Continuing our “Journey to Motherhood” series, two time Tony Award winner and star of the hit television show, Younger, Sutton Foster shares her path to becoming a mom... Read More
From the show: Mamas Talkin' Loud
Guests
Featured Shows
About
Continuing our “Journey to Motherhood” series, two time Tony Award winner and star of the hit television show, Younger, Sutton Foster shares her path to becoming a mom. After struggling with infertility for years, choosing adoption brought her incredible daughter into her life and the knowledge that this path was always meant to be. Between balancing motherhood, life on the set of Younger, and a much anticipated return to Broadway in The Music Man, Sutton openly and honestly shares the emotional rollercoaster of the life of a working artist mother.
Find more info about the podcast via BPN.fm/mamas.
Produced by Dori Berinstein and Alan Seales.
Edited by Derek Gunther.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jessica Rush: Uh uh oh uh uh oh uh uh oh mama's talking loud, mama's talking loud, mama's talking tough, mama's talking how being good with good enough.
[0:14] Cara Cooper: Mama's talking life, mama's talking proud, mama talking trash, mama's talking last.
[0:28] Jessica Rush: Hi, everybody, welcome to this episode of Mama's Talking Loud.
[0:31] I'm Jessica Rush.
[0:33] Cara Cooper: And I'm Cara Cooper, and today we have two-time Tony Award winner for Thoroughly Modern Millie and Anything Goes.
[0:39] Our guest today has starred on Broadway in 11 productions, including the recent revival of Violet, The Drowsy Chaperone, Little Women, Young Frankenstein, Shrek the Musical, the list goes on and on and on.
[0:49] She has a bit of a resume, just a little bit.
[0:52] Uh, she starred in the television series Bunheads and is currently starring as Liza Miller in the TV Land series Younger, which I am mildly obsessed with.
[1:02] And she is basically the nicest person you will ever meet.
[1:05] Welcome, Sutton Foster.
[1:07] Sutton Foster: Hi, you guys. Thank you for having me.
[1:09] Jessica Rush: Yay!
[1:10] Cara Cooper: Thank you so much for being here.
[1:12] We're so thrilled.
[1:14] Sutton Foster: Awesome.
[1:15] Jessica Rush: We keep saying being here. That's like the virtual.
[1:16] We're all together, guys.
[1:19] Cara Cooper: Yeah.
[1:20] Sutton Foster: Totally.
[1:21] Cara Cooper: We miss what we wouldn't give to be like sitting in the studio.
[1:24] But you know, it's all good.
[1:26] Sutton Foster: It's all good.
[1:27] Cara Cooper: And Sutton, we are. This will be our third journey to motherhood episode, actually.
[1:33] That is for our listeners who are following along.
[1:36] We do have a journey to motherhood series.
[1:38] So we're thrilled to have you here with us for it.
[1:42] Sutton Foster: I still can't believe I'm a mom. I was just talking to my husband last night, and I was like, how do you feel every time she goes, Daddy, Daddy? And like, or she goes, like, she calls me like mama or mommy, like it changes, you know. And every time I'm like, that's me. Like every time. Like I still can't believe that it's like that we have this little human that, you know, right.
[2:05] That you are her person and her people.
[2:08] You're in charge.
[2:09] Sutton Foster: You're the person.
[2:10] I'm the person.
[2:11] I know. It's so intense, but it's awesome.
[2:14] Cara Cooper: It's a lot of pressure.
[2:15] Sutton Foster: It's so much pressure.
[2:17] Cara Cooper: Well, if you would get we like to ask our guests um to tell us about their child or their children when they get started because we don't often get asked that if we're being honest, right?
[2:30] Sutton Foster: Um I have a um a three and a half year old uh girl, little girl named her name is Emily. Her name is Emily Dale Griffin Foster. I throw in the Foster at the end. And uh she does too now, which I'm like, oh so proud. And uh she is um she is like she's so smart and uh so funny. And I think she like she also I'm very proud of this, but she also has like the concept of like she goes like is that funny? Like she wants to like make people laugh, and we're um she's just and very empathetic and always wants to help. Can I help you? I have to go get dressed. Can I help you? I I'm gonna make I'm gonna make your oatmeal. Can I help you? Can I stir? Um, she's like very uh she just wants to like be involved. Um she uh she still takes naps.
[3:28] Sutton Foster: She's still lucky you she's napping right now, so she still takes naps. She's uh loves to sleep, has a favorite lovey that she calls Ruffy and it's a unicorn and um she sucks her thumb and she loves to be outside and um you know she was I don't know she's just like uh she's a good hang. She's like not an you know, she's like a good kid. Like she's a really she's like really sweet and uh I don't know, like her most I'm trying to think of like her most challenging, you know, moments. I mean, she's three and a half, so we have you know, we'll have like a day where I'm like, oh, but um mostly she's like uh just like just a really really good kid and and uh we just feel so lucky, you know.
[4:16] Cara Cooper: Yeah, she's just um like a really sweet soul.
[4:19] That's awesome.
[4:20] Cara Cooper: That reminds me. That's just so amazing. About their kids. You like everybody's demeanor changes completely when they talk about their kids.
[4:28] Sutton Foster: No, it's true, because we ask every guest this, and it and it's just so great to see somebody talk about their child, you know?
[4:35] Cara Cooper: Yeah.
[4:36] Sutton Foster: It reminds me what you said about like she's just a good hang, you know, good kid to hang with. I reminds me a lot of my husband says that about Elliot a lot. He's like, She's such a you're just like an awesome addition to our crew. You know, like we're a good team, you know.
[4:51] Cara Cooper: Yeah.
[4:51] Sutton Foster: That's and that's a lovely thing to feel, you know, to want to hang out with your child. We we went on. I mean, we have our moments, but oh yeah, yeah. We we we went on a hike. Um we're we we've been outside the city um since March, uh, and we have a little lake house and and we we take her hiking. I she's she's like 34 pounds, but I I still have like a carrier and I'll put her on my back and we like hike around and she loves to walk and she so we we found like this little trail and and uh and her new favorite word is why.
[5:25] I mean it's we are in the why phase so hard right now, and I and it's intense and I'm like she's like why I'm like well why do you think she's like be because and I'm like exactly so but we I had her on my back and then I let her down to walk for a little bit and and I said it's it's a little rocky she goes it's rocky but I will try my best on the tricky parts oh and I'm like who are you and like she my my dad lives um my dad lives about they him and his lady friend relocated up up here near us at the lake um they live about five minutes away and about once a week you know Emily goes to spend a couple of hours with papa mimi and and and she's like I want to go by myself and I'm like oh okay you could sure you can go over there because she gets to watch like Paw Patrol and dinosaur train or you know and like you know whatever and I'm like okay whatever happens over there she gets to have like four desserts exactly yep last time she was there with my dad he I said how's it going and he texted me and he's like we're making cookies and she said I'm not a very good baker but I'll do my best what like she's three and she's like I'll do my best talk about a positive outlook what are you on mama I mean that's awesome mama that's what that is well definitely also she should write quotes and um motivational quotes because that one about you know the tricky what is the what did she say about the tricky she goes I'll do my best to get through the tricky part yes, to get through the tricky part.
[7:02] Cara Cooper: Yeah.
[7:02] Sutton Foster: We all do our best to get through the tricky part. That should be our motto for this time, right yes the never ending tricky part thank Emily. And I'm like, and I always say, you know, I'm I'm afraid of snakes. And and she I told her, she said, and I said, she goes, if I she goes, if we see a snake, I'll help you be brave.
[7:21] So you can so you can be. I always do things in three. So I always say, she goes, so I so you can be brave, brave, brave. And she said, You so you'll be brave so I can learn about them. I'm like, oh son, I feel like I'm listening to myself.
[7:37] Cara Cooper: I'm definitely afraid of snakes. And my son, we went on a hike, and he goes, Mom, don't ask me what we just saw.
[7:45] Sutton Foster: Don't and you're like, I mean, I know.
[7:48] Cara Cooper: And they're the same age.
[7:49] Sutton Foster: They're they're up the same age.
[7:51] Oh my gosh.
[7:52] Sutton Foster: Oh my god, I love three and a half. I love it. It's like fun. We're like in this really fabulous pocket of, you know, she's really like finding her stepping into her own, but also like super um lovey and like and you know, she's like, Ma, I gotta tell you something.
[8:10] I'm like, I'm like, what? She goes, I love ya. And then she like runs away. And I'm like, I love ya. Like, where did that come from? Like every day is something.
[8:19] Cara Cooper: I love it.
[8:20] Sutton Foster: Yeah, I love ya.
[8:22] I know. She's she did something with Ted yesterday too. She was like, she's like, Dad, Daddy, you want to, I got a granola bar for you.
[8:31] And I'm like, a granola bar? She was like, a granola bar for you. And I'm like, I she was like, she sounded like she was from Fargo. It's like she has like these accents now.
[8:40] Anyway, God. But yeah, she's a good kid. Did you always know you wanted to be a mother, Sutton on your radar?
[8:47] Sutton Foster: No, I was always on the fence about it. Um I was uh I was always so career driven for so long, and then um, and then relationship challenged. Uh although I had been I'd been I'm on my second marriage, but my first marriage, it was like uh we just weren't kids weren't like weren't on the radar.
[9:11] Um they were never like off the table. It just it never felt like the right time. And then I really didn't think about it until I met my husband now when I met Ted.
[9:23] And then my mom had passed away. My mom passed away um six years ago. And I I met my husband, my mom passed away, and like and his father had passed away, and then all of a sudden, I don't know, like the idea of family changed, and like I I finally understood what marriage was and this this combination of bringing families together, and then he he was talking about like right away, and I was 39, so it was like, okay, let's let's let's start trying to have kids, you know.
[10:00] Let's start, let's start trying, let's start trying. And it was like the first time my whole life I had like actively tried to get pregnant, or that it I was even contemplating it. Um, and then we we couldn't get pregnant. It was like we were because we went through the whole fertility, the whole the fertility battle, and which was very confusing to me because I was like, um, because I I didn't I was like, um usually, you know, when I go after something, I can make it happen, you know.
[10:33] And I was like really annoyed by that whole thing. It was so it was so um uh like paralyzing, and um we tried for like a year and a half naturally, and then I was like 40, and then we started to do fertility things, and we went through three different rounds of fertility treatments, IVF, and after the third round, well, after the second round, I had like a total break meltdown, and I was so um it just felt so uh for me, it felt I was like manipulating my body.
[11:09] I was like going through all of this stuff, and it just felt like, and I was like shooting a television show, and like nobody knew, and it was just this weird time. And I remember having like a total meltdown to my husband, and I was like, I can't do it, I can't, this can't be the only way we know, we this isn't the only way we can have a family.
[11:32] This doesn't feel right, like nothing was feeling right. And I had always been very pro-adoption. It was something that I'd always two of my best friends are adopted.
[11:42] Uh it was it was something that I felt was like deep in my heart, and I was like, we have to pursue adoption at the same time. I was like, we cannot just pursue the IVF, like it we have to send out all the battalions, and and I was like, and you have to do it.
[11:58] I was like, I'm putting I'm putting needles in my belly, and you have to call. Like we had a friend of ours who had uh adopted kids, and I was like, you have to call Peter, you have to talk to him and find get to him.
[12:10] And he was like, Okay, okay. And um, and then like as soon as we started pursuing adoption, it was like all the roadblocks we had with fertility, they it was like uh adopt for some crazy, you know, it was clear that this soul was this child was, you know, cannonballing towards us and and like we just um it just all made I still like I you know, our our whole story, her whole story, and someday I can't wait to like, you know, write her whole story when she's old enough to be able to we can write it together.
[12:52] But it was um it was just so clear that it was meant to be. And I you know, I'm still amazed. I like all the paperwork and all of the things and but it was somehow it was so good for me, I think that journey to motherhood where the needles and the pills and the you know, the eggs being pulled out, it's just so strange.
[13:15] But like adoption for me, it just felt because you have to fill out all of these pap all this paperwork. You have to like you have to take all these classes and watch all these and learn about what it means to like be a parent and also have a social worker come to your home and you're like, you know, you have to like ask all these hard questions of yourself and of your spouse.
[13:39] And there was like a different preparation. And I think I needed that. Um then we like everything happened for us very quickly, and we were matched and we were matched with a birth mother, and um, and Emily was, you know, we were there when she was born and we held her 30 minutes after she was born, you know.
[14:01] It was and we have a, you know, a wonderful relationship with the birth family, and it's um it's just been uh it's been wild.
[14:10] Sutton Foster: And now again, and I'm like, how did that happen? But it was just so clear that that was our, you know, I I'm talking way too much, but I have um No, that's what you're here to do. You know, I feel like I have like you, you know, you look out and you're like, like when I was going through, like I met Ted and I was like, oh my gosh, this is the man I want to have a family with. And they were we're like, and I'm like, oh my gosh, we're gonna get and then when we didn't give pride, I was like, wait, wait, why isn't this happening? Why isn't this happening? And then the IVF failed, and I'm like, I was so like upset with the universe, you know. But the reason none of that was working was because Emily was, I know it was waiting.
Yeah, I know. And so I see her and I'm like, there's not a doubt in my mind that she's not my daughter, like that I don't even question it, you know, and um, or that she wasn't meant to be in our life. It's so yeah, it's just it blows me away. And I even think of like both my husband and I just being so fumbly and you know, with the paperwork, and we were like, we were like, oh god, like let's put it together, and we like send it off, you know, and then next thing you know, we're like, oh wait, what? And it's like all happening, and we're just like trying to catch up to it, and how we, I you know, it's just amazing. It's just amazing.
[15:28] Cara Cooper: We're gonna take a quick break and we'll be right back with more of our conversation with Sutton Foster.
[15:37] Jessica Rush: Welcome back, everyone. We're continuing our conversation with Sutton Foster.
[15:41] Sutton Foster: So my journey to motherhood. So in conclusion. Um, um I was, yeah, it's like I was just, yeah. It's like I can look, I can look back on it now and it makes sense. But in the moment it was like, whoa, like crazy. Yeah. But um in those moments you feel, and I found this, I mean it's not the same, but with jobs even or shows, you know what I mean? Like things that you that pass you by, and you think you're so mad. I was supposed to book that, I was supposed to do that, and then in hindsight, you look back and you realize everything you can't miss your destiny, and everything happens the way it's supposed to, and when you get to the other side, you realize, oh the plan was not what I had planned, but this is what was supposed to happen instead.
[16:27] Cara Cooper: Right, exactly.
[16:28] Sutton Foster: Yeah, exactly. It's so interesting. We I just was talking to a gay couple that's going through the adoption process, and all the preparation that you were talking about, the classes and the it feels very intrusive. I think, like you said, and a social worker coming over and and your life being examined by someone else, and so many people don't have to go through that to become parents.
[16:50] Jessica Rush: Yeah, and I think in a lot of ways, and maybe you would agree or disagree with this, but you almost were more prepared than somebody who who obviously became pregnant by accident or or went about it the more typical way. I feel like you really have to examine yourself more before you have a child through adoption, you know, and that yeah, that every step you take, you're learning.
[17:17] Sutton Foster: Yeah, it was actually really helpful. Although I mean, when the baby came, I had no idea what I was doing. I mean, no, they just handed me a baby, and I was like, what the fuck? You know, I know I'm like, I wouldn't, you're just gonna let me like, you know, and it's like this little yoda, this tiny little shriveled yoda child that you're just like, I have no idea. So that was alarming. Um but you know, but we uh but then you just like figure it out, you know, there's some like instinct that clicks in, and but uh but yeah, the the the the and it was actually kind of interesting to have like a the social worker come and I was like, what is she, you know, we're like fluffing the pillows, and like you're like I was like, I don't know, like what you know, and you're just trying to be like present like that you're this uh upstanding or whatever, you know, good and air quotes person, you know, yeah, yeah, yeah.
But you have it all together and yeah, you're gonna be like, and then they she came again like when when Emily was uh I don't know, like six months or something, and again it was like just trying to be like, see, we're doing a good job, like you know, and it's but at the same time, just like grateful that especially in these certain in that circumstance that to have um uh I don't know to someone to sort of hold you accountable that you're doing a big job. I mean, I think there are a lot of parents out there who should have someone holding them accountable to you know, I mean that's it's funny that you talked about fluffing the pillows because I feel like motherhood is basically the messiest thing you could possibly do, but it but it somehow feels like if it if we present like we have it together, maybe we'll feel more like we do. But the truth is that I mean, I'd say 90% of the time I don't have it together.
[19:15] Sutton Foster: No, and I I know, and I we I know behind me is like three piles of laundry, and I just picked up, I just cleaned up. We have two dogs. I just uh you know, cleaned up, I was like, smells like pea, and of course, like one of the dogs had peed in the closet, and I'm like cleaning up pee. And it's like I can't quite like keep it all so so much of it is like embracing the chaos and embracing the mess and realizing you can only do so much, and like uh and the everything's you know, and and that's you like I feel like I like becoming a mom was like and trying to be a uh a working mother, which is uh it's like I felt like I was I felt like I was like uh I was never excelling at anything. I was just sort of I was just sort of like scraping by on um all the things that I was trying to keep afloat in my life, and um, and that was that's hard to like uh uh embrace.
[20:29] Sutton Foster: Um I had to go back to work, right? So Emily was born on March 5th in two when was she born? 17 and I had to go, I had to start filming on April 3rd. So she was four weeks old, and that was like crazy. And I was but there was like a weird lesson in all of it because we had to hire help like right away, and I was so like, I can't like oh, I have to like be in you have to do, I have to be in, you know, in control, and I we had to find someone to help, and then I had to let go of that, and that was actually one of the best things that we could have done is get help, and then I had to go back to work, and I was like so distracted at work, and I thought, oh sh shit, you know, it's gonna show and uh and it ended up in a weird way being like some of the best work I had done because I was like, I don't know, like half I was I wasn't as in my head because my half of my head was you know about the work because I was my life was fuller at home, or I don't I don't know.
It ended up like the balance we we feel like we have to hold tight to every little thing, and like oddly, the more you let go, like the more I let go of even like full control of motherhood and asking for help there made Emily happier and made home life better, and then at work I was I felt like I couldn't be as on top of my, you know, learning the scripts, but then I was more spontaneous, or uh it's it's this weird, you know, there's like this new recipe that not recipe or new um uh this new balance you find, but at some times it's debilitating, but you have to sort of lean into the chaos as opposed to fight it.
[22:26] Cara Cooper: Absolutely. I wish people could see how much Jessica and I were just nodding as we were talking about because you were talking about how when you become a mother, all of a sudden you feel like you're not good at anything, you're just like scraping by, and it's true, especially you know, coming from like being super career driven and having that as a focus, all of a sudden you're not you don't feel like you're succeeding in anything, even though you are it doesn't feel the same, and that's really hard to to adjust to, like you were saying.
[22:54] Sutton Foster: Yeah. Um I I don't I I'm a blown away to hear you talk about that you were struggling at work because certainly I like I said I've watched the whole series and I never I mean I couldn't pinpoint when you had a kid on it. Do you know what I mean? Or when that shift happened. So from an outsider they would never have known. How were the people on Younger supporting you through motherhood? What was that adjustment like? Because obviously you'd been on the show for quite some time before you became a mom.
[23:24] Sutton Foster: Well and what was so interesting too is that Emily was born I wasn't telling anybody because you know I wasn't pregnant and so I wasn't even telling anyone that I was pursuing adoption. It was like a secret because I was like what if it all falls apart or it doesn't happen or you know so I was trying to be super um zen about it all. So literally Emily was born and I like sent a tick a text to my cast and I was like um by the way um I'm now a mom you know and I'm like sending like and everyone's like what the you know but um you know everybody was amazing and I what's so great about Younger is that a lot of the cast have uh family you know uh Peter has three kids and um Debbie has two daughters Miriam has two daughters Hillary has had a son and now has a has a daughter and so there was like and like Hillary's uh son when we started filming was two and a half, and he's like now seven or eight, and um and it's so there there have been like kids around, it's a super like family uh you know, kid friendly, dog friendly set.
It's all very um uh very family, you know, welcoming environment. And a lot of like uh the cast is you we've people they've been around for a while, so but um people were awesome and incredibly supportive. And I I was able to bring Emily to set, you know, a lot of she's been because now she's been alive through three seasons. So she's she's like they've she's been she comes to set, she's she won't be able to come now when we film. Um, but she she came the the last three seasons, and uh so she knows mommy, you know, mommy mommy goes on set and she comes down to say hello to everybody and the crew is you know, they've all watched her like grow up. So it's um it's cool. It's like uh it's just a really the one thing I haven't done with her yet is I haven't done a show with her.
So I haven't done eight shows a week with having a kid. So that I'm a little bit like I don't know what that's gonna be like, like missing bedtime, and you know, but then again, I like I mean the world is so crazy right now. So who knows when theater, I don't know, you know, yeah we listen, we don't don't have to talk about that, but it's all just so sad, but like I'm so excited to introduce her to you know the magical world of theater um someday, but uh, you know, she she knows like that mommy sings and dances and she loves to sing, and um, I think she's a belter, so I'm very proud. She's very loud, it has great resonance. So I'm like very excited. Just wait till she discovers Gimme Gimme, you know, that's okay. Belting the whole out.
[26:41] Cara Cooper: Yeah.
[26:42] Sutton Foster: But um, but yeah, so but everybody was everybody's been like so supportive. And then last season, uh Hillary. Um trying to think, yeah, Hillary had come back after having her Banks and Banks was oh my gosh, like six months, or you know, she was a baby. And um, there's just a lot of the the set of Younger is like really support everyone's like super supportive of one another, so much respect, um, making taking care of one another, and it's like a really happy uh loving environment. So it's it's been and so many of us have gone through like I mean, I got married the first season, you know, had a baby, like so much has happened for all of us, and we've all just been like um I don't know, there for one another. So it's a really supportive, a supportive place.
[27:41] Jessica Rush: That's awesome.
[27:48] Jessica Rush: Thanks so much for listening to this episode of Mamas Talkin' Loud. Special shout outs to Rachel Spencer Hewitt for our fabulous graphic, Kristen Anderson Lopez, Bobby Lopez, and Justin Ward Weber for our awesome theme song. Our producers Dori Berinstein, Alan Seales, and of course the Broadway Podcast Network for bringing us to you. If you like what you're hearing and you want to keep the conversation going, you can follow us on Instagram and Facebook, and of course, subscribe and review us wherever you listen to your podcast. Thanks so much for tuning in.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
