Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 4: Will Roland

Sam and Ilana sit down with Broadway leading man Will Roland and were mesmerized as he shared his history as a member of the Joe Iconis Family and how the role of Jeremy in Be More Chill came his way... Read More

From the show: How To Be More Chill

59 mins
4/28/19

Guests

Featured Shows

About

Sam and Ilana sit down with Broadway leading man Will Roland and were mesmerized as he shared his history as a member of the Joe Iconis Family and how the role of Jeremy in Be More Chill came his way. From the day he first encountered Joe Iconis when he was still a student at NYU to Dear Evan Hansen to the Off-Broadway run of Be More Chill, Will shares never-before-heard stories and revelations from behind the scenes that will make your heart explode with joy!

Part of the Broadway Podcast Network.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:06] Ilana Levine: Hey everyone, I am Ilana.

[0:08] Sam Maher: And I'm Sam.

[0:09] Ilana Levine: And we are two people who had a mutual love for a show called Be More Chill.

[0:16] Sam Maher: And we decided that we would like to find a place where we could bring others who love Be More Chill as much as we do.

[0:25] Ilana Levine: All of the behind the scenes with all of its creatives, and we thought a really great way to do that would be to have a podcast.

[0:32] Sam Maher: And we have called that podcast How to Be More Chill.

[0:36] Ilana Levine: Never hung with a girl like you before.

[0:39] Sam Maher: I don't know if you know it, but I am sure that for me, you are an upgrade.

[0:45] Ilana Levine: It's be each other's upgrade.

[0:47] Sam Maher: Welcome to episode four, which has a very special guest today, Mr. Will Roland, who plays Jeremy here himself, our leading man on Broadway.

[0:58] Ilana Levine: We all first fell in love with Will Roland when we met him as Jared Kleinman in the blockbuster hit Dear Evan Hansen.

[1:07] Sam Maher: Um, and it's really incredible to hear him tell the story of what it was to be such a friend and fan of Joe Iconis and to be in Dear Evan Hansen while Be More Chill was happening at the same time.

[1:20] Ilana Levine: And then this kind of incredible moment where it came to pass that he would get to be in Be More Chill after Dear Evan Hansen.

[1:29] Sam Maher: It's a great story. Let's do this, Will Roland.

[1:42] Ilana Levine: First of all, you are the responsible party for bringing Sam and me together on this particular project.

[1:49] Will Roland: So thank you.

[1:50] Ilana Levine: I feel like matchmaker, matchmaker.

[1:52] Will Roland: Hi, I did good.

[1:54] Ilana Levine: I like to think that if I can do nothing but introduce good people to one another, then my purpose on this earth is fulfilled.

[2:00] Will Roland: It is.

[2:01] Ilana Levine: So thank you for that.

[2:03] Sam Maher: Um we are, as you know, not only your friends, but we are incredible, incredible fans of Be More Chill.

[2:10] Ilana Levine: We think it's one of the most special musicals to ever enter the American musical theater canon.

[2:17] Will Roland: I agree.

[2:18] Ilana Levine: And part of what makes it so special is the family that makes up both something called the Joe Iconis family and then the Be More Chill family.

[2:29] Will Roland: And they're really one in the same.

[2:30] Ilana Levine: Well, it's like a beautiful Venn diagram.

[2:31] Will Roland: Yes.

[2:32] Ilana Levine: There's like a lot of people who live in the middle of that diagram, and there's people who live sort of more to one or the other, maybe like less like a diagram and more like one of those charts in the New Yorker, one of those like scatter plots where you can be like more towards Be More Chill or more towards Iconis and family.

[2:45] Will Roland: Right.

[2:46] Ilana Levine: And it's just like Joe Iconis dead center.

[2:48] Will Roland: Yeah.

[2:49] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[2:49] Will Roland: And like smiling.

[2:50] Ilana Levine: And instead of who he dated, who he has written music for.

[2:55] Sam Maher: So can you share with us before we get deeply into the Be More Chill experience? When did you, Will Roland, become aware of Joe Iconis?

[3:06] Will Roland: Um, I met Joe Iconis in November of 2007. I was a freshman at NYU.

[3:12] Will Roland: Um, and a fellow named John Simpkins, who was the, you know, we sort of ran the program there, now runs the program at Penn State, good friend of ours.

[3:19] Will Roland: Um, Professor John brought in Joe Iconis to talk to the musical theater students about new musical theater and what, you know, he as a writer was interested in and what he looked for from singers and actors, and you know, it was just sort of an opportunity for us to, you know, kids who were learning a lot about Rogers and Hammerstein to meet a 20-something composer and just like sort of hear his thoughts.

[3:44] Sam Maher: Uh, do you remember anything specifically?

[3:46] Will Roland: Oh, yeah, I remember what he said that day very well. I do remember he talked a lot about being interested in and excited by actors who were not afraid to like do something ugly on stage or do something strange.

[3:58] Will Roland: Um, he said he was really delighted by people who at the time he used to say people who looked like they could never be in the ensemble of Wicked.

[4:07] Will Roland: Um, which was sort of, you know, which is that code for it was sort of his way of saying he loved people with perhaps non-traditional body types for the musical theater canon, non-traditional looks.

[4:19] Will Roland: Um, sort of he was he was interested in, he said this a lot in seeing real people on stage rather than some sort of idea of a musical theater person.

[4:28] Will Roland: Um, maybe not afraid of the grit, not afraid of the grittiness, exactly humanity.

[4:33] Will Roland: The sort of he liked people who, you know, to this day, people who were like a little bit rough hewn.

[4:38] Sam Maher: Yeah, yeah, not totally finished all around, quirky, oddly shaped in all in all, you know, physically and emotionally.

[4:44] Will Roland: So people who look like people.

[4:46] Sam Maher: Yeah, people who look like people, like people you might see on the street, but then all of a sudden they're also singers and actors who are quite good.

[4:52] Will Roland: That's the that was what got him going. He sang two songs that day.

[4:55] Will Roland: Um, he sang a song called Helen, which is one of still one of my all-time Joe Iconis favorites, and a song called She Fell Asleep on My Arm.

[6:01] Will Roland: Um, and I was like totally blown away. I was sitting in the front row, I was dressed very strangely because it was my freshman year in college, and that's what you do.

[6:01] Sam Maher: Do you remember what you were wearing?

[6:01] Will Roland: Yeah, I believe I was wearing like a burgundy corduroy suit.

[6:01] Ilana Levine: Yes.

[6:01] Will Roland: Yes.

[6:01] Sam Maher: And I with nowhere you were going after class, which was what you wore to class.

[6:01] Will Roland: Correct.

[6:01] Will Roland: And I know that I own this is a three-piece suit. I cannot say with any certainty that I was wearing all three pieces that day, but I know that I own three pieces and I was wearing at least two.

[6:01] Ilana Levine: I love it.

[6:01] Will Roland: And I had a tie on and I had really long hair. I had like hair that was just brushing my shoulders.

[6:01] Sam Maher: Wow.

[6:01] Ilana Levine: Were there bangs? Did you have bangs?

[6:01] Will Roland: Uh, no, it was all sort of the same length. I'd sort of get it off to the side.

[6:01] Will Roland: I mean, not dissimilar from the way your hair is styled today.

[6:01] Sam Maher: But I never parted it in the center.

[6:01] Will Roland: I always did a side part.

[6:01] Ilana Levine: It's very cool NYU freshman vibes.

[6:01] Will Roland: I mean in my mind.

[6:01] Sam Maher: Cool is a nice word to ascribe to it.

[6:01] Will Roland: Postmortem.

[5:59] Will Roland: But I definitely thought it was cool.

[6:01] Will Roland: Um, but right after the class, I went up to him and I was like, uh, this is amazing. Like, I love your music.

[6:06] Will Roland: Uh, how can I get the music and work on it in class? How can I, and uh he said, yeah, just uh send me an email.

[6:14] Will Roland: And so I sent him this like crazy email.

[6:16] Will Roland: Uh someday we'll publish the full text of it.

[6:18] Will Roland: Um, and it was just like me asking for sheet music, asking when his next concert was, um, and sort of getting all the deets so that I could become a Joe Iconis fan.

[6:27] Ilana Levine: And two weeks later I went to my first family show.

[6:29] Sam Maher: Oh my god. I love these moments.

[6:32] Will Roland: It's just thinking like, what in that moment from the outside looking in, like if you had a video camera on that moment, it is like literally a musical theater composer meeting the guy who's gonna star in his first probably musical.

[6:44] Sam Maher: Like 10, 12, like that moment, that sizzling magic that happens in that moment.

[6:50] Will Roland: And we all identify those moments in our lives, and like we all hope that they can maybe be those kinds of things.

[6:56] Will Roland: And like that one really was.

[6:57] Sam Maher: Yeah.

[6:58] Will Roland: I uh, yeah, that worked out well.

[7:00] Sam Maher: Do you remember are there people who were in that concert that are still...

[7:00] Will Roland: Oh yeah. Like literally nearly all of them.

[7:08] Will Roland: Uh, I mean, we're, uh at the time of this recording, we're getting ready for our Christmas show, and I can tell you that people who were in that concert that are in the Christmas show include Jason Sweetooth Williams, Lauren Marcus, Katrina Rose Diedriksen, uh Lorinda Lasitsa, uh Bill Coyne was not in it, but Bill Coyne was one of the students in the room that day.

[7:29] Will Roland: Um, and obviously John Simpkins directs the Christmas show, so he was there.

[7:33] Will Roland: It's like an i, there's an insane I could sort of keep going if I thought really hard about it, but there's an insane number of people who were, you know, in that room eleven years ago doing that concert, uh, who I'll be on the stage with or in the room with on Friday night.

[7:46] Ilana Levine: Wow.

[7:46] Ilana Levine: And I know from being your friend, separate from Be More Chill, that at some point this notorious director John Simpkins was directing a production of The Black Suits written by our beloved Joe Iconis, and you were in that.

[8:00] Will Roland: I was in that.

[8:00] Ilana Levine: Was that the beginning of your collaboration artistically with Joe?

[8:05] Will Roland: Um, I would say that was where it sort of ascended to the next level.

[8:09] Will Roland: I had done the Christmas show a few times.

[8:11] Sam Maher: But wait, how did you get to sing as part of the family and not just being audience to the Christmas show?

[8:19] Will Roland: Um, it all happened because when I was a senior at NYU, so Christmas 2010, a fella named Rich, who was also in school with me, was slated to do the Christmas show and dropped out like two days before.

[8:33] Will Roland: Um, and so Joe emailed me and was like, do you want to be in the Christmas show?

[8:37] Will Roland: It is truly the smallest role in the entire world.

[8:40] Will Roland: Uh, it was this bit where, um, you know that classic Folgers commercial where, uh, Peter comes home from in the original version the army and then another version college, and he cracks open the Folgers and the whole family's like, oh, we're waking up to the smell of Folger's coffee.

[8:54] Will Roland: Um, I played Peter, the boy who came home and woke up everyone who had fallen asleep.

[8:59] Ilana Levine: Yes, I cry every time I'm at that commercial.

[9:01] Will Roland: Well, decades later, I still cry.

[9:03] Will Roland: We really sent it up that evening.

[9:04] Sam Maher: Okay, cool.

[9:05] Will Roland: Um, but yeah, that was my first encounter with Iconis.

[9:10] Will Roland: Funny epilogue to that story. I had a friend who worked as an intern at Ars Nova years later, and she was tasked with going through some old files and cleaning them out.

[9:18] Will Roland: She found a handwritten note from the day that I'd gotten cast where someone had written down my mother's name and email and said, Beth Rowland, son just casting Christmas show, needs four tickets.

[9:29] Ilana Levine: Wow.

[9:30] Will Roland: Like that's cool.

[9:31] Ilana Levine: It was an insane, uh, that's going in the Smithsonian.

[9:35] Will Roland: Very exciting.

[9:36] Will Roland: It's very, it's yeah, it's been a very, very insane journey with all these people um that I've known for so long.

[9:41] Ilana Levine: And let's do that.

[9:42] Will Roland: That's a note that the twenty-two thousand and eighty Jennifer Ashley Tepper will find in her archives.

[9:49] Ilana Levine: Truly, yeah.

[9:49] Will Roland: No, like the next, yeah, exactly.

[9:51] Ilana Levine: Some Gentepper years and years from now.

[9:53] Will Roland: Uh-huh.

[9:53] Ilana Levine: Um will be...

[9:54] Will Roland: Oh no, it'll be this Jen Tepper.

[9:57] Ilana Levine: If anyone's Jen Tepper at the ripe age of one million.

[10:01] Will Roland: Exactly.

[10:01] Ilana Levine: She's like, hang on, hang on. I'm tweeting, I'm renting the runway, and I am finding Will Roland's mother's thing.

[10:07] Will Roland: She loves her in the runway.

[10:09] Ilana Levine: Uh, well, she has beautiful dresses every time I see her.

[10:12] Will Roland: She's actually, they should sponsor her.

[10:15] Ilana Levine: They should.

[10:16] Will Roland: They should start giving her free dresses for as much as she's gonna wear those dresses everywhere.

[10:19] Ilana Levine: So yeah, there will be many openings in her future.

[10:22] Will Roland: So the timeline here is basically you encounter him at as an NYU freshman three or four years later in your first Iconis Family Christmas show.

[10:31] Will Roland: And then a few years after that, I get invited to do a reading of The Black Suits, which was my, which I saw at the Public Theater in 2008 in the summer play festival.

[10:40] Will Roland: Um, the people who were in it were Jason Williams, Jason Tam, Krista Rodriguez, Annie Golden, Lance Rubin, uh, Nick Blemeyer, and there's one more person.

[10:54] Will Roland: And Sarah Glenn.

[10:55] Ilana Levine: Oh, and Krista Rodriguez and Sarah Glenn Denning, because it was a cast of eight back then.

[10:59] Will Roland: Um, those are the people that I saw on the play.

[11:02] Ilana Levine: And so I was invited to do this reading of it, and I was like so excited because I was like, oh my god, like there's a production of The Black Suits happening.

[11:09] Will Roland: Like I really, really, really want to be in it.

[11:11] Will Roland: Um, and I, I auditioned for it a few weeks after we did this initial read, and I got it.

[11:11] Will Roland: I got it. I got it, and I had to pretend.

[11:25] Will Roland: I feel like I, I think I told this story when I was on the podcast.

[11:27] Will Roland: I had to like pretend I'd been instructed by Joe and John to not to act like I didn't really know them that well.

[11:34] Sam Maher: When you locked into the audition room, correct.

[11:35] Will Roland: I was supposed to go in the audition room and be like not too familiar because there were other people in the room who were wary of having too many family members in the show.

[11:44] Sam Maher: Uh-huh.

[11:45] Will Roland: So the only quote unquote family members who ended up in the show were myself, who was at the time like sort of a proto family member.

[11:51] Will Roland: Like I did Christmas, but I hadn't done any of the other concerts.

[11:54] Will Roland: Uh, and Annie Golden, who was like, uh she must be in it.

[11:57] Will Roland: Um, and other than that, we met some other people who would become fixtures in our lives, including the wonderful Broadway veteran Harrison Chad, who is also gonna be in Christmas this weekend, and uh the one and only Tony Award winner, Mr. Ben Platt.

[12:10] Sam Maher: Um, big deal.

[12:11] Will Roland: Yes.

[12:12] Ilana Levine: After when he had just finished filming some a cappella movie and was playing the demos for us, and I was like, I don't want to listen to this crap.

[12:18] Sam Maher: Yeah.

[12:19] Will Roland: Pitch Perfectly.

[12:20] Sam Maher: Pitch what?

[12:21] Will Roland: Terrible idea.

[12:22] Will Roland: I went with my mom to go see it at the mall in October of that year.

[12:24] Will Roland: Best Roland needs four tickets to Pitch Perfect on the note.

[12:28] Ilana Levine: She needs them immediately.

[12:29] Will Roland: Yeah, we went to see it at the mall. I was like, yeah, I think Ben's got like a Tony role in this movie.

[12:32] Will Roland: And it turns out, oh no, Ben's all over the movie.

[12:34] Ilana Levine: Wow.

[12:35] Will Roland: Yep.

[12:35] Will Roland: Ben's a movie star.

[12:36] Ilana Levine: Who knew?

[12:36] Will Roland: Yeah.

[12:37] Sam Maher: Fun fact I saw Pitch Perfect for the first time two days before seeing Dear Evan Hansen for the first time off Broadway.

[12:42] Will Roland: So for me, it was like a Ben Platt double whiz bang moment.

[12:46] Ilana Levine: You're like, I hope he does magic in Dear Evan Hansen.

[12:48] Will Roland: And I also just realized that I saw you that summer.

[12:50] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[12:51] Will Roland: You played Ben's mom.

[12:52] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[12:52] Will Roland: And I played.

[12:53] Ilana Levine: I did.

[12:54] Will Roland: In The Power of Duff.

[12:55] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[12:55] Will Roland: Starring Craig Kameer.

[12:56] Ilana Levine: Craig Kameer and I were husband and wife.

[12:58] Will Roland: Ben Platt played our son.

[13:00] Ilana Levine: I could not believe this boy could act as well as he did in this very dramatic play.

[13:07] Will Roland: And then in the rehearsal room there was a piano, and then on break, suddenly he'd go to the piano and we were singing Into the Woods.

[13:13] Ilana Levine: Yeah, I know.

[13:14] Will Roland: He can play too.

[13:14] Ilana Levine: It's the same thing.

[13:15] Will Roland: Right.

[13:15] Ilana Levine: Like it was really crazy.

[13:16] Will Roland: And then right afterwards, he was going to do a play at Barrington Stage.

[13:20] Ilana Levine: And I went to see it because we fell madly in love.

[13:24] Will Roland: And then I got my first dose.

[13:27] Will Roland: Uh, a fix I would need many times forever after that of Will Roland.

[13:32] Ilana Levine: So, and then of course, at this moment in time, Dear Evan Hansen is sort of starting to happen.

[13:41] Will Roland: Yeah.

[13:41] Ilana Levine: And Be More Chill is kind of starting to happen in workshops.

[13:45] Will Roland: They're very much on parallel timelines.

[13:47] Will Roland: Like the first draft of Dear Evan Hansen and the first draft of Be More Chill were written like months apart in separate, you know, separate time zones.

[13:54] Will Roland: Um, and then I did a reading of, I did what I believe was the first formal reading of Be More Chill, um, wherein I read the role of Michael, which is now played by some guy named George.

[14:08] Ilana Levine: Um, I don't know if you've heard of him, George Salazar.

[14:11] Will Roland: Sounds cool.

[14:11] Ilana Levine: Cool name.

[14:12] Will Roland: Yeah, it's a very cool name.

[14:13] Ilana Levine: Is he gonna be in French?

[14:14] Will Roland: Is he in it on Broadway?

[14:15] Ilana Levine: Uh, no, I don't think so.

[14:16] Will Roland: No, I'm pretty sure they're replacing him.

[14:17] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[14:18] Will Roland: With someone good.

[14:18] Ilana Levine: Yeah, exactly.

[14:19] Will Roland: Yeah, someone who can sing.

[14:20] Ilana Levine: Yeah.

[14:21] Will Roland: Um but he uh so yeah, that was the very first as far as I know, the very first reading of Be More Chill that was.

[14:27] Ilana Levine: Where was it?

[14:27] Will Roland: Uh it was at the offices of William Morris Endeavor.

[14:29] Ilana Levine: Okay, who was present?

[14:31] Will Roland: Uh I mean, the cast was larger back then, but a lot of people, I mean Lauren Marcus read Christine Canigula, um, and our my friend Seth Elliser read uh Jeremy and who else was in the room.

[14:44] Will Roland: A bunch of people. Lance Rubin, who I saw in the black suits, Jason Williams was there reading the role that he's reading now. Uh, John Diaz, who's the guy at Two River who is, oh, you know, I don't actually know what John's job is. Artistic director, literary director, whatever it is. John was there. Um, yeah, and the agents and the writers, and they didn't have a director yet. It was all very sort of preliminary. And for that reading, did Joe bring in a keyboard or was the music on his computer and you would stop and he would play the songs? Like, how did you get away?

[15:13] Will Roland: Okay. Yeah. So he was playing. Yeah, he played and sang everything and we just read it cold. Oh, I think. Um, yeah, and that was the first time anyone heard "Michael in the Bathroom," um, which was really, we walked out being like, we're truly, it's like me, Lauren, Joe, like standing on 53rd Street, being like, "Michael flying solo, Michael flying solo," because we like couldn't, we didn't know the words yet. Right. Because we'd only heard it one time. But it was a catchy tune even then. Truly, we were like, "Joe, that song's great." Yeah, it's like a lightning bolt strikes the earth. Yeah. I guess we have great taste. Yeah. Clearly. You were right about that song. And then, and then what happens?

[15:52] Will Roland: Uh, and then what happens is, uh, I depart from the Be More Chill development process when they acquire a director. The new director, who is not Steven Brackett, he's like, uh, are we allowed to talk about who is directing? I think it was Scott Ellis. Scott Ellis, great. As long as you could say, I don't know what's secret and what's not. Yeah, so Scott Ellis was directing. It's all secret. That's why this podcast is so amazing. Exactly. We're uncovering dirty. We're the conduit. Yes. Scott Ellis was directing. Uh, Scott Ellis was not interested in Will Roland being in the musical. And so that was when I departed the development process. Do you know that? Are you told that?

[16:26] Will Roland: I mean, I don't, I know. It's not like I got a call from Scott Ellis being like, "You can't be in the show." This is Scott Ellis. "Beth Roland needs four tickets, and Will Roland will not be in my show." Hello, is this Will Roland? I'm here to tell you you're not good enough to be in a play. May I speak to Beth? Truly. I need to tell your mom too. But it, yeah, so it's, uh, that's another, like for me, I'm like my favorite example of like you hand the same show to seven different directors, and you'll get seven entirely different shows, entirely different companies. So, uh, I departed the development process then, and it was right around the same time that I started doing Dear Evan Hansen readings. We're in like, it's like 2014 now.

[17:02] Will Roland: Um, and then as I'm getting ready to do Dear Evan Hansen down in DC, we're doing a workshop. I'm working with Gerard Canonico on this workshop. Uh, and he's like, and we, I find out we're both auditioning for Be More Chill, because Be More Chill has a new director, a fellow named Steven Brackett, who I have known for a number of years and we're very much mutual friends. Like Steven, but we've never worked together. Steven keeps asking me to do a reading, but I'm out of town, and I keep auditioning for something else that he's doing, and I don't get it. And so like Steven Brackett and I have had like multiple occasions where every time we see each other, we're like, we have to work together, but it keeps not happening. Uh-huh.

[17:38] Will Roland: And so I get, uh, an appointment to audition for Jeremy in Be More Chill. And I'm like, this is it. Yeah, this is my moment. I'm finally gonna work with Steven Brackett. It's gonna be great. You know, we, we've been dying to work together. And, uh, I go in and I audition and I have a callback, and I have another callback, and it comes down to me and this other guy named Will, and I didn't get it. And I was like, what? What? And then, uh, but so, and that was, you know, that was that. And then we went to, we went to go see the show down in New Jersey a few times, and then I saw it twice. Uh, Steph, my fiancée saw it six times on the, yeah, but we, we went to some previews and some openings and a closing.

[18:18] Will Roland: And then, uh, and then I went and did Dear Evan Hansen. Um, you know, I went, that was, they happened like months apart and miles apart. The series. So do you audition, do not get Be More Chill post Dear Evan Hansen workshop. And then you re-audition for Dear Evan Hansen when it's actually going to be a production in DC, or do they just offer it to you?

[18:37] Will Roland: No, I miraculously only had to audition. I like to tell people that I've never auditioned for Dear Evan Hansen. I auditioned for the, but it would be a lie. No, I auditioned one time for, uh, the untitled Pasek and Paul Levinson musical, which, which is though it is about a boy named Evan who writes a letter and tells a lie on the internet, it is a nigh unrecognizable show from what would open on Broadway, uh, you know, years later. It was, it was a sort of, uh, it just, it was, it was like totally, uh, it was way more satirical and it was like way longer. Um, and it was a lot more about sort of making fun of us and how we're so addicted to the internet and so addicted to our phones.

[19:10] Will Roland: Um, and it was much less sort of earnest and heartful. Well, I'd like to digress for one second because Steven Levinson, I just had a very long conversation with him who wrote the book for Dear Evan Hansen. The genius Stephen Levinson. Who said, "Well, there was no Jared, and then there was Will Roland, and then we found Jared." So you, he felt very strongly that the voice of that character really came to life when he and you were able to meet and create this guy, and so you're really your everyday DNA. No one is concerned.

[19:50] Will Roland: Well, I'm sure also that the world knows. Do you know this? The Gerard Canonico was the original Evan understudy. No. Yes. Gerard, yeah, Gerard. So Gerard did the, when we did that workshop, there was an ensemble in the show. There were like five kids at school. And the idea was all of the kids at school had a parallel, uh, character that they could understudy. So there were like a few boys who would understudy. There was like a, there was another Connor, another Jared, another Evan, another Alana, et cetera, et cetera. And two offstage parents who would appear at the funeral scene. There was a funeral scene.

[20:21] Will Roland: There's an Alana in Dear Evan Hansen. Yes. And there's an Alana in this recording studio. Yeah. So not for nothing, I would like to note that. Just in terms of it. It's modeled after you. That's all. That's all I'm saying. I agree. But then Gerard rejoined the production at Second Stage, where he was the offstage cover, and he was the swing for all the guys. Um, but then didn't come with us to Broadway because he got Groundhog Day.

[20:47] Will Roland: So he was not a part of Be More Chill until then. He was. Yeah, so True River was before the Second Stage. The timeline's crazy. Yeah, the timeline is him because when I saw Dear Evan Hansen off Broadway at Second Stage, I knew Gerard from Two River Theater's B. Marchell. That was post Two River. Yeah. Okay. And so at the party, I think it was at the influencer night party that I got to go to for Be More Chill. Marchell, I remember just being like, "Gerard," and he's like, "Why are you so into me? Like go talk to Will and Ben." And I was like, "I know, but like, I love you from Be More Chill. I'm a giant fan." Really? That was, and he was so, um, yeah, it was like, it was this, it was actually like very hard for me because it was why all that whole callback process was during the Dear Evan Hansen workshop.

[21:28] Will Roland: So Gerard's like, "I got my offer, I'm due Be More Chill." And I was like, "Great." Checking out every five minutes. Yeah. Yeah, like I'm still waiting for the phone. There's no service in this room. I need to go out to the street. That must be what's happening. Yeah. Um, what a lesson, right? And obviously it all worked out big time, exactly the way it was meant to be.

[21:49] Will Roland: I like to think so. Yeah. I mean, uh, it ended up with, um, Stephen Brackett and I did finally get our chance to work together, um, in the, uh, in the fall of 2017, which was sort of after all the Be More Chill, uh, internet stuff had happened, and it was sort of like everyone's sort of sitting around going, like, why isn't anyone doing Be More Chill? What's going on? Including me. Look at all this crazy internet. Yeah, why isn't anyone doing it? Um, and, and we did a NAMP'ed reading, um, of a show that's going to Barrington this summer, um, called Fall Springs.

[22:22] Will Roland: And, uh, and it was just like, I mean, you know, I had this like at the bar after the reading, I was like, "You just, Steven, like if you ever are, I, this is crazy to be more chill stuff's happening. I don't think if you ever like are doing this show again, I will love to audition. I just, I've sleep with so great and I love to be a part of it." Um, and apparently that was how I got it.

[22:44] Will Roland: That's how you do it. That's how you do it. Yeah, I mean, it was like four months later, so on my birthday, March 5th, 2018, that I got a call from Joe Iconis when he was at the airport, uh, offering me Be More Chill. Oh my god. Lauren was being like strip searched in security. And he was like, "Hey, uh, I just like," he had like go back to her, but he, but they were also like about to miss their flight because Lauren was getting held up in security and he had to make this phone call before he got on the plane so that he could like tell, like tell the powers that be to send the official offer today.

[23:15] Will Roland: It was just like all very crazy. Are you still in Dear Evan Hansen when you get that call? I sure am.

[23:20] Will Roland: So how does that suddenly impact your experience as Jared? Um, I mean, I wouldn't say at that point my performance was pretty solidly locked in. It definitely changed my experience as Will Roland.

[23:34] Will Roland: Okay. It definitely changed my experience as a, well, I was a guy I knew I was like, I knew that I would be, I was like, I'm not gonna be in Dear Evan Hansen a lot longer. You know, this is March. And I'm like, I, you know, my contract is up in May, and like maybe I'll, you know, maybe I'll extend a little bit, but I just don't know. Um, and this made it like clarity. Clarity appeared. I was like, So when Sam and I were talking about this, because I, I was telling him how the thing that's so amazing about you and when I watch your work is that you are able to completely create a character that is singular in how it is, uh, appears on stage, but there's a lot of you in your work at the same time.

[24:21] Will Roland: So as opposed to sort of method actors who are unrecognizable every time they do a part, I feel like you were able to not lose the parts of yourself that are really right for a part. How, how is, and, and there's a, there's more questions to be asked, but how was preparing for the role of Jeremy different from preparing for Jared? How are they the same? What are, how do you create a role when you are handed a role?

[24:50] Will Roland: I am, uh, I'm an actor who, um, I'm like suspicious of acting. I'm like, I don't believe, uh, very strongly in my ability to like transform. I think that the best I can do is sort of give my most sort of honest, earnest, uh, you know, version of what is on the page and it's like my ability to, you know, like I'm looking at, uh, what's his face, Christian Bale as Dick Cheney right now and I'm like, what is that? I didn't even know, I don't know what that is.

[25:23] Will Roland: Um, because I, I think I'm just from a very sort of utilitarian school of acting where like it, it just sort of like either it's gonna work or it's not and I think so the DNA of Will Roland has to sort of match the DNA of Jeremy here or Jared Clyde, which is not to say that I don't, you know, want to play someone who's like way outside of myself but I think that person also has to live in a world that's sort of way outside of our world in order for me to do that.

[25:50] Will Roland: If I'm, because I, I'm tying back to what Joe Iconis likes about actors is like I'm always interested no matter how sort of insane the show is, um, you know, as long as it's based in the real world I really am most invested in being a real person. Um, and that like I will, I will not, I mean, I can that for me is like a pretty my version of real is larger than a lot of other version of the live birth. Yeah, but that's me. That's me in real life. And there's a lot of Jeremies and a lot of Jared's walking around this world.

[26:22] Will Roland: Sure and I like hundreds of thousands of them. Yeah. And I like almost, uh, I was, uh, doing, uh, I was fixing the router which is on top of our counter in our kitchen the other day, and I like slipped a little bit and almost fell. That would have been terrible. But truly the noise I made was like, you know, like that's the, that's the real life, honest to God. If you had been in my kitchen with a microphone that day, you would have heard, you know, like as I almost fell off my marble counter.

[26:47] Will Roland: And so, like when I'm on stage going like, you know, like that feels honest to me. Right. Um, you know, and, and I think that, you know, give it to a different version, and you'd get a different, you know, hopefully honest, you know, version of that whole thing. And so my, my Jared and my Jeremy are as similar as Will Roland and as different as those characters are.

[27:09] Will Roland: You know, I mean, there's an excellent way to put it Will Roland. Oh, thank you. Yeah, I mean, Jared is a snarky, uh, you know, he's constantly deflecting and constantly sort of, uh, ignoring his emotions and, and you know, just like, just like, uh, lashing out as defense, and Jeremy is retreating as defense, and, and those activities, you know, the way that you choose to approach your world, to me, are like that's what makes a character.

[27:35] Will Roland: Like the decision, you know, the, the fact that Jeremy sort of tries and fails and retreats versus Jared, who never tries in the first place. He only sort of takes on the challenge that he knows he will win, that, you know, asserting his power over Evan. Jeremy's like, maybe I can talk to these people. I cannot, I cannot, I must, I must, you know.

[27:52] Will Roland: And then the beauty of it is like very rarely in a show do we get to watch a character have a full blown arc transformation, uh, in one second. Um, which is what's great about the squip. It's like he takes this pill, and obviously it's instructing him, but the real thing that it's doing is giving him permission to follow the impulses that he would have self-censored before.

[28:16] Will Roland: That for me is like hopefully I hope people notice that on the deep reads of the show, but it's not so much that like he, he takes a degree of instruction from the squip at certain moments in certain interactions, but like all of his interactions with Christine are not prompted by the squip. They're things that he wants to say, but would not have said if he thought he could get it wrong.

[28:37] Will Roland: Right. The squip didn't give him the direction, he gave him the permission. Exactly. To be himself. To be himself. And then the sort of breakdown at the end of the show comes when the squip is asking Jeremy to be someone other than himself. That's where it all sort of starts to fall apart. Amazing.

[28:56] Ilana Levine: So take us inside the rehearsal room. You're at the signature backstage in that giant awesome rehearsal room.

[29:02] Will Roland: Great rehearsal room.

[29:06] Ilana Levine: I'm imagining this room, you know, has there's so much going on in there because the half the cast or more than half the cast is the same from this True River production that has this already legendary cast recording that's out in the world. There's a few new cast members, you're getting this first big huge off-Broadway production of Joe Iconis has never had an off-Broadway production.

[29:26] Will Roland: So he's getting that. You're in your first leading role since middle school, which when you tweeted this, it was probably in previews of the Off-Broadway run. My brain exploded. Like you are, you were such a leading man already in my head that like I could not believe that you were the leading man in every play, Sam Maher.

[29:48] Sam Maher: Yes.

[29:48] Will Roland: Had crazy in his mind about you. But now the rest of the world is Dear Evan Hansen in Ben Platt. I mean, my reaction to your tweet was that's not true. And Texas meal like, no, it's not. So your first leading role.

[30:02] Sam Maher: Yeah.

[30:03] Will Roland: Take us inside the rehearsal room. Um, it's totally cool. It's totally four assistants are around you.

[30:08] Sam Maher: Oh, yes, your cars dropped too.

[30:11] Will Roland: It's very, um, yeah. So I walk 17 miles in the heat from the A train to the signature. Nice. Um, and uh, yeah, I show up nice and full flop sweat. I'm a sweater, I'll sweat at nothing. Great. Little known fact, he's a sweater, people. Little known fact, he sweats.

[30:27] Sam Maher: Um, and uh, and what's cool about it is that the cast is this 50-50 split. You know, there's ten actors and ten of them did it in New Jersey, or sorry, five of them did it in New Jersey and five of them are new for New York. Um, and of the five that are new, three of them are me, Jason Tam, Jason Williams, who have known each other for ten plus years. We're all in the family.

[30:46] Will Roland: Um, yeah, we're all in the family. And then there's the sort of two river folks that I know really, really well, uh, being uh George, Gerard, and uh Lauren.

[30:57] Sam Maher: Oh yeah.

[30:57] Will Roland: Um, and I'm sort of getting to know Stephanie and Katie, and we're getting to know Tiffany and Britton. And so it's this very interesting sort of socially, like people who know the show, people who don't know the show, people who are in the family, people who are sort of on the edge of the family, you know, and all this sort of stuff is mixing together.

[31:13] Sam Maher: And so the energy in the room is sort of very creative because you've got a sort of baseline. Like people know that like some people are gonna come to the show. You know, at this point the first couple previews are sold out, so we're excited.

[31:26] Will Roland: Uh, you know, and so people are taking big brilliant risks, um, and also building on previous sort of information that they learned in New Jersey. So the room is operating on this super high level because you've got each of these ten actors is the kind of brilliant comedian that you hire one of for your show.

[31:47] Sam Maher: And you have ten.

[31:48] Will Roland: Correct, and we have ten of them. So it's actually chaos. It's truly chaos from start to finish. It's like herding cats. It's like day two.

[31:55] Sam Maher: So it's really the star of Be More Chill is your stage manager.

[31:58] Will Roland: Uh, absolutely. Birdie, Birdie tows an amazing line in terms of letting people have fun, but still running a room. But like truly on day two, like we're doing Steven's talking us through some scene, and Steven Brackett says, George, what did I just say?

[32:11] Sam Maher: And George is like, I um you just you said, and then he says, like, and Gerard sign up, he goes, he's like, just say you don't know, just say more listen, just say because they were talking to each other like literally like high school.

[32:23] Will Roland: And then George says the wrong thing, and Steven scolds, and we move on. And so it's this like when does that happen in a professional rehearsal process? It is both um unthinkable, like it's like you know, like most you know, most rooms, there's enough fear that something like that would never happen, but it is also like the essence of creation in this process.

[32:41] Sam Maher: There's so much sounds like the warmth prevailed.

[32:44] Will Roland: There's literally like every it's like popcorn, and every time a popcorn kernel pops, like something brilliant has emerged. And so that was the process. Everyone's just like lobbing ideas out there, and then like a few weeks in, we start to make some pretty surgical changes to the show, which is really exciting.

[32:59] Sam Maher: They reorder the second act, they switch the pants song and uh Pitiful Children, which is really great in terms of the sort of escalating arc of action.

[33:07] Will Roland: We now go, like, oh, we're gonna squip the whole school, bam, right into the sort of dump dun dun dump dun dun dump, and we're at the play, and the climax is upon us. Um, and the addition of Loser Geek Whatever.

[33:17] Sam Maher: Um, so at what point did you find out you were getting Loser Geek Whatever?

[33:20] Will Roland: Um, I heard like I heard rumbles like uh the new song is coming. Yeah, they were like, oh, Witjo's writing you a new song. And I'm like, yeah, all right, I'll believe it when I see it. I've heard that before.

[33:27] Sam Maher: Um, you know, and and and so you know, we're sort of like, ah, you know, we'll hear, we'll see, we'll see, we'll see. And then it's like on the schedule, and it's like Will Joe Emily, music rehearsal, everyone else.

[33:38] Will Roland: Emily's our music director, Emily Marshall.

[33:39] Sam Maher: Right.

[33:40] Will Roland: Um, you know, music rehearsal in the second room, and everyone else, you know, choreography on Rich Set Fire in the main room.

[33:44] Sam Maher: Um then that afternoon.

[33:46] Will Roland: Because at that point, there's no other song that would involve just you and the vocals.

[33:50] Sam Maher: Correct.

[33:51] Will Roland: It's the only uh it's the only like real proper solo that I have in the show. There are only uh two real, proper bare stage solos in the show.

[33:58] Sam Maher: It's Loser Geek Whatever and Michael in the Bathroom.

[34:01] Will Roland: Um, I love play rehearsal. Even though Jeremy is leading more than Survive, it's all 10 cast members are all right. Everybody's basically always on stage in this show.

[34:11] Sam Maher: And even in like I love play rehearsal, like I'm sitting there interrupting her.

[34:14] Will Roland: It's the only true, those are the only two like bare stage moments in the show.

[34:17] Sam Maher: Spotlight On.

[34:19] Will Roland: Truly spotlight on, backlights lit, hit center, take a downstage charge in the second verse, you know, like and it is the only one that is those two songs are structured that way.

[34:28] Sam Maher: And from the moment you heard it, so do you go into this other room and Joe plays it for you?

[34:32] Will Roland: Yeah. Um, yeah, I still have the like I have like a my my voice memo recording from that day of like Joe singing it at the piano and like starting in the wrong key and having to go back, and you know, it's just like it was totally uh incredible because I, as I've said, I ho this writer to me, Joe is like the the greatest.

[34:50] Will Roland: He is the greatest. He's the world's greatest, he writes the greatest songs, he writes the greatest shows. Um, and so any time that it's like holy shit, it's a new Joe Iconis song, the world just got a little larger.

[35:01] Sam Maher: That's right.

[35:01] Will Roland: That also that he wrote for you.

[35:03] Sam Maher: Yeah, and there's like there's a certain there's certain elements to which like it yeah, it is so written on my voice.

[35:09] Will Roland: Like there's that moment in the second verse where I go, my instincts suck so much. That's like a sucks so much is a phrase that I use all the time. It's like a Will Roland phrase that is in the musical forever.

[35:18] Sam Maher: I'm like, oh, that sucks so much.

[35:20] Will Roland: Like I just and I don't even I didn't even realize how much I said it until like I was like, oh, it's in the I would say that all the time now.

[35:26] Sam Maher: Wow, that's awesome. Did you go into the process when you think back to the first day, very sweaty.

[35:32] Will Roland: Yeah. Um, you take your ascot off and you hand your your stuff to your assistant.

[35:36] Sam Maher: Um, were you nervous?

[35:38] Will Roland: I was super nervous. I was super duper nervous because I um I have I loved the production in New Jersey so much, and I have never uh played a role that I'd seen another actor play before.

[35:52] Sam Maher: Um, you know, that was I mean, except for like no, actually I'm not sure that I'd ever seen a play that I'd done before I did it.

[35:58] Will Roland: Wow, because I don't go to a lot of stuff. Um, but so I was very um I was just very uh nervous. I sort of felt like on the first day, like I had something to prove, you know.

[36:08] Sam Maher: Like I had to make it clear to all these people in this room uh who had worked with the incredibly talented Will Connolly on this show. I had to sort of prove to them that I deserved to be there.

[36:18] Will Roland: Now this was not true, but in my head it was very true. And so it was a lot of pressure. I mean, there's hundreds of millions of streams at that point.

[36:26] Sam Maher: And it's I can't. The momentum of the show was.

[36:29] Will Roland: And I loved the show and I loved Will in it. And so it was this very uh, you know, it was just this very complicated set of feelings I had about like what I had to do and what I had to bring.

[36:40] Sam Maher: Um luckily I I didn't get so hung up on that that like Do you do a table read on the first after the meeting read and welcome everyone?

[36:48] Will Roland: Do you just sit around the table, scripts in hand and go through it? That was the very first thing we did.

[36:53] Sam Maher: And it's just a lot of people.

[36:55] Will Roland: So what happens the first day? Music rehearsal first.

[36:57] Sam Maher: Okay.

[36:58] Will Roland: Yeah, so the first thing we did, well, we had our meet and greet, and then we dismissed for a long lunch and they started calling people back from lunch to work on so to start working on solos with the new people.

[37:07] Sam Maher: And I will say I was there on that first day. They allowed co-producers in the room to be there when the cast was revealed, the set design.

[37:15] Will Roland: Yeah.

[37:15] Sam Maher: Oh yeah, we do all our design design stuff.

[37:18] Will Roland: And I've never been to one of those rehearsals, so I can't compare it to other stuff.

[37:24] Sam Maher: It's show and tell.

[37:25] Will Roland: Show and tell. It's the best. Usually the director, the producer welcomes everyone, then the director might say something, and then bit by bit, every head of every department shows either with a model or sketches, this is the world you're about to enter.

[37:39] Sam Maher: Yeah.

[37:39] Will Roland: So so when Sam talks about that, that's what he needs to do. Beowulf showed us uh, you know, scenic renderings of every you know, scene by scene was all pinned up on the wall.

[37:47] Sam Maher: And at that point, besides a different leading man, a d a completely different set design was kind of the other biggest change.

[37:54] Will Roland: Yeah, from the True River production.

[37:56] Sam Maher: So that was the thing everyone's designer or just a different set?

[37:59] Will Roland: Okay.

[38:00] Sam Maher: So you get over your nervousness.

[38:02] Will Roland: Yes.

[38:02] Sam Maher: Uh, is that because like sometimes for me, what helps is if I get a laugh right away.

[38:07] Will Roland: Oh yeah.

[38:08] Sam Maher: So I'm like, oh, okay, they I got I'm I'm in the right world here.

[38:12] Will Roland: True. Did you feel like during that first table read the next day you you nailed it?

[38:16] Will Roland: I did.

[38:17] Sam Maher: You crushed it.

[38:17] Will Roland: I did. I felt like, yeah, well, and I and I had reached out to uh the Joes beforehand and said, please send me the materials, let me familiarize myself with it, let me sort of stop listening to the album and start sitting with the score and my piano at home and like, you know, doing it.

[38:33] Sam Maher: Yeah, and just sort of like returning to the the relationship that is the actor to the text, which I hadn't had with the show in many, many years.

[38:40] Will Roland: I had had a relationship to uh like being an audience member and seeing it or listening to it, but I needed to go back to that sort of, you know, core relationship with it.

[38:48] Sam Maher: Did you audition again?

[38:51] Will Roland: I did not.

[38:51] Sam Maher: You just got the offer.

[38:52] Will Roland: I just got the straight offer on my birthday.

[38:54] Sam Maher: Yeah.

[38:55] Will Roland: And I had heard like little rumblings that it was happening in the weeks leading up to it and like sort of had in my mind, like, oh, maybe I'll get to do it.

[39:02] Sam Maher: You are best friends with Jennifer Ashley Tepper.

[39:05] Will Roland: Truly.

[39:05] Sam Maher: So how did you balance being intimately in love platonically with everyone involved with this show? Knowing there were so many rumblings of it happening, not knowing what your place was with all that.

[39:23] Will Roland: Being in a by the way, the biggest Broadway hit ever. It's not like you were, you know, waiting tables at the magic pan.

[39:29] Sam Maher: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

[39:30] Will Roland: Oh, the magic pan.

[39:31] Sam Maher: Yeah.

[39:32] Will Roland: I just interviewed Mary Steenburgen where she where she began her days and then Jack Nicholson cast her.

[39:38] Sam Maher: I know that story very well.

[39:39] Will Roland: Incredible story. Um, that will not be in this episode when we put it on the air, on the air, as it were.

[39:45] Sam Maher: But like emotionally, like we're human beings with hearts. Do we not bleed?

[39:50] Will Roland: So how do you You're so generous, Will Roland, because you're so generous because part of it was painful. So how do you navigate the possibility of this for your friends and and the uncertainty of what your place will be in it?

[40:05] Will Roland: I think part of the journey of being in Joe Iconis family uh is learning to deal with those situations. Um, because we are a big family of performers, and every time that Joe does something, be it a reading, be it a workshop, be it a full production, some of us get to do it and some of us do not.

[40:26] Will Roland: Um, I have the great good fortune at this point of having done two full-blown Joe Iconis productions, which is huge insane. And I recognize how atypical that is for the members of our family and for the actors of the Earth.

[40:39] Sam Maher: Um, and so I'm like, there's no part of me that is sort of like, well, I I deserve to be there. I belong there. I, you know, it's like you you there is that sort of impulse, but you have to sort of get over it a little bit.

[40:52] Will Roland: And you know, I mean, I the very, very wise uh Michael Grief, uh, we were sitting around after a Dear Evan Hansen reading one day, it was me and Michael and Michael Park.

[41:01] Sam Maher: Um, and Mr. Park said, uh, he said, you know, Michael, you've really uh you you've you've assembled such a great family here.

[41:07] Will Roland: And Michael Grief said, I'm very he said, I don't want to call it a family. He said, it's it's that's a tricky word for me because family means unconditional love.

[41:17] Will Roland: And in this industry, the love is so often conditional. The ways in which you can show love is so often conditional.

[41:24] Sam Maher: And so the fact that Joe remains at the center of this group of people, and we we fight and we're unhappy, and you know, like there I was uh I was unhappy to not be in Be More Chill, and you know, there are people in the family who obviously wish they're and be more chill this time and are not, you know, this is all part of sort of sitting around at Christmas dinner or sitting around at Thanksgiving or Halloween or the various holidays that we celebrate, um, and like healing together and being together like a real goddamn family.

[41:55] Will Roland: You know, many of us um are new to this concept or the phrase Joe Iconis and family. So if you were to take a traditional family unit or a non-traditional family unit, because this is a very non-traditional family unit.

[42:12] Sam Maher: Um, we just have one patriarch and everyone orbits him.

[42:15] Will Roland: Is Joe who is Joe in the family?

[42:18] Will Roland: I think of this family like uh like a solar system, uh, like a series of bodies orbiting one another. Uh Joe is the star at the center of it all.

[42:28] Sam Maher: Um, and you know, there are various sort of bodies that orbit in very close proximity and very regular proximity. There's, you know, Jason Williams and uh Katrina Diedriksen and Lance Rubin and these people who are always very near.

[42:40] Will Roland: Um, and then there's people who have sort of entered and left, and there's people who s you know, somewhat infrequently sort of visit us and then go away.

[42:47] Sam Maher: I think, you know, think of like the Christa Rodriguez and the Nick Blameyers who are like, they're constantly working, they're constantly doing stuff, and whenever there's an opportunity for them to do a family thing, uh, you know, they're always asked, and they almost always say yes.

[43:00] Will Roland: You know, it's this sort of thing where, you know, some people are there all the time, and some people are sort of, you know, rotating on the outsides, but it is this sort of thing where we all are drawn together by Joe.

[43:10] Will Roland: Um, and it's it's important to note that the the Joe Iconis and family concerts grew out of uh this sort of Joe reacting to the fact that it's very hard for a young musical theater writer to get your work produced, especially in 2006 when he was graduating, and you know, we were sort of hitting that things were about to slow down big time in our industry, and you know, people were gonna stop taking risks on young writers.

[43:35] Sam Maher: And so doing shows with this group of people um was not nearly as common at the time as it is now.

[43:43] Will Roland: Like these days, every young musical theater writer is like, I'm gonna book an evening in 54 Below and do the songs of John Angus Green, you know, and as if they were Kandor and Ebb, you know, yeah.

[43:54] Sam Maher: And and and so it's become rote, but in in many ways, uh, you know, this sort of notion of a unit doing shows together like a troupe.

[44:03] Will Roland: Uh, you know, we started doing them at the Laurie Beachman Theater, which was exclusively a cabaret and comedy venue at the time, basically, and since has become very much a home base for this family.

[44:13] Will Roland: And so it's like it's interesting that the when the work opportunities come around, they sort of exist in parallel because the family came about as a reaction to a lack of work opportunities for the people involved.

[44:27] Will Roland: The whole thing is so revolutionary. The whole thing. The people involved, the way you're doing it, like it's just this revolutionary. People also forget that Joe Iconis had the first viral musical theater hit in 2006 when Courtney Wolfson recorded "Blue Hair" and put it on YouTube, and Justin Paul is accompanying her at the piano. It's like it's and it had like 200,000 views in 2007. That was insane. That didn't happen in musical theater back then. You know, I mean "Blue Hair" was like a phenomenon all those years ago. And Joe was sitting there going, well, why the hell won't someone do "The Black Suits" then? You know, and that was the fear last summer when all this "Be More Chill" stuff was happening. It was like, well, is someone gonna do this damn show? Or is this gonna be just like, you know, when everyone in the world was emailing Joe asking for "Blue Hair," but like no, but no theater would touch it. It's very strange.

[45:15] Will Roland: So perfect segue, first preview off Broadway, the Signature Theater this summer, summer 2018. Tell us about that first preview.

[45:21] Will Roland: Um, the first preview was incredible. Um that whole first like 10 days was insane because of performance. Yes. Because we've got to be. Wait, did you have an invited dress?

[45:34] Will Roland: Uh no, we canceled it.

[45:35] Sam Maher: Okay.

[45:36] Will Roland: We canceled the invited dress. Right. So we needed the time. We needed the tech time. It was, yeah, it was we were we were insane. We were like losing our minds. We were in tech all day. We were like, you know, we were making these big changes to the show, and everyone's like, well, are we doing the right thing? And are the characters getting lost? And boy, you know, we're all freaking out. Um, and then we're also going, all right, so we know there's going to be this group of super fans here, and they're gonna love it no matter what we do. And they're also gonna hate it no matter what we do. Like they're gonna hate certain things because they're not what they wanted. When you love something so much, you start to like your views on it start to ossify.

They change from ideas to beliefs and they changed from beliefs to faith, you know, and so all these people who worshipped at the altar of "Be More Chill," we sort of knew that there were certain sort of things that as soon as it was different, they'd go like, ugh, or they then they would either love it or they would hate it, but it would react they would react to it in a different way than people who were seeing "Be More Chill" for the first time, whether they had listened to it or not. You know, there's there were these sort of three different levels of the show was operating on, and we were all nervous that like will anyone outside of our devoted fan base like or care about this show.

[46:44] Will Roland: Yeah, and that was the big big fear. Um and then we and for the first two weeks, I would say that it was the audiences were like fifty to seventy-five percent those fans, which was an incredible electricity in the room, like tangible. I was in the second preview, and just that will go down in history for me as my favorite theatrical experience of all time. Like tied literally with like Idina Menzel's last show in "Rent" in 1997. It was both it was both amazing and challenging because we're in previews and we're trying to figure out well, does this moment work? Does that moment work? And the audience, because of their familiarity with the piece, is reacting in ways that a a quote unquote normal audience, you know, an audience of people who don't know the work would not react.

[47:33] Will Roland: Right. Certain lines are getting like screaming cheers. And we're sort of like, uh, what's going on? What that's not a joke. Correct. And yeah, it's already got this sort of culty thing going on. And so we're like, we're sitting there with our previews period going like, ah, we can't actively assess whether these things are working because the audience is not your sort of typical, you know, if the show were to run for 10 years on Broadway, these people would sort of we'd run out of them in the first couple months, and then we then we would be left with sort of like didn't no preconceived idea audience. Did we tweak the show correctly? Did we make the right changes during previews and reaction to an audience that we should have?

So we're freaked out about that. Um and and yeah, there was just a lot of I mean, at this point it all feels like, well, of course the whole thing was sold out, and of course it was going to go to Broadway. It's like, no, none of that was certain.

[48:22] Sam Maher: Are you Katherine Hepburn? What's happening?

[48:23] Will Roland: Haven't you met Jerry Garrett? Exactly what he sounds like. I'm kidding. Catherine Hepburn. Um so there would nothing was certain that now feels sort of like a foregone conclusion. Maybe from the outside, people were like, Well, of course that show's going. You know, multiple newspapers said that. Like there were there were reviews that said like, doesn't matter what I write, this show's going Broadway. And I was like, God, I wish that were true.

[48:44] Will Roland: Yeah. So a special moment for me that I want to thought about too is during the second preview, which, you know, it it should be known that I couldn't even get into the first preview. There's a funny picture from my personal Instagram of me and several other producers of the show literally trying to listen in at the door with their ears through the door. We couldn't get in. I mean, it was that sold out, it was that much of like the epicenter of musical theater that day was right there. I couldn't even mean that. So I did the second preview. Second preview, you know, there was a lot of rumbling about the new song. We kept it a secret that there was the new song, "Loser Geek, Whatever." But it was starting by the first preview, especially, people were the message boards were blowing up people now. And during the second preview of the moment, I say, "Loser Geek, Whatever," which you say the words right before the song starts.

[49:29] Will Roland: Yeah, it's a the use the in the New Jersey version of the show, it went, I already know what it's like to be the loser. I should find out what it's like to not be the loser. I don't want to be special. Oh right. It like went back into that. And so when I went, or the geek or the whatever, that's the first moment that everyone's like super fan next to me, gasped in a way that is a part of my soul at this point. The way I hear that in my brain, like I started weeping. So I want to just what does that mean to you? As we finish, I know we have five minutes left with you. So I wanna, I wanna, because I can talk to Sam about that moment for a long time outside of this moment with you.

[50:11] Will Roland: So you're hearing, like he's a grown man.

[50:13] Sam Maher: Yeah.

[50:14] Will Roland: Yeah.

[50:15] Sam Maher: Like he's not a 15-year-old girl going to like Pleasant View High.

[50:18] Will Roland: No.

[50:19] Sam Maher: No.

[50:21] Will Roland: Sam was a grown-ass man.

[50:22] Sam Maher: Very handsome grown ass man.

[50:23] Will Roland: Indeed. What does this mean for you? What does "Be More Chill" mean to you?

[50:28] Will Roland: For me, the thing that I love about the piece and the thing that makes me honored to be a part of it, is that um I forever, uh all I want to do and all I've ever wanted to do is tell true stories that live in a world that is more fantastical than our own. Um, as much as I love a play that takes place in a living room or on a split level set with two living rooms um that are totally realistic and totally like a study in how we are. We love you, Harold Pinter. We love you, Harold Notcher in any way. I loved "The Humans." I love you know, all these plays. Um but I want to do work that lives in a bigger, more fantastical world than the one that we live in. For better or for worse. I love future dystopian sci-fi.

I love fantasy, I love magical realism. I love all you know, I love like the worlds of like Wes Anderson, and I love the worlds of uh um uh "Pan's Labyrinth" by Guillermo del Toro, you know, like all these sort of worlds, "Shape of Water" was truly my favorite movie ever. And so the fact that I get to be in this musical, which I love so dearly, which is magical realism, which is magical realism, written by this guy who I love so dearly and whose work means so much to me. Um, and I get to sort of carry so much of this show um into this, you know, and and present a sci-fi musical, which is a rarity in our world. And in this whole thing, I get to be totally real and honest and human and give that story to a bunch of people, young and old, who are seeing themselves in this fantastical world.

Um, I think that uh it's it's very cliche to be like, oh, we live in a we live in tough times, you know, with all this Trump stuff. Um, but it's true, and it also, but I feel this way all the time. Like these fantastical worlds transport us and this show transports us, I hope. You know, when when it succeeds, it's this thing where we imagine a better and more magical world than our own. Um, and that's that's what I want to do.

[52:29] Sam Maher: But I love how you're saying that's kind of rooted in reality. Like it's not just a completely fantastical world or it's like you start here and this it is real.

[52:36] Will Roland: There's a bed, you appear on it, you're watching porn.

[52:40] Sam Maher: Yeah.

[52:40] Will Roland: This is real life.

[52:41] Sam Maher: Exactly.

[52:41] Will Roland: And then it just explodes. And the world and it lets us sort of think, like, you know, when we walk out, that like, no, like maybe the world is a little more magical than I think it is. And there's squips in all of us.

[52:52] Sam Maher: Yeah.

[52:53] Will Roland: I want to be a part of that. And so I'm very honored to get to do it now, and I hope to get to do it forever in so many ways.

[52:59] Sam Maher: Yeah.

[53:00] Will Roland: So just to finish, because it's such a close-knit family, and it's very hard to keep a secret from a family member who you love and adore. Um, did you know when the announcement was made and there's video footage of your cast being assembled, learning that you're going to Broadway, there's all the hopes, there's all the rumblings, and you know, as having been around for a long time, doesn't mean it's gonna happen. Doesn't mean the money will be raised. Right. So the moment that there's an announcement, did you know before that it was gonna move? Or when did you find out for the thing?

[53:33] Will Roland: Okay. I got a text from my best friend in the world, Danielle Gimbal, who is the music assistant on the show. We went to NYU together. Um, and she said, What's this company meeting tomorrow? And it was like we'd been open for weeks, Danielle was no longer on the payroll at the show, and I was like, it's gotta be Broadway. Yeah, it's gotta be Broadway. Why is Danielle and the thing is, yeah, but the thing is you don't know, like you say in your mind like it's gotta be Broadway, and we're sitting around, and you know, like as more and more people start to pour into the room, becomes clear what it is, but it's not real until Jerry says it. And I just says it. He says, We're going to Broadway, we're going to the Lyceum in the spring.

And it was like, I mean, as I've said, that my friend Joe Iconis is like the greatest writer I've ever known. And those are like the Joe Iconis' show to open on Broadway is all that I've ever wanted to hear for the last decade. And so all of the things that come with it, my involvement, what the show is, what has happened with the show, it just is it's overwhelming. It's beyond overwhelming. It's it's the most it's the mo it's the best thing that's ever happened. And that moment is captured on video for us all to see.

[54:42] Sam Maher: Oh god's really fun.

[54:43] Will Roland: I watched it a couple times watching just you on a mess. And it but it's like this very specific moment. He loses it. Like it's like the carpet is pulled out from anywhere. Well, something fake becomes real. Something a dream actually becomes a real thing.

[54:56] Sam Maher: So well, I can't wait to check back in with you down the road. And we'll see, like when you're in the middle of it, how it grows, how it changes. And I just want to say thank you for spending this time with us today and for the colour.

[55:09] Will Roland: Thanks for having me. Remarkable. Broadway's the leading man, Will Roland.

[55:13] Will Roland: Thanks, Sam. Thanks, Ilana.

[55:25] Sam Maher: So Sam and I have this idea because "Be More Chill" is such a fan-driven show, and the fans are so much of why the show has made it to Broadway. We wanted to find a way to share what the show means to you with all our listeners. So we went out and asked some fans to share their feelings about "Be More Chill" with us. And here's one now.

[55:48] Fan: Will Roland is a magnetic performer and the kind of person everyone wants to be around. His portrayal of Jeremy shines light on the truth of teenage anxiety while simultaneously embracing a sense of humor for the ridiculousness of the character's situation. He can play this larger than life teen character on a Broadway stage, and at the same time makes it so relatable and personable, speaking fluently to the hearts of real high school kids like me and grown adults alike. Meeting Will was an even better experience than I ever could have hoped for. He has a kind heart and actually cares and takes interest in what us fans have to give to the story of "Be More Chill." Not to mention he is absolutely hilarious. Two minutes talking to Will Roland proved that the comedy of his character does not only come from the writing. Will brings something special to this show. Maybe Jeremy doesn't want to be a hero, but in my eyes, Will Roland sure is one.

[56:44] Fan: And here's another one.

[56:48] Fan: Hi Sam and Ilana. My name is Nico. I'm a vocal major at Frank Sinatra School of the Arts, and "Be More Chill" means a lot to me because it is showing the impact of social standards, acceptance, and how not fitting in can affect someone's self-value. Will Roland makes you feel exactly what Jeremy is feeling when he comes across these types of conflicts and portrays this character perfectly, captivating the audience with his great acting and amazing singing. There are so many people who are going to see this show, listen to this cast album, and feel represented and encouraged to be themselves, which gives it so much more importance. Being a high school student, I know firsthand how brutal it can be if you are not accepted or don't have many friends.

You can feel like you can't breathe. Your palms start to sweat, the walls are closing in on you because you're not gonna get that girl, and you're not gonna get invited to that party. You're alone with no escape. "Be More Chill" is that escape. "Be More Chill" is our way out when we need it. And that is what "Be More Chill" means to me.

[58:16] Fan: Thank you for listening.

[58:17] Sam Maher: Hey, you can find us on Instagram at how to be more chill. And one quick thing before we go, could you go to Apple Podcasts or whatever podcast platform you listen on and just take a moment to rate and review us? We would really appreciate it.

[58:30] Ilana Levine: And do not forget, this is Alana.

[58:35] Sam Maher: This is Sam.

[58:36] Ilana Levine: Tell us how to be more chill.

[58:38] Will Roland: Never hung with a girl like you before. I don't know if you know it, but I am sure that for me you are an upgrade.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred