Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Broadwaysted Presents "One Shot of Holiday Cheer" Part Two

The thrilling holiday murder mystery concludes in Part Two of Broadwaysted's madcap new holiday radio play One Shot of Holiday Cheer by Kevin Jaeger. Detective Holly Day is making her list of suspects in the murder of Candy Cane and Nathan Slane--and she's definitely checking that' list twice... Read More

From the show: Broadwaysted!

49 mins
12/20/22

Guests

About

The thrilling holiday murder mystery concludes in Part Two of Broadwaysted's madcap new holiday radio play One Shot of Holiday Cheer by Kevin Jaeger. Detective Holly Day is making her list of suspects in the murder of Candy Cane and Nathan Slane--and she's definitely checking that' list twice. With the gifts Candy left as clues, Holly has to deduce the murderer and the inheritor--before all of their worlds are jingle bell rocked.

Cast: Aaron J. Albano, Kevin Jaeger, Adam Lash, Amanda Nicholas, Fergie L. Philippe, Bryan Plofsky, Robbie Rozelle, Celeste Sayles, Jay Schmidt, and Kimberly Schmidt.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:04] Kevin Jaeger: Did you bring wine?

[0:05] Bryan Plofsky: I got the glasses.

[0:07] Kimberly Schmidt: You guys, I made a quiz.

[0:08] Adam Lash: I didn't bring anything, but I'm here to have fun.

[0:28] Bryan Plofsky: Hello!

[0:30] Bryan Plofsky: And welcome back to Broadwaysted's Sixth Annual Holiday Radio Play.

[0:35] Bryan Plofsky: I'm Bryan Plofsky, and happy holidays, everyone.

[0:39] Kevin Jaeger: We're so excited to—

[0:40] Kimberly Schmidt: Bryan, no!

[0:43] Kevin Jaeger: What are you doing?

[0:44] Bryan Plofsky: You're starting off wrong again.

[0:46] Kevin Jaeger: What?

[0:47] Bryan Plofsky: No, you wanted me to lean more into the holiday cheer of it all.

[0:50] Kevin Jaeger: Help me out.

[0:51] Kimberly Schmidt: I'm just reading what you wrote.

[0:52] Bryan Plofsky: Sorry, Bri.

[0:54] Kevin Jaeger: I gotta side with K Dog on this one.

[0:56] Bryan Plofsky: Nope.

[0:57] Kevin Jaeger: You're butchering my writing, dude.

[0:59] Bryan Plofsky: Like Sweeney Toddied it.

[1:01] Kevin Jaeger: Really just slaughtered.

[1:03] Bryan Plofsky: We are leaning into the spookiness of the murder mystery experience.

[1:07] Kimberly Schmidt: Wait, we are?

[1:08] Bryan Plofsky: Why?

[1:09] Kevin Jaeger: Because don't you remember what happened in part one, Bryan?

[1:12] Bryan Plofsky: No!

[1:13] Kevin Jaeger: Candy Kane, the world-famous Broadway actress who mysteriously disappeared from the spotlight for almost a decade, had invited a group of the Who's Who of Broadway for a lavish holiday party at her isolated mansion in upstate New York. That reminds me.

[1:28] Kimberly Schmidt: We really gotta take Kevin upstage so we realize it's not so exotic and as crazy as he makes it out to be.

[1:35] Kevin Jaeger: I'm sorry, where are you speaking of?

[1:37] Bryan Plofsky: I'm so I'm so sorry. I was talking about upstate New York!

[1:42] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, oh, oh right.

[1:44] Kimberly Schmidt: Spooky.

[1:46] Bryan Plofsky: Upstate New York.

[1:48] Kevin Jaeger: Even better.

[1:49] Bryan Plofsky: Okay.

[1:51] Bryan Plofsky: Okay, don't you guys remember what happened in the story?

[1:54] Kimberly Schmidt: Of course.

[1:55] Kevin Jaeger: Candy presented everyone at the party with the ultimate possible holiday gift.

[1:59] Bryan Plofsky: The chance to inherit Candy's billions.

[2:02] Kevin Jaeger: But before she could present them with the series of presents, they were supposed to use as clues to narrow it down for who was supposed to be chosen to inherit.

[2:19] Bryan Plofsky: Candy was murdered by poison.

[2:21] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah.

[2:22] Kevin Jaeger: And in the ensuing chaos that followed, the discovery of her murder, venomous theater critic Nathan Slain asked one too many questions about the plot points driving the tension in the narrative.

[2:33] Bryan Plofsky: And he was also killed by the murderer during a sudden blackout.

[2:38] Kevin Jaeger: Luckily for everyone, Detective Holly Day is on the case to figure out the clues from the mysterious presents and use them to hopefully decipher the identity of the heritor and the identity of the murderer.

[2:50] Kimberly Schmidt: And with the house on lockdown, meaning no one can leave, and with the impending danger that they'll all be dead if the case isn't solved by morning, Holly Day sure has her work cut out for her.

[3:00] Adam Lash: I'm still a bit unclear on the details of that.

[3:03] Bryan Plofsky: So the house is going to murder them if they don't figure out who killed Candy and Nathan.

[3:09] Kevin Jaeger: Is that Bryan?

[3:11] Bryan Plofsky: Don't question it.

[3:12] Kevin Jaeger: Writer Kevin wrote for Actor Kevin playing Nathan Slain to question it, just so that writer Kevin can murder actor Kevin's character to prove a point about questioning flimsy plot points that drive the narrative.

[3:24] Kimberly Schmidt: Don't think that writer Kevin won't come for you to say that.

[3:28] Kevin Jaeger: Oh yeah.

[3:29] Kimberly Schmidt: And one more thing we should mention again. Say hi, everyone.

[3:32] Cast: Hi!

[3:33] Cast: Hi!

[3:34] Cast: Totally.

[3:34] Kimberly Schmidt: They won't let us leave.

[3:36] Bryan Plofsky: This year, for the very first time, the entire cast is recording the radio play together, live in my house!

[3:42] Kevin Jaeger: To take—

[3:43] Bryan Plofsky: Alright, I think that catches us all up. Let's dive back in, shall we?

[3:45] Kevin Jaeger: Here goes everyone ready.

[3:49] Cast: Yes!

[3:50] Cast: I think so.

[3:52] Bryan Plofsky: And away we—

[4:20] Adam Lash: Well, I must say, I have been to a party where two people were murdered, and we piled their bodies on the couches, but this is a first for me.

[4:29] Kimberly Schmidt: I'm sorry, what is your name?

[4:31] Fergie L. Philippe: I'm Gil.

[4:32] Fergie L. Philippe: Tea Party.

[4:33] Kimberly Schmidt: Oh, well, I guess my job is done. Case closed.

[4:35] Adam Lash: Or how do you know he did it?

[4:39] Fergie L. Philippe: I didn't do it.

[4:40] Adam Lash: Oh no, I was just kidding.

[4:42] Fergie L. Philippe: Because it's because of his name, though. Like Gil Tea Party. You all get it.

[4:47] Kimberly Schmidt: I don't get it.

[4:48] Fergie L. Philippe: I'm just trying to add a little levity into the situation. It's pretty dark.

[4:52] Adam Lash: No.

[4:53] Fergie L. Philippe: Don't get it.

[4:54] Fergie L. Philippe: People die.

[4:55] Kimberly Schmidt: Okay, oh never mind. You know what? Uh let's just start with the facts, okay?

[4:59] Fergie L. Philippe: So we have two dead bodies.

[5:02] Fergie L. Philippe: The first is Candy Kane, the mysterious woman, who was just about to announce one of you as the sole inheritor of her fortune.

[5:08] Fergie L. Philippe: The second is Nathan Slain, vile theater critic who controlled Who Sank Who Storeswam.

[5:14] Fergie L. Philippe: They did both things in this town with a keystroke of his laptop.

[5:18] Fergie L. Philippe: I can clearly deduce that these people were both murdered by the same person.

[5:24] Kimberly Schmidt: Wow.

[5:24] Kimberly Schmidt: Fascinating.

[5:25] Adam Lash: How did you figure that out?

[5:26] Fergie L. Philippe: Because I'm a brilliant detective, and we've established this to the audience, so now major factual statements I make are accepted freely as factual.

[5:34] Kimberly Schmidt: Oh, for sure.

[5:35] Kimberly Schmidt: Of course it does.

[5:39] Fergie L. Philippe: Just to be clear.

[5:41] Fergie L. Philippe: I did not do it.

[5:42] Cast: I didn't do it.

[5:42] Cast: I didn't do it.

[5:43] Fergie L. Philippe: So one of us killed both Candy and Nathan.

[5:48] Kimberly Schmidt: Wow. That's a lot to unpack.

[5:50] Fergie L. Philippe: I know. I can't believe someone in this room was able to murder not once, but twice.

[5:56] Kimberly Schmidt: No, I meant Yule Tide's bags over there in the corner.

[5:59] Fergie L. Philippe: I didn't mean— Sorry, I keep doing that.

[6:01] Kimberly Schmidt: I know. I'm really just interested in luggage and the amount of unpacking involved.

[6:05] Fergie L. Philippe: I do love luggage, yes.

[6:07] Kimberly Schmidt: Why the fascination with the luggage, Sue?

[6:10] Fergie L. Philippe: Something from your mysterious past perhaps.

[6:14] Kimberly Schmidt: Oh, oh, I'm starting to feel faint again.

[6:18] Fergie L. Philippe: Uh, no need, Miss Dunham. We've all seen that you can perform a convincing feint.

[6:23] Fergie L. Philippe: You executed a near perfect moments before Candy was murdered, I believe.

[6:27] Fergie L. Philippe: It was that distraction that gave the killer time to poison Candy's drink.

[6:32] Kimberly Schmidt: But I would never—

[6:33] Fergie L. Philippe: I think we must all feel a little faint after this excitement, though. Perhaps it would be best if everyone retires to their guest rooms for an hour or so.

[6:42] Fergie L. Philippe: We'll meet back here.

[6:44] Kimberly Schmidt: Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. I don't know if I feel safe with a murderer on the loose.

[6:49] Kimberly Schmidt: That seems a bit dangerous for all of us to split up right now.

[6:53] Fergie L. Philippe: Like we're inviting someone else to die.

[6:56] Kimberly Schmidt: Well, that sounds like something the murderer was saying.

[7:01] Fergie L. Philippe: Phil to throw everyone off their track.

[7:03] Kimberly Schmidt: Oh yeah? Well, that sounds like something the murderer would say.

[7:08] Fergie L. Philippe: Generally.

[7:10] Fergie L. Philippe: As a way to throw everyone.

[7:14] Kimberly Schmidt: Thank you.

[7:19] Fergie L. Philippe: Generally, as a way to throw everyone off their track by accusing someone of throwing everyone off of their track.

[7:29] Kimberly Schmidt: Oh yeah? Well, that sounds like something the murderer would say, Carol Singers, as a way to throw people off their track by accusing someone of accusing someone of throwing people off their track as a means of throwing people off their track.

[7:43] Kevin Jaeger: Wait, Kevin, weren't you Nathan Slain? Aren't you dead?

[7:46] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah. I know. Just continue.

[7:50] Fergie L. Philippe: Okay, everyone to their own rooms, and we'll be back here in an hour.

[7:53] Cast: Okay, thank you. Bye-bye.

[7:57] Kimberly Schmidt: I do not have that.

[7:59] Fergie L. Philippe: Do you have a rolling suitcase?

[8:02] Fergie L. Philippe: So many stairs in this mansion.

[8:04] Fergie L. Philippe: Detective Holly Day. I speak to you.

[8:06] Fergie L. Philippe: Of course, Butler did it. I deduced that you needed to speak with me in private.

[8:11] Fergie L. Philippe: And so I sent everyone away to their room so that I could speak with you in private.

[8:15] Fergie L. Philippe: Well, I sent them to their room so I could test a few early theories and to speak to you in private.

[8:20] Fergie L. Philippe: And well, in you and your accomplice.

[8:24] Fergie L. Philippe: So you figured it out.

[8:25] Fergie L. Philippe: Of course I did. I'm Holly Day, famous detective.

[8:28] Fergie L. Philippe: World famous?

[8:30] Fergie L. Philippe: I am huge in Germany. You wouldn't know it from my accent, but I'm very popular over there.

[8:35] Fergie L. Philippe: Huge! It's like Hasselhoff and me. Seriously, you walk down the streets and see billboards there, it's like Hasselhoff, Hasselhoff, walk a bit, see some trees, Hasselhoff, me, Hasselhoff, Hasselhoff, and then maybe another me, but it's like crazy.

[8:49] Fergie L. Philippe: I still figured it out.

[8:53] Fergie L. Philippe: I am Candy Kane's trusted confidant and best friend, and clearly not a suspect.

[8:59] Fergie L. Philippe: Well, yes, of course. You and your accomplice. There was no way either of you were the murderers. Isn't that right?

[9:05] Fergie L. Philippe: Chris, Miss Cookies and Milk.

[9:09] Fergie L. Philippe: Hmm.

[9:10] Fergie L. Philippe: Wow, you are really good, Detective. How did you decipher that?

[9:16] Fergie L. Philippe: It was two things. Okay, the first was the way that you were so fierce. And the second was that this po— this is the point in the story when a writer realizes there are too many suspects in the mist, and he needs to narrow that list down very, very quickly.

[9:35] Fergie L. Philippe: Well, Candy Kane was right. Your genius is truly unparalleled, and therefore we should accept everything you say as fact.

[9:42] Fergie L. Philippe: It's true.

[9:43] Fergie L. Philippe: Mmm.

[9:44] Fergie L. Philippe: Butler and I are, well, uh, were Candy Kane's closest and truest friends, yeah. We would never murder her.

[9:55] Fergie L. Philippe: I might have wanted to murder that critic guy Wolf. He seemed like a jerk for questioning the legitimacy of the narrative again.

[10:04] Fergie L. Philippe: Understandable. I'm not even that drunk yet.

[10:11] Fergie L. Philippe: Understandable, truly a grave offense, let me tell you.

[10:15] Fergie L. Philippe: Oh, well, we helped us set up the presents for the game, the clues about who was not inheriting and why, and uh, we don't know who it really is inheriting, but uh, we have the presents here for you.

[10:26] Fergie L. Philippe: But there's something we gotta tell you.

[10:28] Fergie L. Philippe: Whoa!

[10:29] Fergie L. Philippe: Two of the presents are already open.

[10:32] Fergie L. Philippe: Oh my god.

[10:33] Fergie L. Philippe: Wait, what?

[10:34] Fergie L. Philippe: Yes! Well, the first after Jordan Rapture, so I knew it immediately when I saw it on a draw next to Nathan Slain's body.

[10:40] Fergie L. Philippe: Everyone was in such a shock you know, no one and then no one saw it.

[10:44] Fergie L. Philippe: The broken laptop.

[10:47] Fergie L. Philippe: Yes! Yes!

[10:48] Fergie L. Philippe: I had deduced that the laptop was the murder weapon used to kill Nathan Slain, and that it must contain some evidence that Nathan Slain wouldn't want out in the world.

[10:59] Fergie L. Philippe: Oh, that what was meant to be a present that singled out Nathan is not inheriting because he has used to write two versions of every review. One good and one terrible.

[11:09] Fergie L. Philippe: And he released a bad one unless the producers grease his pockets, you know, to put some coin in there, you know.

[11:15] Fergie L. Philippe: I can't even knew he was crooked, and that's why she painted ran perfect reviews for another time.

[11:20] Fergie L. Philippe: And she was going to expose him.

[11:23] Fergie L. Philippe: Okay, so someone opened the laptop and knew that it belonged to Nathan somehow.

[11:29] Fergie L. Philippe: Uh, it did have a sticker on the side that said property of Nathan Slain.

[11:32] Fergie L. Philippe: Oh, really?

[11:33] Fergie L. Philippe: Uh yeah. Uh yeah. Candy had it meant, uh yeah.

[11:37] Fergie L. Philippe: Uh yeah. Yeah.

[11:40] Fergie L. Philippe: Yeah, it was a— it's a good yeah.

[11:48] Fergie L. Philippe: Candy had it had meant, uh there's one to be used for uh one of the easier clues.

[11:54] Fergie L. Philippe: I think there's a typo, I don't think that's my fault. She was afraid that they were too complicated, that everyone would just kind of get all get frustrated and give up on the game, you know.

[12:04] Fergie L. Philippe: She wanted people to have fun. You know, it's the holidays and all.

[12:07] Kimberly Schmidt: Of course, that makes a lot of sense.

[12:09] Fergie L. Philippe: Okay, so someone opened the laptop and knew it was Nathan's because it was clearly labeled as such.

[12:14] Kevin Jaeger: But um, then you said there were two presents opened?

[12:17] Bryan Plofsky: Oh, what was the second one?

[12:19] Kevin Jaeger: So here's the thing.

[12:21] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah.

[12:21] Kevin Jaeger: We don't know.

[12:23] Bryan Plofsky: Whatever it was, they took it with them.

[12:25] Kevin Jaeger: Mmm, it's gone.

[12:27] Kevin Jaeger: And we can't figure out what the missing object is until we open the other boxes.

[12:33] Bryan Plofsky: Interesting.

[12:34] Kevin Jaeger: Okay, well, we must assume that the missing item is the gift that was meant for the killer.

[12:40] Bryan Plofsky: That is a brilliant deductive detective.

[12:42] Kevin Jaeger: Thank you.

[12:42] Kevin Jaeger: I introduced it myself.

[12:44] Kevin Jaeger: Okay. Now let's chat about my plan while listeners peek in at a few choice conversations happening in the guest rooms.

[12:59] Kimberly Schmidt: Meanwhile, in one of the guest rooms, listen.

[13:04] Unknown speaker: I think we need to just tell every just tell everyone we're together.

[13:09] Unknown speaker: No one will care, and it will finally be out in the open.

[13:13] Unknown speaker: The big secret that Candy knew.

[13:15] Unknown speaker: Let's just get in front of the reindeer here before we get run over by the.

[13:19] Unknown speaker: Don't you agree?

[13:20] Unknown speaker: We should just tell the truth.

[13:22] Unknown speaker: Right?

[13:22] Unknown speaker: Why aren't you answering me?

[13:24] Unknown speaker: You came to my room instead of going to your room so we could talk.

[13:29] Unknown speaker: Anyone could have seen you coming in here with me.

[13:31] Unknown speaker: So why won't you talk?

[13:35] Unknown speaker: Huh?

[13:37] Unknown speaker: Say something.

[13:38] Unknown speaker: Oh, please, are you just not saying something so that if this conversation were heard in a strictly audio-based medium, they wouldn't know who I was talking to?

[13:47] Unknown speaker: So it adds a level of mystery to this heated discussion between two people in love when you don't know who the second person is.

[13:54] Unknown speaker: I'm in love with you, but no one knows who you are.

[13:58] Unknown speaker: And in another room that is meant for only one guest.

[14:01] Unknown speaker: It's going to be fine, Gil.

[14:05] Unknown speaker: I am not so sure, Phil.

[14:07] Unknown speaker: I don't think we should have done it.

[14:09] Unknown speaker: I mean, that was so extreme.

[14:11] Unknown speaker: Sometimes extreme measures.

[14:13] Unknown speaker: I needed to stay on top, Gil.

[14:16] Unknown speaker: Don't you want to stay on the top?

[14:19] Unknown speaker: I brought you all the this way up with me.

[14:24] Unknown speaker: You heard me right.

[14:26] Unknown speaker: I brought you all the way this way up again.

[14:29] Unknown speaker: Would hate to have you throw you.

[14:32] Unknown speaker: Would hate to have you.

[14:33] Unknown speaker: Oh god, I gotta put my reading glasses on.

[14:37] Unknown speaker: Listen, Gil, I brought you all the way up with me.

[14:40] Unknown speaker: Would hate to have to throw you all the way down to the ground, but I'll do it if I have to.

[14:47] Unknown speaker: No, Phil, you know I appreciate that you brought me this all the way up.

[14:55] Unknown speaker: And I don't, I would hate for you to toss me to the ground down again.

[15:00] Unknown speaker: Well, take what we did to our grave.

[15:02] Unknown speaker: And so will Candy.

[15:17] Unknown speaker: This has been one hour, everyone.

[15:19] Unknown speaker: Please return to the ballroom.

[15:21] Unknown speaker: Thank you.

[15:22] Unknown speaker: Has it really been an hour?

[15:24] Unknown speaker: Oh my god, I don't know.

[15:26] Unknown speaker: That clock just struck nine.

[15:28] Unknown speaker: And we established it was 8 p.m. and we all went back to our separate seas spaces.

[15:34] Unknown speaker: I'm not sure, but after what happened to Nathan Slane, I say we just go with her.

[15:37] Unknown speaker: Oh, sounds good to me.

[15:39] Unknown speaker: Okay, is everybody here?

[15:41] Unknown speaker: But ex-lover, but again, only on stage, I swear.

[15:46] Unknown speaker: Ugh, Jaden and Faded Broadway star.

[15:49] Unknown speaker: Sleezing agent.

[15:50] Unknown speaker: Greedy producer!

[15:51] Unknown speaker: Everyone's favorite drag Queen diva, yeah.

[15:54] Unknown speaker: And I'm here.

[15:56] Fergie L. Philippe: Sue Denim.

[15:57] Fergie L. Philippe: And I'm here, Detective Holly Day.

[15:59] Fergie L. Philippe: And around me are the presents from Candy, her clues for who would inherit.

[16:06] Fergie L. Philippe: Sorry, I took a peek at all of them while you were in your rooms.

[16:09] Unknown speaker: Oh, great.

[16:10] Unknown speaker: Awesome.

[16:10] Unknown speaker: So that's what you were doing the whole time.

[16:12] Unknown speaker: He sent his way to our rooms like bratty children.

[16:15] Fergie L. Philippe: Oh, not the whole time. I also walked the halls of our guest quarters and made a few deductions.

[16:23] Fergie L. Philippe: Some were easy, like discovering a few empty rooms.

[16:28] Fergie L. Philippe: And some of them, well, I'm still working them out, so you'll have to be patient.

[16:36] Fergie L. Philippe: So that's why I re-wracked the gifts, and I thought that you all could help me.

[16:42] Unknown speaker: Well, this does seem like a very unorthodox holiday, that's for sure.

[16:46] Unknown speaker: I'm not sure that I really want to take part in all this.

[16:48] Fergie L. Philippe: Oh, but Sue, the first gift is for you.

[16:53] Unknown speaker: What?

[16:54] Unknown speaker: But it can't be.

[16:55] Unknown speaker: How how could you possibly know that that's- Okay, that's not exactly true.

[16:58] Fergie L. Philippe: The first gift was for Nathan Slane. It was the laptop over there on the floor that was used to murder him.

[17:04] Fergie L. Philippe: It was his laptop.

[17:05] Unknown speaker: Uh not to incriminate myself in any way, but there's some poetic irony in that, right?

[17:14] Fergie L. Philippe: Indeed, Gil.

[17:15] Fergie L. Philippe: Indeed. The second gift has gone missing, clearly taken by the murderer.

[17:20] Fergie L. Philippe: So, Miss Denim, the fact that I believe this gift is for you may mean that you don't inherit, but it also means that I don't think that you're uh uh you well, you are a murderer.

[17:31] Unknown speaker: Now I don't know how to feel.

[17:33] Unknown speaker: Well I don't you just opened the present.

[17:35] Unknown speaker: Okay.

[17:41] Unknown speaker: What is it, Sue?

[17:43] Unknown speaker: Um.

[17:44] Unknown speaker: It's a music box.

[17:46] Unknown speaker: But the lid won't open.

[17:48] Unknown speaker: It seems to be locked.

[17:49] Unknown speaker: So clearly there's nothing else we can do and move on.

[17:52] Fergie L. Philippe: But wait, Sue, if the lid won't open, how did you know that this box was a music box?

[18:01] Unknown speaker: I well.

[18:02] Unknown speaker: I guessed, I guess.

[18:04] Fergie L. Philippe: Or you knew. Because you also know how to unlock it.

[18:08] Fergie L. Philippe: Maybe with that beautiful key on the necklace around your neck, perhaps.

[18:15] Unknown speaker: How did you know?

[18:17] Unknown speaker: Girl, she's a famous detective, like world famous.

[18:21] Unknown speaker: Mostly Germany, once again.

[18:24] Unknown speaker: Yeah, she's like the second most liked celebrity of the Billboard of Germany.

[18:27] Unknown speaker: It's like Hasselhoff, Hasselhoff, Hasselhoff, couple of trees.

[18:31] Unknown speaker: And me.

[18:32] Unknown speaker: Yes.

[18:33] Unknown speaker: I'm the one.

[18:34] Unknown speaker: We're talking about Hasselhoff a lot for a Broadway theme holiday radio show, right?

[18:38] Unknown speaker: I mean, he was in Jekyll and Hyde on Broadway.

[18:41] Unknown speaker: Oh, right, work. Continue.

[18:47] Unknown speaker: Please don't make me open this and expose who I really am.

[18:54] Unknown speaker: Come on.

[18:55] Unknown speaker: It's time that you own who you really are.

[19:00] Unknown speaker: Okay.

[19:01] Unknown speaker: I'll unlock the box.

[19:03] Unknown speaker: What's in the box?

[19:05] Unknown speaker: What's in the box?

[19:07] Unknown speaker: Uh, do you think anyone will get that reference?

[19:10] Unknown speaker: When the poultro did proof in London.

[19:13] Unknown speaker: What?

[19:14] Unknown speaker: She was in the box.

[19:15] Unknown speaker: Oh, yeah, right.

[19:18] Unknown speaker: Okay, okay, everyone.

[19:20] Unknown speaker: Look over at Sue who's making a huge reveal about her much teased about real identity.

[19:26] Unknown speaker: Okay.

[19:27] Unknown speaker: It's unlocked.

[19:29] Unknown speaker: I'm going to open the lid and inside the box, besides an intoxicating melody, is your birth certificate, isn't it?

[19:51] Unknown speaker: Sue.

[19:52] Unknown speaker: Yes.

[19:53] Unknown speaker: But my name isn't Sue Denim, you see.

[19:56] Unknown speaker: I wanted to be an actress more than anything, but having rich parents makes people think you didn't earn your success.

[20:02] Unknown speaker: So I invented Sudanym. A girl from nowhere who just made it.

[20:07] Unknown speaker: But really, my parents are Jeff and Michelle Herring of the Herring's Corn Pudding Empire.

[20:13] Unknown speaker: Oh my favorite.

[20:14] Unknown speaker: I'm an heiress, and my parents named me for my fiery ginger hair.

[20:19] Unknown speaker: My name is Red Herring.

[20:23] Unknown speaker: I love Red Buddy.

[20:25] Unknown speaker: I had to do this.

[20:29] Unknown speaker: Really?

[20:31] Unknown speaker: I'm afraid so.

[20:34] Unknown speaker: Yeah, I had figured that out.

[20:35] Unknown speaker: I did a good job.

[20:38] Unknown speaker: Of course, because you are a genius detective.

[20:42] Unknown speaker: Well now my secret is out there.

[20:44] Unknown speaker: I'm not just a nobody.

[20:45] Unknown speaker: I'm a nobody with incredibly wealthy parents.

[20:49] Unknown speaker: Any chance I can get myself some free corn pudding?

[20:52] Unknown speaker: Yeah, let's talk about that after I let the gravity of my personal reveals wash over me for like five minutes, okay?

[21:11] Unknown speaker: Sorry, too soon?

[21:12] Unknown speaker: Yeah, a bit too soon.

[21:13] Unknown speaker: Alright, alright, sorry.

[21:16] Unknown speaker: Have you folks ever thought of investing in a Broadway show?

[21:19] Unknown speaker: Okay, the next present is here for you, General.

[21:24] Unknown speaker: Ha!

[21:26] Unknown speaker: Take that, everyone!

[21:28] Unknown speaker: I got a present in your face!

[21:31] Unknown speaker: Oh wow, chill out, man.

[21:33] Unknown speaker: That was pretty aggressive.

[21:35] Unknown speaker: Yeah, seriously, it was intense.

[21:37] Unknown speaker: Dare I say hostile.

[21:40] Unknown speaker: Are you all joking?

[21:42] Unknown speaker: My name is General Lee Hostile!

[21:45] Unknown speaker: And this was like the first freaking time I showed any kind of fight, and you're all surprised.

[21:50] Unknown speaker: It's in my name.

[21:51] Unknown speaker: Well, you know what they said, General Lee.

[21:54] Unknown speaker: A rose by any other name would still not be enough.

[21:59] Unknown speaker: Hmm, I want a dozen.

[22:00] Unknown speaker: Yeah, two for a fancy dinner.

[22:05] Unknown speaker: Oh, General Lee Hostile knows all about that, Miss Cookies.

[22:09] Unknown speaker: Oh.

[22:09] Unknown speaker: His name is deceiving.

[22:11] Unknown speaker: He's a lover, not a fighter.

[22:14] Unknown speaker: And that's why this present was intended for you.

[22:17] Unknown speaker: And someone else.

[22:19] Unknown speaker: Go on.

[22:20] Unknown speaker: Open it up.

[22:21] Unknown speaker: Okay.

[22:28] Unknown speaker: It's uh mistletoe.

[22:32] Unknown speaker: When I told you all to go to your own rooms, someone went to your room with you, General.

[22:37] Unknown speaker: Someone that you're in love with.

[22:39] Unknown speaker: Someone that you've loved for a very long time, even when you were married to Candy.

[22:46] Unknown speaker: It's true.

[22:48] Unknown speaker: I won't lie.

[22:49] Unknown speaker: Well, I do appreciate that.

[22:51] Unknown speaker: Thank you very much, General.

[22:53] Unknown speaker: Instead, I'm going to hold this mistletoe high above my head.

[22:58] Unknown speaker: And encourage the one I love to come forward and stand under this mistletoe with me.

[23:04] Unknown speaker: Are you sure, General?

[23:08] Unknown speaker: Oh, I'm sure Carol.

[23:10] Unknown speaker: Step forward.

[23:13] Unknown speaker: Well, all right, after all, it is the holidays.

[23:17] Unknown speaker: Oh wow.

[23:19] Unknown speaker: It's the only real sight of the love triangle everyone imagined, but no one understood.

[23:25] Unknown speaker: General Lee Hostile and you tied.

[23:29] Unknown speaker: Wow.

[23:29] Unknown speaker: What gave us a win?

[23:31] Unknown speaker: Well, first it was the fact that both of you brought so much luggage.

[23:33] Unknown speaker: Clearly, you are moving in together after this party.

[23:36] Unknown speaker: Wow!

[23:37] Unknown speaker: I can't believe you deduced that.

[23:39] Unknown speaker: Well, I'm j I'm an expert deducer.

[23:41] Unknown speaker: We've been over this.

[23:42] Unknown speaker: And you love talking about luggage too.

[23:45] Unknown speaker: Only when it helps me solve a case.

[23:47] Unknown speaker: Oh that vibe.

[23:49] Unknown speaker: That's good.

[23:50] Unknown speaker: I feel so much better now that this is out in the open.

[23:52] Unknown speaker: Truly, the greatest role I've ever played is opposite you in this crazy thing we call life, General.

[23:57] Unknown speaker: Oh.

[23:58] Unknown speaker: You know I love it when you call me General.

[24:03] Unknown speaker: Okay.

[24:04] Unknown speaker: Okay, so who's next?

[24:05] Unknown speaker: You're on a roll, Detective.

[24:06] Unknown speaker: Oh, alright.

[24:07] Unknown speaker: Let's hurry this along this little stay right here, shall we?

[24:10] Unknown speaker: Okay, I'll open up the next present myself.

[24:16] Unknown speaker: And what do I have here?

[24:20] Unknown speaker: Laundry detergent.

[24:22] Unknown speaker: I mean, honestly, that's a thoughtful gift.

[24:24] Unknown speaker: That's not expensive.

[24:26] Unknown speaker: And heavy.

[24:27] Unknown speaker: Look, since I opened the door to talk about our names, can I just put out there that I'm thinking guild tea parties pretty well?

[24:35] Fergie L. Philippe: Guilty.

[24:36] Unknown speaker: Anyone else just assuming he did it?

[24:39] Unknown speaker: Oh, yeah?

[24:39] Unknown speaker: That's what you think?

[24:41] Unknown speaker: Yeah.

[24:43] Unknown speaker: Oh, yeah?

[24:44] Unknown speaker: That's what you think?

[24:46] Unknown speaker: Yeah.

[24:47] Unknown speaker: Well, you wanna know what I think?

[24:50] Unknown speaker: Yeah, what do you think I've been talking to you?

[24:53] Unknown speaker: All the things that you can think if you're willing to try.

[24:57] Unknown speaker: Uh what are you talking about?

[24:59] Unknown speaker: It doesn't matter as long as you're listening.

[25:01] Unknown speaker: But you know what?

[25:02] Unknown speaker: As long as you're listening, I think I need to come clean.

[25:06] Unknown speaker: I need to tell the truth.

[25:08] Unknown speaker: I am guilty.

[25:09] Unknown speaker: Yes, we know.

[25:10] Unknown speaker: Mmm, you said it all mind time, Mark.

[25:12] Unknown speaker: Guilty party.

[25:16] Unknown speaker: No, I don't mean my punny name.

[25:19] Unknown speaker: I mean I'm actually guilty of Jesus!

[25:23] Unknown speaker: Even in the second act.

[25:25] Unknown speaker: Oh no!

[25:27] Unknown speaker: Doesn't give anyone listening and needed the auditory cube for a visual experience like the power going out.

[25:33] Unknown speaker: Oh no!

[25:34] Unknown speaker: Please!

[25:35] Kevin Jaeger: Kevin, why?

[25:37] Unknown speaker: I wasn't gonna tell anyone about you and die.

[25:40] Unknown speaker: Oh the other half of the panel will be dead!

[25:47] Unknown speaker: The power is back on, don't worry.

[25:52] Unknown speaker: It's guilty party.

[25:54] Unknown speaker: He's totally dead.

[25:56] Unknown speaker: Blood into death by the laundry detergent.

[26:00] Unknown speaker: So clearly you all understand now that this gift was meant for Gil.

[26:05] Unknown speaker: Clearly, you've all deduced that he was laundering money from Candy's accounts.

[26:10] Unknown speaker: Hence the laundry detergent gift!

[26:13] Unknown speaker: It's the snowman right on this carrot nose with that metaphor.

[26:16] Unknown speaker: But some people don't like settle.

[26:19] Unknown speaker: Candy cane clearly did not.

[26:20] Unknown speaker: Oh.

[26:21] Unknown speaker: Or our our our murderer.

[26:23] Unknown speaker: I oh no.

[26:25] Unknown speaker: Or our murderer since they decided to kill him with his own crime.

[26:28] Unknown speaker: So wait.

[26:29] Unknown speaker: Who can it be?

[26:30] Unknown speaker: Well, there is only one gift left.

[26:34] Unknown speaker: And I'll take the liberty of opening this one as well.

[26:38] Unknown speaker: That's uh kind of selfish, don't you think, bad detective?

[26:42] Unknown speaker: Feeling jealous, fill my pockets.

[26:47] Unknown speaker: How incredibly out of character for you.

[26:49] Unknown speaker: But I understand.

[26:50] Unknown speaker: You haven't gotten to open a present in front of everyone yet.

[26:54] Unknown speaker: Which means you're still a suspect in my murder investigation.

[26:59] Unknown speaker: Or I'm the person who is set to inherit.

[27:03] Unknown speaker: That person wouldn't get a present either.

[27:05] Unknown speaker: And I'd say I'm in the same boat.

[27:09] Unknown speaker: Made me kidney.

[27:10] Unknown speaker: Finally felt like paying back a little of what should have been mine.

[27:17] Unknown speaker: And wait, what about the butler?

[27:20] Unknown speaker: Butler did it.

[27:21] Unknown speaker: Or Christmas cookies and milk.

[27:23] Unknown speaker: They are both too colorful characters, and I mean it is a classic trope that the butler well did it.

[27:31] Unknown speaker: Yes.

[27:32] Unknown speaker: The butler did it did what?

[27:34] Unknown speaker: Did you not deduce what the butler did it did?

[27:38] Unknown speaker: I did deduce it, darling dear.

[27:40] Unknown speaker: Don't deduct from my deducing domination that I somehow didn't deduce what Butler did it did when he did it and why he did it.

[27:46] Unknown speaker: Even at times why he did it was for the entire Did It Clan.

[27:49] Unknown speaker: Didn't I divulge that after I deduced it?

[27:53] Unknown speaker: Woo!

[27:55] Unknown speaker: Whoa!

[27:56] Unknown speaker: Give that sweet Jesus!

[28:00] Unknown speaker: Forgive that girl a drink, hey!

[28:03] Unknown speaker: I have had plenty, thank you.

[28:07] Kevin Jaeger: But Kevin wrote it.

[28:08] Unknown speaker: Um why aren't the butler and Miss Cookie being considered?

[28:12] Unknown speaker: Because there are just too many of you to be suspects, so the story needed some characters that are guaranteed to not be guilty, okay?

[28:12] Unknown speaker: Okay, okay, okay.

[28:20] Unknown speaker: And you ha all you had to say was it was a producer's decision, and I would have totally understood.

[28:26] Unknown speaker: Trim the fat, I did it.

[28:28] Unknown speaker: Angel Gabriel Union help you if you just called me fat.

[28:32] Unknown speaker: Whoa!

[28:33] Unknown speaker: You all just let me open the final pl present, please, God.

[28:37] Unknown speaker: Thank you.

[28:45] Unknown speaker: The final gift is a mirror.

[28:49] Unknown speaker: That's shocking.

[28:50] Unknown speaker: Honestly, what's shocking is that all of us are so comfortable with now having seen three people be murdered in one night.

[28:57] Unknown speaker: Whoa, shouldn't we be freaking out more?

[29:01] Unknown speaker: It's a holiday murder mystery.

[29:03] Unknown speaker: I think that lightens the mood.

[29:04] Unknown speaker: I mean, 'tis the season of Mariah Carey, so a little murder is bound to happen.

[29:10] Unknown speaker: So, who is the mirror for?

[29:13] Unknown speaker: Does it belong to fill my pockets and send some kind of a message about what the mirror holds?

[29:19] Unknown speaker: Maybe Candy's image or her likeness?

[29:22] Unknown speaker: Or is it meant to say to Carol Singers, take a long hard look at yourself in the mirror and realize you were never going to make it and be as famous as me.

[29:30] Unknown speaker: Know thyself, Carol, and know thyself.

[29:33] Unknown speaker: Oh, no, that thyself is not very good.

[29:35] Unknown speaker: This mirror belongs to one of you two, and then the other person is the murderer who will reveal the present they've already opened and concealed away.

[29:46] Unknown speaker: But wait.

[29:47] Unknown speaker: If one of the two of them gets the mirror and the other one gets the secret present that they'll reveal, then does that mean that no one inherits?

[29:56] Unknown speaker: What do you mean?

[29:58] Unknown speaker: So the rules were that if you got a present, you weren't inheriting.

[30:01] Unknown speaker: Right.

[30:02] Unknown speaker: And if you weren't the murderer, because the murderer stole their present.

[30:05] Unknown speaker: Also true, I deduced that.

[30:07] Unknown speaker: Yes, but then go with me.

[30:09] Unknown speaker: I got the music box, so I'm out.

[30:12] Unknown speaker: General Lee and Yule Tide got the mistletoe, so now they're out.

[30:15] Unknown speaker: Nathan Slain got and guilty party got murdered with their gifts, so they're out.

[30:19] Unknown speaker: Uh so who inherits?

[30:21] Unknown speaker: Oh well, uh, I guess Christmas cookies and milk are butler did it will, since they're Candy's trusted friends who aren't suspects in their murder.

[30:30] Unknown speaker: Well, that's a little anticlimatic in how that story wraps up, then is it?

[30:34] Unknown speaker: No, I think that's totally fine, actually.

[30:35] Unknown speaker: I think that works.

[30:36] Unknown speaker: Yeah, it's fine.

[30:37] Unknown speaker: Well, uh, of course you two think it's fine.

[30:40] Unknown speaker: You're s you're still in line to inherit Candy's fortune.

[30:43] Unknown speaker: You're still in line for something too.

[30:45] Unknown speaker: Oh.

[30:46] Unknown speaker: Yeah.

[30:46] Unknown speaker: In the murder line, not as fun as being in the inheritor line.

[30:51] Unknown speaker: So make your final play, Detective Holly Day.

[30:55] Unknown speaker: Who does the mirror belong to?

[30:58] Unknown speaker: Which one of us is the murderer?

[31:00] Unknown speaker: And how will you?

[31:02] Unknown speaker: Oh dear.

[31:02] Unknown speaker: I guess narrowed down between the two obvious candidates who will inherit Candy's fortune.

[31:10] Kimberly Schmidt: You know what?

[31:11] Kimberly Schmidt: It's not holiday enough.

[31:12] Kevin Jaeger: Kimberly, what are you doing?

[31:14] Kimberly Schmidt: We're the climax of the story.

[31:16] Kimberly Schmidt: You can't just cut in and you're going to end this wrong.

[31:20] Unknown speaker: What?

[31:20] Unknown speaker: No, I am not.

[31:21] Bryan Plofsky: Brian, come on, back me up here.

[31:23] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, I don't know, Kevin.

[31:25] Kevin Jaeger: I think Kimberly's got a point.

[31:27] Unknown speaker: You're really butchering it like American Cycle the Musical before the scrim came down before every kill book during it.

[31:34] Unknown speaker: Oh, yeah.

[31:35] Unknown speaker: Okay.

[31:36] Unknown speaker: I can see how I deserve that.

[31:38] Unknown speaker: We need to throw in a bit of holiday cheer.

[31:41] Unknown speaker: Something holiday fun.

[31:42] Unknown speaker: We have all these friends here.

[31:43] Unknown speaker: Let's play holiday plot points.

[31:45] Unknown speaker: Right now?

[31:46] Unknown speaker: Yes.

[31:47] Unknown speaker: Right before the climax of the story.

[31:49] Unknown speaker: Yes.

[31:50] Unknown speaker: Right now.

[31:51] Unknown speaker: Well, okay then.

[31:53] Unknown speaker: If you say so.

[31:55] Kimberly Schmidt: Take it away, Kimberly.

[31:57] Unknown speaker: Oh, there's a distinction.

[32:02] Unknown speaker: Excuse me, I don't have the words.

[32:03] Kevin Jaeger: Well, this is Kevin explains.

[32:05] Unknown speaker: It does.

[32:07] Unknown speaker: Oh, it does because I thought I was gonna create it beforehand, but I made Kim write.

[32:13] Unknown speaker: Writers.

[32:13] Unknown speaker: So I'll let you do it, Kimberly.

[32:16] Kimberly Schmidt: Okay, in a game of plot points, you're describing the plot to the tune of a song.

[32:20] Kimberly Schmidt: I have two piles of papers, a pink pile and a yellow pile.

[32:24] Kimberly Schmidt: You'll each get one of each.

[32:26] Kimberly Schmidt: Okay.

[32:27] Kimberly Schmidt: The pink paper is one of the top ten Christmas tunes.

[32:31] Kimberly Schmidt: And the yellow papers are a musical that has Christmas at some point in the plot.

[32:37] Kimberly Schmidt: And so when it is your turn, you will sing the tune of the song.

[32:40] Kimberly Schmidt: Tell us the plot of the musical.

[32:41] Kimberly Schmidt: Kevin will go first so that everyone knows how the game works.

[32:44] Kevin Jaeger: Great.

[32:44] Kevin Jaeger: So just along and take one of each.

[32:47] Unknown speaker: No, that's not a musical, but the song.

[32:53] Unknown speaker: Wait, I that's not a musical.

[32:55] Unknown speaker: That's a song.

[32:57] Kevin Jaeger: So I will go first.

[32:58] Kevin Jaeger: Um here we go.

[33:00] Kevin Jaeger: Um I'll uh have a sad Christmas with my group of poor friends.

[33:12] Unknown speaker: We'll all be in New York.

[33:16] Unknown speaker: It'll be Christmas.

[33:17] Unknown speaker: Yes.

[33:19] Unknown speaker: Score one for Roselle.

[33:21] Unknown speaker: It's either rent or Oliver.

[33:22] Unknown speaker: I can't tell.

[33:24] Unknown speaker: Honestly, same show.

[33:26] Unknown speaker: That's it.

[33:26] Unknown speaker: Yeah.

[33:27] Unknown speaker: Oh.

[33:28] Bryan Plofsky: Brian, do you want to go?

[33:29] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah.

[33:30] Unknown speaker: Rent.

[33:32] Unknown speaker: Okay.

[33:33] Unknown speaker: Yes, sir.

[33:34] Unknown speaker: Again, we can all see through your BF.

[33:38] Unknown speaker: Um.

[33:38] Unknown speaker: Good point.

[33:39] Unknown speaker: But we all have binders, so we can use those.

[33:42] Unknown speaker: Oh.

[33:42] Unknown speaker: And Kevin's filming the hair.

[33:44] Unknown speaker: He lives on a mountain over the town.

[33:48] Unknown speaker: Jingle Rock.

[33:49] Unknown speaker: The wrench.

[33:50] Unknown speaker: Yeah, wow.

[33:51] Unknown speaker: I'm just really good at the room.

[33:53] Unknown speaker: Oh, you and Jingle Bell Rock.

[33:59] Unknown speaker: That was a Christmas song.

[34:00] Unknown speaker: That's actually the third sequel to Deuce Big Little.

[34:03] Unknown speaker: Oh, Jiggle Rock.

[34:05] Unknown speaker: J Bird.

[34:07] Unknown speaker: Um, this has Wilfarrell, and he comes from the Northman Elf.

[34:13] Unknown speaker: And Swerver.

[34:18] Unknown speaker: Yes.

[34:20] Unknown speaker: Okay.

[34:23] Unknown speaker: This musical had a Dolly Party in the movie.

[34:26] Unknown speaker: 95.

[34:27] Unknown speaker: And no pizza.

[34:30] Unknown speaker: Little House in Texas.

[34:32] Unknown speaker: Oh, best of the house in Texas.

[34:34] Unknown speaker: No, I said Texas.

[34:36] Unknown speaker: And whore.

[34:38] Unknown speaker: I got a little house.

[34:44] Unknown speaker: New whore.

[34:45] Unknown speaker: I still don't know this song.

[34:46] Unknown speaker: Yeah, um.

[34:47] Unknown speaker: Last Christmas, I gave you my heart.

[34:50] Unknown speaker: Oh, wow.

[34:51] Unknown speaker: Oh, you were thinking of the beginning.

[34:53] Unknown speaker: See, I thought you were saying making my way downtown.

[34:59] Unknown speaker: I was like, that's a Christmas.

[35:03] Unknown speaker: Alright, um.

[35:05] Unknown speaker: I didn't see this play.

[35:07] Unknown speaker: La la la la bla.

[35:09] Unknown speaker: But it's dark shot case.

[35:12] Unknown speaker: It was sort of a bad case, I think.

[35:15] Unknown speaker: Oh, no, an action God.

[35:17] Unknown speaker: No.

[35:17] Unknown speaker: No.

[35:18] Unknown speaker: Promises, promises.

[35:19] Unknown speaker: Oh.

[35:25] Unknown speaker: And it might have been about gays.

[35:26] Unknown speaker: Sort of.

[35:30] Unknown speaker: Alright, very good.

[35:31] Unknown speaker: Good luck to be spot gays.

[35:32] Unknown speaker: Okay.

[35:33] Unknown speaker: I don't know this show really well, but it starred Angela Lansbury.

[35:39] Unknown speaker: It's about an ant.

[35:41] Unknown speaker: What'd you say?

[35:41] Unknown speaker: Name.

[35:42] Unknown speaker: Name.

[35:42] Unknown speaker: Great.

[35:44] Unknown speaker: Let us know, let us know.

[35:46] Unknown speaker: As far as the plot, that's all I got.

[35:49] Unknown speaker: And so figure out the rest.

[35:56] Unknown speaker: Alright, so last.

[35:58] Unknown speaker: I decided to go to war.

[36:03] Unknown speaker: I got a gun.

[36:05] Unknown speaker: And we went to Vermont.

[36:08] Unknown speaker: Simply.

[36:10] Unknown speaker: Simply having a wonderful video.

[36:12] Unknown speaker: Because you sang the lyric.

[36:13] Unknown speaker: I know.

[36:39] Unknown speaker: I got my gun for it.

[36:42] Unknown speaker: Oh my god.

[36:46] Unknown speaker: That was a reach.

[36:47] Unknown speaker: Sorry, everyone.

[36:49] Unknown speaker: Thank you for being fun.

[36:50] Unknown speaker: Okay.

[36:52] Unknown speaker: The non-musical theater person is about to go.

[36:55] Adam Lash: Adam too. Very excited.

[36:56] Unknown speaker: You got it.

[36:57] Unknown speaker: Okay, one second.

[36:59] Unknown speaker: Oh my sorry.

[37:01] Unknown speaker: You'll get it in first line.

[37:02] Unknown speaker: I just gotta make sure I get it right in the first line.

[37:04] Unknown speaker: Okay.

[37:05] Unknown speaker: I just want a deck for Christmas.

[37:08] Unknown speaker: Okay.

[37:11] Unknown speaker: Oh, Annie.

[37:17] Unknown speaker: Isn't it so hard?

[37:18] Unknown speaker: This isn't so hard.

[37:23] Unknown speaker: This job's easy, right?

[37:27] Unknown speaker: But I got a war prophet.

[37:35] Unknown speaker: There's a mother that has two daughters, and she puts it.

[37:40] Unknown speaker: Titsie shows and a baby.

[37:42] Unknown speaker: Nice.

[37:42] Unknown speaker: Yeah.

[37:43] Unknown speaker: That's good.

[37:44] Unknown speaker: Alright, Robbie.

[37:45] Unknown speaker: Laura Banati is at least by right letters.

[37:48] Unknown speaker: It's my favorite show.

[37:50] Unknown speaker: She loves me.

[37:51] Unknown speaker: Correct.

[37:52] Unknown speaker: Okay.

[37:52] Unknown speaker: Is that Christmas?

[37:55] Unknown speaker: Yeah.

[37:56] Unknown speaker: Yeah.

[37:57] Unknown speaker: Greeting cards.

[37:59] Unknown speaker: It's beginning to look a lot more.

[38:00] Unknown speaker: Oh, it's going to look a lot like this.

[38:03] Unknown speaker: She loves me on every time.

[38:06] Unknown speaker: We did it, James.

[38:09] Unknown speaker: I think that everyone has had a turn.

[38:14] Unknown speaker: For the worst.

[38:17] Unknown speaker: What a segue.

[38:18] Kimberly Schmidt: You were right, Kimberly. We definitely all needed that.

[38:22] Unknown speaker: I agree.

[38:23] Unknown speaker: Now we can get back to the murder and inheriting stuff.

[38:26] Unknown speaker: But figure out a way to make the inheriting thing more exciting.

[38:29] Unknown speaker: Audit.

[38:30] Unknown speaker: Alright, so let's get back to it.

[38:34] Unknown speaker: Okay, I know you're all dying to know.

[38:36] Unknown speaker: Candy, Nathan, and Gil of Melise.

[38:39] Unknown speaker: Who is this mirror was meant for?

[38:40] Unknown speaker: But knowing what I know about candy and always wanting to make an appearance, I think a mirror to her meant something she held sacred.

[38:48] Unknown speaker: Her likeness.

[38:50] Unknown speaker: Something you tried to steal from her once.

[38:53] Fergie L. Philippe: Didn't you, Phil? You were going to use new body mapping technology on the opening guide of And Then There Were Some so that you could own a virtual replica of Candy's performance. That way you could remount the production all over the world and you wouldn't even need candy anymore. So that's why you left she left the industry and left you hanging on opening night. And that's why you'd never inherit.

[39:20] Unknown speaker: Gil was investigating some of the money he was.

[39:23] Unknown speaker: Huh.

[39:24] Unknown speaker: In oh I oh yeah, no, he wasn't investigating.

[39:26] Unknown speaker: That's your job.

[39:28] Unknown speaker: He was investing in it.

[39:29] Unknown speaker: He was, he was.

[39:30] Unknown speaker: He was, he was actually investing.

[39:32] Unknown speaker: Gil, the dead guy.

[39:33] Unknown speaker: He was in the so much.

[39:36] Unknown speaker: I blame him.

[39:39] Unknown speaker: Gil was investing some of the money he was embezzling from candy into the technology we were going to use. It was going to make us rich before it tanked both of us.

[39:51] Unknown speaker: Alright, in la.

[39:54] Unknown speaker: All of you better move to the edge of the room quickly and quietly, and no one will get hurt.

[39:59] Unknown speaker: So that leaves you, Carol Singers, in the greatest starring role of your life.

[40:04] Unknown speaker: The murderer of Candy Kane, Nathan Slane, and Gil T Party.

[40:11] Unknown speaker: So what was your gift from Candy that told you you weren't inheriting?

[40:15] Unknown speaker: What was the gift that set you off?

[40:17] Unknown speaker: What was my gift?

[40:18] Unknown speaker: After a decade of therapy to try to control my rage about how a candy cane destroyed my career, her performance, and Nathan Slane's review, and when I realized they were both going to be there together in the same room, I just lost it. I only had to open two gifts until I figured out which was mine. She'd given me poison.

[40:44] Unknown speaker: Poison?

[40:45] Unknown speaker: Poison!

[40:46] Unknown speaker: Yes, because she wanted me to know that she didn't want to poison my career.

[40:50] Unknown speaker: I did.

[40:51] Unknown speaker: I did it to myself.

[40:53] Unknown speaker: How did you figure all of that out from just one bottle of poison?

[40:59] Unknown speaker: Oh no.

[41:00] Unknown speaker: There was a bottle of poison with a note that said, quote, dear Carol, this poison this take this again.

[41:11] Unknown speaker: Oh no.

[41:13] Unknown speaker: There was a bottle of poison with the note that said, Dear Carol, this poison is for you. So that you know that I never poisoned your career.

[41:22] Unknown speaker: You poisoned it yourself.

[41:25] Unknown speaker: You are poison.

[41:27] Unknown speaker: Love candy.

[41:29] Unknown speaker: Uh like I said, I mean, some of the clues were meant to be very easy.

[41:35] Unknown speaker: Oh, I read that and I snapped.

[41:37] Unknown speaker: I snapped, I tell you.

[41:39] Unknown speaker: So when Miss Zue Dunham or Red Herring or whatever the her name was, fainted. I took that opportunity to poison Candy's drink.

[41:50] Unknown speaker: But she regrets that gift now, I tell you, now.

[41:54] Unknown speaker: And what about Nathan Slain?

[41:56] Unknown speaker: I mean, I took advantage of that moment, plus I think writer Kevin kind of was an accomplished in that murder.

[42:04] Unknown speaker: When the fights went out, I used the laptop. I opened before I found my gift and killed Nathan Slain with it in the dark.

[42:11] Unknown speaker: Can you believe he once said I was too old to play Ava Peron?

[42:15] Unknown speaker: And then guilty party.

[42:18] Unknown speaker: Well, Candy wasn't the only one of his clients that Gil was embezzling from.

[42:24] Unknown speaker: When I saw the laundry detergent, I knew immediately who that was for.

[42:28] Unknown speaker: Gail stole a lot from Candy.

[42:30] Unknown speaker: It's just that Candy had so much money that what he stole didn't really change your life the way it changed mine.

[42:38] Unknown speaker: He took it all from me and left me desolate.

[42:41] Unknown speaker: So when I had the chance, I took it all from him and left him dead.

[42:48] Unknown speaker: So congratulations, Detective Holly Day.

[42:51] Unknown speaker: It looks like you crashed the case.

[42:58] Unknown speaker: House lockdown protocols deactivated, imminent danger removed.

[43:02] Unknown speaker: You're all safe now that Detective Holly Day caught the killer.

[43:12] Unknown speaker: And with that, I'd say that brings us to the end of our tale.

[43:17] Unknown speaker: Oh, but wait just a moment, Detective!

[43:20] Unknown speaker: Oh yes.

[43:21] Unknown speaker: Mmm, there's just one more matter of business that needs to be sorted out.

[43:27] Unknown speaker: Oh, yes, Sarah.

[43:28] Unknown speaker: And what's that tray tell?

[43:29] Unknown speaker: Oh, if you wouldn't mind, could you solve the mystery of which of the two of us is going to inherit all of Candy Kane's fortune?

[43:36] Unknown speaker: We're honestly okay either way, who it is.

[43:39] Unknown speaker: We've made a deal that will split the money and assets.

[43:42] Unknown speaker: 50 50.

[43:45] Unknown speaker: Straight-ish down the line.

[43:48] Unknown speaker: So all I've left to do is answer this question.

[43:51] Unknown speaker: The person who was inheriting Candy Kane's fortune is Oh, that's easy.

[43:57] Unknown speaker: Yule Ty.

[43:59] Unknown speaker: Sweet Jesus!

[44:00] Unknown speaker: Say what now?

[44:01] Unknown speaker: Yeah, Yule Tide didn't get a present.

[44:03] Unknown speaker: The mistletoe was given to General Lee Hostile, not Yule Tide, therefore he is the inheritor.

[44:09] Unknown speaker: Oh my god, seriously?

[44:10] Unknown speaker: Of course.

[44:11] Unknown speaker: You let her stay at your place for free when you were out in LA doing your pilot season thing back when you had frosted tits.

[44:17] Unknown speaker: She always felt like she owed you.

[44:19] Unknown speaker: Wow.

[44:19] Unknown speaker: Thanks, Candy, wherever you are.

[44:22] Unknown speaker: General, our holiday season just got a substantial upgrade.

[44:25] Unknown speaker: Damn right.

[44:26] Unknown speaker: But wait!

[44:27] Unknown speaker: What do we get for helping Candy pull everything off and being her closest and most trusted?

[44:33] Unknown speaker: Yeah, friends, huh?

[44:36] Unknown speaker: The ultimate satisfaction of knowing you helped out a friend in need.

[44:40] Unknown speaker: And that's what the holiday season is all about, don't you know?

[44:43] Unknown speaker: Oh, okay.

[44:45] Unknown speaker: That's right.

[44:49] Unknown speaker: And that brings us to the end of our holiday radio play for this season.

[44:54] Unknown speaker: Thank you all for listening and for being supporters of us and the show.

[44:59] Unknown speaker: A huge shout out to our absolutely incredible cast who totally nailed this one shot live recording.

[45:05] Unknown speaker: Well, live to take.

[45:06] Unknown speaker: And now for a not so live to tape explanation of how you can take your one shot to do some good this holiday season.

[45:14] Unknown speaker: Hello there, General Lee Hostile.

[45:20] Unknown speaker: Hey everybody, Colin Donald here.

[45:22] Unknown speaker: This is Patty Newren.

[45:23] Unknown speaker: This is Calvin Moonlow.

[45:24] Unknown speaker: Jalen Markle.

[45:25] Unknown speaker: Jeremy Jordan.

[45:26] Unknown speaker: This is Elliot Maddox.

[45:27] Unknown speaker: I'm Michael Cerberus.

[45:28] Unknown speaker: This is Squiggs.

[45:29] Unknown speaker: Antoine L. Smith.

[45:30] Unknown speaker: This is Jen Gambitese.

[45:31] Unknown speaker: T boych.

[45:32] Unknown speaker: Aaron J. Albano.

[45:32] Unknown speaker: Haley Pachin.

[45:33] Unknown speaker: Robbie Rozelle.

[45:34] Unknown speaker: Michael Kilborgore.

[45:35] Unknown speaker: Madison Stratton.

[45:35] Unknown speaker: Andrew Bradis.

[45:36] Unknown speaker: James Monroe Eichelhart.

[45:38] Unknown speaker: And I'm Hannah Ellis, and this holiday season, all of us friends of the show want to ask all of you, listeners of the show, to look inside your theater loving, radio play listening hearts, and join us in supporting our amazing friends at Broadway Bound Kids.

[45:52] Unknown speaker: Broadway Bound Kids is a nonprofit that inspires and empowers young lives through the performing arts in a transformative and inclusive community.

[45:59] Unknown speaker: Their mission is simple to make arts education accessible to as many students as possible throughout Manhattan and the surrounding boroughs.

[46:06] Unknown speaker: Students in the Broadway Bound Kids program experience creative and exciting classes and workshops.

[46:11] Unknown speaker: Led by talented, caring teaching artists who are professional performers here in the city.

[46:16] Unknown speaker: Just like all of us, Broadway Bound Kids passionately believes that involvement in the performing arts increases self-esteem.

[46:21] Unknown speaker: Confidence, self-expression, critical thinking, and empathy.

[46:24] Unknown speaker: These lessons will aid students at home and in school.

[46:28] Unknown speaker: Your support enables Broadway bound kids to offer free, subsidized, and scholarship programs for more than 500 students every week.

[46:35] Unknown speaker: 1,000 can sponsor one child for Broadway bound kids for an entire year.

[46:40] Unknown speaker: So let's see how many year-long scholarships we can give out for Broadway bound kids.

[46:44] Unknown speaker: If you're a member of Broadway Sits Patreon, 100% of the proceeds from December will be going directly to Broadway bound kids.

[46:51] Unknown speaker: Not a member of Patreon, then go directly to WW.broadwayboundkids.net and click on donate.

[46:57] Unknown speaker: And that's it.

[46:57] Unknown speaker: Hi, my name is Aaron Glass, and I'm the founder of Broadway Bound Kids.

[47:01] Unknown speaker: Thank you so much for your support.

[47:02] Unknown speaker: And from all of us at Broadway Bound Kids, and all of us friends of the show, and from all of us at Broadway, Happy Holidays.

[47:10] Unknown speaker: Happy holiday holidays.

[47:11] Unknown speaker: Happy holidays.

[47:12] Unknown speaker: Happy holidays.

[47:13] Unknown speaker: Happy Christmas.

[47:14] Unknown speaker: A fabulous holiday.

[47:15] Unknown speaker: Happy holidays.

[47:16] Unknown speaker: Merry Christmas.

[47:16] Unknown speaker: Happy Hanukkah.

[47:17] Unknown speaker: Happy Happy.

[47:18] Unknown speaker: Happy holidays.

[47:18] Unknown speaker: Happy holidays.

[47:19] Unknown speaker: Happy holidays.

[47:20] Unknown speaker: Happy holidays.

[47:21] Unknown speaker: Happy holidays.

[47:22] Unknown speaker: Felice Navidad.

[47:23] Unknown speaker: Happy holidays.

[47:26] Unknown speaker: So from all of us at Broadway.

[47:29] Unknown speaker: All of our family of the show.

[47:33] Unknown speaker: Happy holidays.

[47:39] Unknown speaker: Oh, we are actually doing it?

[47:41] Unknown speaker: Happy holiday.

[47:42] Unknown speaker: Happy holidays.

[47:43] Unknown speaker: Happy holidays.

[47:44] Unknown speaker: Good lord, happy holidays.

[47:51] Unknown speaker: And as we end every episode, we raise a glass and say.

[48:17] Unknown speaker: Happy holidays, everyone.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred