Guests
Featured Shows
About
Broadway leading lady on playing Cher alongside the legendary Stephanie J Block, keeping up the belting during the pandemic and why she wouldn’t be able to return to a role like Elphaba again. We also discuss her love and respect for Take That’s Gary Barlow when working on his musical Finding Neverland – and how she’s learnt to love the beautiful individuality of her unique and top-tier voice.
Host: William J Connolly
Produced by: William J Connolly/Darren Bell
abingdontheatre.org
Welcome to eleven. The official theatre podcast that brings the biggest stars and creatives together in one place to discuss life in the arts. Follow eleven on social media via @elevenpodcast and via elevenpodcast.com.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:01] Teal Wicks: My name is Teal Wicks, and you're listening to Eleven, the Official Theatre Podcast.
[0:16] William J Connolly: Hello and welcome to Eleven, the official theatre podcast that brings the biggest stars and creatives together in one place to discuss life in the arts.
[0:24] William J Connolly: She's the Broadway leading lady that's belted her way into the hearts of audiences, earning herself a global fanbase of loyal followers.
[0:31] William J Connolly: She originated roles in both the Cher Show and Finding Neverland on Broadway, alongside playing the lead role of Elphaba in Wicked in the LA, San Francisco and Broadway productions, alongside playing Emma in Jekyll and Hyde.
[0:44] William J Connolly: She's also appeared in Carousel and Pippin.
[0:46] William J Connolly: And this February, she's set to star in an exciting new season by Abingdon Theatre Company, perfectly titled The Broadway and Barry Season.
[0:54] William J Connolly: So here in an exclusive conversation, we discuss playing Cher alongside the legendary Stephanie J. Block, how she wouldn't be able to return to a role like Elphaba again, keeping up belting during the pandemic, her love and respect for Take That's Gary Barlow when they were developing and playing in Finding Neverland, and how she's learnt to love the beautiful individuality of her unique and top-tier voice.
[1:15] William J Connolly: She's the belting Broadway goddess of Teal Wicks here now on this, the next episode of Eleven, the official theatre podcast.
[1:26] William J Connolly: To ensure the safety of all involved in this episode of Eleven, Teal and I connected for this conversation digitally, so please forgive any brief moments while we wait for the internet to catch up.
[1:36] William J Connolly: Enjoy.
[1:41] William J Connolly: Broadway Superstar incoming, and one of my favourite voices, who I surprisingly do actually know rather a lot about, so I'm gonna embarrass myself now by telling her all about it.
[1:50] William J Connolly: The smiliest space in the world. Hello, Teal Wicks, how are you?
[1:52] Teal Wicks: Hello!
[1:53] Teal Wicks: I'm so excited to be able to get to talk to you today, and I was just saying before we started recording that you and I actually have more of a connection than we realized.
[2:00] Teal Wicks: So I've just shown you a photograph, which I'll put on social media and so people can see of the one and only time that we've met in person.
[2:07] Teal Wicks: But this isn't where our sort of non-official friendship, which obviously after today we're gonna be complete besties, so it'll be official official, will have started.
[2:15] Teal Wicks: So this is when you were doing Finding Neverland, which is when I came to Broadway for one of the first times, obsessed with this show. We'll talk about it in a second.
[2:21] Teal Wicks: But you were also in the Cher Show, which I also interviewed you on a very strange phone line where I could just about hear you, and I felt like I was shouting at you the whole time.
[2:30] Teal Wicks: Oh gosh.
[2:31] Teal Wicks: I got to talk to you then. But also Finding Neverland started its journey, which is very different to the production that you did at the Curve Theatre in the UK, which is where I'm from.
[2:40] Teal Wicks: So I basically feel like I'm just William Wicks. Can we just say that? Can we just be like sisters? Is that okay?
[2:44] Teal Wicks: It's like, what is the six degrees of separation? We're not, we're like two degrees.
[2:50] Teal Wicks: But isn't that true? The whole six degrees thing in the theater world is actually true. It's like I do know you like in a weird way, or I've met you, or it's sometimes quite strange.
[2:59] Teal Wicks: It's really, really strange. Steven Schwartz has been somehow like a part of very significant steps in my career before, but like in ways that I don't think he knows at all.
[3:11] Teal Wicks: My very first job when I moved to New York after I graduated from college, moved to New York and through some family friends. My first job was an usher at this theater on 42nd Street.
[3:24] Teal Wicks: It's an off-Broadway theater called the Little Schubert Theatre. And the musical that was there that was the show I was the usher for was called Captain Louie, which was a Stephen Schwartz musical, but like mostly for young kids and whatnot.
[3:38] Teal Wicks: And so that was my very, very first job, and then my very first equity job where I got my equity card and my first lead role in any like professional theater was in Pippin at Goodspeed Opera House.
[3:50] Teal Wicks: Yeah. I played Catherine. And then of course then Wicked happened. But I just it was like they were very big steps in sort of my New York career. Stephen Schwartz was a part of it.
[4:01] Teal Wicks: So I'm like, Steven, I'm ready. I'm ready for the next one. Like, what's next, please?
[4:05] William J Connolly: Well, he's always writing. I've had the pleasure of having him as a guest on Eleven. And one of the things that we discussed was the fact that once you start writing, you can never actually stop. You know, you're always a creative.
[4:17] William J Connolly: So I imagine, you know, in five, ten years' time when it happens, I'll be like, look, we basically manifested the fact that you and Stephen Schwartz are best friends now.
[4:26] Teal Wicks: So we're best friends, yeah.
[4:27] Teal Wicks: Yeah.
[4:28] Teal Wicks: So glad this is started off as such a serious interview. It's like, yeah, no, we're just all best friends.
[4:32] Teal Wicks: We're all best friends. It's the beautiful thing about theater.
[4:35] Teal Wicks: It's community. That's why I miss it so much right now. I just miss being in spaces with all these creative, beautiful people and just having fun and trying to make something meaningful.
[4:47] William J Connolly: Does the pandemic mean that you have to keep working on your instrument? And this probably sounds like such a basic question, but like, do you have to remind yourself that you can belt for the gods? Because obviously we all love it when you do that, but do you have to sort of like keep rehearsing it?
[5:00] Teal Wicks: Yeah, I don't sing very much, not nearly as much as I used to, because I don't have to. I basically, if I have an audition or I'm doing like a random, we've done a lot of, you know, Zoom concerts and things.
[5:17] Teal Wicks: I've done a few in-person singing things, and anytime those come up, I'm like, oh wow, I have to, ooh, we gotta work on this. And because I live in my New York apartment, you know, sharing walls and ceilings with all these other people, and everybody's at home right now.
[5:36] Teal Wicks: And my husband works, he's not in the theater world, he has a corporate job, but he's been working from home the whole time. So he's like on conference calls all day, and our walls are very thin, so I have to like try to figure out what I'm gonna sing in between his conference calls, or I have to leave the apartment and go get like a studio space somewhere because I was like, I really need to belt.
[5:57] Teal Wicks: I like don't know if I can belt. Like, can I hit these notes anymore? I have no idea. So it's a back and forth. I sometimes I'm good. There was a time where I was like, I'm gonna do a warm-up every day, or at least like a few times a week just to do a vocal warm-up and all of that, and then I stopped. I just gave up. I was like, uh.
[6:20] Teal Wicks: But it was interesting, there was a moment where I wasn't singing all the time for work stuff, I found a new joy in singing. Like I sort of went back to when I used to just sing for fun, sing to the radio, sing along to songs, and just sing for fun.
[6:39] Teal Wicks: Because when you're doing it as a career, yes, you're singing for fun, but it's, you know, it's kind of everything's a, I'm more aware. I'll be like, ooh, should I be singing this? Should I save my voice? And I've sort of re-embraced the joy and freedom of just singing to whatever I wanted and being able to sing it badly, sing it loudly, or so you know, like there's no the critic, the singer technique, career-driven critic is silenced, and I'm just like, ah, singing for fun.
[7:09] Teal Wicks: So I don't know, it's been interesting during the pandemic. I am definitely nervous of whenever a show comes back into my life that requires stamina. No idea how that's gonna happen. Woo!
[7:22] William J Connolly: She's gonna be hard. When you're running, you're gonna have some steel right. You've got to get it back into your because obviously it's not just standard singing, you know, which is a complete talent in itself, it's everything else.
[7:36] Teal Wicks: And yeah, and you know, acting, saying words, speaking, having to talk to people, run around like crazy, maybe do crazy quick changes, all the things that you kind of when you haven't been doing it, you sort of I at least I forget depressive have done in the past. Like, oh wow, that's actually that's cool. Good job. I did that.
[7:56] Teal Wicks: Do you have that a lot in your career when you think about back to specific roles, you know, if it is Jekyll and Hyde or if it's the Cher Show, stuff where you think like that in itself was a very specific physical part of my life that would I'd have to train for?
[8:11] Teal Wicks: Yes. Oh goodness, yeah. It's it even with, I mean, Wicked is, you know, it's Wicked, it's Elphaba, she's a sort of a completely different beast. But because I've done that, I know what it takes to do that, and I'm at the point where I was like, oh, I'm too old, I'm too tired. I don't have that. That is for the young ones.
[8:35] Teal Wicks: But even with I think of Finding Neverland for my character Mary Barry, the costume design of her, I would jokingly say I almost was getting a drag because I they really wanted her to be very, very curvy, very like the Gibson girl hourglass silhouette.
[8:53] Teal Wicks: So I had a lot of help and pushing up of the bosom area and like had I put, what did we call them? I basically put hips on, like fake hips on. And so I was getting, I've never really had to do, I've never done that in a show.
[9:10] Teal Wicks: And just the physical act and the way that I would walk and sing and talk with these artificial things added to my body and to all of that was very different, and it definitely had some physical effects on my body that I was like, oh I did not expect this. And wow, and doing it eight times a week and having to put those like chicken cutlets in and the I called them like I think like T-bone steaks or whatever, because these like hip things that were very well made but very awkward to put on with a dresser basically holding them to me while I'm pulling like spanks over them so they all stay in place.
[9:43] Teal Wicks: It's a completely different type of workout that I never expected. So isn't this just so glamorous?
[9:49] Teal Wicks: I know, that's the thing. So sexy being like, yeah, it's not it is it is like sweat and just people are everybody's up in each other's faces and other places just because you gotta get up close and personal.
[10:06] Teal Wicks: And because it's theater, it always has to happen very, very fast. There's no like such thing as a slow changes though, that doesn't exist in theatre.
[10:12] William J Connolly: No, that doesn't exist. But God love Broadway, you know, best place on earth, but it's I mean it's exhausting. I was I was recording an episode with Lizzie Lafontaine who is starring in the West End production of Moulin Rouge, and she was saying like it's great fun and it's like the best job in the world.
[10:26] William J Connolly: But oh my gosh, afterwards she is like, nobody speak to me, nobody talks to me, I just need to go sit in a dark room. It's so intense having not done it for like 18 months that your body is like in shock in a way.
[10:36] Teal Wicks: And I, you know, I sort of feel for some of these people, like you know, the Elphabas, whoever, who are like, Oh, yeah, by the way, you've now got to go do probably the hardest role in the world.
[10:44] Teal Wicks: I know, I know the whole, like, when with Wicked, they were, you know, and everybody was like, Oh, they're calling all the ex-Elphabas to like be in on standby. I mean, if you can even remember the show, even remember what you're supposed to say and sing, but then to just like be like, oh sure, I can sing all of those 11 o'clock numbers back to back and sing some of the highest. Yeah, sure, no braids.
[11:04] Teal Wicks: That is literally anxiety dreams that I still have being thrown into Wicked and having to like play all the roles. It's a dream I still have, and I'm like, why is this still haunting me? Because I love Wicked. I look back on it so fondly. It was a big huge part of my career and a lot of ups and downs, but still gives me anxiety.
[11:22] Teal Wicks: They did not call Teal. She's probably said I've probably said enough in things that I don't think I could do Elphaba again, so they heard me. Don't set them a challenge, please. We all know what they're like. They're like, Oh, that person that said they'd never do it. We love a challenge at Wicked, so you know.
[11:35] Teal Wicks: Yeah, they're like by the time this podcast comes out, it'll be like, yeah, she's done three shows.
[11:38] William J Connolly: I'm like, it's like it doesn't even work now. Anyway, anyway, we've spoken too much about all these random other things, and there's one very specific thing that I want to talk to you about. I'm also terrible at pronunciation, so I feel like I'm gonna say the name of this theatre wrong. So please correct my British accent. But is it Abingdon? Is that the right way to say it?
[11:53] Teal Wicks: Oh, yeah, Abingdon. I was like freaking out the whole way into the introduction, like, I'm gonna say this wrong, and she's gonna be like, You're incompetent, we don't even know what it's called. Okay, Abingdon Theatre Company. Basically, they're celebrating Broadway, which is the most important thing, and my favorite part of that basically audiences are gonna get to just do exactly what I wish I could do right now is listen to you sing, probably belt, and go through some amazing song. So I'm gonna shut up. Can you please tell me an evening with Teal Wicks? What does it include?
[12:18] Teal Wicks: Oh goodness. Well, I'm still trying to figure it out a little bit because it's been so long since I performed, it's I've been listening to so much music over music, is just my like my safety. It's my like warm safety blanket. So I basically probably have about ten separate concerts of material in my head of just I'm like, oh I want to do this, I want to do that, and blah blah blah blah blah. And I get very overly excited and ambitious, so I'm still trying to figure out what exactly it is. But it really is kind of little glimpse into the songs and the artists that inspire me the most and the songs that really resonate with me, especially like throughout the pandemic coming out of this. I'm hopeful I won't have too many.
I'm trying not to have too many like sad songs, because I mean everybody loves like a sad power ballad. Everybody loves that. Nothing like two years unemployed and a global pandemic to make power ballads all the rage. But it's yeah, just a glimpse sort of into a lot of the music and songs and artists that I just love and that move me. It'll be it's usually a mix of it's a little bit of theater, it's not a ton of theater, musical theater. Um, and I might add a few more songs, but it's some some things from some of my favorite shows, like like Hedwig is one of my absolute favorite shows. So um, if I can ever sing a song from that show, I will because I just I love that show so much. Um, and then definitely some like old throwback standards, just because I love me some jazzy jazzy soul songs, and then definitely a mix of a lot of rock folk artists and whatnot.
And yeah, it's just kind of the music that fuels my soul. And that's so fun about this concert that Abingdon's doing. It's at this really cool venue called Dwayne Park, which is downtown, like on the Bowery, hence why the concert series that they're doing is called Broadway on the Bowery. Um, and it's just so it has this great downtown New York vibe, which I just love taking Broadway. We associate it very much with a very specific spot in New York City around, you know, the theater district and all of that. But to like go downtown and then the space is this beautiful, it feels like a 1920s, almost feels like you're transported to like Paris in the 1920s, and it's this great space that they there's a lot of burlesque performances that happen there and whatnot.
So I'm also trying to embrace that sort of vibe just because it I I've been to the space before and sang at a gala there for Abingdon before, and I was like, this I just love the vibe here, and it just makes you want to you know sing a bunch of like Ella Fitzgerald and Billy Holiday, and then also get in some cool, like for me. I'm thinking of like New York iconic sort of downtown New York artists like Patty Smith or like Velvet Underground and all of these, like even Tom Waits and yeah, and mixing that with a little bit of Broadway. So that was a really long explanation.
[15:30] William J Connolly: That's good, and I like the fact that it feels like the audience will get to see lots of different sides of you, not just in terms of who you are as an individual, but also vocally, because a lot of those artists are very different. So I can imagine for you it's quite nice to be like, you know, I can do as we sort of joked at the start, like the belty Broadway stuff, but I don't can also do the vulnerable stuff. We can also do the blue stuff as well. I mean, that sort of feels like the best sort of mashup ever.
[15:52] Teal Wicks: I mean, yes, it's like I could sing like Teal Wicks's greatest hits, which I don't really know what those are because um but there's also you can there's there's a lot of footage you know I'm on cast albums you can hear me sing that song I probably sang it really good on that because obviously it was in a studio and mixed and all of that and that's sort of your snapshot perfect version of like that song. So I I get that I love being able to see what artists love like what music draw is that they're drawn to and what has inspired them and influenced them and see them bring that to life. So and also I always wanted to be in a rock band so any any opportunity I have to try to like live out my rock star fantasies selfishly I'm gonna do that.
[16:39] William J Connolly: Are you the sort of person that likes to lean into their legacy in terms of the career and the roles that you've done or are you the sort of person that respects it and understands the audience that you get but actually you want to show more of you as an artist as sort of generally because some people they will only perform the hits they've done on stage and I completely get that and respect that. Some people are the complete opposite I guess how does it play out for you?
[17:01] Teal Wicks: I'm the I'm the the latter I'm the opposite I like because there's a lot of times certain songs and certain performances I feel like just don't work so well outside of the show and and also when I what I love so much about the shows I've done and and the beautiful what I love about my career is that I've played a lot of different characters and I love going full into into those characters, and along with that comes costume, wardrobe, context for you know where the songs come in the show. And it sometimes it's hard for me to remove to take those, take some of that content outside of the show and just put it on Teal. Like when you're coming to see a night of Teal Wicks, you're you're seeing Teal, like I'm not playing a character.
And so there's also some songs that I I love playing characters, and there's a very there's a very vulnerable being up on stage as yourself and presenting yourself and being like, This is me. This is me without costumes and paint and other actors and all of that. Um, and there's certain and sometimes playing a character is a very safe way to show other sides of you because you're like, you know, this is a character. That's that's not Teal's thoughts, that's um that's Cher's thoughts, you know. That's like what Cher is saying, not Teal. So then when so there's there's a little bit of a safety there. So there are some songs and some things that honestly I'm just even just scared to sing as just Teal Wicks alone, because I was like, I don't know, I don't know.
That's too that's too revealing, or or they'll be like, or it doesn't work, and they'll be like, what is she doing? That's weird. Also, like studio cast albums, specifically like YouTube. Yeah, I'm you know, I'm in favor of people putting favorite performances, they sing concerts or whatever. If you're allowed to, that's fine, but it's always the videos that make it to social media are of closing like performances, or like when someone's completely feeling themselves, and absolutely they should do what they can do within their means, but you know, to do that consistently eight times a week is just the most unrealistic thing ever. And it's like, of course, they're not gonna be able to do that.
And sometimes I feel like it might add a little bit of extra pressure when, like you say, it comes to you know, this is a concert all of me, and I've got to sing or continuously for like two hours. I'm not gonna be able to do that riff that you like, or I didn't an album on eight goes. And I can imagine as an artist, that that must be quite challenging.
[19:29] Teal Wicks: Yeah, it is. It really is. There's there's tons of expectation. And you know, fa if you're lucky enough to have a fan base, and and we're at this sort of place with with social media and with all of that, that that even people who have who have had just at the start of their careers or maybe have only done really small things, still, their content can get out there and they can get a fan base just from like you know, doing this doing a production of Carousel at at a regional theater. That it's amazing that there's that type of exposure for performers, but it's also really scary because it means that everything's out there, and that means that there are people that want specific things and love specific things, and you know, there are people that probably are like, I don't want to see Teal sing like a Patty Smith song.
Like, I don't care. I don't want her to sing that. I don't that doesn't interest me. Or like I don't want to watch Teal live out her dreams of playing Hedwig by singing like a Hedwig song. You know, they're like, mmm, but that's you know, that's why when it comes down to it, I'm like, I gotta stick to the things that I love and that move me and hope that people will somehow be drawn into it and enjoy it. I know you gotta, you know, it comes down to it, you gotta trust your own instincts and and just go with what you love and what moves you because if you do what you love and try to tell, you know, bring this apart and have open your heart up, then people will receive that, and hopefully, whether they like the song or not, or think you sound amazing or not, they'll still somehow be moved because you're so connected to the material. So that's kind of my goal.
[21:01] William J Connolly: Do you accept now that you have those people?
[21:03] Teal Wicks: Yeah, sure. Not everyone will love everything. That's fine. That's sort of the beauty of life, but you do have that core fan base that do really want to see more of you.
[21:12] Teal Wicks: I know it's amazing. There are times where I'm still like, I can't believe that whatever I do on stage that people like it enough that they'll keep going back to see me. That like, you know, that the fact that I was asked to do this concert, I I was like, that's amazing that that the theater and that they believe that there's enough people out there that would be interested in seeing just me without all of the other things that you know come when you see me at a show. Standing up there as myself performing is way more frightening and way more nerve-wracking than doing a Broadway show, like being the lead in a Broadway show, because you're being like, This is me, and you may not like all of this, and that but this is all I have to offer because I don't have sets and costumes and fancy lights and other things to hide behind. This is just me. And so it's very nice to know that so far it seems like some people are still interested.
[22:11] William J Connolly: So are there specific chapters in your career that if you engage with those fans that that love you and have followed you as a performer that that do get mentioned rather a lot? For example, the first thing I want to talk to you about is the Jekyll and Hyde recordings because I'm obsessed, but that's just me, and there are other people that well, I'm sure we'll talk about Wicked or Finding Neverland or whatever it might be. Are there are there specific things you notice a bit of a pattern about?
[22:32] Teal Wicks: Yeah, yeah. It's so funny. Jekyll and Hyde is definitely one of them with that that um our concept album. A lot of people have it did haven't seen the show, but yeah, with Jekyll and Hyde because we did a tour, but a very limited run on Broadway. So not a lot of people some people saw it and some people didn't. A lot of people did not. But we have the uh the concept album, which was very, very cool and was really fun to make, and I'm very proud of that. That was my first like real concept album stepping in and being in a studio and yeah, recording things that then became an album that people buy. So there's that Wicked is a big one.
[23:14] Teal Wicks: It is funny though, a lot of people know my version of Elphaba from whatever clips exist out there in the YouTube world and whatnot. And I'm always impressed when fans will be like, "You're so amazing, I love your Elphaba." I've never seen you in person perform, but I've watched all of your clips and all of that. But I get it though, because I mean, I'm a lot older than a lot of these people, but I still was young-ish when we had YouTube and had clips, and there were definitely videos of people and past Elphabas and whatnot. Before I was hired to actually do Wicked, I would watch these videos, and it's like one of my favorite Elphabas. I saw Wicked in person when I was younger, and I saw it with Idina.
It was Idina and Jennifer Laura Thompson, I think, were doing it when I saw it. It was a long time ago. I saw a lot of videos of Julia Murney playing Elphaba, and I watched a lot of other women who had been Elphaba at that point, their videos that were on YouTube and whatnot. But something about Julia just I loved; I just love her in general. I've been a big fan of hers even beforehand, but something about her interpretation of Elphaba just really resonated well with me, and so I was like, "She's my favorite Elphaba." I never saw her do it live, but just the videos alone. And it is kind of amazing how even just that content can really impact people. And so I find that interesting with fans, especially even with the Cher show.
For some people who never saw the Cher show but love it because they love the cast recording and have watched a few videos that have made it onto the internet. So that kind of always just surprises me. I'm like, "Wow, I guess we did really well. I guess that cast album's really great," because you don't even know what's going on in the show because you never saw it. But cool. You accept that you are also that to a lot of other people. If you take the Julia example, like a lot of people who I imagine who have played or are playing Elphaba or who are in potentially the UK touring, probably West End production of the Cher show about to happen, like you will be that sort of inspiration and that person they look up to. Do you think about that side of it?
[25:41] I do. And it's amazing. I never wanted to—I was talking about this with some actor friends the other night—and I was really, I never really wanted to be like famous. Not to say that I'm famous, but that was not why I pursued this career. I basically wanted to be fancy enough that people would hire me to do all the things that I wanted to do. I wanted people to be like, "Oh, we have to work with Teal because she's amazing," because I just wanted to do great roles and do great shows and all of that. Caroline Bowman, do you know Caroline Bowman?
[26:15] Yes.
[26:16] Teal Wicks: She's Elphaba; she's now Elsa in Frozen. She did a solo concert a while ago and asked me to come and sing, and on stage when we were doing this, she's like, "I have to tell you that you were my favorite Elphaba before she ever did it." And I was like, "Oh my god, that's amazing." But I still find it surprising that I am a person that people might look up to or might be inspired by and all of that, but it's also incredibly amazing because I know how powerful the performers that inspired me are, how meaningful they are to me, and how specific and how unique my connection to them is. So it's very rewarding thinking that what I'm doing on stage is sort of continuing in that line and then inspiring other people who then might be that caliber again, you know. It's just nice to be a part of that ongoing legacy of powerful performances and inspiring performances.
[27:11] William J Connolly: Well, you're laughing.
[27:12] Teal Wicks: I'm laughing because I feel like I'm going on really long tangents.
[27:15] William J Connolly: No, not at all. Honestly, I've interviewed people where they go, "Yes," and you're like, "Great, that's such a fantastic podcast on you so much." You're like, "Thank you." I'm like, "Yeah."
[27:29] Teal Wicks: One thing undeniable is your vocal talent, and you have this incredible tone of your voice that I think if you were to line up loads of belty singers and be like, "Sing the same thing," I think people would be able to pick up your voice straight away. It's so exquisite and so unique. And I wondered, but people that have unique voices, like I remember interviewing Julia Murney, and she was like, "It took me years to like my voice, like to realize that being different was a good thing." Did you have that? Because I feel like when you have a gift—and your voice is very much a gift—it's a journey that you have to go on with yourself before you can give it to other people.
[28:01] Teal Wicks: I like my voice. When I was younger and starting out, I definitely—I—this is not humble, but I was very fortunate to be able to sing almost anything I wanted to sing. I could sing soprano, and I could also belt like I wanted to be. I always joke that my musical inspiration for a long time was Julie Andrews and Janis Joplin. And so when I was younger, I would try to just sing all of that, and luckily I had vocal cords that were strong enough to sustain it for a little bit to do all those different things. So I was very proud that I could sing in all these different ways, and when I would try to sing different styles and in different ways, I was more or less successful, and people seemed to be impressed by it.
So I was kind of like, "Oh cool." But I don't think it was until maybe in the middle of my career when I started having to maybe listen to myself more, listen to recordings more, actually, and being aware of where I sort of fit in the grand scope of my peers as performers. That's when I think I started getting a bit critical and paid much more attention to how I sang and what I sang. No, you know what it was? Here's what it is. I had some vocal injuries when I was halfway through my three years of Wicked. I was singing Elphaba, and I didn't have as much discipline as I needed to coming out of that and trying to figure out how to continue my career and be a strong, safe singer but still be a powerful, impressive singer.
I definitely became far more critical, and I'm still at the point where I'm still working on that. I like my voice. I recognize that it's unique and it's cool, and I like what it can do. I like that I can sing a lot of the songs that I love and want to sing, but she's not perfect. But I don't think perfection is an actual thing that you can achieve. I still hear so many singers that I'm like, "Oh god, I just wish I could make those sounds. Those sounds are so perfect and amazing." And I do love unique voices. Like I'm on board. I don't need vocal perfection. I need honest emotional storytelling with hopefully some really cool, beautiful sounds in between.
[30:21] William J Connolly: Also, I feel like I need to apologize. I feel like I set up that question to sound like you sound like a gremlin when you sing. It was so you're so unique, and you were like, "No, I love that."
[30:30] Teal Wicks: I take that; that means a lot to me. Because I do know I have a unique voice. I don't really know how to describe it, but I've had enough people mention it, so I guess I have to believe it.
[30:44] William J Connolly: One person that definitely has the language to be able to support how much he loves your voice is your friend Seth Rudetsky, who I loved when you were doing that livestream of when you sort of did a little reunion of the Cher show with McKenna and Stephanie, when he pointed out your placement in "Wizard and I," which again, this is a really geeky specific moment, but he was just like, "Yeah, she doesn't really help herself in that she sort of elongates the E sound in her voice, but yeah, it's absolutely beautiful what you do." I mean, you do sort of set yourself up for a little bit of a hard time sometimes.
[31:13] Teal Wicks: Yeah, it's true. And the problem is I don't necessarily know exactly what I'm doing and how I'm doing that, which is gonna now make me sound like I don't know what I'm doing and why am I professional and like take her equity card away. But things that lock in, which I'm very lucky that when they lock in, they lock in in a great way. And sometimes they don't lock in, and that's when I'm like, "Okay, we're gonna have to figure that out." But there are certain times where I don't really know how or why; it just worked out very well.
[31:45] William J Connolly: Yeah, especially on the E.
[31:46] Teal Wicks: I don't know how. I hate long-held E's, and I don't—I forget what note that is, but it's probably like a B flat or something like that, which is usually my Achilles heel note. I'm always like, "Ugh, don't make me."
[32:01] William J Connolly: It's also where your voice sounds so gorgeous. Like it's weird because you hate it, but yet we love it.
[32:06] Teal Wicks: So it's like, "No, no, no, do that thing that you actually hate doing more and more and more, please."
[32:09] William J Connolly: You're like, "Fuck off, leave me alone."
[32:11] Teal Wicks: It's funny, like also doing Cher because there were three of us. Well, the keys were kind of all over the place. Some things were in Cher's normal key, but some things weren't, and then because there were three of us, we had a lot of harmonies. But I would often be like, "Can I have the higher harmony?" And I would realize I have a lot of depth; I have a lot of low notes in my voice, which is I think why I was able to get Cher, because I was like, "Oh, I can power out those chunky, big, you know, full-throated back vocals." But I also needed breaks because the other part of my voice was like, "Girl, we need to come visit up here a little bit because she's getting tired down here. We need to like get out there."
But doing that show, I just kind of got a lot of insight into my voice that I maybe didn't—I guess I knew, but I didn't pay as much attention to because I was like, "Oh wow, there's a lot of range, and we gotta kind of keep some of the higher notes going because otherwise we're gonna burn out and not be able to sing anything."
[33:15] William J Connolly: Also, you were sort of starring alongside one of the greatest vocalists of our generation in Miss Stephanie J. Block, which you're sort of like, "Excuse me. Do you want to just give us some of the other ones of us a chance now? Thank you." Like the placement, the way she presents, it's ridiculous, right?
[33:31] Teal Wicks: Even as a colleague, you might be like, "We just pack it in."
[33:34] William J Connolly: No, I know.
[33:36] Teal Wicks: Yeah. There are times we would just be like, "Ooh," and Michaela and I, you know, we'd be like off stage with certain songs, and we're like, "Mmm, mm-mm." And there are times it'd be like, and we're all singing a lot of the same stuff, and I'd still be like, "How does she make that happen?" And then there's Michaela, who's gonna be—she already has definitely made a name for herself, but I mean, she's incredible. Talk about like you have Steph, who is established, established. Me in the middle, whatever. I don't know what I am saying. I don't know, but not Steph. And then you have Michaela, who is on the trajectory to be like epic, epic, huge, just huge, huge, huge Broadway star, bigger than me, comparable to Steph, maybe, but I mean, who even knows? But there are times I'd listen to that girl sing, and I was like, "Oh, how? How?" It's so fun. That show was so fun to listen to everybody sing. The cast album is so good as well.
[34:39] William J Connolly: It's so freaking good. You're just like, "Yes." Because I'll be honest, I was a bit like, "The Cher show, okay."
[34:46] Teal Wicks: But I think that's the right reaction.
[34:47] William J Connolly: Well, I remember you and I had this discussion about like actually people having an opinion on it before they come is actually a good thing because we can prove them wrong, and you definitely did that.
[34:55] Teal Wicks: Exactly. And yeah, they come in and the best thing for us is people leaving basically having their mind changed, or being like, I did not expect that. I did not think that was gonna happen. I mean, I can't speak for all three of us, but we talked about it a lot, so I feel like generally we had the idea that like what was the most powerful, meaningful thing to us was the sort of empowered, you know, pick yourself up, like you get knocked down, but you get back up, you brush yourself off and keep going, and that sort of being able to be strong and to figure out how to really own yourself and own your courage and stand in your mistakes and move forward and finding empowerment out of that. Like that was very, very meaningful to us, and there are a lot of, I mean, yes, because of Cher, a lot of women, you know, obviously relate to that and found that very, very moving.
And that was one of the best things talking to people at the stage door was just how inspired and how empowered a lot of these people felt. And we were like, yes, that is what we are trying to do with this show. Yes, we're trying to give you, you know, fun Cher and like gorgeous Mackey and all of that, but like the reason why Cher is who she is is because she is a badass and she feels like a goddess warrior, even though she's made so many mistakes and has not had an easy life, but like she still continues to thrive somehow because she just keeps moving forward.
[36:28] Teal Wicks: I would love to talk to you about Finding Neverland because it's obviously where we had that photograph taken. I saw the show and I loved it. But you got to work with one of the UK's greatest exports, and that's Mr. Gary Barlow, who is like, I don't know how big Take That is in the United States. Music is very different, but he's like God tier in terms of music here. Like he's like an actual superstar. And you know, I remember going to the launch in the UK, and it was like, you know, like Obama had just arrived. There was like security, like you have to stand back, and I was like, I've been invited to this. Like they asked me to come, but it was like superstar. And then obviously he talks about the songs, and he's just an absolute genius. What was it like getting that front row seat? Getting to not just work on something with him, but also get to originate something with someone like him?
[37:14] Teal Wicks: Oh gosh, he was so sweet. And yes, so I honestly didn't realize like Take That. I knew that they existed. I had heard of them. So I knew that he was a big deal. And it was funny. I remember not during rehearsals, but like during previews, so when all of the creatives are around still, there were people who came to the show and were at the stage door for him specifically, which I was like, oh, this is the big big deal. But God, he was so sweet. And him and Elliot, because they wrote together, like they were just so sweet, they were so fun and just very, very approachable. Like Gary was very, very approachable. Very, I it was just interesting because knowing how big a star he is, I did not get that in the room from him.
He just seemed like somebody who knew what he was doing and was confident in what he was doing and what the music that they were writing, and they were always just so approachable and so kind and fun, like easy to just joke around with if the opportunity if we ever had, you know, we're just like sitting around trying to figure out music. And I remember during previews, the opening number, like near the end of rehearsals and tech and into previews, the opening number, everybody was trying to figure out what it was, and it kept evolving. It kept like shifting and evolving and shifting and evolving, and they completely rewrote, they like cut the opening number out completely at one point, then made a new one, and we rehearsed it in a day basically and put it in that night.
And I remember Gary and Elliot were both like, they were like, Don't worry, Teal, because Mary Berry didn't have a lot to do. And sort of the opening number she sort of introduces she's a part of it and introducing sort of like Barry to the all the people at the party and all this, whatever. So there was like a little moment, and they're like, Teal, we don't want to take away this moment because it is important to establish who she is and why we have her in the rest of the show. And so we gotta figure out well what to do. And there were some like there were some solo bits in the original thing that I did in the original number, and then that was cut, and they're like, We're trying to figure it out.
And they wrote in that like let's drink champagne line that I sing that's like the big thing, and they're like, We're giving you at least one moment where you can just like do what you do best and just like belt it out and just da-da-da. And it's just very, very sweet, and I always remember that that like they specifically thought about me, and even though Mary Berry is, you know, whatever, like fifth in the like line and like the leads, you know, like number five in the principal lead roles of the show, that it was important to them to keep to give me something that still felt showy and still felt special, and they wanted to make sure that I didn't lose a featured moment, and that's very, very kind of them to do that, and makes you as an artist feel very, very supported and feel like that they were like, Yes, and this is important, this is important for our show because we trust you and we love what you do, and we want to make sure that you get to be highlighted as much as possible.
[40:33] Teal Wicks: It's such a special show. I know that there's this continuing talk about London. I know that they keep saying it's gonna happen, it lives on. It's definitely not the end. I know that I've read lots of interviews with Gary and the team that there's gonna be an opportunity for more or more people based on the fact that it was such a success on the national tour. I know Broadway's a really tricky beast. I know that it's difficult, but even the most established show is never mind something that's brand new. So I'm keeping everything crossed. And to be honest, like the West End would really love it. Like Gary is such a superstar, and I think the story itself, and I I know, I don't know. Maybe this could be my opportunity to convince you to come to London. Maybe we could finally get you for ourselves. I feel like I feel like you might say yes to this.
[41:11] William J Connolly: I am so ready. I am so ready to be.
[41:16] Teal Wicks: It's like it's on my bucket list. That's why for a minute with like Cher shows, like if Cher shows go to the West End, I could do that. Everything has evolved and changed within the last like two years, but I would love to go to the West End. I've only been to London a few times, and I'm dying to be there for a steady amount of time so I can really embrace it and really enjoy it. But yeah, but Finding Neverland, it really is such a special show. I every single night for the full run of that show, maybe you know, minus like a couple, a couple of performances, I would stand in the wings watching that final nursery scene where they do the play in the nursery. That's like 10 minutes, I think, maybe of the show.
And I think it's some of the most beautiful theatrical staging and musical moments that I've ever seen in a show, and I would just stand off stage and just watch it because it moved me so much. And that company, that company and that cast was such an incredible group of people, and we really bonded right off the top. Like it and it was the perfect perfect example of like the trickle-down effect. Like we with Matthew Morrison as our lead, he's such a gracious, fun, fun, dedicated performer. But he very it's as important to him to make sure that like the company as a whole feels like a family as it is for you know him doing really well in his role. He understands how important it is for the company as a whole to feel like a family.
And then you have Kelsey Grammar, who just is hilarious and wild and so fun and so much more like I don't he it was just amazing hanging out with Kelsey and how open he would just be like, Oh yeah, oh I'll joke around and what I and then Laura Michelle Kelly, who's just like an angel, who's just like a wonderful, beautiful little fairy. It was this beautiful, just like group, and it was a trickle-down effect, and we had so we had just such a wonderful time as a company, and everybody, everybody in the company was very open to everyone, like it just very embracing and family, and so it was really special, and I feel like it really comes to life in the show. I hope that it has continues a life somewhere.
There's been so much talk, and I know the pandemic obviously put a stop to that, but I think fingers crossed, good things come to those that wait, and I feel like it's gonna especially because you know like how Bonnie and Clyde had the brief run on Broadway, but then the cast albums made it soar. The same thing definitely happened with Finding Neverland. It's the cast album all the way. I mean, all that matters is like that song that gets churned out all the time, good and bad, but like it's like the songs have become so good. And it's one of those albums where I call it like a no skip where it doesn't matter what song comes on. I'm like, I like this song, I know this song. There's only one song I can't listen to, and that's the finale, because I think Caroline's version of it is just when she sings about she left the stars up in the sky, and it's like it's too emotional. I can't, it's so beautiful.
[44:20] Teal Wicks: Oh god, I know. And Caroline, just her. Ugh, yeah. Do you are you a fan of the album that has all of the like pop stars on it?
[44:30] William J Connolly: Yes.
[44:31] Teal Wicks: Yeah, well, that was like one of the first times I think pre-Greatest Showman where like obviously I know Hamilton did it, and I know it has been done before, but like it got the music world singing Broadway, which I feel like really helps. So we should do this more often.
[44:42] William J Connolly: Yes, and it's and those songs, especially with Finding Neverland and with Gary and Elliot with their musical right their skills as writers, like the fact that these songs still work in a musical as storytelling, you know, plot forwarding songs, but also can still be super entertaining as standalone songs, almost all of them. You know, there might be a few that you know are kind of just store work best in the musical, but there are so many from it that work as standalone, but like believe, which feels feels like a quirky, like little Beatles kind of like the yellow submarine throwback kind of vibe. It's really cool.
[45:22] Teal Wicks: Thank you so much for going through so much of your career. I know that we talked about the beginning about the fact that you like talking about certain things and not others. So thank you so much for deep diving with some of these very niche and specific things. And I make no apologies about the fact that I am obsessed with you, and I don't say it to that many people, but I'm gonna continue to say it. And I look forward to the fact that we can have hopefully maybe a conversation in person where you're not like, Yes, we'll take a picture, I'm at stage door. We can actually have a proper conversation, but just thank you so much.
[45:47] Teal Wicks: Yes, we absolutely should. That'd be so wonderful. That's so much fun. I love it. I love the great questions, good insight. It was fun. And I don't even know how long it's been going on because obviously it's been a really good time, and I go off on tangents, so thank you.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
