Skip to main content
BPN Logo
"Gleekbaiting" (w/ Nicole Crowther)

Allison and Andrew start this week’s episode by talking about Darren Criss…. AGAIN. He’s releasing new music this week, check out Masquerade on 8/20! Allison goes through each new single with Andrew at length. Is Darren Gleekbaiting? Let us know in our DMs... Read More

From the show: Gleek of the Week - A Glee Podcast

1 h 3 mins
8/17/21

Featured Shows

About

Allison and Andrew start this week’s episode by talking about Darren Criss…. AGAIN. He’s releasing new music this week, check out Masquerade on 8/20! Allison goes through each new single with Andrew at length. Is Darren Gleekbaiting? Let us know in our DMs. Our guest this week is Nicole Crowther, a former Glee extra with a truly crazy story involving twitter and Brad Falchuk. Songs this episode include an Annie the Musical Sue solo, a Christmas song that isn’t a Christmas song, and Kurt’s NYADA audition.

FOLLOW GLEEK OF THE WEEK:

https://www.instagram.com/gleekoftheweekpod

https://www.tiktok.com/@gleekoftheweekpod

FOLLOW ALLISON:

https://www.instagram.com/allisondodge

FOLLOW ANDREW:

https://www.instagram.com/mcgui_guy

FOLLOW NICOLE:

https://www.instagram.com/nicolecrowther

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:04] Allison: No, you're starting it exactly the way we always do.

[0:10] Andrew: But I don't know how else to do it.

[0:12] Allison: This is the third episode where we talked about this.

[0:14] Andrew: I don't know how else to start an episode other than Andrew.

[0:18] Allison: Are you?

[0:22] Andrew: Um, I'm doing well. I don't know if that was an actual question or not.

[0:26] Allison: No, I didn't actually care. Um I want to talk to you.

[0:27] Allison: I want to talk to you today about Darren Criss.

[0:35] Andrew: I know that we talk about Darren Criss in every episode.

[0:39] Allison: Yeah.

[0:40] Andrew: Yeah, I don't know if you know him.

[0:41] Allison: He is on Glee.

[0:43] Andrew: He was on Glee.

[0:44] Allison: He played Blaine Anderson.

[0:45] Andrew: He released new music this week.

[0:47] Allison: This episode is gonna come out way later, but yeah, I know.

[0:50] Andrew: Yeah.

[0:51] Allison: But you had the opportunity last week to talk about this new music when it was more fresh, but I know, but then I was like, no, I want to talk about American Horror Story.

[1:01] Andrew: That's okay.

[1:02] Allison: That's okay.

[1:03] Andrew: So Darren Criss, he's released three new songs thus far from a new musical project.

[1:10] Allison: Um I thought it was gonna be an album.

[1:12] Andrew: It's a five-song EP.

[1:14] Allison: Um that he is hyping up just as much as an album, and you know what? You do you. I want more music, more content.

[1:21] Andrew: But we have gotten three songs thus far.

[1:25] Allison: Okay. We got how do you feel about them?

[1:27] Andrew: Um coming from a live, breathe, die by Blaine Anderson, Darren Criss kind of person.

[1:36] Allison: Okay. I mean, I'm gonna listen to it, whether it's good or bad.

[1:39] Andrew: Wait. I sort of wanna unpack the fact that you said Blaine Anderson before Darren Criss, a fictional character before the actual person.

[1:50] Allison: Because uh I'm not gonna go into that.

[1:54] Andrew: I'm not gonna go into that.

[1:55] Allison: Then okay, that's something I'm gonna bring up with my therapist off the pot.

[1:59] Andrew: Um, so we have "Fucking Around," which was the first single, really good. Um, liked it. It was kind of like edgier.

[2:11] Allison: So I think what he's going for with this album is each song is like a very character-driven. Um very like different side of him. "Fucking Around," I liked it. Did you like it?

[2:23] Andrew: It I heard like bits of it. I only heard what he posted to social media.

[2:29] Allison: Okay, so you're not a real fan, you didn't listen to the whole thing.

[2:31] Andrew: I never claimed to be a Darren Criss fan.

[2:34] Allison: Okay. Let that be clear.

[2:36] Andrew: Okay. Well, I'm here driving this boat.

[2:39] Allison: Okay. Um then we have um "I Can't Dance."

[2:45] Andrew: Oh, is that like a callback to "I'm Not Gonna Teach Your Boyfriend How to Dance with You," even?

[2:50] Allison: Sadly, no. I really, really, really wish it was. Um, it's uh very 80s uh character. Like he's playing a character, I think.

[3:02] Andrew: What is the character?

[3:04] Allison: I don't know. I did this one, this is the song I've liked the least thus far.

[3:08] Andrew: Okay, I've been also seeing that Darren Criss is like been like sort of there's queer baiting, and then there's also gleek baiting, which I feel like Darren Criss is doing on his social media.

[3:19] Allison: Darren Criss is gleek baiting?

[3:21] Andrew: He's gleek baiting because he's going on social media and he just like took a picture in front of something that said Warbler, and then like he's like posted it to grid, and it's like, yeah, people are gonna respond.

[3:33] Allison: Yeah, it's not like he would want to celebrate one of his biggest successes in his career by taking a photo.

[3:40] Andrew: No, but he does this like no, he does this constantly. Because like he also recently, I feel like he on his Instagram story or something, he was singing "Don't Stop Believin'," which of course was a Glee original.

[3:52] Allison: Um so I mean like I feel like he's gleek baiting.

[3:57] Andrew: Okay, well, you know what? It's working. If he panders to his audience, it works it's working.

[4:03] Allison: Like I I'm not mad about it. Um I want the Glee content. The Glee if it's gonna make get him views, do it.

[4:10] Andrew: We do the exact same shit. We literally clickbait constantly.

[4:14] Allison: We gleek bait every single day of our lives, okay?

[4:18] Andrew: Um it's the third song that we've had.

[4:23] Allison: Okay, sorry. The from this week. Uh it's called "A Night Like This."

[4:29] Andrew: Uh-huh.

[4:30] Allison: So good.

[4:31] Andrew: Uh-huh.

[4:32] Allison: I really, really thoroughly enjoy it. It's very like COVID is we can see the light at the end of the tunnel, but we're going back into the tunnel, but um, the light at the end of the tunnel is coming, and um, I want to play that song at every party ever.

[4:48] Andrew: And then it's a very good like New Year's song.

[4:51] Allison: Wait, does it like have like the words COVID or pandemic in the song, or are you just sort of like—

[4:51] Andrew: No, but it's a song the lyrics are about like we've been waiting for a night like this, like I'm putting on fancy clothes, you're putting on fancy clothes, we're gonna party, we're gonna dance, we're gonna drink, we're gonna spend a shit ton of money.

[5:10] Allison: Right.

[5:10] Andrew: It's gonna be we've been waiting for this.

[5:12] Allison: And I yeah, I live by that every uh weekend of my life. My bank account cries.

[5:20] Andrew: Wow.

[5:20] Allison: I love that.

[5:22] Andrew: That's great.

[5:23] Allison: Thank you.

[5:24] Andrew: Um is that it?

[5:26] Allison: I wanted to get your reaction to the album. However, I mean like you haven't listened to it, so—

[5:28] Andrew: I haven't listened to it. I didn't I don't I didn't know that this was like an assignment that I had going into this recording.

[5:37] Allison: It is. If you're gonna claim that Darren Criss is gleek baiting, you better come with the facts.

[5:42] Andrew: Okay. I literally do have the facts. He has been posting on social media.

[5:45] Allison: I don't need to listen to this little EP that's not an album.

[5:51] Andrew: His little EP that's not an album. Do you remember we you and I both did go to the Darren Criss concert separate venues?

[5:58] Allison: Separately. Obviously, we did not know each other at the time.

[6:00] Andrew: Obviously.

[6:01] Allison: He played a bunch of new music that he was like, I'm releasing an album. Boom.

[6:06] Andrew: Right.

[6:07] Allison: Never became an album. There are like several songs that I'm like, where are they?

[6:13] Andrew: I remember him like singing like sort of like the slow version of "Teenage Dream," like the one that he does uh in season four, and then it sort of just like goes into the faster version, the poppy version.

[6:28] Allison: Yeah. Right?

[6:28] Andrew: He did that on that tour, right?

[6:30] Allison: Yes, and he also invited somebody on stage at each show.

[6:33] Andrew: I don't know if you're—

[6:34] Allison: Oh, I do recall that, and that was a huge deal.

[6:33] Andrew: Yeah.

[6:33] Allison: That was a huge deal that he didn't pick me.

[6:40] Andrew: I rioted afterwards.

[6:41] Allison: Sorry.

[6:42] Andrew: By not listening to his music for 10 minutes, and then I was back in it again.

[6:46] Allison: You're back in it.

[6:47] Andrew: Wow.

[6:48] Allison: Um, well, Darren Criss, everyone.

[6:52] Andrew: Darren Criss, everybody.

[6:53] Allison: He Darren Criss, yes. He crashed Steve Aoki's set at Lollapalooza. Did you see that?

[6:58] Andrew: I don't know who that is.

[7:01] Allison: I feel like un I I don't feel prepared for this conversation.

[7:09] Andrew: Steve Aoki is a musician.

[7:12] Allison: Okay.

[7:13] Andrew: Um he's made music with a bunch of different artists, including Louis Tomlinson, which is for the One Direction podcast that I will eventually uh—

[7:13] Allison: I'm familiar with that name.

[7:23] Andrew: Yeah. Okay, okay. Um, but Darren and Steve Aoki have a song together, and Darren crashed Steve's uh set at Lollapalooza.

[7:33] Allison: And I think Steve Aoki was performing at the same time as Miley Cyrus.

[7:39] Andrew: Okay.

[7:39] Allison: I know. Which one would you have gone to? Which one are you would you have gone to?

[7:44] Andrew: Miley.

[7:45] Allison: Oh.

[7:47] Andrew: Wait, it's crazy because Darren Criss was my first concert and then Miley Cyrus was my second.

[7:53] Allison: Really?

[7:54] Andrew: I've never seen Miley live.

[7:56] Allison: I really want to see Miley live. I think I probably shouldn't say that publicly.

[8:00] Andrew: What?

[8:01] Allison: I feel like those two people like that's like just like—

[8:04] Andrew: Darren Criss and Miley Cyrus.

[8:06] Allison: It's like not a good, it's not a good first concerts, you know.

[8:10] Andrew: I like it.

[8:11] Allison: Yeah.

[8:11] Andrew: Okay. That's it. Do you have something else to do?

[8:13] Allison: That's all I got for you.

[8:14] Andrew: Okay. Do you do you want to bring in our Gleek of the Week this week?

[8:17] Allison: I do want to bling bling in. I want to bling in our Gleek of the Week.

[8:20] Andrew: Nicole, our Gleek of the Week. How are you doing, Nicole?

[8:26] Nicole Crowther: Hi, I'm good. How are you guys doing?

[8:28] Allison: We're doing so well. Thank you so much for coming on. Um, so uh you had a really crazy experience with Glee that people might not be familiar with. Do you mind just like taking us back to the beginning? Because this story is just like so crazy.

[8:42] Nicole Crowther: Well, uh where do I start with that? So uh first of all, I just want to start by saying I used to be one of the biggest Gleeks in the entire planet. Um, literally lived, breathed, ate, whatever. My family like almost disowned me because I talked about it so much. They were like, okay, relatable content. You gotta go. And I was like, okay, I'm gonna move to LA then where they filmed the show.

[9:04] Nicole Crowther: Um no, so I moved out to Los Angeles uh when I was 19 and to pursue um uh career in film, more or less. I wanted to be more behind the scenes, not I wasn't really trying to be like an actor or anything, but a thing that people do out there as a way to network and meet people is kind of do uh what's called background acting. Obviously, it's pretty self-explanatory. It's the people walk around in the background.

[9:28] Nicole Crowther: And uh it was always my goal to try to get on that show because um as a young person myself dealing with um my own identity problems with my sexuality, uh Glee really spoke to me. It was one of the first shows that kind of embraced that and showed it as like this positive thing. And it just I I was just so I connected to it so much, it was so relatable for me.

[9:53] Nicole Crowther: Um, and so unfortunately I only got to be on the show once when I was doing this background work, and it was in the fall of uh was it 2010? Bear with me, it's been over 10 years. Um, but that's not that's not the main point of that's not actually the main point of what happened was um six months after I was even on the show at all, um, I was invited to a dinner party with some friends that I had made, uh just a couple girls that I knew through also doing background work.

[10:23] Nicole Crowther: Um, you end up working with a lot of people around your age, you know, so you make friends and hang out and support each other and whatever. And so a friend of mine was having this dinner party, and she invited other people that she was friends with that I didn't know. Um, and we happened to all be chatting after dinner, and a couple of the girls had mentioned that, oh hey, we were on Glee this week, and of course, me being the avid fan that I was, yes, I was like, oh my God, tell me everything.

[10:48] Nicole Crowther: And um, everyone had had a couple drinks or whatever, so everyone was just like having fun, just talking freely, whatever. Um, but you know, they ended up telling me they were on the prom episode. And I was like, um, okay, so what happened? And they just they told me and they told me what had happened, and I was like, okay, that's cool. But once again, like I had never met these people. I didn't know if they were being honest. I didn't know I didn't know the truth.

[11:16] Nicole Crowther: I couldn't tell you for sure. Um so what had happened after that is uh uh Twitter had been like a newer thing within the past couple of years at that time, and um, because my family and friends were so annoyed by me and me talking about Glee all the time, I would you know reach out on Twitter to other fans, and I mean I didn't have a large following by any means, you know, it was maybe I I don't remember the exact number, but a few hundred people, nothing crazy.

[11:44] Nicole Crowther: Um so I got onto Twitter and I, you know, as a fan and as like someone who's just like gossiping, I was like, so you know, I found out this um potential spoiler, like kind of reaching out to like see what everyone thinks. Do we think this is possible? Do we think what you know, whatever kind of kind of I that was the idea I had in my head, anyways.

[12:04] Nicole Crowther: And um the spoiler that I had heard was that um Kurt was gonna be um prom queen and Karofsky was gonna be prom king. And so, in a way, I kind of like tweeted it as like this acronym because I thought it was cool or something. I'm not really sure what that was, but as like a funny way to see who could decipher my message. Um, and uh, I mean, that was it. It was later that night. I I didn't really get much response back.

[12:32] Nicole Crowther: So I went back to sleep or went to sleep that night. And uh the next morning I woke up and um this was at the time when Twitter was sending you like notifications for every like you would get an email for every single notification, your mentions, whatever. And I like look at my phone and it's completely blown up. Like I've got 2,000 like emails, and I'm like, what wait, what's happening? It's like very confused. So it's like, did I get hacked? Like, I don't know. So I log on to find out that um lo and behold, um, Brad Falchuk, who is one of the producers of Glee, um, somehow came across my tweet. I'm assuming it was uh must have been retweeted or mentioned amongst people, and he must have came across it somehow.

So he then decided to publicly um kind of call me out for that, and like um I forget his exact words, but it was essentially along the lines of like, you know, like who are you to spoil something? Talented people have spent um months to create and good luck basically working in Hollywood. And uh yeah, so my heart kind of shattered into a million pieces, like my stomach dropped. Um, and it was it was a it was I like I almost thought that I was living in some nightmare. It took me a minute to like really be able to grasp what was happening. Um because then I was getting just an onslaught. Not only for did I read his tweets, but then of course all the fans that were reading that, and as you know, Glee has a very avid fan base.

Um yes, very and I'm very passionate about it. And I mean I love that, I love the passion. I had I had it too. Um, but I was getting a lot of very angry, very angry tweets. And um the unfortunate part was obviously that I I didn't you know I wasn't actually on the show. I didn't know for sure what I was tweeting was even real. So and what happened from there, I mean uh it kind of blew up. So like within the first 24 hours it was um news in like local news in Los Angeles within 48 news it became for sorry 48 hours it became like national news and then within 72 hours it became worldwide news. Like I was literally reading articles from around the globe online that were in different languages with my picture next to it and you know and the title was Glee uh extras uh fired for um spoiling episode and I was like okay well that's not accurate like it's it's not and nobody really did their research or tried to really find out they just ran with this story and it it exploded because I I think at that time it really was kind of one of the you know social media was really becoming a really big thing and you know it was newer and Twitter and all that kind of stuff.

And so I think it was one of the first bigger stories where something like this happened with and and as you guys know Glee was a huge huge show just massive so anything to do with Glee like people just you know blew it up and and ate it up and so you know unfortunately for me um that's uh that's kind of how it transpired within the first three days and I was just like kind of uh kind of mind blown, not gonna lie.

[15:48] Andrew: Um yeah, understandably. I I feel as though it's like Brad Falchuk actually responding to that tweet validates the spoiler in some in some regard, right? Because it's like he could have just like saw the tweet and just like went on his day. But the fact that he responded and was like he did all of that, like he didn't need to do that. In in my personal opinion, um, you know, I as I and I understand as a producer and wanting to protect your show, and if you think you have to do some kind of damage control, but yeah in my opinion, I feel like he almost caused the damage because again, like I said, like I I didn't have a lot of followers. Um I wasn't anybody like you know, with a a a large following where this was gonna get out, really.

Um and it wasn't even confirmed. But I feel like by him tweeting that it confirmed it. And then he sent it out to his thousands of followers, and then that's where the news picked it up. And so, yeah, I you know, I think he he kind of blew it up into what it became, honestly. And also like just for the record, like the tweet like didn't even outwardly say like uh Kurt is it said K is PQ, K A is P K. And it's like that literally could mean anything on like the periodic screen. And it wasn't like here's a glee spoiler.

[17:09] Nicole Crowther: Right. Yeah.

[17:10] Andrew: Exactly. Uh thank you. I feel the same way. I was like, well, I mean, you know, he could have even just messaged me personally and just be like, hey, you know, can you can you take that down? Or yeah, I just don't, you know what I mean? And I I just feel like he didn't do his own research into I mean he didn't he didn't even find out that I wasn't an extra or whatever, and he essentially blacklisted me in Hollywood. Uh before, you know, I I was out there trying to, you know, go to film school and like achieve like my dreams, but here I am essentially blacklisted from a lot of different places now. Like I got dropped from my the casting agency I was working with. Um a lot, yeah, a lot of places, a lot of people didn't want to work with me. So that's uh it it definitely took its toll on me in in a lot of ways.

[17:49] Nicole Crowther: So that was rough.

[17:50] Andrew: Coming from like one of your favorite shows too.

[17:53] Nicole Crowther: Exactly. It was absolutely heartbreaking. Like I just I I was like, this is the worst thing that could have ever happened. I mean, I I adored that whole show, everybody on that show. I was so grateful for the creators and everything about I mean I I can't tell you how much it meant to me. Uh again, dealing with my own sexuality and being able to have that show. It was like it was like a lifeline at some point, you know what I mean? Like it it made you feel uh like you belonged in some ways. And uh it was just a really it was a really cool thing. Uh the show was, and it's just it was unfortunate really for me to ha have to experience that in such a negative way.

[18:27] Andrew: Did you continue watching it after or yeah, yes, yeah, I did um for a little while, um, just because I mean I still wanted to support the actors and the um, you know, and other people wasn't I feel like that maybe was just him specifically that kind of had that reaction. And um also I was still obsessed with the show.

[18:52] Andrew: So um well, we do have six songs that we're gonna get through in this this hour with you. Do you have any favorite performances that we're projecting? Are we are we just picking some or how does this work?

[19:05] Nicole Crowther: We're picking completely random. I'll pick three songs, Allison will pick another three.

[19:09] Andrew: Oh, I love this. That's amazing.

[19:11] Nicole Crowther: Yeah.

[19:13] Andrew: Um do you have any favorite songs from the the series? Anything that comes to mind?

[19:16] Nicole Crowther: I mean, all of them were so amazing. Like I had so many favorite ones. Um I loved anything with uh Santana and Brittany because um again, it's just they they grab my heart.

[19:30] Andrew: Same.

[19:31] Nicole Crowther: Yeah, yeah, so we're projecting Brittany and Santana.

[19:36] Andrew: Okay. Wait, Alison, do you want to go first?

[19:39] Allison: I have been going first. Do you want me to continue to go first?

[19:42] Nicole Crowther: Go first, go first.

[19:43] Allison: Okay, okay.

[19:45] Allison: Okay, okay, it's fine.

[19:49] Allison: I need to find like sweet morning dew.

[20:00] ♪ Musical number: "Sweet Morning Dew" — performed by Allison ♪

[22:05] Andrew: Um, okay.

[22:06] Nicole Crowther: Just like in the middle of Mr. Schuster's history class, I love seeing what he's like teaching on the whiteboard is American bald eagle.

[22:17] Andrew: Like, I'm like, okay, what?

[22:19] Nicole Crowther: All about the eagle.

[22:20] Andrew: All about the eagle.

[22:22] Nicole Crowther: And I'm like, also, he does this impromptu performance in Marley's class.

[22:28] Andrew: But like, everyone knew it was gonna happen because the band was already there in the class with their instruments.

[22:37] Nicole Crowther: And how do they bounce back from that?

[22:39] Andrew: Like when they're like, okay, the song's done, and the people dressed up in costume boys leave the classroom and Marley sits down. How does Mr. Shu just like start class again?

[22:50] Nicole Crowther: And like d does one of the band members actually were like, they were like, oh, actually, I want to learn a little bit more about the bald eagle.

[22:56] Andrew: So I'm gonna stick around.

[22:59] Nicole Crowther: Um, I think this is a very good song, though. I think it's very, very cute.

[23:01] Andrew: Probably the best Jarlie duet, Jake and Marley duet.

[23:07] Nicole Crowther: I like this one a lot.

[23:08] Andrew: Okay.

[23:09] Nicole Crowther: What do you think? What are you thinking of this performance?

[23:13] Andrew: I mean, I think it yeah, I think it was adorable. I think Jake was was uh one of my favorite characters to one of the newer ones.

[23:18] Nicole Crowther: So uh it's really cute between them, yeah.

[23:21] Andrew: And this is when Jake is struggling with the Valentine's Day idea, so he goes to Ryder who has a crush on Marley, right?

[23:29] Nicole Crowther: And is like, what do I do for my girlfriend's Valentine's Day present?

[23:34] Andrew: And Ryder just supplies him with the amazing most perfect most Marley ideas.

[23:40] Nicole Crowther: And Jake's like, oh yeah, thanks.

[23:43] Andrew: Oh, thanks.

[23:44] Nicole Crowther: And then he gets all the credit.

[23:47] Andrew: Yeah.

[23:47] Nicole Crowther: I hate it.

[23:48] Andrew: I hate the show.

[23:50] Nicole Crowther: Um I don't know.

[23:52] Andrew: No more thoughts about it.

[23:53] Nicole Crowther: Like, it's very cute.

[23:54] Andrew: Marley got some pipes.

[23:56] Nicole Crowther: Jake also does.

[23:58] Andrew: Yes.

[23:59] Nicole Crowther: Um, very cute.

[24:01] Andrew: I would be surprised if it doesn't go through, but we'll see.

[24:04] Nicole Crowther: I would be surprised if it would go through.

[24:05] Andrew: Some for some reason the Valentine's Day songs just don't do it for me.

[24:10] Nicole Crowther: Cherish Cherish and Silly Love Songs.

[24:14] Andrew: And Cherish Cherish is iconic, and you need to shut up.

[24:18] Nicole Crowther: I have a I have a Jake performance, a Jake solo.

[24:22] Andrew: So a Jake duet versus Jake solo.

[24:25] Nicole Crowther: Okay.

[24:27] Nicole Crowther: Stop being so modest and get your butt up here, Jake.

[24:38] ♪ Musical number: "I Wish Those Days Could Come Back Once More" — performed by Jake ♪

[26:55] Andrew: Jake does ballet. That was part of his character, I think. Right? I feel like I remember that. Um, wow. A Jake duet versus a Jake solo. Um, I like this one a lot, but I we've had a we've had Jake solos before where it's like very similar to this, where it's like he's dancing around and podcast audio medium. You didn't get to see uh what he was doing. It's very fancy footwork between him and Mike Chang. And it was very good. I liked it. Vocals were also there. Um, I loved it a lot. What are you thinking?

[27:33] Allison: I I mean I do I love a Jake solo. Why do I love a Jake solo so much? This isn't my prerogative though. Is that my prerogative? And it's not Hanukkah Oh Hanukkah, okay? That is the best Jake song on the show. Weird, weird hill to die on. Weird hill. Nicole, how do you feel about this song? Were you uh how did you feel about the second generation, the second coming of Glee? Jake Marley Ryder.

[28:03] Nicole Crowther: I actually knew Jacob Artist. Uh we were friends. We actually went to um uh acting class together. And so I think I will always have a little bit of a soft spot for him. Uh wait, I love that biased. So yeah, oh yeah, I have I have pictures of him with him on Instagram, but that was also again side note, when he got the whole Glee thing, it kind of like he was uh kind of like worried about everything with what had happened with me, so it was kind of um that whole thing. But I mean he's a great guy, great person, very talented. I always knew he was gonna go far, and uh I always like still support him till this day. Um but yeah, the performance. I think he's a great performer. He's got a great voice and kid can dance.

[28:47] Andrew: But when it comes down to it, a a Jake Marley duet versus this Jake solo, Nicole. Do you want to start us off on the vote? Or do you want someone else to start?

[28:59] Nicole Crowther: I am starting.

[29:00] Andrew: Okay, go ahead.

[29:02] Nicole Crowther: I I mean I would go for the solo personally. I sometimes those songs, those uh romantic songs are a little cheesy for me.

[29:08] Allison: I agree.

[29:09] Andrew: Wait, awesome. Are you also going for the solo?

[29:11] Allison: Yeah, I'm also going for I Wish. I'd rather listen to Jake alone than Jake with Marley.

[29:16] Andrew: Oh, I'm going for the duet. I mean, it doesn't matter because it's matter. Because I wish is already going through. Wow. It was good, but it's not as good as the song I just pulled, baby boy.

[29:30] Allison: Oh no, I'm scared.

[29:31] Andrew: It is not as good. Okay.

[29:36] Allison: Oh no. Oh, I've been so excited. Okay. I can't go back to the babysitting breath. Iconic.

[29:46] ♪ Musical number: "Little Girls" — performed by Jane Lynch ♪

[31:24] Andrew: Oh, I have to stop sharing. Okay. I sort of like that image, that final image of just Jane Lynch just like towering over, like I guess. Are they dead? All these Cheerios?

[31:38] Allison: They're simply passed away and passed away at her. She can't deal with these little girls. This is the song her character in Annie on Broadway sang. This was the song that Miss Hannigan sings in Annie, and this is at the end of season four going into the summer, where during the summer Jane Lynch is on Annie uh 2013 singing this song. So I feel like there were probably some conversations between like Jane Lynch's people in Glee where it was like, can we have Jane Lynch sing this song as like sort of like promo for it for Annie on Broadway?

[32:20] Andrew: Yeah. Um, I mean, it's an obvious song for Sue as well, and I think it's just so much fun. I mean, we've had conversations in the past where it's clear that I don't stand by Sue's songs for whatever reason. I mean, this is another one. I'm like, it's really fun. I'd be surprised if it goes through. I think it's just so I I don't know. I'm conflicted.

[32:46] Allison: Was Annie on Broadway? Annie was on Broadway the summer that you and I were at pre-college.

[32:52] Andrew: Yeah.

[32:52] Allison: And so we I remember we go to it. I did not go to it. Did you?

[32:56] Andrew: No. I remember they were like they were like what that whatever that like ticket system that they did where it was like pulled out of a hat or whatever.

[32:57] Allison: Yeah.

[32:57] Andrew: Where it was like whoever will go to Annie. Because I think that was the same night that I saw Cinderella with Laura Osnis, who maybe she's a blake. I don't know, but I want her on the podcast. Laura Osnes. Laura Osmus. Nicole, how do we feel about this?

[33:22] Nicole Crowther: Um I personally in the show, I loved Sue. She cracked me up. I mean, I don't know that I would have been a the biggest fan if she were in real life. But she always, I mean, yeah, she always put on a great funny performance. Um yeah, it's it was pretty good, pretty decent. I feel the identity of like she feels like being a cheer coach is her identity, and I can I can identify with that. I can identify with her identifying with that.

[33:49] Andrew: Because you're also a cheer coach?

[33:51] Nicole Crowther: Because I'm also a cheer coach, and I live, breathe, die by the pump. Right. Try getting waterboarded. That's hard. That's hard. Um this is the point in the series where Sue um has confessed to um bringing a gun into the school and shooting it. And so now she is uh she is like I think teaching like aerobics classes or something, but then like when season five comes around, like she is the principal.

[34:22] Allison: She's principal.

[34:23] Andrew: Which I don't understand how that makes sense. We just forgave the school shooting episode and act like it never happened. Let's see what's against okay. This is a another musical song from a Christmas episode, but not necessarily a Christmas song.

[34:40] Allison: Oh, I know exactly. Can I guess what it is?

[34:42] Andrew: Yeah, what is it?

[34:44] Allison: Is it my favorite things?

[34:47] Andrew: It is my favorite thing. My favorite things is not a Christmas song. I will die. I will die saying that.

[34:50] ♪ Musical number: "My Favorite Things" ♪

[37:05] Andrew: So not a Christmas song.

[37:15] Allison: Not a wait, why is it not a Christmas song?

[37:17] Andrew: It's not a Christmas song because they don't this isn't it's sung at Christmas time. Like I'm pretty sure in the sound of music, it's not Christmas time when they sing this.

[37:27] Allison: Then why did Glee sing it in a Christmas episode?

[37:30] Andrew: Because it's been it's been made by our society.

[37:33] Allison: This is the problem with our society is that they say "My Favorite Things" is a Christmas song, and they play it on the radio during Christmas time. You know what? It's not. What do you think about the Gleecast version of "My Favorite Things"?

[37:46] Andrew: I don't like it.

[37:48] Allison: You don't like it?

[37:48] Andrew: I think it's a very fun performance. I think that for these characters to finally be put in front of a camera, this is exactly how they would act. They're looking directly at the camera the entire time, just completely showing face. They're having so much fun, but they're being very, very annoying. But I think it's still very cute. And I mean like Rachel, Mercedes, Kurt, and Blaine. I think this is the only number the four of them really get all together. I think it's a good performance.

[38:24] Allison: Nicole, what are you thinking of "My Favorite Things"?

[38:27] Nicole Crowther: I agree with you, Allison, that I don't understand the whole Christmas thing. Thank you. Specifically Christmas. So back you up there. I thought it, again, it's cute. I kinda liked more of the ensemble performances myself. I like the different tones and everything. And you got some of the strong singers in there with Mercedes and Rachel and Blaine and Kurt, obviously. I mean all of them really. But it's, you know, yeah, it's a little on the slower side for me.

[38:56] Andrew: Well, going back to, okay, you were an extra on Glee. That scene that you did, did you interact with any of the cast members?

[39:06] Nicole Crowther: Like on the show itself, no, but did I interact with them like behind the scenes? Like it was, you know, you're on set for like eight hours a day. Yeah, I spoke with quite a few of them briefly, very briefly. They're obviously very busy and all over the place and back at their trailers and whatever else, but I didn't interact with them like in any scenes. Again, my main scene was like running through a hallway or something, if I remember correctly. Trying to get out of there, I guess. I don't know.

[39:33] Allison: But that must have been so much fun just like seeing the production happening as a Glee fan, right?

[39:40] Nicole Crowther: I can't tell you. My mind was just exploding the entire time. You could probably find brain bits of mine, like just all over the place. I don't even know what was happening. Like it was just such a rush. I'm not even sure that all my memories are still there from it because I was just so excited.

[39:54] Allison: I just want to say one last thing about "My Favorite Things." I've had this conversation twice today already. So I've made the risky choice. There is a speaker at my workplace that sometimes I get the aux cord to. And I'm like, okay, I have to play music that everybody's gonna be okay with. I feel like the Gleek should know. You don't need to reveal exactly where you live for the Gleek, but like I work at a zoo. I am a zookeeper, so I'm playing these songs not only for me, but also for all of the animals that I work with. So I need music that's gonna please everybody, whether they're human or not. And so I chose to play the Glee Complete playlist at work today. Because I've just been on a binge.

[40:45] Andrew: Do you go through shuffle or just like in order?

[40:48] Allison: Unshuffle. Unshuffle, baby. And usually, I make safe for work playlists that I'm like, okay, if I leave this running and I leave the room, it's not gonna be something weird and super not work appropriate.

[41:02] Andrew: But you patrons wouldn't hear that, right?

[41:05] Allison: No, no, no, no. Not in any way, but like my coworkers would, and I don't want to put them through anything they don't want to be put through when it comes to music. However, with Glee, I never know what the fuck is gonna come out of my phone. Like, I always pause it when I leave the room because I'm like, I could come back and it's the talking song by Will Schuster, like "Make 'Em Laugh," the weird part at the beginning, which I cannot handle. Or it's gonna be something like it's just on like my favorite, "Touch-a, Touch-a, Touch Me."

[41:38] Andrew: Oh no.

[41:40] Allison: I know. So I have to pause it when I leave the room. But when we played it on shuffle today, "My Favorite Things" played, and my coworker and I were like, um, this is not a Christmas song. Literally already had this conversation today.

[41:54] Andrew: Oh my god.

[41:59] Allison: So I kind of love that. When it comes down to it though, "My Favorite Things" versus "Little Girls."

[42:00] Andrew: "Little Girls."

[42:05] Allison: I think it's also "Little Girls" for me.

[42:08] Andrew: No, I did not say I'm not voting "Little Girls." That's not my vote.

[42:11] Allison: Oh, wait, what is your, is your vote "My Favorite Things"?

[42:14] Andrew: I think my vote is "My Favorite Things," which makes Nicole the tiebreaker. I need to say that I need to get myself in good graces with the Sue fandom. With the Sue fans. Because I've just like turned my back too many times on Sue songs. I think every single time, with Sue songs. So hey, this is me. This is me trying.

[42:41] Allison: Nicole, where is it?

[42:43] Nicole Crowther: Oh goodness. No pressure here. No, I think I'm gonna have to go with "My Favorite Things."

[42:47] Andrew: What was it? "My Little Things," "My Favorite Things."

[42:49] Nicole Crowther: "My Favorite Things." Thank you. Yeah, just the ensemble. I like that.

[42:54] Allison: Okay.

[42:55] Andrew: It is two songs, both from musicals.

[42:58] Allison: That's true.

[42:59] Andrew: At the end of the day.

[43:00] Allison: And movie musicals.

[43:01] Andrew: And Fox original live musicals.

[43:05] Allison: Oh, that's true. Wait, wait, did they do the wait, no?

[43:10] Andrew: Wait, they didn't do any live.

[43:11] Allison: I was thinking about the camera.

[43:14] Andrew: That's not a music was Fox with Carrie Underwood.

[43:17] Allison: I think that was NBC.

[43:20] Andrew: Nicole, do you have any knowledge of it?

[43:23] Nicole Crowther: No.

[43:23] Allison: Damn it.

[43:24] Nicole Crowther: No, I don't. I can Google it real quick.

[43:28] Andrew: I think it no, it's okay. I think it was like the NBC that does the "Hairspray," "The Wiz," "Sound of Music," "Peter Pan." I think that was NBC, not Fox.

[43:30] Allison: Who did "Grease"?

[43:30] Andrew: I think it was a different network. The Gleeks are still gonna come after me, even though it's not.

[44:45] Allison: The Gleeks are gonna come after me. You know who would have been on, speaking of "Grease Live," I'm just gonna change the subject here. Who would have been on Glee is Jordan Fisher. I fully believe that Jordan Fisher would have been on Glee.

[44:45] Andrew: Andrew, you do not know who that is.

[44:45] Allison: Cause I've already talked about him.

[44:45] Andrew: Yeah, wait, that name sounds like, wait, you were talking about him last night.

[44:45] Allison: I was talking about him last night. He is Evan Hansen in "Dear Evan Hansen" when "Dear Evan Hansen" comes back to Broadway. He was in Glee or Grease. He was in "Grease Live." I don't know what character he played, though. I don't know the name of the character.

[44:45] Andrew: And you also don't know the network, apparently.

[44:45] Allison: Apparently, I don't. I think it's Fox. I'm gonna go down with that ship that it's Fox and um oh god. Okay. No, it's okay. It's okay. It's okay. Wait. No, I drew a song. I drew a song.

[44:43] Andrew: Oh, you already drew the song, hasn't you? This is how I'm reacting, and the Gleeks are gonna get mad at me.

[44:49] Allison: Oh wait, okay, I'm scared.

[45:15] ♪ Musical number: "Not the Boy Next Door" — performed by Kurt Hummel ♪

[46:59] Andrew: Um, Allison, last night we were having a conversation. This is how sick our conversations are. Is that um again? This is like wow, you had you talked about "My Favorite Things" today. We talked about this song last night.

[47:16] Allison: Yeah, but we talk about Glee every single night. Listeners, just let it be known. It's not always recorded. There's hours of content that nobody's heard. You like asked me what the best Kurt solo was. And I guess this. I think this is my third guess. I think I wanted you to guess what my favorite Kurt solo was.

[47:43] Andrew: Yeah, and I guessed this song. And you had like a very strong negative reaction to this song.

[47:50] Allison: Yeah. For some reason, this is his NYADA audition. For some reason, I think "I Am the Greatest Star" was his NYADA audition.

[47:59] Andrew: What was that?

[48:00] Allison: That was his audition for "West Side Story."

[48:03] Andrew: Oh, I get those two mixed up.

[48:06] Allison: Yeah. No, I don't. For some reason. So being so deep into Tumblr in like 2011, 2012, and being on the Klaine side of Tumblr, I saw a lot of that like Kurt hip roll. Right. Is like burned into my sides of Tumblr. The regular side and then the Klaine side. There's an entire like Klaine fans were cuckoo crazy. I mean, Glee fans in general are cuckoo crazy, and I'm saying that as a Klaine and Glee fan. I am cuckoo crazy. But Klaine fans were just a whole nother thing. I can't tell you the amount of fan fiction that I read that should not have been written. And also, you created fan fiction, but I also did create Klaine fan fiction, so I fed into the obsession.

[49:03] Andrew: Yeah.

[49:03] Allison: However, this it's not Kurt. Like it doesn't feel Kurt, and that's why Whoopi Goldberg is like, no, this is not you. This is very showman. Stop it. Like, no, it's not. It's not.

[49:20] Andrew: No, because you're getting your glacks wrong. You're getting your glacks wrong here.

[49:25] Allison: My glacks?

[49:26] Andrew: Yeah. Your Glee facts. Because Whoopi Goldberg actually says that this was a very good performance. I forget her exact wording, but she likes the performance, which is why it's like met like a few episodes later with such surprise that he doesn't actually get into NYADA.

[49:47] Allison: Did you see Whoopi Goldberg's face that whole entire performance? She was like, Whoopi Goldberg has an ego. She can do whatever she wants with her goddamn face.

[49:57] Andrew: Nicole!

[49:58] Nicole Crowther: Uh-huh.

[50:00] Andrew: Yes, please. Please save us.

[50:04] Andrew: Yeah, I mean, uh again, Kurt, I adore him. Everything he does is so cute. I just love him. Um, I don't know if this is one of his strongest performances, but uh you know, I think it was, I think it spoke to him, and I agree. Whoopi Goldberg didn't look very super impressed, but um, you know, again, yeah, she can do whatever she wants, and um it's true. Yeah, it's the same face that she has every morning on The View whenever Megan McCain is speaking.

[50:34] Allison: Exactly. Um not the boy next door is Megan McCain.

[50:45] Andrew: Um do we do we can Megan McCain?

[50:49] Allison: Megan McCain is the boy next door.

[50:52] Andrew: Okay, you're just like trying, you're trying to say like episode titles right now. You're trying to say episode titles.

[51:01] Allison: This song.

[51:02] Andrew: Okay, wait, bring it back. This song, The Boy from Oz.

[51:06] Allison: I don't know what that is.

[51:07] Andrew: Anybody know what The Boy from Oz is?

[51:11] Allison: No.

[51:12] Andrew: No.

[51:12] Allison: Okay. That is that a musical?

[51:15] Andrew: They make reference to it in this episode that they're like, I'm like Kurt's like, oh, I was thinking about doing um like uh an homage to Hugh Jackman's performance at the Tonies where he does the like the Boy from Oz song. I I've never heard of the Boy from Oz outside of this show. This is just such a deep-seated Broadway reference that feels weird to me.

[51:39] Allison: Yeah. I feel safe about this song. We'll see what I have.

[51:43] Andrew: Are you sure? I wouldn't.

[51:45] Allison: Oh, I have a season one song of a really great final performance. Here we go.

[51:50] Andrew: Hurrah!

[51:55] ♪ Musical number: "Bad Romance" — performed by Lady Gaga ♪

[54:18] Andrew: Okay, Nicole, tell us how you felt about this performance.

[54:22] Nicole Crowther: Season one in general. Yeah. Okay, well, so I mean, season one. Okay, okay. Actually, you guys asked me, and I do think like the first generation of Glee, I just that's I think more my jam with them. Um I'm absolutely in love with Diana Agron. So everything about that performance with her on point. And I mean, who doesn't love Lady Gaga? And I think they had such a fun time with that, and it looks like with all their different outfits, and like as in general, I just I really liked that performance. I thought it was a lot of fun. It was so good. I loved all the costumes. I like I like it's hard to even like pick like a favorite costume. Oh, Santana in the bodysuit with a big bow on her head. Sign me up.

Like quick with with that like hoop at the end of her skirt. I am in love. And she's pregnant at this time too. She's fully pregnant. She's like two episodes away from giving birth. Um my god. I mean, I I love it. I love the costumes. I think Rachel's sewn together dress of stuffed animals is great.

[55:33] Allison: Oh funny. Um, she did where where did the dress go that her mom made her, Adina Menzel?

[55:40] Nicole Crowther: So, like she made this one, like this was like an homage to the Kermit the Frog Lady Gaga dress. And and she made that by herself, and then she showed up to Adina Menzel, who she just realized was her mom, and was like, look how tragic it is without a mom that this is the best I can do with Lady Gaga dress. And then minutes later they sing Poker Face.

[56:04] Allison: Yes.

[56:04] Nicole Crowther: And Adina Menzel is like, actually, I don't want to be in your life. I don't want to be your mom. Um contracts up.

[56:15] Allison: Um, this song means just like okay. So I just remember watching this this song, this episode with my parents. We watched the first season on the DVD box set, and and so like we would watch like an episode like every night or every other night, and we got to this episode. I remember my mom when she got to this performance, like a quarter of the way through this performance was like pause, and she was like, I need to go do things before I can like finish the rest of this song. It was just like it was too much for her.

[56:53] Nicole Crowther: Oversimulating.

[56:54] Allison: It was it was overstimulating, too much costumes. I don't know. I simply don't know. But then like a few years later, when I had my first boyfriend, we I like I put I like like threw the line out there, and I was like, hey, by any chance, do you watch Glee? And he turned out to be a very big Glee fan as well. And his like uh memorable moment with the series was highlighting this performance. Was he every time that he would like put like uh easy mac in the microwave, he instead of like setting a timer, he would put this song on, and whenever it got to the Santana part, um, where she speaks French, that's when he knew to like take it out. That's how you know your easy mac is done. Um but so I mean this song just I I think it's so funny. I think it's just hilarious. I love it. Wait, what was it against? It was it's against not the boy next door. I think all of our votes are obvious.

[58:03] Andrew: Yeah.

[58:04] Nicole Crowther: Wait, I don't want to speak for Nicole.

[58:06] Andrew: You don't even know. I said Nicole as a way to say her vote.

[58:11] Nicole Crowther: Yes.

[58:11] Andrew: I forgot what the other song was even. Go I guess.

[58:15] Nicole Crowther: It's Bad Romance all the way.

[58:17] Andrew: So I pulled all of the losers again this episode.

[58:20] Nicole Crowther: Oh my god, wait, but I like I voted against two of the three, so it doesn't count.

[58:26] Andrew: Does that count? Does that count as me having all of the losers?

[58:30] Nicole Crowther: Yes.

[58:32] Andrew: Um yeah, so all the winners are I Wish, My Favorite Things, and Bad Romance, and you have the losers.

[58:39] Nicole Crowther: All of the losers are You're On, I Need to Get By, Little Girls, and Not the Boy Next Door.

[58:45] Andrew: Oh gosh, I feel like the Gleeks are really gonna be upset about Not the Boy Next Door.

[58:50] Nicole Crowther: I don't think the Gleeks, the Gleeks, hear me out. Listeners. When it comes down to what's my favorite Kurt Solo again? Being Alive. Okay. When it comes to Being Alive, that is the Kurt Solo I will fight for. Being Alive is going to the next round of the Glacket. It will at least make it to the third round. I'm not I'm not gonna promise the fourth. Okay, but it will go. Being Alive will make it to the third round. Being Alive will make it to the third round. That is the Kurt solo I will fight for, Not the Boy Next Door, and maybe I Am the Greatest Star will probably not pass the first round. I mean you've already turned your back on one of them, so I've already turned my back on I Am the Greatest Star. Whenever we pull it, whether I have it, whether I have it, I'm putting it back in.

[59:35] Andrew: Wow.

[59:36] Nicole Crowther: So it's the last song we ever listened to in this round. Oh, my question. I forgot. Nicole.

[59:44] Andrew: At the end of every episode to wrap up, I ask all of our guests if Glee was still on in 2021 today. Because it's a Tuesday, and Glee aired on Tuesdays. What are they singing? What are they performing?

[1:00:00] Nicole Crowther: Oh my goodness. Today, as in right now. Oh, what am I listening to? Uh Bad Habits by Ed Sheeran.

[01:00:08] Andrew: Yes.

[01:00:10] Nicole Crowther: Yes. Oh, for sure. Yes. Wait, who do you think would sing it? Who would you want to sing it?

[01:00:13] Nicole Crowther: Maybe Santana. She had that edge.

[01:00:15] Andrew: That edge to her.

[01:00:17] Nicole Crowther: Yeah.

[01:00:18] Andrew: Yeah. That'd be good. I feel like Glee would do like the whole dedication in the music video too. Like they'd all be in the makeup and it'd be.

[01:00:25] Nicole Crowther: Oh, wait, is that the like the vampire one?

[01:00:28] Andrew: Yeah.

[01:00:28] Nicole Crowther: Yeah.

[01:00:28] Andrew: Well, I think yeah, he's dressed up all yeah, yeah, yeah.

[01:00:31] Nicole Crowther: Yeah.

[01:00:32] Andrew: I feel like there's a whole era. Did they do any Ed Sheeran songs on Glee?

[01:00:38] Nicole Crowther: They did one. They did sing in the final season. The Warblers did.

[01:00:43] Andrew: Oh my god, I forgot about that.

[01:00:45] Nicole Crowther: That's a whole thing that Glee could have done.

[01:00:48] Andrew: Is a whole Ed Sheeran episode.

[01:00:51] Nicole Crowther: Like The A Team.

[01:00:52] Andrew: Who do you think puts in that?

[01:00:54] Nicole Crowther: Oh. Wait, did they not do The A Team?

[01:00:57] Andrew: They did not do The A Team.

[01:00:59] Nicole Crowther: Oh, dang.

[01:01:00] Andrew: I thought they did.

[01:01:01] Nicole Crowther: Yeah. That would have been a good one for real, yeah.

[01:01:03] Andrew: Right?

[01:01:04] Nicole Crowther: Happier, happier would definitely.

[01:01:06] Andrew: It would have been happier, happier.

[01:01:08] Nicole Crowther: Happier, happier.

[01:01:09] Andrew: Yeah.

[01:01:09] Nicole Crowther: Ed Sheeran's Happier, mashed up with Olivia Rodrigo's Happier.

[01:01:13] Andrew: Wow. Perfect. Ryan Murphy.

[01:01:16] Nicole Crowther: Please.

[01:01:18] Andrew: Call us up. We have ideas.

[01:01:20] Nicole Crowther: These are missed opportunities. Come on.

[01:01:24] Andrew: Nicole.

[01:01:25] Nicole Crowther: Um the Gleeks want to know where they can find you. Anything that you want to promote. What's going on?

[01:01:31] Nicole Crowther: Um, probably just Instagram is the easiest. It's where I chat with people and you know keep up with everything. Uh it's literally my name. It's at Nicole Crowther.

[01:01:41] Andrew: Amazing.

[01:01:44] Nicole Crowther: Yeah.

[01:01:45] Andrew: To end every episode, what we do is we just say bye in the most annoying voice.

[01:01:52] Nicole Crowther: Perfect.

[01:01:53] Andrew: And we do it after one, okay? Three, two, one.

[01:01:59] All: Bye.

[01:02:01] Andrew: This has been Gleek of the Week, hosted by Andrew McGuire and Allison Dodge. Make sure to follow us on Instagram. I'm at Allison Dodge. And you can follow me at McGuiGuy, M C G U Y underscore G U Y. And you can even follow the show's page at Gleek of the Week Pod on Instagram and TikTok. Our theme song is mixed by Joe Graves. And the cover art was done by Elias Williams. Don't forget to subscribe. And if you'd like to be a Gleek of the Week, email us at Gleek of the Weekpod at gmail.com. We'd love to have you on.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred