Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 129: Noel Coward In A Changing World, part 5

My guest again this week is Oliver Soden whose recent book is titled Masquerade – The Lives of Noel Coward. I am devoting more episodes to this book than I have to any previous books, but I found the writing and research to be so exceptional, and this conversation with Soden to be so captivating that I don’t want you to miss any of it... Read More

From the show: BROADWAY NATION

27 mins
12/7/23

Guests

Featured Shows

About

My guest again this week is Oliver Soden whose recent book is titled Masquerade – The Lives of Noel Coward.

I am devoting more episodes to this book than I have to any previous books, but I found the writing and research to be so exceptional, and this conversation with Soden to be so captivating that I don’t want you to miss any of it.

Today Oliver and I focus on a very difficult period in Noel Coward’s career when his was seen to be seriously out of step with the theatrical world of post-war Britain. However, in his personal life during this same time he meets the man who will become his life partner, Graham Payn.

If you missed the previous episode in this series you may want to catch up with those before listening to this one.

Become a PATRON of Broadway Nation!

I want to thank our Broadway Nation Patron Club members, such as Larry Spinelli, whose generous support helps to make it possible for me to bring this podcast to you each week. If you would like to support the creation of Broadway Nation, here is the information about how you too can become a patron.

For a just $7.00 a month you will receive exclusive access to never-before-heard, unedited versions of many of the discussions that I have with my guests — in fact I often record nearly twice as much conversation as ends up in the edited versions. You will also have access to additional in-depth conversations with my frequent co-host Albert Evans that have not been featured on the podcast.

All patrons receive special “on-air” shout-outs and acknowledgement of your vital support of this podcast. And if you are very enthusiastic about Broadway Nation there are additional PATRON levels that come with even more benefits.

If you would like to support the work of Broadway Nation and receive these exclusive member benefits, please just click on this link:

https://broadwaynationpodcast.supercast.tech/

Thank you in advance for your support!

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:02] David Armstrong: Welcome to another episode of Broadway Nation, the podcast that tells the remarkable story of how immigrants, Jews, queers, and African Americans invented the Broadway musical.

[0:13] David Armstrong: This is a changing world, my dear.

[0:30] David Armstrong: I'm David Armstrong, and my guest again today is Oliver Soden, whose recent book is titled Masquerade, The Lives of Noel Coward.

[0:40] David Armstrong: As you may have noticed, I'm devoting more episodes to this book than I've ever devoted to any book before, but I found it to be so exceptional and this conversation to be so captivating that I don't want you to miss any of it.

[0:53] David Armstrong: Today, Oliver Soden and I focus on a very difficult period in Coward's career when he seemed to be seriously out of step with post-war Britain.

[1:02] David Armstrong: However, during this same period in his personal life, he meets the man who will become his life partner.

[1:08] David Armstrong: If you missed the previous episodes in this series, you may want to catch up with those before listening to this one.

[1:14] David Armstrong: I want to especially thank our Broadway Nation patron club members, such as Larry Spinelli, whose generous support helps make this podcast possible.

[1:23] David Armstrong: If you would like to help support the creation of Broadway Nation, I'll have information at the end of the episode about how you too can become a patron.

[1:45] David Armstrong: Welcome to living in a changing world.

[2:01] David Armstrong: Here we go.

[2:04] David Armstrong: So the next section of your book you call the desert, and that details a long period of nearly 20 plays, of which only a handful can be considered to be successful, even.

[2:16] Oliver Soden: Yes.

[2:16] David Armstrong: Meanwhile, London is falling in love with the new golden age style American musicals like Oklahoma.

[2:23] David Armstrong: You wrote that I think it was in one of his diaries, Coward wrote that he found it to be quite the loveliest of evenings I've ever spent in the theatre.

[2:30] Oliver Soden: Deep and abiding theatrical pleasure.

[2:33] David Armstrong: Yes.

[2:33] David Armstrong: So it's interesting that he was understandably, because he's a man of the theater, he would appreciate this success of that show and what Roger Hammerstein were able to do with musical theater, but he doesn't seem drawn to try that himself, at least at this period.

[2:48] Oliver Soden: No, it's interesting that.

[2:49] Oliver Soden: Interesting that he was much more embracing than might be expected of the new and the young, because he could be sort of an old curmudgeon when he wanted to be.

[2:58] David Armstrong: Right.

[2:59] Oliver Soden: But I think he believed that he, Coward, was the great purveyor of nostalgia.

[3:04] Oliver Soden: And he got this wrong, but he thought that there would be audience interest in the new, yes, but also in the pre-war or even former century world of operetta.

[3:13] Oliver Soden: He was sort of churning out more bittersweets in a curious way.

[3:16] Oliver Soden: With Pacific 1860, which is really very operetta-like, and then with a musical I barely know, short of the big songs, because it simply hasn't been done again, called Ace of Clubs.

[3:26] David Armstrong: Right.

[3:27] Oliver Soden: And they're not in the vein of the big Broadway musical, particularly not Pacific 1860.

[3:32] Oliver Soden: They have sort of gypsy melodies and operetta songs for soubretes and sopranos.

[3:37] Oliver Soden: And of course, up against Oklahoma, they seemed desperately old-fashioned.

[3:41] Oliver Soden: And they also, particularly Pacific 1860, are just beginning to have a political angle in that this is the period of British decolonization through the Sioux Crisis and on.

[3:53] Oliver Soden: And that is the next generation's social cause in some way.

[3:56] Oliver Soden: And Coward, till the end of his days, remains pretty much a supporter of the British Empire.

[4:01] Oliver Soden: And Pacific 1860 is the first of a number of works that he's set on this fictional island of Somolo, which entertaining as you might think it could be, is pretty much designed to say that the in quotes natives are very happy under British rule.

[4:16] Oliver Soden: And of course, Coward's portrayal of these natives is so stereotypical and condescending.

[4:22] Oliver Soden: So it's the start of a great difficult period in his life where he's against the wind, even as he supports the wind, as far as Oklahoma is concerned.

[4:30] Oliver Soden: But politically, artistically, and sometimes literally, and we'll come on to Las Vegas later.

[4:35] Oliver Soden: He is sort of standing alone in the desert trying to be a bastion of pre-war values with limited success.

[4:43] Oliver Soden: And Mary Martin was the star of Pacific 1860.

[4:46] David Armstrong: But you see, a little accident is a good an accident?

[4:50] Oliver Soden: Oh, nothing in the least serious.

[4:52] Oliver Soden: My horse has cast a shoe.

[4:54] Oliver Soden: A careless thing to do.

[4:56] Oliver Soden: Although he has apologized and showed that he is most upset.

[5:01] Oliver Soden: For conduct so uncivilized, I cannot wipe forgive him a yeah.

[5:09] David Armstrong: Of course, of course.

[5:10] Oliver Soden: There is nothing so uncautious as a horse.

[5:14] Oliver Soden: My horse has cast a shoe.

[5:16] Oliver Soden: So I appeal to you.

[5:18] Oliver Soden: I meet you by your happy chance in the suntime circumstance.

[5:27] Oliver Soden: To be able to assist Madame Salvador is an honor that I shan't forget.

[5:33] Oliver Soden: I will derive you safely home in my father wagon.

[5:43] Oliver Soden: You are so kind.

[5:45] Oliver Soden: I'll be able to death or your shovel be combined with your mother's wagon now.

[5:52] Oliver Soden: Who could not tell?

[5:54] Oliver Soden: That a mountability, what a rage for what we fell.

[5:59] Oliver Soden: Who before me, just exactly by your gate.

[6:03] Oliver Soden: Who knows?

[6:05] Oliver Soden: What magic power guides the heart of home?

[6:15] David Armstrong: And as you write, this was part of this pattern that happened during this period of conflicts during the rehearsal period, numerous rewrites of these shows, and then indifferent or even hostile reviews, and then very short runs for most of the shows.

[6:30] David Armstrong: Also, we have to remember that Coward is used to these massive, huge budget spectaculars that he'd worked on and that we discussed in earlier episodes, such as Cavalcade or Bittersweet.

[6:42] David Armstrong: And now he's dealing with post-war privation.

[6:45] David Armstrong: And one of the theatres, I think the Drury Lane Theatre Royal for Pacific 1860, the box office was being lit by candles.

[6:53] David Armstrong: Even though the war is over, rationing is going to continue in England for years.

[6:57] Oliver Soden: And he and his great friend Gladys Calthrop, who did all the costumes for a great number of his plays, were really struggling with this new world.

[7:06] Oliver Soden: And when the reviews painted Coward as washed up, it made him touchy and nervous, so it meant that whether it was Mary Martin or somebody else, he was very short-tempered in rehearsals.

[7:16] Oliver Soden: So a lot of these post-war plays are struck through with temper and argument.

[7:22] Oliver Soden: It's so interesting that deprivation is something we really don't understand in America, how much it affected just every aspect of daily life during this period through the 50s to a great extent.

[7:33] Oliver Soden: Right through. I mean, I think the last rationing came off in England in the early 60s, even.

[7:38] Oliver Soden: And this is bomb-damaged London. I mean, it's interesting Coward thought he would offer war-tired audiences an escape, this sunlit island in the Pacific Ocean and so on.

[7:48] Oliver Soden: But of course, the disparity between a cold London late 1940s Christmas and the sunlit kind of totally irrelevant idyll on the stage with colonial types wandering about pretty insignificant things, was so it was such a chasm that it just didn't lift off.

[8:05] Oliver Soden: And with Ace of Clubs, which came three years later, which is a sort of I mean it's Coward having a go at Americanisms, there as sailors and gangsters, sort of proto-guys and dolls, as far as I can work out.

[8:16] Oliver Soden: But he didn't know the language really. It's not his comfort zone.

[8:19] Oliver Soden: So I think it came across as oddly as that's and synthetic.

[8:23] Oliver Soden: And it feels to me, again, it's hard to know because there's so little tangible about it to touch, but it feels a little bit like it's a 1930s style gangster-y, nightclub y world or 1920s, even, as opposed to something much more fully fleshed out like Guys and Dolls is.

[8:40] Oliver Soden: Exactly. Although, of course, I've always argued that one thing that didn't leave Coward over this desert-like period was his talent as a lyricist.

[8:49] Oliver Soden: What you can do is read the lyrics for these musicals, and some of them, these scores are odd hotchpotches, cause you have gypsy ballads and you have Viennese waltzes, and you haven't sort of jazz numbers and so on.

[9:00] Oliver Soden: So it's a sort of gallimophrey.

[9:01] Oliver Soden: But when the lyrics are at their most fizzing and dexterous and witty, they're as superb as anything he did.

[9:08] Oliver Soden: I mean, there's a wonderful rhyme for Napoleon Bonaparte and sitting on his own apart or something that I think is from Ace of Clubs, so that there's still the dazzle there, but the overall picture he's finding much more problematic.

[9:20] Oliver Soden: Some terrific songs in that, and a lot of them were then reused later in the reviews of Coward's work.

[9:26] Oliver Soden: They will be familiar to a lot of us.

[9:28] Oliver Soden: The famous one, the one I love so much, is Sail Away, which became the title song of a new musical in its own right, but which I think originated in Ace of Clubs.

[9:38] Oliver Soden: Yes, that's right. First time round.

[9:39] Oliver Soden: These glimmers of the old inspiration.

[9:42] Oliver Soden: I mean, that kind of talent doesn't just wither, it just sort of lost its way.

[9:46] Oliver Soden: But the lights are still on in some way.

[9:48] Oliver Soden: I like America.

[9:50] Oliver Soden: I played around every snappy, happy hunting ground, but I find America okay.

[9:59] Oliver Soden: I've been about a bit, but I must admit that I didn't know the half of it till I hit the USA.

[10:09] Oliver Soden: No likely less in Boston, mass from passion will recoil.

[10:14] Oliver Soden: In Dell Techs, they talk of sex, but only think of oil.

[10:19] Oliver Soden: In Tennessee, the BBC would blush to hear what's said.

[10:25] Oliver Soden: In Chicago will annoy any girl who meets a boy, giggles and shoots him dead.

[10:30] Oliver Soden: But I like America.

[10:32] Oliver Soden: It's society.

[10:34] Oliver Soden: Opposing the variety and calm a walk may.

[10:38] Oliver Soden: I shall return someday to the gold all youather.

[10:50] Oliver Soden: And Ace of Clubs brings Graham Payn back into his life, or really for the first time, although they have a strange intersection prior to that.

[10:59] Oliver Soden: But for the rest of his life, he will be his primary partner.

[11:02] David Armstrong: Is that fair to say?

[11:03] Oliver Soden: Yeah, absolutely.

[11:04] Oliver Soden: Graham Payn was South African.

[11:06] Oliver Soden: He was brought up in South Africa, and he was working during and after the war as a kind of jobbing, handsome actor, singer who'd never quite been made a star.

[11:15] Oliver Soden: And there's also a revue, only reasonably successful again, called Sigh No More, which was their first collaboration when Payn was an adult.

[11:25] Oliver Soden: Oddly, that review in 1932, called Words and Music, had had Payn as a child star when he was, I think, in his early teens, if that.

[11:35] Oliver Soden: So it's a curious relationship in that there is this big age difference, and I don't think it stayed a kind of sexually passionate relationship for all that long.

[11:43] Oliver Soden: But that actually may have been the reason that it could settle when it began in 45 and then lasted, as you say, until Coward's death in 73, onto a much calmer, more platonic, more companionable plane.

[11:54] Oliver Soden: And they were sort of life partners, but living in this curious triangle with Cole Leslie, who we've talked about before, who is now working as Coward's assistant and who gets on with Graham Payn terribly well.

[12:05] Oliver Soden: I don't think it's an amorous menage artois.

[12:08] Oliver Soden: The emotional, um, romantic relationship is very much only between Graham and Coward.

[12:13] Oliver Soden: And yet they were a triangle, with Coward very much at the top.

[12:17] Oliver Soden: So it's a curious domestic setup to try and unpin.

[12:21] Oliver Soden: And of course, he loved Graham and Graham loved him.

[12:24] Oliver Soden: But Coward had no hesitation in telling Graham to his face just where the limitations in his Graham's talent were, while always thinking that were it only for a little spur of ambition, Graham could be a star, which Graham later was quite honest about saying was probably a fantasy.

[12:43] Oliver Soden: So of course, one of the reasons that Coward's work starts to go off the rails a little bit is that he's forever trying to think of vehicles for Graham Payn to star in.

[12:52] Oliver Soden: And of course, if you write so pragmatically, you're probably not letting your comic inspiration have its head.

[12:57] Oliver Soden: And then, of course, it could be argued that Graham's performances were not keeping the Coward plays afloat.

[13:03] Oliver Soden: I mean, there was a disastrous revival of Tonight at 8 30, which really requires from its lead performer, in this case Graham Payn, a massive dexterity and virtuosity and range musically and theatrically, that he simply did not have, especially in the shining light of Gertrude Lawrence, who came back to star in the revival.

[13:22] Oliver Soden: So that production really got bad reviews and didn't last very long.

[13:26] Oliver Soden: It's a curious relationship, but one that brings a lot of domestic contentment for the first time in Coward's life, I think.

[13:33] Oliver Soden: And you quote Cole Leslie as saying that they were a family, that three of them together formed this family.

[13:39] Oliver Soden: Yes.

[13:40] Oliver Soden: Graham had had a pushy stage mother, rather like Coward's, but where Violet Coward was loving, Graham's mother was not. And he rather believed, as I think did Coward, his love for his mother notwithstanding, that water was much thicker than blood. I mean, it's a curious, rather moving flag wave of these often homosexual communities, who are not particularly in this case, but who are often estranged from their own families. They're not able to have or even adopt in this period, children of their own. And therefore the chosen family, the loyalty for the emotional family rather than the blood family, who are chosen rather than inherited, becomes all the stronger and tight-knit. And it's not just this trio of Graham and Cole and Coward, but these concentric ripples of the playwright Clemence Dane, the actress Joyce Carey, Gladys Calthrop, the costume designer, and it becomes a real unit.

And we're back to what Coward's plays of the 30s were trying to do. It's another alternative design for living, whether that's in a gay duo or a trio or a group or whatever it happens to be that is throwing out the idea of the nuclear blood family and any sense that you have a particular tie to people you might be related to even if you don't like them. It's Coward putting the message of his plays into practice, I think, and finding in the 20th century alternative ways to live and love.

[15:01] David Armstrong: At the beginning of this relationship, you say that he fell for Graham Payn with a force nobody had seen since the first days of Jack Wilson, or you quote somebody saying that. Meanwhile, Jack Wilson is having tremendous success on Broadway as the director of "Kiss Me Kate" and "Gentlemen Prefer Blondes." But the relationship with Coward remains to some degree, and even though he's married to Natalia Paley, he's jealous of Graham Payn.

[15:25] Oliver Soden: Hugely so, and by this stage he's also becoming a serious alcoholic, and was very prematurely aged. His hair went white at a very young age. And it's interesting because I've read some of the correspondence at the time where you can see Coward possibly because of the geographical distance between the two, because Wilson is in America and Coward at this stage is still in England most of the time and Jamaica in the winter. Coward is still living in his memory in a certain extent and wanting to believe that things are as they always had been, and has this sort of helpless love for Jack despite some very obvious things that are going on, and then, as you say, complicated by Jack Wilson's success with the new kind of musical that seems to have put Coward out into the cold.

And there's also on the scene the playwright Terence Rattigan, who eventually becomes a friend and supporter of Coward's, but initially seemed to be a younger rival. And a lot of Rattigan's plays were produced on Broadway by Jack Wilson with huge success. And Jack would do things as recorded in Coward's diaries, such as interrupt meals that Coward and Graham were having together, and clearly be rude about Graham in some way, perhaps possibly not unjustified when it came to his performing ability. But there's a heart-rending diary entry of Coward's, where at the end of one of these interruptions from Jack, Coward goes home and he's physically sick in reaction to the stress of what is happening.

And things really begin to break apart between Wilson and Coward. I mean, they haven't been a couple in that sense for a long time, but the friendship had endured, but it really begins to fracture, and Wilson sort of curdles into this alcoholic old age and premature death. It's sad, really.

[17:01] ♪ Musical number: "Let's Say Goodbye" — performed by Noel Coward ♪

[17:39] David Armstrong: Don't go away. Oliver and I will be back with more conversation right after this quick break.

[17:59] ♪ Musical number: "Sail Away" — performed by Noel Coward ♪

[18:50] David Armstrong: Talk a little bit about what Jamaica and Goldenhurst and Firefly mean to Coward during this period. They're so famous in the sort of Coward lore. And again, I don't know how much of that was his own publicity or his ability to sort of craft his story in a way that is so romantic and you understand what I'm getting at.

[19:10] Oliver Soden: Yeah, exactly. The sense of the jet-setting playwright, you know, wintering in Jamaica and so on. I mean, he goes first for a holiday to stay in Ian Fleming's house, Golden Eye, which Coward thought was so uncomfortable he christened it Golden Eye, Nose and Throat. Instantly wants to have a piece of this winter sunshine for himself, and he's very rheumatic at this point. So the winter cold and the grimness of post-war Britain, although he does have a new house on the beach in Kent at this period, is really starting to get into his bones. So a bit of winter sun would be rather nice, thank you. So he goes off and slowly builds what became two properties to spend the winter there. I think he did quite genuinely adore the escape.

I mean, this is the Coward who wrote "Sail Away" and sailed away quite literally when things went badly for him, which they, as I say, did begin to do. So it was a genuine escape. And if it was part of his PR, that backfired because he was turning his back on the British people at a time of deprivation, and he who had seemed to exemplify the English character was now spending less and less time in England. And the sort of jet-setting upper crust set, where they had once been such interesting fodder for theatrical playwriting before the war, and where everybody had seemed so interested in what the rich leisurely set were doing in Mayfair and so on. When they're doing it on Jamaica after the war, it seems increasingly irrelevant to a Labour government and the birth of the welfare state.

But it is a sort of playpen for Coward. He's rich enough to recreate the Peter Pan world. He can still be a lost boy on Neverland, and he can still do upper-class bedhopping. And he can pretend that the pre-war lifestyle is still going on. It just happens to be a very small group of people with money on Jamaica, because Ivor Novello had a house there, Gladys Calthrop had a house, Ian Fleming. So it's a sort of—I mean, we might say as the homophobia in England and America got much more intense than it had been really up till that point. It's a means of living with Graham quite quietly out of the public eye as well. So Jamaica is beloved, but it's a sort of play act as well, I would argue. A sort of playpen, really.

[21:19] David Armstrong: Well, and as you said, so much of his life is a performance, his private life is a performance. And this is another stage to perform on, in a way.

[21:27] Oliver Soden: Or at least for his little world.

[21:28] David Armstrong: Yeah, I agree. He continues with more of the works that we talked about, "Relative Values," another play for the lunch quadrille, which is not a success. And then another musical "After the Ball."

[21:39] Oliver Soden: Oh yes, yes.

[21:41] David Armstrong: Which is based on Oscar Wilde, is that right?

[21:43] Oliver Soden: I still—I could never quite work out why Coward, beyond a need for money, which he did need in this period with very, very high taxes and not particularly successful productions, because he didn't like Oscar Wilde. And this is a musical adaptation of "Lady Windermere's Fan," the Wilde play. It's really a silly idea in the first place because it interrupts the perfect structure of Wilde's play and the sort of lineup of Wilde's witticisms with songs and dancing, which is an architectural problem. He's not sympathetic to Wilde, who was politically very different to Coward, whose wit actually works in a very, very different way. And Cole Leslie was responsible for quite a lot of the book writing, I think.

Coward just works only intermittently on it, and it has an unhappy rehearsal period and so on. But really what you have is the scraping up against one another of Coward's type of humour, because Coward's characters know that they're funny and they wield humour as a shield and as a weapon. Whereas Wilde's characters are in deadly earnest. You can't ever deliver Oscar Wilde's dialogue, tipping the wink to the audience that you know it's funny, because it doesn't work like that. They have to be in deadly, deadly earnest. It's the importance of being earnest, is in the delivery of Wilde's play, really. So it just didn't quite work. And this is all happening at a time when eventually Coward's tax bill is getting so high and he's in so much debt.

He stops being domiciled in England and goes to various tax havens. One of the first celebrities to do this, first in Bermuda and then in Switzerland. And he's not able to supervise a lot of rehearsals for the plays in this period, which means he often sort of swooped in to see the show in Dublin for a dress rehearsal and then decided it was awful and threw everything up in the air and redid it at the last minute. So that these are not comfortable atmospheres in which Coward's work can really be meticulously put together either.

[23:33] David Armstrong: And this is because he's legally restricted from spending a significant amount of time in England.

[23:38] Oliver Soden: In order to cancel his English domicile, he had to have a whole year living abroad. And from then on he could only spend a very limited number of days, either in America or in the UK, and he's living a rather sort of solitary, unhappy life in Bermuda, where his income tax is so low, and then eventually Switzerland in combination with Jamaica. But it means he can sort of only attend his rehearsals almost in secret. He could only ever see his plays in Dublin, and there's one or two plays he never saw staged at all because of this.

[24:08] David Armstrong: Which, as a theatre maker sounds crazy because how could you possibly finish the show or put the final touches on which he was so famous for?

[24:16] Oliver Soden: And this is Coward the theatrical control freak as well.

[24:19] David Armstrong: Exactly. That's what I'm saying. It's hard to rectify how he justified that in his mind, but he had no choice, I guess, or felt he had no choice.

[24:26] Oliver Soden: Yeah, I think so.

[24:27] David Armstrong: In probably the weirdest kind of way, he finds a way out of his economic travails here in Las Vegas.

[24:34] ♪ Musical number: "I Like America" — performed by Noel Coward ♪

[25:08] David Armstrong: On the next episode of Broadway Nation, Oliver and I will follow Noel Coward to his triumph in Las Vegas and his unlikely comeback as a film and television star in a music-filled episode that you won't want to miss. Now here's the information about how you too can become a patron of Broadway Nation. A donation of just seven dollars a month will not only keep Broadway Nation rolling along, it will also provide you with exclusive access to the complete unedited versions of many of the interviews that you hear on this podcast. And all patrons will receive special shout-outs and acknowledgments of your vital support for Broadway Nation. To join, simply go to Broadway Nation Podcast dot supercast dot tech.

That's Broadway Nation Podcast. Or click the link in the show notes to this episode. Broadway Nation is written and produced by me, David Armstrong. Special thanks to Pal'Mox for his help with editing this episode and to the entire team at the Spanish main, eaten sugar cane, but I never tasted cellophane till I struck the USA.

[26:28] ♪ Musical number ♪

[27:08] David Armstrong: Welcome back to Broadway Nation.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred