Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#15 - Wordle the Musical

Today Jess is joined by composer Joel B New to turn the online community challenge "Wordle" into a musical! Link to Joel's Website. Buy Tickets to Tempting Mr. Lincoln... Read More

From the show: Cinema with Cheese

35 mins
1/31/22

About

Today Jess is joined by composer Joel B New to turn the online community challenge "Wordle" into a musical!

Link to Joel's Website

Buy Tickets to Tempting Mr. Lincoln

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:15] Jesse McAnally: Hello and welcome to Cinema with Cheese. Today we have a very special guest. Please welcome podcaster, composer, and all-around great guy, Joel B. New.

[0:27] Joel B. New: Hey, thank you. Oh, great crowd. Great crowd. How are you doing today, Jesse?

[0:30] Jesse McAnally: I'm doing swell. How are you doing?

[0:33] Joel B. New: I'm doing great. I'm sure people remember you from the last time you were on. We did a wonderful interview. It was a lot of fun. But you've got something coming up in the near future. Wanna pitch that a little bit? Because I think it's a great pitch, and I love it.

[0:46] Joel B. New: Thank you. Thank you. Yeah. So I have a brand new original musical that is having its concert premiere on Saturday, February 12th at the Green Room 42 in New York, both in person and live streaming at the same time. And it's called Tempting Mr. Lincoln, and it's like Notting Hill, but if Notting Hill starred a gay hot Abraham Lincoln. It's very that, it's very gay historical fan fiction, loosely inspired by the films of Julia Roberts. And there's time travel. So how does this not like this is what we all need in our lives, and this is like the perfect musical. Like come on. Like I love things that aren't too self-aware. I love it. I love how it's just kind of is what it is, very knows what it is, and embraced it.

And at the end of this episode, you're gonna hear a full number from this. So y'all will get a little sneak peek at it. There will also be links in the description where you can buy your tickets. Get it digitally. You don't even have to risk getting COVID to see this great show. Come on. But it's I w I won't say it's worth the risk, but like you should. I mean, you have to be fully vaccinated to see it in person. I will say that.

[1:57] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, but those in like Missouri, like, come on. They won't see Lincoln get rimmed or whatever.

[2:03] Joel B. New: Yes, I do have a lot of relatives in Missouri who probably won't be turning to it again. But you know, I didn't write it for them.

[2:10] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, you wrote it for us. Speaking of writing things, today, which we're on Week Me a Musical, we're gonna try to make a musical in less than 30 minutes just off of anything. Literally anything. We're going one thing at a time. And today we're doing Wordle.

[2:26] Joel B. New: Mm-hmm. And you know nothing about Wordle, right?

[2:29] Jesse McAnally: I know nothing about it. I just heard about it for the first time maybe a week ago on like an NPR show or something.

[2:36] Joel B. New: Yeah. Yeah, and that's hilarious. Basically, you got five blanks, you gotta try to find the words. Um, and all right. We starting in eight seconds, we got 30 minutes to try to come up with a pitch.

[2:46] Jesse McAnally: Okay. Like full story, full characters, realize this, couple 11 o'clock numbers.

[2:51] Joel B. New: All right, we're good. All right, we get started. All right, so here's my pitch.

[2:54] Jesse McAnally: Go.

[2:54] Joel B. New: So basically, all Wordle is is a dick measuring contest between you and your friends because you're just posting your results on Twitter. What if it becomes like a war between like these three Twitter user factions that have never met each other just trying to one-up each other's Wordle scores?

[3:10] Jesse McAnally: Interesting. Okay, okay, all right. Tell me more.

[3:12] Joel B. New: Tell me more. Um, and I like the fact that stage-wise, like it's COVID safe. We can put one in one quadrant, make it a true three-hander, where they're all got the same goals, and they're like, we could hire like an older Broadway statesman actor, a younger millennial talent, and someone right in the middle. Like, we could get Mary Testa, Christian Borle, and um, um, Sydney Lucas, maybe.

[3:36] Jesse McAnally: Okay, great. Love all those people.

[3:38] Joel B. New: Yeah, just random three people. We could probably add some more color to it, honestly. Now that I did that pitch.

[3:44] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, we should, yeah, there should be some diversity. Let's put Shawnice Williams in there instead of Sydney Lucas. Sorry, Sydney, you're out. Sorry, sorry.

[3:50] Joel B. New: All right. So that's my pitch. What are these three characters? What makes them tick?

[3:58] Jesse McAnally: Um, well, I think that we'll there should definitely be some irony. Um, I think we should have someone who because it's all about wordplay, right?

[4:05] Joel B. New: Yes.

[4:06] Jesse McAnally: It'll kind of be like spelling bee kind of thing where the words kind of introduce the characters to maybe we have like maybe we have like an English major or maybe like a dyslexic English major.

[4:20] Joel B. New: I love it. You know, and you know, so and then we got like different age groups, so then and do they all know each other in real life or something?

[4:28] Jesse McAnally: No, they're just people that just found each other through the internet, don't know each other's faces. Real catfish scenario. Where they're just like these faceless monsters, but we the audience learn who they really are.

[4:39] Joel B. New: Got it, got it. Okay, so and do they all do they have like weird like screen names or am I really aging myself there?

[4:45] Jesse McAnally: You know what? Let's do that. That sounds more fun. Let's like they have weird Twitter usernames and like anime profile pictures or something. Like one of them has a picture of their dog, one of them has a picture of an anime character, and one of them, what would an old lady put? Um, whatever presidential candidate we want. Like crazy cat lady, um Trump is still president or something.

[5:04] Joel B. New: Yeah, yeah. Um, yeah, well, we could do that. Comedy. Let's do it.

[5:07] Jesse McAnally: Okay, yeah. Uh that's Mary Testa. We got that.

[5:09] Joel B. New: She'll nail it.

[5:11] Jesse McAnally: She will nail it. Okay, so we got the three, and like they have anonymous profile names. Do they potentially know each other in real life?

[5:20] Joel B. New: I feel like the opening number, it should feel like, you know, the very first episode of Modern Family where we feel like we're seeing three different stories, and then at the end of the number, then like everyone either like comes out of their house or like they enter and like all of a sudden like they're actually a nuclear family and they didn't and like they don't know.

[5:36] Jesse McAnally: That would be really cool. What if they're all in the same community college?

[5:40] Joel B. New: Because that's the only real way where strangers like could do that.

[5:44] Jesse McAnally: Yes, yes, I see that. I see that. So then we've got like the single, we've got like the single parent, we've got the you know, we've got the burnout, and we've got um maybe the third one's like the professor, right?

[5:54] Joel B. New: Yeah, that's fun. And she's the crazy trumper, and then she becomes the educator, dramatic irony.

[5:59] Jesse McAnally: Yes, yes, okay, all right. I see it. All right, so what is the conflict?

[6:03] Joel B. New: So, like just playing the game. Um, is there like a is there like a big competition as like a Wordle word-off type of let's say maybe there's a reward for whoever gets the highest streak and they are the three in competition that have the highest.

[6:17] Jesse McAnally: Okay, okay. So now it's we're kind of getting to like pageant territory. Like it's like okay, or like Nintendo. Let's think of what our opening number is. Like, like we need to think of like because I assume this is a true three-hander where they are all sharing the name main character spot where we kind of mix their I want songs together into this one big number.

[6:36] Joel B. New: Yes, yeah.

[6:37] Jesse McAnally: It's almost like a Harry Hermione and Ron trio.

[6:40] Joel B. New: Okay.

[6:41] Jesse McAnally: Um, do we wanna um all right, working dummy working title for opening number?

[6:47] Joel B. New: Let's go.

[6:47] Jesse McAnally: In a word.

[6:48] Joel B. New: I like it. Already, this is why they give you the big bucks.

[6:52] Jesse McAnally: Oh, yes, oh yes. Or they sum up who they are, what they want, and what they're missing in life in a word, and then the word of the day coincides with that somehow, kind of spelling bee style.

[7:05] Joel B. New: Exactly, exactly. Oh yeah. Cool. All right, so that in a word, great opening number, great I want song mixed into it.

[7:12] Jesse McAnally: Totally.

[7:13] Joel B. New: Yeah, the bridge is very I want-y. I can hear it.

[7:15] Jesse McAnally: Yep.

[7:16] Joel B. New: Then the second number is like A, they introduce the contest and like this is obviously a one act. Like this is not a full two act.

[7:21] Jesse McAnally: Oh yeah. This is like um new world stages.

[7:27] Joel B. New: Yes.

[7:27] Jesse McAnally: You know, theater row um it won't be running next week.

[7:31] Joel B. New: Yeah. I mean it'll get okay reviews. Ben Brantley will be a little shitty but then everyone else will be fine.

[7:36] Jesse McAnally: They're like, well he tried. Good effort everyone.

[7:40] Joel B. New: Actually what that's actually a funny exercise. Like what is the bad pun title of the review for the case?

[7:45] Jesse McAnally: Oh we do that at the end. We literally do that at the end. What would Ben Brantley's review title be?

[7:50] Joel B. New: All right, great. So we got all three of them and then we introduce the thing oh via like voiceover uh recorded thing like hey coming up and we have to see their trauma. We now know their wants we don't know their traumas.

[8:03] Jesse McAnally: Okay.

[8:07] Joel B. New: Okay. All right. I think this is where dyslexia comes in handy.

[8:11] Jesse McAnally: Yes. You know if I had a nickel every time I said that I feel like that would be really good. Um and let's name Shawnice Williams character real quick. Let's give her a name.

[8:19] Joel B. New: Um let's call her Cassie screw it.

[8:22] Jesse McAnally: Cassie? Okay, great great Cassie love it. Um Cassie um and then Mary Testa, let's call her Alice and then let's call Christian Borle John.

[8:32] Joel B. New: Fuck it. Great.

[8:33] Jesse McAnally: I'm gonna forget all that. That's fine. This is just for the people that'll take notes because they're taking notes, believe me.

[8:39] Joel B. New: Oh they're gonna steal this idea, I tell you.

[8:39] Jesse McAnally: Um so she's dyslexic, and that's her big thing. And you know what? On her way to school, this is where we set up that they're all in the same community college class. Dramatic irony. We uh we know that they're all the Wordle people and they're all bitching about like, you know, this Wordle thing, and oh, I don't know that much about it, and they're like, oh, but we as the audience know that they're like real obsessed with it.

[9:04] Joel B. New: Got it, got it.

[9:05] Jesse McAnally: So one of them, so at least one of them is outward lying and saying, Oh, I don't play that.

[9:10] Joel B. New: Yeah, yeah. Got it.

[9:11] Jesse McAnally: Okay. Um I think it would be the John character because he sees it as a kid in Shawnice's and uh um um Cassie would be like, Yeah, I play it every now and then, I I don't really keep up with it. And then Mary Testa's the one's like, Oh, have you guys played this? I love that. I love that.

[9:26] Joel B. New: And do they do any of them actually like have secretly have like feelings for each other?

[9:31] Jesse McAnally: Or um I think that's like platonic anger, but like very kind. Like they're all maybe uh Cassie's like a surrogate daughter to John because John just his wife left him and took the kids, and he's trying to get his life back on track after that, and that's why he's going back to community college.

[9:49] Joel B. New: Okay, okay, yeah, yeah.

[9:50] Jesse McAnally: Why are they on all in community college?

[9:52] Joel B. New: Um, she didn't do well in high school, thought college wasn't a good idea, went in a job field, wants to go back.

[9:58] Jesse McAnally: Um, so she's back.

[9:59] Joel B. New: That's Cassie getting her degree.

[10:01] Jesse McAnally: Mary Testa, teaching the class, generational wealth, got it in college, and now had nothing better to do. White people.

[10:07] Joel B. New: Um, John wife left him, was a big failure, like was a mechanic right out of college, but then or right out of high school, kind of fell apart when the auto business fell apart.

[10:17] Jesse McAnally: So now he's going back so he can try to like put his life back in hold and get more custody of his kids.

[10:22] Joel B. New: Okay, great.

[10:23] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I get it. I see it all. Um, and they are all just at the end of the day, they're like really stressed out. They're like, she's sick of teaching, he's sick of learning, she's sick of learning, and they all take their frustrations out on today's Wordle.

[10:35] Joel B. New: I was gonna say, is Wordle the way out? Like is that is that the picket?

[10:40] Jesse McAnally: That's where they all just scream. Maybe that's like a fun comedy number where they're all just yelling at it like, Fuck me, got like big swears and all that.

[10:47] Joel B. New: Or they're like all writing down on their like sheets of paper, testing the words out before they type it in, and then somehow they all tie still, like they're still in neck and neck.

[10:57] Jesse McAnally: Wow, wow, wow. It's intense.

[10:59] Joel B. New: That would be a fun title, like neck and neck.

[11:01] Jesse McAnally: That that's a cute title.

[11:02] Joel B. New: That's cute, yeah. I like it.

[11:03] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, it's a comedy number that's pushing forward. And then I feel like we gotta set up John. John's like the one who has to have the next big boo-hoo.

[11:12] Joel B. New: A boo-hoo number?

[11:14] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, a boo-hoo number where he's like, uh, I I don't need anybody, and then he expresses that to the Cassie character, where he's like, I had a life and it was taken away from me, and I blame the world for my mistakes, and I'm not taking responsibility.

[11:28] Joel B. New: And she's like, uh, maybe think about how your wife and kid felt about that, uh, as opposed to just you know, you.

[11:33] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I'm trying to tie that into like words and Wordle and he could never find the words.

[11:39] Joel B. New: You can never find the words.

[11:41] Jesse McAnally: There it is.

[11:42] Joel B. New: No words.

[11:42] Jesse McAnally: That's beautiful.

[11:43] Joel B. New: Yep, there we are.

[11:44] Jesse McAnally: It's a real dramatic number.

[11:46] Joel B. New: And then she relates because she doesn't have the words because she has dyslexia that she struggled with.

[11:51] Jesse McAnally: So they bond over that in different ways.

[11:53] Joel B. New: That's Testa breaks it up.

[11:56] Jesse McAnally: Um, and then I feel like one of them has to get the lead, or one of them has to mess up really bad, so that it kind of like third act breakup.

[12:05] Joel B. New: And I feel like right after she I assume it would be Cassie, the young one, because that's kind of the thing that she's trying to get over with because of the dyslexia and all that.

[12:13] Jesse McAnally: And that is also the moment where they all find out who the other ones are.

[12:18] Joel B. New: I like that.

[12:19] Jesse McAnally: Okay, yeah.

[12:19] Joel B. New: Yeah.

[12:20] Jesse McAnally: And then once John and John and Alice are like, well, we gotta do something to help her, and Alice is like, I don't care, like these youngins, like she'll bounce back.

[12:30] Joel B. New: They always do.

[12:31] Jesse McAnally: Well, that's a big number.

[12:32] Joel B. New: She's gotta have her b you know, yeah her, you know, I'm uh I'm a big belting broad number.

[12:38] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, where she was like, uh even like they'll bounce back, or even she's talking about like all the the horrible things she's gone through, but they're really kind of white people problems.

[12:48] Joel B. New: Like that's kind of funny where she talks about her trauma, but it's really like really first world problem shit.

[12:53] Jesse McAnally: Could we call it first word problems?

[12:56] Joel B. New: Is that is that terrible?

[12:57] Jesse McAnally: I mean the thing is if it's coming from her point of view, would she describe it as a first world problem or a first word problem?

[12:57] Joel B. New: First word problem.

[13:05] Jesse McAnally: Um that's a good point.

[13:07] Joel B. New: It's a good point.

[13:08] Jesse McAnally: Hmm.

[13:08] Joel B. New: I like where your head's at, but you gotta Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[13:11] Jesse McAnally: Um maybe she doesn't even know that's what she's saying.

[13:14] Joel B. New: Maybe she doesn't see the equivalent between like first word problem and first world problems.

[13:19] Jesse McAnally: Maybe she just is like taking it literally, and this was my first word problem, or like it was literally a fucking like word search.

[13:26] Joel B. New: Yeah, and then it grows on to like her essays and all that, and she's like, I figured it out because I am and then you got the backup course where you got Cassie and John like first word problems.

[13:38] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I like it.

[13:39] Joel B. New: Um yeah, and then they all kind of break up, they're all worse off without each other, they realize, and they're like come together, and you know what?

[13:47] Jesse McAnally: They start a wordal team, and instead of like one person against the entire country, it's these three against everyone else, and they find out they work better together than as a part.

[13:58] Joel B. New: Like sentences.

[14:02] Jesse McAnally: Exactly.

[14:03] Joel B. New: You complete me.

[14:04] Jesse McAnally: Like that's that's what it is.

[14:06] Joel B. New: It's like you could complete the sentence or you know.

[14:09] Jesse McAnally: Exactly.

[14:09] Joel B. New: Yeah.

[14:10] Jesse McAnally: And they just keep going, they get better, her grades get better.

[14:13] Joel B. New: Like John stays up all night, like trying to help her with her homework, and she like is a surrogate daughter to him and teaching him how to properly parent.

[14:23] Jesse McAnally: Wow, wow.

[14:24] Joel B. New: Are we in epilogue territory now?

[14:26] Jesse McAnally: Are we still in the show?

[14:27] Joel B. New: I think we're still in the show, but we gotta get to the competition because we've already solved the emotional context, but I think they still lose the competition.

[14:34] Jesse McAnally: I feel like that's the way.

[14:35] Joel B. New: Because it's not about winning, it's the relationships we made along the way.

[14:40] Jesse McAnally: Of course.

[14:41] Joel B. New: Of course.

[14:42] Jesse McAnally: And his daughters show up to the fucking world competition.

[14:46] Joel B. New: Oh last minute cast edition.

[14:48] Jesse McAnally: I love it.

[14:48] Joel B. New: Like, no, you just hear their voices off screen.

[14:51] Jesse McAnally: Like off stage.

[14:52] Joel B. New: He's like, they came!

[14:54] Jesse McAnally: Nice, nice.

[14:54] Joel B. New: And we're doing any like we're not doing any double casting, like Mary Testa could also play his daughters as the daughter.

[15:01] Jesse McAnally: Um maybe not as the wife, maybe.

[15:03] Joel B. New: We could like have her play the wife, um, saying like, hey, maybe weekends, every other weekend you could think of.

[15:13] Jesse McAnally: Yes, I'm just like picturing Lisa Howard putting a shroud on for spelling B and now she's the mom.

[15:17] Joel B. New: Like that's yeah, no, no, that's great.

[15:19] Jesse McAnally: Um like, yeah, things like that could be done throughout the show.

[15:23] Joel B. New: But we need an 11 o'clock number.

[15:25] Jesse McAnally: We need something like I feel like it's gonna be to Cassie, where she's like, maybe it's a sad reprise of I never had the words.

[15:32] Joel B. New: That could be or that could be like the intro, like that could be like the first 30 seconds of the song that launches us into the um the eleven o'clock number.

[15:40] Jesse McAnally: Alright, what's our last uh what's our eleven o'clock numbered?

[15:43] Joel B. New: Alright, what does she need to figure out?

[15:45] Jesse McAnally: Okay, so I I guess we need to figure out her art, because she can't her art can't just be like she had trouble in school and then she does better in school.

[15:54] Joel B. New: Okay, maybe everyone else has like okay, okay.

[15:57] Jesse McAnally: What is Mary Testa's connection?

[15:59] Joel B. New: Because she feels like she's on an island, and yeah, we've kind of set up that she's div it dove into the alt right territory and is kind of delusional.

[16:07] Jesse McAnally: But we need to give her some kind of thing.

[16:10] Joel B. New: I don't want to make it that her she has parent issues because we already did that with John, so we kind of need to find some kind of repla replacement there.

[16:19] Jesse McAnally: Um what do you think?

[16:21] Joel B. New: Hmm.

[16:22] Jesse McAnally: Are we talking about Cassie?

[16:23] Joel B. New: I'm talking about Mary Tesla because I feel like we can find we can find where Cassie's story arc ends while finding where Mary Testas does.

[16:32] Jesse McAnally: Got it, got it.

[16:33] Joel B. New: Okay.

[16:34] Jesse McAnally: So she's the teacher, English.

[16:37] Joel B. New: Yes.

[16:38] Jesse McAnally: Um, let's see.

[16:40] Joel B. New: And she's and she does wordle, I assume, to like escape.

[16:44] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[16:45] Joel B. New: Okay.

[16:45] Jesse McAnally: And she's also like escaping the truth because she's like this weird conspiracy theorist.

[16:50] Joel B. New: Yeah.

[16:51] Jesse McAnally: Um so something about like, you know, facts versus truth versus um I like this.

[16:51] Joel B. New: I like this.

[16:58] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[16:58] Joel B. New: And so she's try she's trying to find the words, which we've already ha done that we've already done that word play.

[17:03] Jesse McAnally: But if it's like um finding the words, um I I imagine she's kind of detached from her family, or maybe something like that, where because of her issues, like yes.

[17:18] Joel B. New: Like maybe she could learn from John how important it is to have that connection.

[17:22] Jesse McAnally: Like maybe she had um a gay child that she disowned, and she was like, I might need to reconnect with them because I see how much John wants to reconnect with his children and how much that, yeah.

[17:35] Joel B. New: That's uh that's an idea, right?

[17:37] Jesse McAnally: I just had this awful.

[17:39] Joel B. New: Because like word word wordle is five it's five letters, right?

[17:42] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, five letters.

[17:44] Joel B. New: So if the song is what's a five-letter word for sorry.

[17:50] Jesse McAnally: I love it.

[17:51] Joel B. New: Because it's like a really shitty apology that would come from this character.

[17:55] Jesse McAnally: And sorry is a five-letter word.

[17:58] Joel B. New: I think, yeah.

[17:59] Jesse McAnally: S-O-R-R-Y.

[18:00] Joel B. New: Well, what if she's like so dumb, she's like, what's a five-letter word for apology, which is not a five-letter word?

[18:07] Jesse McAnally: A-P-O-L-O-G-Y.

[18:09] Joel B. New: That's a seven-letter word.

[18:10] Jesse McAnally: Either way, it works.

[18:11] Joel B. New: I think it's funny if she's, you know, what's a five-letter word for sorry, and sorry is five letters.

[18:16] Jesse McAnally: What if she says what's a five-letter word for I'm sorry?

[18:19] Joel B. New: So it kinda.

[18:21] Jesse McAnally: I see that.

[18:22] Joel B. New: I can see that.

[18:23] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[18:23] Joel B. New: It's very, I mean, I don't know what I'm thinking about this, probably because like the holidays just happened, but I'm thinking about Home Alone the original.

[18:29] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[18:30] Joel B. New: The old man who like was estranged from his family, and we never really find out why.

[18:35] Jesse McAnally: No.

[18:35] Joel B. New: Um, yeah, but thank God McCole Colkin was there.

[18:38] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, he say he saved that old man from never having a relationship with his family.

[18:42] Joel B. New: It ties into the theme.

[18:43] Jesse McAnally: Maybe Shani's um um like is in the foster system and never had a family and finds her newfound family through this like found family kind of thing.

[18:53] Joel B. New: Wow, wow.

[18:54] Jesse McAnally: What if she's the missing letter?

[18:55] Joel B. New: Like that could literally be a song where she's always thought herself as the missing letter.

[18:59] Jesse McAnally: Wow, why?

[19:00] Joel B. New: Oh, like or sometimes why?

[19:03] Jesse McAnally: W H Y.

[19:04] Joel B. New: Sometimes why.

[19:05] Jesse McAnally: I like that.

[19:06] Joel B. New: I like somehow that's that could actually be the eleven o'clock number.

[19:09] Jesse McAnally: I think that's the eleven o'clock number.

[19:10] Joel B. New: Sometimes why.

[19:11] Jesse McAnally: We got it.

[19:12] Joel B. New: Damn it, we got there.

[19:13] Jesse McAnally: I didn't know if we would, but we did.

[19:16] Joel B. New: Um You're a composer.

[19:18] Jesse McAnally: How do you imagine that song going off the top of your head?

[19:21] Joel B. New: Um, let's see.

[19:23] Joel B. New: Well, it have a lot of um vowels in it.

[19:26] Joel B. New: So um, you know, a lot of singing vowels, but also like like the letters of the alphabet.

[19:31] Joel B. New: Like, so I think it'll either be in the key of A or the key of E.

[19:34] Joel B. New: So it'll be a nice vowel um uh key.

[19:38] Jesse McAnally: Is that funny?

[19:38] Joel B. New: I can't tell.

[19:39] Jesse McAnally: No, I can I can see it.

[19:40] Joel B. New: It'd be like one of the things that Sandem explained and be like, no one ever saw that except for you, man.

[19:45] Jesse McAnally: Exactly.

[19:46] Joel B. New: Like you can't you catch how many A's, you catch how many vowels are in that song.

[19:50] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[19:50] Joel B. New: I did this all in 3-4 just because I wanted all to feel waltzy.

[19:55] Jesse McAnally: Exactly.

[19:56] Joel B. New: Exactly.

[19:57] Jesse McAnally: But yeah, I think something like big and sweepy, you know, I think like a good like a strong 6 8, you know, the da-da-da-da-da-da.

[20:05] Joel B. New: You know, or you know, very JRB in that way.

[20:07] Jesse McAnally: Oh god, just uh okay.

[20:11] Joel B. New: That's me getting a little ahead of myself, but god imagine Jerm fucking did this show.

[20:16] Jesse McAnally: Oh, you think?

[20:17] Joel B. New: I don't think he'd touch it with a 10-foot pole to be honest.

[20:20] Jesse McAnally: I don't know if it pays.

[20:21] Joel B. New: You're I mean he drops out of all the ones that pays.

[20:24] Jesse McAnally: Okay, like the the the the the the she's out of your league.

[20:27] Joel B. New: What what is that musical?

[20:28] Jesse McAnally: League of their own musical he was on, the King Kong musical he's on.

[20:32] Joel B. New: Well, I I just leaves.

[20:34] Jesse McAnally: I can't speak to that.

[20:35] Joel B. New: I can't speak if you know he left or if he was asked to leave.

[20:37] Jesse McAnally: I don't I don't know.

[20:39] Joel B. New: That's fair.

[20:39] Jesse McAnally: He I mean he's always signed on for these musicals, and then he never ends up being the final composer.

[20:44] Joel B. New: You know, it's tough out there.

[20:45] Jesse McAnally: It's tough out there, you know, adapting intellectual property.

[20:48] Joel B. New: I mean, we're doing it right now with Wordle, you know.

[20:51] Jesse McAnally: I don't know if I get hired.

[20:53] Joel B. New: I mean I get you know that you're like that's amusing.

[20:55] Jesse McAnally: That's clever.

[20:56] Joel B. New: I mean I I'd watch this musical.

[20:58] Jesse McAnally: Um I think that what if we need like something really emotionally gripping?

[21:03] Joel B. New: Um and we need like the Tony winning moment.

[21:06] Jesse McAnally: Um so after Shawnee says sing sometimes why, um Mary Testa has a Pi Chensier Faye number where she dies, and it's just her and John and they lose their matriarch.

[21:17] Joel B. New: And they're like, Oh, it's just us two now.

[21:20] Jesse McAnally: Okay.

[21:20] Joel B. New: And then what happens?

[21:22] Jesse McAnally: And then they w lose the competition anyway, but they find the new family, and he invites her to come to dinner with him and his children, and they have this brand new thing.

[21:31] Joel B. New: Well that's all lovely.

[21:32] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, that's just a it's a quaint ending, and they have a reprise of all their favorite songs.

[21:37] Joel B. New: Um, like a mega mix, like a Joseph Mega mix.

[21:41] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, 'cause obviously this is not long enough.

[21:43] Joel B. New: They need a Joseph Meghan mix, so it's at least as long as Fun Home across the street.

[21:47] Jesse McAnally: Eight more minutes.

[21:48] Joel B. New: Just eight more eight more minutes in that mega mix.

[21:51] Jesse McAnally: Well, no, they just start saying a bunch of words.

[21:53] Joel B. New: Like they start I imagine there has to be a word where they're a song where they're just spelling words.

[21:58] Jesse McAnally: Yes.

[21:59] Joel B. New: Yeah.

[21:59] Jesse McAnally: I think there could be even like an audience participation element to it.

[22:02] Joel B. New: Like if you have your smartphone out and like you get to play Wordle with them.

[22:07] Jesse McAnally: That would be actually incredible.

[22:08] Joel B. New: Like the hints are like the songs that they're singing a little bit like that sounds so fun.

[22:15] Jesse McAnally: Um, okay.

[22:16] Joel B. New: So we we did it.

[22:17] Jesse McAnally: We did it.

[22:18] Joel B. New: We have this whole musical, we have songs.

[22:19] Jesse McAnally: We did it.

[22:20] Joel B. New: Now it's so easy.

[22:21] Jesse McAnally: It kind of was though.

[22:22] Joel B. New: We had uh l I know you did a podcast all about this, but look, we made a hat where there never was a hat.

[22:28] Jesse McAnally: The musical did not exist before it came here.

[22:30] Joel B. New: Now we have three fully developed characters, a few songs and an entire plot.

[22:34] Jesse McAnally: Think about that for a second.

[22:36] Joel B. New: Yeah, you're welcome.

[22:37] Jesse McAnally: Next up, Broadway.

[22:38] Joel B. New: Um, who do you think would compose this show?

[22:41] Jesse McAnally: I know I mean we toyed with Gerb earlier, but Gerb.

[22:44] Joel B. New: Um well other than me?

[22:46] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I mean I think you'd do great, but I d I honestly feel like it's a little too sincere and not dark enough.

[22:52] Joel B. New: Oh.

[22:52] Jesse McAnally: Well, I would darken it for sure.

[22:54] Joel B. New: You know, I you know, darken around the edges.

[22:57] Jesse McAnally: Um I don't know.

[22:59] Joel B. New: I don't know.

[22:59] Jesse McAnally: Who do you have in mind?

[23:01] Joel B. New: Um, I don't who would be honestly I feel like Janine Sessoria would slum it for a week and do this.

[23:06] Jesse McAnally: She totally would.

[23:07] Joel B. New: She totally would.

[23:08] Jesse McAnally: With like Lisa Crohn or who's her who's her words?

[23:10] Joel B. New: Is she doing words?

[23:11] Jesse McAnally: No, I don't think she'd do words.

[23:13] Jesse McAnally: I think she'd find some new up-and-coming. I feel like it would be like some theater trainee from Carnegie Mellon coming out of school being like, "Hey, I got this little idea," and Janine Tesori's like, "I think this is brilliant." You're a new voice, and I really just connected with the material.

[23:31] Joel B. New: That's a pretty good Janine Tesori.

[23:36] Jesse McAnally: But you know what? We need a little more yellow face.

[23:39] Joel B. New: Um, yellow face.

[23:41] Jesse McAnally: Um, isn't that, yeah, that's Millie, Thoroughly Modern Millie.

[23:45] Joel B. New: Oh god, yes, you're right. I was like, is that where we're going? And yes, got it, got it.

[23:50] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, yeah. Um, it would either be a little more cultural misappropriation. That was just a bad move as far as everyone. There's some rough stuff. Um, we all learn. But maybe this could be Pasek and Paul's big return to the stage, and it's just like them trying to be hip. But honestly, I would prefer Tom Kitt to kind of try his hand at like a musical again instead of just orchestrating musicals.

[24:13] Joel B. New: Well, he had a musical recently, didn't he?

[24:15] Jesse McAnally: He did, Superhero, um, but that's it.

[24:18] Joel B. New: Oh.

[24:18] Jesse McAnally: I thought he had something more recent. Orchestrates a ton of them. Like he orchestrated the SpongeBob musical and it was all over Jagged Little Pill.

[24:26] Joel B. New: Yeah, he did that as well, but he didn't write the songs, obviously.

[24:29] Jesse McAnally: No. Um, so I would like to see what he would do if he wrote a musical again.

[24:34] Joel B. New: Okay, yeah, throw 'em into the mix.

[24:35] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, yeah. Not Brian Gordon's back.

[24:38] Joel B. New: No, no, no, Yorkie for you.

[24:40] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, throw Yorkie back into his um, Thirteen Reasons Why world. Um, keep Kitt. Um, keep Kitt, pair him up with some uh, pair him up with Joel B. New that. We could do that. You know, I feel like you're gonna like it would be a full like music and lyrics by Tom Kitt and Joel B. New. I feel like y'all couldn't split that down a little bit.

[25:02] Joel B. New: I mean, you could also get like Hunter and Jeff, you know, Jeff Bowen and Hunter Bell. I think they're, you know, they could do something silly like this.

[25:09] Jesse McAnally: Who wrote the score to Come From Away? That's coming out like...

[25:11] Joel B. New: Oh gosh.

[25:14] Jesse McAnally: That husband and wife couple. They could do it. They'd probably pick this as like, and it would be the next like big thing somehow.

[25:20] Joel B. New: Well, what are the Diana people doing now?

[25:24] Jesse McAnally: I mean, if we wanted to make something fun, we could, but if we wanted to make something like this, I look good. You know, fun. Fun and good are different. It's the difference between David Hasselhoff, Jekyll and Hyde and like any other Jekyll and Hyde.

[25:32] Joel B. New: Fun and good.

[25:38] Jesse McAnally: Fun and good. I mean, I'd pick fun over good with a show like Wordle.

[25:44] Joel B. New: I guess. I thought we were playing it super sincere. I thought we were playing family drama.

[25:48] Jesse McAnally: Oh. Michael John LaChiusa, he'd, he's probably somehow turned this into something.

[25:54] Joel B. New: He certainly would. He certainly would. And we already have Mary Testa on board, so that's uh, she's like one of his muses.

[26:00] Jesse McAnally: So my last pitch, my last absolute pitch, the last ditch attempt, everyone else said no. William Finn, you fall asleep during the reading and say, "Yeah, I'll do the score." Or he wrote it while sleeping, and it's like this fever dream, and then he, you know, wakes up and he has it and he's like, "Vadim, arrange this." Like that's my Bill Finn.

[26:18] Joel B. New: Call James! Get James in here. Jimmy.

[26:22] Jesse McAnally: Um, what do you think Ben Brantley's review would say?

[26:26] Joel B. New: Or Jesse Green, because now he runs things.

[26:28] Jesse McAnally: Yes, yes, yes, yes. Um, I think he'd hate it.

[26:32] Joel B. New: I think he'd hate it.

[26:33] Jesse McAnally: Really?

[26:34] Joel B. New: I, but he surprisingly liked The Prom.

[26:37] Jesse McAnally: I liked The Prom.

[26:38] Joel B. New: Yeah, everyone liked The Prom, but I didn't expect The New York Times to like The Prom.

[26:42] Jesse McAnally: Fair, fair, I guess. Um, I don't know. They might like it. They might like it.

[26:46] Joel B. New: What do you think the working article titles for me?

[26:50] Jesse McAnally: I think it would just take the like sometimes why, why indeed would probably be like something. Or in a word, pass.

[26:56] Joel B. New: In a word, close.

[27:01] Jesse McAnally: I lost all six, like failed all six attempts, something like that.

[27:05] Joel B. New: Wordle fails all six attempts.

[27:07] Jesse McAnally: Oh, is that a, is that a rule?

[27:08] Joel B. New: Yeah, you can only try six times.

[27:10] Jesse McAnally: Oh man, I wish I had known that. That would have completely reshaped the trajectory of this very important American musical.

[27:17] Joel B. New: This could be one the Pulitzer.

[27:19] Jesse McAnally: This is the next Strange Loop, Joel.

[27:21] Joel B. New: I don't, I don't know if you know this.

[27:23] Jesse McAnally: I did not know that, but I um, I believe you. Anything's possible.

[27:26] Joel B. New: Yeah, Wordle the musical, it's gonna be like Emoji Land the musical where it's like, oh, that was darker than I expected.

[27:32] Jesse McAnally: Okay.

[27:33] Joel B. New: Yeah, people really resonated with the emoji.

[27:36] Jesse McAnally: Emoji Land, is that what's called?

[27:37] Joel B. New: Yeah, yeah.

[27:39] Jesse McAnally: Not to be confused with the Emoji Movie, which is a different vibe altogether.

[27:43] Joel B. New: Yeah. Yeah.

[27:44] Jesse McAnally: Um, yeah, Anne Hirata Supremacy.

[27:47] Joel B. New: Always, always Queen.

[27:48] Jesse McAnally: Why isn't she in Wordle?

[27:50] Joel B. New: Yeah, you know what? Let's make her play every word. Like she plays the Wordle.

[27:54] Jesse McAnally: I like it. I like it's like the bullet in Hamilton.

[27:57] Joel B. New: Exactly. Yes.

[27:58] Jesse McAnally: And it's Anne Hirata as the dictionary.

[28:03] Joel B. New: Yes.

[28:04] Jesse McAnally: Um, alright. We've done it, Joel. We did it. We've got a musical. Um, I expect um you to start writing this next week and to be invited to the 54 Below initial performances and opening night on Broadway.

[28:16] Joel B. New: So fantastic.

[28:17] Jesse McAnally: Alright. I'll be, I'll see you there. I am waiting for the invite.

[28:24] Joel B. New: You are absolutely wonderful. Thank you for playing this game with me. I love chatting with you. I hope you'll do this again in the future when you write another incredible musical that I love.

[28:33] Joel B. New: Yeah, absolutely. Well, hopefully I just did uh with Tempting Mr. Lincoln.

[28:37] Jesse McAnally: Well, I'm excited to see it. Um, why don't you once again promote it for the world to hear so they can know where to buy tickets digitally or in person.

[28:45] Joel B. New: That's right. Uh, if you just go to JoelBNew.com/Lincoln, uh, it'll take you to get tickets. Um, you can, yeah, you can watch it live stream. I think even like for 24 hours. Like you don't even have to be watching it as it's happening, even though that's the way I prefer to watch it. But you know, you have 24 hours to watch it streaming. You can come in person, you just have to be fully vaccinated. Um, it's gonna be a big gay romp. Um, it's so stupid. But I have a huge cast of eight actors, uh, four-person band. Uh, the cast release just came out today. So um, we've got Travis, like Broadway's Travis Kent as Abraham Lincoln, Broadway's Gabe Violet as uh his love interest, Joshua Fry Speed. Who, these are historical characters, these are historical figures, and then um we've got uh Mad Dietrich from Kinky Boots as Mary Todd.

Uh, my bestie Charles Sanchez always and everything that I do is John Wilkes Booth. Um, and then we've got this crazy trio. Um, we've got Cicely Daniels from Little Mermaid and Rent and Porgy and Bess as Penny, because I thought it'd be funny to have a character named Penny in a Lincoln show. And um, and then I have this ensemble of like three flaming homosexuals, Abercrombie, Fitch and Hollister. And um, it's so stupid and lovely. Um, I'm kind of obsessed with it right now, and I think you'd all get a big kick out of it. Um, it's a little more, it's a little more risqué than my usual affair. So um, there are some choice four-letter words, um, which I don't always decorate my shows with, so I'm excited.

And um, yeah, it should be really inappropriate. Come on by. I know this is right up my audience's alley. I think it's great. Um, and you know what? If you don't need, if you need more convincing, which I don't understand why, right after we're done talking, you're gonna hear an entire number from it just to wet your whistle to understand why this is gonna be so great. And this is me talking. You know, I'm the guy that does this podcast every week. I'm not out some paid shill. I just genuinely think this is gonna be good.

[30:49] Jesse McAnally: Oh, I appreciate it. There's also, if you go to um Joel's YouTube page, a lot of songs from when you were previously on our podcast, we were promoting um, what was it?

[30:58] Joel B. New: Monkey Trouble Unleashed.

[31:00] Jesse McAnally: Yes, a lot of great songs from there.

[31:01] Joel B. New: So many good songs. Also, um, this is how I discovered you, Joel, was through your podcast, which I think is now defunct, sadly. Um, you have not updated since 2019. Was fantastic, absolutely incredible podcast um where you try to make musical theater content in a short period of time. It's a lot like this, but kinda. Um, but you've had like Grace McLean on and so many other incredible people on.

[31:23] Joel B. New: Thank you. No, it's um, it's the gift that keeps on giving because it's still out there. You can listen to all of the episodes, um, which has an original song in every episode, and just like fantastic conversations that I'm just so proud um are out there. And like it, you know, she makes an appearance every once in a while, you know. The, you know, she just dusts herself off, and there's new content, you know, every couple of years. Why not?

[31:46] Jesse McAnally: Heck yeah. Um, I'm so proud of to know you. I'm so happy to see your work. Um, thanks for coming on.

[31:52] Joel B. New: My pleasure.

[31:53] Jesse McAnally: Alright. We'll see you next time on Make Me a Musical. Go, go, go, listen to this. It's so great. Jumping Mr. Lincoln, gay Abraham Lincoln, what else do I need to say?

[32:03] Joel B. New: Not a damn thing.

[32:04] Jesse McAnally: We'll see you next time, guys.

[32:06] ♪ Musical number: "Your President" — performed by Joel B. New ♪

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred