Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Special Encore Episode: PAL JOEY & the Silver Age of Broadway

This is a special encore episode of Broadway Nation. In light of the recent revisal of Rodgers & Hart's musical comedy Pal Joey at New York's City Center I thought it would be interesting to revisit one of my favorite episodes... Read More

From the show: BROADWAY NATION

35 mins
11/9/23

Guests

About

This is a special encore episode of Broadway Nation.

In light of the recent revisal of Rodgers & Hart's musical comedy Pal Joey at New York's City Center I thought it would be interesting to revisit one of my favorite episodes.

I’ll be back next week with the third part of my conversation with Oliver Soden regarding his amazing new biography of Noel Coward. In the meantime please enjoy Pal Joey and the Silver Age of Broadway, part 2:

During the 1930s Broadway was severely impacted by the economic disaster of the "Great Depression". However, somehow out of all that hardship and struggle came an extraordinary period of artistic achievement and spectacular continuing development for the Broadway Musical. The inventors of these shows included several new and defining masters of the musical, as well as many of the bright lights of the 1920’s, who now achieved their full wattage in the 1930’s. Among these were Dietz & Schwartz., Lindsay & Crouse, Cole Porter, Rodgers & Hart, The Gershwins, and George "Mr" Abbott.

Become a PATRON of Broadway Nation!

This episode is made possible in part through the generous support of our Patron Club members!

If you would like to help support the work of Broadway Nation I will information at the end of the podcast about how you too can become a Patron.

If you are a fan ofBroadway Nation, I invite you too to become a PATRON!

For a just $7.00 a month you will receive exclusive access to never-before-heard, unedited versions of many of the discussions that I have with my guests — in fact I often record nearly twice as much conversation as ends up in the edited versions. You will also have access to additional in-depth conversations with my frequent co-host Albert Evans that have not been featured on the podcast.

All patrons receive special “on-air” shout-outs and acknowledgement of your vital support of this podcast. And if you are very enthusiastic about Broadway Nation there are additional PATRON levels that come with even more benefits.

If you would like to support the work of Broadway Nation and receive these exclusive member benefits, please just click on this link:

https://broadwaynationpodcast.supercast.tech/

Thank you in advance for your support!

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] David Armstrong: Welcome to a special Encore episode of Broadway Nation.

[0:04] David Armstrong: In light of the recent revisal of PAL JOEY at City Center in New York, I thought it would be interesting to revisit one of my favorite episodes.

[0:12] David Armstrong: I'll be back next week with the third part of my conversation with Oliver Soden regarding his amazing new biography of Noel Coward.

[0:20] David Armstrong: In the meantime, please enjoy PAL JOEY and the Silver Age of Broadway Part 2.

[0:41] David Armstrong: Welcome to another episode of Broadway Nation, the podcast that tells the extraordinary story of how immigrants, Jews, queers, African Americans, and other outcasts invented the Broadway musical and how they changed America in the process.

[0:55] David Armstrong: I'm David Armstrong, and I call this episode the Silver Age of Broadway Part 2.

[1:08] David Armstrong: As I'm sure you can imagine, the Great Depression had a tremendous effect on Broadway.

[1:13] David Armstrong: A number of leading Broadway producers, including Ziegfeld and the Schubert's corporate entity, went bankrupt when the stock market lost $14 billion on October 29th, 1929, and then another 26 billion over the following two weeks.

[1:29] David Armstrong: And the economic impact spread gradually to affect the entire country.

[1:33] David Armstrong: Eight million people were unemployed by the end of that year.

[1:36] David Armstrong: And by the end of 1932, when the entire banking system had virtually collapsed, one quarter of the American workforce was out of a job.

[1:44] David Armstrong: Although many politicians, along with the media of the day, ignored or played down what was happening, a handful of plays, novels, films, and even Broadway musicals reflected what was actually happening to the people of America.

[1:58] David Armstrong: Writer Stanley Green in his book Ring Bells Sing Songs, the Broadway musicals of the 1930s, says that even the musical theater, the most opulent, extravagant, and unabashedly commercial form of theater, could not hide from what was going on.

[2:12] David Armstrong: It could still offer evenings of mirth and hilarity, but it also showed a growing awareness of its own unique ability to make telling comments on such issues of the day as the folly of war, municipal corruption, political campaigns, the workings of the federal government, the rising labor movement, the dangers of both the far right and the far left, and the struggle between democracy and totalitarianism.

[2:36] David Armstrong: He goes on to say that the Broadway musical discovered that a song lyric, a tune, a wisecrack, a bit of comic business, a dance routine, could say things with even more effectiveness than many a serious-minded drama, simply because the appeal was to a far wider spectrum of the theater-going public.

[2:54] David Armstrong: They used to tell me I was building a dream.

[2:59] David Armstrong: And so I followed them all.

[3:04] David Armstrong: When there was earth to plough, our guns to bear I was always there, right on the job.

[3:13] David Armstrong: One example of this is the song Brother Can You Spare a Dime, which was written for a 1930 review called Americana.

[3:21] David Armstrong: Its haunting music was the creation of composer Jay Gorney.

[3:24] David Armstrong: He was born Abraham Jacob Gornski in 1896 in Bialystok, Russia, which is now part of Poland.

[3:31] David Armstrong: He and his parents fled a program there and emigrated to Detroit in 1906.

[3:36] David Armstrong: Gorney paid his way through the University of Michigan as well as their law school by working as a pianist.

[3:41] David Armstrong: His love of music eventually drew him to New York City, where between 1923 and 1950, he would contribute songs to 14 Broadway musicals, most of them reviews.

[3:52] David Armstrong: He said that he had based the tune of Brother Can You Spare a Dime on a lullaby that he had first heard as a child in Russia.

[3:59] David Armstrong: Once I built a railroad, I made it wrong.

[4:05] David Armstrong: Made it race against time.

[4:10] David Armstrong: Once I built a railroad, now it's done.

[4:21] David Armstrong: Once I built a tower.

[4:32] David Armstrong: Once I built a tower, now it's done.

[4:38] David Armstrong: Brother, can you spare a dime?

[4:41] David Armstrong: The song's powerful lyrics were by E. Y. Harburg, known as Yip Harburg, the lyricist of Over the Rainbow.

[4:48] David Armstrong: His parents were also Jewish immigrants from Russia.

[4:50] David Armstrong: Yip grew up on New York's Lower East Side and attended high school with Ira Gershwin.

[4:55] David Armstrong: They were both enthralled by the operettas of Gilbert and Sullivan, and they became lifelong friends.

[5:00] David Armstrong: Both attended city college, where Harburg graduated in 1921.

[5:04] David Armstrong: It was Gershwin who introduced Yip to Jay Gourney, and they began collaborating on songs mostly for Earl Carroll's reviews.

[5:12] David Armstrong: Harburg was a lifelong activist for progressive politics, and this would lead to him being blacklisted from working in film, television, and radio from 1950 to 1962.

[5:24] David Armstrong: Over his long career, he would write lyrics for 19 Broadway musicals during both the Silver and the Golden Age.

[5:30] David Armstrong: And during that time, he worked with several different composers.

[5:44] David Armstrong: In an interview in 1974, Gourney stated that when he was writing Brother Can You Spare a Dime, he didn't want a song that would depress people, but rather a song that would make people think.

[6:57] David Armstrong: Ah, gee, we look swell, full of that Yankee doodly.

[7:05] David Armstrong: Half a million boots went sloggin' through hell.

[7:10] David Armstrong: And I was the kid with a drum.

[7:15] David Armstrong: Say don't you remember?

[7:18] David Armstrong: They call me out.

[7:21] David Armstrong: It was I long the time.

[7:25] David Armstrong: Say don't you remember?

[7:28] David Armstrong: I'm your part.

[7:33] David Armstrong: Can you spare?

[7:40] David Armstrong: But as is evident from that song, somehow out of all that hardship and struggle came an extraordinary period of artistic achievement and continued development for the Broadway musical.

[7:51] David Armstrong: The creators of these new shows included several new and defining masters of the musical, as well as many of the bright lights of the previous decade who now achieved their full wattage in the 1930s.

[8:03] David Armstrong: Among these were Cole Porter, Dietz and Schwartz, Rogers and Hart, and the Gershwins, who kicked off the decade with the smash hit Girl Crazy.

[8:42] David Armstrong: But the biggest excitement came when a brassy young performer named Ethel Merman made her Broadway debut belting out this song.

[8:50] David Armstrong: I got rhythm, I got music, I got my man who's not for anything more.

[8:58] David Armstrong: I got Daisy in Green Pastures.

[9:02] David Armstrong: I got my man who could ask for anything more.

[9:06] David Armstrong: An old man trouble.

[9:08] David Armstrong: Say I don't mind him, but you won't find him round my door.

[9:14] David Armstrong: I got starlight.

[9:16] David Armstrong: I got sweet dream.

[9:18] David Armstrong: I got my man who could ask for anything more.

[9:24] David Armstrong: Oh who could ask for anything more?

[9:32] David Armstrong: Oh who can ask for anything more?

[9:40] David Armstrong: An old man trouble.

[9:42] David Armstrong: Say I don't mind him, for you won't find him hanging round my front of actor.

[9:48] David Armstrong: By all reports, Ethel Merman stopped the show cold and had to perform several encores.

[10:31] David Armstrong: This show introduced the mega hit Night and Day.

[10:34] David Armstrong: Night and Day.

[10:37] David Armstrong: You are the one.

[10:41] David Armstrong: Only you beneath the moon and under the sun.

[10:47] David Armstrong: Whether near to me or far.

[10:50] David Armstrong: It's no matter, darling, where you are or think of you.

[10:57] David Armstrong: Not a day.

[10:59] David Armstrong: But it wasn't all escape.

[11:01] David Armstrong: In addition to glamour and romance, audiences also clamored for Porter's satiric, ironic, irreverent, and sometimes cynical view of a world that seemed to be falling apart around them.

[11:12] David Armstrong: So political and social satire were also often part of the mix.

[11:16] David Armstrong: Porter's 1934 musical Anything Goes is one of the two or three musicals from this period that is still regularly revived on Broadway and is produced frequently in both professional and amateur productions.

[11:28] David Armstrong: I believe this show has remained in the repertoire not just because of its amazing hit-filled score, but also because of its book, which is more solidly constructed than most others of the period, and its characters are truly memorable.

[11:42] David Armstrong: I'm sure many of you have seen *Anything Goes* and enjoyed its madcap humor, but you may have been unaware that it was satirizing several topical issues, events, and personalities from the early 1930s.

[11:53] David Armstrong: The leading character Reno Sweeney was purposely designed as an ironic, improbable cross between the world-famous evangelist Amy Semple McPherson and the notorious nightclub hostess Texas Gynan.

[12:06] David Armstrong: She was the one who famously greeted her customers by shouting, "Hello, suckers."

[12:11] David Armstrong: Amy had recently visited Texas's nightclub to preach, and news of this had filled the gossip columns.

[12:17] David Armstrong: So the musical's authors made Reno Sweeney, a former evangelist, turn nightclub singer.

[12:22] David Armstrong: There's a good lesson for you, sinners. Search your hearts, sign off with Satan, and tune in with heaven.

[12:28] David Armstrong: Where will you stand on the day of glory? Do you hear that playing?

[12:36] David Armstrong: Do you know who's playing?

[12:36] David Armstrong: No, who is that playing?

[12:38] David Armstrong: Well, it's Gabriel Gabriel playing.

[12:43] David Armstrong: Gabriel Gabriel saying, "Will you be ready to go when I blow my hole?"

[12:52] David Armstrong: *Anything Goes* also spoofed the celebrity worship of gangsters during the era.

[12:57] David Armstrong: Earlier that year, public enemy number one John Dillinger had gone on a violent crime spree, robbing banks and killing 10 men, and had then been arrested.

[13:05] David Armstrong: In the musical, when leading man Billy Crocker is mistaken for gangster Snake Eyes Johnson, he is fawned over by the passengers of the ocean liner, not so subtly named the SS American, and they are thrilled to discover that finally there is a real celebrity on board.

[13:42] David Armstrong: Writer Scott Miller describes the show as a rowdy, naughty, subversive masterpiece of musical comedy and goes on to assert that *Anything Goes* is a stinging satire of Americans' quirky habit of turning religion into show business and criminals into celebrities.

[13:59] David Armstrong: *Anything Goes* was the brainstorm of producer Vinton Friedley, who had been financially devastated by the stock market crash.

[14:06] David Armstrong: To escape his creditors, he gave up his New York residence and was living aboard a fishing boat in the Pacific.

[14:11] David Armstrong: That's where he got the idea for the setting for his next musical, which he originally called *Hard to Get*.

[14:17] David Armstrong: It would take place aboard an ocean liner. The passengers would be a madcap collection of sailors, society figures, gangsters, missionaries, and nightclub performers.

[14:26] David Armstrong: Despite his shaky finances, Friedley managed to sign three of the biggest stars of the day, William Gaxton, Ethel Merman, and Victor Moore.

[14:34] David Armstrong: And *Hard to Get* would have a score by the hottest songwriter of the time, Cole Porter.

[14:39] David Armstrong: In the 1930s, musicals were written quickly, from concept to creation to opening night could be just a matter of two or three months, sometimes less.

[14:47] David Armstrong: The songwriters often worked from just a brief, rough outline of the plot, and they often wrote songs that would later have to be shoehorned into the story.

[14:55] David Armstrong: What really mattered in those days were the songs, the stars, and the laughs.

[14:59] David Armstrong: To write the book, Friedley turned to a couple of seasoned pros, Guy Bolton and the comic novelist P. G. Woodhouse.

[15:05] David Armstrong: The two men submitted their script and then went home, Woodhouse to France and Bolton to England.

[15:10] David Armstrong: They figured that any minor adjustments could be taken care of by the director, the producer, and the stars.

[15:16] David Armstrong: There's a famous story about *Anything Goes* that's been told and retold in dozens of books over the years.

[15:22] David Armstrong: It says the plot of the show revolved around a shipwreck, which led to all sorts of farcical scurrying around, pushing to get into lifeboats, men disguised as women, and so forth.

[15:31] David Armstrong: Sort of a slapstick version of *Titanic*.

[15:34] David Armstrong: But about a month before the rehearsals were to start, a real cruise ship, the SS Morrow Castle, was returning from a seven-day cruise to Havana, and as it passed the beach at Asbury Park, New Jersey, it suddenly burst into flames.

[15:47] David Armstrong: Hundreds of beachgoers watched in horror as the ship was swept by fire and quickly sank with a loss of more than 125 people.

[15:56] David Armstrong: It was by far the worst maritime disaster of the 1930s, and it was clear to all involved that the Woodhouse Bolton book could not be used.

[16:04] David Armstrong: And since the show's original authors were no longer available for rewrites, Friedley asked the show's director, Howard Lindsay, to take over the bookwriting duties.

[16:13] David Armstrong: Lindsay said that he would need a partner to get it done in time.

[16:16] David Armstrong: Rehearsals were only a month and a half away, and eventually Russell Krauss, a press agent for the Theater Guild with very little playwriting experience, was hired.

[16:25] David Armstrong: There's just one problem with the story.

[16:27] David Armstrong: It isn't true.

[16:29] David Armstrong: Researchers have uncovered the original script, and guess what? There's no shipwreck.

[16:32] David Armstrong: There never was.

[16:34] David Armstrong: The truth confirmed by letters and telegrams is that the Woodhouse book was unfocused and unfunny, and even by 1930s standards, made no sense.

[16:44] David Armstrong: That whole "we can't have a shipwreck in the show" story was apparently made up by Friedley to explain the sudden change of authors and to give Woodhouse and Bolton a face-saving exit from the production.

[16:55] David Armstrong: The new authors, Lindsay and Krauss, would go on to become one of Broadway's top writing teams with a 30-year career that included straight dramas like *Life with Father* and *Arsenic and Old Lace*, and musicals such as *Call Me Madam* and *The Sound of Music*.

[17:10] David Armstrong: Working around the clock, they quickly rewrote *Hard to Get*, throwing out most of the previous book, keeping just a few of the characters, and of course the ocean liner setting.

[17:19] David Armstrong: Less than six weeks after throwing out the script, Friedley called the cast to rehearsals for the new show, still called *Hard to Get*.

[17:26] David Armstrong: He was hoping for a new title as well, and the creative team was racking their brains trying to come up with one.

[17:32] David Armstrong: Finally, one day, leading man William Gaxton blurted out, "Well, in a show like this, anything goes."

[17:38] David Armstrong: And Cole Porter, knowing a money title when he heard one, rushed home to compose the title song.

[17:43] David Armstrong: The next morning he came in with the catchy melody and brilliant lyrics that we know and love today.

[18:07] David Armstrong: Any shock they would try to stem. Instead of landing on Plymouth Rock, Glamour the Rock would land on them.

[18:21] David Armstrong: In olden days, a glimpse of stocking was a look down or something shocking, but now God knows.

[18:29] David Armstrong: *Anything Goes*.

[18:32] David Armstrong: Good authors, too, who once knew better words, now only use more letter words, writing prose.

[18:40] David Armstrong: *Anything Goes*.

[18:42] David Armstrong: *Anything Goes* opened on November 21st, 1934, and was an immediate resounding success.

[18:48] David Armstrong: Its score was loaded with hit tunes that monopolized the radio and dance band repertoire for months afterwards.

[18:54] David Armstrong: So though I'm not a great romancer, I know that you're bound to answer what I propose.

[19:01] David Armstrong: *Anything Goes*.

[19:17] David Armstrong: Today the script, which has had some revisions over the years, still turns out laughs like clockwork, and the music and lyrics still amuse, thrill, and delight us.

[19:26] David Armstrong: They think he's gangster number one, so they've made him the favorite song, and that goes to show.

[19:34] David Armstrong: *Anything Goes*.

[19:37] David Armstrong: *Anything*, *anything*, *anything*, *go*.

[19:52] David Armstrong: *Strike Up the Band*, *Of The I Sing*, and *Let Them Eat Cake*.

[19:56] David Armstrong: All of them with books by George S. Kaufman and Maury Risken, both the sons of Jewish immigrants.

[20:03] David Armstrong: The most popular of these shows was *Of The I Sing*, which tells the story of presidential candidate John P. Wintergreen and the backroom political machinations and publicity stunts that get him elected president.

[20:18] David Armstrong: Winter Creep for President.

[20:52] David Armstrong: Became the first musical to win the Pulitzer Prize for Drama.

[20:59] David Armstrong: This clearly established the musical as an art form to be taken seriously.

[21:10] David Armstrong: The 1930s was also the heyday of the sophisticated musical review.

[21:15] David Armstrong: This version of the review was more focused and streamlined than in the Ziegfeld era, and the great Jewish American songwriting team of Howard Dietz and Arthur Schwartz were the masters of this form.

[21:36] David Armstrong: They often used a theme like a trip around the world to unify the review's songs, dances, and comedy sketches.

[21:43] David Armstrong: And they strived to be extremely current and topical.

[21:46] David Armstrong: Their string of hit reviews included *Three's a Crowd*, *The Bandwagon*, *Flying Colors*, and *At Home Abroad*, all filled with big stars and hit songs.

[21:56] David Armstrong: *Dancing in the dark*, till the tune ends we're dancing in the dark.

[22:06] David Armstrong: And it soon ends we're waltzing the wonders of why we're time carries by we're here.

[22:25] David Armstrong: Looking for the line.

[22:54] David Armstrong: It used a newspaper format as its unifying concept, and this was the brainchild of Moss Hart and Irving Berlin.

[23:01] David Armstrong: Throughout the show, news headlines would be projected on a screen above the stage, and songs and comedy sketches would then bring those headlines to life.

[23:09] David Armstrong: Irving Berlin had an incredible ability to stay hip and relevant throughout the many decades of his Broadway career.

[23:16] David Armstrong: *As Thousands Cheer* began with *Front Page News*, a comedy sketch about the inauguration of President Roosevelt, and then moved through the *Weather Report*, the song "We're Having a Heat Wave," and the *Funny Pages*, brought to life in a ballet in which all the comic strip characters of the day cavorted with dancing superstar Marilyn Miller.

[23:36] David Armstrong: The first act finale brought to life the illustrated society pages of the newspaper, in which fashionable New Yorkers strolled down Fifth Avenue and introduced the new song Easter Parade.

[24:02] David Armstrong: You are listening to one of the era's biggest stars, actor, singer, dancer Clifton Webb, who headlined as Thousands Cheer as well as 22 other Broadway musical comedies, plays, and reviews.

[24:29] David Armstrong: He was openly gay, not with the general public, of course, but definitely within the professional worlds of Broadway and Hollywood.

[24:36] David Armstrong: The girl I'm taking police the parade.

[24:49] David Armstrong: But then, following a comedy sequence that opened Act Two, a headline appeared reading, Unknown Negro lynched by frenzied mob.

[25:01] David Armstrong: Then below, out of the darkness, Ethel Waters appeared dressed as a poor sharecropper's wife, trying to set the table for dinner.

[25:28] David Armstrong: Some how I will cause dead men of mine coming home no more.

[25:44] David Armstrong: Ethel Waters was the star of nine Broadway musicals.

[26:12] David Armstrong: Irving Berlin wrote this song especially for her.

[26:24] David Armstrong: He was responding to the fact that in 1933, 28 black Americans were lynched in 11 different states.

[26:51] David Armstrong: I'm a set the table because it's about time.

[27:47] David Armstrong: What was most important with the review was the order of the songs and sketches, and these shows creators would go to great lengths to make sure they were programmed for maximum impact.

[27:57] David Armstrong: Rogers and Hart would create ten Broadway musicals during the 1930s, including Jumbo, On Your Toes, Babes in Arms, The Boys from Syracuse, and I'd Rather Be Right, whose central character was Franklin Delano Roosevelt himself, played by George M. Cohan.

[28:13] David Armstrong: But the peak of their partnership came in 1940 with the musical PAL JOEY, and this was a major step forward in the transformation of the loosely assembled musical comedies of the Silver Age into the unified structure that would soon revolutionize the musical.

[28:28] David Armstrong: That show's director and bookwriter was George Abbott.

[28:31] David Armstrong: George Abbott, known as Mr. Abbott, is another of the major exceptions to the central premise of this podcast.

[28:38] David Armstrong: He was a straight, white Anglo-Saxon Protestant male, and yet he was also one of the single most important figures in the entire history of the Broadway musical.

[28:47] David Armstrong: He most certainly had the longest theatrical career of the 20th century.

[28:51] David Armstrong: In the course of his long life, and he lived to be 107 years old, George Abbott was involved as a director, writer, or producer, and sometimes all three of those in more than 120 Broadway productions.

[29:05] David Armstrong: Gilbert Millstein of the New York Times once wrote that on the basis of sheer frightening volume alone, an argument can be drummed up that no living individual or possibly even dead has contributed more to the Broadway theater than George Abbott.

[29:19] David Armstrong: That was written in 1954 when Mr. Abbott had been working for only 40 years and still had 50 years of work ahead of him.

[29:27] David Armstrong: Most of Abbott's shows were plays.

[29:29] David Armstrong: He didn't tackle his first musical until 1935, when he co-directed Rogers and Hart's circus extravaganza Jumbo.

[29:37] David Armstrong: And over the next 27 years, he staged 26 musicals.

[29:42] David Armstrong: 22 of them were major hits.

[29:44] David Armstrong: He wrote and directed the musicals as if they were plays, with respect for their plots and characters.

[29:50] David Armstrong: And he directed the plays like they were musicals, with fast pacing and at breakneck speed.

[29:55] David Armstrong: During the 1930s, even his closest friends and colleagues stopped using his first name, George, and began to call him Mr. Abbott.

[30:02] David Armstrong: He had gained that level of reverence and respect.

[30:06] David Armstrong: And there was much talk about the Abbott touch.

[30:09] David Armstrong: Like the Midas touch, it was thought that George Abbott could touch a production and turn it to gold.

[30:14] David Armstrong: When he was asked to explain the Abbott Touch, he would respond by saying, I just make them say their final syllables.

[30:21] David Armstrong: But there was much more to it than that.

[30:23] David Armstrong: Often characterized as louder, faster, funnier, the Abbott Touch, according to the master himself, most accurately involved timing.

[30:31] David Armstrong: It's keeping the show interesting, he said.

[30:34] David Armstrong: And he added that sometimes if you fix the writing, you fix the directing.

[30:38] David Armstrong: I've seen so many plays bore the audience because the story is muddy.

[30:42] David Armstrong: He also told his actors to always approach comedy situations very seriously.

[30:47] David Armstrong: He said, if you play comedy for laughs, it won't work.

[30:50] David Armstrong: If you play it for real, it will be very funny.

[30:59] David Armstrong: PAL JOEY would become one of the pinnacle achievements of the Silver Age.

[31:03] David Armstrong: Written and directed by George Abbott, with music and lyrics by Rogers and Hart and choreography by Robert Alton.

[31:32] David Armstrong: The show's antihero and cynical provocative storyline brought a darkness and a toughness to the Broadway musical that had never been seen before.

[31:41] David Armstrong: And it was also wildly entertaining with a hit-filled score and thrilling star-making performances by Gene Kelly, Vivian Siegel, and June Havoc.

[31:51] David Armstrong: If they asked me I could write a book about the way you walk and whisper and look.

[32:09] David Armstrong: Although Rogers and Hart would follow PAL JOEY with two more hit musicals, by the early 1940s, Larry Hart was disappearing for days at a time, his drunken binges more and more disturbing.

[32:21] David Armstrong: And then when the team received an offer from the Theater Guild to work on turning the play Greengrow the Lilacs into a musical, Rogers told Hart, I want you to have yourself admitted to a sanitarium, and I'll get myself admitted too.

[32:34] David Armstrong: We'll be there together and work together.

[32:36] David Armstrong: But you've got to get off the street.

[32:38] David Armstrong: Larry made it clear that this was not going to happen.

[32:41] David Armstrong: There was no way he was checking himself into a sanitarium.

[32:44] David Armstrong: He was on his way to Mexico.

[32:46] David Armstrong: Rogers gave him an ultimatum.

[32:48] David Armstrong: Larry, if you walk out now, someone else will do the show with me.

[32:52] David Armstrong: Anyone in mind?

[32:53] David Armstrong: Hart asked.

[32:54] David Armstrong: Rogers replied that Oscar Hammerstein would write the lyrics.

[32:58] David Armstrong: There's no man better for the job, Hart said.

[33:00] David Armstrong: I don't know how you've put up with me all these years.

[33:03] David Armstrong: The best thing would be for you to forget about me.

[33:06] David Armstrong: He walked out of the meeting, leaving Richard Rogers and the show that would become Oklahoma behind.

[33:11] David Armstrong: Larry Hart would attend the opening of that game-changing musical, and he would hug Rogers and tell him that it was the best show he'd ever seen.

[33:19] David Armstrong: But not long after that, he would die of pneumonia after losing his coat during an all-night bender on the streets of New York.

[33:26] David Armstrong: But I think he was too smart not to have seen the writing on the wall.

[33:30] David Armstrong: After all, he had in no small way helped to usher in this sea change that was just about to arrive.

[33:36] David Armstrong: The loose, sometimes ramshackle, but wildly funny, tuneful and entertaining Rogers and Hart style musicals of the Silver Age would soon almost be entirely replaced by the story-driven, character-rich, perfectly crafted, and cohesive musical plays of Rogers and Hammerstein that would usher in the golden age of the Broadway music.

[34:09] David Armstrong: Now here's the information about how you too can become a patron of Broadway Nation.

[34:15] David Armstrong: A donation of just $7 a month will not only keep Broadway Nation rolling along, it will also provide you with exclusive access to the complete unedited versions of many of the interviews that you hear on this podcast.

[34:29] David Armstrong: And all patrons will receive special shout outs and acknowledgments of your vital support for Broadway Nation.

[34:35] David Armstrong: To join, simply go to Broadway Nation Podcast dot supercast.tech.

[34:41] David Armstrong: That's Broadway Nation Podcast dot S-U-P-R-C-A-S-T dot tech.

[34:47] David Armstrong: Or click the link in the show notes to this episode.

[34:51] David Armstrong: Broadway Nation is written and produced by me, David Armstrong.

[34:55] David Armstrong: Special thanks to Pal'Mox for his help with editing this episode and to the entire team at the Broadway Podcast Network.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred