jonesy.

[35:49] Scotty Katzmann: Andrew Knapp was nappy.

[35:50] Ellen Adair: Okay, so I think there's a pattern here.

[35:52] Scotty Katzmann: He was at E to the end.

[35:54] Ellen Adair: It feels like like bad writing, like when you read a script and and that the characters call each other by their names too often and have like bad nicknames for each other, that you're like, nobody would really do that in life.

[36:09] Scotty Katzmann: That's what Gabe Kepler's nicknames. The worst was Girardi with Chase Headley and Ronald Torreyes. And then, you know, he'd be reading the lineup. It would be like, we've got Headley and Torreyes at third and short. It's like, how the hell are we supposed to know who Headley and Torreyes are? And it's like, it's just easier to say Headley and Torreyes. It's like the last name is Headley. How is it one extra syllable? Is it that much harder to say? I feel like Headley, you definitely know who that is, though, right? Torreyes, like could be anybody.

[36:35] Ellen Adair: Yeah.

[36:35] Scotty Katzmann: Could be somebody named like Thomas. It could, it just, yeah. I mean, if you really think about it, if you go through the roster, you're like, oh yeah, yeah, Torreyes, okay. But it takes you a second. You know what though? Girardi had a, uh, okay time with the Yankees. I don't think Yankee fans are very fond looking back on him. Al, you could probably step in here and tell me what your thoughts are during that whole era. But, um, if it weren't for the Houston Astros, he might still be able to get the stuff.

[37:07] Al Malafronte: Yeah, he might still have the job. Although they said that they would have fired him even if they won the 2017 World Series. I don't necessarily believe that. It would have been a very tough move. My thoughts on that are, um, I don't like how he handled the media. He was like a clenched fist in every press conference. However, he did have a difficult task of managing aging stars on the way out, which I do think was a strong suit of his. He was able to stand up to Posada, stood up to A-Rod a couple times. I think that he is good with those types of players. I think with the Phillies, it's gonna be interesting because you have a lot of guys right in the middle of their peak. You don't have a ton of young players, which I do think was one of the reasons why he got fired with the Yankees was the lack of communication skills with, you know, Sanchez and Judge and some of those younger guys that they had coming up through the system. They were kind of concerned about that.

[38:03] Scotty Katzmann: I think with that demographic with the Phillies, as far as the guys that you have, Nola's been around for a little while now. Harper's a star, he's been around for a while now. I know, I guess in age, he's probably what, 27 years old? I think that he could do decently with a team like that. I am curious to see though who's gonna get through the Atlanta Braves, because that's actually my pick for the pennant this year in the National League.

[38:26] Al Malafronte: Well, yeah, I mean, after that Ozuna signing, that's really big for them.

[38:29] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah. I mean, I think that the Braves were sort of like everybody's pick for the pennant. Um, but I think that that was under the assumption that they would do something more at their third base position than they have. On the other hand, I feel like Ozuna fills the same place in their lineup, even if they are rolling out some combination of Camargo or Austin Riley.

[38:52] Ellen Adair: Do you catch a lot of Broadway when you're here in New York?

[38:55] Scotty Katzmann: Um, I definitely see some Broadway shows. I don't know what your definition of a lot is. Like, I definitely go to a lot of baseball games. I don't know that I see a lot of Broadway shows. Um, but yeah, I've, I, uh, over the last half of a year I've barely been in New York. So I think the last thing that I saw on Broadway was, um, Betrayal. But I definitely see a few shows on Broadway every year, and there are some years where like I see a bunch. Kind of depends on how much time and money I have.

[39:31] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah, I mean, so there's a lot of time that you get in New York and you have to allocate it really, however you can. Um, but there's a lot of time to do things like go to Broadway and go to baseball and, you know, do a bunch of crazy stuff that you can't really do anywhere else. But for me, there's only one show that I really want to see.

[39:56] Scotty Katzmann: Um, and it's Beetlejuice. And I've unfortunately, I've already seen it once and it's losing its time on stage to The Music Man. So I can't do that anymore. I can't go see Beetlejuice, which is pretty soul crushing. Because it's the only play I, it's the only musical I care about.

[40:12] Ellen Adair: No, for my entire life.

[40:14] Scotty Katzmann: Oh, you just want to see it consistently.

[40:15] Ellen Adair: Yeah, I love it.

[40:16] Scotty Katzmann: Over and over. Shout out to Beetlejuice.

[40:18] Ellen Adair: Yeah.

[40:19] Scotty Katzmann: I mean, I think it's great. So I had a great time with Beetlejuice. Who's to say they won't find a new home?

[40:24] Ellen Adair: I hope so. Scotty, who's your favorite of Beetlejuice?

[40:28] Scotty Katzmann: Well, it's Carrie Butler.

[40:30] Ellen Adair: Oh.

[40:30] Scotty Katzmann: I mean, yes.

[40:34] Scotty Katzmann: I mean, it's awesome. It's pretty difficult when you have a, you know, this isn't like baseball where your team is always gonna be there whether or not they suck and no one goes to the games. You get booted from Broadway. It's, it's like cutthroat, you know. So even if you do have a favorite, it won't always be there. And you really have to cherish those moments when your favorite show is playing. It just doesn't apply to, uh, to baseball.

[41:00] Ellen Adair: Me as a Mets fan, I can go any day of the week.

[41:03] Scotty Katzmann: It's not the same players though.

[41:06] Ellen Adair: That's true.

[41:06] Scotty Katzmann: You get some really random players on the Mets.

[41:10] Ellen Adair: Sometimes you do.

[41:11] Brittany Bigelow: Britt, you've seen Beetlejuice?

[41:13] Brittany Bigelow: I have.

[41:14] Brittany Bigelow: I had a blast.

[41:15] Ellen Adair: How great.

[41:16] Brittany Bigelow: I know. I had a bunch of friends tell me about it beforehand, and they were like, it's really good. And I went to go see it by myself. And I sat there, I was like, it's really good.

[41:26] Scotty Katzmann: No, it is.

[41:26] Brittany Bigelow: I was very caught off guard by it. Um, and very excited for the whole team and the cast with the resurgence of it. So you always want that for, you know, your teammates.

[41:38] Scotty Katzmann: I got you with the baseball reference.

[41:40] Brittany Bigelow: I'm catching on, folks.

[41:42] Scotty Katzmann: There we go. Wait, wait, I want to, I'm curious here, since you've both seen the show. You haven't seen it yet, Alan?

[41:45] Al Malafronte: I haven't seen it, no.

[41:46] Scotty Katzmann: You have till June. I'm curious for both of you because I do love that soundtrack.

[41:50] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah, for both of you. Give me your favorite song in Beetlejuice.

[41:54] Brittany Bigelow: Oh, I kind of go back and forth on a few.

[41:56] Scotty Katzmann: You could go first.

[41:57] Brittany Bigelow: Well, for me, it's Barbara 2.0.

[41:59] Scotty Katzmann: So did you know that song was new?

[42:02] Brittany Bigelow: Post. You have to listen to Deep Dive Broadway with our main gal Dory Berenstein, but they talk about the development of the show.

[42:09] Scotty Katzmann: You're gonna love it.

[42:10] Brittany Bigelow: Um, that's pretty cool.

[42:11] Scotty Katzmann: I go kind of back and forth between like I think that soundtrack is pretty solid.

[42:17] Brittany Bigelow: You know what's what I love.

[42:18] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah, lay it on me.

[42:19] Brittany Bigelow: Listen to me.

[42:20] Scotty Katzmann: Of course.

[42:21] Brittany Bigelow: Deo.

[42:22] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah.

[42:23] Brittany Bigelow: Oh, what a go into intermission.

[42:25] Scotty Katzmann: That's the best.

[42:26] Brittany Bigelow: It's a good finisher for act one.

[42:28] Scotty Katzmann: That is solid. One of the best parts of the film.

[42:31] Brittany Bigelow: Yeah.

[42:32] Scotty Katzmann: They do a good job on stage with it.

[42:33] Brittany Bigelow: And Jump in the Line was good too.

[42:34] Scotty Katzmann: But Barbara 2.0, though, I know is special for you though, Scott.

[42:37] Scotty Katzmann: Oh, yeah, for sure.

[42:38] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah, I think they replaced the original song or something like that with that.

[42:42] Brittany Bigelow: That's good because it brought tears to my eyes.

[42:44] Scotty Katzmann: Oh wow.

[42:46] Brittany Bigelow: Wow, I love that.

[42:47] Scotty Katzmann: Scotty's a big fan of belting.

[42:49] Brittany Bigelow: That's like I think what it is.

[42:50] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah.

[42:50] Scotty Katzmann: It's that, uh, you know, and I think there's that athletic crossover. Like there's some pun there or something, but, uh, something about putting everything like on the line, you know.

[43:01] Brittany Bigelow: It really applies.

[43:03] Scotty Katzmann: It did apply to that moment in the story, actually, come to think of it. So I see the parallel.

[43:09] Brittany Bigelow: Yeah, way to bring it all together.

[43:10] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah, nice. That's what I'm here for, really.

[43:16] Ellen Adair: So, Ellen, do you have anything exciting going on that you could tell us about?

[43:20] Ellen Adair: Well, um, I am gonna be on an episode of NCIS New Orleans.

[43:26] Scotty Katzmann: Um, Scotty went to school at Tulane.

[43:28] Ellen Adair: I did it, and see now you have your NOLA necklace.

[43:31] Scotty Katzmann: I do.

[43:31] Ellen Adair: I know it kind of is about Aranola.

[43:34] Scotty Katzmann: It's mostly about Aranola.

[43:36] Ellen Adair: Okay, but it is also about New Orleans. I really love New Orleans.

[43:40] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah.

[43:41] Ellen Adair: It's just a great place. It's, it's, I think it's the coolest city in the United States.

[43:48] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah.

[43:49] Ellen Adair: I like, I mean, I love New York. I love New York so much. It is my home. But New Orleans is really cool.

[43:56] Scotty Katzmann: New Orleans is so cool.

[43:58] Ellen Adair: Uh, well, you should definitely catch a New Orleans Baby Cakes game.

[44:01] Scotty Katzmann: That's the minor league team.

[44:03] Ellen Adair: Very much. Unfortunately, the only times that I've been to, uh, I did in fact know that, um, because I have an unhealthy love of baseball.

[44:12] Scotty Katzmann: That's right.

[44:13] Ellen Adair: But, uh, the only times that I've been to New Orleans have been, uh, in the fall after the baseball season, sadly.

[44:21] Scotty Katzmann: Um, I would love to. I would love to go back.

[44:25] Ellen Adair: Oh, wait, Beetlejuice reference. So think about this. If you ever want to go back, Scotty could be your guide. He'll be your G-U-I-D-E to the, to New Orleans.

[44:36] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah.

[44:39] Ellen Adair: Oh my god.

[44:40] Scotty Katzmann: That's awesome.

[44:41] Ellen Adair: Right?

[44:42] Scotty Katzmann: That's good. You gotta see Beetlejuice to understand.

[44:44] Ellen Adair: Did I just break my microphone with that big chuckle?

[44:47] Scotty Katzmann: Oh, you're good.

[44:47] Ellen Adair: I'm good.

[44:48] Scotty Katzmann: We've got a safety net here.

[44:49] Ellen Adair: You're good.

[44:50] Scotty Katzmann: Amazing.

[44:51] Ellen Adair: Oh, that is awesome. So you're gonna be in NCIS and, uh, that'll be, uh, the February 23rd, I believe.

[44:58] Ellen Adair: Yes. I gotta find out who, but I knew there are a lot of people that were in my film program at Tulane who actually work on the show.

[45:05] Scotty Katzmann: Oh, so it was the nicest crew.

[45:08] Ellen Adair: Yeah.

[45:09] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah, yeah.

[45:10] Ellen Adair: Yeah, they're great people.

[45:12] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah, yeah, so good. And do you have a little passion project, I understand, in the works?

[45:15] Ellen Adair: Yes, that's right. Um, I'm also, uh, working on a, uh, television show.

[45:22] Ellen Adair: Well, I'm writing a television show with my friend Chris Garfizzi from Billions about sports writers, about baseball writers.

[45:30] Scotty Katzmann: Let's be real. Do you personally know a lot of sports writers?

[45:33] Ellen Adair: I think I am personally friends, like good friends with maybe one.

[45:38] Scotty Katzmann: Uh, do they know Marlon Abreu?

[45:40] Ellen Adair: Anytime you're on the beat in the MLB, it's a very difficult job. But here in New York, there are a lot of beat writers that have to.

[45:49] Scotty Katzmann: Marlon Abreu is kind of like the glue that holds it together.

[45:52] Ellen Adair: He, for a lot of the Yankees, he's the Spanish interpreter.

[45:54] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah, that's right.

[45:55] Ellen Adair: I mean, we all know Marlon Abreu. I mean, he, the interpreter of the Yankees is a pretty big deal. I'm sure that some of them do know Marlon.

[46:03] Scotty Katzmann: We're huge fans of him, by the way.

[46:05] Ellen Adair: So yeah.

[46:07] Scotty Katzmann: Is he your celebrity crush?

[46:09] Ellen Adair: I mean, Chapman is my celebrity crush.

[46:11] Scotty Katzmann: Yeah.

[46:12] Scotty Katzmann: Scott Franski is my celebrity crush.

[46:14] Ellen Adair: He's the, uh, Phillies radio play-by-play guy.

[46:20] Scotty Katzmann: I love him. You know, I do wish a lot of luck to your Phillies this year.

[46:24] Ellen Adair: Thank you.

[46:25] Scotty Katzmann: I think they might need it.

[46:27] Al Malafronte: And Ellen, where can everyone find you on social media?

[46:30] Ellen Adair: Uh, you can find me at Ellen underscore Adair on Twitter or Ellen Adair G. That's just the letter G on Instagram.

[46:40] Al Malafronte: And Brittany, where can everyone find you?

[46:42] Brittany Bigelow: And it's a Broadsway. Thanks. You can find me at Brittany M. Bigelow and also it's a Broadsway on Instagram.

[46:50] Al Malafronte: And Scotty, where can everyone find you?

[46:53] Scotty Katzmann: My Instagram is GhostfaceScooter with an underscore in the middle.

[46:58] Al Malafronte: This was really fun.

[46:59] Scotty Katzmann: Well, thank you for being so gracious, even though I told you that I had to fundamentalist hatred of your team.

[47:05] Al Malafronte: That'll close out the ball game. This is Al Malafronte signing off for Break A Bat. We'll see you next time.

[47:13] Al Malafronte: Thanks for listening to Break A Bat. This is produced by the fine folks at the Broadway Podcast Network. Visit and subscribe at BPN.fm slash break a bat. You can find me online at break underscore A underscore bat underscore podcasts, and you can also find the Broadway Podcast Network on Instagram at Broadway Podcast Network. It's been so great having you here with us today, and we'll see you next time.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred