Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 54: "You Gotta Take Care Of Business" - The Genius of Tommy Tune, part 2

This is the second part of my conversation with Kevin Winkler, author of the fascinating new book: Everything Is Choreography – The Musical Theater of Tommy Tune. If you missed part one, you may want to go back and listen to that before embarking on this one... Read More

From the show: BROADWAY NATION

26 mins
1/27/22

Guests

About

This is the second part of my conversation with Kevin Winkler, author of the fascinating new book: Everything Is Choreography – The Musical Theater of Tommy Tune.

If you missed part one, you may want to go back and listen to that before embarking on this one.

Today Kevin relates the saga of the all of the incredible behind-the-scenes drama that transpired during the rehearsals and out of town tryout of My One and Only – the “new” Gershwin musical that stared Tommy Tune and Twiggy.

He also shares the story of how Tune transformed a 1950s musical flop into the one of the most acclaimed musicals of what I call “The Modern Era of Broadway”. That show, of course, was Grand Hotel.

Broadway Nation is written and produced by David Armstrong

Special thanks to Pauls Macs for his assistance with editing, as well as KVSH 101.9 the Voice Of Vashon, and the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:02] Kevin Winkler: He liked it. He liked it. He really liked it. He said, Would you be interested in being the assistant choreographer of my new Broadway show?

[0:12] David Armstrong: And I said, Well, uh, gee, you know, I'm not really interested in being an assistant choreographer. I'm lying, I'm lying, I'm lying. I really said, interested. Interested. Would I be interested?

[0:32] Kevin Winkler: Well, it's the beginning. It's not where you start, it's where you finish. It's not how you go, it's how you land. A hundred to one shot. You call him a clotz. Can Al run the favorite. All he needs is the guts.

[0:53] David Armstrong: Welcome to another episode of Broadway Nation, the podcast that tells the remarkable story of how immigrants, Jews, queers, African Americans, and other outcasts invented the Broadway musical and how they changed America in the process. I'm David Armstrong, and I call this episode You Gotta Take Care of Business. The genius of Tommy Tune, Part 2.

[1:16] David Armstrong: This is the second part of my recent conversation with Kevin Winkler, author of the fascinating new book, Everything is Choreography: The Musical Theater of Tommy Tune. If you missed part one, you may want to go back and listen to that before embarking on this one. We ended last week's episode with Kevin making this intriguing statement.

[1:35] Kevin Winkler: The story of My One and Only is one of the great theatrical backstage stories of the end of the 20th century. I mean, it really was quite a saga.

[1:43] David Armstrong: Now you will get to hear that story, as well as the saga of how Tommy Tune transformed a 1950s flop musical into one of the most acclaimed musicals of what I call the modern era of Broadway. That show, of course, was Grand Hotel.

[1:58] David Armstrong: As we begin, it's important to remember that Tommy Tune started out as a performer and first came to fame when he received a Tony Award for Best Supporting Actor in a Musical for his role in Seesaw as a young, aspiring gay choreographer with dreams of making it big on Broadway.

[2:23] Kevin Winkler: Wait, come back, we've got to do a bigger finish.

[2:28] David Armstrong: This was clearly a case of art not only reflecting life, but also predicting it. Because not only was Tune terrific in the role, Seesaw's director Michael Bennett had also asked Tune to choreograph his own showstopping song and dance production number, It's Not Where You Start.

[2:53] Kevin Winkler: And Toon's twin careers as Broadway star and star choreographer were set in motion simultaneously.

[3:00] David Armstrong: Here we go. It all came out of Toon's desire to go back and perform.

[3:05] Kevin Winkler: Nine, Cloud Nine, Hollywood, Ukraine, Poorhouse. He could have done anything he wanted at that point. But he really wanted to get back on stage.

[3:12] Kevin Winkler: It had been 10 years since he had appeared in a Broadway show since Seesaw, someone who was involved in raising money and producing the show, got the idea to pair Tune with Peter Sellers, that S-E-L-L-A-R-S, not the actor, the director.

[3:27] David Armstrong: I remember Peter Sellers was the boy genius. He's sort of like the Orson Welles of the not-for-profit world.

[3:33] Kevin Winkler: And the opera world as well.

[3:35] David Armstrong: And the opera world, yeah. But he was very hot at that moment, and on the cover of the New York Times magazine and things like that.

[3:42] Kevin Winkler: He was, as you said, the boy wonder of avant-garde theater and opera. And did things like he would direct King Lear, like putting a black exploitation movie on stage.

[4:04] David Armstrong: Broadway show. Again, where the clock is ticking and the money is ticking.

[4:08] Kevin Winkler: And they were all works that were established that were not being written. They were Mozart operas or Shakespeare or things that existed.

[4:16] David Armstrong: Exactly.

[4:17] Kevin Winkler: Yes, indeed. He had never developed a show from the ground up. And this was a new show, even though it was based on the 1927 Gershwin musical Funny Face that had starred Fred Astaire.

[4:28] Kevin Winkler: Anyway, he had his own team, a music team and a book writer.

[4:32] David Armstrong: And designers as well.

[4:33] Kevin Winkler: Yes, indeed. All people he had worked with and very successfully worked with. The script that I saw, which is in the Peter Stone papers up at the Performing Arts Library, which I'm pretty sure, from what I can confirm with people who were involved, was the script that they had in place when they went out of town to Boston for their out-of-town tryout.

[4:52] Kevin Winkler: It's really long, it's really talky. Some interesting things, some really interesting, provocative statements about geopolitics and labor unions and relationships between Europe and the United States and the banking industry and stuff like that.

[5:09] Kevin Winkler: But it just seemed to overwhelm the Gershwin songs. It was just long and slow and talky. It wasn't going to deliver the musical comedy that people were clearly expecting.

[5:22] Kevin Winkler: One of the best interviews I did for the book was with the show's production stage manager, Peter von Meyerhauser. He said, you know, it seemed weird, but he said it also seemed like the kind of pairing that could work.

[5:32] Kevin Winkler: Peter Sellers and Tommy Tune, they're both good at what they do. Maybe it'll work. Maybe it'll be something really terrific. And Tommy Tune was doing the choreography as well as starring in the show.

[5:41] Kevin Winkler: He was co-choreographing with Tommy Walsh, who he worked with frequently.

[5:45] David Armstrong: Yes, indeed.

[5:45] Kevin Winkler: And Peter said to me, there was nothing to get from one scene to another. There was no connecting music. There were no gazintas, I guess you could say.

[5:53] Kevin Winkler: And he said to Peter, how are we going to get from this scene to the other? And he said, the one thing that strikes terror in the heart of the stage manager. He said, We'll figure it out in Boston.

[6:03] Kevin Winkler: He said, from that time on, I knew this was trouble.

[6:05] David Armstrong: So they got to Boston, and Tommy told me, he said, we couldn't even tech it. We couldn't even get through the show on stage.

[6:12] Kevin Winkler: They fired Peter Sellers immediately. And they fired his musical team. And they came to Tommy and said, You have to direct the show or we're going to close it.

[6:20] Kevin Winkler: And he said, wait a minute. I'm on stage for the first time in 10 years. I'm teaching Twiggy to tap dance. I'm doing the choreography. This is too many hats to wear.

[6:28] Kevin Winkler: And they said, Well, if you don't do it, we're going to close. So he agreed.

[6:32] Kevin Winkler: The first thing he did was call Mike Nichols. And Mike Nichols came in and he came up to Boston and they literally cut, I don't know, an hour or something out of the show.

[6:41] Kevin Winkler: And Tommy said it still wasn't good, but at least we could get through it. And he said it sort of made sense, sort of.

[6:48] David Armstrong: And correct me if I'm wrong, but they did have these wonderful dance numbers already as part of the show to sort of hang on to and to craft everything else around.

[7:04] Kevin Winkler: You should kill me.

[7:09] Kevin Winkler: So bomb night.

[7:16] Kevin Winkler: What I love to see.

[7:20] Kevin Winkler: You made my life so glamour.

[7:26] Kevin Winkler: You can't blame me for Milan Amoras.

[7:31] Kevin Winkler: Awesome wonderful.

[7:35] Kevin Winkler: Smile.

[7:38] Kevin Winkler: That you should care for me.

[7:41] Kevin Winkler: As one of the dancers said, we knew the numbers were good. The numbers worked. They already had that wonderful number with Tommy and Twiggy dancing in the sliver of water along the stage.

[7:51] Kevin Winkler: They had the hi-hat number with Toon and the Men. So they had all these terrific numbers, and they did more later. That was what kept them going, the fact that the numbers were really working.

[8:01] Kevin Winkler: And they brought in a new musical team, Wally Harper, Jack Lee came in and they started creating a new show, basically.

[8:07] Kevin Winkler: And Peter Stone as well.

[8:08] David Armstrong: And Peter Stone came in, and you know, Peter Stone is another one of the unsung heroes of the musical.

[8:15] Kevin Winkler: He always says that the key to a successful show, it's not the score, it's the book.

[8:20] Kevin Winkler: He said, if the book doesn't work, if it doesn't make sense, doesn't matter how good the score is. He said that's why people listen to cast recordings of flop shows and say, how could this be a flop? The music is so good.

[8:31] Kevin Winkler: But if you go back and read the script, you see that it doesn't hang together. The infrastructure isn't there.

[8:38] Kevin Winkler: So he set about creating an infrastructure. And in the end, it's a very lighter than air confection.

[8:44] Kevin Winkler: It's a boy meets girl, boy loses girl, boy gets girl back show, but done with great style and fabulous dancing.

[8:51] Kevin Winkler: But anyway, they went back into rehearsal after Boston because they couldn't get it together in the limited time they had in Boston.

[8:58] Kevin Winkler: They went back into rehearsal back in New York, did a long preview process, and then finally opened at the very tail end of the season.

[9:05] Kevin Winkler: And turned out to be a hit. I think I say this in the book. So many times when a show goes through all this sturm und drang out of town, it comes into New York looking like something the cat dragged in, just defeated and worn.

[9:17] David Armstrong: This was not like that at all. It was buoyant and light. You'd have no idea that it had gone through all of this drama before it opened.

[9:25] Kevin Winkler: Yeah, it was fantastic. The look of the show was so arresting. Again, so non-realistic.

[9:32] Kevin Winkler: The scenic design was done by Adrianne Lobel, who had worked with Peter Sellers, and it was done in a Russian constructivist style with big slabs of scenery and panels sliding up and going down and so forth.

[9:44] Kevin Winkler: And what Peter told me was he said it was very bland, and he said the set looked like a paper bag.

[9:49] Kevin Winkler: And when you put lights on the stage, they reflected back on the actors, and everybody looked yellow.

[9:54] Kevin Winkler: So Tony Walton came up to Boston and they brightened it up. He created a color palette for it that was deep indigo and bright yellows and primary colors to just kind of make it pop.

[10:06] Kevin Winkler: It has an almost avant-garde feel to it because it's done almost entirely on a bare stage. There are virtually no props, very few set pieces, all the better to clear the stage for dancing, and just panels moving up and down, sliding in and so forth.

[10:21] Kevin Winkler: It's directed in a more sophisticated manner than I think people remember it for.

[10:26] David Armstrong: Absolutely.

[10:26] Kevin Winkler: So it's sort of Adrianne Lobel did the sculpture and then Tony Walton did the color on top of it, which ended up being one of the most spectacular shows I've ever seen in terms of the visuals of it.

[10:35] David Armstrong: Yeah.

[10:37] Kevin Winkler: So the happy ending is that Tommy Tune is able to showcase himself as a performer again for the first time in ten years and very successfully.

[10:46] David Armstrong: And the show runs a long time.

[10:48] Kevin Winkler: Right. The show was a big hit.

[10:49] Kevin Winkler: He won two Tony Awards for its performances at lead actor in a musical.

[10:54] Kevin Winkler: And he and Tommy Walsh won the choreography award. It's a very happy ending to a turbulent beginning.

[11:01] Kevin Winkler: And the show was a big touring title. It toured for a long time after that.

[11:05] Kevin Winkler: And so successful that he even was replaced in the show. It's a vehicle for him, but it's such a hit that someone else takes over the role when he leaves.

[11:12] David Armstrong: That's right.

[11:13] Kevin Winkler: He and Twiggy left, and Sandy Duncan and Don Korea, her husband, came in and replaced them.

[11:18] Kevin Winkler: Then he came back and did it with Sandy for a while.

[11:21] Kevin Winkler: And then they went on tour with it.

[11:22] Kevin Winkler: And then she left, and Lucy Arnaz came in and did it, and they went to Japan.

[11:26] Kevin Winkler: It was a very, very successful touring property.

[11:29] David Armstrong: Don't go away. There's more Broadway Nation right after this short break.

[11:49] Kevin Winkler: So now we're back to another workshop process with Grand Hotel. That process is crucial to the creation of the show.

[11:56] Kevin Winkler: That's another fascinating story. And it was really proof of Toon's ability to kind of take apart and put back together again a musical property.

[12:06] Kevin Winkler: Again, I think if anybody else had done this show, I think it would have been a much more conventional stage musical.

[12:12] David Armstrong: And in fact, it had been that.

[12:13] Kevin Winkler: It had been a conventional musical.

[12:14] Kevin Winkler: Years earlier, right?

[12:15] David Armstrong: Well, back in the late 50s, yeah.

[12:16] Kevin Winkler: By Wright and Forrest.

[12:18] Kevin Winkler: We tried out on the West Coast.

[12:19] Kevin Winkler: It even had a theater book.

[12:20] Kevin Winkler: It was booked into the 46th Street Theater in New York, but Paul Muni was the star of the show.

[12:25] Kevin Winkler: He played Kringlein, the bookkeeper, and he had a lot of issues, and he didn't want to come into New York with the show.

[12:31] Kevin Winkler: So it basically died.

[12:33] Kevin Winkler: And that production, it was heavy with scenery and realism, and the Grand Hotel is on the stage in all of its heaviness.

[12:41] Kevin Winkler: Turntables and grand staircases and bedrooms and yes, it was a big show.

[12:47] David Armstrong: And of course, then Tommy Tune's production becomes the polar opposite of that.

[12:50] Kevin Winkler: Right.

[12:50] Kevin Winkler: So Toon saw something in this that would make a compelling musical in Wright and Forrest score and the book by Luther Davis.

[12:58] Kevin Winkler: So he booked a workshop of the show and he basically took it apart.

[13:02] Kevin Winkler: He drew on Vicky Baum's novel.

[13:05] David Armstrong: Before you go there, tell us about this dream that he has that ends up bringing him to this space that really informs the show.

[13:12] Kevin Winkler: Thank you for reminding me. He had a dream. He dreamed that he was staging a show in a ballroom. Nothing in it but just people moving and dancing around. There were a few chairs here and there, chandeliers, all elegant and beautiful, another world, another era, this big vast ballroom. So he joined this production as director choreographer, Grand Hotel, and he did not want to direct it in a rehearsal hall. He hated rehearsal halls. He said they were antiseptic, they didn't breathe. He always preferred to rehearse in an actual theater. Or in the case of Nine in Hollywood, Ukraine, he rehearsed those at the New Amsterdam roof, uh the roof of the New Amsterdam theater. Anyway, the production team went out scouting for locations and they called him and they said, We've got a place, but you're not gonna like it.

And he said, Well, what is it? Well, it's the ballroom of this old dilapidated diplomat hotel on West 43rd Street. And he said, Hang on, I'll be right there. He got there. They walked in, and it's horrible, it's a mess, paints peeling. He said, This was it. What I saw in my dream. This is the ballroom. I love it. This is where we're going to do the workshop. So he went back to Vicki Baum's novel, The Grand Hotel for dialogue, so forth. And they really sliced and diced the script and the score to create what I call a mosaic of music and movement for the show. They did the workshop. They basically did about an hour of the show. It was received with great enthusiasm. They went into rehearsal. He wanted it in some ways, the show to resemble like a fever dream, resemble the dream in his head, where the action would be a continuous flow.

Nothing would stop. You'd go from movement, music, dialogue, back and forth. It would be one big two-hour gazenta. So a kind of cinematic staging where there were quick cuts and dissolves, different things going on in different parts of the hotel. The ballroom setting allowed him to do that. It was a bare space where he could create anything, any space, just using lights and movement and so forth. There were some old rickety ballroom chairs, banquet chairs at the diplomat, and they began using those. Tony Walton came in. I can't remember who decided on this, but they decided to come up with, I think, uh four dozen gold gilt chairs. And Toon would then use those to create a hallway, to create the entrance, to create a conference room or something.

And they could all be moved by the cast, just like that. He said, I don't want to wait for beds and doorways and staircases. I don't want that. He said, I want it to move quickly. And so Tony Walton basically recreates the ballroom from the diplomat as the set for the show, including four columns that are right in the middle of all the action, basically. There were four mirrored pillars in the middle of the diplomat hotel. Originally, Tune thought that they would put the orchestra at the back of the stage, and for a variety of reasons that didn't work. But Walton said, let's put them above the stage in a kind of lattice work uh framework. And part of the support for that bandstand were these four pillars.

So they really needed to carry over the four pillars to the stage. But of course, you got four pillars stuck in the middle of the stage. But as somebody said to me, Tommy said, The pillars will be our friends. They kind of grounded the action. He worked all kinds of movement around them. They were no impediment whatsoever. He built the show around the pillars. He built the show around the pillars. One of the things he didn't want to do was stop for applause. He wanted it to be one continuous move. They got to Boston. It certainly was not the disaster that my one and only was, not at all. And it got mixed reviews in Boston. But it became very clear, I think to everyone, that by having it be one continuous two hours of movement, it didn't give the audience time to appreciate the numbers and to really express their appreciation.

And it was somewhat confusing. Things needed to be underscored that maybe weren't, things were glossed over and so forth. So once again, Peter Stone came up to Boston and began working with him to kind of clarify plot points and make it clearer. They began to build in applause buttons for the numbers. And this isn't a tale being told out of school because Toon has told it many times. Wright and Forrest were quite elderly at the time, well into their 70s. And he would say, We need a new song for so and so. We need a new song for this spot. And they were very slow to respond. They said to him, Johnny Mercer always said a couple of a day. And Toon said, Johnny Mercer wasn't out of town with a five million dollar flop.

I need the songs now. So he reached out to Maury Eston, who he had worked with on nine, and Mori Eston came up to Boston and he began writing additional songs. He didn't replace the score, but he augmented it. And so the show began to finally come into focus in Boston. There are a couple of things I would take away from this. One is, especially after the My One and Only experience, Toon is a very genial, gracious person. He's a lovely person. I think when you see him interviewed, he has a kind of golly gee ingenuousness. Yeah. But he's he's tough. He knows what needs to get done. On my one and only, he said, you can be a genius and have all these great ideas, but you got to take care of business.

And he knew how to take care of business. And if Wright and Forrest couldn't get those numbers for him, he would get someone in who could get them for him. Perhaps so many people were influenced by Jerry Robbins, he was trying to be the anti-Jarry Robbins in terms of treating everyone well and being genial and nice and respectful and loving, I guess to a certain extent. But that hid that under the surface, he was not in any way unwilling to do what needed to be done and to let people go and make the changes that needed to be done in order to protect the show and protect all the jobs for everybody. He was no pushover, believe me. You cannot helm a multi-million dollar musical and not be tough.

You have to have a spine. When I interviewed people, story after story of his graciousness, how great it was to work with him, how great it was to audition for him, even if he didn't get the job. But he knew how to take care of business and get things done. And he wasn't afraid to make the tough calls. Exactly. Yeah. So the show became to me kind of the apotheosis of the director choreographer shows. His staging became inseparable from the music, lyrics, and book. It's all one. And of equal importance, if not more importance in terms of the final effect of the show. A couple of years ago, they revived Grand Hotel at City Center Encores. Did you see that? No, I wish I had. It was great. I thoroughly enjoyed it.

And it looked very different from Toon's production. The set looked completely different. There was a big giant staircase in the middle. The costumes were different. The cast, of course, is very different, but it was still Toon's show. You can't extricate his work from it. It's part of the infrastructure of the show. It's like chorus line or Dream Girls. How Prince's production of Evita is like this. It's part of the infrastructure, his staging, and a large part of why it's a first rate show. I don't think the material is first rate. Right. But that the show is first rate. The staging elevates it to first rate. Absolutely. One of the things it achieves is taking the musical sequence, one of the hallmarks of the modern musicals, creating these extended musical sequences where you connect large sections of action and plot and dialogue.

And here it's extended for the entire show. It's one big long musical sequence from the top of the show to the end of the show. Indeed. Which is incredibly hard to do. Yeah. And he keeps balls in the air and never lets one drop for it's not quite two hours, just shy of two hours. And he builds in showstoppers. We'll take a glass together. That was one of the most thrilling bullets I've ever spent in a theater. We'll take a glass together. In celebration of a meeting. In celebration. Friendly, civilized, and mess of the race I'll bring to you. No, I to you You'll drink to me. Then you to me. I'm sure we too. I know we do. Good find no finer company. Thank you, Matter. We'll take a glass together.

And we will lift it to the good one. And as we're lifting it, we will most sincerely say cruise it. Your health, sir. Salute and score Australia of all song. All unbecoming in this pose and tellest. We'll take a glass together. And the Wallroom number. Oh, the Valero number. Oh, the Belero number is absolutely thrilling. I want to go to Hollywood. There are showstopping moments in the show, but they add to and create a kind of momentum that pushes the show to a really thrilling conclusion. So again, the show becomes quite a substantial hit. But it's also when Toon starts to be criticized. We start to hear, is he choosing the best material? Is he purposely choosing shows that aren't so good so he can look like the star?

I remember that being in the wind of that period. Frank Rich did a column. I can't remember exactly what he said, but words to that effect. And you know, Toon said, show me the good material. Okay. Give me the good material, and I'll do it. He said, I do what's offered to me, what comes my way. And some of that is the kind of criticism that comes of anyone who's really successful. Right. Is there validity in any of that? Another part of it was that he often chose to work with people who were maybe not of the highest level of stars that could have been in the shows. I don't think that's true of nine, for instance. I don't think it's true of my one and only. As I say in the book, I think beyond Michael Jeter, the principals were journeyman performers.

I don't think everyone was as exactingly cast as they could have been. It's also an ensemble cast, so it's not the kind of thing that would attract star performers anyway. Toon called it a clothesline cast. He said the club was a closed line cast. It's an ensemble. And one of the interesting things, I can't remember who told me this, Grand Hotel. The curtain call at the very end of the show was staged so that nobody got a larger amount of applause. Michael Jeter was clearly the audience favorite in that show, a springline. But he staged it so that people came out in twos, and it was almost a group curtain call, because he said no one will get more applause than Michael, and Michael wasn't really the prominent role.

So I think he was aware of that. I don't know. I'd have to sit and think about that a little more. This brings us to Will Rogers' Follies. And back to back, these two shows have a tremendous impact. Toon wins two Tonies for each of them, one year after the next, which no one has ever done. He's the only person to do that, to win those two awards back to back. And at that moment, he was the King of Broadway.

[24:15] David Armstrong: And the King of Broadway will be the title of next week's episode of Broadway Nation, when once again my guest will be Kevin Winkler, author of Everything is Choreography, the musical theater of Tommy Toon. I do hope you'll join us as we discuss not only the Will Rogers' Follies, but also The Best Little Whorehouse goes Public, Greece, Busker's Alley, and the Incredible theatrical Legacy of Tommy Toon. Broadway Nation is written and produced by me, David Armstrong. If you love this podcast and want to delve even deeper into the world of Broadway musicals, I invite you to become a member of the Broadway Nation Backstage Pass Club. For as little as $7 a month, members will receive exclusive access to never before heard, unedited versions of every season two interview and many from season one as well.

I often record at least twice as much conversation as ends up in the public episodes. And this includes additional in-depth conversations with my frequent co-host, Albert Evans. You will also have the opportunity to ask us any questions about Broadway musicals that you would like to hear answered and to propose topics and subject matter that you would like me to cover, all of which I will incorporate into a special series of Ask Me Anything About Broadway episodes. Last but certainly not least, you will receive special on-air shout-outs and acknowledgement of your vital support for this podcast. To join, just click the link included in the show notes for this episode on our website at www.broadway-nation.com. That's Broadway Dashnation.com. Special thanks to Pals Mox for his help with editing this episode, to KVSH 101.9, the voice of beautiful Vash on Island, Washington, and to the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred