Who will win the Broadwaysted Besties Battle Game! Play along as Kevin ushers in the final rounds of this BFF wild party. Bryan & Jay Schmidt (@TheJaySchmidt - YouTube's pReview'd) vs. Kimberly & Emily Marshall (@emarshall_23 - Be More Chill, Ratatouille The TikTok Musical) vs... Read More
From the show: Broadwaysted!
Guests
Featured Shows
About
Who will win the Broadwaysted Besties Battle Game!
Play along as Kevin ushers in the final rounds of this BFF wild party.
Bryan & Jay Schmidt (@TheJaySchmidt - YouTube's pReview'd)
vs
Kimberly & Emily Marshall (@emarshall_23 - Be More Chill, Ratatouille The TikTok Musical)
vs
Justin Colombo (@JustinHColombo - Kinky Boots, Rock of Ages) & Matt Ban (@battman1167 - Rock of Ages, Spamalot)
Come for the beer and broadway talk, but stay for the intense competition and Eleven O'Clock Number red wine.
Become a supporter on our Patreon: https://bit.ly/2Q2zELG
To buy Eleven O'Clock Number wine and support a good cause, check out Nocking Point Wines HERE.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:04] Bryan Plofsky: Did you bring wine?
[0:05] Kevin Jager: I got the glasses.
[0:06] Kimberly Cooper: Hey guys, I made a quiz.
[0:08] Justin Colombo: I didn't bring anything, but I heard it's a budget.
[0:20] Bryan Plofsky: Hello, and welcome to the official Broadwaysted Podcast where we're drunk on theater. I'm your host, Bryan Plofsky, and who wants to be a millionaire?
[0:28] Bryan Plofsky: Are you a newlywed? Well, then come on down to sweep the supermarket because this race is amazing. You have a minute to win it, but don't feel like you're in jeopardy because it's just a wheel of fortune.
[0:40] Bryan Plofsky: Don't wipe out on the fear factor alone. You're gonna be a card shark, then match game me. Or hop in the cash cab if you're smarter than a fifth grader, but don't be the weakest link. Just make sure that the price is right, you ninja warrior.
[0:54] Bryan Plofsky: Joining us today are the usual to tell the truthers, including Kevin, no whammies, Jager.
[1:00] Kevin Jager: No whammies, no whammies.
[1:03] Bryan Plofsky: Kimberly, our figure it out game master, an unofficial babysitter for the hour.
[1:08] Kimberly Cooper: My favorite show of the child.
[1:10] Bryan Plofsky: And with us today to complete the game is a Nickelodeon arcade of temple guards ready to climb the aggro crag to highlight their highlights again. We will rock you, Rock of Ages, Kinky Boots, the popular YouTube channel pReview'd, Ratatouille, the TikTok musical, Spamalot, Be More Chill, and of course, in my parents' favorite turn, an appearance as liquor store tech guy on Blue Bloods.
[1:34] Bryan Plofsky: Let's give a big Broadwaysted welcome to Friends of the Show.
[1:34] Justin Colombo: Friends of the show.
[1:51] Bryan Plofsky: Y'all ready for this? Welcome everybody to part two of our game, which we, well, Kevin, what are we calling this again?
[1:57] Kevin Jager: Broadway Bestie Battle?
[1:58] Bryan Plofsky: The Broadwaysted Besties Battle.
[2:01] Kevin Jager: Broadwaysted Bestie Battle.
[2:03] Bryan Plofsky: Um, I will start with what are you drinking?
[2:03] Kevin Jager: What are you drinking?
[2:08] Bryan Plofsky: Um, I've switched it up. I, uh, gone back to my, uh, not so classy delight where I'm drinking a pomegranate seltzer and I poured tequila in the top.
[2:18] Kevin Jager: Yes.
[2:19] Bryan Plofsky: Is that good?
[2:20] Kevin Jager: I sent him a delicious.
[2:23] Bryan Plofsky: Um, Matt Ban, why don't you go next? What are you drinking?
[2:26] Matt Ban: I've also switched it up. Uh, this is a little bit of Widow Jane, actually, which, uh, funny enough is the bottle of whiskey I bought for Justin when I was his best man. I bought it for the morning of the wedding, and then I proceeded to leave it on the mainland and then drank it by myself a couple of months.
[2:46] Justin Colombo: Oh no.
[2:47] Bryan Plofsky: So, Matt, if I can ask you a question, what's it like being the best man for your best friend?
[2:53] Matt Ban: Oh, that feels pointed. Hey Bryan, I'll be sure to tell you in a couple of months. I mean, it was fun.
[3:10] Bryan Plofsky: Not my fault. I have a brother, okay?
[3:12] Matt Ban: No, I'm kidding.
[3:13] Bryan Plofsky: Not my fault. Bryan, you and I can commiserate about what it feels like to give a really good speech at the rehearsal dinner.
[3:23] Matt Ban: There's a lot going on here.
[3:24] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, yeah, there's a lot of feelings here.
[3:27] Matt Ban: Last one pack right now. What is everyone? So let's play the game.
[3:33] Bryan Plofsky: All right, so where we left off, Kimberly and Emily were about to get their chance to score extra points. So, what I need right now is either Bryan or Jay to pull up their phone to be ready to time the 30 seconds.
[3:45] Kevin Jager: You were right not to trust us with that.
[3:47] Bryan Plofsky: Right. I just have the time.
[3:50] Kevin Jager: I know.
[3:51] Bryan Plofsky: What was, what I know? All right. Ladies, you get to pick a letter, and we're picking from a decade of light hits, contemporary pop ballads. This is a 2001 classic right here. Kimberly, do you have thoughts on letters?
[3:52] Kimberly Cooper: A letter.
[4:05] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, I'm feeling like an S or a T would give us a lot of options.
[4:09] Bryan Plofsky: Oh, I think S.
[4:10] Kimberly Cooper: All right, great. Let's do that.
[4:12] Bryan Plofsky: Okay. So for S, you have the choices of "Save the Best for Last" by Vanessa Williams. We have "Show Me the Meaning of Being Lonely" by The Backstreet Boys. We have "Smooth" by Santana featuring Rob Thomas. "Something About the Way You Look Tonight" by Elton John. Or "Streets of Philadelphia" by Bruce Springsteen. And last one I'll throw in is "The Sweetest Days" by Vanessa Williams.
[4:45] Emily Marshall: This book came out in 2001.
[4:48] Emily Marshall: Yes.
[4:49] Emily Marshall: If you had given me that list of songs and said, did these songs come out pre-2001? I would have said no.
[4:55] Kimberly Cooper: That's wild to me.
[4:56] Emily Marshall: Yes.
[4:58] Emily Marshall: Pre-2001? No way, not in my watch. What are you choosing?
[5:03] Kimberly Cooper: Emily, I would say "Show Me the Meaning of Being Lonely," but that's where my lyric knowledge ends.
[5:08] Emily Marshall: So that's all.
[5:09] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, and um, and I've been going through the lyrics of it in my head.
[5:18] Emily Marshall: Sorry, you didn't all need to hear.
[5:22] Kimberly Cooper: No, we're right there. We definitely needed to hear that.
[5:24] Emily Marshall: I didn't know that "Smooth" had lyrics. I didn't remember.
[5:27] Kimberly Cooper: Um, I have a question about the... I just remembered the first lyrics of "Smooth." Um, can we skip to another part that we know to grab those lyrics?
[5:40] Bryan Plofsky: Like, do we have to say it was a compilation of how many lyrics you get in the whole song, yeah?
[5:45] Matt Ban: Great question. Thank you. I will allow that. That sounds like fun.
[5:49] Bryan Plofsky: Great, great. Okay, then let's do that one.
[5:51] Kimberly Cooper: Okay.
[5:52] Bryan Plofsky: What song are you choosing?
[5:53] Emily Marshall: "Show Me the Meaning of Being Lonely."
[5:55] Bryan Plofsky: "Show Me the Meaning of Being Lonely," which is on page 234 for those of you along at home. Please open your rimballs.
[6:38] Bryan Plofsky: "Show Me the Meaning of Being Lonely."
[6:38] Bryan Plofsky: Show me the meaning.
[6:38] Bryan Plofsky: Okay. Um, Emily, can you tell me where you'll be starting so I can try to keep track?
[6:38] Emily Marshall: I think it's at the beginning.
[6:38] Bryan Plofsky: No, no, but then we might jump. Ryan, Rainer, Jay.
[6:38] Justin Colombo: Does somebody have like a timer?
[6:38] Kevin Jager: I do. I have it.
[6:38] Justin Colombo: I have a camera.
[6:38] Kevin Jager: All right. Ready? Set. Go.
[6:36] Emily Marshall: Show me the meaning of being lonely.
[6:40] Emily Marshall: Is this a feeling I need to walk with? Tell me what. I can't be there where you are. There's something missing in my heart.
[6:46] Justin Colombo: And then I don't.
[6:48] Emily Marshall: And then it's... and then I remembered the bridge.
[6:54] Justin Colombo: That's why I asked this question.
[6:58] Emily Marshall: I know, I know I did.
[6:59] Justin Colombo: Did being the operative word.
[7:01] Bryan Plofsky: Wait, can we steal it and get points?
[7:03] Justin Colombo: No, this is them drowning.
[7:06] Bryan Plofsky: All right. That's it.
[7:08] Justin Colombo: That was it?
[7:11] Kevin Jager: 30 seconds.
[7:12] Justin Colombo: Yeah, go back to the bridge because I did remember and I should have written something.
[7:16] Emily Marshall: I have no place to go.
[7:18] Justin Colombo: Servendo Yah, body and so.
[7:21] Bryan Plofsky: Okay. So, um, I just would like to remind the group that when Matt Ban and Justin played, they got 44 extra points. Emily and Kimberly scored a whopping nine points.
[7:37] Kevin Jager: Oh no.
[7:39] Bryan Plofsky: Uh, in like the, uh, like the time of the song. Like maybe there were just more measures in there.
[7:47] Kevin Jager: So yeah, the measures really are very... Kimberly and Emily just scored eight points.
[7:53] Justin Colombo: I knew we were gonna put the point yet.
[7:55] Bryan Plofsky: Do we have a prop-out measures still? Should we go to seven?
[8:00] Kevin Jager: Almost like this whole system.
[8:01] Bryan Plofsky: I'm now playing this game the way my mother used to play games at 9:15 when she wanted us to go to bed.
[8:07] Bryan Plofsky: All right. So we're back into our game. So now the way this one's gonna work is the point values have gone up to what first round was one, second round is two. This round is however many points I feel like giving you based on how well you do.
[8:25] Kevin Jager: Excellent.
[8:27] Bryan Plofsky: So for this round, um, we need the first people who left to leave again. Turn your camera off this time, Justin.
[8:37] Justin Colombo: Justin, don't sign out, just walk out of the room.
[8:39] Bryan Plofsky: Great, all right. Let's go to the questions here, and you guys get to choose which set of questions you would like again.
[8:46] Kevin Jager: The options are "Hey Old Friend" or "Bosom Buddies," whatever you want to do.
[8:52] Kimberly Cooper: I vote "Hey Old Friend."
[8:53] Kevin Jager: I voted "Hey Old Friend" too.
[8:55] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah, me too.
[8:56] Bryan Plofsky: Great. All right, so we're doing "Hey Old Friend." So here we go. We got five questions plus a bonus question this round. Six. So five questions.
[9:03] Bryan Plofsky: Question one. At what age did your best friend have their first kiss?
[9:13] Bryan Plofsky: And P.S. We've gone past multiple choice. This is all just guessing numbers now.
[9:19] Bryan Plofsky: Question two. At what age did your best friend leave the country for the first time?
[9:26] Bryan Plofsky: Of course. Question three. Name the time your best friend absolutely completely embarrassed you.
[9:34] Bryan Plofsky: If your best friend was forced to call you a nickname, what would they call you? Gone to their head, they had to call you a nickname. What would that be?
[9:43] Bryan Plofsky: Final question. If you and your best friend were forced to select a movie that is quote, your movie together, what movie would that be?
[9:54] Justin Colombo: If he doesn't get this, I'm gonna be so mad.
[10:10] Matt Ban: Like it's the kind of thing where I was like, if he doesn't understand our history, like what is our future?
[10:16] Matt Ban: This isn't the first thing he thinks of. What are we even doing here?
[10:21] Bryan Plofsky: Our bonus question. Oh, sure. Right bonus, yes. What is Kevin's greatest attribute? A. His godlike, devilishly handsome good looks. B. His voice like a smooth chocolate shallow fountain of goodness. C. His fashion sense that rivals the class of Hepburn and the daring of Gaga. Or D. Kevin has no good attributes.
[10:52] Justin Colombo: Woof, gross town.
[11:03] Justin Colombo: Matt Ban is a very, um, stabilizing force in my life, and I appreciate that about him. He's able to help me kind of grow and get an even kind of sense of the world.
[11:20] Bryan Plofsky: Great. I love that. And you have Emily, I'm gonna give you 10 seconds about Kimberly. Go.
[11:26] Emily Marshall: Um, Kimberly has been the best friend and roommate for a good number of years, and there are not very many people that I could live with and be as happy with and always have a good friendship with.
[11:38] Bryan Plofsky: Great. And Bryan, tell me 10 seconds about why you like Jay.
[11:42] Justin Colombo: Um, he's the nicest person I know. He is the incredible advice giver, and we're just very much on the same wavelength about a lot, about almost everything.
[11:52] Bryan Plofsky: So now we can go on with the round. Round two. Uh, your best friends chose the round for themselves called "Hey Old Friend." We're gonna go through these questions and we'll see how you do.
[12:04] Bryan Plofsky: There's five questions plus a bonus question, and each question is worth five points.
[12:09] Bryan Plofsky: All right, question one. At what age did you have your first kiss? I asked your best friend, at what age did you have your first kiss?
[12:23] Justin Colombo: No, bro, I just got a Rolodex of first kisses. I gotta run through.
[12:27] Bryan Plofsky: All right. We're gonna start with Kimberly.
[12:32] Kimberly Cooper: What kind of kiss?
[12:34] Bryan Plofsky: Oh.
[12:35] Kimberly Cooper: Whatever you answered, whatever you think that Emily would have answered.
[12:39] Bryan Plofsky: Age?
[12:39] Kimberly Cooper: Grade.
[12:40] Bryan Plofsky: Age.
[12:42] Kimberly Cooper: At that age, I think in grades, so I don't know exactly what age I was. I literally just counted on my fingers.
[12:49] Justin Colombo: Because I do the same thing, Kimberly.
[12:51] Kimberly Cooper: Well, favorite grade and age.
[12:54] Bryan Plofsky: Three, two, one.
[12:57] Kimberly Cooper: Twelve?
[12:58] Emily Marshall: I said nine.
[13:00] Kimberly Cooper: I said you were young.
[13:02] Emily Marshall: I think 11 is the truth, but it was sixth grade. I don't remember when it was.
[13:05] Bryan Plofsky: Great. Fifth grade.
[13:09] Kimberly Cooper: Okay. Team one. I would say, I mean, my first kiss was like, was in fifth grade, so I'd be nine or ten. So I'm gonna go with ten.
[13:17] Justin Colombo: You'd be ten or eleven.
[13:19] Jay Schmidt: I said I assumed it was Hillary, so I said sixteen.
[13:24] Kevin Jager: I didn't have my first kiss at 16.
[13:27] Justin Colombo: I don't know.
[13:28] Matt Ban: I don't have Missouri, you're from the East.
[13:33] Kevin Jager: This isn't just the game, it's a learning experience.
[13:36] Jay Schmidt: In Jersey, we start full-on Frenching in kindergarten.
[13:41] Kevin Jager: I also saw the picture of you playing the trumpet in high school, so I assumed that maybe it was later.
[13:45] Matt Ban: Whoa!
[13:46] Justin Colombo: You cannot play the trumpet at the trump.
[13:49] Kevin Jager: Those are the rules.
[13:50] Kevin Jager: All right, team two. What you got for me, boys?
[13:53] Jay Schmidt: Uh, you know, like here's the thing. I I don't know if Mad Band knows the answer to this. I honestly don't know if I know the answer to this. So I'm just gonna throw a dart at the wall and be like eight.
[14:03] Matt Ban: I said 13.
[14:05] Justin Colombo: But you know what? Then I said 22 with me, baby.
[14:12] Kevin Jager: Yeah, actually, that's 22 with you, baby.
[14:14] Kevin Jager: That's right. So no one got points there, but I'm gonna give points to I'm gonna give five points to team two because love is love.
[14:27] Kevin Jager: All right, uh question two. At what age did you leave the country for the first time?
[14:33] Kevin Jager: So what did your best friend say at what age did you leave the country for the first time?
[14:38] Kevin Jager: Uh we'll start with Ryan.
[14:40] Jay Schmidt: Uh 12.
[14:41] Kevin Jager: Jay, what you got for me?
[14:42] Jay Schmidt: I just assume the first time you left the country was when you went to London. So I said 20 into 21 because you turned 21 when you were in London.
[14:50] Justin Colombo: Oh that's no, I mean, like we went to Mexico and Canada when I was in middle school.
[14:56] Kevin Jager: Does that really count though?
[14:58] Justin Colombo: I mean, I needed a passport.
[15:00] Kevin Jager: I was gonna ask if that counted, but then I didn't really answer anyways.
[15:04] Kimberly Cooper: Kimberly, what do you got?
[15:06] Kimberly Cooper: I don't know because I probably went to Canada when I was like nine.
[15:12] Justin Colombo: And then Mexico.
[15:13] Kimberly Cooper: Oh right, so we got it.
[15:17] Kimberly Cooper: Nine, wow.
[15:19] Kevin Jager: I think you found a nine kick. Perfect.
[15:23] Kevin Jager: Okay, so Justin, we're on you, my friend. At what age did Matt Ban think that you left the country for the first time?
[15:30] Justin Colombo: Okay, so the only time that Matt Ban knows that I went out of the country, besides the time I went out of the country with him, was when I went to Russia in college. So it's really just me pinpointing at what year Matt what age Matt Ban thinks that is.
[15:44] Justin Colombo: I'm gonna say 20, even though it feels like 21, but 20 feels good.
[15:48] Kevin Jager: Russia baby. You know what? I'm gonna give you all five points. And that was a really good effort. I see you're on the same page.
[15:57] Justin Colombo: Yeah, yeah. I really botched that one.
[16:01] Kevin Jager: No, it's fine. I just, yeah. Name a time that your best friend completely embarrassed you the most.
[16:08] Kevin Jager: So the question is name a time that you embarrassed your best friend. And we're keeping this lighthearted and fun and happy time. So we're not trying to we're not trying to hit on any like nerves, but we're just and you don't have to go into too many details, but enough that I can tell you guys are on the same page. And we'll start with Kimberly.
[16:29] Kimberly Cooper: I don't know that I've ever seen Emily embarrassed by anything.
[16:33] Emily Marshall: No, you embarrass me.
[16:35] Kimberly Cooper: I know. So I'm trying to think of how I could embarrass you. I've done plenty of embarrassing things around Emily.
[16:43] Kimberly Cooper: And she's been unfazed. But I'm gonna think never. And I wrote never, honestly, though. You've never embarrassed me.
[16:53] Emily Marshall: I don't think that's a thing.
[16:55] Kimberly Cooper: I did write puke in my hat. And that would be the other thing, the puke in the hat, but because I was like, but it didn't embarrass me. We joke about it, and I love it.
[17:03] Emily Marshall: I know. I made a very sturdy hat and I could puke in it and throw it out. I love no embarrassment.
[17:09] Kevin Jager: So I love that you guys are on the same page. Like the Yaya sisterhood is like really sweet and amazing, but I'm gonna take five points away because the fact you don't embarrass each other is gross.
[17:24] Emily Marshall: No, no, I don't embarrass her.
[17:27] Kimberly Cooper: Right. I can embarrass Kimberly. If that was the opposite way, that we would have different answers.
[17:33] Kevin Jager: Right, but but the way it worked out was just gross. So you lost five points. So we're gonna move on to Justin Colombo.
[17:40] Justin Colombo: We're really not gonna win this game, but we're doing very well.
[17:43] Kimberly Cooper: Well, they're one 44 points.
[17:46] Justin Colombo: Oh, we'll lose them. Don't worry. The problem is that I have a lot that I could pick through. So this is the one that I feel like is the funniest. I'm gonna, I'm gonna say, I'm gonna say beer boy. And Matt knows what that is.
[17:59] Matt Ban: Oh my god.
[18:01] Justin Colombo: Oh, you idiot.
[18:03] Justin Colombo: So Matt, okay, Matt wasn't there for it, but it was still what's very embarrassing to him.
[18:11] Matt Ban: That's true.
[18:13] Justin Colombo: Um, I said when you when you ran uh you felt face into the high bus in Omaha.
[18:20] Justin Colombo: Hyatt bus in Omaha, Nebraska. Yeah, he just he just kind of spin one of these and like faceplanted into the one of those hotel shovels.
[18:30] Matt Ban: That was number two.
[18:30] Justin Colombo: That was number two. And I'm a really good best friend, so I just kind of backed away and oh that's a good story, but sadly.
[18:40] Kevin Jager: I could have sworn that one, dude. Ryan, what have you sift through and decided is the answer?
[18:45] Jay Schmidt: I mean, this one's pretty easy. This is July 4th, he's your friend author.
[18:50] Justin Colombo: That's right.
[18:52] Jay Schmidt: That's literally, literally exactly what I wrote.
[18:56] Kevin Jager: July 4th.
[19:02] Justin Colombo: July 4th, he's your friend, hon that cover that all the time and I wasn't even there.
[19:11] Kevin Jager: If you have 45 minutes, I can tell the story of that.
[19:14] Justin Colombo: You know what? I don't have the time, but I do have 10 points for you. So well done.
[19:21] Jay Schmidt: Ever like you're like a part of a story, you feel like you know the whole story.
[19:24] Justin Colombo: I feel like that's that right there.
[19:26] Kevin Jager: Don't put it on. You can you can get it.
[19:28] Jay Schmidt: Oh just that. That's all I needed to know.
[19:31] Kevin Jager: All right, here we go. Next question. If you if your best friend was forced to call or if the question was if your best friend was forced to call you a nickname, what would they call you? And we'll start with Brian.
[19:49] Jay Schmidt: So this is what Jay would call me, just to confirm again.
[19:52] Kevin Jager: No, no, no. This is what you would call me.
[19:55] Jay Schmidt: You would call Jay.
[19:56] Kevin Jager: I mean, his name is a nickname.
[20:01] Jay Schmidt: So I would I would I mean, I would probably just go with J Bird or something like that.
[20:09] Kevin Jager: Boom, there it is.
[20:14] Kevin Jager: Yeah. Okay. That's five points right there.
[20:18] Kimberly Cooper: Uh Emily.
[20:20] Kimberly Cooper: Are you Kimberly?
[20:21] Kimberly Cooper: Kimberly.
[20:23] Kimberly Cooper: Emily does not have a lot of nicknames, but sometimes I call her M.
[20:28] Kevin Jager: Boom. Nice. Well done. Well done.
[20:31] Kevin Jager: Wow. I can't wait for all of us to go two for three on this one.
[20:34] Kevin Jager: Oh, look. That correct that correct answer just negated the five points I took away from you for being lame. Congratulations.
[20:42] Kevin Jager: All right. And uh Map in, what do you got for me, Justin Colombo?
[20:47] Justin Colombo: Like part of me just goes like it's baby. Like I'd be like, that's a baby. Like then you got to say.
[20:52] Kevin Jager: But like are you is your answer that your nickname for Matman is Baby?
[20:58] Justin Colombo: No, it's probably like nah. It's probably like, oh man, this is tough.
[21:04] Kevin Jager: Overthinking it.
[21:04] Justin Colombo: Oh, you're overthinking it. I it's probably a big idiot.
[21:09] Kevin Jager: Alright. What did you say, Matt Ban?
[21:11] Matt Ban: Well, first of all, oh, he said deer boy. I want you to know I wrote down BB. Because when he because sometimes when he texts me and he wants to say baby, he says BB.
[21:21] Justin Colombo: He goes, Okay. I wrote Beer Boy. One time when I was on for Matt Ban in Rock of Ages and Jesse Mueller was in the audience. I forgot the words to uh too much time on your hands, and I mumbled, and then I just said, give me that beer boy, and that's that's it. And it was the most horrifying moment of my entire life.
[21:44] Kevin Jager: Gimme. Have you ever forgotten the song?
[21:56] Justin Colombo: That's an actual lyric.
[21:58] Kevin Jager: I don't know. You know what? You get 10 points for opening up, Justin. Thank you.
[22:04] Justin Colombo: Is this is this covered by my equity insurance?
[22:09] Kevin Jager: No, nothing is anymore. And the last I know. And the last the last regular question before the bonus question is if you and your best friend were forced to select a movie that is quote, your movie together, what movie would that be? We'll start with Justin because he's excited.
[22:28] Justin Colombo: Oh no, another one.
[22:42] Justin Colombo: Uh here's the thing. Uh man, I'm gonna go with uh I'm gonna go with Stepbrothers.
[22:49] Jay Schmidt: Oh see, I wrote I was gonna write that thing.
[22:52] Justin Colombo: Shrek 2, idiot.
[22:54] Jay Schmidt: Oh because it's what terribly British said take your tailor soldier spy, which was unfortunately incorrect.
[23:09] Kevin Jager: Let's go to uh Kimberly.
[23:11] Kimberly Cooper: Um watch movies or know movies.
[23:19] Kevin Jager: I'm gonna again give you 10 points because that'll please me.
[23:28] Kevin Jager: I knew that the first thing she was gonna say is that I don't know movies and I don't know them. We've never watched a movie together.
[23:36] Kimberly Cooper: No, that makes me so happy.
[23:38] Kevin Jager: All right, and Brian, what you got?
[23:40] Jay Schmidt: So Jay and I have the opposite problem.
[23:45] Kevin Jager: Oh, it's pulp fiction.
[23:47] Jay Schmidt: Pulp fiction.
[23:48] Kevin Jager: Yeah, it's pulp fiction. Totally.
[23:54] Jay Schmidt: It's pulp fiction. Brian and I watched Pulp Fiction and a pretzel rods while his while his roommate was like getting ready to go out to the clubs and like get strange.
[24:04] Kevin Jager: This is the first weekend at college.
[24:06] Jay Schmidt: What college is?
[24:11] Kevin Jager: Like I've never seen it. Is that a Cornell?
[24:14] Jay Schmidt: No, it's uh on the campus of the other school. I believe it was East Tower.
[24:17] Kevin Jager: Uh damn.
[24:18] Jay Schmidt: Oh, East Tower, good for you. Great sunset.
[24:21] Kevin Jager: East Tower School.
[24:22] Jay Schmidt: Yeah, me Brian and Rawish German Jordan. Everyone on the East East Tower.
[24:27] Kevin Jager: Oh, hold on. I think you dropped that name. I can pick that up.
[24:29] Jay Schmidt: It's a Massachusetts.
[24:33] Kevin Jager: Don't worry, he doesn't text me back.
[24:36] Kevin Jager: Well, that was amazing. Okay. Let's go into the bonus. We're going into the bonus question, kids. So here's the bonus question you had to answer. So you have to match your partner in this question. The question is, what is Kevin's greatest attribute? A his godlike, devilishly handsome good looks. B his voice, like a smooth chocolate cello fountain of goodness. C his fashion sense that rivals the class of Hepburn and the daring of Gaga. And D, Kevin has no good attributes. Woof, gross town. Let's start with Brian.
[25:19] Jay Schmidt: I think we're going with the chocolate cello voice.
[25:23] Kevin Jager: B. Jay, what'd you say?
[25:25] Jay Schmidt: I just assumed you were gonna be mean to Kevin, so I said D.
[25:31] Kevin Jager: You get zero points.
[25:33] Kevin Jager: All right. Uh what you got?
[25:36] Justin Colombo: Uh wait, hold on. What was C was fashion sense?
[25:40] Kevin Jager: D is not an answer I'm going to give because I respect Kevin too much. And then A was.
[25:45] Kevin Jager: A was my devilishly handsome good looks. You know what I'm gonna say? I'm actually I'm gonna say C and a chocolate cello Emily and Kimberly.
[25:54] Kimberly Cooper: I also said B because I thought it would have made Emily laugh, the chocolate cello voice.
[26:01] Kevin Jager: Well, I said EL of the above minus D.
[26:04] Kevin Jager: Oh, that was very sweet. Oh, that's a good answer. I mean, also you shouldn't lose points for sucking up. I'm gonna give you I want to point out that you and Justin are wearing a very similar color at this point, and so it feels a bit more.
[26:18] Kevin Jager: You will never see me and Jay Schmidt in the same room.
[26:21] Jay Schmidt: You will never see it.
[26:23] Kevin Jager: I'm gonna give Emily and Kimberly six points because then it puts them on like the zero, five ten scale, which makes me feel better.
[26:31] Kevin Jager: Okay. So here we go. We're going into the next round with team T1, Jay and Brian have 35 points. G2, Matt and Justin have 86.5 points. And K and Emily have 45 points.
[26:55] Kevin Jager: The definitive Broadway collection of 142 songs.
[27:00] Bryan Plofsky: So because they won all the advantages, I'm gonna let Bryan, I'm gonna let Kimberly, Emily, Matt, and Justin pick the letter that they have to choose a song from.
[27:15] Justin Colombo: I oh no, I oh no, you're right.
[27:19] Kimberly Cooper: If I love to like no, no, no, no, no.
[27:21] Bryan Plofsky: And here's the thing. Jay Schmidt knows a lot of golden age Broadway.
[27:26] Kevin Jager: He's sneaky about it. Don't think like I don't remember votes from Showcase Jay.
[27:31] Bryan Plofsky: I remember you gotta think about where you can trap him.
[27:34] Kevin Jager: Because also Bryan, Bryan's Forte was also golden age Broadway.
[27:39] Kimberly Cooper: What about like R. You gotta or like K R or K?
[27:44] Justin Colombo: A is good.
[27:45] Bryan Plofsky: K, I feel like doesn't have a lot of words.
[27:48] Kevin Jager: Alright, let's go with K.
[27:49] Kimberly Cooper: I'm with K.
[27:51] Justin Colombo: They're gonna do like a kiss me Kate thing. Watch.
[27:53] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, K is not an option because there's no answers.
[27:59] Kevin Jager: That's why I didn't say X.
[28:04] Bryan Plofsky: Go with G.
[28:05] Kevin Jager: G.
[28:06] Bryan Plofsky: Guys and dolls. Come on. What's the matter with you?
[28:10] Justin Colombo: Yeah. They don't know.
[28:11] Bryan Plofsky: Here's the thing. If they don't know the words of guys and dolls, that's a little bit of like a kick off part, isn't it?
[28:18] Kimberly Cooper: I don't appreciate the amount of thought like going into this like.
[28:29] Kevin Jager: So what's the what's the letter we've decided on?
[28:31] Bryan Plofsky: Let's just go with G.
[28:32] Kevin Jager: Let's get the Zoro.
[28:34] Bryan Plofsky: Okay, the letter is G.
[28:36] Kevin Jager: So Bryan and Jay, your options are get me to the church on time from the church on TV.
[28:43] Bryan Plofsky: Wait, I want to hear the other one.
[28:46] Kevin Jager: Getting to know you from the king and I.
[28:55] Bryan Plofsky: Oh, right. That one.
[28:56] Justin Colombo: Who's that?
[28:58] Kevin Jager: And good night, my someone from Music Man.
[29:03] Bryan Plofsky: I think we go with like you said, get me to the church on time or getting to know you.
[29:03] Justin Colombo: I think getting to the church on time.
[29:12] Bryan Plofsky: Because getting to know you, I know the first verse, but that's it.
[29:15] Kevin Jager: Alright, get me to the church on time.
[29:18] Bryan Plofsky: I'm getting married in the morning.
[29:20] Kevin Jager: Ding dong, the bells are gonna.
[29:22] Bryan Plofsky: Hold on, hold on, hold on. I got excited.
[29:26] Kevin Jager: I got excited. Next win, I'll time it. Chamberly for 30 seconds.
[29:33] Justin Colombo: Ready? Go.
[29:35] Kevin Jager: Go. I'm getting married in the morning.
[29:37] Bryan Plofsky: Ding dong, the bells are gonna chime.
[29:39] Kevin Jager: Uh uh. Pull out the stopper. Let's have a whopper. Get me to the church on time.
[29:45] Bryan Plofsky: Um, I gotta be there in the morning.
[29:48] Justin Colombo: Uh spruce weapon looking in me prime.
[29:51] Bryan Plofsky: Uh girls come and kiss me.
[29:55] Kimberly Cooper: No, show how you miss me. Get me to the church on time.
[29:59] Justin Colombo: What's the beast? What's the big section?
[30:02] Kevin Jager: If I am dancing, roll up the floor. If I am whistling uh something uh you're done.
[30:08] Bryan Plofsky: Roll me out the floor. We're done.
[30:11] Kevin Jager: Wow, I told you, golden age probably are let's see.
[30:20] Bryan Plofsky: Like the whole day I was getting married because it made me happy.
[30:23] Kimberly Cooper: Aww, cute makeup. That's that's really super sweet.
[30:29] Justin Colombo: That was that was you up with a Spotify bomb of um It's your wedding day from the wedding singer.
[30:36] Bryan Plofsky: Wow. Yeah, it really it hit hard too. It was good. It was real good.
[30:40] Justin Colombo: I'm good. It was the best Spotify bomb.
[30:44] Kevin Jager: Okay, so here's where we're at at scores right now. We have in third place, Emily and Kimberly with 45 points.
[30:52] Kevin Jager: In second place, Bryan and Jay with 74 points. And then holding down first place with 86.5 points, Matt and Justin as we move into the last one of the last rounds.
[31:07] Bryan Plofsky: So the next people who hadn't left yet leave again.
[31:13] Kevin Jager: Justin and the Broadwaysted crew. This is gonna be each round is worth six points because that sounds like a fun number of hashtags.
[31:20] Bryan Plofsky: So we're gonna do that. Um okay, so this round is uh bosom buddies.
[31:27] Kevin Jager: So basically they chose hey old friend, you're doing bosom buddies. Very similar questions, but just different.
[31:33] Bryan Plofsky: So we'll see how they go. Alright. And just so you know, all of the multiple choices are gone except for the bonus question this round.
[31:43] Kevin Jager: Okay. Alright. Question one. If you were on a hidden camera show and you would win $10,000 if you legitimately scared the crap out of your best friend, what monster or creature would you use to scare them?
[32:00] Bryan Plofsky: Alright, next question is.
[32:23] Kevin Jager: And the last question. If you and your best friend were forced to select a song that is your song, the way that couples have a song, what song would be your best friend's song?
[32:42] Bryan Plofsky: Okay. So as you guys know, because you got to pick which category you did, they got to do the category that you left behind, which was bosom buddies.
[32:52] Kevin Jager: So we're gonna dive in here and see how you guys do. And I chose that this category is six points per question because that sounded fun.
[33:01] Bryan Plofsky: So question one. No, sorry, if your best friend was on a hidden camera show where they would win ten thousand dollars if they legitimately scared the crap out of you.
[33:21] Kevin Jager: What monster or creature would they use to scare you?
[33:26] Emily Marshall: To scare me, yes, Emily.
[33:29] Emily Marshall: An eye. Eyeballs.
[33:35] Justin Colombo: I hate eyes. I'm so scared of them.
[33:38] Bryan Plofsky: That's amazing. Um, you look like you knew what you got.
[33:44] Jay Schmidt: I'm so predictable.
[33:46] Bryan Plofsky: What?
[33:47] Jay Schmidt: Electro.
[33:50] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah. Oh yeah.
[33:51] Jay Schmidt: Oh leopard pounds.
[33:53] Kevin Jager: Oh, you know what? We're recording this right before St. Patrick's Day. So I'm gonna give you the points.
[34:01] Kevin Jager: Jay and Bryan, what you got?
[34:04] Jay Schmidt: Um his answer was lava.
[34:07] Bryan Plofsky: No.
[34:09] Jay Schmidt: But I well, no, but I I just put a jump scare. Uh but lava is is lava.
[34:17] Bryan Plofsky: I couldn't think of the thing, and it was totally lost. Lava is the answer, but Bryan loses three points because the jump scare isn't a dumb answer.
[34:27] Kevin Jager: So we're gonna be asked question. Is that just if you jump out and scare somebody?
[34:36] Justin Colombo: Yes.
[34:36] Kevin Jager: Okay. It seemed more specific, but I mean I agree with you, Kevin.
[34:41] Bryan Plofsky: But alright. Question two. At what age did you meet your best friend, Jay?
[34:50] Jay Schmidt: Um, we met at uh Syracuse auditions at Syracuse. So I want to say 17.
[34:56] Justin Colombo: You were 17 when we met?
[35:00] Jay Schmidt: Uh I I said Syracuse 17 or 18. I I uh it was one of the two. I don't remember.
[35:06] Kevin Jager: Alright, you get zero points.
[35:09] Matt Ban: So Matt Bannon and Justin.
[35:13] Justin Colombo: I think I was 23 because then I have my 24th birthday with the card that Joey Elrose made that we're not gonna talk about here.
[35:22] Matt Ban: Oh yeah, 24. I guess give me no points.
[35:25] Justin Colombo: I don't know, Matt. Were you 23 in 351 days?
[35:31] Matt Ban: Bro, just round up, dude.
[35:34] Justin Colombo: Round to 24.
[35:38] Kevin Jager: I give you zero points because Matt's correct. That's not how roundy works.
[35:44] Bryan Plofsky: We deserved that. Thank you.
[35:47] Kevin Jager: What you got for me, baby?
[35:48] Matt Ban: We were both 21 at Surflight.
[35:51] Justin Colombo: Both 21 at Surflight Theater.
[35:53] Kevin Jager: Can I see your paper, please?
[35:55] Matt Ban: 21.
[35:56] Kevin Jager: Thank you. Okay. You get five points, not six, because you didn't show your paper right away.
[36:02] Justin Colombo: I'm sorry, but we put it all on the same paper, which I did too, but then I ripped them all.
[36:02] Bryan Plofsky: Jay and Brown, did you guys end up going to Syracuse?
[36:09] Jay Schmidt: See, that's going.
[36:10] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, we went to Syracuse.
[36:12] Jay Schmidt: Ah, damn it. Didn't you see us in Kiss Me Kate at the Syracuse?
[36:17] Kevin Jager: Alright, next question. At what age did you see your first Broadway show?
[36:23] Bryan Plofsky: I asked your best friend to tell me at what age you saw your first Broadway show.
[36:29] Kevin Jager: And we'll start with Jay Schmidt.
[36:32] Jay Schmidt: Um he probably doesn't know about when I came in with my aunt and uncle in fourth grade to see Phantom.
[36:42] Bryan Plofsky: So I'm gonna say he thought I was 20 years old before I saw a Broadway show.
[36:49] Kevin Jager: What did Bryan say?
[36:51] Jay Schmidt: So I went with high school thoroughly modern Millie.
[36:54] Bryan Plofsky: Shit, you're right.
[36:57] Jay Schmidt: Forgot about you know you know me better than I do.
[37:01] Kevin Jager: You were like 17 or 18 when you saw thoroughly modern Millie.
[37:04] Jay Schmidt: No, I was definitely 18. I was definitely 18.
[37:08] Kevin Jager: Shit. You're he knows he's right.
[37:11] Bryan Plofsky: I'm not Jay gets zero points because let's hear her for the choice.
[37:18] Kevin Jager: Just posted a video of Sutton Foster from Thoroughly Modern Millie, and that shouldn't have made you think of it, so you lose points.
[37:24] Bryan Plofsky: Um what about you force?
[37:25] Justin Colombo: You just get zero.
[37:27] Kevin Jager: Alright, so the next one is uh Kimberly.
[37:30] Emily Marshall: Well, me, right?
[37:36] Kimberly Cooper: Um, mine was also Thoroughly Modern Millie, which is when I was 18.
[37:40] Emily Marshall: Damn. I knew it was like school age, but I said 12 or 13.
[37:45] Kimberly Cooper: No, it literally, I didn't see a Broadway show until I was 18.
[37:49] Emily Marshall: I knew it had to be when your parents wouldn't drive you.
[37:51] Kimberly Cooper: Right, and we went on a school orchestra trip.
[37:55] Kevin Jager: Yeah, I try to remember like when the school trip to New York would have happened in Auburn. 18.
[37:59] Kevin Jager: You get zero points because that conversation was boring.
[38:06] Bryan Plofsky: We're learning about each other, Kevin.
[38:08] Kevin Jager: I know, and I love that for you, but it's boring for me.
[38:11] Bryan Plofsky: So just that bad.
[38:13] Justin Colombo: What's your answer?
[38:15] Kimberly Cooper: Okay, so he definitely doesn't know about when my parents took me when I was three to see Cats, and I flipped out and kicked one of the cats in the balls.
[38:23] Justin Colombo: You know when they come out at the beginning of the I fully I freaked out and I kicked one in the nuts.
[38:29] Kimberly Cooper: Um, but no, I would guess he thinks it would probably be like 10 or 11.
[38:34] Justin Colombo: Um I said Jason Robert Brown's best work, 13, is what I said.
[38:40] Bryan Plofsky: 13.
[38:42] Kevin Jager: You know what? Justin made me think of 13. So you get the points.
[38:47] Justin Colombo: I know how to play this game. I know how to get points even if we don't get points.
[38:50] Kimberly Cooper: I don't understand the scoring.
[38:53] Justin Colombo: There's no rules over more.
[38:54] Kevin Jager: I understand the score.
[38:56] Kevin Jager: Okay. Next question is. Next question is name a time your best friend made you laugh the hardest they've ever made you laugh before.
[39:05] Bryan Plofsky: So I'm looking for a time that you, the people I'm asking now, made your best friend laugh harder than they've ever laughed before.
[39:15] Kevin Jager: So Jay, Emily, and Matt, when is a time you made your best friend laugh so hard that they've said that that's the hardest they've ever laughed because of you.
[39:27] Jay Schmidt: I'm going first. We'll start with Jay.
[39:31] Jay Schmidt: Uh it's Mallow Cups.
[39:33] Bryan Plofsky: I know it's Mallow Cups.
[39:35] Justin Colombo: Oh.
[39:36] Bryan Plofsky: What'd you say?
[39:38] Jay Schmidt: I did not say Mallow Cups.
[39:40] Bryan Plofsky: I said I couldn't think of it better.
[39:47] Justin Colombo: I said sausage fingers.
[39:49] Bryan Plofsky: Oh, sausage fingers is really close.
[39:51] Jay Schmidt: Yeah. You know what? Bryan has sausage fingers, and I'm in on that joke, so I'm gonna say 10 points.
[39:59] Jay Schmidt: Mallow cups was a time that Bryan had got a bunch of candy, and I was like, hey man, we were in the show place apartment. I was like, yo, man. I was like, do you get candy? He's like, I got Mallow Cups.
[40:10] Justin Colombo: And he whipped them at me, and they hit me so thoroughly in the nuts that I like I barfed.
[40:19] Jay Schmidt: It was like he just like missed it, and it just went just it's like Luke Skywalker and the photon, you know what I mean?
[40:27] Justin Colombo: Like right, like he blew up the Death Star that was my ball with a thing of mallow cups.
[40:33] Justin Colombo: It was incre it was incredible.
[40:36] Justin Colombo: It was I couldn't even be mad because it was just so fluke.
[40:41] Kimberly Cooper: That's amazing.
[40:46] Emily Marshall: Oh, it's it's hard to think of.
[40:48] Emily Marshall: Um what I would go with is us trying to figure out empanaday.
[41:01] Emily Marshall: Yeah, I I mean I couldn't think of anything, but that would be my best chance of it.
[41:08] Emily Marshall: Is also a good time.
[41:10] Emily Marshall: I had um yeah waves.
[41:13] Justin Colombo: What would you speech waves?
[41:16] Emily Marshall: I could have also said triple round punch.
[41:19] Justin Colombo: Oh, that's that's also fair when I just wandered into the ocean and didn't come back.
[41:25] Matt Ban: That band, what you got for me?
[41:27] Matt Ban: I can't figure out, oh damn it.
[41:30] Matt Ban: I mean, because there's so many.
[41:31] Matt Ban: Like when he split his pants on stage, and oh that's a good one.
[41:35] Matt Ban: Came like scampering up to me.
[41:36] Matt Ban: It was like I remember the one time that we laughed like super hard.
[41:43] Matt Ban: I don't think it was because of him though, it was when we were when we were in LA and freaking at the opening night party of Rock of Ages, and Richard Greco came up to us and was like he got it, he got it!
[42:10] Justin Colombo: That was so specific.
[42:13] Jay Schmidt: So Richard Greco comes up to us.
[42:16] Jay Schmidt: We're we are wasted at this point.
[42:19] Jay Schmidt: And he comes up and he's like, hey guys, great show tonight.
[42:21] Justin Colombo: And we were like, thanks, man.
[42:22] Jay Schmidt: And he's like, and he takes his sunglasses off and looks at us like you get it.
[42:29] Justin Colombo: And we're like, okay.
[42:33] Jay Schmidt: And then he walked away.
[42:34] Jay Schmidt: Like we turned to our company manager.
[42:35] Jay Schmidt: We're like, am I supposed to know who that is?
[42:38] Justin Colombo: He's like, that's Richard Greco, baby.
[42:40] Justin Colombo: No one knows who he is anymore.
[42:43] Emily Marshall: I don't know who that is.
[42:45] Matt Ban: Not he doesn't listen to your podcast.
[42:48] Justin Colombo: Floris Leechman comes out of the Hard Rock Cafe and does a 10-minute like physical comedy bit of her just trying to walk to the cab, and it was the most LA of moments.
[43:00] Matt Ban: Oh, and I still but I still laugh the hardest about Richard Greco.
[43:06] Justin Colombo: That was pretty good.
[43:07] Justin Colombo: I'm so impressed that you guys got that right.
[43:10] Jay Schmidt: And then um, last question was if your best friend was forced to select a song that is your song, the way couples have songs, what song would they choose?
[43:24] Jay Schmidt: And we'll start with Emily.
[43:28] Emily Marshall: You did that just because I looked confused.
[43:33] Emily Marshall: And um, we discussed this in the last song one that I don't have a song.
[43:39] Justin Colombo: Well, like, what is your Kimberly song?
[43:42] Emily Marshall: Mine and Kimberly song.
[43:50] Emily Marshall: Um I don't um well we can go we can go back to the other category with starting line and like really just like lean into that, and then it would be best of me.
[44:03] Emily Marshall: So that would be my best chance.
[44:04] Justin Colombo: That might be correct.
[44:05] Jay Schmidt: Yeah.
[44:06] Justin Colombo: Oh yeah.
[44:10] Justin Colombo: I was like, what concert we both went to?
[44:12] Justin Colombo: A song we both like.
[44:14] Justin Colombo: I mean, like, we we could keep talking about this, but we know you guys want to move on.
[44:19] Justin Colombo: So it's good.
[44:20] Jay Schmidt: Uh Jay, what you got?
[44:22] Jay Schmidt: I just want to point out that was actually kind of a spectacular moment.
[44:25] Jay Schmidt: Cause I did not think Emily was gonna get that.
[44:28] Jay Schmidt: And I was like, what did Kimberly write?
[44:30] Jay Schmidt: And I was like, no, yep, okay.
[44:34] Jay Schmidt: I was like, wow.
[44:35] Jay Schmidt: I was like tell me what you thought about.
[44:37] Jay Schmidt: Got it.
[44:37] Jay Schmidt: I'm really trying to like move on from the moments that we've already had in this game to like jump off to the new ones, you know.
[44:44] Justin Colombo: Learning a lot.
[44:46] Jay Schmidt: Yeah.
[44:47] Jay Schmidt: Anyone else can go now.
[44:49] Justin Colombo: What do you got?
[44:50] Matt Ban: Wait.
[44:51] Matt Ban: It's your turn.
[44:52] Matt Ban: So like our song?
[44:54] Jay Schmidt: Correct.
[44:55] Jay Schmidt: You and Bryan's song is what?
[44:58] Matt Ban: Um it's it's curious.
[45:01] Matt Ban: What would you have danced to at our wedding?
[45:04] Justin Colombo: No, here's the thing.
[45:06] Justin Colombo: Bryan and I actually have very different music tastes, which is in which is I'm gonna say it's the opening track of Aim and Ignite by Fun.
[45:14] Justin Colombo: No, no, no, no, no.
[45:15] Justin Colombo: No, it's some nights.
[45:16] Justin Colombo: It's some nights because we were there at Bowery Ballroom when they played it for the first time.
[45:22] Matt Ban: I did not say that.
[45:24] Justin Colombo: I I put if I knew you were coming, would have been that is uh it's it should have been the steamboat jazz, is what it should have been.
[45:37] Matt Ban: Oh, doing the steamboat jazz.
[45:39] Justin Colombo: You're right.
[45:39] Justin Colombo: It should have been that.
[45:41] Justin Colombo: But um it's it was if so in top class at the school that we went to, um I won't name it, of course.
[45:48] Justin Colombo: Um we had a teacher who every uh every tea every top class we would take, there would be a uh uh it opened with like if I knew you were coming, what a baked a potato, and we used to make up lyrics to it, and uh that was our song.
[46:03] Matt Ban: I didn't know that was a real song, I thought he was saying that around the house.
[46:06] Justin Colombo: I do sing around, I do single.
[46:08] Matt Ban: Okay, you didn't lose points because that was an adequate story.
[46:11] Justin Colombo: Well done.
[46:12] Jay Schmidt: Um Matt and Justin, you guys, what's your answer?
[46:16] Matt Ban: I mean, I I there's only one.
[46:18] Matt Ban: I mean, we've it's like you talked about dancing to it at a wedding.
[46:22] Matt Ban: We've danced to this song at two weddings, mine and his, and it's from Rock Rogers.
[46:28] Justin Colombo: I was like, I know your song.
[46:30] Justin Colombo: Can't fight this It's Can't Fight This Feeling by Ario Speedwagger.
[46:34] Matt Ban: All right, baby.
[46:35] Justin Colombo: Yeah, Kelly Devine both times, baby.
[46:38] Matt Ban: Also, I knew it.
[46:42] Justin Colombo: I think Emily should get points.
[46:44] Matt Ban: Yeah, I agree.
[46:46] Justin Colombo: Emily Emily has played that song for both of us.
[46:50] Matt Ban: I actually have, yeah.
[46:52] Justin Colombo: So I do think that Emily gets points because she has to sip through it.
[46:55] Matt Ban: Well, well, Kevin doesn't want to give me points, but I don't know.
[46:59] Justin Colombo: Give her give her points.
[47:01] Justin Colombo: Give her two of us.
[47:06] Justin Colombo: Doing math or are you texting someone?
[47:08] Matt Ban: No, I'm doing math because it's hard.
[47:12] Justin Colombo: You made it six.
[47:14] Justin Colombo: Okay, so here's we're at right now.
[47:17] Justin Colombo: In first place is Matt and Justin with 114.5 points.
[47:22] Justin Colombo: Triple did.
[47:23] Justin Colombo: Second place is Jay and Bryan with 81 points.
[47:28] Justin Colombo: Third place is Emily and Kimberly with 62 points.
[47:32] Justin Colombo: And now I'm realizing I was so tipsy during the last questioning segment that I forgot to ask the bonus question.
[47:41] Justin Colombo: So here's how it's gonna work.
[47:44] Justin Colombo: I'm gonna read the bonus question now, and then I'm gonna call your team, say one, two, three, and you're each gonna say what letter you think, and we're gonna see if it matches, because I'm an idiot.
[47:56] Justin Colombo: So the bonus question is what would be Kevin's greatest role to return to the stage.
[48:03] Justin Colombo: So what would be my greatest role to return to the stage?
[48:07] Justin Colombo: And A is Tevya, because now that I've seen the show, I'm very emotionally invested in it.
[48:15] Justin Colombo: I just saw the show like on Broadway last year, like with Broadway still happening, and it blew my mind because I thought it was just a satire about like three daughters tricking their dad into letting them marry whoever they want.
[48:27] Justin Colombo: And then I saw the show and I was like, why is it sad?
[48:30] Jay Schmidt: Okay.
[48:33] Justin Colombo: Question uh option two is Sweeney Todd, because Kevin is menacing and operatic and honestly maybe might kill me.
[48:42] Justin Colombo: Um, question answer three is or C is Mark from Rent, because every musical theater guy who didn't have the sex appeal or high C belt of Roger always said they would be a mark, or D, the one non-tapping tapper in a tap heavy show called something like Tippity Tap Tap.
[49:04] Jay Schmidt: Can we add an E because I have a better one?
[49:07] Justin Colombo: If you add an E with a better one and you impress me, I'll give you all the points.
[49:11] Jay Schmidt: Okay.
[49:12] Justin Colombo: We'll start with team one.
[49:14] Justin Colombo: I'm going to count to three, and you'll say your letter.
[49:17] Justin Colombo: Ready?
[49:18] Justin Colombo: One, two, three.
[49:26] Justin Colombo: Nothing was said.
[49:27] Justin Colombo: You both get zero points because you said things that weren't letters.
[49:31] Justin Colombo: Full disclosure.
[49:32] Justin Colombo: I was gonna say the mark one.
[49:33] Jay Schmidt: So I was yeah, I said A.
[49:36] Justin Colombo: We were wrong.
[49:36] Justin Colombo: Yeah.
[49:38] Justin Colombo: All right, team two, gentlemen.
[49:40] Justin Colombo: You got ready A B C or D.
[49:42] Justin Colombo: Ready one, two, three, go.
[49:45] Matt Ban: Hey.
[49:46] Justin Colombo: Really, you should it should be E, uh, Barry Glickman from The Prom because you kill it.
[49:54] Justin Colombo: So we're gonna give you 10 points for that because that was sweet.
[49:57] Justin Colombo: I like that.
[49:58] Justin Colombo: And then ladies, um, you have A B C or D.
[50:04] Justin Colombo: Ready?
[50:04] Justin Colombo: One, two, three, go.
[50:07] Emily Marshall: E.
[50:09] Kimberly Cooper: You choose because we have been shown that that was a choice that you liked, so we chose that.
[50:16] Justin Colombo: I'm gonna give you two points because it was right, but you're a kiss ass.
[50:21] Justin Colombo: So everyone else who is a kiss ass gets points, but I never do.
[50:30] Justin Colombo: Except me.
[50:31] Justin Colombo: If I'm a kiss ass, I lose points.
[50:34] Justin Colombo: All right.
[50:35] Justin Colombo: So now we've made it to the final round.
[50:37] Justin Colombo: And the way this is gonna work is you have to pick who you think is the best person to stay here to answer the questions.
[50:44] Justin Colombo: It's a rapid fire round, so you're gonna try to get as many points as possible to match your partner, and each one is worth 10 points.
[50:52] Justin Colombo: So this is really gonna be a great chance to try to come back.
[50:55] Justin Colombo: So you've got to say, choose between yourselves who's best to stay here and who's best to try to match the answer.
[51:03] Jay Schmidt: Ryan, I think it's a good idea.
[51:05] Jay Schmidt: I think I'm better.
[51:06] Jay Schmidt: You should stay like we you and you can just answer what I'm saying.
[51:12] Justin Colombo: I'll live.
[51:13] Jay Schmidt: Jay, what do you think?
[51:15] Jay Schmidt: I think I should go.
[51:16] Jay Schmidt: I think I'm better at guessing.
[51:18] Justin Colombo: Okay.
[51:18] Justin Colombo: Oh, so we're with the round two, like the second round of people is like what everybody decided was the best.
[51:24] Justin Colombo: Apparently.
[51:26] Justin Colombo: All right.
[51:26] Justin Colombo: So this one is where you need the majority of your papers.
[51:29] Justin Colombo: So this is we have 15 rapid fire questions that I'm gonna ask you about your person, and we're just gonna go through them quick.
[51:36] Bryan Plofsky: Hi, everybody.
[51:37] Bryan Plofsky: Brian here, interrupting Bestie Battle Part 2.
[51:40] Bryan Plofsky: Uh, just wanted to let you know that we're gonna skip straight to when everybody joined us back in the room to keep you from basically listening to Kevin ask us the same 15 questions over and over again and us writing it down.
[51:52] Bryan Plofsky: So we're gonna skip to the point where everybody joins us back.
[51:55] Bryan Plofsky: He's gonna ask the questions we already have the answers.
[51:58] Bryan Plofsky: Um, to see the full video of him asking us the questions and probably us saying some silly things.
[52:02] Bryan Plofsky: Um, you can see the full video and audio on Patreon.
[52:05] Bryan Plofsky: But back to the episode where everybody joins us for the final round.
[52:09] Bryan Plofsky: Who will win?
[52:10] Justin Colombo: Okay, so this is the way this one's gonna work.
[52:13] Justin Colombo: This is a final round, it is 10 points for every question, and we're gonna see how it goes because this could really make or break the lead here.
[52:21] Justin Colombo: Because right now we're in pretty close quarters.
[52:23] Justin Colombo: We have Kimberly and Emily who have a really good chance of coming back at 64 points.
[52:29] Justin Colombo: We have Jay and Bryan in second place at 81, and Matt Bannon and Justin holding strong at 124.5.
[52:37] Justin Colombo: Okay.
[52:37] Justin Colombo: We're gonna see how they do here in the final round.
[52:40] Justin Colombo: And so these are all about your favorites.
[52:43] Justin Colombo: So round vinyl round, rapid fire.
[52:46] Justin Colombo: Question one.
[52:47] Justin Colombo: What did your best friend say is your favorite Muppet?
[52:52] Jay Schmidt: Muppet.
[52:52] Jay Schmidt: So we're gonna start with Jay.
[52:56] Jay Schmidt: Um, it's uh it's this is technically a Muppet.
[53:01] Jay Schmidt: It's Big Bird.
[53:02] Justin Colombo: What did Bryan or Fozzie?
[53:06] Jay Schmidt: I I I put Fozzie.
[53:08] Justin Colombo: Damn it.
[53:09] Justin Colombo: All right, I'll give you five points because I believe in you.
[53:13] Matt Ban: Uh that band I was I'm gonna go ahead and say uh because this is probably the Muppet that I I am is uh Sweetums, the big like human-sized Muppet.
[53:26] Justin Colombo: Ah, damn.
[53:27] Justin Colombo: Nustan, what did you say?
[53:28] Justin Colombo: Well, okay, so first I said Jason Siegel as a Muppet, but then Fozzie Bear.
[53:33] Kevin Jager: So oh you know what? Jason Siegel as a Muppet made me smile, so I'm giving you two points because that section of the movie is so good.
[53:44] Kimberly Cooper: Um Kimberly and Emily, what do you got for me?
[53:55] Emily Marshall: Because if you are a Muppet, you'd be animal.
[53:59] Kevin Jager: I'll take it. I don't I don't know anything though. Maybe I know things or I don't know things, like there's nothing in between for me. I'm gonna give you 20 points because I feel like Emily is so animal that earns 20 points.
[54:13] Emily Marshall: I don't know what that means, but okay.
[54:15] Jay Schmidt: I very, very affectionately referred to as Emily as a Muppet around her house. Emily is a Muppet because more often than not, when you ask Emily a question, she responds in a Muppet, and that she nods her head and she goes, uh-huh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[54:36] Kevin Jager: Perfect. All right. The next question is, what would your partner or your best friend say is your favorite Disney animated film that is not Pixar?
[54:49] Matt Ban: Oh, I know mine is your favorite Disney animated film that is not Pixar. And we're gonna start with Matt Ban.
[54:59] Matt Ban: He's staring at me like I should know this, and I really I take offense to that. Um I'm just gonna go with maybe the Hercules?
[55:14] Justin Colombo: Uh I said Beauty and the Beast, breath.
[55:16] Kevin Jager: Oh.
[55:17] Justin Colombo: Well, I'm wrong. I love both those movies, but zero points.
[55:23] Kevin Jager: Uh uh Kimberly and Emily, what you got for me, Emily?
[55:27] Emily Marshall: Um Little Mermaid was my favorite one growing up.
[55:31] Kimberly Cooper: Oh, I almost wrote Little Mermaid, and then I also said Hercules.
[55:36] Emily Marshall: It's a great movie.
[55:37] Kimberly Cooper: Great movie. It also zero points.
[55:41] Kevin Jager: I'm sorry, that's I agree, it's a great movie. Um what do you got for me, Jay?
[55:47] Jay Schmidt: Salad, the full stop. Aladdin.
[55:51] Kevin Jager: Yeah, Robin Williams. Ten points right there.
[55:54] Kevin Jager: All right, next question. What is your favorite? What is your partner's or what is your favorite movie from by Disney that is Pixar? Your favorite Disney Pixar movie.
[56:06] Kevin Jager: We're gonna start with Emily.
[56:10] Emily Marshall: She doesn't know movies, and I wrote no movies.
[56:16] Kevin Jager: And I'm gonna give you a- I love that you picked Hercules because the cartoon one's like I can figure something out. The other one, I don't know. Anything 3D, not for you. I'm gonna give you seven points because I've always thought the number seven was the lamest number of all.
[56:34] Justin Colombo: I think it's Kevin.
[56:35] Kevin Jager: I think it's prime. And so I'm gonna give you seven points because I always thought seven seven is lame. I hated it. Um so we'll move on to Matt Ban.
[56:45] Matt Ban: Oh god, I don't know. Like Wreck It Ralph, probably.
[56:49] Justin Colombo: Oh no, that's a good answer.
[56:50] Matt Ban: Nah, bro. I thought.
[56:52] Justin Colombo: Oh, Bob's a great movie.
[56:54] Matt Ban: Yeah, but Wreck or Ralph's also a good movie too, because that's easy something we could be in if they ever did live action. So good choice.
[57:00] Kevin Jager: Not Pixar.
[57:01] Matt Ban: I don't know what Justin just said, but he got three points for it.
[57:04] Kevin Jager: And Jay, what you got for me?
[57:06] Jay Schmidt: Pixar movie, babe. I don't know if you're gonna get this. It's my favorite, and I and I feel like it's on the nose because I'm a middle-aged bingbong, but it's uh inside out.
[57:17] Justin Colombo: Oh no, it's monsters incorporated.
[57:20] Jay Schmidt: Oh yeah. Because we are Sully and Mike Sikowski, like hard.
[57:26] Kevin Jager: Well, Zow's yeah, all right. So next one is your what is your favorite band? What did your best friend say is your favorite band? And by band, I defined it as two or more people, just so you know.
[57:39] Jay Schmidt: Uh, we'll start with Jay. What he thinks my favorite band is?
[57:43] Jay Schmidt: Correct. Ben Holtz, Ben Holtz Five, it's done.
[57:47] Matt Ban: Benfold five, Betty!
[57:48] Kevin Jager: All right, baby. Pen folts five question mark. Because there's only three.
[57:53] Matt Ban: Uh, I'm not sure if you said the Beatles or the Jonas brothers. Either way, he'd be right.
[57:59] Justin Colombo: Nah bruh, I was completely wrong. And I said the Tennessee whiskey singer, and then I remembered who it was. I said, oh boy, Chris, but then I said Journey. So like big swing and a miss.
[58:12] Emily Marshall: All right. Uh Emily.
[58:15] Emily Marshall: Well, I'm unsure if it like we're going with the same starting line or if we're going with dashboard or if we're going with Jax Mannequin, but those are the three that I was thinking about.
[58:22] Kevin Jager: What do you pick one? You need to pick five.
[58:24] Emily Marshall: Okay, okay, I'm not looking. Um dashboard.
[58:28] Jay Schmidt: Dashboard!
[58:30] Emily Marshall: I didn't look. I didn't look, I promise.
[58:32] Kevin Jager: I believe you. So I gave you 11 points because I believe you.
[58:38] Kevin Jager: Okay, so now the next question is who is your who did your best friend say is your favorite spice girl?
[58:46] Kevin Jager: Oh what's happening here? If you don't know what my favorite one is, you're out of your mind. Um and we're gonna start this time with Matt Ban because he looked really excited to think about spice girls.
[59:01] Matt Ban: I think it was scary spice.
[59:03] Justin Colombo: Oh man, that was my number two, but I said ginger because I was like, I don't know.
[59:07] Matt Ban: Oh, I love ginger. All right, but it's a good choice, but zero points right there.
[59:12] Kevin Jager: Um what do you got for me, Jay?
[59:15] Jay Schmidt: Yo, it's ginger spice.
[59:17] Kevin Jager: Ginger, of course.
[59:19] Jay Schmidt: Yeah, man. Hello. Have you met my wife? She has the reddis of hair.
[59:25] Emily Marshall: Uh Emily, what you got?
[59:27] Emily Marshall: I don't know all of the spice girls. But what did you say?
[59:30] Kimberly Cooper: Um, what did I say? I I didn't say anything because I I don't have a favorite spice girl.
[59:37] Kimberly Cooper: What did you say, Kimberly?
[59:39] Kimberly Cooper: I said sporty. Because I thought maybe you'd remember her outfits.
[59:44] Emily Marshall: Yeah. Sure. Kimberly, that's a valiant answer, but you guys lose five points because Emily doesn't know at least one name of a spice girl.
[59:52] Emily Marshall: No, I knew the ones that were set. I wanted us to have all the choices.
[59:57] Kevin Jager: I think you're lying, so you might lose 10 points. Next question is what did your best friend say is your favorite animal?
[1:00:07] Kevin Jager: Emily, you're not allowed to hate animals and music and people and friends. Like you let's start with Jay.
[1:00:18] Jay Schmidt: What's your favorite animal? Uh my favorite animal are there the kangaroos.
[1:00:23] Jay Schmidt: No pandas, it's panda, it's panda.
[1:00:25] Kevin Jager: No, it's what are you talking about? It's panda. All right, I'm giving you 10 points because if you didn't say panda, I would personally punch you.
[1:00:33] Jay Schmidt: No, it's panda. I just you were looking at Kango.
[1:00:36] Matt Ban: I was looking at Kang and she's up on the show.
[1:00:38] Matt Ban: What's your favorite animal?
[1:00:40] Matt Ban: Some kind of bear.
[1:00:42] Kevin Jager: Uh yeah. I should have said bear, but it's I said dog. I don't know, man. I was panicking at this point during the question.
[1:00:57] Kevin Jager: Emily, what is your answer?
[1:00:59] Emily Marshall: I apparently hate everything. Um, but like real animal or like cartoon animal. I will say for the fact that when I asked what their favorite animal was, Kimberly's face went, huh? Like she was like, this is a bad question for us.
[1:01:17] Kevin Jager: So like she she knew. She knew.
[1:01:20] Emily Marshall: I don't like animals. Um I like animals that I know, or I like cartoon mice. But what did you what did you say was your what's your is your answer cartoon vice?
[1:01:30] Emily Marshall: Um I was asking if she likes this animal or she's afraid of them, but I said turtle?
[1:01:36] Kimberly Cooper: I'm I'm afraid of them.
[1:01:44] Kevin Jager: Yeah, yeah, no, no, my favorite animal is not a turtle. I don't understand them. I hate it. You've got desperately needed understanding. That's a present for both of them.
[1:01:58] Kevin Jager: All right. So the next question. The next question is what did your best friend say is your favorite cocktail? What would they think is your go-to favorite cocktail?
[1:02:08] Kevin Jager: Emily, what's your yeah?
[1:02:10] Emily Marshall: Well, then I'm gonna have to say tequila grapefruit.
[1:02:13] Kevin Jager: Um what did you say?
[1:02:16] Emily Marshall: Tequila grapefruit.
[1:02:17] Kevin Jager: Perfect. 10 points.
[1:02:19] Emily Marshall: A turtle.
[1:02:22] Kevin Jager: I hate them. I'm so scared of them.
[1:02:25] Matt Ban: What's your favorite cocktail?
[1:02:27] Matt Ban: Um Manhattan.
[1:02:29] Justin Colombo: Oh, dude, nah, bro.
[1:02:31] Matt Ban: That's old fashioned, bro.
[1:02:32] Kevin Jager: Oh well, you know. You know what though? When I was a waiter, when I was a waiter, I was confused between what the two of those were. So I'm gonna give you 10 points because I would have thought that was the same thing.
[1:02:42] Kevin Jager: Wow. Like he's answering all these questions that have to do with his life. I feel like that's how we're winning points. Flashbacks to my first catch. You know, I connect with here's a personal story about how I connect with that. Here's 10 points. I'm like, let's go.
[1:02:58] Jay Schmidt: Jay Schmidt, what you got for me, baby?
[1:03:03] Kevin Jager: The Brian's ordering me. No, just what does he think is your favorite? What does he think your favorite cocktail is?
[1:03:08] Jay Schmidt: Oh, uh tequila soda.
[1:03:11] Kevin Jager: Uh I mean, I no, uh I I put tequila rocks.
[1:03:17] Kevin Jager: That's basically you know what? Water and soda are basically the same thing, so I'm gonna give you 10 points.
[1:03:22] Jay Schmidt: All right. I don't like this game.
[1:03:26] Kevin Jager: Emily got it right, and nobody else did, and everyone got the same points. Emily, I understand this is unfair, so I'm gonna give you 25 points.
[1:03:36] Kevin Jager: Okay, we're good. Well, I'm complaining too now.
[1:03:39] Kevin Jager: All right. Next question. Next question. What did your best friend say is your favorite preparation of potatoes? How would you want your potatoes? Would you want them mashed, baked, double baked, fried into fries, turned into like hash browns? I don't know what they do with potatoes. They do lots of stuff. But what is your specific take on potatoes? We're gonna start with Jay Schmidt, because he looks like he loves his potatoes.
[1:04:06] Jay Schmidt: Potato pancakes from Hal's Deli.
[1:04:09] Kevin Jager: Oh I said I said hash.
[1:04:13] Jay Schmidt: Which is which is not that far off.
[1:04:16] Kevin Jager: No, it's not. It's just not that far off, but it's so far from points.
[1:04:17] Kevin Jager: So far from points. It's zero. So uh Matt Ban, what you got for me?
[1:04:24] Matt Ban: Tater tots.
[1:04:26] Kevin Jager: Oh, I said mash, bruh. You don't know me at all, get out of my life. But I said Alan Alderbra, I said mash those potatoes, bro.
[1:04:33] Kevin Jager: You're a point. I'm sorry.
[1:04:35] Emily Marshall: Uh cheesy tots for cheesy tots for off the wagon days.
[1:04:43] Kimberly Cooper: What did you say?
[1:04:46] Kimberly Cooper: I said sweet potato fries slash baked. An oven baked sweet potato fry.
[1:04:53] Emily Marshall: Oh, no, I would love that, but I was going back to off the wagon days, so I was going further away. I you know, sometimes I don't think of tater tots as potatoes. And this is also skewing into a boring situation. So let's move on.
[1:05:06] Kevin Jager: Kevin hates our conversation.
[1:05:10] Kevin Jager: All right. Wait, so no, no, no, no, no. No, no, no, no, no. We don't no no no no no no. We don't think it's tater tots as potatoes. It's more cheesy tots, I think of as a cheese dish, not a potato dish.
[1:05:23] Justin Colombo: What?
[1:05:26] Kevin Jager: Our cause is not being helped at the moment.
[1:05:28] Justin Colombo: Salad a dressing dish.
[1:05:31] Kevin Jager: See, I agree. Thank you. Well done, Justin. Well done.
[1:05:34] Kevin Jager: All right. Next question. French? What is the temperature that your best friend what is the temperature that your best friend thinks you would order a steak? So if you're ordering a steak, what is your best friend think you're gonna say? And is it uh we're going by temperatures like rare, medium rare, medium, well done. Well, so you're ordering the steak. What is your best friend think you are gonna say? And I'm gonna start with Matt Ban.
[1:06:03] Matt Ban: Rare.
[1:06:05] Justin Colombo: Let's go, bruh. Let's go.
[1:06:10] Kevin Jager: We've got one. Look at you go. Little giants baby only is one time. All right, uh Emily, what's she got?
[1:06:18] Emily Marshall: As rare as you will legally serve it to me.
[1:06:21] Jay Schmidt: I knew that.
[1:06:21] Emily Marshall: Which is why it was said bloody.
[1:06:24] Kevin Jager: Bloody.
[1:06:26] Jay Schmidt: Like not. I know their friendship well enough to being married to half of it. In that yeah.
[1:06:33] Kevin Jager: All right. Jay, what's your answer?
[1:06:36] Jay Schmidt: Um uh rare.
[1:06:38] Kevin Jager: Rare.
[1:06:38] Jay Schmidt: Oh, I I said medium rare.
[1:06:40] Kevin Jager: Damn it. See, you know, that's here's the thing. That's you're trying to be cool by saying rare, but you order medium rare.
[1:06:46] Jay Schmidt: I order medium rare, he's right. You were influenced by those around you. We should all we should all eat meat together though, because we like raw. We should have done this at a steakhouse in the future when we're allowed back in places again at a steakhouse.
[1:06:59] Bryan Plofsky: I love this.
[1:07:01] Kevin Jager: Next question favorite color. What's your favorite color?
[1:07:04] Bryan Plofsky: Matt Ban, what's your favorite color, man?
[1:07:08] Matt Ban: Green.
[1:07:10] Bryan Plofsky: Oh nice, well done. You got it.
[1:07:14] Bryan Plofsky: Jay, what's your favorite color, man?
[1:07:16] Jay Schmidt: Um, red for accessories.
[1:07:20] Kevin Jager: Wait, what else?
[1:07:21] Jay Schmidt: Keep going. It's red for accessories, but like I have favorite colors for different things in my life. Like it's like turquoise and like for like a lot of things.
[1:07:30] Matt Ban: Not turquoise.
[1:07:31] Jay Schmidt: Teal.
[1:07:32] Bryan Plofsky: Oh teal. Did I write red teal for clothes?
[1:07:42] Jay Schmidt: It's red for accessories.
[1:07:43] Bryan Plofsky: Wow! I'm giving you 20 points because that just like look at the hats. That just gave me a semi. Like, that was impressive.
[1:07:53] Matt Ban: That was impressive.
[1:07:55] Bryan Plofsky: All right, Matt Ban. I got a semi. What'd you do with that, man?
[1:07:58] Matt Ban: Your quest, your answer.
[1:07:59] Bryan Plofsky: Wait, what if what I do with your semi?
[1:08:02] Matt Ban: No, what's your answer?
[1:08:04] Bryan Plofsky: I already gave you my answer.
[1:08:06] Kevin Jager: Oh, Emily then.
[1:08:10] Emily Marshall: I don't have one.
[1:08:12] Bryan Plofsky: What?
[1:08:13] Emily Marshall: I don't have a favorite color.
[1:08:15] Bryan Plofsky: What?
[1:08:16] Emily Marshall: To see what Kimberly said.
[1:08:18] Kimberly Cooper: I only tried to panic it said blue.
[1:08:21] Emily Marshall: But then I was like, but it's not true. We discussed this.
[1:08:25] Kimberly Cooper: I know. And then now here I am drinking it again. And I can't recall. And what does that I don't have one though?
[1:08:33] Bryan Plofsky: And that's really sweet, but I give you minus six points because that's also weird.
[1:08:37] Emily Marshall: So I hate how I feel about things, Kevin.
[1:08:41] Bryan Plofsky: But it's okay. All right. Who would your best friend say is your favorite Les Mis character?
[1:08:51] Emily Marshall: Uh Javert.
[1:08:56] Bryan Plofsky: I said Javert, and then I crossed it out and said Éponine because I wasn't sure if you knew his name. That was the first one that came to my mind, and that's the first one that came to my mind. And then I said yes. Kevin hates when we explain like this. So I'm giving you the 10 points because I judge Emily too harshly.
[1:09:13] Bryan Plofsky: Next question. Um, so we're going on to Jay. Um he's never seen this show. Who sings Master of the House?
[1:09:19] Jay Schmidt: That's uh that's Thénardier.
[1:09:25] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, that one, that's so funny.
[1:09:34] Matt Ban: That's good. Uh that bad.
[1:09:36] Jay Schmidt: Ah man, I thought Javert first, but I think I'm gonna go with Thénardier too.
[1:09:42] Bryan Plofsky: You fool.
[1:09:43] Jay Schmidt: Oh Javert.
[1:09:47] Bryan Plofsky: You get five points for having that feeling originally.
[1:09:50] Jay Schmidt: Yeah, it was like a semi. It went away really fast.
[1:09:52] Bryan Plofsky: Right, it went away really quick. Next question is what is the liquor that your best friend would what is the liquor that you would want to take a shot of? If your best friend was like, let's take shots. What's the liquor that you would choose for you to take shots of?
[1:10:09] Jay Schmidt: Can I go first?
[1:10:10] Jay Schmidt: Tequila.
[1:10:12] Bryan Plofsky: Done.
[1:10:13] Jay Schmidt: Tequila.
[1:10:14] Bryan Plofsky: Yep. I would choose for both of us to do.
[1:10:18] Emily Marshall: Yes.
[1:10:19] Bryan Plofsky: Emily, what would you choose for both of you?
[1:10:22] Emily Marshall: Tequila?
[1:10:23] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah. Tequila.
[1:10:25] Bryan Plofsky: All right. Matt and Justin.
[1:10:29] Justin Colombo: Whiskey.
[1:10:30] Matt Ban: I said Widow Jane Bourbon, but I wish they said Bullet. But you know what? That's the old whiskey, so I'll give you whiskey.
[1:10:36] Justin Colombo: I know, but I really wish I could taste Widow Jane.
[1:10:38] Bryan Plofsky: I thought that this is the one that like all of us knew. We're like, it's a good one. You know how to do that.
[1:10:44] Kevin Jager: So can we get specific? That's how we know we're on the like the right.
[1:10:50] Bryan Plofsky: I know our best friend. Uh season. What is your best friend? What is your favorite season of the year? What did your best friend say was your favorite season of the year?
[1:11:01] Bryan Plofsky: And we'll start with Emily.
[1:11:04] Emily Marshall: Uh summer.
[1:11:06] Bryan Plofsky: Summer.
[1:11:08] Kevin Jager: Nice.
[1:11:10] Bryan Plofsky: Uh we had no explanation about that. It was just one word. In and out.
[1:11:15] Bryan Plofsky: Matt Ban.
[1:11:17] Matt Ban: Summer.
[1:11:18] Bryan Plofsky: Boom, baby. Let's go, dude. Yes.
[1:11:21] Bryan Plofsky: Uh Bryan and Jay. Jay, what you got?
[1:11:24] Jay Schmidt: Fall.
[1:11:25] Bryan Plofsky: He hates summer.
[1:11:27] Jay Schmidt: Fall.
[1:11:28] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah. I like a zip-up hoodie. I like, I like, I like a beanie.
[1:11:34] Jay Schmidt: And you have no sun.
[1:11:37] Bryan Plofsky: No, no sense. What is your favorite holiday? And we'll start with Matt Ban.
[1:11:42] Matt Ban: Halloween.
[1:11:46] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, that's the right answer, but I didn't I didn't say that. I said Christmas.
[1:11:49] Emily Marshall: I know. I literally he said the question out loud now, and I realized my folly, so I apologize.
[1:11:57] Bryan Plofsky: Uh Kimberly, what is or Emily, what is Kimberly's or Emily, what is your favorite holiday?
[1:12:04] Emily Marshall: Um I would well, I don't like holidays again because I apparently hate everything. Um but Christmas or Empanada Day would be my answer.
[1:12:15] Bryan Plofsky: Oh, Empanada is a great answer. I said Christmas because of the cookies.
[1:12:18] Emily Marshall: Yeah, I do like making the cookies.
[1:12:20] Bryan Plofsky: Hold on, sidebar. What day is Empanada Day?
[1:12:23] Emily Marshall: Um February 29th.
[1:12:25] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah. It only happens once every four years.
[1:12:29] Emily Marshall: You have to explain the whole story now.
[1:12:31] Bryan Plofsky: At this point, you've mentioned it so many times that I feel like it needs to be like in Kevin Kimberly. There was one time that like, yeah, um, me and Kimberly were we were living together. I don't remember if we were.
[1:12:43] Kimberly Cooper: It was a Harlem apartment.
[1:12:45] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah, I was in your bed. So um me and Kimberly woke up the next morning, and my computer was only screenshots of empanadas, and we didn't know why, because we were very drunk the night before, and we woke up and we were like, we need to eat empanadas, and then we're like, oh, we should eat empanadas every day on this day of the year, and it happened to be February 29th, because we didn't realize that. And so it's the rarest holiday of any holidays that would happen, but we do it every four years now, and we have had three now.
[1:13:15] Kimberly Cooper: Three, okay, or was this four?
[1:13:17] Bryan Plofsky: No, three. This is our third Empanada Day that we have celebrated. So every February 29th, man can really go and find empanadas and eat as many as we can every day on February 29th, every four years.
[1:13:31] Emily Marshall: We didn't mean to have it like be this like really rare, weird holiday, but like we just happened to be. So we woke up drunk on Leap Day and then wanted Empanada Day.
[1:13:39] Bryan Plofsky: It's so much better that way.
[1:13:41] Emily Marshall: It's so much better. It's like Narnia.
[1:13:42] Bryan Plofsky: Narnia shows up on Empanada Day.
[1:13:45] Emily Marshall: It does.
[1:13:46] Bryan Plofsky: Yep. That's Empanada Day.
[1:13:48] Jay Schmidt: That was amazing. Jay, did I ask you your favorite holiday yet?
[1:13:52] Jay Schmidt: No, my favorite holiday is Christmas. And if Bryan doesn't know that, yeah, Christmas. Uh full stop.
[1:13:56] Bryan Plofsky: Yeah. All right. And uh last question is who is your favorite person named Kevin that's not me.
[1:14:12] Kevin Jager: Oh, I know what it is. Your favorite person. Who did your best friend think you would say is your favorite person named Kevin that's not me?
[1:14:22] Bryan Plofsky: And we're gonna start. We're gonna go team one, two, three. We're gonna throw Jay.
[1:14:25] Jay Schmidt: Uh remember that that time I let you on fire at the Pancake Festival. It's Kevin James.
[1:14:31] Bryan Plofsky: It's Kevin James.
[1:14:34] Jay Schmidt: Paul Blart, Mall Cop, Kevin James.
[1:14:37] Bryan Plofsky: What'd you say?
[1:14:40] Justin Colombo: Jerry.
[1:14:44] Bryan Plofsky: I mean, I did not choose Kevin James. Kevin, you said, who did you say?
[1:14:49] Justin Colombo: Who do you think I said?
[1:14:52] Bryan Plofsky: That's what he just said.
[1:14:53] Justin Colombo: Oh, Kevin McAllister from Full House from the Empire.
[1:15:00] Bryan Plofsky: I said, everyone's favorite McAllister from the opposite of Full House, Home Alone.
[1:15:00] Justin Colombo: Home Alone.
[1:15:07] Bryan Plofsky: Um, so you don't know the Full House for Hill House?
[1:15:09] Justin Colombo: Yeah, the opposite of Full House.
[1:15:10] Bryan Plofsky: That was funny. I was you know, Full House they killed those two men with toys.
[1:15:15] Justin Colombo: Yeah, okay.
[1:15:16] Bryan Plofsky: I was gonna give everyone points in this final question, but you don't get points because you overload Full House.
[1:15:16] Bryan Plofsky: All right, so Matt Ban, what she got for me?
[1:15:27] Matt Ban: I was thinking your favorite person named Kevin that's not me. It's Kevin Raponi.
[1:15:32] Bryan Plofsky: Baby, yeah, it is Kevin Raponi.
[1:15:36] Justin Colombo: Oh, Robin.
[1:15:36] Bryan Plofsky: All right, and Emily, who's your favorite person named Kevin that's not me?
[1:15:43] Emily Marshall: Kevin McNaughton. Your friend Kevin, because I couldn't remember his last name.
[1:15:51] Bryan Plofsky: That could be Kevin McCaffrey for all we know.
[1:15:51] Bryan Plofsky: All right. So while I finish up tallying the points for this game, talk amongst yourselves.
[1:16:02] Kimberly Cooper: Okay, cool.
[1:16:03] Bryan Plofsky: Okay. I'll go through the quote of this episode while Kevin does it.
[1:16:08] Kimberly Cooper: Yeah.
[1:16:09] Bryan Plofsky: Oh, you're the best friend that I ever had. I've been with you such a long time. You're my sunshine, and I want you to know that my feelings are true. I really love you. Oh, you're my best friend.
[1:16:21] Kevin Jager: Well, that is the quote. Um, thank you all so much for joining us. You can of course follow us at Broadwaysted. You can find us on social media. Um, you can join our Patreon where you can see this outrageous video. Um you can also find us on Spotify and uh Apple Podcasts. Written review us there. Five stars, please. And thank you.
[1:16:46] Matt Ban: Um, and uh uh Matt, where can we find you since uh you're a first-time guest?
[1:16:54] Matt Ban: Oh uh I'm on Instagram at Batman with two T's, 1167. For those of you who are wondering why, it's because Matt Ban switched the M and the B, get Batman.
[1:17:08] Bryan Plofsky: Um tattoo? Do you have a Batman tattoo?
[1:17:11] Matt Ban: Anyway, uh also uh you know what? That's it. That's really all I deleted my Twitter because I got tired of being on Twitter. So yeah, follow me on Instagram.
[1:17:21] Bryan Plofsky: Right. But here we go. I think it was a great learning experience for all, but there was one winner. So in third place, who are doing really great as best friends, but could like maybe like step it up a notch, are Kimberly Cooper Schmidt and Emily Marshall.
[1:17:42] Justin Colombo: To be fair, she doesn't have a favorite movie or color.
[1:17:46] Bryan Plofsky: So I hate everything.
[1:17:49] Emily Marshall: I hate all people, I hate all animals.
[1:17:52] Bryan Plofsky: So I do agree that if there was an option that was I hate it all, then Kimberly would have won every question.
[1:18:02] Justin Colombo: For sure.
[1:18:03] Bryan Plofsky: Now it comes down to our gentleman, and I will tell you the difference is 1.5 points. But the winners of the Broadwaysted Besties Battle are drumroll.
[1:18:35] Bryan Plofsky: But Jay and Bryan.
[1:18:39] Jay Schmidt: Look at that. But where'd you go to school?
[1:18:42] Bryan Plofsky: We didn't. We didn't go to school. We're not doing this.
[1:18:46] Jay Schmidt: Literally, if somebody if so much. If somebody had said Ithaca, that would have changed the behavior.
[1:18:56] Bryan Plofsky: Look at Allah you boys?
[1:18:58] Jay Schmidt: I think Bryan's sweatshirt should have counted the entire hand.
[1:19:07] Bryan Plofsky: This has been so much fun though. Thank you so much for playing along with us. Thanks, Matt and Justin and Emily, for joining us. Jay, I feel like you kind of just joined us because you're married to Bryan and Kimberly. But thank you for joining us.
[1:19:24] Bryan Plofsky: We have a lot of cool ideas to do these kind of like game show style episodes with you guys. So if you're enjoying them, definitely let us know because we want to keep doing these with amazing people like Emily and Matt and Justin. And Matt will be uh joining our lineup very soon as one of our actual official guests. So make sure to listen out to that one.
[1:19:45] Matt Ban: I'm gonna be listening to that one.
[1:19:47] Bryan Plofsky: Oh yeah. Well, as we end every episode, we raise a glass and we say, he's your friend, author. We say if you have 45 minutes, I'll tell you that story.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
