Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 117: POD SWAP! Broadway Nation meets A Musical Theatre Podcast

This is a special POD SWAP editions of Broadway Nation! Last December it was my great pleasure to be a guest on Jeffrey Scott Parson’s terrific show, A Musical Theatre Podcast, and this week I am thrilled to share that episode with my Broadway Nation audience... Read More

From the show: BROADWAY NATION

1 h 10 mins
8/17/23

Guests

Featured Shows

About

This is a special POD SWAP editions of Broadway Nation!

Last December it was my great pleasure to be a guest on Jeffrey Scott Parson’s terrific show, A Musical Theatre Podcast, and this week I am thrilled to share that episode with my Broadway Nation audience.

Think of this “pod swap” as sort of a “Summer Replacement Special.” If you are too young to remember those, then let me fill you in. Back in the heyday of television variety shows, the big prime time series would take a break during the summer months and be replaced by what they called a “summer replacement.” As a kid, I always looked forward to those because they often served as “pilots” for what would become the next hit prime time variety series. So, this week Broadway Nation takes a break and is replaced by A Musical Theatre Podcast.

On this episode I join Jeffrey Scott Parsons to explore Jerry Herman’s 1961 Broadway debut musical, Milk And Honey, which starred the great Yiddish Theater star Molly Picon, and star of The Most Happy Fella, Robert Weede. This show, which was set in (then) modern-day Israel, had a book by Don Apell, and judging from the script and production photos it featured extensive dance sequences and ballets choreographed by Donald Sadler that showcased a chorus of hunky shirtless male dancers wearing very short shorts, and the musical’s triple-threat co-star, Tommy Rall.

The success of the show put Jerry Herman firmly on the Broadway map and led directly to him being selected by producer David Merrick to create the score for Hello, Dolly! Jeffrey and I discuss all of that and more!

As you will hear, there is a tremendous resonance and kinship between our two podcasts. Both Broadway Nation and A Musical Theatre Podcast take deep thoughtful looks inside the history of the Broadway Musical, its shows, and its creators — in a manner that is both critical and celebratory.

I feel certain that if you enjoy Broadway Nation you will love A Musical Theatre Podcast!

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:07] David Armstrong: Welcome to another episode of Broadway Nation, the podcast that tells the remarkable story of how immigrants, Jews, queers, African Americans, and other outcasts invented the Broadway musical and how they changed America in the process.

[0:23] David Armstrong: I'm David Armstrong, and this is a special pod swap episode of Broadway Nation.

[0:28] David Armstrong: Last December, it was my great pleasure to be a guest on Jeffrey Scott Parsons' terrific show, A Musical Theatre Podcast.

[0:36] David Armstrong: And this week I'm thrilled to share that episode with my audience here on Broadway Nation.

[0:42] David Armstrong: Think of this pod swap as sort of a summer replacement special.

[0:47] David Armstrong: If you're too young to remember what those were, let me fill you in.

[0:51] David Armstrong: Back in the heyday of television variety shows, the big primetime series would take a break during the summer months and be replaced by what were called summer replacement shows.

[1:01] David Armstrong: As a kid, I always looked forward to those because they often served as pilots for what would become the next hit primetime variety series.

[1:09] David Armstrong: So this week, Broadway Nation takes a break and is replaced by A Musical Theatre Podcast.

[1:15] David Armstrong: On this episode, I joined Jeffrey Scott Parsons to explore Jerry Herman's 1961 Broadway debut musical Milk and Honey, which was headlined by the great Yiddish theater star Molly Picon and the star of The Most Happy Fella, Robert Weede.

[1:31] David Armstrong: This show, which was set in then modern-day Israel, had a book by Don Apell, and judging from the script and the production photos, it featured extensive dance sequences and ballets choreographed by Donald Sadler that showcased a chorus of hunky, shirtless male dancers wearing very short shorts, as well as the musical's triple-threat co-star, Tommy Rall.

[1:54] David Armstrong: The success of the show put Jerry Herman firmly on the Broadway map and led directly to him being selected by producer David Merrick to create the score for Hello, Dolly!

[2:05] David Armstrong: Jeffrey and I discuss all of that and more.

[2:08] David Armstrong: As you will hear, there's a tremendous kinship between our two podcasts.

[2:12] David Armstrong: Both Broadway Nation and A Musical Theatre Podcast take deep, thoughtful looks inside the history of the Broadway musical, its shows, and its creators.

[2:22] David Armstrong: And we try to do that in a manner that is both critical and celebratory.

[2:26] David Armstrong: I feel certain that if you enjoy Broadway Nation, you'll love A Musical Theatre Podcast.

[2:31] David Armstrong: Here we go.

[2:33] David Armstrong: In preparation for this, I listened to an interview with Jerry Herman where he talked about Milk and Honey, and he said he had, you know, just his face lights up when he thinks about it because it was such an incredible experience.

[2:43] David Armstrong: But mostly he remembers the first orchestra read-through because he had never heard his music played by an orchestra before.

[2:49] David Armstrong: Of course, off-Broadway, you wouldn't have.

[2:51] David Armstrong: When he actually was the pianist for all those off-Broadway shows because they couldn't afford anybody.

[2:55] David Armstrong: So he's actually playing the piano for everything he does prior to this with just small combos.

[3:01] David Armstrong: And all of a sudden, Hershy Kay had done these orchestrations, and he just said he dissolved into tears.

[3:07] David Armstrong: Oh, that's so beautiful.

[3:09] David Armstrong: And they're great orchestrations.

[3:21] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Welcome everybody to A Musical Theatre Podcast where we discuss the cultural and emotional impact of some of our favorite musicals in theater history.

[3:29] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: My name is Jeffrey Scott Parsons. You can call me Jeff.

[3:31] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Today is Christmas Day.

[3:35] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Well, that's when the episode's coming out.

[3:37] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And I already celebrated Christmas in July earlier this year.

[3:40] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: You all may remember by covering A Christmas Story, which is a really fun episode if you missed it.

[3:46] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And why? Because this past summer was rough for me, and I really wanted an excuse to celebrate and make sugar cookies.

[3:52] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: But anyway, today I still wanted to celebrate.

[3:56] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And I thought, you know, during this time of year, we talk so much about Little Town of Bethlehem and Nazareth and far, far away on Judea's Plains.

[4:05] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: So we should cover a musical that's actually about Israel.

[4:10] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And that's what we're doing. We're covering Jerry Herman's first big Broadway musical, Milk and Honey.

[4:15] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And I'm so excited we're doing it, particularly because of the guest joining me to discuss it.

[4:21] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: He is a Broadway expert, director, writer, producer, lecturer, educator, and choreographer.

[4:30] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: He was the artistic director of the Fifth Avenue Theater in Seattle from 2000 to 2019, which my gosh, how many times have we discussed the Fifth Ave on this podcast?

[4:40] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Speaking of A Christmas Story.

[4:42] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Anyway, um, what else do I want to say about you, David?

[4:45] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: He's the first guest on the podcast to have directed Carolee Carmello in a Tony-nominated performance in the musical Scandalous.

[4:52] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Uh, he's also a podcast host of his own show here on the Broadway Podcast Network.

[4:57] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Everyone, please welcome David Armstrong.

[5:00] David Armstrong: Thank you, thank you so much. It's so great to be here, Jeffrey.

[5:03] David Armstrong: I'm really excited to talk about Milk and Honey, although I am disappointed I didn't get to talk about A Christmas Story.

[5:09] David Armstrong: Because of course, that is very close to my heart because I produced the world premiere of A Christmas Story at the Fifth Avenue Theater.

[5:16] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yes, like you're all over that cast album.

[5:19] David Armstrong: Yeah, well, most of that score was written in the basement of the Fifth Avenue Theater.

[5:25] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Wow, when after we hired Pasek and Paul to do the show.

[5:30] David Armstrong: And it was a very short timeline, so we locked them in the basement and made them work.

[5:36] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: You're like just like passing water and bread underneath the door.

[5:41] David Armstrong: It was not far from that, actually, yeah.

[5:44] David Armstrong: Yeah, we had Ian Eisendrath on for that.

[5:47] David Armstrong: And he had just wonderful things to say about that whole experience.

[5:52] David Armstrong: Well, Ian was on our staff at that time.

[5:55] David Armstrong: He was our resident musical director, and he was integral into making that show happen, especially on the timeline that we had.

[6:02] David Armstrong: And of course, he's gone on to work with them on every project since.

[6:06] David Armstrong: Including Spirited, which is out this holiday season.

[6:10] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: So cool.

[6:13] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: All right, before we jump into Milk and Honey, I want to know a little bit more about you.

[6:17] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Like forever a musical theater nerd. When did this hit? When did the bug get you?

[6:20] David Armstrong: I was one of those strange kids that just knew from the beginning exactly what I wanted to do from the earliest time. The legendary story, and I'm sure I was interested in musical theater before that, mostly from television, from seeing from the movies on television.

[6:40] David Armstrong: I grew up in Cincinnati. I actually don't know the first live theater production I went to. It was probably a high school production of something.

[6:48] David Armstrong: But when I was four or five years old, the story goes, and it doesn't quite add up. So I've always tried to recreate this a couple times. That we were my mother and her friend and the friend's daughter, who was around my age, a little younger, were taking us to the movies to see Dumbo.

[7:11] David Armstrong: Okay. Disney's Dumbo.

[7:13] David Armstrong: And they went to the wrong theater and we saw Gypsy instead.

[7:18] David Armstrong: And from that moment on, and this part is true, I was obsessed with Gypsy.

[7:23] David Armstrong: I apparently demanded to have the cast album. How I knew what a cast album was, I don't know.

[7:29] David Armstrong: But I was immersed in Gypsy from that moment on.

[7:35] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Uh, that's why we're best friends, David. This is great.

[7:36] David Armstrong: I love that so much.

[7:39] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And of course, when you're a kid, Gypsy is a story about kids in show business.

[7:44] David Armstrong: Yeah.

[7:44] David Armstrong: I mean, that's what it's about.

[7:46] David Armstrong: And of course, I was I'm sure I was less interested in the second half of the story than I was in the first half of the story.

[7:52] David Armstrong: But that's what it's about, kids on stage, and you see yourself in it.

[7:57] David Armstrong: And obviously I had taste from the very beginning. I knew what good was.

[8:01] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: So you had amazing taste.

[8:04] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And also I think that Gypsy works, and I can't wait for an episode on Gypsy.

[8:09] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: But like it's operating on so many levels because I think that there is an entry point for children to understand the complex relationships of parents and children and then add show business into all of that.

[8:21] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Like I understand why kids would be interested or at least fascinated by Gypsy.

[8:28] David Armstrong: So from that moment on, or before or shortly after, I was fascinated by Broadway musicals, by film musicals, and then went to started going to dancing school when I was six, and got involved in creative dramatics, which is what they used to call it, then I don't know if they use that term anymore, but it was, you know, basically theater for kids, you know.

[8:50] David Armstrong: It was how do you involve kids in their imagination and theatrical types of things.

[8:56] David Armstrong: And so I was constantly doing that kind of stuff. I did shows, I did community theater shows. I was the kid in a lot of community theater shows and even college shows and stuff like that.

[9:06] David Armstrong: I was never a professional kid, but did lots of theater. Talk about a really strange kid. I would organize the neighborhood into doing shows that I would produce and direct and write and star in before I knew what any of that meant other than star in.

[9:23] David Armstrong: And so I often say I do now what I've done since I was 10 years old, basically.

[9:29] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: That's incredible. We have a lot in common because my scout troop had the best skits at Scout Camp.

[9:37] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And you want to know why? Because of me.

[9:39] David Armstrong: Because of you, of course.

[9:41] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Um no, exactly, and forcing everybody to get into character.

[9:45] David Armstrong: Yeah.

[9:46] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: But I'm sure you did not let anybody slack off.

[9:49] David Armstrong: Oh, no, no, no. Absolutely.

[9:51] David Armstrong: Do you want this merit badge or not?

[9:54] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Um that's fantastic.

[9:56] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: So then you grow up, you become this artistic director. Was the goal when you joined Fifth Ave was to be creating theater that would then transfer to New York?

[10:04] David Armstrong: Yeah. Was that the goal or was that already the tradition?

[10:07] David Armstrong: I'm not sure. It was not tradition. It had done it sort of dabbled in that. It had been part of the original tour that launched Jekyll and Hyde a decade earlier than when I went to the Fifth.

[10:20] David Armstrong: But when I got that job, I was living in New York. I'd been working in theater, I'd been living in New York for 20 years and working in the theater, and I had a lot of contacts.

[10:31] David Armstrong: So everybody I would run into, especially Broadway producers, I would say, I'm going to Seattle, I've to the Fifth Avenue Theater. I think it would be a great place to try out shows.

[10:42] David Armstrong: So as part of the mix of what we did, what we did, and I just kept at that for the six months prior from the time I got the job to before I went to Seattle to take it.

[10:54] David Armstrong: And after about being there six months, I got a call from some producers who said, We've got a show we want to talk to you about, and that show turned out to be Hairspray.

[11:07] David Armstrong: So yeah, so it was very fortuitous.

[11:12] David Armstrong: It was very fortuitous that that was the first. It wasn't the first new, we actually did a different new musical that didn't go anywhere the year before, but it was the first one of the first shows that we did in a as a new musical in a mix of revivals and sometimes presenting.

[11:30] David Armstrong: People are often confused about the Fifth Avenue because it was 90% a producing theater company during the time I was there, and that's what I was brought there to turn it into.

[11:40] David Armstrong: It had been a presenting house prior to that for like tours coming through. Almost all tours, and then it started doing a mix of producing in tandem with Theatre Under the Stars in Houston.

[11:53] David Armstrong: And that was very successful for a while, and then that had sort of run its course, and when I was hired, it was to put the emphasis on producing based in Seattle, still with one or two tours in a season, which is very almost no other theater does that is mostly producing with some presenting.

[12:14] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Crazy amount of staff work to make that happen.

[12:16] David Armstrong: Yeah.

[12:16] David Armstrong: And what I added to it was then working in partnership with New York producers, and then eventually on our own to produce new musicals.

[12:26] David Armstrong: So during the time I was there, we produced 22 new musicals.

[12:31] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Dang.

[12:31] David Armstrong: And nine of them went to Broadway.

[12:33] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Oh my gosh.

[12:34] David Armstrong: Two of them won the Tony Award for Best Musical.

[12:37] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah.

[12:38] David Armstrong: So that's a well, it's crazy.

[12:41] David Armstrong: Right?

[12:41] David Armstrong: Memphis and Hairspray.

[12:42] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah.

[12:43] David Armstrong: If you would ask me in 2000 when I went to the theater, what is the what will what do you see happening in the next 18 years in terms of what would be your dream? I would think one or two shows going to Broadway would have been what I would realistically have said.

[13:00] David Armstrong: So it was way beyond what I ever imagined it could be. It just was luck.

[13:05] David Armstrong: A lot of it was that when we did Hairspray, Margot Lyon, who was the lead producer on that, had a fantastic time.

[13:12] David Armstrong: The show, of course, was very successful, and she went to back to New York and literally told people, told her colleagues, I never want to do another show out of town anywhere except at the Fifth Avenue Theater.

[13:23] David Armstrong: So that started a ball rolling.

[13:26] David Armstrong: Yeah. Which was again just part of some of it was dumb luck, some of it was just smart luck because just making sure to, you know, talk to people and get the word out and do the things that I did.

[13:39] David Armstrong: But it was fantastic. It was the job of a lifetime.

[13:41] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: That's so cool. Well, one of your so I mentioned one of your latest adventures has been into podcasting. And I love I think we our shows hold hands a lot. Tell me tell me the pitch for your podcast.

[13:55] David Armstrong: Sure. My podcast came out of a course that I started teaching when I stepped down from the Fifth Avenue Theater.

[14:02] David Armstrong: The University of Washington invited me to teach a course on the history of the musical theater, or asked me if I would be interested in doing that, and I took a week or two to try to think about what would I do, what would I talk about. And I came up with a course which then inspired the podcast.

[14:19] David Armstrong: Both of those have the same premise. My sort of subtitle for the podcast, which is called Broadway Nation, is the podcast that tells the remarkable story of how immigrants, Jews, queers, African Americans, and other outcasts invented the Broadway musical and how they changed America in the process. And that is very much what I teach as well.

[14:42] David Armstrong: I do a big lecture course at the University of Washington School of Drama. Hallelujah. Beautiful. Well, I love that so much. We all know the cultural and emotional impacts of musical theater are kind of high on my list in terms of priorities and talking about, and in particular the gays and the Jews, man. Two of the most important forces in creating this beautiful tradition.

[15:04] David Armstrong: And I'm so grateful to all of the wonderful people that may have identified as either of that in our history. I can think of few better representatives than Mr. Jerry Herman, who we'll be talking about today, composer extraordinaire of Hello, Dolly!, La Cage aux Folles, and Milk and Honey.

[15:32] David Armstrong: So we've talked a lot about Jerry Herman on the podcast, of course. And if you want to go back and listen to our Hello, Dolly! episode, listeners, you can hear about his childhood and growing up. But if you remember, he started out, I guess in his composing career off-Broadway, writing reviews.

[15:50] David Armstrong: You know, there was this big surge of off-Broadway musical theater review style shows that were really opportunities for amazing performers to strut their stuff. And I mean, he was kind of the king of writing this material, right?

[16:07] David Armstrong: I think he wrote a lot of those songs while he was in college and then came to New York, and it wasn't a way that songwriters could make a name for themselves, at least in a small way, by putting together reviews of their songs or contributing their songs to the various reviews that were happening around town.

[16:30] David Armstrong: And this turned out to be, I mean, this is like the dream scenario for this type of beginning of a career because producers came and saw his stuff, and one in particular by the name of Gerard Ostrovsky, maybe it's, I heard Jerry Herman speak it because I listened to an interview with Jerry Herman and that Ostrovsky, I think, by the way.

[16:56] David Armstrong: We may both be wrong. Hey, we love you, Gerard. Anyway, he approaches Jerry Herman and writer-actor-director Don Apell about writing a musical about Israel. And he sends them literally across the world to Israel to take in the local flavors and surroundings to see what they can come up with.

[17:26] David Armstrong: Now, what I consistently have to remind myself about this musical is this is pre-Fiddler on the Roof. Yeah. Like it's hard for me to think of musical theater before Fiddler on the Roof. And to also recognize how much Jewish influence and culture was found in the art form from the beginning.

[17:46] David Armstrong: And yet, like this was the first big musical about Israel and Jewish life. Yeah, it's part of a series of musicals that happened in the 1960s that started to focus on Jewish life. But for the first time, because I also heard or read something that Sheldon Harnick was talking about that prior to this, Jewish writers, the generation before of Jewish writers didn't really want to identify as Jewish and didn't want to write about Jewish subjects.

[18:11] David Armstrong: They were trying to succeed in spite of their Jewishness because it was still, you know, this was still a marginalized group of people. It could kill a career, so everybody's changing their names, right? I mean, everybody started changing. They want to be Americans, they want to be seen as Americans, and that happens until after World War II.

[18:43] David Armstrong: And he was talking about this generation that comes of age after World War II has a very different idea, and you know what the events that happened with World War II have a lot to do with this, because all of a sudden people want to celebrate their Jewishness or at least identify strongly as Jewish, and this starts a series of shows.

[18:43] David Armstrong: It's hard to pin down exactly. It starts a little bit in the 50s. I think Wish You Were Here maybe might qualify as the first show with a strong Jewish content because it's set at one of those Jewish summer camps in the Catskills kind of thing.

[19:24] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Right.

[19:24] David Armstrong: No, that's true. I didn't think about that.

[19:26] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: It's great.

[19:27] David Armstrong: That's back in the 50s, but there aren't a lot. You're right. And the 60s definitely puts this on the front burner, and Milk and Honey is right at the start of that.

[19:39] David Armstrong: And then I Can Get It for You Wholesale is another show with a strong Jewish flavor, same season as this one, set in the Garment District in the world of the Garment District of the 1930s. And then Funny Girl, I would say, is another show which has Jewishness right front. And then Fiddler. All of those within four years, basically, four or five years.

[20:00] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Wow.

[20:01] David Armstrong: Except for Wish You Were Here, which is back in the 50s. We also would need to talk because obviously Molly Picon is going to come up. Talking about Yiddish theater is going to be important to this particular title.

[20:14] David Armstrong: And when you look at how Yiddish theater informed musical theater, not just from a sense of comedy and the performers who were popular in Yiddish theater, but what it has to say about Jewish performers who were coming to America to seek asylum, essentially, right? Because they're not safe where they are in other places of the world, and how that influx of Jewish artists brings artistic vitality to New York City.

[20:44] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Absolutely.

[20:45] David Armstrong: And the Yiddish theater, which is not discussed, in my opinion, nearly as much as it should be in the history of Broadway, because it really is so much of the roots of the Broadway musical are in the Yiddish theater, which is happening almost simultaneously with the birth of the musical.

[21:00] David Armstrong: So the two things are happening sort of like in parallel universes, one down on Second Avenue and the other in Times Square, starting in the 1900s, basically, more or less at the turn of that century. And so these things are happening, and the Gershwins live on Second Avenue and are involved in Yiddish theater, and there's all this interaction between them that's very seldom talked about.

[21:28] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: So you're right, it is crucial to the history and the development of the Broadway musical, and in so many ways, just the way they tell the stories, the way they use the music.

[21:38] David Armstrong: And I often talk about what Jerry Herman does, the Broadway show tune, is what happens when this Jewish tradition of music and this African American tradition of music intersect, and that's what creates the Broadway show tune.

[21:55] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Glorious.

[21:56] David Armstrong: I love that math. We've had so many great conversations this year on the podcast about kind of our family tree of musical theater. Everything from, you know, finally discussing operetta and those roots in Europe to the ones that were created here out of racism and persecution, like minstrelsy.

[22:19] David Armstrong: And then I love this other layer that we haven't discussed, which is the Yiddish theater that's born out of people coming to America in order to express themselves artistically. Like that is part of our history as well.

[22:36] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Something to be proud of.

[22:36] David Armstrong: We see that story vividly in Fiddler on the Roof. At the end of Fiddler on the Roof, Tevye and his family are moving to America, and the youngest girl in that family, I don't remember what the youngest kids' names are.

[22:52] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Oh, wait.

[22:53] David Armstrong: Yes, the little two, the two ones.

[22:55] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: The two, yeah.

[22:56] David Armstrong: Is the same age as Irving Berlin when he arrives in New York at that exact same moment.

[23:01] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Well, buddy.

[23:02] David Armstrong: So that's Irving Berlin comes from Anatevka, basically. Anatevka is a fictional town, but that's the world he's coming from.

[23:10] David Armstrong: And his story is so amazing because he basically arrives in America, completely uneducated, not speaking English, doesn't go past the third grade probably, and invents American culture.

[23:29] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: You know, speaking of a math equation, my gosh, that's crazy.

[23:34] David Armstrong: How does that happen? But that story is told through so many of these creators, and then, you know, Jerry Herman becomes the second generation, or maybe the third generation that this is passed down to that picks up this baton and carries it forward.

[23:50] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: That's great.

[23:51] David Armstrong: Speaking of the end of Fiddler on the Roof, one of the famous lines from that last scene is from Yenta the Matchmaker. They're talking about maybe meeting again in Jerusalem.

[24:05] David Armstrong: And kind of pivoting into Milk and Honey, there is this Jewish tradition of visiting Israel that starts churning up around there. But the history of this country is vast and complex, and it's also the size of New Jersey.

[24:25] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Like that blows my mind.

[24:27] David Armstrong: It blows my mind that there's this tiny little place in the world that is home to some of the greatest miracles and some of the most contentious relationships ever, all within the state of New Jersey.

[24:43] David Armstrong: And of course, Yenta in the movie, A Fiddler on the Roof is Molly Picon, who is the star of Milk and Honey.

[24:50] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: So yeah.

[24:51] David Armstrong: It's Picon, of course, because Picone would be like Latin.

[24:55] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: I think it's peacock.

[24:56] David Armstrong: I don't know. I'm from the Midwest. I say Picon.

[24:58] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah.

[24:59] David Armstrong: Picon.

[25:01] David Armstrong: I actually don't. I think I've always heard it as Molly Picon, but I don't know.

[25:04] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: No, you're probably right.

[25:05] David Armstrong: You're probably right. So to just touch on a little bit of history of Israel, and this is basically Hebrew Bible. We have Abraham, right?

[25:12] David Armstrong: Abraham has two sons. One is Jacob, Jacob and sons, also known as Israel most of the time, as sons and his wives used to call him Dad. And then the other was Esau, is that right?

[25:26] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Now I'm trying to remember from Sunday school days.

[25:28] David Armstrong: And the brothers don't get along. I'm super generalizing this, everybody, but one takes the northern part of Israel and one takes the southern part of Israel.

[25:38] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And so there's always this division of people who are kind of not getting along.

[25:44] David Armstrong: From there, people are always conquering it. I mean, the mountain and the Romans and everybody.

[25:51] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[25:52] David Armstrong: People keep coming in and taking it over. And probably the last group to do that, the Brits.

[25:59] David Armstrong: And one of the guys in charge, I'm not getting the names right, Chancellor, ambassador, somebody from the UK, decides that by creating an independent state of Israel, it's going to buoy the allies and unify them.

[26:15] David Armstrong: So he writes this whole proclamation kind of to move forward the idea of making Israel its own country. So Israel independence doesn't really happen until 19 what, 1940s?

[26:32] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Is that right?

[26:33] David Armstrong: Yeah, after World War II is really the incentive for this, partly because the events of World War II shine a light on this.

[26:42] David Armstrong: And a lot of the first people who move to Israel are Holocaust survivors and are trying to find a place to, the idea of they should have a homeland, the Jews should have their own homeland or return to their homeland, however you want to look at it, becomes a centerpiece.

[27:02] David Armstrong: But it is the founding of the state of Israel that allows, which I think is only like 15 years old when the events of Milk and Honey happen. It's still pretty fresh.

[27:13] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: The idea of celebrating it, I think, is where this producer comes into play.

[27:18] David Armstrong: And I always find that story you told so interesting because he just says, I want to do a show about Israel, about modern Israel, period go, and they have to figure it out.

[27:27] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: So cool.

[27:28] David Armstrong: All that being said, a really interesting place and an incredibly complex place with a lot of history, and yet also surprisingly new in terms of being recognized as an independent nation.

[27:41] David Armstrong: Now, here's the thing, though, everybody. An epic drama, Milk and Honey is not that.

[27:51] David Armstrong: What they came up with was something maybe more along the lines of, oh gosh, Most Happy Fella. Well, of course, Robert Weede is the star of Most Happy Fella, so and is part of it.

[28:05] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Absolutely, and he has one volume left, loud.

[28:09] David Armstrong: And it's a glorious loud. But I would say Most Happy Fella is a much more dramatic story than Milk and Honey.

[28:17] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah, because Jerry Herman's bringing his cheerfulness for to it for sure.

[28:22] David Armstrong: And a lot more dancing.

[28:23] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: There's a lot of dancing in this.

[28:24] David Armstrong: A lot of dancing, which I was amazed just to read the script and see how much dancing there was.

[28:29] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: We read through the script, you and I. Now I have this theory that what we read was maybe written down by an assistant stage manager.

[28:38] David Armstrong: Oh yeah.

[28:39] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Right.

[28:39] David Armstrong: Definitely.

[28:40] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Oh yeah. I love those scripts though, because it tells you everything that happened on beat five, they do that.

[28:45] David Armstrong: No, literally it says the two counts of eight pass by, and then Ari gets up on a rock. You know, like we don't need to know it, but it's there, and I'm grateful for it. I actually love reading those old stage manager scripts.

[28:59] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: That was that used to every script you got used to be like that because they were trying to help amateur groups just recreate what had happened to the book.

[29:08] David Armstrong: Because they're just ideas libretto full of music, and yeah, exactly.

[29:11] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah. And the idea that you're supposed to do something else even in a high school and not recreate what was done on Broadway is a very recent idea that somebody owns those rights.

[29:22] David Armstrong: They were actually trying to help people recreate the show as best they could.

[29:26] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: As a basic protect their own artistic.

[29:28] David Armstrong: As protect their protect the ideas, yeah.

[29:30] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Wow. Do you know what this also reminds me of? Is in going through this show, and look, I went through, I have my BFA of musical theater, everybody. But part of what we do in higher education now is about like what are you bringing to the song and how are you acting through the song?

[29:49] David Armstrong: And this kind of show, this kind of score is from a time period where, like, just sing the song. And if it's a good song, it'll do a lot of the work for you. I feel that way about a lot of Rogers and Hammerstein songs, where it's like, don't try to do stuff with it, because it was written to just be presented in kind of almost an opera way.

[30:13] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: I mean, the opera tradition definitely holds onto this much tighter than we do. But, uh, do you understand what I mean by that?

[30:20] David Armstrong: I do, I do. Uh, it's not that the performers back then didn't act. They acted through the material more than imposing something on the material.

[30:32] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: There it is. Yes, exactly. But I agree with you that this Robert Weede has one volume, he's an opera singer, he was an opera singer, and in this show, he's partnered with another opera singer, Mimi Bissett.

[30:47] David Armstrong: Is that her name?

[30:47] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Uh, who is not my favorite voice.

[30:51] David Armstrong: She's not a Barbara Cook.

[30:53] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah, no, she has a very heavy, uh, wide vibrato kind of voice, which sounds terrific on certain songs, but not so good everywhere else. But it's interesting because I always knew about this show, and we're already diving into it, and people are probably like, what are you even talking about? But I always knew the show as Molly P.

[31:19] David Armstrong: Her show.

[31:20] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah, yeah. Um, but it's not really about her.

[31:23] David Armstrong: Like I'm sorry. She's the star, but it's not about her at all.

[31:29] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah, that's really it is interesting because she doesn't really have a story, and what little story she has, her love story happens at the last minute, like with a character who we only has maybe five lines.

[31:40] David Armstrong: Exactly. Okay, so before anybody else gets confused and stops listening, let's uh, let's actually go through the show because so many of these things are going to come up. So the show begins in Israel.

[31:52] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Go figure. And here's the thing, everybody. If you go to Spotify and you listen and you type in Milk and Honey, and you click on that Jerry Herman original cast album and you look at it, on the cover are three young, gorgeous dancers, very scantily clad, in kind of like a glissade type position in the air with gorgeous pointed feet. What this show is actually about, I have no idea why that is the cover of the show, because what this show is actually about is older people who have all been widowed.

[32:27] David Armstrong: Male aged people, yeah.

[32:28] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Oh, sure, sure, thank you. Um, because they're not old by all means, but they have all kind of come into a similar point in their lives where they're like, I'm no spring chicken, and I think my romantic life is through.

[32:42] David Armstrong: Yeah, they're in their 40s and 50s, which is a lot older in 1960, is much different than a 40 50 year old person today.

[32:52] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah, yeah. Thank God. And so right here at the top of the show, we meet a woman by the name of Ruth, and Ruth has come to Israel, as with the tradition of many people who maybe took Yenta's words, you know, literally, and said next year in Jerusalem, they're coming to Israel to uh connect to their lives. Like this is the trip to Mecca. This is the opportunity to connect to your history.

[33:22] David Armstrong: And it is her and this group of widows, and they're little like pick a little talk little ladies who are now in Israel right around Independence Day. As they're experiencing this new land, Ruth meets this man by the name of Phil.

[33:43] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And Phil is played by Mr. Opera Voice. And he immediately, they immediately have this connection. He has been living there, even though he is not from there, he's been living there for a while with his daughter and her husband. He's starting to like the place so much that he starts to teach her some of the local customs.

[34:05] David Armstrong: The first one being the word shalom and what it means, which, because I'm in Hawaii, immediately shalom immediately reminded me of Aloha, right?

[34:14] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah.

[34:15] David Armstrong: It serves the same function.

[34:16] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah, it's like it's not only uh a way to say hi, it is a spirit through which you interact with people around you.

[34:26] David Armstrong: Right from the get-go, this song is like one of Jerry Herman's best freaking songs.

[34:31] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: It's so amazing. I love Shalom so much.

[34:35] David Armstrong: I agree with you. It's such a beautiful melody, this lilting and that perfect uh marriage of the lyric and the and the and the music together. It's so simple. What Jerry Herman can do is things seem simple, but it's actually really hard to pull that off.

[34:50] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And he doesn't get enough credit for that.

[34:53] David Armstrong: For that it doesn't. Yeah. It's operating from that place of spiritual abundance, milk and honey, if you will. And then also has the sadness. And I think that that's what I think is so gorgeous about Israeli music, or maybe just the Jewish tradition of music, is the inherent sadness in it that makes it beautiful and deep and more than just mindless optimism.

[35:21] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah.

[35:22] David Armstrong: There's always this, absolutely. It's a scale, it has its own scale, which is not the same as the Western scale that we're used to.

[35:30] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And I'm trying to think what the name of that scale is.

[35:33] David Armstrong: I don't know. It'll come to me in a minute. I do know, but because I teach it, but I some people call it the Jewish mode, is what some musicians will refer to it as. And it's what is part of what I was talking about before. The Jewish mode and the blues scale are very, very similar.

[35:53] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And it's part of why I think Jewish musicians and African American musicians, black musicians, felt this affinity toward, and it's what brought this connection to.

[36:05] David Armstrong: Exactly, is because it sounded like what they were used to. It just was a little different. There's an incredible podcast called There's an incredible podcast I highly recommend called or a radio show that you can listen to called uh blues and Jews. And on that podcast, they play examples of Jewish, early Jewish music, uh, like a uh uh a cantor in in a synagogue performing, and then very early recordings of like black sharecroppers, uh early early blues, the early, and they're almost identical.

[36:42] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Oh wow.

[36:43] David Armstrong: In the and you just hear the connection between them. But in any event, I think there's this affinity that happens between it, which is what makes the show tune again.

[36:51] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Wow, that's so cool. Um I want to say one thing though, please because I agree with you that right off the bat, Jerry Herman, in his first Broadway show as a 29-year-old or however old he was, is just hitting it out of the park. And it even happens with the overture before that, which I think the overture is really exciting and really thrilling. I've never been the type of person that's like, oh, I miss the overtures. But when I listen to this one or shows like this, I'm like, yeah, it really does have a place.

[37:21] David Armstrong: And what you said earlier about him being able to match lyric to music so well, you listen to the overture, and you can tell which song is going to have the words milk and honey before you even hear the song being sung. You can hear the orchestra literally singing milk and honey.

[37:39] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: You it's it's a beautiful match. Anyway, I interrupted your story.

[37:44] David Armstrong: No, no, that's literally what the show is about is about interrupting the story to uh to bring context and tears. So the so out of shalom, lots of dancing for Independence Day. I mean, we're really kind of going into a Rogers and Hammerstein type opportunity of bringing a culture and transporting the audience to a foreign quote unquote place.

[38:12] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: That feels very strong in the show as well. Also very much in that mode, I think in the Agnes de Mille mode of this the choreographer here is Donald Sadler. But I was surprised at how much dancing there was in the show and how much of it seemed to be not dream ballets, but dances that we're expressing emotion, expressing telling the story, especially in the term in regard to the character of David, who is the son-in-law of uh Phil.

[38:42] David Armstrong: Yeah, uh, me too. And uh, and we'll talk more about that because we gotta talk about Tommy Rall.

[38:47] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah. As these two people, as Phil and Ruth are getting to know each other, we learn that Ruth's husband was a famous symphony conductor.

[39:00] David Armstrong: Like even Phil.

[39:01] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Leonard Bernstein or something, yeah, sure.

[39:03] David Armstrong: Yeah. Has heard of him.

[39:05] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And everybody in the place heard of him, it seems like.

[39:08] David Armstrong: He's famous.

[39:09] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah. Very famous. He has passed away, he has passed on. Phil's wife, and we will find this out later, still alive, still kicking. They are still married, and she is living in France. It seems like they've just drifted apart and have very little relationship left. But at the same time, she absolutely refuses to give him a divorce.

[39:31] David Armstrong: And look, everybody, we're trouncing into black ketchup territory, if you know what I mean. So, David, in case you don't know, I use the term black ketchup to refer to my great grandma who had these bottles, these condiment bottles in her basement, because she was certain that they were still good and usable, even though the ketchup had turned black. She's like, it's fine, you know, like it was that generation of not recognizing that it's time to throw something away because they wanted to hold on to it so dearly. And I have used that to talk about some of our musicals that probably don't need to be produced nowadays for various reasons.

[40:12] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And Milk and Honey, unfortunately, has a lot of those types of plot lines where it just probably wouldn't be relevant to an audience right now.

[40:20] David Armstrong: Uh, I don't understand why this evil woman in France wouldn't want to give her husband that she wants nothing to do with uh a divorce.

[40:31] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Uh, I don't understand why everyone's so obsessed with getting married, you know, these things will probably keep it from being produced again.

[40:39] David Armstrong: Well, and of course it's happening right at the dawn of the women's liberation movement.

[40:45] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Exactly. And if you read, I'm reading Mary Rogers' book right now. Uh, and it's interesting that she talks about the same period in the same way, and she's how obsessed she was about being married and finding a man. It's just part of what's going on in the world at this time. We're coming out of the 50s, but we're still in the 50s, really. It's in the early 60s. It's a really interesting period of time.

[41:10] David Armstrong: And this Broadway season, 61 to 62, is one of my favorites because when we look at what came to Broadway in terms of musical theater this year. You had How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying, I Can Get It for You Wholesale, Subways Are for Sleeping, all of which are kind of intellectual commentaries on American life. You've got gorgeous lush scores like Milk and Honey. You've got No Strings, which is pushing the boundaries in terms of multiracial relationships, and Diane Carroll becomes the first black woman to win a Tony Award for best leading actress in a musical. It's really this interesting push and pull.

[42:06] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah.

[42:07] David Armstrong: But you're right. A lot of it is not actually producible. Addressing, well, even like No Strings, it has this interracial love story at the center of it, but there's no conflict about it being an interracial love story.

[42:20] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: That's it's not what you expect it to be when you think we're gonna go back, we're gonna look at this show from 1962 or whatever it was, and this interracial romance, they don't address it, it's just taken for granted in a way.

[42:34] David Armstrong: But I think it's because they're avoiding the conflict.

[42:36] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah, it was enough to just even get it on the stage.

[42:40] David Armstrong: Exactly. And it was shocking, I'm sure, to see it, but they didn't need to talk about it, I guess.

[42:46] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah. In terms of the women expected to be married, they expected to be an adjunct to their husband, and to not be that was to not fulfill your destiny as a woman.

[43:00] David Armstrong: Yeah. So I think it's just we don't agree with that today, but it doesn't mean that wasn't what they believed at the time.

[43:09] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah, they believed it wholeheartedly.

[43:11] David Armstrong: Exactly. Yeah, one of Ruth's friends, here comes Molly P, is named Clara, who is basically like a Jewish Dolly Levi.

[43:24] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Like she's what Barbara Streisand was doing in the movie.

[43:30] David Armstrong: Only 20 years older.

[43:32] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Exactly. And she has her husband is Jaime, she lost Jaime, and he was just like this perfect husband.

[43:40] David Armstrong: And she is really interested in Ruth connecting with Phil, and she encourages her to go with him to I guess it's kind of up north, where his daughter, who's named Barbara, and Barbara's husband David, all kind of are working as farmers.

[44:02] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And so Ruth agrees to go for the weekend and kind of get to know them. In that area, in addition to David and Barbara, the daughter and son-in-law, is this guy by the name of Adi, I believe is how you say his name.

[44:19] David Armstrong: Yeah, I've been thinking of it.

[44:21] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Adi is about to be a father. His girlfriend, because they're not married yet, is about to have a baby.

[44:28] David Armstrong: So they are planning to get married.

[44:31] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: He, however, is not happy with living there in the farm and represents this other voice in Milk and Honey, which is the one that I don't know, that's a little voice of dissent and reality that's everything is not quite so perfect here.

[44:49] David Armstrong: There's this is it, we're in the middle of a desert and we're surrounded. This is the only sort of political aspect to the show, which I think is also why it's not so interesting to us today, is that they don't deal with the politics of the time except in this little bit of commentary that he has about we're you know, we're surrounded by people who hate us, and there's danger here as well.

[45:14] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: He's always trying to get his girlfriend to eat Hershey bars so that the sun will come out being attuned to westernized type things, and hopefully want to live in a city with near a hospital and you know those sorts of ideas.

[45:29] David Armstrong: Yeah. And this is a group of farmers who are working together to settle the land, who to they're still working to create the country of Israel by doing this. Water is very scarce.

[45:41] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah, they're in the middle of a desert.

[45:45] David Armstrong: Yeah. To a certain extent. And the whole the land is and I that commentary that Jerry Herman put in was very, very smart.

[45:52] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And he talked about that too. He wrote the song Milk and Honey, and he thought, well, this is great. This is like an anthem. This could be the commercial for Israel.

[46:01] David Armstrong: But I know.

[46:02] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: But then he said, that that's not the whole story. I need to add some dissent. I need to show the other side of this.

[46:09] David Armstrong: So you've got to be a good idea.

[46:09] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Which he does very effectively.

[46:11] David Armstrong: Yeah, and a little counter melody, which is actually funny and pointed at the same time.

[46:17] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah. He points out all the this is not exactly heaven on earth.

[46:22] David Armstrong: Yeah. For anybody who thinks that Jerry Herman is all optimism all the time, right?

[46:27] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Don't go away. Broadway Nation will be back right after this quick break.

[46:32] David Armstrong: All of this is being told throughout the show through dance as well. This working the land, laying like laying down pipes in the stage direction.

[46:42] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: So many pipes.

[46:44] David Armstrong: But it's all done through dance. It's very and you look at the pictures of that and you see them holding these big pipes, and obviously they were using them as part of the choreography, they were using them and the stories that they're laying pipes, I assume to irrigate the land is what's happening.

[46:59] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: To bring water to the land.

[47:02] David Armstrong: But Donald Sadler turns that into dance storytelling.

[47:07] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And also in the process, and I don't think this is an accident, puts a bunch of really hunky shirtless guys on stage in very, very short shorts.

[47:18] David Armstrong: If you look at those pictures.

[47:22] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Well, this is cool though. I'm glad we're talking about this because if you just read the script, like I did, and maybe that's why my brain is there, the amount that being widowed, that getting married, that all of this like relationship drama is talked about is almost exhausting.

[47:39] David Armstrong: But you add to it this storytelling because, like you said, they're not really willing to talk about the political statements, but here they are being staged.

[47:49] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: These people in a very Oklahoma way are trying to settle the land, are trying to tame it or at least work with it to find a place to live.

[48:00] David Armstrong: And does it make you stronger and tanner and a little oily?

[48:03] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah.

[48:04] David Armstrong: And that's okay too.

[48:08] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: I don't know if you've looked at the pictures, but the beefcake aspect of the show just sort of jumps out at you in a way that you don't expect.

[48:15] David Armstrong: Yeah. The cover work on Spotify, that's what I'm saying.

[48:18] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Like that's what they're using to sell it, exactly.

[48:20] David Armstrong: They are selling it with sex.

[48:23] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And I'm really interested to see what the audiences were actually feeling like the story gave them. Maybe they walked away just being like, weren't those dancers gorgeous? You know, I don't know.

[48:35] David Armstrong: Well, but even Molly Picon's character has a moment where she's surrounded by the shirtless boys and she talks about that.

[48:41] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: She says to that.

[48:43] David Armstrong: Yeah, she so there, it's definitely something they were aware of.

[48:47] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: That's so cute. I love it.

[48:50] David Armstrong: She gets all sort of hot and bothered by it.

[48:52] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah. She has a great song here in the first act called Chin Up Ladies.

[48:57] David Armstrong: I mean, just a perfect Jerry Herman song that I didn't know at all, to be honest, and it's great.

[49:04] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: It's great. She's so fun. If people, listeners, you may not realize that we have already talked about Molly P like back back in the day, we talked about Minnie's Boys, and she was subscribed to be the Shelley Winters role.

[49:18] David Armstrong: I mean, that's who they actually wanted to play, the mother of the Marx brothers.

[49:22] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: So, anyway, she's an incredible comedic talent and also got she's got a great voice, great actor.

[49:28] David Armstrong: Well, and what we appreciate today is that she was a giant star in the Yiddish theater. She did dozens from childhood on.

[49:37] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: She was somebody that they created shows around.

[49:41] David Armstrong: She has dozens of Yiddish theater musicals that are written just for her as vehicles to show off all her talents, which apparently were many.

[49:52] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: It's frustrating because you can't really see we don't have a lot of evidence of that.

[49:56] David Armstrong: And she has a lot of dance breaks in this. Like it talks about her doing can can kicks and all sorts of things.

[50:03] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: She has two at least two big giant dance features in the middle of these of the of the of each act of the show, and that struck me as well.

[50:11] David Armstrong: It's like, wow, they've designed this show to show off Molly Picon's dancing, which I didn't who knew that I don't know much about.

[50:19] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Who knew that that was part of what her bag of tricks was, but basically that if you went to see her, you expected her to dance.

[50:25] David Armstrong: Wow.

[50:26] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And it was one of the things of the Yiddish stars, almost all the Yiddish stars were triple threats.

[50:31] David Armstrong: And I think maybe that idea came from there.

[50:33] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: They sang, they danced, they acted, they were comedians, they did all men and women. That was just expected that that's what they would be able to do.

[50:41] David Armstrong: That's beautiful. I love that. What a great tradition to bring to musical theater because we have another true, true, 100% triple threat in the show, Tommy Rall.

[50:50] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: He's the one who's playing the son-in-law, David.

[50:53] David Armstrong: And I always knew him as a dancer because, like in my flop book, they would always talk about the musical Juno and how Tommy Rall had this amazing dance solo in this flop musical that it was one of the most incredible things you've ever seen in musical theater that few people saw in musical theater.

[51:11] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And so I always thought of him as a dancer, and then I listened to this him singing the song in the second act, what is that called, I Will Follow You.

[51:18] David Armstrong: And this voice and the title song, yeah, exactly, Milk and Honey.

[51:23] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And a true trained tenor on top of it all.

[51:27] David Armstrong: Speaking of Marvin Streisand, he is the prince in Swan Lake.

[51:32] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Exactly.

[51:33] David Armstrong: So I wrote down he was in nine Broadway shows.

[51:37] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And in those shows, and he starts as a dancer as a chorus boy, basically, as a dancer.

[51:41] David Armstrong: He dances for Jerome Robbins, he dances for Gower Champion, he dances for Agnes DeMille, multiple shows with Jerome Robbins.

[51:47] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: So he's the real deal dancer, which of course we can then see in the movies.

[51:53] David Armstrong: Because he did a lot of dancing in the movies.

[51:55] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Star dancing.

[51:56] David Armstrong: He's in the he plays Bill Calhoun in the movie Kiss Me Kate phenomenally.

[52:02] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And my favorite clip of his, he's also in Seven Brides for Seven Brothers.

[52:06] David Armstrong: Oh, the guys.

[52:08] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And but my favorite clip is there's a clip with him and Bob Fosse doing this incredible duet in Give a Girl a Break, which is one of the greatest pieces of dancing you will ever see.

[52:18] David Armstrong: It's a challenge dance between Tommy Rall and Bob Fosse.

[52:22] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And it is staggeringly good.

[52:25] David Armstrong: Okay.

[52:25] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: In a not very good movie.

[52:27] David Armstrong: Most people won't know it because you, but you can find it easily on YouTube.

[52:30] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: It's yeah.

[52:31] David Armstrong: Okay, definitely sharing that with everybody. Thank you for the recommendation.

[52:34] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: But you're right. And he sings very well in those movies.

[52:39] David Armstrong: But I had even in those movies, you don't know that he's gonna sing like this, like a very legit incredible sound.

[52:50] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: It was quite amazing.

[52:53] David Armstrong: And yes, that is exactly right. Tommy Rall can sing almost as well.

[52:57] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Sing pretty comparably to Robert Weede, exactly.

[53:01] David Armstrong: Incredible. Go Tommy Rall, a true pioneer.

[53:04] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And so handsome, and so and very, very if you watch him in Kiss Me Kate around these movies, he's great, he's terrific, holding his own in the comedy scenes with Ann Miller and all that kind of stuff.

[53:16] David Armstrong: So at the end of the first act, amidst all of the hunky dancing and laying pipe, which just sounds X-rated.

[53:25] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: We've got we get to this wedding, this gorgeous, very traditional wedding.

[53:31] David Armstrong: And what happens is Phil asks Ruth to stay, and finally tells her that he's married.

[53:39] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah, which is like the basis of all the drama for the rest of the show.

[53:43] David Armstrong: Is can she feel good about staying with this man marrying him here religiously, but not like necessarily legally, because he will still be married to this woman in France.

[53:56] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Does that make sense?

[53:57] David Armstrong: Anyway, yeah, no, I think that's exactly right. They go, but they go to this wedding of Adi and his pregnant girlfriend, who I can't remember her name.

[54:07] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: I feel bad.

[54:08] David Armstrong: Who are not married?

[54:09] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: She's pregnant, nine months pregnant, and they're just getting married now.

[54:14] David Armstrong: Exactly. Nobody seems to have a problem with it, by the way.

[54:16] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: No, it's very interesting.

[54:17] David Armstrong: The sexual politics of the show are very confused in that way because this seems to be something that they and they say it's that's it's not a big deal here.

[54:25] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: We didn't even need to get married, but we're going to.

[54:28] David Armstrong: Phil's song then goes into the wedding sequence, and it gives me chills just thinking about it.

[54:41] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: This is some of the best musical writing of anything in this Broadway season.

[54:47] David Armstrong: Yeah. It's a wonderful sequence.

[54:49] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: It's an incredible sequence. I highly recommend everybody at least listen to it once because you just don't hear stuff like this every day.

[54:56] David Armstrong: And that song starts a Jerry Herman tradition, I think, which is this idea really made me think of Kiss Her Now from Dear World.

[55:07] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: This we only have this moment, do not let this moment pass by when it's a very good thing.

[55:11] David Armstrong: It only takes a moment there before the parade passes by.

[55:15] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: I you we have to do this now.

[55:17] David Armstrong: Now, now, now don't waste a moment.

[55:20] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: It's lit is interesting that that's becomes a theme through his shows.

[55:23] David Armstrong: Yeah, that's so what I thought was fascinating, which you won't you only know from reading the script, is this sequence culminates with Phil and Ruth going up the stairs to bed.

[55:36] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah he's not pressuring her in any way, but they have come to she has made her peace with I love this man and we're going to, and this is what we're gonna do.

[55:45] David Armstrong: Which I thought was really interesting that the curtain falls on this leaving the wedding to go to the wheel.

[55:52] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: This wedding juxtaposed with them going up to have sex.

[55:58] David Armstrong: I'm not sure exactly what we're supposed to feel about that, whether that's supposed to be a positive or a negative in terms of the way they felt about it at the time.

[56:07] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: You know, are we ending on a crises or ending on a as an upending or a down ending?

[56:12] David Armstrong: I wasn't sure.

[56:13] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Me either, because uh you I get the feeling that we're supposed to feel like, oh, what's gonna happen? Is she gonna be okay with this?

[56:19] David Armstrong: But uh once again, social politics are so different now.

[56:24] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: I yeah, there's not a lot of it.

[56:27] David Armstrong: Well, and actually in the second act, she does have she's she is not at peace with it.

[56:33] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Oh, she runs away in the next scene.

[56:36] David Armstrong: Yeah, literally the first scene in the second act. By the way, Barbara has this whole meltdown too of like the idea of Ruth staying with her father in Israel, like triggers her into this whole meltdown of how much she hates being there.

[56:53] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And which I thought was really not prepared for at all.

[56:56] David Armstrong: No, it feels like it comes out of nowhere.

[56:59] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: But like she just seemed like she loved Israel, she loved being there until all of a sudden she doesn't.

[57:04] David Armstrong: Yeah.

[57:04] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Now, maybe in their acting that we got uh maybe that that just isn't on the page, but was there in the show.

[57:12] David Armstrong: Yeah, I don't think so. I think uh we just we I just think that Barbara seems like a really confusing character.

[57:20] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: But yeah, I I I do think that they maybe wanted another voice of dissent of of also maybe doubt that goes into Ruth's mind because right at the beginning of Act Two, Ruth decides, like she's out.

[57:33] David Armstrong: Phil's like, Ruth, Ruth, where are you? And she's gone, and Barbara's like, yeah, she left. She's gone to Tel Aviv, the big city, with her group of widow friends.

[57:42] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: In Tel Aviv, Phil finds Ruth. I don't know how he finds her in this huge city, but they find each other and uh have kind of the discussion that you would expect.

[57:51] David Armstrong: It's not very interesting. But what is interesting is our favorite Molly, aka Clara, favorite Molly Pinds this new guy, his name's Saul, short for Solomon, and she suddenly has this uh possibility to have love, and so she sings a song called Him to Hime, in which she has it out with her dead husband to see if maybe in a Dolly Levi sort of way, she can get his permission to get married again.

[58:22] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah, the parallels of talking to Ephraim and asking him to let her go are so clear, yeah.

[58:29] David Armstrong: Yeah, but almost carbon copy.

[58:31] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah, except that Jar Herman hasn't written the Hello Dolly yet, and I'm not I I don't know how even how aware he was of the matchmaker at this point, which is comes from the matchmaker.

[58:43] David Armstrong: So whether this was just I I know it's hard to say. And of course, Jerry Herman is very influenced by his mother, who is probably contemporary with Molly Picon. Many of his characters and many of the things that he writes are inspired by his mother.

[59:02] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: He always talks about open a new or um uh it's today was her expression. She had a she came home one day from school and she had a party laid out, and he said, Why are we having the party? And she said, It's today. And he so he would draw, he drew on this stuff throughout his life. It's very interesting.

[59:19] David Armstrong: I so I wonder how much of this character is inspired by his own mother. Because once again, this show comes out of their trip to Israel, Jerry Herman's and the and the book writers. They it's one of the few shows that's not based on source material, yeah.

[59:38] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah, which is partly maybe why it's structurally not too sound.

[59:43] David Armstrong: Exactly, because it's I always say it's really hard to write a story, almost impossible to create a really effective story, and it's really hard to write a musical. And if you put those two things together, you are you you probably will not succeed. And most shows that were not based on source material have not succeeded.

[1:00:03] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Great point. I will also go ahead and say that I think that this is miraculous. I think the fact that he was able to write such a compelling widowed character, and that David Merrick showed up and saw it. I I can't help but see the blueprint of God or the universe or whatever you want to say, laying the groundwork to say this guy needs to write Hello Dolly and Change the World.

[1:00:29] David Armstrong: When of course David Merrick is already optioned the matchmaker to turn into a musical. So I you have to, it's not hard to imagine him sitting in the theater seeing him and going, oh, that's talking to Ephraim. Yeah, this is it. This is the guy.

[1:00:44] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: So whether Jerry Herman made the connection or not, Jerry or David Merrick seems to have, yeah.

[1:00:51] David Armstrong: Yeah. And uh and I think that's pretty inspired. But it's a pretty great piece of uh special material. I mean, he's really adept at writing to Molly Picon's strengths, but he clearly knows how to write for a star.

[1:01:06] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Clearly, that's a great way of saying it. He knows how to write for a star. Give her what she's needs to do.

[1:01:12] David Armstrong: What she needs to do is to say yes to Saul, who also just happens to be a sweet little man who is in diamonds and has a fortune. So uh Molly P and uh Saul get married. And the end of the show, which just happens so so fast, is that Phil realizes it would be wrong for Ruth to live with him without him getting a divorce first.

[1:01:40] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: So he at the airport is about ready to go to France to ask his wife for a divorce. Um Ruth hopes that they will be able to come together in the future. And that's it.

[1:01:55] David Armstrong: I mean, that's kind of it, right?

[1:01:57] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Well, it yeah, it definitely hangs on what maybe felt more compelling at the time of they are in love, they're committed to each other, and he's gonna go and make it happen. Somehow he's gonna get this divorce and make it happen so they can finally be together.

[1:02:12] David Armstrong: Do you think that he does?

[1:02:13] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: I don't I look, I still don't understand why the French woman doesn't want to give him a divorce. So I say I'm I'm thinking that this is gonna be no problem.

[1:02:24] David Armstrong: Yeah, I think it implies that he will because he's our hero, he will do whatever it takes to get that divorce, and they will eventually be together. But it is interesting that the show ends on this note of question mark?

[1:02:40] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Big question mark, exactly. It ends with a question mark will or will they not get together?

[1:02:45] David Armstrong: Yeah. It's a really interesting show that I think if we're looking at you know, cultural significance, brings Israel to the forefront of musical theater, like we talked about for one of the first times. It puts Jerry Herman on a Broadway stage writing about widows that will ultimately pay off big time in Hello Dolly. And then there are these really glorious pieces of just musical magic.

[1:03:11] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And when I look back and think of the things that I wish I could have seen in this show, I'm gonna say Molly Picon for sure would have loved to see her do her thing because they created room for it everywhere throughout the show.

[1:03:27] David Armstrong: And then there is this one sequence that we didn't talk about, which is when David, you know, after Barbara, the daughter has her meltdown about not liking being in this desert farmland. David, her husband, says, Okay, well then let's leave because I want you to be happy. And she's like, No, I would never ask you to do that. And he said, No, I I feel like it's my responsibility. And so then she leaves, and there's this whole dance sequence in which Tommy Rall like comes to terms with how deeply he feels the need to be a farmer and to be working this land, and the pull between that and becoming a businessman in America and how that preys on his identity and he dances it all out.

[1:04:13] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And I would have loved to have seen that. I would have loved, love, loved to have seen that.

[1:04:17] David Armstrong: I agree with you. And reading that description, you just go, I want to see how they did this. What what the he dances his emotions?

[1:04:23] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: He he he which is interesting because that's what he got acclaimed for in Juneau was a very similar dance piece of dance as emotional therapy or something.

[1:04:35] David Armstrong: Yeah.

[1:04:36] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah.

[1:04:37] David Armstrong: But I'm confused. What happened? What did they end up doing?

[1:04:40] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: I I don't no one knows. Does he stay or does she go? Does what's the end of their story?

[1:04:45] David Armstrong: I what I was not clear about that from the case.

[1:04:48] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Nor was I. I I that's why I said the ending happens so quickly, because who knows?

[1:04:54] David Armstrong: Yeah.

[1:04:54] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: It sounds like they're staying, but I I don't know if they're gonna be in the city, like if they're moving to Tel Aviv or if they're staying in the farm because Phil was going to build a house and then he stopped building the house.

[1:05:09] David Armstrong: Well, that's what that's what I mean. Like I don't know if they continued working that land up there because that there was a project and then it got you know paused so that he could go to France.

[1:05:11] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: I don't know.

[1:05:21] David Armstrong: Yeah, it that that part was a little confusing. Again, maybe something happened physically that we don't that's not on the page but is is there. But I would love to go back and see Tommy Rall in that show because it seems like a Broadway star that we just don't talk about. And even though we see him in movies and he's fantastic, he doesn't get talked about much there either.

[1:05:42] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: No, it's true. The other thing I would love to go back and see is when Molly Picon went away to make a movie, Hermione Gingold replaced her.

[1:05:53] David Armstrong: That's right.

[1:05:55] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Which I can't quite imagine.

[1:05:57] David Armstrong: But that seems like a completely different type, right?

[1:06:01] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yes, although this is a good one. She's like Lee Zons.

[1:06:04] David Armstrong: No, that's true. That is true. This is Hermione Gingold, you know.

[1:06:07] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: I guess although it's a decade before Little.

[1:06:10] David Armstrong: But she, if you think of her in Gigi, she we've she's already established because that what you that's the 50s.

[1:06:16] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Yeah.

[1:06:17] David Armstrong: So it's post-Gigi.

[1:06:19] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: It just feels vocally a bit rangy for Hermione.

[1:06:23] David Armstrong: And does she kick up her heels as you know in that way? Did they read they revise that?

[1:06:29] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: I don't know.

[1:06:30] David Armstrong: Yeah, do they lift her up into a giant lift at the end of the number?

[1:06:34] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: But she looks pretty great. There's some pictures of some publicity photos of her, not in the show, but like pre-publicity.

[1:06:40] David Armstrong: Around that time around that of the her with the other stars. That's uh, which are she looks like should be fun, but it would be I would love to be able to go back and see that.

[1:06:50] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: And so this was a hit. Like we're here we are kind of talking about it as something that's not producible anymore, but it was uh it ran.

[1:06:57] David Armstrong: Yeah, it ran 545 performances.

[1:07:00] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: That's great, which is you know, modest but but successful. Apparently, it didn't entirely make back its investment, but it was a successful show.

[1:07:10] David Armstrong: There's no that was it was a hit.

[1:07:12] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: That's really great. David, this has been so much fun. Thank you so much for talking me through it.

[1:07:15] David Armstrong: My pleasure.

[1:07:18] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: You are a fount of knowledge, but also I can tell how much you love it. You love the actual art form, which I think is even more important than knowing everything about it.

[1:07:28] David Armstrong: Absolutely. It's only interesting to me because I love it so much. I mean, that's what that's what makes it fascinating. And the same thing with you. I that's why I do, as you said at the beginning, I think our there's a kinship between our two podcasts, because we are looking to the often looking to the past of Broadway and trying to really deeply understand it, but also celebrate it to a great extent.

[1:07:51] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Agreed. Here's some more. As always, if you have recommendations for shows you'd like us to cover on a musical theater podcast, you can always email me at a musicalpodcast at gmail.com.

[1:08:02] David Armstrong: And don't forget to follow us on social media. We're on Instagram and Twitter at a musical podcast. We're also on TikTok. We've got Patreon exclamation point, where for only one dollar a month you can receive bonus content on top of supporting the regular show.

[1:08:17] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: We have the Tea Public store where the profits we get from those great designs will go to Broadway Cares Equity Fights AIDS. What else do we have?

[1:08:26] David Armstrong: We have our playlists on Spotify. We have a holiday one that just uh came out. We announced that on social media, so go ahead and listen to that.

[1:08:35] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Uh, since it's the end of the year, it's the last episode of the year. I want to give a shout out to Michael Willett for doing our theme music and our artwork. Uh, he's the best.

[1:08:45] David Armstrong: And shout out to all of you. Thank you so much for being a part of this wonderful 2022. I'm really, really pleased with what we were able to do this year and talk about and explore. And it wouldn't be possible without you.

[1:08:58] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: So love you lots. Thanks for being part of this podcasting community.

[1:09:02] David Armstrong: Hey, David, tell us about your show. How do we follow you?

[1:09:05] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Follow it. Uh, the show is called Broadway Nation. You can find it on the Broadway Podcast Network and everywhere that podcasts are found. And you can also uh connect with me on uh we have a big Facebook group, more than 2,000 members on Facebook. People very passionate about musical theater, uh connected to the podcast.

[1:09:26] David Armstrong: Uh you and also you can find it, find me on Instagram and Twitter as well.

[1:09:31] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: David, you're the best. Have a wonderful holiday.

[1:09:35] David Armstrong: Merry Christmas.

[1:09:36] Jeffrey Scott Parsons: Merry Christmas, happy holidays to you and everybody out there. Remember Shalom.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred