Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#15 - Alysha Umphress: The Art of Not Giving a Shit

My new BFF Alysha Umphress is a distant, long forgotten broadway star, but boy is she pretty! She can give ya a high belt whilst changing make-up faster than a MAC cosmetics clown, and that buttery tone melts even my crusty heart... Read More

From the show: Gettin Peggy Wit It

44 mins
9/3/20

Guests

Featured Shows

About

My new BFF Alysha Umphress is a distant, long forgotten broadway star, but boy is she pretty! She can give ya a high belt whilst changing make-up faster than a MAC cosmetics clown, and that buttery tone melts even my crusty heart. Let’s see what she was up to before the world started to go to hell!

Follow me on IG: @greetingsitspeggy & @morganajames

Produced & edited by Ellyn Marie Marsh & Alan Seales

Part of the Broadway Podcast Network.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:03] Peggy: Oh, oh my Peggy?

[0:06] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Thank you so much. You introduced I think that's the first time you've introduced me properly and kindly.

[0:12] Peggy: People are gonna be so confused.

[0:14] Ellyn Marie Marsh: They're gonna turn it off immediately.

[0:16] Peggy: They're like, I didn't sign up for greetings.

[0:18] Ellyn Marie Marsh: It's Peggy getting Peggy with it, starring Peggy with Ellyn Marie Marsh.

[0:22] Peggy: Okay. But if it's what you want, then I want to make you happy.

[0:25] Ellyn Marie Marsh: You know what I mean?

[0:27] Peggy: Uh you want to make me happy or you want to make the listeners happy?

[0:31] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Mm-hmm.

[0:32] Peggy: Okay. Yeah. Um, great. You know, I okay. That was my fault. I really fell into that trap, didn't I? Um, who are we talking to today, Peggy?

[0:41] Peggy: Oh, we're talking to somebody so beautiful, so glamorous, so laissez-faire. She just she just goes about her life like on a cloud.

[0:50] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Okay. Can you guess?

[0:52] Peggy: I mean, I know who it is. Maybe the audience can guess. Can you give like another clue?

[0:56] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Like maybe a show she was in, or yes, okay. She's got a wonderful belt.

[1:00] Peggy: Okay. She is, she's got a really handsome husband. She's very buxom. And she um she loves to post on her story up close is up close pictures of lips.

[1:14] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Okay. And she loves LaCroix.

[1:16] Peggy: She does love LaCroix. She honestly should be a sponsor of LaCroix. And she says things like Hunty and Cunty, and um she she has lots of glamorous gaze in her inner stable.

[1:28] Ellyn Marie Marsh: She really does. Guess who it is?

[1:29] Peggy: I mean, it's like it back at home. It's Alysha Umphress.

[1:33] Ellyn Marie Marsh: But that's probably the most loving introduction you've ever given someone.

[1:37] Peggy: I think quarantine is having an effect on you, Peggy, because you've really you're really like being very generous.

[1:44] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Well, the world's ending, so I I want somebody to come to my funeral.

[1:47] Peggy: Oh, nobody can, because it's all be on Zoom.

[1:50] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Okay, that yeah. Are you are you okay? Are you healthy? Are you planning on making a funeral?

[1:55] Peggy: No, I'm fine, but who knows how long this will will last. You know what I mean? That's dark. Anyway, back to Alysha.

[2:00] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Um, Alysha is so wonderful. I've never seen her in anything I didn't like her in.

[2:04] Peggy: Wow. And okay. What what was the last all right? I mean, she doesn't give a shit. Do you ever notice that?

[2:10] Ellyn Marie Marsh: She doesn't give a shit.

[2:12] Peggy: She's very unbothered.

[2:13] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yes, she is unbothered. That's true. We should probably I don't think she's worked in a long time, but I I can't remember what we talked about, but I know that I was like, oh, you're so pretty. And she's like, okay. And then and then we were basically decided we were gonna be good friends.

[2:26] Peggy: So you're friends.

[2:28] Ellyn Marie Marsh: We're going to be, yeah.

[2:29] Peggy: After quarantine. You she told you that?

[2:32] Ellyn Marie Marsh: It was it was implied.

[2:34] Peggy: Do you ever think that people are just nice to you so that you're not mean to them?

[2:38] Ellyn Marie Marsh: No, because I will be mean regardless.

[2:41] Peggy: Okay. So that's what be yourself. That's a good rule of thumb in life. You might as well be yourself because people are gonna be assholes regardless.

[2:48] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Right. You know what I mean? And that's what really that's what how I became me is because I didn't care what other people thought. And then when I saw Alysha and she just doesn't give a shit, I love that.

[2:58] Peggy: So you guys are like sympatico. You guys are like two you're you're two pieces. Just like Brandon Uranowitz, who's also Alysha's friend.

[3:06] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Brandon Uranowitz and I, we're just like two peas in a pod. We're like besties.

[3:10] Peggy: No, I'm gonna have to disagree with you. I don't think Brandon had a very good time on your podcast. I think I'm not sure. You kept calling him a three-time Tony loser over and over again.

[3:19] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Well, facts are facts.

[3:21] Peggy: Right, but you don't need you know, it's like, you know, if you see something that someone doesn't do well, you don't point that out to them necessarily.

[3:29] Ellyn Marie Marsh: But that is one of the problems in life. It's just we're all delusional, you know what I mean?

[3:33] Peggy: That's one way of looking at it.

[3:34] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Okay. Totally fine, you're totally entitled to that, but I don't want you to go through life thinking these people like you or that they respect you.

[3:42] Peggy: I mean, a lot of times they're just contractually obligated to come on the podcast. It has nothing to do with you.

[3:46] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah, I don't think that's true. Like you always want to, you just show up when you're not even invited. Like you always want to be around me.

[3:55] Peggy: I don't think that's no, actually, that's not true. We had to we had to coordinate with 77 texts just to get this intro kicking.

[4:04] Ellyn Marie Marsh: So I was like making up excuses. I was like, I have a daughter, I have to cook dinner, I have to put it in.

[4:09] Peggy: I knew you didn't have a daughter.

[4:10] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah. That was a fake.

[4:14] Peggy: Anyway, so this is our conversation with Alysha Umphress. Enjoy.

[4:22] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Get in Peggy with it. Greetings! It's Peggy. And you are watching and listening to Gettin Peggy Wit It. Today, my guest is a wonderful lady who's known for her soulful singing voice and for calling people a cunt.

[4:36] Alysha Umphress: Lovingly.

[4:37] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Woo. On my ring.

[4:39] Alysha Umphress: Oh, it says cunt?

[4:40] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah. In the British way.

[4:42] Alysha Umphress: Right? We hope.

[4:43] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah. Yeah, it's not really acceptable in America.

[4:46] Alysha Umphress: But she doesn't care. But anyway, back to her voice. Her voice is so good.

[4:50] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Thank you, Peggy.

[4:52] Alysha Umphress: Yeah. Do you think that it's good?

[4:54] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Um I love to sing.

[4:57] Alysha Umphress: So Alysha Umphress. Her first show was American Idol.

[5:03] Ellyn Marie Marsh: You probably saw her on TV.

[5:05] Alysha Umphress: American Idiot.

[5:06] Ellyn Marie Marsh: American Idiot.

[5:08] Alysha Umphress: Oh, I thought you were on TV.

[5:10] Ellyn Marie Marsh: No.

[5:11] Alysha Umphress: No.

[5:11] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Okay. American Idiot.

[5:13] Alysha Umphress: I don't know. American Idol did not make it. Fuck them.

[5:17] Ellyn Marie Marsh: I think it's a blessing.

[5:18] Alysha Umphress: Yeah, it definitely is. American Idol is horrible.

[5:22] Ellyn Marie Marsh: I'm so glad you weren't on there.

[5:23] Alysha Umphress: I was actually disappointed that when I saw that. Because it's a place that people go to die. You know what I mean?

[5:28] Ellyn Marie Marsh: So American Idiot on Broadway. What even was that?

[5:33] Alysha Umphress: Many people ask that question. It was a Green Day musical.

[5:36] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Green Day.

[5:37] Alysha Umphress: Yeah. Yeah. It was based on their um Grammy Award winning album.

[5:40] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Right. Called American Idiot.

[5:42] Alysha Umphress: Called American Idiot, yeah. Uh-huh. Were you? Who are you? Tell us what you played.

[5:45] Alysha Umphress: I was one of the idiots as we idiot because one of the girls. Yeah, yeah. Um, no, I was on so actually, what's cool about that show is now that they do it at high schools and community theaters.

[5:56] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Um they do, they're allowed to?

[5:58] Alysha Umphress: Yeah. They might do some editing. It's just a little risque.

[6:00] Ellyn Marie Marsh: It is. But they um the girls in the ensemble of that show are just listed in the libretto as our actual names. So sometimes I'll have girls reach out to me on Instagram and be like, I'm playing Alysha, which is so weird.

[6:13] Alysha Umphress: Yeah, that's awkward.

[6:15] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah. Do they take your licks and stuff?

[6:17] Alysha Umphress: I don't know. I haven't seen I haven't seen any vids. American Idiot was the first, it was the original to do the guy liner pumping fists choreography, you know, where everybody just kind of goes to the front of stage and pumps their fists.

[6:29] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah.

[6:30] Alysha Umphress: And gets hype.

[6:32] Ellyn Marie Marsh: And every show does it now.

[6:33] Alysha Umphress: Um, so you really originated that you were one of the originals.

[6:36] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Thank you. Thank you.

[6:37] Alysha Umphress: Um, and then that way no one needs to have any like dance or or stage skills. It at the audition, they were like, Can you sing hi? Can you pump your fists? Can you look mad? And then they that's how everybody got that show. Basically, there was no dance audition, which is weird because after the show was running and they were having replacement calls and calls for the tour, I'd have friends that were going in for it, being like, Oh my god, that was the hardest, most nonsense dance call I've ever been to. And it was funny because we didn't even have a dance call for the original.

[7:04] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah, clearly you didn't. Um, so how long did that show run?

[7:08] Alysha Umphress: A year.

[7:08] Ellyn Marie Marsh: A year. Okay, and you stayed in it the whole time?

[7:11] Alysha Umphress: I did. And did it win any awards?

[7:14] Ellyn Marie Marsh: We won some technical awards. We won set and lighting.

[7:18] Alysha Umphress: Were you nominated for a Tony?

[7:19] Ellyn Marie Marsh: I was not.

[7:20] Alysha Umphress: No. Did you have a song?

[7:21] Ellyn Marie Marsh: I did have a song.

[7:22] Alysha Umphress: What was it?

[7:23] Ellyn Marie Marsh: It's called Too Much Too Soon. No one knows what that is, unfortunately. Um it's stupid that you didn't have that.

[7:28] Alysha Umphress: Do you have the time? Did who say that?

[7:31] Ellyn Marie Marsh: That's not that's not in it because that was from Jukey.

[7:33] Alysha Umphress: Oh, that's that was a shame.

[7:34] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah. That should have been in it. That was a hit.

[7:37] Alysha Umphress: Yeah. What about hope you have the time of your life? Was that the Encore?

[7:42] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah, I thought it was in it.

[7:43] Alysha Umphress: Oh, Megamix Encore. This is very popular in a jukebox musical, as it were, is to put in a mega mix um so that people think they got their money's worth.

[7:51] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Totally.

[7:52] Alysha Umphress: That wasn't necessarily a mix. We just did that song. They did that in Mamma Mia. Um, and they do it now, and every jukebox musical is a mega mix bow.

[8:00] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Sends you out on a high note.

[8:02] Alysha Umphress: Yeah. Makes you want to buy merch.

[8:04] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah. How is your neck?

[8:07] Alysha Umphress: My neck's fine, but a lot of people hurt their neck?

[8:10] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah. A lot of injuries in that show.

[8:13] Alysha Umphress: Wow. Um, that is rough, you know. The price you pay for originating a show.

[8:18] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah, you know. Did you get points?

[8:20] Alysha Umphress: No points.

[8:21] Ellyn Marie Marsh: No. Just my name and the libretto.

[8:24] Alysha Umphress: But I'll be able to keep forever.

[8:25] Ellyn Marie Marsh: But they do that on God's book, so it doesn't say much.

[8:27] Alysha Umphress: Points are Peggy. Some people might not know what that is.

[8:29] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Oh, like royalties.

[8:31] Alysha Umphress: Nobody wants to give those away.

[8:34] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Who gets points?

[8:35] Alysha Umphress: Basically, just the white guys who write shows.

[8:38] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Okay. Well, Hamilton gets a point.

[8:41] Alysha Umphress: Famously, I think Book of Mormon, they get points.

[8:44] Ellyn Marie Marsh: And actually, Wicked gets points.

[8:45] Alysha Umphress: Oh, do they?

[8:46] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Wow. Who what did you say?

[8:47] Alysha Umphress: Wicked.

[8:48] Ellyn Marie Marsh: They do?

[8:49] Alysha Umphress: Yes.

[8:50] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Do they?

[8:50] Alysha Umphress: Yes, they do. You think I don't know much, but I do.

[8:54] Ellyn Marie Marsh: I I don't think you know much.

[8:55] Alysha Umphress: Yeah. What's crazy is Book of Mormon, you know, it was from the last big workshop. They get points. So there was actually two women in that show. I think it was Kate Weatherhead and Heidi Blickenstaff. And they get they still get paychecks, even though there was never any white women in Book of Mormon.

[9:09] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Wow, smart.

[9:11] Alysha Umphress: They are smart. They just skated in under the line, didn't they?

[9:14] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah. Lucky. That's great. What was the coolest thing you did in American Idiot?

[9:19] Alysha Umphress: Well, before we even started rehearsal, we got to perform on the Grammy Awards.

[9:22] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Oh.

[9:23] Alysha Umphress: Which was really cool. I think they recreated that when they did Greatest Showman on the Oscars. Looked like the same choreo.

[9:27] Ellyn Marie Marsh: It might have been. Yeah.

[9:29] Alysha Umphress: Circles, pumping fists.

[9:31] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah. After American Idiot, you did Big Flop, which was uh On a Clear Day You Can See Forever.

[9:38] Alysha Umphress: Or as I like to call it, On a Clear Day you can see for a month and a half.

[9:43] Ellyn Marie Marsh: That's yeah. Uh but you lasted longer than Wonderland.

[9:46] Alysha Umphress: So yeah. I loved Wonderland.

[9:48] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah, you did.

[9:49] Alysha Umphress: I did. Oh, she's the only one. That's so sweet.

[9:51] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah. I loved Wonderland too, actually. Um, but you know, it's not for everybody. Because it has great music, uh satisfying classic rock music.

[10:00] Alysha Umphress: Okay.

[10:01] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Wow. Costumes by Susan Hilfordy. Get into it.

[10:05] Alysha Umphress: Yeah. Um, so on a clear day you can say forever. What did you play?

[10:09] Alysha Umphress: I played a psych student named Paula.

[10:12] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Did you have a song?

[10:14] Alysha Umphress: No.

[10:15] Ellyn Marie Marsh: No. Okay. I'd say I had some solo lines and some group numbers.

[10:18] Alysha Umphress: Yeah. It's really satisfying.

[10:20] Ellyn Marie Marsh: So Harry Connick Jr. was in that, right?

[10:22] Alysha Umphress: He was.

[10:23] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Wow. What was that like?

[10:24] Alysha Umphress: Uh great. Harry was a total sweetheart. He would take us out to cast dinners and um he was lovely.

[10:33] Ellyn Marie Marsh: And Jesse Mueller won her first Tony?

[10:35] Alysha Umphress: Uh, she was nominated.

[10:37] Ellyn Marie Marsh: It was her Broadway debut.

[10:38] Alysha Umphress: Oh, Broadway Debut.

[10:39] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah, she's fabulous. Did she go to Michigan?

[10:41] Alysha Umphress: She didn't. Did you go to Michigan?

[10:43] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Extraordinarily, no.

[10:44] Alysha Umphress: Wow. I know. Can you believe it? Some people make it. They don't go to Michigan. And and it's always a triumph. You know, I think we should put a gold star next to their name in the in the BIOS.

[10:52] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Huge underdogs.

[10:54] Alysha Umphress: Yeah, huge underdogs. Yeah. And uh it's it's really, really coming coming from the bottom, and and now we're here, you know?

[10:59] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah. What did you like about On a Clear Day?

[11:03] Alysha Umphress: Um, I loved the score, and I loved the like I it I think the saddest thing looking back at that show is that we didn't make a cast album. Not for not for me, but just for like Jesse and I mean the the the score the cre the show is crazy, but the score is beautiful.

[11:19] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Donna Claire Stand and look around you.

[11:23] Alysha Umphress: Who sang that song?

[11:24] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Well, Harry sort of started it at the finale and then it turned into a group number.

[11:28] Alysha Umphress: Mega Mixbow?

[11:29] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah. Okay, so how does stunt casting work? What is that?

[11:33] Alysha Umphress: Um the people at home. Well, stunt casting is usually when they want to sell tickets, so they cast someone from TV or film or the music industry.

[11:45] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Housewife or housewife, yes.

[11:46] Alysha Umphress: Well, I'm going to see Erica Jane on Thursday.

[11:48] Ellyn Marie Marsh: You are?

[11:49] Alysha Umphress: Yeah, I'm so excited.

[11:50] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Wow. Okay, so yeah, it does work. Favorite housewife.

[11:54] Alysha Umphress: There are more wow, you have like a list.

[11:56] Ellyn Marie Marsh: No, just really her.

[11:57] Alysha Umphress: Just her. I hear she's great, actually.

[11:59] Ellyn Marie Marsh: I can't wait. Well, it was actually the beginning of the end of Broadway when we started doing stunt casting, and it started with the Grease show, and everything's been downhill from there.

[12:07] Alysha Umphress: Which is Harry Connick stunt casting?

[12:10] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Well, no, because he's a real musician.

[12:12] Alysha Umphress: He is.

[12:13] Ellyn Marie Marsh: He is a star.

[12:14] Alysha Umphress: He is. But he can really sing and play and act.

[12:16] Ellyn Marie Marsh: He can. And he's been famous since he was like 19. It's crazy.

[12:19] Alysha Umphress: Yeah, New Orleans.

[12:20] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah. But no, stunt casting is horrible. Why do we even do it?

[12:24] Alysha Umphress: Yeah, because it's a show business.

[12:27] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah, but we it show business survived for decades and decades without stunt casting. The minute we started letting American Idols and did TV shows for musicals, that was the the end. And then it means that like you know, the Alysha Umphress of the world are stuck playing psych student number five in Clear Day Forever, and you know, American Idiot in the back. You know what I mean? While somebody, I'm sure there was stunt casting in that.

[12:52] Alysha Umphress: Well, Green Day was in that. That's stunt casting. Why'd they put them in that? You know what I mean? Melissa Etheridge did it for a week.

[12:56] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Oh god. This is what we've become. You know?

[13:01] Alysha Umphress: It's it's terrible, really. So then did you do any other Broadway shows?

[13:07] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah, I went, um, and I actually joined R. Ellyn Marie Marsh in Priscilla Queen of the Desert.

[13:12] Alysha Umphress: She was in that?

[13:13] Ellyn Marie Marsh: She was. There were ladies in that.

[13:15] Alysha Umphress: There were, yeah, six ladies.

[13:17] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Six ladies.

[13:18] Alysha Umphress: Yes.

[13:19] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Oh, but there were black ladies.

[13:21] Alysha Umphress: Um whiteies.

[13:23] Ellyn Marie Marsh: There was some whiteies.

[13:24] Alysha Umphress: Oh, okay. You were in that. All right. And then you joined the company?

[13:27] Ellyn Marie Marsh: I did.

[13:27] Alysha Umphress: Wow. I replaced Kayala Settle of Greatest Showman Fame.

[13:31] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Oh, yes. Yes.

[13:33] Alysha Umphress: Yeah. Wow. That's a very good cast, Priscilla.

[13:37] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Was legends in the making.

[13:39] Alysha Umphress: Yeah.

[13:39] Ellyn Marie Marsh: How long were you in that?

[13:41] Alysha Umphress: Well, I closed that show out, so it was probably because of me that we closed out.

[13:44] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah.

[13:45] Alysha Umphress: Four months.

[13:46] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Was it that little?

[13:47] Alysha Umphress: Yeah. I think it was only like it was like February. We closed in June, right? Because it was Pride.

[13:52] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah. So February to June.

[13:54] Alysha Umphress: Yeah. Did you like doing that show?

[13:56] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah. I did. I felt like I was maybe not the best choice for my track. I think, you know, what's funny is that I that's the only show I've ever replaced in and haven't done from the ground up.

[14:08] Alysha Umphress: That's called a humble brag.

[14:10] Ellyn Marie Marsh: No. No, it's not. I think like I It's not a humble brag. You have your own camera, don't look at mine.

[14:16] Alysha Umphress: Sorry. Um, I mean, like w when we auditioned for the replacement in that, it was like it was a whole day of just sort of cuts and boot camp kind of thing. It's like, do these harmonies, now do this dance combination, now do these, do this scene and do some more harmonies. And then at the end of the day, they had four of us go to the theater and get measured for the costume.

[14:35] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Well, dramatic.

[14:37] Alysha Umphress: Very dramatic. Very like smash. Yeah. And I think no one knows what smash is, but we can talk about it later if you really want.

[14:43] Ellyn Marie Marsh: Yeah, I don't. Um Did you change your makeup in the audition as much as you did on stage?

[14:51] Peggy: I love makeup, yeah. It's so fun. Her makeup right now, for those of you just listening, it's like a rainbow. It's like Rainbow Brite meets a wonderful explosion of Sephora. And she's beautiful. Her skin is luminous. She changed makeup so many times in that show. Basically, all she did was sing high and change makeup. Yeah, right? Which is the story of your life. Sing high. Yeah, basically, actually. Alicia Humphrey. Sing high, change makeup. That's your book. My memoir. Thank you, Peggy. You're welcome. Apparently, there's gonna be a chapter about housewives. So it's we've really gone downhill as a society. Were you a drag queen in that show? I were just drag queens, right? Yeah, we all played drag queens at the funeral at the beginning, sort of.

They would never allow that now. It's not PC. Right. Or something. I don't know. Yeah. Men can dress as women. Men dressing as women. Exactly. Yeah. I think are they gonna revive it? I don't know. I don't think so. I mean, maybe eventually, I would guess. Do you know any real drag queens? Uh, it seems like they would love you. Um, I love drag. I mean, I love drag queens. What did you do after that thing you just did? Priscilla. Well, I was the female, I did all the female voiceovers and I sang one of the big songs in Bring It On, but I wasn't actually on stage. Bring It On was all teens, pop locking and doing somersaults. Exactly. But Joshua never done a show before in their life. It's true.

Joshua Henry and I got to, we got it was the best, it's the best job I've ever done on Broadway. Josh Henry was in that? Well, in the same way he did all the male voiceover stuff and he sang one of the big songs of each year, too. We did two shows with Joshua Henry? I did, sort of. But we didn't have to be there. I know he's the best. Were you in the like were you like a pit singer with him? Were you just in the pit in the dark pit with him? No, we didn't even have to show up. We just got paid and got to be on the album and got to go to opening night. Neither of them did were at Michigan. You know, I mean this is this is a true success story. And then here they are just getting paid to do nothing.

That's wonderful. It was great. Sometimes, you know, people that deserve it really make it. Most of the time not. Most of the time not, yeah. It's true. Bring It On. Wow. Did you like that show? Uh, I only saw it on opening night, but I had a great time. It was a blast. Wow. Just mailbox money. That's what they call that. Yeah. Yeah. I've never heard that term, but you're right. Do you do a lot of film and TV? Not a lot. But when you do, you'll get mailbox money someday. Yeah. Someday you could do it. How did you get the job of just that seems like a very cushy job? It was. It was be well, it's a it was a lesson in um survival. In survival. No, in being um in Who You Know and also being um so Tom Kitt, who did the orchestrations for on uh for American Idiot, basically was like, I think that you'd be great for this track.

Why don't you come in? So I had to audition, and you know, um they really put me through it. Andy Blank and Bueller like made me do the scenes multiple times and sing the song multiple times, but um at the end of the day, there was nobody coming in after me. Oh for the she was the only one. I was the only one. That's a lesson in if you are the only one, that then you will get the job. Yes, that's great for you. So after Bring It On, you did one of my favorite musicals ever On the Town. Also one of my favorite musicals. Yeah, it's classic. It's like the way musicals really should be. You know, full orchestra, actual tunes and melodies, um, no pop blocking, you know, no guy liner. It was just classic, you know, and it had actual plot points and twists and romance.

Yeah, it has everything I love in a musical. And you were so good. I saw it twice. Really? Wow. And I hate everything, but I loved it. Thanks, Peggy. The costumes and sets were a little cartoony for me. Did you like that? I mean, I think that was what they were going for. They wanted it to be sort of um lots of primary colors and comic book-ish. Yeah. And Elizabeth Stanley was the same as she is in Jagged Little Pill. Yeah, identical performances. The same. Um, and you were so good, and you had the signature song, and it was wonderful. So, um, tell us what you played in On the Town. I played uh the taxi driver, yes, yeah. Hildi. And you met your husband. When you ask her a question, Peggy, you can let her answer.

She's really rude. I'm sorry. You met your husband in On the Town. I did. How about it? She's got a very, very cute little husband. She does. I bet gays love him. I there's been a few gays that have expressed their love. Yes. Because in musical theater, most people assume every guy's gay. Yeah, especially the ones that dances in the chorus. Yeah, yeah. And they're and I bet they see him and they're like, You look a cute little twink. And he's like, actually, I'm not a twink. Oh, he, you know, he's married to a beautiful lady. And they had a wonderful wedding. I didn't go, but they're just a dreamy couple. Oh, thank you. If you were ever in shows that had dancing, other than you know, then he could help you.

Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. How long did that show run? That was also a year. Did you like the cast? I love the cast. It was American Idiot and On the Town were like my two career highlights. Yeah. Yeah. On the Town was a long time ago. You don't have any other highlights? Um, uh Smoky Joe's was good. That wasn't on Broadway. No, it was off Broadway. Yeah. Nobody cares about off Broadway, unfortunately. Yeah, it's true. Um now you can tell us. We will we won't put this in, but who is a real problem in the cast? In On the Town? Yeah, who made a problem? You can tell us. We've heard a lot of stories. Uh I plead the fifth. Yeah. Um, so tell us the song you sang in that show. I Can Cook Too. Oh, we sing it for us.

Full out. Yeah, you can back up. I Can Cook Too. On top of the rest. My seafood's the best in the town. Yeah, I Can Cook Too. My fish can't be beat. My sugar's the sweetest around. I'm a man's ideal of the perfect meal right down to the demi test. Yeah, I love that song. She's not even warm. This is a real professional. This is how she gets jobs. You know? Yeah, well. With that beautiful tone, it's buttery. Thank you, Peggy. On your socials, um, by the way, your social media handle is Crystal Sheet. I don't know what that is. What is that? Oh, on Twitter. It's Crystals Heat. It's a Showgirls reference, the movie Showgirls. Oh, she's obsessed with Showgirls. I am. I forgot to mention that because it's boring.

She's obsessed with Showgirls. And she makes people watch it. I yeah, I ran into an actor who shouldn't be named that said that you forced him to watch Showgirls at a concert. Yeah. Yeah. He constantly complains about it. Oh, yeah. It's like right up his alley, though. That's what's so rich about that person. So rich. That's another thing she says a lot. Ben Davis. Oh. He made Ben Davis watch it. Oh, yeah. Ben Davis watched it. He complained. Please. It's full of naked girls. He loved it. So she loves Showgirls. Um, when's it gonna be a musical? Oh my gosh, that would be. I mean, maybe I should remain. You and Maria should produce it because you're both equally obsessed. We yes, we are. We're I think getting matching tattoos.

We haven't decided what yet, but it's gonna be oh god. Yeah, think about it. It's gonna be on your body forever. Can't you just like it? We could, but everybody knows you love it. I don't think you need to, you know, immortalize it like that. We can talk about it offline. Um, so uh you on your socials, it looks like you do a lot of concerts. I do is that just what you do now? Basically, yeah, yeah, yeah. Don't get a lot of other work. Um, well, I finished a show at Roundabout last uh in December. What show? It was called Scotland PA. Oh, what's that about? Uh murder and fast food. Okay, it's well that's what fast food is, it's murder of animals. It's true. Yeah. Um, okay, so you do a lot of concerts.

So do you want to try to you could ask her about Scotland PA. Was that on Broadway? No, I'm not having any interest in that. But you know what I want to do? I want to do a segment we like to call Fast Faves. I'm gonna tell you something, and you're just gonna tell me your fave as fast as you can. Okay. Okay, okay. All right. Clothing line. Um Gucci. Broadway memory. On the Town. Your go-to meal. Asaebull from um's generation. Ugh, no one likes a sae bowls. Secret New York spot. Little Branch. Broadway cast album. Light in the Piazza. Ooh, TV show to binge. I just binged you on Netflix. Just finished it. No one knows that is. Yeah. Best thing about 2019. Ugh. Um. It's already been the longest year on earth.

Oh, it's 2020. Just kidding. Um, best thing. Ole. Oh, yeah. Oh, Alicia was in a bunch of commercials for Olay. Yeah, that really brightened my ear. Oh yeah, I bet it. Mailbox money. Yeah, yeah. Girl band. And Vogue. Eyeshadow brand. Pat McGrath. Uh oh, I don't even know what that is. Slang word, cunt. Yeah. Thing about me. Um, I mean your dress. Art McDonald. Legend. Icon. Yeah. Oh, it's wonderful. Great answers. Let's do another segment I like to call Lasting Impressions. Lasting impressions. Okay. So every actor, as you know, has to have impressions in their back pocket because that's how they get jobs. And they all do dozens of impressions. So I'm going to call out some impressions. You can do it for us.

Oh my gosh. Okay. B. I'm a hunta. I like A girl. This is vaguely racist. We'll deal with that later. Drew Barrymore. Um, so basically, I just um well, I I I I thought that maybe uh Billy Bolly. Um, it's a proper it's a place in Bali proper. Um yes, yes, that's that's grit. Everybody else is so bad at this. They were. Evidence for show. Michelle Wolf. Michelle Wolf. You can use your favorite word. Yeah, well, she like she's a cunt, right? Doesn't she like talk like this? Yeah, except like 20 decibels louder. Yeah, cunt! Bugs Bunny. Oh, um, that's all, folks. Is that him? Uh oh god. Well, there we go. Carole Carmelo. She's a singer. No, I know, I know, I know. I'm trying to think of her. Um, what's the song from Parade?

What's the song? You don't know that she's bad. Oh yeah. You don't know. I was trying to think of a song from Scandalous, but alas. Oh yeah, you would like that. Marissa Tomei. So, no, because the cabaret uh couldn't be blah, blah, blah. I don't know. I don't know if that's a good one. That's unlike Tommy Broccco. Thank you. Um Viola Davis. Oh my god. I can't do a Viola Davis, but you know who does the best Viola Davis? Jelani Ramy. Do you know him? Really? Oh, it's him on. You should have him on if only just to hear his Viola Davis impression. It's incredible. Put him on the list. Yeah. Judge Judy. So let me get this straight. You again. Also sounds like Tommy Rocco. Yeah. Tommy Rocco. Kristen Bell.

Kristen Bell. Oh. For the first time in forever. There'll be something and there'll be more. For the first time in forever. Okay, Peg. I want to do a segment I like to call Deep Internet Cuts. Okay. Deep cuts from the internet. So on December 22nd, 2008, you said has crocheted her fingers to the bone today. Oh my god, Rich. Um, what were you making? Uh a hat. Do you think anyone cares about that? This is not good content. It's not. I mean, it was so long ago, though. Like, you have to forgive me that. I was just like, And then you commented on your own. You are dumb because crochet with knit. No likes. No likes. Only comment. All right. That's pretty sad. Well, you know what? 11 years ago. Caught me some slack.

Oh my god. Okay. She's getting a little it's getting out of hand. All right. November 22nd, 2013. Yeah. A gentle reminder. If you abbreviate honeymoon in Vegas, it's a oh HIV. Well, because it was a good point. It was on Broadway, and so everyone was sort of abbreviated. Abreves it. I mean like HIV, and it was sort of like Oh, that's horrible. Maybe it's a public service announcement. That was good of you to do. Crystal sheet. No, crystals heat. Yeah. It was a Z. Crystals. Oh, because the line is no one has crystals. Crystal Jeet. No, crystal. Crystals heat. And she spells it crystal like the champagne, which she clearly says in the scene at Spago. Mm-hmm. Wow. How about some Oscar Roundup? Can you tell us what your favorite things were?

Did you like the Oscars? Uh did I like the actual telecast? Uh, it was fine. It's sort of they're so boring and mostly white people. Yeah, mostly white people, but also they were trying so extra to be so woke. Um, yeah, like though they only nominated white people. Like Jagged Little Pill. Well, in no comment. Yeah. It's like a tornado of wokeness. It is. It's a lot, it's a ton of woke. Yeah. Yawn. Did you like the Judy Garland? Uh yeah. I mean, I was really anxious. I was really anxious that I'm not sure. It probably will. You were anxious? Yeah, I was so anxious in it. Yeah, about her face. No, just like in general. I think maybe it was how you're because you knew that she was gonna die. Yeah.

Spoiler alert. Yeah. So it was just sort of like Diana the musical. What's the point? You know? So sad. People don't want to be sad. This world is sad enough. You know what I mean? Well, you do you're not wrong. Yeah, like why do that's why I ask why do people go to plays? They're mostly sad. Have you ever seen a happy play? You know what I mean? It doesn't exist. You can't take it with you. That's happy. And now a segment we like to call Actors Are Dumb. Everybody knows actors are dumb. We all know actors are pretty stupid. We're gonna ask you some trivia, okay? Okay. You haven't been peeking, right? No. Okay. All right. I'm gonna ask you five trivia questions. Oh, yeah. Alright. What is a whale's tail called?

A tail. A fluke. Like most people's career. Who is the lead singer of the Strokes? Uh do you know what the Strokes are? Yeah. Or do you just listen to musical theater? No, I know who the Strokes are. Don't know. Julian Casablancas. Wow. I don't know who that is. Who was the first African American woman to perform at the Super Bowl halftime show? Whitney Houston? No. Ella Fitzgerald says. I don't think that's true. It is true. Wow, that's so cool.

[29:40] Peggy: They had football back then.

[29:44] Alysha Umphress: I'm sure they made her go through the back.

[29:46] Peggy: What did you what?

[29:47] Alysha Umphress: What did she sing?

[29:48] Peggy: I don't know.

[29:49] Alysha Umphress: I'll look it up.

[29:50] Peggy: Look it up.

[29:50] Alysha Umphress: I'll go back to you.

[29:52] Peggy: In horse racing, the triple crown is awarded to the horse that wins what three races.

[29:58] Alysha Umphress: The long one, the medium one, and the short one.

[30:00] Peggy: What are their names?

[30:02] Alysha Umphress: She's trying to seduce you with her eye makeup, but it's not gonna work.

[30:05] Peggy: Just stick to the plot.

[30:06] Alysha Umphress: I don't know.

[30:07] Peggy: Kentucky Derby.

[30:08] Alysha Umphress: Oh, oh, like what are the races?

[30:10] Peggy: Yeah.

[30:10] Alysha Umphress: Kentucky Derby, probably one in Europe somewhere.

[30:14] Peggy: Nope.

[30:15] Alysha Umphress: They're all in.

[30:16] Peggy: All in America.

[30:18] Alysha Umphress: One in Oh, the Hampton Classic.

[30:19] Peggy: How would the horse get to Europe?

[30:21] Alysha Umphress: I don't know.

[30:21] Peggy: On a boat?

[30:22] Alysha Umphress: Yeah, this is exactly precisely why we do this segment, is to really show you.

[30:26] Peggy: Is the Hampton Classic one of them?

[30:27] Alysha Umphress: Nope.

[30:27] Peggy: That's not even a thing.

[30:28] Alysha Umphress: Belmont Stakes and the Preakness.

[30:31] Peggy: Wow.

[30:32] Alysha Umphress: Don't even I've heard of Belmont Stakes.

[30:34] Peggy: If you're going to Broadway Trivia later, you should probably brush up on some reading.

[30:37] Alysha Umphress: Jeez.

[30:38] Peggy: Which river flows through the Grand Canyon?

[30:41] Alysha Umphress: Take a wild guess.

[30:45] Peggy: Um the Grand Canyon River.

[30:48] Alysha Umphress: No, Colorado River.

[30:50] Peggy: Going back to the Ella Fitzgerald.

[30:52] Alysha Umphress: Yeah, she performed Mac the Knife.

[30:55] Peggy: Oh, cool.

[30:56] Alysha Umphress: Ooh.

[30:57] Peggy: Uh Ella Fitzgerald's wonderful.

[30:58] Alysha Umphress: She's one of my faves.

[31:00] Peggy: Oh, me too.

[31:01] Alysha Umphress: Her listen to her.

[31:02] Peggy: Carol Channing also sang that year.

[31:04] Alysha Umphress: She sang Oh when the Saints go marching in.

[31:07] Peggy: But Ella Fitzgerald, she was not only the first jazz musician to play, but she was the she was the first African and female celebrity singer to sing in Super Bowl history.

[31:18] Alysha Umphress: Wow, that's incredible.

[31:19] Peggy: I didn't know the Super Bowl.

[31:20] Alysha Umphress: You came on this podcast and you learned something.

[31:22] Peggy: Yeah, there you go.

[31:23] Alysha Umphress: I've learned that.

[31:23] Peggy: Well, I learned that she's learned a lot.

[31:25] Alysha Umphress: Yeah.

[31:25] Peggy: Yeah.

[31:25] Alysha Umphress: I'd like to do a segment we like to call Give Me Your Phone.

[31:28] Peggy: Give me a phone.

[31:31] Alysha Umphress: Can you give me your phone?

[31:32] Peggy: It's over there.

[31:34] Alysha Umphress: Can you open this?

[31:41] Peggy: Let's see if there's anything interesting.

[31:48] Alysha Umphress: Joey Taranto.

[31:49] Peggy: Hmm.

[31:50] Alysha Umphress: Oh, a lot of famous people in here.

[31:52] Peggy: Oh, NY Cunts.

[31:54] Alysha Umphress: Let's see what they say.

[31:55] Peggy: That's gonna be juicy.

[31:56] Alysha Umphress: Um, oh, a publicity photo for the roundabout.

[31:59] Peggy: Yeah.

[32:00] Alysha Umphress: Yawn.

[32:01] Peggy: They're talking about what really needs to be talked about.

[32:03] Alysha Umphress: You know what I mean?

[32:04] Peggy: I'm gonna screenshot those for myself.

[32:06] Alysha Umphress: Laura Lee.

[32:07] Peggy: There are a lot of famous.

[32:07] Alysha Umphress: Who's the most famous person in your phone?

[32:09] Peggy: I don't know.

[32:10] Alysha Umphress: Maybe Billy Joe Armstrong.

[32:12] Peggy: Oh, can you call him?

[32:13] Alysha Umphress: No.

[32:15] Peggy: Let's FaceTime him.

[32:17] Alysha Umphress: What about the second most famous?

[32:19] Peggy: Let's FaceTime someone.

[32:20] Alysha Umphress: Oh, I could FaceTime someone.

[32:22] Peggy: Who should we FaceTime?

[32:23] Alysha Umphress: Yeah, somebody big, not some loser.

[32:26] Peggy: Okay.

[32:27] Alysha Umphress: Who are you FaceTiming?

[32:28] Peggy: You'll find out.

[32:29] Alysha Umphress: Okay.

[32:30] Peggy: In real time.

[32:34] Alysha Umphress: If they pick up, we should screenshot for this asshole.

[32:38] Peggy: How rude.

[32:40] Alysha Umphress: Brandon Iranowitz not picking up.

[32:45] Peggy: Has been a guest.

[32:47] Alysha Umphress: He has been a guest.

[32:48] Peggy: He probably knows you're here.

[32:49] Alysha Umphress: Let's call Joey Taranto.

[32:50] Peggy: Yeah, it's his birthday.

[32:51] Alysha Umphress: Call him with shit.

[32:52] Peggy: He's probably on his lunch break, actually.

[32:54] Alysha Umphress: You think?

[32:59] Peggy: Happy birthday!

[33:00] Alysha Umphress: Happy birthday, Joey!

[33:02] Joey Taranto: Thank you.

[33:04] Alysha Umphress: Look at you too.

[33:05] Peggy: We're on air.

[33:06] Alysha Umphress: We're on air, so careful what you say.

[33:08] Joey Taranto: Oh god.

[33:10] Alysha Umphress: Hi duty girls.

[33:11] Joey Taranto: You look beautiful.

[33:12] Alysha Umphress: I would invite you to be on the show, but you haven't done that much.

[33:19] Joey Taranto: Oh.

[33:20] Alysha Umphress: Are you 40 this year?

[33:22] Joey Taranto: Say again.

[33:23] Alysha Umphress: Are you 40?

[33:29] Joey Taranto: We won't be up with that on air.

[33:31] Alysha Umphress: You look Wow, you look great.

[33:33] Joey Taranto: I was actually joking.

[33:34] Alysha Umphress: For a white guy, you look great.

[33:37] Joey Taranto: Thank you.

[33:39] Alysha Umphress: I know we're crazy.

[33:41] Joey Taranto: I'll take that.

[33:41] Alysha Umphress: Thank you.

[33:42] Peggy: You do look incredible, Joey.

[33:44] Alysha Umphress: Ask him what he's doing.

[33:45] Peggy: What project he's working on?

[33:46] Alysha Umphress: What are you working on, Joey?

[33:48] Joey Taranto: I'm working on Muriel's waiting.

[33:50] Alysha Umphress: Muriel's waiting.

[33:51] Joey Taranto: Muriel's wheating.

[33:52] Alysha Umphress: Weeding.

[33:53] Joey Taranto: Yeah.

[33:53] Alysha Umphress: I'm playing a member of ABBA.

[33:56] Peggy: Do you know Ellyn Marie Marsh?

[33:59] Joey Taranto: Never heard of her.

[34:01] Alysha Umphress: Yeah.

[34:01] Joey Taranto: She is a nightmare.

[34:03] Alysha Umphress: She's a total nightmare.

[34:05] Joey Taranto: Um yeah, I would avoid it.

[34:07] Alysha Umphress: She didn't book Muriel's wedding.

[34:08] Joey Taranto: And I you know, it's probably real people in it.

[34:12] Alysha Umphress: It's true.

[34:13] Joey Taranto: True.

[34:14] Alysha Umphress: She came in here doing her callback on their lunch break.

[34:16] Joey Taranto: I was like, this is a nightmare.

[34:20] Alysha Umphress: Are you on your lunch break?

[34:21] Joey Taranto: I am on my lunch break.

[34:23] Alysha Umphress: I'm gonna have a little sweet cream.

[34:25] Joey Taranto: Treat yourself.

[34:25] Alysha Umphress: That's wonderful.

[34:26] Peggy: Treat yourself.

[34:27] Alysha Umphress: Alright, I'm bored.

[34:28] Joey Taranto: Okay, bye.

[34:30] Alysha Umphress: Love you.

[34:30] Joey Taranto: See you at see you at five, fish.

[34:32] Alysha Umphress: Okay.

[34:33] Peggy: Um, Alicia.

[34:34] Alysha Umphress: Yes.

[34:35] Peggy: I want you to take these paper dolls.

[34:37] Alysha Umphress: Yeah.

[34:37] Peggy: And I want you to act out your favorite scene from Showgirls.

[34:41] Alysha Umphress: Oh, okay.

[34:41] Peggy: I know you know all of it by heart.

[34:44] Alysha Umphress: Slap it on the one, two, a three, and four, five, six, and out.

[34:50] Peggy: Uh-uh.

[34:54] Alysha Umphress: Bump.

[34:55] Peggy: What do we think?

[34:56] Alysha Umphress: Is there a scene?

[34:56] Peggy: Is there a scene?

[34:57] Alysha Umphress: Oh, you want to do the scene.

[34:58] Peggy: I was doing the dance.

[34:59] Alysha Umphress: We can we can yeah.

[35:00] Peggy: Yeah, why don't we do the scene at Spargo?

[35:03] Alysha Umphress: Okay.

[35:03] Peggy: Um, you can be do you want to be know me and I'll be crystal?

[35:06] Alysha Umphress: Yeah.

[35:07] Peggy: I name myself after this champagne darling.

[35:11] Alysha Umphress: Mm-hmm.

[35:12] Peggy: Can't tell me my lines.

[35:13] Alysha Umphress: Yeah.

[35:14] Peggy: Um, it would really help if you just knew them though.

[35:16] Alysha Umphress: Do you know anything?

[35:17] Peggy: And do you know any of the scenes?

[35:18] Alysha Umphress: How about this?

[35:19] Peggy: Can you act out a scene from a Shakespeare play?

[35:21] Alysha Umphress: You're an actor.

[35:22] Peggy: Yeah.

[35:22] Alysha Umphress: Great.

[35:23] Alysha Umphress: Make mouths upon me as I turn my back, wink each other, hold the sweet chest up.

[35:28] Peggy: This sport well carried shall be chronicled.

[35:30] Alysha Umphress: And if you had any pity, grace or manners, you would not make me such a mockery.

[35:34] Peggy: Ooh.

[35:36] Alysha Umphress: She actually knows things.

[35:38] Peggy: She's the real deal.

[35:39] Alysha Umphress: Every other loser came in here and did Romeo and Juliet.

[35:42] Peggy: And I did Midsummer Nice Dreams.

[35:43] Alysha Umphress: I know.

[35:43] Peggy: So I well, I know, but at least she knew a speech.

[35:46] Alysha Umphress: Thank you.

[35:47] Peggy: I'm pretty impressed.

[35:48] Alysha Umphress: Thank you.

[35:49] Peggy: Let's do bullet questions.

[35:52] Alysha Umphress: Questions.

[35:53] Peggy: What is your go-to gift to give?

[35:56] Alysha Umphress: Um, well, if it's a baby, uh, I know.

[35:59] Peggy: Babies don't need gifts, they have everything.

[36:01] Alysha Umphress: I know.

[36:02] Peggy: But my signature gift that I give babies are um it's eyeshadow palettes.

[36:06] Alysha Umphress: Yes.

[36:07] Peggy: Something to strive for.

[36:08] Alysha Umphress: Um, no, it's like a bathlight that changes colors when it goes in the water, so it's like a rave.

[36:13] Peggy: I give it to every baby.

[36:14] Alysha Umphress: Any any friend that has a baby, it's my go-to gift.

[36:16] Peggy: You should give that to adults.

[36:17] Alysha Umphress: I know.

[36:17] Peggy: I mean adults that love baths.

[36:19] Alysha Umphress: It's actually so fun.

[36:20] Peggy: Oh that's wonderful.

[36:21] Alysha Umphress: I'm gonna ask another one.

[36:22] Peggy: What's your favorite quote?

[36:24] Alysha Umphress: Oh, my favorite.

[36:26] Peggy: I'm sure it's from Showgirls.

[36:27] Alysha Umphress: Yeah.

[36:27] Peggy: Yawn.

[36:29] Alysha Umphress: Okay.

[36:30] Peggy: What is your worst and your best habit?

[36:33] Alysha Umphress: My worst habit is probably not leaving the house.

[36:38] Alysha Umphress: Like just having days where I'm like, oh, I worked out, that's enough.

[36:42] Alysha Umphress: I don't need to do anything else.

[36:43] Alysha Umphress: I'm just gonna watch TV all day and um be on my phone.

[36:46] Alysha Umphress: It's probably my worst habit.

[36:48] Peggy: My best habit is probably like getting up even on days like that and going to the gym.

[36:54] Alysha Umphress: Oh, that's great.

[36:54] Peggy: That takes motivation.

[36:56] Alysha Umphress: Where do you go?

[36:57] Peggy: Crossfit.

[36:59] Alysha Umphress: Yeah.

[36:59] Peggy: I hate group fitness.

[37:00] Alysha Umphress: It's horrible.

[37:01] Peggy: Yeah.

[37:01] Alysha Umphress: It's an abomination.

[37:02] Peggy: Yeah.

[37:02] Alysha Umphress: It's like adults at Disneyland.

[37:04] Peggy: Ugh.

[37:04] Alysha Umphress: Like sociopaths.

[37:05] Peggy: You know what I mean?

[37:06] Alysha Umphress: I love Disneyland.

[37:07] Peggy: Yeah, disgusting.

[37:08] Alysha Umphress: I just went to Disneyland without kids.

[37:11] Peggy: Why?

[37:11] Alysha Umphress: Disney World, didn't you?

[37:12] Peggy: Yeah, Disney World.

[37:13] Alysha Umphress: Ugh.

[37:13] Peggy: Wasn't it so fun?

[37:14] Alysha Umphress: It's so fun.

[37:15] Peggy: It's way more fun without kids.

[37:16] Alysha Umphress: Yeah, you don't have to.

[37:17] Peggy: Well, kids are horrible, but why would you go to Disney World without kids?

[37:21] Alysha Umphress: Did you have a fast pass or whatever it's called?

[37:23] Peggy: Yeah, you can't go anywhere without a fast pass.

[37:25] Alysha Umphress: Yeah.

[37:26] Peggy: You can only get three fast passes.

[37:27] Alysha Umphress: If you knew Disney, you would know you only get three a day.

[37:30] Peggy: That's a real.

[37:31] Alysha Umphress: I'm a grown person, so no, I don't do that.

[37:34] Peggy: Um, so Alicia, this is the time in the show when we get you to tell us what you really think.

[37:40] Alysha Umphress: Okay.

[37:40] Peggy: We're gonna turn off the cameras, we're gonna turn off the mics, and we won't tell anybody, you know.

[37:44] Alysha Umphress: And um, I just want to know what do you really think about Josh Bergas?

[37:50] Alysha Umphress: I love Josh Bergas.

[37:51] Alysha Umphress: He's a sweet angel.

[37:53] Alysha Umphress: He's so sweet, right?

[37:54] Alysha Umphress: So cute, and he's so collaborative.

[37:55] Alysha Umphress: I feel like it's another one.

[37:57] Alysha Umphress: You think he's gay, but he's not.

[37:59] Alysha Umphress: No, he's married to a ballerina.

[38:03] Alysha Umphress: Who's uh she's on another planet, she's amazing.

[38:05] Peggy: Yeah, no, that was boring.

[38:08] Alysha Umphress: I know.

[38:08] Peggy: Um well ask me about someone that's more controversial.

[38:11] Alysha Umphress: I mean, he's a sweetheart.

[38:12] Peggy: So, what are you doing next?

[38:14] Alysha Umphress: Well, I go to Los Angeles in a couple weeks to work on a new musical with Susan Strowman and Diane Warren.

[38:23] Peggy: What is it?

[38:24] Alysha Umphress: Can't say it doesn't have a title yet, I don't think it's working title, it's very preliminary developmental stages.

[38:31] Peggy: That's exciting.

[38:32] Alysha Umphress: It is, and then I'm going to Italy to do um a symphony.

[38:36] Alysha Umphress: I'm doing Wonderful Town with the Symphony.

[38:38] Peggy: Ooh.

[38:38] Alysha Umphress: In Bari, Italy.

[38:41] Peggy: And then I actually just got offered a show in San Francisco.

[38:45] Alysha Umphress: What is it?

[38:46] Peggy: I can't say that because it's I haven't um it hasn't all been um worked out, but thanks for telling us nothing.

[38:54] Alysha Umphress: Um so um have you ever waited tables?

[38:56] Peggy: I have.

[38:57] Alysha Umphress: You have?

[38:57] Peggy: Where?

[38:58] Alysha Umphress: Ellen Stardust Diner?

[39:00] Peggy: You knew!

[39:03] Alysha Umphress: I guessed.

[39:03] Peggy: Oh yeah.

[39:03] Alysha Umphress: It was my first job.

[39:04] Peggy: I moved to New York with Matt DeAngelis?

[39:07] Alysha Umphress: With Matt DeAngelis, and we didn't move here together, but we did work there.

[39:10] Peggy: Yeah together.

[39:13] Alysha Umphress: He did the tour.

[39:14] Peggy: Okay.

[39:14] Alysha Umphress: Um I also worked there with Ellyn Marie Marsh.

[39:17] Peggy: Ellyn Marie Marsh worked there?

[39:18] Alysha Umphress: Yes.

[39:19] Peggy: That's so on the nose.

[39:21] Alysha Umphress: It was my first job in New York City.

[39:23] Alysha Umphress: I I moved here and a week later I went in and I applied for a job and I got it, and I started a week later.

[39:28] Peggy: Wow.

[39:29] Alysha Umphress: Strapped on poodle skirt and cat eye glasses.

[39:31] Peggy: What's the worst theater job you've ever had?

[39:34] Alysha Umphress: Like in my professional career?

[39:36] Peggy: Yeah.

[39:37] Alysha Umphress: Gosh, that's so hard to say.

[39:40] Alysha Umphress: You know, there was elements of this show that I did in Dallas that I I loved.

[39:46] Alysha Umphress: I love the relationships I made and I loved Dallas and I loved that theater company.

[39:50] Alysha Umphress: But um the show was kind of it was problematic.

[39:54] Alysha Umphress: That was, you know, maybe not my favorite.

[39:57] Peggy: Mm-hmm.

[39:58] Alysha Umphress: Um, are you poor?

[39:59] Peggy: No.

[40:00] Alysha Umphress: Do you wow?

[40:01] Peggy: That was uh all actors are poor, but um do you think you'd make more money uh waiting tables?

[40:08] Alysha Umphress: Uh consistently, probably.

[40:10] Alysha Umphress: I mean, I think I know people that work at Ellen's that they make really Ellen's is still open.

[40:14] Peggy: Oh, Ellen's is open.

[40:15] Alysha Umphress: Did they shut it down?

[40:17] Peggy: Um, they I don't know if it ever got shut down.

[40:21] Alysha Umphress: But they don't know that.

[40:23] Peggy: Good money.

[40:23] Alysha Umphress: There's like a line around the block every time I pass by that place, yeah.

[40:26] Peggy: Ugh.

[40:27] Alysha Umphress: So what's your backup plan?

[40:29] Peggy: Do you think every actor should have a backup plan?

[40:31] Alysha Umphress: I think that you should figure out a way that you can sustain and make money.

[40:36] Alysha Umphress: I mean, luckily, when I'm not doing shows, I've been able to do concert work and symphony work.

[40:40] Alysha Umphress: So it keeps me afloat.

[40:43] Peggy: Yeah, that's great.

[40:43] Alysha Umphress: Yeah.

[40:44] Peggy: She must have sold her soul to get those jobs.

[40:48] Alysha Umphress: Alicia, I would love to hear your life advice.

[40:52] Peggy: What's your advice that you would give to somebody wanting to have a career and don't do it?

[40:57] Alysha Umphress: Music and theater.

[40:58] Alysha Umphress: Don't do it.

[40:58] Peggy: Don't do it.

[40:59] Alysha Umphress: That's what everybody says.

[41:00] Peggy: No, if there's anything else that you that could you could you could see yourself doing that would make you happy, you should do that.

[41:06] Alysha Umphress: I mean, literally everyone says those exact words.

[41:09] Peggy: Yeah.

[41:09] Alysha Umphress: Yeah.

[41:09] Peggy: Do you have anything original?

[41:11] Alysha Umphress: Um, probably not.

[41:12] Peggy: No.

[41:12] Alysha Umphress: Uh, just that if you really insist upon doing it, that it never gets easier and you have to.

[41:18] Alysha Umphress: I mean, I cried last week.

[41:20] Peggy: You did, but it seems like you have everything in your life.

[41:22] Alysha Umphress: Doesn't it?

[41:23] Peggy: Yeah.

[41:23] Alysha Umphress: Yeah.

[41:24] Peggy: Social media.

[41:26] Alysha Umphress: It's real really good.

[41:27] Peggy: She's got a cute little husband.

[41:28] Alysha Umphress: Uh he's great.

[41:29] Peggy: He didn't make me cry.

[41:30] Alysha Umphress: And a dog.

[41:32] Peggy: Oh, she's got a very cute dog.

[41:33] Alysha Umphress: She's so cute.

[41:34] Peggy: Yeah, she's a cute cry.

[41:35] Alysha Umphress: Who doesn't like children?

[41:37] Peggy: She doesn't like children.

[41:38] Alysha Umphress: My dogs don't either.

[41:39] Peggy: Like mother like daughter.

[41:39] Alysha Umphress: Yeah, same.

[41:41] Peggy: Kids are horrible.

[41:43] Alysha Umphress: That's why.

[41:43] Peggy: Taught her well.

[41:44] Alysha Umphress: Who would like kids?

[41:45] Peggy: They're just so rude.

[41:46] Alysha Umphress: I mean, they just think the world revolves around them.

[41:48] Peggy: Yeah, they're selfish and they're not grateful.

[41:51] Alysha Umphress: When I see a kid crying, I'm like, you have everything.

[41:53] Peggy: It's never gonna get easier.

[41:54] Alysha Umphress: Yeah.

[41:54] Peggy: Your life's only gonna get harder.

[41:56] Alysha Umphress: Yeah.

[41:57] Peggy: What about advice for anybody who's like having a dip in their career?

[42:01] Alysha Umphress: Just that actually, that's a good one.

[42:03] Alysha Umphress: Um, just that it can the crazy thing about this business is that it can change, it can turn on a dime.

[42:09] Alysha Umphress: And so, you know, like one week it can just feel desolate and like I'm never gonna work again, and then the next week you can just get an offer out of the blue for something and be like, oh my god, now I have three months of my life, I know what I'm doing, you know?

[42:24] Peggy: Yeah.

[42:24] Alysha Umphress: So just stick with it, stick with it.

[42:27] Alysha Umphress: And you know, I think John Ham is a good uh example.

[42:31] Peggy: The guy from Mad Men.

[42:32] Alysha Umphress: He's gone, bless him.

[42:33] Peggy: Oh, oh yeah, he has now his career's dead, right?

[42:36] Alysha Umphress: But for a brief moment, he no one knew who he was forever, and then he booked Mad Men and he was you know one of the most famous people on the planet at four in his forties.

[42:44] Peggy: So wow.

[42:45] Alysha Umphress: Bonnie Raitt made it in her 40s.

[42:47] Peggy: Yeah, she's amazing.

[42:48] Alysha Umphress: She's the best.

[42:49] Peggy: Where's John Ham now?

[42:50] Alysha Umphress: Nowhere.

[42:51] Peggy: He's around.

[42:52] Alysha Umphress: Oh I mean, he'll be okay, right?

[42:54] Peggy: He's not like dead.

[42:54] Alysha Umphress: He probably has mailbox money.

[42:56] Peggy: Yeah, I would I would think.

[42:57] Alysha Umphress: I'm sure.

[42:58] Peggy: This has been Getting Peggy with it, and I'm with Alicia Umfras.

[43:03] Alysha Umphress: Thank you so much for tuning in.

[43:04] Peggy: And uh Alicia, you've been a joy.

[43:06] Alysha Umphress: Thank you, Peggy.

[43:07] Peggy: Way better than all the other losers.

[43:10] Alysha Umphress: Even though we did try to call a couple of your friends and they didn't pick up.

[43:13] Peggy: Yeah, that makes me a loser.

[43:14] Alysha Umphress: Thanks, Brandon.

[43:15] Peggy: Yeah, Brandon.

[43:16] Alysha Umphress: Shitless.

[43:17] Peggy: He's a three-time Tony loser.

[43:18] Alysha Umphress: It's true.

[43:19] Peggy: He you know he has nothing going on.

[43:21] Alysha Umphress: He might as well pick up.

[43:22] Peggy: I I I mean, yeah.

[43:23] Alysha Umphress: You know, but he people are probably calling him with other jobs, and this is why he doesn't have more in his life.

[43:28] Peggy: Honestly, he's probably still asleep.

[43:31] Alysha Umphress: Whoa.

[43:33] Peggy: It's like night.

[43:35] Alysha Umphress: Well, it's called depression, and it's serious.

[43:38] Peggy: And that's why everyone should be in therapy.

[43:41] Alysha Umphress: So thank you for joining us.

[43:42] Peggy: Bye.

[43:43] Alysha Umphress: Thanks for having me.

[43:44] Peggy: You've been listening to Gettin' Peggy with it on the Broadway Podcast Network.

[43:49] Alysha Umphress: Getting Peggy with it is produced by Alan Seales and directed by Ella Marie Marsh.

[43:53] Peggy: Getting Peggy with it is edited by Alan Seales and Ellyn Marie Marsh, and she won't let you forget it.

[43:58] Alysha Umphress: Please follow Peggy's Adventures at Greetings, it's Peggy.

[44:01] Peggy: One word, dummies.

[44:03] Alysha Umphress: Special thanks to Taylor Newsome and Josh Lehman.

[44:06] Peggy: Peggy is a character created by Morgan James.

[44:09] Alysha Umphress: That's me.

[44:10] Peggy: And Peggy.

[44:13] Alysha Umphress: And Morgan.

[44:15] Peggy: Thanks for listening.

[44:16] Alysha Umphress: I got a whole file on you.

[44:17] Peggy: Oh no.

[44:18] Alysha Umphress: I'm so scared.

[44:19] Peggy: You should be.

[44:20] Alysha Umphress: You ready to be roasted?

[44:21] Peggy: Yeah.

[44:22] Alysha Umphress: Okay.

[44:22] Peggy: Ellen, are you interjecting?

[44:24] Alysha Umphress: Yeah.

[44:25] Peggy: Okay.

[44:25] Alysha Umphress: I help her out when she needs guidance because she can't really do it on her own.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred