Skip to main content
BPN Logo
S10 Ep8: Kevin McHale

The American actor on leaning into the crazy to make his London stage debut this May in Stephen Sondheim's The Frogs at the Southwark Playhouse (including the promise of him in a toga), feeling comfortable in the world of comedy and his ultimate respect for theatrical performers... Read More

From the show: eleven

33 mins
4/18/25

Guests

About

The American actor on leaning into the crazy to make his London stage debut this May in Stephen Sondheim's The Frogs at the Southwark Playhouse (including the promise of him in a toga), feeling comfortable in the world of comedy and his ultimate respect for theatrical performers.

Plus, we talk the thrill of sound-checking with unmatched live vocalists like Nicole Scherzinger, embracing challenging the perceptions others have of you after his time on Glee and an excessive amount of questions about his appearance in the iconic piece of culture perfection that was Bratz: The Movie. Gag.

Host: William J Connolly

Produced by: William J Connolly/Darren Bell

southwarkplayhouse.co.uk

Welcome to eleven. The official theatre podcast that brings the biggest stars and creatives together in one place to discuss life in the arts. Follow eleven on social media via @elevenpodcast and via elevenpodcast.com.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:01] Kevin McHale: My name is Kevin McHale, and you're listening to Eleven, the Official Theatre Podcast.

[0:16] William J Connolly: Hello and welcome to Eleven, the official theatre podcast that brings the biggest stars and creatives together in one place to discuss life in the arts. He's the American stage actor that is about to bring a new telling of the legendary Stephen Sondheim's musical comedy, The Frogs, to London audiences as it plays the Southwark Playhouse from this May, a production that will mark his debut here in the Capitol, and only his second professional theatrical stage job ever. So here, in an exclusive conversation direct from his home state side, we discuss all things The Frogs, including honoring and paying tribute to Stephen Sondheim's, why he's been resistant to live theatre because of how much respect he has for those in the business, especially coming off the back of Glee, and what advice his former screen star and Olivier Winner for Dream Girls, Miss Amber Riley, has for him as he becomes familiar with UK audiences this May.

Plus, we talked sound checking with Nicole Scherzinger, challenging the perceptions of what people have of you, and his appearance in the actual Bratz movie. So join me as we lean into the crazy with the gorgeous Kevin McHale here now on this, the next episode of Eleven, the official theatre podcast.

[1:36] William J Connolly: Please help me welcome to this, the next episode of Eleven. He's the television actor that's about to make his London stage debut in the legendary Stephen Sondheim's comedy musical, The Frogs at the Southwark Playhouse from May this year. And I am thrilled to say that he's here to tell me all about it. So I hope best British accent at the ready. There will be a test, so get ready for that. Hello, Kevin McHale. How are you?

[1:57] Kevin McHale: You know, that being said, I have to go actually. Um, yeah, yeah. It's been fun. Thank you so much. I'm well. How are you?

[2:05] William J Connolly: That was so funny. Your face went from a big smile to utterly terrified in literally like five seconds.

[2:09] Kevin McHale: Yeah, when I initially had a meeting with Georgie, the director of The Frogs, I was like, Do I have to do a British accent? And the answer is what? No, do whatever you want. And like, then I won't be doing that. Well, I said that this is your stage debut here in London, which seems like a crazy, crazy sentence to say out loud. What's it like at the moment in your brain, knowing that this thing, which I imagine coming here doing this has probably been a little bit of a pie tune, as it is for everybody in our industry, but it's actually happening. You're gonna do it. Like, where are you at with the nerves of the minute where you're like, Do you know what, London? I'm coming, get ready.

[2:36] Kevin McHale: This whole theater thing in general for me is new. I only my first like theater debut ever was in October. So I don't I don't know what's happened, but here we are. Yeah, I'm terrified. But also I've seen, you know, I I've been to the Southwark Playhouse before, I've seen the space, this type of like comedy, but The Frogs is this silly, and we're gonna like make it queer as hell. It's gonna be really fun, and so that excites me. And I think because of how the theater is staged, that's exciting to me. So I'm less nervous. I was very nervous with the last one I did in October because I literally had no idea. Like even backstage, I didn't know how it worked. So I at least have some sort of basis. This will be very different, but I just and Georgie we trust and I trust her. And it's gonna be mayhem. I come out there soon, and then I will find out, you know, what I've gotten myself into.

[3:32] William J Connolly: What happened in October last year that made you go, yeah, fuck it, let's do something utterly terrifying? Like, what was the change?

[3:37] Kevin McHale: That's normally how I operate. It's usually this, like, I've had a big sort of like resistance to theater, and I think because upon Glee, I was surrounded by so many theater people that I respect it so much, and I'm aware of how difficult it is and how much theater people love theater. They really, really love it and are passionate about it. And I'm like, I respect that. That's not the world I come from. I don't want to like try to steal anybody's jobs. But Darren Criss and Jenna Ushkowitz and a lot of the Glee people have been pushing me to do it for a very long time. And then The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee was what I did last year, which again fits with my sort of sense of humor.

And it was one of those things where I'm like, oh, I get this. I want to, I want to try to do this. And it just happened to work out. And it was like one of the best, I mean, challenging experiences for sure. I didn't tell anybody that I didn't know what I was doing, not until I think we were two shows in. I was like, by the way, guys, I have never done this before. Everyone just assumed I had. No one had like asked, no one did their research. I was like, thank God, because I have been faking it. But like I used to host a panel show in the UK on E4, and I surrounded by comedians, not a comedian here. I'd never hosted before. I was like, yeah, that seems terrifying. So the idea of things being new and different and challenging excites me.

And I feel like challenging, new and exciting is probably the only way to get through something as you just described, which is when you don't actually know how to do the thing. But you know a version of it, right? Like you're an actor by trade. So therefore, you know, you know you can get to the end. It's just how you get there is the interesting thing.

[5:13] Kevin McHale: Well, you think you know how to get to the end. Uh it's not, it's not always for sure. After the first show, I ran off after Spelling Bee, I ran backstage and just yelled at everyone because I was so stressed. I was so nervous. And I was like, You're all out of your mind. You like doing this? You enjoy doing this? Because normally for me, like if I'm on stage performing, like I performed in arenas before. Easy. I could do I for me. I'm like any day of the week. I'll go do that fine. The feeling I had being on stage for my first like theater performance, I was like, I was not lost in the material. I was too aware of where I was. I was like, this is obviously that went away. Yes. Thank God. And more performances. And everyone was like, Are you okay? I'm like, no, this is not. How do you people like this? And then I understood it. It just took me a minute.

[6:08] William J Connolly: It's so funny because I would immediately, as I think I did fall into the trap of thinking, oh, this guy is gonna be so at home on stage. He's done it before, he's sung on national television. Millions and millions and squillions of people have watched him. And that's that's I mean, firstly, thank you for being very honest about that. But also, it's so interesting how an art form, maybe, as I incorrectly just said, maybe doesn't translate all the way across in terms of confidence.

[6:31] Kevin McHale: They do in some ways. I think I think they do overlap more than I thought they might. Okay. So the experience of actually being on stage, luckily, I am comfortable with that. I am a bit of a ham, even if I had forgotten it because I hadn't been on stage in a minute. Like once you're in that position, even if you're playing a character, like, oh, I yes, right. I this is why I chose to do this profession, you know, and I I do enjoy it. And so there were overlaps. Like the I like being able to feel a crowd's response to jokes or to the setup, but you know, whatever it may be. And luckily, in these two shows, they're comedic, and so you can feel that, and that's the same as doing a concert. Is you're in control of the audience, you can see and feel how they're responding to it.

And I like adapting to that. Like, oh, well, that joke didn't work as well tonight. Maybe it's because I did X, Y, and Z. Figure that out tomorrow. So, like that whole process of it is the same. And being able to, you know, like, well, this crowd's kind of shitty tonight. Let's I'm gonna have to like amp it up when I come back out here. So it's that sort of stuff is is similar. And obviously, like, yeah, there's a live audience, you're not acting on television. You can't redo it. So that's the terrifying bit. But that's also the magic of it. It's I think theater in any capacity, even when it's, you know, Denzel and Jake Gyllenhaal on Broadway right now, it's always sort of a miracle that it happens.

I always feel like anytime this production happens, it's a miracle, no matter how big or small. It takes a lot of people who really love it because it's not a glamorous thing. And that magic of it is what really, you know, the difference between night one and night two to me was because like seeing the dedication, people on stage and off stage, it's it's just there's nothing else like it.

[8:20] William J Connolly: So through fear in a follow-up question of basically making you leave this call and say this guy's trying to scare the living shit out of me. How did you do all that? Feel like that, come in some way to find and be slightly more comfortable with it, and then decide, yeah, let's do it again and let's do it here. Like, what was the thing that you went, yeah, fuck it, let's just do it?

[8:37] Kevin McHale: Well, I had agreed to do this first because it clearly had been something in the back of my mind. It found me in a way where like two years ago, out of nowhere, all these theater casting directors, and I'm very fortunate that this happened, but started asking my availability for things. None of them happened. But I was like, What has why? Why am I all of a sudden on these people's radars? I'm not seeking this out. And then none of it was like really right. And then a friend of mine put me in touch with Georgie, the director of The Frogs. And after one conversation with her and reading the script, and I was not familiar with the show, it's like this obviously is terrifying for all the reasons I've just mentioned, but seems so exciting.

And you know, when you meet someone like I just want to work with her, and um, and my friend who introduced me, um, is like I trust him, also his taste and things, and I've seen other productions of hers, and who doesn't love a bit of Sondheim? Like, so it just seemed and I um I love London. Any excuse, it's sort of like if I get offered to do anything in London, I don't care what it is, I'll just do it. But theater was like, you know, it was heading in that direction. I was on the train, and you know, Spelling Bee came up. So Spelling Bee was sort of the warm-up for Frogs.

[9:51] William J Connolly: So now I feel like I have truly terrified you and asked you to justify what a crazy decision this is.

[9:55] William J Connolly: Let's talk about The Frogs because it is the right decision. It's such a great Sondheim gem that a couple of things. Firstly, I think people sort of know, but maybe don't, and that's the great joy is it could be some people's first opportunity to come in contact with it, which I think is the most exciting part, particularly when sometimes attached, but also as you referenced the comedy, which I personally think will play into your funny bones and you'll lean into and you'll probably feel quite safe with.

[10:20] William J Connolly: But you do have very good source material because when there was that revival that happened, one of the funniest, most genuine stage actors ever, apart from the fact that he was in it, he also co-wrote part of the book as well. And that, of course, is Mr. Nathan Lane.

[10:33] William J Connolly: So, in terms of goodness, like you're cooking with gas with this, right?

[10:38] Kevin McHale: Yeah, correct, exactly. I think it was just nothing but the greatest hits.

[10:42] Kevin McHale: Like when you're exactly what you just said, talking about all the reasons why to do this and why the show is so good and beloved by, yeah, a lot of people don't know it, but I think once they interact with it or see it, then it's sort of like a cult classic.

[10:54] Kevin McHale: Do you feel the same about the people that also do that are coming going, "Oh my gosh, they've not done this in a while. This is like finally my opportunity to probably come back rather a lot?"

[11:02] Kevin McHale: Yeah, and I think I don't know if this is my story to tell, but I'm gonna tell it anyway. Um, I hung out with Georgie in August in London, and she was saying, like, you know, we're trying to get the like permission from the Sondheim Estate to do this production, and everybody wants to do Sondheim productions, and they you know are intentional about who's doing what and where all around the world, and so they sort of said something along the lines of like, Well, I don't know if I can guarantee you know some of the bigger ones, unless like you want something like The Frogs, sort of as a joke.

[11:36] Kevin McHale: And she's like, No, that's actually what I'm calling you about. It's The Frogs. Because people I think forget about it, and Nathan Lane, when they did that revival, it was for you know, they did it in New York and it was right after 9-11, and very timely and topical. And here we are at another strange time in the world, and it feels fitting. And for me, with what's going on in the US, I'm looking very forward to getting out of here and um having a bit of fun with you know all of this.

[12:08] William J Connolly: I don't possibly know what you're referring to.

[12:10] Kevin McHale: Good, good for you. Yeah, you just thought crisp British sunshine in May. That sounds like a bit like me. Yeah, this is a podcast that people can't see biting your lip, nodding furiously, like, yeah, like yeah, yeah, okay. There's a very audio-visual thing going on right now, but um we get the vibe, but also, you are following alongside, of course, Nathan Lane in that production, uh, Mr. Roger Bart, who of course is just this OG genius, like literally the blueprint of so many of our favorite stuff.

[12:37] Kevin McHale: And he, of course, played this role, which means that in terms of like joining a crew, joining a Sondheim legacy, the few people that get to do it, like that's that I feel like that would be pretty high up on my fucking life list. Yeah, also a lot to live up to. So thank you for reminding me. Sorry. Great, great, great, great, great. Do you take home?

[12:55] Kevin McHale: That's when I started to build myself up that I can do this. You're gonna be telling your team like this dude, he was on there going, it's really hard. It's like, okay, cool, yeah. This is like therapy.

[13:04] William J Connolly: It is.

[13:04] Kevin McHale: Thank you. I should be paying you for this, actually.

[13:07] William J Connolly: My time is free.

[13:08] Kevin McHale: But Mr. Roger Bart, do you take a template from him and try and expand on that? Or is this your opportunity, perhaps through your direction, to find something that feels like it's relevant in terms of the time difference that you referenced a second ago? Like this is for now. Like, I guess, is there anything people might recognize, or are you trying to find something perhaps that feels right for 2025?

[13:27] Kevin McHale: Um, I think like the magic of this part is it does feel like a choose your own adventure type thing. Where the jokes are so good you just have to say the jokes. But I think luckily you can't really find bootlegs of this show because I have tried. It's hard to not want to copy like the parts that I love from what he does, you know, but I always think it is. Like you said, it's a good template to go off of. And I'm so excited for rehearsal to just sort of throw everything at the wall and see what sticks and play around with everybody because things are going to change.

[13:58] Kevin McHale: So, you know, in my head, I have a general idea of where I'd like to go with it. But it's I think especially with this show and how we're doing it, it's going to just be about that chemistry with all of us once we're in the room and figuring it out. So, based off the incredibly solid foundation, try not to have to live up to it, try to just do our own thing so they're not compared. But also, we as an audience are coming to respectfully not see the past. We want to come see your version of it. That's what we're choosing to. So you know the audience is on your side, right?

[14:30] Kevin McHale: I hope so. Yes. Wow, that was a long pause. He was like, Yeah, yes, yes. Yeah, they are, right? Yes. Yes. Yes, William nod. William is nodding. Thank you very much. I promise he's agree. But one thing, and I'm gonna get so many people saying, How dare you say that about New York to calm down? Is that one thing I think is very credible about UK audiences, a particular places like the Southwark Playhouse is that people like to experience something new or something that feels like it's going in a direction.

[14:56] Kevin McHale: Like if you want to quote develop something, this is the place to do it. This is the place to try and you know, as you say, throw it at the wall and see what sticks. And I think that we get excited by the fact that you are gonna come and do this, and who knows where it might go, who knows how long it is. But this is like it feels nice to be able to, especially in this quite challenging time for theater in terms of anything new. Like this, I mean, this feels very exciting, however, terrifying it may be at times.

[15:21] Kevin McHale: Yeah, I know it absolutely feels it's much more exciting than terrifying. I think I have a lot of friends who work in London theater and in New York theater, and there is something going on though, in a positive way, I think in London with theater. It there's an excitement and there's like a willingness to experience something new. Where in New York, it's in a bit of a strange place at the moment where it's a bit, I don't know, it's really I mean it's expensive everywhere to make shows happen, and it's hard to get people into seats and rent for the theaters is so expensive, so the ticket prices are so expensive, and it's a strange time, and it feels like there's um a surge in audiences in London going to see different types of things and everything, which feels really, really nice.

[16:05] Kevin McHale: And I love like I love British humor. I love that sort of so like for me, this fits. I feel much more comfortable doing this. You know, I love New York, but this feels like this is also part of what makes this so exciting for me. And also, we did just have obviously the great Sondheim tribute here, which in terms of ticket sales, how much people loved it, critics, etc. Like Sondheim has such a strong relationship with London. We saw that, of course, with the revival of Company and you know, trying new things. And so I feel like you're about to get embraced by a lot of people in the Sondheim world who are just like here to show up for Sondheim, here to show up for you. Like, and I think that I would feel comforted by that.

[16:41] Kevin McHale: Yeah, and I feel like getting Sondheim that's not done as much and is not as well known, it feels like we're getting new Sondheim, which is such a gift um now that he's passed. And so getting to explore like Meryl Streep was in the ensemble of this when they first did it. Right, like there's like such a weird history of it, and when you talk to people, they're like, Oh, yeah, like theater buffs know those things, but generally I don't think people know that. And so I'm just excited to introduce, like you said, introduce this hopefully to a lot of people.

[17:12] Kevin McHale: Here's hoping something good comes of Meryl Streep here's hoping her career takes off.

[17:16] William J Connolly: Yeah, I know she's been struggling, huh?

[17:17] Kevin McHale: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Maybe if she tries a bit harder. Um, I maybe should have asked this question towards the beginning, but could you give people that maybe are coming in contact with it for the first time? Like, what are we talking about with this show? Like, what where does it sit? Where is it? Because some of these words about making it queer and about having Nathan Lane's involvement and Roger, etc., etc. you're like, sorry, run that by me again. So, like, how would you describe it?

[17:41] Kevin McHale: We're just making things up. I mean, it's it's uh I guess what they say, it's like a um loosely adapted or something like that version adaptation of um an Aristophanes story, you know, like Greek mythology Dionysus and um Xantheus like going down into hell to rescue to rescue George Bernard Shaw is basically what the story is because um Dionysus is upset with the state of the world and doesn't love the current state of art and drama, and so thinks this will like cure the world of its issues, which is like we need some of that today, obviously.

[18:23] Kevin McHale: So that's where that comes in, and you know, I think we're just gonna be wearing a lot of togas. There's a lot of that, and it's a silly show, it's really silly, but it also you know, I think borders in that moral and ethical gray area where like you go in for comedy, it does cause you to think a little bit, which is fun, not too much, but just enough, and um there's some meta-ness in it where we talk to the audience and things like that. There's a lot of crowd interaction, I feel like in that, and so it's really fun in that way where you go see the show and it will be fun. The music's great. Um, it's obviously written very well, but then you're also involved as an audience member, and so you're taking this spin, a Sondheim Nathan Lane version of a Greek myth and making it new.

[19:07] Kevin McHale: Toga, you say that's an interesting development. I feel like we should definitely be putting this on the poster. I don't know. We'll see. That's what I heard. That was ages ago, though. So we'll see. Uh uh, hold on a second. That's false advertisement. I'll be like, give me that I guess. I know. I just draped in fabrics. Uh, who knows? That's what I'm imagining. At least, I shouldn't be saying these things, but like, we haven't started rehearsal yet, so I don't know. It's gonna be the least toga, least queer thing ever. People are gonna be like, hold on a second. That man said very straight. Everything's just yeah, I've been to the Celtic playoffs, nothing is any of those things, so that's fine by me.

[19:41] Kevin McHale: Um, you reference about some of your peers from Glee being on stage and the fact that like they've done that, and you know, you're starting to get in more involved in that. Obviously, of course, the wonderful Amber Riley came here, Olivier winner for Dream Girls, and she knows that our audiences can be quite quiet, our listeners, and then when they turn up and show up and vocalize it, most probably at the end of Act One and Act Two, like they then show up. Have you had any advice in terms of the fact that maybe we are a little bit reserved to start with, and like you know, stick with us to the end, and then we will take the roof off the place?

[20:13] Kevin McHale: Oh, yeah, she is told, she has told me exactly that. However, it wasn't like, oh, you know, they're so like quiet. It was like they may be quiet in parts, you're not expecting it, but like, yeah, you guys show up when it's time to show up and are very passionate. So yeah, nothing but good things, and you know, it'll just make me feel like the joke's not landing and I'll panic. So it's fine.

[20:34] Kevin McHale: That's literally what I was thinking was he's gonna be like, they don't like that one. No, not that one, not that one. No, no, okay, we're gonna rewrite that. Call Mr. Nathan Lane. I'm just every time he makes it, I'll be like, yeah, you know, you'll be like, shut the fuck up. I'm trying to I'm trying to remember this shit in a toga in a space, like just I should be working out.

[20:52] Kevin McHale: Oh god, the toga. I feel like this conversation has sent you south. You're gonna be like, This man was not giving. Like, he just made me think this was a terrible idea.

[21:01] William J Connolly: No, this is good. This is this is what I need, you know.

[21:07] Kevin McHale: For you, I feel like there comes a point in people's careers where like challenging things, as much as we joke about this, is actually like a drug to the soul where you're like, you know what? If I haven't done that yet, I want to do this. Was this quite high on your list? I know we joke about like the reasons why you chose to do theater last year and now, but like realistically, was this supposed to happen? Like, was this a conscious decision to put yourself in a vulnerable space, or was it more the opportunity came along first?

[21:33] Kevin McHale: Because if it's a choice, sensible, but also that's a challenging part in which you have to almost go against the world. Do you know what I mean? Like it's it's a big thing to do. Like, how realistically does it play out in your head?

[21:45] Kevin McHale: A little above, but I think it became oh, I need to do this. At first, it was like so far off and terrifying, to so much so where it like wasn't even an interest because I didn't come from the theater world. And then I think because I was around it all the time, I started to get into it, I started to really appreciate it.

[22:05] Kevin McHale: Then started to wonder like, how would I fit into this? What would I want to do? And then when opportunities came up, I'm like, that seems scary in a bad way. Because like I maybe not my thing. And so the intention did become like, okay, let's if I can find a way to do this in a way that seems really natural for me to get into, then let's do that. And this is that. It like speaks to some of my like sensibilities or things that I understand and that I would want to see as an audience member while being like, okay, let's bite off this challenge and do it. And all these people who know me incredibly well keep telling me that I should be doing this and I should have been doing this for decades already. So I'm trusting in them, and they were right the first time, and I know they'll be right this time.

[22:56] William J Connolly: The reason why I ask is I wonder if there's a part you're sort of expecting to come along in this journey that maybe you've bookmarked. Might even be opening night, completing the run even towards the end of it that you want for you. Like what's the thing that you're wanting to do for Kevin that's maybe slightly separate to everyone else away from the public image that's a sort of chapter for you that you think this is something that I'm actually going to turn up and turn out for myself.

[23:19] Kevin McHale: Very good question. Thank you. I think a couple things. I think one is the length of the run. So the one I the show I did in October we did 11 shows. The whole thing was a month. We did two weeks of rehearsal basically a week and a half of shows. Like it was very, very quick. I feel like this is the next step where we're doing like five ish weeks of performances. Um so one to see if I can even you know if I can keep it I know that's not that long for people. Someone who's never really done this that is long that's long for me. And so yeah, hopefully that will work out and I'll be all right. Um I think the other part is is a lot of times I rely on singing, I guess. Um and the I I don't sing I do sing in this, but it's not like a gigantic singing role.

And that's exciting to me to get to dive into also sort of being the sidekick and um serving you know the performance in that way and getting to do a lot of these I I feel like a lot of Xantheus's part in this is sort of voicing what an audience member may be thinking or like a rational rational person may be thinking. And that's really fun for me. Um that's sort of similar to what I did on Glee. I every now and then I'd be like this doesn't seem right. Um, but all those things moving together, doing this, you know, in this way, doing it sort of like in a black box theater, all of those things present new things that like as an actor, I want to see if I can meet those moments of how will I feel with an audience member sitting like a foot away from me?

That seems really exciting, and I just want to see how I maybe I'll fuck up. Who knows? But I'm not really worried about that. It's it's more of I'm going to get through this run and want to see how successfully I can do that and see how physically I feel afterwards. How am I managing my days? Those things that don't sound glamorous, but for me, it's you know, learning. So the next time I do this, maybe I'll do a six-month run of something, you know. So getting all of those things in order.

[25:16] William J Connolly: How is it in terms of when you know people might have interacted with you on television or in a certain other medium? I don't just mean on Glee, I mean on television generally being a face that they recognize they've seen you do something else to then come into a different art form that as we say does have connection. Is there an opportunity for you just to show a different part of you to lean into that and be like, actually, I do other things as well. And thank you for turning up. Let me now show you what else I can do. Or is that actually another layer on top that you sort of that's someone else's business? You sort of have to let that be something that that they sort of focus on. Because we're seeing it so many different ways now.

Just thinking about like Nicole Scherzinger being on stage is a crazy idea, but you only have to go see that show to realize that woman is born to do that. But also, you would also see why she wouldn't want to do it because people have got their version of her versus the stage version of her. So, how does it play out realistically when you have been in the public spotlight?

[26:05] Kevin McHale: How good is Nicole, by the way? Ridiculous. When I was 17, I was in a boy band and we opened up for the Pussycat Dolls. I do know this, yes. And I didn't know she could sing like that. And I remember going to soundcheck and I thought she was lip syncing and like standing on the side of the stage watching her singing. I was like, What? Like, Miss Don't you can do that? And ever since then, it's like, you're a freak. You are she's so good. And and I think what's fun about that is when people come in having one perception of you, it's so much fun to be able to play against that. And the flip side of that is I'm very thankful that if anybody comes knowing me from anything, I hope that you know lends to their willingness of like I have them at least.

They trust me or they'll trust that I won't completely screw it up, and that way you know, we can we have this rapport already, which I think goes a long way. So, regardless if people have seen me in something or not, I still have the same job to do. But I do think there's that extra level of credit or understanding of oh, if this is a comedy, I've seen them do comedy before. This is obviously very different, but like, let's give this a go. And I'm in, and like you said, like the audience wants you to win, they want they're on your side. I don't really take it on as any sort of pressure or anything. It's like if you're there, you're there to see this show, you're there to see all of us in this production. I happen to be in this, and everybody's going to be great and you know, be entertaining and hope you enjoy all of it.

[27:33] William J Connolly: So, in terms of like the camp scale, a toga and sometime opening for the Pussycat Dolls, or what about your guest appearance in the Bratz movie? Which one's first?

[27:41] Kevin McHale: Look, I was in a boy band, it was pre-One Direction post Backstreet Boys and N Sync, so it was no man's land, like no one was looking for a boy band, no one wanted a boy band. It was like we were out there flailing, and we got asked, or somehow we got in this Bratz movie for like 30 seconds, and it's like, oh, this is fun. Finally, like somebody wants us to do something. I can't believe how many people have seen that movie. Yeah. Because like two years, but all of a sudden, people keep bringing it up. Like, why? Why? What has happened? I never even saw it. Like, I don't know what that is. I forgot that that happened, and then somebody mentioned it pretty recently. I was like, wait a second, that people know that. I automatically there's like 30 people who even know I was in a boy band. And then the amount of people who knew I was on a boy band and then saw Bratz has to be even less. So I'm very perplexed by all of it. I have no idea.

[28:32] William J Connolly: If ever there's a personality that loves the Bratz movie, this guy right here. I mean, I'm sorry, but I've I'm I don't mean to be a disrespectful to anything else you've done, but I was like, here we fucking go. Here we go. Bratz, I'd be a brat. No, whatever. Sure. Yes. Yeah. I'm like, yeah, oh my god, I want to do that. Fuck Lee, I want to be in Bratz movie. Like, yeah, I'm like, okay, cool. Bratz 2. That's fine. Yep. Sort of as a part two. It's a piece of cultural history and the greatest cinematic writing of all time. Charlie XCX. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. And if the Bratz movie team are listening, I would like a part in it. Thank you very much. Yeah. I'll sing Kevin's songs. It's fine. We'll have to be in it together. Okay, deal. Just you and me against the world, basically.

[29:12] Kevin McHale: Wow. I'm not being funny, but talking about a Sondheim musical and you coming to London, I did not expect this conversation to pivot in the way that it has, but I am absolutely here for it. And sorry, my fault. The togas don't seem that bad anymore, do they?

[29:23] William J Connolly: Yeah. I've been very conscious of time. So thank you so much for this conversation. I do have one final question for you, which is actually always my favorite part of this interview. And we, of course, have touched on, and people are going to be blowing up my mentions as they always are saying, You didn't ask about my favorite thing. I'm like, Kevin's got places to be, people to meet. This is not an autobund. Please don't give me ideas. But of your career so far, and it's been a very eclectic career, and lots of stuff hopefully that has served you creatively. But when you think about some of the incredible milestones, cough Bratz that has happened to you, and now you're here like doing this incredible chapter in 2025 that, as I sort of referenced a second ago, is serving you, hopefully, and giving you that creative sort of filling your cup in a way, doing something new, particularly with great source material for legends and honoring people.

When you think back to like the very beginning of your career when you thought, you know what, I might actually want to do this as a career. This might actually genuinely be a thing for me. Do you think there was ever a moment for the person way back then that he could imagine you'd be sat here going, I'm actually gonna be in London in something that's fresh doing this. Could he ever have imagined that this chapter would come along?

[30:30] Kevin McHale: No, there's no way. And I think I can say that about most things I've done because it's so hard to have a good enough imagination to imagine that I could sort of stumble. I feel like I just have stumbled into all of these random things that are so creatively fulfilling, and I'm so happily accepting of these opportunities. Um, that no, I don't think there is any way I ever could have imagined it. And if anything, I think I wouldn't have imagined it because I probably thought I'd be too scared to do it. And like what you said, doing a show in London, a Sondheim show, this version of the show, like all of those things just seem so surreal. And I'm yeah, I'm shocked and surprised, and just very thankful.

And no, little Kevin would have never even known that was possible. As a child, I was so obsessed with anything British. All I ever wanted to do was just travel to England once. That's all I ever wanted. And like the first time I ever got to come there was because of Glee in like 2008 or nine. And it's you know, become my favorite place. And so it's extra special that I'm getting to do, get to do this there.

[31:36] William J Connolly: I know there's a famous Last Five Years song that says a summer in Ohio, but I think a summer in London pretty much does the billing, right?

[31:41] Kevin McHale: Oh my god. Are you a sunny day in London in the summer is the most magical thing in the entire world? Ice coffee in hand, Bratz movie soundtrack in here. Yep. And every everybody just like translucent pasty skin in the parks with the shirts off.

[31:55] William J Connolly: And they're togas, don't say shirts off.

[31:56] Kevin McHale: Togas. Yeah, come on. Come on. I'm petitioning for the togas. If there's no togas, I'm walking out, just so you know and go back to my uh go back to my Glee.

[32:04] William J Connolly: I can't walk out, I'll see it and I'll start panicking. Kevin, this has been such a pleasure. Thank you so much for giving me some of your time. And most importantly, congratulations on the journey ahead. I think it's gonna be incredibly exciting. Well done, like massive kudos to you for leaning into the crazy. I if I could write that on a t-shirt and say this is the vibe that I think has best served me and encourage other people to do so. It absolutely would be that. So like good luck with what's ahead. And thank you so much for bringing something new to us, something fresh that's gonna reignite our creative sort of ability here in London. So thank you so much. And I will see you here very, very soon.

[32:08] Kevin McHale: Thank you so much for having me. This conversation made me even more excited to get out there and do it. And hopefully we'll see each other when you know I'm actually there and meet in real life. Thank you so so much for this. I appreciate it.

[32:45] William J Connolly: Amazing. Thank you so much. I'll see you soon.

[32:46] Kevin McHale: See ya.

[32:50] William J Connolly: You've been listening to Eleven, the official theatre podcast. Find out more about Eleven at elevenpodcast.com or via the Broadway Podcast Network.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred