Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 127: Private Lives, Gertrude Lawrence & The Lives of Lives of Noel Coward, part 3

This is the third part of my interview with Oliver Soden author of the truly extraordinary new book MASQUERADE — THE LIVES OF NOEL COWARD... Read More

From the show: BROADWAY NATION

53 mins
11/23/23

Guests

Featured Shows

About

This is the third part of my interview with Oliver Soden author of the truly extraordinary new book MASQUERADE — THE LIVES OF NOEL COWARD.

In this episode we discuss Noel Coward’s life and career during the 1930s including what has become his most produced play Private Lives, his spectacular patriotic anti-war pageant Cavalcade, and his final musical revue, Words And Music (which was titled Set To Music on Broadway.) And most especially his relationship with the great Gertrude Lawrence.

If you missed the first two episodes you may want to catch up with those before embarking on this one.

Oliver Sodon is a writer and broadcaster whose previous books include the critically acclaimed 2019 biography of composer Michael Tippett. Oliver’s writing on art, music and literature has appeared in the Guardian, Spectator, London Review of Books, and the Times Literary supplement, and he is a frequent guest speaker on BBC radio and television broadcasts.

Noel Coward was without a doubt one of the most remarkable figures of the 20th Century and as you will hear Oliver and I had a great time talking about him. And it will be my pleasure to share that conversation with you over the next several episodes.

Become a PATRON of Broadway Nation!

This episode is made possible in part through the generous support of our Patron Club members.

If you would like to help support the work of Broadway Nation I will information at the end of the podcast about how you too can become a Patron.

If you are a fan ofBroadway Nation, I invite you too to become a PATRON!

For a just $7.00 a month you will receive exclusive access to never-before-heard, unedited versions of many of the discussions that I have with my guests — in fact I often record nearly twice as much conversation as ends up in the edited versions. You will also have access to additional in-depth conversations with my frequent co-host Albert Evans that have not been featured on the podcast.

All patrons receive special “on-air” shout-outs and acknowledgement of your vital support of this podcast. And if you are very enthusiastic about Broadway Nation there are additional PATRON levels that come with even more benefits.

If you would like to support the work of Broadway Nation and receive these exclusive member benefits, please just click on this link:

https://broadwaynationpodcast.supercast.tech/

Thank you in advance for your support!

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:28] David Armstrong: Welcome to another episode of Broadway Nation, a podcast that tells the remarkable story of how immigrants, Jews, queers, African Americans, and other outcasts invented the Broadway musical and how they changed America in the process.

[0:44] David Armstrong: I'm David Armstrong, and my guest again this week is Oliver Soden, the author of an amazing new book titled Masquerade: The Lives of Noel Coward.

[0:55] David Armstrong: Critics have hailed this book as a brilliant new biography, illuminating, sympathetic, and riveting, as well as a captivating biography by an emerging literary star.

[1:07] David Armstrong: This is the third part of our conversation, and if you missed the first two episodes, you may want to catch up with those before listening to this one.

[1:14] David Armstrong: Here we go.

[1:16] David Armstrong: Welcome back, Oliver Soden.

[1:18] Oliver Soden: Yes.

[1:24] Oliver Soden: Yes, that was true. Last week there was a reconstruction of Coward's first review, London Calling, A Hundred Years and a Month On from the Premier in the very same theater in the West End.

[1:36] Oliver Soden: It was a little bit frightening for a non-professional actor to go on stage and talk about Coward to a sold-out audience, but it went terribly well.

[1:44] Oliver Soden: And the best thing was that the actual material, the sketches that Coward wrote, which I had only ever read on the page, stood up so well. They were so funny, especially in the hands of actors such as Damien Lewis and Indira Vama.

[1:58] Oliver Soden: But it was a great afternoon. The music was presented as well, yes.

[2:03] David Armstrong: Was it the whole show or was it sort of a capsule version?

[2:06] Oliver Soden: Oh, much shortened. I mean, the thing about these reviews is that they were through well over three hours. You know, they were huge evenings.

[2:13] Oliver Soden: We only had an hour before Andrew Scott was itching to come onto the set and perform his one-man show of Uncle Vanya, so we had to clear out pretty quick.

[2:21] Oliver Soden: So we got edited highlights and the most famous, most endearing songs, Parisian Piero, the most famous really.

[2:40] Oliver Soden: It was a great success. So at the end of our previous episode, Noel was in New York for the American premiere of Bittersweet, just as the stock market came crashing down.

[2:51] David Armstrong: And I love that quote you include in your book where he says people were hurling themselves off the buildings like confetti.

[2:58] Oliver Soden: Yes, there's a certain dramatic license on Coward's part there, because although that was the rumor that bankers were sort of falling from the top floors of skyscrapers, it seems that that was something of an exaggeration and that that didn't entirely happen.

[3:13] Oliver Soden: But New York on the day of the Wall Street crash, and to a lesser extent Boston, was a rather terrifying place to be with the news sort of being called down the avenues and businessmen selling off their Rolls-Royces for ready cash and sleeping the night in gymnasia and so on, because they didn't want to go home and miss any of the news.

[3:30] Oliver Soden: It's amazing how that urban legend has survived, but it's so evocative of what was going on at the time.

[3:36] Oliver Soden: But Coward's own money was safe because of the investments that Jack Wilson had made.

[3:41] David Armstrong: Yes, or um the phrase in the letter is that Jack had invested all of Coward's money, which was considerable by that stage, in gold plated securities, and somehow he managed not to lose anything, which gave him a trust in Jack Wilson's financial acumen that was to get him into hot water a decade or so later.

[4:00] Oliver Soden: So it had its damage, this sense that Wilson knew exactly what he was doing. But even before this, don't you include a letter, or maybe it was a poem that he wrote to Jack Wilson, indicating that he already knew that Jack Wilson was siphoning money away?

[4:15] Oliver Soden: Yes.

[4:16] Oliver Soden: Yes, it is a poem written about and to Jack Wilson. And as so often Coward is disguising some quite serious and unhappy accusations within a jokey rhyming couplet.

[4:27] Oliver Soden: He calls Wilson a predatory louse stealing money from Popper's house. Popper was Wilson's nickname for Coward.

[4:34] Oliver Soden: Whether or not it's sort of real embezzlement or simply Wilson who would not have necessarily had a particularly lucrative career without Coward's own talent and earning power, simply using Coward's money as if they were a single financial unit and enjoying quite a luxurious life off Coward's earnings. That's quite hard to know.

[4:51] Oliver Soden: But I think Wilson let Coward's money run through his fingers like water, certainly. It's rather hard to know what to think about Jack Wilson.

[5:00] Oliver Soden: Certainly he ends up having a substantial career of his own, so he must have had some real talent.

[5:06] Oliver Soden: Yeah, that's true. As a producer and as a director, I mean actually a stage director, of some quite notable performances, but also of the plays that eventually become rivals to Coward's own comedies.

[5:19] Oliver Soden: So he starts working on plays by Terence Rattigan and Christopher Fry, just at a time when Coward, this is later, after the Second World War, is going out of fashion. So this causes friction.

[5:29] Oliver Soden: When the storm loves a riding rule, when the sky sail away, sail away.

[5:40] Oliver Soden: When the love light is hailing in your sweet heart. Sail away.

[5:51] Oliver Soden: When you feel your son is orchestrated wrong. Why should you blow on your stay?

[6:02] Oliver Soden: When the wind and the weather blow your dreams high. Sail away, sail away, sail away.

[6:14] David Armstrong: Let's talk a little bit about travel, because quite famously throughout his life, Coward would escape on these long journeys around the world, sometimes even by himself.

[6:25] Oliver Soden: Yeah.

[6:26] David Armstrong: Why do you think he was drawn to this? And what does it tell us about Coward?

[6:30] Oliver Soden: Well, I think of Noel Coward as somebody, in a way, perpetually in flight, both literally and metaphorically, in flight in some ways, from love and affection, which he believes to be something ephemeral and painful, in flight from failure, in flight from poverty.

[6:47] Oliver Soden: And flight for him is a means of escape from success as well. And his inveterate reaction to all the tumult of critical praise or critical censure, depending on which way the balance of the scales has fallen, is to get on a ship.

[7:01] Oliver Soden: It's a line in his play Designed for Living. Just get on a ship, somebody says. The gay couple in that play do spend, as it were, the interval between Act Two and Three, traveling the world as a sort of double act.

[7:13] Oliver Soden: And I think it's a fear for Coward of what he might find within himself if he ever stopped moving for long enough to be deeply introspective.

[7:23] Oliver Soden: So there is a sense of a man fleeing not only what the world has to say about him and offer him, but fleeing his own nervous, depressive character as well, never stopping for a moment that might permit deep introspection, which is not really his way.

[7:38] David Armstrong: Although you would think days and weeks on a ship would give you nothing to do but...

[7:38] Oliver Soden: Yeah, this is true. That's a very good point. And indeed, some of his worst depressive periods, where he became, I would argue, close to suicidal, do happen on these long voyages at sea, which are possibly intended to rinse the brain clean of dust and depression, but of course, actually mean that he's not being given the distraction that he might need.

[8:05] Oliver Soden: But then the solitude, but also the camaraderie of ship life, especially when he's on a naval ship, and there was no place he preferred to be than on a naval ship, also give Coward what he called some of the happiest times in his life.

[8:18] Oliver Soden: And there is a sense in which that curious no man's land of life at sea, where what goes on on the ship stays on the ship, really is when he begins to feel at his most free, at his most liberated.

[8:31] Oliver Soden: We know that the Navy or at least naval life was a refuge for homosexuals away from the censure of police and society and so on when on dry land. But there's also a sense that ship life provides for Coward a sort of theatre in miniature.

[8:45] Oliver Soden: All the hierarchy of ship life is oddly comparable to the stalls and the circle and the upper circle. It has its costume, it has its rituals, it has Cocoa on the deck with the captain at 9 p.m.

[8:55] Oliver Soden: It's almost a sort of boarding school dormitory life, and there's something in the safety of that routine that I think he finds quite appealing.

[9:03] Oliver Soden: And of course, it appealed to Gilbert and Sullivan, it appeared to Cole Porter. There is a sense that life at sea has this curious camp theatre to it that's able to link the nautical with the naughty, and he enjoys all of that.

[9:15] Oliver Soden: So he embarks on one of these trips for Asia in 1930.

[9:20] Oliver Soden: Yes. And possibly because of the friction with Jack Wilson, he takes Geoffrey Amherst along with him as a traveling companion.

[9:27] David Armstrong: Yeah. Who was Geoffrey Amherst?

[9:30] Oliver Soden: Geoffrey Amherst had been his traveling companion for most of the 1920s. Amherst was a big mogul in the airlines eventually, but he was also aristocratic and he'd served in the First World War.

[9:42] Oliver Soden: He was everything that Coward wasn't. He was blonde and upper class and he'd seen active service in the trenches.

[9:49] Oliver Soden: He may have been homosexual, it may have been an affair, but I'm inclined to think not, because Amherst lived right on into his 90s at a time when it would have been perfectly possible to speak quite openly when homosexuality was legalized, when Coward had eventually died about any kind of affair.

[10:07] Oliver Soden: And he never did, even to my great predecessor Philip Hoare, who interviewed him for the last Coward biography. So I'm tentative. I think it was a sort of homosocial friendship.

[10:16] Oliver Soden: But they made good traveling companions. And of course, Amherst had lots of money, which helped. But then so did Coward by that time.

[10:22] Oliver Soden: These trips were quite productive for Coward. He would write plays and songs while traveling.

[10:25] Oliver Soden: And this one in particular was incredibly productive.

[10:30] Oliver Soden: Yes, Amherst fell really quite seriously ill with amoebic dysentery, which meant that Coward had long periods to fill for his own amusement.

[10:39] Oliver Soden: And he does this in two ways. One, he actually acts, he performs with a local touring theatre company. Among the new recruits, a then young and unknown John Mills, who would go on to win Oscars and so on.

[10:51] Oliver Soden: And he plays the role of Raleigh, which is a large role in the First World War Trench's play Journey's End by R.C. Sheriff in a theatre in Singapore, which is an astonishing thing for him to do when you think about it.

[11:03] Oliver Soden: And he learned with his neo-photographic memory this vast number of lines in all of about a day or two days.

[11:10] Oliver Soden: And the other thing he did was to write. And when he had flew himself, he sat in a hotel over three or four days and by hand in pencil wrote Private Lives, which is now his most imperishable comedy.

[11:23] Oliver Soden: Rather an astonishing thing to do, although I should say that I think writing plays for Coward was a very different thing to writing them down.

[11:30] Oliver Soden: So I'm not saying that he wrote Private Lives in four days, I'm saying he wrote it down in four days after I would argue many months, possibly many years of letting it coalesce.

[11:39] Oliver Soden: Coward did a lot of drafting, but I think he had the kind of mind that allowed him to draft and redraft in his head.

[11:52] David Armstrong: Don't go away. Oliver and I will be back with more conversation right after this quick break.

[12:10] Oliver Soden: Even though at the time, although they found it to be dazzling and delectable, you quote one of them as saying that he didn't think Private Lives would survive a decade.

[12:20] David Armstrong: Yes, it's interesting how Coward's plays have had to mature in order to reveal depth and truth that not only critics but even the author himself somehow hadn't seen were there.

[12:33] Oliver Soden: There's a curious sense in which Coward's plays are more mature than Coward himself, if that's possible.

[12:40] Oliver Soden: And after writing the script, he sends it to Gertrude Lawrence from the hotel in the Far East, saying, you know, it's utterly trivial, but it might be quite fun to play.

[12:48] Oliver Soden: And most of the critics agreed with him, certainly.

[12:51] David Armstrong: And yet now we find great depth in it.

[12:53] Oliver Soden: Yes.

[12:54] Oliver Soden: I mean, why should that be?

[12:55] Oliver Soden: I think because of changing attitudes to Coward, different ways of performing his work. Coward in 1930, which is when Private Lives eventually opens in the West End, is thought by the critics, but also by the intellectual intelligentsia, such as the Bloomsbury Group, to be a talented but frothy purveyor of cheap theatrical tricks that don't last any longer than the two hours spent in the theatre.

[13:20] Oliver Soden: And there's a way in which the actors, even Coward and Gertrude Lawrence, colluded with that, um fell for their own reputation.

[13:27] Oliver Soden: It took actors with a whole new, as it were, Stanislavski and emotional truth, as opposed to Coward's own quick fire, quicksilver comic technique to reveal what he'd actually put in the play.

[13:40] Oliver Soden: I think it's simply a case of standing further off from the script gives us a clearer view of the whole thing.

[13:46] Oliver Soden: Also, the players escaped from the style of Coward himself, which is what all Coward's plays have had to do.

[13:53] Oliver Soden: Many playwrights don't fully understand what they wrote.

[13:56] David Armstrong: Yeah, that may be so.

[13:57] Oliver Soden: There's a wonderful way in which later performances can give back to the author the play that was written as it were by their subconscious rather than by them.

[14:07] Oliver Soden: And sometimes critics are stupid.

[14:08] Oliver Soden: You know, let's not let's not dismiss that as an argument.

[14:12] David Armstrong: What are you doing here?

[14:14] Oliver Soden: I'm on my honeymoon.

[14:16] David Armstrong: Very interesting.

[14:17] Oliver Soden: So am I?

[14:18] David Armstrong: I hope you're enjoying it.

[14:19] Oliver Soden: It it hasn't started yet.

[14:21] David Armstrong: Neither is mine.

[14:23] Oliver Soden: Are you happy?

[14:25] David Armstrong: Perfectly good.

[14:28] Oliver Soden: Are you ecstatically?

[14:30] David Armstrong: What she likes?

[14:33] Oliver Soden: Very pretty plays the piano beautifully.

[14:36] David Armstrong: Very comfortable.

[14:37] Oliver Soden: How's yours?

[14:38] David Armstrong: I'd rather not this happen.

[14:40] Oliver Soden: Oh well it doesn't matter.

[14:41] David Armstrong: He'll probably come popping out in a minute and I shall see for myself.

[14:44] Oliver Soden: Have you known how long?

[14:46] David Armstrong: About four months.

[14:47] Oliver Soden: We met on a house party in Norfolk.

[14:49] David Armstrong: Very flat Mr.

[14:51] Oliver Soden: There's no need to be unpleasant.

[14:53] David Armstrong: That was no reflection on her unless of course she made it flatter.

[14:56] Oliver Soden: Your voice takes on an acid quality every time you mention her I swear I'll never mention her again.

[15:02] David Armstrong: Good.

[15:02] Oliver Soden: And I'll keep off yours.

[15:04] David Armstrong: Thank you.

[15:05] Oliver Soden: Not at all that orchestra seems to have a remarkably small repertoire.

[15:10] Oliver Soden: Strange how potent sheep music is behind you true to the dream I am as I draw near you smile on smile for all we shall stay and in herever.

[15:52] Oliver Soden: Oh sorrow me.

[15:59] Oliver Soden: For I to make you to the you always had a sweet voice, Amanda.

[16:24] David Armstrong: Thank you.

[16:29] Oliver Soden: What exactly were you remembering at that moment?

[16:32] David Armstrong: Lots of things.

[16:33] Oliver Soden: So was I.

[16:35] David Armstrong: What fools we would have ruined it all.

[16:37] Oliver Soden: What utter utter fool.

[16:39] David Armstrong: We were so ridiculously over in love.

[16:42] Oliver Soden: And yet, here we are starting off with two quite different people.

[16:46] David Armstrong: In love all over again, aren't we?

[16:46] Oliver Soden: Aren't we?

[16:51] David Armstrong: No.

[16:53] Oliver Soden: We're not in love all over again, and you know it.

[16:55] David Armstrong: Good night, Amanda.

[16:56] Oliver Soden: Well yet, don't leave me.

[16:59] David Armstrong: We won't talk about ourselves anymore.

[17:01] Oliver Soden: Talk about outside things.

[17:02] David Armstrong: Anything I stay with me till I pull myself together.

[17:05] Oliver Soden: Very well.

[17:07] David Armstrong: What have you been doing lately during these last years?

[17:10] Oliver Soden: I I went round the world, you know, after.

[17:12] David Armstrong: Yes, yes, of course I know.

[17:13] Oliver Soden: How was it?

[17:14] David Armstrong: The world?

[17:14] Oliver Soden: Yes.

[17:14] David Armstrong: Very enjoyable.

[17:15] Oliver Soden: China must be very interesting.

[17:17] David Armstrong: Very big, China.

[17:19] Oliver Soden: And Japan.

[17:20] David Armstrong: Very small.

[17:22] Oliver Soden: Did you eat shark spins and take your shoes off and use chopsticks and everything?

[17:26] David Armstrong: Practically everything.

[17:27] Oliver Soden: And India.

[17:29] David Armstrong: The burning gars or gaps or whatever they are in the Taj Mahal.

[17:32] Oliver Soden: How was the Taj Mahal?

[17:33] David Armstrong: Unbelievable.

[17:34] Oliver Soden: A sort of dream.

[17:36] David Armstrong: That was the moonlight, I think.

[17:39] Oliver Soden: Of course, you saw it in the moon.

[17:40] David Armstrong: Yes.

[17:41] Oliver Soden: Moonlight can be cruelly deceptive.

[17:43] David Armstrong: And it didn't look like a biscuit box, did it?

[17:46] Oliver Soden: You know, I've I've always felt that it might.

[17:48] David Armstrong: Darling, I do love you so.

[17:51] Oliver Soden: I do hope you met a sacred elephant.

[17:53] David Armstrong: They're lint white, I believe, it's very, very sweet.

[17:56] Oliver Soden: I've never loved anybody else for an instant.

[18:00] David Armstrong: And you love me too, don't you?

[18:02] Oliver Soden: There isn't any doubt about it anywhere, is there?

[18:07] David Armstrong: No.

[18:09] Oliver Soden: No doubt anywhere.

[18:11] David Armstrong: You're looking very lovely in this damn moonlight, Amanda.

[18:14] Oliver Soden: Your skin is clear and cool, and your eyes are shining.

[18:17] David Armstrong: You're growing lovelier and lovelier every second as I look at you.

[18:20] Oliver Soden: You don't hold any mystery for me, darling.

[18:23] David Armstrong: Do you mind?

[18:24] Oliver Soden: There isn't a particle of you that I don't know, remember, and want.

[18:33] David Armstrong: More than any desire in the world.

[18:35] Oliver Soden: Deep down in my deepest heart, I want you back again.

[18:40] David Armstrong: Please.

[18:42] Oliver Soden: Don't.

[18:44] David Armstrong: Don't say anymore.

[18:46] Oliver Soden: You're making me cry so deadly.

[18:50] David Armstrong: What is it about private lives that you think audiences still connect with so strongly?

[18:56] Oliver Soden: Oh, many things.

[18:58] Oliver Soden: The sheer perfection of its machinery, of its architecture, the fact that here is a playwright who within 40 minutes, restricting his two lead characters to no more than twelve feet of stage, can manage to reunite a divorced couple and allow them to fall back in love with one another and elope once again, leaving behind their new partners.

[19:22] Oliver Soden: I mean, that is a dazzling and delectable sleight of hand, and an architectural slight at hand.

[19:28] Oliver Soden: It's deeply funny.

[19:29] Oliver Soden: I mean, the sheer comedy of the dialogue is superb.

[19:33] Oliver Soden: The way in which, and this is something Alan Rickman said of the play when he starred in it, and I think it's very profound.

[19:39] Oliver Soden: I only heard this recently, so it's not in the book.

[19:41] Oliver Soden: The way in which each act is different.

[19:43] Oliver Soden: The first act is a Noel Coward comedy, the second act is a play by Chekhov, and the third act is a FedO Farce.

[19:50] Oliver Soden: So it has this amazing theatrical variety.

[19:53] Oliver Soden: But then it also, in its comedy, has something deeply tragic to say about a couple who can't live with or without each other.

[20:00] Oliver Soden: It splits love through a kind of prism into its constituent parts of domestic comfort and affection, of lacerating sexual passion, and of mature love as opposed to the first flush of something new.

[20:13] Oliver Soden: And it dares to say that possibly it's very tricky to combine all those facets in one relationship.

[20:19] Oliver Soden: And it says all those things while making you laugh, which is another sleight of hand in itself.

[20:25] Oliver Soden: And I suppose the dangerous conclusion as to why it still speaks to us today is that it presents us with two modes of living and loving.

[20:35] Oliver Soden: And one is moral and conscientious and safe and calm and comforting, and one is amoral and violent and lacerating and cruel and funny and sexy.

[20:47] Oliver Soden: And it's the second of those two things which is on the side of life, even when it's not necessarily on the side of mere goodness, kindness, niceness, the thing that Coward hated above all.

[20:59] Oliver Soden: Yeah, respectability, indeed, social convention.

[21:02] Oliver Soden: He gives, as it were, the devil not only the best tunes, but the funniest tunes, the liveliest, most appealing tunes.

[21:09] Oliver Soden: So it's a dangerous play.

[21:10] Oliver Soden: And that has become more dangerous with changing attitudes, but of course, danger and risk is deeply appealing.

[21:16] Oliver Soden: And now, from the vantage point of 2023, it's dangerous too in its portrayal of a relationship that combines sex with violence.

[21:25] Oliver Soden: Violence initiated by the woman upon the man, but of course wrought by a man upon a woman, deeply uncomfortable to watch.

[21:33] Oliver Soden: There's always a question as to how seriously you play it, how comic the violence can be.

[21:37] Oliver Soden: Can you even say, as some productions have not, a line such as, quote, women should be struck regularly like gongs, unquote.

[21:45] Oliver Soden: Does Coward mean it?

[21:47] Oliver Soden: Does his character Elliot mean it?

[21:49] Oliver Soden: All these things tumbling around in 2023 that weren't necessarily tumbling around in 1930.

[21:54] Oliver Soden: It was the discussion of atheism that really shocked its contemporary audiences, more than smashing a record over somebody else's head.

[22:02] David Armstrong: I especially enjoyed your analysis of how, as you say, the script is punctuated with rhythm rather than grammar.

[22:10] Oliver Soden: What exactly do you mean by that?

[22:12] Oliver Soden: I mean that the play has a sound world and an acoustic, and if you hear a performance of it, even a performance not necessarily given with cowards' immensely staccato delivery, it's a script fashioned of percussive monosyllables that could be by nobody else.

[22:30] Oliver Soden: It's not luxuriant lyrical writing.

[22:33] Oliver Soden: This is a writer who instead of saying, for example, as white as Lint, he says Lint White.

[22:40] Oliver Soden: And the difference between that lovely bouncing first example and that sharp, two-syllable, crisp second example, is the difference between a mediocre playwright and what Noel Coward can do with comic dialogue.

[22:53] Oliver Soden: It is to be performed in a way, I would argue, like a musical score.

[22:57] Oliver Soden: And you come across a comma, and what it means is a quaver rest in the delivery.

[23:03] Oliver Soden: Thank you very much.

[23:04] Oliver Soden: Which means that there aren't as many, perhaps, in the script as syntax would necessarily require, because you've got to power through in this machine gun fire of Coward's patter and badinage and banter.

[23:17] Oliver Soden: So when you hit a full stop or a comma, those those pauses, those breaths do an awful lot of work for you.

[23:24] Oliver Soden: The other notation Coward gives is the question mark.

[23:27] Oliver Soden: If you look through a Coward's script, you'll find that an awful lot of his lines are questions, but they are almost always unanswered questions.

[23:34] Oliver Soden: And in fact, usually they're answered with another question.

[23:37] Oliver Soden: I think the great inheritor of this technique is Tom Stoppard in his play Rosencrantz and Gildenstern are dead.

[23:43] Oliver Soden: And Rosencrantz and Gildenstern in that play have a long game where they ask each other questions that can be answered only by another question.

[23:52] Oliver Soden: Now, this also adds to the sound world.

[23:54] Oliver Soden: It means that you are constantly asking a question.

[23:56] Oliver Soden: You are constantly giving that rising motif, which people now give even when they're not answering or asking questions, but which in Coward actually has a purpose and a point.

[24:05] Oliver Soden: And it means that his lines are, they don't attract, they repel one another, like opposite magnetic poles.

[24:12] Oliver Soden: And it means that the characters are very often speaking at right angles to one another.

[24:17] Oliver Soden: So it enacts the way they're so rarely in union.

[24:20] Oliver Soden: And of course, the greatest unanswered question in private lives and in other plays by Coward is: Do you love me?

[24:26] Oliver Soden: That's the question that his characters find it very difficult to answer.

[24:29] David Armstrong: I love the final sentence of the paragraph where you talk about all of that. Would you please read that to us?

[24:36] Oliver Soden: I will.

[24:37] Oliver Soden: Knoll's ear was attuned to his era, and the contours of the writing capture the sound and diction of the jazz age, the bang and rattle of the motor car as it drove over the remnants of a bygone world.

[24:50] David Armstrong: Well, actually, as I read it, it sounds a little purple prose to me, but I did want to convey the way he is an antenna for the sound of the twenties and the way each decade has a sound, the way the twenties were full of newly disembodied voices via the telephone and the broadcasting of the wireless and the arrival of the motor car and the drills as the skyscrapers were built up into the sky.

[25:11] Oliver Soden: You know, not just jazz, but a mechanical sound.

[25:14] David Armstrong: Exactly, exactly.

[25:17] Oliver Soden: Of course, he wrote this play specifically for himself and Gertrude Lawrence to star in.

[25:22] Oliver Soden: And then he wrote that whole cycle of plays tonight at 830 for the two of them to do together.

[25:27] David Armstrong: And Gertrude Lawrence was obviously one of the great stars of the era, but she's kind of hard for us to latch on to today.

[25:34] Oliver Soden: Have you been able to figure out exactly what it was about Gertrude Lawrence that made Noel Coward so much want to share the stage with her?

[25:42] Oliver Soden: I think what is interesting is that actually I believe, especially as he got older, he was an actor of emotional truth.

[25:50] Oliver Soden: But of course, he was an actor of impeccable, rigorous, disciplined technique.

[25:56] Oliver Soden: And she, by contrast, as far as one can stop the ephemerality of performance sort of running through one's fingers, was an actor of idiosyncrasy and gut instinct, capable of changing her performance from night to night.

[26:12] Oliver Soden: Oddly, I think the contemporary parallel would be that Coward was an actor such as Maggie Smith, you know, supreme laying out of emotional truth through, not in spite of, but through brilliant comic technique and physical clowning and disciplined performance.

[26:29] Oliver Soden: Whereas Gertrude Lawrence was much more, as I gather and read, an actress such as Vanessa Redgrave now is, who is sort of wild and wayward and ill disciplined and instinctive and wonderful.

[26:41] Oliver Soden: But what I'm trying to describe is, I think it made it hell to perform, but thrilling to watch, a coming together of two totally distinct and different and in fact contrary acting styles.

[26:53] Oliver Soden: And that coming together can be electric. I've seen examples of it, you know, a century on. And much more interesting than Coward simply finding a female actor such as Beatrice Lilly, who was the great star of his review, who performed in a very similar way to him.

[27:07] Oliver Soden: Of course, this meant that there were some nights where he hated what she did, and they came to blows and fist fights in the wings. And I think theirs was a relationship rather like Amanda and Elliot in Private Lives that expressed its deep affection and indeed love through quarrel.

[27:23] Oliver Soden: It's very difficult to get a handle on Noel and Gertie as the relationship has come to be known. Partly because I think a lot of this is Coward's own PR. And something that interested me is that nobody called Gertrude Lawrence Gertie. Her friends called her Gertrude or G.

[27:38] Oliver Soden: It's very much part of the packaging. But the other thing is that they only worked together actually three times as adults, London calling the review Private Lives Tonight at 8 30. You can read one biography and come to the conclusion that they were so close they may even have been lovers in some tentative, unsuccessful way.

[27:57] Oliver Soden: You can read another biography and discover that they hated each other and weren't remotely close, and it was only a rather frosty technical relationship. So I try to pitch my own flag somewhere between those two extremes.

[28:09] Oliver Soden: And clearly at moments it was a deeply important and significant friendship, and then at others, especially when she went on to marry a man that Coward did not much like, it was much more cold, argumentative, distant.

[28:21] Oliver Soden: Much later he wrote a very bad play called South Sea Bubble for her that she did not want to do and didn't do. And then, of course, she dies far too young in the 50s, and he blots the paper. He writes his obituary for the Times on with tears, and is deeply, deeply regretful that he hadn't not necessarily mended things because I don't think it was broken, but seen her as much as he might have done in her last years.

[28:43] Oliver Soden: It has a sad end, but is an important relationship. But then, of course, he worked with an actress such as Celia Johnson as much, if not more, three films and plays later on. But it's amazing how the beam has a lit upon Gertrude Lawrence as being his great muse.

[28:58] Oliver Soden: But she's one of many in some ways. It is amazing how legendary that partnership has become. Without any film or video or tangible evidence of what that partnership was like. The evidence that does exist, I suppose, are the photographs, and they knew how to pose so well for the photographs.

[29:15] Oliver Soden: I'm sure some listeners will have seen them. They look almost like two halves of the same androgynous soul. They're mirror images of one another, with their cigarette holders flourished like stilettos or daggers rather than cigarettes.

[29:27] Oliver Soden: So they knew very well how to do that publicity. And of course, she was a great musical artist. She was known primarily as a singer, and the variety of all the different one act plays that he brought together under that banner of tonight at 8 30 meant that she and he could show off everything they could do.

[29:47] Oliver Soden: They could dance, they could sing, they could act in comedy, they could actually act in tragedy. The thing I would love to have seen is that we all know Brief Encounter, and Celia Johnson is embedded in our memory as Laura. But that was a part created on the stage by Gertrude Lawrence.

[30:03] Oliver Soden: But we're back to this point that the one thing she could not do was ordinary. And there's a wonderful story Coward tells of not being able to make Gertrude Lawrence look like the plain middle class, ordinary suburban woman required of that play and eventually film.

[30:19] Oliver Soden: And he only solved it by buying her clothes that were one size too big. But she clearly had that dazzle that she couldn't turn off. Whereas Celia Johnson, although she is dazzling, dazzles in an altogether more subterranean, subtle, implicit, internal way.

[30:35] Oliver Soden: Lawrence is also puzzling because, as you say, she was primarily known as a musical star. And yet when you hear her recording, she doesn't sound all that great. And even the composers she worked with would often talk about her pitch issues.

[30:49] Oliver Soden: But you put her on stage and they didn't want anybody else to sing their songs. Yes, it's not unlike Judy Dench singing in Sondheim in a way, although Gertrude Lawrence has more of a soprano voice, but it's the way the song is acted in context, the way it is put across.

[31:04] Oliver Soden: Although it was put to me the other day, and I was much persuaded by this, that the technique of recording in the 20s and 30s was so new that the technology was so basic. What survives in the recording of Noel and Gertie is not what they would have done on stage.

[31:23] Oliver Soden: They would have been deeply suspicious at the microphone. It would have required a whole new technique that was slower, crisper, just in the way we hear BBC broadcast voices from the 20s and 30s, and they sound impossibly distant, but of course, do not stand for the way people actually spoke to one another at the period.

[31:39] Oliver Soden: In a way, I think we have a slightly askew sense of what they were actually like as performers. But then this is the difficulty of writing about theatre. What is marvelous is those recordings of private lives that they did.

[31:51] Oliver Soden: Yes. But again, I'd be interested to know if that is a fair picture of what they actually did on the stage with an audience in a much larger theatre. And that was filmed, but nothing survives, which is sad.

[32:04] Oliver Soden: Heartbreaking. Private lives is a major hit in London and on Broadway. Noel is at the top of his game, and his relationship with Jack Wilson seems to be reinvigorated at this time.

[32:16] Oliver Soden: They live together, they buy a weekend house together in Connecticut. Their relationship is very public to a certain extent. How does that change as we move further into the 1930s?

[32:27] Oliver Soden: Well, Private Lives catches the world on a cusp where the roar of the 20s withers into the Great Depression and unemployment of the 1930s. One thing that happens, and I think it is often the case that economic decline goes hand in hand with a less tolerant society, is gay men become a sort of scapegoat.

[32:47] Oliver Soden: There is an idea that homosexuality is associated with the extravagance of 1920s high life, the breakup of the family unit. In the face of unemployment, there's a sense that it's their fault, the economic downturn, that they lived this wild, promiscuous, extravagant high life in the 20s and spent all the money, and that they imperiled the family unit.

[33:10] Oliver Soden: And the police raids on the nightclubs, the gay nightclubs, and the nightlife where gay life had in some ways flourished, in some ways, over the 20s, start to increase in frequency and severity, and all those inklings of something more tolerant, those glimmers of gay rights organizations and instantly closed down.

[33:30] Oliver Soden: So it becomes in a way much more difficult for Noel and Jack Wilson, although then again it's fascinating how often they were photographed arm in arm, as it were living in plain sight. But then it was much more normal for, as it were, homosocial friendships to be physically affectionate.

[33:47] Oliver Soden: I mean, all of Dickens' heroes, like David Copperfield, are forever walking arm in arm down the road with other men, and I'm not sure that that would have been greeted with all that much shock. It is a time that is becoming more dangerous for them to live in anything like openness.

[34:03] Oliver Soden: And eventually Jack Wilson marries in the nineteen thirties, possibly as a disguise, although actually, well, uh definitely as a disguise in some ways, and it offers his Russian wife a passport and a means of getting on in America. She's a white Russian exile from the revolution.

[34:18] Oliver Soden: But it was an affectionate marriage, even if it wasn't a sexual one, and Coward somehow manages to survive this marriage. Indeed, he was best man at the wedding and he was a friend with Jack Wilson's wife.

[34:28] Oliver Soden: So there's a way always in which Coward greets the breakup of his own relationships when the man usually goes off to live with a woman with something like relief, because it means the pain of the initial burning passion has faded and he can just be friends, which is a rather calmer state of affairs for him.

[34:45] Oliver Soden: This relationship that Jack Wilson has with his wife, how does that begin? I guess I'm trying to understand the transition between his relationship with Coward and this idea that now he's going to get married.

[34:57] Oliver Soden: Yes. I mean, the relationship with Coward has never been sexually faithful, certainly not on Jack Wilson's side. And I think by the time he meets Natasha Paley, who the woman he married, or Natalia, her Russian name, the relationship had probably already become not merely business associates, but a non-sexual one.

[35:16] Oliver Soden: How Wilson met Paley, I can't I'm not sure I ever found out, although she had worked as an actress and a model, and I think their paths had crossed on Broadway. I mean I'm guessing here, but there's a sense, although it's interesting that Coward himself never does this, I think there must be a sense in which Wilson is allotted a certain social status and acceptability by having a wife.

[35:37] Oliver Soden: I don't know whether she had money. I suspect being an exile from the revolution, I imagine not. And Wilson himself was earning considerably by this time. It's so ill chronicled, it's very hard to pick apart what actually went on until you suddenly realize that there is Coward giving away his ex-lover to another woman.

[35:56] Oliver Soden: But then Coward worked very well in Triangles. He's a good third in those sort of relationships. Later in his life, as you talk about later in your book, Coward will write a play as sort of a tribute to those kinds of wives.

[36:10] Oliver Soden: Yes. Yes, indeed. His last major play, a song at Twilight, which is in a triptych called Sweet in Three Keys, which is staged with him acting in all three in the mid-sixties, the last performance he gave on the stage.

[36:24] Oliver Soden: And the main play Song at Twilight is about a gay man who has married for a disguise, and yet with intense humanity, Coward makes the wife, the disguise, a figure of great dignity and love and support and truth.

[36:41] Oliver Soden: And of course, you look through Coward's social circle and indeed, the world of the theatre at that time, gay men such as Michael Redgrave, the actor, Cole Porter, Jack Wilson, Somerset More, all of whom had married women who were not merely beards, as the phrase was, of disguise, but women who actually maintained deeply loving relationships, even if platonic ones with these men.

[37:06] Oliver Soden: Okay, Somerset Maum's marriage ended in a very acrimonious divorce. But Coward was on Siri Maum, his wife's side. And I love the dignity that he affords these women and the dignity that he affords what were called Mariage Blanche, you know, the sexless marriages.

[37:22] Oliver Soden: It's very interesting to unpick all these layers and triangles. Okay, now help us appreciate something else that's hard to grasp, and that's this major theatrical event of the 1930s called Cavalcade.

[37:35] Oliver Soden: Yeah. Critics called it one of the greatest stage successes of this generation. Even George Bernard Shaw called it Coward's Claim to Historical Permanence.

[37:45] Oliver Soden: Yeah. How wrong can you get? Because it's the most impermanent thing that Coward did. It's very hard to even work out, although there are photographs, quite what it was, because although the script is published, it's not unusually for Coward a play about words.

[38:01] Oliver Soden: It was designed for theatrical spectacle. Indeed, I think that spectacle was designed to show that the theatre could offer astonishing spectacle, even as film was trying to sort of steal audiences away.

[38:12] Oliver Soden: It's really a pageant, and pageants, of course, had been a hugely important part of community theatre and British theatrical life since about the turn of the century, with huge casts and dazzling visual spectacle and so on.

[38:25] Oliver Soden: And it's a pageant set roughly across the span of Coward's own life, 1900 to 1930. It hooks the story of two families, an upper class family and their servants, the family who worked for them as servants, across that theatrical span, linked to the great events, the sinking of the Titanic, the death of Queen Victoria, the General Strike, thousands of extras, the Titanic on the stage, London omnibuses on the stage, all the changing musical highlights of the different eras, the Ed Wardy and Parlour songs, the beach seaside songs, the operettas, the jazz and blues that were coming in in the twenties.

[39:03] Oliver Soden: And it has its tragedies in that you see soldiers marching off to war, and you see the younger son of the family who are the main characters be killed. Impossible really to think about what it must have looked like. I mean, untold budgets.

[39:16] Oliver Soden: I suppose the most sensationally staged musicals would be the best modern parallel, although there's something of Olympic opening ceremonies, I think, to what Coward did as well, when you think of all the extras of the spectacle and so on.

[39:29] Oliver Soden: And I think there's a socially interesting thing here in that class contrast, the upper class, especially in England, harder perhaps to understand in America, and it didn't ever run in America. But that contrast between the upper class and the lower class and that bubble of class warfare under the surface.

[39:46] Oliver Soden: And there's a cross-class marriage as well, which was daring for 1930. But what Cavalcade was, for really the first time explicitly in Coward's work, was patriotic.

[39:58] Oliver Soden: He catches that shift in the wind away from the radicalism of the 20s. And it ends with the national anthem and the Union Jack waving above the stage. And it's quite interesting. It's a time where a lot of the radical modernists of the 20s, writers such as Evelyn Waugh, T.S. Eliot, are trying to fill the emptiness at the heart of Twenties' life, having been an epitome of sort of Twenties radicalism. And Eliot and Waugh both turn to religion. And Coward, who has no truck with religion of any kind, fills the whole with patriotism. That's in a way what offers him meaning. But it's not an uncomplicated patriotism. I don't think it's merely a tubthumping patriotism. I think Cavalcade showed the dangers of war, the loss of war, the grief of war.

I think it was an attempt really to be pacifist and patriotic at the same time to show that the two things were not mutually exclusive. And it had this fascinating penultimate scene, which was called expressionist by a number of the contemporary critics, and again is impossible to recreate really apart from looking at photographs, but was theatrically very daring. It was chaos. That was the name of the scene. It tried to hold a mirror up to the chaos of contemporary society. And what you saw as a member of the audience, all at the same time, was a scene in the nightclub where someone is singing what is still a famous song of Coward's "20th Century Blues," which is a song of sheer nihilist meaninglessness and bleakness and cynicism.

What is there to strive for to love or keep alive for? Say, hey, hey, call it a day. And while that was going on, sirens blared and airplanes, or the sound of them, soared above the stage, and the stage was strafed with searchlights, and so-called incurables from the First World War sat downstage weaving baskets in sheer mental distress. Communists ranted, everything was chaos. And then this mess shifted into the national anthem, which Cavalcade offered as one potential answer to the questions posed in that song. What is there to strive for, love or keep alive for? Well, maybe, just maybe, king and country. And this was taken as a betrayal on Coward's part from some of the more left-leaning radical contemporaries who thought that he had moved into fascism and Daily Mail and all of that. But it's a very nuanced account of pacifism, I think, and done with, as I say, great theatrical radicalism. It's back to Coward as a sort of radical conservative figure, I think.

[42:33] David Armstrong: It's so interesting, this whole part of the book, and this comes up at other times during his career, that at the same time that he's sort of this avant-garde expressionist artist.

[42:44] Oliver Soden: Yeah.

[42:44] David Armstrong: He appears to be conservative.

[42:47] Oliver Soden: Yeah.

[42:47] David Armstrong: Although I think you tell us that he regretted having the Union Jack, the British flag on the stage at the end.

[42:53] Oliver Soden: Yeah.

[42:54] David Armstrong: Although he didn't take it out.

[42:56] Oliver Soden: No, he never took it out. And of course, Coward was perfectly capable of shifting his mindset to patriotism because it made a good theatrical ending. I mean, in a way. And of course, Cavalcade made him a lot of money, which a lot of his critics, and he had some severe and savage criticism to contend with in the 30s by radical intellectuals who thought he had shifted to the right, as I say, and betrayed them. Nevertheless, it's interesting how, as with T.S. Eliot, who was also politically of the right, how there is a way, Coward proves it, of being conservative and radical, of being patriotic and pacifist, and of doing all this without unnuanced, tubthumping, sort of colonel blimp preaching. But it is hard to untangle the different strands of the way the angry young man of the 1920s begins to age into something much more complicated.

He takes another long trip with Jeffrey Amherst to South America, where he writes Design for Living, but before that can be produced, he goes back to London and opens a new review for Charles Cochran, Words and Music.

[43:58] ♪ Musical number: "Mad Dogs and Englishmen" — performed by Unknown ♪

[44:30] Oliver Soden: Yeah, it's one of the least successful of the reviews. In fact, it's really the last wholly new review, bar a revival in America, that he works on. And again, it's this point of the cusp. Coward is good at transition, societal transition, the twenties shifting into the 30s. You know, 1932 saw the very last party of the bright young things. And Words and Music is all about the party being over. It's where the song "The Party's Over Now" comes from. But it also wasn't a huge commercial success, but it lacked real theatrical spectacle. It was done on a rather simpler scale, which perhaps didn't quite endear it to audiences. But I think it's a fascinating review for this very reason that it charts the end of something. And it introduces some of his most famous songs, "Mad Dogs and Englishmen."

[45:18] David Armstrong: Yeah.

[45:19] Oliver Soden: And "Mad About the Boy."

[45:20] David Armstrong: Yes, yeah. I'm fascinated by that song because although we usually hear it as a solo, that's not how it was conceived or performed in its original conception.

[45:30] Oliver Soden: No. Note the recurrence of the word madness as well. "Mad Dogs and Englishmen," "Mad About the Boy." This notion of madness and of love as a sort of debilitating mental frenzy is so prevalent in Coward, almost all his major plays, somebody says I'm going mad, or you know. "Mad About the Boy" was originally staged really as a sort of piss take of fandom and the perils of celebrity worship. It was done as lots of young star-struck women singing about a movie star. And there've been lots of suggestions as to which movie star Coward meant, but really it's just a sort of archetypal heartthrob. It wasn't actually done in this wonderful sultry way that it's usually done now, whether by Dinah Washington or even Adam Lambert, who recorded it a year ago. It was done as sort of silly little schoolgirls, almost out of Gilbert and Sullivan, saying that they were mad about the boy. Which is interesting.

[45:34] ♪ Musical number: "Mad About the Boy" — performed by Unknown ♪

[48:56] Oliver Soden: But also when Coward transferred Words and Music to Broadway seven years later when it became Set to Music, he added a verse sung by a young man, which was amazingly daring for the time to show a young man with a blatantly homoerotic crush on this male movie star that the producers would not let him include in the text of that verse, which also includes a reference to conversion therapy, a converting homosexuals to heterosexuality. This all came to light long after he died, I think. Fascinating, not unlike "Bewitched Bothered and Bewildered," which in its original form was a sort of gay love song. And I love that reference to Freud because it shows even Dr. Freud cannot explain those vexing dreams I've had about the boy.

The young man was meant to sing about this film star. And it shows Coward absolutely au fait with the latest thinking on sexuality, on dreams and what they mean. Coward, this great chronicler of the dazzling surface, wrestling with Dr. Freud, the great chronicler of hidden depth. It's a fascinating lost verse that.

[52:00] ♪ Musical number ♪

[52:00] David Armstrong: Here's the information about how you too can become a patron of Broadway Nation. A donation of just seven dollars a month will not only keep Broadway Nation rolling along, it will also provide you with exclusive access to the complete unedited versions of many of the interviews that you hear on this podcast. And all patrons will receive special shout-outs and acknowledgments of your vital support for Broadway Nation. To join, simply go to Broadway Nation Podcast dot supercast dot tech. That's Broadway Nation Podcast dot S U P E R C A S T dot Tech. Or click the link in the show notes to this episode. Broadway Nation is written and produced by me, David Armstrong. Special thanks to Pals Mox for his help with editing this episode and to the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred