Skip to main content
BPN Logo
We Love Ali Luff

One of the coolest people on the planet is here. Our friend Ali Luff is hanging with us this week!! She’s most famous for being Alex Finke’s dressing roommate in Les Mis. She’s done a few shows… Waitress, Wicked,, a little ditty on Starz right now called HEELZ .... Read More

From the show: Guys Who Like Musicals

1 h 13 mins
9/3/21

Guests

About

One of the coolest people on the planet is here. Our friend Ali Luff is hanging with us this week!! She’s most famous for being Alex Finke’s dressing roommate in Les Mis. She’s done a few shows… Waitress, Wicked,, a little ditty on Starz right now called HEELZ .. that’s HEELZ with a Z. This was such a fun conversation. Ali walks us through her difficult time leaving Waitress, shooting a TV show during a pandemic, and she inspires all of us to buy a Winnebago.

Her insane resume includes Waitress, Wicked, Scandalous, Escape to Margaritaville, Matlida, Les Mis, Ghost, Mama Mia and a recurring role on New Amsterdam. COME ON!! Ali Luff is a LIFE FORCE. Check us out!

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Alison Luff: Ali Love, how sick are you of doing press?

[0:04] Alison Luff: I'm not that I'm not sick of it because I really like the show, so I like talking about it.

[0:09] Dan Tracy: That's really good.

[0:10] Joe Carroll: That's really good. Because it does seem like you've done about 10,000 interviews in the last month or so.

[0:15] Alison Luff: Yeah, and that's not uh that's not a press answer either. Like I really like talking about the show.

[0:20] Alison Luff: In fact, I thought that I would hate doing podcasts, and I love doing podcasts.

[0:25] Joe Carroll: Oh nice.

[0:26] Dan Tracy: Well, we're about to love doing podcasts.

[0:28] Joe Carroll: We're about to ruin that for you right now.

[0:33] Dan Tracy: Until now.

[0:34] Joe Carroll: Until now.

[0:35] Dan Tracy: Run the credits.

[0:36] Joe Carroll: An actor is saying his lines, and then out of nowhere, he just starts singing.

[0:44] Joe Carroll: Boxing Simony.

[0:48] Joe Carroll: With the song Jimmy.

[0:52] Joe Carroll: Don't cry for me.

[1:02] Joe Carroll: With the whiskey at GoGo t-shirt. It's just like, could you be any cooler?

[1:06] Dan Tracy: You're the coolest person.

[1:09] Alison Luff: I'm a poser.

[1:12] Joe Carroll: No, you're not you're not a poser, because we gotta we'll talk about the band.

[1:15] Dan Tracy: We gotta talk about music. We're gonna talk about a lot of stuff, but you are so not a poser.

[1:19] Dan Tracy: You are you're the embodiment of cool, and you back it up.

[1:23] Alison Luff: I I think.

[1:24] Joe Carroll: Thanks, Joe. I think you're really cool.

[1:26] Joe Carroll: Joe was revealing to me before this that he just wished he were you.

[1:30] Alison Luff: Yeah.

[1:30] Alison Luff: Um, so I just so that we know that that's the direction we're heading in.

[1:34] Alison Luff: You could just get this shirt, and then you could be that's it, you know, like a 60th of me.

[1:40] Joe Carroll: Because I own 60 shirts.

[1:43] Alison Luff: That's amazing.

[1:44] Joe Carroll: There it is.

[1:45] Alison Luff: That's amazing.

[1:45] Joe Carroll: There it is.

[1:46] Alison Luff: Um, I want to know. Well, for we could talk about how we all know each other, because I think it's cool that you you did Les Mis with my wife, Alex Finke.

[1:53] Joe Carroll: Oh horrible person.

[1:57] Alison Luff: Yeah, she's the worst.

[1:58] Joe Carroll: She's the worst.

[1:59] Dan Tracy: Man. You can only say that about someone who is loved unanimously by everyone. That's the only way that you can joke about that.

[2:07] Alison Luff: It's true.

[2:07] Alison Luff: It's a million percent true. And then you and Daniel uh were in the pie shop together.

[2:12] Alison Luff: Yeah.

[2:14] Alison Luff: I did carry her on my shoulders, quite literally.

[2:17] Joe Carroll: Truly.

[2:19] Dan Tracy: Did we get and did we get to do I did Prometer 2 to get it?

[2:25] Alison Luff: We didn't ever have to do it, but you rehearsed me through it.

[2:27] Alison Luff: I rehearsed with you through it, and we did. I I think I did Earl twice. Maybe, maybe more than twice.

[2:35] Joe Carroll: Well, you did it more than twice. Because I feel like the first week.

[2:39] Alison Luff: Like Ben was out or something.

[2:40] Joe Carroll: Yeah, he was having like back issues, I think.

[2:43] Alison Luff: Probably from carrying me.

[2:46] Joe Carroll: I doubt it.

[2:47] Alison Luff: Got it. Well, that's that's a great place to start because I didn't at that point I didn't know who you were, except that Joe told me that, oh, she's the best, she's gonna be great.

[2:58] Alison Luff: Like, and then I met you and you were lovely, and we we worked through the show together, and then we got on stage, and I was not prepared for the fucking life force that is Ali Luff.

[3:11] Joe Carroll: Ali, life force when I I can I could not believe I start that scene in the second act, and I'm screaming my face off, and you come around the couch and you kind of face off and like really look at each other for the first time, and she's scared shitless, and you see a lot of different variations of that.

[3:28] Joe Carroll: Like girls know that they're supposed to be scared. I'm not as scary as Ben Thompson because I'm not a giant dude, but Ali just like in it.

[3:37] Alison Luff: Yeah.

[3:37] Joe Carroll: Dropped in, tears streaming down her face.

[3:41] Alison Luff: Oh man.

[3:42] Joe Carroll: And the voice, Joseph, I know.

[3:45] Joe Carroll: And every note was perfect.

[3:49] Dan Tracy: Did you feel in that moment? Did you feel in that moment like you are being out acted? Like I am being out acted by this person.

[3:56] Alison Luff: I tried not, I tried not to think about that. But I was having clearly having the moment of like wow.

[4:04] Alison Luff: Yeah. Which was not part of the scene.

[4:06] Joe Carroll: Right. Totally.

[4:07] Alison Luff: Wow. I was in fact being out acted.

[4:09] Joe Carroll: Wow.

[4:10] Alison Luff: Thank you. This is a I'm gonna. Are you guys available next week to do another podcast? I just cancel all my therapy and I just do podcasts with you guys.

[4:17] Joe Carroll: Absolutely.

[4:18] Alison Luff: We could talk about it every day.

[4:20] Dan Tracy: Thank you. I you know what? You uh if I seem terrified, it's because I was I'm always terrified.

[4:28] Alison Luff: Not always, but you know, you were you you did it like one of my f I mean the first time we did it together, I feel like it was like one of my first weeks.

[4:37] Alison Luff: And to say that you're not as scary as Ben Thompson because you're not as towering as he is, I found you extremely scary.

[4:45] Alison Luff: You had this like undercurrent, like underbelly uh fizzing up, which I freaking loved, and I found you very WT white trash scary, and that to me coming from Texas is the scariest of them all.

[5:00] Alison Luff: So I freaking loved working with you and acting with you because you were also so dropped in and supportive, and that's what it is. Like, right?

[5:12] Joe Carroll: Absolutely, totally and you guys rehearse together.

[5:16] Alison Luff: Well, yeah, the understudies do like most of the rehearsals.

[5:20] Alison Luff: Well, at least in the beginning, kind of the first like couple days, and then um, yeah.

[5:26] Alison Luff: Yeah, we rehearsed a lot together, and I mean, Mark Evans, luckily for me, he started kind of the same time. Or he we did had the same opening performance, so we rehearsed a lot together as well, but for that track.

[5:39] Alison Luff: But yeah, I feel like you were the majority of my I mean you and Brandon both, but you guys put me in the show, taught me everything.

[5:48] Joe Carroll: Yep.

[5:49] Alison Luff: We did a lot of that, and I was very, very grateful to have you both. But I want to do it again, do something else again with you.

[5:56] Joe Carroll: I know, me too.

[5:57] Alison Luff: Me too. Not that one, but another one.

[6:00] Joe Carroll: You're saying those nice things.

[6:01] Alison Luff: Someday soon.

[6:02] Joe Carroll: It's all true.

[6:03] Alison Luff: It's all very true. Thank you.

[6:05] Joe Carroll: And now you're a big star, and uh just really excited to have you here.

[6:09] Dan Tracy: Joe, where shall we start?

[6:10] Joe Carroll: Well, I think it's fun to talk about like I want to talk about HEELZ, and we can do we because it's it's about to happen.

[6:18] Alison Luff: Anybody who follows you on Instagram knows that it is like so so happening.

[6:23] Alison Luff: Um god, it's because I'm just like vomiting things on Instagram, which I hate, but it's part of the right.

[6:29] Joe Carroll: No, it's part of the job.

[6:30] Alison Luff: It's so great. It's so great.

[6:31] Alison Luff: Because honestly, like Alex and I were like, okay, we gotta sign up for stars. Like we have to get we have to get the stars add-on on Hulu or whatever.

[6:37] Dan Tracy: Right.

[6:38] Alison Luff: Because like I want to watch this show. And also, like Steven and ML, I'm a huge Stephen ML fan.

[6:42] Alison Luff: I just think he is like, is that how you say his name?

[6:44] Alison Luff: I'm maybe.

[6:46] Alison Luff: Okay, I'm gonna be really honest with you guys.

[6:47] Alison Luff: Great. I actually I actually need to call him up because I've been saying Stephen ML, and then our showrunner and writer and executive producer has been calling him Stephen A. Mel.

[6:58] Alison Luff: And so I'm starting to freak out, and I've been doing a lot of press lately, and so I've been kind of doing like one of those. I mean, and I've obviously he's been playing my husband for the last year of my life, and so I've just been doing one of those solid, like steaming ML, like just blending the two versions.

[7:15] Joe Carroll: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[7:16] Alison Luff: Emphasis is sort of wherever.

[7:17] Alison Luff: It's horrible. So I that's so good.

[7:19] Joe Carroll: That's so good.

[7:20] Alison Luff: I I need to like set a mental note. Siri, remind me to text Steven and ask him how he likes his last name pronounced.

[7:31] Joe Carroll: This is brilliant.

[7:34] Alison Luff: Great. Unbelievable.

[7:38] Joe Carroll: Well, so we're very excited about it. And it look the trailers look amazing. Can you just take us through this? Because I, you know, I would love the whole thing, like from the audition process, the you know, and then we could talk about the show itself, but like, how did this come about for you?

[7:54] Alison Luff: Well, okay, so it's a great story, actually.

[7:57] Alison Luff: All right, so I was doing Waitress at the time, right? I was playing Jenna in Waitress, and my contract that I initially went into the show having was cut shorter than I had planned.

[8:10] Alison Luff: And I found out about gosh, what was it? Like three weeks before I was out of the show.

[8:17] Alison Luff: Yeah, the morning of a put in from a press release. It was it was pretty crazy.

[8:23] Alison Luff: So I found out like via the producer calling me and telling me.

[8:30] Joe Carroll: Oh, they did call you, okay.

[8:31] Alison Luff: Yes, they they did call me. Um I was let me tell you first the one really the one of the very very redeeming things about this is the person I got to pass the torch to, Jordan Sparks, is the most incredible salt of the earth human being.

[8:49] Alison Luff: I think you would probably attest to this. Just like one of those people. First of all, when you see her in real life, you're like, Holy shit, you're the prettiest human being I've ever seen.

[8:57] Alison Luff: Like you're genetically so gifted, I don't even understand. I want to touch your face. And then that beauty is just uh radiates because that is how she is in the inside.

[9:08] Alison Luff: And I'm not just saying that she I actually just ran into her at the respect respect premiere as we were both like doing our hair in the mirror, just staring at ourselves, and then she's like, Alison, Jordan, and we were so excited, anyways.

[9:21] Alison Luff: So that was one of the greatest things that could have happened was that I got to pass the torch to Jordan, who is just salt of the earth incredible human being.

[9:31] Alison Luff: But I digress. So my contract was cut shorter than I had originally planned. And they kind of told me it felt a bit dishonest.

[9:42] Alison Luff: I went into it thinking it was a longer contract. I had another job on the line, I had another job opportunity, and I chose to do Waitress because I was like, Well, A, I want to play this role so badly. B, yeah, but I only want to do it for this length of time.

[9:56] Alison Luff: So I felt a little bit um swindled. Is that a word? Swindled.

[10:00] Joe Carroll: Yeah, yeah.

[10:01] Alison Luff: Swindled. Swindled. No sh at the beginning.

[10:05] Joe Carroll: No, no sh.

[10:06] Alison Luff: Okay, but I'm adding that for a fact. Yeah, swindled. I love it.

[10:10] Alison Luff: Um, anyways, this is all goes back to how everything happens for a reason, right? So, in the moment when my contract was cut short, I was obviously super bummed. My ego was just like shot.

[10:25] Alison Luff: Yeah, and yeah, I was just I was I was devastated, and I was reassured it has nothing to do with your work. We just, you know, we need to sell tickets. And meanwhile, I found out later Jordan had was already set to come in, so then it was very it was handled, I thought, a bit bizarre, but um, you know, I wasn't going to sell tickets, quote unquote.

[10:48] Joe Carroll: So um I would say shitty.

[10:50] Alison Luff: That sounds sort of I mean, you could say bizarre, I would say it was it was odd, right? And so, but it and it's easy after the fact for me. I could come and like shit on the way that things were handled, but it's hard to do that then whenever I tell this next bit of the story.

[11:04] Alison Luff: So it's also like, you know, thank you. It's the same way, you know, when someone cheats on you in a relationship, and then the next relationship you're in, you meet your husband.

[11:12] Alison Luff: You know, you're like, you could say that that was shitty, but is that shitty if it turns out the way that it did, you know? So um thank you. Thank you, Waitress.

[11:20] Alison Luff: So I had my last show. Mike O'Malley, who was one of the co-writers, one of the co-book writers on Escape to Margaritaville, he co-wrote it with Greg Garcia.

[11:33] Alison Luff: He texts me and he says, Hey, how's it going? How's Waitress going? And I text him back, and I'm like, oh, funny enough, I actually um and meanwhile, you have to keep in mind too, I had so many people that had already bought tickets for all the you know, for what was supposed to be the last few months of my run as Waitress.

[11:51] Alison Luff: And totally so I was like, oh gosh, is he about to tell me that you know he got tickets because I am just another person to add to the list and tell them like, oh no, I'm just not uh I'm not uh A-list enough.

[12:02] Alison Luff: Um that being said, he he texts me and says, How's Waitress going? And I tell him, Oh, funny enough, I actually just had my last show last night. Um, it was great. I loved playing the role, it was really, really wonderful. Um, might go back later, who knows, you know.

[12:21] Alison Luff: And he said, Oh, okay, well, I actually am working on this project, and um it's there's a part in it that I just keep thinking of you for. I would love for you to read it, and if it resonates with you, I'd love to put yourself on tape and audition for it.

[12:36] Alison Luff: So I was like, okay, cool. So he sends me um the first three episodes of this series, and within the first page, I immediately turned to my husband, and I'm like, holy shit, dude.

[12:51] Alison Luff: Like this her this woman's entrance is so cool. Like the the character's entrance, Stacy's entrance is she walks into uh, she's we see someone weaving through the crowd, a beer in one hand, a s a coke for her son in the other hand, weaving a beer splashes upon her long legs, the camera rolls up to Stacy Spade, a southern Georgia Peach, the only one cheering for the heel, which is the bad guy.

[13:19] Alison Luff: And I was like, okay, who is this? Who's this girl? Um, well, I read the first script and immediately was obsessed with it. And as corny as it sounds, I turned to Matthew again and I was like, This woman dwells inside of me.

[13:35] Alison Luff: Like I know who this woman is. I grew up in the South. She is so many women that I have like suppressed that I don't want to be, and all the women I've inspired to be. She's my mom and my grandmother, my best friend, and probably a bit of me. And I was just obsessed with her.

[13:51] Alison Luff: So I wrote to Mike, I was like, um, I would love to audition. How you know, what do I do? So I put he had me put a couple scenes on tape. He was like, Well, what scenes like we were still picking the audition scenes, you know, this is very preliminary. I just wanted you, I I want you to audition. Who who are your reps?

[14:09] Alison Luff: And so the and I had just gotten new reps too, so I had, you know, kind of forward him that way as well. And so I had all three scripts, so I was like, you know what? I'm just gonna just gonna put all these scenes on tape. I'm just gonna put the ones down, like obviously not these tiny tiny ones, but I'm just gonna put them down. I put the major audition scenes down. I sent them to Mike thinking as a friend, he would probably be like, Okay, cool. Here's a few here's a few like ideas or notes for you.

[14:36] Alison Luff: And he wrote back and he was like, Yeah, great. Uh uh, don't redo them. And I was like, Are you sure? Like, I I kind of didn't think of like you know, final product. I was really just like working with Matthew, and um, but I was off book, I felt really good about them. And so then a few months later, I had a screen test with five other women to play the role. So they flew me to LA, had a screen test. Um, all of them with lots of credits. Um all the ones that I, you know, I'm trying to like look at the names, and you know, I've never been through like a screen test process before, which was really really cool and bizarre. You what I didn't know is that you had to like already negotiate your whole contract for three seasons before you walk into one of these things, and so it's yeah, it I mean it's nuts.

So you're sitting there and then you're just like, Okay, so I could I could walk out of here with the job of a lifetime, or I could um need to call up that family I nanny because I'm not going back to waitress, probably. So this is going well. Um, and what a trip. So I had the screen test with five other women, and then I didn't I contractually I think they had to let me know within five days, and they went five business days. They went all five business days. I didn't hear anything, and it was a Sunday. And my husband and my husband was had to go work his side hustle, which funny enough, he got through waitress. He started driving for the company that waitress used to drive the Jenna. So he was driving around Jordan Sparks and Ryan Cox and just all all the people.

And he's like, You need to call me if you hear anything. And I'm like, It's Sunday, I'm not gonna hear anything. Uh he's like, just text me like red light or something. And um, so sure enough on a Sunday I was out with Ryan Redmond and my friend Keely Hutton and uh a Stephen ML, amel, Steven ML. He's gonna he's gonna be so pissed that I'm fucking up his name. No, not really. Um, he calls me and tells me I got the gig. So that is it was and from what I hear from all the producers is that the thing that makes me kinda go like, oh but also you know, is a testament to how warm that room was for heels was you know, all of those producers said that all of those women left feeling like they had it, which is a testament to how warm the room is, but also makes me go like, Oh, that's that's you know that feeling like when you think you have it and then you don't get it, and but the warm the room was just so warm and everybody was like rooting, you know, to find the right person that they had a bunch of rad women and some of them went and got other series regulars on a star show and you know, other ones I'm sure doing other badass things, but I was just the fortunate one that it went my way this time, so Oh my god.

[17:35] Joe Carroll: Wow. I that's so I love those stories. I absolutely love it. And you were sitting with Ryan. You were you w you were with friends when you got the call?

[17:44] Alison Luff: Yeah. So I was at um gosh, where were we yet? I think we were at Alfie's or something. Yeah. We were at some bar on 9th Avenue. And we were sitting and eating. I was with Keely and Ryan, both two women I did escape to Margarita with. Margarita. Ryan Redman, friend of the pod. Yeah. We love her. And Lady Olaf. Um so yeah, we were we were just sitting there and and Steven's number popped up. Like Steven called me and they're like, answer it. And I'm like, no, I'm not gonna answer it. I don't feel I I can't, you know, me probably just enjoying my Sunday, if you know what I mean. And they're like, no, answer it. Answer it. I was like, I don't wanna. And Ryan like pushed me out of the booth, and I'm like, hey, what's up?

And he's like, hey, Alison, it's uh Steven. I just wanted to tell you that um, how you doing? How how's your how's your weekend going? I'm like, it's good. You know, I'm just just sitting here waiting. I’m in a waiting game for me, you know. I I don't have the gig. And he's like, Well, I actually I wanted to call and tell you congratulations. You know, you you got the part, and I was like, Well, we'll see. I I did feel like it went really well, but you know, who knows? He's like, No, I'm calling, I'm calling to tell you. I asked permission to tell you, and I was like, well, okay. He's like, No, I really did. I just didn't believe him. Oh my god. And he's like, No, I I asked, I found out Mike texted me and was like, it's her, she got it.

And I asked if I could call and tell you because I've never gotten to tell anyone this before. And so he caught and then I probably, you know, destroyed his eardrum with like a very loud squeal. Meanwhile, Ryan and Keely are video recording me through the window window of the restaurant. So it was pretty cool. I do have that video. I should post that.

[19:25] Dan Tracy: That's sweet. Yeah, you should post that epic.

[19:28] Alison Luff: Oh my god, I love that. Super epic. Crazy, right? Super epic story. I I'm not sure. I don't know. It's this is the these are the parts of my life where I'm like, maybe I don't have what it takes.

[19:43] Joe Carroll: Well, you know.

[19:45] Alison Luff: I'm just thinking about like, holy shit, how hard that must have been.

[19:46] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[19:47] Alison Luff: But we do it for musicals all the time. Like, we've been through those experiences. But not with this whole negotiating the fucking contract. Not this whole like, here's three years of my life and the number dollar amount that's attached to it, and like, holy crowd. Like, that to me, that's very that's some pressure, man.

[20:02] Dan Tracy: It's the it is, it is, but I feel like that's where theater people thrive in a way. Like that's one thing I miss about uh auditioning in person.

[20:12] Alison Luff: Like, sure, the self-tapes are super convenient, especially because Matthew and I are just little nomads that are always wandering around. But I miss like you thrive in that environment. I miss being in the room and being able to collaborate and being able to use my sense of humor if I feel awkward and um, but for sure. I mean, I was definitely very I felt very sweaty and I was wearing a tank top that was very cleavy because I was like, well, it's the character, and so I couldn't even use my panty liner trick, which is like in some auditions, I'll like put panty liners under my armpits to try to block the sweat. Because I'm a monster. Um but uh so there's a trick for you, Dan, if you're ever, you know.

[20:55] Dan Tracy: Not a pit sweater, yeah.

[20:57] Alison Luff: Me either. Not I'm not a pit sweater.

[21:00] Dan Tracy: I I I'm I think I'm the sweatiest person on earth.

[21:02] Alison Luff: I think that I am the sweatiest person on the planet. And during the f early shows of of Frozen, I said to Patti Murin, like, I'm so sorry, I'm so fucking sweaty. And she was just like, Well, actually, my cousin, my my husband Colin is even sweatier than you are, so don't worry about it. And like I got away with it. I'm used to it. I'm used to it. And I was like, Okay, thank God, but I am I am a dripping mess.

[21:24] Dan Tracy: I'm gonna steal that idea.

[21:26] Alison Luff: Yeah, it works. I mean, um I I just sweat even when I'm cold, like if I'm getting nervous, I get really cold and then I just start to sweat and yeah, right also right above right above the lip. I'm sure Dan can tell you that from doing waitress. Like it just get like this really, really adorable sweat mustache that is just very present. And like awesome for a screen test. Like that's what they want to see.

[21:49] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[21:50] Alison Luff: That's why you got it with the sweat mustache, I think.

[21:52] Joe Carroll: Probably, you know, she's not afraid to just really be in that Atlanta humidity.

[21:59] Dan Tracy: Amazing. So Allie, you've done so much awesome shit on stage. Mama Mia, Ghost, you did the wicked tour, Matilda, Le Miz, Margarita Ville and Waitress, and then here you are in this television show, which wasn't your first, right? You obviously filmed a couple episodes of New Amsterdam before that, but what's that transition been like? How how has that been?

[22:25] Alison Luff: It's uh it's been super fun. I mean, I've defin I would be lying if I said I didn't feel like I had a little bit of survivor's guilt the last year and a half because I have been making my only means of income f for the last ten years have been theater and has been theater and just you know, as fate would have it, I got lucky and got to film a T V show during a pandemic, and we were one of the very first, if not the first shows to start filming in during the pandemic. So that was kind of crazy. Um, but the transition has been really, really cool. I feel like there's nothing that can set you up for any kind of storytelling world that other than theater, like nothing can set you up better than theater.

Because with theater, we just we know how to run a marathon, we know how to that requires so much self-discipline. And one thing I've learned is that doing TVs, it just requires a different kind of self-discipline. I mean, one thing I have it took me a second to adjust, I would say, because I was really um, and maybe it was also like insecurity and and just a way that I could like protect the fact that I was feeling like a major imposter syndrome, but I was missing theater because I was missing the rehearsal process so much. I mean, rehearsals are my favorite part of the process, and I love the collaboration it takes, and with TV, it takes a different kind of self-discipline in the fact that like you are rehearsing it at home, and you know, I'm very lucky that I'm married to an actor, so I can, you know, rehearse things at nausea nauseum with him.

However, he's very different than he plays a very different Jack than you know, Steven plays. So it takes a lot of self discipline in the work that you put into it at home because then you just gotta come to set and just kind of hope that everybody's on the same page, and you know, you'll say the lines once, but there's no epic rehearsal process, which I really really missed. Especially, I mean, yeah, little things like getting used to the fact of any kind of intimacy scene, which I'm kind of one of those people that like if I'm playing opposite someone and they're comfortable and from the get-go we can establish, like, hey, I trust you, you trust me, let's we're comfortable. Then if if we feel let's let things unfold organically.

If there's not a kiss written in and we are close and we kiss, then like, yeah, or if I'm gonna walk by you in the kitchen, I'm probably gonna smack your butt like I smack my husband's butt, or vice versa. So, but with TV, it is very much like you don't practice any any intimacy until like action. So, whereas with theater people were used to like the first time you rehearse the scene, you do the scene. If there's a kiss in it, you do a kid, you know, you kiss. So also just kind of developing that you know, yeah, the comfort, yeah.

[25:30] Joe Carroll: Yeah, was really different, you know.

[25:34] Alison Luff: Yeah, yeah, totally. It's it it's I've always felt like the takes like the actual coverage, the actual performance on camera is the rehearsal. It's almost like you're filming the rehearsal, the rehearsal is the final product. It's it's like you you're finding it together as you go, and so you have to kind of like get into that mindset that like it's not supposed to be perfect, and for sure, which is scary though when you feel like you have imposter syndrome.

[26:07] Dan Tracy: Absolutely, you know what I mean?

[26:08] Alison Luff: Yeah, and but then there's also things that like make theater prepares you more than anything, it makes you feel super prepared, and you're like, okay, well, then when it comes to doing, you know, seven takes in a row of an emotional scene, you're like, Yeah, I got this. That you know, a lot of people in the TV world would be like, save it for the close-up. And like, huh? I don't get that. Like, I'm gonna give you full out when it's not on my coverage. I'm gonna, you know, like not that you know, people, but not everyone does do that, which is kind of an interesting thing. Luckily, in heels, it's pretty across the board. People are pretty good about that, but that is something that you know, then you feel super prepared for it, and people are like, right, whoa, you did that seven times, and you're like, huh, not eight times a week, though.

[26:55] Joe Carroll: Yeah, yeah, right.

[26:56] Alison Luff: It's like you want it eight, I can do it eight or six months.

[26:58] Dan Tracy: Yeah, yeah. You're not gonna believe it, but I get my weekends off now.

[27:02] Alison Luff: So like I'll do your seven takes, you know.

[27:04] Joe Carroll: Exactly.

[27:05] Alison Luff: Oh my god, and holidays. I've never had I we had like two or three months off for the holidays. I was like, what is this? And weekends, this is crazy.

[27:15] Dan Tracy: Right.

[27:16] Alison Luff: Yeah, yeah. Might be into this. What an idea.

[27:19] Joe Carroll: What an idea, right?

[27:22] Alison Luff: That's just so crazy. Um, well, we love so when does it come out? When when just so we so the the good people at home know, it came out, Joe.

[27:29] Joe Carroll: It's the first episode premiered.

[27:32] Alison Luff: Yeah, it's premiered Sunday.

[27:33] Joe Carroll: It's okay. It's in the notes, Joe.

[27:35] Dan Tracy: It's in the notes.

[27:36] Joe Carroll: Sorry, Dan.

[27:38] Dan Tracy: It's okay. It's okay.

[27:39] Joe Carroll: Yeah, it's he gets we can't. Oh man, I'm offended. We're trying to be a real pod, you know. She's gonna be offended. And she's gonna go tell Stephen Amel not to I'm she's gonna go tell him not to be on the show now, Joe.

[27:54] Alison Luff: I'm gonna get so much shit for mispronouncing his last name.

[27:58] Joe Carroll: It's just some people say Stephen Amel, and some people stay Stephen ML.

[28:01] Alison Luff: Yeah.

[28:02] Joe Carroll: Oh, yeah.

[28:03] Alison Luff: It's okay. That's all right, we won't tell him.

[28:05] Dan Tracy: All right. Well, it's you can catch heels Now. Premiered on August 15th on Stars.

[28:09] Alison Luff: Yeah, so it's the um, I think it's the Sopranos time slot, is what they call it.

[28:14] Joe Carroll: So it is, I know it does it just sounds so cool.

[28:17] Alison Luff: That's why I like saying that.

[28:18] Dan Tracy: That's sick.

[28:19] Alison Luff: Um, but it is 9 p.m. Eastern Standard Time. And I think it's also Sunday night. So it's 9 p.m. and 8 p.m. Central Time. So I think that's also 9 p.m. Then all then it comes on at 9 p.m. in LA as well.

[28:37] Joe Carroll: Yeah, sorry, Pacific Time. That's the word. Those are the words.

[28:40] Alison Luff: Um what is it? So the show it it seems to be about like, you know, it's about like amateur wrestling and about human beings and their relationships sort of in this kind of crazy world. But I mean, what is your can you give us like just a little a little more about the world?

[28:53] Alison Luff: Yeah, so I've gotten really good at the elevator pitch. Are you ready?

[28:58] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[28:59] Alison Luff: So Heels is a Southern family drama that is centered around two brothers that are at odds to keep their late father's legacy alive in the world of professional indie wrestling in a small town.

[29:12] Alison Luff: So I play the youngest matriarch of the Spade family, and I'm married to Steven, who plays Jack Spade, who's the oldest brother. My character, Stacey Spade, is kind of at this, what I like to call like the crossroads in her life because she's ten years into her marriage, so she's not like this newlywed couple. She's got an eight-year-old son, and she's a stay-at-home mom at the moment, which is what she wanted to be, but now her son is at school, you know, and she's done all the laundry and she did all these renovations that she saw on HGTV and thought she could do herself and could do herself, and now she's just kind of like feels like she's lost a bit of who she was and who she wants to be, and just kind of feels like she's losing a bit of her own voice. So we meet her there, and then throughout the season, we get to see what she does with those challenges.

[30:32] Alison Luff: And what the thing that drew me to the character was that I love getting to play wives and mothers because I feel like they are the unsung heroes of the world in a lot of ways, and all the women in this series are very much the heroes without capes. They're the reason that this town functions, the reason that the man functions in the household, and you just kind of see how they navigate that, which is, and the writing is so relatable. That's the other thing I love about it is the marriage is so relatable. It's not this marriage that you're like, oh they fight all the time, or oh, okay. Well, that's not realistic. They would definitely bicker about that. There's this accountability, which, as someone who has been married for six years now, feels like that is the strongest thing that you need in a marriage is this accountability for your partner.

[31:28] Joe Carroll: So cool.

[31:28] Alison Luff: Oh my gosh. That's great. That's a really good pitch. That's a good, that's a great elevator pitch. I'm in.

[31:34] Dan Tracy: I'm in like for the show. My credit card starts here.

[31:37] Alison Luff: Here I'm in. I added to it, I added to it, you know, just now. Like I didn't do word for word. You gotta change it up a little bit, you know what I mean?

[31:44] Joe Carroll: Exactly.

[31:44] Alison Luff: And I also found out that like a Starz membership is only eight dollars or something like that. So I just recently found that out. I haven't used that as a pitch yet. So you guys are trying that on you. Eight dollars. So two lattes, oat milk lattes.

[31:59] Dan Tracy: That's so good.

[32:00] Alison Luff: That's so good. Um well we love all of the TV stuff, and obviously we're a podcast about musicals, but like we'd love to talk about to do another like sort of deep dive into something on stage, something theatrical that you know you've done so many things. Is there a story or a process that pops out to you as incredibly memorable or, you know, I mean Waitress was really memorable for the fact that how it ended and navigating that and my own ego through that, and it being this dream role since the moment I saw it, since the moment I saw Jessie Mueller do it and was so blown away by her. So that was definitely a memorable experience, but they're all memorable for different reasons, right? I could say that Scandalous, which you didn't name, you know, Scandalous.

[32:52] Joe Carroll: Oh, yeah.

[32:53] Alison Luff: Scandalous. Well, the only reason I bring it up is because that was memorable for the fact that it was, I was part of a giant flop, which is very memorable in its own right, and I understood Carolee Carmello at 22. So that was something that was super odd and memorable.

[33:05] Dan Tracy: My god, I remember that.

[33:12] Alison Luff: It was like the marquee was up and a couple, I mean, I was in three-inch character heels, if that tells you anything of how that's gonna go. It's not gonna go well.

[33:25] Joe Carroll: Not gonna get, not no good.

[33:26] Alison Luff: No, that's not your vibe. You don't want to see me in character heels.

[33:30] Joe Carroll: Is that what they call characters?

[33:33] Alison Luff: Ledukas, yeah.

[33:34] Joe Carroll: The Dukes.

[33:35] Alison Luff: Like there's no way that Leduca's gonna be naming a shoe after me. I don't know. Like, but just put that out there. I don't know. There's probably gonna be an Ali Luff heel.

[33:42] Joe Carroll: Okay.

[33:46] Alison Luff: Oh, it's called like the trip or something. Because I trip. Um but, and I mean probably Escape to Margaritaville because it was my first originating role and getting to do that in La Jolla and work with these awesome writers that it was their first time writing a musical, and they're hilarious TV writers that are constantly like, okay, so that process went something like this, right? You had your show in your previews. They'd come up to you and they're like, hey, hey, hey, hey, come here, come here, come here, come here a second. I got this joke. I want you to try this joke tonight. You're like, tonight? Mike, Greg, what are you talking? Okay, come on, come here, come here. I got a bit, I got a bit.

All right, so no, don't tell Chris Ashley. Okay. So tonight, instead of these lines, say these. You're like, okay, all right, all right, I'll do it. Do it. You know, might land, might be great, might not get a laugh. And you would get so connected to certain jokes, and you're like, I love this joke, but if you didn't get the laugh on the first night, they were like, nope, it's not funny, it's not funny, not enough people laugh. Because they would be in the audience listening, and you're like, no, give me, give me one more shot. And they're like, I just didn't say it right. I need to emphasize the different things.

[34:55] Joe Carroll: Exactly.

[34:55] Alison Luff: They're like, I just, I just need to do it once. And they're like, nope, it's cut. New joke, do this. And you're like, oh gosh. So that was a pretty, I mean, a lot of people hate that part of the new musical process. I freaking love that part of the process of like the script changing every night. And that's what I loved about understudying when I would understudy too. I enjoyed the fact of like coming in and the spontaneity and having to save the day and no time to be nervous. You just gotta like be present and make that shit. The other person has to listen to you because all of their patterns won't work.

[35:31] Joe Carroll: That's what I love about it.

[35:33] Alison Luff: Because I go in there and this Jenna's trying to steer the ship, and I'm like, that's, we can't. You gotta, we gotta be do the scene together.

[35:40] Dan Tracy: Yeah.

[35:40] Alison Luff: You know?

[35:41] Joe Carroll: I agree. And sometimes it's hard. Like I think Dr. Pomatter was a really hard role to not do all the time. And like to just jump up and do it because it's so bit heavy. You have to like really like have the bits in your body, but everything else that I totally agree with you. I think that's like we're doing live theater, you know, it's supposed to be real, it's supposed to be new every night. A bit will always work if you listen.

[36:04] Alison Luff: That's my main motto. Is I'm like, I get the question a lot, you know, what do you do when you're really nervous? And I'm like, well, first of all, I used to never get nervous until I'm, that's not true. I would get, you know, like butterflies, but it wasn't until I was six months into my run of playing Alphabet in Wicked that I developed crippling stage fright. I mean, to the point where there was a night where I was in Chicago, which they also say that theater is super haunted. So I was in Chicago, and I just kept going to the White Room during Wizard and I like, I mean lyrics. I just would, and then they would come out of me and I would sing them. But to the point where I walked off stage and I just started sobbing, and I was like, I don't want to do it.

I don't want to go on, I don't, I don't want to do it, I don't want to do it. And they're like, you're gonna be fine, just do it. And I was like, oh god, and when you're doing something like Wicked or a tour in general, you know, this is not a jab into the company, but it's very easy when you're doing a tour, any long-running show that you know, as we were just saying, Dan, you get stuck in the way that you do things. So sometimes you don't necessarily feel like the person you are looking at the person you're on stage with, and you can be like, I'm really scared, you have to help me, and they'd be like, oh yeah, yeah, okay.

[37:25] Alison Luff: Until I actually ended up taking, I was so terrified, I just was stage fried. I just like, I don't want to do, it's just not enjoyable. I'm going to the White Room. I can't, the more I think about it, the more I'm screwed. So I took two shows off, took two shows off, and when the from eight o'clock when the show would start, I would swim laps until the show would end. I would just swim laps in my hotel. I took two what I called mental health days, and I would just swim laps, and I went to like a botanical garden, and then I came back and I did the show. But what I tell people, because now I do have that stage fright is just, it all comes back to listen, just try to listen. You have to try to quiet your mind and listen, just listen, listen, listen, listen, listen, which is hard when you're freaking out.

[38:18] Joe Carroll: But oh my gosh, that's really interesting. I have so many late too. Have you ever had that, Joe?

[38:25] Joe Carroll: No, but uh, well, yes, obviously, but but I've uh the white room on stage a hundred percent, the white room on a Broadway stage, the white room where like somebody's looking at you, like it's this absolute crippling and horrible. But we've heard this, we've had a couple of Alphabas in the show who said the same thing. That there's something about that role in particular that because I think it's, you know, for many reasons, it's such a marathon and such a, so difficult that I don't, did you equate it to the role itself? What was had like the pressure that was on you at the time or?

[38:57] Alison Luff: So what I ended up equating it with was it's the first time I had done a long-running show in a principal track. So I had done like a year on Mama Mia and I had done a, you know, quite a bit of time in Ghost, I suppose. I mean it didn't run that long, but I had done long-running shows before, but it was the first time I had done a principal role for that long. It was six months into a year contract. So I think it was the f what I've come to figure out was because now it starts happening to me every six months. Like when I hit a six-month marker into a show or, you know, four to six-month marker, I start to get really nervous. I start to, before I go online, before I go on stage, I'll start, you know, going through those lyrics, which is the worst, right?

You should never do that, right? Never mind. And then you're like cramming for the test. And then, and we, and you know the test. Right, right. The test two hundred and fifty times at this point. Um then, but then you develop that habit and you're like, well, I have to do it. I do this every show. If I don't do this ritual, like oh. If you don't do it, then you're never gonna, oh man. Just never come up with a ritual. Just never do it.

[40:14] Joe Carroll: So, um what I've equated it to is that I have this, it's not my theory, it's a couple of friends that we gathered this theory is that when you're doing something for a super long time, you're all the information moves from the front part of your brain of, you know, to your muscle memory, right? I don't even know if the front part of your brain is not muscle memory, but let's pretend it is, you know.

[40:36] Alison Luff: Yeah, yeah.

[40:36] Joe Carroll: So the bat it moves to like the back of your brain, this muscle memory. So then when you start thinking about it and you have that thought of like, I wonder if I know this, and then you try to think about it, it's physically not located in that little brain box. It is in the, it's in the muscle memory. So unless you turn that off, you're not gonna be able to find it because it's not located there anymore. It's in the muscle memory.

[41:00] Alison Luff: But it's also, you know, that's my theory at least.

[41:03] Joe Carroll: And so you gotta still obviously. We need to call that neurologist because oh yeah, there's something here.

[41:09] Alison Luff: Yeah, sure. Definitely there's something there. This is so true. I think you're a hundred percent right.

[41:13] Joe Carroll: Doesn't that make sense?

[41:15] Alison Luff: I mean it makes complete sense. That's exact because like you'd never ever ever think about the lyrics until you mess them up, and then you consciously are thinking about them and then you don't know them.

[41:26] Joe Carroll: That's exactly right.

[41:28] Alison Luff: It's isn't that horrible? It's just horrible. And then, oh, it's just, it's horrible. And so I one thing I found with Waitress, I wasn't there six months, I'll tell you that. So never got to that part. Instead, I was just, you know, nervous in and that you can always use the energy, and luckily with Alpha, you could use the energy, and I found that happened with Miss Honey in Matilda too, but again, she's supposed to be kind of this neurotic, frantic, you know, bubbling neuroses of a nervous woman, you know, in the shell of a comforting teacher.

[42:04] Joe Carroll: So my gosh, that's crazy.

[42:07] Alison Luff: That's really wild. Um, yeah, I think we need to get a neurologist on the show and get to the bottom of this.

[42:14] Joe Carroll: Do you guys want me to just be your neurologist?

[42:16] Alison Luff: Yeah, absolutely.

[42:18] Joe Carroll: We'll be your, you'll be, we'll be your psychologist slash like, you know, whatever we were doing at the beginning. You can, you can cut my brain open and see what's going on.

[42:27] Alison Luff: Cool that and, and we'll, I've had a couple concussions, so we'll swindle the masses.

[42:31] Joe Carroll: We can swindle them all. I wanted to ask a question about Margaritaville because I had so much frickin' fun in the audience of that show, and I think, you know, gone, you know, it obviously closed early in the whole thing, but the connection, just the, to hit home the connection between the writer that, you know, sometimes I don't, I don't think it's necessarily that clear cut all the time, you know, but like the writer of that show called you and said, hey, would you send in a tape for Heels? And now this show is maybe gonna, who knows? It's huge for you. It's gonna be great. But like the, the sort of there, I don't know where the question is here, but like the idea that like there's no question.

[43:12] Alison Luff: There's no question.

[43:22] Joe Carroll: Yeah, that well, and also I mean, I read the Escape to Margaritaville review.

[43:26] Dan Tracy: I don't know if you read that review, Allie.

[43:29] Joe Carroll: If I were in that show, it would have been very hard for me to keep going to work.

[43:32] Dan Tracy: It was they were not very nice to you.

[43:34] Joe Carroll: In fact, they went out of their way to be awful to you.

[43:36] Dan Tracy: And now here you are.

[43:38] Joe Carroll: This is another example of like it all works out, you know.

[43:42] Dan Tracy: It you just trust it and honor the relationships and make it about people, and you never know what can happen.

[43:49] Alison Luff: Yeah, it always loves your story. It's in that's something too. It's like Mike O'Malley has become so much more than a coworker to me, too now. I mean, he is I I'm so close with his wife and his kids, and he's like he is family to me. And he's someone, you know, he's an East Coaster. He's like a New Hampshire guy that's like very, you know, so he and Matthew get along great, him being from New Jersey, they're always busting each other's balls, you know, talking about Yankees and Red Sox and which Yankees beat the Red Sox twice yesterday. I'm just gonna put that out there, Michael Malley. But um, you know, they he's still socks, Mike. Oh, gosh, how dare he's a Boston guy. But we became super super close, and you know, that was one thing.

He is a family guy at his core, you know, and so New York was really hard for him to do this musical that was in this world that he was not in, and being away from his family, and then and it's important to like the people that you work with because then same with filming during a pandemic, you know, we were stuck in Atlanta filming. His family was in Los Angeles, and you filming during a pandemic is a whole new thing because it's not like you can just fly home to see your family and your friends on the day off like you normally. So you are you know surrounded by these people, and I just he's also the just to brag on him for a second, he is the biggest cheerleader you could ever have in a room.

Oh, I mean, to the point where like we always joke as a cast in Heels, is we'd finish a take and then you would get the shit scared out of you because all of a sudden you'd hear like, All right, all right, just like the biggest claps. Just like that's what I'm talking about. That's what I'm talking just Oh my god, come here, come here. It gives you a hug. He's because he's an actor and he knows what it's like to you know have an ego and to have for better or for worse and right yeah right that encouragement and that's what makes him such a good writer and that's what makes him such a good producer and that's what makes him such a good showrunner and and then the icing on the cake is in this show you know he's showrunning it he's writing he's on the writing staff and he's writing a lot and he's also an executive producer and then and then he comes in and he does his scenes and it's just like it's so mind blowing to watch him work.

You'll and his character is really introduced in episode two you see a little bit of an episode one but he comes in and then you watch him and Matthew and I the first time we watched the episode we were just like oh okay and that's how you act and that is how you do it. Like it's just a freaking master class and he's just constantly about the work. But other than that, you know he sucks.

[46:42] Joe Carroll: Well he's one of the greatest character actors ever I mean and like if you look you know if you guys if the listeners don't know who Michael Malley is the you you see this guy's face and it's like oh yeah oh he's that guy that from that thing. Oh yeah that fucking guy yeah yeah exactly I was just watching Parks and Rec. It's my favorite my favorite show like my favorite like sort of like um you know warm blanket before bed during a pandemic show. And like the other night like there he is like like he's the shitty guy who like doesn't sell them the vans like there's Michael Malley again. It's like anyway.

[47:14] Alison Luff: I didn't even know that I need to now I need to watch that I get to my brother because I know he watches that.

[47:19] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[47:19] Alison Luff: Um that's so cool. That's so cool.

[47:21] Joe Carroll: Oh my gosh. Well Ali, we're getting to the end. We swear we'll we'll let you go eventually, but we have you know a few more questions that we we want to talk about. We talked about we always ask people what the greatest challenge was and what the what the greatest challenge in your career has been.

[47:33] Alison Luff: And it sounds like I mean we covered a lot of stuff in Waitress with the Waitress story. But is there anything else that you find particularly shitty challenging about our ridiculous job? You know uh you know other than yeah Waitress was something that was definitely a challenge at the time but I think another thing is is since we touched on reviews a little bit so I am someone I don't read reviews. When it comes to theater I'm like not I just can't I'm not gonna do it. You know I'm like one of those people like if you believe the good you gotta believe the bad so I don't really I don't like I don't I don't want to go down that road. But inevitably you get to see some of them in you.

[48:14] So one thing about Margaritaville was that it was it definitely even if you don't read the reviews they come into the theater somehow and even with e people know and even with Heels for instance I it was the first time I actually did read reviews. And and then I kind of I justified it because I was like well my performance is done so I can and and I I guess in TV world it's very different. In theater you at least try to like you're not gonna you know that some people don't so you're not gonna send it on the text train train for Chet text chain for Heels. It's just like people send it and you're like oh curry guards don't really not everyone reads everybody I guess in TV reads them. That that's a generalization.

But so then you read them and for TV it's like, well, the work is already done. I kind of purposely don't read them in theater because I don't want to read them and then have that in my head because I do struggle with stage fright and nerves and ADD brain that I'm like, I can't be thinking about that and then it could change my performance or totally right. Same way I don't like even knowing when people are in an audience. But I think that I think that reviews are tricky because I think that a lot of times these people who are writing the reviews, they could be uh I've learned that not all of them are even coming from a theater world or a theater background.

[49:40] Joe Carroll: Right.

[49:40] Alison Luff: They're like s you know, we're in sports journalism and this and then they the opening in the paper was to write theater reviews. So they're gonna do that. And I just part of me is like, what if what if theater reviews were like just another part of the collaboration? What if these theater critics were people that want shows to succeed and want people to succeed and just want to be another part of the collaborative process and instead of tearing things to shred, and of course we've all seen things that we're like not a fan of or that we think are really bad or we th you know, but there's kind of this like judgment on it that I think that what if we like turn that judgment into like this collaborative thing and it was all part of the process of a way to make something better or I don't know, more creative in the end. Does that make sense?

[50:31] Joe Carroll: A hundred percent complete sense.

[50:34] Alison Luff: I have a thought on that. I love that so much. I have been part of a process where the reviewer of the last show that I did, the show we all knew that the show needed a lot of work. And the reviewer was aware of that too, but ultimately the reviewer was excited about the unique perspective of the story and the characters on stage being something that we need to push forward. So the review was kind.

[51:02] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[51:02] Alison Luff: It's right. Yeah. That that was not the case for Margaritaville, where you had established theater critics from large papers coming in and saying, We don't want this to succeed because that's not the kind of theater we want to exist. And that's the problem. Like we need more voices reviewing at bigger institutions who can speak to different things, right?

[51:26] Alison Luff: Well, and yeah, and it's interesting because I also feel like look, I live in New York, y'all live in New York. There is a social elitist coming from some coming not from New York and having a husband that's from New Jersey and spending time in LA, there and uh looking at the world that we're in today. Everything is so polarized, everything is so politicized, and there is a sense of social elitism. Is that a word? Social elite or elitism, right? Social elitism that I think comes with New York Theater and Broadway. And I think that the thing that bummed me out about Escape to Margaritaville, like I get it, it is not it was not everyone's cup of tea. But when it feels like it's judged, not based on when when it feels like it's judged before you walking in and watching it, yeah. That that is disappointing to me.

[52:22] Joe Carroll: What makes it not disappointing was I don't think we ever ended a show without people on their feet smiling, and it is hands down more than any show that I've ever been in doing press for Heels. It is the show that people are like, oh my gosh, I saw Margaritaville. I'm a huge fan. I mean, peep fans that are like, you know, probably Green Arrow fans, or it's just arrow, arrow fans and Viking fans, and then there's like some Margaritaville fans.

[52:50] Alison Luff: Yeah.

[52:51] Joe Carroll: Yes, because it it should not be viewed under the same lens as like the public theater fucking Shakespeare thing, whatever. Like it was theater for people who it could have been a great gateway for people to who maybe weren't huge fans of musical theater, but were just total Jimmy Buffett fanatics to like come to New York and be like, Wait, what's this thing? Oh, wait a minute. It's playing in the lobby of my hotel.

[53:18] Alison Luff: Yeah.

[53:19] Joe Carroll: Like, you know, I'm just gonna go check it out. And now, next thing you know, they are buying tickets to Waitress. I mean, that's the good, you know. And so we can all be cynical if we want to, but I just that was one of the things that I hated about that review, Dan, too. It's just like, yeah. What the f like what the fuck are we doing? Why do we have to be nasty? And that, and that truly did happen a lot. I don't know how many people, and we would remind each other in the cast of that. I don't know how many people at the stage door we heard that said, This is my first musical I've ever seen. This is my first Broadway show I've ever seen. I I can't wait to see more musicals. We're gonna go, we just bought tickets now. We're gonna go see, you know, blah blah blah.

[53:55] Alison Luff: And another crazy fun fact that I forgot, Michael Waldron, the creator of Heels, who created Heels back in like I don't know, 2007, I think he started scribbling things down on a napkin. He saw Margaritaville. He didn't know Michael Malley at the time, he didn't know anybody. He just came to see Margaritaville because he was a huge Jimmy Buffett fan. And then it wasn't until after my screen test, he texted me and he was like, I saw you in Margaritaville.

[54:21] Joe Carroll: That's amazing.

[54:22] Alison Luff: Isn't that wild? That's great.

[54:24] Joe Carroll: You never know.

[54:25] Alison Luff: You never know.

[54:26] Joe Carroll: Yeah, yeah.

[54:26] Alison Luff: You never know.

[54:28] Joe Carroll: My eyes twitching. I hate that.

[54:30] Alison Luff: I think it means you're dehydrated.

[54:32] Joe Carroll: Drink your water.

[54:32] Alison Luff: I think I need a banana.

[54:33] Joe Carroll: Is there a oh there you go?

[54:35] Alison Luff: Is there a book or a resource that you've found invaluable?

[54:41] Alison Luff: Okay, this is gonna sound really, really corny and cheesy, but it's uh not so much a book, it's more of a resource, and that resource is people watching and just surrounding myself amongst people of all different kinds and all different places and traveling, like that to me is my greatest resource. I know that sounds really cheesy and corny, but and any book, just like reading and like submersing yourself in an imagin in your imagination, but I found like the when I stopped just hanging out with theater people or actors, and I stopped having this preconceived notion of who these people in small towns might be, or you know, suppressing like these people I went to school with that I was like, Well, I'm going to New York City and I'm gonna, you know, and I started like leaning into my roots, so to speak, and like who I was, like who Alison Luff was versus who these other people were that I loved in the community that I was like, Oh, I like what they're doing, they seem cool, I'm gonna be them.

I'm like, well, that was kind of this moment I felt this shift where I was like, I gotta keep doing that because nobody's gonna do Alison Luff better than I'm gonna do her, and I'm not gonna do them better than them. So my main like resource other than my husband, because he's a very well-read individual, um is is just people in general and like using because I didn't go to school, so I kind of learned I didn't learn technique, so to speak, and I didn't I didn't grow up going like to class and like learning these different styles of theater, and that's why I love talking about it with other actors, even though I feel a little stupid sometimes, and then I realize, oh, it doesn't matter. We're all like doing the same thing.

[55:54] Joe Carroll: But I think because I didn't go to school, I didn't I've never had that kind of like study brain. I've always been more of a street smart or uh, you know, learn on the job learner than a a bookie.

[56:41] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[56:42] Alison Luff: That's great.

[56:43] Joe Carroll: That's really good advice, I think, too, because a lot of um, you know, younger people and myself included, when we're trying to like develop characters, I'm like, oh yeah, this is kind of like like Leonardo DiCaprio in Blood Diamond plus this is w where am I going with this? I don't know. Plus uh Dax Shepard and without a paddle. Like that's totally what this character is. It's like I don't know, that was a terrible example, but like you start basing characters based on, you know, theater actors or characters and things.

[57:15] Alison Luff: It's like, no, just go find real human beings.

[57:19] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[57:20] Alison Luff: Yeah.

[57:20] Joe Carroll: Base your characters off of real human beings.

[57:22] Alison Luff: Yeah.

[57:23] Alison Luff: You know, when when Bob Cracker started showing us the um like reality TV like cop shows in class, and was like, look at this girl getting arrested right now. Look at that behavior. She was like fixing her hair and doing all these weird things that you would never do if you were playing that scene.

[57:41] Joe Carroll: Yeah, it's all about stripping the ego, right?

[57:44] Alison Luff: It's that is the it's the goal.

[57:48] Joe Carroll: It's I it's I think it's a constant practice.

[57:50] Alison Luff: You gotta strip away that ego. You gotta just be like, I don't care how I look, I care how I'm making you feel.

[57:57] Joe Carroll: Yeah.

[57:57] Alison Luff: Mm-hmm.

[57:58] Joe Carroll: A hundred percent.

[58:00] Alison Luff: Um what's the most influential musical in your life?

[58:04] Joe Carroll: Can be something you've done, but certainly doesn't have to be.

[58:08] Alison Luff: I think the most influential musical in my life is Parade.

[58:12] Joe Carroll: So I love that musical so much.

[58:17] Alison Luff: So good.

[58:18] Joe Carroll: That's probably a dream role.

[58:19] Alison Luff: I would love to play Lucille.

[58:21] Joe Carroll: Absolutely.

[58:21] Alison Luff: It's a comedy.

[58:22] Joe Carroll: No.

[58:23] Alison Luff: Right?

[58:23] Joe Carroll: Comedy.

[58:24] Alison Luff: Uh if you haven't told I really love dramas.

[58:27] Alison Luff: Yes, I love heartache. Um, that show was super influential to me because I did do it as a kid. I did the Houston premiere of it and um, it was very, very traumatic in my personal life at that time because I had a um, a friend that a neighborhood friend that ended up living with us for a short time who um, whose father passed away very similarly to Leo Frank. And so I was doing that sh not to get super heavy it in this, but doing that and meanwhile I was remembering that from home and like why this friend, this childhood friend was like living with us and um, and watching him process all that trauma of like losing a father to mental illness and in our neighborhood, and then I would like go to this theater and do this show at night and doing Parade, I don't know for other people who have done the show, but it was so moving and maybe I'm biased, but our product I think we had a really, it was a really, really great production at the time.

Like the guy playing Leo and the woman playing Lucille were married, and I think they were going through a divorce at the time, or something like they were going through real shit, and everybody was just kind of coming to this theater and like doing that I guess probably this cathartic process, and every there were multiple nights a week that the audience would give a standing ovation. It was this very small little professional theater in Houston. I think it sat probably 200 people, really small, like little black box, and they'd give us standing ovation, we would leave, we would go to our dressing rooms, we would be half undressed, and they would still be on their feet, and we would have to like come back out.

Wow and bow. And I was probably gosh, I was probably 13 or 14, or I g I was 14 when I did that show. And I just remember feeling like so um privileged and like honored to to get to tell that story, and I felt like it was very sacred, and I felt like this extreme responsibility, this like profound responsibility as a 14-year-old to tell this story and also kind of come at it feeling like I've experienced life, even though it was through my friend, or you know. And so that was probably one of the most impactful um yeah moments of theater for me and my family. I mean, everyone that came was very I mean, it's a very impactful show, so yeah.

[1:01:12] Joe Carroll: That's incredible.

[1:01:13] Dan Tracy: It's an incredible show for anybody who doesn't know it, like spend some time with that cast album.

[1:01:18] Alison Luff: Oh yeah, it's so good. It's so so good. Um yeah, that's so cool. Um so I swear now, I said this like 20 minutes ago, but I swear to god, we are getting to the end.

[1:01:30] Alison Luff: I'm long-winded, it's me.

[1:01:31] Joe Carroll: No, it's podcasting.

[1:01:34] Alison Luff: And we're friends, and we're all friends.

[1:01:35] Dan Tracy: I know, I just like I don't want to take up like I get to this point, I'm like, oh my gosh, we've been talking to these busy people for an hour. Like, you know, I don't want to take up any more time.

[1:01:44] Alison Luff: I'm in my childhood bedroom and I like put a chair in here that doesn't really match the wall, but I just like needed a chair to sit down in.

[1:01:52] Joe Carroll: I love it.

[1:01:52] Alison Luff: Anyways. Um advice. What what advice would you give to someone just starting out, your younger self, Dan and Joe?

[1:02:03] Alison Luff: Well, I mean, I touched on it just a second ago, which was I at least for me, I noticed an extreme shift in the direction of my um career or whatever you want to call it, which was the moment I realized I need to figure out like what I do and what I do best and who I am as a human being, and find a way to bring that into a room, is the second I started noticing like this shift happen and things starting to go in the direction that I wanted to go in. Because I think it's super easy too when you're like starting out to have these people, or if you're like me, who grew up I mean I grew up listening to cast albums and I would sing them, so I started to sound a little bit like Sutton Foster, because that's all I would listen to.

You know what I mean? Or then I would start listening to Idina Menzel, or you like you're listening to all these people, and for me that was very and Dolly Parton and all these people, and so that's kind of how I started to when you're starting out, you are saturating yourself in the material and everything you like, and it's really easy to start, you know, I don't know, morphing into the people that you admire. And I think the second that we start finding our own voice and finding what we have to bring to the table, and even though we're up against the same people, you know how you're always up against like the same people on a callback, like it always ends up being the same people, and sometimes they'll get it, and you'll be like, Oh, yeah, well, I feel like I dug their outfit and they're super cool and they sound like this, and like they're just like easy breezy and like cool, I'm gonna be like them.

And it was the second that I started to just own who I was and try to bring that into a room was when I realized, oh, that is the one thing that nobody is gonna outdo me on or do better than me. Like, no one is going to do me better than I'm going to do me. So I think my advice would be just like lean into who you are and like figure you don't have to know like we're ever evolving human beings, but figure out like what you can like what you or not what you can bring to the table, but what you enjoy bringing to the table and do it.

[1:04:15] Joe Carroll: Yeah, figure out what problem you solve, right?

[1:04:18] Alison Luff: That's it.

[1:04:19] Joe Carroll: That's it. We're just talking about it.

[1:04:20] Dan Tracy: Dan and I talk about this a lot.

[1:04:23] Alison Luff: We're trying to get to the bottom of it, and we haven't got there yet.

[1:04:27] Dan Tracy: But we're gonna figure it out.

[1:04:28] Alison Luff: It's interesting because like you sometimes I don't know if you feel like you can definitely identify the things that you do differently than everyone else, Allie. But it's almost just like giving over to something that you aren't controlling, like just like letting go of ego of self and just like letting whatever happens happen is probably the direction to go in.

[1:04:52] Alison Luff: Yeah, I mean, whatever, be like a tree and let the dead leaves drop, right? I love that silly little quote, but it's so true. And it's like, whatever doesn't serve you, just like be done with it and be okay with the fact that things are only ever not everything's supposed to be in your life forever. I even think about that with with love, and I always talk about that with my husband. I'm like, really? Like, do I believe that you are my soulmate? Yeah, I do, obviously. I married you after a month of knowing you, and we decided a week after. But when it boils down to it, we're just like these little atoms that are like making the constant choice every day to like hang on to one another and just soar through the world, and whenever we, you know, and sometimes you're like, you want to keep you wanna keep attached?

Okay, let's keep attached. And it's like, I think that's with anything in the world. Maybe it's kind of that's kind of like the book Big Magic a little bit, right? It's like you have these little ideas and they're floating around and then they're gone. So just be okay with it's always always comes back to the here and now, right? And being in the moment and like whatever doesn't serve you in that moment, get rid of it, whatever does serve you, lean into it.

[1:06:01] Joe Carroll: Yep.

[1:06:02] Alison Luff: Yep.

[1:06:04] Joe Carroll: Hmm.

[1:06:05] Dan Tracy: That's really good.

[1:06:06] Alison Luff: Dan's there.

[1:06:08] Dan Tracy: I'm there.

[1:06:08] Alison Luff: This is good.

[1:06:09] Joe Carroll: This is good.

[1:06:10] Alison Luff: Um, and then my favorite question, uh the unreachable star question, which is basically, what are you you've accomplished so much, but what are you pointed towards now? Is there something you'd really love to do?

[1:06:24] Alison Luff: Um, something you'd like to, you know, something you'd like to do.

[1:06:31] Alison Luff: You know, eat a sandwich.

[1:06:35] Joe Carroll: No, I'm kidding.

[1:06:35] Alison Luff: Eat a sandwich, yeah. Honestly, like, honestly, that is that's a that's a really good Allie Love answer. If I were to like like the fact that you're like to be in the here and now and all of the things we've talked about for the last hour, and then you're like, you know what I want right now. I'm down for a sandwich. You know, it's just down for a sandwich. Some people are like, I want to be in a Marvel movie, and it's like cool. And other people are like, I wanna be, you know, I want to be a good mom and a good wife, a good husband, a good, you know, father, whatever, and then Allie Allie who who m married her husband. I do love that story that like you guys knew each other for like barely no time at all, and you were like, Nope, this is it.

[1:07:11] Alison Luff: It's crazy. It's a very cool story. No, but truly, like I think that that's the uh but it it is really I like that you say the unreachable star because that's something my mom is so she's so great about. She's always been like, okay, she's always a good check-in, right? She's always the person that's like, so you know, you originated your first role. That was your that was a goal, right? I'm like, yeah. She's like, okay. So what's another goal? You gotta keep setting those. You gotta keep like and I think what I have to be better about is like being specific about them. Because even as a kid, I never said, my dream is to be on Broadway. As a kid, my dream, truly, as like a six-year-old, I would say, I just want to be a content working actor and be financially um stable.

I don't care if it's on Broadway. Like I knew I had the wherewithal to be like Broadway is not everything. Like I could be just as content doing, you know, regional theater. Um, and but I just want to be a consistent working actor. Like, but I think I do it's important to be specific with goals. Like, I can be specific about the sandwich I'm gonna have for sure. So why can't, you know, I I do ultimately, I mean, I could say like the very broad answer of I wanna figure out this balance, continue figuring out this balance of life and theater, and also this new medium that I'm into, this TV and film world and cultivating that. But especially with like the world we're in today and just the un just the fact that it's so unpredictable and there's nothing that reminds you of like everything is fleeting, the good and the bad, like it's all just fleeting.

I think my unreachable star is to and what I've gained out of this last year and a half is to really prioritize my personal life and the way that I make memories and little things like this sounds so corny, but seeing the stars at night, like I realized I don't really want to live in New York City anymore, and I've never thought I don't want that. I never thought that I would say that, but I've been in nature now for a year and a half and like finding that traveling around. So I want to figure out how I can we just bought an RV by the way. So I want to try to figure out how I can live on the road and still do theater wherever I want to do theater, whether that's in New York or like Hey La Jolla, I would do I would just live there and do theater there forever if you know, if you have me. Or, you know, so I think that's the goals, like figuring out how I can take the what I've gained over the year and a half of personal life and travel and still maintain a super productive work life.

[1:10:05] Joe Carroll: Totally.

[1:10:06] Alison Luff: And a sandwich.

[1:10:07] Dan Tracy: And if you ever if you ever want to move to Westchester, I did the same thing. I'm not in the city anymore.

[1:10:13] Joe Carroll: Look, that's my backyard.

[1:10:15] Dan Tracy: I was looking at that.

[1:10:16] Joe Carroll: Side porch over there.

[1:10:18] Dan Tracy: I don't live in the city.

[1:10:20] Joe Carroll: I I I got out. I it it's a very far commute, but I couldn't do it either. And so uh I feel that.

[1:10:27] Alison Luff: Yeah, well, we pick up our RV on Friday. So we're gonna be focused on renovations and traveling around. Um, so we could definitely visit in Westchester. We could be like and season two talks, do you know?

[1:10:43] Joe Carroll: There are certainly talks, but there is nothing uh in I you know, coming from the world of theater, I am never count my chickens before they hatch. I'm sure things are so grateful. I I'm pinching myself that I'm like, whoa, I just did like an eight-hour play. I just did episodes like a full season, and I looked at these scripts and Matthew was like, that's like an eight-hour play. I was like, it is, I just did an eight-hour play. So um I hope I get to do another eight-hour play. That's for darn tootin' sure.

[1:11:12] Alison Luff: That's so great.

[1:11:14] Joe Carroll: Oh my gosh, us too.

[1:11:15] Alison Luff: Us too.

[1:11:16] Dan Tracy: Thanks, man.

[1:11:17] Alison Luff: Thank you so much for the case.

[1:11:21] Joe Carroll: So Carol.

[1:11:22] Dan Tracy: Dan Tracy.

[1:11:23] Joe Carroll: That's it. Thanks for coming on our show.

[1:11:27] Alison Luff: Thank you for chatting with us and sharing. You know what I was gonna say? Just be what I was gonna say this at the beginning. You you may have been one of the the guests that we've been trying to get on here the longest. I think that Dan and asked you like back when you guys were doing Waitress, which was so long ago, and I'm so glad we finally got to make this happen.

[1:11:44] Alison Luff: Me too. I wanted to do this forever. I'm sorry that it hasn't happened sooner, but this feels right.

[1:11:50] Joe Carroll: Listen, you were busy. We were excited you were busy.

[1:11:52] Alison Luff: Absolutely. We tried I think we tried to catch you during filming, but we're so glad you're here now.

[1:11:57] Alison Luff: I'm so glad this worked out.

[1:11:59] Joe Carroll: Me too. You're the best.

[1:12:00] Alison Luff: You're the best. I love y'all. This was really, really fun.

[1:12:05] Dan Tracy: Good. I'm gonna start a podcast now.

[1:12:07] Alison Luff: Honestly, you can't.

[1:12:09] Joe Carroll: Jim's gonna compete with your podcast.

[1:12:10] Alison Luff: Will you guys be my guests?

[1:12:12] Joe Carroll: Yes, yes.

[1:12:13] Dan Tracy: Happily.

[1:12:14] Alison Luff: Happily, happily.

[1:12:18] Joe Carroll: Thank you for listening to Guys Who Like Musicals. We are now part of the Broadway Podcast Network.

[1:12:24] Dan Tracy: Woo!

[1:12:24] Joe Carroll: We are hosted by Dan Tracy.

[1:12:26] Dan Tracy: That's you.

[1:12:27] Joe Carroll: And Joe Carroll.

[1:12:28] Dan Tracy: That's me.

[1:12:28] Joe Carroll: We're produced by Ryan Kincaid, and Matthew Mucha is the social content manager. You can find us on Instagram at Guys Who Like Musicals, on Twitter at Musical Guys, or the old fashioned way at www.guyslikemusicals.com. If you'd like a chance to be featured on the Ask the Guys segment of our show, please call 203 900 7990 and leave a message with your question. As always, thanks for listening.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred