Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 53: The Theatrical Genius Of Tommy Tune, part 1

This episode is made possible in part by the generous support of Broadway Nation “Backstage Pass Club” Producer Level Members: Steven & Paula Reynolds. Today my guest is Kevin Winkler, author of the new book: Everything Is Choreography – The Musical Theater of Tommy Tune... Read More

From the show: BROADWAY NATION

47 mins
1/20/22

Guests

About

This episode is made possible in part by the generous support of Broadway Nation “Backstage Pass Club” Producer Level Members:

Steven & Paula Reynolds.

Today my guest is Kevin Winkler, author of the new book: Everything Is Choreography – The Musical Theater of Tommy Tune.

Kevin’s much acclaimed and award winning first book, Big Deal: Bob Fosse and Dance in the American Musical, was released in 2018. And you may have seen Kevin as an on-screen commentator in the acclaimed documentary, Merely Marvelous: The Dancing Genius of Gwen Verdon.

I was fascinated to read Kevin’s terrific new book – especially since I arrived in New York just as Tommy Tune’s career as a choreographer and director was kicking off, As a result I had the tremendous privilege of seeing first hand every one of Tommy Tune’s Broadway and off-Broadway productions that Kevin covers in the book.

I began our recent conversation by asking Kevin about his two previous careers – as a dancer and a librarian – that have made him uniquely and unusually qualified to write books about Broadway’s great, groundbreaking director/choreographers.

Broadway Nation is written and produced by me – David Armstrong.

Special thanks to Pauls Macs for his help with editing this episode, KVSH 101.9, the voice of beautiful Vashon Island, WA, and the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:07] David Armstrong: Welcome to another episode of Broadway Nation, the podcast that tells the remarkable story of how immigrants, Jews, queers, African Americans, and other outcasts invented the Broadway musical and how they changed America in the process.

[0:22] David Armstrong: I'm David Armstrong, and I call this episode the theatrical genius of Tommy Tune.

[0:35] David Armstrong: This episode is made possible in part by our Broadway Nation Backstage Pass Club producer level members, Steven and Paula Reynolds.

[0:43] David Armstrong: Thank you, Steve and Paula, for your generous support of the mission of this podcast.

[0:48] David Armstrong: And I invite every listener of Broadway Nation to join our Backstage Pass Club, and I'll have more information later in this episode on exactly how you too can become a member.

[0:58] David Armstrong: Today, my guest is Kevin Winkler, who is the author of a new book titled Everything Is Choreography: The Musical Theater of Tommy Tune.

[1:07] David Armstrong: Kevin's much acclaimed and award-winning first book was released in 2018 and was titled Big Deal: Bob Fosse and Dance in the American Musical.

[1:17] David Armstrong: And you may have seen Kevin as an on-screen commentator in the acclaimed documentary Merely Marvelous: Theatrical Genius of Gwen Verdon.

[1:25] David Armstrong: I was fascinated to read Kevin's terrific new book, especially since I arrived in New York just as Tommy Tune's career as a choreographer and director was kicking off.

[1:34] David Armstrong: And as a result, I had the tremendous privilege of seeing firsthand every one of the Broadway and off-Broadway Tommy Tune productions that Kevin covers in the book.

[1:45] David Armstrong: Unfortunately, there was some construction work going on in Kevin's building as we recorded this, so once in a while during the interview, you may hear some odd noises.

[1:54] David Armstrong: I began our recent conversation by asking Kevin about his two previous careers prior to becoming an author that have made him uniquely and quite unusually qualified to write books about Broadway's great groundbreaking director choreographers.

[2:09] David Armstrong: Welcome, Kevin.

[2:10] Kevin Winkler: Thank you so much for joining us today on Broadway Nation.

[2:13] Kevin Winkler: David, it's great to be here.

[2:14] Kevin Winkler: Delighted to be here.

[2:15] Kevin Winkler: I started out as a dancer.

[2:17] Kevin Winkler: I was a professional dancer in New York for about 12 or 13 years.

[2:21] Kevin Winkler: Then in my mid-30s, I realized I was not going to play a long game as a chorus dancer.

[2:26] Kevin Winkler: So I ended up going back to graduate school and I became a librarian.

[2:29] Kevin Winkler: I worked at the New York Public Library for the Performing Arts for many, many years, and uh retired from that, and then kind of fell into this third career writing, writing about dance, about choreographers, merges a couple of loves of mine.

[2:43] Kevin Winkler: Dance, certainly, first and foremost, but also my joy in doing research, archival research, really digging into the historical data to help bolster my understanding of the work of people like Bob Fosse and now Tommy Tune.

[2:59] David Armstrong: Well, you're the only dancer librarian that I know.

[3:02] Kevin Winkler: It's worked out very, very well in terms of this third career, as you say, in merging those two things together to write about these amazing artists.

[3:10] David Armstrong: Thank you. The book about Fosse has been much acclaimed. What inspired you then to move from Fosse to Tommy Tune?

[3:17] Kevin Winkler: Some of the most delightful moments I've experienced in the theater have been at shows that were either choreographed and or directed and or performed by Tommy Tune.

[3:27] Kevin Winkler: And I had just come to think over the last, I don't know, X number of years, that he had become somewhat undervalued as an artist and a creative force in the theater.

[3:36] Kevin Winkler: And I know that sounds strange to say because he has had many, many theatrical successes.

[3:41] Kevin Winkler: He's won a boatload of Tony Awards, received a lifetime achievement Tony Award.

[3:46] Kevin Winkler: But people tend to have short memories, and he hasn't had a show on Broadway in a number of years.

[3:51] Kevin Winkler: I think he had just become one of those people that was certainly not forgotten, but his achievements had been somewhat forgotten.

[3:58] Kevin Winkler: I thought that a book that would do a deep dive into his artistic life would fill a void.

[4:04] Kevin Winkler: I was also really kind of shocked in a way when I began doing research to find how little his career has been documented by historians and commentators about the American musical.

[4:15] Kevin Winkler: He doesn't seem to loom very large.

[4:17] Kevin Winkler: And I thought that was a real mistake because he's had so many great accomplishments in the theater.

[4:21] Kevin Winkler: He's clearly one of the great director choreographers of all time, but I agree with you, he doesn't seem to have a profile.

[4:28] Kevin Winkler: Certainly, young people today have very little knowledge of who he is or what he did.

[4:32] David Armstrong: Do you think that's because the great shows that he did, his great successes have mostly not lived on past those original productions?

[4:40] Kevin Winkler: In a way, a lot of his shows have not been revived.

[4:43] Kevin Winkler: Certainly not like Michael Bennett with Dreamgirls and A Chorus Line, or Fosse with Chicago and Pippin, Gower Champion with Hello Dolly, 42nd Street, shows like that.

[4:54] Kevin Winkler: One of his greatest successes, Nine, was given a fairly mediocre film adaptation that I think really kind of tamped down interest in that property, which I think is a shame.

[5:05] Kevin Winkler: So for all of those reasons, yes, I think those shows have kind of receded in people's memory.

[5:10] Kevin Winkler: But I have to tell you, Tune is very much alive in my mind through his influence and inspiration to a younger generation of director choreographers.

[5:19] Kevin Winkler: And I talk a little bit about that in the book.

[5:21] Kevin Winkler: I mean, you can really trace threads of his work in the work of people like Jerry Mitchell, Casey Nicholaw, Susan Stroman, Jeff Calhoun.

[5:29] Kevin Winkler: Most of these people I just named worked with Tommy early on in their careers as dancers, assistants, associates.

[5:35] Kevin Winkler: His influence is felt even if audiences don't really recognize it.

[5:39] David Armstrong: One of the main threads of this podcast is the connection between the artists throughout the history of the Broadway musical.

[5:47] David Armstrong: And I very much appreciate that in your book you talk about even people like Ned Weyburn and some of the choreographers from the 20s and the 30s who indirectly influenced Tommy Tune.

[5:57] Kevin Winkler: It's really one of the few art forms that's handed down from person to person in a chain that you can document, partly because almost every choreographer starts out as a dancer working for somebody else.

[6:09] Kevin Winkler: So it literally is an apprenticeship for the people who are interested in that.

[6:13] David Armstrong: Let's go back to the beginning, back to the origin story of Tommy Tune. What is it in this unlikely world of Texas that he comes from that creates this director, choreographer, performer?

[6:23] Kevin Winkler: You're right. He's from Texas. He was born in Wichita Falls.

[6:26] Kevin Winkler: And when he was a young boy, he and his family moved to just outside Houston.

[6:30] Kevin Winkler: He started dance lessons very early.

[6:32] Kevin Winkler: I think he started taking dance lessons at the age of five.

[6:35] Kevin Winkler: He was very fortunate in that his family was very supportive of his interest in dance.

[6:40] Kevin Winkler: That's a big deal for a young boy from I won't say the middle of nowhere, but growing up in an environment that you might think is somewhat less enlightened than it could be.

[6:48] Kevin Winkler: But he uh started dance lessons very early, studied ballet.

[6:52] Kevin Winkler: He was exposed to live theater at a very young age.

[6:55] Kevin Winkler: He went to performances with his parents.

[6:58] Kevin Winkler: He has talked about being influenced by touring companies of the Ballet Russe de Monte Carlo Ballet Theater, the precursor of American Ballet Theater, and getting to see plays and musicals in Houston.

[7:10] Kevin Winkler: He um began putting on plays and shows, little reviews in his backyard, and he called them patio reviews, where he'd gather up the neighborhood kids and they just sort of put on a show.

[7:20] Kevin Winkler: He said I was always just naturally bossy, and I just told them what to do, and they did.

[7:25] Kevin Winkler: So he has lived a life very much steeped in dance and theater and performance from a very early age.

[7:32] David Armstrong: So he was directing and choreographing from childhood, basically.

[7:36] Kevin Winkler: Basically, yes, the future Tony winner was staging these reviews on his patio in the backyard.

[7:41] David Armstrong: Yes. How does that lead to heading to New York to pursue this as a career?

[7:46] Kevin Winkler: The other thing that I think is interesting about Tune is so many of the people who he followed behind, people like Michael Bennett, Bob Fosse, Gower Champion, Jerome Robbins, none of them went to college.

[7:57] Kevin Winkler: Robbins took a few classes at NYU.

[8:00] Kevin Winkler: Champion and Fosse graduated from high school.

[8:02] Kevin Winkler: Michael Bennett dropped out of school when he was 16 to go on the road and dance.

[8:06] Kevin Winkler: But Tune went to college as a theater major and then went to graduate school at the University of Houston, getting his master's in theater and directing.

[8:15] Kevin Winkler: And so he was steeped in design and the mechanics of theater from an academic perspective.

[8:21] Kevin Winkler: And he did summer stock.

[8:22] Kevin Winkler: He made his professional debut working at Dallas Summer Musicals in a production of West Side Story, for instance.

[8:28] Kevin Winkler: Tune's always been very generous in talking about the people who influenced him and pushed him forward.

[8:34] Kevin Winkler: He's very generous in giving credit to his early dance teachers, for instance.

[8:38] Kevin Winkler: And one of the people that he credits with bringing him to New York is his childhood friend Phil Osterman, who he grew up with in the Houston area.

[8:46] Kevin Winkler: And Osterman became a director and a producer in New York and was back on a visit to Houston.

[8:51] Kevin Winkler: And as Osterman said, I threw his ass in the car and drove him to New York.

[8:56] Kevin Winkler: He was scared to death.

[8:57] Kevin Winkler: And Osterman really pushed him to move to New York, told him what trade papers to get, how to look for the auditions, where to go, and through that Tune got his first job, his first day in New York, if you can believe that.

[9:10] Kevin Winkler: It's all true, of course, but it's almost like a fairy tale.

[9:12] Kevin Winkler: I'm sure when you're in the actual experience of it, he felt like a struggling artist like everybody else.

[9:17] Kevin Winkler: But compared to many other stories, it seems like he just sort of immediately had success.

[9:22] David Armstrong: It was a pretty easy entree.

[9:24] Kevin Winkler: Right.

[9:25] David Armstrong: Yeah. I was very taken in your book to learn that he was an intellectual to a certain extent, although you wouldn't think of that when you think of Tommy Tune as a personality or as a persona.

[9:36] Kevin Winkler: That intellectual rigor is actually very evident, especially in all his early shows.

[9:41] Kevin Winkler: They really come from an avant-garde sort of approach in many ways.

[9:45] Kevin Winkler: Again, which I think is something people don't appreciate or understand readily about Tommy Tune.

[9:50] Kevin Winkler: I think you're absolutely right.

[9:51] Kevin Winkler: He approached his work from an intellectual standpoint.

[9:54] Kevin Winkler: I happened to see The Club, his first show in New York, and that was a very heady show in its own way.

[10:00] Kevin Winkler: It was incredibly entertaining.

[10:02] Kevin Winkler: I still can see it.

[10:04] Kevin Winkler: I can picture that show, and especially the ticker tape sequence.

[10:07] Kevin Winkler: But as thrillingly entertaining as it was, it was actually a very smart, very sort of intellectual avant-garde approach to making theater.

[10:16] Kevin Winkler: I think he set a pattern with that show because that was his first show as a director in New York.

[10:20] Kevin Winkler: He really set a pattern in that he worked very closely with the writer Eve Merriam, whose idea it was to put the show together using found material, jokes and limericks and songs from the turn of the century, and making them a review.

[10:35] Kevin Winkler: And he really developed that material with Merriam, with musical director, and very, very much so with the cast, and created something that had a theatrical integrity to it in a way that it really didn't have when he got the raw material.

[10:48] Kevin Winkler: He has such taste in terms of stagecraft in understanding how physicality communicates to an audience, especially with that show, with the cast of all women playing all men.

[10:59] Kevin Winkler: And he worked with the cast on conceiving a kind of unique body language.

[11:04] Kevin Winkler: They weren't trying to masquerade as men, they were women playing men.

[11:09] Kevin Winkler: That juxtaposition and that tension was one of the things that made that show so unique.

[11:14] Kevin Winkler: That's also true with the other off-Broadway show that he did, Cloud Nine, the Carol Churchill play.

[11:19] Kevin Winkler: And I really think his direction of that play really introduced Churchill to American audiences.

[11:25] Kevin Winkler: She's such a terrific writer, so unique, she would have found success anyway.

[11:30] Kevin Winkler: But his direction of Cloud Nine really brought an emotional intensity to the material.

[11:36] Kevin Winkler: I've seen revivals of the play since then, but his production had an emotional intensity that I've never seen equaled.

[11:42] Kevin Winkler: I agree. It's such a terrific production. And both of those shows were dealing with issues of gender, dealing with issues of race, with economic disparity, all those kinds of things. And then from a theatrical standpoint, the traverse staging of the club and the way those shows were put on the stage. I think audiences today would think, well, that's cutting edge for now. And this is now what? 45 years ago, exactly.

[12:08] David Armstrong: You're so right. He was dealing with issues of gender, sexuality, race, economic inequalities, and so forth that were very au courant then, and they're certainly au courant today. And it just shows I teach a course at the University of Washington, and my students are always surprised to see things go backwards. We've already been down this path, and now we have to go down it again, unfortunately in so many ways.

[12:31] Kevin Winkler: Yeah. So he starts with the club and Cloud 9 was next or Cloud 9 was after Whorehouse. The club was running it was a huge hit. It ran for about a year and a half close to two years. While the club was running he was approached about joining the creative team of The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas. It was the nicest little whorehouse you ever saw. It lay about a mile down this old dirt road and if you just happened to stumble on it you couldn't help but notice that the barns were painted the fences were up and you might think to yourself why folks that live there might just do to run the river with the little house lay in green Texas glade where the trees were as cooling as fresh lemonade soft summer wind had a trace of perfume and a fan was turning in every room twenty fans returning they were turning twenty fans returning in every room fever's water burning they were burning and they had to have a way to cool down.

[12:51] Kevin Winkler: That show had originally been developed at the Actor's Studio where Peter Masterson, who's the director of the show, was a member. He and his wife Carlin Glenn, who played the lead in the show, they were both members and so it was done at the Actor's Studio and Universal Pictures and a producer named Stevie Phillips picked it up for commercial production. The consensus was the material was terrific. It was rich and flavorful, but things were missing in terms of movement, and as someone said to me, the wow factor was missing for a musical. And that's when he joined it. The show was done off-Broadway and then moved to Broadway. He really infused it with some musical comedy brightness. But what he really did was he made it bigger than the show was originally.

[14:29] David Armstrong: And this football game has been a real stem ladder, just as the experts thought it would. And now, as the gladiators collect themselves during this timeout, let's spend a few special moments with a bunch of kids as American as the Fourth of July and as refreshing as Country Rain. For instance, one of the famous numbers is the Angelette March, which is a delightful drill team number. There they are, the fabled Texas Aggie Angelettes. As fine a bouquet of long still beauty as you will find.

[14:58] Kevin Winkler: One of the women I interviewed for the book said when we were first rehearsing it, it was just some funny lines that Larry L. King wrote. It was supposed to be kind of in a blackout. It was commentary for a football game. And she said Tommy got the idea that they would create a drill team number, a dance number. They'd have us moving around and dancing on stage. We would spout these lines, these funny lines. Hi there, sports fans. I'm talking with IG Charlene Green of the Fabled Texas Aggie Angelettes. We're going to find out a little about the wonderful lives of these wonderful precision girls. Most of you girls are beauty queens. Isn't that right? Oh, this is very true. Miss Vocational Educational Opportunity.

Miss TI Benefits. Just super wonderful. Miss Medical Alcohol, Miss TV dinner, and Miss Mistaken Identity. I know you girls must have high ideals and look up to the people who embody those qualities you most admire. Will you tell us quickly who are your three all-time great American heroes? Oh Jesus! That's one, now name two more. A blood to you, Bob. And then she said, but there are only six of us. She said it didn't feel right. And he got the idea to use these life-size sex dolls and put one on either side of each girl. And so suddenly, I think eight girls became 24 girls through this very, very clever and really theatrically ingenious approach to the number. That's just one example of the kind of theatrical thinking and humor that he brought to that show.

[16:42] David Armstrong: In addition to it being theatrical and adding a dance element, it also underlined the satire. She was always focusing on the story and trying to augment that element of Whorehouse. This was a satirical piece. And so this just underscored the critique of prostitution and selling entertainment with bodies and so forth. It's a sophisticated approach to musical staging. One other thing I should mention about Whorehouse is that he was masterful in creating what I would call conceptual staging, where the concept of the number is really more important than the actual steps. The steps actually are secondary.

[17:21] Kevin Winkler: And he was a master of a practice that he coined a term for that I use in the book called the Gazintas. He says director choreographers go for seamlessness. He said, We don't just play a scene, sing a song, do a dance. Play a scene, sing a song, do a dance. Sort of the George Abbott model, for lack of a better example. He said, We've tried to mix things in and make it seamless so that one thing goes into another thing. This goes into that, that goes into this, the gazintas. A perfect example of that in Whorehouse is the Aggie dance, where the football players, after the Angelette number, the winning team is seen in their locker room being congratulated and being told that they're going to be treated to a night at the chicken ranch whorehouse because they won the game.

[18:04] David Armstrong: We're gonna walk and stop and a little bit of those little gals won't never ever be the same. They're gonna love it when we walk and stop and a little bit of Aggie. They begin singing and changing out of their football uniforms into cowboy hats and boots and shirts and so forth. And as they dance, the dance takes them as they travel from the locker room from the football stadium to the whorehouse. This is all done on stage without moving any scenery. And at the end of the number, after they finished a Tour de Force dance number, they are there at the chicken ranch, and the girls suddenly appear upstairs, out of the sides, and so forth. No scenery involved, lighting changes and so forth. Everything was done with bodies, with movement, and with imagination. That's as pure an example of a gazinta as you can find and really the hallmark of the great director choreographers of this era.

[19:15] Kevin Winkler: Yeah. Almost all of them with a bare stage, a spectacular bare stage. All those shows of the 1970s, most of Tommy Tune's shows, are done in a way that we just don't see anymore. That's almost gone and forgotten. Yes, indeed. Sometimes I'll go to a musical today, I will mention no names. Um and I think where did all this scenery come from? People are jumping around and the scenery's flying in and out. And when I wrote the book on Fosse, I would argue to the death that he was the ultimate minimalist. But having written this book about Tune, I think Tune's right up there with them. And I think the greatest of the director choreographers are right up there as minimalists because they have that in common. They would rather get their effects through the movement of human bodies than acres of scenery.

[20:02] David Armstrong: You quote Tommy Tune a couple times in the book. One time you say that he saw all of his shows as ballets. Explain what he meant by that.

[20:09] Kevin Winkler: I think it's tied into what we're just talking about, isn't it? Indeed, yes. The title for the book comes directly from Tune. Tune says that everything is choreography. Everything you do on stage is choreography. If you just walk across the stage, pick up a telephone, anything, all of that is choreography. He's been very influenced by ballet, by works by people like Anthony Tudor, to convey the essence of a scene, the essence of an exchange through movement alone. He said, if I can get the same effect with two or three gestures, why do I need a dozen gestures? Less is more. It brings a kind of clarity to the staging that audiences appreciate.

[20:48] David Armstrong: I also remember you quoting him as talking about the mega musicals of the British invasion. And they were substituting scenery for choreography. And you know, he's not disparaging them. Actually, he says he loves Phantom of the Opera, but he said they'd get their choreographic effects from scenery. He called them scenic choreography. He said, I'd rather get the same effects with bodies.

[21:09] Kevin Winkler: Exactly. One thing I wanted to go back to when you talk about the Aggie number, that's also underlying the satire and the hypocrisy of the show because the beefcake aspect of that number, just like the Angelettes, is showing up the hypocrisy of closing down this whorehouse and yet using sex to sell everything else.

[21:26] David Armstrong: Indeed. He said these football players make their living through their bodies just the way the women at the whorehouse do. There's an intellectual underpinning to what he was doing, certainly. And I think sometimes the show business of it and the fabulousness of it covered up the fact that this was happening, although I think subliminally those messages were coming through.

[21:45] Kevin Winkler: I agree. I think subliminally that message is conveyed, but the show business of it, the theatricality of it looms very large over it.

[21:52] David Armstrong: Yeah. Whorehouse, I think, is one of the shows that's very misremembered because of the movie, not quite capturing what the original show was about. And again, it hasn't been revived. So most people have never seen that original intention that came behind that show that I remember as being one of the funniest shows I ever saw, one of the most dazzlingly staged shows I ever saw. And yet so simple and also one of the most satirical and thought-provoking shows in many ways.

[22:19] Kevin Winkler: Yeah, and it had a real homey atmosphere to it, beyond the showbiz aspects, beyond the satirical elements to it. It had a down home flavor, a quality to it that was really irresistible. And of course it ran for over four years.

[22:33] David Armstrong: Yeah, amazing. One of the biggest hits ever. But again, it hasn't remained in our heads that way. I think the movie version really coarsened the material. And I also I had this conversation with a couple of the women that I interviewed for the book, and I said, could Whorehouse be revived today? And I'm not sure. The material is certainly high quality. It's certainly a better show than lots of things that do get revived. I think today, a humorous look at prostitution, even as big-hearted and as satiric as the material is, I think is a bit of a tough sell today.

[23:07] Kevin Winkler: Yeah, the idea of the happy hooker is a little hard for us to grasp onto. Even though those women are humanized and they are clearly not the villains in the piece.

[23:17] David Armstrong: Hey. Maybe I'll dye my hair.

[23:24] ♪ Musical number: "Hard Candy Christmas" ♪

[24:07] Kevin Winkler: It's the holy rollers and the crusaders who are the villains. I think it would be a difficult sell today, I think. And that's a shame because the material is terrific. The score is wonderful.

[24:35] David Armstrong: Don't go away. Broadway Nation will be back right after this short break with our discussion of A Day in Hollywood, A Night in the Ukraine, and Tommy Tune's incredible staging of the musical Nine.

[25:27] ♪ Musical number ♪

[25:34] David Armstrong: So this leads him into what eventually results in A Day in Hollywood, A Night in the Ukraine. But he sort of gets there through a weird path. It starts out to be a different show in a way, at least a lot of the concepts that end up in that show.

[25:47] Kevin Winkler: Yeah. In the summer and fall of 1979, he choreographed a show called Double Feature that was directed by Mike Nichols. And that started a very productive working relationship and a friendship between Nichols and Tune. The show was about two couples, two married couples who cope with issues in their marriage and their lives by imagining what iconic movie stars would do in their position. There were two people who were the dancing ensemble, the chorus, and the scenic designer, Tony Walton, created at the top of the stage something that he called the ankle stage, so that these two dancers could appear and evoke recognizable movie stars like Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers, or Ruby Keeler and Dick Powell, or Mickey and Minnie Mouse, people like that, from the knees down.

Tune said, I've seen people on stage try to emulate Rogers and Astaire, and he said it just doesn't work. But he said, if you can give a flavor of what made them so special by showing them just from the knees down, that can work. And so they rigged up this space at the top of the stage with bars and rings so that the dancers could hold on to them. They had something called a spinner where they would walk into this round circular thing that would spin them around. So if they're dancing, instead of doing two or three pirouettes, they could do eight or nine or ten pirouettes. They could literally dance off the floor. They could fly. So just a delicious concept all around. Well, anyway, that show didn't make it.

It didn't go beyond that production at the Long Wharf. But near the end of its run, Tune was approached about directing a transfer of a British review called A Day in Hollywood, A Night in the Ukraine. This had been a show that was done in a French theater in London and then later transferred to the West End. The second act of it was kind of a burlesque of an Anton Chekhov one act as it might have been performed by the Marx Brothers. And then there was a curtain raiser, which was literally nothing more than people standing around a piano singing songs, sort of related to Hollywood. Tune, of course, his imagination bursting really made this show A Day in Hollywood, A Night in the Ukraine, a kind of little jewel box of a show, a brilliant little jewel of a show. And he expanded the first act to be a review about the movies as told by the ushers at Grauman's Chinese Theater.

[28:20] ♪ Musical number ♪

[28:40] Kevin Winkler: And Tony Walton was back as the set designer. And of course, the ankle stage was the perfect vehicle to evoke dozens and dozens of famous movie stars, movie characters, again from the knees down. And Walton expanded the ankle stage. He put mirrors in it so it would reflect the bottom of the stage, so you could see the like the footprints dancing on the footprints in Grauman's Chinese and so forth. So just an ingenious approach to the material. It was again such a terrific show, so thrillingly staged and performed. It's part of this thing that happens. Tune is right in the middle of this revival of the review. I say it starts with Hair, basically. And I think the artists of that period were responding to and rebelling against the Rodgers and Hammerstein model by bringing back the review.

It seemed like a new way of storytelling by going back to this very old way. And so many of Tune's shows draw on this. The club is literally a review, a thematic one tied together with a thread of concept. The first act of Day in Hollywood is a review. Then the second act is a book musical.

[29:46] David Armstrong: Yes, indeed. Did he ever talk about that? Does he have any awareness that this was a different way to make shows than had happened even 10 years earlier?

[29:54] Kevin Winkler: No, we didn't really talk about it. One of the interesting things about Tune, the thing that makes him such a great artist, is that he would tailor his approach to the material. And if the material didn't support that approach, then he would try a different approach. That's one of the reasons, again, why I think he is maybe not as well remembered as others, is that he didn't have an identifiable style. His style was whatever the show needed. And so he gave Hollywood Ukraine a kind of review energy. He just knew that that's what it needed. And actually, the next show that he did after Hollywood Ukraine was Cloud Nine. And he actually directed that in much the same way, in a kind of review format, with a kind of review energy.

The first act is done very much as a kind of vaudeville burlesque staging. And then the second act is done much more naturalistically. He used that same approach to two shows that are completely different, couldn't be any more different, but yet they demanded, he felt, that kind of directorial approach. Cloud Nine, I think, put him in a category which most other director choreographers never got to, which is now he's a very successful director of a serious play, a very funny play, but with very serious intent to it. And to have done Whorehouse and then Day in Hollywood and Cloud Nine really positioned him in a very unique way in the world of theater at that moment. Somebody, uh Walter Kerr, Clive Barnes, I can't remember.

Someone said we're used to Tommy Tune as a brilliant director of musicals. Now we have to get used to Tommy Tune as a brilliant director of plays. It really did put him into a whole other category as a serious artist. I think a lot of times directors of musicals are kind of pigeonholed in that category. Fabulous directors, but it's a musical. It's not a straight play. It's a musical. And he refused to be hemmed in by those artificial boundaries. And he's actually one of the few directors of musicals who had that kind of really serious acclaim for doing a play. Gower Champion did some plays. You could argue that Fosse with his films did drama, not just musicals. But this was startling to see someone who's associated with musicals and tap dancing really direct something with such sensitivity and integrity and intellectual rigor, as you say.

[32:06] David Armstrong: And feeding into that, we skipped over it. Maybe we should go back now and pick this up. We knew Tommy Tune as a performer. So he had this whole personality, unlike all these other director choreographers who we really only knew through their staging, except for Gower Champion, of course, who had a whole career as a performer. But even he didn't have, in my mind, at least, maybe because I was too young to experience that, he didn't have the performance profile that Tommy Tune did, at least at this point.

[32:31] Kevin Winkler: No. And Tommy even said, I always considered myself a performer first. I somehow got sidetracked into this directing stuff, but he always referred to himself as a performer first. I think it was difficult for him to get cast just because he's tall. Very tall. He has a little joke that he's used over the years. He said, instead of saying that I'm six foot six inches tall, I say I'm five feet eighteen inches tall. Because it makes me feel a little shorter. It was difficult for him to get cast. He wasn't right for everything. That was one of the reasons that he kind of moved into directing. Another interesting thing about him, he said, because I had so much trouble getting cast, he said, I feel like anybody should be able to play anything.

And in Cloud Nine, for instance, women play men, men play women, black people play white people. An idol plays Queen Victoria. He said anyone should be able to play anything. The women play men in Cloud Nine. It just occurred to me that's a perfect segue into Tune's next show.

[33:29] David Armstrong: Exactly. Take us there.

[33:30] Kevin Winkler: So Tune's neighbor was a writer named Mario Fratti, an Italian writer, who was working on a new show with a young composer named Maury Yeston. And actually, Maury Yeston was hired to do incidental music for Cloud Nine as well. So Tune knew him from that as well. And they'd also, we don't need to get into this, but Tune and Mike Nichols and Maury Yeston were also for a hot minute involved in a potential musicalization of La Cage aux Folles, which never happened. Before the Jerry Herman, it was a show called The Queen of Basin Street that ended up not happening. So Tune knew Yeston. Anyway, Mario Fratti gave Tune a cassette of the music from Nine.

[34:09] ♪ Musical number ♪

[35:05] Kevin Winkler: It's an orchestra surrounding Guido, and Guido's conducting. He said, I just see it as an orchestra. There's lots of German music. Play. He joined the show as director choreographer, and they were planning a workshop, and he said they kept seeing terrific women come in and audition. Chief among them, Lillianne Montevecchi. How can she be placed in a movie about an Italian film director? So he started to think, why can't everyone on the stage be a woman? Why can't the producer be a woman? Why can't the paparazzi be women? Why can't this person be a woman? This person. And he went to Moriestin, Arthur Coppett, who was writing the book, and said, I want to cast all the characters with women surrounding Guido.

And they didn't like that. And he removed himself from the production for a brief moment. Yestin and Arthur Coppett came back to him finally and they said, Okay, we'll try it, but just for the workshop. And that, of course, is the last time that was ever questioned. The interesting thing about Nine, from my perspective, is that I think when Toon got a hold of it, it was a much more conventional show. And one of the first things he did was insist that Arthur Coppett come in and write the book. Arthur Coppet was a playwright and had recently written a play that was done at the public theater and then transferred to Broadway briefly called Wings about a woman who had had a stroke. And as she tries to regain her use of her body and her speech, it's a play of the mind.

It takes place in her mind. And he said, This is what this show needs to be. It takes place in Guido's mind. And he said, Arthur Coppett knows how to do that, so let's bring him in to work on the show. So that was a foundational requirement, as foundational as his decision to cast all women in the show. Well, in a way, they tie together because his mind is obsessed with all these women. Yes, indeed. There's an ever present harem attending to his every whim, as one of the lyrics goes. It makes perfect sense. Which is part of his problem. It's interesting because I looked at doing a production of it a few years ago, and there was some discussion about whether this was a sexist show or not. And on the surface, I understood why people were questioning that, but the show results in Guido growing up.

And letting go of that juvenile sexist view of the world. Exactly. It took until he's 40 years old to do that, but he finally does. The world that he created for himself is so heady and luxurious, surrounded by women, and he gives into that. And it's only as he goes through a series of things that happened with his marriage and his memories and so forth. Has a breakdown, basically. Has a breakdown, is able to come out of that and leave it behind. Again, a phenomenal production.

[39:26] Kevin Winkler: I'm assuming that to research the book, you went to see everything that's recorded at the library. And you had access to other video recordings of the show so you could refresh your memory. Yeah, well, for Nine, I have a good friend who was in the original cast of Nine. We'd all done a show together, and she got a group of us tickets. I think we saw one of the first previews of Nine. And it was one of those shows that whenever friends were in town, I'd take them to see it. If my friend was on for another role, I'd go see it. So I had very vivid memories of that show. Yes, I went to the Theater on Film and Tape archive at the New York Public Library to catch up on those videotapes of shows that I hadn't seen or to refresh my memory.

There's a lot of stuff out there. I had a couple people, oh, I hear you're doing a book about Tommy Tune. Here's a videotape. Don't tell anyone, but here's a videotape of something. And they'd send me a scratchy tape of something. So there's stuff out there, but I also, as I said earlier, I love doing archival research. So for the Nine chapter, I went down to NYU, where Arthur Coppett's papers are and went through those. That's where I read early drafts of the script by Mario Fratti. I got fabulous, great stuff about casting notes and so forth. That's where I found out that they auditioned Sonny Bono to replace Raoul Julia in Nine. Just interesting things. There were written exercises. They asked each of the women who was cast in the show to write an essay about an encounter with Guido because they knew they'd have to establish characterizations very quickly without a lot of dialogue.

So he said this helped us. It helped the costume designer, it helped everyone kind of get a sense of who each of these women was. Really interesting essays by the actresses. So yeah, that was one of the great joys of writing that chapter was looking at the archival research. And I interviewed Arthur Coppett, who passed away this past year. That was a real opportunity that I was grateful I had.

[41:19] Kevin Winkler: You mentioned the women creating those backstories for themselves, brings up the subject of the workshop process. Michael Bennett somewhat invents that, but I feel like Tommy then really latches onto it. And I feel like that's a story told in your book, which we don't hear all that often, of how he uses this workshop process and becomes a major tool that he relies on to bring this team of people together to make a show. Indeed. And you know, the workshop process should be at its foundation a real opportunity to explore the material. And that's what they did with Nine. It was amorphous enough that it really needed to be workshop for many of the women. There was no character for them. They sort of had to create those characters themselves.

One of my favorite stories in the entire book was told to me by a woman named Laura Kenyon, who was in the show. And she said she was cast as she said, I was an Italian. I had no character. But she knew Italian cinema and she knew Fellini, and she knew that Lena Vertmueller, who later became a celebrated director in her own right, Lena Vert Mueller had been an assistant director to Fellini on this film. And Lena Vert Mueller always wore wild crazy glasses and looked kind of very severe. Yes, very severe, very sinister. And she said, I just started wearing glasses, and my son had a little toy knife. It was a comb that looked like a knife. And she said I would just bring it and I'd just kind of walk around and I was a presence.

And she said, Lillian Montevecchi and I kind of connected over that. And she said, before I knew it, I had a role as this character who was sort of a bodyguard assistant to Lillian Montevecchi's character. She said at one point, Tommy loved that I did this. At one point, I'm just kind of wandering around, and one of the people on stage says, wait a minute, what's Laura Kenyon doing back here? And from the audience, Tommy said, I don't know what Laura Kenyon's doing back there, and I hope I never find out. And she said, He just let me play, and that's how she came up with that character. I don't think that happens in that way much anymore. I think this whole workshop way of putting on a show has receded to be a memory at this point. Now it's much more structured. The clock is ticking, the money is ticking away. You know, and this was 40 years ago, it seems a lifetime ago. I think it's a different environment today.

[43:32] Kevin Winkler: So the next show, he doesn't use the workshop process, then maybe they should have, but this show was about him being a performer. And it started off with him as the star rather than as the creator of the show. It's one of the great sagas, I think, of the Rocky Road to Broadway. I love that you compare it to the movie of The Bandwagon. Because the parallel is so direct. I never thought of that before, but just the way you describe The Bandwagon, and then you say it's also what happened with My One and Only. It was really amazing. The story of My One and Only is one of the great theatrical backstage stories of the end of the 20th century. I mean, it really was quite a saga. Unfortunately, you're going to have to wait for the next episode of Broadway Nation to hear the incredible story of all the backstage drama of My One and Only, as well as the making of Grand Hotel, The Will Rogers Follies, and more, as I continue my conversation with Kevin Winkler, author of the new book Everything Is Choreography, The Musical Theater of Tommy Tune.

[44:32] David Armstrong: Broadway Nation is written and produced by me, David Armstrong. If you love this podcast and want to delve even deeper into the world of Broadway musicals, I invite you to become a member of the Broadway Nation Backstage Pass Club. For as little as $7 a month, members will receive exclusive access to never before heard, unedited versions of every season two interview and many from season one as well. I often record at least twice as much conversation as ends up in the public episodes. And this includes additional in-depth conversations with my frequent co-host, Albert Evans. You will also have the opportunity to ask us any questions about Broadway musicals that you would like to hear answered and to propose topics and subject matter that you would like me to cover, all of which I will incorporate into a special series of Ask Me Anything About Broadway episodes.

Last but certainly not least, you will receive special on-air shout-outs and acknowledgment of your vital support for this podcast. To join, just click the link included in the show notes for this episode on our website at www.broadway-nation.com. That's Broadway Nation.com. Special thanks to Pals Mox for his help with editing this episode, to KVSH 101.9, the voice of beautiful Vashon Island, Washington, and to the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred