Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 141: Exceptional Storytelling Is Possible

My guest again this week is author BEN WEST who returns for the fourth and final segment of our conversation in regard to his exceptional new book The American Musical – Evolution of an Art Form... Read More

From the show: BROADWAY NATION

36 mins
5/13/24

Guests

Featured Shows

About

My guest again this week is author BEN WEST who returns for the fourth and final segment of our conversation in regard to his exceptional new book The American Musical – Evolution of an Art Form.

As you will hear, in today’s episode, we move into what I call the Modern Era of Broadway from the 1970s right up to today and detail the major changes in the way musicals are made over the last 50 years. Our discussion touches on such shows as Hair, Your Own Thing, Rent, The Wiz, Jelly’s Last Jam, Hamilton, The Band’s Visit, and more!

If you missed the previous episodes in this series you may want to go back and catch on that before listening to this one.

Ben West is a musical theatre artist and historian who created the extensive “Timeline Wall” exhibits for the Museum of Broadway that trace the history of the Broadway stage from 1732 to 2021, spotlighting more than 500 productions and 100 artists. He has worked in various capacities on Broadway, Off-Broadway, and regionally and created and directed Unsung Carolyn Leigh for Lincoln Center’s American Songbook series. He has lectured and spoken at Yale University, University of Michigan, the Dramatists Guild, and the Shubert Organization.

Become a PATRON of Broadway Nation!

This podcast is made possible in part by the generous support of our Patron Club Members, including our Producer Level patrons, Paula & Steve Reynolds.

For just $7.00 a month, you will receive exclusive access to never-before-heard, unedited versions of many of the discussions that I have with my guests — in fact I often record nearly twice as much conversation as ends up in the edited versions. You will also have access to additional in-depth conversations with my frequent co-host Albert Evans that have not been featured on the podcast. All patrons receive special “on-air” shout-outs and acknowledgment of your vital support of this podcast. And if you are very enthusiastic about Broadway Nation there are additional PATRON levels that come with even more benefits.

If you would like to support the work of Broadway Nation and receive these exclusive member benefits, please just click on this link:

https://broadwaynationpodcast.supercast.tech/

Thank you in advance for your support!

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:06] David Armstrong: Welcome to another episode of Broadway Nation, the podcast that tells the remarkable story of how immigrant, Jewish, queer, and black artists invented the Broadway musical and how they changed America in the process.

[0:20] David Armstrong: I'm David Armstrong, and my guest again today is author Ben West, who returns for the fourth and final segment of our conversation regarding his exceptional new book, The American Musical: Evolution of an Art Form.

[0:34] David Armstrong: As you will hear, today we move into what I call the modern era of Broadway, from the 1970s right up to today, and the major changes in the way musicals are made that have occurred over the last 50 years.

[0:47] David Armstrong: Our discussion will touch on a variety of shows, including Hair, Your Own Thing, Rent, The Whiz, Jelly's Last Jam, Hamilton, The Band's Visit, and more.

[0:57] David Armstrong: If you missed the previous episodes in this series, you may want to go back and catch up with those before listening to this one.

[1:03] David Armstrong: Ben West is a musical theater artist and historian who created the extensive Timeline Wall exhibits at the Museum of Broadway that trace the history of the Broadway stage from 1732 to 2021, spotlighting more than 500 productions and a hundred artists in the process.

[1:22] David Armstrong: Ben has also worked in various capacities on Broadway, off Broadway, and regionally, and he created and directed Unsung Carolyn Lee for Lincoln Center's American Songbook Series.

[1:34] David Armstrong: As always, I have to thank all of the loyal Patron Club members whose generous support helps to make Broadway Nation possible.

[1:40] David Armstrong: And especially today, a shout-out to our producer level members, Paula and Steve Reynolds.

[1:46] David Armstrong: If you would like to help support the creation of this podcast, I'll have information at the end of the episode about how you two can become a patron.

[1:55] David Armstrong: Here we go.

[1:56] David Armstrong: Another chapter I was really fascinated by early section is your comparing and contrasting of Hair and Your Own Thing.

[2:04] David Armstrong: Hair we know a lot about Your Own Thing. I'll be very honest. Of course, it was a big hit famous show. I remember in high school I had the paperback edition of Twelfth Night and Your Own Thing were in the same volume.

[2:17] David Armstrong: But even then I found Your Own Thing incomprehensible to read. But you've become a great advocate for it. So talk a little bit about how you see those two shows and the positioning of that particular section of your book.

[2:29] Ben West: I would just say advocate for the way it was constructed. I don't think it's something that we can pick up and do today necessarily because it very much has an of the moment feel around it. So yes, these are two musicals that use contemporary rock music as part of the storytelling.

[2:45] Ben West: Hair opens, as people know, I'm sure, opens off Broadway at the end of 1967. It then transfers uptown to a nightclub in, I think it was December of 1967. And in January of 1968, separately, Your Own Thing opens downtown for what is, I think it's roughly a two-year run. It's 900 some odd performances and a huge film deal that didn't go anywhere.

[3:07] Ben West: Then Hair is heavily revised, new director, new design team, new material, and it opens on Broadway. I can't remember the exact date. I think it's in April, I want to say, of 1968. So that's the trajectory of these two particular shows. And they operate very differently.

[3:21] Ben West: Hair is very scattershot in terms of its storytelling. It does effectively aim to tell a story because there is, or at least was initially a thin plot surrounding the character of Claude. This sort of gets obscured to a large extent. But the story is there. It's underlying it in what is again sort of a narrative review. It is a narrative review, perhaps by accident, I think, in that it is Slapdash and how it's assembled.

[3:49] Ben West: The account of certainly its initial director, Gerald Friedman, in terms of it being Slapdash. And this is the account of several critics who enjoyed the piece. I mean, if you go back and look at the original reviews for Hair, it wasn't this critical revolt that I think sometimes is perceived now. But looking at the fundamentals of how they are created and how they bring this rock music and contemporary themes to the stage is just very different.

[4:13] Ben West: And it goes back to structure again. And I think what really drives Hair certainly are the themes, the prescience of those particular themes, and the music in particular, uh, the Galt McDermott music component of the score is extraordinary. I mean, it's this vital, thumping, emotional, pulsating, diverse musical soundscape. It's fantastic. It really is incredible. And there's no question as to why it was a billboard hit, and that was a central component of the longevity of this particular show.

[4:43] Ben West: When the moon is in the seventh house, and Jupiter aligns with what is the planet and love. This is the dying of the A Tarius.

[5:41] Ben West: If you contrast that with Your Own Thing, the music for Your Own Thing is probably the weakest part of that show. I mean, in terms of endurance, you have the of the moment quality. It doesn't help it in doing it today, but in the time period, the music is probably the weakest. And not helped by the cast album. No, I mean it's not a terrific cast album. It seems like the quality of that cast album is very poor, so it's hard to listen to today. So hard to appreciate.

[6:11] Ben West: The music is not terrific. There are just weird things that happen. And there are a lot of truncated phrases. Again, this is part of this trajectory, which I point out in the book, but there is a song that is pre-company in the sense of the flowers and talking about this cold steel metropolis, which is Manhattan. This show is based on Twelfth Night, but essentially we're talking about Manhattan in terms of where this show is set.

[6:32] Ben West: What country friend is this? This is Illyria, lady. And what should I do in Illyria? My brother, he is in Elysium. Perchance he is not drowned. What think you, sailor? It is perchance that you yourself were saved. And so perchance may he be. True, madam. Knowest thou this country? And what should I do in Illyria? So much glass. So much steel. What's there to care? What's there to feel? All that glass. All that coron. Can I ever call this place? Oh.

[7:25] Ben West: Here the air is great and smoggy. My eyes burn and my head seems groggy. How do the flowers grow in their sweet little box in their neat little row? Here come the men to plant new flowers. The beautiful people must see beautiful flowers from their beautiful ivory towers. So much glass. So much steel. So that is interesting. I think the lyrics are of a far higher quality than the music, certainly more effective in telling this particular story.

[8:05] Ben West: And then you have the construction of the show itself and the way that it attempts to deal with contemporary issues by telling this particular story. It integrates these asides from historical figures who one would not pair together. For example, Jesus and W. C. Fields or Humphrey Bogart and Queen Elizabeth. These are commentaries on what is happening. If there was a multimedia feel to the entire piece, sort of a laugh-in style to it, which I think may even predate laugh-in. But certainly in that world, especially with those commentaries that pop in and the Yeah, it is very effective at telling its story, and it uses contemporary music in a purposeful manner and integrates it into the dramaturgy of the play.

[8:46] Ben West: And as a dramaturgical piece, it is far more sound than Hair. As a piece of music, as a visceral piece, and as a representation of a time period, Hair, of course, is more potent in that respect. And certainly why it lasted longer, I think, and why we remember Hair and not Your Own Thing. And why you can still do Hair today very effectively.

[9:07] Ben West: Yes, and it becomes a period piece. I mean, at the end of the day, it's not a terribly well written show. Hair is not. And unfortunately, I think that is a representation of what is going on in terms of popular music at that particular time, where there is a focus on music more so than lyric and lyrical storytelling, which becomes a great challenge when you try to translate that to the musical stage.

[9:29] Ben West: One of the things that I point out in the book is that the challenges and the difficulties that surround this transition in popular music have not so much to do with the music itself, but oftentimes with the lyrics that are associated with said music. On the musical stage, it is the lyric that is furthering the story or telling the story, articulating the story. The nature of popular lyric writing changes for a number of factors, some of which I allude to earlier, with regard to Tin Pan Alley, etc. Hollywood. But anyway, so there's just a change in the way popular music and popular lyrics in particular are operating.

[10:05] Ben West: And so there's this schism oftentimes when you're trying to translate that to the stage. And Hair is a beautiful example of that. I think as it happened, the success of Hair led to a number of other projects after that that become music heavy and don't really reconcile the differences between lyric writing for concert, for album, and lyric writing for telling a story on the theatrical stage.

[10:30] Ben West: And to just jump ahead, that's something that I think Jonathan Larson was so great at doing. And I think why Rent is Rent and Hair is Hair.

[10:38] David Armstrong: Well, and what I think is so interesting about that is that I think the musical theater struggles after Hair. There is that first period of the rock musical and the rise of the rock music. We have five or six of them that have become hits, and deservedly so. We can like or dislike them, but they all had something about them that turned them into hits.

[10:57] David Armstrong: But then we struggle with that, and rock music sort of falls away to a certain extent until we get the Jonathan Larson, who I think finally sort of figures out how to rectify that problem you were just talking about. And from then on, from Rent on, almost every Broadway musical has used pop music as part of it. It was sort of the turning point, the turning point in finding a way to meld the two things together.

[11:22] David Armstrong: It is coherent theatrical storytelling, as he says, quote, on top of a happening beat. It is understanding how to tell a story on stage. And I think music of any sort really can be part of that. And as has been proven by Hamilton, by Noise Funk. Ultimately, when we're talking about storytelling on stage, unless it is a dance piece, we're talking about words, and I think describe there is this reconciliation that needed to take place, and I think that ultimately is crystallized in Rent.

[11:51] Ben West: Yeah, he becomes a key figure in finding the way to meld those together.

[11:56] David Armstrong: Without a doubt, without a doubt.

[11:57] David Armstrong: Don't go away. Ben and I will be back with more Broadway Nation right after this quick break.

[12:04] Ben West: One song, glory. One song before I go.

[12:10] Ben West: One song to leave behind. Interestingly enough, this is where some people I think might take issue with the way you phrase this, although other people will be right there with you. I know that I could name some of them. We get to part six. This begins 1971. We're going to 1980 and through to today is the last two sections of your book. We'll take us through to 2000, basically. 2000, yeah, not quite up to today. Not quite up to date, but you almost get there. You reference a few things that indeed, indeed. And there's a I do an author's note at the end of the book which addresses the 21st century to an extent. But diminution is the title for this section, which of course indicates that things are diminuing.

Yes, there's a falling off. There is a falling off in craft. There is a rift that ultimately happens circa 1970. One can see this in the shows that are being written throughout the 1970s, and one can see this in the interviews of contemporaneous accounts of the authors writing those shows. That there is this dismissal of things that have happened prior to them. So there's, I think Broadway becomes, as has been evidenced by specific interviews by artists at the time, comes to be called quote unquote the establishment. And so there is this sense that establishment gets tied into convention or mature musical storytelling or professionalism. And then both of them sort of get thrown out the window or forgotten about as we try to move forward and be different and revolt against the establishment, revolt against convention.

But I think again, this is for me the misunderstanding of what convention is and the importance of the evolution of this art form. And what's happening, 30s, 40s, 50s, 60s in particular, is a maturity as it relates to telling stories on the musical stage. And whether or not one likes the Hammerstein and Roger stories or that sound, whether or not one likes Kurt Vial, whether or not one likes Lerner and Lowe, Harold Arlin, etc., there is a certain way, and not just one way, a certain way in which these individuals, and I'll say it's not just men, we'll put Carolyn Lee in there and Dorothy Fields and Compton and Green. There's a certain way in which these individuals were assembling, composing their stories and telling these stories and tailoring them for the theatrical stage.

And unfortunately, I think that gets lost in the 1970s to a large extent. I think it's not something that's difficult to see if one is actually analyzing objectively and looking at the material that's happening. It doesn't mean they weren't successful shows and there wasn't some element, as you very succinctly point out, that captured the public, particularly with regard to Pippin, for example, and the music of Andrew Lloyd Weber, and the idea that Superstar and A Vita were put out as albums before they became stage shows. There are elements that capture the public. There are things that are happening during this period in terms of the narratives that are being told on the stage, which are deeply prescient, deeply relevant.

Some of them are difficult, some are provocative. But if we're looking by and large, a lot of what is attempted to be done is sabotaged by a lack of craft and a dismissal of sound dramaturgical structure, the understanding of excellence and professionalism that is possible, as evidenced by the four prior decades.

[15:46] David Armstrong: Give us a few examples of that, and then a few examples of the exceptions to that.

[15:51] Ben West: I think the easiest or the most notable, recognizable examples in terms of exceptions are the Prince Wheeler Saundheim shows, specifically Night Music, Sweeney Todd, a company sort of right before this particular period, also not Q Wheeler, to be fair. Something like Chorusline, which we discussed. And then in terms of the ineffective storytelling, we'll mention some shows, but I won't get into specifics in the way that I do in the book because I spend a great deal of time choosing words and thinking about what I was saying. So I'll refer to the book for those specifics. But certainly Evita would fall into that category. Jesus Christ Superstar would fall into that particular category. Pippin would fall into that particular category.

Those are some of the more notable shows that come out of that particular period, each of which has certain things about it which are well done, and certain things about it which connect to a contemporary audience and still connect to audiences, and those shows are still done. I think Pippin in particular has certain things about it which helped it and continues to help it to remain a permanent part of the repertory. But are the stories of these shows exceptionally well told? Is the question at the end of the day.

[17:03] Ben West: Sure, sure. Vinette Carroll is a major force in that, and she has two of the longest-running shows around black stories during this particular period. One of them in particular actually is a show from the prior period, I will just note. That's Don't Bother Me, I Can't Cope, which started out as a less high profile piece as part of her Urban Arts Corps initiative. That's the Mickey Grant review conceived and directed by Vanette Carroll. We have Ain't Supposed to Die a Natural Death during this particular period. That's actually right at the beginning of this particular period. And the Wiz, of course, which is back on Broadway officially. I haven't seen it, but in a quite, I don't know if it's quite different, but certainly a different version, as I understand it.

I haven't seen it, so I can't comment on it. From everything I've heard about it, it's a revisal of the show, which, you know, as of course, any show being revived 50 years later has usually been revised to a great extent, except for the major classics.

[17:55] David Armstrong: Well, I think if I may just say something, what you just said sort of supports my point in terms of things being revived, particularly we're talking about the whiz in the 1970s. Again, I haven't seen this production. I can't speak directly to it, but just the idea of this show being revised and something like, for example, Guys and Dolls. I have not seen the London treatment. The staging is different, but fundamentally, as I understand it, I could be wrong, it is the fundamental show as it was. So you have something like Guys and Dolls or My Fair Lady, etc. forum that is a sort of example of what I'm alluding to, or specifically referring to.

[18:27] Ben West: Absolutely. I'm always interested in the Vinette Carroll shows at Mickey Grant shows because they were such big hits. And I actually saw all of those shows during that period because they toured to Cincinnati before I moved to New York, and then they were still happening in New York, and they just fell off the radar entirely. What do you attribute that?

[18:45] Ben West: They were just of the moment. I think Don't Bother Me, I Can't Cope was of the moment for sure. And I don't find that score to be a particularly extraordinary score. I think it resonated in its time and it was potent in its time. I don't think it's a timeless score, and I don't think it's extraordinarily well written. And as it relates to your arms too short to box with God, it's not a particularly exceptional piece. From what I understand, and I did not see her initial production. What I surmise in reading about her productions from those who saw them is that a lot of the impact of her shows and a lot of the success, artistic success, commercial success of her shows was to be found in her staging and in the exuberance, power, electricity of what was on the physical stage.

[19:33] Ben West: So now let's take us into the final section of the book, part seven Growing Pains or Identity Crisis. They don't sound like the same thing to me. Identity crisis is clear to me why that's there, but why is it growing pains?

[19:46] Ben West: Well, I think growing pains, you beautifully illuminated when you were discussing Jonathan Larson. The growing pains element of it, or why it might be called growing pains is where are we going essentially? And how is this form going to move forward? How are we going to grow up? Part of that is the idea of addressing contemporary subjects and dealing with contemporary sounds. It has rarely been effectively addressed up to this particular point, particularly as you were describing with regard to rock music and then this reckoning that happens with regard to Jonathan Larson and Rent. So that would speak to the growing pains element of it. The first chapter in that section is called dialogue, song, and dance. What are you delving into there?

[20:25] Ben West: Essentially shows that are telling stories through dialogue, song, and dance. There are different proportions of that, depending on what show it is. We start to see a lot of this is not something new to be clear, but we start to see a lot of sung through musicals that are nonetheless telling a story, and one might describe as a book musical. That's specifically why I didn't say book musical, because as I point out, you still have a book. And so if the show is, as Hamilton is, for example, virtually sunk through or entirely sung through, there is still a libretto. There is still a book, there is still a structure to the story. There are still characters that need to be delineated. If there is a plot, there is a plot that needs to be shaped, etc. So that's why I didn't call it book musical, but dialogue, song, and dance.

One sort of reaction to how can we solve the problem of the musical in a way is let's just have everything sung, and then we won't have to worry about getting from the dialogue into the song. I remember seeing quotes about that from Tim Rice back at some point in all the research I've done. Who, by the way, comes from a pop background, which whether or not what I'm saying is controversial or people are upset by it, certainly that's not my intention, is to upset people, but my intention is to say this is what happened and let us learn from what has happened. Nonetheless, the evidence and history supports what I am saying.

[21:44] Ben West: So we were talking about lyric writing and stage, and Tim Rice very openly discusses, in fact, in an interview I watched after I finished the book, thus it is not directly quoted in the book, but talks about coming from a pop background and writing pop, a very clear example of the gulf that exists between storytelling on the legitimate theatrical stage and the world of pop music, film, television, concert, etc. You devote a whole chapter to George C. Wolfe and the black musical stage. Of course, he's a key figure in the contemporary musical. Just talk a little bit about how you see him and how he fits into this picture.

[22:22] Ben West: He's an extraordinary figure, not just in terms of black stories, but on the musical stage, the stage, period. An incredible artist, showman, particularly as a director. Jelly's Last Jam is his first show on Broadway. It's not his first show, period. He starts to gain a very prominent, strong reputation in the 1980s in particular. Colored museum, folks will probably know, I'm sure, Spunk. Jelly's Last Jam, Noise Funk is also in the 1990s. And it's really extraordinary what he's doing. It is a mature, vibrant, electric, substantive black book musical is Jelly's Last Jam. And it came to pass that a people were born. Then torn from the land that was their home. The story of their pain was set forth in music.

Destined to conquer, take the world by storm. And so messengers were called to spread its glory. Go forth, Armstrong. Go forth, Ellington. Go forth, Basy, Bolden, and Bichet. And it came to pass that a messenger was called who came to believe that the message was him. Yes. He of diamond tooth and flashy threads. He who drinks from the vine of syncopation, but denies the black soil from which this rhythm was born. Denies the black soil from which this rhythm was born. I did not see the original production. I have seen a production of the show, however, not the recent one. It has, as I point out, there are clichés, there are inconsistencies. You know, it is not a flawless piece. But I think the ambition of the piece, the character of the piece, the way in which it sets about telling its story and does so in an uncompromising manner and with such fire is extraordinary.

[24:21] Ben West: It's really an incredible, incredible show.

[24:24] David Armstrong: Welcome to the Chungalin!

[24:28] Ben West: Somewhere between heaven and hell.

[24:37] David Armstrong: Well, we're jamming.

[24:40] Ben West: Yeah, it's a nice.

[24:42] David Armstrong: Helly!

[24:43] Ben West: Yes, and I ain't coming home tonight.

[24:45] David Armstrong: We gotta jump down and jam with jelly.

[24:47] Ben West: The band is blowing, the gin is blowing.

[24:49] David Armstrong: We gotta swim at the slab with jelly.

[24:52] Ben West: Get shaken, we're gonna wheel tonight.

[24:56] David Armstrong: Ooh, pop up the time to follow stuff up, raising out the jelly's jam.

[25:01] Ben West: How's the high tones?

[25:02] David Armstrong: Hustle and talking tongue.

[25:03] Ben West: It's slow down to jam with jelly.

[25:05] David Armstrong: A lot of low lives, a lot of no-lays.

[25:08] Ben West: Wanna join up the jam with jelly?

[25:10] David Armstrong: Turn the heat on, we're gonna cook tonight.

[25:12] Ben West: So here's the choice out to jam with jelly.

[25:14] David Armstrong: Who's this?

[25:18] Ben West: It's the best now chance since way back when it's the one that's chest.

[25:22] David Armstrong: I'll look at it, so let's get some tail.

[25:29] Ben West: Stop and shot.

[25:31] David Armstrong: Turn it up, push the foot down jelly.

[25:34] Ben West: Here I am!

[25:37] David Armstrong: Noise funk, I think is incredible as well.

[25:40] Ben West: That's largely the concept, the wolf staging.

[25:43] David Armstrong: I think the material is not necessarily exceptional material, but it supports the episodic storytelling of that particular show and the extraordinary staging.

[25:51] Ben West: And of course, his most recent musical was Shuffle Along.

[25:55] David Armstrong: Shuffle Along. Talk a little bit about that because it obviously is a show that is addressing part of this history that you're talking about, the continuum of this.

[26:03] Ben West: Sometimes incorrectly.

[26:04] David Armstrong: But yeah, yeah.

[26:06] Ben West: If you want to just from a historical standpoint, the George Wolf Shuffle Along is not entirely accurate.

[26:12] Ben West: And I found it actually a little disingenuous in that one of the themes that he presented in the show was this idea of standing on the shoulders of past generations and remembering past artists.

[26:24] Ben West: He sort of swept the past artists as it relates to Shuffle Along, the artist prior to that, under the rug.

[26:30] Ben West: And in two specific instances, there are songs used.

[26:33] Ben West: One is an entire song, which was one of the showstoppers.

[26:36] Ben West: The other is a sample of a song that are used by these past artists who are not credited in the score.

[26:41] Ben West: Swing Along is one of those that did not get credited to Will Marion Cook.

[26:44] Ben West: And Swing Along was from In Dahomey.

[26:47] Ben West: Which is, to be clear, a Williams and Walker show from 1902 initially, but it plays over a number of years.

[26:53] Ben West: That was a full song that was in George Wolf's Shuffle Along that was not credited.

[26:57] Ben West: And the other one is a sampling of Strut Miss Lizzie, which was a hugely successful Henry Creamer Turner Leighton song, which was also not credited.

[27:05] Ben West: I suspect because they're both public domain.

[27:07] Ben West: Nonetheless, if your theme is to honor past artists and honor the artist upon whose shoulders you stand, if it were me, I would be crediting the songs, particularly the Will Marion Cook, since it is a thunderous Act One showstopper.

[27:21] David Armstrong: Totally.

[27:22] Ben West: And a great piece of material. Terrific, terrific.

[27:24] Ben West: So anyway, that's just the historical component.

[27:27] Ben West: That is one piece of it.

[27:28] Ben West: From a show standpoint, and again, show is different than production.

[27:31] Ben West: From a show standpoint, I thought Act One was largely terrific.

[27:34] Ben West: I thought Act Two was entirely underdone.

[27:36] Ben West: It just was a wonderful idea that needed more time.

[27:39] Ben West: In terms of production, I thought it was riveting, extraordinary, electric, brilliant.

[27:43] Ben West: His staging, it's just it was incredible.

[27:45] Ben West: It was just incredible.

[27:46] David Armstrong: But as a piece, it was ultimately underdone.

[27:48] Ben West: I agree with you.

[27:48] David Armstrong: It didn't seem finished.

[27:49] Ben West: It seemed like they opened before they had finished the show.

[27:52] David Armstrong: Oh, yes.

[27:53] Ben West: Which sometimes that happens.

[27:54] Ben West: That's just the nature of the economics of it sometimes and the commercial nature of Broadway.

[27:59] Ben West: But that was disappointing because I do think that show, had there been a way for it to get completely finished, it might have been one of the great shows of all time.

[28:07] David Armstrong: Oh, I totally agree.

[28:08] Ben West: I completely agree.

[28:09] Ben West: And I will add another, if I may, disappointment for me is given the high-profile nature of that particular piece and the potential it had to define a particular era and really speak about a subject that is not often discussed, given that the historical inaccuracies were a bit upsetting to me.

[28:27] Ben West: And the way in which he chose to speak about through his dialogue, Shuffle Along was also, I think, uh upsetting to me because there are specific references to Noble Sisel UB Blake being the first successful black songwriters on Broadway.

[28:42] Ben West: This is an almost a direct quote give or take a word.

[28:45] Ben West: This is the first show with syncopation.

[28:47] Ben West: It's just mind-boggling, especially that particular one, because the heart of ragtime is syncopation.

[28:52] Ben West: And the ragtime era effectively began in the 1890s, which is more than 20 years before Shuffle Along.

[28:58] Ben West: Some of the things he chose to say, perhaps to inflate the importance of Shuffle Along.

[29:03] Ben West: I don't want to suppose why it was done, but for whatever reason, it was a unnecessary and b unfortunate.

[29:09] David Armstrong: As you've looked back at everything, people always say you can't know where you're going if you don't look at the past.

[29:14] David Armstrong: Where do you think we're going? Do you have any thoughts on that?

[29:17] Ben West: As a definitive statement, I don't know the answer.

[29:19] Ben West: In terms of where I hope we are going, is to a place where we have more exceptional storytelling.

[29:26] Ben West: That is what I hope.

[29:27] Ben West: And if there's anything that is taken away from the book, I hope it is that exceptional storytelling is possible.

[29:33] Ben West: And understanding how this art form matured is integral to exceptional storytelling going forward.

[29:40] Ben West: And there's not a limit to the stories one can tell.

[29:44] Ben West: Right now we're in a period of great social change.

[29:47] Ben West: I suppose we're always in a period of great social change, frankly.

[29:50] David Armstrong: From reading your book, I would say that's true.

[29:52] Ben West: Yes, yes.

[29:53] Ben West: There is a deep connection, at least at the present moment and probably for the foreseeable future, a deep connection between social justice and what is happening socially and what is being presented on stage.

[30:04] Ben West: And I think it is so important and can only enhance the messages of these particular shows and the representation that is found in these shows, if the storytelling, the craft, the quality of the show is exceptional.

[30:18] Ben West: For me, that has been the large takeaway of recent years is that we have unexceptional storytelling.

[30:23] Ben West: I am extraordinarily critical of others and myself.

[30:26] Ben West: And it's not to be catty or bitchy or just to be critical or to be bitter or anything of that nature.

[30:32] Ben West: It's because I now understand, I did not understand prior to this journey that we've discussed, the excellence and professionalism that is possible in terms of telling a story on a legitimate stage and the impact that that can have.

[30:44] Ben West: The stage is high stakes, it is deeply connected to who we are as a country.

[30:49] Ben West: One could argue globally at this point.

[30:51] Ben West: But you know, the stage gave us Jim Crow, if we want to look at some of the darker periods.

[30:55] Ben West: The stage is what was instrumental in elevating the positive national perception of black individuals in the 1920s.

[31:02] Ben West: Florence Mills has a beautiful quote that speaks directly to that, and how the stage is the quickest way to the people.

[31:08] Ben West: I'm sort of paraphrasing here, and the audience's perception of her makes them think better of other black people in the country.

[31:15] Ben West: It is so potent.

[31:16] Ben West: It is such a potent medium, understanding the excellence that is possible based on what we have seen throughout the middle of the 20th century, whether someone wants to call it the golden age or whether you want to call it convention or maturity, as I do, which is more specific to what is happening in that particular period.

[31:30] Ben West: I find it distressing to see such talent and such potential talent in the individuals, potential in the shows and subjects that are chosen to be written about in recent years, currently on Broadway right now, and to find the storytelling unexceptional when it can be made exceptional if we understand the nature and evolution of this particular form.

[31:53] David Armstrong: Really well said and absolutely. Is there a show that you can point to as being an example of how to do it that is contemporary?

[32:00] Ben West: I think the biggest one that everyone just references rightfully so is Hamilton, because it's a beautiful integration of newness and convention.

[32:07] Ben West: And again, convention, not traditional, but convention in the sense of rock solid foundational excellence or maturity in musical storytelling.

[32:15] Ben West: The Band's Visit is a great example of something that is entirely different.

[32:18] Ben West: It has an entirely different feel.

[32:20] Ben West: There's some unexceptional moments in there that I would point to, but I think overall it's an exceptional piece and was exceptionally well done and well realized in its David Cromer production.

[32:30] Ben West: There are others.

[32:30] Ben West: I don't want to limit it to say that that is it.

[32:33] Ben West: I'm trying to be deliberate and thoughtful in the shows that I would reference, and that's immediately what comes to mind.

[32:38] David Armstrong: And those two are certainly brilliant examples of what you're talking about.

[32:43] Ben West: I have the same hesitation to bring up Hamilton because it's so overpraised, but deservedly so because it's really that good.

[32:50] Ben West: It does everything that a musical is supposed to do.

[32:53] David Armstrong: It's an extraordinary piece.

[32:54] Ben West: It is.

[32:54] Ben West: And it's not flawless.

[32:55] Ben West: Let's just be clear.

[32:56] Ben West: There are three areas with which I take issue in terms of the material and/or storytelling, but those are three in a much larger, exceptionally well-built, well-written, well-executed piece that is exceptional at telling its story.

[33:13] Ben West: And in addition to literally telling its story, to layering in themes and metaphors on top of that, which do not take away and do not obscure the fundamental story that it is telling.

[33:25] David Armstrong: Ben West, it has been an absolute pleasure to talk to you about your new book, The American Musical Evolution of an Art Form. Thank you so much for joining us on Broadway Nation.

[33:33] Ben West: Thank you for having me.

[33:35] David Armstrong: Thank you.

[33:36] Ben West: My pleasure.

[33:39] Ben West: Angelica, Eliza and Peggy.

[33:44] Ben West: Angelica Haggy.

[33:47] David Armstrong: Now here's the information about how you too can become a patron of Broadway Nation.

[33:52] David Armstrong: A donation of just seven dollars a month will not only keep Broadway Nation rolling along, it will also provide you with exclusive access to the complete unedited versions of many of the interviews that you hear on this podcast.

[34:06] David Armstrong: And all patrons will receive special shout outs and acknowledgments of your vital support for Broadway Nation.

[34:13] David Armstrong: To join, simply go to Broadway Nation Podcast dot supercast dot tech.

[34:18] David Armstrong: That's Broadway Nation Podcast dot S-U-P-E-R-C-A-S-T dot tech.

[34:25] David Armstrong: Or click the link in the show notes to this episode.

[34:28] David Armstrong: Broadway Nation is written and produced by me, David Armstrong.

[34:32] David Armstrong: Special thanks to Pals Mox for his help with editing this episode and to the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.

[34:42] Ben West: Smells like your daddy's gotten money.

[34:43] Ben West: Why you slummin in the city in your fancy heels?

[34:46] Ben West: You're searching for an urchin who can give you ideals.

[34:49] Ben West: Ah, so you disgust me.

[34:51] Ben West: I'm a trust fund, baby.

[34:52] Ben West: You can trust me.

[34:53] Ben West: I've been reading common sense by Thomas Paine.

[34:55] Ben West: So men say that I'm intense around fane.

[34:58] Ben West: You want a revolution, I want a revelation.

[35:00] Ben West: So listen to my declaration.

[35:02] Ben West: We hold these truths to be self evident that I'm an uncreated equal.

[35:07] Ben West: And when I become a step person, I'm a compel him to include women in the sequel work.

[35:12] Ben West: Look around, look around, how lucky we are to be alive right now.

[35:17] Ben West: Look around, look around, and how lucky we are to be alive right now.

[35:22] Ben West: History is happening in Manhattan, and we just happen to be in the greatest city in the world.

[35:22] Ben West: In the greatest city in the world.

[35:40] Ben West: We hope these round we sell it up and understanding love.

[35:45] Ben West: Look around, look around.

[35:47] Ben West: How lucky we are to be alive right now.

[35:50] Ben West: History is happening in Manhattan.

[35:52] Ben West: And we just happen to be the greatest city in the West.

[35:56] Ben West: In the greatest city in the world.

[36:00] Ben West: Angelica in the light star and Peggy work, the sky's sister.

[36:07] Ben West: We're looking for my work, work.

[36:09] Ben West: Hey, work, work in the greatest city, in the greatest city in the world.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred