This is the second half of my conversation with Rebecca Applin Warner, who is the author of a new book: The Musical Theatre Composer As Dramatist — A Handbook For Collaboration... Read More
From the show: BROADWAY NATION
Featured Shows
About
This is the second half of my conversation with Rebecca Applin Warner, who is the author of a new book: The Musical Theatre Composer As Dramatist — A Handbook For Collaboration.
Last time Rebecca shared some of the fascinating concepts and techniques that can be found in her book in regard to breaking down and analyzing the components of a musical, including its principal and supporting themes (both dramatic and musical), as well as what she calls “the shape” of the musical overall, and in its individual segments, including it various “levels of intensification.” And we discussed how all of that can provide invaluable tools to, not just the composer, but to the entire creative team as they develop their musical. If you missed the part one you may want to catch up with that episode before listening to this on.
We start off this episode by exploring what she calls a musical’s “modes of enunciation.” As in the previous episode Rebeca Applin Warner illustrates these concepts using examples from various contemporary musicals such as In The Heights, Matilda and The Last Five Years, and in what could be called the “11 o’clock spot” of her book and this episode, she ties everything together through a case study of the musical Everybody’s Talking About Jamie.
Whether you are creator of musical theater of just an ardent fan I feel certain that you will find this to be a fascinating conversation.
Rebeca Applin Warner is an award-winning composer with extensive experience both writing musicals and teaching in a variety of degree programs in Musical Theatre and Performing Arts.She has an undergraduate degree in Music from the University of Cambridge, a masters in Composition for the Screen from the Royal college of Music and a PhD in musical theater analysis. Her previous publications include chapters in The Oxford Handbook of the British Musical Theatre and in Reframing the Musical, alongside publication in the Studies in Musical Theatre Journal.
Become A PATRON of Broadway Nation!
This episode is made possible in part by the generous support of our newest Patrons:
Mark Stanton and Anne Welsh.
If you would like to help support the work of Broadway Nation I will information at the end of the podcast about how you too can become a Patron.
If you are a fan ofBroadway Nation, I invite you too to become a PATRON!
For a just $7.00 a month you will receive exclusive access to never-before-heard, unedited versions of many of the discussion that I have with my guests — in fact I often record nearly twice as much conversation as ends up in the edited versions. And you will also have access to additional in-depth conversations with my frequent co-host Albert Evans that have not been featured on the podcast. And all patrons receive special “on-air” shout-outs and acknowledgement of your vital support of this podcast.
And If you are very enthusiastic about Broadway Nation there are additional PATRON levels that come with even more benefits.
If you would like to support the work of Broadway Nation and receive these exclusive member benefits, please just click on this link:
https://broadwaynationpodcast.supercast.tech/
Thank you in advance for your support!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:20] David Armstrong: Welcome to another episode of Broadway Nation, the podcast that tells the remarkable story of how immigrants, Jews, queers, African Americans, and other outcasts invented the Broadway musical and how they changed America in the process. I'm David Armstrong, and this is the second half of my conversation with Rebecca Aplin Warner, who is the author of a new book titled The Musical Theater Composer as Dramatist, a handbook for collaboration. If you missed part one, you may want to catch up on that episode before listening to this one.
[0:53] David Armstrong: Last time, Rebecca shared some of the fascinating concepts and techniques that can be found in her book in regard to breaking down and analyzing the components of a musical, including its principal and supporting themes, both dramatic and musical, as well as what she calls the shape of the musical overall and of its individual segments. And especially how all of that can provide invaluable tools not to just the composer, but to the entire creative team as they develop their musical. As in the previous episode, Rebecca Aplin Warner illustrates her concepts using examples from various contemporary musicals, such as In the Heights, Matilda, and The Last Five Years. And finally, in what could be called the 11 o'clock spot of her book and of this episode, she ties all of it together in a case study of the musical Everybody's Talking About Jamie. Whether you're a creator of musical theater or just an ardent fan, I feel certain that you will find this to be a fascinating conversation. Here we go.
[1:57] David Armstrong: You mentioned this a moment ago, modes of enunciation, which is another way of looking at it, basically. What are these and how do they affect the shape of a musical?
[2:07] Rebecca Aplin Warner: So this is another idea by Kofi Agaru, actually, again related to classical music that I then thought about in a musical theatre context. Agami takes speech mode, song mode, and dance mode. So we've just talked about those as literal performance modes, dialogue and song and dance. But he takes them as metaphorical. So a song might be in speech mode, or a speech might be in song mode. And he gives each of them an intention. So speech mode has the intention of delivering information. And song mode has an intention to affect, so to strike us emotionally, and then dance mode has an intention of rhythm and having a sense of rhythmic drive and involving our own inner rhythms and our own response to that rhythm, physical.
[2:56] Rebecca Aplin Warner: Exactly. And so a song in song mode might be something like "I'm Still Hurting" from The Last Five Years. What about nice, Jimmy? What about things that you swore to be true? What about you, Jamie? So something that's really clearly there to affect us. The character is literally singing and also in song mode. But something like "Revolting Children," for example, in Matilda. And that's probably in dance mode. We've got a song, but the song itself is in dance mode. It's all about the rhythm, it's all about the drive. It's kind of there to fire us up. And in that instance, create a kind of victorious celebratory kind of feel.
[4:43] ♪ Musical number ♪
[5:57] Rebecca Aplin Warner: So this can also be really helpful as a tool in creating shape and thinking, well, I want a song there, but is the song actually there to affect us in song mode, or actually has that song got a purpose that we really need some energy there and some drive and some rhythm? It does kind of really affect what you decide to write the character of that music at any one time.
[6:19] David Armstrong: Any other examples of those different modes of enunciation that you want to share with us?
[6:24] Rebecca Aplin Warner: In the Heights starts with what we'd probably call an extended musical sequence. As so many musicals do, it needs to establish the world, we establish the characters, we establish what it is that's going on at the start of our show, like before the rest of the story unfolds. And so those sequences perhaps are most likely to include all three, like moving between them. And the beginning of In the Heights certainly does that. You've got Uznavi delivering quite a lot of information in speech mode, but then moving into song mode with kind of moments with Vanessa and then the whole community being involved by the end, that has a real moment of dance mode that kind of kicks us into the rest of the show out of that opening sequence.
So I think opening numbers, opening sequences, often navigate through all three modes because they have to set up the show. They have to get the exposition out, but at the same time, they have to excite us to want to see what's going to come next and to touch us enough that we get involved with the characters in the story.
[7:34] Rebecca Aplin Warner: Yeah, that's it. But as you say, you need a little hint of that at the beginning. You know it's gonna come.
[7:39] David Armstrong: Exactly. It's the promise of what will happen.
[7:41] Rebecca Aplin Warner: Yeah. I'm a street light, choking on the heat. The world spins around while I'm frozen to my seat. The people that I know will keep on rolling down the street, but every day is different. So I'm switching up the beat. Cause my parents came with nothing. They got a little more ashore. We're poor, but yo, at least we got the store. It's all about the legacy. They left with me as destiny. And one day I'll be on the beach with Sonny right and text to me. I hate my time on this place. We came to working to live and we gotta comment. I came from miles away. DRBO stary on the sky until the day we go from Harvard.
[8:39] David Armstrong: Broadway Nation will be back right after this quick break.
[8:43] ♪ Musical number ♪
[9:05] David Armstrong: So the next third or so of your book, it's interesting. A moment ago you were talking about the high point, which you know, of course, in musical theater terms, we have 11 o'clock spot as the idea of the high point of a show is already there. The sort of 11 o'clock spot of your book is this section where you illustrate everything that you've written about so far through the process of breaking down and analyzing and seeing in action all of these techniques in one musical. And the show you chose for that is Everybody's Talking About Jamie. Why did you choose that musical? What was it about that show that you thought would help you illustrate these points so clearly?
[10:09] Rebecca Aplin Warner: I think, as we were talking about earlier, actually, the theme of identity in Jamie being really important. I knew that I wanted to set a kind of broad question for that part of the book that we could focus on as if to help maybe someone who was either analyzing a show for an essay, or because they were in a show, or for some other purpose. You usually come to those things with a sense of question. And so for that question to be about identity felt really relevant at the moment. And I think Jamie has a really important message in that show for our time. It was also partly about resources because I wanted to make sure that it was as accessible for people to be able to engage with the script and the score and a film version of it and the recording and kind of be able to access all of that as well to really be able to see and hear what you're talking about.
[11:03] David Armstrong: What elements of Jamie particularly demonstrate the role of the musical theatre composer as dramatist?
[11:10] Rebecca Aplin Warner: Jamie has a predominantly pop score, which I think is really interesting in this regard, actually, because pop structures are perhaps more block-like often. I know we were talking about building blocks, and there's quite a lot of repetition in pop structures. I mean, I love through-composed writing as well, but it doesn't have to be that to be able to follow drama. It can all happen within pop structures as well. All of the songs, in some way, are about Jamie's identity. And I think that so clearly is the score pointing to the universal theme about identity and about Jamie's acceptance of identity. And for me, the show kind of falls into two halves. It's like it's got two high points. One building towards the high point of Jamie's acceptance as me, me, me, which is the drag personality that he is creating.
And then the second half being about his working through acceptance to himself as Jamie knew. The shaping of how that works in each half is absolutely there. It doesn't mean that Jamie's the only one that sings. It's not obvious that it's all about Jamie's identity, but actually, when you wrote the score down and you look at it, they are like branch themes all pointing in towards that central trunk theme, that universal theme of identity.
[12:37] Rebecca Aplin Warner: The modes of enunciation focus on speech and dance mode for quite a lot of the score. I'm holding my breath till I hear the last bell. Then I'm coming out hard and I'm giving a hell. I'm a superstar and you don't even know it. In a wonder bra, and you don't even know it. So blah blah and you don't even know it. I'm like au revoir, and you don't even know it. There's a path up plan. To the promised land. You wanna understand because you're my backing fan. And it's a Jamie show. Cause you're messing up so long and I'm go, go, go.
[13:28] ♪ Musical number ♪
[13:46] Rebecca Aplin Warner: Until towards the end, and particularly found in the songs of Pretty, so Jamie's best friend and Margaret, Jamie's mum, they start to take us into song mode. I think it's really wonderful how the shaping of that leaves that to this final part of the show where it all suddenly becomes much more relational and about Jamie in his closest relationships and what that means.
[14:12] ♪ Musical number ♪
[14:44] ♪ Musical number ♪
[15:17] David Armstrong: That kind of saving of song mode for that section, I think's really wonderful. There's a lot of use of characterful orchestration, which is brilliant. In the film version, which I was particularly analyzing, you get the 80s sound world for "This Was Me," which of course isn't in the stage version. You get kind of nightmarish orchestration techniques in "Work of Art," you get hints of military in "Over the Top," and then you get a really stripped back intimacy for "It Means Beautiful," which is just such a gorgeous song. And so I think the orchestration really tells the story. And also just back to the universal theme and the theme of identity. I think it's really interesting that sung language in the show is used mostly for positivity about Jamie and Jamie's sense of identity.
And I think that really helps in the importance of the message. So the bully Dean doesn't get to sing. The father doesn't get to sing. So the negative voices that Jamie has in his life aren't actually given space in the score, which is really important statement, I think.
[16:17] Rebecca Aplin Warner: I thought that was really interesting that you identified that. I think that's unusual. Our first impulse would be, well, we need to balance the two polarities. You need to have the antagonist have his equal weight with the protagonist. But in this case, you think this was a great choice. Why is that?
[16:33] David Armstrong: I think because music and song, like we were talking about with intensification, it gives things more weight. When you sing something, you sort of assume it's got importance. And so to remove the naysayers, the negative voices from that weight of importance that maybe the score brings, I think is a really important message. It's a really important statement. It's probably working subliminally. We don't necessarily notice that consciously, but I think it's something really meaningful that's there.
[17:07] Rebecca Aplin Warner: Because it's reinforcing this central idea that identity is what the show is about and what Jamie's story is about.
[17:15] David Armstrong: Exactly.
[17:16] Rebecca Aplin Warner: And that acceptance is there in the score right the way through, and it's then Jamie's journey. The score is sort of subliminally affirming him.
[17:25] ♪ Musical number ♪
[18:17] David Armstrong: So in this case, the composer, as dramatist, understood this clearly, whether it was consciously or again just intuitively, but understood this universal theme so well that then he could create a score that would support that and tell that story.
[18:33] Rebecca Aplin Warner: Yes, I'm never meaning to imply that the tools and frameworks I use in the book are the tools that have been used for the writing process. I'm sure that's not the case. But they help as a framework to be able to see even what might be there innately. As you say, it probably is an innate process. Or a combination of some analysis and just getting it.
[18:54] David Armstrong: Yeah.
[18:54] Rebecca Aplin Warner: Which is what I think is so valuable about a book like this is you've put in the thought behind it to identify these processes that are probably going on automatically in the most successful and intuitive of cases. But you've identified what it is that's actually happening. They may not even be aware of.
[19:12] David Armstrong: Yeah, and for those days when you get stuck and just not feeling inspired. This song's just not working, it's not achieving what we want it to. They're there to reach for. I've been in the room when even the greatest writers just get stuck and just don't know how to move forward.
[19:27] ♪ Musical number ♪
[19:31] David Armstrong: The final section of your book is a very practical, hands-on, I guess it's the workbook of the subtitle, a workbook for composers and their teams of collaborators. I'm assuming this is based on exercises that you have put into practice for yourself, possibly with other teams of writers to see how this works.
[20:04] Rebecca Aplin Warner: It is based on ideas from over the years, but the bringing it together in the form in which it is in the book is actually new. So I haven't used it with other people in that full form. I've used the dynamic curve the most with all kinds of groups of people, as I say, from primary school children doing kind of graphic scores and drawing shapes based on a story and then trying to write music to it, and university students writing their own musicals, and it's something that I do all the time myself, little sketches of what's going on in this moment. So the dynamic curve I've used a lot, and I find really helpful as a problem-solving tool.
[20:42] David Armstrong: So do you foresee yourself, now that you have shown yourself to be an expert in this regard, being called in on projects as a consultant to say, can you help us focus our work on this show that we're about to embark on or in the middle of doing or struggling with?
[20:58] Rebecca Aplin Warner: I would love to do that. I would absolutely love it. I'm fortunate to teach on the Master's Programme in Musical Theatre Writing at Goldsmiths. I love being able to help people develop their work. So yes, I would love to do that.
[21:10] David Armstrong: I would think at the university there you will have that opportunity since you have those students confronting those problems down the hall, I assume.
[21:18] Rebecca Aplin Warner: Yes, yep. Definitely.
[21:21] David Armstrong: Throughout the book, you emphasize over and over again the intense collaboration that musical theater requires. What would you say are the most crucial elements that teams need to bring about this successful synthesis of music and drama?
[21:35] Rebecca Aplin Warner: I think it's always coming back to the storytelling as key. That really is where for me everything builds from that nucleus of the storytelling. And so that involves continual discussion, really, always drawing it back to the storytelling. Then for me, those two containers of really broadly theme and shape sort of help to then talk about all sorts of things within there. So you've got absolute focus on the storytelling. And then are we all on the same page about what the themes are? And do we know what shape we're trying to create? And then sort of everything else can arise out of those.
[22:10] David Armstrong: I think that's absolutely right. I've been interviewing several authors over the last several months about various aspects of Rogers and Hammerstein. And what comes out is that the weeks and months that they spent talking about the show before either one of them started to write anything.
[22:25] Rebecca Aplin Warner: Definitely.
[22:26] David Armstrong: By the time they started writing, they were on the same page. Now, of course, they had the advantage that Oscar Hammerstein was doing two of the jobs himself. So obviously the lyrics and the book are in sync with one another from the beginning, but Rogers is right there on that same page. And they were both responsible for the story, and that's what they worked out or at least talked about in depth prior to sitting down to write to put a note on the page.
[22:51] Rebecca Aplin Warner: Yeah, that's it. We're all storytellers.
[22:54] David Armstrong: So thank you, Rebecca Aplin Warner, for being my guest today on Broadway Nation to talk about your new book, The Musical Theater Composer as Dramatist.
[23:03] Rebecca Aplin Warner: Thank you for having me. It's been a pleasure.
[23:05] ♪ Musical number ♪
[23:43] David Armstrong: Broadway Nation is made possible in part through the generous support of our patrons, including our newest patrons, Anne Welsh and Mark Stanton. If you too would like to help support the work of this podcast, here's how you can do it. A donation of just seven dollars a month will not only keep Broadway Nation out of the darkness, it will also provide you with exclusive access to the complete unedited versions of many of the interviews you hear on this podcast, as well as outtakes and additional content created exclusively by Albert Evans and I, especially for our patrons. And all patrons will receive special shout-outs and acknowledgment for your vital support for this podcast. To join, simply go to Broadway Nation Podcast.tech. That's Broadway Nation Podcast dot S-U-P-E-R-C-A-S-T dot tech, or click the link in the show notes to this episode. Broadway Nation is written and produced by me, David Armstrong. Special thanks to Pal's Mox for his help with editing this episode and to the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.
[25:29] ♪ Musical number ♪
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
