Nikki James joins us on LTD! Nikki is a Tony Award winner for The Book of Mormon and was last seen on Broadway as Eponine in Les Miserables. Rory and Nikki are bonded for life over their experience in The Book of Mormon... Read More
From the show: Living the Dream with Rory O'Malley
Guests
Featured Shows
About
Nikki James joins us on LTD! Nikki is a Tony Award winner for The Book of Mormon and was last seen on Broadway as Eponine in Les Miserables. Rory and Nikki are bonded for life over their experience in The Book of Mormon. Nikki takes us through her journey and tells us about the joy and pressure that comes along with winning a major award.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:08] Rory O'Malley: Hey everybody, it's Rory O'Malley. Welcome to Living the Dream. Um I hope you had a great week. I did. I got to go to Los Angeles uh to celebrate a really wonderful man, Gary Marshall, who gave me my first job out of college. I played Richie Cunningham in Happy Days the Musical for Mr. Gary Marshall, and sadly he passed away in July. But we all got together in LA to celebrate his life this past Sunday on his birthday, which would have been his 82nd birthday, and it was probably the most beautiful memorial you could ever imagine. I was uh surrounded by my friends who I met at his theater, the Falcon Theater, which is now going to be renamed the Gary Marshall Theater in Toluca Lake in Burbank, California.
And it was it was, you know, a lot of laughs, a lot of tears. There were, of course, celebrities who credit him with giving them their start, like Henry Winkler spoke, it was he was beautiful. Um Julia Roberts, it was a beautiful speech and very funny, and Tom Hanks basically did an entire stand-up routine as doing his impression of Gary Marshall, and then uh Bet Midler sang Wind Beneath My Wings, and uh my little gay heart broke and I sobbed. But it was it was a celebration, you know. It was it was amazing, and because Gary was a very proud alum of Northwestern, the Northwestern marching band played at the end the Happy Days theme song, and uh we were all a puddle, but it reminded me the power of an artist who doesn't just want to make great art but wants to make a community of and a family, and that's the way that Gary lived his life as a creator, as someone who didn't just put together uh a show that was gonna be a hit, but he put people in a room who he loved to be with, and the the the fact that he put me in one of those rooms early on in my career, first of all, it kept me in this business and it made me who I am today, and uh I'm gonna spend the rest of my career trying to be like the man that I loved so much, Gary Marshall.
So it was a beautiful experience, and it's very fitting that this week I get to talk to someone who I love very, very much. My good friend Nikki James, who won a Tony Award for her portrayal in The Book of Mormon. Uh, we got to experience that together over many, many years of creating the show with the writers, and uh and we've we are bonded for life because of that. I love her very, very much, and had a really wonderful conversation with her. So enjoy.
[3:19] Nikki James: You feel good?
[3:20] Rory O'Malley: I'm going to go.
[3:21] Nikki James: He's going, it's already started. There's only a few places in the world where I like literally don't think about my phone, and one of them is when I work out, which is why I think I work out as much as I do.
[3:30] Rory O'Malley: Because you are have an escape from your phone.
[3:33] Nikki James: Oh my god, it's a really weird thing. Like, it doesn't even occur to me, like when I'm putting my phone like in a locker to go into yoga class that like something important might happen in the hour and a half that I'm like taking this class. But I just went to see um Fantastic Beasts.
[3:50] Rory O'Malley: And where to find them.
[3:51] Nikki James: Yeah. And uh and I was like, oh well, you know, like I'm gonna put my phone in the cup holder. I had like a moment where it was like, what what is gonna happen what like what is crucial that's gonna happen while you like sit here for these two hours? I don't know what when you're going to do something physical, you don't even think about it.
[4:07] Rory O'Malley: Well, I think it's just because your brain is so deeply I mean, obviously, like uh five minutes into the film, you are not like because you're watching the film.
[4:14] Nikki James: Right.
[4:15] Rory O'Malley: Um I just think that there's places where we've decided it's okay to bring our phones, and there's places we've decided that it isn't okay.
[4:23] Nikki James: Yeah.
[4:23] Rory O'Malley: Because I don't think about my phone when I'm at the theater.
[4:26] Nikki James: It's weird. I think it's just because other people talk if someone picked up their phone in a yoga class, I don't know what I would do.
[4:32] Rory O'Malley: Have you seen I've seen people though bring their phones into yoga classes and to like Barry's boot camp.
[4:38] Nikki James: You're a very you got me into Barry's boot camp.
[4:40] Rory O'Malley: I mean that's the dozen times I went. But um But you you are big into Barry's boot camp and people bring their phones and will bring them on the floor while they're doing this crazy workout.
[4:52] Nikki James: I don't have that mentality. I don't know, I don't know how people do that. I mean, my phone would be literally crushed to pieces if you tried to bring it into that. I it I'm not safe in a Barry's boot camp. I'm always like so close to losing a finger and lifting away and like doing one of the maneuvers.
[5:09] Rory O'Malley: I wonder also like it's like so sweaty in there. Like I wonder if that's like damaging to the um the apparatus.
[5:15] Nikki James: Oh, yeah, it's like a hot box. I always think of like Barry's boot camp. Clearly, this is not a promotional, but it it does get me in shape. But I think of it as like Guantanamo Bay torture. Like it's like red lights.
[5:26] Rory O'Malley: Oh, yeah.
[5:29] Nikki James: And but you know the red lights make your muscles look so much better. You haven't noticed that?
[5:33] Rory O'Malley: Well, it's it's dark. I'm like, this is very dark and hard to see.
[5:38] Nikki James: How is this good or safe?
[5:40] Rory O'Malley: Um it's not oh well. I don't know.
[5:43] Nikki James: I don't know if it's good or safe, but I like it.
[5:47] Rory O'Malley: Things we do for love.
[5:49] Nikki James: I mean, I think I'm a masochist. Is that the right word? Sadist? No, masochist. Um I may be a sadist too, I don't know. But um, I think I just really like I don't know, there's so I wasn't a fitness person. I I was a gymnast growing up. I wasn't really like into fitness, and it wasn't until we started doing Mormon that I even had money to think about like spending $25 for someone else to tell me how to run on a treadmill. I mean, it's a little ridiculous, but um, but I think I really like I like seeing how far I can go. Like I really enjoy pushing myself.
[6:22] Rory O'Malley: And some part of it is also the um the competition, because I don't work out as hard if I'm by myself.
[6:29] Nikki James: Really?
[6:30] Rory O'Malley: Oh yeah, like I purposely we used to be we're gonna talk so much about this, but this is it's part of my personality. It's like really interesting insight. So used to be you would choose your treadmills, you didn't you didn't have them assigned, so you would just walk in and choose them, and I would purposely like identify someone who I thought might be a strong runner, like just by looking at them, and then choose the treadmill next to them and then run faster than them.
[6:52] Nikki James: Like that's Wow.
[6:54] Rory O'Malley: I mean, and if I think I might see that in you, I see that you would and if I think I might give up and like the person next to me is like still running, or they'll say, like, run at you know, six miles an hour, and I think okay, and I see the person next to me is like running at seven. I was like, well, then I have to be running at seven or one.
[7:11] Nikki James: Wow.
[7:11] Rory O'Malley: Seven point one.
[7:12] Nikki James: Yeah, it's insane. It's a really good idea.
[7:15] Rory O'Malley: But it's good, it's good to like kind of give yourself some kind of motivation and purpose.
[7:21] Nikki James: It's the actress in you that needs the motivation of your character in the gym.
[7:26] Rory O'Malley: It is my gym character, my gym persona. Um, so let's start uh at the at the beginning before I met you when we were doing the Mormon musical, the secret Mormon musical.
[7:39] Nikki James: What were they called?
[7:40] Rory O'Malley: I think it was called the m the Mormon Project or the Mormon Musical.
[7:45] Nikki James: Yeah.
[7:46] Rory O'Malley: Or it was untitled musical.
[7:48] Nikki James: Untitled musical.
[7:49] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, and then whenever we had signs on the door, it ne it didn't say anything Mormon, it was like just untitled musical project.
[7:56] Nikki James: So specific.
[7:58] Rory O'Malley: Um yeah, but but you you grew up in New Jersey.
[8:02] Nikki James: Yeah, I grew up in New Jersey, just like twenty-five miles from here. And um so you do know like my mother and my father I'm a first generation American.
[8:15] Nikki James: Uh huh. So neither one of my parents were born here. My mom is from Haiti.
[8:19] Rory O'Malley: Right.
[8:19] Nikki James: And she moved here when she was like 13 in the 60s. My dad is from um an island in the Caribbean called St. Vincent, which is a British West Indy.
[8:26] Rory O'Malley: Uh huh.
[8:28] Nikki James: It's like directly below St. Lucia. They have a volcano there.
[8:31] Rory O'Malley: Oh my god.
[8:32] Nikki James: Yeah, it's kinda cool. I didn't know that.
[8:34] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, it's a teeny tiny little island. I don't I don't I mean, I don't know how big or small it is compared to like it's small compared to the United States. And he moved when he was slightly older.
[8:44] Nikki James: So my my dad was already like out of high school, so he moved kind of as a grown-up. I think he was seventeen or eighteen.
[8:49] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, so they met in Queens, which is a place to meet when you're from different islands, I guess. Like so many people live in Queens.
[8:58] Nikki James: And um, I have an older brother, and uh, and by the time I have come, they had moved to New Jersey. So I'm like a first generation American. My mom has like a really funny accent.
[9:09] Rory O'Malley: Oh my god, I love your mom. She's so intense.
[9:10] Nikki James: I had breakfast with her this morning. We did she took the bus in and she was bragging so much about the fact that she can get a senior citizen ticket.
[9:20] Rory O'Malley: So the bus only cost her four dollars and eighty cents.
[9:24] Nikki James: Oh man. Yes. And she bought me socks.
[9:28] Rory O'Malley: She she bought me socks that socks with cats.
[9:32] Nikki James: Literally.
[9:32] Rory O'Malley: Is this like Cats the musical or just cats?
[9:35] Nikki James: No, just cats.
[9:36] Rory O'Malley: Wow.
[9:37] Nikki James: They're socks with cats. They're maroon socks.
[9:39] Rory O'Malley: God bless your mom.
[9:40] Nikki James: Yeah, she's a she's a piece of work. She's she's amazing. And then as far as like the the singing and the all that came around, I was like my dad was a singer, like a really good singer.
[9:51] Nikki James: And when he was in St. Vincent, he was like in a band and he wrote songs and he played like shows, not really as a professional.
[9:59] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, yeah.
[10:00] Nikki James: The way you do when you're a teenager. And so I think I was in I was in kindergarten, and uh it was my kindergarten graduation, and the teacher assigned me the task of singing the greatest love of all at my kindergarten graduation.
[10:02] Rory O'Malley: Kindergarten graduation.
[10:17] Nikki James: Yeah. You got the Whitney Houston song.
[10:19] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, of course. The other thing that's like kind of amazing is it's like also the only black girl in this class.
[10:25] Nikki James: So like I don't know. I'm not gonna assume that she was like Did she know you could sing?
[10:30] Rory O'Malley: I don't know the answer to that. And my mom is sort of my mom's memory on all things is like you I always have it's really suspect.
[10:39] Nikki James: Like she'll tell me things that happened yesterday, and I'll be like, No, that's just not true. Like that's just my mom, my Irish mom always kind of puts her own spin on it.
[10:47] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, she's just better to have a good story than the truth.
[10:51] Nikki James: Um yeah, I uh so anyway, I think no, I I have no idea if this teacher identified me as like a singer and or what, or she was like, Well, I want to do this Whitney Houston song because it's nineteen eighty-eight or eighty-nine or whatever year that was, and and like, I don't know, we'll give the little black girl like she probably sings.
[11:12] Rory O'Malley: So I have no idea. But I sang the song, and that was the first time I sang in front of people. So I was what, five or six?
[11:18] Nikki James: Wow. And I think my dad, like that was the same year I also saw my first Broadway musical.
[11:22] Rory O'Malley: And I think Which was what?
[11:24] Nikki James: Cats.
[11:31] Rory O'Malley: And I think I think my dad both you know, identified my talent and also or talent or love or what I don't know if it's talent when you're five, but also that he you know I think there was like a part of him that encouraged it.
[11:48] Nikki James: Yeah, uh, because it was something that he had given up on, and not in a mama rose way, but in uh in a way where like that is why you moved from where you live to the United States to give your children.
[12:00] Rory O'Malley: Oh, so I see, yeah.
[12:02] Nikki James: You know, to give your children the opportunities that maybe you wouldn't have been able to afford it. He's he he had to take certain risks for a better life.
[12:08] Rory O'Malley: Right.
[12:09] Nikki James: And he he's like, You gotta go for it.
[12:12] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[12:12] Nikki James: If that's what your dream is.
[12:13] Rory O'Malley: Totally.
[12:14] Nikki James: And so I think uh yeah. Catholic, no, I mean I sang in Catholic school and stuff, Catholic church.
[12:21] Rory O'Malley: I was raised Catholic, like you.
[12:23] Nikki James: Like me. So you know that the songs are like when pe when people say, like, Oh, so you started singing in church.
[12:28] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, no.
[12:29] Nikki James: Like singing in Catholic Church is not the case.
[12:32] Rory O'Malley: You up on Eagle's wing.
[12:37] Nikki James: There you are.
[12:42] Rory O'Malley: Make you shine like the sun.
[12:46] Nikki James: And doing the hall of his hat.
[12:53] Rory O'Malley: And so that's not the same.
[12:54] Nikki James: It's like when people But it still will bring a tear to our eye.
[12:58] Rory O'Malley: Oh my god.
[12:59] Nikki James: One Brad One Body is probably my favorite song.
[13:01] Rory O'Malley: Oh my god.
[13:02] Nikki James: So I don't know. They aren't uh at the Broadway inspirational voices concerts.
[13:09] Rory O'Malley: No doubt.
[13:10] Nikki James: Apparently. Would be pretty amazing.
[13:13] Rory O'Malley: I mean, I wait we should have a chance. I bet we could do it.
[13:15] Nikki James: Oh, we actually do an arrangement of can we do a Catholic concert to kind of bring new life?
[13:21] Rory O'Malley: That's that's why I love Sister Act so much. I used to like try to convince the choir that they should do that.
[13:27] Nikki James: If we put a little more pep in our singing here, maybe some more people will come and we can fix the roof, just like Whoopi Goldberg did.
[13:36] Rory O'Malley: We need to fix the roof.
[13:37] Nikki James: We need to fix the roof.
[13:39] Rory O'Malley: Your teacher says take off your robes.
[13:41] Nikki James: What?
[13:41] Rory O'Malley: I don't know, just take off your robes.
[13:43] Nikki James: And Sister Act 2.
[13:45] Rory O'Malley: Yes, I know. I love I I like Sister Act 2 better than Sister Act because I feel like this is where we're gonna have to end the podcast.
[13:51] Nikki James: Yeah, it's over. I'm so sorry, but I actually have this debate with the cast of Hamilton a lot because there's a lot of young kids. And I will say this: Sister Act Two Back in the Habit is a phenomenal movie and is so quotable and has so many amazing moments, but you can't get Sister Act 2 without Sister Act 1, and we need to respect where the story began.
[14:17] Rory O'Malley: Of course.
[14:18] Nikki James: And I just I love Sister Act One so much, and I really did want to become a nun after I saw it.
[14:23] Rory O'Malley: Did you?
[14:24] Nikki James: Yes.
[14:25] Rory O'Malley: Which one would you have been?
[14:26] Nikki James: Oh, I was to be, uh, well, I loved Sister Mary Clarence, obviously Whoopi, but you know, I probably I was more of a Kathleen and Jamie than anyone else. Just really that movie really is so good.
[14:40] Rory O'Malley: What's so good?
[14:41] Nikki James: It's all the whole thing is great. But we it wasn't, you know, that is where we started singing. I started singing in church, but it wasn't the kind of singing that—well, no, it's not the kind of singing that people like when people are like, "Oh, so you started singing in church." Right. And I'm like, well, you know, but like when you see me and you think I started singing in church, like it's not that's not really. Because nobody looks at me and thinks, "Oh, you started singing in church." Like they know that my church—yeah, I mean you know what I'm alluding to. What I'm alluding to, like I didn't get like I didn't like get a gospel choir experience, but I did get to be a cantor.
[15:19] Rory O'Malley: Right.
[15:19] Nikki James: And, you know, but more than church, like my biggest influence was musical theater.
[15:26] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[15:27] Nikki James: I mean, like I didn't—I mean singing at church was a place for me to sing, but I cared much more about, you know, the cast album of, you know, Crazy for You and, you know, State Fair and all those shows that were opening in the mid-90s. Like I was just obsessed with Broadway.
[15:46] Rory O'Malley: And one show in particular.
[15:48] Nikki James: If you think you're gonna escape talking to me about Broadway in the mid-90s and not talk about your love for a certain show, you're mistaken.
[15:56] Rory O'Malley: Rent, yeah.
[15:59] Nikki James: Rent. You were a big renthead.
[16:03] Rory O'Malley: I was a big everything head, but like I was specifically a renthead, which opened what, '95, '95, '96. So I was like 14 or 15. And New York City was cleaning up, but it didn't look the way it looks now.
[16:16] Nikki James: Right.
[16:16] Rory O'Malley: And the show—my first introduction to the show was I think it was their performance on the Tonies that year.
[16:29] Nikki James: Right.
[16:30] Rory O'Malley: And I made a VHS tape of it and replayed it on nauseum and then went maybe that week and I stood on what they called the— which was the line. And at that time you could only wait for a few hours and get tickets and sit in the front row.
[16:47] Nikki James: Wow.
[16:48] Rory O'Malley: And I sat in the front row with my friend Chan and Jocelyn and we took the bus in the train, the midtown direct train from Melbourne, New Jersey. Her parents had dropped us off. I don't really understand like why my parents thought it was okay for us to come to the city by ourselves at that point, but we just like did.
[17:03] Nikki James: Yeah, it was a different era time, I guess.
[17:03] Rory O'Malley: And I sat in the front row and, you know, it was the single best moment of my life up till that point. Like for whatever reason, where we were on the line, we got to sit in what the rentheads call the key seat, which is where it's like right center and it's where Mark drops the key down for Collins.
[17:33] Nikki James: Um, throw down the key, and that's where he threw, so it's called the key seat. It's a very prime location. Um, and so we didn't know that; we sort of lucked into it.
[17:41] Rory O'Malley: Right.
[17:42] Nikki James: And simultaneously, like what was happening—the other thing that was happening right around the time was Rent was the internet. It was like really becoming a thing. And so chat rooms and bulletin boards, and I had made all these virtual friends who I communicated with in the—like immediately, not pen pal-wise, like we could talk, and there were people from all over the country, and I would meet them at the rent line, you would meet them in person, or the people you would meet on the rent line, you would be able to communicate with once you got home. And so it became this like, in addition to the show being the show, which was amazing, it was a place for me to have this community of theater fans and share bootlegs and be a part of this like a mini movement in a way that pro—you know, five years earlier we wouldn't be able to, and even five years later it would be too blown up, you know, and too scary. Like it was before the internet got scary.
[18:37] Rory O'Malley: Right.
[18:39] Nikki James: Before your parents were like, "Wait, you're talking to a four-year-old person who lives with their parents in Iowa," you know, like before we realized that this was also a place to potential good and bad.
[18:50] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, the danger of it.
[18:52] Nikki James: And so it was so funny. This is a really funny story. So the first time I saw it, I was sitting in the key seat, like I said, and I look a lot younger than I am, and so certainly even at 14, I probably looked like eleven or twelve. Right. And I'll never forget Tay Diggs. It came out and I was standing waiting for Playbills, um, autographs, which I did a lot of, and um, and he was like, "Oh my god, you were so cute sitting in that front row, your whole time face," and he like did an imitation of my face, which was like slack-jawed, like in awe, and I kind of became like friendly with them, and you know, and it was this—it was a magical time, and um, and I'll never forget it became—it was so—the line became—the show was a phenomenon, you're—and you've now been a part of two other phenomena musicals, and so once the rest of the world sort of caught up with Rent, it became more and more difficult to sort of just do the little key seat.
[19:54] Rory O'Malley: Oh no, you'd have to sleep on the street for all night, yeah.
[19:58] Nikki James: All night, and then you would shuffle around, and I would show up in the middle of the night. Oh my god, what's wrong with my parents? They would drive us in at like four o'clock in the morning, and then they would park across the street on 41st Street, which was literally the seediest place.
[20:15] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[20:16] Nikki James: There was down the street was like peep shows and like construction sites.
[20:19] Rory O'Malley: Port Authority and yeah.
[20:20] Nikki James: Yeah, and they were doing construction on the New Amsterdam at the time. Like, so that would—nothing was there across the street. That hotel wasn't there, none of that.
[20:28] Rory O'Malley: Oh no.
[20:29] Nikki James: And um, my mom would—my mom, my mom or Shannon's dad would pause sit in the car across the street until the sun came up, and then they would drive back to New York.
[20:41] Rory O'Malley: My God.
[20:43] Nikki James: It's amazing. I have no idea. But it's like I know why I didn't do it. It's because I lived in Cleveland, not because I wouldn't have done it.
[20:52] Rory O'Malley: Oh no, you would have done it.
[20:53] Nikki James: Yeah, yeah. And I mean, the fact that you were able to get here and be a part of that, it had to be so forming of who you are today to actually be a part of it, you know.
[21:06] Rory O'Malley: Um, so you were a renthead, you were a big Broadway fan, and so then you started taking classes, or you did stuff at the Paper Mill, right?
[21:16] Nikki James: Yeah, before that, um, I—so that same friend Shannon. Oh, this is the other thing. My friend Shannon is the other reason why I did any of these things.
[21:25] Rory O'Malley: Right.
[21:26] Nikki James: Because she's a completely crazy person, and I say that with total love and respect. So, like, I would have been nervous about some of these things. And she would just be like, "Oh, yeah," completely fearless.
[21:35] Rory O'Malley: Sure.
[21:36] Nikki James: The stories, I mean, I can do an entire hour just on Shannon. But Shannon and I wanted to be actresses, and she's the one who introduced me to the community theater in my town.
[21:45] Rory O'Malley: Right.
[21:45] Nikki James: 'Cause I went to private school, so I didn't know about a lot of the things that were like the public school kids were doing. Right. And uh, she was like, "Oh, we have a community theater, they do a children's production, you should audition. We're doing— they're doing Charlotte's Web, I'm auditioning on this day." And I was like, "Okay." So I auditioned as well. And then there was a girl named Anne Papalizio who had an agent.
[22:08] Rory O'Malley: Of course, Papalizio had an agent.
[22:11] Nikki James: Mm-hmm.
[22:11] Rory O'Malley: So Shannon—oh my god.
[22:15] Nikki James: Shannon devised this plan.
[22:19] Rory O'Malley: Ann, if you listen to this, I'm so sorry. Because I really—we're friends for real too now.
[22:25] Nikki James: Shannon devised the plan that we would befriend Anne Papalizio and her mother to find out how they got—oh my god.
[22:32] Rory O'Malley: And then also get agents.
[22:34] Nikki James: Oh my god, just scheming.
[22:36] Rory O'Malley: We were 12, I think.
[22:37] Nikki James: Wow.
[22:38] Rory O'Malley: So we were—Anne lived close to Shannon, so what—and she was a year younger than us, maybe two, and we're like, "We want to come over one day." And so we came over one day, and we like sat with Anne and her mom, and they were more than happy to sort of like talk about Anne's career in the city. But Shannon was like taking full-on mental notes, and she was like, "We're getting Backstage magazine. We're—she goes to this voice teacher. We're gonna go to that voice teacher too." And I got a copy of Backstage magazine. I saved money babysitting, and I bought headshots from my mother drove me into the city, so I get headshots from this guy named Danny Darrow.
[23:16] Rory O'Malley: Wow, you have a really good memory.
[23:19] Nikki James: Oh yeah, because these are things that like—that was like ingrained. It's not like you could like write it on your—put it in your phone.
[23:24] Rory O'Malley: No, it was ingrained. You were like, "I've got to memorize this name."
[23:27] Nikki James: Yeah, and also I had to like—I had to like go and like highlight the back of Backstage magazine, which we had to specifically ask our town library to order for us.
[23:38] Rory O'Malley: Because it's the '90s, yeah, like there wasn't the internet, yeah, and I like had to go in the back, and he was only 79. So I was like, "Well, Danny Darrow is my guy, that's how much money I have." And then I sent away for, um, the agent labels, right? And I stuffed envelopes, and I lived walking distance to the post office, and so I walked myself to the post office. It was like, uh, within my area where I could—in your 12. And I did a mailing, and I—you did a mailing when you were 12 years old. That is—yeah, I was in eighth grade, amazing, maybe 13, no, 12, fifth, and I got signed by a manager.
[24:20] Rory O'Malley: Oh my god.
[24:21] Nikki James: And um, and I had my SAG card and my equity card by 1995.
[24:28] Rory O'Malley: Oh, I didn't even know what an agent was when I was 12 years old.
[24:34] Nikki James: Because you didn't know Anne Papalizio, no, I didn't know Anne Papalizio, and you didn't have Shannon, who's diabolical.
[24:40] Rory O'Malley: Shannon's like, "We're gonna become friends with Anne Papalizio and we're gonna find out."
[24:43] Nikki James: I know what we're gonna. But that's how it always is. I mean, it's not like it's not too different from what you do in this business anyway, is try to figure out how this guy or that girl figured out how to get where they are.
[24:55] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, and we don't know who knows how to get ahead and get jobs, but you just have to look to the people around you and be like, "Well, I guess that worked for that person."
[25:03] Nikki James: So wow. I can't believe I never told you that. Yeah, it's really a weird story. What it's funny though, the like the mailings and the getting Backstage at your library, because I went back to Carnegie Mellon to talk to students recently, and I think it was just just the other day that I graduated from Carnegie Mellon.
[25:24] Rory O'Malley: It was not.
[25:25] Nikki James: No.
[25:25] Rory O'Malley: And you know, like when I graduated, you had to have two hotlines set up, voice message boxes that they made us get when we graduated.
[25:34] Nikki James: So one in New York and one in Los Angeles because our numbers were Pittsburgh numbers.
[25:38] Rory O'Malley: So they wanted you to have local numbers.
[25:40] Nikki James: They wanted us to have local numbers because that is genius.
[25:43] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[25:44] Nikki James: So we had to have local numbers, but it's because they didn't think that people would want to dial long distance. Because I had just gotten my cell phone the year before. So you had to get a voicemail box when you—when we were graduating. This is 2003, folks. You could do the math of how old I am, I don't care. And we had to, you know, put together your mailings. You had to have the headshots and everything. And I said to somebody when I went back to talk to them, I was like, "So do you have your voicemail box?"
[26:13] Rory O'Malley: What is that?
[26:14] Nikki James: I was like, "No, I have an email and a cell phone you call it."
[26:17] Rory O'Malley: Oh, I have a cell phone, and I was like, "Oh yeah, I guess they don't need to do that."
[26:21] Nikki James: You're like, "I have a website, a Twitter, an Instagram."
[26:23] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, yeah, like in my mind, that was just like what you had to do, and that would be suspended in time that every person who graduated from school would have to have these voicemail boxes. But then I was like, "Oh, and you know what's really good is to send your headshot in the mail to every casting person."
[26:41] Nikki James: Yeah.
[26:41] Rory O'Malley: I was like, "Postcards." Because they might throw out your eight by ten, so you have to get postcards.
[26:47] Nikki James: That will get past the—um, the mail.
[26:49] Rory O'Malley: The guy was—the kid I was talking to was like, "Um, I just emailed them the picture." I was like, "Oh yeah, I know about email. I heard about that."
[26:59] Nikki James: Right.
[26:59] Rory O'Malley: Like, do you even have a hard copy of your eight by ten that you could locate?
[27:05] Nikki James: To be honest, yes.
[27:08] Rory O'Malley: Where is it?
[27:09] Nikki James: I gave it in the other—I have it in a pile of things over there.
[27:12] Rory O'Malley: I have eight left in the episode.
[27:14] Nikki James: And no one's asked for them.
[27:16] Rory O'Malley: But I got them.
[27:17] Nikki James: I have eight, I haven't like reordered probably in, you know, years. I so I was tested. Speaking of this, I tested for um a TV pilot, uh, I don't know, a couple years ago, whatever pilot it was. And even my manager like called me. Um, now we're getting into like the real nitty-gritty of the business. My manager called me and she was like, "Everyone is freaking out because for some reason they want 20 hard copies of your headshot and resume."
[27:45] Nikki James: And my manager was like, none of us have them. Like, do you? I was like, 20. So literally, like my agent was like, I think we have six, and my manager was like, I think I might have 10. And I was like, I have like three of this one, and like a few of the one from five years ago. Like, yeah, it was so they just we just made photocopies, like color copies of them. Right, but but everyone was so confused that like that human beings wanted to actually hold paper in their hand with my picture on it. Yeah, it's it's not uh it doesn't exist anymore. It's a lot of people. I remember very specifically in college learning how to uh glue your resume to the back of a headshot and make sure that you cut along the edges because the piece of paper is bigger than the headshot.
And if you don't do that, that's just the sign of an unprofessional actor. And it's so annoying because you're like, it's kind of like the hot dogs and the buns. Like, you know how like there's more hot dogs than buns. So if you buy like a package of hot dogs and a package of buns, like it's uneven. Like, why did we decide that headshots should be eight by ten if paper is nine and a half by eleven? Yeah. Oh, it's it's maddening. I think they're just trying to keep those, you know, those um yeah, paper cutters in business. They did. They've lost a lot of revenue since we've all gone digital, mostly from actors not having to cut their shh. Um so back to New Jersey. You you had this love, you were you had the benefit of going into the city and uh Papalizio's uh version of the business, and you were a stalker.
Yeah, it's great. All all positive things to get somewhere in this business, but then you went to college for for acting. Where did you go? I went to MYU. And and how how was that experience for you? It was incredible. It was hard, it was like really going back to like going into college. I am like a a singularly singularly focused person. I think I said that word right, but anyway, um I uh I knew I wanted to go to NYU. I knew I wanted to move to New York City. Obviously, all my experience, like being here, rent, like I had such I wanted to be here. I already had friends who lived here. Right. And I knew I wanted to study performing even though I was already acting professionally. Not like making a ton of money but doing commercials and I had an equity card and a SAC card.
I mean I could have just done it I guess um but I wanted to go to NYU and uh and I remember telling my guidance counselor that I wanted to go to NYU and she said like oh well you know you know it's a difficult school to get into and you know and I was like I'm sorry I don't think you understood me. Like I'm gonna go to NYU and study musical theater. And so to that end I did like the summer program. Like they do a pre-college NYU summer program so that I could meet some that it was like four weeks I got to live on campus and meet the instructors. Right. And um and I applied I applied to one school I looked at Carnegie Mellon but I was like why would anyone want to live in Pittsburgh and who knows like I just I was I didn't even know about you know program like I just heard like NYU has a great program it's conservatory.
I also wanted to double major I wanted to study other things. It was perfect uh storm for me but um you know my dad died um May of my senior year. Oh I didn't realize that's what it was. So I had been accepted to NYU and I remember saying to him like it's really expensive. My dad's like we have money put away for you for college and like yeah it's a really expensive education to like learn how to tap dance but you know if it's what you want you you know you'll have what you want. And so then he he died in May um a a month before my 18th birthday, and then three months later I went to college. And so I have like a mom who's single now, you know, a widow. Right. And um, and she's sending me to this like 40 at the time, I think probably 40,000 a year at institution.
And I had a little bit of scholarship, but not much. And uh, and so it was a both an amazing experience and also like a very so the transformation that someone goes through when they they go from high school to college, and then coupling that with you know learning how to sort of navigate a world in that's been like turned upside down, and then also this stress of of that my mother who had no intention of sort of doing this on my own her own, sending me to college, you know. It was like it was a it was a time where I really think I learned a lot of compartmentalizing, where I had to like this is what you do now to get through this, and like you worry about that other thing later. Right. Um and then also like with the my dad passing away and then going to college, I got to sort of not recreate myself, but you know, I got to a sk I didn't have to like be home.
Like I got to create like a new world for myself. It was a really interesting experience, and um, and then I was still auditioning, and I booked my first Broadway show, so my sophomore year. Which was what? The Adventures of Tom Sawyer. Ah, yes. You did not see it. I did not see it, but I have heard of it. We ran 28 performances. That's wonderful. Yeah, it was a huge flop. Yes, but who else was in it with you? Tomar Wilson. Tomar Wilson. Who's my best friend to this day? Yeah. Who's in in Book of Mormon? He's in the Book of Mormon. Who's a listener? He's one of my listeners. Oh, he is. Yeah, he said he listens, so hi Tomar. Hi T. And um, yeah, and Kristen Bell was in it. Right. Uh I understudied Becky Thatcher.
Wow. I played Tom Sawyer at my children's theaters, so I'm familiar with the material. Oh wow, yeah. Was it a musical? We ran for uh less than 28 performances. It was a musical. But it was it? Yeah, it was. It was. But you know, it's like one of those children's like a sample musical. Yeah, I don't I don't know. I just remember painting the fence, Payton the fans. Nothing's more funer or easier dunner than painting the fence, painting the fence on a Saturday out in the sun. I think we could probably become millionaires if all you have to do is like sell kids a a show called That's true. But guess there in there's a scene where he paints a fence and we're gonna write a song called Paint the Fence, where the lyrics are Paint in the Fence.
Yeah. I mean every school in town would do it. Um yeah, but you so your first experience was a big flop. Oh with so many amazing people. I mean it, you know, how how you were introduced to all those talented folks at once. I don't think Kristen was at NYU too. Kristen was at NYU, my friend Joe Gallagher, who else was in it? There was like a million people, really talented people, and um yeah, but here's the thing about like having a flop show when you're still in college. It was like one semester. Right. It was basically like Did you stay in school at the same time? No, I had to take a took a leave took a leave of absence, sure, and then I just came back. It was like I call it my semester abroad.
Like it was just the equivalent of that. Yeah. And I learned a lot. I learned that like booking a Broadway show or being in a Broadway show is not a guarantee of anything. I think I'm super grateful for the fact that it was a flop. Because can you imagine if my first experience was a big ol' hit? Right. And then the next thing you do is a flop. Right. Like if you think this is how it is. No, I mean there's many, many times I've been grateful that Book of Mormon came in a time in my life when I didn't just think, oh, this is how everything works. I mean, we were old. We we w we we were older. Compared to like the people who actually do the show now. Oh I know. They have children. But we worked on it for for years.
So let's let's get to to that. But you you had that experience, you graduated from college and you did it you did another show. Yeah. Um All Shook Up. Uh-huh. In 2005. So that was a couple years after graduating. Yeah, it's funny, th I worked on that show. I I booked that show and I worked shop that show. So I went out of town with it. We did it at the Norma Terrace and at the Good Speed Opera House, and I did two readings of the show in New York. So it was actually a similar amount of time than that I had worked on it before opening the show on Broadway as as we did with Book of Mormon. Wow. And it's actually um it's another like whatever like business story. I had auditioned for Wicked. Uhhuh.
To play Nessa Rose. And Wicked wasn't at Wicked yet. This was two thousand and three or whatever. Right. And um I didn't get that part. And Steven Remus, who's the musical director of Wicked, was also the musical director of All Shook Up. And I remember thinking that I'll shook Up was my consolation prize. Like when as it was happening, I was like, I bet like because he thought I was like so good at that other audition that he was like, Oh, I have this other project she'd be great for. Yeah. Like, but I have no idea if that's how it played out. Yeah, I know I always thought you always you always try to connect the dots. In this business. Like when things don't work out or when the next thing happens and you think, oh, this was this happened because this, this, and this, but at the end of the day, it's all a fluke.
Like it's all just like it could happen because the way it happened. And it's probably probably is true that he was that I was good in one audition. Yeah, he certainly knew you. But like, but that's probably he wasn't thinking like, well, that poor girl didn't get wicked, so you know, I'm gonna give her this job. Like I don't think that's the way it's getting a Broadway show is never a consolation prize. They don't nobody has any enough sympathy to be like, Well, I feel bad, I'll give her a Broadway show. I don't think it works that way. No, yeah. So that I did that in 2005. Right. And so um also not a hit. Not a hit. Not a flop. Not a flop, but not yeah, a fun show and is done still. Oh yeah.
Um it's uh a good show. So it's kinda like in in the middle there. Yeah, it was like it was all my it was all like leading up, you know, like you ran a mile. Right. You can run like a half marathon. I was just preparing myself for the big prize. Right. So how the big prize, Book of Mormon. Yeah. So what was your um introduction to that? What did you you got a call or what happened? Yeah, I got a phone call. Um, I was living in Canada. I was working at the Stratford Festival in Canada doing classical theater where I did not have to sing not one lick for an entire year. It was amazing. Um with um with Christopher Plummer. Captain Von Track. That's right. Oh yeah. That's amazing. I'm I know. I know.
It's kind of weird. This is a business where you can become friends with people like consider people your friends who are fifty plus years older than you are. Sure. And I'm not like, oh, like, I have this like no, it's like my friend, Christopher Plummer. Like someone I would call for advice or go out for a glass of wine the same way you and I would. Right. It's a really weird thing in this business. Yeah. And so some my manager called me. Oh, by the way, like that manager who signed me when I was thirteen is still managing me today. I know, I know her. It's been twenty eight years. That's unbelievable. I know, I can't disappear. I've never heard of that. I you know, I don't know if it's a bad or good thing, but it's it's what it is.
And she's she's a great person. She certainly works hard for you and adores you. And that's it's just it's it's amazing. Yeah, it's really weird. So loyalty people. Yeah. Sometimes you're rewarded for that. Yeah, I got a call. And she said, I'm sure you got a similar call. And they said, um, so the guys from South Park are working on this show. Um, it's being directed by at the time Jason Moore, who had done Avenue Q, and it's um the guys from South Park and Bobby Lopez who had worked on Avenue Q and Steven Aremas, who I'd worked with on All Shook Up. Right. Still feeling bad about that wicked audition just trying to get away. Yeah, still trying to make up for it. Want to get me that hit. Yes.
And then and she said, So it's a two-week reading. You're gonna be playing um an African they said I think she said princess. She was like, It it's in Africa. And I was like, okay. So we can't sign you the script, we can't give you any of the music, and they just want you to be aware of the irreverent nature of their brand of humor. Which is like I was a person who like South Park premiered when I was in middle school or high school, so I watched it. And also I needed insurance weeks. So I said, like, yeah, sure, whatever. Like, how how bad could this possibly be? It's not gonna be worse than like the worst reading I've ever done. Right. And there have been some bad readings. Sure. And I like all these people.
And so um I showed up and you guys had already done one reading that I wasn't in. Yes, but it was only like six songs. Right. It was just the beginning, and I got a similar phone call from Bobby Lopez, and I was working at a financial firm as a Tem.
[41:13] Nikki James: That's right. Got a call, "Hi, this is Bobby Lopez," and I was like, "Oh, I'm gonna need to take a five in the break room." And you know, I'm getting this like most amazing call ever from someone who I is a genius, and he goes, "Hey, I just want to make sure you know that um when we're doing this reading that uh there's a song in it, and uh you don't sing it, but it's got the lyrics 'F you God' in it."
[41:43] Nikki James: He warned me of it, and I think I didn't get that. I know, but I think it's because it was the first time that they were showing it to any human beings, anyone outside of the three of them, and I really think that they were scared that actors would just not do it. And I said, you wrote this, right? And he said, yes. And I was like, then I can't wait to do it. And I know that I fully trusted that those people would know what they were doing with where and I would go wherever they led me. But they were afraid that it would be too hard to get actors to do it. And at that time, it still said like screenplay on it, because they weren't sure what it was. They weren't sure if it was gonna be a stage show.
And I remember after that first one going up to Trey Parker and being totally in awe of him, but I said, please, please don't make this a movie. I did. I said, Broadway needs this. I need this. Because I cannot work at that. I've gotta get out of my temp job. But you know, and then it was just a three-year period, and that's when you came in, and you know, that rule didn't exist until you came into it and started, you know, making it what it was with them, and you know, my role didn't exist. There was no turn it off or anything. I just had like two little lines in the beginning, and so that three-year period, I think that you agree with this was the most beautiful magical creative experience of my life.
[43:25] Rory O'Malley: I mean, I think like it's so hard because it's been a long time and we talk about it so much, yeah. Like, and I've talked about it so much, and you start to just like, it's like any origin story, you've said it so many times that you like forget that it actually happened, right? And so even just like sitting here right now and hearing like it's like I could get emotional thinking about it, because it really was. Like, um, not only just not only that, the people who were in the room along those ways, like those three years where we really grew up, all together. Yeah. You know, we were in our late twenties, mid to late twenties, which is the time in which a lot of actors leave. Right. And we had all had varying levels of success, but it gets hard, and we were all just on board with this thing.
[44:19] Nikki James: Yeah, I think that's what you're saying too, that we were old. We were around long enough to know a good thing when we saw it. So when it landed in our laps, there wasn't one second where we took it for granted or thought, well, this thing'll, you know, if it goes or not, you know, something else will come around. This was like a precious, precious gift to all of us. And for three years, we held it in our arms and cradled it, and I would be at my temp job Googling, like, is anyone talking about it? Is there what is gonna happen? And just wanting to know where it was gonna go. And I tell the story I think I might have told on the podcast that I went to auditions, and a casting director said, I saw the reading of Book of Mormon you did, funniest thing I've ever seen in my life, but it'll never go to Broadway.
They'll never produce something that raunchy on a Broadway stage. And I believed her. I believed her. I was like, I guess you are true. Well, I mean, I was like, what the fuck? You know what? I, you know, that's part of me was that, but the other part was like, what do I know? I know, you know, it's like what this, the, you never, it's like when Gerald, my now husband, when he asked me if I thought Book of Mormon was gonna do well before it opened, I said, I really think we may run a year. I think we can do it. And I believed that fullheartedly. Like I thought people who love musicals and people who get what this is, they're going to go crazy for it. But there's no way we can stay open for a long period of time. I guess we just didn't know. I had no idea.
[46:08] Nikki James: And he told me when I said that to him, you're a fool. This is gonna be the biggest hit in years. I think I don't wanna like pretend like I had like some kind of crystal ball or that like I'm the luckiest girl in the world. But I've had I've been involved in the like developmental process all of us have on so many musicals. And who know Hindsight's 2020, and like we said earlier, every time like one thing leads to another, you say like, Oh, I always knew, or something led me to this audition and not that audition, and I didn't get that job, so I could have this other job. But three times in my career, I have been in the room where a piece of theater was being developed and I thought, holy shit.
[46:50] Rory O'Malley: Right.
[46:50] Nikki James: The first time was in two thousand when I did a reading of Spring Awakening for Roundabout Theatre Company with Gavin Creel, Leah Michelle, me, like all these people, Roger Bart, because there was a masked man character. Roger Bart played it, and we did another one where Michael McElroy played it. And I remember thinking like, oh my god, this is like This is it. To me, like I was like, This is rent. Like this show is gonna be rent. It was then, it was the reading, the Mormon reading, and the time that Lynn Miranda came backstage at the Book of Mormon and said, I'm working on this musical, I hear your voice singing it. Would you just like come and hang out with us for a few days just so I can hear it aloud?
And I was like, Oh yeah, sure, like what is it? He's like, I'll send you some stuff. But it's like it's like Alexander Hamilton, like it'll be a rap musical. And I was like, Oh, sounds cool, whatever, like I'll show up. And it was just like Lynn, Alex Lackamore, like me, Chris Jackson, a few people, like four or five people just in a rehearsal studio at Chelsea Studios.
[47:58] Rory O'Malley: Wow.
[47:58] Nikki James: For Jeffrey Sellers and Ron, the guy who wrote the book. And it was just really casual, just like 30 minutes or something. It was maybe the first half of the first act. And I remember calling my manager, same manager, and I said, Lynn Miranda is writing the next greatest American musical. She said, What is it? I said, It's a rap musical about Alexander Hamilton. She was like, Oh, come on. Right. And I was like, Okay, fine. I said, I felt the magic. I'm just saying I felt the magic. If he said to me, Hey, do you want to do this? I'll do it. Right. And she was like, Okay. And I said, At least, I've been right three times.
[48:33] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[48:34] Nikki James: No, I mean you the thing is, is that when you are in those situations where you're getting material, you know, there's a lot of good stuff that you're like, it's there, but you know, nothing is flying off the page. Sometimes when you're when you're doing a reading or a musical and like it was like Book of Mormon, it was like it was already written. Like it was already a part of Broadway like texts that you know it just was familiar, and we knew what you know where the writers were going, yeah, and and what it was overall, and that it could have a huge impact. You know, I'm just too Irish Catholic to think that anything that I was involved with could last too long. But I'm like so like immigrant hopeful, right? Yeah, like I am like my thing is like my parents are like you can actually you can you know get on a boat or a plane and like to a country and like make it happen.
[49:30] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, man.
[49:31] Nikki James: I'm a few generations from the immigrant hopefulness and really just trying to like wait not for the other foot to drop, shoot or drop. Yeah, I think um, but I remember really I think that you know I always said that the Book of Mormon Theater was the happiest place to work because you know, one we it was it was just a fun show to do. It was very light and happy and laughter all the time, but again, it was a bunch of people who had worked really hard and and been out there and and not you know, we talked about your story of getting there and only talked about the Broadway shows, but you had plenty of time where you weren't working. And I mean that in the sense that you got where you were, and I will never forget a preview.
At the end of the show, you ran off stage, stage right, where I was waiting for my next entrance with the pink suitcase, and it was just clear that the audience was responding in a way that was beyond our wildest dreams, and you said, I'm never selling lipsticks again.
[50:40] Nikki James: You literally grabbed me and said, I will never sell a lipstick. And I said, Okay, Nikki, I will make you and you will never answer a phone in some temp job. No, because six months before we opened and six months before I won a fucking Tony Award. Crazy shit. Right. I was selling lipstick at Barney's to buy my family Christmas gifts. Right. Because I didn't, you know, my unemployment had run out. And I had turned down a job back in Canada to stay home in New York because my nephew was born and he was really sick. Right. And also because I had this inkling. I was like, I think I want to be available for the Book of Mormon, and I'm pretty sure if I do this job, I would have missed that last workshop. And so it was like those two things, but I didn't have any money because I didn't have a job.
[51:32] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[51:33] Nikki James: And so I was selling lipstick at Barney's. I don't know anything about makeup. Like I had no business selling anything to anyone. But I also wasn't on commission, so I didn't care about selling. So I would just like stand there and people would be like, Oh, well, do you think this color looks good on me? I'd be like, Yeah. And they'd be like, Yeah, me too. And then I'd be like, I don't know. I don't know. And I'd be like, and I would literally be like, it doesn't really matter to me one way or the other if you buy it. I think it's pretty, but like it's expensive. If you don't want a $20 lipstick, then fine. That's why I was such a bad waiter because I am the least picky eater. I will eat anything you put in front of me. So when people have specific demands, I'd be like, Oh, you're that's a suggestion, right? You don't if it has mayo on it, you don't care.
[52:22] Rory O'Malley: They got really angry.
[52:24] Nikki James: Oh, people get so mad. It was really funny. I'll never forget the woman who stood next to me selling lipstick, she sold for another brand called Dr. Sabah. Her name was Soraya, and she was like older, and she had like kids who were teenagers, and she was always asking me for advice about like how to get her kids to like do things, and Soraya was also a shitty saleswoman because she whispered all the time. So like and Dr. Sabah is the name of the line, which is hard to say anyway. And she had a little accent. And people would walk past her and she'd be like, Would you like to write Dr. Sabah? Would you like to dress up Dr. Sabah? We'd be like, Soraya. Literally, those people can't. Sing out, Louise. Dr. Sabah. I just remember I hear that in my head. I was like, oh, I wonder if she won a Tony Award because she wasn't a good sales.
[53:13] Nikki James: So I think that another part of what I'd like to talk about with you, because we have the because of Book of Mormon, we should have that experience, is post-Book of Mormon. Because obviously, Book of Mormon was the greatest experience of our creative lives. Not because there aren't great things in the future and that we haven't gotten to do a lot of really cool things, but I think that a really important thing to talk about is kind of like what it feels like after you leave a show eight times a week doing something that you won a Tony for, I lost a Tony for that you know that you that you get to have that experience, and there are so many people who you know think that after you achieve something like that or get to be part of it, then it's just keep going up that ladder.
Our business sucks for that. That's not a thing. No, like in most people's career, like you reach a certain milestone, and like odds are you don't go back. Like if you become like partner at the law firm, yeah, they don't like make you go back to being a first-year associate next year. Correct, you know, and like, but that's not this business.
[54:23] Rory O'Malley: Not this business.
[54:24] Nikki James: And you are only as good as your next job, and next job, literally. Like you constantly, even when you're doing the job you're doing, it's like two things. Well, first of all, like after I won the Tony Award, um, I became an insane person, like privately, and I had like a lot of performance anxiety, and like I started feeling like doubting myself. Really? I think that there's some element of like striving that was comfortable. Sure. And achieving was really unnatural to me. I'll be I'll be honest with you. I was very relieved to not win a Tony. And I know that some people won't believe that I say that, but I got to watch your experience as well. Which was beautiful. And you winning a Tony and your acceptance speech was one of the best parts of the Book of Mormon for me. Hands down. It's the truth. But I knew that there was a new pressure. Oh god, yeah. Not just on everything that I felt so much pressure on what are you gonna do after Book of Mormon.
[55:27] Nikki James: And I couldn't imagine, you know, after it was what for you what you were going through.
[55:33] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, and we and there was all this expectation put on us, you know.
[55:37] Nikki James: Like you hear like, oh, so and so so and so won a Tony Award and the next year was on Grey's Anatomy. And I'm like, well, that's what's gonna happen to me.
[55:44] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, and like that isn't what happened.
[55:46] Nikki James: Right. Um, I remember you the four of us Josh Josh and Andrew, you and me, and we were all kind of going through this, and Josh and Andrew both got like TV shows right away, right?
[55:59] Rory O'Malley: And we were trying to figure out whether or not we were gonna stay for a second year, and there was the pressure of saying, like, well, if I stay for a second year, is that gonna look like no one else wanted me?
[56:10] Nikki James: Right. But like also remember, we didn't make that much money the first year.
[56:14] Rory O'Malley: Like we did well.
[56:16] Nikki James: I mean, listen, I was thinking, it was just the minimum.
[56:20] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[56:21] Nikki James: And like the year two, it felt like, okay, I could be here and like for the first time in my life at already 30 years old, like have money in a savings account. Like pay off my credit card bills. So like not staying for year two, like didn't make sense to me. And plus I wasn't ready to go.
[56:40] Rory O'Malley: Like, yeah, even when I left, I wasn't ready to go.
[56:44] Nikki James: Right. And so um so I was really confused as to like what was supposed to come next, like with the business, the industry. I remember thinking, you know, oh, I won a Tony Award, and everyone was saying like all the biggest agencies are gonna want to sign you now.
[57:01] Rory O'Malley: And so I thought, like, great, you know, I'm gonna move to and like they all were wouldn't even take a meeting.
[57:07] Nikki James: Right. And I learned a couple of things, like timing is everything, and like nothing means anything. And so you could win a Tony Award and never work again, or you could not win a Tony Award and become the biggest star in the world.
[57:25] Rory O'Malley: And it was really hard, both like feeling a little bit like like uh like I wasn't good enough, or I had moments where I thought, like, did I only win because I was like kind of swept up in the Mormon movement? Like if I were if Mormon wasn't the hit that it was, like maybe I'm not that good, and and the reason why these things aren't happening right away, it's it was a very strange experience, and there's no one to talk to about it.
[57:53] Nikki James: No, and I and I I see that because I understand what you're saying exactly. And that's I I love that I get to joke that I'm the Tony Loser Royal Mally because there's nothing that I have to carry around with me with that.
[58:13] Rory O'Malley: Right. You know, it's very easy.
[58:14] Nikki James: Right. And I know what that felt like for you.
[58:18] Rory O'Malley: Yeah. And the truth is, you know, like I know that everyone listening is. I mean, I'm not gonna give it back. It's in your purse right now, right?
[58:27] Nikki James: There's the days that make me feel like there are the days that make me feel like, oh my god, I want a Tony Award. Does that mean like, oh well, it means I have to be actually good in this concert because otherwise people are gonna be like, she wanted a Tony Award?
[58:37] Rory O'Malley: Yeah, and then there are days where I'm like, I can't get out where I'm like just sitting at home and I have nothing to do, and I like pick up the trophy and like walk around the house with it. Like you know what I mean? Like, I'm never giving it back. I love it more than anything.
[58:49] Nikki James: Yes, but you know, with great responsibility, yes, with great power.
[58:54] Rory O'Malley: Yes, or whatever.
[58:55] Nikki James: Yeah, so yeah, it it it it definitely I think is uh a lonely place to be. There aren't too many Tony winners in the world, and it's it's ti it's hard to live up to the expectation of what that means to you.
[59:12] Rory O'Malley: But the good thing is is that nobody cares about things like that other than us, you know, yeah.
[59:20] Nikki James: It's it's a it's one like I I when I got into the Hamilton cast, you know, they're all like 20 years old. They were like, now what have you done before? And I was like, I was in the show, uh Book of Mormon. They were like, Oh, okay, yes, I know that one. Um, were you there last year? I was like, no, I was in I was there in the beginning, and it is a wonderful gift to me, and I know for you now, like as you do other theatrical things, to have gone through the Book of Mormon experience, and for me to now be in Hamilton, I don't have any pressure on Hamilton for me at all.
[59:57] Rory O'Malley: I mean, not just because I was like going into the show like when it was already open, but like I'm there every day, and every day is just that day.
[1:00:05] Nikki James: Yeah, it's that job, it's that moment. There's no pressure of what am I gonna do after Hamilton? People give that to you, they say, like, oh, what are you gonna do after this? I go, I don't know, I'm probably gonna show up to the theater tomorrow and do it again.
[1:00:16] Rory O'Malley: And also, like, you learn for first of all, I wanna say, like, there's nothing more humbling than like, and like you are a super humble person, and like I hope that I come off as kind of humble as I am as you know, like, but like there's nothing that's like both like more humbling and also satisfying when someone when you know, like someone says or introduces me to a friend, I'll never forget this moment. Someone's like, Well, you know, Nikki won a Tony Award, and the person, oh wow, a Tommy, yeah. What's what's that for?
[1:00:46] Nikki James: And I just remember thinking, like, see, it's that it relieves pressure from you when you realize that like all of this madness is shit that you've just cooked up in your own brain to make you crazy.
[1:00:58] Nikki James: When I was going to a Broadway show, uh, like two weeks ago, the usher saw me and she said, right this way, this entrance for Tony winners, she says to me, and I said, Oh, I didn't win.
[1:01:15] Nikki James: And then she goes, she said, and she got up, no, she got, she got embarrassed, and she went, Oh, and I realized she probably doesn't know my name, she just knows that I was in Mormon and thinks I won a Tony for it.
[1:01:27] Rory O'Malley: So she was like, Oh, well, you should have won.
[1:01:31] Nikki James: And I said, Thank you. You don't know who is in that category or anything. But people, but people, it's just funny to me because the things that we think are so important or or that are to other people, they don't know. And you know, like it's it's a wonderful honor that you won the Tony, and you deserved it, and you were so brilliant in that performance, and like I said, it was it it it felt like a win for all of us. And I and I I mean that not to take credit for your win, but you know it was that was that was you were the heart of a show of a of a show that was uh in need of heart, and that's why I think it was such a success.
[1:02:08] Nikki James: Yeah, and I think that it was uh without what you did, the show just wouldn't be what it was.
[1:02:15] Rory O'Malley: And so it was well learned. I remember after I won, I was in the um like the press area, and so like they make you leave the building, actually, and like and so I had no idea if you had won or not.
[1:02:26] Nikki James: Oh, right.
[1:02:26] Rory O'Malley: And I walked into this room, and they're like, and I was like, so and they were because they I knew that I was going to see whoever won supporting actress supporting actor in a musical, and I saw it was like John Larakette, right? And they wanted me to take all these pictures with him, yeah.
[1:02:26] Nikki James: And I was like, no, I did, but I was like so because that's how I found out.
[1:02:46] Rory O'Malley: I was just like, shit.
[1:02:47] Nikki James: Yeah.
[1:02:48] Rory O'Malley: Talking about winning a Tony, I was sitting next to Andrew Randall's um at I can't remember where we were, but this woman's like, oh well, you know, I was in the theater in the lobby, you know, when you won to Andrew, and he was like, no, and she was like, Yes, I was. I remember because your dad, your your dad was in was trying to get back into the room and they wouldn't let him in because it wasn't a commercial break.
[1:03:14] Nikki James: And and so I know like when you won.
[1:03:16] Rory O'Malley: Right.
[1:03:17] Nikki James: And Andrew was like, no. And she was like, yes, because and she just kept on telling him that. This is what happened. You won a Tony. Yes. And I remember it. And I was there, and this is why I remember it. And and I had to like move myself away from the conversation because I was so like massively uncomfortable that like Andrew had to like get into like basically an argument with this woman. To be like, I didn't win a Tony, ma'am, no matter how much you think my father fought to get into that theater, it just didn't happen. I'm so sorry. And she wouldn't leave it alone. It was pretty awesome.
[1:03:50] Rory O'Malley: Well, it's I think that you know there's a lot there's a lot to take from that in it that a lesson from that in general, not just about Tony Awards, but that the things that we think about are so important in this business, especially when it comes to what other people think.
[1:04:06] Nikki James: Yeah, the milestones of like, I don't know if people really appreciate me if I haven't gotten my first Broadway show or if I haven't done this kind of a role or this. Nobody cares.
[1:04:18] Rory O'Malley: Nobody cares, and that shouldn't be something that makes you sad.
[1:04:22] Nikki James: It should give you some kind of relief.
[1:04:24] Rory O'Malley: It's freeing, it's freeing.
[1:04:26] Nikki James: You can be yourself and you can have your own journey if you're less concerned with how everyone else is perceiving whatever the hell your journey is.
[1:04:32] Rory O'Malley: Right. And like, and you don't know what it's gonna be. I mean, that's that's that's the story of like I'm never selling lipstick again.
[1:04:41] Nikki James: It's like, first of all, I may have to sell lipstick again. I don't and I will be fine with that too. Like I think what you Oh, I still have my temp agent's phone number in my phone. I mean I'm in contact with her every so often. I give her names of people who are looking for work, but I'm always ready. I know that she's the reason I was able to do Book of Mormon, is because she got me work at financial.
[1:05:02] Rory O'Malley: Of course.
[1:05:02] Nikki James: And you have to just have that. And you asked earlier about like what happens after. And like what happened after was um I did a bunch of really amazing things that that doing Mormon allowed me to do while also staying in the show.
[1:05:18] Rory O'Malley: Right.
[1:05:18] Nikki James: Um, like I did a playoff Broadway and I did like a movie and some TV stuff. And then when it was time to leave, it was, you know, Josh and Andrew had already left and you had left already. And I was like, I guess it's time to go.
[1:05:33] Rory O'Malley: And I got this call that they were reviving Lame is Rob. And I was like, Well, I need to be in the show.
[1:05:39] Nikki James: Yeah. That was my ultimate my theater girl fan. And so it was like I got to leave, you know, the show of my dreams that I didn't know existed until I saw it on the paper to do the one that's a other show of my yeah. And it was it was also it was an an amazing experience. And then, you know, I only stayed in Lamez for a year at that point because I've been doing eight shows a week for so long. I was exhausted.
[1:06:02] Rory O'Malley: Yeah.
[1:06:03] Nikki James: But uh, but that was the first like when I left Lay Miz, that was really the first time I had chosen, you know, the abyss of unknown, other than like the comfort and the security of uh of a job in a theater.
[1:06:17] Rory O'Malley: Well, you have a great work ethic, and clearly that is another part of your immigrant family.
[1:06:24] Nikki James: Oh, yeah, you know, of of needing to hustle to make things happen. And I think that you're a great example of someone who's made an amazing mark on this industry. And like I think that you're awesome, and I really appreciate you talking.
[1:06:40] Rory O'Malley: I love talking to you.
[1:06:41] Nikki James: I love talking to you too. I mean, we always do. It's just nice that we can share.
[1:06:45] Rory O'Malley: I hope all these people think it's interesting too.
[1:06:48] Nikki James: They will.
[1:06:49] Rory O'Malley: They will, you know. I think that it's it's um it's nice to get to hear uh a phenomenal actress, Tony Winner, talk about her insecurity after winning, because I think that we all have it every single day, every time we walk into a room and try to say that we are worthy of being doing what we do, and so it's helpful helpful for me knowing how talented you are to know that you have that feeling as well.
[1:07:18] Nikki James: Some people, and you know, I had this I this conversation once, and this is the last thing I'll say, where I had this moment where someone said the reason why they were talking about basketball, the reason why Steph Curry is so good at basketball is because you can see in his face that he never thinks he's not gonna make the shot.
[1:07:36] Rory O'Malley: Right.
[1:07:36] Nikki James: Right? He just and like he has this, and you can see that when you watch him, and I'm like, okay, that's one way. And this guy was like, that's why he's so good. And I was like, well, that's why Steph Curry is so good. But then I watched this Serena Williams um documentary, which if you guys haven't seen it, we haven't seen it, it's it's literally amazing. I'm fully obsessed with her. And she talks about she's arguably the greatest athlete male, male or female who's ever stepped foot on a tennis court, and she talks about what drives her is a little bit of a fear of failure. Like that is her drive. Like she doesn't know that she's the best. That's why she works as hard as she does. Like she's striving constantly, and she has several, and I thought there's two there's a more than one way to get to like six guys to success.
And every and the one other thing is nobody knows what's in someone else's heart. You know, we don't I don't know. I'm saying Steph Curry always thinks he's gonna make the shot because that's the way I'm perceiving him based on his talent or Serena Williams is whatever, and you just don't know what's in people's hearts. It's really uh it's um it was an amazing insight because uh and that's why she's like totally my hero.
[1:08:51] Rory O'Malley: Well, thanks for letting us into your heart.
[1:08:54] Nikki James: Oh yeah, into my heart in a soul.
[1:08:57] Rory O'Malley: I love you.
[1:08:58] Nikki James: Thanks for talking to me.
[1:09:00] Rory O'Malley: Audition, side job, swimming upstream. Believe it or not, you'll live in a dream.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
