Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#16 Mushrooms the Musical (feat. Elizabeth Teeter) - Make me a Musical #16

Today we're joined by the star of Beetlejuice the Musical, Elizebeth Teeter, to turn the concept of "Mushrooms" into a musical!.. Read More

From the show: Cinema with Cheese

31 mins
5/20/22

Guests

Featured Shows

About

Today we're joined by the star of Beetlejuice the Musical, Elizebeth Teeter, to turn the concept of "Mushrooms" into a musical!

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:14] Jesse McAnally: Hello and welcome back to Musicals with Cheese.

[0:16] Elizabeth Teeter: Make me a musical.

[0:17] Jesse McAnally: And Andrew, we have an extra special guest.

[0:21] Elizabeth Teeter: I am actually very, very surprised we have them.

[0:24] Jesse McAnally: Please welcome actress, singer, songwriter, and filmmaker, and current star of Beetlejuice the Musical.

[0:30] Elizabeth Teeter: It's Elizabeth Teeter!

[0:32] Jesse McAnally: Oh my gosh!

[0:35] Elizabeth Teeter: You're surprised to have me here.

[0:36] Jesse McAnally: I'm always surprised when someone's like, oh yeah, we'll see.

[0:39] Elizabeth Teeter: Someone agreed to come on our show. Like what?

[0:41] Jesse McAnally: Well, I didn't know what this was until about two seconds ago.

[0:44] Elizabeth Teeter: So you wouldn't be here if you did, I'm sure.

[0:48] Jesse McAnally: I was looking on the link and I was like, musicals with cheese.

[0:51] Elizabeth Teeter: That sounds fun.

[0:52] Jesse McAnally: I should have done my research.

[0:53] Elizabeth Teeter: I should have listened.

[0:55] Jesse McAnally: Don't worry.

[0:56] Elizabeth Teeter: I'm gonna go, I'm gonna go binge all the other music with cheese episodes after this.

[1:02] Jesse McAnally: I imagine your publicist is gonna write an email like, actually, can you just not put that?

[1:06] Elizabeth Teeter: We don't want to be associated with those gentlemen.

[1:09] Jesse McAnally: Caddy and Crash over here.

[1:10] Elizabeth Teeter: Caddy and Crash.

[1:12] Jesse McAnally: Elizabeth, your first interview was great, but this one was different.

[1:17] Elizabeth Teeter: Well, it is very much gonna be different because it isn't an interview, and within the next 30 minutes, we have to pitch a musical.

[1:26] Jesse McAnally: And you have given us the excellent idea that this musical today is gonna be mushrooms the musical.

[1:31] Elizabeth Teeter: That's our starting pitch.

[1:32] I'd like everyone to know this was because I have a mushroom candle sitting right in front of me.

[1:37] Jesse McAnally: Uh yeah, so not very uh, I don't know, off the top of my head, not very creative, but that's okay.

[1:45] Elizabeth Teeter: This is where it bounces off of.

[1:47] Jesse McAnally: So we can go in like 50 different directions here.

[1:49] Elizabeth Teeter: Are we gonna go through the anthropomorphic side where it is literally a living mushroom?

[1:54] Or are we gonna go with like a morel like hunter for morel mushrooms with his little pig and trying to find him?

[2:02] Jesse McAnally: Which direction?

[2:03] Elizabeth Teeter: We got one of those two choices.

[2:05] Jesse McAnally: I feel like those are two very different musicals.

[2:07] Elizabeth Teeter: Yes.

[2:07] Um it depends on what it depends on what we're doing.

[2:09] Jesse McAnally: What would a mushroom do?

[2:10] If you're a living mushroom, you're just gonna sit there.

[2:13] Elizabeth Teeter: Okay, I have an idea.

[2:14] But if you're a living mushroom, you could have the dilemma of not everyone likes mushrooms, you know.

[2:19] Jesse McAnally: I feel like it's a I feel like you either come across people that hate mushrooms or love mushrooms, and that could be a moral problem for this mushroom.

[2:27] Elizabeth Teeter: So in the world of mushrooms the musical, are mushrooms their main goal to get eaten?

[2:32] Is it like the cat's trying to die?

[2:36] Jesse McAnally: Maybe that's like that's a little morbid, actually.

[2:39] Elizabeth Teeter: They want to be dead.

[2:40] They really want someone to eat them.

[2:42] Jesse McAnally: No one wants to eat meat.

[2:44] Elizabeth Teeter: Oh my god.

[2:46] Jesse McAnally: No.

[2:47] Elizabeth Teeter: I'm kind of into that, actually.

[2:48] I'm into that a little bit.

[2:50] Jesse McAnally: Like I don't know.

[2:51] Elizabeth Teeter: We have another idea.

[2:52] Jesse McAnally: Alright, what's your other one?

[2:53] Elizabeth Teeter: Um, well, that was my idea.

[2:58] But we could go the foraging way.

[3:01] Um, it could be a hunter situation.

[3:04] It could be competing people.

[3:05] They're like competing to like create mushroom like meals out of dishes and stuff, and they have to.

[3:11] Jesse McAnally: It could be a town where mushrooms are their source.

[3:15] Elizabeth Teeter: And I like that.

[3:17] I like this idea.

[3:18] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, mushrooms are their source, and it's like a huge like competition, kind of like Streganona, like she's the pasta maker.

[3:24] Elizabeth Teeter: There's like a mushroom like person, but then conflict arises.

[3:29] Jesse McAnally: Yes.

[3:30] Elizabeth Teeter: To be determined.

[3:32] Jesse McAnally: Um what who is our main character in this little town of the mushroom village or whatever?

[3:38] Elizabeth Teeter: Tramina.

[3:38] Jesse McAnally: Tremina.

[3:39] Elizabeth Teeter: Alright.

[3:40] Jesse McAnally: Shrimina.

[3:41] Elizabeth Teeter: Or Shrimino.

[3:43] Jesse McAnally: Did she get into mushrooms because of the name, or was she named because she got into mushrooms?

[3:49] Elizabeth Teeter: Chicken and the egg.

[3:50] A little of both.

[3:51] Jesse McAnally: A little of both.

[3:52] Elizabeth Teeter: I think it was like one of those like profit situations where like she was born and someone was like, this is our mushroom girl.

[4:00] Jesse McAnally: Alright, alright.

[4:01] Elizabeth Teeter: Now she has to have conflict within herself for the I want song.

[4:06] Jesse McAnally: Oh, the I want song.

[4:07] Like, so if we're gonna give her an I want song, does she love doing mushrooms?

[4:12] Elizabeth Teeter: She wants to be a dentist.

[4:14] Jesse McAnally: I think she wants to be a dentist.

[4:16] Elizabeth Teeter: And I think no, I think like from birth, people have been like training her to be this like mushroom masseuse type person.

[4:25] Jesse McAnally: And they're like, you are the center of our town.

[4:29] Elizabeth Teeter: And you are responsible for you know, basically keeping everyone alive because mushrooms are their source of like their financial source and all that.

[4:38] Jesse McAnally: Like it is their main import-export kind of thing.

[4:41] Elizabeth Teeter: And she, I don't know if she has powers.

[4:42] This could be a different thing.

[4:44] Jesse McAnally: She could have mushroom powers, but like she like helps the mushrooms grow.

[4:48] Elizabeth Teeter: It's like it's like an Elsa situation, but with mushrooms, I like that.

[4:51] Jesse McAnally: She has like a green thumb.

[4:52] Elizabeth Teeter: Right, and she's kind of like brown thumb.

[4:55] Jesse McAnally: But she's like, she's kind of like Elsa in that she's like, I don't want to do this anymore.

[5:00] Elizabeth Teeter: I want to be a dentist.

[5:03] Jesse McAnally: Okay, then the next morning, like after she sings her I want song, sets up her all the mushrooms dead.

[5:09] Elizabeth Teeter: Like her thumb, her thumb power doesn't work.

[5:12] Jesse McAnally: Now she has to go on an adventure to figure out where to get more mushrooms.

[5:16] Elizabeth Teeter: Song and dance.

[5:17] Exactly.

[5:18] Jesse McAnally: And then she goes into friends along the way.

[5:20] Elizabeth Teeter: A cabbage town where you're gonna be.

[5:22] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, she needs a cabbage town, and like maybe there's someone else that's like in charge of the cabbage, cabbages, whatever.

[5:27] Elizabeth Teeter: Wait, what goes with mu cabbage doesn't go with mushrooms, though, does it?

[5:30] Jesse McAnally: Um, spinach.

[5:31] Elizabeth Teeter: That works.

[5:32] Jesse McAnally: Like a sauteed spinach mushroom.

[5:33] Elizabeth Teeter: She falls in the colour.

[5:34] There's gotta be like a meal if she falls in love with the spinach person.

[5:38] Elizabeth Teeter: The spinach queen or king.

[5:41] Jesse McAnally: We need them to be a reflection of her, where they are also unhappy with their lot.

[5:46] Elizabeth Teeter: Yes.

[5:46] They also don't want to be in charge of the spinach land.

[5:49] Jesse McAnally: Maybe they're rival, like rival kingdoms, so to say.

[5:52] Elizabeth Teeter: Like you rival kingdom.

[5:53] Oh, the spinach in the mushroom kingdom.

[5:55] Jesse McAnally: There we go.

[5:57] Now we're talking some Romeo and Juliet type.

[5:59] Elizabeth Teeter: Mushroom Kingdom?

[6:00] What is this?

[6:00] Jesse McAnally: The Mario?

[6:05] Elizabeth Teeter: Okay.

[6:05] Mario Luigi turned spinach mushroom.

[6:10] Jesse McAnally: So Shremina, um, let she wants more than that, she wants to be a dentist.

[6:15] Elizabeth Teeter: Spinocho, which is Spinoccio.

[6:21] Jesse McAnally: And they they kind of like, you know, uh, like a lot of interesting folks there, and they've been warring factions for years, but she decides I'm gonna leave the mushroom to go and to the enemy territory to see if she can find help.

[6:36] Elizabeth Teeter: Oh, the enemy territory.

[6:37] Yeah, because maybe she hears of the previous mushroom king or queen who was like abdicated the throne, and it was like a we don't talk about Bruno moment.

[6:50] Jesse McAnally: And so she's like, Well, I need to find Bruno or whatever the mushroom person is and figure out what went on here.

[6:57] Elizabeth Teeter: Okay, so we got Shremina.

[6:58] Jesse McAnally: We need to give this like like tops or something.

[7:01] Elizabeth Teeter: Something about like what fungi father.

[7:04] Jesse McAnally: Fungy father.

[7:04] Is this a love story?

[7:05] Elizabeth Teeter: Is this like a no?

[7:07] Jesse McAnally: This this is like the guiding thing.

[7:08] Elizabeth Teeter: Yeah, this is the mentor figure that's a good thing.

[7:10] Jesse McAnally: The mentor figure who's like, follow your dreams.

[7:13] Elizabeth Teeter: Exactly.

[7:14] Jesse McAnally: That's the like that's the like.

[7:16] Elizabeth Teeter: But he was so tired of doing the mushrooms that he left and went to live with the spinach people.

[7:22] Jesse McAnally: Oh, so he's like, he's like traitor.

[7:25] Elizabeth Teeter: Maybe he wanted to be the dentist in Shrimina.

[7:28] Jesse McAnally: Shamina is like really into it.

[7:30] Elizabeth Teeter: Like, hey, we gotta do the mushrooms.

[7:31] Jesse McAnally: Then one day just her powers are gone.

[7:33] Elizabeth Teeter: A real kind of Moana situation where she's like, Yeah, I want to.

[7:36] Jesse McAnally: Oh yeah, I can't see.

[7:36] Elizabeth Teeter: She sings the I Want song, and then she wakes up and is like, uh-oh, I guess I wish too hard.

[7:42] Jesse McAnally: My powers are gone and everyone's starving.

[7:44] I have to go.

[7:45] Elizabeth Teeter: Maybe she's like, I gotta go get help.

[7:47] I gotta get my powers back.

[7:48] And then along the way, she's like, I don't want to do this anymore.

[7:52] Jesse McAnally: But then the village is starving, so that's the conflict.

[7:56] Elizabeth Teeter: Yes.

[7:57] She discovers that she doesn't want that to be the only thing in her life by looking at Spinoccio.

[8:01] Jesse McAnally: Spinoccio.

[8:02] Also, like a little jaded about being the spinach master.

[8:06] Elizabeth Teeter: She's like, wait, you don't like spinach either?

[8:09] Jesse McAnally: Like five different stories going on here.

[8:11] Elizabeth Teeter: I really like that.

[8:14] Jesse McAnally: I'm not gonna follow this one with him when I watch it.

[8:16] Elizabeth Teeter: There are three characters.

[8:20] Jesse McAnally: We got three characters.

[8:22] Elizabeth Teeter: C plots is a good one.

[8:23] Jesse McAnally: Was that Spinoccio coming in the back somewhere?

[8:28] Elizabeth Teeter: I think I just saw Spinoccio.

[8:30] Jesse McAnally: Oh my god.

[8:32] Elizabeth Teeter: Oh my gosh, Spinoccio, get out.

[8:34] Jesse McAnally: So basically, she's off to find her father figure, the former king of the mushroom.

[8:39] Elizabeth Teeter: Or my literal father.

[8:40] The former king of he's trying to find King Pete.

[8:43] Jesse McAnally: She finds out that her father is the king of the spinach land.

[8:47] Elizabeth Teeter: Yes.

[8:48] Jesse McAnally: And he never told her this.

[8:50] Elizabeth Teeter: What's going on?

[8:51] Jesse McAnally: That's a lot of people.

[8:52] They have the Unite the Kingdoms at the end, right?

[8:54] Elizabeth Teeter: Yeah, I feel like like she convinces Spinoccio, like, hey, you should give up your power too, because you know, if you're unhappy, you shouldn't do it.

[9:01] Jesse McAnally: And then all the kingdoms just fall apart.

[9:03] Elizabeth Teeter: And then they have together.

[9:04] Jesse McAnally: But then they realize that the only way that they're gonna be able to like survive is just like teamwork.

[9:09] Elizabeth Teeter: Like everyone has to plant the mushrooms, everyone has to plant the spinach.

[9:13] Jesse McAnally: It's not on one person.

[9:14] Elizabeth Teeter: They're like democracy, okay?

[9:16] No kings, queens, just pure uh teamwork.

[9:20] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, because if you're no kings, no mushrooms, just teamwork.

[9:23] Elizabeth Teeter: And it's not just a one one like vegetable kingdom.

[9:27] Jesse McAnally: We can all be like a gathering, a melting pot of vegetables.

[9:31] Elizabeth Teeter: Yeah, they're like, wait a second.

[9:32] They like it's like a ratatouille, it's like a ratatouille moment where he tries the strawberry and the cheese together, and he's like, these colors are beautiful.

[9:39] Jesse McAnally: And they're like, they're like, wait, sauteed spinach and sauteed mushrooms?

[9:43] This is incredible.

[9:44] Elizabeth Teeter: And then the people already we kind of sow the seeds that the townspeople kind of hate each other, but then they meet the other townspeople from the other cities that are.

[9:56] Jesse McAnally: Yes, and then it just gets a little too too sexy, and then Spinoccio and Shrimina get together at the end.

[10:02] Elizabeth Teeter: They're like, wait a sec, you can dance.

[10:06] Jesse McAnally: Well, who is that girl over there?

[10:08] Elizabeth Teeter: She's from the mushroom kingdom.

[10:10] Jesse McAnally: This is like turning into like West Side Stories.

[10:13] Elizabeth Teeter: This is like so this is gonna be a jukebox show, right?

[10:16] Jesse McAnally: Like, oh, that is a good question.

[10:18] Elizabeth Teeter: So I it's not that big of a mess.

[10:22] Jesse McAnally: What if it's both?

[10:23] Elizabeth Teeter: Like, what if it's like the random amount of like it's original songs, and all of a sudden you're like, is that ABBA?

[10:28] Elizabeth Teeter: Yeah. I feel like if I watch this, there's gonna be that moment where it's a pop song, you know, and it's like wait like Katy Perry? That's weird. But then it's like an original ballad afterwards, so it just comes out of nowhere. I don't think that's been done a lot.

[10:43] Jesse McAnally: No, no, it's a jukebox musical made entirely of other jukebox musicals, so they're pulling from ABBA, they're pulling from Moulin Rouge, like only songs used in other ones.

[10:52] Elizabeth Teeter: Well, I feel like we're getting like the Tanz der Vampire thing where it's like "Total Eclipse" is just a song in the musical, but everything else is original. But I feel like with all of these other original songs that have nothing to do with vegetables, it's like a metaphor.

[11:06] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, you know, like if you think like fungi is a lot like being a firework. The whole thing is giving me Gnomeo and Juliet.

[11:18] Elizabeth Teeter: Yeah. It is a little bit like Gnomeo and Juliet, but this is the same.

[11:22] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, this is better, obviously.

[11:23] Elizabeth Teeter: Well, I mean, yeah, I mean Spinocchio and uh I can't even remember the other name right now. Spinocchio, I think Spinocchio is like top tier, like you hear that and you're like soul.

[11:34] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, so we end act one with like all the kingdoms falling because you know there's like a big like crash, and then you're like, uh oh, blackout.

[11:43] Elizabeth Teeter: Yeah, like, oh, how are we gonna solve this? Better come back for act two.

[11:48] Jesse McAnally: Then act two is like, man, we had a real nice clam bake, so that the audience can sit down, we're gonna have our little nonsense song, and then we're gonna start the story up again.

[11:56] Elizabeth Teeter: Yeah, yeah. So how do we gonna end it? Like, what what what is the final goal?

[12:00] Jesse McAnally: I mean, the final goal is all the kingdoms deciding, you know what, we can't rely on one person to do all of our vegetable needs. We have to actually learn as a community.

[12:09] Elizabeth Teeter: Yeah, as a community and food is better. Um the goal is farming.

[12:14] Jesse McAnally: Yes. And a musical about mushrooms, isn't the goal always going to inevitably be farming?

[12:21] Elizabeth Teeter: Um I think it's a really telling piece right now. The Pulitzer. This is gonna be the next A Strange Loop.

[12:29] Jesse McAnally: I think so. I think so. I think so. We have to do something with mushrooms. Like the final message has to be like they learn it because of some metaphor revolving around mushrooms.

[12:42] Elizabeth Teeter: Um they're very top heady. They're like, don't do drugs.

[12:48] Jesse McAnally: Oh snap, we have to do the like yes, they get high as shit scene. Like you have to do that.

[12:54] Elizabeth Teeter: She goes to a place that looks exactly like her. She goes to a place that looks exactly like the mushroom kingdom, like everyone's the same except a little aw.

[13:04] Jesse McAnally: That turns out it's the other kind of mushroom kingdom. And they're all just kind of like, here, try some.

[13:11] Elizabeth Teeter: She's like, Yeah, there's like a there's like a song where like they like try to trick the spinach kingdom, and like that's like their way of attack, as they just.

[13:19] Jesse McAnally: I was thinking more like vision quests kind of thing, you know.

[13:22] Elizabeth Teeter: Oh, like there's like a whole like trippy scene in there, like that's how she learns what needs to happen. And that's like the big let's alligator moment. Spinocchio just walked in the background again.

[13:32] Jesse McAnally: She's like, Whoa, I've had a vision.

[13:36] Elizabeth Teeter: Oh my gosh. A vision of other vegetables. I need to go on my adventure. I need to go on my quest.

[13:44] Jesse McAnally: There's gotta be a good one. Zero's quest. Then of course.

[13:48] Elizabeth Teeter: And of course, she finds her like mentor figure useless, like I don't care about the mushroom kingdom. And then she has to be able to do that.

[13:54] Jesse McAnally: She thinks he's like all that, and he's like a man behind the curtain situation where he's like, I don't care. But at the last minute, he shows up to help because of narrative convenience.

[14:03] Elizabeth Teeter: You're like, Bruno, or I'm just saying that now because Encanto's in the brain.

[14:07] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[14:09] Elizabeth Teeter: His name's like what, Morale?

[14:10] Jesse McAnally: Oh no.

[14:11] Elizabeth Teeter: Morale, I like that.

[14:13] Jesse McAnally: Morale. What are you doing here?

[14:15] Elizabeth Teeter: I've come to save you, child.

[14:19] Jesse McAnally: What do you think I've been doing? You were right about the mushrooms.

[14:25] Elizabeth Teeter: He's like, I was thinking. I was meditating. And I decided I gotta leave my house.

[14:33] Jesse McAnally: And he's played by Danny Burstein.

[14:36] Elizabeth Teeter: You are right, child. I brought my hoe and I'm ready to garden.

[14:41] Jesse McAnally: Oh, yeah. We gotta have celebrity casting in this.

[14:43] Elizabeth Teeter: Um, yeah, so Shremina. So we need like we need like three songs or something.

[14:48] Jesse McAnally: Okay, we have the I want song, which I think is like more than a morale.

[14:48] Elizabeth Teeter: More than a morale. I like that. Maybe that's our family line, the Morale, Shremina Morale.

[15:02] Jesse McAnally: More than mushrooms. There must be something more. It's always more for these characters. I want, I want, I want.

[15:11] Elizabeth Teeter: It's literally the I want to do it. She's good songs going on here. This is gonna be some boss songwriter.

[15:17] Jesse McAnally: Okay, so we usually end with this, but now that it's coming up, who do you think should compose this musical?

[15:24] Elizabeth Teeter: Like us.

[15:26] Jesse McAnally: I mean, Elizabeth Teeter, it would be a like a I'm getting a pretty big like step up. I'd be into it. Like, I'm thinking of you a Shremina, though. I feel like having the acting role and you know the songwriting.

[15:42] Elizabeth Teeter: I wasn't gonna say it, but if we see this on Broadway, we gotta get some credit here.

[15:48] Jesse McAnally: Um so we're gonna pet cast Derek Klena as Spinocchio.

[15:52] Elizabeth Teeter: Okay, perfect. Yeah, I feel like you guys would vibe together.

[15:55] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, Derek Klena, uh Danny Burstein, it's just the whole Moulin Rouge cast. We gotta throw a rock into that. We gotta Beth Malone plays like the matriarch of the the That's got like Leslie Kritzer in it too.

[16:10] Elizabeth Teeter: I want to do it with her. She'll be like uh she'll be like another vegetable like personal.

[16:14] Jesse McAnally: She's the cabbage leader.

[16:15] Elizabeth Teeter: She's the cabbage leader. She has a funny song that she tries to like distract her along the way.

[16:20] Jesse McAnally: Wait, wait, wait. What's a vegetable that absolutely no one likes?

[16:23] Elizabeth Teeter: She's the kale.

[16:25] Jesse McAnally: Brussels?

[16:25] Elizabeth Teeter: I love Brussels sprouts. They're notorious for nobody liking them.

[16:30] Jesse McAnally: No one likes them, but we are.

[16:31] Elizabeth Teeter: Nobody likes kale though.

[16:32] Jesse McAnally: No one actually kale tastes like bug spray.

[16:34] Elizabeth Teeter: Kale chips, though. Those are good.

[16:36] Jesse McAnally: You put bug spray on them, like maybe it's just like.

[16:40] Elizabeth Teeter: How do you know what bug spray tastes like? You've never sprayed it in the air and just been like, oh, I'm walking through this and then some hit my tongue.

[16:48] Jesse McAnally: You open you open your mouth while you're gonna spend a lot of things.

[16:50] Elizabeth Teeter: Well, usually you don't I'm not gonna spend half of our pitch time uh expressing how I know bug spray tastes.

[16:58] Jesse McAnally: That's our next musical, Bug Spray. Let's drink it.

[17:01] Elizabeth Teeter: We should have done Bug Spray. It's like Hairspray, but it's uh like there's someone that wants to be on a dancing TV show.

[17:09] Jesse McAnally: Um, but they can't deal with that bug spray. It's an outdoor show.

[17:15] Elizabeth Teeter: Oh, yes. Well, it's all dancing, but they're like swinging at the floor. You know, this would be great because instead of like a merchandise booth, we'll just have a kitchen.

[17:23] Jesse McAnally: Like the we'll just have um like a stovetop and like people just be sautéing vegetables the whole time.

[17:28] Elizabeth Teeter: So you walk in and you're like, ooh, I smell mushrooms.

[17:31] Jesse McAnally: Exactly. It's just like the waitress thing where they gave you like pies to start with. Uh just like who would want like you walk in and there's like a box of like mushrooms raw, and you're like, hmm.

[17:42] Elizabeth Teeter: Like, Emeril Lagasse's there, like frying up sautéing them every single day.

[17:46] Jesse McAnally: Eight shows a week.

[17:47] Elizabeth Teeter: Eight shows a week. The marketing and merchandising for this show is gonna be much better than the show itself, I think.

[17:53] Jesse McAnally: Um that's not true. The show's great, Angel. You know what? I don't think that is the right attitude we need to make this a successful show.

[18:00] Elizabeth Teeter: Alright, so what's what's our 11 o'clock number?

[18:02] Jesse McAnally: So because we know what the climax is, like they decide you know what we all need to work together, but we need another vegetable pond. What's a vegetable pond we can put here?

[18:12] Elizabeth Teeter: Like um we've grown roots or something like that.

[18:17] Jesse McAnally: Oh yeah, that's we've grown roots one day more.

[18:22] Elizabeth Teeter: Then we just rip off um Les Mis and Showboat.

[18:30] Jesse McAnally: And it's got a little morel mushroom on it.

[18:33] Elizabeth Teeter: Yeah, yeah. No, but it's like they make a salad. They make a salad, like, and they finally put all the vegetables together.

[18:40] Jesse McAnally: Oh we blend together and then we make a salad.

[18:40] Elizabeth Teeter: We make a salad with salad with shrooms and no chio.

[18:58] Jesse McAnally: Yes. Yes, yes. It comes out of nowhere. Everyone's like, oh my god, it sounds like we built this city, but it's not. It's just close enough to be legally a parody.

[19:10] Elizabeth Teeter: Legally not the city, but it is salad. Doo-doo doo. We made this down with spinach and shrooms?

[19:19] Jesse McAnally: Spinach and shrooms. And then they just start listing all the vegetables and carrots and greens and onions.

[19:28] Elizabeth Teeter: I can't remember how the actual song goes after that, but spinach and shrooms.

[19:37] Jesse McAnally: But that's the only pop song. That's the only pop song.

[19:41] Elizabeth Teeter: I just think of like, I don't know why I'm thinking of the Muppets movie where they're like cleaning up the theater, but it's that's you know how to that is they do sing that song there.

[19:41] Jesse McAnally: They do sing that song in the Muppets movie. Um we can get the Muppets in.

[19:55] Elizabeth Teeter: Okay. Alright. Well, the Muppets are our new favorite vegetables. I recently made a slideshow of um like the Muppets Beetlejuice casting. Like if we were to cast Beetlejuice with the Muppets, so like maybe this could be a crossover thing as well.

[20:07] Jesse McAnally: I'm into that. Wick, what was your casting? What was your um I'm pretty proud of my casting?

[20:12] Elizabeth Teeter: Uh this is a little off topic, but um.

[20:12] Jesse McAnally: That's fine.

[20:15] Elizabeth Teeter: Yeah, like his animal, of course.

[20:19] Jesse McAnally: Beetlejuice's animal.

[20:20] Elizabeth Teeter: Uh we said Lydia would be Rizzo the rat.

[20:22] Jesse McAnally: I think that would be perfect.

[20:24] Elizabeth Teeter: What? There aren't many female Muppets to work with. I will give you that. But like Rizzo in like the little dress, like, and he's like sassy and like running up the banister, like screaming.

[20:34] Jesse McAnally: I think I might actually be behind this.

[20:36] Elizabeth Teeter: I too am strange and unusual.

[20:49] Elizabeth Teeter: Kermit is Adam, makes sense. Janice is Barbara, um, the blonde hair, obviously. Um what else did we say? I said Miss Miss Poogie as Juno, like the rival.

[21:00] Jesse McAnally: Yes.

[21:01] Elizabeth Teeter: Brilliant. Um, what are the old what are the two old men?

[21:04] Jesse McAnally: Waldorf and whatever called it.

[21:07] Elizabeth Teeter: Yeah, we said they both would play Maxi Dean. Like at the same time. It's like in Christmas Carol where they split the character into two characters. And then we went on to there are many different like side character roles that we kind of plan out.

[21:24] Jesse McAnally: So this could be a situation.

[21:31] Elizabeth Teeter: If it is the cast, no one's gonna complain.

[21:33] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[21:35] Elizabeth Teeter: I would want to go see it. Jesse, I do have a question, and uh I this might be a personal question, so take it. Have you often in competition with Rizzo the Rat in your roles?

[21:46] Elizabeth Teeter: I didn't it's a little sensitive. Um, it's hard. Um yeah, it's it's it's a sensitive question, and that's why I hesitated to put Rizzo on this celebrity casting. But um, you know, I people look at me and say, Wow, you remind me of Rizzo the Rat. So I mean you go into these auditions, you get up every morning at six, you stand there in line, and you come out and you see Rizzo sitting there and you're like fucking not that rat again.

[22:18] Elizabeth Teeter: It's over. It's not like a tall to be compared to. That rat.

[22:25] Jesse McAnally: All right, we gotta get back to the shrooms.

[22:27] Elizabeth Teeter: Okay, sorry, side point. Um, no, no worries. Um, so what composer do you think would take on uh our shroom musical?

[22:35] Jesse McAnally: We should give it a title.

[22:36] Elizabeth Teeter: Come on, Shermina and Spinoccio, the ballot of Shimina Spinoccio.

[22:41] Jesse McAnally: That makes it seem too much like Romeo.

[22:43] Elizabeth Teeter: Yeah, like Romeo Julia. What about Little Miss Morel?

[22:46] Jesse McAnally: Little Miss, like it's in a little mistake.

[22:48] Elizabeth Teeter: I don't hate that, but it's uh but it's also like maybe something with mushrooms involved.

[22:53] Jesse McAnally: Um Morel is a mushroom, which is a type of mushroom, right?

[22:58] Elizabeth Teeter: Yeah.

[22:58] Jesse McAnally: Oh see, I didn't I didn't actually know that much about mushrooms before.

[23:01] Elizabeth Teeter: Well, we always do our research before we start.

[23:04] Jesse McAnally: Okay.

[23:07] Elizabeth Teeter: I can tell.

[23:08] Jesse McAnally: I can tell. Um the title's the most important part.

[23:15] Elizabeth Teeter: Yeah. It doesn't matter if the show's good. We could just call it shrooms.

[23:18] Jesse McAnally: I can already see the playbill.

[23:19] Elizabeth Teeter: I can see the L Herschel. It's perfect marketing, really.

[23:26] Jesse McAnally: You get the drug scene, you get like the kids involved. Everyone's coming to see that opening weekend. They think it's gonna be some like huge lesson, and then it's really just it's about vegetables.

[23:36] Elizabeth Teeter: It's a sincere story about persevering and not not putting all the pressure on one person in your community.

[23:43] Jesse McAnally: And the uh the poster is like a red poster with white spots, but there's like people dancing as the spots.

[23:49] Elizabeth Teeter: Oh people are like, Man, what is shrooms about? I don't understand. And nobody knows what it's about until they go see it, you know.

[23:55] Jesse McAnally: This will go on the dressing room table.

[23:57] Elizabeth Teeter: Yep, every day. Um smells like uh forest.

[24:02] Jesse McAnally: It's a candle.

[24:04] Elizabeth Teeter: So anyway, no one can see it.

[24:07] Jesse McAnally: Um, you know what?

[24:10] Elizabeth Teeter: Um you can't see it, so sh you know what? Elizabeth's doing backflips right now.

[24:13] Jesse McAnally: She's been doing it the whole time.

[24:14] Elizabeth Teeter: You'll never be able to say she didn't. Dancer first.

[24:21] Jesse McAnally: So my pitch to r for the writer of this might be an off the wall one. I'm thinking Michael R. Jackson.

[24:27] Elizabeth Teeter: Like he's gonna bring something different to this.

[24:31] Jesse McAnally: I uh I don't know if I see it. Is this rock musical?

[24:35] Elizabeth Teeter: Is this like maybe a combination?

[24:37] Jesse McAnally: Like you're like, wait, why does this sound like light in the piazza? And then all of a sudden you're like, rock.

[24:42] Elizabeth Teeter: Adam Gottel, that could be another good one.

[24:45] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, it could be some pretty ballads in there.

[24:47] Elizabeth Teeter: And then we built this city.

[24:48] Jesse McAnally: I mean, we built the we built the salad.

[24:51] Elizabeth Teeter: That just has to be in there.

[24:53] Jesse McAnally: And that's like the that's what to draw all the normal people in. You know, like the non-musical families that come to see it because it's like how it's Shrek by saying I'm a believer just to give you the reward for sitting through Shrek the musical.

[25:05] Elizabeth Teeter: It's just like that.

[25:07] Jesse McAnally: Shrek the musical's good though.

[25:09] Elizabeth Teeter: I love musical.

[25:10] Jesse McAnally: We love Shrek Musical on this podcast.

[25:12] Elizabeth Teeter: And why are you doing that?

[25:15] Jesse McAnally: I'm thinking about the normies that are like, I'm gonna go see Shrek the Musical.

[25:18] Elizabeth Teeter: I'm I want all star.

[25:19] Jesse McAnally: And then it's like, we'll give you I'm a I feel like a normal person be like, oh fine, I'll go see Shrek the Musical and then be like, wait, this was fantastic.

[25:26] Elizabeth Teeter: Except Shay Ferrillis for some reason.

[25:29] Jesse McAnally: Guest of the show.

[25:30] Elizabeth Teeter: He he really hated that musical for no reason.

[25:32] Jesse McAnally: Oh so let's so Ben Brantley going into I know he doesn't do the job anymore.

[25:38] Elizabeth Teeter: Ben Brantley, opening weekend, Shrooms the musical. What what would his reviews say?

[25:43] Jesse McAnally: Um five stars.

[25:45] Elizabeth Teeter: Oh, really?

[25:46] Jesse McAnally: A man who notoriously never gives like number ratings to side know it this time?

[25:50] Elizabeth Teeter: Numbers are going five.

[25:52] Jesse McAnally: My perspective is is if you drag your own musical or you drag like you know, we gotta be our biggest supporters here.

[26:01] Elizabeth Teeter: If no one believes in us, we have to believe in us.

[26:04] Jesse McAnally: I have the Ben Brantley review, I think.

[26:06] Elizabeth Teeter: The whole first paragraph.

[26:08] Jesse McAnally: What's the like title?

[26:09] Elizabeth Teeter: Shrooms more than it's like shrooms, like you'll wish you were high.

[26:15] Jesse McAnally: Shrooms or dooms, yeah.

[26:17] Elizabeth Teeter: And then and then the whole first paragraph is just him talking about how he is it's like you're wandering through a forest looking for a good mushroom, and you can't tell the poison ones from the non-poison ones.

[26:29] Jesse McAnally: And and it you don't understand what he if he liked it or if he didn't like it, but that's the entire like review.

[26:35] Elizabeth Teeter: It's very uh yeah, like mixed.

[26:37] Jesse McAnally: Like you're like, wait, hmm.

[26:38] Elizabeth Teeter: Wait, so is it good? Is it bad? Did you even talk about the show?

[26:41] Jesse McAnally: And then he'll mention like one of the leads was like good or something.

[26:44] Elizabeth Teeter: Yeah.

[26:46] Jesse McAnally: Jack Clenna as Spinoza is Derek Lena, Spinocchio shines.

[26:53] Elizabeth Teeter: I wanted more of him.

[26:54] Jesse McAnally: Not Spinocchio's Spinocchio.

[26:57] Elizabeth Teeter: Spinocchio.

[26:58] Jesse McAnally: He said he spells it wrong with a K somehow.

[27:02] Elizabeth Teeter: Um Jason Robert Brown's one song that he wrote really kind of enchanted me, but the rest was done by Adam Gattell.

[27:12] Jesse McAnally: All right.

[27:13] Elizabeth Teeter: The standout was we built this salad, but I feel like I've heard it before, but I don't know.

[27:19] Jesse McAnally: It like strikes a nostalgic nerve, but it's like is it just different enough where like you can't take the copyright?

[27:26] Elizabeth Teeter: Like exactly, exactly. It's like those SNL parodies.

[27:29] Jesse McAnally: Secretly at least favorite song of all time.

[27:32] Elizabeth Teeter: Okay.

[27:33] Jesse McAnally: He gets really excited.

[27:34] Elizabeth Teeter: The pit so what happens is it's not a hit at first when shrooms hits Broadway.

[27:39] Jesse McAnally: Sadly enough, it seems to be floundering a little bit.

[27:41] Elizabeth Teeter: But then the girl that plays Shrimpina starts doing TikTok trends backstage, and then suddenly it's a hit.

[27:41] Jesse McAnally: Then suddenly it's a hit.

[27:50] Elizabeth Teeter: Then they start to do it.

[27:51] Jesse McAnally: Then Brigad back Peter.

[27:54] Elizabeth Teeter: Umxpected treasure.

[27:58] Jesse McAnally: It's like it's not a hit at first, but then the summer crowd starts to come, and everyone's like, wait, this is fantastic.

[28:05] Elizabeth Teeter: And thankfully, it gets Elizabeth Teeter as Shrimp Shrimpina, their first Tony Award.

[28:11] Jesse McAnally: Thank you so much. This has been uh hold on.

[28:16] Elizabeth Teeter: I need to introduce you.

[28:16] Jesse McAnally: Uh pretend I'm James Earl Jones.

[28:18] Elizabeth Teeter: Okay.

[28:19] Jesse McAnally: And the Tony Award goes to the teeter from Shrooms.

[28:26] Elizabeth Teeter: Yeah!

[28:28] Jesse McAnally: And the music playing.

[28:29] Elizabeth Teeter: Oh my god, we built this salad.

[28:34] Jesse McAnally: Let's like play it on a violin.

[28:36] Elizabeth Teeter: Like no lyrics, so everyone's like, why has we built this city just?

[28:43] Jesse McAnally: And then you end your speech with my casting creatives.

[28:46] Elizabeth Teeter: We really built this salad.

[28:48] Jesse McAnally: We really built this salad to everyone out there.

[28:52] Elizabeth Teeter: It's gonna really it's gonna be one of those things where in 50 years everyone's gonna be a good thing.

[28:57] Jesse McAnally: The next time you go to a restaurant.

[28:59] Elizabeth Teeter: The next time you sit down at a restaurant instead of a burger, get a salad.

[29:04] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, it's really like a commentary on like it's a commentary on like vegetarian, like being a vegetarian, which I'm not, but like Audra McDonald is crying in the front row, like Lady Gaga's like yeah, fantastic.

[29:20] Elizabeth Teeter: She knows uh this is this sounds like it's gonna be a hit.

[29:24] Jesse McAnally: Yes, it's a hit, and I hope we're not running over time.

[29:27] Elizabeth Teeter: Elizabeth, this was absolutely lovely.

[29:30] Jesse McAnally: Thank you so much for making a musical with us.

[29:33] Elizabeth Teeter: There's so many things that you've got on.

[29:35] Jesse McAnally: I'm so unexpected, and um I feel so creatively fulfilled.

[29:41] Elizabeth Teeter: It was a great creative exercise about shrooms to accomplish something.

[29:45] Jesse McAnally: Now, why don't you promote your other endeavors?

[29:47] Elizabeth Teeter: Because we all know that this is gonna be really the big project in your life for the rest of the time.

[29:51] Elizabeth Teeter: Um, well, before you catch me in this shrooms the Musical, uh, you can you can come see Beauty Beetlejuice the musical, which is currently on Broadway at the Marquee Theater.

[30:02] Elizabeth Teeter: Um, yeah, you can find me there.

[30:05] Jesse McAnally: What about your social medias and all that?

[30:07] Elizabeth Teeter: Oh, yes. I am on Instagram at Elizabeth Teeter Official.

[30:11] Elizabeth Teeter: I am on TikTok, but I don't really I I'm not that great at it.

[30:16] Elizabeth Teeter: Um you can't find me there.

[30:19] Elizabeth Teeter: Um Yeah, that's where I am.

[30:22] Jesse McAnally: So And you you say there might be some songwriting endeavors in the near future.

[30:26] Elizabeth Teeter: Yes, I I wrote some s I wrote I have written songs over the pandemic, and I'm hoping to release them soon, hopefully in the next month.

[30:34] Elizabeth Teeter: So, yay! Please check them out if you're interested.

[30:37] Jesse McAnally: And if, you know, if not, that's okay.

[30:40] Elizabeth Teeter: You know what you should be interested, because Elizabeth is a great joy to talk to in a very, very great time.

[30:45] Jesse McAnally: Thank you so much for having fun with us.

[30:47] Elizabeth Teeter: This was so exciting.

[30:49] Jesse McAnally: Thank you. We'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese Make Me a Musical.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred