Skip to main content
BPN Logo
THE PROM

“Note to self: Don’t be gay in Indiana.” In this final installment of the QUEER SERIES, showbiz siblings Kristen and Sarah Goodman dive into one of Broadway’s most adorable, hilarious, and wholesome gay shows: THE PROM!.. Read More

From the show: GOOD SHOW! with Sarah Goodman

35 mins
8/13/24

Featured Shows

About

“Note to self: Don’t be gay in Indiana.” In this final installment of the QUEER SERIES, showbiz siblings Kristen and Sarah Goodman dive into one of Broadway’s most adorable, hilarious, and wholesome gay shows: THE PROM! Find out what Kristen and Sarah loved most about this lovable and affirming piece of theater, and discover “How Queer Is It?” in their final rating of the series. “Build a prom for everyone! Show them all it can be done!”

Good Show Instagram: @goodshowpodcast

Good Show Tik Tok: @goodshowpodcast

broadwaycares.org

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Kristen Goodman: Hi, I'm Kristen Goodman.

[0:02] Sarah Goodman: I'm Sarah Goodman, and we're Showbiz Siblings.

[0:06] Kristen Goodman: We live in New York City.

[0:08] Sarah Goodman: We're both queer, and we love musical theater.

[0:11] Kristen Goodman: This is our podcast.

[0:25] Sarah Goodman: Hey everyone, it's our finale of our queer series, and we're talking about The Prom.

[0:32] Kristen Goodman: What a great way to end the queer series.

[0:34] Sarah Goodman: Proms usually happen at the end of the school year. And so this is our wrap-up of the queer series.

[0:39] Kristen Goodman: Yeah.

[0:40] Sarah Goodman: The Prom is a beautiful and hilarious musical that opened on November 16th, 2018 at the Longacre Theater.

[0:49] Kristen Goodman: It was originally conceived by Jack Vertell and based on loosely based on a true story. Um, the book was written by Bob Martin and Chad Beglin.

[0:59] Sarah Goodman: Bob Martin also wrote The Drowsy Chaperone and played Man in Chair. So another little Beth Level connection.

[1:06] Kristen Goodman: The music was written by Matthew Sklar and Chad Beglin. And it was directed and choreographed by Casey Nicholaw, who we love.

[1:14] Sarah Goodman: We love Casey Nicholaw.

[1:15] Kristen Goodman: We love Casey Nicholaw.

[1:16] Sarah Goodman: And Casey Nicholaw was in the chorus of Victor/Victoria when we watched Victor/Victoria at Talk.

[1:26] Kristen Goodman: So what's it about? Tell us the plot.

[1:27] Sarah Goodman: Yeah, so it starts off with an opening night on Broadway, and it's a musical called Eleanor.

[1:35] Kristen Goodman: It's about Eleanor Roosevelt. And these two very vapid Broadway stars are celebrating themselves and being very narcissistic.

[1:43] Sarah Goodman: And they're at the opening night party, and suddenly the reviews start pouring in about Eleanor, and they are scathing.

[1:50] Kristen Goodman: Everybody in the show is getting called out for their narcissism. The two stars, Dee Dee and Barry, are played by Beth Level and Brooks Ashmankas.

[1:59] Sarah Goodman: I hope I'm saying that right, Brooks.

[2:02] Kristen Goodman: And they're hilarious.

[2:04] Sarah Goodman: They are absolutely so, so, so, so funny. They're just like the perfect caricature of like a self-important actor type who's, you know, at the top of their game.

[2:16] Kristen Goodman: Um, and so the show gets terrible reviews and it immediately closes. And they're like, what are we gonna do? We need to like fix our image.

[2:25] Sarah Goodman: They bump into some friends at the party, a guy named Trent, who's a Juilliard grad, played by Christopher Sieber, he's hilarious, and a Fosse dancer played by Angie Schworer, perfectly named Angie.

[2:39] Kristen Goodman: Pretty sure the part was written for her.

[2:42] Sarah Goodman: For Angie. Um, and we love her. And she was also in Some Like It Hot. Love her in that.

[2:48] Kristen Goodman: So the four stars are like, what are we gonna do? We gotta figure out a way to make ourselves look good and kind of get back in the good graces of the fans.

[2:57] Sarah Goodman: And so they start looking around the internet for some kind of cause to support, and they find this girl Emma, who's a lesbian in Indiana who is denied going to prom with her girlfriend.

[3:09] Kristen Goodman: And there's like a court case surrounding it and all this stuff. So they're like, here's what we're gonna do. We're gonna get on a bus and go to Indiana and help this girl Emma.

[3:19] Sarah Goodman: And they sing this hilarious song where they're like, we're gonna help that little lesbian. It's really funny.

[3:25] Kristen Goodman: Um, the lyrics are so, so funny in this whole show. Uh, so they go they storm their way down to Indiana, they meet Emma.

[3:35] Sarah Goodman: There's this hilarious moment in the PTA conference where Beth Level pops up and sings this song, It's Not About Me.

[3:45] Kristen Goodman: And there's so many hilarious lines in that show in that song. Like, how can you silence a woman who's known for her belt?

[3:49] Sarah Goodman: Her belt.

[3:56] Kristen Goodman: Yeah, that song is so, so funny. Um, so then we find out uh there's another conflict in the story.

[4:04] Sarah Goodman: Emma's girlfriend is the daughter of the head of the PTA, who's like the main person who is fighting against Emma being involved in the prom.

[4:13] Kristen Goodman: And so her girlfriend's in the closet. It's all of this like really kind of high-stakes emotional stuff with these kids.

[4:22] Sarah Goodman: The Broadway stars do their best to kind of bring some acceptance to the community.

[4:29] Kristen Goodman: They do a pop-up performance at a monster truck rally where they sing a song about acceptance and try to get everybody to, you know, hold hands and love each other.

[4:38] Sarah Goodman: It doesn't go very well.

[4:39] Kristen Goodman: They get booed, they get booed off the stage. It's really awful. They actually don't do much of anything. They're kind of just in the way all the time.

[4:46] Sarah Goodman: There's a fun subplot where Dee Dee kind of has the little budding romance with the school principal that's very fun.

[4:53] Kristen Goodman: There's a really great little subplot about how the bus they take to Indiana is a bus from a non-equity tour of Godspell.

[5:01] Sarah Goodman: So the cast of Godspell keeps popping up here and there.

[5:05] Kristen Goodman: Um, unfortunately, when it comes to prom night, they think they've won.

[5:05] Sarah Goodman: They think they've won. They get Emma all dressed up, they're so excited, they show up to the prom and no one is there.

[5:19] Kristen Goodman: Emma's been tricked. They've done two proms. They held a different prom for all the other kids and a prom for Emma by herself.

[5:27] Sarah Goodman: And so she gets totally punked by the whole school and all her friends, and even her girlfriend, Alyssa, who claims to not know anything about it, and we choose to believe her, but Emma does not.

[5:39] Kristen Goodman: So that's a whole nother conflict now. The prom's been ruined, Emma's been humiliated.

[5:45] Sarah Goodman: And then in act two, we come back and try to figure out kind of how to rectify this whole situation.

[5:50] Kristen Goodman: Emma decides to make like a viral video of herself singing a song and playing guitar about being gay and what it's like.

[5:58] Sarah Goodman: And then tons of other kids come out online, which is so sweet. That scene made me cry.

[6:04] Kristen Goodman: So eventually the Broadway stars pool all of their credit cards together and decide to go into tons of debt to throw another prom, one that everyone can go to.

[6:15] Sarah Goodman: And so they invite people from all over the state and the region to come. And it's sort of more like a gay prom, right?

[6:21] Kristen Goodman: I mean, they're making it more inclusive, and when we get to that scene, they have all these cute little queer-looking couples come out, and straight couples too. It's a whole mixed bag of people.

[6:33] Sarah Goodman: Um, and then we get some like rectified situation with uh Emma and her girlfriend. Her girlfriend comes out to her mom, it's a little rough, but it ends up being okay.

[6:42] Kristen Goodman: And we have a beautiful little happy ending. It's so, so sweet.

[6:44] Sarah Goodman: Yeah.

[6:46] Kristen Goodman: And there's a little kiss on stage, which was adorable to see.

[6:50] Sarah Goodman: So heartwarming.

[6:50] Kristen Goodman: So heartwarming.

[6:51] Sarah Goodman: And also the show made huge history because they performed that finale number on the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade, and it was the first lesbian kiss on the parade ever.

[7:06] Kristen Goodman: And so that was televised, you know, national TV, and made a really, really big impact on queer people and visibility, and I know that made a big difference for a lot of young people out there.

[7:18] Sarah Goodman: Yeah. So, you know, what you said about the kiss being like making waves at the Thanksgiving Day Parade makes me think of like kind of just this historical context that we've been trying to add into the queer series.

[7:30] Kristen Goodman: This show obviously is the most recent to have opened on Broadway in our whole series. So the historical context doesn't feel like that long ago, but you know, a lot has happened since 2018, and the world is a very different place than it was like, you know, pre-pandemic times.

[7:47] Sarah Goodman: Um, but yeah, as you mentioned, it opened in the end of 2018 and ran for nine months, played over 300 performances.

[7:55] Kristen Goodman: Um, the national tour was delayed by the pandemic, but um toured 20 cities in 2022.

[8:03] Sarah Goodman: Um, The Prom was nominated for seven Tony Awards and won the Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Musical.

[8:11] Kristen Goodman: Um, the other notable shows that opened on Broadway in the 2018-2019 season were um Frozen, Harry Potter and the Cursed Child, Mean Girls, Beetlejuice, and Hadestown, which ended up just sweeping the Tonys, um, won Best Musical and seven other Tonys that year.

[8:31] Sarah Goodman: So, you know, even though The Prom got a lot of noms, Hadestown kind of swept it up that year.

[8:37] Kristen Goodman: Um, and as you mentioned, Sarah, it is based on the real-life case from Fulton, Mississippi, where a high school student named Constance McMillan was banned from attending her high school prom because she planned to bring a girl as her date.

[8:50] Sarah Goodman: And so Constance McMillan and the ACLU sued the school, and then celebrities like Green Day and Lance Bass and others got involved and they showed their support on social media and agreed to help sponsor this like second chance prom.

[9:03] Kristen Goodman: So kind of cute that they referenced that in the story, but then maybe more fun that they put it in Indiana.

[9:11] Sarah Goodman: Yeah.

[9:12] Kristen Goodman: It's definitely funnier for some reason than Mississippi.

[9:16] Sarah Goodman: Yeah.

[9:17] Kristen Goodman: Um, you mentioned the kiss in the Thanksgiving Day Parade. There was also another kind of first um with this company.

[9:25] Sarah Goodman: So uh in August of 2019, after a performance of one of the shows, um, one of the performances at the Longacre Theater, they had the first ever Broadway on stage same-sex wedding ceremony, or maybe the first on stage wedding period on Broadway.

[9:44] Kristen Goodman: Um, but I guess there was like a script coordinator on the show and a singer and actress friend of the show's musical director who were getting married, and so they had their wedding like on stage of The Prom.

[9:56] Sarah Goodman: Yeah.

[9:56] Kristen Goodman: Oh my god. After one of the performances in August 2019. So that's so cute.

[10:01] Sarah Goodman: Yeah, and this is, you know, this was like in that era of same-sex marriage becoming legalized.

[10:07] Kristen Goodman: Um, you know, it became legalized in the United States in 2015, and then there was this wave of legalization around the world over the next several years.

[10:14] Sarah Goodman: Like many different countries started to pass legislation legalizing same-sex marriage. In liberal states like New York and California, um, they were passing pro-LGBTQ equality legislation, but then you know, conservative states were trying to ban trans people from using the bathroom.

[10:33] Kristen Goodman: This is this whole like bathroom time period.

[10:35] Sarah Goodman: Um, following the inauguration of Trump in 2017, all mentions of LGBT were removed from the White House website, and they withdrew the guidelines for transgender students in public schools with regard to bathrooms.

[10:50] Kristen Goodman: So The Prom opened kind of emits this like wave of pro-LGBTQ acceptance and equality in legislation, but then also this like huge backlash in the Trump administration.

[11:07] Sarah Goodman: So kind of an interesting time, and you know, not that long ago, but definitely feels like a different world away pre-pandemic.

[11:16] Kristen Goodman: Yeah, definitely.

[11:17] Sarah Goodman: It really does. Just the tone of the show, too.

[11:22] Kristen Goodman: I think has a lightheartedness to it that we haven't really seen in many shows since the pandemic on Broadway.

[11:32] Sarah Goodman: Right.

[11:33] Kristen Goodman: Yeah.

[11:33] Sarah Goodman: Yeah. So tell us about um you mentioned the people who wrote the show and created the show, but tell us about um the creative team and the cast and that for this Broadway production.

[11:44] Kristen Goodman: So, as I said before, Casey Nicholaw was the director and choreographer who we love, and such an interesting overlap of connections with Casey Nicholaw and the other shows in the queer series and these other performers that are in The Prom and in some of the other shows he's done in the future.

[12:00] Sarah Goodman: So that's really cool. Um, the set design was Scott Pask. I thought the set was pretty cute.

[12:07] Kristen Goodman: Yeah, so cute.

[12:08] Sarah Goodman: Very cute. Um, I really loved when they did the big fan fun at the end, like the big gay prom at the end. They had all these cutouts of skyscrapers, which is just one of my favorite things.

[12:21] Kristen Goodman: Yeah, you love a skyline.

[12:22] Sarah Goodman: I love a skyline look, you know. Um, so that was super cute. And the Applebee's set was really adorable.

[12:28] Kristen Goodman: Applebee's was adorable.

[12:29] Sarah Goodman: Do you think they got a brand deal with Applebee's? They had to use the real logo and everything.

[12:35] Kristen Goodman: Yeah, otherwise I think they would have had to have changed the name to something else. I do have an inside scoop because my colleagues slash bosses at BPN were both producers on The Prom, Dory Bernstein and Kim Garris. So shout out to them for raising the money to do this show because it's such an adorable show.

[12:53] Sarah Goodman: It really is. It made a big impact on me. The costumes were designed by Matthew Pactman and Anne Roth. There were so many amazing blazers.

[13:01] Kristen Goodman: So many sparkly jackets.

[13:03] Sarah Goodman: Holy shit. Sparkly jackets. Wow, wow, wow. Also, every single costume Beth Level wore was gorge.

[13:09] Kristen Goodman: Gorgeous.

[13:09] Sarah Goodman: Gorgie and Gorgin. Gorgine Gorgine. Um, Natasha Katz did the lighting. We love her. She's the Tony Queen. Uh, Brian Ronin did the sound design. It sounded great in person.

[13:23] Kristen Goodman: Yeah.

[13:23] Sarah Goodman: Uh, when I saw it with Jessica in July of 2019, I was really impressed with the sound. The band is nice and full, and I was in the balcony, so it's always impressive if it sounds good in the balcony. So shout out to the creatives on that show because it was very cohesive, it was very cute, it was really believable. I really loved all the Godspell costumes, the people in the Godspell chorus who would just pop up out of nowhere.

[13:46] Kristen Goodman: That's so cute.

[13:47] Sarah Goodman: Um, and so the cast, fabulous cast. I think this is one of the few times besides maybe some of the cast members in Fun Home where the lead actor playing a gay character is actually queer in real life.

[14:01] Kristen Goodman: Caitlin can in it.

[14:03] Sarah Goodman: Um, so that was very cool. I also really liked seeing that casting because Caitlin is sort of an atypical type for a leading role.

[14:10] Kristen Goodman: Uh-huh.

[14:11] Sarah Goodman: She's what people call mid-sized.

[14:13] Kristen Goodman: Right.

[14:14] Sarah Goodman: So am I. Um, and I really appreciated that. Like seeing someone who's a little unconventional and also queer was like such a big deal for me, being such a big Broadway fan and really not seeing myself on stage a lot.

[14:27] Kristen Goodman: Yeah.

[14:27] Sarah Goodman: But shockingly, seeing it twice at the Long Acre.

[14:30] Kristen Goodman: Ha ha.

[14:30] Sarah Goodman: Yeah. Dee Dee Allen is Beth Level, as we mentioned before.

[14:35] Kristen Goodman: Beth Level, wow.

[14:36] Sarah Goodman: She's incredible. Every song she sings in this show is like an 11 o'clock number.

[14:41] Kristen Goodman: It is.

[14:41] Sarah Goodman: And she just makes it look so easy. It's just like these huge notes are just flying out of her mouth like it's no big deal. She holds out so many long belting notes in this show.

[14:50] Kristen Goodman: So many long notes.

[14:51] Sarah Goodman: It's so good. That "It's Not About Me" song. Go look it up on YouTube, y'all. Hopefully, there's a bootleg or something out there. Or go to Toft just to see that number because it is so good.

[14:57] Kristen Goodman: So good.

[15:03] Sarah Goodman: Uh, Barry Glickman was played by Brooks Eshmankis, um, who we know from Songs for a New World. Amazing.

[15:10] Kristen Goodman: He was very funny and cute as well.

[15:14] Sarah Goodman: So cute. And just like clearly, he's like very much a dancer because his like movement around this, like just the way he carried himself on stage was like really supposed to be channeling this like actor, dancer, Broadway star kind of thing. But he just did it so well, you know.

[15:31] Kristen Goodman: Um, he was always doing little like moves or little kicks, little prancy dances around.

[15:36] Sarah Goodman: Yeah.

[15:36] Kristen Goodman: Yeah.

[15:37] Sarah Goodman: Yeah, it was funny. It was like his nervous stem was like dance like choreo.

[15:41] Kristen Goodman: Exactly.

[15:42] Sarah Goodman: It was really cute. So funny and cute. And the friendship that he builds with the Emma character is very beautiful.

[15:47] Kristen Goodman: So precious, and I loved that intergenerational gay, you know, storyline of Barry's own experience with his estranged mother, and like not being able to be authentic and like coming out to her, like ruined his relationship with her, and like he didn't get to really go to his own prom and like he's sort of living vicariously through Emma and her experience.

[16:09] Sarah Goodman: So cute.

[16:10] Kristen Goodman: Yeah, and Emma was kicked out of the house when she came out, so she doesn't really have parents. She lives with her grandma, who we never meet, and so these goofy Broadway stars who come into town sort of become her chosen family parental sort of figures, which is really sweet.

[16:27] Sarah Goodman: Yeah. The girlfriend Alyssa Green was played by Isabel McCollow, and she was great.

[16:32] Kristen Goodman: She's currently in Water for Elephants on Broadway.

[16:35] Sarah Goodman: Nice. Trent Oliver, the Juilliard grad, was played by Christopher Sieber, who we love. We saw him in Company as Harry. And I recently saw him in Death Becomes Her, which is coming to Broadway next year.

[16:47] Kristen Goodman: It's gonna be really fun.

[16:49] Sarah Goodman: Angie Dickinson is played by Angie Schwarr, because it's Angie.

[16:52] Kristen Goodman: Angie for Angie.

[16:53] Sarah Goodman: We love Angie for Angie. Angie was truly one of my favorite things besides Beth Level when I saw the show because her dancing is so good. Her legs are so long.

[17:04] Kristen Goodman: Give it some Zaz.

[17:05] Sarah Goodman: Give it some Zaz. Zaz is such a great number. Oh my god, when she's like telling the story before Zaz about the Fosse dancer and how Fosse was like, give it some Zaz. And she's like, and that Emma says, and that dancer was you.

[17:18] Kristen Goodman: Yeah.

[17:26] Sarah Goodman: But she doesn't really say no. She doesn't say that, but if I had to guess, I'd say Angie's not the OG Fosse crew.

[17:39] Kristen Goodman: She's like the Fosse new era.

[17:41] Sarah Goodman: Fosse era, Fosse, the musical era crew. So like early 2000s.

[17:46] Kristen Goodman: Yeah.

[17:46] Sarah Goodman: Fosse crew. An Anne Ryan King Fosse girl, maybe.

[17:50] Kristen Goodman: Yeah.

[17:50] Sarah Goodman: Yeah. So that's pretty much the main cast of characters. It's worth mentioning that they also made a movie of The Prom in 2020. And the movie's delightful, but I have to say, Nicole Kidman is no replacement for Angie Schwarr.

[18:07] Kristen Goodman: Seriously.

[18:07] Sarah Goodman: Not even close. I mean, Nicole, you're gorgeous. You're a great actor, but you know dance like that.

[18:12] Kristen Goodman: She does not have Zaz.

[18:13] Sarah Goodman: She doesn't really have the Zaz. Not as good as Angie. But we have Ariana DeBose.

[18:18] Kristen Goodman: Yeah.

[18:18] Sarah Goodman: Fun, love her, and queer, which is exciting.

[18:22] Kristen Goodman: Yes. And funny fun fact, Meryl Streep plays the Beth Level part in the movie of The Prom.

[18:29] Sarah Goodman: Right. And Beth Level played the Meryl Streep part in the musical adaptation of Devil Wears Prada. So there's kind of a devil, or kind of a devil. There's kind of a Meryl Beth connection going on.

[18:40] Kristen Goodman: I don't really know what it is, but maybe they should be in a show together.

[18:44] Sarah Goodman: That would be amazing.

[18:45] Kristen Goodman: Wouldn't it?

[18:45] Sarah Goodman: Wow. That'd be really good.

[18:46] Kristen Goodman: They went ball together.

[18:50] Sarah Goodman: Known for her bath. And Andrew Rannells was also in the movie, right?

[18:54] Kristen Goodman: Andrew Rannells and James Corden.

[18:55] Sarah Goodman: Yeah.

[18:55] Kristen Goodman: So cute.

[18:57] Sarah Goodman: Yeah, super cute. So here I plea or his next dilemma. How do you silence a woman who's known for her belt?

[19:07] Kristen Goodman: Sing it, Eleanor.

[19:09] Sarah Goodman: Her belt! But it's not about me. Get them out of here. Now God afternoon.

[19:22] Kristen Goodman: I had only ever seen the movie before we went to see it at Toft, and um, I loved the show way more than I love the movie. The movie's so cute, but like the show was so hilarious.

[19:32] Sarah Goodman: Yeah, I feel like—

[19:34] Kristen Goodman: Oh go ahead.

[19:34] Sarah Goodman: They just like cut out so many of the theater jokes in the movie.

[19:37] Kristen Goodman: Which I mean, I guess makes sense, but like there were so many inside jokes about Broadway and theater in the show that are just so funny and like poking fun at ourselves, you know, and um, they just played into that like vapid narcissistic actor thing so well throughout so many jokes about that. Like when she's like, I read three quarters of a news story and I knew I had to come.

[20:06] Sarah Goodman: I love that.

[20:08] Kristen Goodman: Yes, I love that so much. Or when they're at the motel and she's like, Do you have a suite? And the guy's like, No, and she's like, What about now? And she pulls her Tony out of her purse.

[20:19] Sarah Goodman: He's like, What's that?

[20:21] Kristen Goodman: And then she pulls out another one. She's just carrying them around in her purse.

[20:24] Sarah Goodman: Those are heavy.

[20:25] Kristen Goodman: Yeah. Yeah, it just had like such an old-fashioned format, which I loved. Like, we had a real overture, a real entreact. Um, the pacing I thought was incredible. Like I loved how the interstitial music came in almost immediately after the button. Like you we got the satisfaction of the button at the end of a production number so that the audience can have that applause moment, but then we're immediately going right into the next thing, and the set is being whisked away and changed, and I just love the pacing of that.

[21:00] Sarah Goodman: It just kept my attention so well. I was like on my edge of my seat wanting to know what's happening with Emma.

[21:05] Kristen Goodman: I think that's really Casey Nicholaw because it felt very similar to the pacing of Some Like It Hot did, which is more like if an old school musical was born today.

[21:15] Sarah Goodman: Right.

[21:16] Kristen Goodman: Because it's got that classic musical theater aesthetic and sound and feel, but it's a very fresh context.

[21:27] Sarah Goodman: Right.

[21:27] Kristen Goodman: And it's fast.

[21:28] Sarah Goodman: Right. It's really fast.

[21:30] Kristen Goodman: Yeah.

[21:31] Sarah Goodman: I love that. Love that. Love all the transitions being really tight. So I think my favorite part of the show is the ladies improving.

[21:40] Kristen Goodman: So good.

[21:41] Sarah Goodman: Because it's just amazing. Beth Level. The fact that Beth Level does two 11 o'clock numbers, because "It's Not About Me" is in the beginning of the show. And it's basically an 11 o'clock number. It's sort of like "Show Off" from Drowsy Chaperone because she's just going the fuck off.

[21:59] Kristen Goodman: It's so good.

[22:00] Sarah Goodman: Um, what's another funny line from that song where she says that they said she was too white to play Eva Perón?

[22:11] Kristen Goodman: Eva Perón.

[22:19] Sarah Goodman: Oh my goodness. Oh my gosh.

[22:24] Kristen Goodman: I thought the whole storyline with Dee Dee and the principal was just so adorable and heartwarming. You know, like here's this big star who has spent most of her career in New York City, and she's in this tiny little Indiana town and kind of fallen in love with this adorable principal who is a fan.

[22:45] Sarah Goodman: And um, I thought that whole side plot was so cute. His affection for Dee Dee and their relationship and the environment sort of bring Dee Dee to become a little bit more selfless and a little less selfish. And she starts to kind of learn, oh maybe helping other people to help them, not just to make myself look good, is good, right?

[23:08] Kristen Goodman: Um, which is really sweet. It's this beautiful, unexpected outcome that some of the Broadway characters learn about helping other people for the sake of helping those other people and not just for their own self-interests is really sweet.

[23:25] Sarah Goodman: It's sweet that we get to see these narcissists sort of figure it out a little bit.

[23:29] Kristen Goodman: Right. Um, even though they went down there for their own fame and their own image, they end up actually helping someone and helping themselves, learning a little bit about themselves.

[23:40] Kristen Goodman: Yeah. There were a few other things I really loved at the end of the show. There's one moment where Trent is sort of giving a lecture to everybody about not really a lecture, but Trent is commenting about how the people in Indiana don't have any empathy, and it's because of their lack of a drama program. And he sort of won over all the teens in the town by singing this Love Thy Neighbor song with the Godspell cast, and they all really like him now. And they're like, "You should be our drama teacher." That was so funny. And he's like, "No, I couldn't." And then he's like, "Class, shh, class." Yeah, he says something like, "With a hatred stoked by centuries of intolerance and the lack of a drama program." Yes. That made me laugh so hard. So many funny lines. The book was so funny.

[24:31] Sarah Goodman: Oh, yeah. The book is hilarious. The book is absolutely hilarious. There's a million funny jokes. I couldn't even keep track, really.

[24:39] Kristen Goodman: Um, I think one of the lines I loved best was when Barry is talking about um they're creating the second chance prom and he says something like, "A distraction is momentary, but an escape is healing." And I feel like that really sums up what I love about good theater is that if it helps you escape, then it really is like this healing experience.

[25:16] Sarah Goodman: Yeah. And differentiating between just like, you know, frivolous distractions that are momentary and escapism, which is like has real value in the world. And I think, you know, as artists, we all go through different phases of, you know, trying to figure out what is our calling or what is our purpose for our art or whatever. And I think it was just great to hear that, like, you know, escapism has value in that it is healing for the audience, it's healing for everyone involved. Um, and this show especially, I think was just so joyful and heartwarming and healing for so many people.

[25:59] Kristen Goodman: Absolutely. Really, really important piece of theater. And I love that it's a comedy, yeah, but still has so much heart.

[26:07] Sarah Goodman: Yeah. And yeah, I couldn't love it anymore. I just think it's so fabulous. And rewatching it reminded me how many other songs in the score are so good. Because I frequently listen to the Beth Level tracks, I'll say. But yeah, I had forgotten about some of the other ones, and there's some really good, really good tunes in there.

[26:25] Kristen Goodman: Mm-hmm. Just helping people have a stepball change of heart.

[26:31] Sarah Goodman: Ball change. That's so good. Ugh, give it some Zaz.

[26:35] Kristen Goodman: Give it some Zaz.

[26:37] Sarah Goodman: Give it some Z.

[26:38] Kristen Goodman: So the age-old question is, how queer is it? So for the queer series, as you may have already been um hearing as we've been going through this series, we are rating the shows on the queer scale. The queerest show, the highest level is queer as fuck. Uh down from that, hella gay. The medium level is love is love. Below that is just fruity. And the lowest level on the queer meter for our series is Pete Buttigieg.

[27:14] Sarah Goodman: Yep. Which is still queer, everybody. Still queer. Just a little under the radar.

[27:19] Kristen Goodman: Right. Just not really in your face about it. So uh Sarah, what do you say about how queer is it? How queer is The Prom?

[27:30] Sarah Goodman: You know, I feel like this was kind of the rating I gave almost all the shows, but I'd say hella gay. I think this show is hella gay. They really don't let you forget it. They talk about it all the time, right from the get-go. They're like, "We're gonna go get that little lesbian and we're gonna help her." And um there's many different gay characters in the show, and it's a really great representation, I think, of a cross-section. It's not super intersectional. Um, but there is some great rep there. And again, like we've mentioned before, with lesbian characters, there are only four shows in the Broadway canon that have lead roles that are a lesbian, and this is one of them.

[28:13] Kristen Goodman: Yep. So that's pretty hella gay, I'd say. What about you?

[28:16] Sarah Goodman: I agree. I'm gonna say hella gay for this one. And uh to quote one of their lines, uh, "Gay is a bucket of wigs."

[28:24] Kristen Goodman: Yes. A bucket of them.

[28:27] Sarah Goodman: That's what Barry says when they first come into the PTA meeting. "I'm as gay as a bucket of wigs."

[28:33] Kristen Goodman: Yeah, and Trent goes, "We're liberal Democrats from Broadway." Yeah, I agree. Like they don't let you forget how gay the show is the whole time. They're constantly talking about it, they're constantly, you know, referencing Barry's personal experience, Emma's experience, Alyssa's experience. Um, everybody, you know, all the queer characters are definitely like going through their experience like the whole time, the whole plot of the show, which I love. And um, yeah, it wasn't super intersectional, but I don't think that's really the story, you know. This was based on a real-life thing, and so I think they were just like small town, rural, right? Just building this adorable, joyful story around this particular historical reference.

[29:21] Sarah Goodman: Yeah. Um, yeah. I don't really think it needs to be any queerer. Like it's the right hella gay is the right amount of gayness for The Prom, yeah.

[29:32] Kristen Goodman: Absolutely. Absolutely it is. I think it's perfect. It's very sweet. And even though it's like really outwardly very gay and very outspoken, it's still very accessible, I think. I don't think they hit you over the head with it. And I think for people who might be a little more center or right-leaning, maybe it would make them change their mind a little bit. Cause I agree. It's so beautiful and fun, and it would be pretty difficult to watch that show and be like, "I hate these characters."

[30:03] Sarah Goodman: Yeah.

[30:04] Kristen Goodman: Yeah. And they never um, they never really vilify the conservative locals in a way that would make it this like extreme us versus them. It's like they're not trying to be super judgmental of the conservative Indiana townspeople who you know don't want Emma to be able to be herself. Um, they just sort of like sweep over the fact that Alyssa's mom is like the coming out of Alyssa to her mom, like doesn't go great, but like the mom isn't painted as this like horrible evil person. Like they're giving her some room to evolve. And so I think that helps any audience members also kind of see maybe themselves or, you know, like have that stepball change of heart.

[30:58] Sarah Goodman: Yeah, yeah. But just so cute. I'm so glad we got to put this in the queer series and like get to see it at Toft. And um, if you are in the New York area and you want to go check it out at the Theater on Film and Tape collection at the New York Performing Arts Library and Lincoln Center, I we highly recommend you go check it out or just, you know, watch the movie because that's super cute too.

[31:22] Kristen Goodman: And um listen to that cast album with Beth Level belting it out.

[31:27] Sarah Goodman: Belting it out for sure.

[31:33] Kristen Goodman: Yeah, and you could do a double feature at Toft with Limpika. Do two long egg your lesbian shows, one after the other.

[31:40] Sarah Goodman: Love it. Any other final thoughts, Sarah?

[31:44] Kristen Goodman: Oh. I just really love this show. It made me feel so happy when I saw it. It made me feel seen. It made me feel like there's some hope for queer people coming up in musical theater to have more representation, to have more options for roles for themselves, to be a little bit less conventional about looks and type and things like that. So I think it's a really important piece of theater.

[32:11] Sarah Goodman: I agree. And I would imagine this will get performed a lot at high schools and colleges. And you know, I think that's just so great to have this kind of show be in the canon for students to be able to perform in someday. And um, yeah, get to be able to play roles that resonate with them and their authentic selves.

[32:30] Kristen Goodman: Yeah. So much fun. Well, we might be going on a short hiatus before we start our next series.

[32:36] Sarah Goodman: All shows written by Stephen Sondheim.

[32:41] Kristen Goodman: The king of Broadway.

[32:43] Sarah Goodman: Um, my favorite composer of all time. And I'm really excited to see what shows we're gonna pick. They have a lot of Sondheim shows at Toft.

[32:51] Kristen Goodman: And Sondheim has an enormous amount of work out there.

[32:54] Sarah Goodman: So it's gonna be hard to narrow it down.

[32:56] Kristen Goodman: Hard to narrow it down, or it's gonna be the longest series of all time.

[32:59] Sarah Goodman: We're just gonna do every single show.

[33:01] Kristen Goodman: Never ending.

[33:02] Sarah Goodman: So stay tuned for that.

[33:04] Kristen Goodman: Stay tuned for that. We're gonna watch all 12 different versions of Follies.

[33:09] Sarah Goodman: Oops, all Follies.

[33:10] Kristen Goodman: Oops, all Follies.

[33:14] Sarah Goodman: Can you imagine?

[33:17] Kristen Goodman: I'm still here.

[33:18] Sarah Goodman: Well, thanks for listening, y'all to the queer series. It's been really fun.

[33:23] Kristen Goodman: Yeah, it's been really gay.

[33:25] Sarah Goodman: It's been mostly hella gay.

[33:27] Kristen Goodman: Yeah.

[33:27] Sarah Goodman: Yeah.

[33:28] Kristen Goodman: All right.

[33:29] Sarah Goodman: Good show.

[33:30] Kristen Goodman: Good show.

[33:33] Sarah Goodman: Hey, Good Show listeners. For the QUEER SERIES, we're highlighting the work of a very special nonprofit organization, Broadway Cares Equity Fights AIDS. Since its founding in 1988, BCEFA has raised over 300 million dollars for critically needed services for people with AIDS, HIV, and other illnesses.

[33:56] Kristen Goodman: You may have seen the actors passing the donation buckets at the end of a national tour production or at a Broadway show.

[34:03] Sarah Goodman: Right. And Broadway Cares Equity Fights AIDS produces several big events like the Broadway Flea, Broadway Bears, and Broadway Barks with my girl Bernie P, just to name a few. The money they raise goes towards funding grants to over 450 AIDS and family service organizations across all 50 states, Puerto Rico, and Washington, DC.

[34:25] Kristen Goodman: To learn more about how you can support Broadway Cares Equity Fights AIDS by volunteering, making a donation, or attending one of their upcoming events, please visit BroadwayCares.org.

[34:36] Sarah Goodman: We hope you've enjoyed this episode of the QUEER SERIES. Thanks for following, liking, and leaving a review on your streaming app. Good Show is a part of the Broadway Podcast Network. You can find us on Instagram and TikTok at Good Show Podcast. That's where we post the archival photos and cool stuff we find in the research collection at the Performing Arts Library. It's also where we post info about our upcoming live shows and so much more.

[34:45] Kristen Goodman: Thanks everybody.

[34:45] Sarah Goodman: Hey Kristen.

[34:45] Kristen Goodman: Good show.

[35:07] Sarah Goodman: Hey Sarah. Good show.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred