This episode discusses the Tony nominees for the MUSICAL CATEGORIES of the 2023/2024 Broadway Season. Follow and connect with all things @HalfHourPodcast on Instagram, and YouTube. Please share your thoughts on your predictions in our podcast cover post... Read More
From the show: Half Hour with Jeff & Richie (Post-Show Broadway Discussions and Interviews)
Featured Shows
About
This episode discusses the Tony nominees for the MUSICAL CATEGORIES of the 2023/2024 Broadway Season.
Follow and connect with all things @HalfHourPodcast on Instagram, and YouTube. Please share your thoughts on your predictions in our podcast cover post.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jeff Malone: Welcome to Half Hour with Jeff and Richie, the podcast where we explore the latest shows we see, sharing our insights and opinions on the performances, storylines, and everything in between.
[0:09] Richie Grasso: In today's episode, we bring you to our 2023, 2024 Tony Awards predictions episode musicals edition.
[0:17] Jeff Malone: Two days ago we released our thoughts on the plays.
[0:20] Richie Grasso: Now we're here to bring you our thoughts on all the musical Tony Award nominations.
[0:25] Jeff Malone: And we're gonna say this earlier this time.
[0:28] Richie Grasso: We have seen every musical and play in this Tony Awards season.
[0:35] Jeff Malone: So we can definitely compare.
[0:38] Richie Grasso: We can talk because we did, yes, we did see everything that we're about to discuss here.
[0:42] Jeff Malone: So that just gives you some insight.
[0:43] Richie Grasso: If you were wondering if we did or not.
[0:45] Jeff Malone: Everything.
[0:46] Richie Grasso: Um so if you're ready to dive into the yeast nomination, stick around with us.
[0:49] Jeff Malone: I'm Jeff.
[0:50] Richie Grasso: And I'm Richie, and we're thrilled to be your host for today's episode.
[0:52] Jeff Malone: But before we start the conversation about our Tony Award musical predictions, here are a few words from our advertisers.
[1:08] Jeff Malone: Welcome everyone to a new episode of Half Hour with Jeff and Richie.
[1:11] Richie Grasso: Today we bring to you our predictions for the 2023, 2024 Tony Awards.
[1:16] Jeff Malone: And in this episode, we are discussing the musical.
[1:19] Richie Grasso: So if you listen to our last episode released a few days ago, we're gonna keep the same format.
[1:23] Jeff Malone: That's all about the plays.
[1:24] Richie Grasso: We're not talking about the 11 Tony Award nominations for plays here.
[1:27] Jeff Malone: We're talking today about the 15 Tony Award nomination categories for musicals.
[1:32] Richie Grasso: So the way this will work is we are gonna read the category, we will read the nominees, and then we will each give you our thoughts on who we think will win, who should win, and if there's any snubs in any of the categories before we move on to the next category.
[1:44] Jeff Malone: Uh, we'll try to keep this to 30 minutes.
[1:45] Richie Grasso: I know we have 15 categories to get through.
[1:47] Jeff Malone: One final thing we like to say is Jeff and I have not shared these with each other.
[1:51] Richie Grasso: What you're hearing right now is our actual first time hearing what our predictions are.
[1:55] Jeff Malone: Of course, throughout the year, we've talked about what could win, what should win.
[1:58] Richie Grasso: Though our official thoughts on our ballots are being discussed live right here for the first time in front of us.
[2:03] Jeff Malone: I don't know what Jeff's about to say.
[2:04] Richie Grasso: He does not know what happened to say.
[2:06] Jeff Malone: So that's kind of adds to the fun of all this, just and let's put let's do a little uh musical bold statement here.
[2:11] Richie Grasso: There were a lot of musicals this year.
[2:14] Jeff Malone: And a lot of snubs, and we will get to some of those as best we can, but more snubs than I've ever seen, I think.
[2:20] Richie Grasso: Um we're gonna go through that.
[2:21] Jeff Malone: So we're gonna start with Paul, we're gonna get to all categories.
[2:24] Richie Grasso: We'll save the big ones like musical, musical revival towards the end, but we want to get right into this because we got 15 categories to get through.
[2:29] Jeff Malone: And we're starting with the first category of best orchestrations.
[2:34] Richie Grasso: Okay, and the nominees are Timo Andres, Illinois, Will Butler and Justin Craig for Stereophonic, Justin Levine, Matt Hinckley, and Jamestown Revival for The Outsiders, Tom Kitt and Adam Blackstone for Hell's Kitchen, and Jonathan Tunick for Merrily We Roll Along.
[2:52] Jeff Malone: I think that Jonathan Tunick from Merrily We Roll Along will win. I actually think he should win because the orchestrations are pretty brilliant in this, and he was not eligible in the 80s because there was no Tony Award yet for that. Uh, he has won a Tony Award for in the 90s for Titanic. He was the first to win the Tony Award for best orchestrations. Who also could win, I think, is The Outsiders. I think there's some great orchestral stuff going on there. It's not full orchestra, but I think there's some great just instrumentation going on there. And I was really impressed with that. But I definitely think Jonathan Tunick from Merrily We Roll Along will win this.
[3:24] Richie Grasso: I easily think that Jonathan Tunick is winning for Merrily We Roll Along. Um, I would love to see Timo Andres win for Illinois. I actually think the orchestrations, if you listen to the original Illinois and then you listen to the orchestrations in this, they're just beautiful. I mean, that soundtrack has been on repeat for me since it has been released. So yeah, I mean, that would be my underdog to win, but I do think Jonathan Tunick is cool.
[3:48] Jeff Malone: Yeah. I mean, I just am blown away by the orchestra in Merrily, so I think that could totally win it.
[3:53] Richie Grasso: So next category we have is choreography.
[3:57] Jeff Malone: Annie B. Parsons, Here Lies Love. Camille A. Brown, Hell's Kitchen. Rick Cooperman and Jeff Cooperman, The Outsiders. Justin Peck, Illinois. Jesse Robb and Shayna Carroll, Water for Elephants.
[4:13] Richie Grasso: What do you think?
[4:14] Jeff Malone: I'm just realizing some of these nominations in here, but I am going with Justin Peck will win for Illinois. I think Justin Peck should win for Illinois. I will say that Rick Cooperman and Jeff Cooperman for The Outsiders really should be appreciated because I think what they are doing in terms of choreography in that show are great. I do also have a snub in here for like a few different things.
[4:42] Richie Grasso: Because Once Upon a One More Time, Choreo should have been nominated. Totally. Heart of Rock and Roll, Choreo should have been nominated. The Who's Tommy should have been nominated. I mean, The Great Gatsby could have been nominated. I don't know why Water for Elephants is on this list.
[5:00] Jeff Malone: And Lauren Litaro doing Heart of Rock and Roll and Who's Tommy and being left off for both blows my mind, especially Tommy, because I thought that Choreo was amazing in Tommy.
[5:10] Richie Grasso: Um I agree, Justin Peck will win and should win. Great shout out to Rick and Jeff Cooperman for The Outsiders. There was some cool choreo there that could definitely win. I think Illinois is gonna take it. Do I like Camille Brown's choreo in Hell's Kitchen? Yes. Do I think that she's owed a Tony award at this point in her life because she's worked really hard for it? This I don't think this is her time, but uh, I think she will be a Tony Award winner one day. I think she's got some cool stuff going on there.
[5:32] Jeff Malone: Um unfortunately Annie B. Parsons' Here Lies Love choreo didn't do enough for me. There were some cool moments, but it was more about staging in that for me than actual choreo. Um and Water for Elephants, other than the acrobatics, if we're talking about acrobatics, sure. But uh in terms of actual movement of actors on stage and dance, no. I don't know how other things didn't beat that out.
[5:50] Richie Grasso: But um Justin Peck's brilliance. I mean, I don't think the acrobatics should be considered choreography, but if it is, I guess I can see why it's there. But there were some hot, heavy dancing happening in some of these other shows that were completely overlooked.
[6:03] Jeff Malone: Yeah, and Justin Peck's Illinois will win for sure.
[6:05] Richie Grasso: I agree with you on that.
[6:06] Jeff Malone: Yeah. Um, all right, costume design of a musical.
[6:08] Richie Grasso: I love this category. We have Didi Ied for Hell's Kitchen, Linda Cho for The Great Gatsby, David Israel Reynelso for Water for Elephants, Tom Scott for Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club, and Paul Tazewell for Suff.
[6:26] Jeff Malone: This is hard. I'm really neck and neck between two, but if I have to choose one, you're probably gonna disagree with me. I really think Paul Tazewell for Suff could win this because those gowns and that costume design is gorgeous to me. And I love a period look, and I think this is one of the only things that are really period. Of course, Water for Elephants is period, Cabaret and Gatsby and Hell's Kitchen, they're all period. But um, I will say Tom Scott for Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club really also should win and could. But if I really had to say my vote would go for Paul, because I thought those Suff costumes were just really nice.
[7:02] Richie Grasso: I don't think it's happening.
[7:04] Jeff Malone: Okay, uh, I do think I do think that Tom Scott is taking the Tony for Cabaret.
[7:09] Richie Grasso: Okay.
[7:09] Jeff Malone: Um I actually think that there's potential for Linda Cho to win for The Great Gatsby.
[7:17] Richie Grasso: Maybe.
[7:18] Jeff Malone: Potential.
[7:19] Richie Grasso: Maybe.
[7:20] Jeff Malone: But no, I do think that Tom Scott is taking this one.
[7:22] Richie Grasso: I don't see it going to Hell's Kitchen. I don't see it going to Water for Elephants.
[7:26] Jeff Malone: Um for this.
[7:27] Richie Grasso: Um.
[7:29] Jeff Malone: So I also thought there was some nice costumes in Merrily. I thought that could have maybe been thrown. I mean, could have been a snub, but you know.
[7:35] Richie Grasso: Yeah. I mean, if there was another thing that I thought that the costumes were pretty cool, I'll this is going to be the episode of me bringing up Once Upon a One More Time because I'll stamp the show.
[7:46] Jeff Malone: I know people were not. They thought it was terrible. Not me. I loved it.
[7:52] Richie Grasso: Listen, those costumes were fun. So I know that Heart of Rock and Roll was like a little bit of like they thought it was uh the too many different periods happening. It wasn't 80s enough or was verging on 90s. But those were costumes were kind of fun as well.
[8:06] Jeff Malone: But no Cabaret for me.
[8:08] Richie Grasso: All right.
[8:09] Jeff Malone: Um moving on to scenic design of a musical.
[8:12] Richie Grasso: Okay, we have Amp featuring Tatiana Kavijan for The Outsiders, Robert Brill and Peter Negrini for Hell's Kitchen. Takashi Kata for Water for Elephants, David Corins, Here Lies Love, Ricardo Hernandez and Peter Negrini for Lempica, Tim Hatley and Finn Ross for Back to the Future, the Musical, and Tom Scott for Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club.
[8:33] Jeff Malone: I mean, all of these are I mean, not all of them. Most of them are really, really great. This is tough.
[8:38] Richie Grasso: This is uh I think that Tom Scott is winning for Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club. I mean, if that is not appreciated, we have some interesting voters here.
[8:49] Jeff Malone: Um, in terms of what I do think should also potentially win is David Corins for Here Lies Love. I think that the immersion in the scenic design of both of those shows is beautiful.
[9:00] Richie Grasso: Um everything else is pretty unit and simple.
[9:05] Jeff Malone: So I think Tom Scott Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club will win for sure and should win.
[9:09] Richie Grasso: I agree with you on that.
[9:11] Jeff Malone: Um if the car alone gives Back to the Future a nomination, sure, it's not gonna win.
[9:18] Richie Grasso: But I'm actually will say one the one good thing I thought about the Back to the Future was that car uh and and what it was doing.
[9:26] Jeff Malone: So, okay, cool. Like, I'm glad you got a nomination, but um, I don't think you're not gonna win.
[9:31] Richie Grasso: Creating a replica of what's in the movie doesn't really get scenic design to me, but I'm talking about the way the car moved, how it came over the audience, how it was brought in and out and spun and all this, you know, things like that.
[9:41] Jeff Malone: I also will say that I agree with you that David Corin's Here Lies Love totally makes sense and could totally win too. It was really, really great.
[9:52] Richie Grasso: I don't know. One more that I will say that I actually really do like the design. I just think that the immersion design is a little bit more elevated, is I really liked The Outsiders' scenic design.
[10:04] Jeff Malone: Yeah. I mean, it was it wasn't my favorite part of The Outsiders, but it worked for what they were trying to do.
[10:09] Richie Grasso: Um, when you see Hell's Kitchen scaffolding, when you see Water for Elephants rolling scaffolding, uh, I don't know, you know about that.
[10:17] Jeff Malone: But Lempica had a cool set, it wasn't used properly, but it was a nice thing to look at.
[10:21] Richie Grasso: But I think half of it was, and then the other half was completely misdirected, but we'll get to that.
[10:27] Jeff Malone: Yeah, yeah.
[10:28] Richie Grasso: All right, and one more category here before we take a little uh pause for our advertiser commercial break. We're going to a big one leading actress in a musical.
[10:36] Jeff Malone: And those nominees are Eden Espinoza for Lempica, Malaya Joy Moon for Hell's Kitchen, Kelly O'Hara, Days of Wine and Roses, Marianne Plunkett for The Notebook, and Gail Rankin for Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club.
[10:52] Richie Grasso: This is tough. But I'm gonna say something, and I don't know if you're gonna agree with me or not. I think Marianne Plunkett will win this Tony Award.
[10:59] Jeff Malone: I really do.
[10:59] Richie Grasso: It was one of the greatest acting I've seen. I understand she's not singing a lot. I get it.
[11:06] Jeff Malone: Um could Gail Rankin win this too? Yes.
[11:10] Richie Grasso: And I think she should too. I think they're neck and neck for me. Eden, Malaya, Kelly, all wonderful in their own way.
[11:17] Jeff Malone: I don't think this is their year, but I really think Marianne Plunkett is gonna win this Tony.
[11:22] Richie Grasso: I I really feel that way.
[11:24] Jeff Malone: I do.
[11:25] Richie Grasso: I think that Marianne is also positioned to win this Tony.
[11:30] Jeff Malone: I this is the one category that I am very torn on because if there's one thing, we did see everything, but we did not see Malaya Joy Moon does an understudy for that the roles.
[11:44] Richie Grasso: She was there was an understudy, and I'm trying to grasp how she might be doing this from like past little videos that I've been seeing and just to see.
[11:53] Jeff Malone: So I'm only torn on it because of that because everyone tells me that she was great in the role.
[11:59] Richie Grasso: I just know what's happening with Marianne Plunkett is Tony Worthy, even though she's not belting her face the whole time.
[12:06] Jeff Malone: So I don't know.
[12:07] Richie Grasso: I go back and forth between Marianne and Malaya Joy Moon on this year, but I would love to see Gail Rankin win.
[12:16] Jeff Malone: I mean, I think that's Sally Bowles is a character that does win.
[12:21] Richie Grasso: So for something like this, you know, and what she's bringing to the role, I I I think is potential.
[12:28] Richie Grasso: I also I'm happy to see Eden finally get nominated. Not for this role. I don't think this was her time. Um, and I will always, always love to see Keller Howard's name on a Tony nomination. Who wouldn't? And I could see her on a Tony nomination list the rest of my life and totally understand that. Also don't think that's her year either. Um, I'm gonna bring up a snub here, though.
[12:47] Jeff Malone: Yeah.
[12:48] Richie Grasso: McKenzie Kurtz in the heart of rock and roll should have been nominated in this category.
[12:56] Jeff Malone: Agreed a thousand percent. Also, I really do think Ava Noble Azada could have been thrown a nomination. She's doing a lot of singing. I did like her in Gatsby, but yeah. No, I'm going with McKenzie on here because that girl was giving us acting. It's comedy, belting, and I know like comedy doesn't always do well in these kinds of awards. But listen, compared to some of what else I'm seeing on the stage. Listen, the girl is going to be someone put the girl on Aida. I said it.
[13:27] Richie Grasso: Yeah. Also, Nichelle Lewis as Dorothy in the whiz was a snub for me in this category because I did really like her in the whiz. I did. And I think that was a snub. So I will throw that one out. So let's see how that rolls.
[13:39] Jeff Malone: Alright, we're gonna take a quick break here for some thoughts from our advertisers before we keep going.
[13:44] Richie Grasso: And we're back moving on through here. We're now to director of a musical.
[13:49] Jeff Malone: Direction.
[13:49] Richie Grasso: Direction. Yes.
[13:52] Jeff Malone: And the nominees are Maria Friedman, Merrily We Roll Along, Michael Grife, Hell's Kitchen, Lee Silverman, Sufs, Jessica Stone, Water for Elephants, Danya Tamore, the Outsiders.
[14:03] Richie Grasso: Okay. I think this is a pretty easy ish one because Maria Friedman is winning that Tony easily. I would personally love to see Dania Tamor win for the Outsiders because I thought that was beautifully directed. And I also would love to see Lee Silverman win for Sufs because both of those, there were a lot of great directed moments in those shows.
[14:27] Jeff Malone: Everything you just said, I completely agree with and did the same thing. I think Maria Friedman from Marily will win and should win. I think Dania Tamor could totally win and should win, but I don't know if this is her year. She's just new to the scene, which is fine. Lee Silverman, love her work and Sufs. I think she could win it too. I quite personally don't really understand what Jessica Stone and Michael Grife are doing on this list. I actually think Michael Grife did better work in other shows than Hell's Kitchen. I don't really know what the direction was of Hell's Kitchen. And I certainly, I'm so sorry, I'm not trying to be disrespectful, don't know what the direction was for Jessica Stone in Water for Elephants.
[15:02] Richie Grasso: Yeah, I don't know where the.
[15:04] Jeff Malone: Well, this is one of those categories where like, how is Rebecca Frecknell for Capoey not here?
[15:09] Richie Grasso: Correct. Correct. Um, it's very interesting. So even like Here Lies Love, I mean Yeah. I do think that this is Maria Friedman's time.
[15:21] Jeff Malone: Yeah. Um, I mean it's happening. And she's great, and the piece is great. It makes complete sense to me. Um, alright, moving on to sound design of a musical.
[15:30] Richie Grasso: We have ML Dog and Cody Spencer for Here Lies Love. We have Kai Harada for Marilee, we roll along. We have Nick Lidster for Autograph, Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club. We have Gareth Owen, Hell's Kitchen, and Cody Spencer, the Outsiders.
[15:47] Jeff Malone: Here it's it's between two for me here. Um, if I had to choose the way I think the Tony voters are going, I think they're gonna go Gareth Owen, Hell's Kitchen because I think there's just so much technical musical this tech sounds, there's also the orchestral sounds. There's just a lot of sound in that show. And I feel like that is gonna way they're gonna go. However, do I think Here Lies Love should win for that sound design? Yes, and I think because it was so long ago, it might get forgotten. We had live DJing, we had some, we just had a lot going on in Here Lies Love, some sound effects of like newscaster reporting. There was so much sound going on. I just think that they're gonna go Hell's Kitchen on this.
[16:28] Richie Grasso: Okay. I am gonna go in a different direction. I think that Cody Spencer for the Outsiders is gonna get sound design. Strictly on the rumble alone.
[16:39] Jeff Malone: Oh, sure.
[16:41] Richie Grasso: And yeah, and some of the audio fighting moments, yeah. The fire and there's a lot of like moments happening in there that I think could easily be remembered. Um yeah, I mean, that's where I'm going. I think that will win that should win.
[16:57] Jeff Malone: Yeah. Alright, cool. Um, moving on to lighting design of a musical.
[17:03] Richie Grasso: Alright, so we have Brandon Sterling Baker for Illinois, Isabella Bird, Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club, Natasha Katz, Hell's Kitchen, Bradley King and David Bengali, Water for Elephants, and Brian McDevitt and Hannah S. Kim, the Outsiders.
[17:18] Jeff Malone: Personally, I think this should win, but also will win is Brian McDevitt and Hannah S. Kim for the Outsiders.
[17:26] Richie Grasso: I put the same thing. It is great lighting design. I also will just say that I could see them going with Nick to Natasha Katz and Hell's Kitchen because it's a big concert-y kind of a show. There was a lot of lighting going on there. I and Natasha wins a lot. I just can see them go in that way. But I do think Brian McDevin and Hannah S. Kim could and should win for Outsiders.
[17:50] Jeff Malone: I agree with. Maybe I'm just being salty about Hell's Kitchen.
[17:54] Richie Grasso: Well, it was great. It's great lighting there. I thought they would like to do that. I thought it was fine. I don't think it was anything like really adding to the actual piece. If anything, I would say Brandon Sterling Baker in Illinois. There was better lighting added there. I mean, with the actual choreo and moving the lights around, doing the different vignettes of the campfire pieces. I mean, I think there's better lighting happening there. But I was really enjoying the lighting from Brian and Hannah for the Outsiders.
[18:22] Jeff Malone: Totally. Alright, we're moving on now to score. This is one of my hardest ones to talk about this season. And let's go through the nominees here. Days of Wine and Roses, Music and Lyrics, David Adam Gettle, excuse me. Here Lies Love, Music, David Byrne and Fat Boy Slim, Lyrics, David Byrne. The Outsiders Music and Lyrics, Jamestown Revival, Jonathan Clay and Zach Chance, and Justin Levine. Stereophonic Music and Lyrics, Will Butler. Sufs, Music and Lyrics, Shayna Tao.
[18:53] Richie Grasso: Let's hear the job. I actually would be happy to see stereophonic music and lyrics by Will Butler win, or Self's music and lyrics by Shayna Tao.
[19:16] Jeff Malone: So I said I said the same thing. I think The Outsiders will win. It's an amazing, wonderful original score. I don't think there's enough music in stereophonic to win.
[19:24] Richie Grasso: I know, but the music that is in it is so good.
[19:26] Jeff Malone: I know. I know. And it's a play, and I think all these other musical theater composers might be like, what? But I don't know.
[19:32] Richie Grasso: Good. Scare them.
[19:34] Jeff Malone: Yeah. So that we get some better written musicals. Also, um, SUFS, totally deserving of this nomination. I could potentially see winning too. And I'm just gonna say something, because this was the rave review from a lot of reviewers this season, and it's a nominee here. Don't be surprised if Days of Moine Roses maybe wins. I don't think it's going to, but people in the industry love Adam Geddle. They loved his work in the past. I don't think this is his best score. I didn't really enjoy the score, actually, for the most part. But there is that classic score for Broadway. Um, that I don't know how these Tony voters are really looking at it. Um, I don't really think it's gonna win. It could get close. I would love to see the outsiders win this. I really would. I think it's a great, great original score with heart and good orchestration and good lyric and just good melody.
[20:26] Richie Grasso: Yeah. Yeah. You know, and I'll say something, and you're probably not gonna agree with me, but listening to the soundtrack of the notebook a little bit more. I'm actually shocked it's not nominated.
[20:39] Jeff Malone: I don't know if I agree with you on that, but okay.
[20:42] Richie Grasso: I one or two songs of the notebook are I know. I'm just like thinking about it a little bit more, and I'm actually shocked. I uh I also I do love the Here Lies Love um score. So I'm happy with most of this year. I didn't like the Days of Wayne and Roses score, so that's why I'm saying um I'm kind of shocked that the notebook's not there. But alright, let's move on to book of a musical. Another really tough one for me here. Um, the nominees the nominees we have Hell's Kitchen, Christopher Diaz, The Notebook, Becca Brunsetter, The Outsiders, Adam Rapp and Justin Levine, SUFs, Shayna Taub, and Water for Elephants, Rick Ellis.
[21:22] Jeff Malone: I really think that Shayna Taub for Sufs could win this. You want to know why it is the only thing up here that is truly an original book.
[21:35] Richie Grasso: Okay, listen, Hell's Kitchen. It's based on someone's real life. So yes.
[21:39] Jeff Malone: Well, okay. Take that off the list. There's no book. I didn't enjoy the book of Hell's Kitchen. It was it was the weakest part of Hell's Kitchen to me was the script of that. The fact that it's even on this list to me is laughable, but do I think that there really should eventually be a Tony Wards character category for best adaptation of a book for a musical? Yeah, because then Water for Elephants, Outsiders Notebook, but you're adapting stories already.
[22:01] Richie Grasso: Yeah.
[22:02] Jeff Malone: That's hard. I get it. And there's nothing wrong with that. But I think what Shayna did with SUFs was really truly creative to adapt a huge movement in American history into a two-hour piece. But this is a good thing. I think Shayna could easily win this.
[22:20] Richie Grasso: Yeah. No, I do think that SUFs will win Book of a Musical easily. I mean, it's interesting when you see the notebook up here because I actually think the score is better than the book. I don't really remember the book scenes and in the notebook.
[22:34] Jeff Malone: So um, I would love to see The Outsiders win. I do think what they did with the book and the film and kind of making this a new version of it, they did a really great job at, which is, you know, when you look at something like the Great Gatsby, who had a book um that was also a book, and how did that get translated to the stage? You know, and that's not nominated. But what's interesting to me is something like Heart of Rock and Roll is not nominated for Book of a Musical because that's an original story.
[23:02] Richie Grasso: Right.
[23:03] Jeff Malone: An actual original story similar to SUFs that like someone writ and thought wrote and thought out like, oh, this is great. Um I would put that here because it's a good book.
[23:15] Richie Grasso: Yeah. Yeah. Well, we have a few five more categories to go. We're running out of time. So we're gonna take a really quick break here and give you some thoughts and messages from our advertisers, and we'll be right back.
[23:28] Richie Grasso: Okay. We're up to probably one of the most challenging categories of the season. Featured actress in a musical. And the nominees are Shoshana Bean Hell's Kitchen, Amber Amon Limpica, Nikki M. James Sufs, Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer, Monty Python, Spam Lot, Heisha Lewis, Hell's Kitchen, Lindsay Mendez, Merrill Rowlong, Bibi New Earth Cabaret at the Kick At Club.
[23:48] Jeff Malone: Wow, I can't believe all these women are in the same category this year. What do you think, Jeff?
[23:51] Richie Grasso: This was definitely the hardest category, I think, especially for as you can tell, the voters had a hard time picking as well. I'm gonna go with my gut here that the Tony voters are giving Keisha Lewis the Tony for Hell's Kitchen this year.
[24:12] Jeff Malone: I said the same thing. She's got huge numbers in the show. It was the I think the best part of Hell's Kitchen was Keisha Lewis. I was the most captivated by the emotional performance that that woman was giving. It is her time.
[24:24] Richie Grasso: Yeah, and she's owed it. Now, with that said. But I I will also say that because I said the same thing, Keisha Lewis. I wanted her on the stage the whole time. Uh huh uh. That that's what makes you believe that they could clean for her to win.
[24:38] Jeff Malone: Yes. Um, I wouldn't be a bit surprised if Lindsay comes through. Wouldn't it be surprised if the Tony? Hopefully enough, Tony Boater saw her. Yeah, because she hasn't, she's not, she calls out of the show a lot of here, I know. Um, Amber Amon was great. I don't know if this is her time, but she was amazing.
[24:53] Richie Grasso: I also love Shoshanabin. Once again, not sure if this is her time. I can't see Shorshana beating out Keisha in that show, um, which is what makes that tough. BB has her Tony, she's amazing, Cabaret. Don't think this is her win. I really think Keisha Lewis is gonna win this. And I really, really hope she does, Jeff. Like, I really think that would give that show the right Tony award in the right moment, you know.
[25:16] Jeff Malone: Yeah.
[25:17] Richie Grasso: So and I'm throwing this little wrench in the mix here because my girl, Jennifer Samard, was overlooked for this nomination from her belting of Toxic in Once Upon a One More Time. Remember, I said it. I'm gonna keep talking about Once Upon a One More Time. I know it didn't last, but hey, what she did with that number, please. Next.
[25:38] Jeff Malone: Yep.
[25:39] Richie Grasso: Uh, so yeah, it's a really stacked category this year for sure. All right, we're moving on to featured actor in a musical. We have Roger Bart, Back to the Future, the musical, Joshua Boone, The Outsiders, Brandon Victor Dixon, Hell's Kitchen, Sky, Lakota Lynch for The Outsiders, Daniel Radcliffe, Merrily, we roll along, and Steven Skybell, Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club.
[26:01] Jeff Malone: I think the Tony Voters are gonna go with Daniel Radcliffe from Early Rollong. I think that's where we're going with this. I think it's his time. Do I think Brandon Victor Dixon, strictly based on those amazing vocals, could win? Yes. I don't know if this is the role, but his vocals to me are everything, and I just think he sings so well in that show.
[26:21] Richie Grasso: Uh, I don't think we're going that way with it.
[26:23] Jeff Malone: Something for him to do in the show. I mean, at least.
[26:25] Richie Grasso: I know, I know. I just have to say that the vocals there are great. Listen, the Tonies could do their whole thing with Marilee and give all three of them the Tonies. I do think that they're giving Daniel Radcliffe the Tony as well, which could make it interesting with actually giving it to Lindy M Lindsey Mendez too. Um, because we'll get to leading actor shortly. But I would prefer to see Joshua Boone for The Outsiders win the Tony.
[26:51] Jeff Malone: Yeah, I agree with you on that. He's great. He's giving feeling, he's giving vocals. He has a moment in that show that is Tony worthy. So that that's my feeling on that. Some of these others, no.
[27:02] Richie Grasso: Yeah. But it could be Daniel's time for sure. All right, we're down to the final. What do we have? Three, right? Three to go. So we're on leading actor in a musical, and the nominees are Brody Grant, The Outsiders, Jonathan Groff, Merrily Rowlong, Dorian Harewood, The Notebook, Brian Darcy James, Days of Wine and Roses, Eddie Redmane Cabaret at the Kick Tackle.
[27:25] Jeff Malone: Wow. So I'm going super predictable on this. Jonathan Groff is winning the Tony. Jonathan Groff should win the Tony. And my two snubs here are that Corey Cott for Heart of Rock and Roll and Jeremy Jordan in The Great Gatsby should have been nominated.
[27:42] Richie Grasso: I will totally agree with you on all this. Jonathan Groff will win and should win. Those snubs that you mentioned for sure. I'm gonna Eddie Redmane is a really tight one for me. I don't think he's gonna win, but he's a close second for me. And I think that he's a great one on this list.
[27:56] Jeff Malone: And I'm gonna tell you something right now. This may not be Brody Grant's time, but I better see Brody Grant up on a stage doing something again soon because he is incredible at The Outsiders.
[28:04] Richie Grasso: Oh, and he is leading that whole lead. Carrying the show. Carrying. And and um Jonathan will win. I totally agree with you on that. And I agree with you, yes, Corey Cop, but especially Jeremy Jordan. The what he is singing in Get Great Gatsby, he should have totally been thrown a nomination.
[28:19] Jeff Malone: What a shame that he did not get a nomination for Great Cats.
[28:21] Richie Grasso: Totally. Okay. All right, musical revival. Yes, and the nominations are Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club, Gutenberg the musical. Forgot about that show. Merrily we roll along and The Who's Tommy.
[28:36] Jeff Malone: To me, it's very easy that it's going to Merrily roll along. It will and should win. Cabaret could be a really close second. I thought Gutenberg was fine, The Who's Tommy was nice. I don't see them winning. Uh I I think I mean it it's easily. I mean, Merrily is winning. Merrily should win. Merrily should win. It is my favorite Sondheim show. I, you know, I'm so happy that this was done right. It's always been my favorite Sondheim show, even when it was bad. Um I just love the music because I never thought that the show was bad. I love it. I think it has so much heart, and people don't get this show because they don't want to live in reality that friendships end.
[29:16] Richie Grasso: Well, friendships end.
[29:19] Jeff Malone: Oh, you're being so sad. But you have to have those feelings inside you because when you actually have reality, and this is why this show is so good and people never got it, was because they don't want to admit it.
[29:31] Richie Grasso: Well, I think we're also talking about giving it's time for Merrily to win Tony Awards. The show is hit our time, right? And then the show will merrily be wrong somewhere.
[29:42] Jeff Malone: Well, it's interesting because if this wins a ton of Tony Awards in the middle of June and it runs two or three more weeks and it's a hard close July 7th. Could you imagine what the ticket prices are gonna be?
[29:50] Richie Grasso: Oh, I'm glad we saw this when we did. And all I said, Jeff, if you remember me leaving, all I said was, I'm gonna come back and see this again. I don't know if I am, but I thought it was the best. I cried about it.
[30:00] Jeff Malone: Better enter that lottery every day.
[30:03] Richie Grasso: Yeah, it's the best thing I saw this season, you know.
[30:05] Jeff Malone: Yes. Down to the final cast. Best musical. And this is so tough. But the best musical nominations are Hell's Kitchen, Illinois, The Outsiders, SUFs, and Water for Elephants.
[30:16] Richie Grasso: Well, what do you think is really gonna happen here, Jeff?
[30:19] Jeff Malone: I really don't want to say this. But you know what I'm gonna say. I think that Hell's Kitchen is winning the Tony.
[30:28] Richie Grasso: Okay.
[30:30] Jeff Malone: But Illinois should win the Tony. Illinois should win the Tony. Illinois will win Coreyo. It's neck and neck to me between Illinois and I do I kind of agree with you on Hell's Kitchen, but I'm gonna be honest with you. I wouldn't be a bit surprised if The Outsiders took it.
[30:45] Richie Grasso: I could see them take I could totally see the Tony voters going that way. Don't forget to go to the world.
[30:49] Jeff Malone: I would love that. I would love for The Outsiders to take it. I really want Illinois because that show was the show that I felt the most in this whole season. I have an issue where I are. I think that Illinois is not winning, is because it was not nominated for direction. And to me, it doesn't add up if certain awards are not.
[31:12] Richie Grasso: Here's my secret. When something is not nominated for certain things, it's an easy ad up here that it is overlooked in certain areas.
[31:20] Jeff Malone: So also don't forget the marketing on this, right? I think it was Mean Girls that are like 10 Tony nominations. It was Mean Girls with the most but Mean Girls, and then it didn't win one. So don't forget that just because we're saying right now, Hell's Kitchen has the most Hell's Kitchen has what, 11? And The Outsiders is 10. It's only one less than Hell's Kitchen, which leads me to believe you never know. Hell's Kitchen could win one or two, and The Outsiders could win four. It doesn't mean just because you have a lot of, you know what I'm saying? I I'm not saying that's gonna happen here, but it wouldn't be a bit surprised if The Outsiders wins or Illinois wins. Sure, Hell's Kitchen could either.
I actually I don't understand how Water for Elephants is on this list. There were so many other musicals that could have been on this list. I think Great Gatsby could have totally been up here. Um but also SUFs. Once I one more time, yeah. I don't I don't think SUFs is winning, but I'm glad to see SUFs was honored with the nomination. Um yeah, I it's it's gonna be so tough. But I'm good. I just think I'm sticking with The Outsiders on this. I really am. I think that's I would I would love to see that it's doing well. I really want Illinois. I'll just keep going back to that. But there's just something in me that's telling me that Hell's Kitchen is winning, especially when I'm pretty sure what did it win the drama desk or the drama lane?
[32:32] Richie Grasso: Yeah, I won something already, yeah.
[32:33] Jeff Malone: So I mean it could. It really could. It really could. Semi-inless, and it is what it is. If it wins, I just there's something that the community is getting with the show that I didn't. So sometimes that happens. But it's interesting. Here we go. I'm going with Hell's Kitchen. It's interesting how we looked at when I look back at this whole list. I say, okay, it Merrily is standing out right now for what we think, but there's a little bit to SUFs. There's a little bit to The Notebook, there's a little bit to there's a little bit of scatter here. Um, you know, The Outsiders, we gave a little bit of thoughts to. Uh, but um, that's why I don't know. I just I really think Merrily's gonna take a lot.
I really do. I think it's gonna be the standout show. And listen, is there a slight chance that the show could transfer to the theater with a new cast? Sure, I don't think that's happening. I think we're just closing it in July. We know Mattress is going in there. So I don't think really, I think look, Jody Comer won last year for Prima Facie, and then that closed two weeks later. Like this happens. It totally happens, right? You know what they could do? They could cancel that other film of Merrily be roll along early now and put these three in the film and just like film it now that we don't have to wait for however many years to see Ben Platt play the role that no one really wants.
[33:45] Richie Grasso: Anyway.
[33:46] Jeff Malone: Oh my gosh. I I'm sure they filmed this Merrily somehow, some way, shape or something.
[33:51] Richie Grasso: No, but I like an actual film.
[33:52] Jeff Malone: Oh yeah.
[33:54] Richie Grasso: Well, that is we are just about out of time here. Oh what are your final sassy? What are your final thoughts on the Tony predictions of musicals for 2023-2024?
[34:05] Jeff Malone: My final thoughts are I'm so happy that the 2023-2024 season is over and that we're moving on to a new season very soon. Um this was a very, very full year for us, and um great year, but full year in terms of theater. And congrats to everyone that worked this year. This really feels like the first year that we were really fully back from the pandemic, um, without any interruptions, cancellations, etc. So, you know, you know, everyone should be proud of the work that they put on here.
[34:44] Richie Grasso: What people are saying about your show is just to kind of give feedback. Everyone should take things with a grain of salt and be happy that you have your work on the stage.
[34:56] Jeff Malone: You know, I totally agree. There's so much work this seemed to be one of the last years of COVID backlog of shows that were supposed to open, and you know, Olympica, Heart of Rock and Roll, those were all pre-co, you know. But also, we have a lot coming up this year, right? It was an oversaturated season. It was a little exhausting. I can only imagine what these people eight times a week are doing to, you know, plus this long-running shows that weren't even part of this better running. And yeah, I have nothing horrible to say about all these shows. They're all wonderful in their own way. Some things I liked better than others, of course. But you know, the wealth was spread to summon Sony Awards. You know, obviously, when things like The Wiz get no Tony nominations, Gatsby gets one, Heart of Rock and Roll gets nothing. It's tough, but uh, The Cottage gets nothing. You know, Shark is broken. There's so much we can say.
[35:37] Richie Grasso: And we have one big bold statement about the 23, 2024 Broadway season. To all the writers out there, and to whoever is putting things on the stage going forward. Get rid of the narrator. We don't want it, we don't need it, and trust your audience. And if you're gonna use a narrator, use it really smart, really creatively, kind of like an Eddie Redmain cabaret. Use a narrator smart. Please don't have a scene happen where we as an audience clearly see what's happening and then make one of those people turn to the audience and tell them what just happened. That's not a narrator. That's not the point of an hour read. Please trust your audience's more book writers and producers and directors. We don't need all these narrators in all these shows. It is really belittling to us as an audience. Please trust me that I understand what is going on in this plot.
[36:32] Jeff Malone: And there you go. There's our big note, our big note. Our director's notes of the season. Uh uh. Maybe someone should write a musical about narrators, and everyone in the show is narrating the show.
[36:43] Richie Grasso: And that's all the shows. Look, we can make a spoof off properly.
[36:46] Jeff Malone: There we go. You heard it here first. It's coming. Well, listen, this does wrap up our discussion for the episode today. I know we went a few minutes over, but we hope you enjoyed our deep dive into our picks for the musical Tony Award categories. And don't forget, we want to hear from you. Continue the conversation with us on Instagram at Half Hour Podcast. And let us know your thoughts on the episode and your predictions. And if you enjoyed our show, please leave us a review. Your feedback helps us bring more theater to you. Remember, you can listen to past episodes and stay tuned for upcoming ones as well. Until next time, I'm Jeff.
[37:14] Richie Grasso: And I'm Richie saying ta-ta for now.
[37:16] Jeff Malone: Bye.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
