Skip to main content
BPN Logo
S4 EP4 Opening Doors to Open Calls with Jason Styres - Part 2

We have casting director, Jason Styres, back for part two- giving insight into the casting process. Jason discusses casting from open calls- What makes someone stand out in auditions? How to work on the material for auditions... Read More

From the show: Breaking Broadway with Kerry Butler

27 mins
2/20/24

Featured Shows

About

We have casting director, Jason Styres, back for part two- giving insight into the casting process. Jason discusses casting from open calls- What makes someone stand out in auditions? How to work on the material for auditions. Then we have Margot Plum on to chat about side hustles.

Jason is an award-winning casting director whose work is currently globally represented, covering every facet of the industry: theatre, film, television, commercials, live events, dance, company consultation, and more. He is the founder and creative director of the Casting Collaborative, as well as the founder of the Caucus for Independent Casting.

He has cast projects such as the Tony Award Winning Best Musical A Gentleman’s Guide to Love & Murder (Broadway, 1st National Tour, and 2nd National Tour), the hit Off-Broadway comedy Puffs, The Lion King (Broadway & National Tour), and over 15 different productions for the prestigious New York City Center Encores! series., from Merrily We Roll Along (starring Lin Manuel Miranda, 2012) to Cabin in the Sky (his first foray into stage collaboration with Camille A. Brown, 2016).

You can find me on Instagram @kerrybutler1 and TikTok @kerrybutlernyc. For coaching and teaching, visit my website at kerrybutlercoach.com, follow @kerrybutlercoach on Instagram, or email me at kerrybutlercoach@gmail.com.

Follow Jason Styres:

Instagram: @castingbyjasonstyres and @thecastingcollab

www.thecastingcollab.com

Follow Margot Plum:

Instagram: @margyplum and @plumtreeprojects

Follow The Hustle:

Instagram: @thehustle_nyc

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:04] Kerry Butler: Once I played a penny who just couldn't stop the beat. Yes, with all their skates on her feet. Although it's recently to see a real comical version of Tina. Now come with me, Emma. I am your host, Miss Kerry Butler. Together, you and I are breaking run away.

[0:54] Kerry Butler: We're back for part two with casting director Jason Styres. If you haven't listened to part one, go back and listen to that one first. He gives some great advice. Is there like um another way for people to break into the business like that's not traditional? Have you ever cast someone, you know, that you met or you saw someplace else, and or you like, oh, I need to call them in?

[1:22] Jason Styres: Actually, yeah, I mean, I affectionately say I like the weirdos. I love weirdos. I like straight, like I like people that are just not the traditional, you know, cookie cutter path, especially in musical theater, because it so often can be that. Um, but there's a woman that I fell in love with, she was performing down in the subway. Ashwa. Her name is Ashwa. She's absolutely amazing, and I think she's actually ended up doing some really cool things too, but like I just remember like she's a contralto. Um, and I was just like, oh my gosh, I don't know what I'm gonna do with you. I have no clue because I was like, I was racking my brain. I was like, where does where can I find space? And I was just like, we had some kind of like off-kilter projects that we're working that needed kind of general performers that you know and like kind of specialty acts.

And I was just like, okay, maybe there. So, like, got to know her a little bit better through those processes. And then we were doing a production of of uh Little Mermaid regionally, and I was like, Oh my god, I would die to see your version of like poor unfortunate souls. And then it was absolutely stunning. She didn't book it, you know. Like she booked, I don't think I've ever she's ever been officially cast, but to this day, I can I can she's automatically in the lists of like, is there a space for her? Is there a space for her in the case? It's gonna happen. It's gonna happen.

[2:43] Kerry Butler: Yeah, and that is so cool that you found her in the subway station.

[2:48] Jason Styres: She's and she's absolutely amazing. She's been doing other things ever since, you know. And I and that's the thing, is like I don't even know if they remember like if she remembers in the sense of like in these moments like that where like people remember like, oh, that's where it started, because you know, people are just you know hustling, you know, everyone's like just doing what they need to do and grind, like getting out there and grinding to get something going. And you just at that point, you're just like saying yes to whatever opportunities that may come up. Um, but I just I always loved being in that moment of being like that's that's something that's something special and unique, and I've never experienced anybody anybody like that in our world in musical theater. So, like, is there is there a way that I can get that into our world?

[3:34] Kerry Butler: I love that. Um, how much negotiation goes on? Like, say there are two people who, you know, are really, really great, or how much say do you have? What happens behind the scenes that we don't know about when we're like close to getting apart?

[3:49] Jason Styres: I think it definitely varies. And I think that's important for people to understand too that like with certain teams that I've worked with a really long time, I have a they really value my opinion, right? They they care. They they they're like they take the what I say to them very, you know, to heart. Newer teams sometimes, you know, they do value my opinion, but ultimately they know what they want. And then there's some people it it really can vary. But I would say that it's very often, especially when it's down to like two people, right? If you're kind of making a decision between two people it's a very arduous and tough process, you know, and we've been in those situations before where we're having to choose between somebody who maybe has worked on this production before and deciding whether or not they continue with it.

Like things like that are obviously very hard and they I mean it involves crying and like I mean it's it's all happen. Like I mean I I've seen that much and and it involves heartbreak and because somebody has to tell that person you know that they're not getting it. You know and so then it becomes like okay who is going to be the best person to let the person know that they're not getting it because you know we I am lucky enough that I work with a lot of people who actually are human and care. So you know we we speak extensively about how we're gonna handle that that aspect of it, as well as yes, the easy part is going to tell tell someone they're booking something or that you know, like they're gonna be making their Broadway debut, or you know, um yeah, I think that's easy part, you know.

[5:32] Jason Styres: That's that's fun. And even like, you know, another great example of like circuitous how to handle the kind of we get a lot of no's. There's a ton of rejection in this business. All of us, all of us. You know, I get told no, or I don't even get told no a lot. I just it's implied no, right? Um, you know, a good friend of mine actually just made his Broadway debut in Spamalot, ironically. Um he he has been in and out of the business over so many years. Like he did, I cast him in Forum down at Shakespeare Theater DC with Josh Rhodes uh as the choreographer. And you know, it was from that that he got to know Josh Rhodes. So, you know, it over since then that was like 2015, 14, I think it was. And then that time frame, you know, between then and now, he had left the business, got into real estate.

Oh, weirdly, somehow a reality show picked up his real estate office to be doing that. So he did that. Even the business came after him, it seems like that stopped. He got out of it again, and then after four years of not, he's like, I haven't put on tap shoes in four years. I don't know if I can do this anymore. He went in for an audition for Spam a lot, which I'm not involved with that this production, but except for the fact that Josh Rhodes is directing and choreographing. So Josh had reached out, I'm I'm betting, and you know, reached out to be like, hey, see if Matt is around. He would be an excellent like swing who could like cover things and like he's wonderful and I love working with him.

So he went in, booked it, made his Broadway debut after being out of the technically out of the business for four years. I should have him on my podcast. He's stunning. He's a love and a lovely person. And he's and he's just seen, I even knew that I was like, he texted me, he's like, Hey, do you like out of the blue? He's like, Hey, do you have a couple seconds? I was like, Oh, what is it now? Are you like booking a film or something? You know, I just assumed it was something big, and he like he told me that he was making his Broadway debut, and I was just like crying. We were both like, because you know, he worked so hard for I mean, I met him in 2009, 10, you know, that's 14, 15 years later making your Broadway debut and in a very unexpected way.

[7:45] Kerry Butler: So yeah, that is so sweet. You're you're bringing out the good stories.

[7:51] Jason Styres: I mean, I'm lucky enough to have had them.

[7:54] Kerry Butler: So what advice would you give to somebody who's just coming to New York and trying to make it? And also, do you know any like other ways people can network and and you know anything that they might not know about, any like small theater companies or something they could start out with?

[8:13] Jason Styres: Absolutely. I I think come to New York, fall in love with the city if you can. Because I think that I'm I'm such a again, since I don't I didn't come from the art world. I'm and maybe this is my stepdad, my mom, my parents, you know, they they raised that I'm definitely their child. Um, you know, being financially stable allows you to take a lot more risks in this crazy expensive city. A hundred percent. You know, and there's other ways of of doing making that happen. You don't like, yes, I'm sure I've never, I I can safely say that I've never, I've never waited tables, which is not a good or a bad thing, it just is. But I have worked in the coffee shop, right? I was I I'm a morning person. That was an easy job for me to make good money and also stay sane and gave me flexibility.

So you got to find the thing that's right for you. Don't assume that just because other everyone else in this industry kind of gets like pushed into this world of like, oh, you gotta work in this sort of find something that will work for you because there are wonderful opportunities that can give you the financial stability and the flexibility to be able to take the risks that you need to take.

[9:20] Jason Styres: Um there are a lot of different opportunities. I did a whole uh season on side hustles for people. Yes. Because it it is, it's so important. It is, and it it truly if you get burnt out, you won't do good auditions. You don't, you don't want to go to auditions. You show even if you do go to auditions, like that energy comes with you and it's evident, you know, it's so evident. And like that energy is so important to try to like hey, I don't I can't imagine carrying that around. It's baggage, you know what I mean? Like it's it and and you'll go through phases where that happens, you know, where you're upset with the industry, you're upset with so many things. We we all go through that. But I think finding ways of like mitigating that and really uh handling it like an adult, you know, as you know, as you kind of push into this industry as a professional, um, it's that's an important aspect.

[10:14] Jason Styres: And then as far as like other ways of getting to know, like I think that we we now live in a digital age, right? So I think having, you know, any sort of material available, making sure that you are ready to say yes to a job, right? Or yes to an audition. Um, that is the most important part, is like being having your stuff that out there in a very readily accessible way, and you being accessible enough to be able to get you into the room, right? Sometimes we don't have a lot of lead time. I just got an email asking for um 10 people-ish to be brought in for an audition tomorrow. And I'm like, these are tomorrow, everyone. Like, you know, like, and I don't think anyone did that maliciously. I think people's lives just got busy. But at the same time, I'm like, I I unfortunately I am the person that has to go to them and say, Hey, I know this audition's tomorrow at 11:30 a.m. Can you be there?

[11:09] Kerry Butler: Yeah.

[11:09] Jason Styres: So and it's that's just very often how this goes. Um, so being ready to being again the mise en place of it all, right? The having all your tools ready to go and not letting that fluster you. That's to me, that's actual audition technique. It's not it's not like, oh, how do you break down a song? Yeah, you need to know how to do that. You should figure that out. But I think the uh true audition technique comes in just like it's it's is the boring stuff, like even when you're in ballet class, bar work, you know, tandu clothes, tadu clothes, is knowing that no matter what I do, I know where that foot goes. I know, okay, great, it closes back to fifth. And a lot of like that, a lot of how I approach my my brain and how I approach this business is based thankfully in in dance because I dance for so long. So um, that is a huge part of my the core of my being.

[12:03] Jason Styres: Um, yeah. So I would say that, you know, that's finding non-traditional paths, obviously being available in the virtual space is really great. Instagram's essentially free, annoying, but free. Um, and you know, and having a very easy path to from for me sitting down at my desk, not on my phone, right? I sending messages on Instagram is like it's fine to start the conversation, but like I work at a desk, right? You know, and so I'm gonna be sending emails and stuff like that. So having the sort of like I think having a basic level of of you know, what is you know, clerical in a way, keeping up with your emails, having that readily available in some way, shape, or form. Make sure it's I'm always preaching about like you know, brand consistency, even though I don't believe that humans are brands, but we can learn from brand consistency.

We can say across all platforms, it's you know, there your name is your name, not you know, like my first name is actually Robert. Surprise. It's not like it's on one platform, it says Robert Styres, and then the next one says Jason Styres, because then I'm like, those are not the same person. Being consistent across it, that helps us to make sure it cuts down on time so I can just click through and like all the same person, this is the person that we need to bring in.

[13:21] Kerry Butler: That's a really good point. What about um and I have no idea about this, but is there an etiquette to people contacting you? Like, say they're in a show and they want you to come see it or something like that. How do you feel about that? Or for and not you specifically, but even any casting director.

[13:40] Jason Styres: I would say that, you know, like since I I I'm in communication with a lot of independent casting directors, and so we uh we we regularly have this, and we all have our own opinions on this, right?

[13:49] Jason Styres: And I think that's makes it hard. But also what I can say generally is that, you know, if you are going to invite, you know, a casting director, just be aware that sometimes things don't get responded to because that ends up being a lower priority, and that's hard not to take personally. Sometimes it's just like I have to get all these people in for tomorrow's audition, you know, like we're scrambling all the time to make up for, you know, poor planning. Um, so I would say that don't be afraid to reach out, but just realize that, you know, you may get no answer. Um, that doesn't mean keep following up. That means it just may not be the time. Um, and then, you know, I don't think, you know, I have had people like tag me on Instagram posts sometimes, and like, will I look at it?

Sure. That doesn't mean it's going to result in anything necessarily. Right. Um, you know, as far as like, but it doesn't, it doesn't annoy you. It doesn't, it's it is what it is. You know, it is what it is. And I like, I get it. I like I respect the hustle and I respect, but you know, if it becomes a like a hyper regular thing where it's like every day I'm getting the same thing, that might edge into like a little bit of an invasion of like professional behavior. Um, but I do think that like, you know, it our job is to find, right? We're seekers, we're out there trying to find the right person. So if you are doing the best you can to make sure that you have everything you need out there, you will be found.

I mean, not to be like cheesy in that moment, but like, no, I love that. You will, you know, our job is to find, you know, it's you know, the good casting directors, the good casting associates, the good casting assistants and interns. We're all out here just trying to find somebody new and fresh and exciting, and also surround them with pros who will support their youngness, their newness, their, you know, inexperience, you know, which is not a bad thing. It just we want to make sure that all of those people are being supported and put in the right positions. Because we the way I look at it is like I'm not trying to, I'm not trying to cast a star. Star, you know, ultimately stars should be cast by producers.

We'll talk about that on another day. But you know, like, um, I'm trying to assemble the constellation. I'm trying to assemble a constellation that allows for the, you know, the North Star to let me know. Oh, look at this whole piece together and how they actually interact with each other. That energy between the two. That is that's exciting to me, you know, it's relative.

[16:35] Kerry Butler: Yeah.

[16:35] Jason Styres: So, you know, prepare yourself. And if you are prepared, you will be able to say yes to the opportunity when the time is right.

[16:45] Kerry Butler: Great. So before we end, I just want to hear a little bit about the things that you have created and founded, the casting collaborative.

[16:53] Jason Styres: Yeah.

[16:54] Kerry Butler: So the casting collaborative.

[16:55] Jason Styres: And the caucus, right?

[16:56] Kerry Butler: Yeah, the caucus for independent casting.

[16:58] Jason Styres: So, you know, we saw a big part of this, you know, came about because I wanted to make sure that casting was being that the future of casting was going to have a very broad and very diverse lens. And I mean that very not in the hot button issue concept of diversity, right? I mean that in like true different backgrounds, different mindsets, in addition to obviously talking about any issues of like gender, race, uh, anything whatsoever. Um, and I think that so I created the casting collaborative, which allows it's a I refer to it as a creative project that allows independent casting directors to work together on projects or independently of each other on projects. So that way the project itself gets the best for example, you wouldn't choose someone who was bad at, you know, you know you're choosing lighting you're choosing lighting designers, you're choosing choreographers, you're choosing all of these things based off of their appropriateness for the project.

Ostensibly, right? So why are we not doing that with casting? You know, we need a casting director who's gonna understand the world of this play in addition to understanding the communities that they're reaching out to. So that allows us the ability to kind of like hop in on projects, tag team on projects or work solo on projects without it like weighing down the project and the production itself.

[18:27] Kerry Butler: Oh that's great.

[18:28] Jason Styres: Yeah. And the caucus is a separate concept which allowed a bunch of independent casting directors to just start talking to each other. It allows us to communicate with each other, share ideas about our own industry, um, but also when we find somebody exciting, when you meet somebody on a subway platform, you're like, I have nothing for this person, please just check them out. Check them out and find if anybody has a good opportunity for them, please find a place for them.

[18:54] Kerry Butler: That's so nice.

[18:59] Jason Styres: Um, so do you have anything else to plug today or um can people follow you anywhere?

[19:06] Jason Styres: Absolutely of course on Instagram is kind of my main platform. Um it's casting by Jason Styres. Um and then also the casting collab has its own Instagram as well, which we're just now starting, which is a mistake on my behalf. I need to take my own advice. Um, but we're getting that up and running for twenty twenty four so that way everyone can start understanding it a little bit better.

[19:29] Kerry Butler: Great. Thank you so so much for joining us. Really, really insightful information.

[19:36] Jason Styres: Thank you.

[19:37] Kerry Butler: Thank you, Jason. We just mentioned side hustles with Jason, so I'm gonna go back to our queen of the open calls, my niece, Margot Plum.

[19:45] Margot Plum: So you have a side hustle. How do you work that around your auditions?

[19:49] Margot Plum: It's challenging. Um, but I will take on my phone and try and sign up for auditions during work if I can. You know, sometimes I'm not able to, and that's um disheartening. But with the EPAs, they do have 40 open slots where you can walk in and sign up. Then they have the alternate list. So if you don't get a slot, you can sign up for the alternate list. You know, for EPAs, I like going to EPAs more because you get to sing more. You get 32 bars, which is about a minute, a minute and a half. For ECCs, you get 16 bars, which is about 45 to 60 seconds. So I always try and go to EPAs because I want to sing more. But um, you know, if everybody's singing a minute and a half song, then they're not gonna fit in EMCs or non-union people.

[20:46] Jason Styres: Right.

[20:47] Margot Plum: So I do try and be mindful of that a little bit. Like I'll more often than not pick my shorter cut, which is about a minute instead of a minute and a half. You can also feel it in the room when your cut is too long.

[21:03] Kerry Butler: And you were not a smart actor, so they're another kind of actor.

[21:07] Margot Plum: When people are coming to New York. Um, what type of job do they have to have to be able to, like what kind of schedule do they have to pay have to be able to go on auditions?

[21:21] Margot Plum: Um, I think you can do a variety of things. You just have to know what your body can take. So I knew that I could not be on my feet all day. So I did not want to go into the restaurant industry. I also saw a lot of my friends get really sucked into those industries, and um they were not able to um go to auditions because they were too tired. Um, I'd see a lot of people babysit.

[21:53] Jason Styres: And um that's a good one.

[21:55] Margot Plum: Yeah.

[21:55] Margot Plum: Yeah. Babysitting got me through the pan through up till the pandemic, and then I sort of weaned off of it because I started my quilting business and I didn't need to babysit anymore. Um, I see a lot of people with side hustles. So um I've seen a couple people do voice lessons. Like I know one of the people who's cast in that non-union tour of little women that I mentioned, her name's Rachel um Pantazis. She teaches voice lessons on the side. And so like sh I know she has like crafted her schedule around that. She's on TikTok and I she talks a lot about auditions as well. And um she also is very calm when she talks about auditions.

[22:41] Margot Plum: I've noticed like a lot of people on social media are very like, these are the auditions that I went to, like throwing a lot of musical theater energy onto TikTok, and um you don't need to go to every audition. Like when I see that stuff, I see people who are trying to go to every audition. And I just wonder, are you right for every odd every room you're walking into? Like, do you need to?

[23:09] Jason Styres: Well, I do think it's good to go on auditions that you're not right for because that's so much of the business's networking. So the casting directors will see you come in. You'll be disciplined, you're consistently giving good auditions, and you're showing a variety of work. So you're showing them that one time you can do comedy, one time you can do drama. So, and there's no pressure because you don't actually feel like you're right for the part. And so then that's how you build a relationship, and that's when they start maybe calling you in for stuff because they've seen you do all these different auditions.

[23:43] Margot Plum: Is there anything else that people need to know? Any other like websites or things people should follow for um auditioning now?

[23:52] Margot Plum: I definitely have recommended The Hustle on Instagram to everyone because they I don't know how they're getting their information. People must be like sending them like this is what's happening in the room, but they are so clear and concise about what's going on in the room. That's really helpful for like if you have to go to work and you have to come back for the open calls.

[24:15] Kerry Butler: Yeah, yeah. Those are great. We'll add all of the people that you suggested in uh the description because that's really helpful, I think, for people.

[24:24] Margot Plum: Let everyone know where they can find you and also a quilt business, your side hustle.

[24:29] Margot Plum: Oh, it needs a quilt. So my Instagram is Margie, M-A-R-G-Y plum, like the fruit, and my um quilting Instagram is Plum Tree Projects. At a certain point, I was trying to like do singing videos and also do um quilting stuff, but I do not have the energy to do all of it.

[24:51] Margot Plum: I cannot.

[24:52] Kerry Butler: It's a lot of work.

[24:53] Margot Plum: It's a lot of stuff. Especially in audition season.

[24:56] Kerry Butler: That's also something. Audition season is really January to May.

[25:02] Margot Plum: Oh, that's good to know.

[25:03] Kerry Butler: Yeah, it's very intense. The week of Natalie's wedding, I was trying to get his wedding, Margot's sister. I was trying to sign up on the equity portal, was like number 350. And if you're over a hundred, you kind of know you're not gonna get an appointment. But you want to stay on the page because maybe you will. So I um did not get an appointment. And then I was driving back from Ohio at a gas station, and I was like, maybe people have canceled their auditions. So that Monday I got an appointment for the call that was on Wednesday because there was an open time slot. And it happened to be my favorite time slot, first one of the day.

[25:58] Margot Plum: So I did not go to the equity open call, which um the series of events was very interesting, but I am always on the equity website. I've noticed that the calls come out two to three weeks before the actual call. And there's like three theaters who want to have auditions February 2nd.

[26:17] Margot Plum: Oh wow.

[26:18] Kerry Butler: How am I going to?

[26:20] Margot Plum: That's hard to get appointments to. One theater is gonna have to go. I'm not gonna, I'm just not gonna be seen at one. And then one theater, I'll go and sign up and wait, and then one theater I'll try and get an appointment at.

[26:32] Kerry Butler: Okay. All right. Well, thank you so much for sharing all great information. Our Queen open calls, Margot Plum.

[26:41] Margot Plum: Thanks for being here, Margot.

[26:46] Kerry Butler: Thank you so much for listening. If you would like me to come to your school or theater group and give a masterclass or a talk back, please reach out at kerrybutlercoach.com. If you like this podcast, subscribe and leave a rating. And in the comments, let me know what topics you want me to cover. You're listening to the Broadway Podcast Network. Together, you and I are breaking Broadway.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred