This is the fourth part of my interview with Oliver Soden author of the truly extraordinary new book MASQUERADE — THE LIVES OF NOEL COWARD... Read More
From the show: BROADWAY NATION
Guests
About
This is the fourth part of my interview with Oliver Soden author of the truly extraordinary new book MASQUERADE — THE LIVES OF NOEL COWARD.
In this episode we discuss Noel Coward’s life and career during the late 1930s including his amazingly provocative play DESIGN FOR LIVING and the bisexual love triangle at the center of it, as well as dazzling series of nine one act plays and musicals that make up TONIGHT AT 8:30 in which Coward and Gertrude Lawrence played a dazzling array of characters, and Oliver especially focusses on the surrealistic SHADOW PLAY.
Then Soden recounts Cowards secret and dangerous activities during the Second World War working as a spy for the British government — much of which he has uncovered and revealed in his book for the very first time. During this incredibly active period Coward also created the plays PRESENT LAUGHTER and BLYTHE SPIRIT and the classic films IN WHICH WE SERVE and BRIEF ENCOUNTER.
If you missed the first three episodes you may want to catch up with those before embarking on this one.
Oliver Sodon is a writer and broadcaster whose previous books include the critically acclaimed 2019 biography of composer Michael Tippett. Oliver’s writing on art, music and literature has appeared in the Guardian, Spectator, London Review of Books, and the Times Literary supplement, and he is a frequent guest speaker on BBC radio and television broadcasts.
Coward was without a doubt one of the most remarkable figures of the 20th Century and as you will hear Oliver and I had a great time talking about him. And it will be my pleasure to share that conversation with you over the next several episodes.
Critics have hailed this book and Oliver Soden as “Brilliant,” “Excellent,” “Illuminating,” Captivating,” “Definitive,” “fresh and original…a brilliant young writer,” “and emerging literary star.”
Become a PATRON of Broadway Nation!
This episode is made possible in part through the generous support of our Patron Club members.
If you would like to help support the work of Broadway Nation I will information at the end of the podcast about how you too can become a Patron.
If you are a fan ofBroadway Nation, I invite you too to become a PATRON!
For a just $7.00 a month you will receive exclusive access to never-before-heard, unedited versions of many of the discussions that I have with my guests — in fact I often record nearly twice as much conversation as ends up in the edited versions. You will also have access to additional in-depth conversations with my frequent co-host Albert Evans that have not been featured on the podcast.
All patrons receive special “on-air” shout-outs and acknowledgement of your vital support of this podcast. And if you are very enthusiastic about Broadway Nation there are additional PATRON levels that come with even more benefits.
If you would like to support the work of Broadway Nation and receive these exclusive member benefits, please just click on this link:
https://broadwaynationpodcast.supercast.tech/
Thank you in advance for your support!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:04] David Armstrong: Welcome to another episode of Broadway Nation.
[0:09] ♪ Musical number: "Twentieth Century Blues" — performed by Unknown performer ♪
[0:26] David Armstrong: The podcast that tells the remarkable story of how immigrants, Jews, queers, African Americans, and other outcasts invented the Broadway musical and how they changed America in the process.
[0:38] David Armstrong: I'm David Armstrong, and my guest again today is Oliver Soden, the author of Masquerade, The Lives of NOEL COWARD.
[0:47] ♪ Musical number ♪
[1:32] David Armstrong: On today's episode, Oliver and I will follow NOEL COWARD during an incredibly productive period of his life from the late 1930s and through the Second World War.
[1:43] David Armstrong: This is the fourth part of our conversation, so if you missed the previous three episodes, you may want to catch up with those before listening to this one.
[1:50] David Armstrong: As always, Broadway Nation is made possible in part through the generous support of our patron club members.
[1:57] David Armstrong: At the end of the episode, I'll have information about how you too can become a patron of Broadway Nation.
[2:03] David Armstrong: Here we go.
[2:04] David Armstrong: Let's talk about Design for Living. I think one of his most important plays, not done quite as often as perhaps it should be. In fact, a new edition of COWARD's work came out this year, and they asked me which play would you most like to introduce? And I said Design for Living because it was about, it is about a bisexual love triangle played by the Lunz and by COWARD. So explicitly do the two men have an evidently sexual physical affection for one another, while having a very genuine sexual love for the woman, that the Lord Chamberlain in England simply would not allow it to be staged when it was first written. It wasn't done in England for another six years, and it was done in America where it was a huge success.
It's a wonderful play because it contrasts different designs for living. It shows COWARD is a great chronicler of women, and Design for Living shows first and foremost a young woman trying all the different options available to her in the 1930s in England and in Paris and in America, as a married woman living a conventional life, as a woman living in a ménage à trois living an unconventional life. And the interesting thing about the play is it doesn't quite do what you would expect. It doesn't necessarily proffer this trio, this free living, laughing trio, as a happy bohemian example of the right way to live, putting two fingers up to Victorian convention. It contrasts all these different ways of doing it in twos or threes, married, unmarried as a mother, not as a mother, earning your own living, all of these ways, and shows them all in a way equally flawed.
The Bohemianism of the trio leaves them almost as unhappy. This is COWARD's bleakness coming out, as any more conventional option might have done. So it's not simply the triumph of Bohemianism over convention. It's more nuanced, more profound. It's about three people who laugh at everything. That is their philosophy, as it was COWARD's philosophy, and who end the play laughing, but they laugh with a sort of painful, unending hysteria, because their tragedy may be the funniest joke of all. And I think really the female character in it, Gilda, is an inheritor not so much of COWARD's earlier women, but of characters in Ibsen, who leave their husbands and slam the door, but you know, don't necessarily have all that many options available to them.
It's a fascinating play. I love it. And even though it's not saying bohemianism is superior to conventional society, it is conversely saying that conventional society is just as flawed as Bohemianism.
[4:40] Oliver Soden: Yeah, oh, exactly. Conventional society comes in the person of a character called Ernest, whom Gilda eventually lives with and marries. Ernest, that's an undeniable nod to Oscar Wilde, and the importance of being earnest and COWARD's philosophy that actually being earnest isn't important at all. It's complicated, I think. So in spite of these, in many ways, very radical plays that he's writing, he starts to acquire a very conservative reputation.
[5:09] David Armstrong: Yes. He has money to earn. And at the same time as all these radical plays of the 30s, Design for Living, a wonderful play also for the Lunz called Point Velaine, which is sort of proto-Tennessee Williams, and Tonight at 8:30. He's also filling West End theatres with fluffy musicals and operettas, Conversation Piece, operette is the title of one of them. I mean, they're quite successful, they're quite well reviewed, but they're hardly avant-garde. His reputation changes into, you know, not the shocking young man who wrote The Vortex, but someone who wants to earn a quick buck with some sort of frothy entertainment. And as you say, at this moment, he was most famous for Cavalcade and Bitter Sweet.
[5:50] Oliver Soden: Yes, in a way. If you think that no English audience had seen Hay Fever since 1925, and none of them had seen Design for Living, and by the outbreak of the Second World War, Private Lives is nine years old and hasn't been revived. The idea of COWARD then is not the idea of COWARD that we have now, and it's the fluffy musicals that have gone away and the plays that have lasted. If I had the proverbial time machine and could go back in time and see any COWARD production, I would choose Tonight at 8:30.
[6:19] David Armstrong: Ladies and gentlemen, with your very kind indulgence, my wife and myself will present to you our famous nautical extravaganza.
[6:27] Oliver Soden: Thank you, Bert.
[6:32] David Armstrong: Yes.
[6:33] Oliver Soden: All nine plays.
[6:34] David Armstrong: Yeah, be fascinating to see them.
[6:40] Oliver Soden: What's to be done with the drive and say the show the same goes?
[6:43] David Armstrong: We are not talking for an angel.
[6:47] Oliver Soden: We lost our wine and we lost our pain to make the thing complete.
[6:51] David Armstrong: We beat and gone and lost them dooming plea.
[6:55] Oliver Soden: As anybody see Nash, the S peculiar.
[6:59] David Armstrong: We've been on shore for a month or more.
[7:01] Oliver Soden: When we see the cat, and we should get what for the Home Hart is.
[7:04] David Armstrong: Sing glory.
[7:05] Oliver Soden: Hallelujah.
[7:07] David Armstrong: A lady bold as she could be.
[7:09] Oliver Soden: Pinched out was also the golden key.
[7:12] David Armstrong: Now we're in between the devil and the deep those see us.
[7:17] Oliver Soden: Because it's just so hard to understand what the effect of them really was, it was such a stunt.
[7:23] David Armstrong: And then each of those plays is so interesting.
[7:25] Oliver Soden: And we've seen versions of them.
[7:27] David Armstrong: Yep.
[7:29] Oliver Soden: But I just don't think there's anything that quite captures what they were really about.
[7:34] David Armstrong: No, or the sheer physical feat. You know, COWARD and Gertrude Lawrence were performing nine one-act plays, the nine grouped in trios across three evenings. With matinees as well, Lawrence was filming during the day. I mean, there's a sheer level of energy and stamina, and in fact it gave out when it went to Broadway and COWARD had another major nervous breakdown. But what I would love to have seen was the first performance of one of the one-act plays, which is called SHADOW PLAY, which I think is the most radical and experimental thing COWARD ever did. It's about the breakdown of a relationship of a couple who have just been out to the theatre, and the woman takes a sleeping pill, and the play is essentially her fever dream.
It splices their, as it were, realistic conversation with memories of the play. They shift into song, they shift into dance, they're conscious on occasion that they're in a play. The staging was done under sort of harsh pools of white light with shadows, silhouettes thrown up on a back cloth. I mean, those who condemn COWARD as a rather tedious, realistic playwright should look at SHADOW PLAY to see him at his most expressionist, most theatrically daring, and most, I mean, this is an ahistoric term, but postmodern, in the sense of his writing having a consciousness of its own theatricality.
[8:49] Oliver Soden: Sometimes you think in SHADOW PLAY that the actors have forgotten their lines and they comment to one another as actors. They say things such as you're skipping again. It's a melee of the real and the dream and the imagined and the musical and the dance numbers.
[9:04] David Armstrong: Are you engaged for this dance?
[9:06] Oliver Soden: I was.
[9:07] David Armstrong: But I'll cut it if you promise to love me always and never let anything or anybody come between us ever.
[9:12] Oliver Soden: But of course that's understood.
[9:14] David Armstrong: I saw you in the ballroom.
[9:15] Oliver Soden: I wondered who you were.
[9:16] David Armstrong: My name's Victoria, Victoria Martin.
[9:19] Oliver Soden: Mine, Simon Gayford.
[9:21] David Armstrong: How do you do?
[9:21] Oliver Soden: Quite well, thank you.
[9:23] David Armstrong: I suppose you came down from London for the dance.
[9:25] Oliver Soden: I'm staying with the Bursleys.
[9:27] David Armstrong: What do you do?
[9:28] Oliver Soden: I'm in a bank.
[9:29] David Armstrong: High up in a bank?
[9:30] Oliver Soden: Or just sitting in a little cage, toting up things?
[9:33] David Armstrong: Quite high up, really.
[9:35] Oliver Soden: It's a very good bank.
[9:36] David Armstrong: I'm so glad.
[9:38] Oliver Soden: How lovely you are.
[9:39] David Armstrong: No, no, no.
[9:40] Oliver Soden: That came later.
[9:40] David Armstrong: You're skipping.
[9:42] Oliver Soden: I'm so sorry.
[9:43] David Armstrong: You're nice and thin.
[9:45] Oliver Soden: Your eyes are funny.
[9:47] David Armstrong: You move easily.
[9:49] Oliver Soden: I'm afraid you're terribly attractive.
[9:51] David Armstrong: You never said that.
[9:52] Oliver Soden: No, but I thought it.
[9:53] David Armstrong: Stick to the script.
[9:55] Oliver Soden: Small talk.
[9:56] David Armstrong: A lot of small talk with other thoughts going on behind me.
[10:00] Oliver Soden: And this garden's really lovely.
[10:02] David Armstrong: Are you good at gardens?
[10:04] Oliver Soden: Not very, but I'm persevering.
[10:06] David Armstrong: I'm all right on the more straightforward rooms, like Snapdragon and Cornflower and Tobacco Plant.
[10:11] Oliver Soden: And I can tell a Dorothy Perkins a mylaw.
[10:14] David Armstrong: That hedge over there is called cupressus macrocarpa.
[10:17] Oliver Soden: Do you swear it?
[10:19] David Armstrong: It grows terribly quickly.
[10:20] Oliver Soden: But they do say it gets a little thin underneath in about 20 years.
[10:24] David Armstrong: How beastly of them to say that.
[10:26] Oliver Soden: It's slander.
[10:27] David Armstrong: Did you know about Valerian smelling of cats?
[10:30] Oliver Soden: You're showing off again.
[10:32] David Armstrong: It's true.
[10:33] Oliver Soden: I can go one better than that.
[10:34] David Armstrong: Lotuses smell of pineapple.
[10:36] Oliver Soden: Oh dear.
[10:36] David Armstrong: Everything smells of something else.
[10:39] Oliver Soden: It's dreadfully confusing.
[10:41] David Armstrong: Never mind, darling.
[10:42] Oliver Soden: I love you desperately.
[10:43] David Armstrong: I knew it the first second I saw you.
[10:45] Oliver Soden: No, no, no, you're skipping again.
[10:49] David Armstrong: Was it in a real world, or was it in a dream?
[10:54] Oliver Soden: Was it just a note in some eternal theme?
[11:00] David Armstrong: Was it accidental or accurately planned?
[11:05] Oliver Soden: How could I hesitate?
[11:08] David Armstrong: Knowing that my fate led me by the hand.
[11:14] Oliver Soden: You were I saw you and my heart stopped beating.
[11:25] David Armstrong: And in that first enchanted meeting, life changed its tune.
[11:30] Oliver Soden: The stars, the moon came near to me.
[11:35] David Armstrong: Dreams that I dreamed like magic seemed to be clear to me.
[11:41] Oliver Soden: Dear to me.
[11:47] David Armstrong: Do we have any sense of what influenced this?
[11:50] Oliver Soden: Obviously, surrealism and everything else that goes along with that were very much part of the art world at this time.
[11:56] David Armstrong: Yeah, that's a very interesting question that I hadn't thought about.
[11:59] Oliver Soden: And in a way, it's surrealist, so it's hard to see where it comes from. I mean, this is the era of what in England was called the group theatre. Experimental theatre with music by Benjamin Britten, texts by figures such as W. H. Auden, Christopher Isherwood, that went much further down that road at the same time of experimental theatre, self-consciously theatrical theatre, surrealism, and so on. I think COWARD would have actively disdained that world. And I don't know whether he saw very much of it. I think there's a European influence, the great German producer Max Reinhardt who did huge, large-scale shows, but you know, using the avant-garde techniques, sort of post-Miterlink. I mean, it may come through Europe.
But then reviews of the 20s and 30s had been as avant-garde as you could possibly wish, and it's only an extension of the scene I described in the last episode of Dance Little Lady, which you know had its own lighting effects and dance techniques and used masks and so on. So in a way, I think it's COWARD's own creation. And also COWARD had seen no plays, NOH in Japan, which use mime and puppetry. I mean he'd laughed at them, but he laughs at things that he often admires secretly. He loved Commedia dell'Arte. He knew about techniques which are actually as old as the theatre, whether it's silhouettes on a shadow cloth or on a cyclorama, or puppetry or masking. I mean, in a way, these techniques are avant-garde by dint of being as old as time. So he's a magpie where theatre is concerned. And as you say, he'd seen theatre all over the world, literally.
[13:32] Oliver Soden: Yeah, indeed, indeed. He'd seen in China and Japan and especially. So on the personal life front, several things happen during this period.
[13:40] Oliver Soden: Cole Leslie comes into his life.
[13:43] David Armstrong: Yeah.
[13:44] Oliver Soden: And I find it so interesting that this man who starts off as a servant, I guess, is that fair to say?
[13:50] Oliver Soden: A valet, yes.
[13:51] David Armstrong: Uh yeah, exactly, or uh even a cook at the time, yeah.
[13:54] Oliver Soden: But then he becomes a central partner in COWARD's life to a deep degree, although not as a romantic partner.
[14:02] Oliver Soden: No, I don't believe so. But yes, Cole Leslie, a sort of stage-struck working-class young man, begins as a chef, becomes a valet, turns into a secretary and assistant, and then one of his most intimate friends.
[14:14] Oliver Soden: And his Boswell, in the sense that he wrote the second most complete and still a very fine biography of COWARD, and was left half the money and the house in Jamaica, I think.
[14:25] David Armstrong: It's a massive shift.
[14:26] Oliver Soden: And he saw COWARD at his best and at his worst. But he was clearly brilliantly clever and taught himself fluent French and followed COWARD to France in the war and so on.
[14:35] Oliver Soden: I have unfinished business with Cole Leslie in a way, because I think he's so fascinating. On the professional front, as you say in the book, in contrast to the new American musicals that were sort of taking over London at this point from Broadway, Cole Porter, Rogers and Hart, Irving Berlin, for some reason, although COWARD is able to write terrific music in a jazz style, he keeps returning to the operetta.
[15:01] David Armstrong: Yes, and with diminishing returns.
[15:04] Oliver Soden: I guess he's trying to emulate the success of Bittersweet, and more and more he's tapping into a desire for nostalgia in the 30s, which tends to afflict any time of economic depression.
[15:15] Oliver Soden: The past suddenly seems cozy and rose-tinted. You know, that whole genre of Regency romance begins to take off in the 30s and so on.
[15:23] Oliver Soden: But it all culminates in a work called Operette, which he writes really as a vehicle for the Jewish actress Fritzi Massery, who is fleeing fascist Europe by this time.
[15:32] Oliver Soden: And of course, it doesn't work. It's about an aged star of Viennese operetta returning to the stage.
[15:38] Oliver Soden: It wasn't a success for COWARD at all, and I think only one song from it survives, The Stately Homes of England, which is very, very funny.
[15:45] Oliver Soden: But the whole show is sort of so ephemeral as to be barely there. And the timing seems to be very wrong.
[15:51] Oliver Soden: The show opened in London on the 16th of March 1938.
[15:56] David Armstrong: Yeah.
[15:56] Oliver Soden: And as you write in the book, with the curtain rising on a frothy haze of Viennese noblemen and ball-gowned ingenues, just the day after cheering crowds had gathered in the Austrian capital to witness Hitler announced the country's annexation.
[16:12] David Armstrong: Yes.
[16:12] Oliver Soden: I mean, you could had the work, dare I say it been of better quality, that contrast between the cozy history and the frightening present could have worked in its favour.
[16:21] Oliver Soden: But somehow, given the work in COWARD's own admission was rushed and not first rate, the chasm between COWARD's on-stage world and the terror of the off-stage one, I think was really too severe for it to last.
[16:34] Oliver Soden: And Mastery's English was no good, which didn't really help.
[16:38] David Armstrong: But it's interesting that he often seems to be creating work in order to help other people out.
[16:43] Oliver Soden: Yes. I mean, Gertrude Lawrence was forever in debt to the tax man. She could never sort out her finances.
[16:48] Oliver Soden: A lot of his work with her, especially Tonight at 8:30, was designed to give her income a bit of a boost, which it invariably did.
[16:55] Oliver Soden: And then the aim to help Fritzi Massary comes from what we might go on to talk about, which is his early formed and entirely genuine and I think in hindsight deeply admirable fear of fascism.
[17:07] Oliver Soden: He has a friend, a writer friend called William Belito, who died very young, but who was one of the first to tell the world about the darker side of Mussolini, who, in the view of a lot of Englishmen, had made the trains run on time in Italy.
[17:19] Oliver Soden: Coward had seen Mussolini speak, and he'd laughed, but he'd also been repelled. His friend Max Reinhardt, whom I mentioned a moment ago, had had to flee Germany owing to being Jewish.
[17:29] Oliver Soden: And COWARD had seen the dangers of fascism and knew, dare one say it earlier than some of his colleagues in the theatre actually did, and earlier, maybe even in the government, what the reality of Hitler was going to be.
[17:42] Oliver Soden: I admire him for his help not only for Jewish performers, but for black performers as well. And to go back to Cavalcade and Words and Music, both shows show COWARD working in innovative and in significant ways with black performers.
[17:56] Oliver Soden: The pianist Jack London, who'd also been an Olympic sprinter, I think, who was African American, he was given work in Cavalcade. And Words and Music was choreographed by Buddy Bradley, making Bradley the first black choreographer to work, I think, on a West End show by a white creative writer.
[18:16] Oliver Soden: He has a pretty good track record, I think, on helping performers who, in various different ways, might have been outcasts.
[18:26] David Armstrong: Don't go away. Oliver and I will be back with more conversation right after this quick break.
[18:40] Oliver Soden: My own.
[19:07] David Armstrong: Yeah.
[19:08] Oliver Soden: Which you have titled Tinsel and Sawdust a War Film.
[19:12] Oliver Soden: Yes. Which again, the way you've structured your book, with each section being a different genre of theatrical production, makes a lot of sense for this period where COWARD's life sort of does become like a war movie, and movies themselves become a prominent part of his creation during this period.
[19:31] Oliver Soden: Yeah, he creates the archetypal war film. He likens in his diary at one point the experience of being he was on a boat and he gets shot at and the bullets whiz past his head, and he expects to hear a movie director's voice say cut.
[19:45] Oliver Soden: So we're back to this point that I made right at the beginning of our conversation in the previous episode, that COWARD, even in the dangers of war, somehow feels he is performing, that he's in a fictional creation.
[19:56] Oliver Soden: And of course, it allowed me to use transcripts of some important moments during the war that could simply be set out in quasi screenplay form.
[20:04] Oliver Soden: And Tinsel and Sawdust, which is a phrase from a play he wrote during the war, PRESENT LAUGHTER, actors and nothing but puppets, creatures of tinsel and sawdust.
[20:14] Oliver Soden: A phrase, incidentally, that Ingmar Bergman picked up for the title of a film. I don't know if it was a conscious illusion.
[20:19] Oliver Soden: I thought it captured the simultaneous glamour and grubbiness of war, where sort of sawdust and sandbags and bomb damage were prevalent parts of life, but where there was a certain shiny, tinselly glamour to COWARD's idea, if not the reality, but COWARD's idea of what he could contribute, and indeed a shininess and a glint to the value and meaning that war gave to him in the event.
[20:46] Oliver Soden: Right back to Cavalcade, what is there to strive for, love or keep alive for? Well, if romantic love and British politics hadn't provided an answer to that question, having to fight in a war against the Nazis, where the cost of losing that war would have been unimaginable.
[21:01] Oliver Soden: This curiously hands to COWARD a sense of meaning and possibly even contentment that he admitted he hadn't felt for years.
[21:08] Oliver Soden: I think this happened to a lot of people in the Second World War. Suddenly, that sort of vacuousness of the interwar lifestyle, which was meaningless and we all party because there's nothing to live for, suddenly you had something to live for.
[21:20] David Armstrong: What were the various ways that COWARD both publicly and secretly became involved with the war?
[21:27] Oliver Soden: Ah, how long have you got? I very nearly thought for a while of making this book COWARD in World War II because there was simply so much, to stuff it all into the proverbial nutshell.
[21:38] Oliver Soden: It all begins with COWARD being hugely against the British government's policy of appeasement, of appeasing Hitler, of giving him the Sudetenland at the Munich Conference, regardless of the cost to the Czechs, regardless of the fact that they were doing a deal with someone who was evidently appalling.
[21:57] Oliver Soden: But it was the official government line for a long time. This went so far that you could not put anti-Hitler sentiment on the West End stage because the Lord Chamberlain would censor it as not being in line with the parliamentary view.
[22:10] Oliver Soden: And COWARD greatly to his credit, at a time where not everyone in the theatre agrees with him, and when George Bernard Shaw is acclaiming the Soviet Union, for example, as a land of promise run by a genius, thinks that Hitler is the end, and allies himself very quickly with a group of politicians who are out of government and out in the cold, Winston Churchill, Anthony Eden, Robert Boothby, Robert Mansittar.
[22:33] Oliver Soden: And what is interesting and most to the point is that the secret services in this country at this time, MI5, MI6, were not undertaking espionage work against Mussolini or against Hitler, because the government trusted, or almost trusted, the German government.
[22:50] Oliver Soden: And Churchill and that group set up an anti-MI5 secret service, funded by a lot of rich men in the entertainment industry, NOEL COWARD not least, sending COWARD and others as early as 1938 across the Soviet Union, Scandinavia, under the guise of visiting Grandee, but secretly COWARD is reporting back mainly to this figure Robert Van Sittart, who runs the whole outfit and possibly to another more elusive spymaster called Claude Danzi as to whether Nazi propaganda is infiltrating into ostensibly neutral countries.
[23:24] Oliver Soden: And COWARD goes to the Soviet Union and very quickly sees through the horrors of Stalinism and is followed everywhere and is bugged and passes documents across borders, locking himself into compartments on trains and so on and so forth.
[23:37] Oliver Soden: He ends up in what was called the Free City of Danzig on the Baltic coast north of Poland, which is where the Second World War really begins to kick off because the Nazis think it should belong to them.
[23:47] Oliver Soden: And he walks along streets with swastika banners unfurled from the government buildings handing over his secret document and manages with some difficulty to get back to England the day before, I think, Chamberlain, whom he detested for his politics and for appeasing Hitler, broadcasts to the nation that we're finally at war with Germany.
[24:07] Oliver Soden: And he's then recruited by the ex-editor of the Times, Campbell Stewart, to work in Paris secretly for the Ministry of Information.
[24:14] Oliver Soden: Then he's trained in a place called Woburn Abbey, which is more secret than for code-breaking at Bletchley Park at the time. He's sent to France, where he has a final time in Paris dealing with the inadequacies of the French Ministry of Information, but working essentially in propaganda.
[24:29] Oliver Soden: He's sent to America to see where American public opinion is lying, as trying to persuade them to help the Allied forces.
[24:36] Oliver Soden: He eventually ends up flying back to Paris just before Hitler and the Nazis march in and unfurl the swastika from the Arc de Triomphe, and he gets back to America.
[24:45] Oliver Soden: He works for William Stevenson, who's one of the biggest spy masters in the Western hemisphere. He travels through America spying for Stevenson, meeting figures such as Harry Truman, working out where America stands as far as the war is concerned, and then of course passing messages from Churchill to Roosevelt and back again.
[25:03] Oliver Soden: I mean, he ends up sitting on Roosevelt's bed. It's absolutely astonishing what he's doing, while making various ill-advised comments to the press, which start giving him a bad reputation in London.
[25:13] Oliver Soden: It's also the time of the Roosevelt Wendell-Wilkie election, which Roosevelt eventually wins, and he's reporting undercover on that as well, and where the election is likely to go and which newspaper magnates are going to support whom and so on.
[25:27] Oliver Soden: I mean, this barely takes us into 1941, and already he's done more than you know, enough to fill a short book in itself. Um but it is real espionage, it is spying in neutral countries, the consequences would have been severe, and the papers had been hidden for a long time, and I was able to look at diaries and reports in the National Archives and so on that had not been seen and just pieced together all of this, what he was doing from 38 to 41, as far as espionage was concerned.
[25:54] David Armstrong: It's so interesting because of course, and that's possibly the genius of choosing him to do this, is he seems like the least likely suspect to be involved in espionage.
[26:04] Oliver Soden: Yeah, exactly. It's another mask for him to wear.
[26:07] Oliver Soden: There's a great link between homosexuality and espionage in the two wars, partly because if this isn't too neat a parallel, gay men are used to a certain form of clandestine subterfuge in their life.
[26:21] Oliver Soden: But it's interesting how NOEL COWARD, who is born on the wrong side of the tracks, who is not aristocratic in any sense, ends up being a spy because it's the ultimate form of belonging to one country over another.
[26:32] Oliver Soden: It's an amazing form of acceptance for a gay man from Teddington, while also being simultaneously the ultimate act of outsider-ness, which is what NOEL COWARD always is.
[26:43] Oliver Soden: So it suits him more than you might think, even though he does, it has to be said, some foolish things and can't resist telling everybody that he's spying for the most famous spy master of the Western Hemisphere, and so on, and some of it, while I do think it comes from a very genuine patriotism and anti-Nazi sentiment, it also comes from the hope that he might possibly get a knighthood out of Churchill at the end of it.
[27:03] Oliver Soden: And we can't discount residual guilt from the First World War, I think. I think this is a means of offering to the second war what he was not able to give to the first.
[27:12] Oliver Soden: And of course he wasn't allowed to talk about this publicly. It didn't stop him doing it. You know, he would tell everybody, well, you know, if you heard of this man William Stevenson and so on.
[27:20] Oliver Soden: But of course it did. The work for Van Sittart, the anti-appeasement spying, never came out in his lifetime. He never spoke about that publicly. And that created a problem because what he was able to say caused him to come into a lot of criticism from the press.
[27:35] David Armstrong: From the press?
[27:36] Oliver Soden: And eventually from the government. Because Churchill had never entirely taken him seriously, and had said to him that the best thing to do would be to go and sing to the troops while the guns are firing. But this rather awful and well-known homophobe and closet homosexual I now gather, called Hugh Dalton, who worked in the government, eventually blocks COWARD from doing any espionage work. And I found in Dalton's diaries the entry saying that, you know, well, of course, COWARD was a Nancy. It is in the end a suspicion of his fame, a sense that, you know, a playwright shouldn't be getting involved in the highest levels of government, but also deep homophobia that puts an end to COWARD's spying work, really.
[28:15] David Armstrong: And of course, throughout all of this, his career and his personal life are continuing on.
[28:21] Oliver Soden: Yes.
[28:22] David Armstrong: He writes several of his most famous plays during this period PRESENT LAUGHTER, BLYTHE SPIRIT, both certainly at the top of the list of plays that get revived over and over again and have lived on.
[28:33] Oliver Soden: Completely. And Blythe Spirit outruns the war and is a play, a comedy about death and ghosts and domestic destruction put on in the middle of a London crushed by the Blitz. Very daring, but it paid off. I mean, COWARD's own house was bombed, and a lot of this spying work he'd done at his own expense without declaring his foreign currency, which it was his legal requirement to do. And part of this is Jack Wilson forgetting to do it and mucking things up with his American bank account. And he ends up in the dock at the Old Bailey in London. Two wartime trials that he has to get through, and he escapes with a fine. And he does the war films, and he tours the world as a performer. So there's more activity in the war than it seems almost humanly possible for one man to achieve.
[29:18] David Armstrong: And he begins a relationship with Michael Redgrave.
[29:21] Oliver Soden: Yeah.
[29:22] David Armstrong: Who will later become the father of Lynn Redgrave and Vanessa Redgrave.
[29:26] Oliver Soden: And Corinne yes, yeah.
[29:28] David Armstrong: Share with us just a little bit about that.
[29:30] Oliver Soden: Well, it's very hard to chart this relationship. I think sexually it was quite brief, and it was conducted at the Savoy where COWARD was living, and then was cut short by Redgrave going into the Navy, which was always COWARD's great attraction in young men. And Redgrave was intellectual and left wing and quite highbrow. He'd been in T. S. Elliott plays and so on before beginning a career in movies. But somehow it worked, and although it was short-lived, it seems to have been quite passionate. I still want to go and look at Michael Redgrave's diaries, which are held at the Victoria and Albert Museum in London, but which haven't been open or available in the last couple of years. And that might shed more light.
I mean, they stayed friends their whole life. But the really extraordinary thing, and we're back to my point about the dignity of wives in these bisexual love triangles, is that Michael Redgrave was married to the actress Rachel Kempson. And when Redgrave was called up and went to sea and went to the war, he spent his last night of his leave, not with his wife Rachel, but with NOEL COWARD. And what is interesting is that although that upset Rachel Kempson very much, she and COWARD actually had a rather loving relationship, and she said that she loved him and she worked with him and toured in his plays during the war. So we're back to these curious triangles that mingle platonic love and sexual passion and then calm themselves onto a sort of lighter plane.
[30:50] David Armstrong: And on top of all that, Noel is the producer, the writer, the star, the composer of the score, and the co-director of what was called at the time the best war film ever made.
[31:01] Oliver Soden: Yeah, in which we serve I'm often asked what COWARD was most proud of in his career, what he thought was his most important achievement, at least artistically. And I think more than any of the great comedies he might have nominated in WHICH WE SERVE, which he thought was his greatest contribution, the most important thing he ever did. I mean, I'm sure people have seen it. It's the sort of archetypal semi fictionalized war movie. It sets up the pattern for all the war movies that were to come. It's a thinly veiled account of the sinking of his Majesty's ship Crete, which was commanded by Louis Mountbatten, the naval commander who went on to be the Viceroy of India and was linked to the royal family and so on.
[31:41] David Armstrong: And he was a very close friend of COWARD.
[31:43] Oliver Soden: Very close friend of COWARD, of whom rather dark details are still emerging that I don't believe COWARD had anything to do with. And COWARD plays the Mountbatten naval figure, rather more like NOEL COWARD than as Louis Mountbatten, sort of dealing with the sinking of the ship with stiff British upper lips and so on. It rather like cavalcade. It is not simply a tubthumpingly patriotic work of art. It's a mosaic of domestic miniature showing the wives that were left behind. It very daringly shows a British defeat in order to raise British morale, which is an interesting conundrum. It had huge resonance. It's deeply moving still. It had visual spectacle and was very, very difficult to make, and involved sort of real planes being used and the construction of the warship and films shot in filthy tanks of freezing water to recreate the Mediterranean, and Mountbatten thought that the conditions in the real sinking of HMS Crete were rather easier than the ones that all the actors, among them Richard Attenborough, John Mills, COWARD himself, had to put up with.
And indeed, a studio engineer was killed in the making of In Which We Served when he took the lid off a tin of gunpowder that was still hot and it exploded in his face. But it was a triumph and nearly led to COWARD being knighted, were it not for those trials owing to the American currency.
[32:57] David Armstrong: And how was that movie in which we served perceived today?
[33:01] Oliver Soden: Well, it's a sort of Christmas classic here in England. I don't know if it is in America.
[33:05] David Armstrong: No, it hasn't entered the culture here in that way.
[33:08] Oliver Soden: I didn't think so. It certainly requires you, as a viewer in 2023, to place it back within its time, if you are to accept scenes such as the cheering of the death of German sailors, for example. But it absolutely moves still on a human level, on its focus on, as I say, the death of the women and the children, on the way it's able to combine this epic spectacle with this domestic miniature of individuals that make up a war. That's what I find moving about it. And it does it with great subtlety and restraint. For example, a man on board the ship is informed of the death of his wife, and he responds simply by saying, Oh yes, yes, I see, that's it. A man who has survived the sinking of the ship sends news of his survival to his anxious family merely in two words.
Okay, love. And I think that amazing economy and subtlety. And COWARD does all of that relief and wanting to reassure in two words. So it's a work of economy and subtlety. And I have one more example, and it's very hard to describe why I think this is so good. It's a parting scene between a sailor going to war who might be killed and his wife who is going back home on her own. And instead of professing undying love or saying all the important things that need to be said, she says to him, I won't forget to get the lawnmower mended. And it's hard to convey why I think that line is genius. But I think it is genius in that it conveys so much. It conveys a woman's understanding of a man, it contains a man's priorities, it contains reassurance, and it contains everything they need to tell one another about how much they love one another and how scared they are and all their hopes and fears, and he does it with a line about a lawnmower, and in so doing, I guess he would argue, captures something about the British character of restraint. Very few playwrights, I think, would have included, I shan't forget to get the lawnmower mended. But that is the difference somehow between a good film and a great film.
[35:14] David Armstrong: And an understanding of human nature, somehow.
[35:17] Oliver Soden: And as with so much of COWARD's work, it's about what the characters don't say.
[35:22] David Armstrong: Indeed, exactly.
[35:23] Oliver Soden: And if that wasn't enough, there's then sort of a double whammy of a second major film.
[35:28] David Armstrong: BRIEF ENCOUNTER.
[35:30] Oliver Soden: Yes.
[35:30] David Armstrong: And film has not particularly been COWARD's métier up to this point.
[35:34] Oliver Soden: No, all his early screen tests apparently showed that he couldn't act. But of course, he's joined forces now with the young director David Lean, who becomes a legendary figure and concedes all the support COWARD gave him. Producers, he has a troop of wonderful actors, Celia Johnson is in, in which we serve, and in BRIEF ENCOUNTER. So between them they make of BRIEF ENCOUNTER one of those films that's become immortal, and which I didn't see till I was quite some way through the project. I saw it at the sort of right time in the writing. And I was blown away by it. I thought it was just a masterpiece. And deeply moving and upsetting and passionate. And has that same technique of a couple falling in love through a discussion of ostensible trivia.
[36:14] David Armstrong: And although it's released after the war, it is written and produced during the war.
[36:19] Oliver Soden: Yes. And its whole atmosphere, I mean it's shot in black and white, its lighting, its shadows, speak of war-torn England somehow. And of all those affairs that happened behind the blackout curtains, and of all the meaning that the war gave to women who suddenly were taken away from the kitchen sink and put in the driver's seats of ambulances or the code breaking of Bletchley Park or whatever. And it captures the way that was taken away again, and how everything clamped up in 1945, and how all these brilliant women who had had affairs or had worked in high levels of war were put back in front of the sink, and the men were put back in charge, and they were returned to their sort of dreary life of suburbia and padded curtains and family and child rearing.
And it catches all of that in the way it shows a suburban woman having an affair that is doomed to impermanence, and she has to go back to her husband who doesn't understand what's happened. It's COWARD catching a cuss again. He's very good at these sort of seismic notions of social change, both progressive and regressive.
[37:20] David Armstrong: What happens at the end of the war is that a copy of what was called the Zonder von Dungslister was discovered, which is the hit list of everyone who was going to be murdered or executed, come the Nazi invasion of Britain had it happened. And COWARD was on this list, which shows the levels to which he was working, that the Nazis believed him to be in a secret location somewhere. And also on this list was Rebecca West, and when it became known that they were both going to be up against the war in this auspicious company, Virginia Wolfe, Churchill, so on. Rebecca West sent COWARD a telegram, and the telegram said, My dear, the people we should have been seen dead with. And I love that because it is very funny, but it puts into practice COWARD's philosophy, which may have been Rebecca West's as well, that laughing in the face of the unimaginable and the frightening and the apocalyptic is really the best weapon. And I love that quip as an example of putting COWARD's entire flippant serious philosophy into practice.
[38:21] David Armstrong: Please join Oliver and I on the next episode of Broadway Nation, when we will follow Noor Coward into the 1950s.
[38:29] ♪ Musical number ♪
[39:03] David Armstrong: A donation of just seven dollars a month will not only keep Broadway Nation rolling along, it will also provide you with exclusive access to the complete unedited versions of many of the interviews that you hear on this podcast. And all patrons will receive special shout-outs and acknowledgments of your vital support for Broadway Nation. To join, simply go to Broadway Nation Podcast. That's Broadway Nation Podcast. S-U-P-R-C-A-S-T. Or click the link in the show notes to this episode. Broadway Nation is written and produced by me, David Armstrong. Special thanks to Pal'Mox for his help with editing this episode and to the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.
[39:51] ♪ Musical number ♪
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
