Skip to main content
BPN Logo
JJ Niemann (Broadway’s Book of Mormon/MTCA Alum) on putting the “me” in Social Media

In this Artist Exploration, JJ and Charlie discuss: His move from Elon to Book of Mormon. How JJ’s assistant skills aided him in being a Swing. TikTok stardom. Building a career around his personality. If you want to hear more from JJ be sure to check out: TikTok: @jjniemann... Read More

From the show: Mapping The College Audition: An MTCA Podcast

1 h 11 mins
8/31/22

Guests

Featured Shows

About

In this Artist Exploration, JJ and Charlie discuss:

  • His move from Elon to Book of Mormon
  • How JJ’s assistant skills aided him in being a Swing
  • TikTok stardom
  • Building a career around his personality

If you want to hear more from JJ be sure to check out:

If you have any questions about the college audition process, feel free to reach out at mailbag@mappingthecollegeaudition.com. If you’re interested in working with MTCA for help with your individualized preparation for your College Audition journey, please check us out at mtcollegeauditions.com, or on Instagram or Facebook.

Follow Us!

Instagram: @musicaltheatercollegeauditions

YouTube: @MTCA (Musical Theater College Auditions)

TikTok: @mtcollegeauditions

Charlie Murphy:@charmur7

Meghan Cordier:@meghanmarie2014

About MTCA:

Musical Theater College Auditions (MTCA) is the leader in coaching acting and musical theater students through the college audition process and beyond with superlative results. MTCA has assembled a roster of expert artist-educators who can guide students artistically, organizationally, strategically, and psychologically through the competitive college audition process. MTCA provides the tools, resources, and expertise along with a vast and strong support system. They train the unique individual, empowering the artist to bring their true, authentic self to their work. MTCA believes that by helping students reveal their potential it allows each school to connect with those who are truly right for their programs, which in turn guides each student toward their best college fit.

About Charlie Murphy:

Charlie is a proud graduate of Carnegie Mellon University’s BFA program. As an Actor he has performed with theaters such as: NY Public Theatre’s “Shakespeare in the Park”, The Pearl Theatre Company, Hudson Valley Shakespeare Festival, Chautauqua Theatre Company, Kinetic Theatre Company, and the Shakespeare Theatre of DC.

With MTCA [Musical Theater College Auditions -- mtca.nyc], he has been helping prospective theatre students through the college process for over 15 years. As a Teacher and Director, he is able to do a few of his favorite things in life: help students to find their authentic selves as artists, and then help them find their best fit for their collegiate journey. Through this podcast, he hopes to continue that work as well as help demystify this intricate process.

This episode was produced by Meghan Cordier and Charlie Murphy. Episode theme music is created by Will Reynolds.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:10] Charlie Murphy: Hello, hello, and welcome to Mapping the College Audition, a podcast where we explore the landscape of the college theater world and try to demystify this daunting audition process.

[0:20] Charlie Murphy: I'm your host, Charlie Murphy, director of MTCA. That's Musical Theatre College Auditions. And today we have a viral phenomenon of a show lined up for you.

[0:31] Charlie Murphy: JJ Niemann from Broadway's Book of Mormon is on the show today to talk all things social media. These are some really special episodes where we get a chat with our alumni. JJ is an MTCA alum.

[0:45] Charlie Murphy: And it is just crazy how many of them have grown up to be so successful. We had Ashley Reyes on the pod a few months ago, and she is still crushing it as the lead of Walker Texas Ranger that reboot. And one of our coaches just booked a role on that show.

[0:59] Charlie Murphy: And so fun to be like, hey, have fun. You're gonna be a bit lower on the call sheet than Ashley. Um and oh boy, is that true about JJ too. Um as I've started to try to join and understand the world of social media a decade too late, I know. Um, it's incredible to see what some of our students have done with this.

[1:16] Charlie Murphy: And JJ is so down to earth with all of the success and attention, as I say, it couldn't have happened to a nicer guy. Um today on the pod, we'll get into JJ's MTCA journey and some of the advice that we did not give him on the way.

[1:30] Charlie Murphy: Um we talk about his experience at Elon, we talk about the process of booking Book of Mormon. Um we talk about the skills needed to swing in JJ's very detail-oriented self. Um, JJ reminds you that some people do call your references, so be careful there.

[1:44] Charlie Murphy: Um, and then the second half of the show, we talk a lot about TikTok, kind of JJ's rise to stardom there, um, how he comes up with his content, um, and kind of coming to terms with his dual careers and his realization about building a career around his personality.

[1:58] Charlie Murphy: Um, upcoming in the next couple weeks, we got Dr. Jesse Carlo, the new head of Pace. Um, we have Krista Rodriguez, timed beautifully for Survivor's return. Um, she's also a big Survivor fan. Um, we have Josh Grizzetti of CSU Fullerton, and then our first multi-guest episode with Will Reynolds, MTCA Zone, and Hannah Corneau.

[2:21] Charlie Murphy: I think with all that, we should just get right into it, right? I could give you some words about being back to school or something, but to be honest, my partner cannot stop booking television shows at the moment. Literally back to back, like a boss.

[2:31] Charlie Murphy: And I'm pulling a lot of daddy duty, so I'm kind of falling asleep while recording this. So just like JJ, we're all gonna grab a cup of coffee, even if it's noon where you are, and enjoy what I think is a really great episode.

[2:51] Charlie Murphy: Well, we are so excited to be joined by JJ Niemann. JJ has a BFA from Elon in musical theater. He is also an MTCA alum. What's up? Um, he's been on Broadway in the Book of Mormon. Uh, it looks like a couple different times. He was in there for two years, and then he came back uh once again in the pandemic moment when everyone was coming back to shows.

[3:13] Charlie Murphy: Um, he's also done shows like at the Muni, Pittsburgh CLO, Bay Street Theater, and many other regional places. And one of the big reasons we wanted JJ on the pod is because he is a TikTok insta social media phenomenon. Um, he's been like a viral hit in a lot of videos.

[3:31] Charlie Murphy: Literally, some of these videos I was looking at last night were like 4.5 million views or whatever. He has like 300 million page views. I don't even know what that means. Someone wrote that down on his page. Like 300 million people, JJ. It's ridiculous.

[3:42] Charlie Murphy: Um, but through TikTok, he's done like Ratatouille, the musical, um, for you page, which was a TikTok musical. We'll talk about that and maybe some of the other workshops and things that are happening in your life as well. But JJ, welcome on the pod. How are you feeling today?

[3:54] JJ Niemann: Hi, thank you so much for having me. I'm feeling good, feeling awake. I got my coffee, my little latte, and yeah I'm ready to do a pod.

[4:04] Charlie Murphy: JJ's trying to pretend like it's like nine in the morning. It's three in the afternoon. He's like, got my coffee, I'm ready, I'm awake truly, truly and and I I told Charlie I just finished a contract and so like truly I slept till noon today. I've been on like rest mode for the past few days like recovery.

[4:21] JJ Niemann: It's a good life. This is gonna be a slow warm-up of a pod then but but let's start with so let's take you all the way back to when you were with MTCA back in the day. But especially like 16, 17 year old you, as you really started contemplating colleges and were looking at like what kind of colleges might I look for um I'd love to kind of hear like what was your if you had a mission statement or if you had a this is what I think I'm looking for in the college process before you really dove into it.

[4:47] JJ Niemann: What were you looking for then and then how did that change as you went through the process and ended up in Elon?

[4:47] JJ Niemann: Yeah well I truly had no idea what I was doing. Genuinely I really wasn't sure I was like a little bit of a late start you know I didn't know right away that I wanted to study theater in college or that it was a possibility I had a director that was like hey listen like told my parents when I was um about to go into my senior year he was like listen like there are conservatories and there's programs, there's places where JJ can go and train.

[5:19] JJ Niemann: Like, I think he could make a career in this if he wanted to. And so my parents were like, oh, well, let's start looking into it. And a few people recommended MTCA, obviously.

[5:28] JJ Niemann: Wise people. Wise people, because honestly, I needed some form of guidance. And I was actually very risky because my parents wanted me to apply. Like, I'm like a quadruple whatever legacy at Princeton. I have so many family members that went to like a lot of Ivy Leagues and stuff like that.

[5:45] JJ Niemann: And so my parents really wanted me to apply to a lot of schools academically. And my, you know, way of compromising, I was like, I'll apply to these schools. You want me to if you let me apply to some schools for musical theater and see what happens.

[5:57] JJ Niemann: So I was a little bit like between the lines. Um, and I like to think if I didn't end up going to school for it, I genuinely think I would have gotten in my freshman year in college and would have tried to do the process all over again.

[6:09] JJ Niemann: And like, I don't think I would have been happy doing anything else. But I didn't know that yet. So anyway, I um I only auditioned for three programs for musical theater.

[6:19] Charlie Murphy: All right, it was so nice having you on the pod. Thanks so much. We're gonna find another MTCA alum.

[6:21] JJ Niemann: Unbelievable.

[6:24] Charlie Murphy: You're like don't give anyone advice. This is not co-sponsored.

[6:26] JJ Niemann: Three programs. What were the three programs you applied for?

[6:30] JJ Niemann: Um, they were Carnegie, Mellon, Emerson, and Elon.

[6:33] Charlie Murphy: So a total of like a five percent admission rate.

[6:35] JJ Niemann: Right, right. Unbelievable.

[6:38] JJ Niemann: Um, and and so in terms of a mission statement of where I wanted to go, it was very much honestly. I let my parents run the ship a little bit.

[6:45] JJ Niemann: And looking back, I maybe shouldn't have, but um, because like my dad was like, Well, you're not going to school like Michigan, that's too big. Well, you're not going to Texas, you're not going to Florida, you're not, he would just like, you're not going here, you're not going there.

[6:57] JJ Niemann: I was like, okay. He was like, you're not gonna go to like a Cincinnati conservatory. He was like, so basically, we were left with a few places, and um, I'm so thankful because I remember, like, you know, I didn't know at the time exactly what I wanted, but I know what I needed was a safe space.

[7:17] JJ Niemann: I needed a place that was like nurturing because I was pretty rough around the edges. I had a lot of raw talent, but didn't know what to do with it. MTCA, thank God, helped me pick some good material.

[7:28] JJ Niemann: I didn't know how to find a monologue. I had never taken an acting class.

[7:32] Charlie Murphy: You still don't know how to find a monologue.

[7:33] JJ Niemann: That's I still don't. I actually really don't. Because that is not something you do a ton in the professional world.

[7:38] Charlie Murphy: No, we do not.

[7:39] JJ Niemann: I still use my college monologue every now and then.

[7:41] Charlie Murphy: A lot of people do. Let's be honest.

[7:43] JJ Niemann: Yeah.

[7:43] JJ Niemann: Um, but yeah, so like for helping material and just like knowing somewhat of a vision, thankfully, like Leo and Ellen and the people at MTCA like really helped like guide me.

[7:54] JJ Niemann: Um terrible guidance with a school list. So let's we're just gonna ignore that for a second.

[7:56] Charlie Murphy: But it's not not MTCA recommended, let's be clear.

[8:01] JJ Niemann: Not at all. They were like, are you sure?

[8:03] JJ Niemann: Um thankfully, like I went to like the Elon audition, and I remember crying on my way home, the drive home, and I'm from North Carolina, like I I live three hours from Elon, like when I'm home.

[8:17] JJ Niemann: Um, and I just remember being like, this is it. Like, this is where I have to go. Like, I just knew it in my heart and felt the vibes, and thank God I got in.

[8:25] JJ Niemann: And I really got lucky because that was like it was just it.

[8:28] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, that's definitely risky. But let's talk about your parents.

[8:31] Charlie Murphy: So it seems like a pretty involved dad with mom and dad both pretty involved.

[8:34] JJ Niemann: Mm-hmm.

[8:35] Charlie Murphy: So we talked about what what was the relationship with them like through this process.

[8:38] Charlie Murphy: If you remember both from like their level of support, and it seems like now some of their levels of demands of what schools um you were gonna go into.

[8:45] Charlie Murphy: Obviously, they supported you financially through with a program like MTCA. What was the experience like?

[8:48] JJ Niemann: I just want to hear all that. Emotionally. What was it like going on that roller coaster ride with them? What was it like, you know, for those couple years?

[8:54] JJ Niemann: I mean, they were super supportive. Like, like they came with me to all of like visit all these schools to all these auditions.

[9:00] JJ Niemann: Like they did like, you know, they wanted to invest in me. And I think a lot of what they thought was I would end up going to maybe an academically based school.

[9:09] JJ Niemann: And then just a school would happen to have great. Like my dad went to Princeton. And they had like, they have all of these student directed, like he was up, he he was an actor.

[9:19] JJ Niemann: Like he was a part of all of the like improv troop and like all this stuff, and they have amazing a cappella groups. So I think in his mind, he was like, you can go to school like that and not have to like study it.

[9:28] JJ Niemann: That's I mean, sure, for some people, absolutely. But I needed the training.

[9:34] JJ Niemann: And I don't think at the time we knew how much I needed the training and how much I could grow because it was an immense growth process in college.

[9:44] JJ Niemann: Um, but they were very supportive. And I think I mean, my dad, my dad's mom was also an actor, and she made him promise that he would never let any of his kids go into the arts.

[9:56] JJ Niemann: She's not with us anymore, so she didn't live to see that he did not keep the promise.

[10:00] JJ Niemann: But I like to think that she's looking down and is proud of how it all turned out, you know.

[10:04] Charlie Murphy: You better believe she is.

[10:05] Charlie Murphy: You better believe that's how I mean it's funny, Elizabeth and I talk about that a lot with our daughter. Of like, I'm like, she'll be a scientist, let's be here. She'll be a business person. She's not gonna be a theater, but like some part of me also would be like so proud.

[10:14] Charlie Murphy: I'd be like, Oh my god, she's so good. You know, yeah.

[10:16] JJ Niemann: Anyway, we'll see when we get there.

[10:18] Charlie Murphy: Um, but I do think there's something really interesting.

[10:19] Charlie Murphy: You know, one of my friends in um I grew up growing up at Pittsburgh, fantastic actor.

[10:25] Charlie Murphy: I mean, just as good and as talented as anyone you'd ever see. His parents so insisted, it's funny you bring up Princeton that he goes to an Ivy League school is also super smart.

[10:34] Charlie Murphy: And so he studied, went to Princeton, he studied pre-med, but they ended up coming back to Pittsburgh and doing nothing but acting.

[10:39] Charlie Murphy: He still is an actor to this day.

[10:40] JJ Niemann: Right.

[10:40] Charlie Murphy: And so to him, it was like they focused so much on that backup plan that they also never got to like help with what he clearly wanted to be an actor the whole time.

[10:47] Charlie Murphy: He was like I think he would have benefited from going to a conservatory and he would have so there are some those flip sides of of course we want to go to Princeton if we go to Princeton that's amazing.

[10:55] Charlie Murphy: But yeah if the goal is to you know be in Book of Mormon or to do the you know that you got training that is really specific to being able to do that.

[11:02] JJ Niemann: Absolutely.

[11:02] Charlie Murphy: Let's get into that training.

[11:03] Charlie Murphy: So let's talk about so what was the experience at Elon like for you?

[11:07] JJ Niemann: How did it feel you know talking me through freshman year talking me through what what your growth what was the experience like?

[11:12] JJ Niemann: Yeah. Yeah I mean I really like I said I I think I had a lot of raw talent.

[11:18] JJ Niemann: I was a pretty solid dancer but like I didn't have much flexibility. I didn't have my splits I couldn't do a really solid double pirouette.

[11:27] JJ Niemann: Um in terms of singing I had a lot of raw ability but my voice teacher in high school actually taught me to sing incorrectly and like yell.

[11:36] JJ Niemann: And let's call them out who this name this voice teacher say their name say their name.

[11:41] JJ Niemann: No but I like I really needed a rewiring and I was terrified of of going to school and I was actually terrified the most about acting class because I was convinced I wasn't very good at it.

[11:54] JJ Niemann: And the reason I think the reason I wasn't very good at it is because I wasn't authentic.

[11:58] JJ Niemann: Like I wasn't I had a lot to figure out about myself and I went I was in a very um private I went to a private Christian school and was raised very religious and like I was closeted and had a lot of built up trauma and I wasn't willing to be myself yet.

[12:15] JJ Niemann: And thankfully, like, like I said before, Elon was just such an obvious choice in the sense that like, yes, it is a conservatory style program.

[12:23] JJ Niemann: It's intense. I didn't actually realize until I got there how high level it was and how intense it was, because it really is like just an incredible school and the talent there is insane.

[12:37] JJ Niemann: But the teachers and like the mentors, like it was very much like felt like it was like moms, like raising you.

[12:44] JJ Niemann: And it felt like home and it felt safe. And that's why I picked it in the first place.

[12:49] JJ Niemann: I mean, it just was such a clear option, but like I just knew stepping on there and meeting the faculty and meeting the students.

[12:56] JJ Niemann: I was like, this seems like a safe space to like fall and fail and crash and burn and everything in between.

[13:03] JJ Niemann: And I needed that.

[13:05] JJ Niemann: Um, but also there's teachers there that give tough love and are really hard, you know?

[13:08] Charlie Murphy: Yep.

[13:09] JJ Niemann: It's so interesting.

[13:10] JJ Niemann: I mean, I I love that phrasing of I didn't realize how.

[13:12] Charlie Murphy: It's not I don't think what's the word you use?

[13:14] JJ Niemann: It wasn't exclusive. You said just like high level.

[13:16] Charlie Murphy: High level, right?

[13:17] JJ Niemann: Yeah.

[13:17] JJ Niemann: And I think often the the expectations um or work where students often come in is they they kind of know dance expectations of like, I here's where I am as a dancer.

[13:26] JJ Niemann: I don't have a double, but I can kick my, you know, up almost my face, but not quite my face.

[13:29] JJ Niemann: Like you have a sense of what that is dance-wise.

[13:32] JJ Niemann: But I think most people don't come in with this process knowing what are those equivalents acting wise.

[13:37] JJ Niemann: Like, I'm this much vulnerable, I'm this authentic.

[13:40] JJ Niemann: I'm, you know, it's just hard, it's a softer skill, right?

[13:42] JJ Niemann: But the still the expectations of what you're bringing in, you know, to school and what you're gonna work on in school are that same thing of getting that double and getting that to that place.

[13:50] Charlie Murphy: It's just a lot harder to know what is that equivalent acting wise, of like, I'm ready to be my true authentic self.

[13:55] JJ Niemann: Right.

[13:56] JJ Niemann: Exactly.

[13:58] JJ Niemann: It's it's very subjective.

[13:59] JJ Niemann: And so is, I mean, singing the technique is probably a little more objective, but liking to listen to someone's voice is subjective.

[14:07] JJ Niemann: So it's it's a very interesting thing.

[14:09] JJ Niemann: And I left out the part of the story that I was sick as a dog on my Elon audition day.

[14:16] JJ Niemann: Like when I tell you by the end of the day, I nailed that dance call, even though I did, I do vividly remember during one of the run-throughs, because you know how you get to do a dance like more than once. We did a dance from Chicago, like the opening of Chicago, and very Charleston-y, you know, I go and do my high kick and I literally slip and fall on my butt. And like in front of everyone and all the students and teacher, they were like, oop. And then I got up and I kept going, and then obviously we got to do it again and I nailed it. But like, A, that happened. Yes. And then also like by the end of the day, because Elon's audition day is like 12 hours or like 10 hours. And I was croaking by the time I got to the monologue section.

Like I literally was so sick and I was like trying to get through and I was convinced I wouldn't get in because of that. But I think they could see past that and they were like, he has a lot of potential. And that's something that I think Elon looks for. They're not looking for like polished perfection. When you go in, they're like genuinely like they are looking for humans.

[15:14] Charlie Murphy: I agree. That's a lot of these schools. And I will pause it now, you as a more mature actor looking back, I'll bet you realize that some of you falling on your butt and picking yourself up was actually as attractive as you nailing it next time. Like it's good that you nailed it the next time. But they watched how you oh look, he flubbed up and he didn't get frustrated. He didn't, you know, lose it completely. He was able to pick himself back up and then do it. I think is something they often look for in those dance calls.

[15:37] JJ Niemann: Yeah, absolutely. Um, if you had to take one thing now that you're using in your career, like what is one of the biggest things, whether it's a class, whether it's something, a skill that you really feel like you acquired. What do you feel like you're so grateful that you have under your belt now from your time?

[15:50] JJ Niemann: Well, yeah, I don't even know where I would start, but the most obvious one to me is the vocal training because I specifically worked with some teachers. Um one of them was Kurt Robinson who runs full voice studio in New York and works on a lot of shows. And he specifically, like with the pop rock style, he was amazing, but also I grew up singing. I grew up learning to sing by watching American Idol and like being in musicals. Like I never sang any, I had no sort of classical training. So going to college and them forcing that on you, which is like the last thing you want to do. Like nobody wants to sing an aria, like no one, like I did not, at least. And I want to belt some A's is what I want to do.

Yeah. And like I genuinely, though, learned I was taught how to mix. I was taught how to sing correctly, I was taught how to work around vocal trauma that I got in high school because I was taught to sing incorrectly, and literally my range expanded almost twice as much. Like I am known for my high voice, but I did not always have that because I didn't know how to access it in a non-yelly chesty way, you know? So it's pretty wild. And now I'm in Book of Mormon, which is like literally one of the like scrutinyest like high singing shows ever.

[17:06] Charlie Murphy: Love it. Well, then what about on the in the converse? Is there something that if you could go back to school and say, I added in this class, this feels like it was missing. I've now learned this after school, or I'm learning it still, but I kind of wish I'd known this at 22.

[17:19] JJ Niemann: Uh, yes. Specifically, something that keeps coming back around that I wish I had is a is dialects. And I Elon, I think they might have changed it now, but at the time it was only available to the acting majors and not the musical theater majors, which I think is such a disservice because think of how many shows there are where you're doing a British accent or Irish or Australian or versions of that. Like I just had to decline an audition last week because I said, I don't, I don't have time. I was also doing a show, but it was for a show that I had to do an Australian accent, and I was like, I can't learn that in three days, like and be confident in sending this in. Like, I'm not gonna do that.

Um so I wish I had that. And um a little bit more because of how much we're doing self-tapes, like at the time it wasn't as big. So I wish I had a little bit more self-tape training or like how to like portray yourself as a musical theater actor but on film and still be big but subtle, you know. So I feel like especially for musical theater, because that that feels like post-pandemic, one of the things we learned is like, what is it to sing on camera? Because like a lot of schools had some acting on camera, we'd at least learn what is the idea of, you know, how do I take it down a little bit and put it using quotes here, taking it down in terms of you know, it's a little more naturalistic, it's a little easier when you're acting, like speaking, but then to do that while you're doing sound time or something is like it's a weird skill.

It's a weird thing that that like I just don't feel like it was done a lot. I mean, it was done in like the Lay Miz movie or whatever, but there wasn't a lot of like close-up singing in that way of like singing acting on camera pre-pandemic, and then it became a whole thing.

[18:51] JJ Niemann: Yeah. Um while we're on that, talk to me a little bit about your post-showcase life. So you you uh graduate, you're crushing it, you've learned how to sing octaves have increased, you're feeling confident, I'm sure you're in the best shape of your life. Here you are, your time to, you know, um get out into the business. And pretty quickly now you're getting into the Book of Mormon. Talk to me about like what was that on-ramp for you? What was the experience of did you find an agent first? Did you meet casting directors? How did that work for you coming out of school?

[19:17] JJ Niemann: Yeah, so at Elon, we do it a little bit differently than other schools. Instead of doing like a full New York showcase, we like pay basically casting directors and agents to come down, and the senior class actually helps raise a lot of that money that is used to bring the people down. And I was like one of the people in charge of that. So I was very proud of like the money we raise. And you know, we put on all these performances and things at school. But um like doing cabarets or whatever locally. Yep, exactly. Love cool. Um, selling merch, you know, we sold like BFA, you know, Elon merch. You got to practice some of your entrepreneurial skills, which we'll get into in the second half for sure.

[19:51] JJ Niemann: Yeah, and I was a business minor, so I was applying skills already. And it was cool also when you're doing something like that and bringing people down. For example, the agent I ended up signing with, um, which was CGF talent, and Michael Goddard was the agent that came to visit from CGF. And literally, like I picked him up from the airport, and like you get an hour in a car with an industry professional and just to like be a people literally would pay for that. They would pay for that privilege to get to sit down with an agent for an hour. So and then like, so what we do when we bring people to school, and they do still do this, and some of it's on Zoom now, but they do still do this, is we like do a full you you know, each student gets like 10, 15 minutes to do songs of their own and like, you know, workshop them and work with the agent or casting director that is there, and we basically try to bring down someone from every major office in terms of casting, um, and then bring down some of the best agents and the ones that often sign Elon folks.

Um and then we do like a whole dance call where we're doing like four different dances, and people get to pick the ones that they want in their strong suits and you know, choose to show tap if they want to. Um, and we do like a whole reception, a QA, like we do a dinner with them. It's a whole thing where you like are getting to know them and and asking them actual questions and stuff. So that was a really cool experience. And that is how I, you know, I ended up after all of that, went up to New York for spring break, got to have meetings with all of the agents. I was, you know, choosing between five or six different agencies and went with the ones I went with because of you know, just the heart.

I mean, you didn't have that connection now. You knew Yeah, exactly. And it felt like people, I was like, I need to have an agent. I can just call up and be like, hey girl, what's up? Like, you know, I wanna talk about this or like I'm struggling with this, or like, can I go in for this? Um, because the last thing I wanted was to sign with someone who felt cold and I was scared of them.

[21:43] Charlie Murphy: Uh-huh.

[21:43] JJ Niemann: Because they work for you. It's like it's a collaboration. You work together. So um, so I signed with them over spring break, and I also got um uh a video submission request, a self-tape request. That was probably my first one I ever did, too. Was for Book of Mormon. And it was because uh the associate had come down to campus and they I think contacted five or six of us for my class to submit self-tapes, and that was like material from the show, song of your own, a tap, you know, performance, all this stuff. And so then I got a callback to go up to New York and do a lot of the material and do a dance call in person and all that. So the callback ended up being two days after I graduated college. So I graduated from Elon on a Saturday, packed in my apartment, flew up to New York on Sunday, was staying on a friend's couch, and Monday morning, 10 a.m. was my callback.

[22:35] JJ Niemann: Uh-huh. And so I went, did all the material, all that stuff. It went super well. I got a final callback for the next day, next morning. And I I didn't move to New York yet. This was just a week trip that I was like going up. I think I was also up for like wait the waitress tour at the time. Yeah. And so I went to my final callback. Well, didn't know it was a final callback, but went to the other callback and had to do all the same material, but for more of the creatives. They filmed it for Casey Dickelau, who wasn't there. Um, and I also was pulled into a room and the dance captain taught an extra dance combo to like three or four guys. And I didn't know at the time, but I found out after the fact that that was kind of the swing test.

He was like, I'm just gonna teach this as fast as I can. How quick can you pick it up? How quick can you pick it up? And how many details can they retain after teaching it? And thankfully, that's like a huge strong suit of mine. Like I'm very detail-oriented and I learn dances fast. And that's just something that's you know, a skill I've either learned or just you know, um finest. But uh yeah.

[23:35] Charlie Murphy: But so you booked it, you booked the show.

[23:36] JJ Niemann: Oh, I booked it, yeah, yeah, yeah. I literally got a call the next morning.

[23:36] Charlie Murphy: Unbelievable.

[23:36] JJ Niemann: Yeah, I literally got a call the next morning. They were like, and I had just gotten cut from another dance call for something else. And um, I was like, whoa, okay, that's the reality of New York. I like bombed that, and then I literally had a voicemail from my agent like call me about Book of Mormon, and they were like, they want you to go to the theater at 3 p.m., sign your contracts and start music rehearsals. And I literally started rehearsals that day.

[24:00] Charlie Murphy: Unbelievable. Unbelievable. Crazy.

[24:03] JJ Niemann: So did you ever feel like, and of course you were in the with that show for a while, and then you're only a couple years out of school, really. But like, do you feel any of the trajectory of like because obviously that is so lucky? Like, not that many people, even if you're really successful, even if you get an agent right out of school, not many people booking a Broadway show within the first week of graduating or whatever, right? That's awesome when that happens. It's not unheard of, but it's but it's awesome. Do you feel a little bit of like I I don't want to say disappointment is kind of the wrong word, but but just like what you're feeling now after the show, the sort of post-show letdown.

Does it feel weird then to be like, okay, so now what's next? Like, I already achieved what was probably a pretty big dream being on Broadway immediately. Of like, now how do I navigate my career? What happens, you know, because now I see you're doing all these amazing things, you're doing regional stuff, you're doing workshops. But is it weird to be like, oh God, I had this thing immediately, and now how do I traverse to the next step? You know, having hit that big thing.

[24:53] JJ Niemann: Yeah, totally. I mean, it was very interesting, and it it's like um I have a lot of thoughts, but I'm not gonna take up too much of your time. But it's obviously because that's that's a years long journey of ups and downs. And like I was a swing as well. So it took me even six months in the show to even start feeling like I was like confident in everything. I had debuted all my tracks, I had done everything. So, like, it was like it kept it so exciting and fresh. Um, and I think, you know, I I would see friends going and doing a lot of regional work, doing world premieres, doing things like that, and working with people and building the roster of their connections. And now Book of Mormon is an amazing show.

It's genuinely so fun. It feels like home when I get to go back. And so, for those of you who don't know, like post-pandemic, also like I chose to leave the show. They asked me to come back. I said no because I had filled my time there. But now I'm a vacation swing. And so when I'm available and when they're available, like for example, they called me for two weeks to come in while I was in Cape Cod doing Greece just now, and I couldn't go. And so they asked someone else, but like if I'm available, like I've done 10 or 11 weeks there post-pandemic, which has been so lovely. And it feels like a homecoming, like, like I'm coming home. But um, I call it almost like the golden handcuffs because it is a government job, it is stable. You are making good money, you're able to save, you're able to pay rent. But not new connections. You're just making these same connections again and again.

[26:20] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.

[26:20] JJ Niemann: It's a little bit of a dead end job in the sense that you're not gonna like they want the people that book that show to stay there, and people do. And most people stay there for years and years and years. And so for someone right out of school, I didn't realize at the time that at times it was holding me back from certain opportunities. And I had to like really force myself to put myself out there. And I was like, at times, like had to swallow my pride a little bit and be like, I can't believe I'm in a Broadway show, but I'm going to an open call for like this random project or like this random tour. In my mind, I should be going in for it, or like people should. I'm on Broadway. Like, do people know who I am?

But any other 23 year old wouldn't feel that way, or 24, you know, when you're early and you're any other 24 would be like, it's of cool. I'm building up my stuff, of course. I'm getting to know people. I start at the bottom, it's fine. And I I gotta be honest, like being able to have the title of like Broadway actor and like that on your resume opened so many doors for me, and I'm so thankful for it. And again, the show is so fun. And like genuinely, I learned so quickly because I got to final callback after final callback after final callback for all these original Broadway shows. And there was always it was always one thing. It was always, oh, we ended up going with someone who can tumble.

Oh, we ended up going with someone who looks old enough to cover the 35-year-old role, which I do not like, and and I just learned I was like, oh, I got so lucky. It reminded me how lucky I got because I was like, I booked a show that was so perfect for me. Yes. And not every show, even if I'm if I have all the skill set in the world, it's not like the perfect lineup. So it's about finding those, and it's not for some people can find it time after time after time, and others, it's it's fewer and far between. And so um, I'm fortunate to be pretty much working consistently, and I haven't ever not been working as an actor since graduating college, except for obviously the pandemic when no one was working. Um, so yeah, I'm very lucky and it's it's provided a lot of good knowledge and experiences.

[28:09] Charlie Murphy: Really is amazing. All right, but the last question before our break, and after the break, we'll talk a little bit about social media, um, which I can't wait. But let's talk. You mentioned swinging, and we've had a number of successful people who've done swing swinging or being a swing. Swinging makes it sound weird if I say you've done swinging.

[28:23] Charlie Murphy: Um, but we've had a number on the pod, and we've talked a little bit about the intricacies of it. I'd love to just hear like, so you said you're someone who's detail-oriented. Was it something you feel specifically Elon prepared you to do? Was it a conversation that you had in school of like how to do this, you know, kind of unique thing, you know? I think, uh, understudying, I've never swung a musical, right? But understudying a role was really hard, I think, in and of itself. The idea of doing multiple roles, especially where there sometimes is like costume changes and furniture's gotta move and everything's gotta hit the mark. Like, like finding, I guess I'm interested in what is the detail-oriented part. And then you said after six months, like when, if any, does the artistry come in when you've got so much happening in your head, so much technical stuff going on?

[29:07] JJ Niemann: Yeah, I mean, I definitely okay. So, in terms of being prepared for it, I feel like the skill set wise it was prepared, but that's swinging is something I feel like you just have to do. Like, there's no way for you to prepare for it until you're doing it. And honestly, sometimes people get cast as it and they're like, oh wow, I don't like doing this, I'm not good at it, and I'm not gonna do it again, or I'm not gonna do it any longer. I had never when I got hired as a swing, I had never understudied, I had never covered, I had never done any of that. So I just had to trust that I was good at it. And the funny part is the casting director actually called the head of my program at Elon when they were deciding if they were gonna cast me or not for Mormon.

They literally called Kathy, and they were like, Hey, so we're thinking of hiring JJ for this. Um, is he capable of this? Does he have a skill set for this? Because just because someone's a good auditioner or a good actor, doesn't mean that they're gonna be good at that. And I was literally the head of my program, Kathy's assistant. I helped respond her emails, organize audition days, do everything.

[30:08] Charlie Murphy: You're taking the call.

[30:08] JJ Niemann: Here you go. You're like, oh, catch you in a cafe.

[30:10] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, literally, she literally was like, Oh, JJ will be perfect for this. He will show up with color-coded notes. He will be the best person you could have for this job. And so, A, it shows that people do check in with references. So do pay attention to that and how you operate in places, schools, workplaces, etc. But, um, I was like, she spoke it into existence, and I said, You're right. So I got all my color-coded stuff ready, and like I'm just I am very type A. I love planning out, writing out everything to-do lists. Not every artist is like that. A lot of artists are like mad scientists, and they're just like a hot mess in life, which is beautiful, but I'm very like organized. So I was excited and ready for it.

[30:52] Charlie Murphy: But did you feel like what after the six months or whenever that started, did you feel like there was a point where you were able to now infuse through those details through the color-coded notes, some of now your vulnerable artistry? Because maybe you're not now living your authentic self a little bit more than you were at 17 when you did. So, like, did you feel acting wise, like, okay, that it after a certain amount of time, after going on a certain amount of times, how did it work then where you go, I'm actually just like doing the role now? It's when I'm on, as opposed to like I'm just hitting my marks.

[31:19] JJ Niemann: Yeah, I mean, it's it I think of it as a puzzle piece. So when you have all the pieces of the puzzle, or when you start putting more together, you're like, okay, great, I got this. And a lot of times I got very fortunate with Mormon that like if I was debuting a new role, they would give me like a week of performances while someone was on vacation. So I got to after one or two shows, you're like, okay, great, I'm locked in. I get the jokes, the timing, like my harmonies, and you just enjoy it. But like the challenge makes it so fun. And, um, I think the more and more like every time I go back, I feel so different as a human and an actor, even post-pandemic to pre. And so I, um, yeah, I love going back and being like, wow, I'm approaching so much of this with a different light or different comedic energy, and I feel so confident where I used to be so scared of some of these of not landing some of these jokes, and I am now like it's yeah, it's really cool.

[32:10] Charlie Murphy: Oh, and I can't, we're gonna talk about comedy on the back end of the break as well. So let's get to it. Let's pay some bills with some of these ads. Maybe it'll be today ticks. Who knows what's gonna play for you? Um, some Broadway shows, and we'll be back in a flash with JJ Niemann.

[32:27] Charlie Murphy: All right, we are back with JJ Niemann. And even on the break, we started talking about some of this social media spoils, and so I can't wait to talk about it. So we've had a number of different artists on this pod, uh, some of them a bit older than you, um, talk about the dangers and the downsides of social media, which I think I certainly understand and ascribe to, and I think it's worth hearing about all those things too. But I really want to hear, because this seems like it's something that's been a real successful part of your career, and something that you've parlayed in some of the positive. So feel free, of course, to talk about downsides as well. But I would love to hear a little bit of the story of how this happened.

So, was this something that you consciously set out to do? Um, were you a fan of these platforms? And then you started saying, Yeah, I can participate or how did how do you go from a human being who's just a person no one's heard of to now having 4.5 million views on your videos or whatever?

[33:19] JJ Niemann: Yeah, I mean, I it was a pandemic thing. Like, I think, um, quite a few people fell into. I used to make videos as a kid, actually, in like middle and high school, I had a, uh, YouTube channel called JJ Web Shows. And I mean should we link to it in the show?

[33:34] Charlie Murphy: Um, no, it is not.

[33:36] JJ Niemann: I privated almost all of it.

[33:38] Charlie Murphy: We'll crawl the internet to find something.

[33:39] JJ Niemann: Yeah, I'm sure you can find some things, but they're very embarrassing. But anyway, I honestly my sisters were like super supportive of it, and like they bought me, they would buy me like wigs for my birthday and Christmas, and I would be doing like skits and like just like really stupid stuff. And I honestly ran out of time to do it the more I got into theater, and then also a little bit because on the internet, like when you're growing up, you're like, okay, maybe this is a little cringy, you get self-conscious. The internet can be really honestly super toxic. And there was a lot, you know, I would get a lot of hate comments, and again, I was closeted, I wasn't comfortable with who I was, and so it was hard.

So, um, that was something I kind of, uh, of a facet of my artistic ability or something I love doing that I held off on for so long. And then all of a sudden, there's no theater. I'm at home in North Carolina and I'm in my childhood bedroom again and like cleaning out. I like redecorated everything because I was like, I'm gonna be here a minute, I guess. And I found all my old wigs, and I had just downloaded TikTok and I was like, you know what? Let me start just like dabbling with making some videos. Didn't really know how to use the app. It took me a few months to like really get into it. Um, and then it was pretty much like summer of 2020 was when I really started making videos, and it really started taking off in like August, September of 2020.

[34:59] Charlie Murphy: And was it did it start out as only an artistic project? Or did some part of you have that entrepreneurial, hey, this seems to be a way people market themselves?

[35:07] JJ Niemann: No, it was not at all. I did not set out to get a ton of followers or like make it a career like at all. And I think I think that's a good thing. And I think honestly, that's why a lot of people like my videos, is because I never set out to be like you can't smell it on you. No, and I can smell it on other people, which is something that bothers me. But anyway, that's where it's like. So then, so then whoops, it happens to some extent. Oh my god, people are really watching our thing. I'd love to talk and only, of course, share what you feel comfortable with. But like what was that process of capitalizing on it or monetizing it? I'm thinking specifically of like my friend from TPAP, a friend who like had this crazy hit viral video, millions and millions of views.

Got invited on Jimmy Kimmel and she did all these amazing things. But she also wasn't actively pursuing acting at the time. She was a teacher at Texas State, and so she was like, I don't kind of know what I'm to do with this, right? Like, and and kind of didn't necessarily want it. Right? Maybe part of her did want it. You know, I don't know exactly what was inside her mind at the time, but it was this weird thing of so much attention, but it didn't seem like it really got capitalized into what I don't know, the financial gain in the way that it could have potentially if that was her big goal. So at some point you must realize, oh god, I have I have all of this something, which is the thing that we all want, which is attention, you know, thing we all want, meaning the companies and capitalism and all those things, right?

But you probably don't have a way to snap your fingers and go, and that makes me a millionaire, or that gets me the next job, or how did that process go from attention to now how do I work this into something I'm known for?

[36:33] JJ Niemann: Yeah, I mean, I started using like on TikTok, like doing the creator fund, which doesn't make a ton of money, but you know, it pays you based on views and stuff, and I would have some places reach out and it would be like truly like no money. Um, but I was like, this is so cool. Like, sure, I'll like help make a video if you like send me products. Like, like what? That's so cool. Then I signed with a manager and started working with him. He reached out through my agents. He knew one of my agents. This is an LA based manager. His name is Paul. He works for Select Management Group that manages a. I'm sure if I showed you a bunch of people, you would recognize a ton of them from the internet. Um, but it's a 360 management, so they also do TV film, they do all this, but also primarily are helping grow social media people's platforms and like businesses.

And he had been, you know, watching my videos for like six months and was like, I really just think you have something very special, and I would love to like meet with you. And so we did like a, you know, few month trial run. And we started with some small brand deals, and honestly, so much of it comes through them, or if places reach out to me, everything goes through my manager, and they're able to negotiate stuff I never ever imagined. And now that's my primary source of income, and acting is the fluff. Acting is like what I get to do for fun. I can go to Cape Cod and take like a vacation, yeah, even if I'm getting paid, you know, seven, eight hundred dollars a week, which is not much, but like I can do that because it's not my primary source of income anymore.

[38:06] Charlie Murphy: Which is the dream of dreams. I mean, it's one of the sort of messed up systems of like sort of capitalism and the fact that a lot of people want to do actors, be actors, and so we can pay them very little. It's like it makes it this really difficult thing that if you want to do this, most jobs. I mean, of course, TV and film world gets paid very well, but most non-Broadway theater jobs do not pay even really living wage, or if it's living, it's living only while you're actively in that work, and it's not gonna sustain you through the fallow period. So that like to be able to say this is acting is the thing I get to do because it feeds my spirit, but I actually can pay the bills some other way, is of course the journey to dream.

[38:39] JJ Niemann: It's so nice. Yeah, and like and and it's nice because now some of it comes directly to me, which is really cool that yes, like the manager's helpful, but a lot of people like see me. And like I now have relationships with people at Meta who run Facebook and Instagram. I'm with the TikTok creator portal, and of course I've been doing actual musicals created and produced by TikTok. And so like, and I have brand deals basically with Instagram, and like so I'm paid, regardless of views now, like to just post and have consistent content. And it's really nice to like, I don't know, have like a six-month deal with someone, and you're like, I can pay rent, like this is rent, and then some for the next foreseeable future. Like, I don't have to worry about paying bills. It's really, really nice to have.

[39:24] Charlie Murphy: And so talk to me about those. So both the Ratatouille and For You Page are both like TikTok musicals, right?

[39:30] JJ Niemann: So Ratatouille was not produced by TikTok. That was like an independent project.

[39:32] Charlie Murphy: Okay.

[39:34] JJ Niemann: That just became a whole phenomenon on TikTok. And then I guess maybe TikTok gave their approval, but they weren't a part of any of the production of it.

[39:43] Charlie Murphy: Uh-huh.

[39:43] JJ Niemann: And then I think they saw the success there and how it can be a collaborative platform. They can say, We're writing this musical, people contribute, and then they can use all of these people's, um, you know, um, creative abilities and create something really cool. Um, and so that's they've started doing more of those and now sponsored, but they just did one with like Taco Bell, and I was like, what is going on? But anyway, and now we're like, we're they're trying to get nominated for an Emmy for like variety um like special for the For You Page musical, and I'm very intrigued to see if that happens.

[40:16] Charlie Murphy: That would be so cool. And those who can't tell, it's for you, P A I G E. If you can't tell by the way, we're not doing that. It's not the For You Page, it's For You Page.

[40:24] JJ Niemann: Yeah.

[40:24] Charlie Murphy: Um, that's so cool. Now, is that something that you ever worried about like almost becoming too much part of your identity? Like, have you ever been like, okay, boy, man, like I do, I am now someone I saw it online and you said you're the king of theater TikTok or something. I'm like, is that like are you like, that's awesome? I own that well, or are you like, okay, I also do want to be other theater stuff? Or how does that, you know, jive for you?

[40:44] JJ Niemann: Yeah, I was I was really not sure when I was coming back post-pandemic as an actor and having this whole platform. I was like, what is that gonna be like? And am I gonna be getting opportunities because I deserve them and I'm talented, or because of this? Are people gonna want me in their shows because I have followers and can sell them tickets, or because of my talent, and like I want it to be because of my talent. I don't want to get anything because I can sell tickets. Like, but it is a little bit of both. And I think that the biggest thing on TikTok is that I always led, like, truly, like, yes, it is a personality base, and like it is so special to me. Like, I had not recognized that I can make a career around my personality.

I never knew that that could be a thing, and honestly, it's so powerful because it has been the most empowering thing for me as an actor coming back into auditioning and constantly getting rejection and no's and whatever, and constantly going in for things to see that there's power in my personality. That me coming into a room and showing who I am or my take on a side or scene or per like a, uh, role is powerful, and if it's not right, it doesn't matter. Like, it's powerful because it's me. And I think I just always thought of myself as such like a product and a musical theater. Like, I was just always trying to be the right answer instead of being like my own answer. Like being what they wanted versus what I was, and it's so easy to say that. I've preached that for years, but I didn't actually really understand what that was.

[42:20] Charlie Murphy: Well, and it almost feels antithetical to the idea of being a chameleon, right? We have this idea of we're a musical theater chameleon. I can fit into anything. I tap, I jazz, I Charleston, I do everything. And I can sing in this way and I can sing in this way and act and so which is great.

[42:33] JJ Niemann: You want to work on all your skills, right? But we can't let the chameleon mean that you'll blend into the wall.

[42:38] Charlie Murphy: Correct.

[42:38] JJ Niemann: If that's what you walk into the audition room and go, I can do anything. I'm blank. I'm still here blank. Like you still do have to say, yes, I'm flexible like the chameleon, but I can come in with my hot pink, this is what I'm wearing today. Is my chameleon looks like this today? Like that like they're still able to make choices and be bold and all those things.

[42:54] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.

[42:55] JJ Niemann: And I do think because thankfully, because I already had an established career in the industry, had already been doing development works, had already been doing Broadway for several years. I think a lot of people were I really liked being able to make videos that peel back the curtain a little bit and show because Broadway seems so elite, elusive, very mysterious. And I liked being like, no, this is what it's like. This is what we were doing. It's like high school theater or whatever. You're giving me like high school theater view of Broadway or Broadway as high school theater or whatever.

[43:23] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, and showing that we're all goofballs. We're professionals and we do it as a job, but we're still theater kids. We're still goofballs, we're still like doing stupid stuff backstage.

[43:33] JJ Niemann: And so I think people really appreciated me pulling back the curtain on that. And I love that I get to now be back on Broadway, be back performing constantly, and like taking people with me with this new perspective too.

[43:46] Charlie Murphy: Um that's cool. Well, but you also have the training, so it's not like someone's gonna go, right? Oh, JJ's only because of this, or whatever they're like, yeah, but he's also fantastic and he's trained and he has roots in this too.

[43:47] JJ Niemann: So it's not like you know, you're a stunt casting off, you know, you've never done anything but watch American Idol or whatever the um talk to me a little bit about different platforms so I I know I saw an Instagram and TikTok are you on other platforms too or yeah just those two and are you different content for the different platforms you are you conscious about like this is my TikTok thing Instagram is more curated or Instagram is how does that work for you?

[44:18] JJ Niemann: I'll be honest most stuff I cross post but of course there are some things that like make much more sense on TikTok and that sense of humor than Instagram um yeah it's very interesting but but now that I have deals for example with Instagram right I have to be cognizant of I'm making content that is exclusive to Instagram for a month and then I can post it on TikTok. So I have to constantly be coming up with content that's like I can cross post and then some that I can post on one place and not the other it's very interesting.

[44:49] Charlie Murphy: Okay well you said coming up with content so we gotta talk about that. So you the detail oriented multicolored um you know assistant that was you are you someone who is planning out your month of content are you writing stuff in advance are you having sit down writing sessions with content or is it more off the cuff of like let's see what I feel like?

[45:07] JJ Niemann: Yeah it's more off the cuff and improved I will say I really keep tabs on trends every time I I it's funny because like I do watch TikTok and stuff for humor and it's literally I will be like in bed like crying laughing for an hour at TikTok like it is just so good. When it hits it hits but I will say that a lot of times I'm truly scrolling with a business mindset. And I am constantly saving sounds, saving videos, and looking at trends and being like, how can I use this? Or is this something I can easily use in the theater realm or artist realm or New York City realm? And I keep a notes, a tab on my notes app just every time I have an idea, write it down. Doesn't matter if it's stupid. I might I sometimes wake up in the middle of the night and had a dream about an idea and I write it down. I don't plan out content really. I do most of my videos are just improved and I just do it as I go.

[46:02] Charlie Murphy: But I think more like you're more like a stand-up comedian then. Rather, it's not fully, it's like in terms of like that's they they write down little notes and they're like, I'm gonna try that out on stage or whatever. Like there's a joke there somehow. I'm gonna get, I gotta get a camera on and we'll see what's funny than that. And sometimes it flops, like sometimes it flops and you go, done, you know.

[46:19] JJ Niemann: Yeah.

[46:19] Charlie Murphy: But but you for the most part, it's more you've just got a gem of an idea than I'm doing a full script and I know exactly what's gonna happen.

[46:25] JJ Niemann: Yeah, I never really write out a script unless it's a brand deal.

[46:28] Charlie Murphy: Where does that funny juice come from? Like, where does you know, you kids doing a kid doing videos, you know, but then at some point you didn't feel like an authentic actor and you weren't, you know, sort of locked in in that way. How how do you feel like you were able to harness because it seems like a lot of what you're doing is comedy, right? A lot of these videos are more funny than like deeply. I mean, I'm not gonna pretend there's no thirst traps on there. Let's be honest. We people you see JJ with a little open shirt or whatever. But more of more of what we're getting from you is like, oh, is personality your point. It is funny. It is, I'm at least giggling or smiling at it as opposed to like, God, that's so deep.

[47:01] JJ Niemann: Right. Um, it's the trauma. I'm kidding. Um the the the funny comes from the the pain. No, I mean, I like to say that everyone that's like every comedian that's like very funny. I don't even consider myself a comedian to be honest, but anyone who is, I feel like genuinely has trauma and it uses it because there's nothing better than like low-key a little bit self-deprecating, or like, you know what I mean? Like being relatable and just real. Um, and so I don't know. I feel like I feel like more than like knee slapping comedy of my stuff, I feel like it's just more a little relatable. And I it's specifically, I found that there's universality and specificity. And so what I mean by that is the more specific you are about like I'm making a video about being backstage, my mic accidentally is on when I think it's off, I'm talking about Chipotle, or like I'm using the bathroom backstage and my mic gets turned on, like the amount of people who are like this exact thing has happened to me, or the amount of people on Broadway who are like, did you wiretap into my conversations backstage at Mean Girls on Broadway?

And I'm like, no, but like I just know that this is and so people find so much humor in like the more specific stuff and niche stuff. It it finds the right audience. So a lot of people would see my videos and be like, what the heck is this? Like, this isn't funny, this is cringy. It doesn't matter to me. Whatever. But for the people who liked it, they're like, this is so right, I'm gonna share it, which is how it goes viral. They're like, This is oh my god, this happened to my friend Melissa. Melissa, you have to watch this video. Like, it's like then they share and then she reshares and they watch the thousand times. And you I'm I'm always shocked at how many people I meet people on the street almost every day in New York who like have seen my videos. It's absolutely crazy. But it's also like a lot of times people aren't even actors or or did one theater show growing up and then they just love it.

[48:48] JJ Niemann: Yeah, and like you forget how many people choose to not pursue it, but like almost everyone has done a show at some point in their life, and there's so much core memories there. One of my best friend's wife um is like the greatest karaoke singer. She's never in her life, only worked for the government, never done the theater. But she's like, did high school theater and still whoops that out of karaoke. She would love those videos for sure.

[49:07] Charlie Murphy: Um, how can we talk a little bit about so how has your business success on socials changed your consumption pattern? If it has like, has it changed? You said some of it's more work-oriented. Are you, as you put out more, are you consuming less? Are you consuming more? Do you worry about the like danger of it all in terms of what I'm leaning into and how you know we do kind of know on a large scale that you you are contributing to rotting all of our brains.

[49:33] JJ Niemann: Yeah, Jim. It's not your fault specifically. But is that something you think about of like, okay, I'm I'm putting this out there, but I gotta be careful because it is seductive or it is addictive or any of that kind of stuff.

[49:46] JJ Niemann: Yeah, I mean, I I like to think if if people people are gonna use social media whether or not I'm making videos. So I'm like, if my stuff is wholesome and is appropriate and is fun and funny and lighthearted and harmless, like I think that that's good. You know what I mean? And so I'm like, work. But um, yeah, I mean, I definitely spend that's the that it is a weird thing because I'm never unplugged. I'm on a trip, I'm home, I'm flying. Like, I almost never am not posting some form of something. And it is hard sometimes when I'm doing, for example, a show. I'm doing rehearsals every day, I'm exhausted, and then I have to also keep up with making content. Honestly, when I'm in a creative process, the content creating takes a back burner.

I'm like, this is my job, and unless I have to do a brand deal or something that's like I have to do, I'm gonna take a step back. But it's hard when I'm, for example, with a pro uh platform like Instagram, I have to make two videos a week, or at some time three videos a week. And it doesn't matter what it is, but having to constantly come up with content, yeah, sometimes it's hard to be present. It's hard to be like focused and honed in on like my acting and like my rehearsal process when I'm like juggling that, and that's taking up brain space.

[50:59] Charlie Murphy: Yes.

[50:59] JJ Niemann: It's weird. And I also when I talk about addictive, I actually was not thinking though you're right to some extent, it could be addictive to the consumer. I actually kind of mean for yourself of like I can't, I cannot process what 300 million pain page views. Can you? I mean, like, like I can think of like the what's the biggest theater you've ever performed in? It was Mormon a thousand seats, 800 seats.

[51:19] JJ Niemann: I mean um the biggest one was probably well, the Muni.

[51:22] Charlie Murphy: So that's 12,000.

[51:23] JJ Niemann: Munis.

[51:24] Charlie Murphy: Okay, so most people imagine you haven't performed in the Muni. Like a Broadway house, like I'm thinking, the biggest I've ever performed at would be like Shakespeare in the Park, which may be like 1300 people. Like and that feels huge. It feels like a stadium, you know. And to think like just how many shows you would have to do full of that many people to get to 300 million, I'm not gonna try to do the math, but you know what I mean? Like that it's it's an incalculable number.

[51:48] JJ Niemann: It's it's just like you would have there'd be years and years and years and years of your life doing shows every night to get seen by that many people. Does that how does that I how do you take that in? Or how do you, you know, for the sake of your ego, for the sake of your like, do you do you need more? Like I I get so excited by the little red dot of oh, someone followed me, like one follow. Like, you know what I mean? Like when you're talking about m the numbers of millions, how how do you I guess wrestle with that in terms of your own how you stay sane with it all?

[52:16] JJ Niemann: Honestly, it doesn't feel real. I just feel like it's numbers and I know that it is. None of it's real. And yeah, and like at times, sometimes I'll sit back and be like, oh my God, like at my worst, at my lowest view count of a video is like two or three hundred thousand. That's like at minimum what I normally get. And so thinking about that is like insane because once upon a time, that would have been unreal. Like insane, yeah. It and I'm just so used to it now, and so like yes, I want to continue growing, but I also am really content with like I don't ever want to be like really famous. Like that that is just like I don't know, like I just think about some people and I'm just like the lack of privacy it's just next level and a lot of people social media stars like get to this crazy level of fame but also crazy levels of hate.

And my pages stay pretty positive. I very rarely deal with hate. And if I do it's like y'all just don't get it or like they say gay and it's like yeah like I don't care like creative genuinely like or they're like oh like theater kids are so annoying it's like yeah period like to you for you um so anyway I just like I'm so like I don't give a crap really about most of that but the views don't seem real.

[53:30] Charlie Murphy: Yeah no that's a really healthy way to think of it. And I and boy God if you can keep it positive that's I don't know how you can do that but it seems like it's I think it's because I've slowly built my platforms and it's been a lot of theater kids performers just like kind humans and I think they're like really honestly really loyal and so like I just don't have a you know some people get viral success overnight and that's when it's scary because then you have a ton of people following you and all of a sudden shoving me into your face I don't want to see this. Why are they in my feed? I never asked for this and and they are following you without really knowing who you are versus building a following slowly I have close to a million followers now on TikTok and it's like but that's been in the making for two years now.

And so it's like I like it. Like I'm I'm chilling and I feel like the people are rider dies and it's nice and they like got my back and it's it's cool, but yeah, the views count the view count doesn't feel real.

[54:23] JJ Niemann: What is cool is I'm literally like last summer I was like choreographing a show, a regional show in Montana, random. And I was there and I would meet people almost every day who like watch my videos in Montana. And I'm just like, what? It's just like that's when it's crazy. And I'm like, wow, that you forget that every single view count is a real person watching this somewhere.

[54:42] Charlie Murphy: Um we've done a little like theme of of type. We've talked about type a bunch of different times in the past four or five episodes. So I'd love to kind of continue that in this framing, especially maybe branding is a better word than type, if you think about it in terms of like your the way you think you're branding yourself for the theater industry, but then also how that affects your online presence in terms of what your branding is. And branding, I guess I don't mean like, am I branding for this product, but just in terms of like, oh, JJ, what's what's his thing? Like, do you is that something you consciously think about both in the online world and theater world differently? Have those two merged for you now, where you're like, this is my online press personality, but in the theater world, I play these kind of roles?

[55:21] JJ Niemann: I just love to hear like how type and or branding is kind of fit into your life.

[55:24] JJ Niemann: Yeah, um, I might not have the best outlook on this because I definitely have found lately, I feel like a um a hard spot that I'm in is that I'm a little between types. And what I mean by that is like I'm like growing up, but I'm still very young. I'm 26, but I can look like I'm in high school. But like for TV and film, they're now casting actual high schoolers. But like my voice, my energy, and everything about me is so youthful that people often think I'm young much younger than I am. And so I don't know, it's tricky. And then also, like, I look like often just like a romantic interest boy next door kind of vibe, but I'm also queer. But a lot of times queer people are getting cast as side characters, comedic relief.

Um, they're not normally a lot of times they don't look like me in in shows. It's very interesting how the types work. So, and but I I used to think like I have to be like XYZ, and like I just played like duty in Greece, who's like silly, comedic relief, like always kind of the butt of the jokes. He's like the little brother to everyone. And then this fall I'm about to play Sky in Mamma Mia, who's like the hunky, like love interest fiance, like hot boy.

[56:48] JJ Niemann: And like I went into that audition, and I remember going in, and I was like, I am sexy, I am confident, I'm confident in my body, I may not have a six-pack, but I feel good in my own skin, and like I'm gonna go in and nail this. And I felt, I went in and felt that way. And I booked it, and like I was like, this is such a mind over matter. As soon as I started viewing myself as more than just like a little like deep dee-deep deep little like, you know, Mormon boy, the longer I was in that show, the more of a mind, you know what it was. You get trapped into that box of going, this is what I am. But to you saying, like, hey, this is me, I am sexy. I'm me, I'm JJ sexy. Not I have to play some idea of sexy, but this is sex JJ S sexy. People have seen me as sexy. We talk about those thirst strap photos or whatever. You're like, I live in that world. I can do that. That's part of me. For sure.

[57:37] Charlie Murphy: All right, we're gonna have to let you get out of here. So we have to play our game.

[57:40] JJ Niemann: Okay.

[57:40] Charlie Murphy: This each of our artists play a unique game. This one, the title, I'm not proud of this, JJ, is Mormon or Come On. Okay? Mormon or Come On. I'm gonna give you some facts about Mormonism. Okay, and you are gonna tell me if it's true or false. Mormon, true, come on, false. Great. Come on, like that. That's what I was trying to do. You understand? Okay. These are all from the internet, and there's like no fact checking. So this could all be wrong. We're gonna see how much you learned from the book of Mormon.

[58:08] JJ Niemann: I'm nervous.

[58:09] Charlie Murphy: Do you feel like you learned some for that show of Mormonism itself?

[58:12] JJ Niemann: Yes. When we join the show, they give us a packet of all of the references from the show and like what the, you know. I thought I remembered hearing that. So we'll see how you well you do. These are relatively hard, but not impossible. Okay, so they're all true or false questions. Do you feel ready?

[58:27] JJ Niemann: Mormons always have a modern day prophet in the president of their church. Mormon or come on.

[58:36] JJ Niemann: Um, I'm gonna say Mormon.

[58:36] Charlie Murphy: Mormon.

[58:39] Charlie Murphy: That is true. That is 100% right. You don't have to keep pronouncing it that way. Thomas Monson is uh Wow, very good, right? That's right. And a prophet, uh whatever, something's about being a prophet. That was online. Okay. Mormons all try to live a healthy lifestyle, including abstaining from alcohol and other vices, and have an average life expectancy of over 10 years longer than the national average.

[59:01] JJ Niemann: I'm gonna say come on.

[59:02] JJ Niemann: Come on.

[59:03] Charlie Murphy: It's two years ago longer.

[59:04] Charlie Murphy: Two years longer. Everything else is true except two years. Okay. Mormons are encouraged to take a rumspringer where they abandon their followings for a year as a teenager.

[59:13] JJ Niemann: I'm gonna say Mormon.

[59:15] Charlie Murphy: That no, that's that's come on. That's Amish people.

[59:18] JJ Niemann: Oh no!

[59:18] Charlie Murphy: Very close. We got you on one. Okay. The Twilight series is an allegory for the Mormon belief in eternal marriage.

[59:27] JJ Niemann: I'm gonna say come on, because that sounds crazy.

[59:29] Charlie Murphy: It's Mormons than Mormon for 100%. Okay, we're doing good. We're about 50%. We're doing good. Okay, okay, okay. Mormon men outnumber women by almost two to one.

[59:42] JJ Niemann: Come on.

[59:43] JJ Niemann: How could that be true? That was just a good kind of thing. Okay. The modern Mormon church does not allow for polygamy, does not allow for polygamy.

[59:53] JJ Niemann: Mormon.

[59:54] Charlie Murphy: That's true, but some still practice polygamy. Very good. Two of the centuries presidential/slash vice presidential candidates have been practicing Mormons in Mitt Romney and Tim Kane.

[1:00:06] JJ Niemann: I'm going to say come on because it might be more.

[1:00:08] Charlie Murphy: Oh, cool. You're right for the for the wrong reason. Only Mitt Romney. No. Tim Kane was like Catholic or something. I don't know, but not Mormon. The term Mormon, which is the nickname for the followers of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, comes from the Book of Mormon named after Joseph Smith's father, Mormon Smith.

[1:00:26] JJ Niemann: Come on.

[1:00:27] JJ Niemann: Sure, I made it up. It could be true, but the Mormons believe when Jesus returns, his headquarters will be in Jackson County, Mississippi.

[1:00:36] JJ Niemann: Uh, come on, because it's Missouri.

[1:00:38] Charlie Murphy: Oh my gosh, you're so good. You cannot be fooled. Hey, the Mormon Tabernacle Choir is the oldest singing group in the United States.

[1:00:48] JJ Niemann: Mormon.

[1:00:49] JJ Niemann: Mormon.

[1:00:50] JJ Niemann: Mormon. The Mormons wear special underwear as protection, partially because Joseph Smith was shot dead on a day he wasn't wearing his.

[1:00:59] JJ Niemann: Oh, that's funny. I'm gonna say Mormon because I hope that's true.

[1:01:03] Charlie Murphy: No, it's I made it up. It could be true, but he was shot, so that's how he died, but I don't think it has to do with the underwear. Mormons have secret handshakes with each other.

[1:01:13] JJ Niemann: Come on.

[1:01:14] JJ Niemann: No, that's Mormon.

[1:01:15] Charlie Murphy: Really? Mormons believe in multiple heavens.

[1:01:19] JJ Niemann: Mormon.

[1:01:20] JJ Niemann: Mormon, 100%. Mormonism has an open religious canon. The doctrine always has the potential to change.

[1:01:27] JJ Niemann: Wait, say that one more time.

[1:01:29] JJ Niemann: An open religious canon. So it's like their Bible is always open. It can always be changing.

[1:01:33] JJ Niemann: I'm gonna say, come on.

[1:01:35] Charlie Murphy: That's Mormon.

[1:01:36] JJ Niemann: What? Mormons believe Jesus will return in the year 2032.

[1:01:42] JJ Niemann: Come on.

[1:01:43] JJ Niemann: Come on, I made that up. Mormons believe you become responsible for your sins at the age of eight.

[1:01:49] JJ Niemann: Mormon.

[1:01:50] Charlie Murphy: Very good. You're doing very well with this. Not easy, JJ. We got a couple more. Mormons are baptized three distinct times in their lives.

[1:01:57] JJ Niemann: Three times they get baptized.

[1:01:59] JJ Niemann: Come on.

[1:01:59] JJ Niemann: Come on. Mormons are required to tithe 25% of their income to the church.

[1:02:05] JJ Niemann: Come on.

[1:02:06] JJ Niemann: Come on. It's 10%. Mormons are the third largest religion on earth.

[1:02:12] JJ Niemann: No way.

[1:02:13] JJ Niemann: No way. They're the fourth largest, though, unbelievably.

[1:02:15] Charlie Murphy: Really?

[1:02:16] Charlie Murphy: Mormons. Yes. Mormons believe you can tell the difference between an angel and a demon by the strength of their handshake.

[1:02:25] JJ Niemann: Oh, if you made that up, that's funny. Wait, uh, I'm gonna say come on.

[1:02:30] Charlie Murphy: It is true. It is true. Apparently, a demon will not squeeze your hand tightly. Only an angel will give you a firm handshake. JJ, you've done fantastically with this game. That's over 50%. You've beaten a monkey clicking true or false, without a doubt. I wasn't counting how well you did. But you did very well with that.

[1:02:43] JJ Niemann: Yeah, yeah.

[1:02:45] Charlie Murphy: I tried to make that hard. I make all of our.

[1:02:47] JJ Niemann: No, you um you came up with some good, good uh what's it called? Alternative facts.

[1:02:51] Charlie Murphy: Oh, yeah, yeah. I'm a good liar.

[1:02:53] JJ Niemann: I'm a good liar, JJ.

[1:02:54] Charlie Murphy: It's called acting.

[1:02:55] JJ Niemann: I'm studying it well. Um, okay, we're gonna wrap up here. I've got one more question for you, which is just, I want you to think about you at that 17-year-old self, clueless as he was. Um, and just some give some advice to little young 17-year-old JJ. And for bonus points, if you want to think about your parents, whatever age they were at that time, if you were to give some advice to them, going through the process, if you're doing it all again, what would you ask JJ to do differently? And what would you ask your parents to do differently? Specifically of the college audition process, the college process. 17 years old, you're doing the whole thing again.

[1:03:27] JJ Niemann: I mean, what advice wouldn't I give? Baby, I did everything wrong. So I really wish that I could go back, but also I wouldn't change anything of how you know it ended. But um, I think more than anything, authenticity is key. There's power in who you are. So, with whatever you do, how you present yourself, how you what you choose to do, material, honestly, obviously trust your coaches and trust the people giving you guidance, but like if you feel strongly about something, the most amazing auditions I saw, because I sat in on a lot of college auditions as well. And the most amazing auditions I saw were the ones where they just were like exactly who they were, and you're like, heck yeah, they came in, they chose to do this song that was risky, and like, or like they chose to wear this outfit, like I know exactly who they are.

And I just think there's power and authenticity. There's only one you, and that's so basic and so like cliche, but like the more that you can embrace that, do not try to model your career and your life and your art history based off of someone else. It is so easy to say, that's what Jeremy Jordan did, or that's what Laura Bonanti did. But like what'd you say? That's what JJ Neiman did. Okay, now you can do I'm just kidding. No, but like truly, like as much as you can remind yourself that your artistry is your own, it is no one else's, and even though you might remind someone of someone else, you are your own unique artist. So go in with that mentality. And for parents out there, just I don't know, leave with love.

Like, you know, if your kid really wants to pursue something like really try to lead with love, obviously parents know more about the world and have more realism about things. So, you know, there's a way to approach that and do that. But I think, you know, letting your children pursue their dreams. If people are gonna fail or fall, let them fail or fall because they did it and they tried and they took the jump. It doesn't matter if you end up on Broadway, it doesn't matter if you end up behind a desk, it doesn't matter where you end up. If you love what you do, it's amazing. And I just hope you allow your children to pursue that.

[1:05:33] Charlie Murphy: I love it. Well, we know folks can follow you at JJ Neiman on Instagram and TikTok. That's N-I-E-M-A-N-N. That'll be in our little show notes for anyone who's not already following you, even though half the damn world is. So I'm sure everyone listening already is following you, but just in case they can find you there. Um, JJ, thank you so much for your time today.

[1:05:49] JJ Niemann: Thank you.

[1:05:51] JJ Niemann: A pleasure. Thank you for having me.

[1:05:53] Charlie Murphy: Bye, everyone.

[1:05:59] Charlie Murphy: Oh boy, I hope you enjoyed that chat with JJ. He's so fun and funny and smart. Uh, and he wasn't kidding on detail-oriented. I couldn't get in with Missouri versus Mississippi. That was impressive. And it was just such a joy to have him on, like I said at the beginning, you know, to see our alum, not just as fellow artists, but someone to be really looked up to and inspired by. And I think many of our students will feel that way. So that's really exciting. Um, to think that you can be inspired by someone who is once in your shoes, and then you will be that inspiration afterward. Um, but speaking about inspiration and a bit of wisdom, I thought JJ brought up so much on the pod. I just want to zero in on a very short conversation we had about kind of bringing yourself to a role.

I've tried to have kind of an expansive conversation around type for the sake of our alumni and our older listeners. In some of the ways that it might manifest in the business, even though, as you've heard me say many times now, it is not something it should be overly considered for the college process. But I think this is a great example of where the business and the college process really can coalesce. While the business may do more to try to put you in a box or try to figure out how to sell you or how to brand you in college editions will be much more of an open question. Both are always looking for you to walk in the room and tell them who you are. What are you gonna be like to work with for four years?

Or in the professional world, what would you do with this role? Of course, in both situations, we want you to show flexibility and malleability whenever you're given directions. But I think sometimes we're so afraid of doing something that might be wrong that we end up not truly making a choice at all in our first run. And I really like how JJ put it. He said something like, um, instead of trying to be the right answer, I was being my own answer. Every casting director, every college professor wants you to be the answer to their question. And in answering the question they're asking in the college process, it's often like, who are you? Please, please, please don't fear specificity. You don't have to make up some personality that's more specific or more unique than your own.

But too often actors dull themselves so much in order to not be off-putting that their audition kind of speeds by and they never get really a chance to show themselves. Please don't let this happen to you. For each individual audition, most people won't get the part. And for each college, most people won't get into that college. You're not there to walk in and not get rejected. Walk in and dare them not to take you. Leave the room smelling so much like you that the next person has to spray Fabrize. And if they don't like what you're smelling like, then that school is probably not for you. The smelling thing is all a metaphor. Some people don't like when I talk about smelling, but you know what I mean, leaving the room smelling like you, metaphorically, is what I'm saying.

But and same thing in the professional world. You know, if they're just not kind of vibing with you, then that part's not yours, right? But with the professional world, you're doing a service to that director if you're showing what your best take is on the role, rather than waiting to see what they were gonna tell you it was supposed to be. Right? It is absolutely possible you'll get it wrong and they'll say, no, thank you. That's not what we're looking for. But maybe you'll be exactly what they were thinking, or maybe even more likely you'll be something different than what they were kind of thinking, but that it intrigues them and excites them, or maybe they didn't have something exactly specific in mind.

But what you do, they go, Yes, that's it. That's my Tony. That's what I want, right? Or maybe you'll answer a different question that inspires them artistically from a different project or a different role within this same project, right? But don't let the desire for flexibility make you an etch a sketch actor, right? It's great to be a true chameleon, like we talked about, but what colors do you show when it's just you alone in the room? Let's see those in your audition, at least with that first take. Well, if you enjoyed this episode, alone in your room and you want to hear more, please hit that follow button. A huge thank you to those who have rated and reviewed us on your different platforms.

Thank you for doing that. If you haven't yet gotten around to doing that, I suggest doing it right now instead of opening your next social media window. They say it's better to create than consume content. So I'm actually really helping you by letting you create a rating and review versus just like consuming some social media content, right? So don't open that meta portal, open your podcast app and give us a rating and review. Tell the world how much you like mapping the college edition. You must, you're here in the outro, listening to me talk after the episode's over. You must actually be a fan. Um, speaking of social media, you can follow JJ Neiman for a lot of great content. I believe he's at Charmer7 on Instagram, or you could try musical theater College Auditions.

Or you could actually do at JJ Neiman, but he has enough followers already. So follow us. Don't follow him. He's got plenty. He doesn't even want it. He won't notice it, right? Um, if you want to check out what we're cooking up at MTCA, I said cooking up a little weird there, but we're gonna leave it in. Um, if you want to check us out, that's at mtca.nyc for help with your individual college process. To my young artists out there mapping their journeys. Don't throw out those wigs in your attic. They could be your next source of income. We'll see you next week.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred