Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Holiday Mailbag Episode

Check out our MTCA Events HERE! If you have any questions about the college audition process, feel free to reach out at mailbag@mappingthecollegeaudition.com... Read More

From the show: Mapping The College Audition: An MTCA Podcast

47 mins
12/25/24

Guests

Featured Shows

About

Check out our MTCA Events HERE!

If you have any questions about the college audition process, feel free to reach out at mailbag@mappingthecollegeaudition.com. If you’re interested in working with MTCA for help with your individualized preparation for your College Audition journey, please check us out at mtcollegeauditions.com, or on Instagram or Facebook.

Follow Us!

Instagram: @mappingthecollegeaudition

YouTube: @MTCA (Musical Theater College Auditions)

TikTok: @mtcollegeauditions

Charlie Murphy:@charmur7

About MTCA:

Musical Theater College Auditions (MTCA) is the leader in coaching acting and musical theater students through the college audition process and beyond with superlative results. MTCA has assembled a roster of expert artist-educators who can guide students artistically, organizationally, strategically, and psychologically through the competitive college audition process. MTCA provides the tools, resources, and expertise along with a vast and strong support system. They train the unique individual, empowering the artist to bring their true, authentic self to their work. MTCA believes that by helping students reveal their potential it allows each school to connect with those who are truly right for their programs, which in turn guides each student toward their best college fit.

About Charlie Murphy:

Charlie is a proud graduate of Carnegie Mellon University’s BFA program. As an Actor he has performed with theaters such as: NY Public Theatre’s “Shakespeare in the Park”, The Pearl Theatre Company, Hudson Valley Shakespeare Festival, Chautauqua Theatre Company, Kinetic Theatre Company, and the Shakespeare Theatre of DC.

With MTCA [Musical Theater College Auditions -- mtca.nyc], he has been helping prospective theatre students through the college process for over 15 years. As a Teacher and Director, he is able to do a few of his favorite things in life: help students to find their authentic selves as artists, and then help them find their best fit for their collegiate journey. Through this podcast, he hopes to continue that work as well as help demystify this intricate process.

This episode was produced by Kelly Prendergast. Episode theme music is created by Will Reynolds with Additional Vocals from Elizabeth Stanley

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Charlie Murphy: Hello, hello, and happy holidays, and welcome to Mapping the College Audition.

[0:05] Charlie Murphy: I'm Charlie Murphy, Director of MTCA.

[0:07] Charlie Murphy: That's Musical Theater College Auditions.

[0:09] Charlie Murphy: Check us out at MTCA.com.

[0:11] Charlie Murphy: And today we have a special Christmas Day episode for you as this drops on the very day of Christmas.

[0:18] Charlie Murphy: And also for my fellow members of the tribe, happy first day of Hanukkah.

[0:23] Charlie Murphy: My daughter has been learning about her culture recently at school and is very proud of all the different meanings of the word of heritages and cultures and stuff like that.

[0:31] Charlie Murphy: She's even insisting recently that Jesus is my culture.

[0:36] Charlie Murphy: She was saying that to my wife before we realized that she was actually trying to say that Jewish is my culture.

[0:41] Charlie Murphy: Which, you know, I think adults would find a potentially confusing mistake to make.

[0:45] Charlie Murphy: Uh, but there you have it.

[0:46] Charlie Murphy: Um, I hope you're all having wonderful holidays and enjoying some of that rest and relaxation.

[0:51] Charlie Murphy: We're always going on about.

[0:53] Charlie Murphy: Uh, today we thought we'd do a bit of a clip show looking back at some of our favorite moments of the year, as well as a promised bit of mailbag at the top, which we'll do right now, answering a few questions.

[1:04] Charlie Murphy: Um, I'm gonna try to keep this one relatively short.

[1:07] Charlie Murphy: Those are famous last words, I know, and then I'll pass it off to our awesome producer Kelly, who's put together this clip package.

[1:14] Charlie Murphy: You know, if you're someone out there who hates clip shows, and I feel you, I've been that person in my life.

[1:18] Charlie Murphy: Maybe you've already listened to every single episode in detail.

[1:21] Charlie Murphy: I totally understand.

[1:22] Charlie Murphy: Feel free to sign off after the mailbag section.

[1:25] Charlie Murphy: We'll be back next week with our regularly scheduled artist and college episodes and have some really fun ones coming up in the new year that we've already recorded, as well as some really exciting ones that are planned and that I'm crossing my fingers they come through in terms of some special guests.

[1:39] Charlie Murphy: So we're gonna keep on keeping on.

[1:40] Charlie Murphy: We're really excited to do it.

[1:41] Charlie Murphy: But okay, so just for the sake of your ears and what they're used to, I'm gonna toss it to our theme music, and we'll be back in a bit with a bit more of me answering some mailbag questions.

[2:03] Charlie Murphy: Okay, we are back with me answering a few mailbag questions.

[2:08] Charlie Murphy: Uh we got a number of great short ones through our Instagram and our email.

[2:11] Charlie Murphy: Uh and then I'm also gonna add in a few questions that came in during our Meet MTCA workshop that I didn't have a chance to answer.

[2:18] Charlie Murphy: We had a lot of great attendance at that last meet MTCA workshop and more questions than I could possibly answer in that short bit of time.

[2:24] Charlie Murphy: So especially at the end, there's like this long flood of questions.

[2:26] Charlie Murphy: I just took a screenshot, and so I have a bunch of those questions.

[2:29] Charlie Murphy: So if you're listening, you may finally get a question answered from that as well.

[2:33] Charlie Murphy: Um I'm I really got a number of different kinds of groups of questions.

[2:37] Charlie Murphy: So each question I'm gonna answer may be a little bit like three or four questions in once, though I'll pick one of the specific questions as well.

[2:43] Charlie Murphy: So that's why we'll do it.

[2:51] Charlie Murphy: Okay, so let's start off with one that we've gotten more and more versions of, especially as our listener base expands and we have younger and younger students.

[2:59] Charlie Murphy: So now we really have a lot of listeners who are freshmen, sophomores, even some in middle schools or the parents of such a student.

[3:05] Charlie Murphy: So I basically got 15 versions of what can I be doing now?

[3:09] Charlie Murphy: So I want to try to answer maybe the broader question of what can I be doing now.

[3:13] Charlie Murphy: And then to get more specific from an MTCA perspective, um, I'm gonna take Carson's question, which says, My sinus class of 2027, when should we schedule our first initial consultation?

[3:22] Charlie Murphy: So we get tons of different versions of that question, but that's one of them.

[3:24] Charlie Murphy: It's like, hey, when should we start with MTCA?

[3:27] Charlie Murphy: So I'd love to break this down into kind of two sections in terms of what you can be doing.

[3:32] Charlie Murphy: One before your junior year, and then what you can do as you kind of kick that junior year and your real process off.

[3:39] Charlie Murphy: And let's be clear, I'm using that as an arbitrary marker.

[3:42] Charlie Murphy: There's no magic to the start of junior year, but I know that's when a lot of our families do like to really kick off their college process in earnest, at least start thinking about it.

[3:49] Charlie Murphy: And if they're prepped in advance and able to do so, I think it's a real luxury to have that whole year of your junior year to actively prep and then be prepared to knock it out of the park start of senior year.

[3:59] Charlie Murphy: Because you know, by the time your senior year starts, you really the process is has to have already begun, likely, or you're gonna feel a little bit behind.

[4:05] Charlie Murphy: So you can determine exactly what that date is for you.

[4:08] Charlie Murphy: There's no magic to the date.

[4:09] Charlie Murphy: We have people who might kick off that start right at the end of their sophomore year, and so the summer of being a rising junior, great.

[4:15] Charlie Murphy: Some might start fall of their sophomore year, or some juniors might start in earnest around right now, you know, sort of January of their junior year as the year flips into March, whatever.

[4:23] Charlie Murphy: There's all of it can absolutely work.

[4:24] Charlie Murphy: But I think either way, it's helpful just to have a little bit of a jumping off point that says, hey, right now I'm starting in earnest, and this is becoming something else.

[4:32] Charlie Murphy: This training that I've been doing now is gonna have a focus that has an element of college prep to it.

[4:36] Charlie Murphy: So I like having some sort of line in the sand for myself there.

[4:39] Charlie Murphy: So then I would break it down into what you do before that time and then what you do after.

[4:43] Charlie Murphy: And of course, you could break it down much more.

[4:45] Charlie Murphy: You'll hear Leo break down the chapters of that after section many different times, and I'll do that in terms of timeline.

[4:50] Charlie Murphy: Check out the blog, we'll talk about that, right?

[4:52] Charlie Murphy: But to answer the question as broadly as I can in the QA format, I want to talk about that period, you know, the before section of the line, which is that it should be about two big things, two big things I would suggest in that before section.

[5:04] Charlie Murphy: One is foundational skill-based work, and then the other would be like a rigorous self-exploration.

[5:10] Charlie Murphy: So I'll say that again.

[5:11] Charlie Murphy: One foundational skill-based work, and the second is rigorous self-exploration.

[5:16] Charlie Murphy: That's everything you can be doing before it turns real, before you start doing the sort of specific strategic, psychological, all this kind of stuff that we talk about in the college prep process.

[5:24] Charlie Murphy: So, to the best of your ability, when I talk about those are pretty advanced thoughts when you're talking about a 15, 16 year old, some of you will be 14, 15 as you're answering this question.

[5:32] Charlie Murphy: But as best as you can do foundational skill-based work and then that rigorous self-exploration.

[5:36] Charlie Murphy: So for the foundational work, it should be about increasing your skill level.

[5:41] Charlie Murphy: So often this means, hey, diving into dance class, or if you can find a really excellent voice teacher, working with a voice teacher who can help you navigate your changing and/or change voice.

[5:50] Charlie Murphy: I think that's really helpful.

[5:52] Charlie Murphy: Often, this is some of the first work that people will do with MTCA if you really start early.

[5:56] Charlie Murphy: If you meet us freshman year, right?

[5:58] Charlie Murphy: Or you know, if maybe you know that you need high-level vocal instruction, this can really help you lay the foundation for that at the college level.

[6:05] Charlie Murphy: You know, this is where it's really important to make sure that you have someone who is really good, especially when we talk about vocal technique teachers.

[6:12] Charlie Murphy: There's that phrase that like practice doesn't make perfect, perfect practice does.

[6:16] Charlie Murphy: And of course, we don't really like the phrase perfect.

[6:18] Charlie Murphy: So make your adjustments to that phrase how it should bring in your ears, whether it's about expert practice or intentional practice, whatever you prefer.

[6:24] Charlie Murphy: But basically, you don't want to just groove in singing the exact same way that you've been singing since you were eight years old.

[6:30] Charlie Murphy: And if you've been having that same voice teacher since you're eight and you're just doing the same thing again and again, it can potentially not be helpful and maybe even a little harmful.

[6:37] Charlie Murphy: Of course, uh, we're just gonna say this could be the exception to this rule could be your specific voice teacher who may be incredible and absolutely know what they're doing and able to navigate that changing voice.

[6:47] Charlie Murphy: We really do see all kinds, right?

[6:48] Charlie Murphy: There's some amazing voice teachers out there.

[6:50] Charlie Murphy: But it is definitely not uncommon that students come to us with more to unlearn in terms of navigating their adult instrument because they maybe picked up some bad habits along the way.

[6:59] Charlie Murphy: And then I think when you talk about foundational skills, that can go beyond singing and dance.

[7:02] Charlie Murphy: Those are two obvious ones that a lot of people go, I know I need help really navigating my voice.

[7:06] Charlie Murphy: I know I really need more foundational dance, but as it pertains to your interest, it can really broaden beyond that, right?

[7:11] Charlie Murphy: Do you want to take an instrument?

[7:13] Charlie Murphy: Is that something that could be a foundational skill that you add to your bag?

[7:16] Charlie Murphy: Really cool.

[7:16] Charlie Murphy: That could be great, both for your ability as a musician and also could absolutely be something that adds to your versatility as a performer.

[7:23] Charlie Murphy: Just to have basic piano skills, to have guitar skills, that kind of thing, that could absolutely come in handy for you in your career.

[7:29] Charlie Murphy: You know, I often have used the example that Elizabeth could play the tuba.

[7:32] Charlie Murphy: That certainly helped her book her Broadway debut in company when her character had to play it on stage.

[7:36] Charlie Murphy: How many people do you know that can act and sing and play the tuba, right?

[7:39] Charlie Murphy: That does put you in a small class of people.

[7:42] Charlie Murphy: And anything like that, which increases your versatility, that can really go beyond the directly artistic.

[7:47] Charlie Murphy: It could be about gaining expertise in some non-artistic, like a high-level academic pursuit, which also would certainly help with the college aspect of things if you have any of those high-level academic pursuits, or playing high-level sports could help too, right?

[8:00] Charlie Murphy: Those can definitely pay dividends specifically in college admissions, but it also could be about like fun hobbies that are unique to you.

[8:06] Charlie Murphy: You know, we've had students do all sorts of fun, interesting hobbies at a high level, which then end up being surprisingly relevant in audition rooms.

[8:14] Charlie Murphy: They show up in your wild cards.

[8:15] Charlie Murphy: Who knows where you're gonna, it's gonna end up being like, Yes, I'm so glad I had that, you know, kind of odd hobby.

[8:20] Charlie Murphy: And of course, you wouldn't pursue these things just to have an interesting wild card, right?

[8:24] Charlie Murphy: It would because they're genuinely interesting to you, but you're still adding additional foundational skills to yourself, right?

[8:29] Charlie Murphy: They can absolutely come back in surprising ways throughout your career.

[8:32] Charlie Murphy: So that's all stuff you can be doing that freshman and sophomore year.

[8:35] Charlie Murphy: And then hand in hand with this idea of laying foundation and increasing your flexibility and your versatility, I think is a kind of a call and response question and answer with who you are and what you want.

[8:47] Charlie Murphy: That's what I mean by that rigorous self-exploration.

[8:50] Charlie Murphy: I spend a lot of time in the takeaways of this pod talking about what some of those questions might be when you're talking about schools, you know, from the amount of academics you might want in a school, whether that's a BFA or BM, whether it's a BA, etc., to what part of the artistic world you might want to focus on, whether that's one of the three main aspects of musical theater, or exploring some of those other hyphens like directing or writing or that kind of thing, right?

[9:12] Charlie Murphy: As I often say, starting to form answers to these questions will be both helpful for you in determining what kind of net you're casting over the school list itself, but it will also be so helpful in the actual audition and interview process.

[9:24] Charlie Murphy: For you to know what you want and how that does or doesn't fit with their certain schools, that'll make you a more confident and attractive interviewee for those schools.

[9:32] Charlie Murphy: And I'm always careful to say that it's not about you don't have to have all the answers.

[9:36] Charlie Murphy: You don't need to have it all tied in a bow by 17 or 18 years old, but to be living and present with those questions and have thought about it, have an awareness of what you know and what you're staying curious to is a really great place to be as you go through your audition journey.

[9:50] Charlie Murphy: And then, this is all in that first phase, again, the sort of pre-this is become real junior year, whenever that's happening phase.

[9:57] Charlie Murphy: You know, and in this one, I'm not gonna go all the way through the senior year in terms of timeline.

[10:01] Charlie Murphy: We do talk about that specifically in these shows.

[10:03] Charlie Murphy: And again, I invite you to check out my blog post on the subject if you want a little bit more of a written out timeline of what do you do after the it's become real phase.

[10:10] Charlie Murphy: But the one thing I would say as you flip over into this phase of, hey, I'm really doing that, is that it is a real gift to yourself if you can do that with enough time that you can really be doing this, that it can be real, but not have the pressure of this is the final draft.

[10:26] Charlie Murphy: So, in terms of the timing of where you draw that line, I wouldn't draw it with just enough time to make it all happen for yourself, right?

[10:32] Charlie Murphy: Meaning if you start at the top of your junior year with picking material, again, that's just an example at the top of your junior year.

[10:38] Charlie Murphy: You have the luxury of trying on some pieces that you think are a great fit, exploring them in classroom scenarios, and seeing what that experience is ultimately like.

[10:47] Charlie Murphy: So you may discover you love a piece, but as you work on it and you work on it, it almost feels like it's it's solved or it almost feels like it gets stuck.

[10:54] Charlie Murphy: Whereas another piece, you might discover there feels like an almost endless amount of options to explore.

[10:58] Charlie Murphy: That might mean that first piece ends up being put in your back pocket where the second one stays as a leading piece for you, right?

[11:04] Charlie Murphy: That's such a great artistic way to go through this process to build your book of things that are that are for real, meaning you've started counting them, but they don't have the pressure of having to be the one, right?

[11:14] Charlie Murphy: So that those answers can kind of float to the top organically as you go through the artistic process.

[11:18] Charlie Murphy: Sometimes students grow in their work over the course of six months to the point that they genuinely outgrow a piece and that one that was appropriate for you six months ago is no longer appropriate.

[11:27] Charlie Murphy: You know, the same way that you might outgrow some clothing, right?

[11:29] Charlie Murphy: And it's so exciting to then go back and pick another piece for this different, more mature actor in front of us, right?

[11:35] Charlie Murphy: And so that that almost then makes it like three processes.

[11:38] Charlie Murphy: You have the like foundational self-exploration part part of it, you have the it counts, but it doesn't really count yet section, and then you have the it really really counts as we kind of get into pre-screed section.

[11:47] Charlie Murphy: And again, there's no one way to break it down. You could break it down 15 different ways, three different ways, two different ways, however you want to break down those sections. You know, you'll notice one thing I didn't go deep on in foundational skills was talking about acting classes. You know, if you have a great acting class in your year that you can get into, I'm all for it, go for it. I don't think it's a bad thing or that you're gonna learn unlearnable bad habits or anything like that we're talking about with the vocal tech where there could be some habits you have to unlearn. It's not so much about that. But I will say that to me, acting more so than singing or dancing, it strikes me as something that a student can learn in a relatively short amount of time in this process, and often do learn directly with our coaches through their work on the material.

You know, we most and often are the first high-level acting training and often the only high-level acting training that someone's had, right? They may have had a high school theater class, but they won't have had like a higher, more kind of college-level acting training. And I'll just say, from an acting perspective, that has not been a problem in a way that depending on the timing when we meet you, some foundational aspects of dance technique and singing technique, it would have been helpful to have a longer period of time to do some muscular work. So again, depending when we meet you, we might have gone, oh, I wish I could have gotten you a dance class a year ago, to just be a little stronger with some of the stuff.

But I often don't find that true. If I have six months with an actor, I'm not like, man, I wish I had three years with this actor to sort of lay that foundational acting technique. And with that, I think with voice and dance, it can be a little bit more that way. You know, it is all learnable in a short period of time, and it's all nice to have a long period of time across the board. But I think I would think of those slightly differently in the way, the amount of time that I might need to lay some of that foundation. So, and then to address Carson's question specifically about when you might meet MTCA. In general, if you're in high school, we always feel like the sooner the better. We want to meet you, right?

The earlier we meet you, the more that conversation and game plan will be about how you do set up those foundational skills, as well as that self-explanation process, as well as the planning and organizing your roadmap for your school list and organizational parts of the process. But it also then does allow us to supply anything that you may be missing from a foundational perspective. If you need help with voice, if you need hands with help with dance class, etc. Even if then, if you meet us pretty young, your coaching itself might not begin in earnest in a uh as regular a fashion as it would if you meet us a little bit longer. So you might have a little time before you make that flip and you go, now I am meeting on a really regular basis with all of my individual coaches, because that first year, depending when you meet us, maybe the first year and a half, two years, could be more about foundational work and monitoring, as opposed to us going super deep on a weekly lesson with you, picking monologues or that kind of thing. Okay, there we go. 10 minutes in, that's one question answered.

[14:15] Charlie Murphy: Yes. But actually, that was like six different questions from a bunch of different people that I put together. So I'm counting that as six answers. We have six questions answered. Okay. Uh the next question I have here is from Lila saying, What can someone take away from the master classes and workshops that MTCA offers? So, what can someone take away from master classes and workshops? We also had a few different versions of this question, including another question about whether you should take them before your senior year. So, again, it gets a little bit back down into that the question before what can I be doing as a junior and a sophomore, right? I really love that question. And it comes uh to a few other questions that people also had about budget.

So I'm gonna try to weave these three answers in together as best as I possibly uh can. Some people ask about budgeting for summer programs or budgeting uh for other things, which I'm gonna try to put all that into the pot and see what we can uh come up with here. You know, I'll say that I really liked some of you might have heard Mitch Zoll's episode. I really like the way that Mitch talked on his episode about his son trying to understand what the gain of each event and workshop might be as this question gets to. Of course, it is impossible to know exactly what you'll gain from any given event before you do it. There are no guarantees in art that attending this class will make a piece grow 18% or anything like that, right?

However, we do try to help our MTCA students try to understand the why between different events so that they can budget appropriately, as well as kind of the order of importance we think for our budget conscious family. So, and this answer is gonna be a little bit more maybe toward our MTCA students or people who are who are seriously considering MTCA because I'm gonna talk about MTCA specific events uh in some detail here. So, when it comes to MCCA, the first and foremost, most important then that we always talk about, is the one on one-on-one coaching. Before any of the events, the the absolute one on one-on-one coaching is the primary most important thing. That is the guided work itself, and I think why we have a company and what we're known for, and the most important thing, alongside, of course, the work that we have each student do on their own time.

So there's the guided work within the sessions and the student doing the work on their own time. That is the most direct impact on the students getting into school, right? The most direct impact on their success comes from the one-on-one coaching. So when we have a student ask, you know, if they're on a budget, should they focus on coaching or masterclasses? And it's one or the other, we would always prioritize one-on-one coaching. And then in terms of the events themselves, the most important event we always recommend is a mock audition that you would do your senior year. For our families with larger budgets, you can attend a mock audition your junior year. That's becoming more and more popular if you're really ahead of the game and you're ready for it.

But this would be a supplement and not a replacement for your mock senior year, which is the most important thing from our perspective to fully practice all of your material, all of your audition skills, including stuff like interview questions, adjustments, all those interstitial moments we always talk about on all the college episodes that make up an audition that aren't just about the material themselves. So you'll prepared all of this stuff with your individual coaches and prepared for those interstitial moments as well, but there's nothing like really getting to practice the real thing with guest coaches who are not your primary coaches and then getting that guided feedback.

[17:05] Charlie Murphy: But then that leads me to the actual question, which is about masterclasses, which that would be the next thing on the list in terms of events that we think you could really prioritize and budget for. I say this because whether they are with us or other organizations, when you're talking about a college faculty masterclass, there's definitely an expense involved. It is something that you have to budget for compared to this should be on the same sort of tier as like our webinars, which we think are fantastic, but our webinars are a lot less money that you're gonna be budgeting for compared to uh a college masterclass. For the families that can afford them, I think they're really wonderful. You get a direct window into how a college faculty member works and thinks, and it often gives you a really clear idea of what the program is that they're a part of.

Of course, not every teacher at every program will always be the same as that specific teacher, but I do think in general you can learn a great deal. And of course, regardless of the school, if the teacher is good, and so many of these teachers are excellent, you're gonna learn a lot about the piece itself in seeing how it lands on an outside eye who's unfamiliar with the work that you've done so far. That's where we really like placing these masterclasses at a point where you've done significant work on the piece, so it shouldn't be something that's brand new to you, but it's not necessarily a piece that feels like it's totally done or completely audition ready. And there's nothing wrong with the piece being in really good shape if you're open to hearing more feedback on it, but it's just to me, it's the most useful if it's in that in-between place where you really know it, but you're still really working on it.

You're still really on the hunt with it, right? That's where we really like the timing of our summer masterclasses at the top of August, because that often works really well for us students. They're gonna go away from that week, they have some real new stuff to work on, and then they're gonna firm up some of their choices with their coaches over the next few weeks as they really get into pre-screen filming season. That's why we do our August masterclass week at the top of August with the idea that you got a couple weeks, and then you can you're ready to hit that pre-screen filming season, whenever feels right for you in the that next bit of the early fall. But so the idea is you really can take away a lot from masterclasses, you can take away new exercises, new ideas, new perspectives, new avenues to work on things within the material.

And most importantly, you can take a lot away not just from your own work, but from watching your classmates work. If you sing a really dramatic song and love an adjustment you got, you might also pick up some really cool exercises from another student's comedic monologue that directly applies to you as well. Or even in watching the way other students take adjustments in play, you can often learn what you want to emulate or notice issues you have as well. You know, if you watch a student who's really trying to get it right, when you see a faculty member actively trying to kind of loosen them up and stop gripping so much and they're trying to like get the right answer, you might think to yourself, oh, I kind of do that too for Charlie Murphy.

I kind of do that too, right? In a way that's tough. When the pressure's on, it's tough not to try to get it right and do that thing, even if you're like, I think something's going on here, but it's it's harder to observe when you're in the pressure cooker yourself. But then when you're watching someone else do it, you can go, ah, I get it. Now I see how I would act differently in that moment if I was in that those shoes. It's always easier when you're watching someone else's shoes.

[19:57] Charlie Murphy: You know, the one thing I want to emphasize that I don't think you take away from these classes is access. I really I love that Mitch was so clear on that. It's something that we stand firmly behind as well as MTCA. You're not doing these classes to get an early in or to do an audition for these teachers. They are classes and they're educational. Can you make a relationship with a faculty that's beneficial to you? Of course. But that kind of relationship is not necessary to succeed in this process. If you walk into a room at a most competitive program and they're meeting you for the first time, you can absolutely book that room every bit as much as a student who's done three masterclasses with that same teacher.

You know, and I say that because I think parents sometimes see the illusion of paying for access. And even I think some less scrupulous companies will make it seem like that is what's happening, that we're giving you access to these most competitive schools, and it's really not. You're paying for an educational opportunity. You're not greasing the palm with these faculty members or with MTCA. We're not doing anything to, well, they did three master classes, let's try to kick them up the list. Can I talk to my friend? That's just not how it works in this business at all, and certainly not with MTCA, right? That's true for master classes, that's true for exclusive audition opportunities with us as well.

We think that can be really nice and can really add a lot of convenience for you for sure, but this is not a pay-to-play situation. And if you can believe it, this process really is a true meritocracy. I always say it's a subjective meritocracy, which means it's really murky and confusing. But these schools are genuinely doing their best to select the best classes for their schools, whatever it means for them, regardless of all the other factors of apparent access. It may not seem that way from the outside, but in the vast majority of all cases, it really is that way. It is a subjective meritocracy and especially true at the most competitive programs. They have integrity and they have expertise in what they're looking for as they try to build and maintain the best program they can for themselves, and that's what they're most focused on.

[21:46] Charlie Murphy: And just a side note to bring in the summer programs, get a couple questions about summer programs. The same idea holds true there as well. You'd be paying for an educational experience, which can be an awesome educational experience, of course, and which will differ a lot from program to program, but you aren't paying for access or to guarantee yourself a leg up in admission at that specific school. And again, that's especially so at a most competitive school. And the reason I emphasize that is because I do think places out there will kind of make it seem like that's true. They'll go, this person did the summer program and they got in. And that means because they did the summer program they got in.

No, that does the because isn't true just because these two things happened. But of course, for the sake of the selling the summer program, you'll see that that thing on there, and you go, I guess I have to do the summer program too. And that's just not the way the thing works. Okay, I've gone on and on. Of course, I only have time for one more question because I said I'm not gonna go more than 30 minutes. We'll see. I've try not to go more than 30 minutes on this intro. Um, and that question is about gap years. Uh so this comes from Maya. Just can you share your thoughts on gap years and deferring admissions? Um, yes, okay. This one hopefully will be a little easier to be shorter because I don't have much genius to say here.

Not that, of course, what I ever say is genius, but I often have a lot of thoughts to say. Um, but I'll just say in general, I am a huge fan of gap years when they're possible. Honestly, I've said it before on the pod, but I think every student should get at least like a half gap year. Like I wish these conservatory programs started the second semester of a normal college year, so that like seniors from high school could graduate from high school, do their school musical, have prom, have a joyous experience, and then they do their auditions in like the fall after a summer of like audition prep and self-exploration, all that kind of stuff. If they did like the fall of what would have been their freshman year and then started in January, that's would be to me the perfect way to do this system.

[23:26] Charlie Murphy: But unfortunately, that's not how the world works. It's not gonna change just because I say this into the podcast, nor will these schools stop requiring essays. There's a lot of things that I'll say, I wish this would happen, but it's not gonna happen that way. But so it's really your choice in the process is gonna be to be pretty meticulous with your planning and starting early in the process. That's why we talk about some of the advantages of starting a junior year, so that you can navigate the double duty of both being a senior, which has its own weight to it, and then auditioning for schools, or you do have the choice to potentially look at taking a gap year to allow you to do the process more thoroughly.

If you know there's a crazy reason that your senior year is just not possible to do that, you might say, and you know you're a little behind, you may say, I'm uh I think I'm gonna do this gap year so that I can really focus on this problem, this process in a healthy way. Of course, there is another choice, which plenty of families do make, which is just to have a really packed and stressful senior year without planning very well for it. I'm not gonna recommend that particular choice. People make it work. There's no reason you can't make that third choice work where you go, hey, listen, gap year's just not in the cards for us, it's not possible. Here we go. We're gonna triage and do our best.

And you can have a really successful process. It just can be pretty stressful if you're not planned for it and just diving in and trying to do both these things at once. But we'll talk about gap years. From an auditioning perspective, there's no disadvantage to being a gap year student. Schools would look at you with the same level of seriousness, and often those students have had a chance to kind of breathe and mature in that time off and come in with a really positive perspective. The only possible downside I've sometimes seen with students who do a gap year is if they are the kind of student who is really lacking in structure, and maybe if you were a little bit behind in this process, you might tend to be that student who's a little bit more lacking in structure, maybe you're a little bit more of a uh someone who puts things off.

It can actually sometimes make them a bit lazier with the process to not have other things to do. So to sort of sort of have that morass of time, often to kind of put them in a less competitive place and they go, I had all this time and I still didn't work on my monologue and I didn't get all the things done that I was supposed to do, and I'm still feel behind, and then as they sort of beat themselves up about it, right? But that really is gonna vary by personality type. Plenty of people would or would be that with a gap year and plenty wouldn't, right? And certainly something you can try to construct a schedule for yourself, some scaffolding to avoid falling into that specific trap, especially now that I've warned you of it.

Um, but of course, from the strategic perspective, that that's one thing in terms of it is more possible to make it happen. There is, of course, this sort of personal and social perspective that gap years can be hard on a student if all of your friends go off to school and you feel like you're left behind. You know, especially if you don't have any other friends in that situation, it can be like, oh man, I'm I'm I'm all alone here in my hometown and everyone's off wherever at school and I'm I'm still here, right? And also depending on your family situation, it might be difficult to figure out what that means for just delaying your child's launch into adulthood in terms of financially and socially and all the different things that that aren't about the strategy, though, of course you can figure that part out for yourself.

You know, I think of it a little bit like that Malcolm Gladwell idea that basically everybody should start school later if they want to go to an Ivy League school. You know, it was one of the biggest statistical determinative factors in Ivy League admission was like age relative to their incoming classmates. So in theory, it's an easy choice. If you're optimizing for success, you would love to just start later. But in practice, that can be really tricky. If you have a really bright child, let's say who's already like reading and doing a lot of math or whatever, and you're gonna hold them back from first grade, that's not an easy choice of what could be a really boring and difficult year just for some theoretical long-term future gain that you read at a book somewhere, right?

And I would say gap years are very common, but definitely not the norm either, right? So it's not the case that like most of an incoming class of a BFA program will be gap year kids. Most will not, right? Unlike in that Harvard example, it really is the majority of graduating seniors who are older than 22. Like they're mostly 23, 24, like mostly one or two years older than they should be. That's not the case where most people would have done a gap year. The majority would not have done a gap year. I think from um from my class at Carnegie, uh maybe a total of four or five of the freshmen were in any way older than 18, meaning whether that was gap year and a re-audition gap year, which kind of is the same thing, but could be different, or a transfer from maybe spend a year at a different school and then audition, right?

So I think, yeah, four or five total between uh in my class at Carnegie, if you're counting 24. So, you know, not unusual, but not the norm either in terms of those numbers. But I would say if you are contemplating taking a gap year, do so intentionally, right? Give some thought about how you're gonna spend your days in a way that kind of fuels you artistically, but then doesn't become a time suck that actually distracts you from the process. So the idea of doing something that gives you an opportunity to perform or to continue and train in some ways, I think that's great. But I wouldn't necessarily recommend like working professionally in a show during those fall winter months, because that of course could pull you away from actually doing your auditions, right?

And the other small bit of advice I would give is just to make sure you're intentional from what you're doing with your academic perspective of it all too, right? If you're an MTCA student, I would recommend talking to one of our college advisors to get their thoughts on whether you would want to take any college type classes or whether that might actually be a detriment to you sort of admissions-wise. You know, they can talk to you about your specific academic profile and your goals from there. But if you enroll in a non-BFA college and then you're you're being looked at as a transfer academically, that does alter your process significantly from an academic perspective. You'd still be in almost all cases, certainly in a non-BFA case, in all cases, you'd be starting as a freshman with the BFA, with the conservatory itself.

You'd be starting as a freshman, potentially with academics already knocked out of the way, which could be good or bad for you. But the academic admission process would change significantly if you're academically looked at as a freshman, again, even or as a transfer, even if you start as a freshman. A little bit confusing, but um worth working out of going. Do I do I want to take these classes? Some people just sort of cavalierly go, eh, might as well take some community college classes, might as well enroll in this junior college because I'm here anyway and I know I'm auditioned next year. I wouldn't make that decision cavalierly. I'd make sure you talk to someone who knows what they're doing in terms of your academic profile.

Um, I realize I also didn't talk specifically about the idea of deferring admission. If you meant that as a separate idea, Maya, um, the idea of deferring admission certainly is much less common than a gap year. That would be like auditioning as a senior and then spending a year in Europe or whatever before you start school, right? You might not have even meant that. You might have just meant, you know, sort of had deferring as auditioning later in part of your gap year question. I'm not sure that you meant specifically to talk about deferring. Um, but because it's there, I'll just say there is no downside in deferring if your school will let you do it. I don't see a problem with it in being 19 when you start college, if you have some amazing reason that you want to defer.

Um, certainly we've had students who've had injuries or issues that uh cause them to defer, and you know, a bunch of kids during COVID ended up deferring at least a year and some even more. Um, just so you know, in that case, uh, there's no theoretical downside to it if there's a reason you need to or a reason you want to, but technically, you would have to clear it with the school to avoid the need to re-audition with the next class. So it's not automatic at every school that you could just say, Hey, I'll take I'll just take it next year. They may say, sorry, you'd have to re-audition. We accepted you into this class. You might not be in the next class of 12 for whatever reason. So um some schools would say no problem, kind of across the board.

And most, if you had a really good reason for it, I think would go, we'll try to make that work for you. But it's something you would have to ask them. It's not just an automatic thing that you definitely get. Okay, I think that is more than enough of a holiday mailbag. Thank you all for the great questions. And as always, feel free to get them in when you have them, right? Um, I'll solicit these every once in a while. If maybe if twice a year, we'll probably do an official mailbag show. Um, but we can save them up and do them in mailbags if you ask them, you know, earlier. And then if it's a particularly intriguing question that we haven't touched on in the show, I might weave it into other episodes that I like I already did um a few a few times this season with some specific singular questions that might do them in a takeaway or at the top of a show.

Um and also just we get a ton of questions, it might mean hey, we'll do a mailbag four times a year or whatever. You know, we're we're always open to your feedback. And again, that is mailbag at mapping the college audition.com. That's mailbag at mapping the college audition.com for those questions and any kind of feedback. Uh, we thank you for your listenership. We thank you for your wonderful ratings and reviews, your follows, all the ways you continue to spread our little podcast to the world. It means a lot to me. And happy holidays to you all. I hope you get some joyous time with loved ones, some rest, some recuperation. I'm gonna try to do the same and come back strong for you all in 2025. Now, please enjoy this fabulous clip show put together by the one and only Kelly Prendergast.

[31:37] Kelly Prendergast: Hello, hello. I am Kelly Prendergast. And please excuse my minor cough. Um, but I had the wonderful task of selecting standout clips from this year's podcasts. While there were, of course, countless moments worth highlighting, I chose these five because I feel they capture what this year on Mapping the College Audition has been all about. This was a year filled with big name schools and renowned artist guests, as well as opportunities to shine a light on some lesser-known schools that have incredible programs, as well as some young successful artists making waves in the industry today. Together, I feel these clips showcase a wealth of well-rounded insights and invaluable advice. I hope you enjoy this little clip show.

First up, we have a clip from our episode with Tim Espinoza from Boston Conservatory at Berkeley. I chose this clip because Tim's candid response about why people choose Boco or don't is both endearing and insightful. It offers a genuine glimpse into what Boco is all about. This episode was filled with educational and very honest moments, and I feel this clip captures the essence of it all pretty perfectly.

[32:57] Charlie Murphy: Here we are. It's March 15th as we're recording this. It'll probably release, I think two or three weeks from now. Um, but we're in decision time. Many students are gonna be running down deposits and making a decision in the next couple weeks. Um, why do you find, you know, as you are you're in these discussions, you know, with students and people are uh they've got multiple options or an FTCA student, they got tons of great options, right? Why do you find they end up signing on the dotted line and say, hey, I think Boko's the one for me? And or, you know, are why do you find that a student might say, I think actually I'm not gonna go here? I think this uh thank you for the offer, but I think uh better fits them right? What what what do you sort of see as those determining factors for for the yes and the no uh so far?

[33:36] Charlie Murphy: Uh for me, this is just a personal choice, and I think that's something that we're working toward we're be we're beginning to articulate across the entire conservatory. Um I feel like a student is auditioning their universities as much as we are auditioning them. And I always try to reiterate that um no two institutions are the same. You can't really, you know, uh, and oftentimes I say throw out that top 10 list. It really and I don't know, I don't know if that's something you all talk about with your students. I did a whole grant on it. I mean, because they were top two according to who? Who's yeah, totally. Exactly. Uh who's who's coming up with a measure?

[34:11] Charlie Murphy: So I I think if I could give a piece of advice to any of the prospective students out there that are listening, ask the difficult questions that you need the information to get out of your out of the faculty and the leadership that are running these programs. Don't try to get caught up in top 10 lists because there are some excellent schools out there on the East Coast and the Midwest on the West Coast that can serve your individual needs. And uh so coming back to the conservatory, you know, we talked a lot about um about what we do and who we are over the course of this hour. Uh and if that sounds like something that's appealing to the students and that aligns with the the culture of learning that they and where they want to spend the next four years of their education, we are gonna do our darnest to make sure we find those students that align with that um that viewpoint.

Um where you know the students that want to lean into that multi-hyphenate, multidisciplinary artist mindset um that will still get the foundational and strong foundational training in singing, dancing, and acting uh in contemporary theater.

[35:11] Charlie Murphy: Uh but if we're not, then that's okay. And they often choose to go to a different school, and that's okay. Um, but we still maintain a community a connection to them regardless of where they are. I get equally as excited about, you know, uh past prospective students that are at the University of Michigan or at Shenandoah or wherever have you, um, because I see them thriving. And so, uh, I kind of went off track there, but uh, but I but uh for me it's um you know it if there's a selling point to what we do is you know, we are really looking for the student that wants to lean into a multidisciplinary aspect of their musical uh and contemporary theater training, that that don't want to be pigeonholed into a super super prescriptive model that um that they're excited and interested in the idea of possibly being the next Janine Tassori or uh Jason Robert Brown in terms of songwriting or be be uh learn about choreography and learn about how musical theater dance can serve you both in your current in your career and then after your after your performing arts career is done. Um that's kind of the student we're looking for.

[36:51] Charlie Murphy: Up next, we have two standout clips from our episode featuring the incredible Sarah Neal. I'm spotlighting this episode because Sarah's extensive dance resume brings a perspective we don't often get on the podcast, as we haven't had a ton of dancer dancers or dancers, as some like to say. Uh she was such a delight. Uh her vibrant personality really shone through, especially as she danced in her seat during Charlie and her conversation. The first clip I selected is not only funny, but I also just love how Sarah owns her talent with such unapologetic confidence. And the second clip features a piece of advice that I found especially meaningful coming from someone as seasoned as Sarah who is both a performer and someone who has spent time behind the table. It's a gem of wisdom that I think the young performers can really benefit from.

[37:45] Sarah Neal: I think I was afraid to say that I wanted to do Broadway because I didn't want people to be like Sarah thinks she's good enough for that. You know, I had like that self-doubty fear.

[37:54] Charlie Murphy: Like you said had self-doubty fear like you no longer do. What's wrong with you?

[37:58] Sarah Neal: Well, how'd you get rid of it?

[37:59] Charlie Murphy: Oh, I I just like believe in myself now.

[38:02] Sarah Neal: Charlie, you have to give us some of that.

[38:04] Charlie Murphy: Whatever that pill Sarah's taking. We have to we're gonna sell that at the podcast.

[38:07] Sarah Neal: That's a really good idea. It took a long time. Just get rid of the self-doubt.

[38:09] Charlie Murphy: I just you rarely hear someone be like, I used to think I wasn't good enough, but now I am. Like, that's great. I want that.

[38:15] Sarah Neal: I'm with some of what you have. That sounds great.

[38:18] Sarah Neal: The most important thing you could do is have your own sense of style. Look in a mirror, do it by yourself. So if you if it makes you feel more comfortable, understand your angles. Know how you know what makes you feel cute or good. So if you are a heels wearing person, understand like how you're how you're gonna shoulder roll. Because when I see when I see people learn choreography, I'm not looking for the one who's the most technical. I am looking for the one who is the most like living. If you can live because you're comfortable in a shoulder roll or in a head roll and you love it, and I can tell that you love to dance or that you are eating and you just love to serve, like that is so much more delicious for me.

I then I want you because you have a personality. You're making me hungry. They're serving, they're eating, they're you're it's delicious. Okay, those are the lingos right now. Let me tell you, my last name is Neil, so we love to play into like the full well balanced. So but like this whole thing, like the the idea of the shoulder roll and like it coming from a place of like I'm I love this, this is fun for me. I it's delicious to do a jazz hand, like that stuff is so much more important to me than the technical stuff.

[39:31] Sarah Neal: So and and if you are not a heels wearing person, if you are wearing flats and you got a little bit of game, you know, come in, you're like sub, and you have some swag, whatever that is, that is so much more attractive and appealing to someone who wants to um hire you to see that you have a connection and you're telling a story and like it feels good in your bones. So be comp turn on some music and like find your groove.

[39:53] Sarah Neal: Yeah. And feel comfortable grooving because that wins 100% of the time, where sometimes I see the most technical dancers who are boring, they have no story to tell, and they're freaked out and they're afraid, and I can't use them.

[40:07] Charlie Murphy: Okay, on to the next clip from our episode featuring KO from Northwestern University. I selected this clip because I feel it perfectly captures what I believe to be Northwestern's unique quote unquote brand. Uh by the end of this episode, I really felt like I had a clear sense of what Northwestern is all about and the kind of student that they aim to attract.

[40:34] KO: And so that's by offering them different opportunities. Like something that is not a part of the curriculum, but it is something that is a part of the certificate program that you can be a part of without having to get into the certificate is that every quarter we do a pathways workshop, which is on the weekend we take the morning, faculty members create workshops, and then you sign up, and then we make art together. That's a very important portion of the trajectory of a student who wants to work in music theater at Northwestern, and specifically with the certificate program.

[41:09] KO: I I will I'll be very frank with you. I'm not interested in creating cookie cutters. I mean, I wouldn't have a uh I wouldn't have had a career and wouldn't have a career had I followed the model of you should be a dancer because you're tall. You know what I mean? What I'm interested in is the student who has the mind to be a creator and who also either writes music, sings, dances, acts, all of these things. And so it really is the School of Northwestern is built for multi hyphenates, and what we're looking to do is support the multi hyphenate artist.

[41:44] KO: So the the pedagogy is gonna lean much more towards experimental things. You will get the fundamentals, but then it will be a little bit more about like how are you looking at art? How do you want to innovate art? And how can we supply you with tools and a fertile ground so the things that you want to experiment with, you can do so while you're here.

[42:04] Charlie Murphy: This next clip is from our episode featuring Andrew Rannels. I chose this clip because here he is talking about embracing just being himself in an audition room and not trying to be somebody else.

[42:22] Charlie Murphy: I really think this is a piece of insight that every actor needs to hear. Yes, it is a piece of insight and advice our listeners hear time and time again. But as an actor myself, this is some advice I wish I listened to a lot sooner.

[42:40] Andrew Rannels: Because after, you know, for years of trying to be, you know, trying to be Brian Darcy James or trying to be even Gavin, like trying to be, you know, it's like I get I don't do that. I don't very differently. I admire them, and I wish that at times that I could do what they do, and and but I I I spent a lot of time chasing other people and trying to sound like other people and then something clicked around the time I turned, you know, like 28. Uh that I was like, I think I just gotta, I think I just gotta embrace it.

[43:13] Andrew Rannels: And then I and then I got a couple jobs based on that. Like I did Lisa Strata Jones out of town with Matt Miran, and and that was really odd and fun. And um Douglas Carter Bean just sort of let Patty and I like do whatever the hell we wanted. So that was really fun. And then I did um the workshops of Little Miss Sunshine with James LePine and Bill Finn, um, which you know, years later would lead to this falsetto's revival. But like, you know, at the time I, you know, they didn't know who I was, and I went in and auditioned for the ensemble of Little Miss Sunshine, and James said he was like, It's you you just there's something kind of quirky and odd about the way you're reading these little parts, and I like it. It's fanning the flames of your your freak flag or whatever. You're saying that was like, oh, okay, great.

[44:01] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.

[44:01] Andrew Rannels: So by the time I auditioned for the Book of Mormon, it was like, okay, I had enough sort of positive feedback that I felt like I could go in and do it.

[44:10] Charlie Murphy: And finally, this last clip is from our episode with MTCA alum Ali Lewis Borski. Ali is the second recent MTCA graduate making their Broadway debut to join us on the podcast this year. I selected this clip because it shares a piece of advice from someone who's fresh out of school that I think is so important. And as you'll hear, Charlie does too.

[44:35] Ali Lewis Borski: Another thing that I think is a huge um piece of advice that's really useful is uh, you know, uh crave critique. Um don't go to college assuming or don't go to college already with the mindset that you know everything because you're not gonna get your money's worth. I for the audition process and going into college, I went in craving to be absolutely teared down. Like I wanted to be roasted, sliced and diced. I wanted them to critique me on everything. Um that's what I was there for. And I know I think I I remember a lot of my fellow students really getting upset and being really um self-conscious about getting all kinds of notes, but it's like that's why we're here.

[45:21] Charlie Murphy: Um, and I think you you have to focus on that.

[45:23] Ali Lewis Borski: Yeah, it's such a good thing for young people to hear, you know, crave critique, you know, and it doesn't have to be masochistic in the way that you're saying tear me down.

[45:30] Charlie Murphy: But maybe especially—

[45:31] Ali Lewis Borski: No, no, not at all. Uh I don't crave validation. I don't want to take your beautiful crave critique and turn it into a negative because you said it the right way. But I think so often from an audition, we don't even realize what we're really hoping for is a gold star at the end.

[45:43] Charlie Murphy: Yes.

[45:44] Ali Lewis Borski: That was fantastic. You were amazing. Like sometimes students will come out and go, I it was terrible. And I'd be like, what was terrible about it? And it was basically that they didn't get a lot of compliments at the end. I was like, that's not a bad audition just because they didn't say, you're amazing. That's the best I've ever heard that song song.

[46:00] Charlie Murphy: Okay, I hope you enjoyed that. Again, sending some holiday love to you all. You know where you can find us. That's at Mapping the College Audition on Insta. If you want to tell Kelly what a great job she did, put it in the comments of the clip show or email us at mailbag at mapping the college audition.com. If you have questions or feedback of any kind, you can always check out our website at mtca.com for any individual coaching prep. And to my young artists out there mapping their journeys. Have a wonderful holiday. We'll catch you next week.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred