In the ninth episode in the “Conversations From Away” series, we are proud to present another installment of BIPOC: Behind the Curtain. This time, we’re diving into world of the music... Read More
From the show: Conversations From Away
Featured Shows
About
In the ninth episode in the “Conversations From Away” series, we are proud to present another installment of BIPOC: Behind the Curtain. This time, we’re diving into world of the music. Listen in as Aaron chats with Alvin Hough, Jr (TINA: The Tina Turner Musical, Once On This Island), Zane Mark (Bring in ’da Noise, Bring in ’da Funk (co-writer), The Cher Show, Motown the Musical), and Cameron Moncur (Music Director-Come From Away North American Tour, Jersey Boys) about their experiences and observations as musicians in the theater industry, and what they see on the horizon. We also learn all about Musicians United for Social Equity (MUSE), a phenomenal organization that strives to cultivate more racial equity in theatrical music departments.
Learn more about MUSE and it’s sister organizations:
Host: Aaron Michael Ray (@aaronraystagram on Instagram)
Guests: Alvin Hough, Jr. (@alvinhoughpiano on Instagram and Twitter)
Zane Mark
Cameron Moncur
Special Thanks to Broadway Podcast Network and Junkyard Dog Productions
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:02] Aaron Michael Ray: Alright, welcome back everyone to Conversations from Away.
[0:06] Aaron Michael Ray: I'm your host, Aaron Michael Ray, and we are super excited to continue our BIPOC behind the curtains series for this episode.
[0:15] Aaron Michael Ray: So in our last episode of this series, we talked about wardrobe and costumes and really got into detail about just what that department is and what the representation also looks like for BIPOC folks in the styling in wardrobe.
[0:31] Aaron Michael Ray: And so for this time, we are gonna get into music.
[0:36] Aaron Michael Ray: And I brought three people that I think are pretty okay at what they do.
[0:42] Aaron Michael Ray: So I'm really excited to have them all here.
[0:47] Aaron Michael Ray: Zane Zayn, oh I don't know. Um, so I am going to introduce our guests.
[0:53] Aaron Michael Ray: Our first one, as our Come From Away representative, is one of my very, very dear friends, Cameron Moncur.
[1:03] Aaron Michael Ray: Cameron is our music director on the Come From Away tour.
[1:07] Aaron Michael Ray: And his Broadway credits include Mean Girls, Finding Neverland, Tuck Everlasting, and he also did the Finding Neverland and Jersey Boys Tours.
[1:15] Aaron Michael Ray: Welcome, Cam.
[1:17] Cameron Moncur: Hi.
[1:20] Aaron Michael Ray: And we also have two really special guests who I'm so excited to just pick their brains and get to know.
[1:27] Aaron Michael Ray: Our first one is Alvin Hough Jr., who is currently the associate music director on Tina, the Tina Turner musical.
[1:35] Aaron Michael Ray: Also, Broadway credits include Once on This Island, The Color Purple, Motown, and Scandalous.
[1:42] Aaron Michael Ray: Alvin, I'm so excited that you are here as well.
[1:44] Alvin Hough Jr.: Thank you so much. Great, great to be here.
[1:49] Aaron Michael Ray: And last but not least, we have Zane Mark here, who was one of the co-writers for Bring in the Noise, Bringin' De Funk, and his Broadway credits include Holler If You Can Hear Me, Motown, The Cher Show, Pippin, and quite a lot more.
[2:06] Aaron Michael Ray: There's such a great list of credits.
[2:09] Aaron Michael Ray: So Zane, I'm really excited that you were here as well.
[2:12] Zane Mark: Thanks for the invite.
[2:15] Aaron Michael Ray: Of course.
[2:17] Aaron Michael Ray: So as I said before, we're getting into BIPOC behind the curtain for music.
[2:21] Aaron Michael Ray: And so I think I just honestly want to start by asking all three of you, did you go to school to be musicians for theater?
[2:30] Aaron Michael Ray: And if you did, when was that shift to wanting to work on Broadway? What about you, Cam?
[2:38] Cameron Moncur: Um, I actually started out as a performer.
[2:42] Cameron Moncur: So I played piano my whole life and I went, I'm originally from Canada.
[2:47] Cameron Moncur: And so I went to school for performing at Sheridan College, um, for music theater, and ended up playing more classes as an accompanist than I did actually performing in any of the shows, and fell in love with it and decided to make the shift.
[3:07] Cameron Moncur: So I transferred and I knew that if I wanted to be a musician, I wanted to be in New York, and so I decided to go to an American school to help with immigration stuff, and so I went to Berklee with the one and only Aaron Michael Ray.
[3:21] Cameron Moncur: And uh yeah, got my degree at Berklee and then graduated and moved to New York and the rest is history.
[3:26] Cameron Moncur: But yeah, there was definitely a shift for me.
[3:29] Aaron Michael Ray: Okay, okay.
[3:30] Aaron Michael Ray: Yes, that is quite the fun fact of the day.
[3:33] Aaron Michael Ray: Is Cam and I go way back to the college days of Berklee College of Music.
[3:38] Aaron Michael Ray: Uh shout out to our alma mater.
[3:40] Aaron Michael Ray: Um what about you, Zane?
[3:44] Zane Mark: I um didn't really have any piano lessons when I grew up.
[3:49] Zane Mark: Uh my grandmother taught us a little piano when we were young.
[3:52] Zane Mark: I did go to music and art high school in uh New York, and they didn't really have any piano class as it were.
[4:02] Zane Mark: The piano that they taught was vocalist, so that they had some basic piano theory.
[4:07] Zane Mark: So my um, my my piano playing is really applied theory.
