Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Chris McCarrell (Broadway’s Lightning Thief) on Embracing the Unpolished

In this Artist Exploration, Charlie and Chris discuss: Strategically working towards artistic goals while in school. Finessing “flying by the seat of your pants” The differences when approaching roles like Marius and Percy Jackson... Read More

From the show: Mapping The College Audition: An MTCA Podcast

1 h 43 mins
3/22/23

Guests

Featured Shows

About

In this Artist Exploration, Charlie and Chris discuss:

  • Strategically working towards artistic goals while in school
  • Finessing “flying by the seat of your pants”
  • The differences when approaching roles like Marius and Percy Jackson
  • The secret juice behind Chris’ TikToks

If you would like to hear more from Chris, check him out in the following places:

If you have any questions about the college audition process, feel free to reach out at mailbag@mappingthecollegeaudition.com. If you’re interested in working with MTCA for help with your individualized preparation for your College Audition journey, please check us out at mtcollegeauditions.com, or on Instagram or Facebook.

Follow Us!

Instagram: @mappingthecollegeaudition

YouTube: @MTCA (Musical Theater College Auditions)

TikTok: @mtcollegeauditions

Charlie Murphy:@charmur7

Meghan Cordier:@meghanmarie2014

About MTCA:

Musical Theater College Auditions (MTCA) is the leader in coaching acting and musical theater students through the college audition process and beyond with superlative results. MTCA has assembled a roster of expert artist-educators who can guide students artistically, organizationally, strategically, and psychologically through the competitive college audition process. MTCA provides the tools, resources, and expertise along with a vast and strong support system. They train the unique individual, empowering the artist to bring their true, authentic self to their work. MTCA believes that by helping students reveal their potential it allows each school to connect with those who are truly right for their programs, which in turn guides each student toward their best college fit.

About Charlie Murphy:

Charlie is a proud graduate of Carnegie Mellon University’s BFA program. As an Actor he has performed with theaters such as: NY Public Theatre’s “Shakespeare in the Park”, The Pearl Theatre Company, Hudson Valley Shakespeare Festival, Chautauqua Theatre Company, Kinetic Theatre Company, and the Shakespeare Theatre of DC.

With MTCA [Musical Theater College Auditions -- mtca.nyc], he has been helping prospective theatre students through the college process for over 15 years. As a Teacher and Director, he is able to do a few of his favorite things in life: help students to find their authentic selves as artists, and then help them find their best fit for their collegiate journey. Through this podcast, he hopes to continue that work as well as help demystify this intricate process.

This episode was produced by Meghan Cordier and Charlie Murphy. Episode theme music is created by Will Reynolds.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:10] Charlie Murphy: Hello and welcome to Mapping the College Audition, a podcast where we explore the landscape of the college theater world and try to demystify this daunting audition process.

[0:19] Charlie Murphy: I'm your host, Charlie Murphy, Director of MTCA, that's Musical Theater College Auditions. And today we've got a past, present, and yet to come show lined up for you.

[0:30] Charlie Murphy: Chris McCarrell of Lightning Thief and TikTok Fame is on the pod today. We've met a few times in different social situations, but we got to hang out a few weeks back at Chicago Unifieds, and it was so fun to have him on the pod.

[0:45] Charlie Murphy: Speaking of so fun, MTCA just wrapped an amazing junior weekend, both live in person and online. It was exciting to see our family. Some of them were local, some of them really from abroad who made the trip, and of course those who participated online.

[1:01] Charlie Murphy: And the weekend got me so excited for our summer faculty masterclass week, which is August 1st through 6th this summer. You know, this weekend was really about preparation for the kind of work we'll be doing in those faculty classes.

[1:14] Charlie Murphy: We'll do this in our spring classes online, but especially for that summer, I got to see some of the community start to be built between the students, and it's just really reminiscent of what happens in the summer. We are back, baby. It's very exciting.

[1:27] Charlie Murphy: Um, so that will be 12 amazing classes, seeing a Broadway’s show together, doing a talk back, some Q&As with amazing Broadway’s actors. Um, we'll have all these exciting meetings like with some of our MTCA alumni. Very excited for that week.

[1:40] Charlie Murphy: Um, I know some of the parents really bonded this weekend and already were making plans for that week. So um, I will just say please plan ahead for that if you can, August 1st through 6th. Try to be here in New York City participating in that wonderful summer faculty masterclass week.

[1:54] Charlie Murphy: Um, in other exciting news, as many of you may have seen, um, if you happen to follow me on socials, um, Elizabeth and I were honored to be guests of our friend Sean Alan Krill, um, who's a future podcast guest, fear not, um, for the opening of Parade.

[2:10] Charlie Murphy: Uh, and it was just an incredible experience. Not to shill for a show, which may or may not be a BPN advertiser, but please run to see the show if you can. The music was incredible, but I was really blown away by the acting and the direction, as well as the adjustments they made to the show.

[2:25] Charlie Murphy: They clearly put care into updating the work and making it a bit more intersectional, and I think beautifully subtler than previous productions I've seen, which is a big feat in a story that I would not normally describe as a subtle story.

[2:38] Charlie Murphy: Um, and Sean was incredible. He plays Governor Slayton, who's sort of like a moral conscience of the South going through this moment, and he will tug your heartstrings, as of course will Ben and Michaela and the rest of the cast. Definitely worth the price of admission.

[2:52] Charlie Murphy: I'm especially excited for you to hear this episode with Chris, though we do have to give some apologies. We had some significant technical issues. You'll hear it's not gonna sound very different on your end. Chris's audio quality isn't quite as good as it should be.

[3:05] Charlie Murphy: You'll hear like a little couple moments of that. This is somehow due to complicated internet stuff. I don't fully understand. Um, but I have to give a huge shout out to the amazing Meghan Cordier, who did a yeoman's job stitching this all together so seamlessly.

[3:18] Charlie Murphy: I think occasionally you'll hear little cuts as she tries to fix timing because we are on two separate feeds and this kind of discrepancy and timing that comes with that. Um, but I think in general you're gonna find it a really smooth listen, which is an impressive job by her, and I think a really excellent episode.

[3:32] Charlie Murphy: I think you're really gonna enjoy um hearing Chris's perspective, and I think we'll be a really engaging conversation. And with that, let's get to the episode with Chris McCarrell.

[3:48] Charlie Murphy: Well, we are so excited to be joined by Chris McCarrell. Chris has a BM from Baldwin Wallace University. He's been on Broadway’s in shows like uh Le Miz, where he played Marius, uh opposite our MTCA coach Alex Fink.

[4:04] Charlie Murphy: Percy in The Lightning Thief, the Percy Jackson musical. That's too many Persies in one title. Written by former MTCA coach Rob Rokiki. My God, so many shout-outs here. Um, he's done regional shows like Bubble Boy, which your own podcast hosts helped develop Bubble Boy.

[4:18] Charlie Murphy: That's why we're pulling it from your bio. I was in the Carnegie Mellon, whatever development reading of this way back in the day. He's also been in TV and things like Peter Pan, the OA. Um, he's a well-known cabaret performer.

[4:27] Charlie Murphy: He's featured on the EP of Never Be King alongside the most recent podcast guest, Talia Saskower. What a small world. Um, and he runs a great TikTok where he gives lots of great tips on being an actor, a singer, auditioning, the college process, all kinds of great information.

[4:45] Charlie Murphy: He's also on the board of the Fund for College Auditions, TFCA, our sister organization. So we're so excited to chat about all that today and to officially welcome you to the pod. Chris, how are you doing?

[4:56] Chris McCarrell: I am good. What an intro. Wow, when you really list it out. I'm like, wow, that's getting longer than I thought. But I guess we make you sound fancy.

[5:03] Charlie Murphy: We do. We we jazz it up a bit if we need to, you know.

[5:08] Chris McCarrell: You just keep doing things by the time you're 32. You got like a whole whole thing.

[5:12] Chris McCarrell: I thought it might be fun to add one fake credit to everyone's bio and just see what they did.

[5:17] Chris McCarrell: I've been tempted to do that of just like one small, it wouldn't be like the most fancy credit, but it would just be like an add an off Broadway’s show and just see like, are they gonna call me out or are they just gonna let me let that live?

[5:26] Charlie Murphy: Just let it slide.

[5:28] Charlie Murphy: Um, Chris, I'm gonna start you off with our the question we asked all of our artist guests to start off, which is just you know, for our current students thinking about yourself at 16, 17, you know, if you remember what you were looking for in the college process, if you kind of remember as I began looking at schools and what I thought I was trying to get out of school, what I might eventually wanted to do.

[5:46] Charlie Murphy: What were you thinking about in that sort of like um your goals for your college list?

[5:51] Chris McCarrell: I just wanted I it I I was not very strategic. I wanted to just go to one of the top schools. My backup plan was to gap year, and I was so sick of any classes that didn't have to do with music theater that I just wanted an intense program that was good, that was you wake up and you fall asleep, and all you do all day is sing, dance, and act.

[6:16] Chris McCarrell: So I was like ready to just drop my education at high school, which I worked hard to like keep broadband. Like I took a lot of high-level classes knowing that it was gonna be done. That was it. Next was conservatory and then conservatory.

[6:34] Charlie Murphy: So that's what I did. And when you say top, for you, was it like it was really about the reputation? Like you cared about these five schools I've heard about. How did you determine that?

[6:42] Chris McCarrell: I mean, you're not that much younger than me, so if you know the internet would have existed for you at least somewhat, but it wouldn't have been like, you know, you wouldn't have had the same, you wouldn't have had TikTok, you wouldn't have had social media doing this yet. How were you determining which five, ten schools you thought of as as top of the top?

[6:56] Chris McCarrell: Um, it was kind of a different world back then. There was less, you know, less programs. It was kind of more clear cut, but to be honest, it was the it was the programs that had students that I actually thought were better than me or were good. You know what I mean?

[7:11] Charlie Murphy: And is that but like are you watching YouTube videos? Are you seeing actual shows?

[7:14] Chris McCarrell: How YouTube. And then my brother went to Baldwin's. I have like a really weird journey. My brother wasn't music theater major seven years ahead of me. So like I grew up going to Baldwin shows, hanging out with like the college kids after the show.

[7:34] Chris McCarrell: Um so like I had a really insider scoop of like what being a music theater major was like.

[7:41] Charlie Murphy: And did that mean did you feel like a a judgment of a Baldwin before you were starting of like, oh it's not what you know it's where my brother went so it's not to you what those you know where those other schools were?

[7:41] Chris McCarrell: I desperately tried to get away. I desperately I was like I want to get out of Cleveland. I don't want to go where my brother I don't want to be in my brother's footsteps and I tried my hardest and the universe just pushed me right back right back to it and I it's like truly like my home of where I fell in love with it.

[8:13] Charlie Murphy: And the universe being the schools just said no, right?

[8:16] Chris McCarrell: So you auditioned for about four or five of those schools or whatever you did and they said no.

[8:19] Chris McCarrell: Yes.

[8:20] Charlie Murphy: I got rejected from everywhere and I was devastated.

[8:23] Chris McCarrell: Unbelievable. Unbelievable and what were your parents like at the time? So were they supportive of I guess you're you want to do this but also then like what was that experience like of like oh I got all these no's and I guess I'll go to this school that's in my backyard.

[8:35] Chris McCarrell: I was headstrong. I like uh there wasn't a lot of like guessing on my part, you know I mean and it all has to do with my brother. Like I just knew what I was getting into.

[8:45] Chris McCarrell: I knew how treacherous New York was for him adapting to New York. So when I decided to do this, I was like, we're you know, I'm gonna frickin' make this work my way.

[8:56] Chris McCarrell: I was very clear with them, and my mom's a college counselor. She's like, what are your backups? What are your safeties? I'm like gap year. Gap year is my safety.

[9:02] Chris McCarrell: She's like, you can't just say that. And I'm like, yes, I can. I'm not gonna waste your money in majoring in advertising for a year to then try to go to a music theater school again.

[9:14] Chris McCarrell: But I was devastated. It was a really hard time.

[9:18] Charlie Murphy: But then you end up getting into and going to what many students now would think of as one of their top schools. When when we come now to um you know we don't have this is what our list of top but we see when our students bring in schools often you see like which of the schools that they're they come in with when they bring in six or seven schools.

[9:33] Charlie Murphy: Well Molly's very often on the list also our very first podcast guest was Vicky Buster to very first of college yes now. But so tell me about the experience.

[9:41] Chris McCarrell: So what was now this what might not have seemed like the dream for you at the time but then it turned out to be you said a home for you in a a a positive um it felt like I just I think I really wanted the experience of going in as a stranger and people being like wow and I just didn't have that.

[10:00] Chris McCarrell: And so the experience was because people already knew you like the people on campus like oh you're oh what's your brother's name?

[10:06] Chris McCarrell: Yeah Mitch Mitch McCarroll you're Mitch's brother it'd be like what's up oh it's Mitch's brother yes yes yes and Vicky was like I have been waiting for you to audition for the past seven years.

[10:15] Chris McCarrell: You know like so um and it was just a different time like um I remember going to BW, knowing the program well um knowing it was like cooking with gas.

[10:28] Chris McCarrell: It was right when it was like popping off. Um, but at I knew going into BW, I was like, there is not one male alumni whose career I want, which was like a huge kind of turning point for me because I was like, I have to drive this.

[10:43] Chris McCarrell: I can't Right. You have to be that male alumni that now people looking forward to carve my own path through this training, and I really used it rather than like just sitting on the conveyor belt being like, well, if I just do everything right, I'll pop out on the other side like Gavin Creel.

[11:01] Chris McCarrell: You know what I mean? Like it there was none of that. So I really had like a firm hand on the steering wheel and really like used the heck out of everything that program had to offer, which was so much, so much.

[11:16] Charlie Murphy: And from what from what I understand from having dove deep down the rabbit hole of your TikTok, which we'll get into uh certainly on the second half, you really have a a great deal of vocal expertise, and I would say more than I think many, you know, very strong musical theater performers.

[11:32] Charlie Murphy: Not every really strong singer necessarily has that much knowledge and expertise about their voice. Do you feel like that was because of maybe specifically the bachelor's of music at Baldwin's?

[11:42] Chris McCarrell: Is that is that where you feel like you were getting a lot of that, or is it more about continued training after? Where do you feel like you landed at that point where you go, I really know myself a couple things.

[11:50] Chris McCarrell: Definitely being around um, because we were like right next to you know, the violinists, the clarinetists, the piano virtuosos, just being around those brains.

[12:02] Chris McCarrell: It's a much more mathematical um kind of vibe going on, so we could really like nerd out um just about you know the science of music, and my teachers like really were just freaking nerds about the science of sound, not necessarily the science of singing.

[12:24] Charlie Murphy: I would say so so are you, right? I mean, it seems like you you sometimes I'm seeing some of it couched in kind of fun contemporary language, but you're giving me a lot of nerdery, even though you're like doing it sassy.

[12:34] Chris McCarrell: But I'm like, this is really complex vocal expertise that you're giving me, even though you're doing it.

[12:38] Chris McCarrell: Oh, totally. I mean, when I say like in high school, I was taking high-level classes. I was like a math physics, acoustic nerd, chemistry who just loved theater.

[12:52] Chris McCarrell: Like, I was not like history English at all. Like I've wanted to like figure out how everything freaking worked and why it worked.

[13:01] Charlie Murphy: You got all that vocal nerdery and and maybe uh um musical expertise. Is there anything that you feel like from the program? If you could now go back being a professional actor, is there anything you go, you know.

[13:11] Chris McCarrell: I wish this program had a little bit more of this. I wish I could add a little bit more into this program now.

[13:15] Chris McCarrell: I think this applies to pretty much I think every program. The biggest switch, and I think about this all the time.

[13:22] Chris McCarrell: In college and in high school, you're usually performing material you know really, really well. On in usually the higher pressure situation is the higher.

[13:34] Chris McCarrell: How can I say that? Now we're getting into physics. So E equals pressure, pressure times acceleration plus mass divided by the this is really getting into it.

[13:42] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, the higher pressure situation.

[13:43] Chris McCarrell: I'm with usually the higher the pressure of the situation, the more you prepare and know the material.

[13:51] Chris McCarrell: Then you get lobbed into New York, and you're literally going into Broadway’s auditions with some of the most important people in theater, and you got the music two days ago.

[14:02] Chris McCarrell: So I wish I'm still uncomfortable unless I have like weeks to like run it in the space with the people in front of me.

[14:10] Chris McCarrell: Um, I wish I built a muscle of being more comfortable flying by the seat of my pants on um material I barely know.

[14:20] Chris McCarrell: Because once I know the material.

[14:22] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, it's so interesting that it's a the way we choose to audition and find out how people get jobs, given that like that is such a rare skill set that you would need.

[14:31] Charlie Murphy: When do you need to perform? I mean, I guess maybe you're swinging in and during COVID, you have two days to practice go.

[14:36] Charlie Murphy: But for the most part, it's like you get a lot of time to practice, and we're not seeing your improv skills.

[14:41] Charlie Murphy: We're seeing your ability with the time and with the it's a weird thing that we choose to audition.

[14:46] Chris McCarrell: Yeah, it's just kind of like the devil that you gotta deal with, because like what's the other but I wish there was more awareness of just like this is a completely different skill set, and people who are great at this, you know, might give the exact same performance after a month of rehearsal, and then other people can craft like a masterpiece and can barely remember lyrics in an audition room. Uh but it and it's so stressful. It's just a consistent stress of your life of just barely knowing.

[15:13] Charlie Murphy: Well, talk to me about that those early days. Here we are, I guess a decade ago, given that you've named yourself and your age, my God. Um it's a decade ago, you've come out, you're you're not exactly Gavin Greel as you maybe thought you were gonna be, but you're gonna you're yourself, right? Uh what are those early, you know, you you're 22, 23. How are you hitting the pavement in New York City? How are you figuring it out? You know, you're gonna book Le Miz pretty soon in the grand scheme of things. How's all that happened for you?

[15:38] Chris McCarrell: It was it was absolute chaos. Um, you know, I just you keep saying it was a different time. It wasn't that long ago. I know, but it really has a lot has changed, especially with like people navigating the industry fresh out of college now. It's a completely just the amount of work happening. But I was auditioning literally every other day. Uh-huh. It was chaos. It's right when you're pressing. You booked an agent out of showcase and they're sending you out on stuff.

[16:06] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.

[16:07] Chris McCarrell: And I got a really great one. And he was like just gung-ho. You don't have to whisper it, Chris. You're like, I got a really, really great one. It's okay. It's fantastic. Well, I freaking love him. Ben Sands, and he was brand new at his agency at the time. So he brought me and Sierra in, and we were the two people he ever brought on to this new agency that he moved up to. So he was like basically managing us. Me and Sierra Renee. So literally every other day auditions, um, casting is trying to basically stress testing you to figure out your vibe.

[16:45] Chris McCarrell: So, you know, I'm going in for like jock rolls, like stuff that like now they're like, oh my god, Chris could not pull that off if he wanted to. Um, and it was insanity, and I tried to be like a grade A student, and I would prepare and I would sleep and I would walk in and I would just bomb it. And so I gave up. I literally gave up.

[17:06] Charlie Murphy: You gave up preparing, you mean?

[17:11] Chris McCarrell: I gave up trying to look polished. Uh-huh. Because I literally didn't have the time or the energy energy. Um, you know, I was like walking from having a monologue prepared to having four songs ready. It was just like chaos. So um it was really just like a chaotic controlled stumble of me trying not to embarrass myself, and I gave like I accidentally was myself because I didn't have any energy.

[17:44] Charlie Murphy: Right.

[17:44] Chris McCarrell: You stumbled into authenticity. I didn't have any energy to manipulate how I was seeming. You mean in and maybe some of those, especially those different roles where you're like, I'm gonna try to be a jock, and you're giving them something where like which I'm sure vocally you can give them that, but you're like, that's not really energetically who I am, so I'm putting on this fake thing, and then as you lose that, and actually you're Chris, we get to go, Oh, I see what to do with Chris, I see where you feel like.

[18:07] Chris McCarrell: Exactly. And I think if I if I only had one audition a week, I would have really like filtered my, you know, even how I walk in or like interacted with the team, you know what I mean? Uh so hard. We talked about with a couple different casting directors that, and it's hard, I think, from their end to truly to give that advice, but I do think it is it is such a tricky balance of like how much do I show the role you're asking me for, but it's also the first time you're meeting me, so I want to show you Charlie. But I do want to book this role, it'd be great to book the role. Like it's like finding that even though it's probably an outside shot, because this is a bit of a stretch for me.

[18:41] Chris McCarrell: That's a really tricky and I mean this is like a huge thing that is not really talked about that much, but also being gay, like there's a huge pressure that I think every gay guy in theater can relate to, where you kind of try to cover it up when you walk into the room if you're auditioning for a romantic lead. And I I got to the point where I even gave that up. I was not like trying to butch up Chris to be like, Oh, I can be Marious. And and theater, thank God, is ahead enough where the teams could actually see you as a person and be like, Yeah, that's Chris, but you should see his Marius, you know what I mean?

[19:26] Charlie Murphy: Totally.

[19:26] Chris McCarrell: And and maybe in in butching up yourself or butching up Marius, you actually would not be playing your best version of Marius, right? In some ways, like what Marius is such a there's a lot of a feat to him that works. And there's a lot of poetry and him being a kind of bro would be like, what? That doesn't kinda that doesn't work for this part. But even just yourself, it's like how you walk into rooms, you're very aware of like what you're giving off and like what secrets you're letting out about you as a human, let alone once you start acting, you know, what the character you made is.

[19:56] Charlie Murphy: Well, and it's such a skill set to let people in, especially to your point, E equals pressure times mass acceleration. You know, when you're feeling the stress, like it is really hard to walk in a room. You want to be seen well, but to be seen. And and any of those things that you do to say, I don't want them to see this part, you're just you put up a wall, and then it's just like I don't get to know Charlie as well. Because Charlie's not really here. Charlie's showing his representative, not Charlie showing.

[20:20] Chris McCarrell: Yeah.

[20:21] Charlie Murphy: Yeah. And like, yeah. What about so early on, were you doing any crazy were you waiting tables while you're doing all this? Were you doing or were you like, nope, I get to be an actor all the time uh for those early.

[20:30] Chris McCarrell: Short answer is no. Short answer is I came into the city with four thousand dollars and I never worked uh I got lameness within four months. Longer answer is is I like planned for that a little bit. So sophomore year, an agent was like, What are you doing this summer? And I was like, Summer stock, and he's like, Don't do that, come to the city and audition and I'll represent you for the summer. Uh and I was like, Oh, well, that's great experience. So I'll just do that. So I went and did that, and I auditioned, you know, two every other day for an entire summer. I didn't get one call back.

[21:12] Chris McCarrell: And no one was like, that's a vibe. Everyone was like, you are so loud. You have one color you're just like you kind of come in and you just like throw it to the walls. We already told you you're not good enough to get into Michigan. What are you doing? Or reject you're like I'm getting nothing but rejection.

[21:28] Charlie Murphy: Right, just rejection and I was like so I took like one workshop with um with the casting director and was just like do you have any other colors than just like vibrato belt loud? And I was like, oh my God, not really. I didn't the colors. I didn't know their colors would be needed. I thought I'd be saying textures. What? And so I went back to school being like, I need to step this up or I'm going to and meanwhile I have my brother who's seven years ahead who's waiting tables trying to make it work. I'm like I gotta really frickin' over nail this launch into the city. So I so it's not like I just stumbled in the city and was like oh my god like I just got Broadway’s immediately. Like this was a very strategic I trained the heck out of my last two years at school getting you know pop rock textures in my voice like really creating kind of my own curriculum with my voice teacher of like over like just putting extra gas in this tank and kind of redid my entire voice the last two years.

[22:34] Charlie Murphy: So well and I think some strategy to come even with four thousand dollars and coming with a plan maybe from having seen your brother like that's where I just i we often talk about how hard it is for people to land in New York City. You know, sometimes it takes you a full year to even figure out how to live and how to get a roommate and figure out, you know, all that kind of stuff. That it can be hard to be doing that while you're doing. Blessedly, you have this great agent and you're auditioning every other day, but doing all the life skill stuff while you do that is really tricky.

[23:00] Chris McCarrell: It's tough to wait tables and I don't know how I did it. What a world. Um, but so there you are, four months in you book lightning theme. This is terrible. Megan, we have to get some people who oh thank you. Book they mis. I was just gonna say, but uh um Talia also was our most recent guest, had uh she booked almost immediately out of school. So we have to have more people who struggle more because it's more common to struggle than to book right out of school. This is not the common path. I'm sorry, I'll bring in more tortured artists.

[23:24] Charlie Murphy: Thank you, please.

[23:24] Chris McCarrell: I keep I was like, Talia, when did it get bad? She was like, never, it's fantastic all the time. Godem, I was like, good, great, you got sick. Anyway, um really you once you got sick, you almost died, who kids. Um but no, you book lightning. I keep wanting to say that you book Lightning Theme Formts, which you did. You booked Le Miz and you ran that for a while, yeah. What was that experience now hitting the Broadway’s debut so early? A pretty big checkbox, I'm sure on the big list, um happening at 22.

[23:51] Chris McCarrell: It was oh frickin' frick. It's just ha it's hard. Oh my gosh. It's just everything you you wanted. It's literally just every I got a rehearsal process. People don't understand the difference between like, you know, being in an original cast, uh like the original revival cast, how different of a creative experience. The original revival cast. That's even a weird its own weird thing of like it's not the original, but I am reviving originally, not coming in. The fact that like I wasn't even just plugged into a Broadway’s show, but I got to like truly make my own track. I was also understudying a lead. I got to be in rehearsal with Tony winners and people I looked up to, uh, like, oh my god, every day I was just so lit up.

And that team knew the real me. They 'cause uh talk about the audition story online but I was a stumbling mess you know and you know running by the seat of my pants and I was definitely just giving Chris because I don't even I was blacking out for half of it so they knew me and they truly adored me so I didn't even have to put on a filter of like you know hyper professionality they were like yeah Chris just came out of school and so I just felt so supported and it was just a crazy creative environment um and then you know you perform on the Tonies you open the show the reviews come out and you go through the whole life cycle in the good and the bad when people start leaving the show doesn't feel like the show you made anymore when you were covering Mary's from the beginning and then took it over yes so yeah I was the OG Marriott's cover but on stage so I was one of the barricade boys um that can't be the name of your Barricade Boys that was your guy Jolie I was Jolie oh thank you yes Jolie I was like I am Choli and then a year in uh they were like we want you to come to finals to take over Marius and like by that time there was already some like buzz cooking like people were like coming in I like knew something was up like people were coming like directors were coming in when I would go on I was like something's cooking they're looking at me yeah and then I I was in finals, it was me and another dude.

[26:17] Chris McCarrell: And the shout out who who lost the part? Tell the tell us who no, I'm kidding. Well, they offered it uh it was it was Colton Ryan. It was two BW boys. It was the Colton Ryan literally just graduated from BW and was coming in hot. And it was me and him for Marius, and then he got offered my role, and then and then he became like a huge fricking, huge freaking star. Then he was under then he was the first cover for Ben Platt. Correct, right. No, but then so then tell us about that. So uh because I do think most people don't know. All right, so then when you take over, what kind of rehearsal do you get as Marius now, you know, in this new role?

[26:57] Chris McCarrell: And I was super fricking lucky. Um I came in with a new Epony, a new um Cosette, not a new Cosette. I think came later. Um basically it was a big cast turnover all at once. And Le Miz, they know how shows get stale. Uh-huh. So they know that like we gotta re-invigorate the show every time a huge cast change happens. So we basically had a rehearsal process, full blown, coming up with new blocking, um, working like just like chef's kiss, like other people and other producers literally just can't afford that. Like we've literally had the lighting designer come in and relight the show around our cast. Yes, that is unusual. Very unusual. Um, because Cameron's like, I don't I don't care money. The just make it make it alive. You care money, make it good. Make it alive. Uh so I was super super lucky with that. It was basically like reoriginating.

[28:01] Chris McCarrell: Right, you got to recreate the role. Yeah. Well, it's something like Elizabeth talked about that a lot in coming back to Jagged after the pandemic, that she and Heidi were so close they really spent so much time going, you know, talking. Here's what this is, and you know, she kind of watched Heidi struggle putting on her shoes on. And then when she came back on, she had to put her shoes back on that Heidi had changed, of course I know. So she's like, I'm now doing a show that where I'm like justifying choices that I originated that like it's really tricky of like 'cause Heidi had to make it her own. She had to make it work for her. And so then she's like, but how do I take it back? And now I kind of miss that the way I did it, you know, two years ago when stuff is really tricky.

[28:38] Chris McCarrell: It is very tricky. Like just roles being passed from down from people to people to people. And I think long running shows kind of understand like that really requires a lot more attention. It's like season two, season three. It needs a new it needs a new remote each time when when we get back. Well then let's talk about the what I keep trying to say, which is Lightning Thief. Um let's talk about you getting to originate a lead role on Broadway’s, which talk about a dream that is I mean that's like at the top of basically everyone's bucket list. When I say like what's next for you career wise so many people are like I wanna originate a role on Broadway’s and especially if it's a lead role, a titular role my God. Um what was that experience? How did that the casting happen and then what was the experience to actually get to to do that show?

[29:25] Chris McCarrell: Oh my gosh, this quad have this love like oh my god I could write a whole book. Um, okay so casting was this little weird weird show. Like I'm always like if Le Miz was a ship it was a freaking unsinkable like aircraft carrier. If and then Lightning Thief is literally like the sailboat that could. So I'm coming off this like aircraft carrier and I'm like, uh off Broadway’s show. Literally, it had a note in the audition being like actors will not have to um be part of the stage crew and put up and take down the set. I was like, what the heck is this talking about? And they're like, oh, theater works has tours sometimes where they have and I'm like, whatever. I like the music. I learned "Good Kid" in the shower the day of.

My roommate was so my roommate was also a music theater guy and was like, you literally learned that in the shower before you went. And I'm like, I know. So I went, I did it, and there's sometimes scripts and songs literally just resonate with your DNA so well. It's all so easy. Like it was the easiest thing to act. It was the easiest like comedy to figure out. The songs sat in my book. It was just like special.

[30:45] Charlie Murphy: Well, and I can say having seen you, I saw you opening night, and now getting to know you as a person. That integration was is very clear that happened in the show. I don't feel like, oh my god, you're so different then. You were like, nope, I feel like I'm meeting Percy, basically. It feels very similar. Like you are that person in the show, which is that's I think that I think of that as a great compliment to give someone, actually. That like it wasn't like who is this person that I spent two hours with, and who am I talking to now? Yeah, it was like, and I kind of knew that this was gonna be kind of the role that was just gonna be like my guts up there. Because I love roles that are so different than me that I go out there, and I'm like, this one, you just gotta make it as much what is frickin' different about you. Uh and I walked out and I got the phone call like 20 minutes after I walked out.

[31:33] Chris McCarrell: That you booked it. One audition booked it, done. Yeah. So by the time I got home, I was like, I got it. And my friend was like, you of course you freaking did. Of course you frickin'. Shower still. You learned it in the shower. You walk out, and then you come back and you say you got it. Like that's good vocal health, right? You're get you steaming as you sing. It's great. Everything is perfect. And I sang it in 4-4. I remember that. The song's in 3-4. It changes between 3-4 and 4-4. And I kept it in 4-4. Anyway, we laugh about that. Or exactly. The audio of me singing "Good Kid" and 4-4 and the piano player trying to like figure out what the heck to do with me. Um, and you get to originate this role.

So of course, this is you know, you're taking from off road to Broadway’s, but but this is now a you know, from an IP perspective, this exists in the world, right? Uh, you know, these are not books that I was familiar with, but I know they were like a huge deal, you know, if you were maybe a couple a little younger than me, maybe actually probably around your age. Were these books that you had read as a kid? Uh, how did you interact with like knowing there's movies, there's books, there's expectations from some fans coming to see the show that they're not gonna see Chris up there, they're gonna see their idea of Percy, who they read about when they were seven years old, or whatever that was. How does that if it weighs on you at all, how did that affect your performance or in the rehearsal room? Is that stuff that you guys talked about?

[32:50] Chris McCarrell: Uh, well, what's good is coming off of Les Mis and Marius and how I approached Marius. I was like, I'm doing it the same way. Like, I no, I had no relationship to the book. I read the first book, I was like, oh, this kid is me. And then I just went in how I always freaking go in. It's like my only job is to make sure this kid, this character makes sense. If you just make them make sense, you will have a fully developed, weird, idiosyncratic character. So I'm like, he's gotta feel like he has ADD. He's gotta feel like he has dyslexia. He's gotta feel like he's truly a loner at school. There's gotta be a reason teachers hate him. Like it there's so much to work with. Like, why would I ever watch a movie?

I'm like, I'm I got a plate full of stuff I'm problem solving. Why would I watch how someone else problem solved it? Um, so no, I put my blinders on and I just there's not one, and then I just go through and I'm like, every single frickin' detail, I don't let one thing slip where I don't make it make sense somehow in the character.

[34:07] Charlie Murphy: Uh-huh. And was there did there end up being a large Venn diagram overlap of people who were Percy Jackson fans and musical theater Percy the musical fans? Because it seems like there's both there's a cult following for both. I mean, people love the show. It's now being produced every high school in the damn country is doing Percy Jackson, right? So, like, but and people I think have a relationship with the musical separate from the book. Was there a big like stage door then overlap for you? Like, oh my god, I read that when I was five.

[34:35] Chris McCarrell: Huge. And we truly did not know. Like, to all of us, this was just a scrappy off-Broadway show. Like, when I got the show, it is if I knew then what I knew now, it was just this weird, weird off-Broadway show. And then opening night is when we were like, oh shoot, oh shoot. Like the people came and they came hard. Yeah, and it was I mean, three I have so many stories of people being like, Percy got me through middle school. Um, a lot of people's first time to a musical. Um, a lot of people that were terrified of a musical adaptation of a book they love and then realizing how musicals can actually like elevate or like give a new spin on something. So people started like respecting the art form.

They're like, oh my god, we thought you were just gonna butcher this and make it like a musical, but it's actually really creative and fun, and it feels exactly like the books. And we're like, yeah, musicals can be musicals have the ability to not butcher their source material. Like we can pull it off. Um so much overlap.

[35:50] Charlie Murphy: Like in and for like the other musical book you you did. I mean Les was first the book to somebody before it was. Very long book. Very, very long book. A very long book, which I didn't ask you if you read. I wouldn't want to try to trap you. Um well then what about how was the roller coaster then of oh my gosh, so off Broadway’s couldn't have expected any of what had happened, and then boom, a Broadway’s thing happened, and then a pretty quick closing, right? In terms of just the the journey of like, oh my god, way beyond my dreams, and then what was that experience of boom, and it's over that fast.

[36:22] Chris McCarrell: It was so quick. It was it was like a month run in like a what 250 seat theater. Um, but it started having like this like you know, cultural clout in a way, and so when we released the album, the sales were crazy, crazy. And we thought there was always talk of an off-Broadway transfer, open-ended, you know, like New World, um, or stage forty two. When we closed, we didn't think that was our closing. We thought we were moving in a week and then it fell through. Right. Because it is a little bit of a porous line. I mean, it's less of a good salary for the actors, but the line between a small Broadway’s house and some of those big standing off-Broadway places where you say they can run an open-ended, it's not that huge of a difference as an actor in terms of the experience of what you're doing.

[37:10] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, and just the idea of it being open-ended, because it just felt like the the problem was never ticket sales or people being interested in it. So it just felt like stupid that it wasn't being done anywhere. Um, and then they you know, your heart just gets, you know, hopes go up, hopes go down, and then they announce the tour. And I'm like, yeah, because the the people that this show needs to be seen by are, you know, the families that aren't organized enough to come to New York. The show isn't made for, you know, correct rich families coming, bringing their kids to New York for like a little family fun day. So we were going, it felt like it aligned with this heart of the show to take it on tour.

And I was like, I will do that. Because I was like, I'm not touring. I'm not just gonna go tour, but I'm like the Lightning Thief, I'll freaking tour that. Um again, it was always supposed to go to an off-Broadway open-ended run. Always, always, always, always. And then last second, they were like, we're going into the Longacre. And I was like, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. I did not make this character for the Broadway’s stage. Like, he's so kind of gay, he's crazy, he's so fri he's a big swing of a character. Uh-huh.

[38:42] Chris McCarrell: And they were like, we're going to Broadway’s with it. And I literally panicked. I was like, oh my God, oh my God, I don't know if I'm ready to like put this character up in front of everyone on Broadway’s. And I was like, should I, you know, should I make him more of just like a heart throb hero, you know? Should I make him more of like a just something more palatable to everyone? And then I remember being like, yo low, you only live once. We're going in exactly how we started this. And I guess I remember being terrified and just being like, reviews might shred me. I don't freaking care. I'm going in as lanky AHD kind of androgynous, young kid trying to save his mom. And looking back, that's like honestly the most the like little win of like that I'm most proud of is that I truly just like took a breath and dove hard into maintaining the scrappiness that we had building the show while it was on Broadway’s. Because it's terrifying. It's terrifying.

[39:50] Charlie Murphy: Well and it just highlights how little control we have as actors like you have control over that of what you want to bring in as to you know what I want to do with the character. But you know casting you have no control over and where the show goes or all the money behind it unless you are choosing to also produce the show as well. Like you just don't have that control. You don't get to say no I don't want to go with the Longacre. You don't have that option it's it's come with it or not. You that all you have is a yes or the no.

[40:13] Chris McCarrell: Yeah. And it was a you know, just a frickin' a frickin' dream. Like start to finish, truly like uh just a frickin' dream. I know that's boring to hear, but it really just creatively the the team, how how much I adored our producers, how much they tried to keep ticket prices down to make it more accessible, who the show was designed for. Like, it just really goes to show that Broadway’s and theater is not always this, like, you know, money hungry, disrespecting our actors, we're working under a thumb of some big producer. It's rarely that to be honest. But most Broadway’s producers are not doing that specifically to get rich. Of course, they tend to be money people, but if you choose to be a Broadway’s producer, it's normally some love that you've got for the art and not just like I want the money. No, it's like literally, what is it, sayomasochism? It's literally just like and sometimes for a little bit vanity for some of them if I want to, you know, have the project and all this thing.

[41:18] Charlie Murphy: But I think it's not boring at all to hear that it's a dream, because I do think we spend a lot of time trying to make sure people see the ups and downs of a career and see how hard it is. You know, see the because people have the dream of quote unquote Broadway’s, but it's also nice to know that the dream can be wonderful too. I mean, you know, some of that I'm like, obviously the good part's wonderful, but like it's worth sitting in that for a second and saying, when it hits and you get the thing that you want, it's can be amazing and and a positive experience, and not just, you know, oh god, it's so hard and the next one's hard, and then you still don't have another job, and you know, all that part of it.

[41:50] Chris McCarrell: Yeah. And I really engineered, I also like wanna it's I always try to be like I I'm not just stumbling into this or through this. Like this was all very kind of engineered. Like how I trained, how seeing my brother seven years ahead, how I was like, I don't want the careers of just you know bouncing from show to show. I trained exactly for what I wanted. And so then when a show got me and I excelled in the areas of like origination, going hard, taking big swings, being fearless, even under huge, highly visible situations. And then looking back and I'm like, that was exactly what I wanted. It's like kind of hard to like see where it started. You know, it really started like my freshman year of college.

[42:47] Charlie Murphy: Um, so I always like try to urge people to like be careful what you get good at because you might get hired to do it, you know. So it's like get good at what you truly want to do. And I'm so happy that my career so far has aligned with exactly what I intended to do with my talent.

[43:07] Chris McCarrell: There's something so beautiful about that word intention, you know. We're gonna shout, I'm gonna shout out Thomas Douglas, who was my voice teacher at Carnegie Mellon, um, who's gotten a lot of shout-outs on this podcast. I gotta send it to him now. Um, but he always used to say, like, when we did something really good, he would stop and go, wait, you did that on purpose, right? Because I think sometimes we would do things, we'd be like, oh guess it's on a good, whatever, right? And he really wanted us to line up like that was on purpose. Like be clear that that you did that, that really worked. You worked to make that happen. It wasn't just in in some ways, also he was making his own. It's not just your phenomenal talent, and that you are so special, and that you, you know, it's not this isn't something that happened to you, it's something that the work that you did to this point made that thing happen, right?

And that lining up kind of your intention with when the result then works to be able to own that and go, this was my intention. My intention was Percy Jackson, and it happened, and and to start that process of when you're training to go, it's as opposed to like I guess it could happen to me.

[44:01] Chris McCarrell: Right. Exactly. Yes.

[44:05] Chris McCarrell: This is but basically now I've a one and a half year old now. It's like, no, it's not because you're smart, it's because you tried hard. It's because you worked hard that you did. Like, what are we complimenting? What are we rewarding? Yeah, and it's very easy to like look at certain, you know, timelines and just be like, oh, that happened, you know. Um, but or or you're so talented, and therefore it's it it just happened to you as opposed to but you at the top of any field, the top of sports, top of art, you also worked hard. There's nobody who's just born with it and does no work. Like some people have to work harder, of course, and some people are born with maybe more God-given ability, but all the people who you look up to admire have some kind of work ethic, even if in your case it's only in the shower, but still um and sustainability.

I'm like, I I always push that too. Like, as much about it is working hard, it's also taking care of yourself and respecting yourself for sustainability. So it's like sometimes I prepare just three hours before an audition because that's all I can I all I got. And also that's a whole other combo, but yes. And then what about post-Percy Jackson? Was there uh like what were the conversations with representatives or what in terms of your next intention? Was there a big next step um in terms of how uh how Chris is gonna um try to move in the world? I mean, that you have now checked off a huge um bucket list thing, right? And then are you thinking about what is the next big public thing that I do?

Or how are you thinking about how do I move forward in this? Giving away my secrets. Um that's what you do on your TikTok. You give away all your secrets, I'll give away more. Come on. Um yeah, the the big thing, you know, I I feel like I showed that, you know, I can handle the creative process, I can handle originating, I can handle, you know, kind of holding a show through its life. Um so the ne the w we played the next uh Evan Hansen. I wanted to I wanted to work with like top tip top top talent, huge money originating, developing it in Chicago for a few months, bringing I wanted to I wanted it originating on a new hit. Not a whoops, this is this came from off Broadway’s to Broadway’s, but at least it's intended to Broadway’s.

Exactly. So like I wanted the creative process that Evan Hansen had and the success Evan Hansen had, but uh a new show, a new role that I could really be in the DNA of uh You're saying wanted is this no longer a want? Um I just th just with the pandemic, it's like we got all put on hold so no I'm just thinking about right when I left. I'm just saying, can we s re-spark? Can we re-spark at the fan the first time? Oh, it's sparked. This is what's coming next year. Let's just come on, why not? Yeah, it's hard to go adding some oxygen. We're slowly getting really back into the the hardcore ring. Um yeah, so that was always always the aim. And then there was also a big push for like we gotta get you on T V film, T V film, T V film.

Uh-huh. And I was always kinda blurry on that. I'm like, okay, maybe. And then during the pandemic, I was in LA for eight months of it. And on accident. But uh one of the biggest things that I learned from the pandemic is just how kind of uninterested artistically I am in TV and film. So I like kind of reaffirmed my clarity and my love for theater and like what is next. It's all sales. Yep. I mean, something we talk a lot about of if you if you were not clear on your intention, your your representatives will always push you toward TV. Yes. Let'll just be the natural gravity. It's just like there is more money, more realistic, sustainable money that's gonna happen for them on a Netflix show than there's gonna be on Broadway’s.

Even the top uh and Broadway’s pay. It's just not the the the same level that they can. It is such a different craft. I I giggled now when people, you know, these music theater schools are like you take one class in TV, and then every kid graduating is like I'm also very interested in pursuing TV and film. I'm like, it's a whole different craft. It's literally like complete like I took a peek into the mechanics of it and was like, oh, that is too much to figure out for me. So I'm staying in my link. I mean, not on like how you might feel if an LA actor was like, I guess let's try Broadway’s. Let's try it. And you're like, there's a lot of work I've been doing to get it. Yes. And how people just gloss on they're like, Oh, I know how to act.

Put me put me on Broadway’s. I'm like, good the frick luck. Good luck. Good the frick luck. Good frick luck. Let's use that as a toss to a break. We'll run an ad or two, and then we're gonna come back and chat about TikTok. This is what people have scrolled to this point in the episode. This is what they really want to hear. Um we'll do that on the back end of the break. All right, we are back from break with Chris McCarrell. We both have Coke Zeros in hand. This uh hopefully the ad that we just ran was not for Pepsi or something. Um but we're just doing our best here. But can we talk about TikTok? Because I will say, Chris, having despite having originated a lead role on Broadway’s, when all of our students saw you at Unified, and let's be honest, a shocking number of our parents too, they didn't say, Oh my god, that's Chris McCarrell from Lightning Thief.

They were like, That's Chris McCarrell from TikTok. Like all of them, like they were like, Oh my god, I follow him. Oh my god, like it was like you were the biggest celebrity, all because of TikTok. So I'm gonna ask, what inspired this from you? You know, maybe specifically TikTok, I want to get into some of the mechanisms of it, but also just like what inspired the impulse to share these granular and specific tips online. Because I'm gonna say, from my experience in scrolling and the little social media I've consumed, this is way less so self-promotional than most accounts I see, right? This is not like you mostly singing, and then oh, here's a tip or two, or here's a tip that leads me to my coaching.

It almost all is like me giving away the gold, giving away the juice, right? You could just watch the TikTok and learn something. So, what inspired that? I guess I'd love to hear uh about that. Um something happens. It was something happens when you get a little older, around 30, and all your friends experience it. We all experienced it together, where usually people start thinking about having kids, you know? It there's something uh where just being self-serving and being in the the rat race that is just helping yourself and trying to get ahead and playing the game and playing the game, the idea of recommitting to that for another decade just doesn't sound fun. It doesn't sound fun at all. So um my way was I was like, I'm gonna start like putting an eye on the next generation coming up and seeing what they need and like start supporting like the next generation because I think it's a responsibility if you've done well, um, if you've had kind of like the insider's scoop to see exactly what is needed, what is being utilized, um, to pass the baton on in a way.

Um, so but I would say that I think leads a lot of people to teaching. I'm thinking I totally agree with the impulse that you had, which many people have of going, I want to give back I want to give something back now, but often also I want some sustainability for myself economically, and so do I have this side business that also kind of works for me as a vocal coach or a teacher, or maybe I teach at a university, right? But what led to the TikTok of it all? What led to the I mean, give a give give it away? Um it all started. My friend gave me the idea. Um, because I found this TikTok and it was like, you should have no tension in your voice ever. And I was like, oh my god, shut uh and so I posted that video on Instagram, and then I listed every vocal technique that required tension and who what big singer uses it that we know, and I was basically breaking down how you need tension to sound modern.

And my friend was like, This isn't an Instagram story, this is a TikTok, this is a TikTok, and I was like, LOL, can you imagine? And so I just made a draft once of like a vocal tip, and I put it out, and the second one got like 50,000 hits. So I was like, then it just became easy. I was like, oh, if that gooped you, I got a whole ton of stuff. And so it just became this thing. And then I just followed the natural. I really came at it as like support, you know, and then I just followed where people needed it. People were like, Do you do coachings? You'd be a great teacher. So I just followed it. So I opened up some coachings. And then that happened. Um and then being at Pearl Studios like every Sunday and Saturday now.

Um, that's how I figured found out about the fund, which but all the all of the energy was just where am I needed within this next generation? Um to just help a little bit. It's treacherous. Uh other than the um coaching, which course you can monetize to some extent. Are you thinking about monetizing, or maybe have you already monetize the TikTok itself? Something one of our our former MTCA students who's now a big TikTok star has talked about successfully having monetized his TikTok, though it's that becomes its own thing. Is that something that you you are considering? Money's always hard because anything you put money on changes the vibe of it, of doing it, makes it less fun, makes it feel like a job, puts pressure on it when it's not going well, it feels like, oh my gosh, oh my gosh.

So I like I currently pay my rent through my coachings. Um, that I do in the city, so that's kind of my way to like monetize it. I don't even like that word, but just support myself. Uh just baseline support by giving away something of much more value than what it is. Um but no, I don't want to get into the game of like being trying to get millions of hits on my videos. And now you're gonna be using a belt box, and belt box will be giving you money or something like that. No, that's not happening. Right. I don't even want to get into that game. I have a very clear tag this episode March 8th, a couple months from now, we're just gonna check back in to see if it's a little bit more. There'll be a belt box on Chris's. Let's be honest.

When we see it, we'll be like, there it is. There's a fontus laws that are in the world. Like uh this post is sponsored by ibuprofen and no cough drops and a shot. This is by showers by me taking a shower. Um, what about so you you obviously your friend told you hey you should be going to TikTok. Were you then consuming TikTok yourself? Like, how did you because I think you seem from my very limited understanding of social media, but you seem to have really gotten the style, it may have been natural for you, of what TikTok is, even with like the literal technical, like these quick cut edits and jumps and like to me that's I've only seen that on TikTok or maybe now on Instagrams that are copying TikToks, but but like how did you figure out the mechanics of it for maybe some of our people who are like I'd want to create, but I don't kind of know how that would happen?

Yes, I yes. I was definitely on TikTok, and then I was so annoyed at all the content trying to give tips for music theater. I was like, you guys are so far off, I don't even know where to start. Um and then naturally, like my DNA, I was kind of set up for this. I've been waiting. Oh my gosh, I have been waiting for things to get a little more chaotic and messy, like for that to be in style. And so people want really hard-hitting information from people not just being a polished professional version of themselves, but just like really throwing down how they think and what they know. Um, so the actual style, the tone of it was so in my DNA. Um, and you really throw it to the wind. Because growing up, like social media, it was a very polished version of that was very likable, hireable, dateable.

And TikTok, I'm like, I'm never gonna be hired again. I'm never gonna date again, and I'm never gonna be liked again. You know, you gotta go in with just that, toss it to the wind. It truly feels like you're blowing up your entire reputation. I was worried about like my agents seeing it, I was worried about casting seeing it, I was worried about you know, other actors seeing it, and something coming out of the pandemic. I'm like, I got nothing to lose. So I just came in being like, this is all bullshit. Start thinking like this, start thinking like that. That's so infinita and annoying. I you just it's a very different game than what our parents were taught, and even what millennials were doing.

It's okay, how dare you? Don't throw the word millennials out there, like it's a bad thing. Unbelievable. Well, there's just a lack of professionality, yeah. It's but and it's it's something that's makes it such a hit for you. I mean, I my first experience is my first thought watching your TikTok videos, was oh my god, the camera angle you've chosen is like aggressively under the chin. And I don't know if that's just because like you are so skinny and so you can pull that off, but it felt like I was like, I kept I just not used to seeing that on like Instagram or whatever. Like you would have the uh you know, cup looking down on me, attractive angle of my face. I'm getting all like wobble from you.

It's all just whole gobble gobble under the neck, but it works it's like makes it feel more raw and truthful and like it's just like a person talking. They didn't set this up to make it be some you know beautiful video. There's something so cool about that. Yeah, I really don't think about it at all. Like I just care about what I'm saying. Everything else, and it's like it's literally because it takes less effort to like keep my phone below me. And I feel like if anyone saw me through my window with like my hand up, I would look like an uh the influencer. So I'm like, I don't want to look like an influencer, I just want to keep my phone like I'm reading the text, but I'm recording a video.

[58:51] Charlie Murphy: I don't know. There's something so cool about that, yeah. Um, but what about I I've noticed like tonally in the videos. I mean, there's such great information. Um, but it does seem like, and I don't know if this is a TikTok thing, you are giving an element of like fun certitude. You know, it's very fun, but but it's like sometimes it sounds like this is this. Do you ever feel like you're worried about like, you know, the the thing that I I would think is like, okay, but I have to equivocate this. I have to say, except for some singers, which this might not be true. Except for you, like there's no except for for you. You know, it seems like it's often, even as I heard you like reading the you know, tips you learn from Unified, so like this is all great information, but I have so many footnotes to be like, well, that's sometimes true, but in 2022 that would have been true, but actually, I wouldn't necessarily put it in that order.

You know, it's like, how do you there's a I guess a confidence or a bravery to put that out there and be like, yeah, some people are gonna be able to pick nits with me. Um, is that something you think about when you're doing it, especially vocally, where you're like, there's so much knowledge and people have different opinions, and you didn't say that perfectly?

[59:50] Chris McCarrell: Oh, I'm so aware of that. Um it really goes back to from listening to philosophers speak, like Alan Watts. He's like, You do know I talk in much bolder claims than what is real, but that's the only way to get your attention. That's the only way to like wake people up. If we get bogged down in, you know, thinking that you're gonna get sued if someone's like, Well, that actually didn't work for me. Like, it's you won't get anything out there, you won't be heard, you won't make an impact. And how I consume content is that's known. I know that. Like, that's right, right, you know. There's an in my opinion hanging around your neck always. Yeah, always, always, always, always. I think a lot of people consume information with that awareness as well.

And the people who don't, I'm like with the in my opinion, come on. Like, of course, like anytime people are like, well, I'm like, well, of course, of course, of course, of course. Um, but yes, of course. It's something I have been accused of personally so much by both my partner and my best friend, have often accused me of saying things as if they were factually true when they're not. And I always feel like I'm like, of course it's not factually true. I'm venturing an opinion. This couldn't be a fact, but that's like you have this low voice, and you're this giant guy. And so when you say, I I think it feels nice today, or whatever you're saying it like, it's like it is true. Nice is true. Um, it's something I've become so conscious of.

I've tried it now, like, well, actually, let me let me let's make it clear that this is I'm stating this opinion. Um, it was something something refreshing to see people just be like, yeah, this is obviously my opinion, and I'm saying it. I mean, a lot of people are doing it, it's kind of like the spirit of TikTok a little bit too. It's kind of like uh you can come for me if you want, but I'm saying this. Now I'm gonna be aware of that. But yes, you're right. It's great, it's great. It's it's just something I know. And I'm I'm really not a consumer of TikTok, so that's what part of me is maybe realizing, oh, this is what's making this successful on TikTok in a way that it just would never be said that way in a classroom.

[1:01:57] Charlie Murphy: Right. You know, because it's the tone is different, the media is different. Right. And it's also breaking down the fragility around this art form. Like, that's what I really came in swinging with too. I'm like, uh all the how I think about music theater is like painting. And it's like imagine like a painter being like, Well, be careful, you might get caught up a tunnel if you paint if you do pointalism too much. It's like, of course. If your wrists start hurting, stop. Can we get back to the painting? And like there's so much more to talk about if you throw away the fragility and polish that this art form has kind of created from the educational process and get back into like the dirtiness of it.

And you know, it's uh the that's boring. That's exciting, you know. Really I was like, I wanna be like the hungover painting teacher that has like paint in his eyebrows from the night before where he was manically painting at 3 a.m. I want to be that for my voice students.

[1:03:00] Chris McCarrell: Um well and it seems like you're trying to lead with it. I mean, this is from watching uh a number of videos, though I've not seen the whole oeuvre uh of the thing, but it seems like you're also trying to kind of break down like that all this knowledge only lives at certain institutions. There's only learnable in certain ways. I mean, I think that's something that sometimes people think if you didn't go to one of those institutions, and then when you do, you're like, no, it's just the same crap. I mean, there's you know, yes, they teach it well, and yes, there's it can be really nice to be somewhere for four years to study your craft, but it's not like the knowledge is some secret thing that you can only get while you're 19 years old at this school, right?

It's not it's not like there's a secret, you know, treasure chest that is only accessible at one of these universities. There's something cool about seeing it just there in your in your feet. It's not so much the not it's the attention, you know. That's what you really get from paying people in school. It's someone with a high taste level looking and caring about you. Getting better. That's like truly the thing that's like locked up. It's like people's attention at you. Um but there's not like some little PDF where if it got leaked, everyone would know what's up.

[1:04:11] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, then oh no, all the trade secrets. Yeah. It's something that's yeah, I often talk about that when our students are stressed about the amount of attention, maybe from their coaches, from their parents, you know, and then of course when they're about to go to school, is just like you're really gonna miss it. As soon as you get out of school, you really miss like somebody stares at me and cares about my improvement as much as I care about my improvement. It is that's a really special thing. Yeah, to have many smart people staring at you and really. And how do you how do you come in bold enough, confident enough, and secretly cocky enough to not use that as a crutch? Where if that was taken away, you would still be as bold and fearless as when you have all that attention around you.

[1:04:54] Chris McCarrell: Yep, totally. That's really important. Now, given this incredible success that you have had, which really, I mean, you have to think numerically, the success you've had on TikTok is shocking, right? In terms of like, not shocking that you could pull it off, but just in terms of the now millions of people, multiple millions of people have viewed your videos, which is like way more than saw the entire run of Lightning Thief. The entire run of lame is for the years you were doing it, right? Like, what is that? How do you reckon with that? Of like more people are seeing me in my three minutes under Chin Waddle than are seeing the fully prepped performance that I spent weeks rehearsing. Like, what does that feel like as an actor? Who obviously you trained for theater, not trained for you know three-minute TikToks.

[1:05:36] Chris McCarrell: Uh yes. I have no I have truly never been more famous in my life, which is such not something I really looked for. But I get stopped more on the street now than I ever have in my entire life. Uh which was never the point at all. But it's the way that people interact with me in person that I'm like, this is right. Cause like fans from seeing me on stage, there's kind of this like, you know, starry-eyed, like, oh my god, I love you. I love you. You were so good. You're like not human. There's kind of like this inhumanity. But people who come up to me, they have such this like warm, like thank you groundedness that it actually like really freaking lights me up. Like, kind of not the community that I'm building, but just the interaction uh feels much warmer and heartfelt that when I like see it face to face, like I'm like, this is exactly what I wanted to do. I wanted to help people like you. I wanted to at least be a voice, and they just freaking get it. Yeah.

[1:06:57] Charlie Murphy: Has it changed your consumption habits? Like now that you create, do you look differently at how you consume other people's work? Uh and I also made I mean both the consumption of other like TikToks, but also like how do you now consume your own numbers and analytics and like are there compare and despairs of like, oh my god, why did that or this person's video get two million? My god, a hundred thousand or you know, is there any of that in your consumption of TikTok?

[1:07:20] Chris McCarrell: No, I I find it really fascinating. And I'm not like, you know, I'm not like trying some people just it's like, you know, just bigger, bigger, bigger, bigger, bigger. I'm like, I'm I'm totally fine with well, bigger, bigger if you're trying to monetize it, right? If you're trying to say like I'm trying to become a professional TikTok and live off of this, then you need to grow, you know, in the Right, right, right. So like the strategy, you know, differs with how big you're trying to get. But what I find really fascinating is the type of information I put out versus how well it does is so telling. Cause I just think, oh, people really needed that. Like that was a hot spot that was needed. Um, and honestly, my more complex stuff that I actually feel like is really frickin' super, super valuable that no one will frickin' figure out and tell you does less well than just the stuff that I'm like, oh, this is basic. Like, stop stop starting words on vowels while you're singing.

[1:08:17] Charlie Murphy: And that was absolutely my observation. The stuff that I was like, oh, that's really interesting was the stuff that was least viewed. Like when I would look click through and be like, oh, this one's got a million views, millions. I'm like, okay, great, but most of that was like pretty basic. The stuff that I was like, that's really smart. That had like 30,000 views for it. I was like, what how's that fair?

[1:08:35] Chris McCarrell: Yeah. People don't want their vegetables, I guess. They want the the delicious dessert. So I find well, and it's also the demographic, you know, when you're in high school or middle school, it's like, uh, what are you freaking talking about? And like maybe the 10,000 people, that's all that were the 10,000 people in New York that needed them. So I'm like, great. Uh so I find that really interesting. But no, I'm not in the whole game of like, you know, there's such a culture right now of just like social media strategy optimization, bigger, bigger, bigger, bigger, bigger. This is literally like my outreach department. You know what I mean? I'm like, this is just in some ways, maybe helping you become more successful that you're not, because I think you can sniff those things so easily. Anytime we've gotten kind of marketing advice, I'm like, God, but it feels like marketing. Ugh.

[1:09:20] Charlie Murphy: It just feels gross and doesn't feel authentic and all that. Do you feel like uh did you have any big learnings from the experience of this what two years of doing this?

[1:09:28] Chris McCarrell: Something like that? Uh one year.

[1:09:29] Charlie Murphy: Only one year.

[1:09:30] Chris McCarrell: Not even a year.

[1:09:31] Charlie Murphy: Not even my God. Okay, so in this year of doing this, what have you learned? What what do you know now that you didn't know a year ago about the TikTok of it all?

[1:09:39] Chris McCarrell: Oh my gosh. I have so I wish I could make a tip on making TikToks.

[1:09:44] Charlie Murphy: Yes, this is what we want. We want this tip.

[1:09:46] Chris McCarrell: Because I'm in the city. But I'm like, that doesn't really go with like I don't I never want it to be too self-aware. But I really came at it. I'm like giving away my secrets. Secrets behind the secrets. But I really identify people's insecurities within the art form. And I secretly try to make that feel better. So I always like search for pain points in myself, in the industry, and then somehow give tips and advice that by the end you go, oh my gosh, that felt chaotic. He kind of s it kind of felt hard hitting. It I can't believe he's saying that, but secretly I feel better about something that I was insecure about. And I think that's really what makes my content travel further and also have cut, but people are like I love it. Like it feels warm even though you're yelling at me.

[1:10:42] Charlie Murphy: That's my experience absolutely you feel warm even though it's harsh.

[1:10:45] Chris McCarrell: There's a harshness to it. Because secretly the harshness is to make you feel better about an insecurity in a lot of them. Stop stop beating yourself up. Yeah wake up. And then also like uh and 'cause you'll know when you've hit a pain point or an insecurity and you didn't treat it with enough attention because the backlash is fragile and it's much more treacherous water than you think. Cause I've just talked about stuff and if you just miss the mark a little bit the backlash like you got a few comments and people are like eh. So you gotta be really freaking aware and like three steps ahead of like pain points because if people are insecure or angry about something and you just touch on it and just keep talking like it's not a big deal they're like you're so unaware of something that really affects my life. So I try to be really aware of like oh noted what is a pain point?

[1:11:40] Charlie Murphy: I mean if I don't know that word what or that that term but what do you mean as an example of a kind of um like writers or um like people in straight theater programs feel like music theater outshines their program. So if I talk about like how singing is singing requires more structure than a monologue, there's gonna be backlash of being like no straight acting's also hard. I'm like, of course straight acting is hard, but like it's like I missed a pain point. Does that make sense?

[1:12:16] Chris McCarrell: Totally makes sense.

[1:12:17] Charlie Murphy: Yep. You mean yeah, people's specific insecurities or their hangups.

[1:12:21] Chris McCarrell: Yeah. If you hit it, you're gonna Or a writer, actors keep changing my lines. So me talking about like you don't have to say every line perfectly. Writers are gonna zoom in and be like, uh, stop. You're like, this isn't for you, writers. Get off my TikTok.

[1:12:35] Chris McCarrell: Um, what about um I I know you're also we talk about in your bio the expertise with concerts is something that you've done a lot of. Um w what have you learned from that experience from putting on a solo show? It seems in some ways like a TikTok, just much longer, right? The same charisma and fun that's gotta happen in storytelling just now over the course of a of an hour or whatever. Um, what has that experience been?

[1:12:55] Chris McCarrell: Fricking fun. Like my solo shows, I really think of them I approach them like concerts, um, and I put a ton of priority on the the sound experience, you know, it's like meaning different styles, different different styles, and there's not a lot and sometimes there is a music theater section. Um, but like spending a ton like I get the best of the best when it comes to like arrangers, music directors, the band, like I find like the more of a musical experience that feels like the nightlife of New York musically, the more successful.

[1:13:34] Chris McCarrell: And then I, you know, string together a structure. But I've learned a lot from like, you know, I do my own thing and then I'll go to another show and I'm like, why is this not a party? Like no one's screaming. No one's and I'm like, oh I really do structure mine to be a party. And then people respond accordingly. But the biggest thing I it's like you have to get out of college recital. Oh my God, y'all. We gotta move past it. We could And that means what? That means like showing off myself vocally. Where the big mistake I would make if I'm trying to read you a college recital. Where I'm like aware of your types. Uh-huh. You know what I mean? Like I sing Lizzo and like Harry Styles at my concerts and like I'm like imagine if I just did like Pippin, Giants in the Sky da da I'm like, oh my God, this is not for teachers. Like who's your demographic basically? It's like your teacher should not be your demographic of your concert.

[1:14:32] Charlie Murphy: That's really smart.

[1:14:33] Chris McCarrell: I watched Elizabeth do this and she's been a lot of concert over the past couple years of like depending on yeah depending on who was throwing it basically the age group how much of what kind of pop is gonna be in the like it can't be too much modern pop if they're all over sixty. It's like what are they gonna want to hear and what are they gonna want to dance to what are they gonna want to go oh my god I love that. Yeah Joni Mitchell might fit in every show but some things don't you know because it's like this 20 year olds don't want to hear this or six year olds don't want to hear this. Yeah. But I've learned a yeah ton from it just what hits in that environment um and I would well and you know you hate the word monetize but of course this is another way that you know that TikTok could help help continue to sell sell those shows, right?

That like just in growing your God forbid brand or growing your awareness people's awareness of you. That is something that eventually, you know, we you can turn into. I know. Sustainable yeah concert especially if you don't want to do T V and film. Because it's hard if you don't want to. Yeah, there's so much freaking work. Um, let's get to our game.

[1:15:31] Charlie Murphy: And for our regular listeners, we're we have a rarity here. Normally, of course, I kind of host a game that our listeners have to now participate in, and I mean our listeners that our guest has to participate in, often me giving them trivia or various things. But our wonderful producer Megan has created a game for Chris and I to play against each other.

[1:15:51] Chris McCarrell: Yeah.

[1:15:51] Charlie Murphy: This is gonna go terribly for both of us. We're just setting this up. The expectations are low. Chris and I are both gonna struggle, but I'm gonna struggle more, almost certainly. So I pass this off to you, Megan, to lead the game.

[1:16:04] Meghan Cordier: The game. And Charlie is uh a little unsure about how we are playing this game, so it's even better.

[1:16:09] Chris McCarrell: He better believe it.

[1:16:10] Meghan Cordier: Completely in the dark.

[1:16:11] Chris McCarrell: In the dark.

[1:16:12] Meghan Cordier: I love it. I have a document on this that's attached to a document that I don't have access to. I keep wanting clicking it and going, can I see what will happen?

[1:16:19] Chris McCarrell: This is my favorite when I don't give you access to documents.

[1:16:23] Meghan Cordier: But I'm calling this game good kids at empty tables.

[1:16:27] Chris McCarrell: Oh god.

[1:16:28] Meghan Cordier: Oh, oh god. And we will be playing clips of a good kid and empty chairs at empty tables. And you will be tasked with naming who is singing.

[1:16:40] Chris McCarrell: Oh no.

[1:16:41] Meghan Cordier: Um, I will play the clip. If you have an idea, you can raise your hands because our listeners will play along at home because they can name these people. Um they may Charlie, stop pulling up examples of the show.

[1:16:54] Charlie Murphy: No, I literally was Googling alright. I was trying to cheat already. Megan caught me. I literally I just want to have enough.

[1:16:59] Chris McCarrell: I feel Charlie enough to know when he's like reading an email when I'm talking to him.

[1:17:04] Charlie Murphy: I don't even have a cheat. It was just trying to come up with like young musical theater performers. I'm just like, who's 22 to 26? Because I'm like, I'm worried. Like Jeremy Jordan is my most recent uh example. I'm like, I'm in trouble if they're young.

[1:17:15] Chris McCarrell: Charlie's losing.

[1:17:16] Charlie Murphy: Alright, I can't wait. I cannot wait. Here we go. This is gonna be embarrassing.

[1:17:20] Meghan Cordier: Great. Are we ready for our first person?

[1:17:23] Chris McCarrell: Schools in six years. And kicked down on every place. Everything I ever do is wrong. Everybody on my kid.

[1:17:34] Charlie Murphy: Okay, Charlie has his hand raised. Do you have a I'm gonna guess Colton Ryan? He's gotta be in this game somewhere, right?

[1:17:39] Meghan Cordier: I did look for him, but he is not unfortunately not one of the answers, so I'll I'll save you some grief.

[1:17:44] Charlie Murphy: Great. Okay, great. I'll give you the first clue. He's from your alma mater.

[1:17:48] Chris McCarrell: Oh god, that's embarrassing. Okay. Okay, can you play it again? And now I'm gonna lose it with this.

[1:17:58] Meghan Cordier: This is piano.

[1:17:58] Chris McCarrell: Oh, I know. I know, I know.

[1:18:01] Charlie Murphy: Yes, Chris.

[1:18:02] Chris McCarrell: Oh, cool. Oh, wait, darn it, darn it. Now I know because he started to say it. You go.

[1:18:06] Chris McCarrell: Corey Cott.

[1:18:08] Charlie Murphy: Dang it. Dang it. Dang it. He sang that before me. I remember looking that up to learn the song.

[1:18:14] Chris McCarrell: You had Corey Cott in the shower with you.

[1:18:16] Charlie Murphy: My God. In the shower. Before the shower, I was listening to Cory. I literally went to school with Corey. We played on the same intramural football team together.

[1:18:25] Chris McCarrell: Oh my gosh, of course.

[1:18:27] Charlie Murphy: Football at CMU. That was the only one I had a chance at getting, basically. That was my one I could have gotten.

[1:18:33] Chris McCarrell: Well, you may get this next one if you, you know, use your knowledge.

[1:18:44] Chris McCarrell: Dad was never in there. The only family that really mattered.

[1:18:49] Meghan Cordier: Well, she's answering.

[1:18:51] Chris McCarrell: Chris.

[1:18:52] Chris McCarrell: Sam Light.

[1:18:52] Charlie Murphy: Oh my god. And Friend of the Power. These are two I had a chance at. Megan, you gave me two I had a chance at, and I didn't.

[1:18:59] Meghan Cordier: It's okay.

[1:18:59] Chris McCarrell: I'm like, not many people have sung good kid, have they?

[1:19:03] Meghan Cordier: Well, we're about to see how many. And I I think I may have them all listed here. Suspense.

[1:19:09] Chris McCarrell: I've got a pre-guess loaded, don't worry. I've got it.

[1:19:14] Chris McCarrell: Colton Ryan.

[1:19:15] Charlie Murphy: No, Charlie.

[1:19:18] Chris McCarrell: Well, she vanished into the air. And now I'm finally fine. Solidly see where I can stay.

[1:19:27] Charlie Murphy: I like that.

[1:19:29] Chris McCarrell: We had back up this time.

[1:19:32] Charlie Murphy: Oh, so this is out of college. Maybe, maybe not.

[1:19:36] Chris McCarrell: I never went to her.

[1:19:38] Chris McCarrell: Or a Rob Rockiki and then.

[1:19:40] Charlie Murphy: Wait, is this Rob Rocky?

[1:19:42] Chris McCarrell: No, I was trying to do that.

[1:19:43] Charlie Murphy: Oh, that would have been great.

[1:19:45] Chris McCarrell: No, I didn't find Rob to do that. Rob has a beautiful voice, by the way. Everyone heard him sing. He's a gorgeous voice.

[1:19:49] Charlie Murphy: Oh, give us a clue. Can we get a clue?

[1:19:50] Meghan Cordier: Yes. Um, he is part of Team Under Study. We didn't have more than one. He part of Team, not necessarily a Percy, I should say. He's part of Team Under Study.

[1:20:00] Chris McCarrell: Oh.

[1:20:00] Charlie Murphy: And is he?

[1:20:01] Chris McCarrell: Yeah, it is. That's what Izzy sounds like singing good kid. I've only heard him do uh Grover stuff.

[1:20:08] Charlie Murphy: Oh my god, go off is the clip to get the full experience. I love that.

[1:20:16] Meghan Cordier: Our next person.

[1:20:19] Chris McCarrell: All I have to do is take the scale, I skipped on a good job. They all sound so good.

[1:20:29] Chris McCarrell: Yes, Chris.

[1:20:31] Chris McCarrell: Is that Mike from BW in my production?

[1:20:33] Meghan Cordier: Yes, you got it. That is lovely.

[1:20:36] Charlie Murphy: Chris just directed uh Lightning Thief last year at PW.

[1:20:40] Chris McCarrell: So or Playhouse Square. Yeah. And and the fastest one he knew, which is good. That's his generous director. He immediately knew his own tab.

[1:20:47] Chris McCarrell: I I heard that. I was like, ah, I know that. My God. Chris, you're destroying us at this game. You're doing great.

[1:20:51] Charlie Murphy: You said you were gonna do well. You did really well. Well, it's there's just not too many to pick for that. I've heard most of these in person. I'm gonna have more of a chance at empty chairs. I feel like I'm gonna have more of a chance there.

[1:21:01] Chris McCarrell: Yes. Do you have me in high school singing it? Uh Megan, is that on there when that begins?

[1:21:07] Meghan Cordier: Yes.

[1:21:07] Chris McCarrell: Oh my god, I'm gonna die.

[1:21:09] Charlie Murphy: Empty chairs. I'm embarrassed of like how much of uh I went into finding these videos. It's definitely not on YouTube. This is before video existed.

[1:21:18] Chris McCarrell: There was a video of you singing it. I would have found it, but I didn't.

[1:21:22] Charlie Murphy: It's a different type. My voice was changing. It was rough. Okay, who is this person?

[1:21:35] Chris McCarrell: Yes, Charlie.

[1:21:36] Charlie Murphy: I'm gonna guess Chris Peluso.

[1:21:38] Meghan Cordier: No.

[1:21:39] Charlie Murphy: Oh, come on. Not Chris Pelusa. I'm just trying to make a podcast connection of someone.

[1:21:43] Chris McCarrell: Oh, I know. I freaking know. Is it Jonas?

[1:21:47] Meghan Cordier: It is.

[1:21:47] Charlie Murphy: It's Nick Jonas.

[1:21:48] Chris McCarrell: Nick Jonas?

[1:21:51] Charlie Murphy: He's on a map in the college edition podcast. He's coming next season, guys. Oh god, he's our hundredth guest. Tune in.

[1:21:56] Chris McCarrell: He's our secret hundredth guest that we're uh we're we are plugging. A special guest.

[1:22:09] Charlie Murphy: Okay, Josh Group. Not this one. Okay. Sounds like Tony Awards. Okay, I'll get the skip ahead.

[1:22:23] Chris McCarrell: That is me. That's absolutely me.

[1:22:24] Charlie Murphy: Sounds like me.

[1:22:26] Chris McCarrell: It's me alright.

[1:22:27] Charlie Murphy: It's almost Andy, but not.

[1:22:34] Chris McCarrell: Okay, not getting guessing Andy.

[1:22:36] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.

[1:22:39] Chris McCarrell: Sure.

[1:22:40] Meghan Cordier: Yes, the hand is raised. The guess is Andy.

[1:22:42] Chris McCarrell: Andy.

[1:22:43] Meghan Cordier: It is.

[1:22:43] Chris McCarrell: It is.

[1:22:44] Charlie Murphy: Oh, come on. That's another one. I don't remember that low note.

[1:22:48] Chris McCarrell: Yeah, yeah.

[1:22:50] Charlie Murphy: That's why I thought it was me. It sounded like Mark. Maybe maybe on this Thursday evening when I read this. Maybe that's what it sounded like in the house.

[1:22:59] Chris McCarrell: Yes, Charlie.

[1:23:01] Chris McCarrell: I should have gotten this answer.

[1:23:04] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.

[1:23:05] Chris McCarrell: You grew with Alien. We did high school theater together back in the day.

[1:23:10] Charlie Murphy: Oh, I didn't.

[1:23:11] Chris McCarrell: I should have made that connection that he did it. Damn it.

[1:23:13] Charlie Murphy: Damn it.

[1:23:14] Chris McCarrell: Alright.

[1:23:15] Charlie Murphy: Alright. Focus on the for nine. I can go over nine.

[1:23:20] Chris McCarrell: Yes, it's it's not a good showing.

[1:23:26] Chris McCarrell: Oh my friends hunter.

[1:23:29] Charlie Murphy: Yes, Charlie.

[1:23:31] Charlie Murphy: Yes!

[1:23:31] Chris McCarrell: Yes!

[1:23:32] Charlie Murphy: I almost guessed myself.

[1:23:33] Chris McCarrell: I almost guessed myself.

[1:23:35] Charlie Murphy: Okay, this is our last one.

[1:23:45] Chris McCarrell: No.

[1:23:56] Charlie Murphy: The very one.

[1:24:01] Charlie Murphy: Yes, Charlie.

[1:24:02] Charlie Murphy: Kelly O'Hara?

[1:24:04] Meghan Cordier: No.

[1:24:06] Charlie Murphy: I love how scared you are together.

[1:24:10] Chris McCarrell: Is that a reasonable guess?

[1:24:12] Meghan Cordier: My clue for um this person is was she was in flower drum song with friend of the pod, Telly Leon.

[1:24:19] Chris McCarrell: Leia Salonga?

[1:24:20] Meghan Cordier: Yes.

[1:24:24] Chris McCarrell: How fun. I've never heard that.

[1:24:26] Charlie Murphy: Well, congratulations, Chris. You did significantly better than Charlie, but you did have a little bit of head start, you know, delving yourself into the material.

[1:24:34] Chris McCarrell: But you got all the ones I could have gotten.

[1:24:36] Charlie Murphy: You got all the people I knew. I I was I was definitely catering it somewhat towards your knowledge, but alas, you got it a little bit.

[1:24:45] Chris McCarrell: Alright, congratulations. Me Googling young musical theater performers did not end up helping. The fact that that is just pulled up is funny.

[1:24:53] Charlie Murphy: Um, Chris, this was fantastic. Thank you for playing this game with us. One thing I want to talk as we're wrapping up here, um, a little bit about TFCA. Um, wonderful fun for the college edition. So you mentioned through Pearl Studios magically, you got involved with Alan and TFCA. How did that happen? And then and tell me a little bit about your work um with them.

[1:25:10] Chris McCarrell: So I was in Pearl Studios because I coach there every Saturday and Sunday now, and I saw MTCA was on the freaking board. And now I'm like, oh my gosh. I I knew I never met any of y'all. I like met Ellen real quick once. But I was like, kind of, you know, I'm like, well, I'm like in this game, I'm more adjacent to that. I want to just go say hi and be like, you know, we're we're on we're doing similar things. And I see Amy Linden, who uh is from Cleveland and is one of the vocal tech. Is that what you call them? Vocal tech at uh MTCA, and so I was like, hey da da da and I'm like, yeah, I'm coaching now. And um, and I was like, how is Ellen doing because I was because I knew of Ellen Ellen was always just this like mysterious cool lady and I met her real quick once I was just gonna like say hi um and she's like well she actually works for the fund for college auditions and I'm like what is that and they're look she explained that it's Ellen's new like child uh it's a new not so new anymore it's been the runner for a couple years now but yeah uh nonprofit and the kids sweep every year and they're all underrepresented from low income backgrounds and I was like shut up that is number one so needed and so exciting to me and so I sprinted into Ellen's inbox and I was like oh my god oh my god oh my god tell me everything about the fund and we got on a zoom call and I had like I was like I want to be like boots on the ground helping like anyway and so I got we like kind of talked a little bit and I was given ideas and fundraising ideas and where I could see it going and da da da da we just kind of like started brainstorming about it together and she's like you need to be on the board and like we need you need to be like part of this so I'm now like a board member and me and Ellen are like brainstorming like where this nonprofit can go and just what it can accomplish and I freaking adore its mission and just how freaking successful it is.

It's just like so it's just so fun to be like this is so necessary to the point that it's like laughably just they just sweep when they come in. It's just so exciting. We're right now at the time of year where Alan texts us every time a TFCA student gets into school, and it's like, here's this, here's this, here's this, and some amazing, amazing results, which we won't really veal any of the public people and results yet, so they haven't made their choices yet. But um, there's some, you know, just talk about some of the schools that all said no to you. I mean, understandable. Um, are all are all they're just crash them to be pointing saying sweeping?

[1:28:12] Charlie Murphy: It's really exciting. And what do you think? What are the next as you brainstorm like where does it scale? And we had Ellen on, I think two years ago, to chat a little bit about where it had been and where it was going. But where what is the next sort of steps for the TFCA?

[1:28:26] Chris McCarrell: I think the next step is how do we use the organization to really make changes that affect everyone, not just our few scholars that we have every year. Um, and Ellen is just I can't think of anyone who has more of a knowledge of simple, easy changes that we could make to this process to make it more equitable and accessible uh to everyone, not just people reach out to us. Um I could I see it really getting into kind of like activism and uh um petitioning coalitions, you know, uh there's there's so much more structural change, getting more schools on board, being like, here's the issue. It costs $50 to apply to your school, plus uh whatever pre-screen, but times that by 20. Because that's what these kids are doing.

It's not just your school, it's times it at times everything you charge by 20, at least. And these kids at Amy Allen Finds are so extraordinary. But the whole point is like you shouldn't have to be so extraordinary. Like that like everybody should be able to train and study this if this is what they want to do, want to do, you know. Um it's like the old Chris Rock joke of like, I'm amazing, my place is amazing, like, and I'm like famous and so successful, my life is great, and the guy, my neighbor is a dentist. Like, to be to be extraordinary, you shouldn't have to be so extraordinary to get to um find that level of success. You should be able to just be a person who's has talent and wants to train and wants to get better and and then continue to be able to do that at the college level.

[1:30:00] Charlie Murphy: Yeah. Let's wrap with just you've given uh so much advice away on TikTok already, my God, some of it today. But um, if I had a young artist um that I'm working with, or maybe who's listening to this podcast who says, I want to be Chris McCarrell when I grow up. I want to be, and I want to go to Baldwin Wallace and have his wonderful successful career. What advice would you give to the young person? How how do they achieve being uh um a Chris McCarrell?

[1:30:24] Chris McCarrell: Oh my gosh. Um I would say the biggest thing to everyone. I mean, to everyone, everyone I know who comes into New York and really feels like they have instincts and really get stuff done. You have to swing through the frickin' ball with your training. Oh, see, this is because I said football. You're using a baseball analogy now. See, this is Chris's modulating, is using more sports now. I was thinking golf. Oh, okay. But swinging through the ball where we're using col sometimes people get so tripped up in just the game and the strategy of college that they think that that skill is the skill that is going to make you work later, and it's not. It's a whole different environment in New York. So I had my brother, you know, that I was looking at that was seven years ahead.

So I was preparing for that in using school to prepare for New York. Uh-huh. But that requires knowing New York. So that requires like, you know, maybe finding network, I don't know, but find boots on the ground in New York, explore their life, and then use your training to set you up for success in that environment. Um it's not gonna come from your teachers. It's not. This art form changes every single day. Everyone is guessing, everyone is sprinting to keep up to an art form that is just flying on. So y your instincts of how to prepare for that are going to outmatch your teachers. If that's scary to say, but it is, and you collaborate with teachers, um, but you gotta be you gotta be headstrong and have instincts and not a drop of fear, and you gotta truly love what a drop of fear.

I'm not allowed any fear. No, you're not you're not. I'm not gonna make it. Okay, no, that's not gonna work. I need a little bit of fear, but yes. See, I'm s I'm speaking in certain terms, not a tree to not a drop of fear. You knock the fear off the ball. No, it's not a good I feel I don't know. That's a great thing. Boy, it's a great piece of advice. I mean, I taught say to our students all the time of like school is not the end, it's the beginning. Like it's like you're doing all this stuff and your focus is for these nine months and a year, however long you're really training in this, you have to be focused on it. It's too big not to put some a significant percentage of your focus on it, but you need the bigger goal, do you need a bigger dream? Because the school is to train you to do the next thing, and then the dream expands and changes and you know, all those things.

[1:32:57] Chris McCarrell: That's great advice.

[1:32:57] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, and just I say it's great advice because I say it too. So that means in my opinion. In my opinion, it's great advice. And a lot of people just, you know, so one of the biggest, yeah. I could talk forever. But one of the biggest things is that so many kids quit within the first year of New York. They realize, like, oh, I was not, I didn't sign up for this. So it's like, know what you're signing up for, and then prepare to nail it. Ugh.

[1:33:24] Charlie Murphy: That's right. Hard. They all know what they're signing up for as a regular listener to this podcast, of course, Chris. But um it's really great advice. Um, if people want to check you out, of course, we've kept plugging your cr your TikTok, which is Chris M Z Carroll. Am I saying that right?

[1:33:30] Chris McCarrell: Chris M Z Carroll C-A-R-R-E-L-L on TikTok. I'm sure that's not they don't like search for you. I'm sure there's like a you just put your eyes in and somehow it just shows up on their feed because they've been listening to it. I'm sure there's a different way to do it. Oh, they could do that on Instagram too, right? And it's Chris Ms. Carroll. No one uh everyone that always goes over people's heads. Chris Ms. Carroll, like Christmas Carol. Oh, I did not catch that. I thought it was M Z like like it's uh instead of M Mr. So that was the first time. People think it's like because of like Ms. People like think it's like Ms. I'm like, no, it's because my name sounds like Christmas Carol.

[1:34:12] Charlie Murphy: Chris, in your defense, I've only realized recently, and I've been working with Charlie for five years that his email is charmer because he's you know a charmer, but it's also the the start of his first and last name.

[1:34:24] Chris McCarrell: Yes.

[1:34:26] Charlie Murphy: I had to say that out loud. I was like, I get it, because you're interested. We think too much about our screens.

[1:34:32] Chris McCarrell: We sure do.

[1:34:32] Charlie Murphy: But we also can find him on Instagram on Cameo, um, the link to TFCA if you want to donate, which all of you should do. We'd love to throw a couple bucks their way if possible. Please, please donate to the fund. Please. It's the biggest bang for your frickin' buck in this industry to actually support people who need it. Please donate to the fund. Please.

[1:34:53] Chris McCarrell: Thank you for your time today, man. It was such a pleasure.

[1:34:56] Charlie Murphy: It was so fun talking to you, Charlie.

[1:35:04] Chris McCarrell: Darn Tutin isn't Chris a Hooten. I really enjoy chatting with him and getting to know him better. I think he's such a kind and genuine person, which I come think comes through in his media, both podcast and social. Um, I am gonna do a takeaway, but before that, I just do want to do a re-shout out to the fund for college auditions. If you're someone who believes in more equity in this process and wants to help that along, a donation there is a great bang for your buck, as Chris did say. Uh Ellen does really remarkable stuff with her students, and we are so honored to help so many of them to their phenomenal success. So that link will be in the show notes to donate, or you can head directly to the fund for college editions.org if you like typing stuff out.

[1:35:48] Charlie Murphy: As far as a takeaway, I thought Chris brought up some really awesome stuff on authenticity within social media, but that is so far from my expertise that I will leave that one right where it is. Um, I did think it was worth expanding a bit about audition preparation in terms of how much time you spend as a professional on these fast turnaround auditions you get early in your career, and now most often these fast turnaround self tapes. I thought it was really interesting that Chris felt like he fell backward into success because he was so crazed that he stopped over preparing. And I would say it's likely not just how busy he was, but also the repeated reps of again and again that made him feel more comfortable in the room to be himself.

But either way, I think it's a really interesting balance for people to find. You hear that phrase over preparing a lot. And I just want to talk a little bit about that. To me, over-prepared is not normally about spending too much time, but about the way you spend your time. If you're working something with line readings, or Chris mentioned really trying to create a desired effect, this can make something feel polished or off-putting in sometimes. And if I'm putting on a show for you and showing you what I've done, like showing you my homework, this is what I would be, I am like this. Well, then I'm not genuinely interacting with the material in the room when you're lucky enough to be in the room, right?

But this same polish often happens from being underprepared too, as you try to learn the lines so quickly that you only memorize them with a certain emotional effect that you kind of imagine these lines are supposed to have, and then your lack of preparation is actually what creates the rigidity in your work.

[1:37:19] Charlie Murphy: I think I've told this story before. But one of my early auditions in the city, which was a new play at the public, and the casting director knew me, he'd cast me before. Um he really threw me a bone of an adjustment, which was to do the scene with a Pittsburgh dialect. I think he'd heard me do a Pittsburgh dialect before, and he was like throwing it to the director, like, oh, you're gonna love this. And the character originally had a southern dialect. So I thought that's gonna be a super easy change. I already learned the thing with the dialect. Here we go, I'm gonna switch Southern into Pittsburgh. I can do both these dialects. I just could not make the switch, which really confounded me. And unfortunately, I think underrepresented how flexible of an actor I actually am in the room.

This is a particular skill of mine. I am really flexible, I'm good at taking direction. But I believe, my theory at least, is this all came from me not preparing well. It wasn't actually that I was under or over prepared, but I'd crafted my performance, especially in my work on that dialect, so tightly, partially because I cared about that edition so much, I thought this was a really great play, and that was really a good opportunity, that I didn't find room for flexibility within my work. So those lines were grooved in tightly with that Southern dialect, and I couldn't pull them out of their grooves. So my big advice to young actors preparing is actually to focus more on how you prepare than just how much.

You will often hear actors talking about fear of overworking, working something too much. That's why they're gonna put their audition away for a bit, right? They'll often say that. But I think nine times out of ten, it is not actually too much tonnage of time, but rather too tightly gripped of a methodology of preparation. And certainly being underprepared is even riskier. Sometimes you'll have an amazing audition because you barely remember the words, and it feels so loose and improvitary and you feel great about all that, right? But the other edge of that sword can feel really bad. I mean, if they're watching you struggle with the lines, or you like take this path which leads to some really bad acting because you're trying to justify this weird choice that you tried to make because you didn't kind of read the scene or beat it out enough for yourself to know what was going on, that can be a really, really hard feeling when it's an edition you care about.

You heard a couple episodes ago that story about Jimmy Nicholas and that amazing casting director, I think it was Meg Simon, I think is who it was, um, who gave him that tough love about how underprepared he was, right? She looked at him as like, what am I supposed to do with this? Right, turned the camera off and was like, give him a little talking to you of Jimmy, this is inappropriate. You definitely don't want to fall into that trap of being underprepared.

[1:39:35] Charlie Murphy: And I'm gonna tag on a little bit of bonus sub-advice about preparation, especially when it comes to self-tapes and memorization. This is one of the most common mistakes I see young actors make, and older actors too. It's really hard, but a lot of people make this mistake. In the limited time of turnaround, the question of do I memorize this? Do I memorize most of this but look down for the one monologue section in this one sentence that's got tricky language, right? Do I use one of those apps where I can read off the teleprompter, or is that gonna make me look like I'm reading, right? I think everyone needs to find their balance and where they feel comfortable. I don't think there's one answer to this.

But my big advice of what to try to avoid is please try to avoid the stage where you're mostly but not completely memorized, if at all humanly possible. Either go all the way there, have it memorized, or just have the paper to glance at if you need it, or do use those apps or whatever you do in terms of a teleprompter. But so often actors are like close enough that they feel like they almost can put down the paper, but they're still just a little shaky on some of the sections. So either you'll get an awkward paraphrase, which often for TV and film can be a little bit awkward if it's like, oh, I messed up the technical mumbo jumbo jargon, which is half the point of this law and order audition, whatever it is, or I think worst of all, and this is maybe a personal pet peeve of mine, you'll do that like Joey Tribiani smell the fart acting, right?

It's where you take these long pauses and really try to, you know, act your way until you can figure out what the line is. I have seen so many talented actors ruin a pretty good self-tape with some intense justification for a pause where it doesn't make sense just because they needed the time to think of the line. If that's gonna be the case, I would rather you have the paper, look down and come back up again. And there's a whole long, we could go deep into maybe a different takeaway with long audition advice about you know what kinds of things should you really memorize for TV versus for theater versus how many pages it is, right? You're gonna hear all different kinds of advice, and there are certain auditions which really should be memorized, some auditions which is truly fine, and then it's hard to find exactly where that line is in between.

You'll hear different guidelines for different from different people. That's a whole other takeaway. But the big thing I'll say is just try, try, try to not be in that in between state, right? Be honest with yourself. If you're not off book, hold the paper. If you're off book, great, be really off book, right? But don't be caught in that no man's land where the whole take becomes about trying to remember the lines. That itself is not very interesting acting when I just watch an actor try to summon those lines from the ether.

[1:41:57] Charlie Murphy: Well, that's it. Another incredible episode of Mapping the College Audition, produced expertly by the great Meghan Cordier. If you want to follow us for more social content and try to catch the steam of our mystery guest, hundredth guest, then hit us up at Mapping the College Audition. Please give us a follow there. You can also give us a rating and review. You know, you can write us in reviews on your podcast and from a plan. You can also follow MTCA on all our socials. Follow me at Charmer7 if you want to see one of my five posts a year. I just posted of some pictures from our night of parade. And you can check out MTCA at MT College Edition for help with your individual college prep. To my young artists mapping their journeys, what are you doing with your showers? We'll see you next week.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred