Andy Karl (ROCKY, GROUNDHOG DAY, PRETTY WOMAN) has been the leading man in a musical on Broadway in nearly every season for the last decade. He is known for his talent, dedication to the work, and great sense of humor... Read More
From the show: Living the Dream with Rory O'Malley
Guests
Featured Shows
About
Andy Karl (ROCKY, GROUNDHOG DAY, PRETTY WOMAN) has been the leading man in a musical on Broadway in nearly every season for the last decade. He is known for his talent, dedication to the work, and great sense of humor. Andy and Rory go way back to working on HAPPY DAYS THE MUSICAL for the late great Garry Marshall, who co-wrote Andy's current hit show PRETTY WOMAN. Andy discusses the joy of getting to do what you love at a dinner theater and the agony of getting a closing notice when you are on Broadway. There is also a surprise guest appearance by his wife and co-star Orfeh. They talk about the upside to working together on an 8 show a week schedule.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Rory O'Malley: You're listening to episode number 68 of Living the Dream with Rory O'Malley.
[0:06] Rory O'Malley: Audition, side job, swimming upstream. Believe it or not, you're living the dream.
[0:12] Rory O'Malley: Hello, dreamers, Rory O'Malley here. Thanks for listening to Living the Dream.
[0:17] Rory O'Malley: If you like the podcast, you know what to do. Write a review. Tell your friends. Give me a good rating on iTunes. I so appreciate that when you do that.
[0:30] Rory O'Malley: We just want everyone to know about the podcast so we can keep doing them. I'm in New York City. I am so excited. It was kind of a last minute trip. I'm here to talk with folks in the industry about hashtag belt the vote.
[0:46] Rory O'Malley: Beltthevote.org. B-E-L-Thevote.org. This is the movement to get the entire theater community to vote November 6th. There's a midterm election. We all need to go out and make our voices heard.
[1:04] Rory O'Malley: But to do that, we have to make sure that we're registered. So what I'm going to ask of you is that you go to that website, make sure that you're registered to vote, and then vote on November 6th.
[1:15] Rory O'Malley: This coming week is National Voter Registration Week, and we're actually doing a ton of voter registration drives in theaters all across the country from ART in Boston to the Geffen Playhouse in Los Angeles to the Goodman in Chicago to my hometown, the Cleveland Playhouse is joining us.
[1:37] Rory O'Malley: So there are tons of theaters that are joining us in this and schools, my school, Carnegie Mellon University. If you want your school, if you want your theater to get involved, it's so easy. Just go to Beltthevote.org and you can sign them up.
[1:58] Rory O'Malley: You can let me know that they want to participate if it's your theater and you can speak for them. And just go to the contact page there because the person answering that page is me. So I will find out right away that you want to be involved with Belt the Vote.
[2:17] Rory O'Malley: Um, yeah, but just go to register to vote, folks. It's so easy, and we're so lucky to be partnering with Broadway Cares, Equity Fights AIDS, and an organization called When We All Vote.
[2:30] Rory O'Malley: It's Michelle Obama's nonprofit that is getting people everywhere to get registered to vote because when we all vote, things change for the better. Um so yeah, that's what I'm doing here. And I'm also seeing as many Broadway shows as I possibly can.
[2:52] Rory O'Malley: Um, I've seen three so far. I saw Nicolette Robinson, my buddy Leslie Odom Jr.'s wife in Waitress. She was glorious, and I just love that show. And then I just saw PRETTY WOMAN last night with my buddy Andy Karl.
[3:14] Rory O'Malley: And we'll get into why that's such a special show for me. I loved the show. It was so much fun. The audience went crazy for it. Um, but the writer, the co-writer of PRETTY WOMAN is Garry Marshall, the late great Garry Marshall.
[3:30] Rory O'Malley: And he directed and wrote HAPPY DAYS the Musical, his hit TV show. He turned into a musical several years ago, and I played Richie Cunningham, the Ron Howard character, and Andy Karl played The Fonz for a period of time.
[3:47] Rory O'Malley: And that's when I first met Andy and absolutely thought he was such a stand-up fantastic guy. And he's my guest today. It was such an emotional thing to get to see him in this Broadway show because he was fantastic, but also because of all that it would mean to Garry to have a hit show on Broadway, but also to have Andy representing one of being one of the leads in the show, somebody that he knew, one of his people.
[4:27] Rory O'Malley: That's my Garry. Um, he was the greatest man ever and a mentor to me and to so many people, pretty much anyone who ever worked with him. You learned a lot from Garry when you were in his presence.
[4:41] Rory O'Malley: And um, he's the one who taught me how to live the dream. Speaking of which, like he, when it comes down to how you want to live in this business, Garry was the guy who I kind of took the cue from of surrounding yourself with your family, friends, and people you can be excited to show up to work with.
[5:08] Rory O'Malley: And uh, I can tell that that's what's going on in the Nederlander Theater, and that Andy Karl is a leader of that. Um, he's in the show with his wife Orfeh, and she's a powerhouse.
[5:22] Rory O'Malley: Um, and she happened to stop by his dressing room in the middle of our interview to say hello, and so I just said, hey, just come on in, just join the interview. So we have her as a special guest appearance.
[5:36] Rory O'Malley: Um, and yeah, what else can I say? PRETTY WOMAN was great. Samantha Barks is genuinely a star, truly. And um, and Eric Anderson, my buddy, who is also from the Garry Marshall world back at the Garry Marshall Theater, the Falcon Theater, as it used to be called.
[5:56] Rory O'Malley: So it was a really, um, it was it felt like coming home seeing the show last night. It was very special. Uh, I think that Andy was very honest, and I just so appreciate when people come on this podcast and they don't sugarcoat stuff.
[6:13] Rory O'Malley: I hope that that is beneficial to you. I love talking to people at all different aspects of this business and getting the highs and the lows and the hardships and the ecstasy and agony of their life.
[6:30] Rory O'Malley: And um, I think it's harder sometimes for people who have had such success like Andy to be honest about what the hard parts are, and I think that he was so honest and articulate about the hardships of having a show not succeed and how you pour your entire heart into it.
[6:51] Rory O'Malley: I've seen Andy pour himself into a role, and uh he really gives his all. So it only naturally would be painful when um his last show, GROUNDHOG DAY, did not um run as long as it should have. So here's my conversation with one of the current stars of PRETTY WOMAN on Broadway, Mr. Andy Karl.
[7:14] Rory O'Malley: Broadway's Andy Karl.
[7:18] Andy Karl: Um, hi Rory O'Malley.
[7:19] Rory O'Malley: Hello, Andy Karl. I am so excited to be in your dressing room here.
[7:23] Andy Karl: My God. The Nederlander.
[7:25] Rory O'Malley: Last time we were in a dressing room together. Uh, I was much younger.
[7:28] Andy Karl: Well, so was I.
[7:30] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, I know. I look at you and remember how young I was.
[7:34] Andy Karl: Yeah, yeah.
[7:35] Andy Karl: We were in HAPPY DAYS the Musical at the Falcon Theater.
[7:39] Rory O'Malley: Hey.
[7:39] Andy Karl: Hey, you were the Garry Marshall production.
[7:42] Rory O'Malley: That's right.
[7:43] Andy Karl: That's right. And now we're in a dressing room at PRETTY WOMAN, the Nederlander in a Garry Marshall production.
[7:50] Rory O'Malley: Yes. Isn't it amazing how things come together and all the connections?
[7:56] Andy Karl: I mean, when I started doing HAPPY DAYS the Musical readings with Garry, I had no idea that it was going to lead to me meeting so many talented people like you.
[8:05] Andy Karl: I remember when you came in, I was like, oh man, this guy's a real deal.
[8:09] Rory O'Malley: Thanks, man. I just thought I was just trying to.
[8:11] Andy Karl: Was Joey McIntyre was the Fonz at the time.
[8:14] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[8:15] Andy Karl: Joey Mack was the Fonz, and he either had to leave early.
[8:20] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, we extended. It was a big hit.
[8:22] Andy Karl: And like I think it was you and I who we were in a car together following Joey McIntyre in LA because it was like one of his last nights, and we were all just like, you know, I was we were transferring over to me going into the show, but we were all hanging out.
[8:22] Rory O'Malley: I think we were playing poker. I don't know what we were doing.
[8:38] Andy Karl: I'm sure.
[8:39] Andy Karl: But uh we were in a car and Joey's like calling you on the phone saying, Can I borrow a few bucks? Cause to go to the McDonald's.
[8:49] Rory O'Malley: And under your breath, you're like, don't give him any money because you'll never see it back.
[8:55] Andy Karl: I was like, no, not Joey Mac.
[8:57] Rory O'Malley: Oh, yeah. No, Joey is, he's he actually, he was probably just giving me shit because I was so broke all the time and trying to get money from me.
[9:06] Andy Karl: He actually, I remember during that production, I was wearing the same tennis shoes that were so busted, they fell apart while we were in rehearsals.
[9:14] Rory O'Malley: And he ended up buying me a new pair of tennis shoes before the end of the run.
[9:19] Andy Karl: But then he always needed money for McDonald's.
[9:21] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, so it added up.
[9:23] Andy Karl: Yeah.
[9:24] Andy Karl: Um, but yeah, you came, you came in from New York, you know, they flew you out. We're gonna get this guy to fill in for Joey, and we all knew like well, you were the real Broadway deal because at that point you had done Altar Boys, right?
[9:41] Andy Karl: Yep.
[9:42] Andy Karl: What else did you done at that point that we knew?
[9:42] Rory O'Malley: Had I done Wedding Singer at that point, yeah.
[9:46] Andy Karl: I think I was I did Saturday Night Fever or my wife.
[9:50] Rory O'Malley: Yes.
[9:51] Andy Karl: That probably did No Wedding Singer was directly after.
[9:51] Rory O'Malley: Yes, and I saw you in it. I saw you in it.
[10:00] Andy Karl: I saw well, Legally Blonde and Singer.
[10:03] Rory O'Malley: Yeah. Because I didn't you get Legally Blonde while you were doing HAPPY DAYS with us?
[10:09] Andy Karl: Uh no, I got I was doing Lady DeKino. I was doing workshops of Legally Blonde. This is 2006.
[10:21] Rory O'Malley: God, I yeah, this is a little bit start to mix together.
[10:27] Andy Karl: Um Legally Blonde happened right after Altar Boys because Jerry Mitchell, and we're in a jury, I'm in a jury, Mitchell Burton here at PRETTY WOMAN, saw me in Altar Boys, and he's like, I want that guy to come in and do something.
[10:42] Andy Karl: So he like gave me all these different roles, including Kyle the UPS guy. And during one of the workshops, they used to have Elle Woods acceptance into Harvard. She was trying to get people to recommend her via video screen.
[10:58] Andy Karl: So they had Arnold Schwarzenegger and Jack Nicholson, and I was supposed to dress up like these guys and be like, hear me now, and I tell you later, Elle Woods will get into Harvard, you will love her.
[11:13] Andy Karl: You know, it was this kind of just character madness. And I was like, You want the truth, you can't handle the truth. Elle Woods belongs in Harvard. It was this whole montage of stars, Hollywood stars getting Elle Woods into Harvard, but they cut it because they just it was just too good, it was too random.
[11:32] Rory O'Malley: No, I mean that that's I love that because that is so you're a goofball. I don't think people realize that because you're a leading man on Broadway, but I remember you like coming to HAPPY DAYS and showing us cartoons that you had made.
[11:48] Andy Karl: Oh, okay.
[11:51] Andy Karl: I'm like, I was gonna let you decide a lot of things. That's like the only television I made.
[11:55] Rory O'Malley: Well, you were like, I made this cartoon, it was hilarious.
[11:58] Andy Karl: It was, yeah, and it had me and Jeremy Kushner during in Philadelphia during Bright Light's Big City. I don't know how random we were, but it was pretty random.
[12:09] Andy Karl: Came up with the adventures of poop. So it was like it was yeah, some Spaniard, he was a poop and a Spaniard, and he had adventures in inside the toilet bowl.
[12:23] Rory O'Malley: He had a lot of adventures, and I uh I don't think I ever looked at you the same way after watching.
[12:28] Andy Karl: I was always on stage with the Fonz. I was like, I will always like eventually go to that point where people don't know if they should be offended or laugh or just like look at me like what what are you doing?
[12:42] Rory O'Malley: You have you have a bit of a twisted sense of humor. You're a funny guy. You're a character guy. Clearly, you can come up with these different impressions and and you are a leading man, but really there's a there's a character actor.
[12:53] Andy Karl: Yeah, and I was watching, I was watching way too much Bugs Bunny and Steve Martin when I was growing up.
[12:59] Rory O'Malley: Um, where did you grow up?
[13:01] Andy Karl: Baltimore, Maryland.
[13:02] Rory O'Malley: Ah, a weird town, too. And I'm actually trying to write a script like based on all the weirdness sort of like of my childhood and of growing up there and being an artist.
[13:12] Andy Karl: And I started out painting and being a you know, a visual artist before I got into theater. When I was in high school, I was like really dedicated to art. Like I was going to all the museums and I was painting, I was learning all this abstract art, I was learning all this stuff.
[13:26] Andy Karl: I went to the Maryland Art Institute during the summer to study with some of the professors there, and it was it was a fun, weird world. And my brother is very much he, my older brother who lives in San Francisco now, he's he's very much a hands-on visual artist as well.
[13:44] Andy Karl: He kept with it, he's such like a bohemian. He uh I think the last thing they he just did was going on a raft down the Hudson with a whole bunch of other artists that they they had built this raft, first of all.
[13:58] Rory O'Malley: Hudson here in New York.
[13:59] Andy Karl: Yeah, and then they were creating pieces of like artwork on the Hudson. And that was but he's made stuff for Burning Man. He's kind of like, you know, into that way, that's sort of expensive.
[14:13] Rory O'Malley: Did you grow up in a really artistic?
[14:13] Andy Karl: No, like my dad was an appliance refinisher, but it was very hands-on, like you knew welding.
[14:20] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[14:20] Andy Karl: We were taught, you know, how to, you know, sand and stain and do all the stuff that all the basics for Burning Man.
[14:25] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[14:26] Andy Karl: So it was taking all those elements and using them in visual. But my mother, she played piano for her church and she studied music, and so that's kind of where I started gearing myself towards that.
[14:39] Andy Karl: And um church singing. So church singing was part of me, yeah. I don't I don't not a lot of things. At least got you to sing with Dolly Parton. Yeah, I was an altar boy, but that you know, randomly like I actually was an altar boy lighting candles and stuff like that in church.
[14:54] Rory O'Malley: In a Catholic church?
[14:55] Andy Karl: Uh Episcopalian.
[14:56] Rory O'Malley: Uh okay, so Catholic light.
[14:58] Andy Karl: Yes, exactly. Yes. Like 80% less fat.
[15:03] Rory O'Malley: Maybe even more or less fat. Um okay, so you grew up and and your mom kind of was the reason that you were into music.
[15:13] Andy Karl: Yeah, totally. She had uh she had the West Side Story album and the Jesus Christ Superstar album around the house. We had videos of like Superstar and West Side Story and Tommy. Well, so I actually got to do a tour of Tommy. Uh it was like the non-equity, like bus and truck, yeah, big league theatricals, sleeping on the bus. Yeah, yeah. Uh, but I loved every minute of it when I was like 20 or something like that, just like on the road singing the Who's Tommy?
[15:44] Rory O'Malley: Did you go to Cleveland?
[15:45] Andy Karl: Maybe I saw you.
[15:46] Rory O'Malley: I'm sure we did, yeah. Yeah, I mean I guess every city. It was amazing. All those that are the big ones and the small ones, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[15:53] Rory O'Malley: So where did it did you just start doing theater in high school or uh yes, yes, yes. Uh like the summer musicals uh that public schools would put on. Uh I was singing in the chorus as one of my electives. Um music was just around the house. We all piano was on the house. Uh so I started singing there in high school, and I think one of the teachers like just wanted me to audition for random chorus person in uh was it Anything Goes. So I was like random guy in the back in a sailor suit, kind of like Anything Goes. Uh and I was Billy.
[16:40] Andy Karl: You were Billy? See, you had a part.
[16:41] Rory O'Malley: I don't I don't know that you have a part. But come next year, Oklahoma, Judd Fry.
[16:47] Andy Karl: Oh man, big big jump. And uh the year after that, uh General Bull Moose in Lil Abner.
[16:55] Rory O'Malley: That's an obscure weird music.
[16:57] Andy Karl: Yeah, yeah. I don't even know that that show. It's I just like saying Lil Abner.
[17:01] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, it's it's a weird show, and it's very political, and it's very yeah, it's it's all like based on the cartoon these political cartoons from back in the day, and it's like how you know the government wants to like bomb this uh was it I can't remember the name of the town that they lived in uh because no one lived, no one was worth anything there, so they wanted to bomb this place just to like have a bomb explode. That's what Lil Abner's clear it out.
[17:25] Andy Karl: I figured it was just like an old musical about getting the daughter married. They were like trying to prove the the mayor was trying to prove that the town was like you know, worth something, and I think they uncover a statue of like a shit of a general from back in the day.
[17:43] Rory O'Malley: Wow, you know, General Bull Moose was the bad guy, though. He wanted to clear out the town and buy it out. I can't remember exactly what he did, but he was the villain with all the money.
[17:55] Andy Karl: Wow. I mean, Judd, you were starting to get like put into the me and uh Evan Farmer, who was the other guy who got all the leads, he got the leads. I always got the villain. So I thought for sure Lil Abner, I was gonna get the lead, but I didn't. So Evan, the handman.
[18:13] Rory O'Malley: Evan now. I don't know where he is. You know, well, he's probably listening. He's probably making a lot more money than I am.
[18:19] Andy Karl: Um, so you did you go to college for theater? What are your decisions on theater?
[18:24] Rory O'Malley: I went to college for music. So I went to two years at Towson State University to study music, and I uh where's that?
[18:31] Andy Karl: In Towson, Maryland, which I just went back to talk to my high school, actually. Um that was you know, that's why I don't know if you've ever talked to your high school.
[18:41] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, it's so weird.
[18:43] Andy Karl: It's like you can go back and the smells come back and the same some of the some of the walls have changed, but it's definitely the same feel.
[18:52] Rory O'Malley: For me, it's like also you like see teachers or rooms and you're like, oh, these are all just people.
[18:58] Andy Karl: Yeah, like this was something different to me back then, but now I realize, oh, these are all just people doing their best and you know, getting through the day. And then I was supposed to speak to all these kids and sort of like trying not to panic, but you know, because it's like well, how am I supposed to talk to them? Yeah, I guess I've had enough experience talking to people. Um and just sort of get them because who knows if one of those kids sees me talking about something that really clicks with them, yeah. Um, and they want to be a part of it. Any words of advice I can give or any you know constructive criticism I can give is.
[19:35] Rory O'Malley: Did they get more for you as well?
[19:36] Andy Karl: No. Oh no, they well, I went into the core the chorus room, uh-huh, sort of where I found my first time, you know, going into theater. Really on stage, right? So uh and I was in that room, and I think they were singing the album matter, which is which I also realized like it's it's kind of cryptic. And it's like uh do must deep within our hearts. So da-da-da-da-da, uh until death do us part. It was there the very death school. And it was like death in it, it was weird. It was like it's very dark.
[20:15] Rory O'Malley: So were they singing it when you walked into the room?
[20:18] Andy Karl: I walked in the room while they're singing the album honor because I think they actually have to sing it at like some event. They weren't doing it for me. I was walked into the room. It sounds like highly produced that you're like walking in, like we're reality TV show cameras there or something.
[20:31] Rory O'Malley: No, I wish there was no one to document it other than kids with their phones and Instagram. Um so you say that is the room where you really started to form that you wanted to be professional.
[20:41] Andy Karl: I I it that's where I guess the spark of like being on stage, like, oh, this is interesting. Um you got Tommy at 20, so did you leave school to do that?
[20:52] Rory O'Malley: Uh I did like I went to two years at Castle State. And I was like, this. Can I curse?
[20:57] Andy Karl: You can say fuck on this.
[20:59] Rory O'Malley: Uh it was to to it was sort of like studying to be a vocal vocal coach, a vocal teacher. Right, right, right. And I realized that I didn't like any of the people in the class. They were all very uh critical and I think guy somewhere guided on a road, somewhere where I was like, I'm not a part of this journey with these people who want to be vocal teachers, which is a great, you know, yeah, they're on their path, but it's not the one that I it was just not, it was something it was like, what are you all doing? What are you being really uh adamant about being critical and about making sure that everything's perfect? And so I was like, I just I I don't live that way, and I still don't live that way.
[21:41] Rory O'Malley: Yeah. I like the imperfections of what we do, it's kind of what is amazing and fun about theater.
[21:46] Andy Karl: Yeah. Um so I just I just stopped going because I wanted to do some theater and I started doing uh theater in town, like uh the uh dinner theaters in Baltimore in Baltimore, Balmer dinner theaters.
[22:00] Rory O'Malley: Nice act two dinner theater off Pulaski Highway. We have a couple of uh Toby's dinner theater veterans here, which is Toby's in Columbia, Maryland. Um, Jake Otamark and Alan. Uh there's three of us who work there, so it's really interesting to like, oh, you guys are like Baltimore, Washington, you know, people that all work the same thing. Dinner theaters across America are uh great sources of income for actors and actually giving careers to people all across the country.
[22:30] Andy Karl: Yeah, when you can realize you can get paid to do this, it was kind of that was that was the first like yeah spark of like, oh interesting. I I love doing this, and I'm being paid to do this. Wasn't it was hardly anything, but at the time it was like it's this or work at 7 Eleven.
[22:46] Rory O'Malley: Yeah. I'd much rather sing and dance and jump around like an idiot for you know two and a half hours.
[22:55] Andy Karl: When did you realize that you had to move to New York, or was that did that happen by accident?
[23:00] Rory O'Malley: Uh yeah, I mean I Toby's dinner theater was kind of like the last dinner theater I worked at. And it's one of the last that actually like exists in that area because the ones I was working at were very small and compact, and don't know how they made any money, but they did. They made a lot of money off of uh big group sales of sure, you know, old folks' homes coming in to see great old shows, which is they they wanted to they do these old folks want to see senior setters, keep the arts alive. They want to see these great old school musicals, these great uh which are the only reason why I like know and love all these classics.
[23:40] Andy Karl: Right and you realize where it all comes from. Yeah. I mean, I guess like now it you know, in my 40s, there all those folks are dead. Well, and you're carrying my generation has to, you know, fall in love with that. You're telling people all about Lil Abner and you're doing it.
[23:55] Rory O'Malley: Exactly. I'm doing it. Any more obscure classic musical theater references I can make. But you but so that took you to New York or so Toby's was the the last one, but it was also eight shows a week.
[24:08] Andy Karl: And it was it was like you're realizing, oh, this is like this is how Broadway works. This is how you know theaters that's amazing that it's eight years ago. Tuesday, yeah, Tuesdays through Sundays, and have your one day off and this is the full commitment. Then you sort of get your you realize how much work goes into it and then how much uh time goes into it. And and if you're really passionate about passionate about it and you love it, which I did, like I would sleep in my car in the parking lot some nights because I didn't want to go home because I knew I had to get up and start cleaning silverware for the next day to start doing the show the next day.
[24:45] Rory O'Malley: Really?
[24:46] Andy Karl: Like you had to start cleaning silverware to as a part of the part of the waiting tables. So it's like Toby's is a dinner theater, so I'd wait tables as well as or I would do the kid show in the morning. Right. And then they'd clean up shop. I'd go, you know, get a nap and a meal, come back and do the evening show, adult show.
[25:04] Rory O'Malley: Um holy shit.
[25:05] Andy Karl: Oh yeah, but it was like Yeah, I loved every single second of it. I mean, my car smelled like Burger King. Uh, and I would wash, you know, take a shower at the theater, and it was like, but this is how it's supposed to be, right? This is the full commitment. This is my job.
[25:22] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[25:23] Andy Karl: Um, and I loved it. I mean, it was it was interesting to keep the repetition going. I'm sure that's what colleges do. You know, that was my that was my learning center. That was instead of going to college, I actually like performed it, performed it, performed it, performed.
[25:38] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[25:39] Andy Karl: As much as I possibly could. It's amazing. I mean, you know that that that actually I've heard that from so many people on this podcast that their education was actually doing it. There's a lot of people who've spent a lot of money at schools who don't get to do it for those four years, even and you know, only leave with a lot of debt. It's it really is another part of your schooling, even if you do do go to college. Once you get out, you just have to do every piece of theater that comes your way, any performance opportunity that comes your way, that's kind of like your graduate school.
[26:11] Andy Karl: So you just kind of skipped right to graduate school.
[26:13] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, I mean, I s I sp uh it works differently. I think it, you know, look, I'm I'm a person that would get hired for these things. There's people that could be in my position that wouldn't be hired, and so therefore they would have to go work 7-Eleven wait table somewhere else, which I've also done, but I was lucky enough that I got to that Toby Ornstein liked me and kept putting me in shows.
[26:38] Andy Karl: Um if it had been a you know, some somebody else who didn't get that opportunity, they would they wouldn't be doing that. So I'm thinking the same way colleges and schools, it's like if you're if you're lucky enough, and with any job really, if you're lucky enough to leave school and get employment right away, that's a small percentage of people.
[27:00] Rory O'Malley: Very, yeah.
[27:01] Andy Karl: Um you're still looking at trying to make it all work. So either way, you have to find that education that feeds you. Um and what what works for you because I've seen people that get right out of college and they're gangbusters, they they never stop working. Um I've also seen the other side of that. It was just like somebody didn't really like lost interest or didn't feel like it was they fit in, or like you get here and you realize it's not what you expected, and it's it's all variations of luck and time.
[27:33] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, I mean, I feel like everybody has uh different the same experience at different moments.
[27:40] Andy Karl: Yeah, you know, like we all have a amount of rejection and success, but it all comes at different parts of the journey. So you kind of just have to be willing to ride on all parts of it.
[27:50] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, that's beautiful. It's and it's like people come to see PRETTY WOMAN or they saw GROUNDHOG DAY and they remember me like, oh man, Rocky was really your starting point, man. Really, you're like, I don't know, no, my success has been since I've been working as an actor.
[28:09] Andy Karl: Yeah, I feel really good about the fact that I was back at Toby's getting you know leads in these shows, and I feel great that I was like, I moved to New York and I was like working at the Accrunator Theater that you know we'd they would fly cast to New York and fly us out, and I'd be there. I was like, wow, man, I'm I'm making it as an actor. I'm actually like working as a musical theater artist.
[28:33] Rory O'Malley: Yeah. You have a lot of gratitude.
[28:36] Andy Karl: I mean, it's one of the things I remember most about you when you came to work on the show because you had so much gratitude to be putting on the leather jacket and playing Bonds, you know, for a limited time and working with Gary, and you were so excited to be there.
[28:50] Rory O'Malley: We'd only worked together for like a what a maybe a month. I don't remember how long of a period of time. I thought it was terrible in the show, but you were a fantastic in the show.
[28:59] Andy Karl: I don't think I ever think I'm like there's only one or two times I would be like, yeah, I was I was perfect. I mean, yeah, well, it's also it it's hard to live up to the Henry Winkler. You know, you had to live up to other performances.
[29:13] Andy Karl: Yeah, I know. Come on. Wasn't that so exciting? He's just the best. If you saw him in Barry, ladies were really funny. Brilliant. It's just totally brilliant. But you know, he created a character that we both grew up with that was the king of cool. So the fact that you were like taking that on so quickly, yeah, it could have been, you came in with just total gratitude and excitement, and that's something I remember. And clearly the guy who sleeps in his car before going to do his dinner theater job is somebody who is going to show up anywhere where he gets to do his art and be happy and have gratitude. That's yeah. I think it's why you work. I think it's why you work. You're that's always in the back of my brain. Now I can't say that I live by that code like a hundred percent of the time.
[30:02] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, well, everyone has bad days.
[30:03] Andy Karl: I've been fucking bitter sometimes when even like in the last year or so. Even the bitters and even with success. What are those things that come up? I don't know. There's this moment, and this happened all during GROUNDHOG DAY, which didn't run very long. They got these amazing reviews, and like I couldn't believe, and it was like one of these shows that I was like, I'm fitting really well into a role. I've done my homework, I'm busting ass, I know exactly what I'm doing. I feel like I'm cooking on all cylinders right now. And it was an interesting thing. It's like you come into this, there's like Come From Away is going on, Dear Evan Hansen is going on, a big show at Hamilton is still rocking, and it's like there's not enough asses to fill our seats, and you're just like, my god, it's like how do we how do we how do I have this thing in my hand that I have like an Olivier from London and I have all this stuff, and the critics are saying yes, yes, yes.
And the show closes, and it's like so unbelievably bitter at that moment. Just like how like I've put in all this time, and also like with an injury that happened right before opening. Yeah, it was like I am spiritually giving you everything that I possibly can. I am taking all that stuff that I took from, you know, Baltimore and I'm bringing it all here, and I'm making and I've polished it, and I'm you know, I got all the tricks up my sleeve, and if there's something that's perfect or imperfect, I roll with it, I can do it. If we don't have the set doesn't move, we shut this thing down, we sing it out front in front of the people in front of the stage, which happened. Ray Lee was on the podcast and he told the story for us.
It's and how the material is just like works all by itself. And like now add all the stuff that Matthew Ward just did, and like you have Tim mentioning this great writing and everything's working and all the cast is fucking amazing. And you just look at it, and it was I sort of felt that way about Rocky as well when that closed a little too soon. I'm like, like, is it so I'm thinking like, is it me? Like people fucking hate me, and I hate you back. I'm like, I don't understand what you want. I don't understand what this world wants as far as that.
[32:17] Rory O'Malley: So I s uh you know, I spent the time it closed, I started working right away. Like I knew I needed to keep working, even like on an injured leg, I was like, so I did like a television show. So I did an independent movie, and then I got my surgery, and then I did the television show, this television pilot, um, because I knew I needed to like not sit and brew with that that like sort of spine-tingling bitterness. Yeah, it was it was like you could ask Orfe, she knew how hard it hit me, and uh it's like I just hated everything, I hate everything about the Tony's, I hate everything about the uh about Broadway. I just like I didn't want to see it again, I don't want to talk to it, talk about it again.
Yeah, um so on the other side of having so much gratitude when you're coming up and then going to those spots, you're like, well, what does it all mean? I need to take the time for myself. I'm not exactly sure what it all means. I just know that if we keep moving forward and we keep working towards doing our best work, no matter what it is, eventually the sort of calm to the storm happens, and you realize I can be grateful, I can be bitter, I can be all these things, and it's okay.
[33:43] Andy Karl: Yeah. Um it's a tough one to live with because people want to like, so are you really pissed off? I'm like, yeah, I'm pissed off, but I'm okay, I'm fine, and I'm and the people who worked really hard in other shows deserve just as much effort and work because they everybody's doing this great amount of work, and you just so it's it's all it's all like different levels of all that. So I'm super grateful about my position in life to work as an actor. Yeah, but also like extremely bitter at a certain point. Like, and and like I'll always watch out for that, and I'll always be aware that putting yourself out there will can lead to being like kicked in the face.
[34:25] Andy Karl: In some, like, yes, I should be grateful that I'm working and I'm an actor, I'm a lead on a show. It's a tremendous show. People like me for it, it's fantastic. But sort of like when you're looking for something like being accepted for all the work that you've done and all the standing on the shoulders of all these people that you worked with and being able to give you, give everything, you sort of like as an actor, we're out there in front of me an audience, boom-duh. What'd you think, everybody? And they people are like, yay, next, and you're like, oh man, so the world is kind of cruel that way.
[35:02] Rory O'Malley: Um, I mean, just I kept move keep moving forward and finally got over the extreme bitterness into a more aware bitterness. I feel like you're you're never going to give something anything less than your entire heart and soul, you, Andy. I mean, that's that's how you work. And so when something closes way too soon, as GROUNDHOG DAY did, I didn't get to see it. I mean, I was angry because I knew half the cast. I wanted to get to be able to come to New York and see it. And everybody loved it. Everybody had a moment to shine. It's amazing.
[35:42] Andy Karl: Yeah, no, and and I know that it was a phenomenal production, and when things close too early like that, it's always sad. But when you know that it works and that it's great, and that for some reason, part of this equation that we nobody can really ever figure out for sure how to make something work when it just doesn't connect with people buying tickets, and that ends up being the deciding factor, things get to keep going. It's devastating, and it's I can't imagine how you wouldn't take that personally. And from who, I don't know. You know, it's like is it the audience that doesn't know about it, or is it the people who do you trying to make a you're trying to point fingers, yeah? You can't. You can't really, like it is there's some kind of crazy magic that goes into a show crossing a threshold of just running for an appropriate amount of time. And I don't think that people realize how difficult it is to have that rejection. Because when we think about rejection in our business, we think about auditions.
[36:51] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[36:51] Andy Karl: Well, no one comes to all my shitty auditions and sees, you know, like me next, you know, like yeah, but when you're the lead of a show and it's your baby, and your face is plastered all over it and it closes early. That's hard.
[37:07] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, yeah.
[37:09] Andy Karl: It's it's and I know so many people have been through that in their lives, and uh like it was really interesting that it's I think it's here's here's just like a lesson for anybody who's listening. It's like I have never stopped being highly aware of my peripheral vision of seeing other people's reactions to things or other people's acting and how good somebody is, or how like, oh, I don't want to do that, whatever. Something like on the 20th Century, brilliant production, another like glowing review for the show, especially for Kristen Chenowith. Right, like sh like it was this amazing thing. She also went on to host the Tony's while we were doing the show, which I'm like, you're insane. You're going to co-host the Tony with Alan Cummings while you're doing 20th Century, which is a monster role, basically, that she was doing, and giving nothing but love and nothing but pouring her heart out there, and it and it and when there's nothing to say with like when she didn't win, it's like the Tony, it was kind of like, oh, it's like it's not the amount of effort, it's just whatever's hitting right at the right time, it's so many variables can happen.
[38:34] Rory O'Malley: Um you watch like somebody who's at the top of their game sort of funnily be she was so she was she didn't win the Tony. She played it off very cool, and she was like making jokes on camera and all this stuff, but I know kind of how much she put in. I saw how much she put into this role, and I saw also how much she's not a girl who's gonna show you a lot of pain and anguish and tears because she didn't win, but I was like, I know that meant something to her. I know that meant and it's not to say of like say that she should have won, man, it was a total rob. It was just like it happened that way, and from that I could see it happening to her. I was like, I could everything when GROUNDHOG DAY went sort of like in that way.
I was like, I had at least the perspective of watching somebody who like in my mind because I was in the show, like she was everything, she gave everything, she should have she should have won. It was amazing. I wasn't in The King and I, so I don't, you know, I'm sure it was the same way over there, but it just gave me an interesting perspective of how like you know, there's seeing it outside of yourself, yeah, and knowing, yeah, I that happens all the time. When I see somebody experience experience uh rejection or something bad in this business, and I'm like, my god, they've done everything. It actually makes it a little easier when it happens to me to know that hey, if this person who I admire and respect so much, who I've seen give everything has disappointment, then I can take it too.
[40:11] Rory O'Malley: Right.
[40:11] Andy Karl: And these are luxury problems, they are luxury problems, and I know that, and you know what? Everyone listening on this podcast knows that I talk to everyone on all parts of this business. We all are going through ups and downs in different parts of our journey, but it doesn't mean that what you're talking about doesn't hurt. And I think everyone can understand. If it didn't hurt, that would be a problem.
[40:33] Rory O'Malley: Yes.
[40:34] Andy Karl: Because we're very passionate about what we do. And it's like when you pour yourself out there, it's like yeah, you can have all the perspective in the world, but like with Rocky, I was just like, I was getting busted in the face every single time in my life. And I would black out sometimes because I'd get take a wrong hit to the face and I'd black out for like two seconds, like a second I would just see complete black. That final sequence, that final sequence of Rocky was one of the most astounding things I've ever seen in a live theater. Absolutely. I ranged between uh uh 40 pounds off and on between rehearsals and the last show. I was like, I was up and down because I would just like I was just sweating and doing everything I could and like climbing that hill and climbing those stairs and going to the gym and and and and giving every scene its full worth because I completely believed in it. And that's I mean, the journey that journey is part of the triumph. That's my own like award I can take a take with me.
[41:36] Rory O'Malley: Um you know, but it's like so much of Broadway is geared towards, and now we're I'm in another show, and I can see it start to go that way. We're all gearing up to try to get all them nominations and votes and right, and it's not even like six months away. Like uh that's the I start to feel a little panicked because I'm like it's not what it's about, it's not what it's about. It's about it's about the work, it's about it's about making the audiences every night believe in love and believe in the chemistry between Samantha and I and making sure that it all works the way it's supposed to work. That's what it's all about.
[42:11] Andy Karl: Yeah, um it's hard though, because you have people who are in charge of producing it and they know the power of you know the Tony Awards are a wonderful honor for sure. You know, I've lost one. I'm very honored to have lost one. But you're so proud when you when you were nominated that. Oh, thanks, bud. Um but you know, like it's also just a really, really elaborate marketing campaign.
[42:35] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[42:35] Andy Karl: And it's fantastic because it brings theater into people's homes once a year. They get to see all the shows on one night. I love the Tonies, I love what they do. But when you are a part of like a Tony process and you're part they the uh the weight of each one of each campaign or each show, it's it's tremendous. And especially when you, again, are the face of it. People might not know who wrote the show you're in. They might know who's producing it, they might know the person who's been working on it for years, but they know Andy Karl's in it. And you know, you walked out on that stage and got entrance applause. And I was like near tears. I was so excited. I know that you've earned that, but you're still like you're still Andy who came to the Falcon to play Fonzie too.
[43:25] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, and every time that it's like if there's ever applause from the audiences I'm coming out of stage for the first time, it makes me more hyper aware of like I need to tell the story and make sure that they don't think of Andy Karl doing they see Edward Lewis doing it. I'm like, oh shit. Thank you so much. But let's let's move on to telling the story.
[43:47] Andy Karl: You really inhabit your characters though.
[43:49] Rory O'Malley: I mean, we were getting at it with you being a secret character actor, but we were talking about before because the cast recording's about to come out for PRETTY WOMAN.
[43:59] Andy Karl: Tomorrow.
[44:00] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, I don't know. I'm gonna put it out tonight, probably.
[44:03] Andy Karl: So we'll, yeah, tomorrow. Um, you are so well suited to Bryan Adams, your voice in this, and I didn't expect you to be able to pull that off in that way. And I think that it's because I think you utilized who was writing it in the style to inform who your character was as well. Like, this is the way that Edward would sing.
[44:29] Andy Karl: It's a bit of a real toss-up with that, the vocal stylings and this story and this character.
[44:37] Rory O'Malley: Right. Because Edward Lewis is pretty, he like went to boarding school and he's from, you know, probably went to Connecticut boarding school with the Trumps, you know, that kind of stuff. Uh, he's from this world that is all luxury and paid for and he's got all the privileges of life, so what does that guy sing like? What does he talk like? Uh, there's been, it's like trying to figure that out, and Bryan Adams definitely has a style and you can definitely hear his voice in the show.
[45:10] Andy Karl: So it's really interesting because as an actor, I was like, I wanna f— I'm trying to fight this rock and roll sound that wants to because it's sort of mixing with the Edward Lewis, like listens to classical music and opera. He's, you know, this is the kind of, he plays the piano, uh, he's very musically inclined, but it's all been based in classical music.
[45:32] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[45:33] Andy Karl: How do you give this guy a voice in the rock and roll life? But you just sort of succumb to it. You're like, okay, well, it's a show that involves a certain style of music, and then a certain, the music is sort of solid mostly soliloquy in the show.
[45:50] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[45:51] Andy Karl: Um, there's a few tunes that are definitely like storytelling, and I think those suit those characters more. As Edward Lewis, I sing in more of a soliloquy most of the time.
[46:01] Rory O'Malley: Yes.
[46:02] Andy Karl: Um, so his inner voice is like this rocker.
[46:06] Rory O'Malley: And she's bringing out of him, yeah.
[46:08] Andy Karl: You know, it's almost like that's what, you know, what the whole show is her kind of bringing that rock and roll or, you know, free spirit. And like I was talking to the assistant director, he like keeps trying to pull me back into more of like a tell the story classical sound, right? Musical theater sound. He's not, he's suggesting it. And I'm like, I get what you're saying, but um, people don't realize that there's always an ongoing discussion or, you know, notes or like because a show is not put up on a stage and then it lives exactly the same way, it changes every night because we change every night, we're different, we're different actors and doing different parts of it.
[46:47] Rory O'Malley: So yeah, and it's been interesting doing styles of music in musicals, um, because Aaron's and Flaherty's Rocky is another battle. It's like how do you, this piece people want to tell stories, but they're trying to find the musicality of the sound of the character. Um, which speaking of, I'm sorry, but how did you figure out how Rocky sings? Because that's an, I mean, I think they did a lot of work in there.
[47:12] Andy Karl: They were putting everything low and they're right, like slow and like the music was more like more rock, uh, folk-ish sort of sound that Aaron's and Flaherty can surprisingly do well. Um, and uh, because there's just so musical theater inclined and they tell such great sweeping, like Ragtime is a phenomenal score, that kind of stuff. Um, it was just like once I had the voice, then the voice had to like kick into like my nose ain't broken. So it was very character influenced.
[47:46] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[47:47] Andy Karl: So that worked for that one. This one is just like Edward Lewis has more of like a rock tenor sound in his voice. And I, you know, you sort of give into it because you're just like that's what the score does. And the score and the music are actually very romantic and very power ballady songs and very sort of rock power ballads, which actually works very well for telling PRETTY WOMAN the musical, this sort of nineties fantasy movie musical that needs to have that vibe about it.
[48:27] Rory O'Malley: Um, and it's not that it sounds like it's pulled from the nineties, it's just that it's these sweeping rock ballads and it really works well and just sort of like it, the whole thing just smooth like butter.
[48:43] Andy Karl: Yeah, I mean I hadn't seen the movie in a while, actually, and I was kind of amazed how the entire story felt, kind of like how you're talking about going back to school and feeling like familiarity of it, like just the story going through and be like, oh yeah, that's what happens, and the music was so helpful in that.
[49:03] Rory O'Malley: There's a nostalgia there, but it's all completely new, which I did, I thought I might miss some of the songs just on the soundtrack, which is a great soundtrack.
[49:10] Andy Karl: It is, it's a great soundtrack, but I didn't, and I really felt, especially by the end, that you guys had earned every single moment of that you were able to pay tribute to the film without being like completely, you know, beholden to every single line that they said, just checking off boxes. You were telling a story on its own.
[49:36] Rory O'Malley: So there were still cheers from the fans of the movie. I heard a few people shout out the lines before. I was like, are you kidding me right now?
[49:43] Andy Karl: Yeah, yeah. Um, there was definitely, I think that's what, you know, a musical like this is dependent upon the nostalgia. And it's nostalgia and sex, which are great sellers for any show. It's, and it's, we got it, we got them both, but then it's like it's lifted by this sort of fantasy musical version of it, which makes sort of like your, makes you a little tingly because you're like, you're like, oh, I'm rocking out, PRETTY WOMAN is like the coolest movie ever, and it's all right.
[50:20] Rory O'Malley: And they do depend heavily on the script from the movie, um, which that was another battle. Like, Jerry Mitchell's very good at this. He's good at making that smooth over by transitions, so you're not cutting and pasting and editing like movies, you're making these transitions into the next scenes and adding a character here and a character here that will help navigate you through the entire show. He's had a lot of experience with Kinky Boots, Hairspray, he's been involved with a lot of movies coming to Broadway.
[50:50] Andy Karl: Yeah, so and so of Ice, which is this sort of thing of like, okay, we're dealing with nostalgia, and how much of it do we want to use? How much do we want to create our own thing? Um, GROUNDHOG DAY was this really beautiful, like I know they spent a lot of time with that script, tearing it apart, putting it back together. How's this world gonna work? They created this world around the philosophy of the show. Um, PRETTY WOMAN is creating a world around the nostalgia of the movie, which is so important.
[51:24] Rory O'Malley: I think if you tore PRETTY WOMAN apart and made it something completely different than people remember, yeah, you're running into—
[51:33] Andy Karl: Oh hi.
[51:35] Rory O'Malley: Oh, who is that?
[51:36] Andy Karl: That was my beautiful woman. Do you want to say something on the podcast?
[51:41] Orfeh: Hi, I just crashed the party. We're just, we're recording right now.
[51:46] Rory O'Malley: Hi.
[51:46] Orfeh: Do you want to say hi to the live Living the Dream listeners?
[51:49] Orfeh: Hi, Living the Dream listeners, it's Orfeh right now with Rory and Andy. The show is gonna start at seven, so we probably don't have too much more time, but you can hear like the dressers, there's music in the background. That's the best part about recording. I just come and say hello, and then I'll, I'm out.
[52:05] Andy Karl: Please.
[52:06] Orfeh: So, yeah, my wife is—
[52:07] Andy Karl: We're literally just getting to the subject of you.
[52:10] Orfeh: Here I am.
[52:11] Andy Karl: So you're right on cue.
[52:12] Orfeh: Here you are. Perfect. So how, but while you're here, I wanted to talk to you guys about working together. What if, well, would you, is it okay to ask you some questions?
[52:21] Orfeh: Yeah, why are you saying that's what a gentleman?
[52:25] Andy Karl: That's exactly what we're doing. We're not on tape. You don't have to pretend to be a gentleman.
[52:29] Orfeh: Whether it's being her seat.
[52:32] Andy Karl: Notice I did not. I sat right where I left.
[52:35] Orfeh: No, but that's fine because I'm like, you're driving this engine. Um, you guys have worked together, and that's how you met.
[52:42] Andy Karl: Yes.
[52:42] Orfeh: But this is your third time working together.
[52:44] Andy Karl: This is our third Broadway show, our multiple, every kind of show, and we do a lot of concerts together.
[52:52] Orfeh: Yes.
[52:52] Andy Karl: But we have done a lot of off-Broadway and regional, oddly. We've done a lot of regional together.
[52:56] Orfeh: Really?
[52:58] Andy Karl: Yeah.
[52:58] Orfeh: How, I mean, obviously that's how you met, so it's kind of like what you knew of each other. Right. But how do you make that work? Being on stage, having the same schedule. Does that, is that a good thing?
[53:11] Andy Karl: No, it's a really good thing.
[53:13] Orfeh: It is.
[53:13] Andy Karl: I think over the course of our marriage, the fact that we've spent so much time apart has been a good thing because we could never get sick of each other because there are periods of time we literally never see each other.
[53:25] Orfeh: Right.
[53:26] Andy Karl: But when we get to work together, it's the only time we're ever on the same schedule.
[53:32] Orfeh: Yeah.
[53:32] Andy Karl: So it's the only time we ever actually get to go, oh, good morning. Oh, good night. Oh, you want to have a meal? You want to go together? You want to go home together? It's really the only time.
[53:40] Orfeh: For all the date nights that we have.
[53:42] Andy Karl: Yeah, that we've missed over the years. I mean, there was a five-year stretch, I think, other than a couple of random concerts here and there. We didn't see each other.
[53:49] Orfeh: Yeah.
[53:50] Andy Karl: Barely, you know. So it's the best of all worlds when we're in a show together, and I don't see him on stage, as you know.
[53:57] Orfeh: We have no stage time in this one.
[53:59] Andy Karl: Yeah.
[54:01] Orfeh: Except a curtain call.
[54:01] Andy Karl: Except a curtain call where I get to hold his hand, and I'm really paying much more attention to Ezra.
[54:06] Orfeh: Yeah.
[54:08] Andy Karl: So, but I love it. I love it.
[54:10] Orfeh: Yeah.
[54:10] Andy Karl: Yeah, I mean, you guys have really been able to do it more than a lot of other Broadway couples, I think. Especially because you're both playing great parts when you're doing it and getting to do it great opportunities.
[54:22] Orfeh: Yeah.
[54:23] Andy Karl: Do you seek these opportunities?
[54:25] Orfeh: Absolutely.
[54:25] Andy Karl: Yes.
[54:26] Orfeh: And there were many times I didn't get the part in the show he was in.
[54:30] Andy Karl: Yeah, yeah.
[54:31] Orfeh: It's not like, you know, we make calls and say, hey, uh, you're gonna put Orfeh in this show. It doesn't, it hasn't yet worked that way. Maybe now you know, there were parts I didn't get that I wanted in shows that I wanted to be in, not just because I wanted to work with him, but because I really wanted to be in the show.
[54:47] Andy Karl: Yeah, so it doesn't always happen.
[54:49] Orfeh: So when it happens, we're really happy that it does.
[54:52] Andy Karl: Yeah, yeah.
[54:53] Orfeh: Um, do you, we were talking a lot about rejection? Yeah, and even not just in auditions, but in like when shows close, like we talked about GROUNDHOG DAY and how difficult that was. I know that for my husband, he hates, he's not in the business and he hates seeing me upset about it.
[55:11] Andy Karl: Oh yeah.
[55:12] Orfeh: But for some, when you know exactly what the situation is and what it can feel like, do you take each other's rejection even harder than the person who's going through it?
[55:22] Andy Karl: You know, I generally take all of his woes harder than he does because he's just much more mellow than me about that kind of stuff, and I'm much more mellow about other stuff, so it's a good thing that we don't have the same flare triggers, you know what I mean? Like what I get upset about, what I freak out about, he doesn't, and vice versa.
[55:40] Orfeh: So I take, I took the whole ACL tear on stage really hard because people were tweeting, private messaging me, which I don't private message anymore. One of the reasons is that they were saying Andy's dead, like it was stuff like that. So I, I tend, you know, word to the wise, check your stats before you start texting people's husbands, wives, and lovers.
[56:02] Andy Karl: Yeah, you know. Um, so that's hard, but I generally take like when he loses a Tony, I take it really hard.
[56:09] Orfeh: Yeah, I'm the one who wants to storm the castle. I'm the one who wants to pull a Kanye and run up and grab Taylor Swift's trophy out of her hand.
[56:17] Andy Karl: Um, and I have threatened to do that on multiple occasions.
[56:20] Orfeh: But um, I think I take it harder than he does, and I think that's the thing we balance each other out. When I'm nuts, he's not. When he's nuts, I'm not, and it works out. But I do take his moments of not such fabulous moments a little bit harder than he does.
[56:36] Andy Karl: Yeah.
[56:36] Orfeh: It means more to me.
[56:37] Andy Karl: I think for both of you, you can see how much dedication the other person has put into their career.
[56:46] Orfeh: Yeah.
[56:46] Andy Karl: I know, I mean, I'm gonna have to have a whole podcast episode with you to get your back.
[56:52] Orfeh: I crashed this, I feel so bad.
[56:53] Andy Karl: No, no, no. I really was like, this was right cool. Right on cue. Because I wanted, this is what I wanted to talk about.
[57:00] Orfeh: But I also think that, you know, you're talking about people messaging, you know, Andy's dead.
[57:06] Andy Karl: Yeah.
[57:06] Orfeh: There's a lot of loving, but ownership of you guys in our community because everyone adores you both, knows that you guys or reviles us fiercely.
[57:19] Andy Karl: I don't think that's true at all.
[57:22] Orfeh: But there's a lot of like, there are fans and people in this business who think that they know you very well, and when you have a marriage, I mean I can't imagine my marriage being in the spotlight in the way that is with you. So, how do you deal with that?
[57:41] Andy Karl: Um, and how, and especially like over social media and being public, but still having some kind of boundaries.
[57:49] Orfeh: Uh yeah, I mean I, I'm from the age of there was no internet.
[57:55] Andy Karl: Right?
[57:56] Orfeh: Us, we're both Gen Xers.
[57:57] Andy Karl: Yeah, yeah.
[57:58] Orfeh: So it's a little different.
[57:59] Andy Karl: Yeah.
[57:59] Orfeh: Um, that's my perspective. Like I'm not a millennial because I'm not sure, like to millennials, it, the internet must mean everything. It's a form of communication. It's like the telephone. Um, for my generation.
[58:11] Andy Karl: Um, so I, I take, I don't take it seriously. I like putting stuff out there. I, you know, uh, there was, there was a time, I think, was it, there's some websites out there that have chat boards on them.
[58:29] Andy Karl: And when you're exposed to that kind of like negative and positive comments, you it's like it can take you down this wormhole of like how to what should I think of myself.
[58:43] Andy Karl: But as soon as you break yourself of that and realize how kind of like it's just people's egos throwing themselves up on some chatboard because they don't have a voice.
[58:53] Andy Karl: Which by the way, words of the wise again or not so wise, no one's anonymous.
[58:57] Rory O'Malley: Right.
[58:58] Andy Karl: It just takes a simple subpoena to find out who you are and where you live. Trust me on that.
[59:03] Rory O'Malley: I would not subpoena is gonna be our child's name.
[59:06] Andy Karl: No, just no.
[59:07] Rory O'Malley: No, don't.
[59:08] Andy Karl: And that then that brings me to like why I must remain calm.
[59:13] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[59:13] Andy Karl: Out of sheer necessity.
[59:14] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[59:15] Andy Karl: Um because if we both get on the boat of like Yeah, yeah. Defense. It's it can it can go wrong, but it but it's like we switch off though. Like but she's definitely like she's she's the muscle of the group.
[59:34] Rory O'Malley: No, no, I always say what I say is I could cure cancer, but Andy's still the one that walks on water.
[59:40] Andy Karl: Oh, yeah, you know, it's always you know, the wife is always vilified in any sort of situation, not just in our world.
[59:49] Rory O'Malley: Well, especially because there are so many young female fans of Braun.
[59:55] Andy Karl: Even as like a gay actor, I always thought that when I did Book of Mormon, I was playing this young gay character that I was gonna get fan letters from young gay boys.
[1:00:06] Rory O'Malley: No, but it's all girls.
[1:00:07] Andy Karl: It's all girls.
[1:00:08] Andy Karl: A lot of them young lesbians, which I love. They you know that they want to talk about being LGBTQ, and but the majority are young girls.
[1:00:17] Rory O'Malley: So obviously a lot of them look to these leading men.
[1:00:21] Andy Karl: Sure.
[1:00:21] Andy Karl: And so listen, there's a lot of oh, you're so lucky. Like, like I'm chop liver. You know what I mean? It's like I'm not walking around with teeth growing out of the sides of my head.
[1:00:33] Andy Karl: You know, it breaks down for me. It's like if I'm doing a show, I was like doing altar boys back in the day at the new world stages, which was the Dodger stages at the time. It was this big off-Broadway hit, and we started getting this like ownership fan base, which is great, it's what we wanted, but then you realize the stuff that comes with it is sort of like okay, now I gotta, you know, they want me to sing at their birthday party, and if I don't sing at their birthday party, it's gonna be all hell to pay on social media. Like, where do you go with that?
[1:01:01] Andy Karl: Then trailer park, uh the Great American Trailer Park, which Star Warfare came into the new world stages, and it became the thing of like new shiny thing. Yeah, and they all felt like through knowing me could get to her and be ownership of this extremely talented, like verbose gorgeous girl who's on stage. And it was it became this like circle of weirdness.
[1:01:33] Andy Karl: Um, and they've but because we had accepted them as at Altar Boys through the producers as well, trying to like create swirl for the show like a boy band. It became this like fan base that felt like they owned us first, and therefore we can own anything that's attached to us.
[1:01:51] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, and it can look listen, it can get a little ugly.
[1:01:55] Andy Karl: Yeah, it can get ugly for sure.
[1:01:59] Andy Karl: Like who's got the closest relationship? And I'm I you can just hear all the Broadway folks right now nodding violently, their heads are about to fall off, because it's no longer about who's it it becomes in the splinter cell of the fan base. Who's got the closest relationship to Andy? Who's got the closest relationship to Orfe? Who's got the closest relationship to you? Do you know what I mean? It's like, no, but they looked at me more and they said seven more words to me, and blah blah blah. And listen, we're all lucky, we wouldn't be here. Yeah, it's a microcosm. It's a it's it's how humanity works, I think.
[1:02:34] Rory O'Malley: But it's also it's the nature of what we do. We put our art right in front of people and then we see them right out stage door, right out there. They know where we the I've said this a million times. We're very accessible. And the entertainment world hasn't come around to the fact that you can't get on a TV set, you can't get on a movie set. You can't, you know, you literally have to bum rush a stage to get to other, you know, to get to a rock star, and then you've got you're gonna get arrested.
[1:03:02] Andy Karl: Right, you know, if someone bum rushes us at the stage door, no one's really going to get arrested. Yeah, and then someone's gonna go home and say, Oh, the security at the Niederlander was mean to me.
[1:03:12] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[1:03:13] Andy Karl: They were mean to you because you were up in my grill and about to make me feel really nervous that I'm here. And you know, it's not always like that. We're giving you the really ugly, ugly.
[1:03:22] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, no.
[1:03:22] Andy Karl: But it's it's a fan of the Book of Mormon Crash My Wedding. You see what I'm saying?
[1:03:28] Andy Karl: So I know that it can get boundaries can be crossed. Yeah, boundaries get blurred. They feel such a connection to your work and your it is it is it actually is disappointing because a lot of the time these are people who truly do appreciate your art in a way that you've worked your whole life to to have that happen. So it it's it's tough. And I think that like the social media has kind of just thrown gasoline on a fire that was always there.
[1:03:59] Andy Karl: Yeah, there were rent heads outside the Niederlander theater and sleeping on the street. I know when it turned. I saw it turn. I saw the turn. It was it was the rent. Listen, there were always Michael Crawford fans. Don't forget there were there were middle-aged women following him home and standing outside his much like crashing your wedding. There were there were women standing outside his apartment or his house on his lawn going, Oh, let me in.
[1:04:22] Rory O'Malley: So fanhood has never been any different than it is now.
[1:04:26] Andy Karl: There are just more ways for them to get angry at you publicly where that wasn't a thing. It's like I think the thing about, and I'm I'm saying this to the fans right now, the level of insatiability is a problem. Yeah, it's like there there doesn't need to be one more picture or one more trans, you know, action between it, you know, another conversation or another playbill signed. If you've come to the show 16 times, you don't need the 17th play bill signed. Give a chance to the people that are ever only going to come once.
[1:04:58] Rory O'Malley: Right.
[1:04:58] Andy Karl: But I, you know, the producers of every show are like, please. No, it's great, but I'm saying please come back and then we'll be able to do that. Come back. Come back every night. But don't get it. If there are other people, we have to go and sign their first and only play bill or take their only picture with us, or just, you know, someone who's from Germany, I'm gonna want to pay attention to them because it's likely they're not gonna fly in 15 times to see the show.
[1:05:24] Rory O'Malley: Right.
[1:05:24] Andy Karl: You know, so it's like the core fan bases have to not always be so offended. Yeah. There are things you have to talk about. And we're not robots, yeah. Yeah, we're doing this stuff eight shows a week, but it's like every night. No, I noticed look, I'm lucky because especially with like Hamilton, I was doing 10 minutes of stage time and I was like, you know, it was still eight times a week. Eight times a week. It was standout else. The demand from the Hamilton fans was so huge, and they would get upset if other actors weren't coming to the stage.
[1:05:55] Andy Karl: And I you know, I was like going out there on a regular basis because I didn't have to work for I only worked for 10% of the station. So you know, I I just I I think that there is an expectation of of access to people on Broadway. That is it's it is. And I'm always happy to accommodate, but then then once you give once you know the person who's coming back on a regular basis, you're like how about this little girl has a moment. Yeah, how about this? Don't give me dirty looks and follow, you know, my eye down the line waiting for me and saying, Did you just not pay attention to me?
[1:06:33] Rory O'Malley: Yeah in every in every way for for fans not to get upset. Yes. We just set a boundary there. Like I think that everyone is genuinely trying to give as much of themselves as possible when while they're doing eight shows a week.
[1:06:48] Andy Karl: Right.
[1:06:49] Andy Karl: So if people could just not be upset that they're not getting enough frosting on the cake. Me, I am a huge germophobe, and I'm I'm a notorious germophobe. You know me, it's like one of the jokes about me. I'm you know, so I will wear gloves and sunglasses at night at the stage door. That's just one less way.
[1:07:09] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, right.
[1:07:10] Andy Karl: That's where it is. No, but like if they spit in my eye, then that's one less way to get a germ. So you know, you you've got opening night, you've got Tony season, you've got this. These are times where you go, oh God, and it's flu season, and you know every third person on the line is sick. It's your job. You you have to be very, you know, you have to somehow preserve your own wellness. You know, I generally try not to go out, I try to pack all the stuff I have to do every day into the matinee days.
[1:07:38] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[1:07:39] Andy Karl: So I don't go out after matinee days because I'm either running to an appointment, running, it's again, it's not like oh, she doesn't come out on matinees. It's because I'm packing everything in on those two matinee days so I can see the other six shows a week. So these are lessons, lessons for fans by the carls and how this whole podcast has been like a oh like looking at the journey of what it's like to first start out, yeah, get to like everything that you're putting in and being so gracious and and and then the the world that is open up to you later as you get up here and how hard everybody's working or how hard people aren't working, and you figure there's so many different sort of philosophies about every everything that's going on.
[1:08:20] Rory O'Malley: So, including stage stage doors, and it's it's uh it's really interesting. I mean, just coming from what we've talked about earlier to now, it's like remembering to be gracious, but also remembering that we need to preserve what we do as a living, make it the best possible thing ever, and not make it a competition to to attain something that's unattainable.
[1:08:47] Andy Karl: Yes, there you go.
[1:08:48] Andy Karl: Um, and so the work matters and everything keep moving, keep moving forward and keep going and never you can be in you can be bit well, that's something I said before. You can be bitter and you can be happy and you can be gracious and you could be fully aware, all of that together. You can have all those emotions. We're not expected to be super superheroes.
[1:09:09] Andy Karl: What's what's always amazing to me is when I hear about people's stories, how they started and where they are now. It really is up to us to decide how we want to be and how we want to feel every day, so that when you're working at this dinner theater and and polishing silverware before you can get on stage, you have to decide that you love it and that there are hard parts of it and how to work through those hard parts because that's exactly how it's like when you're doing eight shows a week leading a show on Broadway. You have to make a decision how to get through the ups and downs of your day.
[1:09:45] Rory O'Malley: But I imagine, but you know what? I always say this we do this. I imagine it's the same for a bunch of people in medical school and doing their rounds and law school, and then getting a job at a law firm and trying to work your way up to that, you know, to getting partner on the incredulous people that you have to that that all the people you have to deal with. Like we're just in one microcosm of the universe, you know what I mean?
[1:10:10] Andy Karl: And to also what we were saying, the stage door today is exactly as it was when I did Footloose.
[1:10:18] Rory O'Malley: Really?
[1:10:19] Andy Karl: Same exact kinds of kids and the same fervor and the same energy and the same repeat, repeat, you know, clientele for lack of a better word. But they didn't have someplace to talk about it.
[1:10:33] Rory O'Malley: Right.
[1:10:33] Andy Karl: They didn't have iPhones that take brilliant portrait pictures. Do you know what I'm saying? There was just your interaction. Maybe someone had an insta-camera or you know, this is we're talking about the Stone Age now. It's hard for me to even fathom that I've been doing this for 20 years. It's weird.
[1:10:50] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[1:10:50] Andy Karl: But it's exactly the same. It's exactly the same. Just the tremendous amount of avenues with which to discuss it didn't exist.
[1:11:04] Rory O'Malley: Right.
[1:11:04] Andy Karl: It was just the entertainment business, it's very public. I mean, we're literally on a podcast.
[1:11:09] Rory O'Malley: No, I mean podcasts are the biggest thing on the planet now. It's like you don't want a book deal anymore, you want to get a podcast.
[1:11:15] Andy Karl: It exposes the truth and exposes the the nuances that are involved.
[1:11:19] Rory O'Malley: Right.
[1:11:19] Andy Karl: I mean, my my I'm I'm we'll wrap up here because you guys are. I feel so bad I crashed, I still don't know.
[1:11:25] Rory O'Malley: Perfect.
[1:11:26] Andy Karl: This is perfect. This is exactly I'm so so happy that this worked out. I couldn't have gone better if you had it. Um I I feel like the the reason that I started this, and I say this all the time here, is to give people a longer conversation rather than just 280 characters or an Instagram picture of what's like you know, we put out the the picture of us, which is a freaking amazing picture, but I love that picture so much. And it's so fun, but you know, everyone thinks, oh man, that's all that Broadway is. It's just joy. Look how great, look how happy is exciting they are. You know, there's yeah, but again, all factions of life. We are just in this part of this life.
[1:12:07] Andy Karl: Right.
[1:12:07] Rory O'Malley: And um HBO is gonna buy your podcast. We're gonna make a you know four-year series time. Whatever musical we're doing, episode, whatever movie musical we're doing. Um, I am I'm so glad I got to speak to both of you. Thank you.
[1:12:21] Andy Karl: Thanks for letting me randomly and unknowingly crash.
[1:12:25] Andy Karl: One of them hanging in a dressing room with you in a Garry Marshall production again.
[1:12:29] Rory O'Malley: I know, I know. It's it's actually I've done this a few times in dressing rooms before a show, and it's my favorite time to do it because people can hear theater getting ready in the background.
[1:12:38] Andy Karl: Oh, it's real.
[1:12:39] Rory O'Malley: Other actors are coming in. It's really happening.
[1:12:41] Andy Karl: Um have a wonderful show tonight.
[1:12:43] Rory O'Malley: Thank you.
[1:12:43] Andy Karl: Thank you.
[1:12:43] Rory O'Malley: Talented, beautiful, wonderful people.
[1:12:45] Andy Karl: Coming from you.
[1:12:46] Rory O'Malley: Hello.
[1:12:47] Andy Karl: Hello.
[1:12:49] Andy Karl: Audition, side job, swimming upstream. Believe it or not, you'll live in the dream.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
