DON'T CALL ME CUPID: Katie is completely smitten with a new man in her life and is eager to show him off to her roommate. Love takes a tragic backseat, however, when the god of love, Eros (aka Cupid), appears and accidentally shoots her new boyfriend with the wrong arrow... Read More
From the show: Gather by the Ghost Light
Guests
About
DON'T CALL ME CUPID: Katie is completely smitten with a new man in her life and is eager to show him off to her roommate. Love takes a tragic backseat, however, when the god of love, Eros (aka Cupid), appears and accidentally shoots her new boyfriend with the wrong arrow. Dark Comedy.
Written and directed by Jonathan Cook
Performed by Paige Blackcloud, Kate Dailey, and Jonathan Cook
If you are associated with a theatre and would like to perform the stage version of this play, please contact gatherbytheghostlight@gmail.com and we'll put you in touch with the playwright.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:17] Jonathan Cook: Hey there, welcome back to Gather by the Ghost Light, original stories for Radio Theater.
[0:22] Jonathan Cook: I'm Jonathan Cook, and today is Valentine's Day, a day of love, a day to spin with that special someone in your life.
[0:30] Jonathan Cook: And what better way to celebrate on this podcast than with a dark comedic story about love featuring the god of love himself, Eros.
[0:39] Jonathan Cook: Also known as CUPID.
[0:41] Jonathan Cook: Now, I bet you've always wondered what would happen if CUPID made a mistake.
[0:46] Jonathan Cook: Uh, not a mistake in the sense that he matches up a couple who are just never able to get along, but a mistake is in he accidentally uses the wrong arrow and accidentally kills someone.
[0:59] Jonathan Cook: Well, today's story, we're gonna witness just that.
[1:03] Jonathan Cook: Now, gather around the ghost light, sit back and enjoy.
[1:06] Jonathan Cook: This is Don't Call Me CUPID, performed by Paige Blackcloud, Kate Dailey, and Jonathan Cook.
[1:16] Kate Dailey: Travis is such a perfect gentleman. I mean, there's absolutely no one else in the world like him.
[1:22] Paige Blackcloud: Here's your coffee. Careful, it's steaming hot.
[1:25] Kate Dailey: Just like Travis.
[1:27] Paige Blackcloud: He sounds delightful.
[1:28] Kate Dailey: You'll see what I'm talking about when you meet him.
[1:30] Kate Dailey: Paige, I'm so in love.
[1:34] Paige Blackcloud: Don't fall too fast.
[1:35] Kate Dailey: I can't help myself. I mean, my dreams have come to life. Walking and talking and saying the sweetest things to me at just the right moment.
[1:44] Paige Blackcloud: Please tell me he has a twin brother.
[1:46] Kate Dailey: Preferably single.
[1:47] Paige Blackcloud: Sorry, he's an only child.
[1:49] Kate Dailey: Well, how about a cute best friend then? Come on. Have you met any of his friends yet?
[1:53] Paige Blackcloud: Not yet, but everything's been moving scary fast.
[1:56] Kate Dailey: Like good scary. I wouldn't be surprised if he introduced me to his parents within like the next week.
[2:02] Paige Blackcloud: Well, I for one am excited for you. You deserve it.
[2:05] Kate Dailey: I do, don't I? I mean, this past year's been tough. And Travis is such an excellent fit for my life right now.
[2:13] Paige Blackcloud: Karma is on your side.
[2:14] Kate Dailey: I know, right? This coffee's hot, but it's terrific.
[2:19] Kate Dailey: I love this flavor. What is it?
[2:20] Paige Blackcloud: Oh, it's from Mocha Joe's, one of their new gourmet blends.
[2:25] Kate Dailey: Oh shit, he's here. Uh uh do I look okay?
[2:28] Paige Blackcloud: Gorgeous.
[2:29] Kate Dailey: Do I have I don't know coffee breath?
[2:32] Paige Blackcloud: Katie, get out of my face. You're gonna make me spill this all over me.
[2:35] Kate Dailey: Oh, come on, help me out. Do I need a mint or anything?
[2:39] Paige Blackcloud: Just go answer the door, you weirdo. Your knight is waiting to take you off into the sunset.
[2:45] Kate Dailey: And this fair damsel's in need of a rescue from her wicked step roommate.
[2:52] Paige Blackcloud: Oh it's coming.
[2:56] Kate Dailey: What the hell is that?
[3:00] Kate Dailey: Oh my god! Oh my god! Someone shot him with an arrow!
[3:13] Kate Dailey: Travis? Is he dead?
[3:17] Paige Blackcloud: I don't know.
[3:18] Kate Dailey: Oh my god! Oh my god! Somebody help!
[3:23] Kate Dailey: Oh no, no, no, no, no. Good heavens!
[3:27] Eros: Who are you?
[3:28] Eros: I know what you're thinking, but let me explain.
[3:31] Kate Dailey: You killed him!
[3:32] Eros: Well, um, yes, uh, I suppose I did. But it was an accident, I swear.
[3:39] Kate Dailey: You you're your murderer!
[3:41] Paige Blackcloud: Somebody help us!
[3:43] Eros: Oh, just wait a second, will you? Oh, please, please don't hurt us.
[3:46] Eros: I'm not going to hurt you. Listen, you know me. Well, I hope you've heard of me.
[3:54] Eros: Who who are you?
[3:56] Eros: My name is Eros.
[3:59] Kate Dailey: Huh?
[4:00] Eros: Who?
[4:01] Eros: Oh, come on. Really? Or you might know me better from my other name?
[4:10] Eros: Cupid.
[4:11] Kate Dailey: Do you think we're stupid?
[4:13] Eros: Cupid?
[4:13] Eros: Right. Let me guess. You're expecting a chubby little baby with wings.
[4:19] Eros: I swear. I take the form of a stupid little baby one time, once, and it's the only incarnation you people have been drawing me as for ages.
[4:30] Eros: I'm a god. I take whatever form I want.
[4:34] Paige Blackcloud: Stay where you are.
[4:35] Paige Blackcloud: Jonathan, call the police.
[4:37] Eros: What is that?
[4:38] Paige Blackcloud: Pepper spray. And it'll make your eyes burn so bad you'll want to rip them out and piss on him just to cool down the heat.
[4:45] Eros: Piss on my eyes. Look. I truly admire your bravery here, but you can't hurt me.
[4:52] Eros: I don't feel pain. I'm immortal.
[4:55] Paige Blackcloud: Oh, yeah?
[4:55] Eros: Yeah, how about a face full of hot coffee?
[4:58] Eros: Now, was that really necessary?
[5:03] Eros: Ooh, is that Mocha Joe's new gourmet blend?
[5:06] Paige Blackcloud: What do you want from us?
[5:07] Eros: You killed the love of my life.
[5:11] Eros: Tress.
[5:12] Eros: Bless your sweet soul. Yes, I admit. I did kill him, but that was not my intent, I promise.
[5:19] Eros: I don't know how, but I will repay you in some way. You have my word.
[5:24] Kate Dailey: Why did you shoot him?
[5:26] Eros: Catherine, my dear, I am the god of desire and love. I only wanted to fill his heart with overwhelming love for you.
[5:35] Kate Dailey: That's not love. That's a freaking arrow! An arrow sticking out of my poor Travis's heart.
[5:43] Eros: I don't know where you come from, but in my house, love doesn't come in the form of pointy foot-long sticks.
[5:52] Eros: Right. There was a mistake, and I'll explain. You see, I was out hunting with a friend yesterday, Orion. Maybe you've heard of him?
[6:01] Kate Dailey: Yes?
[6:03] Eros: No? It doesn't matter. Anyway, when I returned, I forgot to replace the hunting arrows with my arrows of love.
[6:13] Eros: So when I traveled here from my domain, I accidentally shot your boyfriend with the wrong arrow.
[6:24] Eros: Oopsie.
[6:25] Kate Dailey: You're supposed to help people, aren't you? Can't you fix this? Reverse it in some way?
[6:31] Eros: Reverse? No, he's dead. There's no coming back to life.
[6:35] Kate Dailey: Well, we want to talk to your superiors. You hear me?
[6:39] Eros: Is that like uh Zeus or something?
[6:42] Eros: Technically, yes, but he's been retired for some time now.
[6:47] Kate Dailey: Wait a second. This doesn't make any sense. You say you're CUPID.
[6:52] Eros: I said it, yes, but I'd prefer the name Eros, please.
[6:57] Kate Dailey: So you shoot people with these love arrows, and it makes them fall in love, right?
[7:04] Eros: Well, it's a bit more technical than that. I have proof that this was no accident then.
[7:11] Kate Dailey: I knew you killed him on purpose. You see, Travis was my boyfriend.
[7:17] Kate Dailey: He loved me dearly. We shared many intimate moments together. Our devotion was incomparable to anything else in the world.
[7:27] Kate Dailey: Our souls were meant for each other. You understand? He didn't need any of your silly arrows.
[7:36] Eros: Well, that's the other unfortunate part of all this.
[7:42] Kate Dailey: What?
[7:42] Eros: Are you really going to make me say it?
[7:46] Kate Dailey: No, no, no, you're wrong. He didn't love you. He was actually planning to break it all off tonight.
[7:52] Kate Dailey: Shut up, CUPID! Can't you see how emotional she is right now?
[7:56] Eros: I was only trying to help. I wanted to make him renew his love in you.
[8:01] Eros: My arrow of love would have sparked that interest again and made his mind dwell on all those tender, intimate moments you spoke of.
[8:10] Eros: I wanted him to think of you and only you as his number one desire. I wanted him to crave you so much that he would completely forget about his other girlfriend because you are absolutely right.
[8:24] Eros: You were made for each other.
[8:27] Kate Dailey: Wait, wait, what did you say?
[8:30] Eros: You were made for each other.
[8:33] Kate Dailey: No. What did you say before that?
[8:37] Eros: I wanted him to crave you, question mark.
[8:42] Kate Dailey: He had another girlfriend?
[8:44] Eros: Oh shit, did I say that?
[8:46] Eros: Yes, yes, I I I I did say that. I'm sorry. I should not have told you that.
[8:51] Kate Dailey: This dickhead was cheating on me.
[8:54] Eros: Oh, hey now, a little respect for the dead, please. You can't just go around kicking corpses.
[9:01] Kate Dailey: How dare you, you son of a bitch!
[9:04] Eros: Okay, just take it easy. Yes, he was having a bit of an indiscretion. I hope this makes sense now when you realize that I was trying to do something good here.
[9:16] Kate Dailey: Well, there's no saving the relationship now.
[9:19] Eros: Saving? Saving? I don't want that little two-timing piece of shit now.
[9:27] Kate Dailey: Even if you'd used the right arrow and made him love me again, he would have never told me about this affair.
[9:33] Kate Dailey: And you definitely wouldn't want to be with a guy that has secrets like that.
[9:38] Kate Dailey: But at least I would have been happy.
[9:43] Eros: Well then, lady, I must bid you good day now and be on my way. Again, I'm terribly sorry for this inconvenience. Farewell to you both.
[9:54] Kate Dailey: Hey! No, wait a minute. You can't leave yet. You said you'd repay me.
[10:00] Eros: Oh, right. That. Well, let's see. Um oh, I do have a small collection of treasures. I could part with some gold or silver if that's something you fancy. Or my wife has this lovely collection of jewels, and actually, let me have a word with her before I commit to offering any of her things. She can be a little feisty.
[10:26] Kate Dailey: What's wrong with you? I didn't lose money or jewels. You killed my lover. The man of my dreams. I was planning to spend the rest of my life with.
[10:36] Paige Blackcloud: I think what she's trying to say is that you owe her another man.
[10:40] Eros: What? Uh uh, listen. Come on, CUPID. I mean Eros. That's only fair, right? You took away my lovers, so you must repay me with another.
[10:52] Eros: You did give her your word.
[10:54] Eros: It's not right for humans to make such a demand. That kind of decision is left to the gods.
[11:00] Kate Dailey: You owe me. And that is what I want. Make it happen.
[11:07] Eros: Fine. Now I will choose another suitor for you as soon as possible.
[11:12] Kate Dailey: No, no way. My choice.
[11:14] Eros: What? No, no, no, no, no, no. Sorry. I cannot allow that.
[11:19] Kate Dailey: You will.
[11:20] Eros: This is unheard of. You're a human. You have no idea what you want.
[11:26] Paige Blackcloud: Oh, she knows what she wants. Believe me. That's the deal. I choose, and you make the love happen.
[11:33] Eros: And then I make the love happen. You know what I mean. Besides, how can you say no? You did just murder her boyfriend.
[11:45] Eros: Fine. Carry on. Okay, here's what I want. Uh, he needs to be taller than me for starters. I'm five-six, so you do the math. Um, a nice fit body. Not a complete meathead, though you know what I mean. That sort of lean muscle tone. Oh, and uh, definitely a nice set of hair in his head. Ooh, blondish? No, I want to go darker this time. Oh, he's gotta be smart, too. Uh, sense of humor is a plus. I want him to be witty, but not wittier than me. My jokes should always be funny.
[12:15] Eros: Stop right there. Please know that I don't have the power to construct this person you're describing out of thin air.
[12:23] Kate Dailey: But that's what I want.
[12:25] Eros: There are rules to follow. You must choose a real person. I can't create them for you.
[12:32] Kate Dailey: Aren't you a god?
[12:34] Eros: One of many. Be realistic with your choices, or this deal is off. It must be someone alive today, not a mere description of your ideal.
[12:44] Eros: See, this is why humans shouldn't make these decisions.
[12:48] Kate Dailey: Okay, okay. Um, oh, I got it. I want David Beckham.
[12:55] Eros: Good choice. Again. Stop.
[12:57] Eros: First off, it must be a person you could possibly make some form of social contact with. You don't want to choose someone that you'll likely never meet in your lifetime. I can't make the meetings happen. You must make the connection on your own, and then I can take over from there. That's the best I can offer you. Second, I cannot force someone to fall in love with you if they're already in love with someone else. It is against my nature.
[13:26] Kate Dailey: Yeah, well, David Beckham is already married. You don't want to be a homewrecker.
[13:31] Eros: Damn all these rules. Fine. I can play this game. All right. Oh, yeah, I got I've got a reasonable choice. Uh there's a bartender at the Rebel Yell Tavern. His name is Matt. He's local, he's met me before. And he's single. He's so hot, too. Who he fits into all of your rules.
[13:54] Eros: Very well. Matt. Bartender at the Rebel Yell Tavern. I can work with that. You'll notice a slight change in his behavior the next time you see him. His interest in you will get a little spark.
[14:09] Kate Dailey: A spark? I want you to ignite that puppy.
[14:12] Eros: In due time. Consider yourself repaid. Now, ladies, I must be going.
[14:19] Kate Dailey: Hold up. Oh, what is it now?
[14:23] Paige Blackcloud: Well. This event. I mean, it has all been very traumatizing. I mean, I actually witnessed someone getting killed today by a freaking arrow. And it appeared to be a very painful way to die, and I just well, I don't know if I'll ever be able to get over this.
[14:44] Eros: Yeah, uh, Paige. Oh my goodness. I've been so selfish. You must be devastated by all of this.
[14:54] Paige Blackcloud: I am. It has all been so tragic, Katie. I mean, you spoke so many kind words about Travis. I mean, how nice he was and how handsome and how loving he was. And this is the first time I was supposed to meet him, and wham! Just did on my living room floor.
[15:18] Eros: Oh god of love. There must be something you can do.
[15:22] Paige Blackcloud: Are you serious? Are you trying to scam me now?
[15:27] Kate Dailey: Eros! Why? Help her, please!
[15:31] Eros: What do you want me to do?
[15:33] Kate Dailey: My roommate witnessed all this madness. You owe her just as much as you owe me.
[15:39] Eros: Are you telling me that I have to secure a lover for her as well?
[15:43] Paige Blackcloud: That would be honorable of you. Oh, wise God arrows. If that's what you suggest, then yes, she'll take it.
[15:50] Eros: Now, hold on. I didn't say—
[15:53] Paige Blackcloud: Yes. That seems like a generous and sensible offer. I accept.
[15:56] Eros: Just wait a minute.
[15:57] Paige Blackcloud: It's fine, it'll be quick. I already have my choice in mind. Following all of your rules.
[16:04] Eros: Fucking 80s.
[16:06] Eros: Fine. Who is it?
[16:08] Paige Blackcloud: Gustav Murdoch.
[16:11] Eros: Gustav? Is he that boring guy we met at the book club?
[16:15] Paige Blackcloud: Yes. I've had the most seductive dreams about that man. He gives me butterflies.
[16:21] Eros: Accent.
[16:22] Paige Blackcloud: I could listen to him for hours.
[16:23] Kate Dailey: You wanna switch with me?
[16:25] Paige Blackcloud: What?
[16:25] Kate Dailey: I want Gustave. You take Matt.
[16:26] Paige Blackcloud: I don't want Matt. I want Gustav.
[16:28] Kate Dailey: You said you think Matt is hot. I mean, come on, switch with me.
[16:30] Paige Blackcloud: No, that's not fair. Don't take mine just because you're not happy with your choice anymore.
[16:34] Eros: Ladies, please. Eros, I've changed my mind.
[16:38] Paige Blackcloud: Don't you do it.
[16:41] Kate Dailey: I choose Gustav.
[16:43] Paige Blackcloud: Oh, that is low. My future fiance died today, okay?
[16:47] Kate Dailey: Bullshit! You only met him two weeks ago, and he was gonna break up with you anyway.
[16:50] Paige Blackcloud: It doesn't matter. I get first dips.
[16:52] Eros: Fine. Take Gustav then. Eros, I've got a new choice as well. I'll take Brent McMurphy instead.
[17:00] Paige Blackcloud: No, she won't.
[17:02] Eros: Let's turn down the hostility, ladies. She's only choosing him out of spite.
[17:05] Paige Blackcloud: Brent is one of my ex-boyfriends, and you are not allowed to date or love any of my exes. You get me?
[17:13] Kate Dailey: Well, you're only changing your decision because you're angry that you didn't think of Gustav first.
[17:17] Paige Blackcloud: You should have reminded me of Gustav.
[17:18] Kate Dailey: Well, how am I supposed to know that you had a thing for Gustav?
[17:22] Eros: Uh, humans. This deal is about to be over if you ladies can't compromise. I really don't have the time for this.
[17:31] Kate Dailey: Okay. Okay. Fine. You know what? I've thought it over, and I'm okay with Matt. He really is a charming guy.
[17:43] Paige Blackcloud: Yes. He is. Gustavo is more my type anyway.
[17:47] Eros: It's settled then. You're both happy with your choices.
[17:52] Kate Dailey: Yes, I am.
[17:53] Paige Blackcloud: I'm sorry, I just got caught up in the moment. I want my sexy bartender to serve me all night long.
[18:01] Eros: Right. Alright, that's it. Everything is final. You do your part, and I'll do mine. Thank you. I have to go now. Uh, for real this time. Farewell to you both.
[18:19] Kate Dailey: How awesome is that? It feels like we're in a fairy tale. Like we just made a wish upon a falling star.
[18:27] Paige Blackcloud: Are you okay?
[18:28] Kate Dailey: Yeah, what the heck did I just trip on?
[18:30] Paige Blackcloud: Oh no. Katie.
[18:34] Paige Blackcloud: We have a problem.
[18:36] Kate Dailey: What do we do about this dead guy?
[18:38] Paige Blackcloud: Oh shit.
[18:44] Jonathan Cook: That was Don't Call Me CUPID, an original production written and produced by Jonathan Cook. It was performed by Paige Blackcloud, Kate Dailey, and Jonathan Cook. Intro music is provided by artist JK47. I want to give you all many thanks for listening today. And hey, if you like what you've heard today, please subscribe and find us on social media to stay up to date on when we'll be dropping our next episode. As always, stay safe, and I'll see you next time we gather by the ghost light.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
