In this Theatre Chat episode of Half Hour with Jeff & Richie, we dig into the final trailer for Wicked: For Good, new casting announcements for Gruesome Playground Injuries and Oh Mary!, and the unique immersive Nightmare Before Christmas light trail experience... Read More
From the show: Half Hour with Jeff & Richie (Post-Show Broadway Discussions and Interviews)
Featured Shows
About
In this Theatre Chat episode of Half Hour with Jeff & Richie, we dig into the final trailer for Wicked: For Good, new casting announcements for Gruesome Playground Injuries and Oh Mary!, and the unique immersive Nightmare Before Christmas light trail experience. We also take a closer look at Broadway’s challenges. Are musicals struggling to stay profitable, or is the industry adapting to new audience trends? Additionally, we review the latest box office grosses and highlight which shows are performing well.
Follow and connect with all things @HalfHourPodcast on Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube. Share your thoughts with us on our podcast cover post on Instagram.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jeff Malone: Welcome to Half Hour with Jeff and Richie, the podcast where we explore the latest shows we see, sharing our insights and opinions on the performances, storylines, and everything in between.
[0:08] Richie Grasso: In today's episode, we're bringing you a new theater chat episode, an episode where we recap current topics happening in the theater industry.
[0:14] Jeff Malone: So join us as we dive into these hot topics, and don't forget to share your thoughts with us.
[0:18] Jeff Malone: I'm Jeff.
[0:18] Richie Grasso: And I'm Richie, and we're thrilled to be your host for this episode.
[0:21] Jeff Malone: But before we get started, let's take a quick moment to hear from our sponsors.
[0:25] Richie Grasso: So welcome everyone to a new episode of Theater Chat. Let's start things off with the hot topics of the week.
[0:30] Jeff Malone: All right, we're starting with the final trailer of Wicked: For Good has been released.
[0:34] Richie Grasso: We got to hear a little bit of Cynthia Erivo's "No Good Deed," amongst many other spoiler potentials. What do you think of this trailer?
[0:40] Jeff Malone: All right. I'm gonna say it because most people, if you know this podcast, I am not a very big fan of Act Two of Wicked.
[0:48] Richie Grasso: But don't understand that.
[0:50] Jeff Malone: I'm not the only one. Many people have told me the same thing. So anyway, but this trailer looks epic. You know, we have to realize is like Act One is the prequel, but a lot of Act Two, not all Act Two, but a lot of Act Two is the when Dorothy comes. So it's the overlay moment, right? For some people, we don't like that. Or for some people, they don't think it was as strong as the prequel. Act One is truly like a prequel, right?
[1:15] Richie Grasso: So I do like that. I just think this trailer makes it look so great. Where you learn what's gonna happen when Dorothy comes, how Dorothy comes, when she comes, what happens when she's here. Um, I believe it was stated Cynthia Erivo gave an interview, and it was I don't know if this is on the record or off the record, but apparently um we won't necessarily be seeing Dorothy's face throughout the film. We're only gonna see the back of Dorothy progressing down the Elber Road doing the story, but which I think just makes complete sense to me.
[1:45] Jeff Malone: You've had iconic people, Judy Garland, uh, Diana Ross plays Dorothy in the Wiz movie, right? So there's like so many people have played Dorothy in this iconic way that you get to remember Dorothy for who you want Dorothy to be, and let Dorothy down the Elber Road not be the focal point per se. Let's look at the actual Glinda relationship.
[2:03] Richie Grasso: Right. Well, it's not about Dorothy in Wicked, and it is, but it isn't. You know, we never see Dorothy's face, even in the stage production. So I think you know what I'm really enjoying more with you know, this whole film in general is giving us the time to sit with the characters and sit with the actual plot of Wicked versus I always found Act Two kind of like flies by you don't have a lot of time to connect with it.
[2:32] Jeff Malone: And I think with what they're doing with the film, even with you know the first part of Wicked, it was more expanded for us to really fully dive into the characters. So, you know, and from what I'm seeing with the trailer, we're definitely gonna get that.
[2:47] Richie Grasso: Yeah, no, totally. I think it's great. So I'm very excited for that, and that's coming soon. So big big movie this holiday season coming right before Thanksgiving time.
[2:56] Jeff Malone: Yes, it was also just announced this past week that Nicholas Braun and Kara Young will star in Gruesome Playground Injuries off Broadway. This two-time Tony Award winner, Kara Young and three-time Emmy Award nominee Nicholas Braun will lead the return of the Gruesome Playground Injuries off Broadway.
[3:12] Richie Grasso: Yeah, this sounds interesting to me. I think Kara Young is always working, she's always finding great projects, always working, and I love her. And I think we've seen like just about everything she's been in in some way, shape, or form. She's really, really talented. I really, really love her.
[3:27] Jeff Malone: Um, the story plot is very interesting. Uh Kayleen and Doug's friendship spans 30 years with their lives intersecting during bizarre and painful moments as they literally and emotionally compare scars. So, okay, see what that's like. Listen, and it's in a small theater. I love seeing Kara Young up and close because it's like you really get to see her full acting skills in that way. And I love it. I love it. She's like one of my favorite actors on Broadway ever.
[3:54] Richie Grasso: Yeah, really, really great. And we have some more Oh Mary casting announcements to talk about.
[3:59] Jeff Malone: I do weave. Yes, James Monsoon is wrapping up her run as Mary Todd Lincoln right now in the Broadway smash hit. Uh, we now have Jane Krakowski coming into the role in a couple of weeks, and along with Jane Krakowski, we're gonna have Cheyenne Jackson, uh, Emmy nominee as teacher, and we have Tony nominee John Andrew Morrison from A Strange Loop playing Mary's husband.
[4:20] Richie Grasso: So, you know, it's not just Mary they replace with some big names too. They're putting these other names in, and they're going at what seems to be like six-ish week runs, maybe seven or eight week runs. I think Jane only goes to early mid December, so it's about two months or so. Uh, what do you think?
[4:38] Jeff Malone: Who's ever casting this show is give them some sort of an award this year because it's on point with every ounce of casting this show. You know, as soon as you see Jane get announced, you're like, okay, well, what are they gonna do next? And then all of a sudden we see Cheyenne announced, and then also John Andrew Morrison, and I'm like, oh yeah, the tickets for the show are just constantly going to be insane.
[5:06] Richie Grasso: And I remember when people were like, Oh, I'm just gonna buy tickets for like that window down the six months from now when I don't know who's playing Mary then. And some people are like, that's a great idea. And so they're like, Oh, I don't know who's playing Mary, but then they buy the ticket, probably cheaper, and then they see Jane Krakowski and like, oh, great, glad I have a ticket now. Like, it's kind of smart to just, if you want to go buy a ticket for like February or whenever they're selling tickets till because we don't know who's playing Mary then, but chances are it'll be someone great, it's always been someone great.
[5:32] Jeff Malone: Every person, and if like it's someone that you've already seen, you can just sell your tickets because the tickets are having no problem getting resold. And it just keeps extending and going, and for a play, it's pretty amazing. So when you look at a play like this, do you think first of all, how long do you think this play is gonna run?
[5:51] Richie Grasso: It depends as long as there's the demand, it's gonna keep going, it's just gonna keep going. I mean, especially if you can get the right cast in there. It's so funny when you really look at this because I know so many people that were like, Oh, Mary should not transfer to Broadway, no one's gonna get it, it's not gonna work, it's not gonna work. And I'm like, No, it's gonna work.
[6:09] Jeff Malone: Yeah, it really is gonna work, and like this will be studied. This yeah, oh yeah, it's a historic comedy for its time. It will really be studied because, like, obviously, Harry Potter has been running on Broadway for many years now, and we have not had a play like this do the same thing that Harry Potter has done in a very long time.
[6:31] Richie Grasso: We're talking about Harry Potter has a ton of people in its cast, huge production elements. Oh, Mary's probably week to week operating, is probably a lot lower, right? So, but when you have something like Harry Potter, the intellectual property is so huge, it already has such a huge fan base. Now, this is so different because, like, where does this fan base come from? It's fans of the people playing Mary, it's also people who know Abraham Lincoln and Mary Todd Lincoln a little bit from social studies class, right? So, and now I think like you're just gonna get even bigger and bigger stars because now people are like, Oh, I could do it, I want to do it. Why not? You know, next we'll hear like Emma Stone is gonna be playing Mary Todd Lincoln. Could you imagine?
[7:05] Jeff Malone: Well, then you predicted it here first.
[7:10] Richie Grasso: I gotta start making a list of people I would want to play this role because everyone.
[7:14] Jeff Malone: Everyone, yeah, right.
[7:16] Richie Grasso: But all of the roles, that's the part that's the part. You know, there's like we're not yes, Mary Todd Lincoln is great, but like also the other roles in the show are also great.
[7:26] Jeff Malone: Yeah, no, it is just so great. Also, Jeff Ross's Take a Banana for the Ride was just concluded this Broadway run. It will be filmed for Netflix, or maybe it was filmed during its run. Um really, really great to hear that. We really enjoyed that on Broadway. And I think it's great that the masses can kind of check that out and see his story. And we did talk about that because we said, like, oh, do you think they're gonna film this for Netflix? And voila.
[7:47] Richie Grasso: There we go.
[7:48] Jeff Malone: You heard it here first, too.
[7:50] Richie Grasso: All right. So um, we're gonna talk about one other thing in this section today. We got to take a little visit to the New York Botanical Garden for the invited press night of Nightmare Before Christmas light trail.
[8:02] Jeff Malone: Yes, so we saw this immersive light trail event at the New York Botanical Gardens in the Bronx. It's the second year. Um, a lot of people who went last year said they really like upped it in terms of the lights and the music and the statues, and it's a highly elevated experience now from last year. Apparently, we did not go last year, but I will say between the LED and the 3D sculptures, incredible, incredible stuff.
[8:25] Richie Grasso: I mean, I love that movie. It was very, very immersive. Uh, you got to walk through botanical. It's all outdoors in the botanical gardens. You walk through the trails and it's lit, and there's music playing, and you can stop at the statue, take pictures. There's um little bar snack huts set up throughout. You can get a snack or a drink and walk around and enjoy yourself.
[8:43] Jeff Malone: Uh, there's a gift shop at the start, and just a wonderful experience.
[8:48] Richie Grasso: Yeah, it was a great experience, and it is one of my favorite Tim Burton and Disney films out there. I think like the Nightmare Before Christmas doesn't get enough credit sometimes where it really deserves something bigger. Um maybe a stage musical. Jeffrey Seller, who's a Broadway producer, is behind this, and Jeffrey spoke a little bit at the event and talked about how important it was to elevate this and tell the story.
[9:13] Jeff Malone: When you have Broadway Hamilton producers mixed with Disney and Tim Burton production, mixed with the New York Botanical Garden as a host space. You have big, big level people bring this in. Uh, but it was very, very, very just wonderful to start the season like that. Because I actually like that it's actually running now, select evenings all the way until November 30th.
[9:32] Richie Grasso: Right. Because it is this Halloween to Christmas hybrid crossover. Like, what do we do in November when it's too early for Christmas, but Halloween's over? We'll go to the Nightmare Before Christmas Light Trail because it's like the perfect crossover, I find, you know.
[9:43] Jeff Malone: And a lot of people said too, like they have merch now and they have the food stations throughout the whole trail. You know, it's a great experience for a family. They have all of the characters throughout the trail as well. You can see Jack, you can see Oogie Boogie, Sally, uh Zero in all the different settings, so it's fun.
[10:04] Richie Grasso: I definitely think the kids will love it. And it's you know, not that bad. Uh $33 for children and $45 for adults. You get a full experience, like you're it's not something that, oh, it's over in 10 minutes. Like we were there quite a long time.
[10:15] Jeff Malone: Yeah, it was quite a long walkthrough. I felt like we really enjoyed the whole evening of it. Lots of photo ops, music playing is that that Danny Elfman score is incredible. I love that score.
[10:23] Richie Grasso: So it's a little spooky. And it's spooky spooky in the woods. But like good for the, you know, bring the kids. It's not too scary for them.
[10:31] Jeff Malone: No, it's fine.
[10:32] Richie Grasso: I actually walking through it, I felt many times that someone was going to pop out and scare me. But I was like, it almost was like they should have a special night like on Halloween or something where it is a little more scary, but it's like maybe the characters that'd be kind of cool, right?
[10:46] Jeff Malone: Um, so yeah.
[10:48] Richie Grasso: Yeah, yeah, go check that out for sure.
[10:49] Jeff Malone: All right. Well, those are the hot topics for the week. So let's take a quick break, and when we get back, we're gonna discuss our other Broadway topic of the week, which is around the Broadway musical.
[10:59] Richie Grasso: All right, so we're back. And is the Broadway musical in trouble?
[11:04] Jeff Malone: Well, that's what the New York Times article is claiming, potentially, right? The New York Times recently came out with an article discussing how the Broadway musical is in trouble.
[11:12] Richie Grasso: So I mean, let's talk about this. We if we talked, you know, just based on some facts. There's a lot of plays right now. There's a lot of new plays and play revivals. There's a lot of musical revivals. Actually, if you wanted to talk about musical revivals for two seconds quick, most Broadway revival musicals right now are like 1970s and beyond. We're not actually getting a ton of golden age Royal revivals unless it's Lincoln Center.
[11:37] Richie Grasso: We haven't seen a ton of the golden age. They come back from time to time. But when you look at the revivals coming up of Chess, Rocky Horror, Ragtime, these were all musicals that were written and produced in the 80s, the 90s, you know, the more modern revival. So we're seeing a lot of that. But when you talk about the new musical, we had so many new musicals last season. And just about all of them, besides two, are closed. Is Death Becomes Her and maybe Happy Ending? The only two new musicals from last season currently running. And we had so many. And the year before that, we had so many. And a lot of people claim it's COVID backlog of shows that were maybe pre-funded or preset, and we just had to wait a couple years, and we're just still in the COVID backlog.
Maybe, right? Well, since the pandemic, 46 new musicals have opened, costing a combined 800 million with only three reaching profitability. So to me, I look at that number and I say that's staggeringly low. That's not even close to like me. But then again, you have to say maybe there's always open theaters, there's always competition for these theaters. But if you're an investor and you're seeing that there's really low chance that you're getting your full money back, yeah, that's gonna be really tough. And when the ticket prices are expensive and the quality is expensive to put on, listen, it's expensive to put on community theater or high school shows now, or college shows that's expensive.
But I wonder with some of the shows, like do they take into consideration like there are still shows that are running? They may have not recouped yet. So shows like The Outsiders or Hell's Kitchen, Great Gatsby, obviously, maybe Happy Ending and Death Becomes Her. They're all new musicals that Operation Mincemeat is even still running, they're all still new musicals, they have not recouped, but you know, and Juliet and MJ have recouped and Six, I believe, is that considered closed in this new batch. Um, because that show did open. Actually, no, it didn't open before the pandemic. I don't remember. Yeah, well, either way, I'm looking at it and I'm saying things still are like Moulin Rouge is even still on Broadway.
Like you and I have this conversation all the time, as well as there's usually one or two musicals that kind of last a season. Right now, it is maybe Happy Ending and Death Becomes Her, and those shows could eventually recoup the year before that. It was Great Gatsby and Hell's Kitchen and The Outsiders. Oh, also and Operation Mincemeat is still running, which was only supposed to be a limited run. Right, and that keeps going too. Although, unfortunately, it's in the when we do the grosses later, it's not hitting too high of grosses right now. But it might be closing. But it looks to me that something around that show might not have the high operating cost, which is something that I think producers and design teams are going to start taking into account.
And we might start seeing a little bit more around like these stripped back productions, so that they're not hitting high budget. You know, Death Becomes Her has a high operating cost because of how big the cast is and the design around it and the special effects. I think that yes, is it maybe a little less expensive to put on a play? And even with the star in it, yes. I will say to go back to the original topic, is the Broadway musical in trouble? No, I don't think the musical's in trouble. I think maybe the way that we're going about this might need to be looked at. I think the way we're funding these projects, the projects we're deciding to put on. Is every department working correctly for the common goal?
I don't know, right? Like, are designers doing something and the producers don't like that? Or are the marketing people doing something different than maybe the designers wish they just, you know, are we all? I don't know enough about that per show. But I think that there's always a demand for Broadway. I just think that maybe we're gonna see less new shows now because the COVID backlog is winding down. I don't know. It doesn't. If I look at the upcoming season, yes, maybe in the musical category, we're seeing less of that. And maybe we'll get a little bit more of a staggering, like only three to four new musicals a season, which I think is important because that gives them the time to thrive, versus like what we were talking about around tours coming in now and kind of helping the space of Broadway during that time.
So maybe someone's coming in to see Mamma Mia, which is like the tour is here right now. Can we even say it like that, right? I mean it is but it is the touring production. You know, Beetlejuice is going to be coming. It's the touring production. And like if we're gonna see more of that on Broadway, well then also maybe we might get these like star-studded limited run Chess or Ragtime and then we only get two new musicals in the fall and two new musicals in the spring. That was what it kind of was pre-pandemic. You know, there were some years that there were only four new musicals or five not eighteen. Yeah. Yeah. And I don't think and I think people love musical theater enough that it'll that art form is going to keep going strong.
How we actually do it, that's up to these producers and these theater owners to figure that out. But and then it also lets some of the shows that are running also still continue building the fan base it also does I mean and and I will say it doesn't help the New York Times puts an article out like this because the non-theater person just sits and reads that and says oh yeah they are in trouble. But do you think but if you're a non-theater person yeah are if you're a shark on Shark Tank and you're watching these numbers you might be like what I don't know if I would have I don't know. But do you feel like the article somewhat contradicts many things because when we get articles and Broadway grosses that it's like oh we're at the best Broadway season in the last five years but then you see an article like this like isn't there some sort of a contradiction around that or is it like they're just trying to show how much it costs to actually run a production?
[17:29] Jeff Malone: Yeah I think I think it was just an opportunity also to say, hey, this was a lot of shows that opened, and most of them aren't here anymore. And they didn't even last a couple of months at best. So a lot of factors, but I could talk about that for a whole nother half hour, but interesting stuff there for sure.
[17:46] Richie Grasso: Right. So I mean, yeah, we'll see what happens there. But all right, let's take a quick break, and when we get back, we're gonna discuss the grosses.
[17:53] Jeff Malone: Okay, and we're back. So we have the Broadway grosses rounding out the week 921. Yes, the top show of this week was Hamilton at the Richard Rogers Theater, which brought in over three point five million dollars. We know Leslie Odom Jr. is back in it. I'm gonna assume that's why that has kept gone keep going up and up and up. That is a lot of money for one week for that show.
[18:12] Richie Grasso: Well, Hamilton is not hurting at all.
[18:15] Jeff Malone: Yeah, so in terms of the musical being dead, Hamilton is not.
[18:19] Richie Grasso: You're right, right. And that's going back to what we were just saying about the New York Times article. Like, yeah, the long running shows are doing really well. Book of Mormon still sits around, Aladdin, Wicked, you know, Lion King, Hamilton, and and actually I just named half of those because Hamilton, Wicked, and Lion King are all here in the top five.
[18:34] Jeff Malone: Yeah, Wicked making over two million, Lion King, one point seven million. Um, Waiting for Godot one point eight million, and one point eight million just starting, right? The Jamie Lloyd production. The first full week, and they're at one point eight million dollars. For a play that's been around a long time, that's got a new creative team on it with Jamie Lloyd kind of at the helm there. So validates having star power in Kelly Reilly is in this, right? In the Broadway play there, and then yeah, and then we still have Mamma Mia here, rounding out the top five, one point six million dollars. So it's clear that people go to see what's comfortable, what they know they're gonna get. They know they're gonna get blank out of this show.
So if you're a family that brings their kids to the Lion King every year, you know you're gonna get that quality show out of it, right? It's just that people. Some people come to New York City to see the Rockettes every Christmas. There could be a million other things to do, but that's what they come to do. There is a lot of bridge and tunnelers that we know that just come to the city because they love Wicked. So they're just going to go see Wicked once a year for 15 straight years. They're going to see Wicked 15 times. Right. I'm not saying that's right or wrong. I'm just saying that's what people are doing. Clearly, according to the numbers, right? But when you look at the shows that are also still like from last season with Maybe Happy Ending and Death Becomes Her, it has enough word of mouth now that people are going to them.
[19:53] Jeff Malone: Yeah. And this is also the dead of, not to say dead of, you know, summer's winding down. We're not quite into the holidays yet. So this next few weeks are really telling for a lot of shows.
[20:03] Richie Grasso: Yeah. And that kind of does lead us into the five lowest-grossing shows. In the final week of Jeff Ross Take a Banana for the Ride, that played 240,000 and change. Um, kind of low, but that was a one-person show. Uh, Punch just started. It's just shy of 300,000. It's got 297,000. So it's just starting. We'll see how those reviews go in new play at the Samuel J. Friedman. Um, Art is in here because it took it out a lot of performances off. I think they took a week off, maybe, or most of a week off. So they only had three performances, and they made 315,000 in just three shows. It's pretty good. That's why that had a big tip. Uh, Six is still sitting low at 700,000. I don't know what's going on there if they need to. But I think they're fine. They might be fine just paying their weekly bills like that, right? And then Operation Mincemeat has dipped a little low too, 703,000 in change. But that show might also just be fine with making that much money.
[20:51] Jeff Malone: Right. The small cast with the one scenery kind of thing.
[20:54] Richie Grasso: Yeah. Yeah. Right. So it's very, very interesting to see all this. You know, one thing to look at too here is that several shows did exceed or hit full capacity, including Justin Time, which we did not talk about in our last section, which is also a musical from last correct from this past season that is running. So it's four musicals that are technically still running from last season, which Justin Time has a hundred and three point seven percent coaching. Which I think they're putting standing room in almost every show. Every show and Hamilton at 101, Buena Vista, oh, and Bonavista Social Club. Oh, so we were wrong at the beginning that there were only two. There's a lot more than two.
[21:29] Jeff Malone: Yeah, uh so five shows.
[21:32] Richie Grasso: Yeah, but still, there was a lot of new musicals. It was a lot. So that's what's the shape. The ratio doesn't seem to be quite. Maybe they were talking about original musicals because Buena Vista Social Club and Justin Time are jukebox musicals.
[21:46] Jeff Malone: Maybe that's what they oh, maybe that's what they meant.
[21:47] Richie Grasso: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Um so that, and then Mamma Mia 101%, and Maybe Happy Ending 100%. So Maybe Happy Ending is selling out 100% capacity still. Which I remember those grosses of Maybe Happy Ending way at the beginning. I was like, Oh, I hope this show makes it and now look, it got best musical. It's going strong. Um, and just real I mean, the ticket prices are going up and up, but you know, people are paying the prices still, so they are it's interesting because the right after summer and right after the holidays are when most people like kind of stop spending as much money and lay low and try to, but you look, Broadway's still proving that with the shows that still stay strong, and we'll see now in the next few weeks how some new shows will be interesting to see, and especially like with you looking at Waiting for Godot, it's standing out not only for its high gross, but the average ticket price is 266.96 cents, you know, with a hundred percent capacity. So a lot of money, especially if two or four people go together, you definitely almost a thousand dollars. And the Hudson Theater, it's a big it's a big space there.
[22:43] Jeff Malone: So yeah, yeah. Big big things. Well, I'd just hope to see you in the next few weeks go for sure.
[22:48] Richie Grasso: So oh my gosh. Well, that does wrap up our theater chat discussion for this episode. Remember, we want to hear from you. Continue the conversation with us on Instagram at Half Hour Podcast, and drop us a comment on Spotify and let us know your thoughts on the topics this week. If you enjoyed our show, please leave us a review. Your feedback helps us bring more theater to you. And remember you can listen to past episodes and stay tuned for the many upcoming ones as well. Until next time, I'm Jeff.
[23:11] Richie Grasso: And I'm Richie Sang Tata for now. Bye.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
