We are head over heels to be in the room with Steven’s great friend, Emmy Award winner and Tony nominee Penny Fuller (Cabaret! Applause! A New Brain! Sunday in the Park With George!) How lucky we are to be hanging at her divine apartment on the Upper West Side in NYC, listening to her reminisce about her illustrious career... Read More
From the show: IN THE ROOM with Steven & Dana
Guests
Featured Shows
About
We are head over heels to be in the room with Steven’s great friend, Emmy Award winner and Tony nominee Penny Fuller (Cabaret! Applause! A New Brain! Sunday in the Park With George!) How lucky we are to be hanging at her divine apartment on the Upper West Side in NYC, listening to her reminisce about her illustrious career. Sit back, relax, and join our dinner party conversation as Penny tells stories about the legends in her life such as Lauren Bacall, Elizabeth Ashley, Robert Redford, Rip Torn, Tommy Lee Jones, Bette Davis, Elizabeth Taylor, Joel Grey, Hal Prince, Cynthia Nixon, and her new hero, Jake Gyllenhaal. We love you Penny!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Steven Ferezy: Take one.
[0:01] Dana Craig: Knock knock.
[0:04] Steven Ferezy: We're Steven and Dana.
[0:05] Dana Craig: We can't believe you thought I could not.
[0:10] Steven Ferezy: We're so glad you're listening to, and we would never listen to.
[0:13] Dana Craig: But I don't even want to listen to it to edit it.
[0:15] Steven Ferezy: I don't even want to wake up in the morning.
[0:18] Dana Craig: Steven and Dana and we're in the room.
[0:23] Steven Ferezy: Oh god.
[0:25] Dana Craig: I'm wound up like a spring that's been tygooned.
[0:29] Steven Ferezy: Dreamy and dizzy, but not a bit bright and I'm alive.
[0:29] Dana Craig: I'm alive.
[0:35] Steven Ferezy: No one.
[0:38] Dana Craig: Everybody loves the winner, but nobody loves the block.
[0:44] Steven Ferezy: No one worries how you got there.
[0:47] Dana Craig: You're just standing on the top.
[0:50] Steven Ferezy: So I feel up and together and steady.
[0:54] Dana Craig: Eager excited so come on already.
[0:57] Steven Ferezy: Ready for the climb.
[1:00] Dana Craig: Baby, it's my time.
[1:03] Steven Ferezy: You believe it!
[1:05] Dana Craig: I'm alone.
[1:24] Steven Ferezy: Welcome to In the Room with Steven and Dana.
[1:27] Dana Craig: I'm Dana.
[1:28] Steven Ferezy: I'm Steven.
[1:29] Dana Craig: That's Steven.
[1:30] Steven Ferezy: Hi.
[1:30] Dana Craig: We apologize up top.
[1:32] Steven Ferezy: So the last episode.
[1:33] Dana Craig: With Josh Lehman, your friend and mine.
[1:35] Steven Ferezy: He's the greatest.
[1:36] Dana Craig: We just saw him yesterday.
[1:38] Steven Ferezy: What did you do?
[1:39] Dana Craig: And we can officially talk about the thing we weren't allowed to talk about, which is that The Prom is coming to Broadway.
[1:45] Steven Ferezy: Yes!
[1:46] Dana Craig: Starring uh in the room guest Bonnie Milligan.
[1:49] Steven Ferezy: Different show.
[1:50] Dana Craig: She's in Head Over Heels.
[1:52] Steven Ferezy: Oh my god, there's two in the room.
[1:54] Dana Craig: Two in the room guests have had Broadway announcements this week.
[1:58] Steven Ferezy: And they were top secret when we were doing the podcast.
[2:01] Dana Craig: Correct.
[2:01] Steven Ferezy: I'd like to shout out both of them, Bonnie Milligan.
[2:04] Dana Craig: Bonnie Milligan, who will be starring in Head Over Heels, the Go-Go's musical at the Hudson Theater this summer.
[2:09] Steven Ferezy: Wow, information.
[2:12] Dana Craig: And Josh Lehman who will be starring in The Prom at a different theater.
[2:17] Steven Ferezy: Great in the fall.
[2:18] Dana Craig: Great.
[2:18] Steven Ferezy: Do we know anything about Prom?
[2:20] Dana Craig: About Prom?
[2:21] Steven Ferezy: Uh I know that they did, I think it was in San Diego last year with Chrissy Berberth.
[2:27] Dana Craig: So it's gonna be one of those, and it's gonna be great, and I can't wait.
[2:31] Steven Ferezy: And then Bonnie Milligan making her Broadway debut as a principal in the Go-Go's.
[2:37] Dana Craig: Not a principal.
[2:38] Steven Ferezy: The principal.
[2:39] Dana Craig: The principal.
[2:40] Steven Ferezy: Yeah.
[2:41] Dana Craig: A principal.
[2:42] Steven Ferezy: The principal.
[2:44] Dana Craig: Like School of Rock principal?
[2:46] Steven Ferezy: Like she's the school in School of Rock?
[2:49] Dana Craig: She's a school principal.
[2:50] Steven Ferezy: Is she the head or the heels?
[2:51] Dana Craig: She's the head.
[2:52] Steven Ferezy: She's the head.
[2:53] Dana Craig: She's the head.
[2:54] Steven Ferezy: She's very funny and intuitive.
[2:56] Dana Craig: Great.
[2:57] Steven Ferezy: Intellectual.
[2:58] Dana Craig: And she says cool cool cool.
[3:01] Steven Ferezy: Which immediately Bonnie and Drees.
[3:04] Dana Craig: After our episode, I started saying cool cool cool.
[3:07] Steven Ferezy: Um, so thank you, Bonnie Milligan.
[3:09] Dana Craig: Um I hope she gets to use all of her dialect work in this piece.
[3:13] Steven Ferezy: Use in a views.
[3:14] Dana Craig: Use in a beautiful.
[3:16] Steven Ferezy: What did you do since uh Josh Lehman episode?
[3:18] Dana Craig: I've been working a lot and I have an unearned murder.
[3:25] Steven Ferezy: Um I have a show coming up with the Deplex, March nineteenth, 9:30 p.m.
[3:31] Dana Craig: Sondheim in the City.
[3:33] Steven Ferezy: Taking the tales of Sex and the City and exploring them through Sondheim songs.
[3:39] Dana Craig: That sounds so gay.
[3:41] Steven Ferezy: And you're doing it with Byron St. Cyr.
[3:42] Dana Craig: Correct.
[3:43] Steven Ferezy: Who is he and why should we come see the show?
[3:46] Dana Craig: He's a loyal listener of this podcast.
[3:48] Steven Ferezy: Um he's wildly talented.
[3:51] Dana Craig: He just had uh a show called 4600 Mithra, which is a tribute to New Orleans jazz.
[3:58] Steven Ferezy: Yes, because he's like one of those cool people we know.
[4:01] Dana Craig: Yeah, he's like from somewhere interesting and has a point of view and wears hats.
[4:08] Steven Ferezy: Yeah.
[4:08] Dana Craig: Yeah, he always has a mean burger.
[4:12] Steven Ferezy: Oh, those burgers are really good.
[4:14] Dana Craig: Anyway, you're doing that show with him.
[4:16] Steven Ferezy: Doing that show with him.
[4:17] Dana Craig: And you share a love of Sex and the City and Sondheim.
[4:19] Steven Ferezy: Correct.
[4:20] Dana Craig: As will anybody in the audience, including you.
[4:24] Steven Ferezy: You know, I've seen Sex and the City uh one time.
[4:28] Dana Craig: Well, well, it was one time I did uh beginning to end in a summer, and that was fantastic.
[4:34] Steven Ferezy: When I when I get uh inspired by something, when I get obsessed with something, I'm gonna watch it beginning to end.
[4:40] Dana Craig: Uh-huh.
[4:40] Steven Ferezy: I don't like doing one-offs.
[4:43] Dana Craig: Oh, interesting.
[4:44] Steven Ferezy: You don't have a jumping in point as background noise.
[4:46] Dana Craig: It's not your background.
[4:47] Steven Ferezy: I don't watch background noise.
[4:48] Dana Craig: I don't just turn on TV.
[4:50] Steven Ferezy: Maybe the Kardashians, maybe like Chelsea Handler, but when I watch TV, I watch it.
[4:54] Dana Craig: Right.
[4:55] Steven Ferezy: I don't just I've seen this so many times that without looking at it, I know what the camera shot is.
[5:00] Dana Craig: The thing about that is I want new content.
[5:02] Steven Ferezy: Oh.
[5:03] Dana Craig: If I'm if I have on background music, it's new music.
[5:07] Steven Ferezy: If I have on a podcast, it's a new podcast.
[5:10] Dana Craig: I'm not reliving my life watching something again.
[5:12] Steven Ferezy: Interesting.
[5:13] Dana Craig: I it's it's my cozy sweater.
[5:16] Steven Ferezy: I would get so annoyed with that.
[5:19] Dana Craig: I'd be like, and now I hate Sex and the City.
[5:21] Steven Ferezy: What a pity.
[5:24] Dana Craig: Is it?
[5:25] Steven Ferezy: I mean, just don't do it because I want you to continue.
[5:27] Dana Craig: We're gonna maybe get in a fight at this point because like you also don't watch new stuff.
[5:32] Steven Ferezy: I do watch new stuff.
[5:33] Dana Craig: I just watched three new episodes of television today.
[5:37] Steven Ferezy: Listen to other things besides Sondheim music.
[5:39] Dana Craig: That's what I'm saying.
[5:40] Steven Ferezy: So we're like, I have no idea who Kesha is.
[5:42] Dana Craig: I know.
[5:45] Steven Ferezy: I don't even know what he looks like.
[5:47] Dana Craig: Penny Fuller has on a hat.
[5:48] Steven Ferezy: Okay, let's get through this.
[5:49] Dana Craig: Let's get through it.
[5:50] Steven Ferezy: I would have no idea who Bruno Mars was if I saw him on the street.
[5:53] Dana Craig: Okay, well, listen to new things.
[5:55] Steven Ferezy: Let's can we can we do that?
[5:58] Dana Craig: Listen to new things.
[6:00] Steven Ferezy: It's just not Bruno Mars and Kesha.
[6:02] Dana Craig: Okay, great.
[6:02] Steven Ferezy: Um, what else have we done?
[6:04] Dana Craig: Do we announce our other thing?
[6:07] Steven Ferezy: Is that we have to sign a contract first?
[6:09] Dana Craig: Okay.
[6:09] Steven Ferezy: Yeah.
[6:10] Dana Craig: I will feel better when it's signed.
[6:12] Steven Ferezy: God, it sounds fancy.
[6:14] Dana Craig: We have to sign a contract first.
[6:17] Steven Ferezy: You know what? Right.
[6:18] Dana Craig: Hashtag Poppy Kramer.
[6:19] Steven Ferezy: Let's continue.
[6:21] Dana Craig: Has anything happened to you?
[6:22] Steven Ferezy: I've just been working on it and working on this soccer.
[6:27] Dana Craig: Good God.
[6:28] Steven Ferezy: I'm going to Chicago on, well, a week from today, but when this airs, it'll be Friday.
[6:33] Dana Craig: So I'm going to Chicago Friday to Monday.
[6:36] Steven Ferezy: Are we excited?
[6:37] Dana Craig: The most.
[6:38] Steven Ferezy: The most.
[6:39] Dana Craig: With my boy from Denver.
[6:40] Steven Ferezy: Tickets were super cheap.
[6:42] Dana Craig: He's still live there.
[6:43] Steven Ferezy: He's going to show me around his old stomping.
[6:44] Dana Craig: Are you going to stand in front of the painting again?
[6:46] Steven Ferezy: Yeah.
[6:47] Dana Craig: Not I'm not giving him the full experience.
[6:51] Steven Ferezy: Great.
[6:52] Dana Craig: Um.
[6:53] Steven Ferezy: But there is, so there's a bar there called Sidetrack.
[6:56] Dana Craig: And they do show tune Sundays.
[7:00] Steven Ferezy: And I guess there's a tradition there where they would play "Don't Cry for Me Argentina" and everyone throws their napkins in the air.
[7:07] Dana Craig: But they would always play Madonna's rendition.
[7:12] Steven Ferezy: Until the Grammys.
[7:14] Dana Craig: Where it has since been replaced with Patti LuPone.
[7:17] Steven Ferezy: Sure, sure, sure.
[7:18] Dana Craig: Singing live at the Grammys.
[7:19] Steven Ferezy: Sure, sure.
[7:20] Dana Craig: Which was a dream.
[7:21] Steven Ferezy: Giving it, giving it, giving it, arms up.
[7:24] Dana Craig: It was a dream.
[7:25] Steven Ferezy: She was remarkable.
[7:27] Dana Craig: Patti LuPone and the Grammys.
[7:29] Steven Ferezy: Uh Donald Trump is president.
[7:31] Dana Craig: That was amazing.
[7:32] Steven Ferezy: Yeah.
[7:33] Dana Craig: There are no rules anymore.
[7:34] Steven Ferezy: No rules.
[7:35] Dana Craig: No rules.
[7:36] Steven Ferezy: I didn't know the Grammys were in New York until day.
[7:38] Dana Craig: Didn't know that that was a thing.
[7:40] Steven Ferezy: No one watching cares.
[7:41] Dana Craig: No one watching is like, oh, that venue is in New York.
[7:45] Steven Ferezy: Guess what? No one knows that.
[7:48] Dana Craig: It's in a building.
[7:48] Steven Ferezy: We could do it at the Muni.
[7:50] Dana Craig: Yeah, you don't have to say, and now the Grammys are at the Muni.
[7:55] Steven Ferezy: Uproar!
[7:56] Dana Craig: Who cares?
[7:56] Steven Ferezy: Statewide.
[7:57] Dana Craig: No one cares.
[7:59] Steven Ferezy: Nobody cares.
[7:59] Dana Craig: Speaking of nobody caring, I know somebody who doesn't care about what anybody thinks.
[8:11] Steven Ferezy: Okay.
[8:13] Dana Craig: She's wearing a fantastic.
[8:13] Steven Ferezy: Is that your Faith Prince hat?
[8:18] Dana Craig: You know what hat that is?
[8:20] Steven Ferezy: That is a Jennifer Lewis, Tony's hat.
[8:22] Dana Craig: Nope, Tony Basil.
[8:22] Steven Ferezy: Hey Mickey or so fine, who I think is in Jackie's back wearing that hat.
[8:27] Dana Craig: Probably.
[8:27] Steven Ferezy: Well, I just didn't want Byron to do something I couldn't do.
[8:30] Dana Craig: Well, anything Byron can do, Penny Fuller can do better.
[8:33] Steven Ferezy: Uh ladies and gentlemen, uh, Emmy winner and two-time Tony Award nominee is Penny Fuller.
[8:41] Penny Fuller: Hello.
[8:41] Steven Ferezy: Oh what is that we're leaving for?
[8:49] Penny Fuller: Hi.
[8:49] Dana Craig: Hi, gang.
[8:54] Penny Fuller: Jazz.
[8:52] Dana Craig: Um.
[8:52] Penny Fuller: Well, I'm gonna I'm gonna remember to do this right at the top as we like to do.
[8:55] Dana Craig: We play a little game with all of our guests called What Was Your First Impression of Each of Us?
[9:01] Penny Fuller: Go.
[9:02] Steven Ferezy: Well, you tell me that I met you when I don't remember meeting you.
[9:05] Penny Fuller: So that's not your first impression of me.
[9:07] Steven Ferezy: Oh.
[9:08] Penny Fuller: My first impression of you, I guess, was at Norman's.
[9:11] Steven Ferezy: And I thought you were a nice kid.
[9:14] Penny Fuller: When was this?
[9:16] Steven Ferezy: A hundred years ago.
[9:17] Penny Fuller: When he was a nice kid.
[9:19] Steven Ferezy: Mm-hmm.
[9:19] Penny Fuller: Yeah, no, when was it?
[9:20] Steven Ferezy: About how many years ago?
[9:22] Penny Fuller: I'm gonna guess that was the tone of the wheel.
[9:25] Steven Ferezy: It was up there?
[9:26] Penny Fuller: Yeah.
[9:27] Steven Ferezy: So they had moved already.
[9:28] Penny Fuller: Oh, they'd moved already.
[9:31] Steven Ferezy: I'm gonna guess that was 2009 or 10.
[9:34] Penny Fuller: Okay.
[9:38] Steven Ferezy: Yes.
[9:38] Penny Fuller: Well, you said I met you when I came to talk to your school.
[9:41] Steven Ferezy: Yeah, I was in a class called Vitoni Awards.
[9:45] Penny Fuller: And oh my god!
[9:47] Steven Ferezy: Yeah.
[9:48] Penny Fuller: That was the name of the class.
[9:50] Steven Ferezy: Amazing!
[9:51] Penny Fuller: Oh my god.
[9:52] Steven Ferezy: And uh we were at Cabaret Week, so you came in with John Benjamin Hickey.
[9:58] Penny Fuller: And was William Ivy Long there too?
[10:01] Steven Ferezy: Might have been.
[10:05] Penny Fuller: Yeah.
[10:06] Steven Ferezy: Uh talking about cabaret.
[10:08] Penny Fuller: It was a four-hour lecture class.
[10:10] Steven Ferezy: And cabaret the musical, not cabaret the art.
[10:10] Penny Fuller: The art.
[10:15] Steven Ferezy: Yes.
[10:16] Penny Fuller: Um, in which you were in the original production.
[10:19] Steven Ferezy: I was indeed.
[10:20] Penny Fuller: What did you pin in that?
[10:23] Steven Ferezy: What was your first impression of Dana?
[10:24] Penny Fuller: Yes, please.
[10:25] Steven Ferezy: And then I'll ask you this one.
[10:26] Penny Fuller: Oh, well, I thought she was a lot quieter than I thought you were gonna.
[10:30] Steven Ferezy: She was gonna be.
[10:32] Penny Fuller: People on the who listen to the street.
[10:33] Steven Ferezy: Then I found out too.
[10:35] Penny Fuller: People on the street.
[10:35] Steven Ferezy: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[10:36] Penny Fuller: I found out differently lately, but that's what I thought.
[10:40] Steven Ferezy: And she's tall.
[10:42] Penny Fuller: She's very tall, but I think she's very beautiful I do too I enjoy that yeah I really do I really do but you are tall how tall are you well I cheated today I had on my heels but I mean without your guy five seven well that's tall I'm five well I was five four and a half but now I'm five three and a half shrinking shrinking shrinking everybody's shrinking it's the 90s well during the assignment we don't usually say what our first impression was of the guest no can we start sure because that's very unfair for our guest I mean my first impression of Penny Fuller I must have been eight or nine years old listening to the original cast album of Applause oh my god and let's be real and then getting into my cabaret well and dig into the bottom of that whatever um and learning who every replacement was and every everything and her name came up there too and I started keeping track really hmm interesting I had a lot of friends not funny but interesting my first impression of you not in person was A New Brain oh my god my favorite show ever we'll talk about that okay but yeah I mean I knew Penny Fuller from that so really but you didn't know who I was before that that was my entry point for you and then I met you in person because you were one of Steven's besties.
[12:14] Penny Fuller: Yeah it was always nerve-wracking to meet a bestie.
[12:17] Steven Ferezy: Well, I'm glad I met you you.
[12:19] Penny Fuller: You're a bestie.
[12:20] Steven Ferezy: Yeah.
[12:21] Penny Fuller: And one of the other side.
[12:22] Steven Ferezy: I mean, one of the other, the younger bestie.
[12:26] Penny Fuller: Yes.
[12:26] Steven Ferezy: I want you to tell the story about.
[12:28] Penny Fuller: So you're in Cabaret and you're standing by for Jill Howard.
[12:32] Steven Ferezy: Mm-hmm.
[12:33] Penny Fuller: I want you to tell the story about your first time going on for her.
[12:38] Steven Ferezy: Oh wow.
[12:40] Penny Fuller: Jeez.
[12:41] Steven Ferezy: Well, first of all, a whole bunch of us auditioned for the origin for the to play.
[12:48] Penny Fuller: And if I'm, I mean, if I'm to believe what I was told, I was the top girl for a while, but one of the many people said, no, I don't like her.
[12:58] Steven Ferezy: So they kept looking.
[12:59] Penny Fuller: And then somebody said, no, I don't like that one.
[13:01] Steven Ferezy: And then other one said they don't like that one.
[13:02] Penny Fuller: So they were getting really desperate.
[13:04] Steven Ferezy: And somebody suggested Jill Hallworth, who had just been in the movie of Exodus.
[13:10] Penny Fuller: Is that right?
[13:12] Steven Ferezy: With Paul Newman?
[13:13] Penny Fuller: Yeah.
[13:14] Steven Ferezy: Some I can check my check here.
[13:17] Penny Fuller: Yeah, check your whatever.
[13:19] Steven Ferezy: Yeah.
[13:19] Penny Fuller: But I think that's what it is.
[13:20] Steven Ferezy: And Hal Prince was by this time.
[13:22] Penny Fuller: This I don't know if this is true, but here's what the word was.
[13:25] Steven Ferezy: He said, if she can sing a note, I want her.
[13:28] Penny Fuller: I can't go through this again with every three out of a seven one-you want and five out of, you know, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
[13:34] Steven Ferezy: So they hired her.
[13:35] Penny Fuller: And she said it's 1960.
[13:38] Steven Ferezy: She was British and tiny and kind of wonderful.
[13:43] Penny Fuller: Wonderful, sort of wacky kind of thing.
[13:45] Steven Ferezy: And so um, so they hired her.
[13:48] Penny Fuller: And then I guess I don't know.
[13:51] Steven Ferezy: They were out of town and she broke her leg or did something bad, so she was hobbling a lot and she was missing performances, and they had an understudy.
[14:00] Penny Fuller: And then um she wasn't getting good reviews, and they uh somehow they weren't able to help her.
[14:07] Steven Ferezy: They did give her a black wig, which interestingly enough, um was a kind of a thing that let her not she could hide and then she could come out more.
[14:20] Penny Fuller: It was interesting. I mean, some people when they gave me the wig, I just disappeared, so that I had to wear it once. But um, for her, it allowed her to come out more. Anyway, so she opened, and I don't want to repeat the review because Bruce Weber wrote repeated this review in his obituary of her because she died sadly a couple of years ago. It was a terrible review, and he repeated it. Oh god. But he did say, however, Joel Gray later said that she got better and was really quite talented or something like that. But Walter Kerr, who was you know a really good critic and not a mean bitchy critic, wrote terrible things about her because I went with my then boyfriend to get the paper that did the thing when the thing came by, and I read it, and even though I didn't get the part, I cried for how bad, how cruel that review was from of all people, Walter Kerr, who was not a cruel guy.
So, and then whatever that did to her psyche and the leg and the thing, and then she didn't know how to use her voice really, and blah blah blah blah. So finally they thought we've got to get a standby, not just an understudy. A standby is somebody who is not in the show. An understudy is somebody who's in the show, like a chorus girl who can cover at a minute's notice or something. The standby is theoretically a higher class thing to do because in those days you didn't have to be at the theater. You could say hi to the stage manager, it's Penny. I'll be home tonight. And the next day I say, Hi, it's Penny. I'm gonna be at the court theater, I'll be in seat A53 on the left-hand side. You could do all those things.
And you didn't have to be there once you checked in to make sure she was in. Yeah, that was the old that was the. You had to let them know because God knows what was gonna happen. Wow. So I started rehearsing. I had my first rehearsal, and then I had my second rehearsal, then I had my third rehearsal, and then I had my fourth rehearsal. And in those things were the trying to learn this Kit Kat Club dance, which was really hard. So after my fourth rehearsal, where I could not drink the prairie oyster. You know what a prairie oyster is? It's a raw egg with Worcestershire sauce. And she has to do it. But I couldn't do it. So later on, when I was playing it a lot, we did chocolate sauce and orange juice because I couldn't do it.
I couldn't do it. So anyway, I had my rehearsal, and then I went over to the Russian tea room to have a couple of Moscow mules to celebrate the fact that I had this job and everything. And I got a little too many Moscow mules, and I stumbled home, and I went to bed, and I woke up the next morning with a phone ringing saying, Penny, it's Jim, you're the stage manager, you're on at the matinee. Now I'd had four rehearsals, and I was hungover. But I somehow I got through it. I've all I've had these things happen to me so many times. And I remember they dressed me all up, and the wonderful dresser was named Rose, and she was taking care of me, and Lottie Lanya was next door, and she was taking care of me, and they were dressing me and you know, patting me and kissing me and everything.
And they sent me on, and my first entrance is on this rolling bar that comes on. And Joel Gray was over in the corner getting ready to come on as the weird master of ceremonies, and I'm on the bar and it's going like those rides at the theme park thing. And there's silver ribbons for a curtain, and it's so grotesque, I can't believe it. And I had just asked the conductor, do I sing or do you point to me? I mean, that's how bad it was. So and I get there and I put my hands, I come through the and I was even I could tell you I was amazing that I got through it and I did it well. I did it well. And I had had a funny thing with Hal Prince because he called me and he said, We want you to stand by.
We were in Joel Gray's dressing room. He said, I want you to stand by. I said, Great. And he said, and I'll give you $300 a week plus $50 every time you go on to stop at $500. And I said, because I was young, no. He said, What? I said no. I said, I'll go on. Give me $500 a week, and I'll go on for nothing. You know, I just get $500 a week. And he said, No, that won't do. He said, I'll tell you what we'll do. We'll give you $300 a week and $50 a performance with no stop clause. So you could possibly make $1,100 a week, which in those days was a lot of money. And I went on over a hundred times. Not a girl. So I got through that first one. I did, I did. Which brings it back to what we were talking about before.
When you are at your wits and exhausted, and quite possibly a brilliant performance can be done. Yeah, because nothing's in the way. Nothing's in the way. And God has adrenaline. Yes. But I finally I went on so many times, they made me learn the fruit shop dance, which was really hard. And you had to do, I don't know if you understand, but there's the orchestra pit in front of you, and the guy is looking at you, you had to come up and do an assembly. He would pick you up and lift you over the orchestra pit, sort of, and you'd end on his shoulders and he'd turn around. And I thought, I'll never be able to do this. And the day, the first day I went on, which was later on, in the fruit shop dance, because I would watch it in the early days of my performances.
The stage manager went out and he came back out and he said, My eyes, tears were rolling down my eyes. I was so proud of you because I could see this look of terror as he swung you around. Yeah. The magic of the theatre. Yes, indeed. Moving on from cabaret, you received your first Tony Award nomination for your portrayal of Eve in the original company of Applause. That is correct. We have an applause question from a loyal listener. Oh. I mean, obviously, they want to know about working with Lauren Bacall, but also more specifically, if you have any opinions about the Creative's team decision to adapt the story of All About Eve to be so current for the 70s that it was instantly dated the second it was over.
Well, I you know, in a way it was dated anyway, but it's classic. I mean, you don't need to update it because it's a classic story, it's like a Greek drama with the perennial characters, you know, that you would say the good guy, the bad guy, the whatever that's what it was. And and and when it was done, it was in the 50s, wasn't it? The movie and the 50s. The movie was 1950. Yeah. So I don't I I don't but I guess with the dress and the sound of the music is all very stylized for the 70s, which I think is why it hasn't been revived. I don't know. I think it maybe hasn't been revived because there's never been a star like Lauren Bacall to play Eve. Now, yes, she's not a singer, but she was a great movie star, a legendary movie star who came on and did it.
Who do you know? I mean, Eleanor Parker did it on tour, Arlene Dahl did it on tour, and let's see, who else did? Dan Baxter was well, that's different because Ann Baxter was the original Eve, which was the character I played. And Ann Baxter was a legit actress who could sing, but she was an actress, and it was a play about the theater, a musical about the theater. And I had auditioned for it, and I didn't get it. And so, well, at when I left I was living in California when they gave me, they gave me the script and said, go home to California and we'll let you know. And I read it and thought, oh my God, don't let me get it, because I don't have the nerve to turn it down. It's terrible. So I didn't get it.
So that was fine. And they were doing they I at that point I was doing a television comedy pilot that was written for me. And I had my own parking space at Paramount. Now you have to understand that I'm a serious actress who's interested in Shakespeare and Shaw. Well, not so much Shaw, but Chekhov and you know the Greeks and Shakespeare. I said that. So that, you know, theoretically, Hollywood, I was just out there to get some attention so I could come back and not be the standby, but be the get the first one. Oh, I draw I had my own parking space at Paramount with my name on it. And they said, Miss Fuller, we want to get a sample of your hair because we're fixing the rugs in the apartment and we want to get it to go well.
And even I, who care nothing about it and was impressed by that. I thought, oh my God. So we shoot the pilots all over, and I'm at O'Ray's beauty salon on Santa Monica Boulevard, right across from the Santa Palm car wash. Got the picture, and my head is in the sink, and they're washing my hair, and they say, Your manager's on the telephone, and they bring me the thing, and they say, uh, he says, uh, they want you to come to Baltimore, Maryland, and uh look at Applause. They could decide to fire the gal who did it, who's doing it. And I said, Oh, really? When? They said, tonight. Okay, so I get on the plane and I go and I say to the people, I say, for sure, make sure, because I'm gonna see the Saturday matinee, make or no, the Saturday evening.
They said, I said, make sure that I'm not close to the stage because those gypsies will see me, and with my reputation of being the cabaret and the boyfoot in the park, the takeover over person, they'll know. I said, Don't be silly. You can say you're here to see your aunt. I said, Listen to me, and they didn't. And Jean Foote, who's one of the famous dancers of that era, comes on, does a pirouette and goes, ah, Penny Fuller was in the audience. So they it spread around. So the next day I go to meet Bacall. Oh, first of all, and it's not that I'm that smart, but I could see why they were having a problem, and that's because my predecessor, Diane McAfee, a wonderful talented performer, but very young.
And it was not in the best interest of the story to have the person who's grasping after Lauren Bacall's part and stuff to be such a young girl because you didn't quite believe she was too old, Bacall was too old, and so forth. So with me, yes, I was younger, but there was I played her as a woman, and this was her last shot before she was too late for her to do anything. Whereas Diane was still a young girl. And I was like an old girl, you know. So um, so I kind of understood exactly what was needed because I saw it. I saw that that was the problem. And um, so the next day they had me meet Bacall, and I remember thinking before I went in, I thought, let her know, God, that if I'm good, it will help her.
And she looked me straight in the eye, and I looked at her, and she was very kind to me. And when we started rehearsal, well, that's later on, but at one point later in the rehearsal, she just was thrilled. She said, Finally, I've got an actress to work with, which is nothing against Diane. It really had to do with the aesthetic weight. It really did. She was too young to be a threat to Lauren Bacall. And I could balance the thing between being still a young woman, but also with the power. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So, yeah. So I opened, I had a music rehearsal Monday. Tuesday, I had rehearsal with the understudies, Wednesday. Diane and I both learned a new dance that was in the bar that they went to, which I didn't notice until four days later later, was a gay bar because I didn't have time to look around and see who was there.
And then Thursday I had a rehearsal with the real people, the real Lauren Bacall, and I had orchestra, lights, everything. And Larry Casher, the wonderful producer, came over and said, and I'm sitting on the side of the stage just getting ready for my big rehearsal with the whole world looking at me. And he brought me a tuna sandwich, and I remember thinking, this is classier than having a parking spot at Paramount. Yeah. To have the producer of a Broadway musical bring you a tuna sandwich before you have your full rehearsal. Wow. So, yeah, they wanted me to go on the road, and I said, No, I can't. I can't do it anymore. It was a very dark part.
[28:25] Penny Fuller: It was not easy to do. I don't had to get slapped every night. No, I slapped. No, he slapped me. Yeah. Slapped me and always missed. And I was it was hard because it was always going in this. I'm gonna beat you kind of mood. And that's hard to do day after day after day. It's easier with a musical. Musical helps.
[28:43] Steven Ferezy: How so?
[28:48] Penny Fuller: Well, just because the music carries you. If you're feeling like I can't do this, and they go bum bum bum bum bum bum bum bum bum bum bum bum? It kind of gets you going, even if you're not wanting to.
[29:07] Steven Ferezy: Did Lauren Bacall hang? Did she hang out? Did you hang out?
[29:11] Penny Fuller: She we did. She and Leroy Reims, who played the hairdresser, the first really important gay part in a straight play or a straight. I would love to play that part.
[29:23] Steven Ferezy: Yeah, you'd be great.
[29:25] Penny Fuller: And I remember when I went to see her years later in Hollywood in Sweet Bird of Youth, and we went, I went back to see her, and we got in the car to go home, and she said, here we are again. Two gorgeous broads in the back of a limousine going home alone. And I said, What is it we're doing wrong, Betty? What are we doing wrong?
[29:46] Steven Ferezy: Betty.
[29:47] Penny Fuller: Yeah.
[29:48] Steven Ferezy: Betty McCall.
[29:49] Penny Fuller: Betty Persky.
[29:50] Steven Ferezy: Oh.
[29:50] Penny Fuller: That was her name, Betty Persky. Do you know? Have you ever heard this story? She told me this story. When she was very young in those Howard Hawkes movies, if you remember how she kind of had the look just above, like looking through. Do you know why?
[30:09] Steven Ferezy: Um, I've heard the story why, and I can't remember.
[30:12] Penny Fuller: She was so terrified because she was grabbed out of a modeling school or something and thrown into movies with people like Humphrey Bogart, whom she later married, that her chin would shake, and Howard Hawke said, just put your chin down, that'll stop it from shaking. And that's how the look came out.
[30:30] Steven Ferezy: I didn't know that.
[30:31] Penny Fuller: Icon I great. Oh, I love that. Isn't that fabulous? I heard that on the Lauren Bacall episode of You Must Remember This podcast.
[30:39] Steven Ferezy: Oh.
[30:39] Penny Fuller: Yeah. They went through it.
[30:42] Steven Ferezy: Got it.
[30:43] Penny Fuller: You can catch Penny Fuller and Lauren Bacall in applause. I believe it's all on YouTube. It was they did a made-for-television production of the musical.
[30:55] Steven Ferezy: And it's all on YouTube.
[30:57] Penny Fuller: And you can see Penny Fuller.
[30:58] Steven Ferezy: See, I didn't know that.
[30:59] Penny Fuller: Somebody I met wants to see it.
[31:01] Steven Ferezy: You're online.
[31:03] Penny Fuller: Oh my God. You can see Penny Fuller dancing with Lauren Bacall.
[31:07] Steven Ferezy: And isn't she wearing your jacket by mistake?
[31:09] Penny Fuller: Oh, yes, in the television we started. Uh, what's his name? Uh, the designer?
[31:13] Steven Ferezy: Uh Bob Ackie.
[31:16] Penny Fuller: No, no, no, no. Well, you might long.
[31:19] Steven Ferezy: No, no, the the design, the clothing designer.
[31:22] Penny Fuller: Begins with H.
[31:23] Steven Ferezy: Halston.
[31:24] Penny Fuller: Halston. Correct. Halston was doing the costumes for the television. And everything stopped on the first day while he came in in a in uh in a cape and walked through the set of the kids and went to press Miss Bacall's dress for the first shot, which was in the gay bar. And uh so we did the thing and we did the thing and we get going, and like two weeks later, I'm still waiting around to do another scene. And I thought, oh, I haven't done that scene where I have to wear her dress. I should see if it's okay. And I got it out and I put it on the jacket and the strings, it had fringe, and the fringe was way below my fingernails. And I thought, that's so funny. I remember that woman cutting my cutting the fringe off my and I went to Bacole's dressing room and I looked, and her jacket said Penny Fuller. She had worn my jacket in the very first scene of the musical. And if you look, she's got like three-quarter sleeves.
[32:34] Steven Ferezy: Wardrobe malfunction.
[32:36] Penny Fuller: Yes. I love shit like that.
[32:40] Steven Ferezy: Yeah.
[32:40] Penny Fuller: I like hearing that she's cool.
[32:43] Steven Ferezy: She is cool.
[32:44] Penny Fuller: People have had a hard time with her. You know, but I want to say, if you use your brain, you think of a 13, 18-year-old girl who was a model who becomes a movie star. And then and with the one of the great men of all of our lives, Humphrey Bogart. And then he dies. She has three children. Jesus. I mean, and she's in that um in that position. Uh and so, and then she later marries Jason Rosebart and has another kid. But the point is, yeah, the point is that she went from being nobody to be somebody really extra a big somebody, not just her own work, but just in the so she she I always thought she was terrified. And so the bark was to cover up her terror. And she could be really mean, and she could particularly be mean if you were stupid and got and didn't and was, you know.
[33:47] Steven Ferezy: She did a series of, I guess it must have been the early 80s. She did a series of high point coffee commercials.
[33:56] Penny Fuller: I take it by the look in your eye, you've never seen them.
[33:58] Steven Ferezy: No.
[33:59] Penny Fuller: I wasn't born.
[34:01] Steven Ferezy: Right.
[34:02] Penny Fuller: I forget.
[34:03] Steven Ferezy: Uh they were just extraordinary. First of all, commercials were so different then than they are now. But also, I mean, they would turn you on about this decaffeinated coffee. You think coffee and sleep don't mix. They do if it's high time. Talk about, I mean, didn't Elizabeth Ashley do one for was it Weight Watchers or Slim Fast?
[34:30] Penny Fuller: Slim Fast.
[34:31] Steven Ferezy: And it's just so sexual.
[34:33] Penny Fuller: Wow. She made she made me want to lose weight immediately by Slim Fast.
[34:40] Steven Ferezy: Speaking of Elizabeth Ashley, was Barefoot in the Park your debut, or had you done a Broadway show before?
[34:46] Penny Fuller: No, no.
[34:47] Steven Ferezy: It was your debut.
[34:48] Penny Fuller: Yeah. Replacing Elizabeth Ashley and Barefoot in the Firefox.
[34:52] Steven Ferezy: Yeah, I was her standby first.
[34:54] Penny Fuller: And the first time I went on with that was after four work. I'd been over the third act twice. It was still on print typed, hand typed onion pages. You know, onion skin. What do you call that?
[35:05] Steven Ferezy: Onion skin type.
[35:07] Penny Fuller: Now we call it carbon copy.
[35:08] Steven Ferezy: Yeah, well, like Bible pages?
[35:10] Penny Fuller: Yeah, kind of. And so we were rehearsing, and I was rehearsing from that book. And this was the first night, because I'd been with it two weeks now. And I, if this was the first night I was going to be allowed to leave my number and say, I'm so and so. And I get there, and she's had a back spasm thing. And they said, I think you have to go on. And I said, Here's a dime. That lets you know how long ago that was. Here's a dime. Call my boyfriend and ask him to bring my sneakers because her sneakers are too big for me. And I went in. I mean, this calm took over me. And she's writhing on the couch in pain and worried about me. And I'm worried about her writhing out, writhing in the paint in the on the couch in pain.
So it was kind of good. And they got me all in the thing, and she talked me through it, and she was so good to me and so sweet. And I said, I don't have a wedding ring. She can bring my old one from Jimmy Ferrentino. So I wore Jimmy Ferentino's wedding ring. And they put this big white sheepskin coat on me. That when they put it on me, I thought it was going to pass out. It was so heavy, I was stumbling. And then they handed me the big purse, the tote purse, and the tin can that had and a no, no, tulips in my hand. And I heard them say, ladies and gentlemen, tonight the part that played by Elizabeth Ashley will be played by Pennyville.
[36:39] Steven Ferezy: Oh, they all said in the audience.
[36:42] Penny Fuller: And I thought, and they say, okay, and I go in and I close the door and I'm out of breath because I've climbed up the four steps, four flights of stairs, and then I go and I I put the put the water in the can and I put the in the paint can that's around and I put the flowers in the paint can I sit that down and and I looked I thought I have no idea what's next and this is 30 seconds into the show what am I gonna do and I said I think I'll go sit over there and just sit down on that stair and cry and everybody will understand and as I went over there I saw the suitcase that was there and I and I knew exactly what was next I opened the suitcase there were logs in there I wouldn't put them over in the little pot bellied stove and I never forgot another thing the whole night long and Mildred Natwick and and Bob Redford were coming on with stark terror in their eyes not knowing what was going to meet them and I kept saying it's I trying to say it's all right it's all right I'm all right I know I don't do I know I know and then Bob Radford kissed me and I still knew what I was doing and you became a woman and I became a woman yes was that his first Broadway show no and last he and no he and Liz were in something called tall story something like that they were both in it I think um and she was I know I know she was in take her she's mine I can't remember it's just so long uh talk about was was that were they big movie stars at that point or was this before this was before that this was before all of that and in those days that's how they got to be movie stars.
[38:30] Penny Fuller: You see, it was not the movie stars came to do the plays, it was the young people who were discovered and went to do movies.
[38:38] Steven Ferezy: Yeah, now it's backwards.
[38:38] Penny Fuller: Yeah those were the days.
[38:43] Steven Ferezy: Days.
[38:44] Penny Fuller: Days.
[38:46] Steven Ferezy: Days.
[38:49] Penny Fuller: Um I this timeline is so non-linear, but I want to jump ahead to many years later, you do you're living in LA and you do Elephant Man.
[39:03] Steven Ferezy: TV?
[39:03] Penny Fuller: No.
[39:04] Steven Ferezy: Wait a minute, is that what I did?
[39:06] Penny Fuller: Yes.
[39:07] Steven Ferezy: Yes, yeah.
[39:08] Penny Fuller: TV, but also the road company.
[39:09] Steven Ferezy: Cook Road Company, yeah.
[39:11] Penny Fuller: I was just divorced. I flew to meet Philip Anglem, who was gonna be taking it on the road, and I went up to his dressing room area, and we were supposed to have this meeting, and he said, at one point he said, Do you drink? And I thought, oh my God, what am I supposed to say? I mean, I'm not a drinker, but yeah, I drink. But I mean, is that gonna squeer the job? And I I said, Yes, um, he said, Oh, thank God. Because he had ideas of being cut all over the country with nobody to hang out with and drink after the show. And he and Ken Ruda taught me how to drink gin martinis.
[39:48] Steven Ferezy: I've never had one.
[39:52] Penny Fuller: I'm gonna keep that in. There might be another one, I can't tell.
[39:57] Steven Ferezy: So you were on the road with two two dudes drinking gin martinis.
[40:02] Penny Fuller: Yeah. Uh this was uh the elephant man. I was playing Carol Shelley's part, or we shared the part, or however you want to say it. And we had a first class tour, and I had my I was just divorced, and I had a two-year-old child with me. And we went all over the country.
[40:19] Steven Ferezy: That two-year-old child provided the microphone that we used for this podcast.
[40:24] Penny Fuller: Yes, I see, it's very pretty.
[40:26] Steven Ferezy: Thank you, Heather.
[40:27] Penny Fuller: Why didn't you give it to me?
[40:30] Steven Ferezy: That'll be fun.
[40:31] Penny Fuller: Okay. So you do the Road Company, and then American Playhouse wants to do it for television.
[40:38] Steven Ferezy: It wasn't American Playhouse.
[40:40] Penny Fuller: Wasn't it?
[40:40] Steven Ferezy: Oh, yes.
[40:41] Penny Fuller: It was Shelley DeVoe.
[40:42] Steven Ferezy: No, no, it was channel ABC.
[40:45] Penny Fuller: And that, and we shot it in Toronto.
[40:49] Steven Ferezy: Toronto.
[40:50] Penny Fuller: Yeah. For which you were nominated and won an Emmy Award.
[40:56] Steven Ferezy: I did indeed.
[40:58] Penny Fuller: I did not expect it. You can watch that acceptance speech on YouTube as well.
[41:02] Steven Ferezy: Who are you up against?
[41:04] Penny Fuller: Let's drop some names on it.
[41:05] Steven Ferezy: I think that's a good one.
[41:07] Penny Fuller: I was on Claire Bloom.
[41:09] Steven Ferezy: Okay.
[41:10] Penny Fuller: I bet it's on the clip.
[41:11] Steven Ferezy: It's on Wikipedia, definitely.
[41:13] Penny Fuller: Wikib uh see, who else was it?
[41:15] Steven Ferezy: You're a best uh supporting actress in a limited series.
[41:19] Penny Fuller: Is that what it was?
[41:20] Steven Ferezy: Or leading actress in a no, it's best supporting actress.
[41:24] Penny Fuller: Oh, it starts with the winner, but there's pictures of everybody.
[41:28] Steven Ferezy: So there's Penny with her red hair.
[41:30] Penny Fuller: Yes.
[41:31] Steven Ferezy: I don't recognize anyone.
[41:33] Penny Fuller: That is um Lawrence.
[41:34] Steven Ferezy: Vicky Lawrence.
[41:36] Penny Fuller: Uh-huh.
[41:37] Steven Ferezy: I can't tell who that is.
[41:39] Penny Fuller: Let me see.
[41:40] Steven Ferezy: They're awful.
[41:41] Penny Fuller: Rooney Mara.
[41:43] Steven Ferezy: No.
[41:44] Penny Fuller: You know who else?
[41:45] Steven Ferezy: That's Claire, Claire Bloom.
[41:48] Penny Fuller: Oh, there I am.
[41:50] Steven Ferezy: Vicky, that person you said.
[41:52] Penny Fuller: And who's that?
[41:53] Steven Ferezy: Judy Davis.
[41:54] Penny Fuller: Judy Davis?
[41:56] Steven Ferezy: I beat Judy Davis?
[41:58] Penny Fuller: Get it, girl!
[41:59] Steven Ferezy: Oh my god!
[42:03] Penny Fuller: Oh my god, I think she's the best actress I've remarkable.
[42:08] Steven Ferezy: I don't remember that.
[42:09] Penny Fuller: Because I mean, I don't remember that. The only thing I remember about the O'Toni Awards is that they had Emmy, Emmy, Emmy Awards, is they had Kate Smith.
[42:19] Penny Fuller: They rolled her in. Do you know who Kate Smith is?
[42:22] Steven Ferezy: They rolled her in on a wheelchair, and everybody stood up.
[42:27] Penny Fuller: And when I was a little girl, I learned to sing God Bless America.
[42:32] Penny Fuller: And my mother, who died in 1975, so she wasn't there to see me get this award. My mother used to love the way I misdid the words wrong, and she never corrected me. And it would be from the mountains to the fraies. Now I don't The Frerezies? The Fraires. Not the Fraires. The Fraies. So while she was there, everybody in the audience sang God Bless America for Kate, and I sang as loud as I could to my mother up in heaven or wherever she is. From the mountains to the Fairies. Because can you imagine having to win an award and your doting loving mother that I had such a great relationship wasn't there, is it? So in some funny way, the Frarries made her there. That's amazing. Isn't that silly and fun?
Around that time though, you did do a lot of plays for television, like Hat on a Hutton Roof. That was later. That was later. Mm-hmm. Produced by partially by Liz Ashley. Didn't know that. Well, I don't know that it was like in freaking out right now. Jason Powell. Jason Powell, who's that? Oh, the one who's oh I see. Oh, I see. Well, I'm not sure that it was what her title was, but of course she was left or some verb like that, the rights by Tennessee. Williams, everyone. Tennessee Williams. Yeah. Not instant. Not Tennessee, not Tennessee Smith. Did you do the audiobook of the John Lahr book on Tennessee Williams? That's a list of Ashley reading it. Yes. I know what I'm doing this weekend. Yep.
And do you know something else? Well, you won't want to put this on here, but I won't remember if I don't tell you. Okay. Pretty soon is opening at the Morgan Library, a whole thing on Tennessee Williams. Yeah. Oh see. Looks really good. Anyway, um what was I saying? There was something good. Cat on a hot tin roof. Oh, so Liz was supposed to do it. Liz was supposed to do it, and then by the time she got around to it, she was too old. So she so this Cat on a Hot Tin Roof was directed by Jack Hofsess, who directed The Elephant Man. And I played Sister Woman, and Kim Stanley played Big Mama, Rip Torn played Big Daddy. Rip Torn. Tommy Lee Jones played Brick. Jessica Lang played Maggie and David David Duke married uh played Gooper.
And I played and yeah. That was 1984, ladies and gentlemen. Yes, what cast, Rip Torn, secondly Kim Stanley. Kim Stanley. Excuse me, Kim Stanley. You're excused. Yeah. Jesus. Look at this list of names. Yeah. In the last however many minutes. It's just truth. That you've got to just be in the room with. I know. Okay, so I'm it's the first day of rehearsal, and I get a call from Heather School, my daughter. She's what was this? 84, you said, so she's seven. And they call and they say, We she fell and hurt and cut herself, and we've got her at the hospital. She's okay. And I hang up the phone, and I think, I don't know what to do. I mean, I'm in Silver Lake and get to Santa Monica. That's, I mean, I miss rehearsal, and you're not supposed to miss rehearsal.
I remember reading that in the Stanislavski book. And I'm thinking, what shall I do? And how um Rip Torn said, You get in that car and you go and you look after your baby. Don't you worry about this. I'll never forget it. It was so great. And see. Rip was anything but torn. Rip was anything but broken. But then he was kind of crazy later. And I was the can I was the kind of the cheerleader of all of the people, and I'd play games and make Tommy Lee and Jessica laugh because it was tension-filled at that point. And Rip was being somewhat difficult. And there was a kid, he had a scene with a kid, and it had to be done by six o'clock because it was Labor Day weekend. I think it was Labor Day, some three-day weekend.
And if it wasn't fit fit done by the five o'clock or whatever I said, it wouldn't be done until Tuesday, and they'd have to pay us. And uh Rip was being difficult, but finally they got it. But I was being the cheerleader backstage. And I always had sort of the one of the visions that I always wanted to do, which was to play Blanche Dubois to Tommy Lee Jones's Stanley. Because that's a Southern boy who there's no reason why Stanley can't be Polish and Southern. He is Southern, I mean he's in New Orleans. And that Southern boy, I mean that's that kind of a Stanley would have been interesting. And what was really good about this show, if we if you if particularly if you know about Southern behavior in men, the the scenes between Big Daddy and Brick were fabulous.
Be not because of anything they did but because of what they brought with them from who they were where they came from. It was wonderful. You're so damn smart father. Well I'm smart why nobody today would ever say that about anything. Oh I'm just old I'm not smart. Okay so you've been in the business uh uh not just theater uh movies uh television few movies not a few movies you're all you're a lady of the theater she did a movie with Bette Davis that was a TV movie still a movie to T DV right now with Betty Gibbs with Betty Gibbs who has transformed the most have having worked with them and then like seeing their career that's not who you were when we were paling around boy I can't I mean you say you've known Robert Redford since before all of the movie stuff so that's where that question comes from he was always one of like my daughter one of the funniest people I've ever known because it's dry and undercut and not and witty, not but um.
He was always funny. We he and his then wife, and they had two children then. We'd go up to his house on Sundays and play charades. I mean, he's just a great guy. Is he a goofy? He's a goofball, but but it no, not in goofy, not in goofy ways. He's sharp, goofy. And just uh, he's everything you'd want him to be. You know, your hero, just like my latest hero, Jake Gyllenhaal is everybody, everything. And Redford, I once went a friend of ours and I went out to visit him in Utah, and it was the weekend when his then wife Lola, who was from Utah, Provo, Provo and all that, and they they were having a meeting in town, or no, I guess they came to the house, and they were deciding what to do because Bob had bought this land and they were going to make it into something called they were working on the name of it uh that that night, and they picked Sundance, and that's when they could.
And he that's the last time I rode a horse too. We went riding all afternoon. I came back, I could not move. And he said, get out, get off the horse. I said, I can't, and got me off the horse, and he threw me in the shower and he said, and just stay in there for about an hour. So you know, I finally was able to walk the next day. But he and Lola were just we had such a good time, and it was right about that time that Lola had taken a phone call. That was his then wife, and the mother of his children, um, and the you know, the hangout when we would do the showades and everything. But um, she got a phone call, and this guy said, Uh, this is Paul Newman. Can I speak to her? She said, Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
He said, No, I mean, this is Paul Newman. I'd like to speak to Redford about this movie called Butch Cassidy, and she said, Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. She didn't think it was Paul Newman, and it was Paul Newman calling Bob to say would he be interested in doing Butch Cassidy and the Sunday kid. Good God. Wonderful guys, wonderful, really great guys. Um, you just mentioned Jake Gyllenhaal, who you met in your last Broadway venture, Sunday in the park with George here in New York, which is about this time last year. I'm realizing. Oh my god, it's early February. Right. So you, I mean, I remember you, I was in LA because you were doing a play in LA, and I happened to be in LA. So we saw it, and I was driving to the airport, and he called me.
He said, They want me to play the old lady. And I lost my mind. And he said, Don't get too excited, I can't do it. So, why the hell am I? He said, Well, I'm still out here doing this show, and they start rehearsals on Tuesday. I said, Penny, it's the old lady, they're gonna let you start a week late. You're like, Well, I'm trying, but don't get your hopes up. Fine, fly back to New York, get a phone call the next day, they're gonna let me do it. So the brain was closed because I remember a lot of the boat put that into the universe. Yeah. Decades ago. All both decades. Oh god, it was it's interesting though, but I it's uh was one of the greatest experiences because I was so excited, and then it didn't look like I could do it because I was doing my play, and I knew I had grown up because I said, Well, I got the shot at it, and I'm fine.
And I thought, you're a grown-up now. You're not gonna say, Oh, it's not fair. I and it was so great. It was great. I loved it. Maturity is lovely. But then you got to do it. You can then I got it. I came back on Monday. I went Tuesday, I went to the costume fitting, then I went to the rehearsal. I watched Tuesday and Wednesday, Thursday I walked through it, Friday I walked through it, Saturday. We had the orchestra rehearsal, and the um, and uh we went into tech on Tuesday. I think I had finally learned that song. What's that song? It's hot up here. Uh-huh. I think I'd learned that by the last performance. You did. I did, because I used to just mouth it because I couldn't learn at all. And nobody had time to teach it to me.
So I'd listen to the record and stuff and try to hear where my lines were. Listening to Drivel. Yes, right. That's it. That was one of the greatest moments of Stephen's life because we saw it the same night. We went to the dress together, but not together. You were randomly there, I was randomly there, and we sat together randomly. Well, on purpose at that point. Yeah. But we didn't wake up that morning, no. He was just like clutching anything he could like touch, tears streaming down his face. It was it was quite amazing. I was glorious. I was quite glorious. And then I saw it four more times. Well, Stephen, I have to say, you are a devotee. Oh, that rhymes. Stephen, I have to say, you are a devotee.
But um it was a wonderful production. It really was. It wasn't just you, and it wasn't just me because I was in it. It was an extraordinary thing. And I could hear the kids who had come to see paid all that money to see Jake, Jill and Hall screaming when he came on and he started. And as the show went on, you could still hear them, but you could hear their screams more thoughtful and more deep, and they got the story at the same time as they were worshiping at this shrine of one of their heroes. And he's another one. I mean, he's a serious, like Redford, a serious man about his work. Liz Ashley is serious about her work. It's amazing the people that are and the people that aren't. Oh, I just remembering that production now.
As I drink out of the Oh, you've got the glass. The closing night champagne flute. Flute. But see, I didn't have time to buy opening night presents because I only had one day or something. So I got closing night presents. You were a hot ticket. And I the ticket, the the glass. That says Sunday in the park with George, and and then the person's name in the company. So this one says and Penny, because I made her get one for herself. And then it has the opening date, February 23rd, 2017 to April 23rd, 2017. Love Penny. Was it really? Yeah. You were there. I was there. You were? Did I see her? She was catering the party. Oh, that's right. That's right. Oh, that was like an opening night. Opening night.
Correct. It was at the New York Public Live. That was like press step and reviews. Yes, yeah. Oh, I had to wear a little black dress. I think I remember seeing her. And made uh loyal listeners, Johnny and Scotty, go shoe shopping with me. Absolutely. I put my suit on. And you took my daughter. I took your daughter. We had a hotel room next door because they were giving the cast good rates because they shared a building. Um landed. I guess the curtain was set for 6:30. Her plane landed maybe at four in Newark.
[56:44] Penny Fuller: So I say go to the hotel. I'll buy a hotel room right next door to the theater, so she could. She got ready. We ordered diner food. We went next door. Trians. After the show, we went back upstairs real quick to drop our playbills and take a shot. And uh we went back downstairs, found you, walked our—you looked fat.
[57:09] Steven Ferezy: Oh cute.
[57:13] Penny Fuller: It's all coming back to me. Yep. Yeah. Oh good. Yep. Yep. That was a fun. That was quite a night. That was definitely, I think one of the top three highlights of 2017 for me.
[57:25] Steven Ferezy: 2017 was a lot.
[57:26] Penny Fuller: I was gonna say. I would say it's one of the highlights of my life because not only is it that show, but my daughter was there, a grown-up daughter instead of a little girl. Come and see your mommy, and she wouldn't know what she was seeing. You were there, and it was the kind of thing that I—my training back 150 years ago when theater, even musical theater, was more serious. And it's you know, uh that show particularly, it's a wonderful show. But it's also a dynamic piece of theater. And the kind of theater that I was taught to want to do. And uh it was a stripped down version. Yeah. But it was—it was great. Really wonderful.
[58:17] Penny Fuller: On the opening night, I was sitting in the same row as Steven Sondheim.
[58:21] Steven Ferezy: Really?
[58:22] Penny Fuller: And you know, I'd obviously I'd seen the invited dress, so I kind of allowed myself to peek at him once in a while to see what that was. And to watch him watch you sing "Beautiful" was something I'll never forget.
[58:38] Steven Ferezy: You never told me that.
[58:40] Penny Fuller: I didn't?
[58:41] Steven Ferezy: No.
[58:42] Penny Fuller: Oh yeah. Really? Oh yeah. It was the one time I didn't really watch you sing that. I watched him watch you sing that. And he just said he was so focused. And then he did this uh oh Georgie, how I long for the old view. And you just see him do his signature wide clap.
[59:05] Steven Ferezy: Wow!
[59:06] Penny Fuller: Full wingspan on time. I'm sweating thinking about it forever in my brain.
[59:13] Steven Ferezy: Yeah, that's great. I told you that other story, which I'm not gonna tell on the air.
[59:18] Penny Fuller: Right.
[59:18] Steven Ferezy: But remind me him.
[59:19] Penny Fuller: I will. Um, I can talk about your career forever, but we have other segments. I want to talk about the space that we're in.
[59:24] Steven Ferezy: Sure.
[59:27] Penny Fuller: The room that we are in.
[59:28] Steven Ferezy: Sure.
[59:29] Penny Fuller: It's Penny Fuller's apartment on the Upper West Side. The most glorious apartment I've ever been in.
[59:34] Steven Ferezy: It's oh, it's a little bit more. Not because it's the fanciest apartment I've ever been in, and not because it's the largest, not because of anything other than it is when you see the right person living in the right home.
[59:45] Penny Fuller: Oh, yes.
[59:46] Steven Ferezy: Yeah, which really loves it. Everything seems important. And I think that's a good idea.
[59:51] Penny Fuller: Everything has a story for that.
[59:52] Steven Ferezy: Everything has a story. I want you to tell some stories about what are your favorite—point out something.
[59:56] Penny Fuller: Here, I'll go get my favorite one.
[59:58] Steven Ferezy: Okay.
[59:59] Penny Fuller: Okay, what is it? Everything looks like a freaking treasure.
[1:00:03] Penny Fuller: Well, it all has—what's that? You would open up the treasure chest. Here we go. Okay, well, this is a silver apple from Tiffany. When Anne Baxter came into the show of "Applause," I bought her an open night present of this little silver apple from Tiffany. Apple Eve, you get it. Apple Eve. And I had printed, uh, uh, uh, engraved on it, "Goodbye, Eve. Hello, Margot," because she had played Eve in the movie and was now playing Margot, and I said, uh, "Love, A.B. from P.F." And when I left the show, she was still doing it, and she bought me the same, another little apple, and it says, "Goodbye, Eve. Hooray, Penny. Love, A.B." She was a great broad too, in a different way, in a different way. She was fabulous. They were both those women where they just don't make people like that anymore. People aren't like that anymore.
[1:01:08] Steven Ferezy: Will you tell that story I love so much about rehearsing the scene with the dress?
[1:01:12] Penny Fuller: Oh, right. Well, on my opening night, a friend of mine had given me for my opening night as Eve Harrington, the famous picture of a photograph of Anne Baxter with Bette Davis's dress, where Bette Davis is presumably left, and she's bowing in front of Anne—uh, Eve is bowing in front of the mirror, holding the dress up, just imagining what it's gonna be like. And it just as she's doing that, Bette Davis opens the door. So, okay, somebody gave me that picture of her holding the dress up. We better let Mrs. Brown come along for the water.
[1:01:49] Steven Ferezy: Oh, I don't remember that.
[1:01:50] Penny Fuller: Okay, so okay, so now it's my opening night. And I mean it's so—it's all very significant because I do that every night and I have the original picture. Now Betty—uh, Anne Baxter is coming into the play, and my understudy rehearsed with her first, and she said, "When you say that line about how I've seen all your movies, you're just gonna go crazy." So, uh, when we get to my turn to rehearse, I said, "When you see all those movies," and I didn't go crazy. So anyway, so we kept going and kept going, and then I do the take the moment where I'm holding the dress and I'm standing in front of the mirror and I'm bowing, and she opened the door. Margot opens the door and says, "Eve," and I quick look, and it's Anne Baxter looking at me doing what I have the picture of Anne Baxter doing.
Do you follow what I'm saying? So, but the thing that was so astonishing is that both of us knew at that moment, she knew exactly what I was thinking of, and she was thinking of it too. And in a funny way, we did not look unalike because she was smaller than Bacall, you know, so and I went, and we both screamed at the same moment and then dropped everything and came and hugged each other. It was wonderful. It was a wonderful moment.
[1:03:07] Steven Ferezy: Can we make a little still life? Can I go grab another item?
[1:03:11] Penny Fuller: Mm-hmm.
[1:03:13] Steven Ferezy: Yeah. This'll be fun because I—I am cheating and I know the stories, and that only makes sense.
[1:03:20] Penny Fuller: Can I find one story you don't know?
[1:03:22] Steven Ferezy: You already did.
[1:03:22] Penny Fuller: I don't remember what it was, but I will when I listen to this again.
[1:03:25] Steven Ferezy: Oh, okay. I just mean your stories are so specific.
[1:03:28] Penny Fuller: That's great. Um, what's she looking for?
[1:03:30] Steven Ferezy: Oh, she doesn't know.
[1:03:31] Penny Fuller: Look on the desk, darling. There's a whole collection.
[1:03:34] Steven Ferezy: Don't tell me what I'm looking for.
[1:03:37] Penny Fuller: She's looking for something she's seen or looking for something.
[1:03:40] Steven Ferezy: I think she's just looking for something that looks touchy.
[1:03:43] Penny Fuller: Oh, they're none of them.
[1:03:44] Steven Ferezy: Oh, I knew it, I knew it.
[1:03:48] Penny Fuller: What a great segue, you don't even know. Talk about it.
[1:03:52] Penny Fuller: We're gonna take a little photo. Dano just handed me a brass key.
[1:03:59] Steven Ferezy: You want to know what this is?
[1:04:01] Penny Fuller: I do. I would love to know what that is.
[1:04:04] Penny Fuller: This is a prop that was in my purse in Neil Simon's "The Dinner Party," for which you earned your second Tony Award nomination.
[1:04:14] Steven Ferezy: That's true.
[1:04:15] Penny Fuller: Because this was a—this was a wild, funny play, very un-Neil Simony-y. It was something like a Boulevard French farce, sort of. And I lock these—um, my ex-husband and two other women and their ex-husbands and me in a room in a private dining room with this key in Paris. And I decide I'm trying to get my husband, Len Cariou, back. And I say, okay, we're gonna play a game. Alright, each one of you, you can't get out. So which one—uh, each one of you has to say, what is the thing that you like least about your husband? And—or something like that. And everybody says, and then I said, "Okay, now what is it you like best?" And of course, everybody starts to sort of fall back in love with their people and so forth and so forth.
And I finally open the door and say, "Okay, I'm staying for dinner." If any of you would like to stay and join me, and one girl, uh, Jan Maxwell and beloved John Ritter, they were married, they sat down, and Henry Winkler sat down, and Henry Winkler's wife, VN Cox, ran out, started going out the door, and then she came back on, and now there's Len Cariou who left, and just me. And I walk up to him and he says, "I'm sorry, Gabrielle, I can't." And he walks out and closes the door, and my back is to the audience. And you can, I hope, feel that I'm thinking he's gonna walk back in any minute, and he doesn't, and I do a lot of back acting. Backing. And there's no he walking through. So I walk to the table and I sit down and I unfold my napkin and I wave a thing.
And as I'm looking at the people, there's a wonderful shaft of light that comes across my face as I look at the empty seat across, and that's the curtain. Except for the final curtain. On the final curtain night, I walk, he closes the door, I do back acting, I do back acting, the last back acting in this show, and then I walk to the table, and just as I'm about to lift up my glass, the door opens, and there's a waiter who comes in with a mustache and short jacket and a basket of bread. And he comes over and offers it to me. It's Len fucking Cariou. He's—he's—he's—he took away my beautiful moment, but he did this wonderful thing of it coming in at the last minute of the play. It was just the best thing that ever happened.
It was divine. He'd been practicing for days to see if he could change and then get back. And I mean, I didn't know nobody. It was wonderful. It was wonderful. But that's what this key is. This is what this key is.
[1:07:27] Steven Ferezy: Do we do one more and pick it together?
[1:07:29] Penny Fuller: Yeah.
[1:07:30] Steven Ferezy: Yeah.
[1:07:30] Penny Fuller: One more what?
[1:07:31] Steven Ferezy: Oh, one more.
[1:07:31] Penny Fuller: One more key, sorry.
[1:07:33] Steven Ferezy: Yeah.
[1:07:34] Penny Fuller: We're gonna pick it together.
[1:07:38] Steven Ferezy: Is this a regular or is this a—is it gonna be like Ouija board where our hands are together and it just kind of like—
[1:08:03] Penny Fuller: And stuff on the bookcases.
[1:08:12] Steven Ferezy: Oh, very interesting.
[1:08:15] Penny Fuller: Lady butt.
[1:08:17] Steven Ferezy: This is a beautiful little statue in bronze that was, I believe, my great Aunt Margaret's, who was a sculptress of her own, but not this one. But this is done by somebody that I looked up once. What is his name?
[1:08:38] Penny Fuller: Philippe something. See if you can find his name.
[1:08:42] Steven Ferezy: I think it's Philippe somebody. It's on there.
[1:08:46] Penny Fuller: P.B.
[1:08:52] Steven Ferezy: It's beautiful.
[1:08:52] Penny Fuller: And it's tiny. And I just love it. I mean, I would never buy it if I had the money, but I inherited it through a bunch of stuff.
[1:09:02] Steven Ferezy: P.B. what?
[1:09:04] Penny Fuller: It's no, it's got a real name there.
[1:09:06] Steven Ferezy: Oh, here we go. Uh, it's P. dot Philippe.
[1:09:11] Penny Fuller: It doesn't have the first name.
[1:09:15] Steven Ferezy: P. Philippe Bronze.
[1:09:16] Penny Fuller: Yep.
[1:09:20] Steven Ferezy: It's worth a couple of bucks, ladies.
[1:09:23] Penny Fuller: Is it?
[1:09:23] Steven Ferezy: How much?
[1:09:24] Penny Fuller: Elegant Bronze, "The Awakening" by Paul Philippe. $4,800.
[1:09:29] Steven Ferezy: Oh, I can't sell it because uh Yuri, my crazy Russian friend, wants it.
[1:09:33] Penny Fuller: If I die. Bronze statue of a bather after a 1937 plaster. $63,000.
[1:09:41] Steven Ferezy: Oh. Can we take a photo?
[1:09:43] Penny Fuller: Sure.
[1:09:44] Steven Ferezy: Well, I mean, she's the one that's naked. Ask her.
[1:09:48] Penny Fuller: Can I tell the great—can I tell the greatest theater story ever?
[1:09:51] Steven Ferezy: You can tell any story you want.
[1:09:53] Penny Fuller: It's the greatest theater story ever. And I know that because I've heard people telling it wrong because they weren't there.
[1:10:00] Steven Ferezy: I'm ready.
[1:10:05] Penny Fuller: I was doing a production of "The Cherry Orchard" at the York Theater.
[1:10:11] Penny Fuller: And my—the same York Theater as is now.
[1:10:18] Steven Ferezy: No.
[1:10:19] Penny Fuller: I don't think so.
[1:10:21] Steven Ferezy: Okay, great.
[1:10:22] Penny Fuller: It was in the—that church.
[1:10:24] Steven Ferezy: Yeah.
[1:10:24] Penny Fuller: In the church on Fifth Avenue.
[1:10:26] Steven Ferezy: Is that where the York Theater is?
[1:10:28] Penny Fuller: No, no, no. No, this was a church. We had to walk through the AA meetings on our way to the backstage. But um just as a subtle reminder. So it was no, it was called the York Theater, and it was in this church on Fifth Avenue at about 101st Street. And um so in "The Cherry Orchard," uh in the third act, the mother, that's me, as uh who's not dealing too well in reality.
[1:10:59] Penny Fuller: I mean, she's not crazy, she's just not being very realistic about anything. While her beloved, um while her beloved cherry orchard is being sold by her brother, she's giving a ball. And so she in this scene that they're dancing, and she dances on with a young man who is her daughter's boyfriend. He's a revolutionary sort of guy, and uh they waltz on, and we're supposed to say, and I say, Oh, I'm so tired, I must rest. And we sit down, and just at that moment, my daughter, who's played by Cynthia Nixon, comes on and says, Mama, mama, I just heard in the kitchen that the cherry orchard was sold. Catastrophe. Okay, so one Saturday afternoon, I'm waltzing on, and I say, Oh, I'm so tired, I must rest.
And we sit down, and there's no Cynthia Nixon. Now, here's what happens. You learn in acting school, you're supposed to improvise and do things to save the moment. But I had learned in Barefoot in the Park when Kurt Klasner didn't come in one night to take Mildred Natwick home. What happened was in Barefoot in the Park, Bob Redford has carried her up the four flights of stairs, puts her on the couch, and he's passed out on the floor. And I have gone up with Mr. Velasco to get some wine or something. And we come in and we're singing, Shamma, Shawma, Mom, and Mama says she's gonna go home, and he says, I'll drive you home, Ethel. That's Mr. Velasco. So this night, he brings her in, he puts her on the chair.
Redford's out on the and I look and I say to Harvey, our stage manager, I said, Where's Kurt? Where's Kurt? Kurt Kassner. And he said, Kurt, Kurt over the speaker system. So he runs upstairs to Kurt's, but of course the guys down in the basement, the curtain guys, Kurt Curtin, are downstairs playing poker. And they come upstairs thinking something's happened. Well, there's no Harvey there, no stage manager, but they look out and they see Bob Redford passed out on the floor. God forbid they've seen the play. So they start bringing the curtain in. And then Kurt, then Harvey comes back and says, No, no, no, no, no. So the curtain goes back up again. And Kurt is in his shorts and his bathrobe. He forgot he had an entrance.
And he said, Let me go on. How could she go on without me? And I said, No, no, no, it's okay. I mean, they said, go, go. I said, okay. And I go on and I go, Sama. Sama. I'm trying to think what I'm supposed to say because he's supposed to say, I'll drive you home. And Mother, Mrs. Natwick, Miss Natwick gets up and says, takes one look and says, Well, dear, tell Mr. Velasco I said goodnight. And she leaves. That's what I learned. Don't stay. Get the hell off the stage. Don't try and fix it. So, because I would still be there if Redford hadn't finally gotten off the floor and started something. So that's what reminded me that night when Cynthia didn't show up. I thought, Mildred's right, just get off the stage, don't try and improvise.
But my legs were crossed, and it's like in a bad dream when you can't get your legs to move. It wouldn't come uncrossed. And I thought, what am I going to do? And she still not come on. And the boy says, You know, before I met Anya, I never danced. And my leg, that was his improvisation, and my leg came on crossed so fast, and I said, Well, you're doing very well. And I got up to get the hell off. At which point the maid, Dunyasha came on stage with this look in her eye, like, don't worry, I've got it all under control. And she said, Madame, madam, I just heard backstage that the cherry orchard was sold. Backstage? Uh-huh. Backstage. And the little look on her face was, oh, she thought she'd saved the moment.
Well, I would still be laughing. I don't know how we got off the stage. It was so terrible. And I was telling this story. When I was telling this story in a dressing room in Palo Alto, New York, in a California, in a green room. And there was one of the characters in the place, it's true. I saw the matinee. I was dating the guy playing Yasha. I saw it when it happened. And we didn't get that crazy because it would make sense that she heard backstage. I mean, it made it kind of a logical say it wasn't as illogical as an audience watching, you know. Oh my God. It's one of the best ever. And Cynthia Nixon. I saw we did a play two or three years ago, and I said to her, if you don't do X, Y, and Z, whatever it was I wanted to do, I'm gonna tell the story.
No, don't tell the story. I said, okay, then you better, whatever. That is the actor's nightmare. Yes. You know, you've told a few stories this evening about gaffes in live theater. Was I in the middle of something that I did that? Told you that, or did I finish that story? Yeah, I think I did I diverted by telling the Melbourne that we speaking of diversions, there are seven very well known dwarfs in history. If you were the eighth dwarf, what would your name be?
[1:16:51] Penny Fuller: I have no idea. I wouldn't name myself. Somebody else would have to name me. Why? Am I supposed to note something? We've got a sleepy. Yeah. Sleepy. Doc, dopey, sneezy. Sleepy. Cry baby to me. Wheezy. Wheezy. Thank you, Trag. Glorious. My name would be Glorious. Well, Glorious. I thought you were gonna say Penny. No. Glorious. Where's that glorious dwarf? There she is. Hi How. All five, three and a half. Is there a role that you never got to play that you given the opportunity today in an out of context, completely blind cast, you would still do knowing you were completely wrong for it?
[1:17:53] Penny Fuller: Yeah. Two of them Cleopatra in Royal Shakespeare's Anthony and Cleopatra. And what was the other one? Well, any of those Chekhov ladies. Any of those Chekhov ladies. Again, I played, you've played a lot of them. I played Arcadina twice, and I played Ranevskaya, the Cherry User, once, but I never played any of the three sisters. Uh, but there was something else that's Blanche? Yes, Blanche. Uh that kills. I would kill to see it. Yeah, I wish I wish I'd gotten a chance to do it. I did it in my acting class. The first person I did it with was the Tony Danza. It was his first scene in Milton Katzellus' acting class, and we did Streetcar. And he was good. He's a great. He's another one that's the good, the real deal.
You're Blanche. I mean, the listeners probably don't know that you're from the South. You're a Southern girl. Mm-hmm. I am. Lumberton. Lumberton. Well, yeah, a lady in Lumberton. I was born in Durham. And I grew up part-time in Southern Pines when I wasn't in New York. And then my mother, she came back and married her first boyfriend. And they because they were divorced, my parents, and we moved to Lumberton. Mum B or not Mum B? That is the question. Very good. Cheers. Who was that? Mr. Shakespeare. Oh yeah, Abfab and Laura Osnes. Laura Osnes. Yes. Okay. Well, I got to play one of my favorite roles, of course, which was Desiree and a little night music up in White Plains, New York. And Laura Osnes was to play Charlotte?
Anne. Anne. And on the and on the second or third day, I get to rehearsal. I come up into the, I don't remember one of those buildings, come up in the elevator, and Laura Osnes is on the phone. She said, and I hear her say, I did. Really? I did. Oh, wait. And then she went somewhere else. And that was when they called her to tell her she got the replacement for Kelly O'Hara in South Pacific. Wow. So she didn't get to play Anne, but I got to see her get the news that she was gonna play.
[1:20:21] Dana Craig: Sure.
[1:20:22] Penny Fuller: That's amazing. Who was your aunt? Oh, just worked with her. In in in Southern Yes. What's her name? Aaron Davy. David. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. She's wonderful. You were playing, and then I promise we'll wrap it up. Uh, you were playing the next time you did it. You were playing Madame Armfeld. We're talking about little night music, you know. Well, if they don't know they're listening to her on the podcast. That's true. You were playing Madame Armfeld when the world got the news that Elaine Stritch had passed.
[1:20:58] Penny Fuller: Well, the world in wherever I was, Pittsfield, Massachusetts, didn't get the news, but I did. It was a matinee day. And there's a moment in Sunday in the uh what is the name of it? Little night music. When Madame Armfeld, she's old and she's in the wheelchair, and she she's got her granddaughter there, and she says, I can't remember, but something about three times. What's the the night smiles three times? Smeet Street The Night of the Moon. The night I don't know. Anyway, something. And then she's in the thing, she goes. The first time for the children, the second time for the lovers, and the third time for me! Somebody call Lonnie Price. Um anyway, whatever it was. Anyway, so usually what she does is The Fools.
Yes. But doesn't she sing the Azels again a little bit? No, but I think the pianos do. Yeah, and then she just in the wit in the wheelchair, she just closed the eye. A lot of people thought she fell asleep, but she died. So I worked it out with my director, which is that well, I had this thing where I said whatever, and I'm looking at it, and all of a sudden I saw what was coming. I saw where I was going. I was saw the pearl, whatever I saw. And I stood up, and you knew I had died. And I turned to walk, and the what are the singers called? Oh, I forget, but they're the remember. Yeah, those about six of them or something. Have made an aisle, a walkway on either side. And I turn and I walk directly upstage, and offstage is a light, and I walk towards the light.
And I was as I was walking towards it, I was thinking of Elaine, and I just wept all the way. And that night I announced to the crowd to the audience after the kid that she had died. But that it was so early at that point. It was during the day. I was working. I left work. I was finishing a shift, and I was like, I gotta go. This day's over. Yeah. I was at a retail job. And it's like, I'm there's nothing left for me to sell today. I told you my original thing with Stritch, right? Stritch angle bit. As we record this on her birthday. Yes, happy birthday. Happy birthday. She for many years, or I don't know whether it was many years, but many years ago, she was dating Joe Allen. Restaurant? Res.
And um there was some talk, and I don't tend to dispread stuff about if that I'm supposed to that I'm connected with because I don't want to jinx anything. But in those days, it was there was some talk that she was gonna go to Hollywood and do a TV series of my sister Eileen, or what is that? Wonderful Town. And I remember, I don't know where I was, but they Joe and Elaine were sitting in a corner booth, Elaine and Joe. And I went over to talk to them. And that's the first time I remember ever talking to her. I mean, I was slightly friendly through the years, but there was some discussion of maybe if it all works out, we'll all be we'll be working together. And of course we didn't, and I got to go to London in her role in a in a sort of sail-away, which was uh Noel Coward musical, and what I did was I did a sort of a it's almost in a way it's sad that Encores isn't like this. I understand why Encores is what it is, but this was just people in evening clothes with scripts just reading old musicals is what the thing was called. Lost musicals, yeah.
[1:25:05] Penny Fuller: And I got to play streety. You have just got to work and mingle with the greatest of this business ever.
[1:25:15] Steven Ferezy: I think you're right.
[1:25:17] Penny Fuller: I think you're right. I really be it theater or film. Eileen Heckert. I got to work with her. Wonderful, wonderful actress. Day one of your career, you're working with Bette Davis twice.
[1:25:30] Steven Ferezy: Yes, Bette Davis.
[1:25:32] Penny Fuller: Meryl Streep. Yes, I did Meryl Streep, God bless her. What's the secret of longevity? Sustainability. Being born at a different time than this. I mean, it was just a different time. Not that you don't look 25 right now.
[1:25:51] Steven Ferezy: Of course.
[1:25:51] Penny Fuller: Because you do. Sure. Do you think if you were 25 right now, you would have the same success?
[1:26:00] Penny Fuller: No, because I don't think the values are the same. We were talking, was it you and I we were talking earlier about the uh what's happening and the arguments and the forces for and against the fact that artists who have committed harassment and stuff like that, they're taking their paintings out of exhibits and so forth. And I don't think, I mean, I don't, I haven't thought this totally true, but my through, but my main feeling is that the art is not about the artists, it's about the art. And the art is about what it not saying that Johnny Johnston or whatever, whoever it is, did that painting, but is what is the effect of that painting? What does that bring out in me? The art is another thing from the artist and the viewer. It is something that floats and becomes part of both.
[1:26:55] Steven Ferezy: Right.
[1:26:55] Penny Fuller: And I think that something about that that Miss Krause, my first real teacher of drama, was such an idealist. And I think I was, and it was still an age of that time. So all of my ideals came from her. And then most people are lucky if they have one teacher in their lives. I've had four. Now that's pretty piggy, but I have had four geniuses. Miss Krause. And I would even say five because I worked with Philip Burton, Philip uh Richard Burton's foster father in on Shakespeare. But Philip Burton, Miss Krause, my dear friend Diana Maddox, who taught me more about Shakespeare and theater than anybody, and she had come over after the war with the Royal Shakespeare Company from England, so that's true.
And my teacher uh in Los Angeles, Milton Cotzellis. And my teacher who taught me about singing, not about singing, but about performing in music, I would call it David Craig. And they were life changers. And you usually get one, two if you're lucky, but I've had four. So it's made it a pretty serious profession to me. It's I'm not a priest, but it's not that far from a priest in that I have a kind of a mission to bring that other world to you in the audience, whether it's with a fun musical or whether a deep thing, I mean, that's kind of where, and I don't think, I don't think, and I'm not putting them down, but I don't think that's the impetus today. And that has to do with the times that I came up in.
[1:28:46] Penny Fuller: I mean, we were an innocent country kind of in the 50s. You know, I mean, after the war and everything, it was all quite different, and the things from which things sprouted was different than today, and this is really hard. And I I'm really send you all my sympathy because it's not coming from the same place that made it okay in a way, because it was so it was important about what it was about in my day, or else I'm crazy. And that's also possible.
[1:29:22] Steven Ferezy: Well, how does that how does it what is it do to you when I say that?
[1:29:27] Penny Fuller: I mean, I wanted to do this growing up. I had cast albums and I had those American playhouse plays and musicals to watch and to see when I grow up, I want to run around the stage with a cow on a handle and tell this fake fairy tale. Something about that was what I wanted to do, and I somehow saw myself doing it. And then I moved here, and it didn't take long before it was hard to see myself doing it because all of a sudden, oh, I didn't know that there was such a thing as a tenor and a baritone. I thought you just sang it. Doesn't matter. And I didn't know that there were things like typing out, because growing up working in regional theaters in Los Angeles was a talented boy that could kick his face.
It wasn't hard for me to book work, so I didn't know about I don't know typing out. Wanted to be in the chorus. Give me a fucking wig. And now I just I see all of that. I see exclusively that. I see exclusively, oh this director, this choreographer, this casting director brings the same person from show to show to show to show.
[1:30:55] Steven Ferezy: You want an answer to that, or do you just want to?
[1:30:59] Penny Fuller: Okay. Well, no, then that's the the argument of uh not an argument, it's the fact of it's show business. But it was show business when I was along, but it was there was people on the business end had those same values stars in their eyes in some way. It wasn't it wasn't to make the money, it was to be to do the show and and get the money. And uh yeah, it's it's a different world. It's real I mean every every part of the world is different. Because it's not mainstream enough. Now it's all about the cast album. Musicals do well because the album goes out and kids all over here, and I think that's great that kids have access to it if they can't get here. However, you stop telling a story that requires the book of a musical and you start creating things for the ears.
And not for the theater. That's it. Because that's where you're gonna make more of your money. I didn't think of it like I never thought of it. And if you don't have enough Twitter followers, we'll probably not hire you.
[1:32:09] Steven Ferezy: Yes, I know.
[1:32:10] Penny Fuller: Well, I have a good friend who's supposed to help me with that. We want you to do your own PR.
[1:32:16] Steven Ferezy: Yeah.
[1:32:16] Penny Fuller: So you can't do it. I hear you have to do everything yourself now. You have to put yourself on TV. Which is more transparent. There are emails that go out on the first day of rehearsals saying, okay, now that it's announced that we're doing the show, here's the official graphic we want you to use to tell people. Right, that's right. I asked you about medias, and you know, if you're going to tweet, please make sure you include this link so that we know how many people are buying tickets from you guys and uh I'm sorry, I have to memorize lines.
[1:32:48] Steven Ferezy: Yeah.
[1:32:48] Penny Fuller: I remember there was a lot of that in the dressing room. I had, and I'm not a snob, but I hadn't been in a chorus dressing room in a long time. And I used to have to say, go into the hair room and say, I just have to get out of there. The squealing is just driving me crazy. I can't. I mean, I love them. But the pitch of the voices, but like nine of them, I can't do it. I can't do it. Taping out. You're used to you and Liz in a room.
[1:33:15] Steven Ferezy: Well, Liz would say, Come here, you don't know anything about wigs and hair. Let me do yeah.
[1:33:21] Penny Fuller: So we did this play off Broadway, and she did my hair. And so they said, okay, now we're gonna do it on Broadway. And I said, they said, uh it's whatever it is, it's the favorite nations, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And I said, but I have to have Liz Ashley doing my hair. And my agents have so much humor. They thought I was serious. So they came back and they said, You can have everything else, but you can't have I said, This has to be a uh uh what do you call it? You and your butt. I said, I'm are you kidding? I knew that. You can't have the she said, you have no wing skills. Come in.
[1:33:58] Penny Fuller: That's true. There's one story you promised you would tell on the podcast, and then I promise we will wrap it up because my computer is done. We're at our three. Well, you can plug it in. I know, but I mean, I don't care about I don't mean we can talk to you. Well, this is Penny Fuller part one. Um, you have a Hal Prince story that you uh forgot to tell at 54 below last week with our dear friend Bonnie Milligan. That we want to make sure that Bonnie hears.
[1:34:27] Penny Fuller: Didn't I tell her in the car? I think I'm not sure.
[1:34:29] Steven Ferezy: Oh, I don't know, but for everyone else that isn't Bonnie.
[1:34:32] Penny Fuller: Well, you have to understand, I have to tell a little bit of background about what it is, right?
[1:34:36] Steven Ferezy: Yes.
[1:34:36] Penny Fuller: So, but I mean, oh no, that was on the video, you didn't say okay. Okay. Okay, so I'm in a play called Rex, and I you would have thought this was all I needed. A classically trained actress who also sings. I'm playing Anne Boleyn in the first act, and Princess Elizabeth, who becomes Queen Elizabeth in the second act, and Nicole Williamson, one of the great actors of our time, is playing King Henry. I mean, come on. Well, I mean, this is it, baby. So um so, okay, so we're rehearsing, and I'm keeping a diary, which will not be part of this program. But um, so I have this lovely song called uh we all forget that it's called Too Soon, because we all call it So Much You Loved Me, but that was not the title. And the song, I have to tell that whole part. You want don't mind getting the charger. Keep talking.
[1:35:32] Penny Fuller: Oh, okay. So the song comes when I have just given birth to a beautiful little baby girl whose name is Elizabeth, and my husband, the king of England, has to have a son, because that's the way it worked. Later, of course, Queen Elizabeth became the greatest monarch in English history or something. But anyway, so Henry's furious that I didn't have a boy. So now he's playing around with the Lady Jane Seymour. And Lady Jane Seymour, I catch them, and I say, get her out of here. And I have this huge fight with him. And I say, you know, come to bed with me, or if you don't, and Elizabeth will be and we'll make sons, and if you don't, Elizabeth will be queen. He says, Lady, I raised you up. I can't push you down.
And he storms out, and you hear this bum bum bum bum bum. And I can't sing the song because it isn't quite from the place that you're left from in that scene. So we went through a lot of hell trying to fix it, and Sheldon Harnock even wrote me new lyrics, but it didn't help. And nobody quite understood, and I wasn't able to articulate what the problem was. So we get to Washington, DC, and there's a lot of problems, and Hal Prince is there to come. They bring him in just to advise. And he has some ideas. So we get to Boston, and he has the idea, and he understands what I'm saying, so that all the kids were watching the one night this was put into the show. And I run in, and there's Lady Seymour and Jane Seymour, and I said, get her out.
And he says, and I we start squabbling, and then I sing the first half or the my part of the song that we sang in the first act that was our love song called Away from You. And I sing it to woo him back to me. And I'm doing pretty well, but then something happens, I can't remember what. We get into a fight again, and then he goes, and then I can sing how much you loved me because it okay. So it was that one night in Boston, and of course, my whole story worked, but it wasn't gonna work in the show because it became too much about my character, so that got cut. But after that one night that it was in there, Hal said, Come on, let's go over and let's have a drink. I said, okay. He said, You know where I got the idea of doing it like that with the two songs?
I said, No. He said, Well, you know, I'm directing a little night music, the movie with Elizabeth Taylor. I said, Oh, right. And he said, and Elliot Castner, the producer, called me and said, Hal, whatever you do, don't go to the Lowell Hotel where Elizabeth is until Monday night at 8 o'clock. Don't dare show up before then to have your meeting with her. So Hal said, okay. So he goes over at 11 at 8 o'clock on Monday night, knocks on the door, and the door opens, and it's Richard Burton. And he says, Good evening, Hal. My soon-to-be ex-wife will be with you in a minute. Goodbye, Elizabeth. And I mean, goodbye. And he goes out and slams the door. Now, Hal Prince is there in a moment of history with nobody to nudge, nobody to say, did you hear that?
No, he's all by himself. And he's uh he's about to have a heart attack, practically. And then Elizabeth Taylor comes out of the bedroom in a terrycloth robe and her hair in a towel, and she said, That son of a bitch, do you know what he did to me today?
[1:39:16] Penny Fuller: And Hal said, uh no. And she said, he brought the woman that he's gonna marry over to meet me. And Al said, oh, oh, oh, whoa, oh, really? And she said, and do you know what I did? And Hal said, nope. And she said, I just reminded him of everything about me that he fell in love with. And that's where Hal got the idea to do that scene in Rex, where I try to seduce him, and then how do you like rolls? I can't even breathe right now.
[1:39:55] Steven Ferezy: Why?
[1:39:57] Penny Fuller: That's insane.
[1:39:59] Steven Ferezy: Of course it's insane.
[1:40:00] Penny Fuller: But it's true. And no one Elizabeth Taylor impression.
[1:40:05] Steven Ferezy: Oh, that's fair.
[1:40:08] Penny Fuller: Oh, thank you, thank you. Well, they often get. I spent an evening. When I was in Barefoot in the Park, you may not want this. When I was in Barefoot in the Park, I took over Barefoot in the Park, and Mike Nichols came. I had one rehearsal or two, maybe two days of rehearsal with Mike, even though I'd been playing it as the understudy. And he refined it all. And he came to see it, and he said, Let's go to Sarty's and we'll have a drink and I'll give you a couple of notes. I said, Great. And we're walking towards Sarty's from the Biltmore Theater, and he said, Oh, let's go by and say hello to Richard. I said, Richard, who? He's at Burton. You know, he's playing Hamlet. Oh, I said, Of course he is.
And in those days, they had the horseshoe, what do you call those? The sawhorses across the streets, people behind the sawhorses, because they were bound to see the newlyweds, Richard and Miss Taylor. So we go into the backstage of the Lanfon, and we go up, and the guy says, go upstairs. He's on stage, but he'll be up in his dressing room soon. So we go up to the second floor, and pretty soon I said, May here, Mike, Mike. And I look down, and at the bottom of the stairway, and I, by the way, didn't care much for Richard Burton. I look down at the stairs and he's looking up at me like Rhett Butler and Scarlet. And he says, Oh, Mike, as he comes up. What a lovely girl. And I'm thinking, I'm gone, I'm gone, I'm gone.
And I don't even like him. I'm gone. So he says, come with uh we're going to El Morocco. So after you have your thing, come on over to El Morocco. So I am sitting at the table in El Morocco with Elizabeth Taylor, Richard Burton, Mike Nichols, Penny Fuller, um Philip Burton, his foster father, and I think, but I can't be sure of this. I think Sammy Davis was there too.
[1:42:10] Steven Ferezy: I can't with you right now.
[1:42:11] Penny Fuller: So when I told my mother the next day, she said, okay, well, oh, and tell the gang I said hi. Yeah, that was it. And they were talking, and I was smoking and drinking because they were all telling theater stories, and I hadn't been in the theater long enough to have any stories.
[1:42:29] Steven Ferezy: So you had to keep your foot.
[1:42:31] Penny Fuller: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's how I am tonight.
[1:42:33] Steven Ferezy: Oh, dazzling anything.
[1:42:35] Penny Fuller: Oh, yeah. Well, but that was that's a dinner party. That was amazing. God damn it. And I went into, I thought, oh, I have to go to the ladies' room, and she was in there. I said, I can't go in there, but she's in there. What'll I say? I mean, I don't want to say, well, how's your China pattern or whatever, you know? So I went in there and she was doing her hair, and we just sort of smiled, and I don't think I said anything. She left and I did what I had to do and I came back.
[1:43:01] Steven Ferezy: If you ran into Elizabeth Taylor in the ladies' room, what would you say?
[1:43:04] Penny Fuller: There's something about Elizabeth Taylor that I think is approachable. Like she's a like she's a cool chick. Because she's like not afraid to do a telephone. Like she's not afraid to be fat and on screen.
[1:43:16] Steven Ferezy: Like, like yeah, but see, this was before that.
[1:43:19] Penny Fuller: That was before that, so she was a little scared.
[1:43:22] Steven Ferezy: She was she well, she was scary, yeah.
[1:43:25] Penny Fuller: I'm Jackson.
[1:43:26] Steven Ferezy: Like she's a good one.
[1:43:27] Penny Fuller: Oh, but that was come on 30 years later.
[1:43:29] Steven Ferezy: But it's in her blunt.
[1:43:30] Penny Fuller: I mean, there's something that I can like.
[1:43:32] Steven Ferezy: No, I know, but it's not in my book.
[1:43:35] Penny Fuller: So I guess my real question is if you ran into Elizabeth Taylor in the late 60s.
[1:43:40] Steven Ferezy: There we go.
[1:43:40] Penny Fuller: In the ladies' room.
[1:43:41] Steven Ferezy: There we go.
[1:43:42] Penny Fuller: Yeah, um terrifying. Would have been terrifying. And she I can remember she had on a black top and a polka dot white poker and black po the white with black polka dot wrapped chiffon skirt.
[1:43:57] Steven Ferezy: Good god.
[1:43:58] Penny Fuller: Yeah, yeah. Um then during those days, they had a special, it was it was around them because yeah. Um Kurt Casmer, it was a Sunday night, and Kurt Kasner took me to this poetry reading. It was Richard Burton, Philip Burton, and Elizabeth Taylor doing poetry readings. Now you have to understand that slam poetry?
[1:44:24] Steven Ferezy: No, no, real poetry.
[1:44:26] Penny Fuller: I mean, no, no, no, classy poetry, classic poetry. Yes, that kind of stuff. And uh Elizabeth Taylor had never been on a stage. Now she's here in New York with all the sharks waiting to eat her alive. She's on stage, she's doing fucking poetry. And Richard and the man that that you know made him and so forth, and there they are. And I remember one of her, one of her th one of her poems, I don't know what it was, but it went Despair, Despair, Despair and then I and then she blew up some lines she said oh I screwed up can I start again it was so ingenuous that she everybody was so in love with her and Richard Burton is sitting with his legs and his hand over and his face is getting ready says I had no idea she'd be this good I mean she was fantastic and you talk about brave I don't mean sing a song which you do all the time or so read poetry to a New York theater full of snakes and sharks and me I just found our title snakes and sharks and me featuring Penny Cohen I can't with you my heart is full well we've been wrapping up for about 45 minutes now so the stories just keep coming what if we had wrapped up 50 minutes ago I know I'm so glad we didn't see it part two pure gold well pure heart of gold I oh that's right I forget that I have all these stories because you know it was a long time ago and it was wonderful then but it it sort of just became part of the patchwork quilt of my life do you write them down do you have a journal of well I have a journal but I don't write them down you I'm saying what the fuck am I gonna do with my life Taylor you're not gonna forget that no I'm not gonna forget that except I did forget that story at the the day of the catapulting Prattful but that's okay.
[1:46:47] Steven Ferezy: It was long enough.
[1:46:48] Penny Fuller: What a fantastic life. It really has been wonderful. And I have been able to have my daughter and raise her, and she's sane. I'm not rich. I'm not a big star, but I've had a great lot of stuff to do, and she's great. And I'm not too crazy, you know. I mean, I'm really happy.
[1:47:12] Steven Ferezy: You're just right.
[1:47:13] Penny Fuller: Yeah. You're a star to us, and um, at least one person every time we've ever gone to get a manicure together.
[1:47:23] Steven Ferezy: Every time we've gone to get a manicure, somebody's been like, You're that actress, Penny, right?
[1:47:27] Penny Fuller: No.
[1:47:28] Steven Ferezy: Oh.
[1:47:30] Penny Fuller: You can walk down the street with her. You cannot get your nails done with her.
[1:47:33] Steven Ferezy: Henny, thank you so much for sitting down with us.
[1:47:36] Penny Fuller: It was my pleasure, Stephen.
[1:47:38] Steven Ferezy: Thank you.
[1:47:39] Penny Fuller: Thank you for your thoughts.
[1:47:40] Steven Ferezy: Oh.
[1:47:41] Penny Fuller: And your stories?
[1:47:42] Steven Ferezy: I was happy to share them with you.
[1:47:44] Steven Ferezy: Are we as fun as all the talk shows that you've done in your life?
[1:47:47] Penny Fuller: I don't remember any talk shows.
[1:47:49] Steven Ferezy: Oh yes.
[1:47:50] Penny Fuller: Yes, I do. I remember when Johnny Carson said.
[1:47:56] Steven Ferezy: What did he say?
[1:47:57] Penny Fuller: I want to marry him.
[1:47:58] Steven Ferezy: Oh no, you don't.
[1:47:59] Penny Fuller: Yes.
[1:47:59] Steven Ferezy: No, no, you don't.
[1:48:00] Penny Fuller: I'll change my name to Joanne.
[1:48:02] Steven Ferezy: No, no, no, you don't.
[1:48:03] Penny Fuller: You don't.
[1:48:04] Steven Ferezy: Okay.
[1:48:05] Penny Fuller: You know whoever you want to marry is Norman Lear.
[1:48:08] Steven Ferezy: I want to marry Norman Lear.
[1:48:12] Penny Fuller: No, but Anita does.
[1:48:14] Steven Ferezy: Sure.
[1:48:16] Penny Fuller: I mean, I knew him, but I met him, but I don't know him. Because I, you know, I never did. I kept turning down sitcoms.
[1:48:23] Steven Ferezy: Sure.
[1:48:23] Penny Fuller: You're not a sitcom gal.
[1:48:25] Steven Ferezy: I did a million of them.
[1:48:27] Penny Fuller: I know, but you but it's not your, it's not your heart and soul.
[1:48:31] Steven Ferezy: You're a classically trained actress.
[1:48:34] Penny Fuller: Yes, I am.
[1:48:35] Penny Fuller: Well, I did, I did what's her name's mother?
[1:48:40] Steven Ferezy: What's her name?
[1:48:41] Penny Fuller: Helen Hunt?
[1:48:42] Steven Ferezy: Mad About You.
[1:48:43] Penny Fuller: Mad About You.
[1:48:45] Penny Fuller: Yeah, I was the mother for four episodes. Until they fired me so that Carol Burnett could take over.
[1:48:55] Steven Ferezy: You were the first Becky.
[1:48:56] Penny Fuller: No, I was the second.
[1:48:59] Steven Ferezy: The snake in the wood.
[1:49:00] Penny Fuller: No, oh God.
[1:49:01] Steven Ferezy: Oh, that's so weird.
[1:49:03] Penny Fuller: I think the funniest thing I ever said in my life is I'd we'd done some huge thing about Thanksgiving. And somehow, I don't know, the turkey got thrown out the window. And about three weeks later, I was on the show again, and we would get in Ren. I walked outside and said, Hey, there's a turkey out here on the It was very funny. I was quite proud of myself.
[1:49:26] Steven Ferezy: First of all, Helen Hunt looks nothing like Carol Burnett and looks a lot like uh your lineage.
[1:49:32] Penny Fuller: Yes, I know.
[1:49:33] Penny Fuller: So don't I don't want anybody to know what I'm gonna say, so I'll tell that when it turned off.
[1:49:39] Steven Ferezy: Tapping out, tapping out.
[1:49:40] Penny Fuller: Thank you so much for agreeing to do this.
[1:49:43] Steven Ferezy: This is the classiest I've felt in a while.
[1:49:46] Penny Fuller: Wow.
[1:49:46] Steven Ferezy: Isn't that sweet?
[1:49:49] Penny Fuller: I love you so much.
[1:49:50] Steven Ferezy: This is normally where we ask uh where people can find you on the internet, but you've saved us a step.
[1:49:55] Penny Fuller: Well, you too.
[1:49:56] Steven Ferezy: Where can they find me?
[1:49:57] Penny Fuller: You're all over YouTube.
[1:49:58] Steven Ferezy: Oh, I am Spotify.
[1:50:03] Penny Fuller: I listen to it all the time.
[1:50:04] Steven Ferezy: Beautiful.
[1:50:04] Penny Fuller: I haven't even heard it.
[1:50:05] Steven Ferezy: Get into it.
[1:50:07] Penny Fuller: Um, but yeah, definitely go watch that applause on YouTube. Go watch her accept her Emmy on YouTube. It's a good speech and a good dress.
[1:50:18] Penny Fuller: It's by her bathroom.
[1:50:20] Steven Ferezy: I've touched it.
[1:50:20] Penny Fuller: Sorry.
[1:50:21] Penny Fuller: It's not by her bathroom anymore.
[1:50:22] Steven Ferezy: Oh she's brought it into the living room.
[1:50:24] Penny Fuller: Yeah, not a doorstep. But it's hidden, it's hidden around the corner.
[1:50:27] Steven Ferezy: Still in the library.
[1:50:29] Penny Fuller: It's still, it still has a certain you know modesty about it.
[1:50:33] Steven Ferezy: Sure, of course.
[1:50:34] Penny Fuller: Yeah.
[1:50:34] Steven Ferezy: Oh, we love it.
[1:50:35] Penny Fuller: What the hell was I gonna tell you?
[1:50:38] Steven Ferezy: We love you so much.
[1:50:39] Penny Fuller: You're welcome back anytime.
[1:50:41] Steven Ferezy: Thank you for having us in your life.
[1:50:43] Penny Fuller: Thank you.
[1:50:43] Steven Ferezy: Thank you.
[1:50:44] Penny Fuller: Thank you.
[1:50:45] Steven Ferezy: In your room.
[1:50:46] Penny Fuller: This was fun.
[1:50:47] Steven Ferezy: You know, I'm gonna have a podcast, I think.
[1:50:50] Penny Fuller: You should.
[1:50:50] Steven Ferezy: That's right, plug.
[1:50:51] Penny Fuller: Do you have anything to plug?
[1:50:52] Steven Ferezy: Yeah, I do have something to plug, my podcast.
[1:50:55] Penny Fuller: Um a friend of mine who was a lawyer in show business. I was gonna do it with somebody else, and my son-in-law, who was kind of in this sort of rat race before he started doing virtual reality documentaries. He kind of said, Why don't you do it? Because you, Doug Nevin, are a younger generation. It'll be the two generations looking at the theater today, blah blah blah blah. So we're we've got our producer and everything, but we just haven't gotten around to it.
[1:51:26] Steven Ferezy: Christmas got it.
[1:51:30] Penny Fuller: Well, I'm not gonna interview me, I'm gonna interview Jake and people like that.
[1:51:35] Steven Ferezy: That's all part of it.
[1:51:36] Penny Fuller: Yeah, okay.
[1:51:37] Steven Ferezy: Okay.
[1:51:40] Penny Fuller: Well, it'll be interesting because it's about uh my generation of theater and y'all's generation, and we're, you know, all of that kind of stuff.
[1:51:51] Steven Ferezy: Uh yeah, yeah.
[1:51:53] Penny Fuller: I'll be the first to leave a rating and a review.
[1:51:57] Steven Ferezy: Mm-hmm.
[1:51:57] Penny Fuller: Okay.
[1:51:58] Steven Ferezy: And finally, what is it that we are living for?
[1:52:05] Penny Fuller: The next moment.
[1:52:06] Steven Ferezy: Oi, the answer is a pause, applause.
[1:52:09] Penny Fuller: No, it isn't.
[1:52:11] Steven Ferezy: No.
[1:52:13] Penny Fuller: Great.
[1:52:13] Steven Ferezy: Well done.
[1:52:14] Penny Fuller: Good one.
[1:52:15] Steven Ferezy: Well done.
[1:52:16] Penny Fuller: Bye.
[1:52:24] Steven Ferezy: In the Room with Steven and Dana is produced by Stephen Ferrasie.
[1:52:28] Dana Craig: And Dana Craig.
[1:52:29] Steven Ferezy: Special thanks to Joel Wagoner for tinkling the ivories on our theme song.
[1:52:34] Dana Craig: Hit him up at Joel Wagoner.com.
[1:52:36] Steven Ferezy: We apologize, and you're welcome.
[1:52:39] Dana Craig: We'd also like to thank Jesse Wiener, W-I-E-N-E-R, for our jazzy original music sprinkled throughout each episode.
[1:52:47] Steven Ferezy: You can find him at jessewiener.com.
[1:52:50] Dana Craig: Last but certainly not least, we'd like to thank Kevin Thomas Garcia for taking all of our ridiculous photos.
[1:52:56] Steven Ferezy: You can find him online at KTGNYC.com.
[1:53:02] Dana Craig: We are all over the internet on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter at In the Room Pod.
[1:53:08] Steven Ferezy: Follow us, like us, share us, pimp us out.
[1:53:11] Dana Craig: And don't forget to subscribe to In the Room Podcast.
[1:53:14] Steven Ferezy: We everywhere so subscribe.
[1:53:16] Dana Craig: And thank you so much for listening.
[1:53:18] Steven Ferezy: Thank you so much.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
