In this episode of Half Hour with Jeff & Richie, we delve into the off-Broadway production of "Joy: A New True Musical" at the Laura Pels Theatre. We explore the inspiring story of Joy Mangano, brought to life by Betsy Wolfe, and discuss the creative direction by Lorin Latarro... Read More
From the show: Half Hour with Jeff & Richie (Post-Show Broadway Discussions and Interviews)
Guests
Featured Shows
About
In this episode of Half Hour with Jeff & Richie, we delve into the off-Broadway production of "Joy: A New True Musical" at the Laura Pels Theatre. We explore the inspiring story of Joy Mangano, brought to life by Betsy Wolfe, and discuss the creative direction by Lorin Latarro. Join us as we analyze the production's themes and standout performances.
Follow and connect with all things @HalfHourPodcast on Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube. Share your thoughts with us on our podcast cover post on Instagram.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jeff Malone: Welcome to Half Hour with Jeff and Richie, the podcast where we explore the latest shows we see, sharing our insights and opinions on the performances, storylines, and everything in between.
[0:08] Richie Grasso: In today's episode, we're discussing the new off-Broadway production of Joy, a true new musical playing at Laura Pels Theatre in New York City.
[0:16] Jeff Malone: Whether you cannot catch the show in person or you want to expand your thoughts after seeing it, this episode is for you.
[0:22] Richie Grasso: And as always, we want to inform you that this episode will contain spoilers.
[0:26] Jeff Malone: So if you're ready to dive into this production, stick around with us.
[0:29] Jeff Malone: I'm Jeff.
[0:29] Richie Grasso: And I'm Richie, and we're thrilled to be your hosts for today's episode.
[0:33] Jeff Malone: But before we start the conversation about Joy, a true new musical, here are a few words from our advertisers.
[0:38] Richie Grasso: Welcome everyone to a new episode of Half Hour with Jeff and Richie.
[0:42] Jeff Malone: Today we're discussing Joy, a true new musical.
[0:45] Richie Grasso: Joy is an uplifting musical based on the true story of entrepreneur and inventor Joy Mangano.
[0:50] Jeff Malone: Her journey, also told in the 2015 film Joy, starring Oscar nominee Jennifer Lawrence, now comes to life on stage.
[0:57] Richie Grasso: From single motherhood and financial struggles to building a business empire, Joy's story shows the power of resilience and determination.
[1:03] Jeff Malone: So you don't want to miss this inspiring celebration of a woman who never gave up and redefined the American dream.
[1:10] Richie Grasso: And I would just like to also note that this musical has a book by Ken Davenport.
[1:16] Jeff Malone: It has music and lyrics by Anne-Marie Malazzo, choreography by Joshua Bagassi, and direction by Lorin Latarro.
[1:23] Richie Grasso: All right. So let's get into our theater hot take for Joy, a true new musical.
[1:28] Jeff Malone: I feel that my hot take on here is around Betsy Wolfe being a master at portraying Joy, but that I found this book to not really tackle enough of the struggle that I was kind of wanting to see.
[1:43] Richie Grasso: And while I take those points that you're hearing, I will say that my hot take is a little lukewarm. I just felt very lukewarm about this whole thing.
[1:56] Jeff Malone: And in terms of the acting in the book, yes, but some score issues I had with some plot movement. I just wasn't blown away by this as much as I wanted to, even though it does have heart.
[2:09] Richie Grasso: So I want to kind of dive into that.
[2:11] Jeff Malone: All right. We'll get into our overthoughts on the plot and concept here.
[2:17] Richie Grasso: So, right off the bat, I think if we're talking about plot and concept with Joy, I like parts of where this book was going with this.
[2:29] Jeff Malone: It felt like it was taking a kind of segment of the real history of how Joy got started in the whole inventing world. It gives you a little backstory on her as a child and wanting to invent things and continuing throughout her life, being an inventor and having so many failed items that eventually she gets there, and we're kind of really surrounded around the mop.
[2:56] Richie Grasso: So getting to QVC. It felt like that was so much of this plot, was like this whole thing was about this mop.
[3:05] Jeff Malone: Yeah. And when you do research on this woman and you find out that she's invented so many other things, she's had such a successful career since the mop, it was very clear that the writers decided to just end this telling of the story at the win of the lawsuit from the mop.
[3:21] Richie Grasso: And then we don't move forward. And listen, I'm not gonna juxtapose what I say a lot on here, which is like, why do we need a hundred year span of someone's whole life story in two hours? Just focus on one thing.
[3:32] Jeff Malone: But I think that this only went halfway with that. When I say focus on one thing, I mean give us a week, an hour, a month, a moment in someone's life. Not or, you know, I love when you say like a week in this family, and then go through not like a few years of a major story.
[3:54] Richie Grasso: Like the whole first act for me, we don't even get to the mop until we're like mop crazy by intermission.
[4:02] Jeff Malone: Yeah. And then I'm like, oh, and actually I remember thinking in intermission, oh great, now we'll get the rest of her story in act two. And when we stayed stagnant in this mop land for the whole act two, I just thought like we really moved very slowly through this woman's life.
[4:21] Richie Grasso: And it didn't feel like that in the beginning. It was like we were moving, we saw she lost her job, okay, and then she cut her hand, and oh, the mop was a bit, and she was trying to get the patent and all, and it was moving and it felt, and I kind of loved the way act one kind of ended with this like QVC, you get a mop, and you get a mop, and whoa, and then I don't know, act two didn't do it for me because it was just so cluttered with like sadness and what's going on with the lawsuit and the mother and the ex-boyfriend, the love with, and I'm like, wait, what happened with her like career story?
[4:52] Jeff Malone: Yeah, I felt that when you really look at the writing here, it's like there's multiple conflicts happening. There's so many almost too many conflicts happening, like you're saying, around her being divorced or her parents being divorced, but they also live with her, and then they also she has a child, but in real life she has three children, and it's just like there's so many different things that feel like is this an inspired story by Joy, or is it a real true life story by Joy?
[5:22] Richie Grasso: Right. And that's why, you know, we had mentioned, like, we realized in some research that she had many children, not just one, but this show focused on her having one. When you pick and choose the things you decide to include in the story, I'm not saying that's 100% good or bad when it comes to minor details, but I don't know. Having three children versus one child to me is a pretty big deal.
[5:45] Jeff Malone: Well, right, because I think when you actually look at Joy and you say, okay, the struggle, which is why I in my hot take, I talk about how like there wasn't enough of the struggle. If I'm looking at this woman and I'm like, okay, she's trying to invent something, she's trying to make a life for herself and her family. I would look at this and saying, like, but she has her parents living in the home with her, she has her ex-husband living in the home with her, and she has one child. But now, if there's two more children in here, it would also make so much more sense to me that I'm like, oh, she's really struggling, she really needs this job.
[6:19] Richie Grasso: And it felt like it didn't really look like they were struggling in the home. Does that make sense? Like, I felt like it was kind of glossed over for the Broadway stage that it was like, okay, they look like they're fine.
[6:34] Jeff Malone: Yeah, and there's like a lot of family living in this house, and money is tight. I understood they tried to tell that as best they could. I almost look at it from this perspective of the it just didn't seem like we're telling this woman's life story.
[6:48] Richie Grasso: I guess it's I understand that it's been filmed and that this woman's been, she's still living, right? So we're telling maybe she had some input on this. The overall plot to me was like it just seems like we focused on just the one big thing.
[7:02] Jeff Malone: And for this woman to have had so many more inventions and so much more life to her and success, I don't know why we ended act two, and I thought, well, what about her other success? I have to go read about it now when I just sat for two and a half hours learning about it.
[7:17] Richie Grasso: Well, it's like they kind of show the clips at the end.
[7:19] Jeff Malone: Yeah, which I like full circle. I did like that.
[7:22] Richie Grasso: Which is like, yeah, I think that's obviously a choice made. I don't know if that's actually written in the script to like show what else Joy has invented.
[7:31] Jeff Malone: I find that this is a lot more about like, yeah, it's around kind of like the American dream of like, you know, if you have the willpower to want to do something and you keep your mind to it and you execute it, you're gonna get it. And like she never gave up.
[7:45] Richie Grasso: So I think there's like heart in it in that way, but like now we're turning this into a musical, so now we're kind of making this glitzy. And when I look at the music to this, I didn't really find that the music kind of added anything special to the story.
[8:01] Jeff Malone: You know, I think that's probably where your struggle also comes from with this because it's like kind of unforgettable songs. The score wasn't doing it for me. Her 11 o'clock number is amazing.
[8:12] Richie Grasso: Um, I still don't even quite remember that. Like, I don't remember, I remember she used to be mine from Waitress. I don't remember this from, not to compare the stories, but there was a lot of similarity to it.
[8:22] Jeff Malone: Right. When you are comparing it to it, many people will say, well, what's Joy like? Well, yeah, you would say it's kind of like a little bit of a mix between Waitress and Legally Blonde. And like it has so many different moments of that in there, mixed with a little bit of like a Dear Evan Hansen sounding score.
[8:39] Richie Grasso: Yeah. And I just didn't think the score in the book did what I would have personally done to tell Joy's story. It seemed like cookie cutter, it seemed like hitting the bases. We gotta have plot, we have to have conflict, we have to have a romance, we have to have an I want song. We have to have a silly, campy rodeo country western, whatever that was.
[9:01] Jeff Malone: I don't know. Like, okay, because the patent guy was from Texas, we have to like make some Dolly Parton-esque number now out of this. Like, I don't understand that. That's just not my thing, you know.
[9:13] Richie Grasso: But I, you know, it was just, yeah, that's why I say lukewarm because I thought there were actually some really great production elements to it. I think from a production standpoint, it was really clean the design and the choices, and we'll get into some of that, you know, next.
[9:28] Jeff Malone: But as an overall concept, in theory, this works. I think it seems like it's screaming to the tourists of the world. It's like, everyone come to New York to see this, because you all bought this mop in 1990, whatever. So, like, come and see it. It's a tourist trap show.
[9:46] Richie Grasso: And it doesn't feel like we need that. And I feel like, yes, maybe, but we've talked to now multiple people that used to actually even buy during the QVC days and the HSN days. And we're like, who is that? And they're like, who?
[10:01] Jeff Malone: Yeah. And that actually even confused me more because I thought like this was like a known, you know, staple in the industry. And like now I only know that it's a known staple in the industry if you bought in that category.
[10:25] Richie Grasso: Yeah, it's interesting.
[10:26] Jeff Malone: Right.
[10:26] Richie Grasso: So we were young when this was all happening, so like I wasn't really watching QVC as a child, but we knew of it, you know, and HSN is another type of QVC and things like that.
[10:36] Jeff Malone: But yeah, just to me, this was just a choice of a plot and a concept that I don't know if I 100% agree with because it seemed really sugarcoated.
[10:46] Richie Grasso: Right, right.
[10:46] Jeff Malone: So I think this is a great time to get into the overall production now.
[10:50] Richie Grasso: So let's take a quick break and when we get back, we'll get into the direction, actor performances, and design.
[10:55] Jeff Malone: Okay, so we're back.
[10:56] Richie Grasso: So let's start talking about this actual production because you and I I think both had the same feeling around something like this show.
[11:03] Jeff Malone: And while we're watching it, I'm looking at this and I was saying, wow, there really has been a lot of work put into this from the production side of things.
[11:11] Richie Grasso: It's almost like it can easily be lifted and put on a Broadway stage.
[11:16] Jeff Malone: Yeah, you're taking a show with no automation, no probably huge wings and flies.
[11:21] Richie Grasso: When we see off Broadway in commercial spaces, specifically in midtown, but even downtown too.
[11:26] Jeff Malone: I find that we're dealing with, and I've been backstage to some of these theaters, right? You're dealing with little to no wing space, some don't have any fly systems in them.
[11:34] Richie Grasso: You're dealing with small houses and small property.
[11:37] Jeff Malone: You're not dealing with the big Broadway houses with the huge flies and the automations and the basements and all that, right?
[11:42] Richie Grasso: So what they're doing is they're doing multiple locations.
[11:45] Jeff Malone: They didn't just throw projections up, they did actual physical scenery that came on and off.
[11:49] Richie Grasso: And yes, maybe there was some automation. Like I feel like some things automated and moved.
[11:54] Jeff Malone: But you know, like they tried to do the best with the space that they had to show multiple locations.
[11:59] Richie Grasso: I actually thought the scene transitions were really strong.
[12:01] Jeff Malone: I thought the way that we went into one scene and the other seemed seamless when we went into QVC, we went into the house and then out of the house.
[12:08] Richie Grasso: It seemed to really move like, oh, yeah, if I'm a potential investor, producer coming to see this, I can now envision how this will look on a Broadway stage.
[12:16] Jeff Malone: I don't have to sit and say, oh wow, they got to redesign half of this time.
[12:20] Richie Grasso: Right, like it needs more budget.
[12:22] Jeff Malone: Out of town in New York.
[12:23] Richie Grasso: Right.
[12:23] Jeff Malone: And it was very well polished from a design perspective.
[12:26] Richie Grasso: These wigs that these women are wearing and the jeans sweater, like 90s looks, I was very impressed with the costumes.
[12:34] Jeff Malone: I remember thinking, like, wow, you really think you're right in the 90s.
[12:38] Richie Grasso: The men had the baggy pants and the pleats, and like it was just so 90s.
[12:42] Jeff Malone: And it like was very, very smart in the way I think they were doing those designs.
[12:47] Richie Grasso: So kudos to costume design uh Tina McCartney for that.
[12:50] Jeff Malone: Right.
[12:51] Richie Grasso: Scenic design, Anna Luisios, and uh lighting design, Yala Lubetsky, sound design, D'Anna Lundberg.
[12:56] Jeff Malone: I thought all the, you know, projection and video design, David Bengali, hair and wig design.
[13:00] Richie Grasso: There we go, Liz Prince.
[13:01] Jeff Malone: I think there were some really great design choices here where all these designers really worked really hard together to put this on in a small space, and it worked in that way, in that way.
[13:11] Richie Grasso: It did.
[13:11] Jeff Malone: I do think the design element of this was like fine.
[13:15] Richie Grasso: It almost kind of felt like you were on that kind of set of QBC, yeah.
[13:19] Jeff Malone: Yeah, you know, you really did have a lot of those moments.
[13:22] Richie Grasso: Listen, you know, sometimes Lauren Lataro is hit or miss for us.
[13:26] Jeff Malone: We do enjoy her choreography sometimes when we see it.
[13:29] Richie Grasso: So I don't know if this is the first thing we're seeing her actually direct.
[13:32] Jeff Malone: Maybe it's the first thing we're seeing her direct.
[13:33] Richie Grasso: Yeah, we've only really seen her choreo.
[13:35] Jeff Malone: Um, and I actually was shocked that we didn't get more choreography in the...
[13:35] Richie Grasso: I know, and it's Joshua Bergassi's name on this, who's a big choreographer, and I thought we were gonna get, but again, we're dealing with you know, but there weren't like dance breaks, right?
[13:47] Jeff Malone: And I maybe they were trying to avoid that, but there wasn't like dance numbers in this.
[13:51] Richie Grasso: Yeah, and almost felt mostly the country western song, I guess.
[13:57] Jeff Malone: Sure, yes.
[13:58] Richie Grasso: I think when you kind of bounced back and forth between like the plot and concept of this and the overall production of this, it felt like one of these shows that like does it want to be serious or does it want to be camp?
[14:13] Jeff Malone: And we throw that word camp around a lot because things like Diana ended up ultimately getting the camp.
[14:20] Richie Grasso: But I don't think they intended for it.
[14:22] Jeff Malone: No, they didn't, and that was like a big thing that's camp.
[14:24] Richie Grasso: Right.
[14:24] Jeff Malone: That was a big thing that everyone talked about around how, like, oh, it was it's so campy, they didn't even realize it was camp.
[14:31] Richie Grasso: But it but a woman trying to sell a mop screams camp to me, right?
[14:37] Jeff Malone: And I think they tried to go there with some of the comedy of it, especially when she was on QVC and she was nervous and trying to sell it.
[14:44] Richie Grasso: But then when you take us out of that and you go to I'm a struggling mother, I have a struggling romance, I have a daughter I have to raise, my mother and my father are still living here, and and you start to kind of go to serious town.
[14:57] Jeff Malone: You say, Oh, now this piece is trying to be something serious.
[15:01] Richie Grasso: But I thought we were just talking about this woman selling this mop.
[15:04] Jeff Malone: So it's like we're back and forth on that, and that's what made this uneasy for me because I'm looking at them like it doesn't know what it wants to be yet.
[15:12] Richie Grasso: Is it gonna be that splashy Taurus Trap Disney-esque feeling show?
[15:16] Jeff Malone: Or is it gonna be the oh Mary S campy comedy, push the boundaries on comedy?
[15:21] Richie Grasso: It didn't really do either, right?
[15:22] Jeff Malone: And that's why when you go to the things like the Diana's or like the Tammy Faye or like Boop, and it has such different like spectacle elements to it that you kind of get in the Broadway show.
[15:34] Richie Grasso: I don't think it fully has the spectacle yet of what that could either make a crossover to being this like campy inspirational thing or just being a serious piece, right?
[15:45] Jeff Malone: And the music didn't really do that enough for me in bringing in it being super um serious and ballady, or it kind of was.
[15:58] Richie Grasso: There were a bunch of ballads in it, but I don't know.
[16:00] Jeff Malone: Like the lyrics just felt surface.
[16:02] Richie Grasso: Right.
[16:03] Jeff Malone: And let's go into some of the performances though for a second.
[16:05] Richie Grasso: Because let's talk about Betsy Wolfe.
[16:07] Jeff Malone: Betsy Wolfe is great.
[16:08] Richie Grasso: She's a Tony nominee. Really enjoy her.
[16:10] Jeff Malone: I don't know if I would 100% agree with what you said in your hot take about her being the master at this role because she's singing it so well.
[16:19] Richie Grasso: The acting is there.
[16:20] Jeff Malone: But I will I will just call out one acting moment.
[16:23] Richie Grasso: I read the Long Island accent kept coming in and out for me throughout the whole piece.
[16:29] Jeff Malone: And sometimes I literally just thought I was watching Betsy.
[16:32] Richie Grasso: And then all of a sudden she go to the Long Island, and I'd be like, whoa, whoa, whoa, where did that come from?
[16:36] Jeff Malone: Like it's almost like it was the comedic moment to put it on and take it off.
[16:40] Richie Grasso: And when I've listened to clips of Joy Mangano speaking, I'm like, there's a little bit of a New York Long Island.
[16:46] Jeff Malone: You know, it's so funny.
[16:46] Richie Grasso: I um people who are not from New York listen to me talk, and they're like, oh my god, you have such a New York accent.
[16:51] Jeff Malone: I don't think I do when I hear accent.
[16:54] Richie Grasso: So I've done a lot of dialect accent work in my undergrad days, and I remember really tuning my ear to some of that and getting the vocal inflections on some of it, and it was just in and out and in and out for me that it did it again.
[17:06] Jeff Malone: If you were gonna push that Long Island accent the whole time, I'm Joy Mangano, there would have been the camp.
[17:13] Richie Grasso: But then it's like we lost it when she was like, you know what I mean?
[17:16] Jeff Malone: Like I said, well, it's so funny too, because like we're so close to Long Island, so it seems like the whole cast could come straight from Long Island, yeah, even the supporting cast where it's like it would be on the same level, and yes, when you do listen to the real joy speak, there is a lot of Long Island in that sales pitch.
[17:35] Richie Grasso: So, like when she is selling.
[17:36] Jeff Malone: Right.
[17:37] Richie Grasso: So, yeah, I I mean, I think it wasn't the worst part of it.
[17:40] Jeff Malone: I thought Betsy still was carrying the whole show.
[17:42] Richie Grasso: She's really great.
[17:43] Jeff Malone: I just it was a right.
[17:44] Richie Grasso: That's probably more what I meant.
[17:45] Jeff Malone: Yeah.
[17:46] Richie Grasso: And carrying the show here, I think she did a great job.
[17:49] Jeff Malone: I do think maybe there could have been a few more directing moments with her, instead of her just standing like front and center on the stage or like looking around.
[17:57] Richie Grasso: It did feel a little bit like okay, what do I do now?
[18:00] Jeff Malone: Yeah.
[18:00] Richie Grasso: At times.
[18:01] Jeff Malone: Right, right.
[18:02] Richie Grasso: But vocally and kind of some of those acting moments did hit it for me.
[18:09] Jeff Malone: Totally.
[18:09] Richie Grasso: And another name I wanted to mention, uh, Jill Abramovitz, who played the mother, she has a great 11 o'clock number.
[18:15] Jeff Malone: I've seen her in a million Broadway shows.
[18:16] Richie Grasso: I feel like she's done a million things.
[18:17] Jeff Malone: It's nice to see her up there.
[18:19] Richie Grasso: That character had a nice arc and change from this really, you know, kind of sad, homebound woman to this, like I showed up for my daughter.
[18:27] Jeff Malone: Right.
[18:28] Richie Grasso: I kind of liked that.
[18:29] Jeff Malone: Right.
[18:29] Richie Grasso: Um, that was a nice touch.
[18:30] Jeff Malone: Um, also really great, just just across the board.
[18:34] Richie Grasso: I thought the ensemble was working really hard.
[18:35] Jeff Malone: I thought there was some nice things throughout.
[18:38] Richie Grasso: Overall, any other specific acting moments that stood out for you?
[18:43] Jeff Malone: I I did enjoy the daughter.
[18:45] Richie Grasso: Yeah, the daughter was great.
[18:47] Jeff Malone: And and actually I want to kind of talk about a director choice here that bothered me a little bit because a lot of times we talk about directors starting a concept or an idea and not finishing it.
[18:58] Richie Grasso: Okay.
[18:59] Jeff Malone: And in the beginning, what do we see? We see the younger version of Joy with the box, and then Joy walks out, and there she is.
[19:05] Richie Grasso: And later on, we see it again, her younger version.
[19:09] Jeff Malone: And that's where theater is to me.
[19:10] Richie Grasso: And I'm like, oh, that's so cool.
[19:12] Jeff Malone: Like you're you're growing in your life and you're reflecting on the younger version of yourself.
[19:16] Richie Grasso: I love that.
[19:17] Jeff Malone: And then at the very, very end of the show, I remember sitting here, it's the last five minutes, they're all belting out this big number, and I thought to myself, oh, the younger version of her will come out.
[19:26] Richie Grasso: Yeah.
[19:27] Jeff Malone: And here she and there she is with her family and her daughter and her life ahead of her.
[19:31] Richie Grasso: And there's the younger version of herself.
[19:33] Jeff Malone: It didn't happen.
[19:34] Richie Grasso: And I'm not even saying like a spoilery thing that been like, oh, this I'm saying what I think probably a lot of people would have thought.
[19:42] Jeff Malone: You started and you and and they're all singing at the end.
[19:45] Richie Grasso: And I thought to myself, where is the actress playing the younger version of her?
[19:48] Jeff Malone: Because she could have just come out.
[19:50] Richie Grasso: And I was like, oh, I unless I'm I don't think it was the same actress who was playing her daughter.
[19:56] Jeff Malone: I don't know.
[19:57] Richie Grasso: I don't know, young joy.
[19:58] Jeff Malone: So I'm like, where was Young Joy at the end to bookend it and button it and bring that out?
[20:04] Richie Grasso: It didn't have to be a million times in the show.
[20:06] Jeff Malone: I just thought at the end that would have been a bookend to her younger version seeing what she became because we never saw her.
[20:13] Richie Grasso: One thing to kind of talk on that is like, don't you feel like their intention is going like that?
[20:21] Jeff Malone: This daughter is the one that continues inventing things.
[20:24] Richie Grasso: Right.
[20:25] Jeff Malone: And we would never know from this musical if that's the truth or not.
[20:28] Richie Grasso: Like, I'm sure we can Google it.
[20:30] Richie Grasso: But I would never know if like the torch is passed on to that child.
[20:35] Jeff Malone: And that's why the one that she singled out in is in the show and not her other two kids.
[20:41] Richie Grasso: Yeah, or but there's then you have multiple things going on at the end. It's like, oh, now it's my daughter, but also what about you? Because we know that she has still has a career going. But it's why there's plot issues because I look at it and I say, Well, oh, okay, are they actually inventing something together? She's trying to get the daughter to do it with her, with the mom. It just feels like a little bit like, oh, it's supposed to happen with her, and that's why we're coming full circle by the end of this show. That like now the daughter kind of takes over as well. And that never really happened. So it's almost like, why is the rest of this happening? And it's kind of almost like you don't really need to see her family at all throughout the piece.
And then they came together for her at the end in the course. But more so just like around what is her struggle and what is her American dream and getting beyond. And that's why, but we started the first four minutes of the show with a concept. This was a it wasn't just Joy walking out. It was the younger version. So we didn't finish the concept from a director perspective. That was a big moment I noticed at the end.
[21:47] Jeff Malone: Right. And I was like, where was this girl? I don't know. She, you're you actually have the actress there. I don't know.
[21:53] Richie Grasso: Right. So I thought that was a missed opportunity.
[21:55] Jeff Malone: I can agree with you. Just a little. Well, this is a good time to segue over to our own experience at the show and what we think is next for Joy. Um, but before we do that, we're gonna take a quick break.
[22:07] Jeff Malone: Okay, and we're back. So let's kind of get into our own experience at the show and kind of like what we felt with the audience around us and what we experienced, and also like what we think is next for Joy. So it this is running in the summer when a lot of Broadway shows close. It actually, again, I'll say this in theory, you would think something like this would be like you're in midtown at a big commercial off-Broadway space, they're advertising this a lot, it's running most of the summer, but the seats aren't really full. There wasn't a full audience. It's running. I don't know if this had any plans to extend or not. It doesn't seem like it's going to. Could they try to put this on Broadway?
I think it got some mixed reviews. Um, they could potentially put it on Broadway next spring or in the future. I personally would go back to the drawing boards and edit a little and fix and clean up. I'm sure they will. I do think like what we said earlier with this is I think that starting something off Broadway in New York seems to be a big trend right now.
[23:03] Richie Grasso: We're seeing a ton of plays. Yeah, we're seeing a ton of plays. We're seeing a ton of musicals that have been transferring and getting that kind of like moment on Broadway. If I really look at something like this, I say to myself, oh, they need to offer a kind of open on Broadway for one moment at least. Whether it's going to be successful or not, I don't know. I don't know what the demand is for a show like Joy, because right now I almost feel like the story is maybe 10 years too behind. Like it should have happened 10 years ago with something like this, where there's a little bit more buzz around Joy and HSN and QVC and things like that. I think we've moved so far away from those kinds of like uh like TV selling uh moments.
But I kind of also think about this a little bit and I say, oh, I think I said to the to you when we were leaving the theater, does this get a high school kind of book to it now where like kids are doing this show in high school? Maybe I don't know.
[24:07] Jeff Malone: I feel like it's it is you know, it's wild to think that this is like a period piece in a way, like a 90s show and there was still no like cell phones and Instagram. You know what? I one thing I said to you is like it is what I found very inspiring and fascinating is how long and difficult it took for this woman to go get this invention shown to the right people. Where nowadays people are creating their own marketplaces on their Instagrams or their Facebooks or they're creating their own stores, their websites. They're they're creating it's very easy to put videos out and get followers. Not it's not easy, but it's easier to get your sometimes your name out in whatever you're doing than it was 20, 30 years ago. Different world, different time.
[24:45] Richie Grasso: So that was interesting to see. Like if this woman invented this mop today, would it have been easier to sell it on her own than having to go to what did they show caldors, right? And like all these stories well that's what you used to have to do. You just have to go and you need to to speak with the buyer and you would have to get a place in the store and it would not always work. But it was like foot to pavement brick and mortar. It wasn't sit at home at the phone and just click yes here's my shops open now you know it's different times.
[25:13] Jeff Malone: So I think that was what was inspiring about the piece. And this piece does have joy no pun intended there is an uplifting feeling to it. It has a feel good feel to it. I just don't know the audience seemed to like it when we were there it wasn't 100% full but I think I enjoyed parts of it.
[25:27] Richie Grasso: Yeah I mean if I kind of think about the audience a little bit and even my own experience with something like this is like it we have joy a true new musical number one I don't really love when we add those subtitles kind of subtitles to the the pieces I think that musicals used to be able to just live on their own it was like rent it was not like rent a new musical if it was a chorus line a true new musical I mean like we didn't have to do that you didn't have to spell it out for everyone it's like a new musical it's like everything just kind of lived on its own it's like aida rent right a chorus like gypsy gypsy it's like why uh why do we do that now I don't know why I it's like really it goes back to like trusting the audience and if it was just like joy I think joy is so powerful on its own.
[26:18] Jeff Malone: It's the single word that we always talk about in a title. Just boom. Now it's like a true new musical. Okay, it's giving me the whole like cliche vibe.
[26:28] Richie Grasso: You mean the title A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum isn't short enough for you?
[26:32] Jeff Malone: No, I love that. I think that's strong, but it wasn't a funny thing happened on the way to the forum. A new music. It's like whatever. We talk about that all the time. If I ever write a musical, uh, I'm not putting a musical behind it.
[26:45] Richie Grasso: Right. But you know, one thing I did want to kind of say in my own experience here is around the actual building of this mop. And I think the biggest moment in this show should have been around that mop. And it just felt a little lackluster for yeah, the drawing the yarn or the rope around stage with the different women, it seemed like it had a concept to it, but it didn't kind of execute the real masterful mind of her creating this more as much as you know, it's and that's the moment where you would think it would be the wow factor in the audience from everyone. And it it you didn't really get that.
[27:21] Jeff Malone: Like I actually almost felt like if they were gonna go camp on this, it would have been the most over exaggerated mop. And I'll give you an example in a Christmas story when the dad opens the leg lamp box, and you're like, what? This family is so excited about the fragile, fragile, the whole thing, right? I'm not a huge fan of that kind of movie, but I get the the hype binds and right. Everything's it's hysterical that this guy put the leg lamp in, and then in the Broadway show, they had the whole leg lamp number, right? It was like I love it.
[27:53] Richie Grasso: But that when the mop came and she just pulled it out. First of all, in the real world, you would have had packaging in it. Like it was just like it looked like, oh, she just pulled it out of the prop box. Like it didn't have the oh my god, her mop is here. This is her brain child. And it didn't feel like that.
[28:10] Jeff Malone: Right. Which could have been, yeah.
[28:12] Richie Grasso: Maybe we just want this to be campier. Maybe it's gonna do musical theater. And like, even you know, we're getting to the act one finale, and they're running through the audience, and they're basically throwing mops at people, which is hysterical, I think. But like, even that could have been more yeah, the you get them up, you get them up, everyone gets a mop, you know.
[28:30] Jeff Malone: But like uh, but now I even think about mop, and I'm like, who uses a mop anymore? You use a Swiffer, or you use something that's different, and it's like you know, yeah, different time.
[28:40] Richie Grasso: I know. But overall, I wonder whatever happens with this. It'll be interesting to see. It could sit on a shelf, it could go to a Broadway. I mean, those are two very different outcomes of this. It had a long summer run, it didn't close early. It is, I mean, as we record this, and we don't know if it's closing early, it's going till mid-aware. You know, also, is it something that goes to the West End and has a bigger moment there? You know, sometimes I find the West End is very interested in like American, you know, stories and things like Tammy Faye did so well there, but like didn't do well here, and now this is having its moment here, but maybe it does go there, or maybe a tours, maybe like you the rest of America loves something like the communities want to do it in high schools and colleges, and it licenses out, you say, you know, you know, it could be one of those things, so yeah.
[29:27] Jeff Malone: Oh my gosh, just about out of time. What are your final thoughts on Joy? A true new musical.
[29:32] Richie Grasso: Listen, I I didn't hate it, I didn't, you know, love it. It wasn't the greatest thing I've had ever seen, but yeah, it does have heart, it does have moments in the piece that like I think are inspiring to some. And I was inspired enduring moments. Uh, but I did find that I needed more from the struggle in this. I wanted to connect more, just a little bit more with her in really seeing the passion that she had for inventing something. Because that's probably the biggest word for me that may have been missing from her performance was the true passion of wanting to invent something.
[30:10] Jeff Malone: Yeah.
[30:10] Richie Grasso: And overall, like I said, same thing I said earlier. Lukewarm didn't love it, didn't hate it. I fell on the fence about it. It felt overall okay. This is what we're getting now. This is a story to tell. And it is a true new musical. And let's tell it in a way this was a choice. And uh we'll we'll see what happens.
[30:27] Jeff Malone: Right. And if it goes to Broadway, we'll see if they make changes.
[30:30] Richie Grasso: Yeah, you know.
[30:31] Jeff Malone: Exactly. Well, that does wrap up our discussion of this episode. We hope you enjoyed our deep dive into Joy, a true new musical.
[30:37] Richie Grasso: And remember, we want to hear from you. Continue the conversation with us on Instagram and TikTok at Half Hour Podcast.
[30:43] Jeff Malone: And drop us a comment on Spotify and let us know your thoughts on Joy, a true new musical.
[30:49] Richie Grasso: Please also leave us a review. Your reviews mean so much to us.
[30:52] Jeff Malone: And remember to subscribe to our channel for all past and future episodes.
[30:56] Richie Grasso: Until next time, I'm Jeff.
[30:57] Jeff Malone: And I'm Richie saying ta ta for now.
[30:59] Richie Grasso: Bye.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
