Play along as Michael Fatica (The Cher Show) joins Bryan, Kevin, and Kimberly for whiskey, broadway talk, theatre games, bad puns, and tequila. Become a supporter on our Patreon: https://bit.ly/2Q2zELG. This episode is brought to you by Goldstar!.. Read More
From the show: Broadwaysted!
Featured Shows
About
Play along as Michael Fatica (The Cher Show) joins Bryan, Kevin, and Kimberly for whiskey, broadway talk, theatre games, bad puns, and tequila.
Become a supporter on our Patreon: https://bit.ly/2Q2zELG
This episode is brought to you by Goldstar! Get $10 off already discounted tickets by using the code BROADWAYSTED at checkout.
goldstar.com/broadwaysted
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Bryan Plovsky: Was that a rainbow, guys? Um, and I also see there is a pot of gold at the end of it. That's right, everyone. The leprechauns are here, and they're almost ready to come to your house like they do every St. Patrick's Day morning in everyone's house in all of America. That is terrifying. No, ever does it the leprechaun comes to your house? Nope. Nope. Did the leprechaun come to your house? But I leprechauns don't love you. You know where they're gonna go? Green Room 42. No, we don't do it. I was trying to figure out how to make that Irish. I was like, jig jig jig jing jig jing jig jig jig jing jig jing jing. After the leprechauns have left your home, they're going to come to a night show. Yeah.
9:30 p.m. at Green Room 42, and they're gonna toast my 30th birthday, and you know, have some fun and games and like special guests from Broadway and stuff, but mostly. Yeah, so come to our live show March 17th, St. Patrick's Day. Um, you can get tickets on the Green Room 42 website. Yeah. You can get them, or you can be linked there through our Twitter, Instagram, Facebook. Um, we would love to see you there. It's gonna be super fun. That's true, they're tricksters. Oh, to get broad-waisted tickets? Yes. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah, yeah, not gold. No, right, just tickets. Much more precious than gold. Yeah, exactly. So come and see our show. We're gonna have some great live guests, um, live events.
We're gonna celebrate Kimberly turning old. It's gonna be super exciting. Yeah. Uh, check us out at Green Room 42. I'll knit the whole time. But in the meantime, here's your regularly scheduled broad-waisted.
[1:29] Kevin Jaeger: Hey, that's us.
[1:34] Bryan Plovsky: Did you bring wine?
[1:35] Kimberly Cooper: I got the glasses.
[1:37] Michael Fatica: You guys, I made a quiz.
[1:38] Bryan Plovsky: I didn't bring anything, but I'm here to have bugs.
[1:50] Bryan Plovsky: Hello, and welcome to the official broad-wasted podcast where we're drunk on theater. I'm your host, Bryan Plovsky, and today there will be sun. Maybe not on day one, perhaps not day two, but definitely on day three. Well, one day, if I had my time again, I'll hope the night will come and I'll be seeing you. Then I'll see you again and again and again and again. Shadows, am I right? Meh, nobody cares. Joining us today are the usual stuck and philandering punks a tawny rockers, including Kevin playing Nancy Jaeger.
[2:20] Kevin Jaeger: I'll take it.
[2:23] Bryan Plovsky: Nancy's a good role.
[2:24] Kevin Jaeger: I'll play.
[2:25] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[2:25] Bryan Plovsky: And Kimberly, our What a Game Master and unofficial babysitter for the hour.
[2:29] Kimberly Cooper: Yes, welcome on early spring.
[2:30] Bryan Plovsky: Yes. And with us today is another guest aiding us on our quest to collect all of the news.
[2:36] Michael Fatica: Gotta catch them all.
[2:38] Bryan Plovsky: Um, aside from leaping onto the Broadway stage in Disney's most popular show about child unions, you've seen him in shows like She Loves Me, Groundhog's Day, Groundhog's Day, Groundhog's Day, Paper Mill's The Sting. And now, snapping out of it in Cher.
[2:54] Michael Fatica: Oh, I got my jug now.
[2:56] Bryan Plovsky: Snapper.
[2:57] Michael Fatica: Snapping out of it in Cher.
[2:58] Bryan Plovsky: I was like, Bryan, that's so dumb. Why would you write that? I'm like, oh, package.
[3:03] Michael Fatica: I hear this eight times a week.
[3:05] Bryan Plovsky: I know that one. Let's give him a big broad-wasted welcome to Friend of the Show.
[3:09] All: Friend of the show.
[3:10] Bryan Plovsky: Michael Fatica!
[3:16] Michael Fatica: Bryan, that was the best intro I've ever heard in my entire life.
[3:19] Bryan Plovsky: You're very welcome.
[3:20] Michael Fatica: I'm like, Dave, come on. You got all of them.
[3:25] Bryan Plovsky: I need a copy of that.
[3:25] Michael Fatica: Sure, sure, sure.
[3:26] Bryan Plovsky: That's your new bio for Cher.
[3:27] Michael Fatica: Absolutely.
[3:28] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah, yeah, yeah definitely. Um, Mr. Playbill.
[3:30] Michael Fatica: I have to change my bio.
[3:31] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah.
[3:32] Michael Fatica: Yeah, Mr. Playbook.
[3:33] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah, that's how it works.
[3:34] Michael Fatica: Of course.
[3:36] Bryan Plovsky: You can follow him at his name, Michael Fatica, on social media.
[3:40] Michael Fatica: Yes, sir.
[3:40] Bryan Plovsky: You're a lucky man.
[3:41] Michael Fatica: Yeah, you got it across the platforms.
[3:43] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah. I mean, it's not a really common name. There are a few other Michael Fatica, but not in the theater world.
[3:47] Michael Fatica: Oh, so it works great.
[3:48] Bryan Plovsky: It's great, right?
[3:49] Michael Fatica: Yeah.
[3:50] Bryan Plovsky: Um, let's just go with what are you drinking?
[3:52] Michael Fatica: What are you drinking?
[3:55] Michael Fatica: Well, I'm drinking an old-fashioned New York drink. It is the first old-fashioned I've actually made. It's not nearly as good as I normally am treated to. However, I think it's a good solid college try.
[4:06] Bryan Plovsky: There you go.
[4:07] Michael Fatica: Yeah. And what cup are you drinking out of?
[4:09] Michael Fatica: Oh, it's a School of Rock cup.
[4:10] Kimberly Cooper: Oh.
[4:11] Michael Fatica: Which I saw three times.
[4:12] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, really?
[4:12] Michael Fatica: Absolutely.
[4:14] Bryan Plovsky: You got schooled.
[4:15] Michael Fatica: I got schooled many times.
[4:16] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah, yeah. Those kids are amazing.
[4:18] Michael Fatica: Yeah. I just had friends join the show, so I would come see them again.
[4:23] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, sure, sure, sure.
[4:24] Michael Fatica: The kids.
[4:24] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, me and my friends who are 11.
[4:28] Michael Fatica: That are more taunt than I am.
[4:29] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[4:30] Michael Fatica: Musical prodigies.
[4:32] Kimberly Cooper: Kimberly and I are also drinking old fashions that we made.
[4:36] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[4:37] Michael Fatica: I also made the simple syrup.
[4:38] Kimberly Cooper: It's a brown sugar vanilla.
[4:40] Michael Fatica: Yes, thank you. It is very simple, as is the name, but apparently I'm the only one at this table that knows that it's not.
[4:46] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, it's like, oh god, we're gonna have to make old fashions. Can you make simple syrup? And she's like, yes, I can put water and sugar together.
[4:54] Michael Fatica: Exactly. Two minutes. It's a one-to-one ratio. Keep till dissolved. Bring to room temperature.
[5:00] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, I'd be like, it's gelatinous. What did I do?
[5:04] Michael Fatica: Oh hot. I don't think it would get it.
[5:05] Kimberly Cooper: Exactly. I'd be like, oh god, what am I doing?
[5:07] Michael Fatica: I guess if you boil it too hard, you can make caramel.
[5:10] Kimberly Cooper: I'm more like a nailed it person than like a great British baking.
[5:14] Michael Fatica: Sure, sure.
[5:15] Kimberly Cooper: And we all know I'm a baking show person.
[5:17] Michael Fatica: I just spy.
[5:18] Kimberly Cooper: Kimberly, I have no idea what cup you're drinking out of.
[5:20] Kimberly Cooper: Alright, and no one has ever heard me say these words before, but I'm obviously drinking out of Reuben and Clay's first annual Christmas Carol Family Fun, Pageant Spectacular Reunion Show.
[5:30] All: Woo!
[5:31] Kimberly Cooper: I'm never gonna remember all those words.
[5:33] Michael Fatica: No.
[5:33] Kimberly Cooper: And I drink out of this every time.
[5:34] Michael Fatica: That's it.
[5:36] Kimberly Cooper: Can you say it three times fast?
[5:37] Michael Fatica: No.
[5:39] Kimberly Cooper: I can't say it one time slow.
[5:42] Kimberly Cooper: I'm also drinking the old fashioned I made it. Uh, it's very good, and it's in a waitress cup.
[5:47] Michael Fatica: Nice.
[5:47] Kimberly Cooper: Delicious.
[5:48] Michael Fatica: And then I'm drinking, I'm breaking from the tradition.
[5:51] Kimberly Cooper: Um, I'm drinking too.
[5:52] Michael Fatica: Is it a tradition?
[5:53] Kimberly Cooper: Well, I mean, I guess the tradition that everyone started today of Michael Fatica episodes where we drink whiskey.
[6:00] Michael Fatica: So our new tradition of that.
[6:02] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, I love it.
[6:02] Michael Fatica: I've broken that.
[6:03] Kimberly Cooper: And I'm having the uh milagro tequila.
[6:06] Michael Fatica: So good.
[6:06] Kimberly Cooper: It's so good.
[6:07] Michael Fatica: And I'm doing it with a margarita mix, so I made myself like an actual kind of like a fancy margarita.
[6:12] Bryan Plovsky: Cool for you.
[6:13] All: Well, cheers, everyone cheers.
[6:15] Kevin Jaeger: Sweet Kevin, which cup?
[6:16] Michael Fatica: I'm so sorry.
[6:16] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, I'm sorry.
[6:17] Kevin Jaeger: I'm in the uh Natasha Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812.
[6:21] Michael Fatica: I always say great comment and bragging bad that I didn't say the whole title.
[6:24] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah, but I'm now happy.
[6:27] Kevin Jaeger: I say the whole title, you have to say the whole title.
[6:31] Michael Fatica: There are rules.
[6:32] Bryan Plovsky: That's very true.
[6:33] Bryan Plovsky: So, Michael, we're gonna ask you some questions.
[6:35] Michael Fatica: Okay.
[6:35] Bryan Plovsky: If you don't mind.
[6:36] Michael Fatica: I would love that.
[6:37] Bryan Plovsky: No, let's just start with uh way, way back many centuries ago.
[6:42] Bryan Plovsky: Um apparently, the rumor has it is that you went to Florida State University.
[6:47] Michael Fatica: Go Noles!
[6:48] Bryan Plovsky: Yay! Um we and you've had an interesting kind of road to Broadway.
[6:53] Michael Fatica: We have had a lot of guests come on the show that have not been uh to college or had formal like BFA type of training.
[7:00] Bryan Plovsky: Um, but you have. Can you talk about how the school prepared you to kind of get to where you are now?
[7:06] Michael Fatica: Yes, absolutely. Uh I think the thing that like a BFA program will do for you is that it makes you confident in uh figuring out how to best utilize your own talents. It's it's interesting because you don't in Florida, it's in Tallahassee, Florida, it's a very small city. You don't audition very much.
[7:22] Michael Fatica: And we maybe auditioned once a year and with a callback or two. But Kevin, you went to Florida State University.
[7:31] Kevin Jaeger: This is news to me in mine.
[7:33] Michael Fatica: Is that what that hat is?
[7:35] Kevin Jaeger: I always wear.
[7:37] Michael Fatica: Not today, though.
[7:37] Kevin Jaeger: No, damn wearing the Jaegermeister hat.
[7:39] Michael Fatica: Yeah, the Jaeger Meister.
[7:40] Kevin Jaeger: I'm an extra bro today.
[7:44] Michael Fatica: I've never heard that one before.
[7:46] Kevin Jaeger: No one's ever said that to me.
[7:48] Michael Fatica: Alright.
[7:48] Michael Fatica: Back to Florida. Uh yeah, it's so you don't really get a lot of audition practice. So what I think you get you it does for you is you learn how to be an actor and you learn how to have the skills.
[7:57] Michael Fatica: Uh and then once you sort of enter the theatrical world in New York, you sort of figure it out using those skills how to audition. It's an interesting sort of game you you have to play when you get here.
[8:06] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah.
[8:07] Michael Fatica: Um but the school, I mean, I love Florida State, an amazing experience there, and it is very, very uh good for training sort of triple threats in a way.
[8:14] Michael Fatica: There are people there that can move, you learn how to move with intention, and as an actor, uh, you take a ton of acting class, all the sort of classical styles, take a lot of classical voice. It's just a really good, well-rounded program.
[8:25] Michael Fatica: Um and then all sorts of blossoming flowers come out of it. Some some people are incredible singers, some people are incredible dancers, some people can do all of it, some people you know, you just kind of learn while you're there what's going on.
[8:36] Kevin Jaeger: It's unfortunate for you, yes.
[8:37] Michael Fatica: You came out none of those.
[8:38] Kevin Jaeger: I can't do any of those.
[8:41] Kevin Jaeger: I'm a beautiful point dancer.
[8:45] Michael Fatica: He's wearing his point shoes.
[8:48] Kevin Jaeger: Dainty, delicate flower.
[8:49] Michael Fatica: Yeah. But so you got out of school and you came to New York.
[8:53] Michael Fatica: Well, yes, but first I toured for two years.
[8:55] Bryan Plovsky: Uh I did two.
[8:56] Michael Fatica: With what?
[8:57] Michael Fatica: I did Cats, the Musicale.
[8:59] Bryan Plovsky: Oh, I did.
[9:00] Michael Fatica: Straight out of school. I was here in the States for like a month, and we went to uh the blowup set?
[9:04] Bryan Plovsky: Uh yeah, the blowup set.
[9:06] Michael Fatica: But only for a bit of it. I did a tour for four months, and we also went to South and Central America for three of those months.
[9:10] Kevin Jaeger: Whoa.
[9:11] Michael Fatica: And that was not the blowup set. That was the um basically there was like a wood plank with drops on it.
[9:18] Bryan Plovsky: Oh yeah, it was the traveling set when they couldn't travel the blowup set.
[9:24] Michael Fatica: Um they couldn't take it overseas really.
[9:26] Bryan Plovsky: And you just carried it on your back for you.
[9:28] Michael Fatica: I personally carried it on your back.
[9:31] Kevin Jaeger: Florida State prepared him for that.
[9:32] Michael Fatica: Yeah, yeah.
[9:33] Michael Fatica: It was carrying a keg to the game.
[9:38] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah, so I did that for a few months, and then I did the Beauty and the Beast tour, played LeFou for a year and a few months.
[9:43] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, cool.
[9:44] Michael Fatica: So that and North America?
[9:45] Michael Fatica: In yeah, that was all on North American tour.
[9:47] Michael Fatica: Um and then uh that had another Florida Stater, Sarah Claire Smith.
[9:50] Kevin Jaeger: Hey girl.
[9:51] Michael Fatica: Uh-huh. Um, yeah, and then uh moved here in 2001.
[9:56] Kevin Jaeger: Me too.
[9:57] Michael Fatica: Yes.
[9:57] Kevin Jaeger: Hey!
[9:58] Michael Fatica: And then you started selling papes.
[10:00] Michael Fatica: And then I started selling papes shortly after, yeah.
[10:02] Kevin Jaeger: Four months.
[10:02] Michael Fatica: Paper mill run as well.
[10:03] Bryan Plovsky: No, so I had to just moved here.
[10:06] Michael Fatica: The Papser Mill.
[10:07] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, you have to drink for that one.
[10:09] Michael Fatica: Yeah.
[10:11] Michael Fatica: Um yeah, no, I moved here uh in the spring and I did a few contracts.
[10:15] Michael Fatica: I did a show at the Angmin Theater and then at the Fulton Theater.
[10:18] Kevin Jaeger: Cool.
[10:18] Michael Fatica: Uh so it's in and out.
[10:19] Michael Fatica: I was at the Fulton when they were auditioning for Newsies.
[10:21] Michael Fatica: Uh and actually didn't get the Paper Mill run.
[10:23] Michael Fatica: I was devastated.
[10:24] Michael Fatica: I was in Final Callbacks.
[10:25] Michael Fatica: I absolutely for sure thought I was gonna get it, and then I didn't.
[10:28] Michael Fatica: Um and then uh I remember sitting watching the Thanksgiving Day Parade, watching the Newsies dance, and I was like, ah, I really want to be there.
[10:35] Michael Fatica: I really wish that was me.
[10:36] Bryan Plovsky: Uh and then I they had a few auditions to um add some tracks to the Barbara show.
[10:41] Michael Fatica: So I auditioned for that in the fall.
[10:43] Michael Fatica: And then we started that.
[10:44] Michael Fatica: It started in December, yeah.
[10:45] Bryan Plovsky: That's awesome for the show.
[10:46] Kevin Jaeger: Did you have a newsy name as a swing?
[10:48] Michael Fatica: Oh yeah.
[10:48] Michael Fatica: So mine was Knobs.
[10:50] Kevin Jaeger: Of course.
[10:51] Michael Fatica: And the uh backstory is Bend Knobs and Brooms.
[10:55] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah.
[10:56] Michael Fatica: The backstory is that he was a thief and he could like break into any building and you can get rid of your doorknobs.
[11:02] Kevin Jaeger: Okay.
[11:10] Bryan Plovsky: Do you remember seeing your first Broadway show? Or even what tour that you saw that like kind of like made you addicted to this?
[11:19] Michael Fatica: It was definitely my first Broadway show. I was in Show Choir in middle school.
[11:22] Bryan Plovsky: Okay.
[11:23] Michael Fatica: Where are you from?
[11:24] Michael Fatica: Florida.
[11:24] Bryan Plovsky: Oh.
[11:24] Michael Fatica: From Fort Myers, Florida.
[11:26] Michael Fatica: Um, and it it wasn't a big deal, Show Choir, but we we did perform in the Macy's Day Parade when I was in seventh grade.
[11:32] Kevin Jaeger: Whoa.
[11:32] Michael Fatica: Um do you remember?
[11:34] Michael Fatica: It was a huge deal. Do you remember um they used to have open with the show choir number with kids in white pants, white gloves, and I do remember that.
[11:41] Michael Fatica: I definitely remember that America sings.
[11:42] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[11:43] Michael Fatica: Um our chorus or show choir did that.
[11:46] Kevin Jaeger: You were one of the American singers.
[11:48] Michael Fatica: I sure was.
[11:48] Kevin Jaeger: Oh my god.
[11:49] Michael Fatica: Is that in the first thing in all of your bios?
[11:52] Michael Fatica: Wait, we didn't.
[11:53] Kevin Jaeger: I need to do the intro over the house.
[11:57] Michael Fatica: I do.
[11:58] Michael Fatica: Yeah.
[11:58] Michael Fatica: It actually fits me now as an adult because it really was a good thing.
[12:01] Michael Fatica: Because it was so big.
[12:04] Michael Fatica: So I was always coming to the book.
[12:09] Michael Fatica: America sings to the Maddie, Mississippi.
[12:12] Bryan Plovsky: You're welcome for that.
[12:14] Michael Fatica: Um yes, we did that and I we saw Footloose when I was here.
[12:18] Bryan Plovsky: That was your first show.
[12:18] Michael Fatica: First Barber show that I saw, and I was obsessed with it.
[12:20] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah.
[12:21] Michael Fatica: Uh Jeremy Kushner, yeah, in front of the show.
[12:23] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, yeah, yeah.
[12:24] Michael Fatica: Uh Jennifer Laura Thompson.
[12:26] Kimberly Cooper: Of course.
[12:26] Michael Fatica: People we all know and love.
[12:27] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, fantastic.
[12:28] Michael Fatica: And I I was like hooked after that.
[12:30] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah.
[12:30] Michael Fatica: Oh, awesome.
[12:31] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[12:31] Michael Fatica: So awesome. What's your favorite show?
[12:33] Bryan Plovsky: Oh, that's a hard question.
[12:36] Michael Fatica: I always say top three, or like your favorite right now.
[12:40] Bryan Plovsky: Well, I always I'll just say my my usual answer for that is ragtime because it's the CD that I wore out the absolute most.
[12:46] Michael Fatica: Yeah.
[12:46] Bryan Plovsky: I think the music is unbelievable. I think performances are unbelievable. Um, it's just one of those that I that like if it's it's sort of the most uh uh culturally interesting and beautiful show that I say is my favorite.
[12:59] Michael Fatica: Things that I wore out the most when I was young, I mean Rent.
[13:02] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah, that city is everyone, right?
[13:04] Michael Fatica: Have you heard of it?
[13:05] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah, yeah.
[13:05] Michael Fatica: Um yeah, I have many favorite musicals.
[13:08] Kimberly Cooper: Of course.
[13:09] Michael Fatica: Yeah. Everyone's but mostly with R's only things with R.
[13:12] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[13:14] Michael Fatica: Of course. I will not listen to a single one with that.
[13:17] Kimberly Cooper: Um do you have a favorite experiencing a show that you not necessarily your favorite show, but uh you were just kind of like shook or whatever afterwards.
[13:25] Michael Fatica: Did you say shook?
[13:26] Kimberly Cooper: I did, I'm so sorry.
[13:29] Michael Fatica: Uh you know, I think that my my most uh intense experience was I came here uh while I was in college or just shortly after, maybe I hadn't I didn't live here, but I saw Gypsy with uh Patty Pone and Anti.
[13:45] Bryan Plovsky: Um Isotoner or not?
[13:47] Michael Fatica: I was gonna say, were that was she wearing the isotoners? Was this like poster or injury?
[13:51] Kimberly Cooper: Because you also saw her with their slippery.
[13:52] Michael Fatica: I did, I think.
[13:53] Kimberly Cooper: Okay, I think the purple isotoners remember them, so I imagine it was before that.
[13:56] Michael Fatica: You would have noticed if she was a very good idea.
[13:58] Kimberly Cooper: That would have been the experience you remembered.
[13:59] Michael Fatica: Well, that's a minute.
[14:01] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, oh yeah.
[14:02] Michael Fatica: Like they came out there like, just so you know, due to an ankle injury, Ms. Lapone will be performing in her isotoners.
[14:05] Kimberly Cooper: And I was like, is it an ad for the slipper company?
[14:10] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah.
[14:10] Michael Fatica: They told us exactly what happened.
[14:13] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, yeah. Oh, so was there just like the overall performances?
[14:18] Michael Fatica: It just kind of blew you away. To be honest, it was Lord of Nancy's performance. I you know, I had seen the show. Rumor issue on a Tony. Rumor has it.
[14:24] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah.
[14:24] Michael Fatica: Um I I remember, you know, I I I sort of knew she was. I was I was definitely a Broadway nerd in college. Uh, but I I I'd never seen her. And uh I just thought that what she did with that character was so incredible.
[14:35] Michael Fatica: And of course, all of them, especially of course the three leads, but everybody in the show was fantastic. But I just thought what she did was so good, and I I remember being really surprised by it, which is why it really affected me.
[14:45] Kimberly Cooper: And then you got to work with her years later.
[14:47] Michael Fatica: Yes, twice. I've worked with her two times.
[14:48] Kimberly Cooper: That's crazy.
[14:50] Michael Fatica: Um yeah, uh, she's lovely. Uh we did the Radio City New York Spring Spring Spectacular. I was the assistant choreographer on that.
[14:56] Bryan Plovsky: Uh-oh.
[14:59] Michael Fatica: Yeah. And then we did She Loves Me in the next the next year.
[15:01] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, yeah, yeah. I loved that production so much.
[15:03] Michael Fatica: Thank you. And you beat Hamilton for sick!
[15:06] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah.
[15:09] Michael Fatica: Is that set with it? Take that, Hamilton.
[15:11] Kimberly Cooper: That was that polypocket set is my favorite thing in the world.
[15:13] Michael Fatica: Oh, Poly Pocket. That's what we call it too.
[15:14] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, wait, really?
[15:15] Michael Fatica: Yeah. I think I knew that.
[15:16] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, we had a camera now. It's beautiful.
[15:17] Michael Fatica: Oh, yeah, that's right. Oh, it's a beautiful set.
[15:20] Kimberly Cooper: That's awesome.
[15:20] Michael Fatica: It was automated and it worked. That's the thing. You know, because you also worked on Grand Hug Days.
[15:27] Kimberly Cooper: Let me cry for a second.
[15:28] Michael Fatica: No, I'm kidding. Uh it is, you know, automated.
[15:34] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[15:34] Michael Fatica: Yeah. There are a lot of difficulties about that. That's what was a crazy thing. That was so cool, though.
[15:39] Kimberly Cooper: I'm the ground high show.
[15:40] Michael Fatica: Me too.
[15:41] Kimberly Cooper: By far my favorite experience so far.
[15:43] Michael Fatica: I think it's just what was your character called?
[15:46] Kimberly Cooper: The Chubby Man.
[15:47] Michael Fatica: Yes, of course.
[15:48] Kimberly Cooper: Same as Jonathan.
[15:53] Michael Fatica: I want to see a single called Knobs and the Chubby Man.
[15:55] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[15:57] Michael Fatica: Coming to it. Theater new year.
[15:59] Kimberly Cooper: Well, you know, I was auditioning for a role uh first called Fred, who uh Gerard Canonico played.
[16:05] Michael Fatica: Oh sure.
[16:05] Kimberly Cooper: Um and then they brought me back in um for the role of the deputy, played by Joe Madeiros. Obviously, um, spoiler alert, I didn't get either of those roles.
[16:13] Michael Fatica: Uh but then my agent called and they're like, So we're getting an offer for Groundhog Day, and I was very excited, of course. And then they said, and the role is uh the Chubby Man.
[16:21] Kimberly Cooper: And then I was like, huh.
[16:23] Michael Fatica: Okay, cool. Like I'd never heard of it. I'd never really like, you know, I never read anything about it. I was like, tell me more about it. And they were like, he's just like a it's a uh uh they they called him like a beacon of light. They were like, that's sort of his his he's tried, he's there to be like positive and to enjoy the day. And it was awesome. I wore like a suit that sort of patted me up and had a beer and a wig, and it was it was so fun to play that part.
[16:46] Kimberly Cooper: Because you're a petite gentleman, so like for those of you who are listening to the podcast. Audio.
[16:53] Michael Fatica: Did you cover anyone?
[16:54] Kimberly Cooper: No.
[16:55] Michael Fatica: Oh, so fun. What a fun job.
[16:56] Kimberly Cooper: I was one of the dance captains for the show.
[16:57] Michael Fatica: Oh, that's cool.
[16:58] Kimberly Cooper: So you were we talked a little about newsies, we talked a little bit about Groundhog Day. Sure. Those are two shows that like really resonated opposite with the fans and the stage door. So let's do a little stage door story. Anything that comes to your head that's funny, sincere, heartwarming, whatever you wanted, let us know. But your experience with the stage tour as a as a performer.
[17:18] Michael Fatica: You know, Newsies was incredible because as an ensemble member, a lot of times you come out to the stage door and people who come are like, Who are you? Who did you play? And you know, because it's difficult to recognize people, or sometimes, you know, and share, I have a lot of sort of disguises, so I'll say something, I'll be like, Oh, I played this person. They're like, Who was that? You're like, okay, cool. And you explain more, and they're like, which one? It's like, okay, next. Moving on. Um, uh, but in New Zealies, every person who came out would get applause from the people of the station.
[17:44] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, yeah.
[17:45] Michael Fatica: Which, you know, it's a testament to the fans for that show. It's also a testament to the fact that every character was individual. Yeah. And that's, I think, really special for an ensemble and rare. Uh, and the the fans there knew us. You know, we had and we knew them. You know, we would come in, you'd see uh people who've come to see the show 10, 15 times and ask how they're doing. We'd know where they were going to school or what they're doing, we could have a conversation with them. And that was magic.
[18:10] Kimberly Cooper: Very cool.
[18:11] Michael Fatica: Oh, thank you. Yeah, it was um incredible experience. Let's play a game.
[18:13] Bryan Plovsky: Yay!
[18:14] Michael Fatica: Let's do play a game.
[18:15] Kimberly Cooper: So we're gonna play a quick game of a hands on a hard body.
[18:18] Michael Fatica: So we're gonna put two hands on the table. That's the hard body. It's a categories game. So we usually do a we all rock you beat, and then we go around in a circle and say something in a category. So, for instance, colors would go red, green, blue, red.
[18:35] Kimberly Cooper: Oh no, I repeat.
[18:36] Michael Fatica: Oh no.
[18:38] Kimberly Cooper: You repeat, or you stutter, or you like miss up, miss up, mess up.
[18:42] Michael Fatica: Yes, you put one hand up. That's your dirty hand. When you put two hands up, you're out. We play till one person wins. Okay. And then if you get out, you get to pick the next category. I will pick the first one. And today's game of hands on a hard body is brought to you by goldstar.com.
[18:58] Bryan Plovsky: Oh.
[18:59] Michael Fatica: Where you can get tickets to anything in New York, outside of New York concert, concert, concert concerts.
[19:05] Kimberly Cooper: Ooh, I love those.
[19:06] Michael Fatica: Mega concerts of concerts. Theater concerts, dance activities, apparently speed dating, Kevin told us at some point.
[19:14] Kevin Jaeger: They have the gay, like professional speed dating, they have gay men with scruff speed dating.
[19:19] Michael Fatica: Sign me up for both of those.
[19:20] Bryan Plovsky: I know. I was like, yes, we have 1250. Yes, I'm gonna do that. They also have two different Fifty Shades of Grey parodies listed on their website right now that are taking place in May in two different places. One like in Virginia and Indianapolis. If one of them isn't cast with fully drag queens, then it's just 50 shades of gay.
[19:38] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, I'm not playing.
[19:39] Michael Fatica: I'm not playing.
[19:40] Kimberly Cooper: How long have you held on to that?
[19:42] Michael Fatica: I told you these rules before.
[19:43] Kimberly Cooper: You made that joke in your head.
[19:46] Michael Fatica: I did. I'm gonna make this happen.
[19:48] Kimberly Cooper: So to commemorate 50 shades, um, our first round is gonna be 50 shades of Dolly Levi.
[19:53] Michael Fatica: So just actresses of Dolly.
[19:56] Kimberly Cooper: Dalet.
[19:57] Michael Fatica: Um actresses who've played Dolly.
[19:59] Kimberly Cooper: Okay. Uh I'll go.
[20:03] Michael Fatica: Bett Midler.
[20:06] Kimberly Cooper: Donna Murphy.
[20:08] Michael Fatica: Ooh.
[20:09] Kimberly Cooper: Carol Channing.
[20:10] Michael Fatica: I love that she was third.
[20:11] Kimberly Cooper: Bernadette, Peter's.
[20:14] Michael Fatica: Betty Buckley.
[20:17] Kimberly Cooper: Pearl Bailey.
[20:18] Michael Fatica: Yeah.
[20:20] Kimberly Cooper: Suzanne Struthers.
[20:22] Michael Fatica: Does she?
[20:23] Kimberly Cooper: Sure.
[20:23] Michael Fatica: Her name is Sally Stranders.
[20:26] Kimberly Cooper: Does she?
[20:26] Michael Fatica: I don't think she did me.
[20:29] Kimberly Cooper: Which is great because I didn't have an answer.
[20:32] Michael Fatica: I got Suzanne Summers and Sally Struthers.
[20:36] Kimberly Cooper: You mixed up in my head.
[20:37] Michael Fatica: They're different people. I thought Pearl Bailey was gonna be like my in the pocket one. And then you pulled that out. I was like, damn.
[20:42] Kimberly Cooper: That's our fluid. That's why I had to pull out a blonde-haired woman from a man.
[20:55] Michael Fatica: I have one hand up. It's in the picket category. I'm gonna go with uh share movies.
[21:00] Kimberly Cooper: Movies?
[21:01] Michael Fatica: Yeah, movies.
[21:02] Kimberly Cooper: There's more than two?
[21:03] Michael Fatica: Yes.
[21:03] Kimberly Cooper: Okay. You have to go first, though, right?
[21:05] Michael Fatica: Sure. I'll go with the easy one. Moonstruck.
[21:10] Kimberly Cooper: Tea with Mussolini.
[21:12] Michael Fatica: Burlesque?
[21:14] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[21:15] Michael Fatica: Mask.
[21:16] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[21:18] Michael Fatica: Silkwood.
[21:21] Kimberly Cooper: Uh me a two!
[21:23] Michael Fatica: What?
[21:26] Kimberly Cooper: I stuck it in there.
[21:27] Michael Fatica: Malcolmia too.
[21:28] Kimberly Cooper: Oh.
[21:29] Michael Fatica: No idea.
[21:31] Kimberly Cooper: I was out too.
[21:33] Michael Fatica: Mermaids.
[21:34] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, mermaids. That was my extra merch.
[21:36] Michael Fatica: Oh, I should. I should have known.
[21:37] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, and then uh, which is the V Switch.
[21:39] Michael Fatica: Yeah, uh huh.
[21:40] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, yeah. I'm gonna be fired.
[21:42] Michael Fatica: Also, London?
[21:45] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, yeah.
[21:45] Michael Fatica: Yes. So Kim and I have one hand up. It's also my turn.
[21:47] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, if she is winning.
[21:49] Michael Fatica: Yeah. Okay. Triple through it. Drinking and playing games.
[21:56] Kimberly Cooper: We're real good at that.
[21:57] Michael Fatica: Yeah. Um, oh, okay. Um, college drinking games.
[22:01] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, okay.
[22:05] Michael Fatica: Kings.
[22:07] Kimberly Cooper: Beer pond.
[22:08] Michael Fatica: Cool.
[22:10] Kimberly Cooper: Darts.
[22:12] Michael Fatica: Flip cup.
[22:15] Kimberly Cooper: Quarters.
[22:16] Michael Fatica: Oh yeah.
[22:17] Kimberly Cooper: Strip poker.
[22:20] Michael Fatica: Suck and blow.
[22:22] Kimberly Cooper: Power hour?
[22:23] Michael Fatica: Yeah, sure.
[22:24] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[22:30] Michael Fatica: Did you guys play fool?
[22:31] Kimberly Cooper: You?
[22:32] Michael Fatica: Yeah, we do.
[22:33] Kimberly Cooper: Okay, I didn't want to say it.
[22:35] Michael Fatica: Kimberly's out.
[22:36] Kimberly Cooper: And out, so I'll give you my last round category from me before.
[22:40] Michael Fatica: Um, again to tie in with our sponsor Gold Star.
[22:43] Kimberly Cooper: Sure.
[22:44] Michael Fatica: Uh, you can buy tickets to the prom on Gold Star.
[22:46] Kimberly Cooper: Okay, so good.
[22:47] Michael Fatica: But not your prom in high school. The prom on Broadway.
[22:53] Kimberly Cooper: But imagine the three of you that you're on the prom committee. So um, give us some prom expenses.
[23:01] Michael Fatica: Okay.
[23:04] Kimberly Cooper: Sure.
[23:04] Michael Fatica: Got it. A tux.
[23:10] Kimberly Cooper: A limousine.
[23:11] Michael Fatica: A limousine.
[23:13] Kimberly Cooper: Uh corsage.
[23:15] Michael Fatica: A flask.
[23:18] Kimberly Cooper: Book mirror.
[23:20] Michael Fatica: Oh yeah.
[23:20] Kimberly Cooper: A hotel room.
[23:23] Michael Fatica: Car gel.
[23:24] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[23:25] Michael Fatica: Yeah. Also, like cool.
[23:27] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, I see.
[23:29] Michael Fatica: Uh punch.
[23:31] Kimberly Cooper: A band.
[23:32] Michael Fatica: Good one.
[23:33] Kimberly Cooper: Unless you get a DJ.
[23:37] Michael Fatica: Speakers.
[23:39] Kimberly Cooper: Security?
[23:42] Michael Fatica: Totally.
[23:43] Kimberly Cooper: Shoes.
[23:43] Michael Fatica: Uh-huh.
[23:46] Kimberly Cooper: Prom stuff.
[23:50] Michael Fatica: So you get to pick now, Kevin.
[23:51] Kevin Jaeger: I do. Um, this category is going to be Tony Award winning women.
[23:58] Michael Fatica: Okay.
[23:59] Kevin Jaeger: Just any woman that has won a Tony Award for anything.
[24:01] Michael Fatica: Okay.
[24:03] Kevin Jaeger: Do I have to start?
[24:04] Michael Fatica: Yes.
[24:05] Kevin Jaeger: The men in the room. Laura Bonante.
[24:07] Michael Fatica: Oh no.
[24:08] Kevin Jaeger: Jane Krakowski.
[24:11] Michael Fatica: Patty Lapone.
[24:14] Kevin Jaeger: Christine Eversoll.
[24:17] Michael Fatica: Audrey McDonald.
[24:20] Michael Fatica: Uh Julie Tamore.
[24:23] Michael Fatica: Angela Lansbury.
[24:27] Michael Fatica: Ah!
[24:29] Michael Fatica: There are too many options.
[24:31] Michael Fatica: You're like Chipotle.
[24:32] Michael Fatica: Like, no, no.
[24:34] Michael Fatica: So wait, does everyone have one hand up now?
[24:36] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[24:36] Bryan Plovsky: Yeah.
[24:37] Michael Fatica: Should we do a sudden death round?
[24:39] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[24:39] Michael Fatica: I think so.
[24:40] Kimberly Cooper: Okay.
[24:41] Michael Fatica: Wait, who just got out?
[24:41] Kimberly Cooper: It was me.
[24:42] Michael Fatica: Oh.
[24:43] Kimberly Cooper: You guys pick a category for sudden death.
[24:44] Michael Fatica: So if you get out, you just step away and you keep going.
[24:47] Kimberly Cooper: I'm gonna say choreographers.
[24:50] Michael Fatica: Okay.
[24:50] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[24:51] Michael Fatica: Pick something you know you'll win.
[24:53] Kimberly Cooper: Chris Catelley.
[24:56] Michael Fatica: Warren Carlisle.
[24:59] Kimberly Cooper: Tommy Toon.
[25:02] Michael Fatica: Dennis Jones.
[25:05] Kimberly Cooper: Bob Fossey.
[25:11] Michael Fatica: I'm backing away.
[25:13] Kimberly Cooper: Okay.
[25:14] Michael Fatica: Andy Bike and Beeler.
[25:18] Kimberly Cooper: Connect us.
[25:19] Michael Fatica: Dan connect us.
[25:20] Kimberly Cooper: Oh.
[25:21] Michael Fatica: Who?
[25:21] Kimberly Cooper: Oh no!
[25:23] Michael Fatica: Peter Darling.
[25:26] Kimberly Cooper: Spencer Liff.
[25:29] Michael Fatica: Robbie Roy.
[25:32] Kimberly Cooper: Michael Bennett out of Ricard.
[25:36] Michael Fatica: Oh my god, I'm blanking!
[25:40] Kimberly Cooper: You in the game.
[25:44] Michael Fatica: It's embarrassing.
[25:44] Kimberly Cooper: I thought I went in the that one in the back.
[25:46] Michael Fatica: That's okay.
[25:47] Kimberly Cooper: I thought you were gonna just start pulling out you and your friends' names.
[25:49] Michael Fatica: Like just like.
[25:50] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, right, I wish.
[25:53] Michael Fatica: I should have said Aaron Gialbano.
[25:54] Kimberly Cooper: No.
[25:55] Michael Fatica: Oh yeah.
[25:56] Kimberly Cooper: Well, that was dirty hands on a hard body.
[25:59] Michael Fatica: And again, that round of dirty hands on a hard body was brought to you by Goldstar.com.
[26:03] Kimberly Cooper: Make sure you go to goldstar.com backslash broadwaisted to get discount tickets to concert concerts, etc.
[26:09] Michael Fatica: And use our code Broadwaisted all capital letters at checkout for a $10 off.
[26:14] Kimberly Cooper: Do it.
[26:15] Michael Fatica: It's a prize because you won this game.
[26:17] Kimberly Cooper: So let's talk about Cher a little bit.
[26:19] Michael Fatica: Okay.
[26:19] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[26:20] Michael Fatica: Sharing is caring.
[26:21] Kimberly Cooper: Certainly.
[26:22] Michael Fatica: We had such a good time.
[26:22] Kimberly Cooper: We had a great time.
[26:23] Michael Fatica: Oh, great.
[26:24] Kimberly Cooper: Oh my god, we loved it so much.
[26:25] Michael Fatica: Um, so you were in it in Chicago.
[26:27] Kimberly Cooper: I was.
[26:28] Michael Fatica: And you moved with it here.
[26:29] Kimberly Cooper: Yep.
[26:29] Michael Fatica: Um, can you talk a little bit about a Chicago audience versus a New York audience, especially when you're doing the same type of show, and like because they know in Chicago that this is a tryout, like, is it there more forgiving feel to it?
[26:43] Michael Fatica: Yes. Um, there's two sort of major components in that. First of all, the theater in Chicago is much bigger.
[26:50] Kimberly Cooper: Where were you in Chicago?
[26:51] Michael Fatica: The uh it's now called the Nederlander Theater. Uh the Oriental.
[26:55] Kimberly Cooper: Sure.
[26:55] Michael Fatica: Recently renamed.
[26:56] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[26:56] Michael Fatica: Um, but it's a touring house. Um, and so they're huge. It was like uh it's probably a thousand or so more people than right we have here.
[27:03] Kimberly Cooper: So the audience feels much further away.
[27:06] Michael Fatica: So it's sort of that wall of sound you kind of have to push through. So the response time is is it feels slower, it doesn't feel quite as intimate.
[27:14] Kimberly Cooper: Okay, and that's just a product of the house.
[27:16] Michael Fatica: That sort of happens on any touring show, too. Um also the show was much different there. Um we had a we can talk about that too, but it was a it was a um it was a different sort of linear line of the show.
[27:27] Michael Fatica: It was based in variety. There were you were seeing a variety show be filmed on stage, was the sort of concept. You were watching that happen. So uh um just in general, it's hard to compare A to B. Um but you know, the audience was very forgiving. Chicago was a great audience. People came uh and loved the show for its theatricality, and some people are huge Cher fans, so they came with that energy.
[27:50] Michael Fatica: So it really depended. And we did not end the show the way we do here, which is uh a finale concert. So it didn't get as raucous at the end.
[27:56] Kimberly Cooper: Sure.
[27:59] Michael Fatica: By any means. So that was uh it does now it's certainly the disco balls. Um yeah, the Chicago audience was great though. They were really forgiving and um I wouldn't say forgiving, they were just they were open to see to um see what the show was about.
[28:13] Michael Fatica: And I think they understand that a lot of times they're watching new shows be made uh and I think there's a bit of privilege to that in a in a great way they come s excited to see a new show before it's done being made yeah and that's a really cool thing about being an audience member in a city where that happens you know Seattle LA Chicago yeah I mean you get to see the inception of the show before it really has finished you get insider knowledge yeah totally yeah and a lot of people have come from Chicago to see the show here and that's awesome are at the stage door and they'll say oh my god I love this part or I missed this part or this is so much better or this you know this I'm I wish this song was still in it you know everyone has an opinion and now you you in the show not not only do you play uh multiple actual roles but you also cover the role of Sonny I do now uh is it different when you're covering a role like this when you also have like your own specific roles in the show because like you're not just an ensemble member you're like a featured ensemble member with your own like specific roles so like had was that a different experience like creating roles that you know are gonna be like definitive and you but also trying to create yeah I I think that that's really a lucky thing to be able to do uh and Jason Moore our director was very open in just letting us run with whatever we wanted to do and then sort of uh focusing that um so and I I am lucky to be able to play a few different roles so I wanted to really differentiate them.
[29:36] Michael Fatica: Um and so that was fun coming up with kind of uh a spin on each one so that they didn't sound like the same person in a way but you could sort of you know obviously you can tell it's me.
[29:44] Kimberly Cooper: Um and you play a you play someone who's a real person.
[29:48] Michael Fatica: Yes, Phil Spector.
[29:49] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, so what was that like playing a character that's like an actual person that people know.
[29:54] Michael Fatica: Well, uh it's funny because Phil Spector, uh, if you don't know, is currently in jail.
[29:59] Kimberly Cooper: Um and they had to get his permission to um have his name taken the show.
[30:04] Michael Fatica: Yeah. Uh and there's very few uh there are very few videos that you can find of Phil Spector where he's a young man.
[30:10] Kimberly Cooper: So you went to meet him in jail.
[30:11] Michael Fatica: Yeah, how was that?
[30:11] Michael Fatica: Absolutely went to jail.
[30:16] Michael Fatica: My day a whole documentary.
[30:18] Michael Fatica: Yeah, absolutely. It'll be about in 2020.
[30:20] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[30:21] Michael Fatica: Um well you he went to jail for murdering someone.
[30:24] Kimberly Cooper: So Phil he went off the deep end a bit.
[30:26] Michael Fatica: Uh and uh that where you see him in the show is early.
[30:30] Kimberly Cooper: So obviously you're yeah, so I can't legally talk about that.
[30:34] Michael Fatica: Um bound by a lot of things.
[30:37] Michael Fatica: Uh no, he uh the character is is interesting because he's very quirky.
[30:41] Michael Fatica: So you find all these videos of him, you know, at his trial or at his um there, you know, there's a documentary sort of made about him where you see him sort of later in life.
[30:50] Michael Fatica: But I found one video with the help of our associate, Travis Chrysler, associate director.
[30:54] Michael Fatica: Uh he we found a video of him on the Merv Griffin show.
[30:57] Kimberly Cooper: Cool.
[30:57] Michael Fatica: Where he was uh um sort of a squirrely little guy, uh poking some real daggers at Eartha Kitt.
[31:05] Michael Fatica: Uh and he, you know, I I kind of grabbed to him being very uh a bit caustic in his humor, and we kind of went that way with it, which was you know interesting.
[31:15] Michael Fatica: But you know, Phil Spector, he's on stage a lot here in New York.
[31:18] Michael Fatica: He was in Donna Summer, uh Woman.
[31:21] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[31:21] Michael Fatica: Uh and uh, you know, you mentioned him in Beautiful, and I'm sure he'll be mentioned in the Temptations musical.
[31:27] Michael Fatica: So uh, you know, he's around.
[31:28] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, cool.
[31:29] Michael Fatica: And the other two And you play him in every show?
[31:31] Michael Fatica: Yeah, I do.
[31:32] Michael Fatica: Yeah I'll be I am He runs from theaters.
[31:34] Michael Fatica: I was in Donna Summer as well as a woman.
[31:36] Kimberly Cooper: No.
[31:37] Michael Fatica: Um, uh yeah, I feel Phil wants if you need a Phil Spector, it's my my MO.
[31:41] Michael Fatica: Uh but no, I also play a a British talk show host who that's sort of just uh I wouldn't say stereotype, but sort of taken of the the schmarmy sort of uh lecherous side of that era of TV hosts.
[31:54] Michael Fatica: Um and then Sid the Censor is like a little nerdy censor who does not like that Cher is not wearing any clothes.
[32:01] Michael Fatica: Uh and then an infomercial director who's very rookie, you know, just doesn't have any time.
[32:07] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[32:07] Michael Fatica: Uh a little little known fact for those of you who saw the show in Chicago.
[32:11] Michael Fatica: I used to open the show lip singing as a stage manager as Cher, which was a blast.
[32:17] Kimberly Cooper: And I'm sorry, it's just like you behind like backstage things.
[32:22] Michael Fatica: I had a few inceptions, but uh no, we we started the show as if we were making her concert uh and it was to turn back time.
[32:27] Michael Fatica: Um or not turn back time, it was um uh to believe.
[32:31] Michael Fatica: Uh and so the guys were dancing, and then Cher was supposed to show up, and uh Michael Bress, who played uh our director, Frank, comes in and he's like, Well, where's Cher? Where's Cher?
[32:39] Michael Fatica: And he looked at uh me, who was another stage manager, and he's like, Oh, we just need someone to stand in, you stand in.
[32:44] Michael Fatica: And then he'd start to lip sing, um, not really committing to it, and then starts to like the attention of the guys around him.
[32:51] Michael Fatica: Get into it and really go for it.
[32:53] Kimberly Cooper: Cool.
[32:55] Michael Fatica: Um, but you you also dance a lot in the show.
[32:57] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[32:57] Michael Fatica: I guess from a dancer, you news ease from a dancer's perspective, what's your warm-up like? Because you do a lot of dancing.
[33:02] Michael Fatica: Well, it depends on the show, I have to say, but with Cher, it's really nice because it warms up in the movement as we go.
[33:09] Michael Fatica: So I do a warm up, uh, I do a little uh really basic, like, you know, calf quad, hamstring, stretch, and I'll like get my neck going a little bit.
[33:18] Michael Fatica: But really, uh turn back time, our opening number is not uh super heavy for the guys, so I you kind of take that take it easy through that.
[33:26] Michael Fatica: It's sort of like old 80s jazz flowy movement.
[33:29] Michael Fatica: Uh and then I don't really dance until the end of Act One because then I play all these characters sort of in a row.
[33:34] Michael Fatica: So uh the you just kind of get going through the show, and then uh I'll do a little, you know, I do a little shoulder and arm warm-up uh before bang bang, which is when we really come back on because I uh lift the beautiful atmosphere.
[33:45] Kimberly Cooper: Is that the jar go?
[33:46] Michael Fatica: Uh no, that's uh it's the women are dressed in the like uh leather, bra and thong, moment.
[33:53] Kimberly Cooper: Uh-huh.
[33:53] Michael Fatica: Uh-huh. It's a it's a concert, and the guys come out in our um leather thongs as well.
[33:57] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[33:58] Michael Fatica: Come see the Cher show. We have collars and all.
[34:00] Michael Fatica: Uh but we come out, it's you know, that's a music video moment, so that's when I dance again.
[34:05] Michael Fatica: But you know, with newsies, I would do a 15-20 minute sort of ballet warm-up, and she loves me.
[34:10] Michael Fatica: I wasn't on stage for a full hour, so I would have a full time to warm up.
[34:14] Michael Fatica: I'd go down to the the VIP suite, they call it at 54 below, um, and hang out with the bartenders and do a full like, you know, cardio warm-up just to stay in shape, really.
[34:24] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[34:24] Michael Fatica: Yeah, but for Cher it kind of does it for us, which is a good thing.
[34:26] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, cool.
[34:27] Michael Fatica: That's interesting that you're that way.
[34:29] Michael Fatica: We do have one dancer, Ashley Fitzgerald, who plays The Dark Lady, she's a tango.
[34:32] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, she does a full ballet bar.
[34:34] Michael Fatica: Oh, it's a great number.
[34:35] Kimberly Cooper: She's amazing.
[34:36] Michael Fatica: She's she's incredible.
[34:37] Kimberly Cooper: And the audience.
[34:37] Michael Fatica: And yeah, she would have to do a full ballet bar.
[34:41] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, great.
[34:42] Michael Fatica: It's so good.
[34:42] Kimberly Cooper: Speaking of the audience, what type of reactions have you seen?
[34:45] Michael Fatica: Like we had Jared's Really, who was in the Donna Summer musical on, and he talked a little bit about the ru the craziness of the audience.
[34:50] Kimberly Cooper: Like, what do you sing at the Cher show?
[34:52] Michael Fatica: They sing it along.
[34:53] Kimberly Cooper: Well, they sure are.
[34:54] Michael Fatica: Depends on the day.
[34:55] Kimberly Cooper: And it really depends on the day, you know.
[34:56] Michael Fatica: Sometimes the show the audience they well, they feed each other, really.
[34:59] Michael Fatica: Sometimes they come in really ready to rock, and you can really tell as soon as the show starts.
[35:03] Michael Fatica: When they hear that turn back time beat start, uh when the audience starts to yell, we know that it's gonna be a uh a big show.
[35:11] Michael Fatica: The audience is gonna be a big part of that reaction.
[35:13] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[35:13] Michael Fatica: Uh and sometimes it is a very theatrical audience where they're coming to see her story, and it it does feel like you're doing a musical rather than a concert.
[35:21] Michael Fatica: But uh a few days ago, um we had one of the loudest audiences we've ever had, and they were up on their feet at the end of the show dancing for the full seven-minute number.
[35:30] Michael Fatica: Just like every time, you know, Cher would have a moment, some people would yell out, be like, You got it, girl.
[35:35] Michael Fatica: Yell back to the stage.
[35:37] Michael Fatica: And we do break the fourth wall, or Cher does.
[35:39] Michael Fatica: So Stephanie J. Block, who plays our uh star character, she um she can feed that, she can talk back to them if she wants to.
[35:47] Michael Fatica: There are definitely built-in moments for her to accept that reaction from the audience.
[35:51] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, not to not to promote that it you should talk through the whole show, obviously, but um it it is a it is an interesting audience in the way that they relate to the music differently than a musical audience, right?
[36:02] Michael Fatica: You know, they come with a knowledge of what it's gonna be.
[36:04] Kimberly Cooper: Sure.
[36:05] Michael Fatica: Um, and I've never done a jukebox musical before.
[36:07] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, and so that is a new experience for me too.
[36:10] Michael Fatica: And I was swung out of the show to watch uh uh Sonny Bono, Jared Specter, uh, and the people around me were talking the whole time, which is interesting.
[36:20] Michael Fatica: It wasn't rude though, they were just every time they were to remember something, or they'd be like, Oh my god, I remember this moment.
[36:25] Michael Fatica: Oh, I got you that's my favorite song. They would give a little there was a conversation going from their memory. Bryan and I had a similar moment when we saw Beautiful: The Carole King Musical. There was like a woman in front of us with her son, like adult son, and every time a different song started, she would turn and tell her son like what that made her remember, like what part of her life. And it like it wasn't disruptive because it was almost like a really sweet, like it's almost like a nice tapestry.
[36:50] Kevin Jaeger: No shit.
[36:51] Michael Fatica: No.
[36:52] Kevin Jaeger: We're gonna give a slow golf.
[36:56] Bryan Plovsky: Oh, bro.
[36:57] Michael Fatica: That's bad. So Cher premiered in Chicago.
[37:00] Kevin Jaeger: Yes.
[37:01] Michael Fatica: It's now on Broadway.
[37:02] Kevin Jaeger: Yes.
[37:03] Michael Fatica: Um, but we should go one other place.
[37:05] Kevin Jaeger: We should go one other place.
[37:06] Michael Fatica: Do you want to come with us?
[37:06] Kevin Jaeger: I would love to.
[37:07] Michael Fatica: Do you want to go to there?
[37:08] Kevin Jaeger: I would love to.
[37:10] Kevin Jaeger: Tuesdays in the corner with Kevin.
[37:15] Kevin Jaeger: Michael, welcome to Kevin's Corner, where I have three highly researched questions about you based on things I found out on the internet.
[37:21] Michael Fatica: I'm terrified.
[37:22] Kevin Jaeger: And um, we're gonna just go down a weird rabbit hole and see what you have to say for these answers. So here we go. Number one. You are currently appearing in The Cher Show, where you play a character named Phil Spector and understudy a role played by actor Jared Spector, who, spoiler alert, comes back and talks to Cher as a ghost. So he's a Spectre played by a Spectre, while you also play a different Spectre. None of this has anything to do with Regina Spektor, who is a Russian-born American singer, songwriter, and pianist who appears with Fenfolds on the Hamilton Mixtapes album singing "Dear Theodosia." Great. I'm going to say it again. I think it would be brilliant if "Dear Theodosia" became "Dear Evan Hansen," and it was a song for the mom to sing while she's watching Evan sleep, and Connor's dad sings while he's staring at Connor's empty bed. I think that would be really brilliant, and they should just let them borrow that song and make that happen. Please do.
[38:15] Michael Fatica: Bedknobs on Broomsticks is a brilliant 1971 American musical fantasy film starring David Tomlinson and the incomparable queen of everything, Angela Lansbury. Angela is on my short list of favorite female diva inspirations. So my question is who are the divas on your inspiration list?
[38:34] Michael Fatica: Oh wow. What a long-winded question. Welcome. Oh, I love a diva. Are you kidding? It depends on my era of life, I have to say. My college diva was Shoshana Bean.
[38:45] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, yeah.
[38:46] Michael Fatica: So good. I think my all-time diva was, uh, oh, Marin Mazzie. Just so you know, Ragtime's my jam.
[38:53] Kevin Jaeger: Oh my gosh.
[38:54] Michael Fatica: Those are musicals! Um, oh man, other divas, let's see. Well, I mean, Stephanie J. Block's a diva, and she's always I'm a fan of her. She's incredible. Um, you get to laugh in her face eight times a week. Take that, SJP. No, she's really cool and sings her face off. Uh, and also, you know, a huge diva inspiration, I'd say, uh, was I saw Eden Espinoza in Brooklyn. I saw that. Followed her to the letter of whatever she sang, so I thought she was incredible.
[39:23] Kevin Jaeger: So good.
[39:24] Michael Fatica: Oh, I mean, I could list the divas for days.
[39:26] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, divas for days. I like that.
[39:28] Michael Fatica: Just Alphabet's. Only Alphabet.
[39:29] Kevin Jaeger: Only if you played Alpha Bass.
[39:32] Michael Fatica: Oh, that's to be true. All right, question two. You appeared in The Sting at our fave Paper Mill Playhouse.
[39:42] Michael Fatica: Yeah. A musical version of the famous Robert Redford, Paul Newman movie that my parents made me and my siblings watch all the time as kids. And my mom would always point out the exact moment in the movie that she says she fell in love with Paul Newman in the movie theater, shouting, "Look at those eyes." I mean, come on, look at them. As my dad yells, "Yeah, well, you're lucky I never met Andie MacDowell." Because if my parents actually had a hall pass list of like who they could hook up with and not get in trouble, my dad's number one would randomly be Andie MacDowell because he's always had a thing for her. And my brother and I always make fun of him because her southern accent is so pronounced, so much so that she appeared in Tarzan and Jane and they had a British actress dub all of her lines. I know because she couldn't speak English.
[40:22] Michael Fatica: I did not know that.
[40:23] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah. Yeah. But he's obsessed with her. Like she's in all those like Neutrogena, like revitalizing commercials. My dad's like, "Oh, I love her so much." My mom just gets mad, so they're weird. So my question is if you had to cast a fantasy musical version of the movie How to Lose a Guy in Ten Days.
[40:42] Michael Fatica: Oh yeah. Who would you cast as number one, Andy Anderson, played by Kate Hudson?
[40:46] Kevin Jaeger: Of course.
[40:47] Michael Fatica: Oh, who would I cast that? Yeah, who would you cast?
[40:49] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, okay. Uh, well, Annaleigh Ashford.
[40:51] Michael Fatica: Yes, 100%. Perfect choice. Who would be Benjamin Barry, who's Matthew McConaughey?
[40:56] Kevin Jaeger: Okay.
[40:57] Michael Fatica: Um, P.S. It's Andy Anderson and Benjamin Barry. I've never put that together.
[41:01] Kevin Jaeger: I never until I wrote that out. I was like, wow, that's disgusting, but I love it.
[41:04] Michael Fatica: It's a rom-com.
[41:05] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah. So who, yeah, who is Andy Carl?
[41:08] Michael Fatica: Perfect. Great. He loves those rom-coms.
[41:11] Kevin Jaeger: He sure does. Michelle, who's Catherine Hahn. She's like the zany friend who pretends to be the couples' therapist.
[41:17] Michael Fatica: Oh right. Okay, Catherine Hahn. Well, I want to say. Um, Jesse Mueller.
[41:29] Kevin Jaeger: Down with that.
[41:30] Michael Fatica: That's actually great. Uh, Jeannie, who is by Annie Parisse. It's like an exotic Samantha type, like from like Sex in the City. So she's like the like smart mouth like sex pot.
[41:41] Kevin Jaeger: A smart mouth sex pot.
[41:41] Michael Fatica: This is not appropriate, but I'd like to see Audra McDonald stretch her bearings and do that.
[41:47] Kevin Jaeger: Oh my god, I would actually.
[41:50] Michael Fatica: And then the next one is, uh, Lana, Lana Jang, who is uh, baby New Earth.
[41:56] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, well, can't she play it?
[41:58] Michael Fatica: Yeah. What are you talking about? That's a good choice. So yeah, she's perfect. No, let's have Angie Schworer play that. She's now in The Prom.
[42:06] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, yes. I love her.
[42:07] Michael Fatica: She's made her possible star, didn't you say?
[42:09] Kevin Jaeger: 100%. What's it was Zaz?
[42:12] Michael Fatica: Zaz.
[42:16] Kevin Jaeger: I love it. Now that's question two. So we'll move on to question one. I can't believe, first of all, you didn't connect the Audra McDonald to Groundhog Day.
[42:22] Michael Fatica: Yeah, that's what I was thinking. I thought that's what I was going. I was going to, but then I just, I don't know. I went to 10 things.
[42:28] Kevin Jaeger: How does it got in 10 days?
[42:29] Michael Fatica: So you're welcome. Uh, number three. You and I both attended Florida State University.
[42:34] Kevin Jaeger: Good old, where we appeared in Sweeney Todd together.
[42:37] Michael Fatica: Oh you as Toby and me as a member of the ensemble. We've heard some tales. My guys got shaved like during like the like when he's competing against Pirelli. I got to be shaved. It was a whole thing.
[42:49] Kevin Jaeger: Did they actually shave you?
[42:50] Michael Fatica: No, they just put like just the first night. Shaving cream on my face.
[42:55] Kevin Jaeger: No, I didn't have a beard back in college. This is like a post-college.
[42:58] Michael Fatica: He was a little I was a little baby-faced. So they put like brown, we put like brown stuff on my face, so then when they shaved it, it like came off. It was like a whole thing. High budget.
[43:08] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, but I was, but yeah, he he was uh Michael was a principal. He was Toby. And I was a member of the ensemble.
[43:15] Michael Fatica: Excuse me. Did you get a shock wig?
[43:18] Kevin Jaeger: I didn't know that.
[43:19] Michael Fatica: I don't want to imagine.
[43:22] Kevin Jaeger: Like full on like uh like Albert Einstein wig.
[43:25] Michael Fatica: It was perfect. I'm sure it was from Ricky's.
[43:30] Kevin Jaeger: Now, ensemble learning in statistics or machine learning means using multiple learning algorithms to obtain better predictive performance than could be obtained from any other constituent learning algorithms alone.
[43:41] Michael Fatica: I don't know the horse.
[43:43] Kevin Jaeger: Right. Alone is a really stupid way to watch a horror film because you have no one to bring you back to reality, so to speak, since you're so scared. So your mind starts playing tricks on you. So your question is what are some of your tricks for staying centered, grounded, and happy in your personal life as you live your best performer life on eight shows a week on Broadway?
[44:04] Michael Fatica: Alcohol.
[44:09] Kevin Jaeger: 100%.
[44:17] Michael Fatica: Strong supports. And um, you know, when you're having a terrible day that you can call and say I fell down on stage or I, you know, did something extremely stupid, or you're I'm overwhelmed with the people around me and then they slap you and tell you to get over it. So that's Snap out of it. Um then uh also just having a life outside of your job. I think it's so important. You know, because we all do that in any job. You need uh you know, a nine to fiver goes to work and then you know, sort of has to have a different life. You know, my sister, uh, she's a scientist and she's just not allowed to work other than the hours that she's there because she has to sign into her computer. So you you're required to have other things to do, really.
[45:01] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah.
[45:01] Michael Fatica: Um and that's I think so hard to do as a as a theater professional in any way because it takes so much mental energy, so much time, you have to be conditioning your body, you're always working on you know, new audition material, new whatever. You're just always doing something. So you I think it's so good to have other interests and like make yourself actively do them.
[45:23] Kevin Jaeger: Cool.
[45:23] Michael Fatica: So for me, um, I read, I'm a podcaster actually. I love podcasts. I live in Brooklyn.
[45:28] Kevin Jaeger: Yes.
[45:29] Michael Fatica: Uh so if you live in Brooklyn, you have to podcast. You have to do something on that train ride. But you know, do that. Bike, you know, in the summer. You know, you just have to do stuff that's not actressing or dancing.
[45:42] Kevin Jaeger: Actressing.
[45:43] Michael Fatica: Now I have to go to the gym because of Cher because we don't wear any clothes.
[45:46] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, you've never had clothes on this.
[45:47] Michael Fatica: It's never been a part of my life. Are you in the costume parade?
[45:50] Kevin Jaeger: No.
[45:51] Michael Fatica: Number?
[45:51] Kevin Jaeger: No.
[45:52] Michael Fatica: That's my name. That's all women and this incredibly beautiful man. So you cover him too?
[45:58] Kevin Jaeger: Absolutely.
[46:00] Michael Fatica: Torian and I do change together at one point into the uh bang bang number, which is shirtless. And you know, you he'll be changing.
[46:08] Kevin Jaeger: Well, not for us.
[46:10] Michael Fatica: He's almost like cartoon character built. It's like Hercules, like from Disney built where like he has a tiny waist.
[46:17] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah.
[46:17] Michael Fatica: And then just like gargantuan muscles.
[46:19] Kevin Jaeger: Oh, should we dreamcast him as Hercules in the live action?
[46:22] Michael Fatica: Oh yeah.
[46:24] Kevin Jaeger: Can I be the like little hooved man?
[46:27] Michael Fatica: Danny DeVito part.
[46:29] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah, really relate to that.
[46:30] Michael Fatica: All right. But you don't have this role. We've got all that LaFoo time.
[46:34] Kevin Jaeger: So it's just like LaFoo the Seder.
[46:37] Michael Fatica: That's true.
[46:39] Kevin Jaeger: That's what I'm gonna be for Halloween next year.
[46:41] Michael Fatica: There you go. Um but Torian, you know, I changed next to him, and we'll both have this moment where we look in the mirror and fix things, and you know, it really heightens my self-esteem. Yeah, he comes out in that costume print and I was like, I didn't know that those muscles existed on legs.
[46:56] Kevin Jaeger: Oh my god.
[46:57] Michael Fatica: He just has muscles on top of muscles. I'm like, he has extra. This is fair. He's like the picture, the medical picture of my muscles.
[47:02] Kevin Jaeger: Oh yeah, yes, yes, yeah.
[47:04] Michael Fatica: That's exactly what I'm saying. Why are they labeled his tattoo on top of each one? He is the desktop. He is Gray's Anatomy.
[47:10] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah.
[47:12] Kevin Jaeger: Oh my god. That's been Kevin's corner.
[47:15] Michael Fatica: Yeah.
[47:15] Kevin Jaeger: Thanks, Kevin. That was amazing. Well, let's uh let's play another game.
[47:20] Michael Fatica: Okay.
[47:20] Kevin Jaeger: Okay. So I have just a little round of Celebrity to play.
[47:24] Michael Fatica: Oh, so how Celebrity works is we will do two teams. I guess just me and Kevin.
[47:27] Kevin Jaeger: Cool.
[47:29] Michael Fatica: As we're sitting across from each other. Bryan and I. Let's do this.
[47:31] Kevin Jaeger: Yeah.
[47:33] Michael Fatica: I don't lose.
[47:34] Kevin Jaeger: I have a smattering of Lights of Broadway show cards that I picked at random in this deck.
[47:39] Michael Fatica: Okay.
[47:40] Kevin Jaeger: Um each team will have one minute to try and guess as many as they can. You'll alternate the three rounds. The first round you can say as many things as you want. You just can't say the name of the person on the card.
[47:45] Michael Fatica: Got it.
[47:51] Kevin Jaeger: Obviously. It's like taboo style.
[47:53] Michael Fatica: Yes.
[47:54] Kevin Jaeger: We got the BMs versus the KK's.
[47:56] Michael Fatica: Yeah.
[47:57] Kevin Jaeger: Yes. Interesting.
[48:00] Michael Fatica: Sure.
[48:01] Kevin Jaeger: The second round, you will have to do so with only.
[48:08] Michael Fatica: There's usually a charades round in Celebrity. That obviously does not work on a podcast.
[48:12] Kevin Jaeger: Okay.
[48:22] Michael Fatica: So our second round will be just one word to get through everything.
[48:26] Kevin Jaeger: Okay. Oh gosh.
[48:27] Michael Fatica: The third round will be either like song or noises.
[48:30] Kevin Jaeger: Got it.
[48:31] Michael Fatica: But no actual talking.
[48:32] Kevin Jaeger: Okay, great.
[48:32] Michael Fatica: Great.
[48:33] Kimberly Cooper: And noises round.
[48:34] Michael Fatica: I'm great.
[48:37] Kimberly Cooper: Wheelhouse is noises.
[48:39] Michael Fatica: I make them all the time.
[48:42] Bryan Plovsky: So pick amongst your team who wants to be giving the clues first.
[48:45] Kevin Jaeger: One minute on the clock.
[48:47] Michael Fatica: Okay, I'm ready.
[48:48] Kimberly Cooper: I'm stressed, Bryan.
[48:49] Bryan Plovsky: Okay. I'm letting you know now.
[48:51] Michael Fatica: Um he was in Anastasia.
[48:52] Kimberly Cooper: He was also in Derek Leno?
[48:54] Michael Fatica: Yes.
[48:58] Kimberly Cooper: He yes.
[48:59] Michael Fatica: Oh, he's a director.
[49:00] Kimberly Cooper: He directed Shuffle Along, Angels in America.
[49:02] Bryan Plovsky: Okay. Bring into noise, bring into funk.
[49:04] Kimberly Cooper: Oh.
[49:04] Michael Fatica: Caroliner Change.
[49:06] Kimberly Cooper: Oh God.
[49:06] Michael Fatica: Um.
[49:07] Kimberly Cooper: What is a dog that's in the wild?
[49:10] Michael Fatica: Uh uh uh a mutt.
[49:12] Kimberly Cooper: Not a coyote, but like uh a wolf?
[49:14] Michael Fatica: Yes.
[49:15] Kimberly Cooper: Wolf Blitzer.
[49:19] Michael Fatica: George C. Wolf.
[49:20] Kimberly Cooper: Yes!
[49:20] Michael Fatica: Yes, okay, I'm there.
[49:22] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, of course, Wolf Litzer.
[49:24] Michael Fatica: Oh, another director.
[49:25] Kimberly Cooper: You may know him from Rent.
[49:27] Michael Fatica: Michael Grief?
[49:28] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[49:29] Michael Fatica: Another director.
[49:30] Kimberly Cooper: Okay.
[49:30] Michael Fatica: Um you might know her from Spider-Man.
[49:33] Kimberly Cooper: Or Lion King.
[49:34] Michael Fatica: Um, um, um, um, I I can see her in my face.
[49:37] Kimberly Cooper: Um Blake and Julia.
[49:42] Michael Fatica: Uh what?
[49:44] Kimberly Cooper: Julie Taymor.
[49:45] Michael Fatica: There it is.
[49:46] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, my time is that.
[49:46] Michael Fatica: I was like Romeo Taymor.
[49:48] Kimberly Cooper: Oh my goodness.
[49:51] Kimberly Cooper: So what do we get, you guys?
[49:53] Michael Fatica: Four.
[49:53] Kimberly Cooper: Four.
[49:54] Michael Fatica: Oh, wolf hits her through me.
[49:56] Kimberly Cooper: Okay, we've started out high.
[49:58] Bryan Plovsky: Alright, ready?
[49:58] Michael Fatica: I'm always and go.
[50:02] Kimberly Cooper: Okay.
[50:02] Michael Fatica: Oh.
[50:03] Kimberly Cooper: Uh he was in uh uh Natasha Pierre, Blonde Hair.
[50:07] Michael Fatica: Um sing very high.
[50:08] Kimberly Cooper: Steel?
[50:09] Michael Fatica: Yes, that's the right last name.
[50:11] Kimberly Cooper: Uh Ryan was in Newsies, though.
[50:13] Michael Fatica: Very talented.
[50:13] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, first name, uh, okay, uh, George Blank in Star Wars, directed Star Wars.
[50:17] Michael Fatica: Oh, Lucas Steel.
[50:18] Kimberly Cooper: Yes, that's right.
[50:18] Michael Fatica: Welcome to the over the nerds.
[50:23] Kimberly Cooper: Uh it's based on a movie, French.
[50:24] Michael Fatica: Philip Asso is in it.
[50:26] Kimberly Cooper: Um Ali.
[50:27] Michael Fatica: Yes.
[50:29] Kimberly Cooper: Okay, this is also a musical.
[50:31] Michael Fatica: Okay.
[50:31] Kimberly Cooper: Uh Son Time.
[50:32] Michael Fatica: Um Sunny in the Park.
[50:34] Kimberly Cooper: Into the Woods.
[50:35] Michael Fatica: Uh uh.
[50:37] Kimberly Cooper: Catherine Zeta-Jones was in it.
[50:38] Michael Fatica: Oh, um, oh uh it's about not a big big day song.
[50:46] Kimberly Cooper: The opposite of that.
[50:47] Michael Fatica: Wait, give me words from makeup.
[50:50] Kimberly Cooper: Okay, not big, but small.
[50:51] Michael Fatica: Uh little.
[50:52] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[50:52] Michael Fatica: A little nightmare.
[50:53] Kimberly Cooper: Oh my gosh.
[50:54] Michael Fatica: Okay, here we go.
[50:55] Kimberly Cooper: Okay, this is also musical.
[50:56] Michael Fatica: Okay.
[50:57] Kimberly Cooper: Um, was it the Niederlander?
[50:58] Michael Fatica: Um uh Patty LuPone was in it with Christine Ebersole.
[51:01] Kimberly Cooper: More paintings.
[51:01] Michael Fatica: That's it.
[51:02] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, got it.
[51:04] Michael Fatica: How many was that?
[51:05] Kimberly Cooper: We got I want to see Big Day songs.
[51:09] Michael Fatica: Really bad.
[51:09] Kimberly Cooper: I feel like that'd be a great show.
[51:11] Michael Fatica: My job.
[51:12] Kimberly Cooper: I couldn't remember the name of that show.
[51:13] Michael Fatica: Okay, it's okay.
[51:14] Kimberly Cooper: But what is a little really helped me?
[51:15] Michael Fatica: Good.
[51:16] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, yeah.
[51:16] Michael Fatica: We're still in the first round.
[51:18] Kimberly Cooper: Okay, so I was.
[51:19] Michael Fatica: Okay, so I any codes.
[51:20] Kimberly Cooper: Any clues?
[51:21] Michael Fatica: Yes.
[51:21] Kimberly Cooper: Got it.
[51:21] Michael Fatica: Any clothes?
[51:22] Kimberly Cooper: Any clues.
[51:22] Michael Fatica: Any clothes.
[51:23] Kimberly Cooper: Any clothes, got it.
[51:24] Michael Fatica: But I just want to see.
[51:25] Kimberly Cooper: And go.
[51:26] Michael Fatica: Okay.
[51:27] Kimberly Cooper: Um.
[51:27] Michael Fatica: Oh, she's a friend of the show.
[51:29] Kimberly Cooper: She was in, um, she was Jane in Tarzan.
[51:31] Michael Fatica: Jen Gambitese.
[51:32] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[51:33] Michael Fatica: Um.
[51:33] Kimberly Cooper: Uh they wrote Le Miz and the Pirate Queen and Miss Saigon.
[51:37] Michael Fatica: Schoenberg and Boublil?
[51:39] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[51:39] Michael Fatica: Bob.
[51:42] Kimberly Cooper: He directed Once on this Island this year.
[51:44] Michael Fatica: My Glarden.
[51:45] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[51:45] Michael Fatica: Um.
[51:46] Kimberly Cooper: The old man in A Christmas Story.
[51:49] Michael Fatica: Um.
[51:51] Kimberly Cooper: He was the standby for Spamalot.
[51:53] Michael Fatica: Blank Appleseed.
[51:55] Kimberly Cooper: Frank Appleseed.
[51:56] Michael Fatica: No.
[51:57] Kimberly Cooper: Johnny Appleseed.
[51:58] Michael Fatica: Yes.
[51:59] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, Frank Applegate.
[52:01] Michael Fatica: Johnny Appleseed.
[52:02] Kimberly Cooper: And he and like the the 80s and like power belter blank, like Michael.
[52:07] Michael Fatica: Benatar?
[52:08] Kimberly Cooper: Oh.
[52:09] Michael Fatica: Michael Bolton?
[52:11] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[52:11] Michael Fatica: Johnny Bolton?
[52:12] Kimberly Cooper: John Bolton.
[52:12] Michael Fatica: John Bolton.
[52:13] Kimberly Cooper: John Bolton.
[52:15] Michael Fatica: We almost got my God.
[52:17] Kimberly Cooper: That was a hard one.
[52:18] Michael Fatica: I didn't know that was.
[52:20] Kimberly Cooper: So we got four.
[52:21] Michael Fatica: Okay.
[52:21] Kimberly Cooper: Brian's turn.
[52:22] Michael Fatica: Uh directed SpongeBob.
[52:24] Kimberly Cooper: Uh Tina Landau.
[52:25] Michael Fatica: We did it!
[52:26] Kimberly Cooper: Yay!
[52:27] Michael Fatica: Alright. But now you also get all of the cards and you start the next round.
[52:31] Kimberly Cooper: Okay, I see.
[52:31] Michael Fatica: So that it's not just us always starting.
[52:33] Kimberly Cooper: This is one.
[52:34] Michael Fatica: So now this is one word, please.
[52:35] Kimberly Cooper: Yes, one word.
[52:36] Michael Fatica: Whenever we're ready.
[52:37] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, and go.
[52:39] Michael Fatica: SpongeBob.
[52:40] Kimberly Cooper: Tina Landau.
[52:41] Michael Fatica: Oh yeah.
[52:42] Kimberly Cooper: LuPone.
[52:43] Michael Fatica: Patty.
[52:44] Kimberly Cooper: Oh.
[52:44] Michael Fatica: War Paint.
[52:45] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[52:46] Michael Fatica: Island.
[52:48] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, oh, Island.
[52:50] Michael Fatica: I want to say Once on this Island, but that's not the right way to go.
[52:52] Kimberly Cooper: It is the right way to go.
[52:54] Michael Fatica: Were they in it?
[52:55] Kimberly Cooper: Were they uh?
[52:58] Michael Fatica: Oh no! The director of it.
[53:01] Kimberly Cooper: Um I don't remember who directed it.
[53:03] Michael Fatica: George C. Wolf?
[53:04] Kimberly Cooper: No.
[53:06] Michael Fatica: Oh, pass.
[53:08] Kimberly Cooper: Okay, pass.
[53:08] Michael Fatica: Cool.
[53:10] Kimberly Cooper: Miserable.
[53:10] Michael Fatica: Um Schoenberg, Cloud, Cloud and Schoenberg.
[53:14] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[53:14] Michael Fatica: Oh, I remember who directed Once on this Island.
[53:17] Kimberly Cooper: Michael Arden, you're very talented.
[53:19] Michael Fatica: Tarzan.
[53:20] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, Jen Gambitese.
[53:22] Michael Fatica: Comet.
[53:23] Kimberly Cooper: Uh Lucas Steel.
[53:25] Michael Fatica: Anastasia.
[53:26] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, uh Derek Leno.
[53:29] Michael Fatica: French.
[53:29] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, pretty good.
[53:31] Michael Fatica: That was really good.
[53:32] Kimberly Cooper: That was good when it was.
[53:33] Michael Fatica: It's hard when you look good.
[53:34] Kimberly Cooper: You definitely know people's names, but just because you're in the game, you like connected.
[53:38] Michael Fatica: Alright, so begin.
[53:43] Kimberly Cooper: Um Michael.
[53:45] Michael Fatica: Michael Arden.
[53:46] Kimberly Cooper: Michael.
[53:50] Michael Fatica: What?
[53:54] Kimberly Cooper: Um Lion.
[53:56] Michael Fatica: Julie Taymor.
[53:57] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[53:58] Michael Fatica: Um.
[54:00] Kimberly Cooper: Rent.
[54:01] Michael Fatica: Michael Greif.
[54:02] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[54:03] Michael Fatica: Um.
[54:05] Kimberly Cooper: Shuffle.
[54:06] Michael Fatica: George C. Wolf.
[54:07] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[54:08] Michael Fatica: Um.
[54:09] Kimberly Cooper: Sondheim.
[54:10] Michael Fatica: A Little Night Music.
[54:11] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[54:12] Michael Fatica: Uh Philippa.
[54:14] Kimberly Cooper: Analy.
[54:14] Michael Fatica: Yes.
[54:15] Kimberly Cooper: Uh Island.
[54:17] Michael Fatica: Michael Arden.
[54:18] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[54:19] Michael Fatica: Michael.
[54:22] Kimberly Cooper: Wait a minute.
[54:23] Michael Fatica: We said John Bolton?
[54:24] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[54:27] Michael Fatica: So we got one, two, three, four, five, six, seven.
[54:31] Kimberly Cooper: And was that the end of the bag?
[54:33] Michael Fatica: Yes.
[54:33] Kimberly Cooper: So what what's the next round?
[54:35] Michael Fatica: Songs.
[54:35] Kimberly Cooper: Songs.
[54:36] Michael Fatica: So you get to sing something that makes us think of the version.
[54:39] Kimberly Cooper: Alright, are you ready?
[54:40] Michael Fatica: Yes.
[54:41] Kimberly Cooper: And go.
[54:42] Michael Fatica: Okay. Um, oh, I cannot sing a single thing from this, but I'm gonna do um be from it.
[54:47] Kimberly Cooper: You can just make up anything.
[54:48] Michael Fatica: Um bed is it, my turn.
[54:55] Kimberly Cooper: Dream for myself.
[54:57] Michael Fatica: Uh everything's coming up, roses.
[55:02] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[55:03] Michael Fatica: Oh, War Paint?
[55:04] Kimberly Cooper: Yes!
[55:05] Michael Fatica: Okay.
[55:07] Kimberly Cooper: Okay.
[55:07] Michael Fatica: You said I'm a sponge.
[55:09] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, Tina Landau, yeah.
[55:13] Michael Fatica: Um stars in your multitude.
[55:15] Kimberly Cooper: Uh Little Night Music.
[55:16] Michael Fatica: Oh no.
[55:17] Kimberly Cooper: What?
[55:18] Michael Fatica: Okay, uh, one day more.
[55:19] Kimberly Cooper: Oh my gosh.
[55:20] Michael Fatica: Mobile in Cloud Schumberg.
[55:23] Kimberly Cooper: Okay, um, yeah, yeah.
[55:25] Michael Fatica: Oh, I that's right, that's right.
[55:26] Kimberly Cooper: Um, I was in Fame.
[55:27] Michael Fatica: I'm a woman, I'm beautiful.
[55:29] Kimberly Cooper: And um, I was in School of Rock, I was a replacement.
[55:32] Michael Fatica: Gigabites!
[55:32] Kimberly Cooper: Yes, okay.
[55:37] Michael Fatica: I'm sorry, I failed you better.
[55:38] Kimberly Cooper: That is a hard one.
[55:39] Michael Fatica: It's a four.
[55:40] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, we know four.
[55:42] Michael Fatica: But we did it with style, so honestly.
[55:45] Kimberly Cooper: Alright, can I ready?
[55:47] Michael Fatica: The cup you're drinking out of.
[55:49] Kimberly Cooper: The great color.
[55:50] Michael Fatica: Lukey Steele.
[55:51] Kimberly Cooper: Correct.
[55:53] Michael Fatica: We just won.
[55:54] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[55:56] Michael Fatica: Go ahead.
[55:57] Kimberly Cooper: He was in Dogfight.
[55:59] Michael Fatica: Derek.
[56:02] Kimberly Cooper: The circle of lies.
[56:04] Michael Fatica: Julie Taymor.
[56:06] Kimberly Cooper: Um, how we gonna pay?
[56:09] Michael Fatica: Michael Griffith.
[56:09] Kimberly Fatica: Yeah.
[56:10] Michael Fatica: As we shuffle along.
[56:12] Kimberly Cooper: George C. Wolf.
[56:16] Michael Fatica: Send in the clowns.
[56:18] Kimberly Cooper: A Little Night Music.
[56:21] Michael Fatica: John Bolton.
[56:26] Kimberly Cooper: They say times are hard for dreamers.
[56:29] Michael Fatica: Oh, we're done.
[56:31] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, what was that?
[56:32] Michael Fatica: Amelie.
[56:33] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, I missed it.
[56:34] Michael Fatica: Two, three, four, five, six.
[56:37] Kimberly Cooper: Your turn.
[56:37] Michael Fatica: Oh, yeah, go.
[56:39] Kimberly Cooper: I'm the one person no one really knows or can't remember that.
[56:43] Michael Fatica: I'm in here.
[56:44] Kimberly Cooper: Michael Blank.
[56:45] Michael Fatica: Oh, uh John Bolton.
[56:47] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[56:48] Michael Fatica: I directed Once on this Island.
[56:50] Kimberly Cooper: Michael Arden!
[56:51] Michael Fatica: Yeah.
[56:52] Kimberly Cooper: Bonjour.
[56:53] Michael Fatica: I am Lee.
[56:54] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[56:57] Michael Fatica: So.
[56:58] Kimberly Cooper: We know that.
[56:58] Michael Fatica: So it's so who wins?
[57:00] Kimberly Cooper: We win.
[57:02] Michael Fatica: We got 18.
[57:03] Kimberly Cooper: You got way more than that.
[57:04] Michael Fatica: 21.
[57:05] Kimberly Cooper: I'd like a recount.
[57:06] Michael Fatica: That's three more.
[57:08] Kimberly Cooper: Well, that brings us to the end of our episode.
[57:10] Michael Fatica: It does.
[57:10] Kimberly Cooper: Thank you so much for joining us.
[57:12] Michael Fatica: Thank you for watching.
[57:12] Kimberly Cooper: This was so much fun.
[57:14] Michael Fatica: A blast.
[57:14] Kimberly Cooper: You can follow him at his name, Michael Fatica on uh all social media.
[57:19] Michael Fatica: Yes.
[57:19] Kimberly Cooper: You can follow us at Broadwaysted on all social media.
[57:22] Michael Fatica: Hey, that's us.
[57:23] Kimberly Cooper: Again, go ahead.
[57:23] Michael Fatica: Or TikTok.
[57:24] Kimberly Cooper: What?
[57:24] Michael Fatica: Not TikTok.
[57:25] Kimberly Cooper: Tic Tac.
[57:26] Michael Fatica: TikTok.
[57:26] Kimberly Cooper: TikTok.
[57:27] Michael Fatica: Great.
[57:27] Kimberly Cooper: Right?
[57:28] Michael Fatica: The new ones.
[57:28] Kimberly Cooper: I'm trying to think of the new stuff that we don't do.
[57:30] Michael Fatica: No, we don't do that.
[57:30] Kimberly Cooper: No Snapchats.
[57:31] Michael Fatica: But we do Facebook group and Kevin runs that.
[57:34] Kimberly Cooper: We do.
[57:34] Michael Fatica: We have fun stuff.
[57:35] Kimberly Cooper: We do like little games, little uh vote things, little questions to us, and ask you guys crazy questions.
[57:41] Michael Fatica: It's always fun.
[57:41] Kimberly Cooper: I'll have a vote thing.
[57:42] Michael Fatica: Yeah, a little vote.
[57:43] Kimberly Cooper: Kimberly wins all the vote things.
[57:46] Michael Fatica: Apparently, I survived a zombie apocalypse.
[57:48] Kimberly Cooper: This scenario, and I always lose, and Camber.
[57:50] Michael Fatica: They always wins.
[57:51] Kimberly Cooper: Which is fundamentally untrue.
[57:54] Michael Fatica: I'm very tough.
[57:55] Kimberly Cooper: I could beat up zombies.
[57:56] Michael Fatica: I could not.
[57:57] Kimberly Cooper: I believe you.
[57:58] Michael Fatica: Yeah, right.
[57:58] Kimberly Cooper: Uh, we also are uh on iTunes, Spotify.
[58:02] Michael Fatica: Subscribe to us there, rate and review us.
[58:04] Kimberly Cooper: Five stars.
[58:06] Michael Fatica: Thank you.
[58:07] Kimberly Cooper: Um again, uh, thank you to Goldstar so much.
[58:09] Michael Fatica: Um, you can go to goldstar.com backslash Broadwaysted to get discounted tickets to all of your favorite shows, comedy, concert concerts, dance, um tours.
[58:21] Kimberly Cooper: Um, again, you can use our code Broadwaysted all caps to get $10 off your next order.
[58:26] Michael Fatica: Go see all the new stuff coming out, all the stuff that's already on Broadway or anything in your neck of the woods.
[58:31] Kimberly Cooper: Do it.
[58:31] Michael Fatica: Um and uh we end every episode with a quote.
[58:34] Kimberly Cooper: We do we do, Kevin.
[58:36] Michael Fatica: And this time it's MacArthur's Park is melting in the dark, all the sweet green icing flowing down.
[58:41] Kimberly Cooper: Someone left the cake out in the rain.
[58:43] Michael Fatica: I don't think that it can I can take it because it took so long to make it to bake it, and I'll never have that recipe again.
[58:50] Kimberly Cooper: Oh no.
[58:51] Michael Fatica: Oh recipes work.
[58:54] Kimberly Cooper: It was so brilliant.
[58:55] Michael Fatica: It's like that song is such an epic sing.
[58:58] Kimberly Cooper: But like the words itself, you're like, what is that bitch talking about?
[59:01] Michael Fatica: Oh my goodness.
[59:02] Kimberly Cooper: The recipes that baked into the cake.
[59:04] Michael Fatica: Like so many people recorded that song.
[59:06] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, like it's not even just in the summer, like that summer show in her song, like so many people sang it.
[59:11] Michael Fatica: Yeah, like even the guy who was like the original uh King Arthur in Camelot.
[59:15] Kimberly Cooper: Sure.
[59:15] Michael Fatica: He did his own version, Richard Burton.
[59:17] Kimberly Cooper: Well, I think that would have come.
[59:19] Michael Fatica: Yeah, it's in like MacArthur's Park in the dog.
[59:23] Kimberly Cooper: I think what comes out is people like sweet sweet melodies and sweet sweet cake.
[59:28] Michael Fatica: Yeah, yeah.
[59:28] Kimberly Cooper: That's being rained on.
[59:29] Michael Fatica: Yeah, I love rainy cake.
[59:31] Kimberly Cooper: Who doesn't love rainy cake?
[59:33] Michael Fatica: One time I brought Jay a birthday cake, it did get rained on.
[59:35] Kimberly Cooper: And was great.
[59:36] Michael Fatica: Yeah.
[59:37] Kimberly Cooper: So we're all right.
[59:38] Michael Fatica: I have the recipe though.
[59:39] Kimberly Cooper: We've passed by Tompkins Square Park.
[59:41] Michael Fatica: Right.
[59:41] Kimberly Cooper: So it's like that's getting big.
[59:43] Michael Fatica: Yeah, exactly the same thing.
[59:44] Kimberly Cooper: Well, I'm Donna Summer.
[59:47] Michael Fatica: Yeah.
[59:47] Kimberly Cooper: Let's just put a cake in Tompkins Square Park.
[59:49] Michael Fatica: Yeah.
[59:50] Kimberly Cooper: I love it.
[59:51] Michael Fatica: Leave it out in the sun.
[59:52] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[59:53] Michael Fatica: Thank you so much for joining us.
[59:54] Kimberly Cooper: Go see Cher.
[59:56] Michael Fatica: It's on Broadway now at the Neil Simon.
[59:58] Kimberly Cooper: You can get tickets from many different places.
[1:00:00] Michael Fatica: So go to those places and get them.
[1:00:02] Kimberly Cooper: Just Google Cher.
[1:00:03] Michael Fatica: Yeah.
[1:00:03] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, just Google Cher.
[1:00:05] Michael Fatica: Thank you again.
[1:00:05] Kimberly Cooper: But buy tickets to the Cher Show.
[1:00:08] Michael Fatica: Not a Cher concert in a different city.
[1:00:10] Kimberly Cooper: Yes.
[1:00:10] Michael Fatica: Be very specific that you're looking for the Cher Show on Broadway.
[1:00:14] Kimberly Cooper: And on that note, we end every episode.
[1:00:15] Michael Fatica: We raise our glasses.
[1:00:17] Kimberly Cooper: Zoot you up, Bob.
[1:00:19] Michael Fatica: Cheers.
[1:00:21] Kimberly Cooper: Thank you.
[1:00:21] Michael Fatica: I should have learned the song.
[1:00:23] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, it's from Greece.
[1:00:24] Michael Fatica: We've never done Greece.
[1:00:25] Kimberly Cooper: Never heard of it.
[1:00:26] Michael Fatica: What's Greece?
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