[4:13] Zane Mark: Um so um, but eventually I, you know, got my hand in books out just so that I could play what I heard.
[4:20] Zane Mark: Um my father was a musician, so that was a major influence in my life.
[4:25] Zane Mark: He was a woodwind player, so my lazy ass when I went to music and art, because they didn't teach piano, I'd say what is the smallest and lightest instrument I can, you know, so I I became pretty good on the flute because I was lazy, and there you go.
[4:42] Aaron Michael Ray: Okay.
[4:43] Aaron Michael Ray: Well, I mean, listen, if that's also what brought you to here, then I think the flute got you somewhere pretty far.
[4:52] Zane Mark: Well, my father was, like I said, he was a musician in the um, the second half of his life, say 75% of his jobs were in theater.
[5:01] Zane Mark: So I would hang around, and that's that was my introduction, actually to theater, was hanging around backstage with my father.
[5:07] Zane Mark: And hey kid, copy this.
[5:09] Zane Mark: I was a copyist when I first got involved.
[5:11] Zane Mark: So I copied music for a lot of shows, and that was my introduction into arranging as well.
[5:16] Aaron Michael Ray: Oh, okay.
[5:17] Aaron Michael Ray: And you also have, speaking of which, because you have done a lot of dance arranging, and I think I know what that means to be a dance arranger, but I think it would be best for you to explain it.
[5:30] Aaron Michael Ray: So could you just give us a little uh info about what it means to be a dance arranger for Broadway shows?
[5:35] Zane Mark: Yeah, so first of all, don't feel bad about that, because my wife, who's also a performer, still I don't think is 100% sure what I do.
[5:44] Zane Mark: But the simplest explanation would be any time there is music, I mean there's dancing and there's music and no singing, 95% of the time in the show I create that music.
[5:58] Zane Mark: So sometimes that might be just taking a verse with the song the way it exists and just creating um letting the music be more supportive of the dance.
[6:09] Zane Mark: It might be creating something completely different that doesn't exist at all and tells a different story in there, but 95% of the time when there's no music for an extended, you know, amount of time, I create that music or edit that music or arrange that music, however you want to.
[6:24] Aaron Michael Ray: Okay.
[6:26] Aaron Michael Ray: Uh I mean, listen, the more you know, I'm glad that you broke that down because I had truly no idea.
[6:32] Aaron Michael Ray: Um so Alvin, your story is very interesting because you did not go to school for theater or for music.
[6:43] Aaron Michael Ray: So what was your training and upbringing musically like?
[6:49] Alvin Hough Jr.: Uh, great question.
[6:50] Alvin Hough Jr.: Uh I'm from Washington, DC originally, and I was five, and it was Halloween.
[6:56] Alvin Hough Jr.: I remember that.
[6:57] Alvin Hough Jr.: Because it was a big deal to go trick-or-treating.
[6:59] Alvin Hough Jr.: And this was the first day of school that no one could come pick me up.
[7:02] Alvin Hough Jr.: Uh, everyone had a doctor's appointment, beauty salon, whatever.
[7:06] Alvin Hough Jr.: Everybody was busy.
[7:07] Alvin Hough Jr.: Like, Alvin, just go to the after school room for an hour, we'll come get you.
[7:10] Alvin Hough Jr.: Uh, that teacher told my mom when she came to get me, you see that piano over there?
[7:16] Alvin Hough Jr.: Alvin wasn't banging on it like the other kids.
[7:18] Alvin Hough Jr.: He seemed like he was trying to do something.
[7:20] Alvin Hough Jr.: Get him some lessons, see what happens.
[7:22] Alvin Hough Jr.: Total shot in the dark.
[7:23] Alvin Hough Jr.: No one in my immediate family has any training.
[7:26] Alvin Hough Jr.: I found this great private teacher when I was five.
[7:29] Alvin Hough Jr.: And she told me when I was 13, I started off classically.
[7:31] Alvin Hough Jr.: She essentially said, hey kid, you're starting to get good at this.
[7:34] Alvin Hough Jr.: If you ever want to make money, you're not gonna make money if you can only play Bach.
[7:39] Alvin Hough Jr.: So she knew what she did.
[7:41] Alvin Hough Jr.: She knew what she knew, and she knew what she didn't know.
[7:43] Alvin Hough Jr.: She's like, Well, I can teach you Bach, but I can't teach you anything else.
[7:46] Alvin Hough Jr.: But I know people.
[7:47] Alvin Hough Jr.: She says, You are going to play at your church service, and you will this is going to happen.
[7:53] Alvin Hough Jr.: There's no ifs, ands, or buts.
[7:54] Alvin Hough Jr.: I'm forcing them to let you play in church.
[7:56] Alvin Hough Jr.: A place where you know everyone loved me, everyone knew me, been going to that church for years, grew up in that church.
[8:02] Alvin Hough Jr.: And there's when I, you know, I remember that uh it was uh like first Sunday in July when I was 13, and I remember the exact moment.
[8:11] Alvin Hough Jr.: Um I locked eyes with organists on the first song, and he pointed up, and I had no idea what that meant.
[8:16] Alvin Hough Jr.: And of course, that meant he went up a half step and I crashed and burned.
[8:20] Alvin Hough Jr.: It was awful.
[8:22] Alvin Hough Jr.: But because my teacher put me in a place where I was loved and could be nurtured, that's where I learned how to cite transpose.
[8:22] Alvin Hough Jr.: That's where I learned how to follow soloists.
[8:32] Alvin Hough Jr.: That's where I learned how to, you know, follow a choir director, all those things that you that Bach can't teach you.
[8:38] Aaron Michael Ray: Right.
[8:38] Alvin Hough Jr.: And she also took me to um a summer camp and I was introduced to theater.
[8:43] Alvin Hough Jr.: My first show was uh Tommy.
[8:47] Alvin Hough Jr.: I knew nothing about the Who, nothing about rock music, so that was like an eye-opening moment for me.
[8:52] Alvin Hough Jr.: Um, so that all happened when I was 13.
[8:55] Alvin Hough Jr.: Um, so I didn't go to school for music.
[8:57] Alvin Hough Jr.: Um my other passion is meteorology and I won't bore your listeners here with that but I would I have a bachelor's from Harvard in Earth and Planetary Sciences and I got my master's from Georgia Tech in meteorology.
[9:10] Alvin Hough Jr.: I never got to apply it on TV or anything but I know how inexact the science is and how much we're all guessing.
[9:17] Alvin Hough Jr.: But that's for another day.
[9:20] Alvin Hough Jr.: But um I had friends from DC move up to New York and one of them called me and said hey Alvin I think you're good enough to play piano in New York and I thought he was insane.
[9:28] Alvin Hough Jr.: And he said if you ever if that weather thing doesn't work out give me a call I know some people so when I graduated in the fall of 08 right when the economy crashed I didn't have a job couldn't find anything so I'm like hey let's go to New York let's make this happen see what see what works and I've been here now 12 years and luckily have found a way to make it work.
[9:49] Alvin Hough Jr.: Um I have to say that I really love that one of your first shows was the uh the Who's Tommy because that was one of the I think that was the first show I ever like got paid to do at this you know community theater um and Cam even came to see me in this production.
[10:10] Alvin Hough Jr.: So I that really just has a special place in my heart as well.
[10:16] Alvin Hough Jr.: Pinball Wizard man I tell you so okay let's get into it.
[10:22] Aaron Michael Ray: So I feel like in my career so far something I realized I honestly had to I couldn't believe myself when I found this out, and I had to actually go through each and every show that I have done to make sure that I this is true.
[10:38] Aaron Michael Ray: But in my career so far, um, in shows that I have gotten paid to do as an actor, I have yet to have a black person or even a person of color on the music team.
[10:53] Aaron Michael Ray: And I kind of a part of me can't really believe like it's really hard for me to believe that, but at the same time, I I don't know, maybe it isn't.
[11:02] Aaron Michael Ray: And so I feel so something I want to ask y'all is is it because it's actually hard to find someone of color to fulfill these jobs, or are they not trying hard enough to search for BIPOC representation in these shows?
[11:20] Alvin Hough Jr.: Um, I can start there.
[11:21] Alvin Hough Jr.: Uh I think theater is I think every every genre of music has its own, you know, unique, you know, uh descriptors, ways to go about it, ways to excel in it.
[11:35] Alvin Hough Jr.: And I think the overarching issue is that there are plenty of talented people who are of color, who are black, men, women doesn't matter, but they don't know that they can apply their skills to theater with the right guidance.
[11:52] Alvin Hough Jr.: They may be a fantastic choir director at a church, they may know how to work the jazz club scene, they may, I don't know, pick a place that may they may be in improv, they may be at an amusement park.
[12:05] Alvin Hough Jr.: And they're great where they are, and all they need is just to be shown like how what they know can be applied to theater, like you know, knowing, you know, what a what a you know what half hour means and what you know, all these, all the language that we have.
[12:20] Alvin Hough Jr.: And I think um that's part of the problem, like going f finding those people and letting them know, hey, if you are interested in doing something else you know there's a regional theater down the road or there's you know someone's doing a community theater thing over here I think it's just a matter of exposure and letting and and getting people making people aware that what they already know can just be you know you know just add a little extra add just what they know is of solid foundation just sprinkle a little theater language in there and you can come and do this too.
[12:20] Aaron Michael Ray: Yeah, okay yeah and I think something we've definitely talked about a lot is you know just like especially with casting right like we whenever someone's looking specifically for someone of a certain type or certain cultural background and then maybe they don't find it and it's just kind of like well you know whoever showed up um you know is kind of what we went with but a lot of the time they also just aren't looking hard enough and so I'm always just curious you know how much that overlaps in other parts within our industry but in different departments so um yeah and so I feel like if there that's why that's honestly why I wanted to ask y'all you know if this is if it's that same kind of thing because you know I feel like there just could also there could always be more representation and I and we're gonna get into Muse um the organization that um Alvin and Zane are in very shortly but which I feel like we'll really we'll get into that.
[14:01] Aaron Michael Ray: But I am curious just to know, you know, what that is like for y'all um does there tend to be more diversity in projects you work on for shows that have a culturally specific story?
[14:16] Aaron Michael Ray: Because, you know, when I and I and I think when I'm thinking about shows, you know, like if you if there's a 42nd Street or if there's a little shop or you know, those kinds of shows, like, is there still, you know, the same kind of effort that you would see when doing like The Color Purple or Motown for seeking diversity or no?
[14:39] Zane Mark: So just to dovetail back on what Alvin was saying, I'm safely going to say I'm the oldest guy in the room now. And so I've been at it for a minute, and back in the day, there was an issue with hiring musicians of color, male or female, and subsequently you don't have a lot of us now, and there were all sorts of reasons why that didn't happen. So things are starting to change, but I think the bigger problem, quote unquote, and this is my own little phrase now is if you're gonna be quote unquote stuck in a pit with a group of musicians, you're gonna try to make that as comfortable as possible. And this is not necessarily a good thing or a bad thing, but you're gonna hire your friends, the people that you know, you know who they are.
And if all of your friends are white, or all of your friends are male, or all your friends are filled in the blank, that's who you're gonna put with you. So it's not necessarily a racist thing or a sexist thing, it's just you're hiring your friends. So what I say over and over is we need to get some new friends, and that's really the baby version of it. There are a whole bunch of other things going on as to why more people of color are not, you know, on a lot more Broadway shows. I'm doing Mrs. Doubtfire right now. I am the only person of color on the entire creative team. I mean I think there's a woman in, I think Cookie's doing makeup. But it's me. Now, I hasten to add, I don't think it's a racist thing.
I'm working with Ethan Pop, I love him. He is hiring his friends, and there's nothing wrong with that. Nothing at all, but we need some more friends, and that I think is the baby version and the quickest answer not being politically correct. That's just the facts. As far as your last question you posed, that's another issue for musicians of color. We will get the Motowns, we will get the ones on this island, but we can do My Fair Lady and Oklahoma, and we can do those shows also, but the hiring the people in position to hire us, I guess assume or think or whatever it is that we're better equipped to do that, the other soul shows, the groove shows, the whatever it is show, as opposed to the other shows.
So the goal is not to be, you know, a great black musician, the goal is just to be a great musician, not a great female, not a male, just a great musician that's always on call. I want this person that can do anything, so I can do a funky show, I can do a legit show, all Gershwin Two, whatever you want me to do. I can do it, and that should be our goal collectively, and as well as allowing everybody to have a pipeline to the chair, and that's I think where the breakdown is. Us along with we need some new friends.
[17:59] Cameron Moncur: This is so interesting for me because I feel I'm probably in the infancy of my career, so I've never been in a place to hire anyone. So that's I think the most important thing is people in my position or below me being a part of this conversation and understanding where we've come from, because I love that quote, we need some new friends, because you're absolutely right. Of course, you hire your friends, that's how it works. But just knowing this as I move forward into positions of power where I will be hiring people and I will be crossing those boundaries, it's just fascinating to hear you guys talk.
[18:33] Alvin Hough Jr.: Yeah, and I think, oh I'm sorry, go ahead, Cameron.
[18:36] Cameron Moncur: Oh, I just, it's just continuing the line of thought. I think it's, I got two kids, I got a four-year-old son, two-year-old daughter. One of the books that we got, you know, it's funny as a parent to like learn, relearn things or be reminded of things through your kids and their books and their interactions. And there's an amazing book that Sonia Sotomayor wrote, and it's called Just Ask. It's like, does this kid have autism or a peanut allergy? All these things, and I'm trying to think about that. How we could apply, just ask. You look at me, you think I can only play Motown, but I've been playing classically since I was five. Just ask me, hey, would you, can you do, do you play classically?
Do you play rock? Can you show me? Can you play a 16-bar cut from My Fair Lady? Whatever. Just I think if people just were more comfortable with approaching folks and saying, tell me what you can do. Show me what you can do. Give me the list of your capabilities. And then say, you know, where can I put you? Where can I hire you? I think if I think we often people get put in a box. And they're, and where the box they're put in is not necessarily all-encompassing of what they can do. People just want to show what they can. If you're in this business, you're in it because you want to be creative and you want to share your creation, your art with other, you want to collaborate with other folks and then share with an audience. Share with, you know, people who are going to hear it. And I feel you got to know what everybody can bring to the table so that you get the best, you know, product at the end.
[20:19] Zane Mark: Yeah, I 100% co-sign on all of that. And I just think it's because I think like we've especially, you know, as black people, again, like, you know, even with you saying, you know, they look at you and they say, okay, then we got you on the Motowns and the Color Purple or whatever, but it's like you also don't know what else I could do. You don't know that I actually like I too vocally was classically trained at first. And before I even started getting into jazz, which is primarily, you know, where kind of my voice wants to go, but at the same time, you know, I've also done the My Fair Ladies or done like Sweeney Todd, like all these other kinds of shows on my resume that show that, like, yeah, I can actually do this kind of style musically for what you're looking for, so don't just put me in that box because I think in this industry we're all trying so I think it's, it's the trap is, you know, once you find that box, once you find your brand or whatever that is, you know, you work from that, but at the same time, you know, it can't be super binding to that.
[21:27] Alvin Hough Jr.: And Zane, I really love that you said, you know, it's time to get new friends because we have absolutely talked about that on this podcast of saying, you know, if you can't find people of color or a certain cultural or queer or gender backgrounds or whatever that is for a certain role or a certain project or certain, you know, position, then that means you need to get new friends, and you know, that's not, it's not even just me trying to, you know, be shady or whatever, you know, that's what it is, and that's what presents itself. Pendulum swings both ways, and we have to be careful. So I'm very cautious about trying to ask anybody to do anything that I'm not prepared to do myself. And so, what happens is a friend of mine asked me about doing blind auditions.
So we're just gonna get in the theater and everyone's gonna sing or play or whatever it is behind a curtain, and we're gonna bring all the black musicians in and they're gonna turn it out, but they'll be auditioning with the white musicians also. So, what happens if we pull the curtain back and it's all white guys that made the cut and not black guys? Huh? What happens when you go to say, all right, I want to take a chance and I want to hire some non-white male musicians, and I got nothing against white male musicians. But what happens? I want to hire something that fits in that other box. Am I willing to risk this multi-million dollar Broadway show on this person that is not tried and true?
No. Am I willing to put this person in the pit who's never been here before, who might be a complete butt head and just jack up the whole vibe of the band? No. And so it's not just, you know, you're in there because you're black. No. The goal is to be in there because you're a great oboe player or whatever it is. The other thing with the stereotypes is, you know, there's some black people that can't play gospel music. They're just clueless. You ask them to play a blues, it's not gonna happen. And there's some white guys that'll turn that out. You know what I'm saying? So the stereotype thing is going to be bad across the board, period. I go back to what Alvin said. We need to ask. We need to ask.
But I'm sure Cam will tell you in a heartbeat, I'm on the road with these guys. One guy acting the butt head is going to jack up everything. And the whole show now is, you know, so, and that's white, black, green, straight, gay, it doesn't matter. Yeah, butt heads a butt head. It takes one person, only one, and the whole apple basket is jacked up. So it's not as simple as burn it all down to the ground, just hire black people, start from scratch. It's not that simple. And I think as probably the most impatient person in the world, I have had to, you know, reset and go, okay, I need to set some goals. Six months, one year, three years, five years. And so, and so in some of the other projects that I'm working in, I have to say, this is what it is now.
Here are the numbers. I hope the numbers improve in six months, one year, three months, whatever. And let's just take stock on that time period. Because I would love if you're a black female conductor right now, you're the golden unicorn. Everybody wants you. And honestly, as far as people that I could recommend for the job as head person in charge of the music department, I only know about five. And each one of them have 600 jobs already because they are the golden unicorn. So what do we do? We get some new friends and we school them, we mentor them, we train them. But that takes time and energy. But now that's just my responsibility now. And that's what I have to step up, do. But I say all of that to say I don't think there's a quick band-aid that we can just throw on this problem.
And this is not just with musicians, this is with actors, this is with producers. The actual show that you're actually working on, it just runs the gamut. And for us, anyone to think it's a simple thing that we're gonna correct overnight is foolish, and but it's gonna take a lot of work, and I think all of us on the same path with the same goal, or at least a similar goal, trying to get some new friends, trying to do a more collective hold hands and sing kumbaya, and hopefully we can get it all together, we got a better chance.
[26:06] Aaron Michael Ray: Okay, well, I really I love everything you just said, and I feel like that's going to be a perfect segue going into asking you about news. So before we do that, let's take a quick break.
[26:26] Aaron Michael Ray: All right, welcome back. So, Alvin and Zane, I'm really, really excited to ask y'all about this amazing, amazing organization called Muse, which stands for Musicians United for Social Equity. Is that right?
[26:43] Alvin Hough Jr.: Yep.
[26:44] Zane Mark: Right.
[26:45] Aaron Michael Ray: Yes. Okay. I was trying to make sure, you know, if I'm gonna plug the organization, I gotta say it right. So for me, you two are part of the founding members of Muse. So what inspired you to help create this organization?
[27:03] Alvin Hough Jr.: Well, I mean, and what and also what is Muse? I guess I should have said that too.
[27:11] Zane Mark: Fair enough. I'm gonna start with just, you know, George Floyd should still be alive. I think anyone with, you know, a brain can agree with that. But I think a way that the world is honoring him and his family is by actually taking a step back and thinking about, you know, the differences between right and wrong and how something like equity could be achieved. We formed shortly after that horrific incident and being in the middle of a pandemic kind of allowed us all to fully invest into thinking about what we can do as, you know, our own little microcosm of the world to say what can musicians, you know, for professional level theater, what can we do to make our world look a little bit more like, you know, New York, more like the United States to make it more, you know, more equitable.
We're happy with where we are after a year, but we want more. We're in it for the long haul. We're here to develop that pipeline that Zane was talking about because all the people who are our founding members, you know, we're known in the industry. People have called us a lot. What we want to do is to say that when all of us are old and great, what have we left behind? What sort of access have we given to other people to, you know, not have that question be raised of, well, you know, I couldn't find anybody. Where are the, you know, fill in the blanks? Where are the Latinx? Where are the, we all know the list. Where are those people of color who, you know, tend to get the short end of the stick?
And we hope to, you know, have rendered that question obsolete so that people, you know, know can come to our directory and find high quality folks, but we need time to mentor, to teach, to build that pipeline to get people up to stuff.
[29:28] Alvin Hough Jr.: It's an honor to be part of Muse. It personally gave me something to look forward to, gave me something to do, gave me a reason to wake up during the worst of the pandemic. My wife is an ICU doctor, and the things that she's seen and knows, which I only know slivers of, are enough to really make you think about what the world has gone through this past year. Things were quite grim, but Muse is something that gave me hope. Looking to the future, what can the 19 founding members do to inspire other people down the road and to grow our industry so it looks more like what America looks like?
[30:25] Alvin Hough Jr.: I just have to start by saying, on the website, which is museonline.org by the way, I gotta plug it. When I was looking on this website, I was almost getting emotional. I feel like we talked a lot on this podcast about what can we do, what are the steps, how do we do this? This is the first organization that has come up through COVID or something that I have seen within our industry that I said, this is the work, this is what is actually about to change so many things. I'm so excited for the potential and the future of Muse. I went through just a directory to see, do I know anybody on here? I know a lot of people on there, and there are people that I've worked on small projects or full shows, and it's so amazing to see.
[31:35] Alvin Hough Jr.: I've been spending the pandemic in Alabama and have gotten into playing high school shows in Alabama. There is a guy that I've become friends with who lives down here who has applied to some of your piano programs. He already knows about Muse, he's in the directory, and he's applying for these programs and getting the mentorship that you all are talking about. That just blew my mind to know that here that's happening in the reach of Muse already in one year.
[32:14] Alvin Hough Jr.: If I could just fill in a couple more blanks on where Alan's speaking, for those of you that don't know, there's a job called the music assistant. This person basically runs around behind the musical supervisor, the musical director, and does everything and anything, from light arranging to getting coffee. They're not recognized by the local unions, so normally the producer is the one that gives them a little nickel or two, and often the musical supervisor or director has to give them a little extra money to make it make sense because especially in New York, you can't do anything for four or five hundred dollars a week before taxes.
[32:57] Alvin Hough Jr.: In the very beginning, that was one of the major problems we were trying to address. Let's get these people on salary, get them recognized because that job usually leads to the rehearsal pianists, and then they become an assistant in the show, and then become the assistant director, the conductor, the musical director, and so on. That was a major thing we were trying to do, and then we could also have piano camp and mentoring programs. We reached out to everybody we knew that were musical directors on Broadway now.
[33:38] Alvin Hough Jr.: There's another group, the Maestra group, which is primarily women, all colors, all things, you just have to be identified as a woman, and then in you go. Their website is a monster, so anybody listening, maestra.com, check them out. If you're not a member and you're a musician, sign up immediately. Their website, I was just blown away. We should kind of copy their stuff because it's really good. We primarily did, and we got their web designers, and that's what brought us over.
[34:10] Alvin Hough Jr.: We started to recognize a whole bunch of other problems that we needed to address. It sounds like someone just listened and thought, oh, you guys have a great thing, all of the Black people in the entire world are in there, and we can just go in there and populate. No, we have more work to do. You would think that any Black established musician in New York would be in the directory. They're not.
[34:42] Alvin Hough Jr.: Our goal is to get everybody in there. What we're finding though is there's a lot of younger musicians, some that don't have a lot of credit, some that are still in school, that as Alvin mentioned, didn't realize that there might be an avenue for them in musical theater. If you're an arranger, you can arrange for musical theater, which is a thing by itself, but you can arrange for anything. Our goal is to try to address each and every one of those guys, then you have theaters across the country.
[35:28] Alvin Hough Jr.: I could bore you with some of the craziness that's going on out there, but I'll give you one. There are certain locals that if you're the oldest member, not in age, but just when you join the union, if you're the oldest member, just by seniority, you get first refusal when a show comes through. So if you're 6,000 years old and you can't play that high C anymore on your trumpet, the gig has to be offered to you first. A musician getting out of school that lives in that town has to wait for that guy to die to be offered a chair. Something is wrong.
[36:15] Alvin Hough Jr.: We started in Southern California, just asking theaters to get their numbers, and everyone will admit right off the bat, our numbers don't look good as far as who they're hiring. Acknowledging that there is a problem and that you're part of it is step one. Muse doesn't want to be the one to come in, put on a Superman cape and save the day. We want to assist you in taking care of your problem as opposed to us doing the work.
[36:47] Alvin Hough Jr.: Thank you for pumping us up, but we're not where we need to be yet. We're hoping to grow, and we're going to do that with a larger membership, a lot of people signing up and getting on, but it's work for everybody on all sorts of levels, white, black, and otherwise.
[37:11] Zane Mark: I think one of the things that makes Muse special and unique is that it's not just a bunch of Black people pushing for change, nothing against those organizations who are, but we are a collection of white and Black musical directors who recognize the issues in front of us. We're not trying to blow things up. There is a system, there are unions, there are things in place, but how can we work within the foundation, the system that we already have?
[37:44] Zane Mark: What can we do to tweak things, to modify things, to change clauses in a CBA to figure out how we can take what we have and just modify it to bring other people into the fold? I think that that's something that makes us special, and the fact that we realize we need allies, we need people on all fronts of all colors, of all genders, everything to help us too, because we can't do this as people of color by ourselves.
[38:18] Cameron Moncur: That is something that I noticed right away just going on the website, that all the founding members are very diverse. A lot of them have been people I've auditioned for or have worked with in some way. It was really inspiring to see because it's not just Black people leading the change. Unfortunately, whenever that is the case in some situations, it's not always as well received because there has to be some sort of white face attached to it.
[38:40] Cameron Moncur: I think it's really great to see that there are a lot of different people behind this, all helping to move this forward. I believe in this organization so much, and I'm really excited to see where it goes.
[39:38] Alvin Hough Jr.: I think another mindset that I'm running into is we're waiting for them to fix the way they think and act. Why can't we do it ourselves? Where is the new Negro Ensemble Company? Why are we waiting for them? Why does Broadway have to be the end-all, be-all for everything? Where are these other places? During this pandemic, how many Zoom presentations have you seen? There are so many other things that we can do for us that I don't know if we've really scratched that too hard.
[40:35] Alvin Hough Jr.: We need to dig deeper as opposed to just asking for help. There's nothing wrong with that, but I think we need to say, I can write music by myself. I can play this, you know how to sing, you know how to act, let's do it. Waiting on somebody to give me is not good.
[41:00] Alvin Hough Jr.: And I'm saying on the somebody as in theater producers, unions, just run the gabin of whatever is slowing down.
[41:09] Alvin Hough Jr.: Do you really have to do it that way or can you go around it and get the same thing?
[41:12] Alvin Hough Jr.: And I'm not saying, uh, screw the unions, that's not what I'm saying.
[41:16] Alvin Hough Jr.: I'm just saying that, well, I'll say this and then I'll leave it.
[41:22] Alvin Hough Jr.: How many people of color do you know in Local One? How many brothers or sisters have you seen pulling cable, running electrics, doing the boards, even loading in and out? How do we change that? If you think it's going to happen overnight, it is not. But how do we change that? Half of the solution is identifying that this is a problem and calling it a problem.
[42:00] Alvin Hough Jr.: We had discussions with contractors, the men that used to be solely in charge of putting butts in the chairs in the pits. A good friend asked me, what do you want? I said, I'd like to look over opening night into the pit and not see a hundred percent white men in the pit. I'd like it to be a little bit more diverse. He said, okay, how many do you want? I didn't have an answer.
[42:39] Alvin Hough Jr.: There are only seven guys in the pit. If we're going to say 10%, I guess I gotta get a biracial guy in there. What do we do? There is no one set answer for anything.
[43:04] Alvin Hough Jr.: I'm going to take a pause and I'll let y'all go. I receive all of that. This is something we've all thought about at some point, especially for y'all being musicians in theater. If this is something that we're finally having this conversation about, then let's have it. It's also about where are these people and whose responsibility is it to find the talent?
[43:40] Alvin Hough Jr.: And I think we in news are saying, well, we can't wait for XYZ person who's been doing it for 40 years to go out and find the talent because maybe they don't want to, maybe they feel it isn't their responsibility, maybe they're it's another case of like waiting for someone else or some other entity to have this change of heart that may or may not come, and you're just sitting there waiting, and you could say, Well, no, how about we do something, you know, find a way to hold an audition that isn't called an audition. How do we because I think that's part of the problem? All I feel a sensible way to go about this is to say people just want to be seen or heard if you're playing an instrument, people just want to be heard.
And if you never have a chance to be heard, how do you how do you move up the ranks? And the thing is, even if you want to hire your friend for X show, if there's a way you could have whoever come in, you know, why a big pool of people to come play, you can say, Oh my gosh, this is this person. I've never seen them, never heard her, but that's a talented person. And even if I don't hire them for this show, I now know that they exist. And in five years, when something comes up, you know, here it is. I think as MDs, we do that all the time. When you all when we audition actors and you have a plan and you say, Well, this is you know what I want it to look like, and you have your vision, but then someone comes in and does a kick-ass audition, and you're just like, screw your vision.
You're like, I'm good. Look at me. You could say, Okay, maybe this person doesn't fit for this show, but that talent is too good to overlook. I will find something for you in my next show, or I will, you know, um, what's what I'm looking for? I will uh defer uh I will pass you on to some to a colleague to say, Hey, this person is good, you should use him, her. That's a great trombone player. I don't care what you're doing find something for them in the next two years that give them something because they're good.
[45:49] Alvin Hough Jr.: You know I and I think conversation conversation. So key I think everybody Cam's doing a tour, I'm doing a show, Zayn's doing it and everybody's got their own little I don't know island, their own little thing that they're sitting on and you have your own little house rules, your own little things and I feel if we as a community just open up and talk about things and say what what is your situation? How is this similar to mine? How is it different? And I think a more open book just in the industry just to to to see where people stand and say, you know, I'm looking for I don't think anybody's no one's trying to poach anybody. It's like hey I need a XYZ so and so I know is leaving the tour and I need to fill this spot.
Hey do you know any French horn players out there that might fit and it's like actually I do. I saw this person audition whatever six months ago call her up. I don't know there there's a way for us to do more to be more collaborative. Even though we work in a collaborative environment I feel there's we can still do more to talk amongst uh each other.
[46:56] Zane Mark: I also think it's important to point out kind of what Alvin's touching on is that for non-musicians who don't know we're technically not allowed to audition musicians. So getting people heard is a huge problem especially when as Zayn said you're gonna trust this multi million dollar show to someone that you can't asked to audition for you, you can't have in the room. Again, it goes back to you're gonna go with the tried and true and people you know, and having that dialogue and that openness to hear people is a huge step in just knowing what's out there and being able to trust what's out there. And and to Cam's point, we've been speaking with our union, 802 and contractors on that audition. When I when I mentioned this to my wife, an actress, like musicians don't audition.
You know, um so here's the musicians credo. As musicians on Broadway, we're expected to get a job without auditioning. So if you want to I'm gonna get a business gig at IBM, I want the job, I don't want you to interview me. Once I get the job, I have the job for life. You can't find. I mean, you know, it's just like, you know, I have to like get on stage in the middle of the show, punch somebody and urinate into the pit. I mean, it has to be bad to get fired, you know. And who does that?
[48:30] Alvin Hough Jr.: And so let me add one more monkey wrench into the and it sounds very gloomy, but I think the number we got was like this, like 7,000 musicians in New York that are in the union, but maybe only a thousand of them are actually making enough money or working enough to call themselves I am a musician and I can pay my rent and feed my family, and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. There's only so many theaters in New York, and there's only so many chairs. And so now of those thousand people or seven thousand people in that pool, news or whoever it is wants to put more people in the pool. So those thousand people, that means that my chances of getting a gig are even smaller. This is not a racial thing.
This is not, you know, uh sex thing. I just want to pay my rent. And so am I gonna support something that's gonna go against me being able to pay my rent? And I think we just have to be honest. You know, Alan mentioned conversations, we have to be honest about this. You know, you can call it racial if you want, but you know, that's not the way, and there's plenty of racial crap going on, please. I've been here for a long time. I've known it and seen it. But I think right now, this is just sheer economics. This is about green, and um, you know, there's so many different fronts that we have to attack this issue right now. And I I think a lot of the focus is on a racial thing, but you you focus on racial and somebody's gonna come up behind you and hit you in the head with something else.
And I think we have to be conscious of everything at all time, and goes back to the conversation and recognizing that this is an issue and how do we address it? And are you going to be on the team to address it or not? And if you're not, that's cool. Just sit over there and be cool. You know what I'm saying? But um, we have to move forward with or without your help.
[50:33] Alvin Hough Jr.: And and then last thing I want to meant, you know, um, a producer's job is to make money. So if a producer thought he could make money doing ain't misbehaving, dream girls, just name all of the quote unquote black shows, trust me, that's all you would see. But if he thinks he can make money doing cats, and no one knows what the hell makes you cats, but whatever, you know. But pick what is the widest show you can think of. If if that was it, then that's what it would be. Now, there's a couple of cats out there that are really all concerned about the art in it all, but the bottom line is about making money. And you can have the greatest arty thing in the world, but um I can't afford to put this multi-million dollar flop on stage.
We have to open our eyes up a little bit wider, I think, and realize it's not just one issue here. There's a whole bunch of issues. You know, how do I get to the theater and I just feel safe? Safe that you know, somebody is not gonna say something that is like, I have locks. You know how many times people want to touch my hair? Might not seem like a big deal, but like really, you you need to know that that's not cool.
[51:55] Alvin Hough Jr.: I just heard um, I think it was an IKEA someplace, and for Juneteenth, they thought they were gonna do something lovely and serve watermelon and fried chicken. And this was gonna be look just, you know. And I'm like, wow, dude, really. So it there's a whole bunch of things that need to be addressed. And uh a lot of these um uh committees that I'm with, you know, they start off with a whole diversity that you need training to know that this is not cool. You need training to know that uh you can't say, Well, I have a lot of black friends, and and I don't own any slaves, and uh, I don't know, like it's more than that. And and I think we all need to get to a baseline and then move forward, but it's not just a one problem issue that we're dealing with here.
And I don't know if it's gonna go away overnight. But I think more conversations like this where people are aware of what's going on, um, and and know that there are some non-BIPOC people that are quote unquote woke enough to support, you know. But I don't think they should be leading the charge, um, per se. But if you want to help me out, I'm gonna take your help. But we need to all kind of like, you know, huddle up and figure out what's going on and deal with it and know that it's not just a racial problem, but that's a major component. And I'm not trying to belittle that anyway, but there's a lot going on. And I'm just very curious to see what's gonna happen when we actually get back in the theater with a whole bunch of other people.
[53:36] Aaron Michael Ray: Yeah, and I that is something that I have expressed a lot on this podcast is you know, out of all the changes that we really want to see in the you know, Broadway reconstruction, as I like to call it, um, I feel like thank you, thank you. Um, I feel like if you know it's not gonna happen overnight, like you know, especially when we think of, you know, like uh just the the diversity question of like when we go see shows, is it gonna be a diverse enough cast at least? You know, like some people need their jobs back, so when you come back, it might not be diverse right away because it's still gonna be the same people who were doing their old job, but it's gonna be about the new wave of people, which is why I'm so I'm just really glad that I was able to talk to you three today, and especially um Alvin and Zane about news, because I think that you know, just that is really putting in the effort for change because it's not again it's not overnight at all it won't happen in a month it might happen in six months you know and but like the the change is coming and it's and I really really do see an incredible potential with it so um I feel like that's one one one final thing I just don't just just just because I know Zayn will say it if I don't the what what what we what we want what we need everyone listening if you know someone who you feel belongs in the muse directory talk to them have a candid conversation with them get them to join like a lot of us family members are new york based we have some out west but we want we want more alab Alabamians is that the right word we want more you know we want people all around the country we want we want to pocket in Nashville we want to pocket in Seattle we want to pocket in in Chicago and I challenge you to not we've heard that some folks have been intimidated they look at the family members they're like oh my god Zayn Mark Alex Lackable oh I can't possibly be in a yes you can be in an organization with us we want to I mean we can't take our knowledge with us after we're gone we want to give it back and the thing is I there there there's the the learning is not a one-way street if I have a mentee it doesn't mean that I'm doing all the teaching and he or she's doing all the learning, you know, or they're doing all the learning.
It doesn't, it doesn't work that way I I want to get better too. So I want to learn from somebody else. So I think the more people we get in the directory, the more people can talk, and the more we can just learn from each other. So if you know someone who wants to be our ally, who needs to be in our directory, you know, forward them our our our webmuzonline.org, forward them our website, like have a candid conversation with them, get them to click that join button and then tell two friends so we can as Zayn say get more friends. We all need more friends.
[56:34] Alvin Hough Jr.: Yeah. Well, you can just call Alvin at her. The cell phone number is on good Wi-Fi, Alvin, for that.
[56:46] Zane Mark: Very true.
[56:48] Alvin Hough Jr.: Oh, but it here's his address. See, just show up. Just ring the bell.
[56:52] Zane Mark: That's so weird about being oh go ahead.
[56:54] Alvin Hough Jr.: Sorry.
[56:55] Zane Mark: Oh, no, go ahead.
[56:56] Alvin Hough Jr.: Go ahead.
[56:56] Zane Mark: I was just saying that's the benefit of being on tour. Is we do get people who always, I don't know how it's gonna work post-COVID, but you always have people who want to sit in the pit, who want to come in, and having somewhere to uh direct them to is going to be, I think, a huge step.
[57:12] Cameron Moncur: I think so too. And I also think that's a great place to end our conversation today. Thank you, three so much for coming on to this episode. I'm so glad that we were all able to connect and talk about this and just amplify Muse. For those who again need that website, it's Museonline.org. We're gonna put that uh website in the link of the bio for this episode. Um, thank you, Zane. Thank you, Alvin, thank you, Cam. I'm so so glad that we were able to talk today.
[57:18] Alvin Hough Jr.: Thank you.
[57:46] Zane Mark: My pleasure, yes.
[57:48] Aaron Michael Ray: All right. Well, thank you everyone for listening, and we will see you next time.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
