Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Inside TROPHY BOYS: Gender and Power at MCC Theatre

Join us as we discuss "Trophy Boys," the Off-Broadway sensation at MCC Theatre. This episode unpacks the play's exploration of gender roles and power dynamics, and the performances by Terry Hu, Louisa Jacobson, Esco Jouléy, and Emmanuelle Mattana... Read More

From the show: Half Hour with Jeff & Richie (Post-Show Broadway Discussions and Interviews)

26 mins
7/25/25

Guests

About

Join us as we discuss "Trophy Boys," the Off-Broadway sensation at MCC Theatre. This episode unpacks the play's exploration of gender roles and power dynamics, and the performances by Terry Hu, Louisa Jacobson, Esco Jouléy, and Emmanuelle Mattana. Directed by Donya Taymor, "Trophy Boys" presents a thought-provoking examination of contemporary issues.

Follow and connect with all things @HalfHourPodcast on ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Instagram⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠, ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠TikTok⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠, and ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠YouTube⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠. Share your thoughts with us ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠on our podcast cover post on Instagram.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Jeff Malone: Welcome to Half Hour with Jeff and Richie, the podcast where we explore the latest shows we see, sharing our insights and opinions on the performances, storylines, and everything in between.

[0:08] Richie Grasso: In today's episode, we're discussing the off-Broadway production of TROPHY Boys, playing at Robert W. Wilson MCC's Theater Space in New York City.

[0:16] Jeff Malone: Whether you cannot catch the show in person or you want to expand your thoughts after seeing it, this episode is for you.

[0:21] Richie Grasso: And as always, we want to inform you that this episode will contain spoilers.

[0:24] Jeff Malone: So if you're ready to dive into this production, stick around with us.

[0:28] Jeff Malone: I'm Jeff.

[0:28] Richie Grasso: And I'm Richie, and we're thrilled to be your hosts for today's episode.

[0:31] Jeff Malone: But before we start the conversation about TROPHY Boys, here are a few words from our advertisers.

[0:38] Richie Grasso: Welcome everyone to a new episode of Half Hour with Jeff and Richie.

[0:41] Jeff Malone: Today we're discussing TROPHY Boys.

[0:43] Richie Grasso: Quote, feminism has failed women, end quote. That is the prompt given to the debate team of an elite all-boys prep school one hour before the final match of their high school careers.

[0:54] Jeff Malone: As they develop compelling arguments to demolish their sister school, a rumor leaks about their team that threatens to blow up everything they have worked for.

[1:02] Richie Grasso: What begins as a riotously funny satire turns into a sharp exploration of power and privilege from high school to the highest circles of political influence.

[1:11] Jeff Malone: Following multiple sold-out runs in Australia, playwright Emmanuelle Mattana's TROPHY Boys makes its American premiere in a thrilling new production featuring Mattana as part of the cast.

[1:21] Richie Grasso: Directed by 2024 Tony Award winner Donya Taymor of The Outsiders, TROPHY Boys is a provocative comedy about the singular pursuit of victory and the cost of reaching it.

[1:32] Jeff Malone: So let's get into our hot take for TROPHY Boys.

[1:35] Richie Grasso: My hot take here is that MCC Theater has once again hit it out of the park by bringing us one of the most, I think, thought-provoking plays that I've seen within the last year.

[1:50] Jeff Malone: I would say totally agree with that. I think TROPHY Boys is taking what we're currently dealing with in the world. It's pushing us into the future to look ahead and say, how do we think? How do we act? What's the next generation gonna be like? And what are we doing now to further that or prevent things from happening in the future in many ways?

[2:10] Richie Grasso: And this play really dives into so many topics regarding...

[2:13] Jeff Malone: I couldn't agree more. And I can't wait to start discussing this play with you. Here we go.

[2:17] Richie Grasso: So when we talk about our overall thoughts on this, I mean, I think we're dealing with two things here. We're talking about, first of all, I always like plays that just are set in a specific time period at a specific time, and not let's tell this person's story over 50 years. And instead, we're talking about a very time-crunched moment here.

[2:37] Jeff Malone: One hour before a debate at an all-boys Catholic school facing an all-girls school, and we're gonna just start the debate. So already we're set up with gender because it's an all-boys team competing against an all-girls team and their prep schools.

[2:51] Richie Grasso: I don't I think I said Catholic school, I think they're prep schools, right?

[2:53] Jeff Malone: Yeah. And so here we are in this classroom. There's one hour. The play is only a little over an hour. So we're like on the clock with them. So I already feel very like wow, beat the clock kind of feeling. I think that's really exciting.

[3:06] Richie Grasso: So we start with that feeling. So, in just in terms of the concept alone, one location, one group of people, we don't see the other prep team. We don't actually see the actual debate. We're just seeing the preparation. Already I feel like the stakes are high when something like that is set like that in this concept. Would you agree?

[3:24] Jeff Malone: I totally agree. And to touch on one thing you just said there, we don't actually see the debate, but the way the play is written, it leads you to believe we're either watching the debate live, and it's just in this setting in the classroom, but also what their prep was like during it. So it has, I mean, it's never really clarified that way. That's just up for us as the visual to say, like, oh, because they have moments where they talk about like, hey mom and dad, or hey grandma in the audience, you don't know. And they do break that fourth wall of time. So you never really a hundred percent. If that's like, oh, wait, is that supposed to be them in the debate? It's almost like a flashback or like a flash forward.

[4:05] Richie Grasso: Yeah, you know, something like that. And so we have like this concept, and already I'm thinking this concept works, right? We're gonna talk about feminism and male and female, and we're gonna, and then I think the next layer of this becomes casting the quote unquote trophy boys as female presenting or non-binary presenting actors. We don't, I believe, have any male identifying he, him pronoun actors playing these roles. And yet the characters are male boy characters.

[4:34] Jeff Malone: So I think that's like a whole nother level here because I remember leaving the show and saying to you, would this show work the same way or differently if it was for male presenting actors playing these roles? Because I think already the show could have worked in that way, and I think this makes you think so much deeper and makes the play so much better and more interesting to say, ooh, this is cool. They're playing these really, you know, masculine boys, you know, masculine, like toxic masculinity, if you want to say it in that way.

[5:11] Richie Grasso: Do you think that this play presents differently with male identifying actors playing these characters versus this production, which is using female or non-binary actors playing the roles?

[5:24] Jeff Malone: I think that that would make a different play. And I love what they did with this play with the casting and the way they presented these really, you know, masculine characters in the way that they did with the actors that they have. I think it would totally change it if it was, you know, male identifying or presenting actors playing the roles. I don't think that this play is about that at all. I think this is about kind of breaking down the boundary of how we see gender in this world and how it's been such a construct for so long of like who is female presenting and who is male presenting.

[6:01] Richie Grasso: Because I think, you know, if I really dig deep into what the playwright is trying to kind of convey in having, you know, female presenting, but in the male kind of getup, is that like anyone can be that? Mm-hmm. And then why do we like make it, oh, you know, men have to wear this or women have to wear this.

[6:25] Jeff Malone: Right. And yet, in the context of the piece, we're talking about the all boys' school versus the all girls' school. So already we're set up for like, wait, we're gonna talk about this topic being feminine, uh, what did I say earlier? So feminism, feminism has failed women. So we're already talking about a very gender heavy topic, and it's not a mixed male and female team versus a mixed male and female team, which you think it should be. Because we're talking about, and yet we're gonna take these two prep schools that are all female, all male and debate it.

[6:57] Richie Grasso: And as the play unravels, I think you see the difficulties that this team goes through. They're all four very different characters, if you realize that. Who's more jock-oriented, who's more booky-oriented, and they all come together, who's friends and who's not, and they learn more about each other throughout this one hour.

[7:17] Jeff Malone: And they present these ideas where some of them, like, oh yeah, yeah, yeah, do that. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, do that. And they kind of almost play like the naive high school boy, right? The like, and they have those moments where they like rip their shirts off and they're like humping the desk, and they just show the animalistic sexual energy of the man, right? And that's kind of funny. You're sitting there, like, wow, they're really kind of going into this whole that's where the comedy comes with this is the absurdity of like an all men's team talking about this.

[7:48] Richie Grasso: And yet at times I think there's glimmers of hope, like, oh wait, they're making a good point. Oh, wait, I think they dropped the ball. Wait, but they're actually making a really good point there. Uh, but wait a second, now they're talking about their friend and this girlfriend, and okay, wait, now we're so it just feels like as an audience member, we're pushing the gas and then we're pushing the break and pushing the gas and pushing the break. And I felt good about that. Sometimes I leave shows and I say, whoa, whoa, whoa, I'm on a roller coaster and I can't keep up.

[8:15] Jeff Malone: Yeah. And I felt like instead I was like, oh, you're taking me along with you. You're all over that classroom, physically and intellectually. That was smart direction and smart acting and smart writing.

[8:27] Richie Grasso: Right. And when you look at going back to the smart writing of this, I feel that there are many parallels in this as well. That I feel like, you know, Emmanuelle might be saying, like, hey, what is sexual exploration in high school amongst your peers? You know, and you have four very different men who are going through like what is their sexual exploration, right now? Because there are even themes of like male on male. Well, there's homosexual themes here, there's heterosexual themes with dating women and how they interact with women, and you know, they're also coming from an all-boys school, which like maybe their interactions with females are different than if they went to a co-ed high school, right? And what that would have been like for them, things like that.

[9:20] Jeff Malone: But when you have the prompt here around feminism has failed women, I find that there is such a bigger topic as well. Now we're watching four female presenting women play male characters playing the male characters, right? Playing the males. Okay. And now it's probably written that way too, if you get the play, um, in the same way. So when I look at that, I say, oh, what would this be like if the tables were turned and we were in the female room right now? You know, that's where I would put the question back to you is like, what would this play be like if you have four women there that are played by men?

[9:55] Richie Grasso: Yeah, male identifying actors, right? I assume you're saying, yeah, it does. And then I'm what are the topics that they're talking about around feminism? Because I find it even bigger. It's like, oh, are they going through the same sexual exploration? And, you know, we touch on this topic of me too here because ultimately the twist in this play is that someone is uh accused of having um I don't remember the exact accusation, but there was some rumor that was spread about sexual assault.

[10:28] Jeff Malone: Yes.

[10:28] Richie Grasso: Okay, so one of the team members on the female side was sexually assaulted by one of the guys in the room. Okay, so that I think that's a big topic, but like what how did that get to that point in that other room is also and it became cutthroat at that point and it became accusatory, and we are in a world right now where there's nothing but accusations and trials and and crimes committed and people be uh I mean, look at what we're dealing with in the world today with politicians and celebrities and all of that, and male and female.

[11:00] Jeff Malone: And I also find in the word from the playwright in the uh it says from Emmanuelle, it says, quote, gender is learnt, which also means which means it is also taught, and quote. So I think that's what's interesting too, is gender is wow. Like what I can sit here for another half an hour and talk just about gender, right? But the play is making enough statement on gender without beating you over the head with it. They're just telling you through story, they're telling you through a piece of theater.

[11:25] Richie Grasso: And that's is how you, as an audience member, can leave and say, Oh, I felt I could connect it with that character, or I felt like I connected with the playwright, or or I don't know if I I don't know what I agree with on the topic of feminism as fail women or not. You know, it lets you well, all right. There are so many things. There's so many things to think.

[11:39] Jeff Malone: And when you look at that, and from that quote from the letter about gender is taught, I think there's so much to say about what we're actually seeing on the stage because we're talking about the gender that we have been taught to know and speak by, and not only gender identity, but the societal quote unquote norms of those things. Boys do this, girls do that, boys dress this way, girls dress that way, and that's been a very hot topic for so long, right? Is all these feelings around gender and and sexual orientation, and those are two different things, but also kind of sometimes go in and end depending on what we're talking about.

[12:17] Richie Grasso: So there's a lot to talk about. And and leads it into like the bigger topic of all around power. Like that's uh the biggest thing that we're not even touching on, is like all four of them want power, all four of them want to move on in their careers. And now that they potentially have a sexual assault case on them pinned on them, one of them has to figure out who it is. And all four of them go down a rabbit hole of what you're possibly who that person is in that room, which makes it even more mind blowing.

[12:49] Jeff Malone: Well, I do want to get onto some of the actor performances and the design choices and some of the actual, uh, those aspects of the piece.

[12:56] Richie Grasso: So why don't we take a quick break and then when we get back, we'll go into some of those aspects of the piece when we get back from a word from our sponsors.

[13:04] Jeff Malone: And we're back. So I want to talk a little bit about some of the direction and some of the design choices and the acting performances here. So I think Emmanuel writing this piece and putting themselves in the piece already is an awesome choice. I think that's really, really cool. I love seeing playwrights put themselves in their own pieces. Some people don't like that. I really like that. I think that's kind of cool. I think when it works, it works.

[13:23] Richie Grasso: Yeah, and in this case, I think it works really well.

[13:27] Jeff Malone: Yes. I think putting Donya Taymor on this makes complete sense. I think Danya is really accomplished in what she's doing, did with The Outsiders, winning the Tony Award for that, and then going on to something like this. She seems to work really well with high school age characters, male and female, and working together with them. She also did John Proctor is the Villain this season, too. So she's got a lot of representation in New York right now. Also high school, also high school, right? So I think she's dealing with like that so well, and she's working with some really great playwrights telling great stories like that. So I think she was a great choice.

[14:03] Richie Grasso: I love the direction of breaking moments to go into lighting effects where we would go into talking to the audience or that whole sexual animalistic energy scene, right? Or when a song would play, you know, this. What did we notice about all the songs that were being played?

[14:20] Jeff Malone: They were very controversial pop tunes, right? Would you say?

[14:24] Richie Grasso: Well, I would say more along the lines of what we were talking about earlier around toxic masculinity or male questionable lyric. Right, male like sexual exploration, very like could it be, you know, touchy. Right. And so I think that was very, very interesting. I also do want to talk a lot about the scenic design here was by Matt Saunders. And I thought what was so interesting about the scenic design is when the play first started, it said on the podium that it was a cat, oh, I keep saying Catholic school, I believe it was a prep all girls school. And it said all girls school. And I looked around the room and I saw all these. Did you see all the very prolific and important women of history posted everywhere and the magazines and everything looked like and so when they came in the first five minutes?

I was I didn't even know they were male characters. I thought they were just the female characters in the school getup, and I wasn't, I was like, wait a second, is this an all-girl? And when they say, oh, we're at the all-girls school debating them, and this is the room we're using. I found the irony there and the juxtaposition of this toxic masculine character energy mixed with like Ruth Bader Ginsburg on the wall. You know what I'm saying? Like, I think, and I don't know about you, but I kept looking up at the wall to just see those women's faces and be like, and I literally had multiple times. So I thought to myself, what would they think right now of what's going on in this?

[15:52] Jeff Malone: Well, I think that's the whole point. And they're literally and figuratively like looming over them while they're writing on the board and writing on the desk and typing things out and figuring out how to win this debate. Because again, it also seems to come down to winning. There's this what is the title of this play? Trophy Boys, the trophy, the win. And multiple times these characters say, I need to go to college. I need to get that great job. I need to move out of this town. I need to, and this need to be the best that they can be because of the school environment they go to or their families, or whatever it is. There's this like looming feeling of like fight, fight, fight, win, win, win.

Right. And oh my gosh, I'm gonna get derailed. How do we avoid that? It's it would it almost didn't become about the debate topic anymore. We had drifted so far away from has feminism failed women or not? And instead we're talking about a scandal. Right. And actually, one of the reviewers, I believe it was Theater Mania, said, it this piece feels like Gossip Girl meets Lord of the Flies. And I thought that was so interesting because it was Gossip Girly at times, and it was totally Lord of the Flies at times. And so you're taking these like ooh, really high stakes moments, and you're drastically changing the lighting and you're putting on music that's very interesting. And the costumes are though very prep school, and yet you have then the scenic design with these women. So, like up on the wall. So, all of these design choices, I think, worked flawlessly together in this branch.

[17:21] Richie Grasso: I think so too. I mean, I think the biggest thing there is like, yes, these super powerful and high profile women on these walls that are overlooking this is like the irony in it of itself. Like, hey, these guys are just in the all-girls prep school right now, and they're debating a topic around feminism. When you would say that most of those women up on the wall are some of the biggest feminists out there, and then you have this happening, and then also going to that topic, yes. Going away from the topic seem to be the issue throughout the piece itself. And the actual topic of debate clubs and debate teams is always most times a controversial statement. It's usually a one-liner that's like, ooh, great thought on that.

What do we think? And that's how you decide who wins based on all the research they do, right? So I thought all those design choices were great. If we talk about some of the actor performances, I really thought all four were wonderful. Terry Hu, Louisa Jacobson, Esco Jouléy, and Emmanuelle Mattana, all really brought a completely different energy to the room. And they really had a great collaboration between the four of them, connection between the four of them. I think they all really volleyed off of each other with the text that's given to them. I would say big standout for me was probably Esco Jouléy, who played Scott. I thought there was such a connection that they had with their character that you could really feel some of like the masculine, feminine pulling back and forth, and it just like was a big standoff, right?

I and I look at these performers and I say, can they bring this to Broadway? Can they bring this to a film? Can the four of them keep doing this? I know it's only running to August 3rd, but I mean, it was it was just good energy.

[19:19] Jeff Malone: Yeah, I think when you see actors putting in that great energy and they're in this tight space, and we're in a small theater and we're there with them, and we're just there, yeah, and you're just letting the plot play out. I think Danya's direction of them and having the again, like I said, having the playwright in the cast to me is great. I just like that a lot. I really do like that a lot. So cool stuff. Well, maybe we'll take a quick break and we'll go over to some thoughts on what we thought about our own experiences just being at MCC, being at the show, and maybe what we think might be next for this play. So we'll be right back after a few words from our sponsors.

[19:54] Jeff Malone: Okay, and we're back here. So let's get into our own experience at the show and also what we think might be next for TROPHY Boys. So I'm gonna start this one off here with our own experience at the show because what did we have during the show? We had three very famous strong women sitting in right in front of us.

[20:16] Richie Grasso: Yes, and it was the gay gasp by the two of us at this show because just start listing them off. We had I'm so sorry, Julie Tamore, who is related to Donya Taymor. So that there was the family supporting the family. I love that female director to female director. And then we live our love. Yeah, and then we see I'm so sorry, Meryl Streep sitting right in front of us next to I'm so sorry, Laurie Metcalf. And they're just like laughing and loving it and intrigued by it. And I kept looking at Meryl, and Meryl was in it. She was in it. Meryl, if you're listening, I saw you. I think you liked that, Meryl. And so I was like, go produce the film version of this, maybe or something. I loved that she was there.

Yeah, I loved that these strong women in the theater and in film are just there supporting this young new piece. Like when you think of all the Broadway shows that Meryl Streep could be sitting in right now and all the London West End shows, and you're here, yeah, we're in midtown still, but you're on an off-Broadway space at a new show, yeah, that is making its world premiere American premiere, I should say, right here. Let's get this to the next level. I think more audiences need to see this. I can totally, you know what? I leave MCC, and almost every time I say that could go to Broadway.

[21:31] Jeff Malone: Oh, yeah. I say it almost every time. The Jason Robert Brown musical. I was like, I saw The Connector, we saw Shimmy Fan. I was like, that's the Table of 17. Table 17 could go to Broadway. This MCC to me is always the like, oh my gosh, this could go right to Broadway. And I know that's not the end goal for every show. I totally get that. But MCC to me, I've never left a show in MCC and didn't like it. I've always loved the energy and the mission and the meaning behind what they're doing in their awesome space right in Midtown. I just find the work to be so new, to be so modern, to be so like thought-provoking, as I love to say on this podcast. Like, if you make me think and you keep me engaged, which is like has been a success for us when we go to an MCC show.

[22:12] Richie Grasso: Yeah, I mean, I'm very excited about it. And when you see these other people in the audience with us and that they're enjoying it as well, you know that there's so much potential for the works that are coming out of this space, you know. And it's really great.

[22:27] Jeff Malone: Totally. And I think, and the to ask the other question, what do you think could be the future of this play? I think there's a lot of potential for this play. I think that yes, it could easily go to a Broadway stage. This is very on the nose with like Manhattan Theater Club and what they're putting on the stage. I think that you know, this is aligned with something like John Proctor is the Villain. You know, maybe John Proctor is the Villain has a bigger title, which gets, you know, a younger group of people in right now. But I think that this has something as well. It has heart. It has a mission. And I think, you know, putting a new work on a stage like this would be super important. I think it could go to another space and play.

I think a film adaptation of this could totally work. Yeah. And hopefully it'll pick up some off-Broadway theater awards this year because I think it could totally have that energy. Not that it's about the awards, but I think it could totally be eligible for some of that too.

[23:22] Richie Grasso: Yeah, I would love to see this as a film. Yeah. Just like I have said I we just recently heard John Proctor is the Villain is going to be made into a film. But like when you see something like this as a film, do you keep it exactly as is or do you expand? Almost every time a play is adapted for film, there's usually a screenwriter or an adapter on board to edit it because a lot of times, you know, films will try to make one room shows more filmic. So they'll try to bring you to multiple locations or do flashbacks or so I wonder if this would stay the like one hour in the room. Maybe we actually see the debate or maybe we would see flashbacks or maybe we would see the other debate team at some times.

You know sometimes I feel like shows do maybe I don't know or maybe it's very a la like Breakfast Club like they stay in the room the whole time. Right. They get to their point and then like they're walking across the field after and you find out what happens in that way. Very old school 80s style you know I think that would be fun.

[24:22] Jeff Malone: Totally totally but so oh my gosh just about out of time here. What are your final thoughts on MCC Theater's American premiere of TROPHY Boys Off Broadway?

[24:26] Richie Grasso: Listen, I'll say it again. Love MCC Theater. I love the works that they're putting out. I think that it's some of my favorite stuff that comes out. So definitely check this out while you still can. I mean, you know, and I hope there's going to be more for this play after this.

[24:46] Jeff Malone: Yeah, it's playing till August 3rd. Run and grab a ticket if you can. We really enjoy this. It's an hour and 10 minutes, no intermission. It's thought-provoking. It's a think piece. Go in, think, observe, and see great acting, great direction, great writing. It's just really refreshing. In a time where Broadway is really quiet right now with new works, I'm always diving into the off-Broadway new works to check out what's going on. So totally recommended.

[25:09] Richie Grasso: All right. Well, that wraps up our discussion for this episode. We hope you enjoyed our deep dive into TROPHY Boys. Remember, we want to hear from you. Continue the conversation with us on Instagram at TikTok at Half Hour Podcast. And drop us a comment on Spotify and let us know your thoughts on TROPHY Boys. And please leave us a review because your reviews mean so much to us. And remember to subscribe to our channel for all past and future episodes. Until next time, I'm Jeff.

[25:31] Richie Grasso: And I'm Richie saying ta-ta for now.

[25:33] Jeff Malone: Bye.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred