Broadway's Erika Henningsen breaks down her career creating the iconic role of "Cady Heron" in Mean Girls the Musical and making her Broadway debut as :Fantine" in Les Misérables in this week's episode of LITTLE ME!.. Read More
From the show: LITTLE ME: Growing Up Broadway
Guests
Featured Shows
About
Broadway's Erika Henningsen breaks down her career creating the iconic role of "Cady Heron" in Mean Girls the Musical and making her Broadway debut as :Fantine" in Les Misérables in this week's episode of LITTLE ME!
Erika sits down with Broadway Workshop director, Marc Tumminelli and shares how she fell in love with musical theater through her grandmother, watching movie musicals as a child, taking summer theater classes, performing in several musical productions in high school and realizing that she wanted to pursue this as a career when she played Belle in Beauty and the Beast, and her biggest takeaway from attending the competitive musical theater program at University of Michigan.
Erika tells LITTLE ME listeners about her fearless performance as Kim in Showboat with the New York Philharmonic, being a part of the out-of-town run of the musical Diner for which Sheryl Crow wrote the score, making her Broadway debut in Les Misérables, why it was a full circle moment for her, and what it was like playing Fantine at only 23 years old.
Erika also talks about her journey to booking the role of Cady Heron in Mean Girls, the meaningful compliments she and her cast received from Patti LuPone, what she misses most about leading a show on Broadway, working with Tina Fey again on the star-studded TV show Girls5eva in which she played the younger version of Paula Pell’s character Gloria, her love of teaching musical theater workshops, and her passion for social activism.
After a sold-out residency at The Green Room 42 this past spring and summer, Erika will be performing a solo show at Chelsea Table & Stage on Sunday, September 19! Marc and Erika break down what to expect from this new show!
Produced by Marc Tumminelli and The Broadway Podcast Network
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:01] ♪ Musical number ♪
[0:21] Marc Tumminelli: Hi everybody, it's Marc Tumminelli, and welcome back to LITTLE ME: Growing Up Broadway. My guest today is best known for her work on Broadway, originated the role of Cady Heron in the 2018 Tony-nominated musical Mean Girls, for which she received an Outer Critics Circle Award nomination. She made her Broadway debut as Fantine in the revival of Les Misérables and starred as Beth in the musical Diner with music and lyrics by Sheryl Crow. She played Kim in the New York Philharmonic Showboat concert on PBS. Her other theater credits include Penny in Hairspray, Carrie in Carrie, Roxy in Chicago, Nellie in South Pacific, Becca in Found, Nita in Dear World, Sophie in Mamma Mia, and recently she made you pee in your pants in Girls5eva on Peacock. Please welcome my dear friend Erika Henningsen.
[1:23] Erika Henningsen: Hi, Marc. I cannot believe you found footage of the wagon wheel Chicago.
[1:28] Marc Tumminelli: Oh no. That thing's gonna get so many views now.
[1:31] Erika Henningsen: It's amazing. Um, okay. So I also used to be a perfectionist about this, and I would have done that intro like three times over, but I think this is what this is becoming. This is real.
[1:41] Marc Tumminelli: This is the real take. Okay, now you were not a child star, correct?
[1:45] Erika Henningsen: I was not a child star. I mean, to my parents, I was, but I was not.
[1:50] Marc Tumminelli: So to the billions of people listening right now, you're wondering, why is Erika doing the LITTLE ME podcast? Well, I am expanding the vision of this year's podcast so that I will still be talking to former messed up child stars, but I will also be talking to people I love about what they were doing as theater-obsessed Broadway kids.
[2:07] Erika Henningsen: So to currently messed up adult stars.
[2:11] Marc Tumminelli: Yeah, that's how that works. So I'm so thrilled you're here. Before we go back to the beginning, I want to talk about this very exciting thing that's coming up for you. You've taken the cabaret world by storm after your sold-out residency at the Green Room 42 this past spring and summer. And now you're bringing a brand new solo show to Chelsea Table and Stage, which is a gorgeous venue on Sunday, September 19th. So what can you tell us about the new show, Erika?
[2:37] Erika Henningsen: The new show. I'm so excited. Well, the new show is essentially trying to tie together the three worlds of music that I grew up with: the standards of my grandparents, the 70s rock of my father, and then this new world I've been introduced to via Mean Girls, which is the Gen Z pop world. Um, so I think there's gonna be a little bit of music for everybody, and then some stories. And you know, the title is a bit still in flux, but as of now, we're calling it Raise Your Standards. Uh so you're gonna obviously hear some standards, and then it's gonna kind of take off from there.
[3:15] Marc Tumminelli: Well, this is very exciting. Who's musical directing the show?
[3:18] Erika Henningsen: Mary Mitchell Campbell is musical directing the show.
[3:21] Marc Tumminelli: Oh, what a legend. And can I plug you as well? Because the only reason that we had such success at the Green Room 42 concerts was because you, Marc Tumminelli, have been my director, and I'm so excited to reunite with you for this.
[3:31] Marc Tumminelli: What a dream. Well, I'm really excited about it too. You're brilliant on stage. Your voice is ridiculous, but you're also like the funniest little storyteller. And you seem like you're having the best time when you're doing this kind of solo show work. And it's like a little bit infectious.
[3:48] Erika Henningsen: So uh what have you found sort of doing this cabaret after doing so many years on Broadway, kind of having this kind of freedom?
[3:55] Erika Henningsen: I think the reason I wanted to do it was I obviously I think we all missed live theater this year, but I missed the most the singing of it. I didn't necessarily miss playing a character because I feel like I've played a character for so long. I was excited to just introduce myself. And I think the thing that I've found the most is that I have many different sides to my personality. And I think for a while, I was kind of only putting forth one, especially when I was doing a show because it was just I am the actor who is fun and easy to work with. And that is certainly the case, but I have a bunch of other weird idiosyncrasies that have been in the context of an hour-long cabaret where it's just me, those things get to come out for better or for worse.
[4:40] Marc Tumminelli: For better for me, I'm sure sometimes the audience is like, oh, this girl's a whack job.
[4:43] Erika Henningsen: No, they like love it. We had so many students at Broadway Workshop who had seen the Green Room show, and they were just like, that was like the best night. It's also like a really fun night out because you're having a good time and we're having a good time on stage.
[4:56] Marc Tumminelli: It's you're brilliant. So I'm excited about this new show at Chelsea Table and Stage, which I've actually never even been to. Have you done anything there?
[5:04] Erika Henningsen: It's a new, it's a new, new-ish venue. And what's fun is that on obviously for throughout most of the week it's like instrumentalists and jazz musicians um and pop. So you never know. Maybe I'll throw some of that in there. So on Sunday nights, it's the Broadway guest artists, and I'm going in on September 19th with Mary Mitchell Campbell, and we'll be there for you know an hour, 75 minutes. Who knows? Maybe I'll talk a little bit.
[5:29] Erika Henningsen: Yeah, three hours. Maybe I'll also be there if you're looking to meet me.
[5:33] Marc Tumminelli: Um you can't. You're singing in it. Are you ready?
[5:36] Erika Henningsen: No, I'm not. Um okay. So you can go to Chelsea Table and Stage.com to get your tickets for this new show. And we can't wait to see it. It's gonna be so great. Um, it's also a big room, so come on out, friends.
[5:49] Erika Henningsen: Yeah, I think it's like 250 seats. It's kind of one of the bigger cabaret venues that I've gotten to do. So let's hope it's good.
[5:56] Marc Tumminelli: Segway nicely going back to talk about your youth because you're touching down on a lot of the music that you loved as a kid. Tell me how you were first exposed to the sort of musical theater at Broadway. How did this world come to you?
[6:06] Erika Henningsen: Yes, it was all through my grandparents, specifically my grandmother, because she shared all the sort of Judy Garland classics, uh, Meet Me in St. Louis, obviously Somewhere Over the Rainbow. Uh Judy also had at that point, I think she had done one concert at Carnegie Hall that was taped, and so she shared that with me. And then it was sort of the MGM movie musicals. Uh Oklahoma, Brigadoon. Uh, and I feel like that was the first musical taste that I ever formed. Obviously, it came to me through my grandparents, but it was the first thing that I watched going, oh, I like this, I individually like this, not just I like this because uh my family likes this and I'm just jumping on board. It was something that she and I shared together. And then ultimately I shared with my mom. Um, going back to like the black and white um Fred and Ginger movies as well. So it was kind of the first jumping off point for my musical lineage.
[7:07] Marc Tumminelli: What was your favorite thing? Like what thing did you want to watch over and over again?
[7:11] Erika Henningsen: I watched Wizard of Oz over and over again. I really loved, I loved Meet Me in St. Louis, but specifically, I would rewatch The Boy Next Door, that song. Just oh, you just wanted to be longing for something at eight or seven years old.
[7:21] Marc Tumminelli: Eight or seven years old. Like I don't actually remember what happens at the end of Meet Me in St. Louis, but I remember that.
[7:32] Erika Henningsen: It all works out, I think. I think it probably all works out. Um, and then of course, we've talked about this. I was really obsessed. This is where it kind of took a turn was I was really obsessed with the um Joseph starring Donny Osmond, which was that was when I started to get into musical theater just in any format whatsoever. Like the recording of Company was something I loved when I was a teenager, that cast recording that they did, um, the documentary of that. So it kind of extrapolated from there.
[8:01] Marc Tumminelli: Okay. Tell me about the turkey shot out of the oven.
[8:05] Erika Henningsen: Oh my gosh, where did you find that?
[8:07] Marc Tumminelli: It's on your Wikipedia page.
[8:09] Erika Henningsen: No, it's not.
[8:11] Marc Tumminelli: I don't know who's in charge of Wikipedia, but it is very helpful when you're doing a podcast.
[8:16] Erika Henningsen: That is so funny. Okay, I can literally recite the entire monologue poem for you there right now. Um, it's a Shel Silverstein poem, I think. And I did it in my first acting class ever was like a summer camp program. And I had done sports until I was seven, and then I think my mom just kind of realized none of those are really sticking. So they started putting me into um summer classes, like theater classes. And I had this incredible teacher, Janly Marshall, who truly, I mean, when I think of your students, Marc, that you've had, it's like she did for me what you do for those students, where it's just like she just made it so uh just everybody was there to express and have fun, but she also treated you like an adult, and it didn't feel like you were going to like kids' stuff.
It really felt like, oh no, I'm gonna make you learn, and you're gonna have an opinion on this craft. But obviously at age eight, I was brand new. And so I got this monologue, the turkey shot out of the oven, and ricocheted. I can do it for you right now if you want to do it.
[9:20] Erika Henningsen: Okay, I will do as much as I can. The turkey shot out of the oven and ricocheted into the air. It partly demolished a table and almost overturned a chair. It ricocheted into the corner and burst with a deafening boom, then scattered all over the kitchen, completely obscuring the room. There was turkey on the walls and the windows, it even coated the floor. There was even turkey on the ceiling where there had never been turkey before.
[9:44] Marc Tumminelli: We'll take it.
[9:45] Erika Henningsen: We'll take it.
[9:46] Marc Tumminelli: We'd like to see you at three to dance.
[9:48] Erika Henningsen: Um, so you did the turkey shot out of the oven in summer camp or whatever that was.
[9:55] Erika Henningsen: And uh first taste. It was just the first taste of making people laugh. I don't even remember if they were laughing at the text. I don't I think they were probably laughing at me for like how into it I was. But it was just the first, it was the first time I had ever been on a stage alone saying something that was entertaining in some regard.
[10:17] Marc Tumminelli: When were you first like in a stage musical where you were like, you know, and had an overture or something?
[10:23] Erika Henningsen: I did that wasn't a school play because I did school plays.
[10:29] Marc Tumminelli: Well, we'll take the school play. What was the first school play?
[10:30] Erika Henningsen: The first school play was Oliver and I was Oliver.
[10:35] Marc Tumminelli: Oh, the titular character.
[10:37] Erika Henningsen: The titular character. I played a lot of young boys um up until I was 15. And um the titular character.
[10:45] Marc Tumminelli: First of all, though, Oliver's like not the most fun. I don't think people realize that until you're playing Oliver and realize it's way more fun to be the Artful Dodger or Fagin.
[10:54] Erika Henningsen: Yeah.
[10:55] Marc Tumminelli: As a person who spent a lot of their career playing the Artful Dodger, I can tell you.
[11:01] Erika Henningsen: I mean, not all if he does end some. Like I did it so many times, Erika. That was my whole thing.
[11:05] Marc Tumminelli: You would have been, should we do an adult version of Oliver?
[11:10] Erika Henningsen: No, because it's so long.
[11:11] Marc Tumminelli: It's three hours long. It's the you know what you forget about Oliver, that there's like the Widow Corney and like all these other characters, Mr. Bumble, where you're like, oh my God.
[11:22] Erika Henningsen: And that's why the audience loves Dodger so much, is because he comes in 40 minutes into the show and changes and makes it fun for the next half hour.
[11:29] Marc Tumminelli: And so everyone loves him. It's so fun to do that. And you don't have to get ready until the play's already been going on for 20 minutes before you have to get dressed.
[11:36] Erika Henningsen: It's a dream.
[11:37] Marc Tumminelli: Dreams. I've never been in a show like that. I'm always the person who has to be ready to go, right at the top. Christian Borle used to say that all the time about Legally Blonde was like the best job because he didn't have to get ready until 20 minutes in or whatever it was.
[11:52] Erika Henningsen: Dreams to watch movies.
[11:52] Marc Tumminelli: So back to Oliver. So you played Oliver. So obviously, someone was like, This girl can sing.
[11:59] Erika Henningsen: Yeah, I think it was. I think the thing that was available to me when I was younger was um, should I pause for these church bells that are about to go off?
[12:07] Marc Tumminelli: No, I think it's really, I think it really sets the army up.
[12:09] Erika Henningsen: Okay, great. I live in a church.
[12:10] Marc Tumminelli: She's lives in a convent.
[12:12] Erika Henningsen: I'm doing a Sound of Music movie, and I'm going really method. Um, I was in choir. So that was kind of the thing that was available to me. And um, I can't believe Joseph just has like a through line in life because I've never told you this, but like I was in the San Francisco Girls Chorus, which was kind of how I started to learn how to sing, which is how I started to learn how to be on pitch. And they had us sing an audition song for that, and like these girls knew we were in choir, so they were going to audition with like choir songs and Italian arias or just art songs. And I didn't really understand that because I didn't listen to that music. So I came in with a flash of drums, a crash of light, my golden coat flew out of sight, and like sang the entirety of that song for my choir audition.
Um, but that was like the first moment that I realized oh, there's a place to sing I can sing and I should. And I liked doing it. I didn't, I was not like um, and I guess this is maybe the difference between a lot of the guests you've had. I was not like a Broadway kid. I didn't have those aspirations. I just had the hobbies that I started to do after school, were more and more geared towards performing and singing in choir and dance classes.
[13:26] Marc Tumminelli: And what were you doing? Like your when you were in high school, did you do your high school musicals like every year?
[13:30] Erika Henningsen: Yeah, and that was basically it. The first I did my high school musicals every year.
[13:33] Erika Henningsen: There was a what were they? I'm always fast. It's my favorite fresh. Um, well, freshman year it was Hello Dolly, and I was a freshman, so I was, you know, in the ensemble, which was amazing. And then sophomore year was Oklahoma. I don't think I did that one for some reason. I think I was like trying to become a swimmer again, and it didn't go so well. So I was swimming that year, and then I did Drowning. Go ahead. By swimming, I mean drowning. Um, but really though, I was like in the last heat, but there was like only one other person with me, and I was like, I should not be doing this anymore. Um okay, wait, so Oklahoma, and then my junior year was that was like the thing that changed everything.
I did Beauty and the Beast, and I got to be Belle. And then my senior year, we did Titanic, which was kind of funky. And I played um Kate. No, that's what I thought I was gonna play. The other person, um, Alice Bean. Oh, yeah. Who sings like the really project that her second wife? Oh, yeah, yeah. And then she has a really fun song at the top of that, too. I just can't remember it. It's like I mean, there's not that many fun things that are happening. Oh, because she goes into dress in your pajamas in the Grand Salon, and then she comes in. Yeah, what's the song? She's so excited, but it's not really a song. Yeah, it's more like a dance number that she's kind of yelling throughout. It reminds me a lot of like the revolutionary costume of today from Grey Gardens, where it's like this one like moment of levity as the entire boat, everyone's gonna die. Exactly. Just uh 1,500 people are about to die. But no, I do love Titanic. But keep dancing. Keep dancing until the last moment.
[15:04] Marc Tumminelli: Okay. So you got to do these two shows, and then was there a conversation with your parents? Like, this is what I'm going to do. And were they supportive, not supportive? Like, how did you make the decision that you would go to college for musical theater having not really been like a kid who was like wildly obsessed, meaning that you went from one production of Annie to the next?
[15:24] Erika Henningsen: Oh, right, correct. Um, I think it was when I figured out that there even was college musical theater programs, is when I kind of thought, like, oh, I that's that's what you I shouldn't say that's what you do, but for me it made sense because I thought I don't understand how you get from being in your high school musicals to being on Broadway. I didn't understand like how do you bridge that gap? And I had sort of a uh older friend and a mentor, my friend Laura Reed growing up, who was like in all these community theater productions with me. She went to a high school nearby. We just kind of grew up together, and she was two years older, and she went to University of Michigan for musical theater before I did.
And that was sort of my first portal into the idea of like, oh, there's a place that is going to teach me how to do this at a professional level, not just a hobby level. And I think what happened with my parents was I essentially kind of made a deal with them where I said, like, I have three schools I really, really want to go to. I'd be happy going to any of them. If I don't get into any of them, I'll go to, I think at that point I had heard back from Boston College, um, where I had like applied really early to Boston College. I said, I'll go there for liberal arts, like I'll do something else. And I think they I mean, I think they would have supported any choice, but that was kind of the limit that I put on myself, which was I I know I really want to do this, so I want to go somewhere that's gonna take it really, really seriously.
And um, where I had done a lot of research on these places already. And that was sort of the the turning point was honestly that junior year high school production, realizing like, oh, I can do this and I should do this, and then tying it together with the idea of college being the next step, which is not the next step for everybody, but it wasn't.
[17:08] Marc Tumminelli: And you knew a lot about musicals, partly because your mother’s CD binder.
[17:13] Erika Henningsen: Oh my gosh. Which we do talk about in your solo show, but tell the people tell your tell the people about your mother's CD binder.
[17:20] Erika Henningsen: Oh my gosh. Okay, you could basically like, I feel like this seed, it sounds like we're saying CD, like like um salacious. Uh compact disc binder. Yeah. Those things that you would like stick into like a boom box or a Walkman or a Discman, whatever it's like. In your car. In your car. And that's where we had it. We had it in our car. It's like the size, it it's literally like the size of um, it weighs about 15 pounds. I kid you not, you could like do like light Peloton exercises with it. Um, and it's basically this alphabetized binder that my mom started creating of every single musical theater cast album that she liked or she thought I would like. So it started like started with Annie, and then I remember the last one was Zorba, and we never really listened to Zorba because not a ton of good chestnuts on that.
There is, there is, trust me. Is there? Wow. There is. Give it a listen. I'll I'll pull it out. I have it here. And um, my I mean, when you grow up in California, you drive everywhere. I grew up um outside San Francisco, and I was driving into San Francisco for dance classes and voice lessons. So we were in the car sometimes for like two hours a day between getting to school and then going to whatever extracurricular activity I had. And that's when my mom started creating this binder, and we would listen to literally every single musical. I she really loves Jacques Brel's. Because that was the musical she did or she did in high school, and then she also loved You're a Goodman Charlie Brown because she played Lucy.
Um, which is kind of like all I know about my mom's high school musical theater career. But those were two that we listened to a ton, and then we started filling it in with, you know, the more cutting edge things like Wicked. Ooh, wicked Wicked.
[19:01] Marc Tumminelli: Okay. So you get into the University of Michigan, which is a very actually difficult school to get into for musical theater.
[19:07] Erika Henningsen: Yeah.
[19:08] Marc Tumminelli: So bravo. Um, and obviously it seems like you had a pretty incredible experience there, and it really kind of prepped you for your career and also made connections for you to really kind of get it started. What would you say was like the biggest takeaway of your four years there? Because I want to obviously talk about you putting it all to actual good use after it.
[19:29] Erika Henningsen: But yeah, you mean my takeaway is like a student artist?
[19:32] Marc Tumminelli: Yeah, as a student, like what did what did that program give you that you think maybe another program wouldn't have, or how were you super prepared to like go out and do this career?
[19:40] Erika Henningsen: Yeah, I honestly think it gave me a work ethic. Like I um, and and this is why I I don't always think college is for everybody, but for me, it gave me sort of a container to figure out how do you do this at a professional level. And the answer for me, or the one that that they provided was like a ton of research and a ton of um curiosity about the field in general. I feel like sometimes I think there is a beautiful emphasis being placed now on sort of like the individual and like what do you bring to it and just kind of go in there and do your thing. And Michigan provided a lot of structure and like there's a history here that you need to know and respect in order to figure out how to do it.
It's like the same way doctors have to go to med school and have their um uh uh residencies in every single facet of medicine before they have their specific practice. And so that's what I liked about it. It's like I felt like I walked away knowing how I would audition for singing in the rain and then how I would audition for something like Jagged Little Pill. Um, because they they made sure that you understood where musical theater came from and where it was ultimately going and how they're both intrinsically linked. Um, and they just made you work like they made you be students of the craft, not just talented people who happened to do it.
[21:01] Marc Tumminelli: No, when you yeah, it makes a lot of sense. When you go to school with a level of people who are equally obsessed and have worked really hard, and obviously at the top of their high school program or whatever, because it's really the best of the best. I imagine that there's a lot of stress being around how many kids were in your class.
[21:19] Erika Henningsen: Uh 24.
[21:20] Marc Tumminelli: So 24 kids that all want it as much as you do, and all have the drive and are all doing that, mostly doing the amount of work. You know, I imagine that that's like a weird place to cook.
[21:27] Erika Henningsen: Yes.
[21:31] Erika Henningsen: Yeah, a very weird place to cook.
[21:33] Erika Henningsen: It's a weird place to cook because they also are your best friends. So it's like this weird thing where you're like, I am going into class with people I really love and care for, and then also grappling with this uh feeling of comparison because how could you not? These really talented people are right next to you. And also the thing that was so clear to me is that everybody grows differently. It's like there were classmates I had who freshman and sophomore year, you were kind of like, I don't know, they're like not getting it, or they're not moving forward, and then junior year they just exploded, and that might have been the time that I was getting stuck in kind of doing one thing the same way over and over, and it took me to get over that hump.
So that was the thing that in hindsight I get now. Like everybody grows at a different rate. But at the time, if you were in a place of um, you know, maybe your voice was changing or adapting or adjusting to a new sound, like an adult sound, or if you were a dancer, maybe you were not picking up on things as quickly as you were right when you entered. So that was interesting to watch. It's like I feel like I went in and out of waves of feeling like I'm on top of the world, I'm nailing this, I'm getting it, and then moments where inevitably you're you're growing at a slower rate, or it feels slower in comparison to other people. But it's just because we're all on sort of different wavelengths throughout those four years, and then obviously, as when you graduate, that's the same same thing happens.
[22:57] Marc Tumminelli: Um let's talk about you graduating. What was the first big job you booked?
[23:01] Erika Henningsen: Um, the first big job I booked was this was the first one.
[23:08] Erika Henningsen: Yeah. Thank you, Craig Burns. If I don't know, does Craig Burns listen to this?
[23:11] Marc Tumminelli: I think he might actually.
[23:13] Erika Henningsen: I think he might. I hope well I'll tell him to listen to this one. He cast me in the New York Philharmonic was doing a uh orchestrated live performance of Showboat in its entirety, which like I don't the last time Showboat was done in entirety was I don't know, the 50s.
[23:28] Erika Henningsen: Okay, I have no idea. Um, at least in New York. And it was there's uh a part, the main character has a daughter. She doesn't really come out to the end. This was the only time that I had the Christian Borrell track. I didn't come on until literally it's a three hour show. I came in at two and a half. And um, I sang this like one really fun song and got to dance with two of the most incredible dancers to this day. I'm so happy I did that when I was 21 because I think I was afraid of nothing at that age, but now it would terrify me to dance with the two gentlemen that I got to dance with on the uh symphonic stage with the New York Phil. And um, that was my first big job. And it's also how I got my equity card, which I showed up on the first day, and they said, if you're not equity, you need to leave the room.
And I literally, in this large cast, I was so young, I was the only non equity member, and I walked out and they said, Okay, great, you have to fill out this page right now, and you're gonna join the union today. And that is not how it happens for a lot of people. And I'm just like, I'm so lucky, and I don't know if I've ever said this to Craig Burns, and it's like I got my equity card doing that, doing this concert production.
[24:37] Marc Tumminelli: Yeah, most of us get it like making $200 a week at a theater that's gonna beast.
[24:41] Erika Henningsen: Exactly. Exactly. And it's just like it's just how I got mine.
[24:45] Erika Henningsen: There you go. I thought I was gonna get mine doing all those wagon wheel shows, but I never got enough points.
[24:50] Marc Tumminelli: Well, now you just have to show up and say, I'd like to be, I like to try.
[24:54] Erika Henningsen: And then they um I used to know. I'm gonna tell you a funny quick story.
[24:58] Erika Henningsen: I hear it. I used to work at the Lion King, as we know. And I part of that wasn't part of my job, but I used to walk CD La Loca home after the show. She's the original Rafiki. And one night she looked at the rent marquee and went, Rent. I like to try. She wanted to try to be in rent.
[25:14] Marc Tumminelli: Oh god, I loved her.
[25:15] Erika Henningsen: And then we'd stop and get microwave popcorn, and I dropped her off her apartment at the Camelot. And I did that every night for like a year.
[25:23] Marc Tumminelli: Dream of dreams. Was that your like survival? Like, I wish I had worked. I worked in a gym for my survival job. I didn't work in anything like artistic.
[25:29] Erika Henningsen: I ushered on Broadway for a long time.
[25:33] Marc Tumminelli: And it was like it was, it was a trip. It actually was so fun at the beginning. And then at one night I had a nervous breakdown when the elephant was coming down the aisle. I just started crying, and I went down to my boss's office. I was like, I can't watch this anymore. Um I have to go home. Not like I can't usher, it's like I literally just can't watch Lion King anymore.
[25:48] Erika Henningsen: This show anymore.
[25:48] Erika Henningsen: I have to go home. I have to go home.
[25:58] Marc Tumminelli: Because Disney makes you watch.
[25:59] Erika Henningsen: You have to stand in the back like you're in the army with the flashlight, and um you have to really watch the lion. It's like some sort of weird torture.
[26:06] Marc Tumminelli: Um but it was cool.
[26:08] Erika Henningsen: I mean, whatever.
[26:09] Marc Tumminelli: Okay. Um, so back to you.
[26:11] Marc Tumminelli: So Showboat also filmed for television.
[26:14] Erika Henningsen: I mean, that's a very cool thing.
[26:16] Erika Henningsen: Another cool thing. First job on the television.
[26:19] Erika Henningsen: I know, and I'm so happy. That's what I mean by it's like I really admire these young people who come out because, like, because I felt it too. I was so fearless. I didn't know what to be afraid of. Like it didn't occur to me that like this is going live on PBS. So if you F this up, like it will be on video forever. I just didn't, I'm sure in the back of my head I knew that, but I didn't understand what a big deal that could be because I was so young. So I just kind of dove in at first.
[26:46] Erika Henningsen: Um, and it's very cool. I watched it. It was like, I mean, I watched to report it and watched the whole thing.
[26:51] Marc Tumminelli: Um, I don't have three and a half hours.
[26:53] Erika Henningsen: I was gonna say speaking of three and a half hours, you made your Broadway debut in Les Misérables. How long after that first big job of getting to do, because it wasn't that long after doing Showboat, what kind of was happening for you.
[27:09] Erika Henningsen: Um, you're gonna hear my convent bells. It's um 11 a.m. So it's gonna be 11 of them. So just enjoy counting that. Um okay, so I did Show Boat. I got to do um a show out of town. I got to do Diner out of town, and that was the first time that I'm gonna do it. This is the beginning of the Diner long story about Diner. Yes. So we'll talk about Diner before we go to Les Mis.
[27:27] Marc Tumminelli: So you get you book uh Diner, which is Sheryl Crow is writing the musical version of this movie, and it just seems like this is a no way that this is not coming to Broadway.
[27:40] Erika Henningsen: Yeah, directed by Kathleen Marshall, Kathleen Marshall, who is a gem. Um, Barry Levinson was who was the original screenwriter, was still involved in sort of the libretto of it. And it had, you know, like amazing people. We had like Matthew James Thomas, Derek Klena was in that. Um, Breno Malley and Whitney Bashor uh were two of the leading women in various permutations. So it was just like Dream of Dreams, these incredible people. And a really fun show, I thought. And then, of course, you know, as is always the case that happens with an out-of-town show, we think it's amazing. And in a way, it was very special. And to this day, like the music, I just want Sheryl Crow to record the music because it's so good.
But it didn't land for the audience in terms of maybe the story. I'm not sure if it was a sign of the times. It was a story from the 50s, and it was kind of nostalgic in a way that was beautiful, but was really right for people of that era. And trying to update it made it something that it wasn't. And I think that was sort of the problem. And I find that's the problem with a lot of these movies from that era. They were created in a specific time. So to update them, you're not doing the story that made it so successful. And then people can sense that discord if they're a young audience member. And then if they're an older audience member who loved the original, they're disappointed because you've messed with their memory and you've messed with their nostalgia.
Um which is why to me the music of it is so beautiful and should be heard. And but the overarching nugget, I think, didn't quite land the mark because it was trying to be something that it just couldn't.
[29:21] Marc Tumminelli: Did it feel heartbreaking to you that that didn't have a bigger life or that you didn't get to do it in New York?
[29:27] Erika Henningsen: Yeah, it's heartbreaking. I mean, it's heartbreaking. I think actors are so used to that. So like my heartbreaks more for the people who really brought it. I mean, the actors, of course, brought it to life, but we move on to something else. Like, I really do my heartbreaks for Sheryl Crow. Because I just think, you know, Barry Levinson had written this movie um a while ago. So he like it. He was detached in some way.
[29:50] Marc Tumminelli: Exactly.
[29:50] Erika Henningsen: And she had been living in it, writing it. Exactly. And she had been writing it, creating it. Um, and it was like her baby, and she did such a beautiful job in a way that I don't think people expected her to do. Like, it doesn't sound like Sheryl Crow's music. She wrote something that was so iconically um 50s, like it sounds right for the era. It doesn't sound like, whoa, this is a period piece, and now hear Sheryl Crow's voice. She wrote for these characters in a way that I don't think a lot of pop writers do on Broadway. It's like she found the sound for an ensemble cast of I mean, there were like eight leads. So my heartbreaks for that, but it was kind of the first lesson for me, and I'm so happy I had it.
Like, if it all if it had all gone swimmingly, you know, I think it would have been such a shocking reality for me down the road when things inevitably don't work out like that. And that was kind of my first exposure to it, and it was my second job. And then I didn't know. Hopefully, it'll come back around in some.
[30:48] Marc Tumminelli: I hope so.
[30:49] Erika Henningsen: I truly think I just want to do maybe I'll just like write somebody and be like, yo, we have to host this concert. We need to do this. I'm saying it here first. All right, ooh, breaking news. All right, Les Mis, your first Broadway show. This is a pretty big deal.
[31:02] Marc Tumminelli: So this was the last revival of Les Mis.
[31:05] Erika Henningsen: Casey Levy was leaving because she was about to give birth.
[31:09] Marc Tumminelli: Oh, right, right.
[31:11] Erika Henningsen: She's like very pregnant in a lot of that, which is actually kind of not a terrible thing.
[31:11] Marc Tumminelli: Not a terrible thing, a little scary though, because it's like you get tossed around.
[31:21] Erika Henningsen: I mean, yeah, I got really beat up. So tell me about auditioning because the show that you not think a 20. How old were you at this point?
[31:29] Marc Tumminelli: 23, 22.
[31:30] Erika Henningsen: So 23 year old is not normally playing Fantine.
[31:33] Marc Tumminelli: No, they missed so um when you first had that audition appointment, were you like, is this I'm probably more of an Eponine and Cosette, maybe.
[31:41] Erika Henningsen: Yeah, I think I reached out to sort of my mentor at the time who worked in casting, and I was like, um, I got the audition when I was down in DC doing Diner, and it would have meant coming up on my day off to audition. And I think I was already so overwhelmed with putting up a new show and being as young as I was. And I just thought, you know, I don't know, I don't know if I'm right for this. I don't know if I should go in for Fantine. It just feels like such a pipe dream. And she basically said, like, they wouldn't call you in if they didn't think you could do it. And at that point, I had already auditioned for Cosette. And I thought that was the role that I was maybe more right for, and I didn't get called back.
So it was this moment where I thought, like, just trust. Just you wouldn't be there if you didn't, if they didn't think you could in some capacity do this, and they've already seen you perform one thing and decided it wasn't it. So I took a train in um we're gonna get honest on this. I was like in the midst of like such a tumultuous like love heartbreak moment whilst doing that show in DC. And I came up on my day off and like was by myself in the city and it was pouring down rain, and I had like five hours of sleep to catch my train, and then I went in that way to do Les Mis, which is probably perfect. And I like sang about this person that I was feeling heartbroken over, and was looked just a sight um straight from the Penn Station swamp.
Um, and that was my audition, and I sang it once, and then I went outside and they said, Can you come back later this afternoon? We just want to film you singing it because they were going to send that to Cameron Mackintosh. So my callback was that was the same day. So I came back, I did it. Um, and fun fact, two fun facts, actually. Les Mis Fantine was the last role I did in college. I was um in our college spring production of Les Mis. I got to play Fantine. So that was like this moment where it's like, this is crazy. And then the second thing was at that point I knew that Ramin Karimloo was going to be uh Jean Valjean still in the he was still he was staying even as other people were leaving. And he was one of the first people I checked in to the Columbus Circle Equinox that I worked at.
[32:11] Marc Tumminelli: Your survival job.
[32:11] Erika Henningsen: My survival job. So it really was this moment where I was like, this would be so full circle in many ways if I got this. Um, and I came back, I taped for Cameron, I went back to DC, I finished out the run of Diner, and on like a beautiful snowstorm day in December, I got the call eventually that I was going to be playing it, making my Broadway debut.
[34:13] Marc Tumminelli: I'm sure who'd you call for? Who's the first person you called?
[34:15] Erika Henningsen: My mom. I definitely called my mom first. And then I called my sisters, and then I walked to the theater because I lived in Midtown at that time. So then I walked to the Imperial.
[34:25] Marc Tumminelli: You're like, I this is I'm coming here.
[34:28] Erika Henningsen: I'm going to there. I'm going to go to there. What do you remember about your uh first opening night performance on Broadway?
[34:35] Erika Henningsen: Literally nothing. I blacked out. I really like it. Everybody who's ever done Les Mis really does black out because there's so much to think about. Oh, there's no turntable in this one, but there's no turntable, but like it's just it's so big. It's like, again, it's this thing where I'm like, I don't think I understood how big I was obviously so grateful and excited to be there, but I don't think I understood how big of a thing I was joining. And I think if I had, I would have never not left my dressing room. I would have been paralyzed. Cause it's just insane what that show is and means to people. And also, I mean, Fantine is the best track, a little bit. It's the opposite, because you can knock it all out at the top and then just kind of have fun for the rest of the night. You get her done.
[35:15] Marc Tumminelli: Yeah, you get her done. There's some interview. I think it's like with Richie Ridge of our opening night or like that cast opening night party. And like I'm not blinking. My eyes are like wide open. Like I look fully deranged because I just think it was so much stimulation and dreams coming true happening at once in this like never before imagined way. I never thought that that would be my Broadway debut. It's just like I still don't quite, it feels like a different person when I think about it because it's just so bizarre.
[35:45] Marc Tumminelli: Now, how do you at 23 make your Fantine different than Casey's or Randy Graf on the album or any of the women who've done it and it's been filmed?
[35:55] Erika Henningsen: Um, how did how did you even think about that?
[35:58] Erika Henningsen: Well, I'm happy you asked that because I don't think I did. And I think that's why I would love to do it again. Okay, great. Because at age 23, feeling so young and and not not quite trusting myself yet, but not even being aware that I was doing that. Like, I just think I did like a hybrid version of um, I mimicked other people's. Like I created something that didn't quite come from me. It came from me emotionally, but in terms of what it sounded like, I think I was trying to replicate things I had heard on cast albums and in live studio concert versions of it. Um that's you know, that was such a big learning tool. Cause I remember we had one rehearsal with Cameron at one point, like three months into the run, and he called us all in to sing our songs for him, and he kind of stopped me halfway through, and he was like, Well, what is what's your voice?
Like, can you just sing something you like for me? And it was really, and at the time I really didn't understand, I think I panicked and I didn't quite understand what he meant, but I see now what he was getting at, where he was like, I you are a good singer, but I want to hear you sing. I don't want to hear your idea of what Fantine sounds like. Um, and I hope to, you know, do that role again one day. Cause I think I've I think it was just for what I what my age was at the time, I'm proud of it. But looking back on it now, I'm like, oh, I did not trust myself as much as I should have to create my own version. But I think it's pretty incredible to just even do it at that age and do it and do it when I'm gonna do it.
[37:31] Marc Tumminelli: And to do it, yeah. I that's saying I'm like, I'm so proud of that version and that young person who did it. Um and it's really it's one of those things where it's like just as an actor, you're just never done. It's like as soon as you leave a show, and you're gonna be a good thing.
[37:46] Erika Henningsen: Exactly. Let's talk about the role that sort of has made you uh Instagram famous, and also like teenage girls and many boys um around the world sort of falling in love with you, which is playing Cady Heron in Mean Girls, which kind of almost didn't happen. Are we allowed to talk about that?
[38:01] Erika Henningsen: Oh my god, I love talking about it. It's my favorite thing. So tell us how that almost didn't happen.
[38:08] Erika Henningsen: Not to bring in Sound of Music once again, but when what is the saying? It's like when God closes a door, opens a window.
[38:15] Marc Tumminelli: That's the one.
[38:15] Erika Henningsen: I know they say that in Mame, but I don't know.
[38:18] Marc Tumminelli: They also okay, scratch that.
[38:21] Erika Henningsen: This is a Mean Girls story. Dear God. Everyone just like turned off their podcast. And now they're going to go listen to Mame.
[38:31] Erika Henningsen: Um, what happened? Yes, I auditioned for I like I like telling a story because of two reasons. One was that I was certain I was going to be Anna in Frozen on Broadway. I was like, that is me. I am she, it will be me. And I got very, very close in the audition process. Uh, like I remember this is also what's so crazy because Casey Levy was who I replaced in Les Mis. At my final audition for Frozen, they had us do it on a theater because on a theatrical stage, because they're British and do those things. And um, or Michael was, and they brought Casey out. They knew she was going to be Elsa, and they had Casey sing with the Annas. And it was just like insane to be looking at her. I was like, you are my older, like I like it was just such a weird, crazy moment.
And obviously, that was not the show that ended up being the the thing for me. And um, as soon as Mean Girls did work out, it it was just so clear why. So I just shared that story because it's like you just don't know what is for you. And I promise, if it is for you, it it won't pass you by. Um so when Mean Girls came along, I was so bummed because I was like, I don't know about this. I felt like Frozen was my bag. I thought that was gonna be the thing. And I went in for Mean Girls and ended up getting really excited about it because the team was so amazing and the music was really funky and cool, and it was kind of stuff I hadn't heard before. And for the lab production, when the lab is essentially um a version that you do in a studio in New York, usually that has limited band but fully blocked and realized, in the sense that full production numbers, everything is as close as it could be without a set and costumes and lighting.
And the lab cast is oftentimes close to who they might end up bringing to do it out of town and then ultimately on Broadway. So it's a big deal to audition for the lab. And I got down to me and one other uh wonderful actress, and I didn't get it. And that moment when getting really close again, and this all happened within the same month, was kind of like it did not, we get rejected all the time.
[40:40] Erika Henningsen: It did not break me in any way, but it did make me just think like, well, what am I doing wrong? Like I must be doing something wrong. Because how can I keep getting so close for things that I feel like I'm really right for and not getting it? And then I put it out of my mind for three months. They did the lab. And then they called me back in for the out-of-town tryout. And usually what that means is just whatever puzzle they had created in the lab, they needed a new puzzle. They were like, we need to rearrange the pieces. Something is just not fitting together. It's not because things aren't working, it's just it's not fitting. But does that make you think like, well, you didn't want me the last time, why would you want me this time?
[41:21] Yeah, exactly. And I think that is honestly the reason I ended up doing okay in those auditions and getting it, because I'd already been rejected once. I'd already lost it and put these people and this project out of my mind because that's the only thing you can do when you get rejected from something you really wanted. And so when I went back in, I just thought I have nothing to lose. I have literally nothing to lose. I've already lost it. So let me just go in. And instead of trying to be the girl, because they've seen me do this so many times, I'm just going to be me. Because I don't even, they don't know what the girl is. That's why I'm back again. They don't know what they want. So all I have to do is just figure out how I would tell this story.
And that was the biggest shift because that's the difference between even how I auditioned for Les Mis, which was I had an idea of what Fantine should be, so I did that. I had an idea of what Cady should be in round one, so I did that. And it wasn't until I got brought back for round two that I thought nobody knows what this should be because they already saw me do it and they didn't want it, and now they're having me back.
[42:24] So it's like clearly nobody knows. So you just have to do what feels authentic to you. It worked out. And it worked out. And they cast you. And they cast it. And I swear, it's like it's those moments where you kind of relinquish control or trying to do it right is when anything happens. Obviously I'm working on that, but creating a new musical feels like it might be the most stressful thing in the world. How did you sort of deal with the process of the changes and figuring out who this character was and getting information from so many different departments about who Cady Heron is and how do you meet her? How do you meet that in the middle?
[43:05] I think it was like the constant battle. It was like every day of rehearsal was trying to figure out if you're getting one note from Tina and then another note from Casey. It wasn't that they were in conflict with one another, it's that they're shaping the story in different ways. Casey was shaping it really visually, and Tina's a writer, she sees the words on the page. And so it's trying to figure out how do I, how do I my job is to help these people bring their vision to life, and then to also have my own stamp on it. And in terms of the changes, I think something, I don't know if my brain will ever be able to do it again, but I think something just happened where I was like, my only all my focus was on that. Like there was no, and I think that's also what allowed me to not get overwhelmed is because there was so much to think about. I never worried about there wasn't room to second guess things.
[44:10] You just had to do it. Yeah. And I think that is kind of a joy of creating something new, especially if you're a part that's kind of at the epicenter of the story, where it's like there's so much that's changing around you. You don't have time to second guess yourself. You just have to jump in. My only negative thing to say about that is that sometimes that's happening so fast, you don't realize because you're so deep inside it, you don't always realize, like, oh, wait a second. If we lose this bit, then we're losing this. And that's something that like you just, you just don't know until you get on top of it. And that doesn't really happen until you've been doing it for like a month or so.
[44:49] So the role of Cady was like very enormous. I mean, it's the equivalent to Jean Valjean, but it's just in a very like sort of pink show about high school kids. So I feel like there's not enough credit for the amount of work that you had to do every night in that show. I think that there's something like, oh, it's fun, it's pink, it's light, it's high school juniors. Like, you know what I mean? It's not that, but physically and mentally, emotionally, vocally, it's the same amount of stamina it would take to, you know, do a Carolina Change. Like it honestly is like, it is like a marathon, and I don't think you got enough credit for that. And I don't know if you felt that, or I don't know how do you go to work every day being like, this is a marathon and nobody knows it but nobody knows.
[45:32] I appreciate you saying that. I think the thing that made me feel that, because those thoughts fully entered my mind, it's like, my job was to make it look easy. It's like nobody wants to go to a Broadway show and be like, whoo, that girl's working because then you're watching that. So it's like I knew, I was like, I knew I eventually figured out it was like, oh, nobody knows how hard I'm working because I'm making it look easy. And that's the point. And that means I'm succeeding. But it meant something to me when people from our industry, people like you, a teacher who came, Alex Geminiani, who was the person who had cast me in that Les Mis in college. People who said, like, you know, keep trust, trust that it's not going unnoticed. And the fact that it, the fact that it's that people maybe don't know means that you are doing a good job.
[46:21] And for me, that's the thing that like people know Broadway's hard, but I never wanted I think at a certain point my responsibility to the show superseded my desire to be acknowledged for it. And I thought that was like, and it's what I miss the most about Mean Girls and performing in general in that capacity. I don't miss the accolade or the affirmation, though, of course we all like that part if you're an actor. But I do miss the responsibility of being the lead. Not because I like being the person who's like first on the call sheet, but because carrying that show, that responsibility, I enjoyed it and I liked filling that role for my cast and for my backstage team and my stage managers.
[47:13] It was something that ultimately, I did not care if people didn't notice because I felt so fulfilled in that position. Not because of the affirmation from the audience, but because of the responsibility to my cast felt. Well, it's sort of is like being a CEO of a company. It's like how it's exactly what it was. Because, you know, and I had a friend that was in Little Night Music, and she's like, if Angela Lansbury can come to work and be in a great mood and I can't say show, so can I. You know what I mean?
[47:44] Exactly. And it's such a, it's the best thing. It's why I'm like, I loved it's so true. It's like getting to set the tone and being Tina on our first day of rehearsal, and I think it like stuck in my head somewhere. She said the fish rots from the head. It's like an old, I think it's a Greek saying. I literally say it all the time. You say it all the time. And I remember hearing that, and I was like, I was brand new. These people had already been in a lab together. So I was the new kid. I was like the full Cady Heron. And I remember hearing that and thinking like, you cannot be afraid. You cannot, you know, hold back. I was like, you have to lead. Because if you don't set the tone, then this thing is going to fall apart at the seams because there's too many personalities.
[48:22] There's too many firsts, probably debuts, first big moments of press and excitement. It's like if that overrides our job to bring this train home every night, and I'm the person who does that, then this is going to be a cluster. Deep. Also, I mean, you did incredible work in that show. And I'm so grateful for Mean Girls because we only at, you know, probably workshop, we get a show every decade that is every theater kid's obsessed with. And it's so good for business, it's so good for morale, it's so good for opportunity. And so Mean Girls was so that. And I think that was so much had to do with your what that exactly what you just said, setting that tone, and you could feel that spirit when you were watching the show.
[49:06] And I it truly was a party, and I had the best time. I saw Mean Girls more than probably anyone because I was going to all these events at the workshop. And also it's fun to see you on Broadway. You also kind of met and fell in love with your future husband, Kyle Sealig during that process. So if nothing else good came from Mean Girls, that is a very good thing. Exactly. I just watched a YouTube of your final I See Stars.
[49:36] Why? Oh my god, I like have you watched it? I watched it once, like ages ago. It's really special because you are the most wonderful human and you can feel it radiating from you as you say thank you to all of these people. Thank you for this last three years. Thank you for allowing me to do this. It was never like I'm amazed. It was so thank you. And it's to sing those, sing the lyrics of that song to those people to close out this experience, which I know because I was around, was pretty magical for you for the most part.
[50:07] Yeah. It just was really like it's a nice thing that supersedes, it's not about your last show. It's sort of about thank you for this last three years. I'm happy it comes off that way. Because I remember being really mad that I was crying because I was like, I don't want people to think that I'm crying for me, or that I'm like it I'm happy it comes off that way because that is what I remember feeling. It's just like it's so rare for a lead of a show to get to end her show by talking to her entire cast.
[50:35] Yeah, like it just doesn't happen. Normally you're talking to the audience, and I get to in that one moment, my other finally becomes instead of this nebulous thing out in the darkness of the theater, it becomes these people I'm on stage with. And I remember thinking like that's so special that I get to like say thank you to these people because they're the ones who mattered. Obviously, I was so grateful for our audience, but like that was like an overwhelming moment in the best way because it was about that. It was like saying goodbye to the team was what I was doing.
[51:05] It was very special. I'm glad it exists. I know that we don't love the YouTubing, but I'm glad it exists too. When you're like years old at the nursing home, you can be like, look at me here. I really do feel that. I was like, thank and also it's like great footage. It looks like the person's on stage with us. I literally was like, did Renee Rath bring her phone on so we didn't film this? It is sort of crazy. I get I've seen some stuff that I'm like, is this film for television? It's like gorgeous. We have to wrap up, but I'm gonna talk about Girls5eva, which I honestly was like such a romp for me.
[51:38] I thought it was so fun. That's the best word, a romp. It's a romp. So you play Young Gloria, which is Paula Pell's character as a younger performer. As part of this like 90s girl group called Girls5eva. And Sara Bareilles is the star of the show. And isn't Tina the executive producer or a producer? Yes, executive producer. And then it's a good thing you weren't a B I T C H at Mean Girls because it has really paid off for you. Yes, be nice to everybody. Be nice to everybody.
[52:05] Yeah. Tell me about sort of working on that show. And I know filming during COVID is a nightmare, but it's very, it's so cool like to be part of this all-girl TV hilariousness. Oh, it's the best. I'm so grateful that like the two really big projects, like my Broadway original was like in a cast that had six leading women, and then my TV debut was in a cast of like it's women, it's like amazing. And the women who are like the best at what they do. It's like to have Sara Bareilles and then Renee and then Busy and then Paula, you just like add it all up. You're like, these are people who the thing that they do, they're the best at it.
[52:41] So that was really fun. And an amazing like learning experience for a medium that you don't know inside and out. Yeah. A medium that I don't know inside and out, and with people who were also sort of learning. It's like Sara, I loved watching Sara because she's everywhere. But she's a great example of somebody who leads from like she if she's at the top, that fish is not gonna rot because she just leads with like such kindness. But also, she was like, it was cool to watch her take ownership of this new space. Obviously, she's like sold out concert halls for years, but it's like to be the lead of a TV sitcom thing was a new experience.
[53:21] So I learned a ton just from watching those leading women, people like Paula who have been doing it for years. She knew how to support the scene. If the scene was not about her, she was like the greatest scene partner. But then when she did have something, it was like she knew exactly how to be in the pocket and to just sort of trust the writing and herself, because the writing was so funny. Did you have conversations with Paula about how to create this character?
[53:46] Because, well, it's interesting. And this is the other news of like I didn't understand this about television. When you create a show from the ground up with a musical theater cast, you guys are there all day, every day. You're calling from nine to six, ten to six. So you see it happening. Paula and I were very rarely never on screen together because of the time difference.
[54:08] The because you play her at like 18 or 19. Yeah, exactly. And so we were never, it's like beyond the first day where I like I was kind of afraid to talk to anybody, we didn't beyond just saying hi, I watched some videos of Paula.
[54:23] Erika Henningsen: Um, but at a certain point, I remember being like, Well, I actually have no idea. I was like, that's Paula. I have no idea what she's doing with this character. And I would go on to set and just sort of like try my best, and they would give notes, and then I would take the notes. And I remember thinking, like, I have no idea if there is any connection between the two of us. I have no idea. I feel like I'm not seeing dailies of Paula. I'm never called to set the same day she is. So I have no clue if this is reading. And then seeing it come together, there's like one specific moment. Paula has a line where she goes, like, I know this feeling, it's joy. And like she like does this little like kick and like says it's joy.
And I was like, oh my God, I that is that is how I behave. So, like, it was this weird moment where you don't always know in TV because when you're the actor, you're not getting the full picture. You're only getting the picture for that day. But it made me realize, like, oh, of course, I was in the best hands of people like Meredith and Tina. Um, they were not going to lead me astray. So when I, when they said that's it, that's the take, it made me realize like, oh, they knew what they were doing. They knew that the thread was being connected, even though for me, I was like, I'm acting in a tunnel. I have no concept if this works.
[55:35] Marc Tumminelli: What can you tell us about season two? Anything?
[55:37] Erika Henningsen: Nothing else. Really, nothing, just that we have one. I just that's all I know.
[55:41] Marc Tumminelli: Well, I love that you're on television. It makes me so happy. Even if we lose you from Broadway for a minute, we'll get you back.
[55:49] Erika Henningsen: Yes.
[55:50] Marc Tumminelli: We have to do obsessed quick fire questions, and but I have to quickly talk about what a brilliant teacher you are, because that is how we sort of know each other. And you're such an amazing communicator of how to do this thing because you've been doing it and figuring it out. And I'm just so thankful that you've taught so much at Broadway Workshop. And I'm so grateful for all the teachers who taught you because you really have passed it on in the best way possible. And uh, I'm sure I mean it seems like you really love to do it.
[56:18] Erika Henningsen: I love it. I'm so grateful. I and I'm very grateful that we met all those years ago because you are like true friendship. I gotta give you like five stars for your social activism. You have this amazing platform because of Mean Girls, and you have used it, I think, in the best way possible, which was really to share what you believe is true and uh you know, educate young people about ways that they can be just better humans on Earth. And so thank you for that, Erika Henningsen.
[56:46] Erika Henningsen: Thank you.
[56:47] Marc Tumminelli: Oh, it is my it is a privilege to have people who care about what I say. If you're not following Erika, pause this, follow her and start it up because we're about to do obsessed and quickfire. So, Erika Henningsen, what are you obsessed with right now?
[57:01] Erika Henningsen: The White Lotus.
[57:02] Marc Tumminelli: So good.
[57:03] Erika Henningsen: Oh my gosh. On HBO. I'm obsessed with The White Lotus on HBO. Period. I just finished, right? I finished it, and then yesterday there was a lot of things. It's gonna be out until the second week of September, so everyone has finished it by now. But it's um it's so great. It's so good. There was a hurricane yesterday, or hurricane in air quotes and hurricane yesterday, which is in August.
[57:24] Marc Tumminelli: In August.
[57:24] Erika Henningsen: Uh, and I used that day to rewatch it again.
[57:27] Marc Tumminelli: You watched it again?
[57:28] Erika Henningsen: I watched it again because it's that good. I'm watching Enlightened now because I want to watch more Mike White things.
[57:34] Marc Tumminelli: Yeah, we're like, I feel like you and Mike White would be amazing collaborators.
[57:37] Erika Henningsen: Chuck and Buck. I used to love that movie, which is his first big movie, which you should check out. It's so weird. Um okay. My obsession this week is a podcast I listened to a couple weeks ago called The Los Feliz Murder Mansion. And it's about the history of this house where a family was tragically murdered by the father of the family, but um, the history of the house is really quite fascinating before him, after him. And it's been sort of empty for the last like 50 years. And this girl does an incredible job doing a deep dive. So Los Feliz Murder Mansion podcast. Check it out where you listen to podcasts.
[58:10] Marc Tumminelli: Okay. Here we go. The Broadway Workshop Quick Fire Questions.
[58:13] Erika Henningsen: Oh boy.
[58:14] Marc Tumminelli: These are questions that have been put together for you. And you really should just don't overthink it. Just go with it. And I think you'll have fun. First audition song.
[58:24] Erika Henningsen: Wouldn't it be lovely?
[58:24] Marc Tumminelli: First Broadway show you saw.
[58:34] Erika Henningsen: The Sound of Music National Tour.
[58:36] Marc Tumminelli: Fill in the blank. Tina Fey is the bomb.
[58:40] Erika Henningsen: Strangest stage door interaction.
[58:45] Marc Tumminelli: Strangest. Or maybe most memorable. I'll take anything.
[58:49] Erika Henningsen: Most memorable. A mother and daughter told me that they became friends through Mean Girls through listening to our songs. And I thought that's a good thing. And also I'm sure someone gave you something strange, like a strange gift in some sense.
[58:59] Erika Henningsen: Somebody gave me like their hair in like that's that's strange, Erika.
[59:04] Marc Tumminelli: Um artists you would like to work with, but you haven't.
[59:09] Erika Henningsen: Oh, uh Phoebe Waller-Bridge.
[59:11] Marc Tumminelli: What, right?
[59:12] Erika Henningsen: Um, what revival on Broadway would you like to star in? You could pick anything.
[59:16] Erika Henningsen: Um, I want to be in The Light in the Piazza, and I need Kelly O'Hara to age so she can play that part and I can play, but she's ageless. She looks like she's 35 still.
[59:27] Marc Tumminelli: Okay. Um, one thing in Mean Girls you wish did not get cut.
[59:32] Erika Henningsen: Uh, the scene with Aaron, uh, bottom of act one in his basement studying for math. It was a really beautiful reprise of "Stupid with Love," gorgeous harmonies, and like a tender moment, but it really brought the house down.
[59:47] Marc Tumminelli: So gender. Were you ever in Annie?
[59:52] Erika Henningsen: No.
[59:53] Marc Tumminelli: Um, go to album for a car trip.
[59:57] Erika Henningsen: Um, go to album for a car uh Haim's new album, Women in Business.
[1:00:02] Marc Tumminelli: Great.
[1:00:03] Erika Henningsen: Um, Erika, are you stupid with love?
[1:00:08] Erika Henningsen: Yes.
[1:00:09] Marc Tumminelli: What is your problem with the musical romance romance?
[1:00:15] Erika Henningsen: What's not my problem with the musical romance romance?
[1:00:18] Marc Tumminelli: Tell us one thing about working with Tyne Daly, which you did in Dear World at the York Theater.
[1:00:24] Erika Henningsen: Legend, legend. If she can be who she is and be in the basement of the York Theater and giving it to like sometimes we had an audience with like 25. I was like, I can do like if Tyne can do it, anybody can do anything and not complain about it. So people who complain about being in the theater world, like Tyne's a gem. She never can.
[1:00:42] Marc Tumminelli: Can you name one song in the musical Pipe Dream?
[1:00:47] Erika Henningsen: Yes. Um, uh everybody's got a home but me.
[1:00:52] Marc Tumminelli: I knew you could. Um, who's your number one favorite, probably leading man, and you can't say Kyle?
[1:00:58] Erika Henningsen: Oh, um Brian Darcy James.
[1:01:00] Marc Tumminelli: Okay.
[1:01:01] Erika Henningsen: I want blank movie to be a musical.
[1:01:04] Erika Henningsen: Oh, I want. Uh um, yeah. Well, this is my dream. I want um the baseball movie with the women. I want A League of Their Own to be a musical, and I want to be Kit.
[1:01:16] Marc Tumminelli: Yes.
[1:01:17] Erika Henningsen: And that's gonna happen, and I'm going to win a Tony for doing it. So it's happening now.
[1:01:21] Marc Tumminelli: What Mean Girl should Patti LuPone play? Like if age didn't matter.
[1:01:24] Erika Henningsen: Oh, she has to be Regina George.
[1:01:27] Marc Tumminelli: Yes. Oh my god, she'd be so good.
[1:01:29] Erika Henningsen: Can you name two real housewives?
[1:01:32] Marc Tumminelli: I can name one because Kyle just did a movie with her.
[1:01:35] Erika Henningsen: Kyle Chandler.
[1:01:37] Marc Tumminelli: Wait, no, that's the guy from Friday Night Lights.
[1:01:41] Erika Henningsen: Kyle Richards.
[1:01:43] Marc Tumminelli: He's in a movie with Kyle Richards.
[1:01:45] Erika Henningsen: Oh my god, I knew you heard it here first.
[1:01:49] Marc Tumminelli: Okay.
[1:01:49] Erika Henningsen: Um, that's amazing. Wait, I have to tell a Patti LuPone story.
[1:01:53] Marc Tumminelli: All right, quick. Do you have time?
[1:01:54] Erika Henningsen: I'm telling you now.
[1:01:56] Marc Tumminelli: I'm telling you now.
[1:01:57] Erika Henningsen: Patti LuPone came to our stage door. She came to see Mean Girls. Yes, it was like dreams. She it was Patti, yeah, because it was during Company was going up. She came to see Mean Girls, and she obviously didn't come backstage afterwards because she was like, I'm going home. It's time for bed. And she came to the stage door and asked for a stage manager and said, like, I didn't come backstage last night because it was just gonna be too much. But I wanted you to know to tell those girls it was so cool seeing six women standing in their power at the edge of the stage on Broadway. She was like, I've never seen that before. It's also like the greatest story, and I don't know if like anybody ever said that to like Tina or Casey. I hope they did, because it was like Patti talks to our stage manager.
[1:02:37] Marc Tumminelli: Oh my god, I love it.
[1:02:38] Erika Henningsen: To like pass on that message. It's so old school, and I love it.
[1:02:41] Marc Tumminelli: Okay, what TV sitcom would family would you want to be part of?
[1:02:45] Erika Henningsen: Um, I think Modern Family.
[1:02:47] Marc Tumminelli: No, no, no. I want to be part of the Gellers.
[1:02:49] Erika Henningsen: I want to be the part of the Gellers in Friends.
[1:02:51] Marc Tumminelli: Um who is your favorite Muppet?
[1:02:54] Erika Henningsen: Kermit.
[1:02:55] Marc Tumminelli: Least favorite Les Mis song?
[1:02:58] Erika Henningsen: Um, the one in the sewers.
[1:03:00] Marc Tumminelli: Yes that that Thenardier sings.
[1:03:02] Erika Henningsen: Terrifying.
[1:03:03] Marc Tumminelli: Does Fantine's Bullet Boy have a name? Like, does that character that she plays in Act Two have a name?
[1:03:09] Erika Henningsen: No.
[1:03:09] Marc Tumminelli: I didn't.
[1:03:10] Erika Henningsen: I mean, I'm sure some Fantine made a name.
[1:03:12] Marc Tumminelli: I did not.
[1:03:13] Erika Henningsen: I was like, this is a big one. I'm Gerald. I'm Charles and all me in a font.
[1:03:17] Marc Tumminelli: The barricade.
[1:03:18] Erika Henningsen: With my British accent in France.
[1:03:20] Marc Tumminelli: Okay. If you can go back in time and see any Broadway show, what would it be?
[1:03:25] Erika Henningsen: Um, I want to see.
[1:03:30] Erika Henningsen: Oh, oh, I want to see the carousel that Audra McDonald played.
[1:03:35] Marc Tumminelli: Um, are you a fan of true crime? If so, what case would you want to have solved?
[1:03:40] Erika Henningsen: Oh, I am a fan of true crime, and I really want that staircase thing to be figured out.
[1:03:45] Marc Tumminelli: Oh, okay.
[1:03:46] Erika Henningsen: Is that it? Is it the staircase?
[1:03:47] Marc Tumminelli: Yeah, staircase.
[1:03:48] Erika Henningsen: Yeah.
[1:03:49] Marc Tumminelli: Um creepy.
[1:03:50] Erika Henningsen: Totally creepy. I mean, he pushed her down a flight of stairs.
[1:03:53] Marc Tumminelli: He fully did.
[1:03:54] Erika Henningsen: I mean, you fully did.
[1:03:58] Marc Tumminelli: Okay, that's so we solved it.
[1:04:01] Erika Henningsen: Um, okay.
[1:04:02] Marc Tumminelli: Um, how do you feel about Invisalign?
[1:04:07] Erika Henningsen: No comments.
[1:04:08] Marc Tumminelli: Okay.
[1:04:09] Erika Henningsen: Word.
[1:04:11] Marc Tumminelli: You're not gonna like this one. One word to describe Cameron Dallas.
[1:04:15] Erika Henningsen: Nice boy.
[1:04:16] Marc Tumminelli: Nice boy.
[1:04:17] Erika Henningsen: Who makes you starstruck?
[1:04:20] Marc Tumminelli: Um I mean, John Mulaney made me starstruck when I met him.
[1:04:28] Erika Henningsen: I like had a whole thing prepared to say, and I bombed all of it.
[1:04:32] Marc Tumminelli: Um have you ever seen a ghost?
[1:04:35] Erika Henningsen: I I felt a ghost.
[1:04:37] Marc Tumminelli: Have you ever seen the musical Ghost?
[1:04:40] Erika Henningsen: I have not seen the musical Ghost.
[1:04:42] Marc Tumminelli: I'll just find Casey Levy. This is a Casey Levy podcast.
[1:04:45] Erika Henningsen: Um, what musical would you be okay with never seeing again?
[1:04:48] Marc Tumminelli: It's not a mean thing. You're just like, I've had enough of it.
[1:04:50] Erika Henningsen: I've had enough. The Band's Visit.
[1:04:53] Marc Tumminelli: Okay.
[1:04:54] Erika Henningsen: Um, what musical would you like to see me in?
[1:04:58] Marc Tumminelli: The Band's Visit.
[1:05:00] Erika Henningsen: Actually, it'd be so good. I want you to do the roller skating number.
[1:05:04] Marc Tumminelli: I would see The Band's Visit again for you to be in the roller skating number.
[1:05:07] Erika Henningsen: Have you ever left a show at intermission?
[1:05:10] Marc Tumminelli: Yes, I left a production of the show. You don't have to tell us what it is.
[1:05:13] Erika Henningsen: Well, it was like a regional production of Oklahoma and it was bad.
[1:05:16] Marc Tumminelli: Great. You don't have to tell us what it is.
[1:05:18] Erika Henningsen: What I mean, like everybody's always like, do I have to tell you what it is?
[1:05:22] Marc Tumminelli: Um what movie can you watch over and over again?
[1:05:25] Erika Henningsen: Um, honestly, How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days.
[1:05:28] Marc Tumminelli: Let's make that a musical.
[1:05:30] Erika Henningsen: That would be so good.
[1:05:31] Marc Tumminelli: Um what advice do you have for young performers? Last question.
[1:05:34] Erika Henningsen: Oh, it's okay to have role models, but stop YouTubing them to figure out how you should do a song.
[1:05:40] Marc Tumminelli: I love it. Erika Henningsen, you are a flippin' delight. This is so much fun.
[1:05:47] Erika Henningsen: Okay, uh, tell the people where they can follow you. I'm sure they already know.
[1:05:49] Erika Henningsen: Oh, um, well, I deleted, I only have Instagram, so I I didn't delete Instagram. You can follow me, it's Erika Henningsen. E-R-I-K-A-H-E-N-N-I-N-G-S-E-N. Um, and that's it. I'm not on TikTok or Twitter because I spent too much time on my phone already.
[1:06:04] Marc Tumminelli: Well, we're all gonna follow you.
[1:06:06] Erika Henningsen: Follow you.
[1:06:06] Marc Tumminelli: I don't even speak English. Everybody follow Erika on Instagram. And are we looking for a dog bark? What's happening?
[1:06:13] Erika Henningsen: Right. Oh, look at her. She got the squeaky toy out. Also, we don't have a couch right now. We're getting a new couch, so we just have chairs.
[1:06:20] Marc Tumminelli: Okay, so like five chairs.
[1:06:21] Erika Henningsen: Video component to this.
[1:06:22] Marc Tumminelli: So no one's no video.
[1:06:24] Erika Henningsen: This I already mentioned that.
[1:06:25] Marc Tumminelli: Um said all of this.
[1:06:26] Erika Henningsen: No, I'm keeping it. It's so good.
[1:06:28] Marc Tumminelli: Um, Erika, I love you. Thank you for doing the Little Me Podcast. We I can't wait till see you at Chelsea Table and Stage in just like a week from the time you're listening to this.
[1:06:39] Erika Henningsen: Thank you.
[1:06:39] Marc Tumminelli: And thank you, everyone, for tuning in or listening in today. And remember, you can go and subscribe to the Little Me Podcast, write a review if you enjoyed today's interview. I'll be back next week with an all new episode. And I um I don't know if I can say at this point because I don't I like to record before I announce who's coming up next.
[1:07:01] Erika Henningsen: Got it, got it.
[1:07:02] Marc Tumminelli: But thank you for listening. I'm obsessed with all of you. Follow me at Marc Tumminelli on Instagram and follow us at Little Me Podcast also on Instagram. I'm obsessed with everybody. Thank you for another great week. Wow!
[1:07:12] Erika Henningsen: French kiss.
[1:07:15] Marc Tumminelli: Fresh kiss!
[1:07:16] Erika Henningsen: French kiss.
[1:07:17] Marc Tumminelli: Chef's kiss. Bye.
[1:07:20] Erika Henningsen: Thank you, listeners. This podcast is produced by Alan Seales, Dory Barenstein, and the Broadway Podcast Network and edited by Derek Gunther.
[1:07:29] Erika Henningsen: For more information on the LITTLE ME podcast, go to bpn.fm slash little me.
[1:07:34] Marc Tumminelli: And follow me on Instagram at Marc Tumminelli or on Twitter at that to manelli. And for more information on workshops, classes, and everything Broadway Workshop, go to BroadwayWorkshop.com. Thank you for listening.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
