In this episode, we sit down with Matt Koplik, Host of the BROADWAY BREAKDOWN to dive into the Fall 2024 Broadway season. We discuss a diverse lineup of musicals including MAYBE HAPPY ENDING, SUNSET BOULEVARD, A WONDERFUL WORLD, TAMMY FAYE, DEATH BECOMES HER, SWEPT AWAY, and GYPSY... Read More
From the show: Half Hour with Jeff & Richie (Post-Show Broadway Discussions and Interviews)
Guests
Featured Shows
About
In this episode, we sit down with Matt Koplik, Host of the BROADWAY BREAKDOWN to dive into the Fall 2024 Broadway season. We discuss a diverse lineup of musicals including MAYBE HAPPY ENDING, SUNSET BOULEVARD, A WONDERFUL WORLD, TAMMY FAYE, DEATH BECOMES HER, SWEPT AWAY, and GYPSY. With an honorable summer season mention ONCE UPON A MATTRESS. Join us as we explore the casting choices, directors, and creative teams behind these productions, and share our thoughts on their potential impact on the theater industry. We also make early Tony predictions.
Follow and connect with all things @HalfHourPodcast on Instagram, and YouTube. Share your thoughts with us on our podcast cover post on Instagram.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:08] Jeff Malone: Welcome to Half Hour with Jeff and Richie.
[0:10] Richie Grasso: I'm Jeff.
[0:11] Richie Grasso: And I'm Richie.
[0:12] Jeff Malone: And today we welcome back Matt Koplik for part two of our fall 2024 Broadway season conversation, where we are now focusing on the musicals.
[0:21] Matt Koplik: Thank you for having me back.
[0:22] Jeff Malone: It's been days since we've talked to you about the plays.
[0:27] Matt Koplik: It really has. I was so nervous you weren't gonna bring me back that I pooped the bed so hard. And that you called and you said, "No, you're coming back, boy." And I clicked my heels and here I am.
[0:40] Jeff Malone: Here we go. Great. Boy, you're back on the podcast.
[0:43] Richie Grasso: Just a reminder, everyone, Matt hosts the Broadway Breakdown, and this show can be found on the Broadway Podcast Network. So make sure you go and listen to Matt and the Broadway Breakdown.
[0:54] Jeff Malone: So if you've listened, we have a part one to this. It was about all the plays. So we ask you to go and listen to some of that so you can get an idea of what all the plays are for this upcoming season.
[1:03] Richie Grasso: We're only going through 2024. We're not talking about anything past January 1st, 2025 because that's a whole nother podcast episode for another day.
[1:11] Jeff Malone: But today we're talking about the fall 2024 musicals, actually kind of starting with ONCE UPON a Mattress, technically summer and moving through.
[1:18] Richie Grasso: So the musicals that we're going to discuss today in no particular order are ONCE UPON a Mattress, MAYBE HAPPY ENDING, SUNSET BOULEVARD, A WONDERFUL WORLD, TAMMY FAYE, DEATH BECOMES HER, SWEPT AWAY, and Gypsy.
[1:33] Matt Koplik: And if you asked Rogers and Hammerstein 75 years ago if that was gonna be the lineup of shows, I don't know what they would have said because those are the most wildly obscure titles I just read there in one breath, but I can't read that.
[1:47] Jeff Malone: But I think Hammerstein would have been thrilled. He was all for having as many stories and representations out there as possible.
[1:54] Richie Grasso: Yeah.
[1:55] Matt Koplik: He truly was the epitome of ally of the 40s and 50s.
[2:00] Jeff Malone: Yeah, yeah, yeah. They were cutting edge with their stuff too.
[2:02] Richie Grasso: We'll have an R and H episode because I think that could be fun one day.
[2:05] Matt Koplik: Oh, well, if you bring me on for an R and H episode, that'll be the one 90-minute half hour episode you ever do.
[2:11] Richie Grasso: It'll be half hour times three with Matt.
[2:13] Matt Koplik: Exactly. Part yeah, we'll do a three-parter.
[2:16] Richie Grasso: Yes.
[2:17] Matt Koplik: That's all you need to know. They were cutting it.
[2:18] Jeff Malone: So maybe we'll start with ONCE UPON a Mattress only because that's what's currently happening right now.
[2:23] Richie Grasso: It just opened.
[2:24] Matt Koplik: We're actually seeing it tomorrow.
[2:27] Richie Grasso: But we saw it at City Center, so we can certainly talk about the majority of the casting stayed the same.
[2:31] Matt Koplik: But I just saw it. So I know you have a whole episode coming out or out already.
[2:36] Richie Grasso: It'll be out by this point, yeah.
[2:37] Matt Koplik: Great, amazing. So thoughts on Sutton and Mattress?
[2:40] Matt Koplik: So I also saw Mattress at Encores. I have a season subscription, thank you. And I thought it was fine at Encores. I wasn't in love with it, but also I never go to Encores being like, "What's gonna be the show to transfer?" I think that's the wrong way to approach any production of Encores. I thought it was a perfectly pleasant Encores production.
[2:58] Matt Koplik: And so when they announced they were transferring it, I was a little surprised. I saw it with a friend who loved it at Encores. He was a little more negative on the Broadway version than I was. I think he was expecting a lot more beefing up of the production and not a literal copy-paste of what it is.
[3:17] Matt Koplik: They have not done much to beef it up. They've added $20 to the set. There are a couple of new cast members, and I think they've added a bit more choreo, but overall it's the same. I think this production is fine. I don't think it's terribly special. I don't think Mattress is a terribly special musical to begin with.
[3:35] Matt Koplik: I would argue the best thing about it is Michael Urie. He's so funny. For me, he is the MVP because for a show like Mattress, it's gotta be fast, it's gotta be funny, it's gotta be bubbly. So that means everyone in the company has to be making choices that are big, specific, and tight. And I think Urie is really the only one who does all three.
[3:54] Matt Koplik: Sutton goes big and she goes specific, but I wouldn't say her performance is particularly tight.
[4:00] Richie Grasso: Okay.
[4:01] Matt Koplik: And then a lot of all the new cast members are trying, but they have not spent as much time with this material as the Encore people have. So like Anna Gasteyer is still very much finding her footing. She hasn't really figured it out yet. Will Chase is figuring it out.
[4:15] Matt Koplik: So yeah, I'll be interested to see what happens. It got very good reviews when we're recording this episode, but it does close in November and we have a lot of other revivals coming in and a lot of musicals to compete with performances.
[4:30] Richie Grasso: So I'm fascinated to see if this does well at all with the Tonys, or if it's just like it happened so long ago and recently.
[4:38] Matt Koplik: I actually never really thought I would ever see this on Broadway in my life because I thought when Sarah Jessica Parker did it in the 90s and we never really heard of the show again, and Carol Burnett obviously from the original, I was like, "Okay, maybe this show is like done," but every high school and middle school and community theater seems to do it. It's like such a popular show.
[4:54] Richie Grasso: So I'm like, okay, I listen, I'm a huge Sutton fan. I don't think that woman could do any wrong personally. I think that this woman is just constantly working, she's growing as a performer. I loved her in it.
[5:05] Matt Koplik: And Michael, like you said, yes, Michael is comedy gold in this. I think he's so funny.
[5:09] Matt Koplik: Yeah, and some of the songs are a little forgettable, I'll be honest. I think it's, you know, I don't know. It's not like there's a few standout songs, but yeah, this is a copy and paste.
[5:19] Richie Grasso: And I know Into the Woods was, I guess Parade kind of was. I don't know if that's just their new thing.
[5:24] Matt Koplik: It kind of is. I don't want to speak too much out of school because I'm not the one in the room for all of this, but I have enough spies in those rooms. I do know that Encores is trying to make one transfer a season happen, and the more they can just copy-paste the better because it's cheaper to move, it is easier for them to recoup.
[5:47] Matt Koplik: Parade, I do know there was a little bit of beefing up, but it was probably like 85% what was at City Center. Into the Woods was exactly the way it was at City Center. The difference is Into the Woods is a better musical than Mattress.
[6:00] Matt Koplik: And like, yeah, you're right, Mattress is done all over the country. It's always been done all over the country. Part of it is because it is not a show with a lot of demands on its cast, so a lot of different ages can do it. There are like eight, nine principal roles, and so that's easy for schools and community theaters to do.
[6:16] Matt Koplik: And Sutton is good in Mattress. This is definitely, I think, more in her wheelhouse than Sweeney or Music Man.
[6:23] Richie Grasso: I think for me, I was, yeah, and I'm Sutton's very important to me too. I think I was hoping she would sing it with the same gusto we remember her for in Anything Goes and Millie.
[6:40] Matt Koplik: And Sutton is singing a little more carefully and intelligently these days, which power to her. She's like, "I have my two Tonys, I'm an above-the-title star, I've been one for years. I don't have to kill myself vocally to please you, so I'm not gonna do that."
[6:55] Matt Koplik: So I'm like, I get that. But I will say I found, and she sings a lot of this score well, but "Shy," which is the first big number, I still find to be a little vocally underwhelming from her. But when she and Urie are on stage, it's great.
[7:08] Richie Grasso: Right, right.
[7:08] Matt Koplik: And um, so that's interesting to see it again.
[7:11] Richie Grasso: Yeah, and like when we talk about revivals, I mean, this is just one of many leading women in a musical or female actresses in a musical will be very saturated because we already have her for that. We have Nicole Scherzinger for SUNSET BOULEVARD, we have Audra McDonald for Gypsy, Meghan Hilty and Jennifer Samard for Death Becomes.
[7:32] Matt Koplik: These are all potential. It's just so, is Sutton forgotten, maybe?
[7:35] Richie Grasso: I hate to say that.
[7:36] Matt Koplik: Yeah, because I think this show will be kind of forgotten by the time we get to Tonys next.
[7:39] Richie Grasso: Yeah, I mean, that's just, you know, off the top of our head, we also have the leading actress from TAMMY FAYE, the leading actress from MAYBE HAPPY ENDING. We've got Adina for Redwood, we've got Jasmine Rogers for Boop, whoever whatever talented gal they get to play Mabel in Pirates of Penzance.
[7:45] Matt Koplik: She could be a stellar performance.
[7:57] Richie Grasso: I do, I see a world where Sutton does get forgotten come Tony time, and it's just gonna be because the show will have been so far away, and it wasn't too far away, and it's not the cultural phenomenon that Woods was.
[7:57] Matt Koplik: Like it got good reviews, it didn't get the kind of reviews Woods got, and like Woods came in from Encores like hot to trot, a big ticket, for at least for the time that Sarah Bareilles was in the show, and that isn't really happening with Mattress.
[8:22] Richie Grasso: And so I feel like that had a lot like going around it, like coming back from COVID into the what's going on, and C and Sonic just passed away.
[8:30] Matt Koplik: Yeah, it was like all the right moments, and like going back to what you're saying about Encores wanting to maybe transfer at least one a season, it feels very lazy to me.
[8:38] Richie Grasso: I don't really know why that's happening.
[8:41] Matt Koplik: Because I feel like it should be inspiration, and then like if they really want to move it, can we elevate it to something else?
[8:49] Richie Grasso: Yeah, that's, and like the sense of event is gone now.
[8:54] Matt Koplik: The only time I watched an Encores is because in the past when Encores shows did transfer, it was a genuine sense of like, "Oh, this can't end here. This is too," it was an audience collectively going, "This show is better than we remembered it being, and the person they have spearheading this is so perfect for it."
[9:12] Richie Grasso: So, like Chicago was obviously the impetus for all this, but the next time that really happened was Donna Murphy with Wonderful Town.
[9:19] Matt Koplik: And the only time I ever experienced that in person at Encores was Chenoweth doing The Apple Tree, where everyone went, "Oh, this show is actually really good. Chenoweth is perfect for it. This has to go somewhere."
[9:31] Richie Grasso: And that wasn't really for me, that wasn't the case of Mattress. Mattress was everyone going, like, "This is so much fun." And that was it.
[9:37] Matt Koplik: Yeah.
[9:37] Richie Grasso: Right, exactly.
[9:38] Matt Koplik: And maybe that's the summer bubbly thing.
[9:40] Richie Grasso: But then you look at, and we get dark things coming. I mean, I even look, I mean, let me stay on revival for a second. If we were to go down the path of SUNSET BOULEVARD and Gypsy, yes, I mean, I think we're gonna get two very different revivals.
[9:54] Matt Koplik: What I'm hearing is that this, we, the Sunset's gonna be its own thing doing, it's a very avant-garde, different thing with lush full orchestration still, thank God, because that's always my favorite part, is that they keep full orchestras in these revivals.
[10:08] Richie Grasso: Gypsy sounds like it's gonna be like traditional-esque, but also skew a little bit into a different light, but also won't be like we're gonna have a bare stage and we're gonna like all be in black, like in SUNSET BOULEVARD.
[10:20] Matt Koplik: So, like, I think we're gonna get completely different, like, right?
[10:24] Richie Grasso: I don't know. Like, I think we're gonna get such different revivals here.
[10:26] Matt Koplik: Yeah, right. Again, I'm not in the rooms for any of these things, but I do have people involved with Gypsy on both the producer and on the creative team end.
[10:36] Matt Koplik: And I have confirmation that it is the original libretto. There are no changes being made. Not that there ever were, but there was a rumor going around before they announced it that they were doing a rewrite.
[10:46] Richie Grasso: And the people I know involved were like, "No, that was never happening. I don't know where that rumor started from."
[10:51] Matt Koplik: But George C. Wolfe has no intention of changing the text. He is such a brilliant man.
[11:02] Richie Grasso: Oh my gosh.
[11:04] Matt Koplik: Even if the man just did the original Angels in America, he's the man that did the original Angels in America.
[11:09] Richie Grasso: Right.
[11:10] Matt Koplik: But also like the original Jelly's Last Jam and Shuffle Along and Caroline or Change and that revival of Normal Heart that was so exceptional.
[11:18] Richie Grasso: And yes, he has had duds, but I would argue he's never done anything that has been a total why or without merit, even the things that didn't work.
[11:27] Matt Koplik: Like I understand why in 1999 he wanted to do On the Town. I understand why he wanted to do an Iceman Come with Denzel Washington or like Gary for Taylor Mac.
[11:37] Richie Grasso: Like it's, he has such a varied career.
[11:40] Matt Koplik: And with Gypsy, I think the rewards can be really plentiful. It may not work in the end, but the possibility of what it can be is so exciting.
[11:48] Richie Grasso: And I do understand it's gonna be a full orchestra.
[11:51] Matt Koplik: I mean design-wise, who knows? I don't think it's gonna be bare, but right, he's got a keen eye, and he's really figuring out like by casting Audra and not changing the text, how does this change everything?
[12:02] Richie Grasso: We have to be conscious without forcing anything.
[12:06] Matt Koplik: And if ever there was a director I trusted to do that, it's George.
[12:10] Richie Grasso: So I'm, it's why I again, arm's length open mind. Like I'm very excited, but I'm not letting it ruin it.
[12:17] Matt Koplik: And to me, I think if I had to, it sounds like it's gonna be between Nicole Scherzinger and Audra McDonald for the Tony.
[12:22] Richie Grasso: That's just what I'm envisioning.
[12:23] Matt Koplik: It's gonna be neck and neck.
[12:25] Richie Grasso: I would think.
[12:26] Matt Koplik: I could be so wrong, but bold statement.
[12:28] Richie Grasso: Yeah.
[12:30] Matt Koplik: We haven't even, who the heck knows what's going to happen with Smash that's coming in in the spring.
[12:35] Richie Grasso: Yeah, we have the lead actress from TAMMY FAYE who I think was up against Nicole for the Olivier last year.
[12:41] Matt Koplik: Yeah, she won the—
[12:42] Richie Grasso: Oh.
[12:43] Matt Koplik: Oh, then she won, then she won the year before because she did win in this woman.
[12:45] Richie Grasso: I forget her name, but I forget her name as well.
[12:48] Matt Koplik: And then Jasmine Rogers for Boop, like just got stars born reviews out of town, and everyone was like, if they can get this show like in check, this thing is gonna launch her.
[12:59] Richie Grasso: And then we got Jen and Megan, who you know everyone loves, and we're just like give them the right vehicle.
[13:04] Matt Koplik: So yeah, I mean, I think Audra's in this sort of weird position with Gypsy where it's everyone's like, this is the role of all roles. She is Audra, who is the ultimate.
[13:14] Matt Koplik: And if she does what we think can happen, because everyone's also like not sure if she's right for it.
[13:20] Matt Koplik: So it's a combination of like, is she is this a case of Audrey biting off more than she can chew? Or is this the case of where she's gonna yet again prove us all wrong?
[13:37] Richie Grasso: Welcome back. What I'm starting to see, and this could be a whole nother conversation of the day, too, is like when you're putting Sutton Foster and Marion Peru, when you're putting Audra McDonald and you're taking vocals that are usually not the traditional Barbara Cook, Shirley Jones, or Patti LuPone, Ethel Merman. And so it's like, okay, I think we're just I don't think we're changing score or book per se. I think we're just changing our ear a little bit to say maybe this role can be done this way because it's been done 80 times this way, so maybe we try it this way. I think that's just the world we're living in.
[14:07] Matt Koplik: Well, I'm in a very different seat because I've never seen a stage production of Gypsy. So I have no one to compare it to.
[14:18] Richie Grasso: Good.
[14:19] Matt Koplik: No, I don't know. I was gonna say everyone's already saying, like, is she gonna be better than Patti? And like everyone's gonna compare it to Patti.
[14:26] Matt Koplik: Okay, so I'm gonna say something very controversial on this podcast, everyone.
[14:30] Richie Grasso: Okay.
[14:31] Matt Koplik: I am a homosexual who is not in love with the Patti LuPone Gypsy. I'm sorry, we have to go, everyone. Thank you so much for listening.
[14:40] Matt Koplik: And I'm a homosexual that's not in love with Patti LuPone. And I think I became a homosexual when I saw Patti do the 2008 Gypsy revival. There we have it.
[14:51] Matt Koplik: Okay. I think Gypsy is one of those shows where you know its reputation precedes it, and it's so easy to treat it with kid gloves or micromanage it. My intro to it was of all things the Tyne Daly cast recording, and Tyne famously not like the world's greatest singer, and she was also sick when they recorded that cast album. So she's not like giving you powerhouse vocals on it, although I think she makes up for it with her stamina and her intensity. If you watch, there is a bootleg of her on YouTube of the whole production, and she is in a much better voice in that.
[15:22] Richie Grasso: Yeah, it's pretty cool.
[15:24] Matt Koplik: It is, I mean, that recording is for me still so fantastic. Just like the fire and energy of it. It's my favorite recording of that overture, Eric Stern, who's the music conductor of that one. And if you're a nerd like I am, you know that Eric Stern is the top. It's the dankness of that orchestra. Like when they get to the vaudeville stuff, you're like, ooh, this is dirty, and it's so good.
[15:49] Matt Koplik: My issue with the Patti Gypsy, and it's not Patti necessarily, it was more Arthur Lawrence for me, who was so anti the Sam Mendes revival, and he would be like the burn of dead, right? And he said, I want everyone to know because he did the same thing with his West Side Story revival, which was just like a real gap and Calvin Klein presents West Side Story. He was like, I want everyone to know before I die that yes, Sondheim became Sondheim and Julie Stein and all those people. But like I wrote the book for Gypsy, and you're gonna know that this book is good because we're gonna stretch everything out to five hours long. And he told his cast, you are all actors, and no one's gonna act this better than you, and you are going to act it.
[16:29] Matt Koplik: And so I saw it early in the run when it was good, and then I saw it six months into the run where I was like, Oh, now it's nine hours long.
[16:35] Richie Grasso: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[16:36] Matt Koplik: So I was I have mixed memories of that. Um, so I'm excited for George Seawolf to just come in and F things up.
[16:44] Richie Grasso: Yeah, just I think treat our classics, you don't disrespect them, but like they have fun with them, you know.
[16:53] Matt Koplik: Right. It was my issue with his past Sweeney Todd of like, why is this so clean and precise and safe? Like, it's Sweeney. Get dirty, get messy, get dangerous. But even with the Camelot revival, it was like this very sterile, like, uh, where is the castle? Like, I get it, like you know, but you're in Lincoln Center, and I'm like, what I'm like, what underwhelming.
[17:12] Richie Grasso: And then you're very underwhelming.
[17:14] Matt Koplik: So, you know, I mean, and it's interesting because we'll have Pirates of Penzance in the spring, which I guess is another revival, and then I think there's something else on this. Floyd Collins and Last Five Years.
[17:24] Richie Grasso: Uh, and Last Five Years, right?
[17:26] Matt Koplik: Yeah. Which um we those those are all three revivals that are giant question marks for me. Not of like why, but just let us see.
[17:36] Matt Koplik: And then it's interesting because when I look at new works, I say to myself, Well, last year's new works were How to Dance in Ohio and Harmony and didn't make it to the Tonys and got nothing. So it's like when I look at SWEPT AWAY, TAMMY FAYE, DEATH BECOMES HER, MAYBE HAPPY ENDING. I'm like, okay, I don't want to say that one of them is gonna flop, but what doesn't make it past New Year's Day? Because at this point, I feel like there's always something in the summer or the fall that doesn't make it, but maybe they will all make it. I don't know.
[18:01] Matt Koplik: I'm gonna be pessimistic and say I've heard lovely things about SWEPT AWAY. I just, and maybe it'll prove me wrong. I don't see that making it to Tony Time. At least maybe it'll get nominated for stuff. I don't see it running till then. Um I don't see TAMMY FAYE running till then. That they are just in too big a theater.
[18:20] Richie Grasso: I know.
[18:22] Matt Koplik: And they lost Andrew Rannells now to Christian Borle, which is fine. Um, but I thought I think Andrew Rannells would have been the bigger pull for the wise. It just puts a bad taste in everyone's mouth about how that went down.
[18:34] Richie Grasso: I know, yeah, I know.
[18:35] Matt Koplik: And it's like Elton's trying to do this, but he's also trying to do Devil Wears Prada in London and eventually that get here. I don't know. And Elton's not a good enough musical theater writer to multitask that way. Like if he's gonna actually work on something, he's gotta be in the room. But he's someone has forgotten to remind him that he also did Lestat and not just Aida and Lion King and Billy Elliott. I'm like, you also did these. So like you need to there's always you need to be here, baby.
[19:05] Matt Koplik: Sometimes I also wonder if for A WONDERFUL WORLD, I keep forgetting it's coming because once again, there's been no promo. We've seen the photos of um oh my gosh, why am I blanking on his name? James Monroe Iglehart doing it, and he looks so different in this Louis Armstrong look. To me, is it like is it gonna be the older generation Taurus trappy kind of show? Because we all love the Louis Armstrong stuff. Is it gonna be a flop? I don't know with that show. It's yeah, I know it did well on the road, it just got bad reviews, but apparently they've done a big rewrite for Broadway.
[19:39] Matt Koplik: Um we'll see I've I have a friend who's in it and he hasn't read the script yet, but he said the sides are really good. So um yeah, and I think it's Chris Renshaw's directing it who did the Donna Murphy King and I.
[19:51] Richie Grasso: Uh which is yeah, such a random that is so random.
[19:55] Matt Koplik: Yeah, a long time ago.
[19:57] Richie Grasso: Yeah, he also did Taboo with uh George.
[20:00] Matt Koplik: Yeah, so yeah, Taboo, Taboo.
[20:03] Matt Koplik: Uh I sound like Catherine O'Hara in Schitt's Creek. Taboo.
[20:10] Richie Grasso: Taboo.
[20:11] Matt Koplik: Uh yeah, no, we'll say bio jukebox musicals, jukebox musicals in general, but especially bio jukebox musicals. I feel like if we're talking about Tonys here, they don't acknowledge them often. It's more begrudgingly. You have to be an Ain't Too Proud or a Jersey Boys. It's just too big a hit to deny. And we're and where critics are going like, you know what? Pleasantly surprised.
[20:34] Richie Grasso: Right.
[20:36] Matt Koplik: Because people say, Oh, uh Tony voters love to award people for playing real people. I'm like, yeah, you know, we do have Stephanie J. Block winning for Cher Show and the Boys from Jersey Boys winning, but it's not that common. Uh like Rashad was nominated, didn't win. Will Swenson wasn't behind it at all. Alicia Keys last year. I mean, and we did have uh Jessie Mueller for Carole King. She didn't that's but again, that was too big a hit to deny, and critics going, This was better than I expected.
[21:05] Richie Grasso: Right.
[21:05] Matt Koplik: That was also a case of Broadway being like, finally, like we can award Jessie as like the next big thing. Like there's so many politics that go into it.
[21:13] Richie Grasso: And then where has she been?
[21:14] Matt Koplik: Where please, Jessie Mueller, if you're listening. I love her, and I don't know where she is.
[21:19] Richie Grasso: Well it's been years.
[21:20] Matt Koplik: I know post-COVID, she did The Minutes, and I understand why she'd want to do her. And she did the Guys and Dolls um in Kennedy Center.
[21:30] Richie Grasso: I last year with Philippa Soo.
[21:32] Matt Koplik: So I know she's doing stuff, but I do like her. She's in her like I don't have to prove anything to anyone phase, which I appreciate.
[21:39] Richie Grasso: Yeah.
[21:40] Matt Koplik: Yeah, I think with A WONDERFUL WORLD, it's gonna be interesting because I wonder if we're moving farther away from older biomusicals and just the newer stuff is what might stick.
[21:50] Richie Grasso: Yeah, I don't know.
[21:52] Matt Koplik: I think it always just depends because something like MJ, obviously, Michael Jackson just sells no matter where that material goes, no matter what stigma is on it or controversy. What helps is that that production has like four numbers that are so incredibly done and they happen far apart enough that you can forget about anything in between them that was maybe a little mediocre.
[22:16] Matt Koplik: And which I don't think that's um shady to say. Like there's a lot of mediocre nice in MJ, but they like the opening, the smooth criminal, the finale, the rise of the Jackson Five, like those are four tent pole moments that happen just far enough apart that the audience of the city. No, those were the good moments.
[22:35] Richie Grasso: I agree with you.
[22:36] Matt Koplik: The rest was very mediocre. None of it was like summer bad, but it was it was it but you because you know what I mean.
[22:44] Richie Grasso: Like summer for me was it was a case of they had a concept that didn't work in terms of you know, we have all these women playing men and we're gonna have the three different Donnas but also the problem is when you have the estate involved in the in the show you can't ever really delve into the bad stuff because you want you're supposed to make them look as good as possible.
[23:05] Matt Koplik: So they try to like play off the whole Donna saying Adam and Eve, not Adam and Steve. And it and yeah, and it's all we left there and we were like no.
[23:17] Richie Grasso: Yeah, it was not what it could have been.
[23:19] Matt Koplik: I also think that it'll be real I have I'm really stumped on this MAYBE HAPPY ENDING because it seems like it came out of left field. You do have Darren Criss on it that could sell the tickets, but it's no one knows it.
[23:32] Richie Grasso: I don't know what's it's gonna be.
[23:34] Matt Koplik: And now they delayed by a few weeks because of technical um supply chain issues. So now they're like, I guess it's gonna be very tech heavy. I don't know what to think of this one.
[23:43] Matt Koplik: I truly don't.
[23:43] Richie Grasso: Yeah, I've asked around about this one, and everyone who has been to either readings or I think they they did it in Atlanta, right?
[23:52] Matt Koplik: It was at the Alliance.
[23:53] Richie Grasso: Yeah, I had people saw it there.
[23:55] Matt Koplik: And everyone says like it's a really charming show. What they're nervous about is not the quality or even Darren's ability to sell tickets, because he does sell tickets anytime he does Broadway, but they said that they're nervous that they're gonna make it too big of a production for what that story is, because it's ultimately a three-person show.
[24:15] Richie Grasso: And I mean, the Belasco's not a barn, but every any theater can feel like a barn if it's housing the wrong show, right?
[24:23] Matt Koplik: Like uh Heart of Rock and Roll, the Jones is not a huge theater, but it does have a lot of open orchestra space, and it was too big for Heart of Rock and Roll. The Hayes is a famously small theater, and yet I think it's too big for Job.
[24:37] Richie Grasso: Like it's uh and I wonder if the Barrymore might seem too big for MAYBE HAPPY ENDING, if that's a show that should be in like the Music Box or something.
[24:45] Matt Koplik: And the uh Longacre was too big for Limpika because I felt like I was the only person in there.
[24:50] Richie Grasso: Well, there were so many empty seats, I couldn't.
[24:53] Matt Koplik: I was like, why is this here?
[24:55] Richie Grasso: I don't I don't know.
[24:56] Matt Koplik: That's an interesting space too.
[24:57] Richie Grasso: But that was just my take on it.
[24:59] Matt Koplik: We only have so many more minutes, Richie.
[25:00] Richie Grasso: I can't get into the I know.
[25:04] Matt Koplik: It's a whole conversation of the day.
[25:06] Richie Grasso: Yes.
[25:06] Matt Koplik: I didn't talk and we didn't talk about DEATH BECOMES HER really at all. I'm very excited about it. I think it's gonna work. I don't know. I just have this cut that all the Chicago people that I know loved it.
[25:16] Richie Grasso: I don't know. How do both of you feel about the movie?
[25:22] Matt Koplik: We'll be right back.
[25:26] Richie Grasso: Let's jump back into things.
[25:29] Matt Koplik: Great.
[25:29] Richie Grasso: I like the movie.
[25:30] Matt Koplik: Yeah, it's campy 90s uh kids, you know.
[25:34] Richie Grasso: I don't know. Jeff, speak more on this.
[25:37] Jeff Malone: I feel like it's just one of those things that you remember like when you were younger, you're like, ooh, I probably shouldn't be watching this movie. And um it's like Meryl Streep, Goldie Hawn, realness for us, and I think that's why I'm excited about it, but I don't know.
[25:53] Matt Koplik: I think Megan and Jennifer might give us that, which I'm fine with.
[25:59] Jeff Malone: Well, yeah, I love both of them. I still think they're that they should be switching roles, but people tell me that no, I tell you there it works when you see the show, it works.
[26:08] Matt Koplik: But for me, the movie would be interesting to see that though, because I feel like they're fine in their roles, but I don't know.
[26:15] Jeff Malone: I like I just I I more picture Jennifer Samara doing what Meryl does, and I more picture Megan doing what Goldie does, but maybe they're far more versatile than we realize.
[26:27] Matt Koplik: They are.
[26:27] Jeff Malone: I love them both dearly. The movie has never been a classic for me. I love anything where Meryl and Goldie are on screen together. Like I think Isabella Rossellini is wild in that movie, and I'm so bored by everything Bruce Willis does in it.
[26:42] Matt Koplik: So, like for me, it is 40% of a hysterical camp classic and 60% of a okay. So I'm interested to see how they handle it in the stage show. If they make enough changes to really expand the campy fun that we all remember the movie for being. It's funny because we have so many family and friends and just people that we talk to, and when they get tell me what's coming, and oh I gotta see DEATH BECOMES HER, like I think of the non-theater person a lot. I say, is the non-theater person going to MAYBE HAPPY ENDING, or is the non-theater person going to DEATH BECOMES HER? And all I hear is like, oh, Halloween time, DEATH BECOMES HER? Yeah, it can't be fun. Yeah, totally, I'm there. Like, so I don't know.
Like, who knows, right? I mean I think if it ends up working, it could be a nice surprise hit because it is gonna be big enough that tourists will feel like they got their money's worth in terms of spectacle, and it'll be weird enough that gays and New Yorkers will feel like it's not just run-of-the-mill right commercial cash grab. Like, I'm listening anything that's on Broadway.
[27:46] Richie Grasso: Yeah, anything on Broadway is technically speaking a commercial cash grab. Everyone is trying to make money on Broadway, but you can have a little more fun with doing that. Well, when it used to be movies to the stage, it would be very, I don't know, different. Like when you look at something like the early Modern Millie and you go back and watch that film, they're so very different, and it was used as inspiration, not like let's just translate the early Modern Millie to the stage.
[28:12] Matt Koplik: Yeah, and I feel like that's what's missing a lot in what's coming now. It just feels like, oh, let's just put the same thing on the stage.
[28:20] Richie Grasso: Yeah. Where how can you expand it? How can you maybe even improve it? That's also what I think is great about the best movie remakes. Like if you watch the original Thomas Crown Affair and then the Rene Russo Thomas Crown Affair, you're like, oh, they made this far funnier and sexier and more interesting. And it just makes more sense.
[28:39] Matt Koplik: But yeah, Millie, I mean, anyone I always say people who complain about the racial politics of the stage version of Millie, and it is not perfect, it is not perfect. But if you watch the original movie, it is so clear how hard they worked to improve it and make huge strides, and they did, they really did. And even in the music that they wrote for it, like they found the interesting parts of the film and they created songs around it rather than just making a dumb song like Back to the Future did that had nothing to do with the movie, right?
[29:10] Richie Grasso: The other epic musical.
[29:12] Matt Koplik: I'm just saying, right, right. No one can see me, but I was waving my arms like kill it with fire the moment Jeff brought up Back to the Future.
[29:19] Richie Grasso: No, thank you, no ma'am. I had to bring it up because we all have those episodes on our podcast of that show. But I'm bringing this up because that's how I found Matt. I found Matt through his Back to the Future review, and I will never go back to not reading that review because that's one of my favorites.
[29:36] Matt Koplik: Thank you. And I will also say, you know, we're almost out of time, but we have a lot of shows coming in the spring as well. But whether some of these shows close early, we can't also forget the shows that are currently playing because I did just read the grosses today of the week of August, what are we, 11th, closing, and Water for Elephants dipped in the middle of the summer, Notebook dipped in the middle of the summer.
[29:58] Richie Grasso: Wait, like way dipped, yes.
[29:59] Matt Koplik: And so I'm like, oh, if Elephants and Notebook don't make it past Christmas, do we have those theaters empty for new potential musicals to come in the spring?
[30:08] Richie Grasso: 1000%. Hell's Kitchen's really strong. Cabaret's really strong. Outsiders is really strong.
[30:15] Matt Koplik: Unless, and I put stuff in the mix there.
[30:18] Richie Grasso: Subsystem a little too and Back to the Future. Honestly, Back to the Future did clear a million this past week, but barely. And this is tourist season, and they just got to their year mark, and it costs literally a million dollars a week to run. I don't think Back to the Future makes it past January of next year.
[30:35] Matt Koplik: Yeah. And we discussed after job about a show that is interested in that theater. So we won't say it on mic, but yeah, but yeah, in that theater.
[30:45] Richie Grasso: And the Harmony Theater filled it, and the oh, How to Dance in Ohio filled it. Like these theaters find a way of filling. I someone I know in the industry is someone who knows some of they say there is apparently a long laundry list waiting list of...
[30:51] Matt Koplik: Oh yes. I can tell you with confidence that Buena Vista Social Club and Dead Outlaw are like primed and ready to go for the spring, which I'm here for. I'm here for. I think crowded as this season is, I say we could never have too many musicals in a season. I'm like, because if sometimes they're not good, or sometimes they just don't hit, and we need things to hit, so...
[31:14] Richie Grasso: And then I'll say the last thing is then it's also really smart if you're the producer of Queen of Versailles and you're like, hey, we're coming in 2026, we'll see you then. Yeah, because maybe they're like Kristen needs the Tony for this, or we want a best musical potential, and it's just too saturated right now. So we'll be the first one on the list for the next, you know.
[31:32] Matt Koplik: You know, I think that's smart producing, I think, in a way, you know.
[31:37] Richie Grasso: Okay, and take a year to fix the book, because I heard the book is...
[31:37] Matt Koplik: Yeah, I think it was a smart decision for many reasons. It builds them more momentum, it builds them time. Kristen can do a project in between. She can clear the way from Audra and Adina for possible actress win. And yes, then the reviews came out. They were like, there's something here you have work to do. So that does buy them time. And also, and Michael's got MAYBE HAPPY ENDING in the fall anyway. So like that gives him time to do that show, and then in the spring work on Versailles.
[32:06] Richie Grasso: That's the other thing I want to say, because in your email to me, was talking about trends, and I didn't get to say this in the last episode.
[32:13] Matt Koplik: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[32:13] Richie Grasso: The trend this season is how many directors have like more than one show this season? Because we have Strowman doing our favorite play of the year, Left on Tenth, and then Smash in the spring. We have Kenny Leon with Home and then Our Town and then Othello in the spring. Everyone's like doing a million shows.
[32:30] Matt Koplik: Kenny Leon always working, always working.
[32:33] Richie Grasso: And then Jake. I'm always like, I'm just I'm a little bit, you know, being a director, working with directors and seeing some wonderful directors work. I'm always like, can you just have one show? Can you let someone else kind of come in? I'm not saying like we need to... There's just so many great off-Broadway directors, off-off-Broadway directors that are just waiting to kind of come in here. And when you see, like, oh, you know, Michael Grief had three last season. I think it's like, I don't know.
[32:56] Matt Koplik: I give I have one.
[32:58] Richie Grasso: I mean three shows, same facade, different... three shows, same color palette, and I can't rightfully say that I loved any of them, but that's not... I don't know. It's one of those things where I'm just like, I would rather these directors, I mean, and it's not up to Michael, like it's sometimes the money's there and it goes and they have to figure it out. But yeah, I'm like, I would rather you have one show this season and really give it your all and knock me sideways and have three shows that I walk out and go, okay.
[33:33] Matt Koplik: Yeah, which was that, that was if you what you just said was how we walked out of maybe 75% of all the shows this past season was okay. What did we say? Most of not all, but most kill the narrator in every musical going forward. I'm sick and tired of it. I say it all the time here. I'm sick and baby cheeses. The number of narrators we had last season, I was like, well, and when Lempica came out, and I think it was Helen Shaw Vulture in her review, is like, so can we stop for a minute of starting shows with someone coming out being like, I guess you want to know how we got here?
[34:06] Matt Koplik: And then Michael R. Jackson was like, How about you don't tell writers what to do? And I'm like, how about writers look around and realize, oh, if 20 of us did the same thing, maybe I should think of something else. But it comes down to what I always say, which is you have to trust your audience a little bit more because we've spent a hundred years of the Broadway industry with yes, of course, there's been narrators, some shows like Into the Woods have prolific narrators for a reason, but you have to trust your audience that we're gonna follow this plot. Come on, but I'm so sick of it.
[34:35] Richie Grasso: They also changed that last minute in Lempica because we had a friend that saw probably like what the second week preview or whatever, and they were like, There was no narrator. What are you talking about? And I was like, What do you mean? She literally comes out and narrates in the beginning, and he's like, Oh no, I hate that.
[34:48] Matt Koplik: Yeah, yeah. They, they, I think it always started on the park bench, but it was just her singing, and then they added the like, I bet you want to know how I got here. And I'm sitting here being like, I don't know who you are.
[35:00] Richie Grasso: Yeah, right. The best narrators in shows, there is a reason, and we gotta wrap up because we are going over. But there's always a reason. Like, as you said, the narrator in Into the Woods, but that serves a dramatic purpose in addition to like being part of fairy tales. Man and the Man in Chair and Drowsy Chaperone, not only does he give us tidbits, but like thematically and for his character, it all ties together. The MC and Cabaret. I mean, there's a reason why he's hosting that show.
[35:23] Matt Koplik: And Jersey Boys, all four of them are the narrators, and we come to realize like halfway through act one that they're all unreliable. And it creates like a fun tension to that show.
[35:34] Richie Grasso: But everything else is like it does just seem lazy and like an exposition dump.
[35:38] Matt Koplik: Yep.
[35:39] Richie Grasso: Last thing I'll say before we wrap up here, we'll give our best musical picks because if Dead Outlaw comes, like you said, maybe it's coming. That's my pick for winning best musical.
[35:52] Matt Koplik: Oh yeah. So I'm gonna, yeah, I'm gonna go in the narrative that Dead Outlaw and Buena Vista Social Club come in this season, and I'm going to say, oh, also another director doing two shows, Tina Lenda with Redwood, and then Floyd Collins. Also like very tight turnaround for those shows.
[36:08] Richie Grasso: I am gonna say Dead Outlaw, Buena Vista Social Club. I'm gonna say, hmm. I'm gonna say boop. I'm hoping that they get their act together and it works. I'm gonna say DEATH BECOMES HER.
[36:23] Matt Koplik: And there's a fifth.
[36:25] Richie Grasso: I would throw Smash in there. I think there's potential for it. I don't know because I love the music from that show. I'm gonna say now I don't think Smash is doing the right thing with this production.
[36:35] Matt Koplik: Okay.
[36:35] Richie Grasso: I everyone I know who saw the workshop of Smash was like, it's fascinating. I can't say it's good. But also, I'm speaking secondhand, so I haven't seen it. And I just everyone has said, like, there's what they think they're doing, and then there's what they're doing. And if they were doing what they thought they were doing, it would be brilliant and like run for 10 years. But like, but that's not actually what's happening right now.
[37:03] Matt Koplik: Right.
[37:04] Richie Grasso: So one I know. Yeah, you hope that with we also have, I mean there's also Old Friends, the Sondheim review with the butt.
[37:11] Matt Koplik: Oh my god.
[37:12] Richie Grasso: Yeah, I know, right? We'll have to talk spring in another episode for this.
[37:15] Matt Koplik: That's another one.
[37:17] Richie Grasso: I don't know. I mean I've heard lovely things about SWEPT AWAY, but it's just a matter of like, can they make it to the spring? If they can make it to the spring, I'll give them my fifth slot. Selling tickets in January and February is the hardest time. It's kind of hard in September, October too-ish, but January, February is really tough to sell tickets.
[37:33] Matt Koplik: Yeah.
[37:33] Richie Grasso: SWEPT AWAY has the same marketing and look as Amazing Grace, and I feel like it's gonna come and go.
[37:39] Matt Koplik: Well, I'm hoping it's better than Amazing Grace.
[37:42] Richie Grasso: Just yeah, like I'll never forget fighting with a room full of people after having seen that show, which was bad. We all know it was objectively bad. But this room of people said to me, Well, you can't deny that the message is important. And I said, The message is that slavery is bad. Of course, that's important. The show is garbage. Like, what did it want? The best the last five minutes of them singing Amazing Grace was the best part.
[38:07] Matt Koplik: Well, you know what it gave me? It gave me Tick, Tick... Boom vibes, the movie where it's like we have this whole story that has nothing to do with the final product, and everyone comes on stage and they go, and then he made the art, and we all said, Thank you, leading man, for making the art. And then here and here is the art. Like it's like Tick, Tick... Boom is all about Jonathan Larson being a mess and trying to get this one show up that doesn't happen. And then at the very end, Alexandra Shipp is just like, and then he wrote Rent, and we all said, Thank you, Jonathan.
[38:32] Richie Grasso: And like that's Tick, Tick... Boom.
[38:34] Matt Koplik: Right, right. I love it.
[38:36] Richie Grasso: Well, we are out of time, over time. We gotta run, we gotta run. But this is amazing.
[38:41] Matt Koplik: Thank you so much for being here, and we need to have you back. We have other we just talked about it in a Roger Hammerstein potential episode.
[38:48] Richie Grasso: We're gonna do it.
[38:48] Matt Koplik: Oh, and I'm having you boys on on the pod soon. I've told you I am figuring out exactly how to use you.
[38:54] Richie Grasso: But yeah, yes.
[38:56] Matt Koplik: Oh, Richie just... Richie, let up.
[38:58] Richie Grasso: Use me.
[38:59] Matt Koplik: I feel like a commodity.
[39:03] Richie Grasso: Yeah.
[39:04] Matt Koplik: No, we are all here.
[39:04] Richie Grasso: Yeah, no, I d I I am I'm lazy and I'm bad at planning, so I'm forcing myself for this month of August to do it.
[39:14] Matt Koplik: We're good planners, so we'll nudge you.
[39:16] Richie Grasso: Yay.
[39:17] Matt Koplik: Thank you.
[39:17] Richie Grasso: Thank you.
[39:18] Matt Koplik: If I don't have you on the podcast soon enough, I'm sure I'll run into you at a show and we'll get drinks and talk and it'll be great.
[39:23] Richie Grasso: There we go.
[39:24] Matt Koplik: It'll be awesome.
[39:24] Richie Grasso: That's great. Well, thank you all so much for listening to today's episode of Half Hour. We really appreciate it.
[39:28] Matt Koplik: Yes, and we're obviously going to share more information on where you can listen to Matt on the Broadway Podcast Network with Broadway Breakdown, and we hope you enjoyed this conversation today.
[39:39] Richie Grasso: To all our listeners, if you have suggestions for future episodes, we'd love to hear from you. You can connect with us on Instagram at Half Hour Podcast.
[39:46] Matt Koplik: So signing off for now, I'm Richie saying ta-ta for now.
[39:50] Matt Koplik: Bye.
[39:51] Richie Grasso: Bye.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
