Today we're turning the classic David Fincher critique of Capitalism "Fight Club" into a musical! Donate to Black Lives Matter here. Our WEBSITE. Musicals with Cheese on Twitter. Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram. Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com... Read More
From the show: Cinema with Cheese
About
Today we're turning the classic David Fincher critique of Capitalism "Fight Club" into a musical!
Donate to Black Lives Matter here
Social Media:
Musicals with Cheese on Twitter
Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram
Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com
Jess Socials
Andrew Socials
Brianna Socials
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:14] Jesse McAnally: Hello and welcome back to Cinema with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew and I forgot what show I'm doing.
[0:23] Andrew: Shit.
[0:23] Jesse McAnally: We're trying to make a musical in less than 30 minutes.
[0:26] Andrew: What wait, what what show are we doing?
[0:28] Jesse McAnally: Make me a musical.
[0:31] Andrew: Ah, excellent.
[0:33] Jesse McAnally: Oh my god.
[0:34] Andrew: Oh my god.
[0:35] Jesse McAnally: Oh the camera's shaking.
[0:36] Andrew: Oh, Jesse, are you just like the evil version of me?
[0:41] Jesse McAnally: I am you.
[0:43] Andrew: Oh no!
[0:45] Jesse McAnally: What a twist!
[0:46] Andrew: I am not Edward Norton. I am in fact Brad Pitt. I'm you, I'm the you that you wish you could be.
[0:54] Jesse McAnally: I feel like that brings a greater subtext of the entirety of our show in all honesty. Um we're talking about the thing that I guess has already been tried to turn into a musical, but it never happened, according to some articles from 2015.
[1:09] Andrew: Hey, hey, it hadn't happened, so we got free reign. Um we're gonna try to turn Fight Club into a musical today, guys.
[1:17] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Um so Andrew, for I'm gonna guess there's probably at least one person that doesn't know the plot of Fight Club. What is the plot of Fight Club?
[1:27] Andrew: Uh Fight Club is a book and movie. Most people probably know the movie about a guy who is um unable to find any happiness at all. Um and is very upset with the world because he isn't getting what the world promised him. And so he meets someone who promises to get him that by beating the shit out of him. Um and then they start a place where everyone beats the shit out of each other. Um that's called Fight Club. And then there's more stuff that happens, but I don't know. Do we keep going?
[2:08] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Um so spoilers for Fight Club, if like yeah, whatever we were getting. This is the real spoiler territory, because you could probably gather what I just said from the title.
[2:19] Andrew: Yeah. Um it turns out that the main character is actually like this anarchist best friend, they're the same person, and that's the twist.
[2:28] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[2:29] Andrew: I don't even know if I could call him an anarchist. He's kind of doesn't have a real He like represents everything that the current society and system upholds as like the ultimate good, like super masculine macho.
[2:51] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[2:52] Andrew: So they wanna they basically want to tear down the system to implement the system again. Like it's kind of like they don't really know what they want. I don't know.
[3:08] Jesse McAnally: It's a very relevant movie, though. Like, I know they're anti-consumerism, that's like their big thing.
[3:14] Andrew: They're anti-consumerism, they're also anti um like feminization, or what they view as uh, or or demasculization is probably a better term. Um, or what they view as that. Like there's a lot of references to like men growing uh breasts and uh also uh he goes to the the um place where the the men had testicular cancer and and lost their testicles. Like there's a whole lot of references to that. Um it's it's uh the feminization in men, there's a lot of crazy crazy stupid stuff in this show. But really, really what it is is just it's mostly just about somebody fully embracing like all of the tossed toxic elements of masculinity.
[4:03] Jesse McAnally: Yes, and where that leads you and the horrible things that can get you to do just by feeling like you're less of a man.
[4:13] Andrew: Yeah.
[4:14] Jesse McAnally: And in that way, I think it's honestly maybe even more relevant today than when it came out, because I mean, we've seen that type of stuff just take over our culture in a lot of ways. And the film isn't subtle with what it's trying to say.
[4:29] Andrew: It's meant it's framing these as toxic, horrible people that just feel like their dicks are smaller than everyone else, so they have to cause violence and all that shit to make them feel more like men. They have to beat the shit out of each other, they have to do all these like destructive things to gain control of their masculinity.
[4:46] Jesse McAnally: Um and the thing is, when this film came out and many years afterwards, a lot of dude bros that it was criticizing embraced it because man, this looks fucking badass. They're so cool, beat the shit out of each other.
[4:59] Andrew: Yeah, and I mean that always happens though, like, you know, it's very hard to create a satire piece that satirizes a group of people like this where they won't just embrace it. And we talked about this uh in our funerals episode as well.
[5:14] Jesse McAnally: You have stuff like Starship Troopers where like actual fascists just latch on to it and they're like, Yeah, this is great because like look it, it's so cool. It's just like, well, it's making fun of you though.
[5:25] Andrew: Like, like you don't see that. Well, that's a reason why you kinda have the most effective satire comes from comedy. Um, like Jojo Rabbit, the producers.
[5:35] Jesse McAnally: Because it's hard to latch on to something that's actively making you a joke.
[5:39] Andrew: Yes.
[5:39] Jesse McAnally: Um and the worst thing that fascists and toxic men hate is being made fun of, making their dicks feel small.
[5:48] Andrew: Yeah.
[5:49] Jesse McAnally: No, I agree. And that's why they like this, because Brad the Brad Pitt character uh in this genuinely is like kind of fun to watch and and cool.
[5:59] Andrew: Uh cool in quotations, like Yeah, but he's the idealized version of a man, and then at the end it turns out he's a fantasy that doesn't exist.
[6:07] Jesse McAnally: Oh yeah. No, I'm not saying that it it's not making fun of them, it's just I could see how they would completely miss it. And David Fincher, the director of the film, has said more recently, like, you know what, if like my daughter was dating a guy and he came up to me and said Fight Club was his favorite movie, I would definitely not want my daughter dating him.
[6:29] Andrew: You'd have to at least ask why they like Fight Club.
[6:33] Jesse McAnally: I feel like when you frame it that way and you look at the guy, you kind of know your answer.
[6:40] Andrew: Yeah, it's like, okay, so Fight Club is a really good movie. I could see a lot of different types of people really liking it and saying it's their favorite, but uh you know that one type of guy who's like, Yeah, Fight Club is my favorite. That becomes their entire personality.
[6:56] Jesse McAnally: Like you can kind of get where they're like, I will Tyler Durden's such a badass.
[7:01] Andrew: The type of people that post on their Facebook memes that have Tyler Durden quotes. It's like, oh no.
[7:06] Jesse McAnally: Oh no. Tyler Durden is not a real thing, you idiot.
[7:12] Andrew: He's not he's not real even in the movie.
[7:17] Jesse McAnally: Alright, so we need to figure out how we're turning this into a musical. And I feel like we lead much harder into the satire, lead it more into like dark comedy territory.
[7:26] Andrew: Um and not to say that there isn't dark comedy there, but I imagine the opening scene is a song called Support, where the narrator, which is all Ed Norton's characters ever really called in there in the film, um, just talks to you about like how everyone's looking for support.
[7:43] Jesse McAnally: And we kind of like both. Well, you could have a number that's just him going to several different support groups over and over and like they all sing. The name of the song is called Support, meaning that he's going to support groups and everyone's looking for support.
[8:00] Andrew: Yeah.
[8:01] Jesse McAnally: Um I'm wondering if we could do like a mix of music styles here, because I almost feel like the support groups and the um uh what is the what is the uh the only girl's name in this movie?
[8:14] Andrew: I I can't remember her name if they even gave her one.
[8:17] Jesse McAnally: Marla, Marla Singer.
[8:18] Andrew: Marla.
[8:18] Jesse McAnally: I almost feel like they should have a different music style than the uh Tyler Durden and and the in the lead do. I feel like Tyler Durden has to have a sound unlike anyone else to kind of He has to be like hard rocky telegraph, like maybe no, not punk.
[8:35] Andrew: I think he should be hard rock. I think he should be like ACDC kind of like just hard, you know.
[8:42] Jesse McAnally: And I feel like Rock shouldn't appear when he's not around. Unless we're like kind of, you know, hinting at him.
[8:51] Andrew: Yeah, I think him and potentially uh the unnamed main character could have a similar music style because technically they are supposed to be the same person.
[9:03] Jesse McAnally: Uh so something that ties them together, like you have the narrator's theme and then Tyler's theme be the same thing, but like with such different instrumentation you can barely tell.
[9:15] Andrew: Oh yeah, yeah.
[9:16] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, you have separate instrumentation, but then by the end of it they kind of completely bore together.
[9:21] Andrew: Exactly, where they kind of co-op each other.
[9:24] Jesse McAnally: Or like one is part of a phrase, the other finishes the phrase, and you kind of think that they're their own individual things until they come together at the end.
[9:32] Andrew: Yeah.
[9:33] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I definitely like that, because you can play with that musically more than you even could in something like film, so and I feel like we need like Tyler's song to be like his opening number to be like soap or something, like something a pun about soap.
[9:50] Andrew: Yeah.
[9:51] Jesse McAnally: I think and what's really great is he just kind of shows up too.
[9:55] Andrew: Yes.
[9:56] Jesse McAnally: And you can even have you can even like hint at him in earlier songs, and then he just kind of shows up. I mean, in the film they literally put him into the background of the shot for like one frame, that kind of stuff.
[10:10] Andrew: You could probably do that in staging a bit.
[10:12] Jesse McAnally: You could do that with like projection, or you could even put an actor out there for a bit and then kind of hide him.
[10:19] Andrew: Yeah, you could do something like that. You could also instrument instrument-wise, like say he's symbolized by like an electric guitar or something, just have like one strum somewhere in a song, like, you know, what I I have no idea. I'm not sure exactly how you would do something like that, but I think it could be cool.
[10:35] Jesse McAnally: Now, how do we perform the fight scenes?
[10:40] Andrew: Um I mean, I d the fight. I feel like we shouldn't focus on them. It's kind of the thing I was about to suggest. They shouldn't be focused on, I don't think, but also the fighting even in the movie isn't really like glamourized.
[10:53] Jesse McAnally: It's kind of like dirty and like uh I almost feel like just having them do mock fist fighting on stage would be plenty.
[11:02] Andrew: And it kind of has to look terrible.
[11:04] Jesse McAnally: I want them to be like not good fighters at all.
[11:08] Andrew: Yeah.
[11:09] Jesse McAnally: Well, I mean, there the fighting in the movie isn't really ever a main showcase. Like there's not like fight scenes in it, from what I remember.
[11:19] Andrew: Um they ha they do fist fighting, but it's like it's always like somebody gets punched and they're just like bleeding.
[11:26] Jesse McAnally: I had this idea as we're talking, and maybe misguided, but I was like, eh, it's something to bring up. What if every character outside of the two leads, Tyler and the narrator, was played by someone not a man, whether it be like someone trans non-binary or a woman, which would kind of like hammer in the home of like the toxic masculinity side.
[11:51] Andrew: I don't know if I like that necessarily.
[11:54] Jesse McAnally: I think it's interesting enough to like broach it because this is a very male heavy show.
[12:00] Andrew: I kind of feel like it might work against it a little bit though.
[12:04] Jesse McAnally: Because the idea of the show is that like the people who have lost their testicles or or the guy who has is growing breasts or whatever, they're all men.
[12:14] Andrew: Yeah.
[12:15] Jesse McAnally: Like the idea is that they aren't they didn't actually lose their masculinity. They are still men. So if anything, I kind of feel like maybe they should all be played by men no matter what.
[12:26] Andrew: Fair enough.
[12:27] Jesse McAnally: Uh it was just something I was thinking about. Um Marla needs her own song, though.
[12:31] Andrew: Like, and I don't like the kind of jokes in the movie with her.
[12:36] Jesse McAnally: I kind of want to make her more of a person, 'cause like her iconic line in the film is I haven't gotten fucked like that since grade school.
[12:43] Andrew: Which is just like ah.
[12:45] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, if there's one actual really good criticism about the movie is that she's barely a character.
[12:51] Andrew: Yeah, she's just like this poor battered woman, confused and angry, and rightfully so once you know the twist.
[12:59] Jesse McAnally: Oh yeah, of course. I mean, she's like, what is going on with this guy? He's actually like back and forth between different personalities.
[13:12] Jesse McAnally: Um I don't know what you do with her though. You know? I feel like give her some backstory. Give her a reason to actually be interested in both of the men. Give them a moment with both versions of the man where you kind of see like why she's into either of them. I feel like she doesn't have much agency in the story where she's just suddenly fucking men.
[13:34] Andrew: Yeah. No, I mean I do agree. I just I personally don't know how to solve it.
[13:38] Jesse McAnally: I don't either. Um, but I like even just a song called Marla where she gets to say who she is and where she stands and all that, maybe just that and is enough to give her more of a presence outside of an object, which she is in the movie.
[13:56] Andrew: Oh yeah. No, I mean that's it is a good legitimate criticism. Uh I don't know what I would do with it. Whereas I think that's not much David Fincher's fault, as we've seen later, he's very good at portraying women in his films. Um I think it's probably from the book.
[14:15] Jesse McAnally: If I it probably is. Though if you take the movie incorrectly, like a lot of people do, it definitely sends a really bad message of like women are just not even really people. You know?
[14:41] Andrew: Yeah, that movie is kind of sickening. Um so consumerism, that side of it, the terrorism. I feel like a lot of that stuff could be shown through like projections. I feel like this is a good show to like embrace the projection side. Especially for that ending shot where I kind of think we should recreate on stage.
[15:01] Jesse McAnally: Oh yeah. And that's that'd be a pretty easy one to do with projections. Uh it would probably look about as good as Prince of Egypt, but you know, we could do it.
[15:10] Andrew: I mean, it's not hard to do things better than Prince of Egypt, though.
[15:14] Jesse McAnally: No, I mean hopefully we could do it a little bit better than that, but it wouldn't be that hard to do. I mean, it's literally just two actors holding hands and then a projection of buildings falling, right? That'd be all you have to do.
[15:26] Andrew: Yeah, and like all of that. And do we use the same music cue or do we write our own thing where it's like so so starts it all.
[15:35] Jesse McAnally: You'd you we would write our own thing. We're not gonna use a uh what what's what type what uh band do they use?
[15:41] Andrew: I I almost forget. I can hear it in my head, but I could not tell you what band that was.
[15:49] Jesse McAnally: I used to sound track was like what the song was thing when the movie came out. It's the pixie it's the pixies.
[15:54] Andrew: Oh god. Yeah, we don't we don't use that. Um I mean this at a certain point this just kind of becomes like recreating the movie. What are we gonna do stage wise, staging wise, that sets it apart from the film.
[16:12] Jesse McAnally: So what do we do with um staging things like the weird like because the movie is full of this weird editing and like uh camera tricks and things, like what do we do with that?
[16:29] Andrew: I mean, you gotta try to figure out a way to tell it all in one single thing. Um I feel like you could use the projection as part of it. Like, because we set up that Tyler Durden is a film projectionist, and you can kind of work that in, where suddenly the background starts to weave and bob like the film reels used to. You could do a lot of cool shit that way.
[16:52] Jesse McAnally: Is this like usually you're very against projections, so is this like uh you just think it would work so well into the story, yes. And there's so many opportunities here.
[17:04] Andrew: I mean, realistically, I think a lot of this could just be projections and like minimal like I don't think you'd need much of a set.
[17:14] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, but I'm like imagining a scene where you've got like the violent angel face Jared Leto beating, and then you just see his blood splatter onto the projection screen in sync, like kind of like the Terminator ride. Like, and I'm like, that shit could work.
[17:30] Andrew: I'm I mean, yeah. I'm not against it. I don't yeah, I mean, I think we've put out our ideas here, and a lot of this is just gonna be like Do the movie and just recreate it. You've seen the movie, do that!
[17:43] Jesse McAnally: Come on. Is there anything from the movie that you think we should specifically cut that like wouldn't work in a stage show al uh environment?
[17:56] Andrew: I feel like the sex scenes are a little too like there's like the literal all CGI sex scene where it's like, no, I feel like we don't need to see those.
[18:05] Jesse McAnally: Oh, you're right. Yeah, you're definitely right. I feel like uh just we imply the sex, and then he gets all butthurt.
[18:13] Andrew: Yeah, I don't think we need that. Um would it be long enough? How long is the movie?
[18:19] Jesse McAnally: Movie is about two hours.
[18:21] Andrew: So I think we've already got enough there.
[18:24] Jesse McAnally: 139 minutes, shit. That's a musical right there. Dang, this is an easy one. Why is this not already a fucking musical?
[18:31] Andrew: Is the reality. As you said, in 2015 they were thinking about it. Actually, uh it actually goes back to 2011. I'm looking at these here.
[18:40] Jesse McAnally: Oh wow. Uh Broadway.com has an article from 2011 saying that Fight Club might become years, guys. And then there's another one in 2015 saying that they're still thinking about it.
[18:55] Andrew: Um, so Chuck's got to be able to do that. Just put this damn thing out hook. Um, it was the guy who was interested in that. And he wants to turn it into a rock opera, which I think might be the best way to do it.
[19:05] Jesse McAnally: So it's like so obscenely different. Here's who he is, um, and what he's done. Um oh, he is the writer of the book, Fight Club, it looks like.
[19:15] Andrew: Okay, so it's a a direct adaptation of his book. Um curious who Okay, he wanted Julie Tamore and Trent Reznor working together on it.
[19:26] Jesse McAnally: So Oh my the girl that did Lion King and Spider-Man shut off the dark was directing a version of Fight Club produced by David Fincher with music by Trent Reznor.
[19:37] Andrew: Oh god, well who's Trent Reznor again? He didn't I know the name.
[19:41] Jesse McAnally: He's from Nine Inch Nails. He does all the stuff.
[19:43] Andrew: Oh my god, yes. For David Fincher's uh movies now. He just won an Oscar for Soul last weekend.
[19:51] Jesse McAnally: Um fuck. Well uh Julie Tamor is this is an insane person, and I want this. Where is this? Why is this not a thing yet?
[20:02] Andrew: I don't know, but I really want this to happen now. Like, fuck our version. Julie Tamor, Trent Reznor, and David Fincher making a musical, a rock opera. Insert this into my veins, please.
[20:14] Jesse McAnally: Wow. If only. I yeah, I'm like looking at articles. I'm like trying to figure out what happened to this. Why didn't it come out? Apparently, like Trent Reznor wanted a year to put it apart in 2015, and there there's been nothing since.
[20:29] Andrew: I hope that they're still working on it. Like can someone just pester Trent Reznor? Like, yo, dude, I know you just won an Oscar and were nominated in two categories, like you were nominated for two of the five uh nominations this year, but can you work on that Fight Club rock opera, please?
[20:48] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, like this is like legitimately the best case scenario for something like this, right?
[20:54] Andrew: Yeah, it's also like a really honestly, I think you'd be good. As long as they kind of went in. I think the fact that it you have the original creators in there, like the hindsight of like what they interpreted from the book and what audiences interpreted from the film might help them more than something. It might help them make something more pointed, like they might be able to like uh create something that's more accurate to the thing that they wanted to portray than the movie was.
[21:23] Jesse McAnally: Not that the movie did a bad job, it's just that they could do it better. The thing is if you have a fan going into that and like interpreting it their own way, they're just gonna replicate what they liked before. They're gonna be less inclined to change it.
[21:37] Andrew: I mean, the worst case scenario is you get one of those dude bros who got all the wrong messages, and then they remake it, and it's like it the whole thing is just like Tyler Durden is super cool, and he was right the whole time.
[21:52] Jesse McAnally: Oh my god. Like, alright, can we all just like someone make one of those change it.org petitions. Trent Reznor, get get to writing the fight club rock opera.
[22:04] Andrew: Yeah, no. Uh make this happen. Uh when it happens already support it unless it's very bad.
[22:11] Jesse McAnally: Well, yeah, I mean, it still could be bad, but like come on. Come on. And what would the critics think?
[22:20] Andrew: Yeah. The critics would love it because I feel like David Fincher is so meticulous in what he wants. Julie Tamore is the only personality just as like meticulous as David Fincher, and I feel like they'd fight in the best ways, and therefore the product would be great, and I think Ben Brantley would love it.
[22:38] Jesse McAnally: It might even save um fucking Julie Tamore's reputation in the New York theater scene, which was kind of tainted by the Pider Man of it all.
[22:47] Andrew: No, I mean The only way I can imagine critics not liking it is if somehow it's just far, far worse than the uh movie adaptation, but I can't imagine it would be with it being created by the same people.
[23:01] Jesse McAnally: So I I mean that is a double-edged sword, the same people worked on the Prince of Egypt musical, and look what happened there.
[23:08] Andrew: You're right. You're right. But I think the Julie Tamor makes me more confident in all because yeah, she makes some big broad decisions, but she'd also be like a new voice added into the mix.
[23:21] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Also, I think it's unfair to pin the blame of Spider-Man on her.
[23:26] Andrew: Yes, it is. 100%.
[23:29] Jesse McAnally: I think that that was just a doomed project. Uh oh, yeah, Bono is writing the music.
[23:42] Andrew: So would you say that uh Fight Club would uh scrub her reputation clean like a bar of soap?
[23:49] Jesse McAnally: I would, in fact. I I I think it would. Um She's got a weird reputation, and a lot of it's earned, a lot of it isn't. She does take other people's cultures and co-opt it into new things a lot, which is icky. But I think she is very talented, so I'd like to see her come back to Broadway in a musical forum because she knocked Lion King out of the park.
[24:11] Andrew: Yeah. Hopefully we're doing Lion King soon on musicals with cheese proper.
[24:16] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. I don't think I have anything more to say on Fight Club. Um it was a good talk, and honestly, I think the takeaway here is finish what you started. Come on. Finish the hat, guys.
[24:29] Andrew: Alright. Legitimately, I just want to see it. Just you like you must have something there. And obviously, with multiple articles being written within a five year period, like they want it to happen. Like, come on.
[24:46] Jesse McAnally: I can't imagine David Fincher being like, I really want this musical to exist. I feel like he's like too much like, uh, what the fuck are you talking about? No, I don't want this shit.
[25:00] Jesse McAnally: I don't think he's pushing for it. I think he's like, yeah, whatever. If you guys want to do it, I I'll support it. I bet that's more what he means his involvement.
[25:03] Andrew: I mean, I disagree looking at these articles, they're saying that he's one of the ones pushing for it.
[25:09] Andrew: Maybe. I don't know. I'm uh I want it to happen, is all I can say.
[25:22] Jesse McAnally: Oh no, Andrew, you're fighting me, but I'm fighting myself. Turns out I never existed after all. And I've just been in a room talking to myself for all these episodes.
[25:35] Andrew: Oh no. What a what a crazy reveal that would be.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
