Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#1 - OKLAHOMA!: Oh What A Beautiful Podcast (Part 1)

Part 1 of the deep dive behind-the-curtain of the 2019 Tony-winning revival of Rodgers & Hammerstein's OKLAHOMA with extraordinary artists from the show including: Director Daniel Fish, star Mary Testa (Aunt Eller), star James Davis (Will Parker), Music Director Nathan Cosci and Producer Eva Price... Read More

From the show: Deep Dive Broadway

25 mins
12/1/19

Guests

Featured Shows

About

Part 1 of the deep dive behind-the-curtain of the 2019 Tony-winning revival of Rodgers & Hammerstein's OKLAHOMA with extraordinary artists from the show including: Director Daniel Fish, star Mary Testa (Aunt Eller), star James Davis (Will Parker), Music Director Nathan Cosci and Producer Eva Price. DEEP DIVE BROADWAY explores how this classic musical was entirely re-imagined for a contemporary world without changing one word of dialogue. Oh what a beautiful podcast!

Connect with Dori

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:06] Dori Berinstein: Hi, this is Dori Berinstein, and you are listening to Deep Dive Broadway, the podcast that takes you on an immersive adventure inside the creation of Broadway shows with the visionary directors, creators, producers, and stars that bring these shows to life.

[0:21] Dori Berinstein: I've been producing Broadway shows for over 25 years and love more than anything the show Behind the Curtain. There's nothing like it.

[0:30] Dori Berinstein: I'm thrilled to kick off episode one of Deep Dive Broadway with a look inside the creation of the 2019 Tony-winning revival of Rodgers and Hammerstein's Oklahoma. Joining me today are incredible artists from the show. Please welcome Tony-nominated director Daniel Fish, Tony-nominated star Mary Testa, who stars as Aunt Eller, actor James Davis, who stars as Will Parker, Nathan Cosci, Oklahoma's music director, and the producer of the Tony-winning show, Eva Price.

[1:01] Dori Berinstein: Let's dive in. Just to start, I want to quote Ben Brantley because I just am obsessed with this quote. He said, "How is it that the coolest new show on Broadway in 2019 is a 1943 musical, usually regarded as a very square slice of American pie?" It is so far from square. It is cutting edge, beautiful, simple, but unbelievably impactful. And so let's get a little context. So, Daniel, if you could set the scene, because I believe in 2006 with Joanne Acolydis, she came to you and said, "I want you to do a show."

[1:44] Daniel Fish: Joanne was running the Theater Department of Art College, and she said, "I want you to come do something with the students here." And I said, "I don't really know why I said this, but I said, I want to do Oklahoma and I want to do it as dinner theater," and Joanne, being Joanne, said, "Yes." So I did. And I think like a lot of people, I thought I knew Oklahoma. You know, that it's a show whose music I've been listening to since I was a kid. And when I started to work on it, I thought, "Oh, actually, I don't know this show as well as I thought I did." And I started to see a show that I didn't know was there. And the story about community and the nature of exclusion and justice that I had no idea was in the piece. And that sort of became the heart of what I ended up working on on and off for 12 years.

[2:32] Daniel Fish: And so Oklahoma in the very beginning for you was a challenge. You could have said anything, I guess.

[2:38] Daniel Fish: Well, I mean, there must have been some reason. I mean, you know, I'd sort of trust my instincts. I mean, I don't think it came out of nowhere. You know, I think I probably thought about doing a production at some point and thought, "Well, who would let me do this?" Joanne would. But it was so long ago, I can't really remember what the impulses behind it were. And in terms of starting to shape a very different creative vision than the original production of many productions of Oklahoma that have been out there, could you talk us a little bit through how your creative vision started to take shape and what from going all the way back to the Bard production remains today?

[3:21] Daniel Fish: Yeah, it's funny, somebody else asked me that recently, and a lot of that production remains today. It was set in a kind of wooden room, much smaller than the wooden room that we're in now at Circle in the Square. I think there were about a hundred people in it. They were all sitting at tables and they were all sitting around chili pots, those very same chili pots. And that really grew out of a conversation with the set designer at the time, John Conklin, and the costume designer at the time, K-Boys. We were kind of talking about dinner theater and like, what is that about? What is this weird genre, dinner theater that I think no other culture has? And is there something about people sitting down to a meal together and people going to see a play? There's some similarity there. And it kind of just started with that question and got unpacked from there.

[4:18] Daniel Fish: And then once we started really looking at the text of it, I started to find out all these other things. And after the Bard production, did you have the vision way back then that I am gonna continue to work on this and one day?

[4:33] Daniel Fish: Well, I mean, it went very well at Bard, and a number of people saw it. Gideon Lester, who at the time was running the American Repertory Theater in Cambridge, saw it and he was interested in doing it at ART as a professional production, and for a number of reasons that did not happen. Jumped to 2015, 2014. Gideon was now running the Visual Center at Bard, which had a summer festival, and he said, "Let's do it here and let's really, you know, seriously do a professional production. Let's have a new orchestration, let's have a great cast," and that really was a huge step forward. And I think the real beginnings of the production that's currently at Circle on the Square.

[5:18] Daniel Fish: So either 2006 and 2015 production in the same space at Bard?

[5:23] Daniel Fish: Yes, the very same space.

[5:24] Dori Berinstein: Oh my gosh.

[5:25] Daniel Fish: And many people know Patrick Vale, who plays Judd Fry, played Judd Fry as a 20-year-old or 21-year-old senior at Bard in that production. So, Eva, you saw the production in 2015, and you immediately said, "Oh my gosh," could you talk about your reaction and what you did?

[5:47] Eva Price: Yeah, sure. I had seen one production of Oklahoma previously, when I was nine years old at a very cheesy summer stock theater in New Hampshire in a barn. So I had one vision for what Oklahoma could be. So when I had gotten word about this production at the Bard Summerscape, I didn't believe that it was all these things that this casual friend had told me it had become because I thought, "Well, I know the show and I know that score really well, and how could that be Oklahoma?" So I went to see it at the Bard Summerscape. I remember I had to call three different people to get a ticket because it was completely sold out because it was 200 seats at that point, and a three-week run, I think. And this was near the end of it that I went and was completely flabbergasted the two hours, 45 minutes that I was in that room.

I couldn't believe I was actually watching Oklahoma. I couldn't believe that this was the same text and the same score that I knew so well from being a fan of American classic musicals. And for that reason, I felt that it deserved a much wider life, and I felt like I was a little bit of a maverick producer, sort of on the younger side, kind of newer. The things I was interested in doing were a little more edgy and innovative, and I thought, "Well, I think I'm the right person for this." And I'm willing to not bring it to Broadway if that's what the world wants. If it's not meant to be there, that's also fine. I'll still figure out a way to get it seen by more people.

[7:29] Eva Price: So it was through then a series of many, many phone calls, many, many meetings. There was a chance train ride from Chicago to Milwaukee that we don't need to get into today, that Ted Chapin was also on. And I eventually was able to help everyone over at the Rogers and Hammerstein organization see that this production was meant for greener pastures, and that eventually led to the St. Anne's Warehouse production, which again, we did not have the rights for Broadway, but I just had faith, and my gut told me that if we can get it right and make it inevitable in Brooklyn, we will make it inevitable for Broadway, and more things will even be possible from that. And here we are.

[8:16] Dori Berinstein: What extraordinary producing vision. But you know, it is so remarkable because I think the script is intact, and the score is, you know, you're quite true to the original arrangements, and but it's so different. It's so different. It's just you, you know, it reveals so much more than you even realize when you first saw the production or saw the film. And who knew, or maybe you did, that it would be ridiculously timely, and just kind of bring up subjects that are so important in the world we're living in today, whether or not it's bullying or gun violence. And you know, when you saw it, I would imagine that these issues resonated in such a huge way for you.

[9:10] Eva Price: It was really interesting about that point, actually. So it was summer of 2015. Obama was still president. Hamilton had not appeared on Broadway yet, but had had its run at the public. Marriage equality had just passed. There was an urgency. Gun violence was a problem that had unfortunately never gone away. The idea of an outsider was a thing. The idea of a community being culpable for something and everyone being in something together was a thing. But I remember quite distinctly, a year later, summer of 2016, while I was still working to get the rights to the show and get it to New York, Brexit happened. And we had yet to have had our 2016 election where more things fell apart in this country.

But Brexit was sort of the first instinct that outsiders and the idea of xenophobia and the idea of being afraid of things that are different could drive political change. That was sort of the first moment that the world was falling apart. And I remember talking to the artistic director of the Bard Summerscape, who together we were working to further the show's life. He said, "I think Brexit's good for the show." And I said, "I think unfortunately you're right." And as we know, the world continued to change, making the show even more relevant and more impactful and more urgent.

[10:49] Dori Berinstein: Yeah, you know, I mean, but I think you know, one of the things about the theater is it's always about the moment that it's happening. And so I don't, I mean, I think in some ways it's fair to say that the show is, you know, like it's a sort of synchronistic combination of the show and the time. But the fact is, I think if we're doing our job, any play, any show we do is gonna be about the moment that we're working in, so that we're living in. So, you know, in 2015 Obama was president, and with that line, "The country's a change and got a change with it," had a kind of very positive resonance. Skip to now, and we have a sociopathic moron running the country, and that line means something very different, as does mob mentality and everything else that comes out.

[11:47] Dori Berinstein: Mary, how when did you get involved and what was it about hearing about it or you that just made it something that you had to do?

[11:57] Mary Testa: Well, I had worked with Daniel. He had to remind me because I forget everything on a reading with a mutual friend of ours, Polly Penn, of a musical. We had done like a week reading or a two-week reading, and he called me and asked me to do this, and I sort of had to be reminded. And I just thought, "Oh, it sounds interesting." I'm kind of like a pinball, whatever I hit up against, I do. So I thought, "Oh, this sounds interesting because we worked on around a table for a week or two weeks at New York Theater Workshop just looking at the script." So I thought that's cool, so that's how I became involved.

[12:23] Mary Testa: And you know, you're known for your brilliant comedy but also your serious roles, and it's such a perfect amalgamation of everything that you do. And I love that Aunt Eller is such a fierce woman that is an inspiration.

[12:23] Mary Testa: Well, thank you, that's awfully nice. But you know, how did you find the truth in that character? What was your process?

[12:23] Mary Testa: It's just finding, you can't not find the truth. It's absolutely no, I mean, it's just finding truth in what you're doing and saying and relationships and my relationship with Lori and my relationship with Curly as the woman who is sort of on this farm with Lori and trying to create some sort of backstory that makes sense to me with all of the characters. And that's, you know, he's the type of director that does not tolerate any falseness. So it was fairly easy to create a reality bounced off of all the other actors who are part of this as well. Jimmy has been with it from the beginning as well, and you just want to be truthful. You want to get the beats right. You want to know what you're saying, where you're going, and make it all seem real.

[14:02] Mary Testa: And so that's kind of what we what I did.

[14:06] James Davis: Yeah. Um Jimmy, you I I read that you played Will Parker in high school.

[14:12] James Davis: I did. And it was probably like one of my last musical that I did too. So I wanna I want to think that that Daniel saw your production in high school and had you in mind. But what what really happened for you?

[14:24] James Davis: Um I remember do you remember what happened? I and uh what's your version of it? I want to hear your version.

[14:29] Mary Testa: Well, we did a reading together um and uh of a play, and then we did a week-long workshop up at New York Theater Workshop of a David Foster piece, um, which we all sat at tables and had um, I forget which which book it was.

[14:44] James Davis: The Pale King.

[14:45] Mary Testa: The Pale King from the Pale King. And it was it was very experimental, and we'd sit down and we'd just read kind of without any inflection or meaning the lines until he pointed to somebody else and said, You continue to read, and there were about six actors, so we did that. Um so I knew how much he he likes things to be like on the language, which is also how I work too. Um and then I took uh an 11-day road trip out to LA because I thought I was gonna move there, and they asked me to put myself on tape for Allie Hackham, which I thought was bizarre, but um, you know, I didn't know anything about this production yet. And I thought, dude, I I just moved out here. Do I really want to go back to do a regional theater production of Oklahoma?

And I was like, wait, Daniel's directing this, this is gonna be great and insane. And of course you book something in New York when you go out to LA, so it's just a sign to get out there. And um, we did that two-week workshop at New York Theater Workshop, and I think I was I was brought in as cast, and so they were throwing Allie Hackham stuff at me, Will Parker's stuff at me, and I think by the end of the day it was pretty much just all Will Parker's stuff that I was doing.

[15:52] James Davis: Yeah. I love that. Um Well, what was your story?

[15:56] Mary Testa: Yeah. I I had forgotten about the Wallace workshop. My story is sort of like that, but but I remember like, yeah, you sort of my version is like you were like, oh, I want to play Will Parker. I want to play Will Parker. I was like, really? Well, probably. I don't I don't think you're right for Will Parker, but but you came in and then dismissed. This was an internal conversation you were having with yourself. And then and then you made it impossible to not play Parker. I also like a new I shouldn't tell him that I played it in high school. I was like, this will come to no good if he knows that I've already done this in high school.

[16:29] Nathan Cosci: Nathan, you um uh you're the music director, but this is not your typical music director uh opportunity. You're you are a character in the show. You're on stage the entire time.

[16:40] Nathan Cosci: He's slim. Thank you. I am uh so you have a backstory in the whole thing?

[16:48] Mary Testa: I'm sorry.

[16:50] Nathan Cosci: He has no mic support and trying not to giggle, trying to say my loud laugh my line loud enough. That's my that's my backstory.

[16:58] Mary Testa: Um Nathan is pretty brilliant, I have to say.

[17:00] James Davis: Oh go on.

[17:01] Nathan Cosci: I'm very now I have to say that because I'm very impressed. I'm very impressed by you every day.

[17:05] James Davis: I'm more impressed by you.

[17:06] Nathan Cosci: Likewise, he's pretty brilliant, yeah. Um I came to this through I worked with Daniel on a kind of a multimedia oratorio opera piece about Chelsea Manning called The Source. That was written by a composer named Ted Hearn, and I was conducting and playing keyboards on that, which I think that's the first thing I did with Daniel. Um, and that was a beautiful and austere piece. It involved a lot of projections and large-scale human faces and the band hidden in a behind a screen. And the next email I got from Daniel was asking me if I wanted to do Oklahoma, which felt like, is this the same Daniel? Is this? Are you sure? I'm not, I don't understand your sense of humor yet. So maybe this isn't um, but definitely came from a very kind of experimental theater and an experimental music background.

Um but had been working in some either music directing or conducting or sometimes composing um that kind of facilitation role in theater. So I said yes because I didn't know any better. And uh and Daniel Kluger was already on. Klug Kluger and Fish were both, I believe, already it's I think so. Uh hatching plans, and then I was kind of brought in to music direct.

[18:15] Mary Testa: And I mean I I think your job is sort of goes beyond music direction.

[18:20] Nathan Cosci: Yeah. I mean I think Nathan was really you know instrumental in rehearsals. We were figuring out what the feel of each song was gonna be, and and um and and how parts were gonna get assigned, even because we we were reassigning, we were reassigning vocal parts as we went along, and um so he was you know sort of instrumental in the in the in the building of the musical vocabulary. And and originally uh I believe Oklahoma had 28 musicians, and you have seven.

[18:51] Nathan Cosci: Exactly. How did how did you manage that?

[18:55] Nathan Cosci: That's a question for Daniel Kluger.

[18:57] Nathan Cosci: That's a really I I admit when I first came on, you know, I knew that it was kind of a you know the the big terms I had were kind of folk music, Oklahoma, and and in my mind I admit I was um I I foresaw a world, and admittedly kind of where I think Kluger, Daniel Kluger, I it's fine to call him Kluger. Uh he's a genius in these ways that I was like, oh, this is gonna be kind of a simplified, like, oh yeah, guitar and bass playing kind of like not necessarily dumbed down, but certainly kind of focused version of these songs, and and and Daniel Kluger had a much different, much more meticulous idea, which I think is what really makes another thing that makes it so good. That none of it is just like the text, none of it has really changed even.

I think he took these original um Robert Russell Bennett orchestrations in the 40s that were for a big orchestra and had winds and brass and strings and harps and timpani and all manner of things, and really um, you know, surgically and like carefully took really distilled them to our instrumentation and created these parts that are really um uh in certain moments very idiomatic to bluegrass music, and we're and we're you know, banjo sounds like a banjo and blue bluegrass band, but a lot of the times also having the banjo player be the bassoon player or be the clarinet player and these really like specific lines that aren't necessarily idiomatic initially to the instruments, but I think then kind of uh through all of us and the band working together kind of made them fit the instrumentation and fit the room and everything.

[20:25] Nathan Cosci: And you can hear our cast recording on Spotify iTunes or wherever you guys go right now.

[20:32] Mary Testa: Um I I would love for you to talk for a minute about the instrument of hope because that is such a powerful thing that you guys did.

[20:40] Nathan Cosci: Absolutely. And that I feel like that I was Eva along with level forward, am I correct? Um, this amazing instrument that was uh sprang out of the students at Marjorie Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, where the Parkland shooting happened, teamed up with a local brass technician who's actually my brass repair guy, Josh Landris, uh uh beautiful guy, beautiful brass shop, uh, built an instrument that that was made, parts of were made from melted down bullet casings. And I believe the the number of of AK 17 casings that represent the number of deaths from that shooting. Um they have uh the it's called Shine MSD. Uh and they've taken this instrument through numerous performing artists and bands.

And I know I saw a thing in New York where all like a 30 or 40 trumpet players in the New York studio scene got together and recorded this amazing uh song using the instrument and their own trumpets. Um we were, I believe, the first Broadway show to feature it after our show. We did a little arrangement about in my dreams. Um I came up on a for better or for worse, play a lot of different instruments, trumpet being one of them. So we did an arrangement after the show. And it was really um, I don't know, you do these shows, you do eight a week, and you know stuff's coming up, and you know, oh we're gonna do this, and it's all really such great stuff. But I feel like Mary gave a speech before we did it.

[21:59] Mary Testa: Well, I just started crying, yeah, you know, two lines into the speech, and there were stone, there were Marjorie Stoneman people in the audience, and it was very moving. And I think there's such a contrast to between hearing a three-hour show where all the instruments are stringed instruments and an accordion, and then you have this powerful bellowing trumpet, and I think it just like knocked everybody off of their feet. And they were conditioned to hear one type of sound, and then they heard this like grand, fill the room sort of undeniable uh blunt instrument. And Mary, I think your speech and then your uh trumpet performance, it's online. Yeah, apparently they'll go and listen to this, you will be changed. Your entire you will be changed. Yeah, it's beautiful.

[22:46] Mary Testa: I would imagine, just for all of you, that there are audiences that come into the theater and they are they've read about it or they they they've heard, you know, just that this is not your your old traditional Oklahoma and that there are audience members who have they're just they saw Oklahoma, they're gonna buy a ticket. And are you aware of like all sorts of different audience experiences that are happening in that space?

[23:17] Daniel Fish: Very much so. Yeah, they're lit the entire time, so we see all 600 faces every night. And it's really indiscernible to know what people are thinking. You think somebody hates something and they're stone faced, and then they you realize they've been sitting there thinking about it for three hours and they can't tell you, can't wait to tell you what they think about how profound it was to them. And you know, I saw them during the audience and I thought they were hating it the entire time, so you never know. We've had a fair, we have a fair amount of people who at the last in the last Oklahoma after the trial scene and after all the violence. Um we sing Oklahoma and they clap along, and um it's a little uh weird because they've just witnessed something really uh intense and violent, and and then they clap along like it's a happy thing.

And I've actually had twice in the autograph line, young people say to me, Do they do that all the time? And and I've said some some people do, yeah, and they find it they found it really weird. Um it's really an interesting dichotomy because the young people seem it really resonates with them, and then sometimes the older people want their Oklahoma the way they want their Oklahoma. They don't want to, they don't want to take in anything that's um too brutal. So And that's how I define the way people live in this country and consume what happens. Like sometimes they want to give in to the pain and to the anxiety and to the upset that is the reality, and then some people want to smile and clap and not see it. And that's America. So if that's what's happening in the Encore, that's okay because that's real life.

[24:55] Dori Berinstein: Thanks so much for listening to part one of our look inside the creation of the Tony Winning Revival of Rogers and Hammerstein's Oklahoma. There's so much more, so please join us for part two.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred